Pod Insights Waveform: The MKBHD Podcast There Are Problems With This Humanoid Robot About this episode In this Halloween special edition of Waveform the crew celebrates spooky season! First, Marques, Andrew, and David debate the struggling iPhone Air before talking about how the new Neo robot is too good to be true. Then David explains Adobe’s latest AI-powered creative tools and gets way too excited about the Boox Palma 2 Pro e-reader. It wraps up with a chaotic blind Halloween candy ranking that ended up being the most cursed candy list ever. Enjoy! 🎃
Links:
Fortune - iPhone Air sales: https://fortune.com/2025/10/22/apple-iphone-air-demand-weak-production-cuts-vs-17-pro/
@avstorm on X - YouTube animations: https://x.com/avstorm/status/1983066476144886019
WSJ - Neo robot video with Joanna Stern: https://youtu.be/f3c4mQty_so?si=wiD04Y6fCOyPaHFa
MKBHD - New Robot video: https://youtu.be/j31dmodZ-5c?si=qHMqhrDOYkSCEFto
Adobe Max keynote: https://www.adobe.com/max/2025/sessions/opening-keynote-gs1.html
This episode brought to you by:
Life360: https://www.life360.com (code: wave)
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/MKBHD
Miro: https://www.miro.com
Zapier: https://www.zapier.com/wave
T-Mobile: https://www.t-mobile.com/switch
Music provided by Epidemic Sound
Shop the merch:
https://shop.mkbhd.com
Social:
Waveform Threads: https://www.threads.net/@waveformpodcast
Waveform Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/waveformpodcast/?hl=en
Hosts:
Marques: https://www.threads.net/@mkbhd
Andrew: https://www.threads.net/@andrew_manganelli
David: https://www.threads.net/@davidimel
Adam: https://www.threads.net/@parmesanpapi17
Ellis: https://twitter.com/EllisRovin
TikTok:
https://www.tiