Pod Insights WHAT WENT WRONG A Star Is Born (2018) About this episode How did the 4th (or maybe 5th) version of ‘A Star is Born’ take almost 20 years to make… and why did it almost star Russell Crowe and Beyoncé?! This week Lizzie and Chris break down Bradley Cooper’s 2018 directorial debut, and discover why Lady Gaga was initially a tough sell. Find out how everyone from Jamie Foxx to Metallica had a hand in this Oscar nominated film’s journey to the screen. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript 16,501 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 Verizon FiOS celebrates the holiday hostess with the mostess. When the whole family's over, you've got Verizon FiOS Whole Home Wi-Fi. Fast, reliable, 100% fiber internet in every room. So your little nephews can blast video games on full volume. Your daughter can stream football under the dinner table. And grandpa can turn on the same movie for the third time. A full house with full Wi-Fi coverage. So everyone can do their own thing. Together, 100% fiber internet for 100% holiday hosts. Switch to Verizon FiOS today. Whole home Wi-Fi included with all FiOS gig plans. Availability varies.
0:32 Chris Winterbauer? Life can be a lot sometimes. Traffic, taxes, and that dreaded text that just says, "Call me." Why not go where life is good? Escape to Pluto TV. Turn off all your day-to-day problems and turn on the movies and shows you already love. From Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy to Dirty Dancing. From Alias to The X-Files. Channel Surf Live TV or browse the menu to find exactly what you're in the mood for. It's all free, no subscription, no credit card, no catch. The best things on TV are free. So escape to Pluto TV. Stream now. Pay never.
1:23 Chris Winterbauer? Hello, dear listeners, and welcome back to another episode of What Went Wrong, your favorite podcast full stop that just so happens to be about movies and how it is nearly impossible to make them, let alone a good one. And I'm excited to talk about what I think is a pretty good one tonight. As always, I am going to kick it over to my co-host, Lizzie Bassett. Lizzie, how you doing?
1:45 Lizzie Bassett? Well, thank you, Chris. I'm doing murder.
1:47 Chris Winterbauer? Oh, yeah.
1:48 Lizzie Bassett? Sorry, I can't even do it.
1:50 Chris Winterbauer? I can't get that low either. And by the way, it's only his speaking voice. When he sings, he goes into normal Bradley Cooper register.
1:58 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, sorry. I was trying to do my best Bradley Cooper as Jackson Maine, and it didn't quite work. That's because we are, of course, talking about the 2018 version of A Star is Born today.
2:10 Chris Winterbauer? A star!
2:11 Lizzie Bassett? A star! I'm also very excited to talk about this because I also think it's a really good movie. And that's it.
2:17 Chris Winterbauer? It's okay. Great. Yeah, that's it. Nothing went wrong. Um, no, I'm, I'm excited. I enjoyed this film. Lizzie, I'm assuming you'd seen it before.
2:26 Lizzie Bassett? Oh, you bet your brother. I saw this in theaters and I've seen it many times since and I love it every time. I do want to mention at the top before we get into this because of the subject matter of this movie. And we're going to talk about the many iterations prior to this version of it. There is going to be mention of suicide and also substance abuse across the episode. So just FYI. I think that's well known about this franchise, but it is there.
2:50 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah.
2:51 Lizzie Bassett? This is one of those movies that like, every time I turn it on, I think I'm going to be able to make it through without just like uncontrollable ugly sobs. And it doesn't happen. It's, I can't. I get to the end when Bradley Cooper's spoiler alert, actual dog is sitting outside of his garage. And it's just, I can't do it. It makes me uncontrollably sad. Um, Chris, what, what'd you think upon this watch?
3:17 Chris Winterbauer? So I, I'd only seen it, uh, it's the 2018 version. One time before I saw it in theaters. I enjoyed it. I still enjoyed it upon rewatching it. It does not hit me emotionally very hard. I also rewatched.
3:29 Lizzie Bassett? Cause you have no soul.
3:31 Chris Winterbauer? I guess not. Um, I actually found the end of the 1954 version more tragic and it, it hit me a little harder.
3:40 Lizzie Bassett? Yes, I think it is in some ways.
3:42 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah. The James Mason Judy Garland version. I think what's really, there's so many interesting things about this movie. First of all, it's a remarkable directorial debut.
3:50 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, I'll say.
3:52 Chris Winterbauer? But at the same time, I do think it's a movie, I, I've heard it picked on, especially amongst like kind of more film snobby circles. And I think it's an easy movie to pick on because it's a very earnest movie. It, it really, it's almost uncomfortably earnest in, in certain moments. But it's so well acted. I think it gets through those moments.
4:09 Lizzie Bassett? Well, it also has to be like, when you consider what the franchise is, there's no way for this not to be that. It would not work.
4:17 Chris Winterbauer? It, it paints with a very broad brush. It has to, to get through so much story and it's running time. I do think that that's to the detriment of the 20 2018 version, the 1954 version has room to breathe at three hours. I would say
4:31 Lizzie Bassett? I was gonna say at three hours long, yes.
4:34 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, but they're cramming a lot of story and even more romance into the 2018. And it can feel a bit, I think, montage-y at moments as a result. There's this interesting line of criticism I have heard that I don't ultimately agree with, but I do think is interesting, which is kind of what Bradley Cooper's character, Jackson Maine asserts at the beginning of the film. There are many, many talented people and there are very few who have something to say.
5:00 Chris Winterbauer? Almost feels true of him as the director in a sense, because it's hard to feel what his handwriting or perspective is in the movie, I think, in a way, compared to other auteurs right now. Again, I'm not, I don't
5:14 Lizzie Bassett? That's interesting. I totally don't agree.
5:17 Chris Winterbauer? I don't fully agree with it either, but I do think it's an interesting line of criticism that I've heard about the movie.
5:22 Lizzie Bassett? I think there's plenty of valid criticism about this movie. We'll get into some of it a little bit. I think one of the most interesting lines of criticism is like, why did they need to remake this? It's been made so many times, as we're going to get to. And like, what did this add to that? I think it added a lot.
5:40 Chris Winterbauer? I think that's kind of the extension of the argument I was just making.
5:44 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah. Well, why do you think Hollywood keeps remaking this movie?
5:48 Chris Winterbauer? I think watching a supernova and then, you know, a star collapse into itself is fascinating. You get a rise story and a fall story in one.
6:01 Chris Winterbauer? There is a kind of beautiful symmetry to where they meet in the middle in both versions. You know, as we watch one person kind of rail against the night and the other person ascend.
6:16 Chris Winterbauer? And I think that in a way, it is comforting to know, and this is gonna sound very grotesque, but it's comforting to know that there will
6:30 Chris Winterbauer? Be room for that next generation to write like the the old generation needs to die for the next generation to come up in a weird way and
6:39 Lizzie Bassett? See, that's so interesting. I think that is every version prior to this.
6:43 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, I agree. This version is very different than that.
6:46 Lizzie Bassett? It is. And I think that's one of the best things that it does with the franchise is that it's not inevitable that he needs to fall in order for her to succeed. I think that this movie, which is going to go against many articles that I read, but I actually think that this movie and this story from the very beginning has really been Hollywood's sort of telling on itself in terms of how weak some of the men in charge are. I think it's a really interesting portrait of male weakness. And I think that is the case from the very beginning, which is sort of surprising, given when this got started. And I know there's a lot to say that the story is very anti feminist and I don't necessarily agree,
7:31 Lizzie Bassett? especially because it seems to have come from a woman, which we will get into. Let's talk about it. Today, we are going to learn how it took 20 years to make this remake of a remake of a remake of a maybe also remake.
7:44 Chris Winterbauer? Kind of also, yeah, exactly.
7:45 Lizzie Bassett? Why it might be the best version yet. I know people are going to fight me on this and I don't care. And how everyone from Clint Eastwood to Lars Ulrich, the drummer from Metallica, had a hand in bringing it to life. As always, here is the basic info. A Star is Born is directed by Bradley Cooper, written by Eric Roth, Bradley Cooper, Will Fetters, and about a bajillion other people who we'll get into a little bit, but I'm not going to list out here. The release date was October 5, 2018. The studios were Warner Brothers and interestingly Live Nation amongst some others. It stars Lady Gaga, Bradley Cooper, Sam Elliott, Anthony Ramos, Andrew Dice Clay, Dave Chappelle, and more. Here's
8:26 Lizzie Bassett? the IMDb logline. A musician helps a young singer find fame as age and alcoholism send his own career into a downward spiral.
8:34 Chris Winterbauer? And tinnitus.
8:36 Lizzie Bassett? And tinnitus. That's right. Which they don't do a ton with after they first introduce it. But I think it's an interesting element, but.
8:43 Chris Winterbauer? I thought they actually did a better job tracking the progression of his tinnitus than they did his alcoholism, just with little moments where he had to lean in and people had to repeat their words to him.
8:52 Lizzie Bassett? That's true.
8:53 Chris Winterbauer? So I actually thought, I thought they handled that fairly well.
8:56 Lizzie Bassett? That is true. There's a great moment when he's backstage with Sam Elliott at Saturday Night Live, which I'd never noticed before. But if you watch it carefully, it's, it's clear he can't actually hear what Sam Elliott is saying. And he's responding based on like what he's guessing he's saying. There are, you're right. I take it back. There are some very smart elements of that in this. So let's briefly walk through the history of A Star is Born, because as we mentioned, this is one of the most retold stories in Hollywood history, and it's a big old mess. So it starts all the way back in the silent film era. The origins are murky, but it allegedly all stems from a story co-written by Hollywood journalist and screenwriter Adela Rogers St. John called The Truth About Hollywood. This is sometime in the late twenties or early thirties, and there are a few real lives that the story
9:40 Lizzie Bassett? appears to draw on. Colleen Moore, a silent film starlet who put her husband, producer, and publicity man John McCormick in charge of her career for a time only for his alcoholism and jealousy to prevent her from moving into the talkies until everyone else had already gotten their shot. He apparently attempted suicide by walking into the ocean. He survived. And he was fired from his job for being absolutely publicly wasted. This one is the most likely source for the story, since Moore was personal friends with Adela Rogers St. John, who wrote the original piece. Barbara Stanwyck is another potential inspiration. She went from chorus line girl to Hollywood superstar while her husband descended further into alcoholism and despair. And then there are the potential Jackson or Norman main
10:24 Lizzie Bassett? prototypes, including John Barrymore, John Gilbert, and silent film actor John Bowers, who very sadly did seem to drown himself in the Pacific Ocean when his career went down the toilet. By the way, we searched high and low for the original story from Adela, but it was absolutely impossible to find. So listeners, if you know where it is, I would love to read it. Please tell me. So in 1932, we get the first onscreen version of the story, though of course it is not called A Star is Born. It's called What Price Hollywood?
10:54 Chris Winterbauer? Mm hmm.
10:54 Lizzie Bassett? Which I would argue is not quite as catchy. This is directed by George Kuakor and produced by David O. Selznick for RKO. And we've talked about both of those guys before, particularly in our Gone with the Wind episode. So go give that a listen if you want to learn more about them. What Price Hollywood is based on the story by Adela Rogers St. John. So we get the really bare bones version here, though it's set in Hollywood, not the music industry. It is not a musical, nor is it really a romance. The main character is not romantically involved with the drunken lead. She falls for a different asshole and there's sort of a different trajectory there. So technically, not the beginning of a Star is Born franchise. However, too many similarities, I think, to not consider this the beginning of the IP.
11:39 Lizzie Bassett? Just four years later, in 1937, we get the first A Star is Born. And can you guess who it's produced by, Chris?
11:45 Chris Winterbauer? Is it O. Selznick again?
11:47 Lizzie Bassett? You betcha. It's David O. Selznick.
11:49 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah.
11:49 Lizzie Bassett? Because he's with United Artists now. And he's like, you know what? Let's do it again. Apparently, he even asked George Kuakor to direct, but Kuakor declined because the stories were so similar.
12:00 Chris Winterbauer? And O. Selznick said, let me do some more speed and ask somebody else.
12:05 Lizzie Bassett? He sure did. And William Wellman was like, sure.
12:07 Chris Winterbauer? Let's do it.
12:10 Lizzie Bassett? So he writes and directs instead. This one stars Janet Gaynor and Friedrich March. Contrary to the plot, Gaynor's career was actually in a downturn, which does mirror Judy Garland's as well. And it was this film that revived it. Now, the details of this are also murky, but it seems RKO explored a plagiarism lawsuit against Selznick because they were so similar. However, this is where the template for all of the future films is really set. We get the names Norman Maine, later Jackson Maine in our version, and Esther Blodgett changed to Ally for obvious reasons.
12:45 Chris Winterbauer? A name so bad you couldn't make it up. You didn't make it up. Nobody would choose that name.
12:50 Lizzie Bassett? That's a whole running thing in the Judy Garland one. We get the public embarrassment of our starlet at an awards show and we get the basic story. A struggling actress falls in love with a once successful actor who is struggling with alcohol abuse as her star rises, his falls, eventually to his death. That's the trajectory we see across the whole series, but this is still not a musical.
13:10 Chris Winterbauer? Got it.
13:10 Lizzie Bassett? It was, however, a big financial success. So naturally in 1954, they decide to remake it because why not? Hollywood's never liked original IP.
13:20 Chris Winterbauer? So finally came down from that last bump and he's like, we gotta, we gotta go back to the well.
13:25 Lizzie Bassett? One more time. Now this is a musical starring Judy Garland and James Mason. This one is produced by Warner Brothers. This is, I think, when Warner Brothers gets a hold of the IP. Now I'm going to gloss over this because honestly, a lot went wrong and I think it deserves its own episode. So.
13:44 Chris Winterbauer? Hundred percent. A hundred percent deserves it. So I know a little bit about this one and it deserves its own episode.
13:50 Lizzie Bassett? It's wild. I was not as familiar with the backstory in this until I started researching it and I was just like, okay, I'm going to stop. Um, yeah. So listeners, if you're interested in a dedicated Judy stars born episode, let us know. We will make it happen. But here's the brief background. George Cukor comes back to direct.
14:08 Chris Winterbauer? Yep.
14:09 Lizzie Bassett? Ira Gershwin and Harold Arden write the music. So Chris, you did watch this one and it sounds like you enjoyed it. Very briefly, what was it that you liked about this?
14:18 Chris Winterbauer? There were three things I really liked about this version that were different in the 2018 version. The first is I appreciated that Norman Maine's character was a womanizer and a real cad at the beginning of the movie.
14:32 Lizzie Bassett? He's a mess.
14:33 Chris Winterbauer? He's more of a mess and they allow him to be frankly, kind of more of a, a piece of shit. And I think that that makes for a more interesting turn when he becomes earnestly invested in Esther Blodgett, Judy Garland's career. So I appreciated that as opposed to the 2018 version. I think they do a lot of work. To try to really get you to like Jackson.
14:51 Lizzie Bassett? Yes.
14:51 Chris Winterbauer? Right at the beginning of the movie. That's a just different sensibilities.
14:54 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, he's appalling at the beginning of this.
14:57 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, and I really liked that. And I really liked James Mason as an actor. And I, there's a scene where he's, you know, going to pick up women at a, at a bar and.
15:04 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah.
15:05 Chris Winterbauer? And he's like, you know, my last relationship lasted a week, basically. And, you know, who do you, basically, who's, who's around that I can pick up? And there's a funny Pasadena reference that I had to look up because I didn't fully understand it, but it was referring to old money. Anywho, I like that. Second thing, Lady Gaga is remarkable, and I think her acting, we'll get to it, is great in this movie. Oh, my God, I forgot how good Judy Garland was, especially as a singer.
15:28 Lizzie Bassett? She is incredible.
15:30 Chris Winterbauer? Wow. Her voice is technically perfect. I mean, it's remarkable.
15:36 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah.
15:36 Chris Winterbauer? Crazy. So that was two. And then the third thing that we mentioned, I, for some reason, the runtime and the pacing, it allowed me to settle in a little. I know it was long, it was three hours, but I, I guess I preferred, there's a romanticism to walking into the ocean that I just found very moving. And with the LA setting and whatnot, I thought that worked really well. So those were the things that I really liked about the 54 version.
16:02 Lizzie Bassett? I agree. I think that this version is incredible. I think Judy Garland is really stunning in it, both as an actress and as a singer. We've talked about her before in our Wizard of Oz episode. If you want to hear that, please go back and listen to it. She had a very, very hard life. By all accounts, she was not well during the filming of this. She'd gotten herself released from her contract with MGM in 1950 and had not made a movie since. She was struggling with substance abuse and a few suicide attempts of her own. She also had some pretty wild weight fluctuations across the film. They had to constantly account for and made continuity a problem. She did lose the Oscar to Grace Kelly for The Country Girl in what's considered one of the biggest snubs ever. And she never really recovered after this.
16:46 Lizzie Bassett? Production was very difficult. Post-production was even worse. We're not going to talk about it, except for one thing. Chris, did you notice something weird about this film?
16:53 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, I'll let you explain it, but you'll see when you watch the film, there are basically scenes missing that are filled in with photo montages. And there's a very specific reason for that. And Lizzie, I'm sure you'll explain why.
17:05 Lizzie Bassett? That is right. There's a lot of missing footage. That's because studio execs cut almost 30 minutes of the film after the premiere without George Cukor's input because they wanted a shorter runtime to sell more screenings. It's something we've talked about in the past. You want to pack as many screenings into each theater as you can. It has been mostly reconstructed, the film has, but unfortunately, that missing footage has been lost forever, it seems. They have the audio. So they kind of cover it. They almost like storyboard it.
17:34 Chris Winterbauer? Exactly.
17:34 Lizzie Bassett? With production stills, which is pretty clever and like it works, but it is unfortunate that that's gone. Even though the film was adored by critics and audiences, it did not make money because it had been so expensive behind the scenes. So fast forward to 1976.
17:49 Chris Winterbauer? Oh, yeah.
17:51 Lizzie Bassett? Here we go.
17:52 Chris Winterbauer? It's my least favorite one of the four.
17:54 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah. We finally move into the music industry with the absolutely batshit bonkers Barbara Streisand and Kris Kristofferson version. Uh, yeah, we can just, we can kind of zip along this one.
18:06 Chris Winterbauer? We can do it. Nothing to see here, folks.
18:10 Lizzie Bassett? Again, produced by Warner Brothers. It does win an Oscar for Best Original Song for Evergreen and it's a song. I don't know. Listen, listen, Barbara, Barbara's great. But it's not her best.
18:24 Chris Winterbauer? I, I think it's, if you look at it as like a stepping stone to the 2018 version, right? It, it gets you part of the way there, if that makes sense. I think it's easier to appreciate.
18:34 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, it has a lot of similarities to the 2018 version, including he sees her at a nightclub while looking for a drink after his gig, although this is a connection to previous versions because he always finds her at an after-hours club. He brings her on stage for her big break. After he drives his car off the road and dies, in this version, she performs at his memorial service, singing a song that he wrote for her. Of course, we see that again here. And she does introduce herself with his surname at that memorial, although again, that's something that actually all of the versions did. So I would argue that yes, there are a lot of similarities. I think the biggest thing is that it moves us into the music industry instead of Hollywood. But I think it really is just building off of existing Star is Born franchise tropes and
19:15 Lizzie Bassett? kind of translating them. People do love this version. God bless you. If you, if you like this one, it is something and it did very well at the box office. That's all I'm gonna say about that.
19:28 Chris Winterbauer? And didn't this one also kind of establish, wasn't John Peters a producer on this movie? And I believe that it's kind of what broke him in.
19:35 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, we're gonna get to John Peters.
19:37 Chris Winterbauer? You'll see his name in the credits of the 2018 version as well.
19:40 Lizzie Bassett? Which we will talk about. That caused some not great press for it. Yes. If you're not familiar who John Peters is, he was a very famous Hollywood hairstylist who eventually became a big producer. I believe the film Shampoo was loosely based on him. And he was Barbra Streisand's partner during this time, among many other things. So we've got a consistently commercially successful and sometimes critically successful IP. Chris, what does Hollywood do next?
20:07 Chris Winterbauer? Make it again.
20:08 Lizzie Bassett? That's right. Make it again.
20:09 Chris Winterbauer? But first, put it in development hell.
20:11 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, I was gonna say, we're finally at the Gaga and Cooper version, except we're not, because it has to go through 20 years of development.
20:23 Chris Winterbauer? This podcast is supported by Article. Guys, after my family lost our house in the Eaton Canyon fires, we needed new furniture ASAP for our rental. We needed stuff that would arrive quickly, ideally be pretty stylish and be durable, because we got a couple of young kids, which is why we ordered the Sennow dining table in walnut from Article and it showed up within days at our new rental. And our kids started beating up on it and it still looks great over a year later. Since then, we've added a couch, the Senni sectional, and we have just become bigger fans of Article. Article makes it effortless for you to create a stylish, long-lasting home at truly unbeatable prices. Not only do you not have to wait for stuff to be shipped from warehouses all over the world for weeks and weeks, it arrives
21:05 Chris Winterbauer? quickly and it will last. Again, we have two kids under five. I cannot believe that our dining table and our sectional still look great. Article's offering our listeners $50 off your first purchase of $100 or more. To claim, visit article.com/wrong and the discount will be automatically applied at checkout. That's article.com/wrong for $50 off your first purchase of $100 or more. This podcast is supported by Monarch. Guys, there's nothing more difficult than paying down debt. It can feel like a true Sisyphean task, like you're pushing that rock up that hill, like you're running up that hill, like you are Kate Bush running up that hill. I don't know if that's technically what that song's about, but we're going to use it as a metaphor here. The point is, debt's a lot easier to tackle when you can see the finish line, and that's where Monarch comes in.
21:49 Chris Winterbauer? Monarch's debt paydown simulator and visualizer shows you the exact date that you're going to be debt-free based on your real-time balances and payments. Plus, you can test out different payment options to see which one's going to fit your schedule best. I love Monarch because it doesn't just tell me what I've spent, it helps me set out goals, map out big purchases, pay down my debt, and figure out how to do these things before it's too late to adjust. So, write your own money story with Monarch. Use code WRONG at monarch.com to get your first year of Monarch Core half off at just $50. That's 50% off your first year at monarch.com with code WRONG.
22:28 Speaker 03 The next chapter is here. The Hulu original series, The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County, is coming to Hulu and Hulu on Disney+ on November 12.
22:37 Speaker 04 We've all been shaped by Mormonism in one way or another.
22:40 Speaker 05 But there are moral divides that are pushing everyone to opposite directions. I am here to be a good example for the church.
22:47 Speaker 04 I think it's a cult.
22:48 Speaker 05 We're gonna have a problem.
22:49 Speaker 03 Watch the Hulu original series, The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County, November 12, streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney+ for bundle subscribers. Terms apply.
23:06 Lizzie Bassett? So, as early as 1999, there are mentions in the trades of a fourth version of A Star is Born that has been germinating. Warner Brothers began developing the film with Carl Franklin, director. At that point, he'd directed One False Move, Devil in a Blue Dress, and One True Thing, amongst some other things. And they had a very specific actor in mind to play the leading role. Chris, do you know who it is? I will tell you. Age-wise, it doesn't make a ton of sense, because he's only about 31 at this point.
23:32 Chris Winterbauer? 31. Is this a musical version, or is it a...
23:35 Lizzie Bassett? Yes.
23:37 Chris Winterbauer? Jamie Foxx.
23:38 Lizzie Bassett? He's gonna come in later. It's not him right now.
23:40 Chris Winterbauer? All right, that would have been too early. I don't know. Who?
23:42 Lizzie Bassett? Will Smith.
23:43 Chris Winterbauer? Oh, you know what's funny? I swear to God, I was considering Will Smith. And I was like, but he doesn't sing. He raps.
23:50 Lizzie Bassett? It could have been a rapping Norman Maine. You don't know.
23:53 Chris Winterbauer? I, I agree. That was Chris being prejudicial. I should not have made that assumption.
23:58 Lizzie Bassett? That's right. They're also courting Lauryn Hill to be the lead.
24:01 Chris Winterbauer? Oh.
24:01 Lizzie Bassett? She would have been good.
24:02 Chris Winterbauer? Very good.
24:03 Lizzie Bassett? So Smith eventually passes to play Muhammad Ali in Ali. Probably a good move as that really transitioned him into a more serious actor. And he's very good in that.
24:12 Chris Winterbauer? With Jamie Foxx.
24:13 Lizzie Bassett? Yes. And funny you should mention Mr. Fox because by 2000, we've moved on to Jamie Foxx teaming up with Oliver Stone for A Star is Born.
24:23 Chris Winterbauer? Okay, that sounds like a fun version of the movie.
24:26 Lizzie Bassett? What would this have been like?
24:28 Chris Winterbauer? It's also a conspiracy theory movie about how Hollywood is run by the guys who assassinated JFK.
24:34 Lizzie Bassett? Honestly, I would watch it.
24:36 Chris Winterbauer? Wildly entertaining. Love Oliver Stone.
24:38 Lizzie Bassett? They had just teamed up for Any Given Sunday, which obviously was a big hit.
24:41 Chris Winterbauer? I love Any Given Sunday. So ridiculous.
24:44 Lizzie Bassett? They actually had a finished script for this one. I think they got pretty far.
24:47 Chris Winterbauer? Wow.
24:48 Lizzie Bassett? But no leading lady. So Fox goes after Lauryn Hill again. But this time, she won't even pick up the phone for them, to the point where Fox said he felt like a stalker because he was showing up at her concerts and tracking her moves. At one point, she finally said, quote, "You're making me nervous." So Fox drops it, saying, "I guess she's busy with her children." Leave her alone. Leave her alone. She doesn't want to do this.
25:15 Chris Winterbauer? I love getting that message. It's like, "You're making me nervous." And he's like, "Ah, I guess she's busy with her kids."
25:21 Chris Winterbauer? That's what you draw from it.
25:24 Lizzie Bassett? So he turns to another major R&B hitmaker at the time for the lead role, Aaliyah.
25:31 Chris Winterbauer? Oh, with, uh, Queen of the Damned.
25:33 Lizzie Bassett? That's right. She was filming Queen of the Damned at the time.
25:36 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah.
25:36 Lizzie Bassett? She expressed interest in the project and was excited to read the script, but on August 25th, 2001, she tragically died in a plane crash at the age of 22 years old.
25:47 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah.
25:48 Lizzie Bassett? This seems to be where Fox and Stone kind of lose interest and drop the project. But Warner Brothers will never give this up. And so sometime around 2002, Will Smith reenters the picture. This time, he's teaming up with director Joel Schumacher, and the two of them are courting Jennifer Lopez for the lead.
26:09 Chris Winterbauer? I like it.
26:10 Lizzie Bassett? They want to base it in the world of Latin music.
26:12 Chris Winterbauer? Fun.
26:12 Lizzie Bassett? I mean, she's great in Selena. According to a 2018 interview with J-Lo, they got pretty serious about this and discussed the script quite a bit, but the project never took off, and they all went their separate ways.
26:22 Chris Winterbauer? Well, she went to Jee Lee.
26:26 Lizzie Bassett? Oops.
26:27 Chris Winterbauer? Sorry. Just saying. Timing lines up.
26:30 Lizzie Bassett? Yep. So next, A Star is Born lays dormant for eight years, like the Ring of Power, lying in wait for Gollum to snatch it up. And this time, our slimy cave dweller is Nick Cassavetes.
26:42 Chris Winterbauer? Wow, okay.
26:43 Lizzie Bassett? Director. Yeah. He just directed John Q. The Notebook. And Alpha Dog.
26:49 Chris Winterbauer? I know. It's always wild to me that a Cassavetes directed The Notebook. Nothing wrong with it. It's just not the combo you would have expected.
26:58 Lizzie Bassett? No. Also, John Q. The Notebook plus Alpha Dog doesn't necessarily equal A Star is Born to me, but I guess it could.
27:05 Chris Winterbauer? Why not?
27:06 Lizzie Bassett? Sure. In January of 2010, it's announced that he is in early talks to join the project, mostly because of how much he liked a draft by writer Will Fetters. So I think this is the first time that we are seeing the earliest iteration of the actual 2018 version we wind up with. And again, this is 2010. So Cassavetes is interested in a leading lady, who apparently had been in discussion before as well, and that is who, Chris? Haven't mentioned her yet, but you did.
27:32 Chris Winterbauer? I mentioned her.
27:33 Lizzie Bassett? You did.
27:34 Chris Winterbauer? Mariah Carey? Beyonce?
27:36 Lizzie Bassett? There we go. The queen be herself.
27:37 Chris Winterbauer? I just want it to be Mariah Carey.
27:39 Lizzie Bassett? It's never Mariah Carey. They've seen glitter.
27:44 Lizzie Bassett? So Alicia Keys and Rihanna are both under consideration too, as are Robert Downey Jr. And Jon Hamm. What is this movie?
27:54 Chris Winterbauer? I actually think Robert Downey Jr., Alicia Keys would have been really interesting.
27:59 Lizzie Bassett? That's true. I could maybe see that.
28:00 Chris Winterbauer? I think Robert Downey Jr. As the quick talking, extremely charming, self-destructive alcoholic. I mean, God, the guy could draw on his own past with substance abuse.
28:10 Lizzie Bassett? That's true.
28:11 Chris Winterbauer? I think that'd be, and I, I think Alicia Keys is extremely magnetic. I think they would be really interesting opposite one another.
28:17 Lizzie Bassett? She is. My understanding is that she kind of withdrew herself from the running because she felt like this was maybe a little too close to some of her own experiences. And so she was just like, nah, I don't, I don't want to do something sort of within the music industry like this.
28:32 Chris Winterbauer? Fair.
28:33 Lizzie Bassett? But by February, Chris, and this is my favorite pairing of the whole episode. Another actor emerged as the frontrunner. I just can't, I just, I was like crying, laughing, trying to imagine what this.
28:46 Chris Winterbauer? I feel bad for whoever this is.
28:49 Lizzie Bassett? Don't. He's fine. It is, of course.
28:55 Chris Winterbauer? Jesus.
28:56 Lizzie Bassett? Sorry.
28:59 Lizzie Bassett? Russell Crowe.
29:00 Chris Winterbauer? Oh my God, yes. This would be, I would love this. I love Russell Crowe. And it would have been so fun.
29:08 Lizzie Bassett? It was gonna be Russell Crowe opposite Beyonce as directed by the director of The Notebook.
29:14 Chris Winterbauer? This sounds great. I, I love it. And give Russell Crowe an Italian accent and a Vespa.
29:20 Lizzie Bassett? Oh.
29:20 Chris Winterbauer? Like this sounds great.
29:23 Lizzie Bassett? Absolutely. This was his turn towards the pre-sexorcist 20 years earlier.
29:30 Chris Winterbauer? I, I think, look, Russell Crowe is an amazing actor.
29:35 Lizzie Bassett? I love him.
29:35 Chris Winterbauer? As we learned, as we learned in Les Miserables, he is not the strongest singer, I think by his own admission. So that makes it a little unusual if it's got the musical angle. And I think what we learned about Beyonce and Austin Powers is she's an incredible singer and she's not the strongest actress.
29:50 Lizzie Bassett? I agree.
29:50 Chris Winterbauer? So I think this would have been a very. Dangerous pairing on screen.
29:57 Lizzie Bassett? I think so too. I, yeah, I mean, listen, Beehive, please don't come after us. I think she's an absolutely incredible performer, musician, businesswoman, everything. I've seen Dreamgirls, I've seen Austin Powers. She's, she's not amazing as an actress and like especially opposite Russell Crowe, it just would have been so weird. That being said, give it to me right now. I want to see it.
30:18 Chris Winterbauer? Exactly. I want to mainline this.
30:20 Lizzie Bassett? Yes. But by January of 2011, Cassavetes has exited stage right and the project has been picked up by a much more massive director and that is because Clint Eastwood has hopped on board the Star is Born train.
30:35 Chris Winterbauer? Nice.
30:36 Lizzie Bassett? Will Fetters has stayed on as the screenwriter and Beyonce has managed to stay on as the star. Now, I, I think Beyonce with a stronger director, maybe, and a stronger lead. Cause obviously she's-
30:48 Chris Winterbauer? You're saying Beyonce with Mr. You get two takes Clint Eastwood is going to be the right fit?
30:53 Lizzie Bassett? All right, maybe not. That's true. That's true.
30:57 Chris Winterbauer? Nope, moving on.
30:58 Lizzie Bassett? Oh, boy. And he is pursuing a whole new actor for the lead role. You gotta get this one, right, Chris? Who do you think this is?
31:09 Chris Winterbauer? I have no context. What?
31:11 Lizzie Bassett? He doesn't date anybody over the age of 25.
31:14 Chris Winterbauer? Leonardo DiCaprio.
31:15 Lizzie Bassett? There you go.
31:16 Chris Winterbauer? Can he sing?
31:18 Lizzie Bassett? I don't know. Probably not. Now, you mentioned this before, but controversial Hollywood producer, John Peters, is set to be one of the producers on this. He was Barbara's boyfriend, like I said, and his involvement in the franchise will come with controversy later on. Also, it seems that it's around this time that Live Nation starts to express interest in being a part of the film as producers, though they don't come fully on board until later too. Around 2011 or 2012, Eastwood approaches Bradley Cooper for the role of the aging rock star.
31:48 Chris Winterbauer? That's a lot earlier than I would have expected.
31:52 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah.
31:52 Chris Winterbauer? That's, I guess that's a few years removed from Wedding Crashers and must be post First Hangover?
32:00 Lizzie Bassett? Yes. So, we can breathe a sigh of relief because we've almost made it to our final version. Just kidding, because Bradley Cooper turns it down. He was only 38 at the time and correctly felt that it was, he was too young to pull it off, which I think is right.
32:15 Chris Winterbauer? I agree.
32:16 Lizzie Bassett? By 2012, the project was dead again with Beyonce and Clint Eastwood unable to line up their schedules, according to Beyonce. Producer Bill Gerber blamed it on her being pregnant, saying, quote, "There was a moment where that was the best version of the movie and then all of a sudden Beyonce got pregnant. Do we wait?"
32:33 Chris Winterbauer? And then she decided to have a family. That bitch.
32:38 Lizzie Bassett? Do we wait for Beyonce? I don't know, maybe.
32:41 Chris Winterbauer? What?
32:45 Lizzie Bassett? He does acknowledge that she was amazing about it, saying, quote, "She always understood if we were going to take a different direction and then Clint went off and did another movie." Okay, so was that the problem?
32:54 Chris Winterbauer? No, and we're being uncharitable. It's the-
32:56 Lizzie Bassett? They're both impossible, yeah.
32:58 Chris Winterbauer? Of course, and the other folks involved, I'm sure, are pouring their lives into trying to get this thing made and here you have two people, it's trying to get the planets to align. You know, they have enormous gravitational pulls, so I understand the frustration. I don't mean to belittle their concerns.
33:17 Lizzie Bassett? No, it's just, it's a funny quote. I'm sorry, Bill Gerber, I set you up to fail there.
33:21 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah.
33:22 Lizzie Bassett? The movie that Clint left for was likely American Sniper, which of course stars our one true Jackson main, Bradley Cooper. There we go. While working on the film, it seems like Cooper expressed interest in directing, something he had long dreamed of, and discussed reviving A Star is Born as the director himself with Clint. They saw Annie Lennox perform I Put a Spell on You, and this lit a fire under Cooper's butt. He woke up the next day, called Greg Silverman, the head of Warner Brothers at the time, and asked to pitch him a crazy idea, and it was the way that he saw A Star is Born, how he felt the camera moving, everything. So Silverman said, "Okay, go write it." In 2015, Clint Eastwood announced he is officially passing the Star is Born torch to Bradley Cooper, who will make his directorial debut with the film.
34:06 Lizzie Bassett? So, finally, let's get a little background on Bradley Cooper. He was born in 1975 in Abington Township, Pennsylvania. You mentioned the tinnitus. He actually was born with cholesteatoma, a growth in the middle ear that causes deafness and had to have an operation right away. Later, when he began diving, he punctured his eardrum and had to have four to five surgeries between the ages of five and 18 to try to fix it, but he still has a hole in his eardrum.
34:36 Chris Winterbauer? Hmm.
34:37 Lizzie Bassett? He studied English and French in undergrad, made a brief television debut in 1999 on Sex and the City, and then famously attended the Actors Studio at the New School, where he received his MFA. I say famously because there are several clips of Cooper asking questions to actors like Sean Penn and Robert De Niro on YouTube and TikTok.
34:53 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, I've seen the De Niro ones.
34:56 Lizzie Bassett? He makes his film debut in Wet Hot American Summer in 2001.
34:59 Chris Winterbauer? He's very good. He's very funny.
35:02 Lizzie Bassett? And then breaks out even more with the role of Will Tippin on Alias. It's on the second season of Alias, however, that Cooper hits a low point in his career. He was frustrated that his role had been severely diminished between the first and second seasons of the show. He was also struggling with drug and alcohol abuse at the time and spiraled into a depression where he started to think that he wanted to kill himself. He told The Hollywood Reporter that once, quote, "I was at a party and deliberately bashed my head on the concrete floor, like, hey, look how tough I am, and I came up and blood dripped down, and then I did it again. I spent the night at St. Vincent's Hospital with a sock of ice waiting for them to stitch me up." Against the advice of all of his friends, he asked J.J. Abrams to write him off the show, even though he had no other job prospects lined up.
35:45 Lizzie Bassett? Abrams did, and fortunately, by 2004, Cooper, at age 29, got and stayed sober. You mentioned this, but it is Wedding Crashers in 2005 that really puts him on the map, and then 2009's The Hangover that makes him a bona fide star. Around 2012, he starts to take on more dramatic roles in Place Beyond the Pines, and of course, Silver Linings Playbook, for which he was nominated for an Oscar. So now with Clint Eastwood's blessing, Cooper begins working on the script, but he still needs a star. Prior to Lady Gaga entering the picture, he did go back to a familiar well and pitched Beyonce on the project. He got sign off from Greg Silverman to go for her if he made the movie for under $25 million. That feels like just her fee, so I don't know how
36:30 Chris Winterbauer? I was gonna say.
36:31 Lizzie Bassett? that was possibly gonna work.
36:33 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, that's probably why he set that bar at $25 million, basically.
36:39 Lizzie Bassett? There's no way.
36:40 Chris Winterbauer? If we could get Beyonce, or if we could get her to do it for a song, that would be a huge win for the studio. Beyonce, at $25 million, you're going to make money.
36:49 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, but there's no, like, why would she do that?
36:51 Chris Winterbauer? No, I know, of course.
36:52 Lizzie Bassett? She could command so much more than that.
36:53 Chris Winterbauer? Well, and she, her, it doesn't seem like her interest is acting anyway, so there's not much of a carrot there.
36:57 Lizzie Bassett? I don't know about that. I actually think she was invested in this, the idea of making this movie. She was very courteous.
37:04 Chris Winterbauer? I, I guess I'm saying it didn't seem like she had, like, dreams of Oscar glory, and you know what I'm saying, in the way that maybe she did in the music industry.
37:11 Lizzie Bassett? I don't know. Dreamgirls might, I think, I think she had her eye on something.
37:14 Chris Winterbauer? All right, fair.
37:15 Lizzie Bassett? Apparently, she was very courteous. Cooper went to her house to pitch her on it. This is one of my favorite facts in the entire thing. Jay-Z was in the background watching Judge Judy the entire time.
37:26 Chris Winterbauer? Good on you, Jay-Z.
37:27 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah. Bradley Cooper was freaking out and said that he had a weird nervous little cough that he couldn't shake the whole time because he's trying to pitch Beyonce on a Star is Born with Judge Judy playing in the background. Despite all of this, it seems like she was again interested, and they developed it for kind of a long time, like, maybe almost a year before it fell through.
37:45 Chris Winterbauer? Wow.
37:46 Lizzie Bassett? Next, he approached Adele, who only texted him back once, to say she was busy.
37:51 Chris Winterbauer? I'm busy.
37:52 Lizzie Bassett? I'm busy. Good for her.
37:53 Chris Winterbauer? New phone, who dis? My Cockney Adele. Apologies, Adele.
37:58 Lizzie Bassett? Finally, in 2016, Cooper attended a benefit concert in Sean Parker's backyard, where he saw one Stephanie Germanotta, aka Lady Gaga, perform, and he knew he had found his alley. Guess what song she sang?
38:11 Chris Winterbauer? Love You and Rose?
38:12 Lizzie Bassett? Yes.
38:13 Chris Winterbauer? Oh, good job, Chris. One guess correct this whole episode.
38:16 Lizzie Bassett? He did it. Let's talk about Lady Gaga.
38:26 Speaker 00 Verizon FiOS celebrates the holiday hostess with the mostest. When the whole family's over, you've got Verizon FiOS whole home Wi-Fi. Fast, reliable, 100% fiber internet in every room. So your little nephews can blast video games on full volume. Your daughter can stream football under the dinner table. And grandpa can turn on the same movie for the third time. A full house with full Wi-Fi coverage. So everyone can do their own thing together. 100% fiber internet for 100% holiday hosts. Switch to Verizon FiOS today. All home Wi-Fi included with all FiOS gig plans. Availability varies.
38:56 Speaker 06 Some travelers want the charm of an independent hotel. Others want the confidence of a trusted global brand. With Series by Marriott, you get both. Each property is uniquely connected to its destination, delivering local experiences and memorable stays, while being backed by the quality, reliability, and Marriott Bonvoy benefits travelers know and trust. Experience the destination without the compromise. Series by Marriott is part of Marriott Bonvoy. Book direct at marriott.com or on the Marriott Bonvoy app.
39:27 Speaker 03 The next chapter is here. The Hulu original series, The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County, is coming to Hulu and Hulu on Disney+ on November 12.
39:36 Speaker 04 We've all been shaped by Mormonism in one way or another.
39:39 Speaker 05 But there are moral divides that are pushing everyone to opposite directions. I am here to be a good example for the church.
39:46 Speaker 04 I think it's a cult.
39:47 Speaker 05 We're gonna have a problem.
39:48 Speaker 03 Watch the Hulu original series, The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County, November 12, streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney+ for Bumble subscribers. Terms apply.
40:06 Lizzie Bassett? Stephanie Germanato was born in New York City in 1986. She describes herself as an outcast and misfit throughout school, but she was incredibly talented musically from a very young age, starting to study piano at four. In 2003, she gained early admission to NYU's Tisch School for the Arts in CAP 21, which I want to mention is an acting and musical theater program. Remember that. But just two years later withdrew to focus on music full-time.
40:31 Chris Winterbauer? I also started studying piano at four. And I podcast.
40:37 Lizzie Bassett? I'll let Gaga explain this transition into music herself in this interview with SAG-AFTRA.
40:43 Speaker 06 I've been thinking a lot about this recently, and I think that because I always wanted to be an actress before I wanted to be a singer, you know, I studied at the Lee Strasberg Institute, I did some Meisner, I did some Adler, I went to Circle in the Square for a little while, you know, I kind of had it in me. And I've, over the years, created characters for myself because I could not get a job as an actress. So I became a musician that acted as well.
41:15 Chris Winterbauer? Makes sense. I mean, her performances are very much a persona.
41:20 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, that is Gaga speaking at a SAG-AFTRA Q and A, by the way. And I play that because, like, she's rattling off some of the best acting training that you can possibly get. So I'll just leave that there.
41:33 Chris Winterbauer? She's exceptional as an actress in the movie. She doesn't feel like an amateur. She does not feel raw in the way that you might expect a musician to feel. She's extremely natural. It's clear they have a good rapport and chemistry as well. But even her scenes with Andrew Dice Clay, who I really like as her father, are really charming. And she, again, just feels like very comfortable and she can hold her own with anybody in the movie.
42:02 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, I agree. I think she's amazing, both as an actor and a singer in this. Unfortunately, the next thing that happens to Stephanie is very upsetting. Sometime around the age of 19, she was raped by a music producer, something that led to a psychotic break and has caused her years of PTSD and physical pain, which led to self-harm and some drug abuse. She has chosen not to ever name this person, so we're not going to do any speculating. I mention it because I do think it's important that both Gaga and Cooper had extensive personal experience with trauma, substance abuse, and depression. Just three years later, in 2008, she became a household name as Lady Gaga with her album, "The Fame," featuring hits like "Poker Face" and "Just Dance." By 2015, she was one of the most successful artists in the world.
42:47 Lizzie Bassett? By 2016, she earned her first Oscar nomination for co-writing the original song from "The Hunting Ground" with Diane Warren. Also in 2016, she won a Golden Globe for her performance on "American Horror Story: Hotel." I'm telling you all of this just to make it very clear that she was not exactly untested as an actress by the time "A Star is Born" came around.
43:07 Chris Winterbauer? She was also bigger than Bradley Cooper in terms of international Q-rating by a mile at this point.
43:15 Lizzie Bassett? Yes. So naturally, the studio took one look at Lady Gaga and said, "I don't know."
43:22 Chris Winterbauer? What's that? What's her name? Lady?
43:25 Lizzie Bassett? They said, "We'll see. Do a screen test." And not just a screen test for, at that point, six-time Grammy-winning artist Gaga, but a screen test for her and Academy Award-nominated actor Bradley Cooper. So, Chris, how unusual is that for people of their stature?
43:43 Lizzie Bassett? And this is not a chemistry. This is like to get it greenlit.
43:47 Chris Winterbauer? "I don't know," is the short answer. I've never been involved with a project of this scale, obviously. Normally, what I've heard of is that if they had a number of actresses or performers, like they were down to three, and they were like, "Well, let's get Cooper on screen with all three, and let's see how they do." But if it's more, if they're really just saying, "Well, we need to see her chops."
44:05 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah.
44:06 Chris Winterbauer? That seems more unusual. And I guess the question would be, would they have done the same thing with Beyoncé? And we don't know the answer to that. It doesn't seem likely.
44:14 Lizzie Bassett? Oh, I don't think so. I think they were fully on board for her. They were fully on board to sign her on. And I'm...
44:19 Chris Winterbauer? Which is interesting, because as you mentioned, Gaga definitely has more experience, although I guess she has a technically thinner on-screen resume in the sense that if she just had "American Horror Story," there was less footage for them to see. And that's also such a heightened, campy, stylistic show.
44:35 Lizzie Bassett? Sure. And all of her theatrical performances are also very heightened, very campy. So that's a good point. But Bradley Cooper did not initially want to do this, because this felt like a bit of a slap in the face.
44:46 Chris Winterbauer? She's bigger than him, and I think he's probably very smart about that and realizes, like, this is a get if we can get her.
44:53 Lizzie Bassett? Also, Clint Eastwood was not sure that Gaga was gonna be right for the role. And this is something I don't understand throughout this whole thing. So many people were like, we're not sure she makes sense. And I don't get it, cuz like, I remember when they announced this, and hearing that she was the lead in this was the most appealing part of going to go see this movie.
45:12 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, I'm trying to think of a reason other than a lot of the reasons that they write into the film that are actually so compelling. When she discusses her nose, the way she looks. She's also, I know, I guess, what, she's technically a mezzo-soprano, but she has a huskier, I would argue, like, speaking voice. She's, does she have, really have like a Long Island, like, kind of accent?
45:35 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, I think so. She's, I mean, she's an Italian-American woman from Manhattan.
45:39 Chris Winterbauer? Exactly, she feels a little rough around the edges in a way that works so perfectly in the movie, but maybe the studio thought, oh, well, she's not really polished, you know? How is she gonna appeal on screen? I don't know.
45:51 Lizzie Bassett? I don't know either. I think perhaps part of it is that she had made a career out of, you know, not quite looking like herself, which was intentional, because as she's spoken about a lot, you know, she had a hard time with people giving her shit for her looks, even though she is beautiful.
46:07 Chris Winterbauer? I didn't really know what she looked like until I saw this movie.
46:10 Lizzie Bassett? A lot of people have said that. And I get it, but at the same time, could you really not be willing to see beyond that or underneath it to give her a chance to do something else? But they did, so that's good. Eventually Bradley Cooper decides to take it in stride and treat it as his first chance to really direct. So he writes 10 pages of dialogue, calls up Lady Gaga, and they agree to shoot the screen test at her house. They also very casually call upon Janusz Kaminski to shoot it. He had worked with her on her Alejandro video, great video. He's only Steven Spielberg's DP since Schindler's List, so no big deal. So much of what you see in this movie is the two of them calling in massive, massive favors. You can watch some of the footage from the screen test online. It looks gorgeous.
46:54 Lizzie Bassett? Cooper didn't really have the character of Jackson Maine created at this point, and you can see from the footage, he looks very clean-cut, not so leathery, and he has a little earring, which he swiftly realized was a mistake.
47:09 Lizzie Bassett? Now, much has been made of Bradley Cooper wiping off Gaga's makeup at the screen test. Here's how the LA Times describes it. She walked downstairs, and there he was staring at her. He stepped toward her, examined her face, concealer, mascara, rouge. "Take it off," Bradley Cooper told Lady Gaga. She noticed something in his hand. It was a makeup wipe. With it, he er- Hold on.
47:38 Chris Winterbauer? I thought he was gonna have something else in his hand, the way you're talking.
47:40 Lizzie Bassett? Hold on. This is my audition for Smutty Audiobooks.
47:45 Chris Winterbauer? Great.
47:46 Lizzie Bassett? With it, he erased the colors from her forehead down to her chin. But he left her neck. Oh, God. Left a real weird line at her chin. This journalist is an incredible fanfic writer. So, in reality, the scene he had written featured Ally just waking up in bed, and Cooper correctly assumed that she would not have slept in her makeup. I just want to say thank you, Bradley Cooper. That's one of my least favorite things that I see in movies, is when women wake up fully made up. You don't do that. You would have fucked up skin if you did that. So, when she showed up fully made up, he realized it wasn't gonna read right, and he asked if he could wipe the makeup off, because she wouldn't have gone to bed with it.
48:26 Chris Winterbauer? Which, of course, mirrors a famous scene from the 1954 version where Norman Maine, "Not so sweetly."
48:34 Lizzie Bassett? No. Smears cold cream all over her face, yeah.
48:37 Chris Winterbauer? And basically it says, "You look like a clown, honey," as he rubs the makeup off of Judy Garland's face.
48:42 Lizzie Bassett? "You stayed in the chair about an hour too long."
48:44 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah. It's a very funny scene. I really liked it, but yeah, it's not quite as romantic.
48:50 Lizzie Bassett? I do honestly think if he hadn't done this, the studio might not have gone for it. I know that sounds dumb, but like, to what we were just talking about, she doesn't look like Lady Gaga. She is wearing nothing. She has no makeup on. I think that was really important, and I think he knew that. This also feels like sort of the beginning of this romanticization of the two of them that we see throughout the rest of the press tour.
49:16 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, I remember their performance at the Oscars, right? Where it was.
49:20 Lizzie Bassett? Of course, they gotta Googleize at each other. It's fine.
49:23 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah.
49:23 Lizzie Bassett? But again, this moment, not quite as sassy as it was portrayed in this article.
49:30 Chris Winterbauer? I think that's just how all women look at Bradley Cooper. I was, my wife was watching A Star is Born. I was like, we need to turn this off. This is, uh, this is not fun.
49:37 Lizzie Bassett? He's the only Jackson Maine who is actually attractive.
49:40 Chris Winterbauer? He's very attractive.
49:41 Lizzie Bassett? So the screen test does the trick and Warner Brothers greenlights the film. It also does the trick for Gaga, who realized how badly she wanted the part after this experience. And part of that may have been realizing that Cooper actually could sing. Here she is talking about that moment on the Graham Norton Show.
49:56 Speaker 05 And then he wanted to sing with me, a song by Creedence Clearwater Revival, Midnight Special. So I was playing it on the piano and he started to sing and I was like, oh my gosh, Bradley, your voice. I was blown away by him. I mean, he just, he sings from his soul. He sings from his gut. And when he sings, he's a storyteller and I was just so moved by his passion, you know, for, for, for music and for this film. And quite frankly, it was him that had to convince other people to have me in the movie. Not anyone trying to convince me. I mean, he really fought for me.
50:33 Chris Winterbauer? Quite a compliment.
50:34 Lizzie Bassett? This video of them singing Midnight Special was a big part of what got the film fully greenlit, along with the screen test. So in August of 2016, she's announced as the lead. Now, she wasn't the only actor that Cooper had his heart set on from the beginning. He had always had Sam Elliott in mind for the role of his older brother, Bobby. So much so that he actually based Jackson Maine's voice on Sam Elliott's natural speaking voice and had been working with a vocal coach on it for months. To get Sam Elliott on board, Cooper played him a tape of himself doing Sam Elliott's voice. It was an interview Elliott had given at Sundance a few years earlier, but again, it was Cooper doing all the dialogue. Fortunately, this didn't creep Sam Elliott out and he signed on.
51:14 Chris Winterbauer? I bet you he was just like, goddamn, sounds just like me. You're a good man. I'll do your picture. All right.
51:20 Lizzie Bassett? Andrew Dice Clay was cast as Ally's father after a chance encounter with Bradley Cooper at the Troubadour. Apparently Dice Clay said, "By the way, you were good, an American sniper."
51:29 Chris Winterbauer? It was good, those snipes. Those are good snipes. You did.
51:32 Lizzie Bassett? His agent sent an email to Todd Phillips, also a producer on this film, saying that Dice was "a weirdly good actor," and that was enough to get him a meeting and he got the part.
51:40 Chris Winterbauer? He is a weirdly good actor. He's very natural. I liked him.
51:44 Lizzie Bassett? Hamilton star Anthony Ramos was cast as Ally's best friend Ramon. I think he's great in this. I know it's a small part.
51:49 Chris Winterbauer? He's always, he's always super fun.
51:51 Lizzie Bassett? Dave Chappelle apparently took quite a bit of convincing to take the part. He had met Bradley Cooper briefly in London, but was surprised when Cooper showed up unannounced to Chappelle's annual barn party in Ohio.
52:02 Chris Winterbauer? Mm-hmm.
52:03 Lizzie Bassett? Cooper then called him every two days after that to get him on board, and Chappelle said that he agreed mostly to get Bradley Cooper to stop calling him. It's the old Jamie Foxx to Lauryn Hill tactic.
52:12 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, and I will not do my Dave Chappelle impression right now, but...
52:17 Lizzie Bassett? We'll hear from him a little later. He also said Cooper sent him the script and he never read it because he, quote, "didn't know the shit was gonna be good." I love this.
52:27 Chris Winterbauer? That checks out.
52:28 Lizzie Bassett? The running thing with Dave Chappelle throughout the entire press story is he actually had never seen the movie, I think, until the TIFF premiere. And afterwards, he was like, "Wait a minute. This is the best thing I've ever been in."
52:38 Chris Winterbauer? I was seeing this?
52:39 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, he's very surprised. It was time to polish the script that Cooper and Will Fetterer had been writing. Now, I had a hard time finding exactly why the studio wanted another writer brought on. The best I can tell is they thought that it needed a general polish. And it seems like Cooper did agree. That being said, I think the rewrite that happens may have been pretty substantial, given the actual co-writing credit that the writer got. So they bring on veteran screenwriter Eric Roth. He's written Forrest Gump, Munich, The Insider, Dune Part One, Killers of the Flower Moon.
53:11 Chris Winterbauer? If I were to guess, the script was too long.
53:15 Lizzie Bassett? That would make sense.
53:16 Chris Winterbauer? And they brought Eric Roth in because he has, across his career, handled very unwieldy narratives. Every movie you just mentioned, two-plus hours.
53:26 Lizzie Bassett? That's true.
53:26 Chris Winterbauer? Covering massive amounts of time. Forrest Gump, for example. And I wonder if it was, "Hey, come in here. Let's get the page count down. Let's streamline some of these sequences. How can we keep the pacing up?" You know what I mean? Without hitting a three-hour movie.
53:42 Lizzie Bassett? That does make sense. In addition to being an excellent screenwriter, he's also a self-proclaimed curmudgeon who does not like to visit set, uses a now-defunct screenwriting software called Movie Master that's completely incompatible with email, and only has so many pages of memory, he says. And he had no problem doling out some pretty harsh criticism to Cooper. They had their share of prickly moments throughout, but Roth says that's just a part of the process. He's also 73 years old, and he had eight weeks to do this rewrite. That being said, it sounds like he and Cooper did find a rhythm. Evidently, neither of them sleep very much, so they just stayed up all night for eight weeks texting each other ideas, and they wound up with something that they were happy with. Also, Gaga asked him what characters she should look for inspiration in, and he pointed her
54:25 Lizzie Bassett? to Cher in Moonstruck, which I think comes through.
54:28 Chris Winterbauer? Oh, I love Moonstruck.
54:31 Lizzie Bassett? One of my favorite movies of all time.
54:33 Chris Winterbauer? It's a great movie.
54:34 Lizzie Bassett? Some very due credit to Bradley Cooper here. It sounds like he was really the driving force behind making everything so conversational in this movie. Some of the dialogue is obviously improvised, but a lot is written very naturally. It was also his idea to have her sing the prelude to Somewhere Over the Rainbow at the top of the film as an ode to Judy.
54:53 Chris Winterbauer? Mm-hmm.
54:54 Lizzie Bassett? But of course, Chris, this is a musical, so the script wasn't the only thing they needed to write. They gotta write some songs. So Cooper and Gaga looped in the best of the best. The most major player on the soundtrack outside of Gaga herself is probably Lucas Nelson. If you don't know, he is Willie Nelson's son. He has his own band, The Promise of the Real. Cooper saw him at Desert Trip and immediately wanted him on board. He actually played Lucas Nelson, the recording of himself and Gaga singing Midnight Special, which is what got Nelson on board. They ended up working together on the music for over a year before filming. He also worked together with Lady Gaga very well, to the point where she sang on a few tracks on his album as well. Nelson, you will notice, appears on camera in the film. Did you know this, Chris?
55:37 Chris Winterbauer? No, I noticed a different member of the crew during a specific scene. Maddy Libetique, the cinematographer, plays the photographer
55:45 Lizzie Bassett? Oh.
55:46 Chris Winterbauer? when she's getting her headshots done.
55:47 Lizzie Bassett? I wasn't gonna mention it, but what a lovely cameo. No, so Lucas Nelson is the guitarist in Jackson Maine's band.
55:55 Chris Winterbauer? Oh, very cool.
55:56 Lizzie Bassett? And his entire band is The Promise of the Real. It is Lucas Nelson's band.
56:02 Chris Winterbauer? I had no idea.
56:03 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah. So even though Bradley Cooper did learn how to play guitar pretty damn well prior to the film, the guitar you're hearing is not him, it is Lucas Nelson playing. Out of 18 songs on the soundtrack, Gaga's credited as a writer or co-writer on 13 of them. Cooper co-wrote three. Lucas Nelson co-wrote almost all the songs on the soundtrack with the notable exception of "Shallow" and a few others. Now, one of the only songs with only one credited writer is "Maybe It's Time," the song that Jackson sings in the drag bar and then again later onstage that becomes kind of like one of his main staples.
56:36 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, "Maybe It's Time" to let the old ways die.
56:38 Lizzie Bassett? Very pretty song. It's written by Jason Isbell, who's one of my favorite musicians of all time. It sounds very much like a Jason Isbell song.
56:45 Chris Winterbauer? I thought it might be a real song. When I, it, it's probably, it feels like maybe the most fully baked, if that makes sense, of, of all the songs in the soundtrack. And the, and the, all the songs are great. Don't get me wrong.
56:56 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah. So Isbell was contacted by his producer, Dave Cobb, who was working with Cooper on the movie. And Jason Isbell's initial response was, quote, "No, Dave, I don't have time for that shit."
57:07 Chris Winterbauer? And he went back to hanging out with Dave Chappelle.
57:10 Lizzie Bassett? But his wife was like, "You're an idiot. Write this song for this movie." So he very begrudgingly wrote "Maybe It's Time" and sent it off to Cooper. Cooper sent back a demo to Isbell, and Isbell was scared to listen because he figured Bradley Cooper must suck at singing. But when he finally listened, he was very impressed, and he told Cooper so. I'll let Jason Isbell explain how this went down.
57:31 Speaker 06 He's a good-looking fella, you know. Normally, if you're that, if you're that handsome, you don't really have to learn how to sing. But he went through the process of learning how to sing, and he sent me a recording of this. Then I didn't listen to it because I thought, well, man, if this sucks, I'm not, I don't know if I could call him and be like, "Yeah, I'm sorry, Bradley. This sucks. I don't want your money. Your voice sounds like ass. Can't handle it." But, uh, so I didn't, I didn't listen to it. I waited for a few hours. I didn't know that he actually cared about my opinion until much later. He was doing an interview when the movie premiered, and he said he was sitting there staring at his phone for like five
58:15 Chris Winterbauer? Five hours, just sweating his ass off. Thinking, I don't know if he's gonna let me use the song. He might not like my voice, but luckily he did a good job. It's gotta be something he's bad at.
58:28 Chris Winterbauer? I like Jason Esbel, that was very funny.
58:30 Lizzie Bassett? He's great. Previous Gaga collaborators Mark Ronson, DJ White Shadow, and Hillary Lindsay were also brought on to write. Ronson, of course, co-wrote Shallow, along with some others.
58:45 Speaker 07 Hey, this is Penn and Kim Holderness from Laugh Lines. Some travelers want the charm of an independent hotel. Others want the confidence of a trusted global brand. With Series by Marriott, you get both. Each property is uniquely connected to its destination, delivering local experiences and memorable stays while being backed by the quality, reliability, and Marriott Bonvoy benefits that travelers know and trust. Experience the destination without the compromise. Series by Marriott is part of Marriott Bonvoy. Book direct at Marriott.com or on the Marriott Bonvoy app.
59:18 Speaker 00 Verizon Fios celebrates the holiday hostess with the mostess. When the whole family's over, you've got Verizon Fios Whole Home Wi-Fi. Fast, reliable, 100% fiber internet in every room. So your little nephews can blast video games on full volume. Your daughter can stream football under the dinner table. And grandpa can turn on the same movie for the third time. A full house with full Wi-Fi coverage. So everyone can do their own thing, together. 100% fiber internet for 100% holiday hosts. Switch to Verizon Fios today. All home Wi-Fi included with all Fios gig plans. Availability varies.
59:49 Speaker 03 The next chapter is here. The Hulu original series, The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County, is coming to Hulu and Hulu on Disney+ on November 12.
59:57 Speaker 04 We've all been shaped by Mormonism in one way or another. But there are moral divides that are pushing everyone to opposite directions.
1:00:05 Speaker 06 I am here to be a good example for the church. I think it's a cult.
1:00:09 Speaker 03 We're gonna have a problem. Watch the Hulu original series, The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County, November 12, streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney+ for bundle subscribers. Terms apply.
1:00:26 Lizzie Bassett? So in April of 2017, principal photography begins. Roth, who again famously hated being on set, seems to have broken his rule for this and kept writing through production. It did take Lady Gaga a little bit to loosen up. She is such a hard worker and she showed up to set with all of her lines completely memorized. So on the first day of shooting, Cooper immediately went off book to try and get her to loosen up, and she was so confused that she just started repeating her line back to him over and over again, and he asked her if she was okay. And she burst into tears.
1:00:56 Chris Winterbauer? Oh.
1:00:57 Lizzie Bassett? But she got over it very quickly, and he said that her learning curve just from day one to day two was absolutely crazy. You mentioned this, but he brought on legendary cinematographer Matthew Libatique on a recommendation from Jennifer Lawrence. He's probably best known for being Darren Aronofsky's go-to cinematographer on everything from Requiem for a Dream to Black Swan. Also has done a ton of music videos, so he makes a lot of sense for this. Early on, Cooper discussed the way that he saw the film being shot, all from the stage and from the performer's perspective. He got the idea from a Metallica concert where he was behind Lars Ulrich's drum kit, seeing the sweat drip off of him and realizing how crazy it was to be really on the stage with this level of performer.
1:01:37 Chris Winterbauer? Mm-hmm.
1:01:38 Lizzie Bassett? Libatique and Cooper also turned to iconic concert films like The Last Waltz and stopped making sense for inspiration on how to shoot the scenes. Chris, what do you think about the cinematography in this movie?
1:01:47 Chris Winterbauer? I think it's beautiful. I think it's very naturalistic. I think at first, it almost feels a little disorienting because it's anamorphic, super widescreen in like the first shots, and you're kind of wheeling around, you know, the stage with them. But then what you realize, or what I realized, is that, oh, we're drunk like him. And I think that's what the cinematography does so well in the movie, is that it really grounds you in the perspectives of these two characters and in their worlds. And it feels very naturalistic in the same way that I think the performances do, and Lizzie, as you mentioned, the dialogue does. So I think it works incredibly well across the movie.
1:02:26 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, I think it's one of the best parts of this movie. I think the choice to film all of the music and concert scenes exclusively from the stage, never from the audience's perspective, is really smart. And it's something that we haven't really seen in this kind of film before, I don't think. Speaking of the concert scenes, they were one of the most challenging aspects to film. Not only are they singing live the whole way through, which Lady Gaga insisted on, several of the scenes were shot at real festivals. The opening scene-
1:02:57 Chris Winterbauer? I was wondering.
1:02:58 Lizzie Bassett? This is crazy. So the opening scene with Jackson Maine, you mentioned this, where it's sort of reeling, it's very fast. There is a reason for that. It's because it was shot at Stagecoach in the eight minutes between Jamie Johnson and Willie Nelson's sets. That's it.
1:03:13 Chris Winterbauer? Wow.
1:03:14 Lizzie Bassett? Producer Bill Gerber called up Willie Nelson's manager, and apparently Nelson said, "Our stage is your stage." Probably helped that his son was playing in the band.
1:03:22 Chris Winterbauer? I was gonna say, hey, we got your kid a job. You wanna help us out?
1:03:27 Lizzie Bassett? So they also shot at Glastonbury, right before, of all people, Kris Kristofferson's set. This one is nuts, so much so that Matty Le Batteque turned to an unusual camera operator. The night before they were gonna go on, Metallica drummer Lars Ulrich, he's back, offered himself as a camera operator if they needed him. And Le Batteque was like, "What? No. Why would I do that?" But the day of, they learned that they didn't have 10 minutes like they thought. They had three minutes. So he was like, "Lars, you're on."
1:03:58 Chris Winterbauer? Here you go, buddy.
1:03:59 Lizzie Bassett? You're gonna take this camera, and you're gonna come on after me. So you are seeing the work of camera operator Lars Ulrich in that scene.
1:04:07 Chris Winterbauer? Wow.
1:04:08 Lizzie Bassett? Gaga was headlining Coachella that year, so they used the days between her sets to capture more. I believe this is "Always Remember Us This Way" and some other moments as well. This is not a real Coachella audience, those are extras. I also don't know this, but I think in those massive, massive Coachella scenes, my guess is that a lot of the crowd was added in post, because I don't think you would call in that many extras.
1:04:29 Chris Winterbauer? I would assume so.
1:04:31 Lizzie Bassett? They also shot at The Virgil for her opening number in the drag bar, the Greek Theatre for her first performance of Shallow. Excuse me, Sha-hello. And the Shrine Auditorium for the final scene, which is also where Judy taped "The Man That Got Away" from her version. Another nod to the Judy Garland one. A sad note about this final scene right before filming it, Gaga learned that her longtime friend was close to losing their battle with cancer. So she snuck off set and drove an hour to try and say goodbye, only to find out that she had actually missed her friend's death by 10 minutes. She drove straight back to set and they shot "I'll Never Love Again" in one take.
1:05:08 Chris Winterbauer? Wow.
1:05:10 Lizzie Bassett? Cooper would stay in character while directing scenes where Jackson was the most shitfaced. And here is Dave Chappelle at TIFF describing a little bit of what that was like.
1:05:21 Speaker 06 Literally, we would be just sitting before take and he would just talk to me about a scene. We would talk about the relationship with the characters. We would talk about, you know, what things were about. And then I would see that Bradley was slurring his words. And then as we were talking about, oh shit, we're shooting.
1:05:48 Speaker 06 But like for me, like, you know, I never really had much interest in being a movie actor. But if I were a movie actor, it'd be really hard to work with any other director because he's so sensitive to the emotional content of the characters and the people that are portraying the characters. It was amazing to see.
1:06:11 Chris Winterbauer? I will remind Mr. Chappelle of his incredible turn in Con Air.
1:06:19 Lizzie Bassett? That's right.
1:06:20 Chris Winterbauer? Which is one of my favorite films he's ever been in. So he is a movie actor.
1:06:23 Lizzie Bassett? He is a movie actor.
1:06:25 Chris Winterbauer? And Half Baked.
1:06:26 Lizzie Bassett? That's right.
1:06:26 Chris Winterbauer? Great film.
1:06:27 Lizzie Bassett? So Cooper used menthol to make his eyes bloodshot and watery. He also got a self tan every other day.
1:06:35 Chris Winterbauer? He does look, my one thought, the first scene when he's in the drag bar, because of the way it's lit, he looks.
1:06:44 Lizzie Bassett? Like purple.
1:06:45 Chris Winterbauer? So, oh, he looks like he is.
1:06:49 Chris Winterbauer? Dying of, um, what is the colloidal silver that people take?
1:06:56 Lizzie Bassett? The love has one disease. Yeah.
1:06:58 Chris Winterbauer? They think it's a medicinal and they turn purple.
1:07:02 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah. He does.
1:07:04 Chris Winterbauer? He is positively radioactive in that first scene.
1:07:07 Lizzie Bassett? I love it. Good for him.
1:07:08 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah.
1:07:09 Lizzie Bassett? In total, they shot for only about 42 days, which I think is.
1:07:14 Chris Winterbauer? That's very quick.
1:07:14 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, very quick for the scale of this.
1:07:16 Chris Winterbauer? Absolutely.
1:07:17 Lizzie Bassett? Now, I couldn't find a ton about post-production, but it sounds like Cooper had quite a lot of time, which was both a blessing and a curse. Lebatique referenced seeing at least five different cuts of the film with Cooper focusing more and more intently on the love story each time. To your point, I think they were just chopping this farther and farther down. Lebatique told the American cinematographer, quote, "After a while, it's like one of those situations on Top Chef, put your knives down."
1:07:41 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah.
1:07:42 Lizzie Bassett? But he also spoke extremely highly of Cooper, saying he's a great leader because he encourages everyone to think. That is consistent across every interview I saw with every cast and crew member on this, is that I think Bradley Cooper does what we've seen in all the best directors, which is that he hires people he trusts and then he actually listens to them.
1:08:00 Chris Winterbauer? I will say, it's such a trade off because I do think that the love story is very easy to track in this one, much easier to track in earlier than in earlier versions.
1:08:08 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah.
1:08:08 Chris Winterbauer? The professional, in particular, fall of Jackson Maine is very hard to track, I would argue, in this one.
1:08:16 Lizzie Bassett? You know what? That doesn't bother me because he doesn't, he doesn't actually fall professionally necessarily. Like, he is not, he's not a flop at the top of this, which I think is interesting.
1:08:27 Chris Winterbauer? No, but I think they're implying that he does, you know, he does the sellout show.
1:08:32 Lizzie Bassett? That's true.
1:08:33 Chris Winterbauer? Where he's playing like a pharmaceutical conference or something like that. And then he obviously is booked, he believes, to sing at the Grammys, but then it's effectively to play rhythm guitar, you know, to a Roy Orbison impersonator or something like that. And my point is, those scenes are played for aftermath as opposed to for cause. And I agree with you. I think they struck a great balance. However, in the earlier versions, you get more of that downward spiral professionally than you do here. And I wonder if those scenes are on the cutting room floor.
1:09:05 Lizzie Bassett? Definitely. They probably are. A Star is Born premiered at Venice Film Festival, August 31, 2018, to rave reviews and opened wide October 5 of 2018.
1:09:16 Lizzie Bassett? I mentioned Live Nation earlier. As far as I understand it, their involvement was more around promo and release than it was securing concert venues for filming. They put the trailer in front of thousands of music fans at live events like Lollapalooza. And then, this is a bit creepy, they used Ticketmaster to send emails to anyone who had brought Lady Gaga tickets for her most recent tour. They didn't even stop there. They also targeted Dave Chappelle fans and even Bruno Mars fans because Mark Ronson had co-written Uptown Funk. It worked. This movie made so much money. On a relatively modest budget of around $36 million, again, this was a lot of favors called in, it made over $430 million worldwide.
1:09:56 Chris Winterbauer? Crazy successful.
1:09:57 Lizzie Bassett? Yes. While there was some valid criticism of the film's treatment of addiction and also its depiction of pop music as seemingly soulless, that's actually my biggest problem with the whole thing, is sort of what Ally turns into and that that is played as negative in some lights of this.
1:10:15 Chris Winterbauer? Well, I think it's tough. It's like they're trying to, I don't know, I was trying to think of a contemporary, and I think it almost feels like they compressed Taylor Swift's entire two-decade career into a like, six-month trajectory, and which is why it feels a little rushed. It also reminded me of the, I don't know if it's apocryphal or not, but the story of how Florence Welsh, Florence and the Machine was discovered. Like, somebody heard her singing in a pub in London, and you know, she kind of exploded off the strength of her voice, obviously. Anyway, I don't know, I didn't think they hit that that hard, personally. I thought it was more from Jackson's perspective. He was saying like, "Look at you, you sell out," but he was a hypocrite too, so it didn't bother me that much.
1:10:54 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, that's true. There's also quite a bit of discussion about whether the gender politics of the film are as antiquated as the source material, or if Cooper did something different here. I, as I mentioned at the top, I think he does something different. I think that unlike pretty much all of the previous versions, his downfall is not directly tied to her success. He's a mess who's hiding it well at the beginning, versus all of the other versions where he's kind of already a washed-up drunken slob. Like, James Mason is a huge mess in the Judy Garland one at the top, like, embarrassing disaster. And Kris Kristofferson is a mess too, at the top of his. He's also fully rooting for her in
1:11:36 Lizzie Bassett? this one, I think. I think he, I mean, I think there is some jealousy that comes forward, but I don't think that is what destroys him.
1:11:45 Chris Winterbauer? I think I would offer maybe one of two interpretations. I think the first is he is deeply self-destructive and toxic.
1:11:55 Lizzie Bassett? Yes.
1:11:55 Chris Winterbauer? And he struggles with her ascent in many ways. And from, you know, she tells him about her meeting with the manager. He rubs the cream cheese on her face.
1:12:05 Lizzie Bassett? Totally.
1:12:06 Chris Winterbauer? And it's kind of played as playful, but it's, he's being a prick.
1:12:09 Lizzie Bassett? No, it's clear that he's being a drunken asshole.
1:12:11 Chris Winterbauer? And I think his inability to recognize that, you know, he needs to accept that this night is not for him at the Grammys. You know what I mean? Is another instance of sabotage. I understand it's played a little more as self-destructive and then she's the inadvertent collateral damage.
1:12:29 Lizzie Bassett? I think more so than in most of the other versions, it is played as him not fully understanding what he is doing. The, I mean, the James Mason one, he literally stands up there and says, I need a job.
1:12:42 Chris Winterbauer? No, I know. I guess, and my, the way I interpret the ending of this version, though, ultimately is that he, the noble version is he like, he recognizes that there's no way out for him. And that at some point he will fuck up and bring her back down. And so therefore he's gonna, you know, pull the, pull the ripcord.
1:13:02 Lizzie Bassett? Yes.
1:13:02 Chris Winterbauer? The toxic version of that, though, is it's a self-fulfilling prophecy. He, he, he doesn't set her free.
1:13:09 Lizzie Bassett? No.
1:13:09 Chris Winterbauer? He hangs himself and pulls her emotionally with him. So she'll always have a foot half in the grave with him.
1:13:16 Lizzie Bassett? Yes.
1:13:16 Chris Winterbauer? So I don't know. I guess I'm just hesitant to say.
1:13:18 Lizzie Bassett? No, here, here's what I, here's my thing. I think this is the only version where it feels like he did actually have a way out and that they could have potentially had a life together where she maintained her career and he was happy. It like, it, I think it's the Dave Chappelle section of this movie that actually achieves that. Um, where he has someone offering to him, this is a port in the storm. This is actually good. You could do this. You could be happy. And I think he believes it. And then the impetus for him to, you know, take the final act here is actually not anything that she does. It's what her slimy manager comes and tells him, which is that.
1:13:55 Chris Winterbauer? Fair.
1:13:56 Lizzie Bassett? You will always drag her down. That is different from the other versions and almost all the other ones. I think particularly the Judy Garland one, which is really heartbreaking. He overhears a conversation between her and the studio head where she is saying to the studio head. Take me out of my contract. I need to be done. My job is now taking care of him. That's it. I want to leave. And he's like, I'm not going to do that to her because I'm always going to be a mess. So.
1:14:21 Chris Winterbauer? What I liked about that version too. I love that that ending.
1:14:24 Lizzie Bassett? It's really sad. Sean Penn, who Bradley Cooper once watched with rapt attention at the Actors Studio in New York City, said, "It's the best, most important commercial film I've seen in so many years." But one critic, Chris, who definitely didn't love it, was Barbara.
1:14:42 Lizzie Bassett? Miss Streisand told Variety, quote, "At first, when I heard it was going to be done again, it was supposed to be Will Smith and Beyonce. And I thought, that's interesting. Really make it different again. Different kind of music, integrated actors. I thought it was a great idea."
1:14:54 Chris Winterbauer? Integrated actors.
1:14:55 Lizzie Bassett? That's what it says. Oh, Babs.
1:14:57 Chris Winterbauer? All right.
1:14:58 Lizzie Bassett? So I was surprised when I saw how alike it was to the version that I did in 1976. Well,
1:15:05 Lizzie Bassett? you made a movie. I mean, there are similarities. Anyway, yeah, yeah.
1:15:08 Chris Winterbauer? No, it's a remake, to be fair.
1:15:10 Lizzie Bassett? It's a remake. She went on to call the film "the wrong idea" in future interviews and stated that she, quote, "doesn't care so much about success as I do originality."
1:15:19 Chris Winterbauer? Yours was also a remake of a remake.
1:15:23 Lizzie Bassett? I know, I know. Something else Barbara related that raised a few eyebrows that you've mentioned in the post Me Too era was the inclusion of John Peters as a producer on the film. Remember that he produced the 1976 version with Babs and he was her boyfriend at the time? In 2011, he was ordered to pay an assistant $3 million in damages for sexual harassment. That is pretty disgusting. I will not get into it. Warner Brothers was forced to issue a statement that John Peters' attachment to this property goes as far back as 1976 and legally, we had to honor the contractual obligation in order to make this film. Fun fact, not the first time Warner Brothers had to pay him out for doing absolutely nothing. He collected millions on Man of Steel because of his involvement in the franchise. And according to him, quote, "My reputation scares these guys."
1:16:10 Lizzie Bassett? Cool dude.
1:16:10 Chris Winterbauer? Scares a lot of people.
1:16:12 Lizzie Bassett? Although, a Star is Born producer, Bill Gerber, did say that John could not have been more helpful getting it all in line in regards to the 20 years of development on the film. So, I don't know how involved he was in this. All right, we're almost at the end here. Rumors of infidelity plagued both Gaga and Cooper because they were, as we said, so googly eyed and drooly with each other during the press tour. I'm not going to give this that much real estate because A, I don't care. And, yes, Chris?
1:16:37 Chris Winterbauer? I will say, it's probably just the good quality of Mr. Cooper's, but every clip you played me of Lady Gaga talking, he is staring at her.
1:16:47 Lizzie Bassett? They are staring at each other.
1:16:49 Chris Winterbauer? I know, but in particular, he doesn't even move. I was like, "Good God, sir."
1:16:54 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah. Listen, of course, they fell in love with each other after doing this movie.
1:16:58 Chris Winterbauer? But also, they're selling, they're selling the movie and...
1:17:01 Lizzie Bassett? They're selling the ultimate, you know, Hollywood love story.
1:17:04 Chris Winterbauer? A great job selling it.
1:17:05 Lizzie Bassett? I'm sure they did love each other. It doesn't, like, it may not have been a romantic love. This was an enormous effort on both of their parts. They had deep respect for each other.
1:17:13 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah.
1:17:14 Lizzie Bassett? I don't care. Didn't help that he did end up breaking up with Irina Shayk a few months after their extraordinarily googly Oscars performance, but whatever.
1:17:23 Lizzie Bassett? Speaking of the Oscars, we have to briefly mention Lady Gaga's famous, "There can be 99 people in a room who don't believe in you" speech that she said over and over during the press tour. If you are not familiar, here is the line.
1:17:36 Speaker 05 You can have 100 people in the room that are watching you, and 99 don't believe in you, and one does, and that was him. So, you know, all my gratitude goes to him.
1:17:49 Lizzie Bassett? Now, it was laughed at and much memed, but I'm going to say this again, who cares? I think she was nervous. She was unaccustomed to actually being in the spotlight in this way, which sounds weird, but she really hadn't done, like... I think interviews on this scale prior to this, where she is really being herself and more stripped down. I can totally see feeling like you have a good story or good line and repeating it and then not thinking about how it will be perceived. That being said, she does say it in every interview and I watched a lot of them.
1:18:20 Chris Winterbauer? There are 99 people in this world, but Bradley Cooper is one of them.
1:18:25 Lizzie Bassett? Oh, my God. Yeah, it was. It was a lot, but whatever. All in all, the film was nominated for eight Oscars, including Best Picture, Best Actor, Best Actress, Best Supporting Actor, and only one for Best Original Song.
1:18:37 Chris Winterbauer? And not Best Director.
1:18:38 Lizzie Bassett? That is correct. That's what I was just gonna say. I think he was robbed of a Best Director nomination for this. I'm not saying he should have won.
1:18:46 Chris Winterbauer? Do you know who was nominated?
1:18:48 Lizzie Bassett? Yes, I do. I have the list.
1:18:50 Chris Winterbauer? Oh, great.
1:18:51 Lizzie Bassett? I came prepared, Chris, for your questions.
1:18:53 Chris Winterbauer? Let's Monday morning quarterback it.
1:18:55 Lizzie Bassett? So the other nominees were Spike Lee for Black Klansman, I would say deserved, Alfonso Cuarón for Roma, who won, very deserved, Pawel Pawlkowski for Cold War, Yorgos Lanthimos for The Favorite, and Adam McKay for Vice. I think there's one you can scoot, scoot right out of there and put Mr. Cooper in, and it is that one.
1:19:18 Chris Winterbauer? I would have kicked McKay off. There is one other person on that list who I actually also would have kicked off, but I'm gonna keep that to myself.
1:19:24 Lizzie Bassett? Spike Lee, he didn't like Black Klansman. I did.
1:19:30 Chris Winterbauer? I liked it. I just didn't think it was his best work.
1:19:36 Lizzie Bassett? Okay, there you go.
1:19:37 Chris Winterbauer? Cut it, David, cut it.
1:19:39 Lizzie Bassett? Leave it in. I think this is bullshit. I think the fact that he did not get a nomination for this as a directorial debut is ridiculous. And I love Adam McKay. I think he's great. Vice is certainly not his greatest work. Christian Bale's great, but outside of that, you know, not amazing. So, yeah, I'm still mad about this. And you know what? I think they've done a disservice by not nominating him because he's trying really hard in all of his other movies. Did you see Maestro? He tries so hard.
1:20:06 Chris Winterbauer? That's, I mean, I think, I think in a way that. Again, it it works against him. And I think it's very Hollywood thing. This need to make it feel effortless, or this need to make it seem as if you don't want it when everybody wants it. You know what I mean?
1:20:23 Lizzie Bassett? Well, he did want it and like really campaigned for it.
1:20:26 Chris Winterbauer? I agree. He's he did. He said, this is what I want. And he continues to say that this is what he wants. You open yourself up to a line of criticism that is, oh, are you just striving, you know?
1:20:38 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah.
1:20:38 Chris Winterbauer? For that glory or to achieve greatness. And at the end of the day, like, do you choose a vehicle like Maestro or A Star is Born as a means to an end, as opposed to a story to tell? Again, I don't think that's entirely fair. But I do think he, in a way, gets punished. I mean, Leonardo DiCaprio, there is the running joke, you know, of him crawling his way to his Oscar and the Revenant that we discussed in that episode. It reminds me of that a little bit.
1:21:06 Lizzie Bassett? Well, Chris, the soundtrack also became Gaga's fifth number one album. So did pretty well for everybody, even if Mr. Cooper was snubbed. So finally, here we are at the end. What went right?
1:21:19 Chris Winterbauer? I have to give mine to Lady Gaga. Because I think, and I think Bradley Cooper's great in this movie. I think he directed the hell out of it. And and you could say a lot of her performance, we obviously have to credit to him as a director and as her scene partner. That should not go overlooked. I just, upon rewatching it, was really struck by the fact that I at no point thought of her persona. I didn't think of Lady Gaga. I didn't. I just thought this, she is great. She anchors the scenes that she's in. It does not feel like she slips into melodrama unnecessarily. And she felt very natural. I hope to see her do more acting.
1:22:03 Chris Winterbauer? And my, Elise, I'm going to give one what went wrong. I just give her a more dynamic stage name than Ally. Like, I just, when they were like, and the Grammy goes to Ally, I was like, no!
1:22:15 Lizzie Bassett? Esther Blodgett. Bring it back.
1:22:18 Chris Winterbauer? Vicky.
1:22:19 Lizzie Bassett? Vicky Lester. That's not a hot name either.
1:22:22 Chris Winterbauer? Which is not a better name.
1:22:23 Lizzie Bassett? No, it's not.
1:22:25 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah.
1:22:26 Lizzie Bassett? It's not.
1:22:27 Chris Winterbauer? Anywho, so I'll give mine to Lady Gaga. Stephanie, you are absolutely phenomenal in this movie.
1:22:33 Lizzie Bassett? Yes, she is. And I thoroughly enjoyed House of Gucci. I will watch her in pretty much anything. I'm gonna give, I'm gonna give a two parter here. Ah, man, it's hard. There's a lot that goes really right. The obvious one is Bradley Cooper as a director. I think that he was particularly adept at bringing on collaborators for this. I think he knew where his weak spots were and he didn't try to overcompensate by handling everything himself. He relied on industry vets like Eric Roth and Matty Le Batteig. And I think it shows, I think, shows in the cinematography, which is, again, I think, really incredible in this.
1:23:18 Lizzie Bassett? And I think also the desire to bring in this many musicians of the caliber that they did to write everything. It just, it sounds great. It looks great. So I guess I will come back and just give it to Bradley Cooper as the, the head of this unwieldy beast and for doing it right in terms of actually listening to and trusting the people that he hired.
1:23:42 Chris Winterbauer? I mean, well deserved. It's certainly one of the best directorial debuts maybe ever and of the last 30 years. Definitely.
1:23:49 Lizzie Bassett? Yeah, I think so, too. So that's it. That wraps up A Star is Born.
1:23:55 Chris Winterbauer? And I, I really, I don't think it'll be the last time we visit this franchise. I'm excited to talk about these other movies. It was really fun actually watching kind of how the story changed over the years. And it's really interesting to learn that trajectory. So thank you for walking it through us.
1:24:10 Lizzie Bassett? But of course, we have to thank the people who make this podcast possible, and that is you, dear listeners. Thank you for giving us ratings and reviews. That is a great way to support us. You know what? Little bit of homework for you this week. Tell one person about the show. Try and get one person on board. Tell them something, girl, about this, about this here show. And of course, we have to shout out our patrons. You truly support us. There are many tiers that you can support us at. At $1, you get the right to vote. She bet twice the price. At $5, at $5, you get the ad-free RSS feed.
1:24:53 Lizzie Bassett? Check it out by going to patreon.com/whatwentwrongpodcast. But as always, our Full Stop patrons, those patrons who truly, truly love us, get a very special shout out at the end of every episode. And this one, oh, boy, this one is particularly special.
1:25:11 Chris Winterbauer? I would like to apologize in advance.
1:25:14 Lizzie Bassett? Chris has got a guitar, so.
1:25:16 Chris Winterbauer? I do.
1:25:17 Lizzie Bassett? Get ready.
1:25:17 Chris Winterbauer? All right, let me see if I can figure this out. All right, now, if you're not a patron, I'd suggest you turn this off.
1:25:25 Lizzie Bassett? No, no, no, we're all gonna stay here for Chris slash Ally's debut.
1:25:29 Chris Winterbauer? All right, no, I'm doing Jackson Maine.
1:25:32 Lizzie Bassett? Oh, okay.
1:25:33 Chris Winterbauer? All right, here we go. Let's see.
1:25:38 Chris Winterbauer? This one goes out to our Full Stops. Lance Stider, Night the Knife. Y'all signed up after I wrote the song, so calling you out now.
1:25:54 Chris Winterbauer? Tell me something, friend.
1:25:59 Chris Winterbauer? Tired of podcast ads that never end.
1:26:04 Chris Winterbauer? And do you need more?
1:26:08 Chris Winterbauer? Are you feeling like a corporate whore? Go ahead, free. Get that RSS feed that's so, so clean. Or maybe, if you've got the means, come get a shout out like one of these.
1:26:36 Chris Winterbauer? Tell me something, gang. Do you and Sadie only have one name? Or are you like George?
1:26:49 Speaker 03 You leave me wondering if there's something more. Oh Kathleen. Olsen and Tom Kristin with us you stood. So manchino. I pre-ordered your book, it looks so good. Brittany Morris, we don't deserve this. Michael McGrath, you rule. Rosemary Salwood and Steve Winterbauer. I guess I expected from you. I'm thinking Anna, Andrea and Stacy.
1:27:34 Speaker 03 Dammel and Half Greyhound. Ramon Villanueva, you just may have saved us. Darren and Dale, stick around. I'm thinking Andrew McFagel Bagel. I'm thinking Matthew Jacobson. I'm thinking Brian Donahue. Don Schabel, I'm thinking you. Adrian Pankoria and Leah Bowman, you bought our love. Helen Singleton and trust to Scott Girlwin.
1:28:18 Speaker 03 You got a place with us. Without Jewish or resumé. Poor Chris Leo, we would surely be lost. Jake Killen, keep on killing it. Grace Potter, I hope you didn't listen to this.
1:28:44 Chris Winterbauer? All right. That was my thank you. I'm very embarrassed.
1:28:50 Lizzie Bassett? By the way.
1:28:51 Chris Winterbauer? Thank you all.
1:28:51 Lizzie Bassett? That was not Lucas Nelson playing the guitar. Bradley Cooper stuck it. That was Chris Winterbauer.
1:28:57 Chris Winterbauer? Yeah, that's right.
1:28:59 Lizzie Bassett? That was great, Chris.
1:28:59 Chris Winterbauer? That's why you can hear all the mistakes.
1:29:01 Lizzie Bassett? Good job.
1:29:03 Chris Winterbauer? Never really learned the guitar. As I mentioned, I've studied the piano since I was five.
1:29:07 Lizzie Bassett? All right, what's coming up next week, Chris?
1:29:11 Chris Winterbauer? Next, we are talking about the seminal 1999 Star Wars reboot. Lizzie's face.
1:29:23 Lizzie Bassett? I forgot, that's what was next.
1:29:25 Chris Winterbauer? We're talking about the Phantom Menace. Guys, I'm very excited. It's gonna be a really fun episode. Whether you like the movie or not, it is a fascinating story. And really, I'll just say, it is a deep dive into the mind and emotional turmoil of George Lucas. And I'm very excited.
1:29:44 Lizzie Bassett? All right, I'm ready.
1:29:47 Chris Winterbauer? All right, I just gotta send that file off to David to autotune and we will.
1:29:52 Lizzie Bassett? We'll see you in two weeks. Thank you, everybody.
1:29:55 Chris Winterbauer? Thanks, guys.
1:29:57 Speaker 07 Go to patreon.com/whatwentwrongpodcast to support What Went Wrong and check out our website at whatwentwrongpod.com. What Went Wrong is a Sad Boom podcast presented by Lizzie Basset and Chris Winterbauer. Editing and music by David Bowman. Research for this episode provided by Sarah Baum.
Next Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace (Part 1) Page updated November 7, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated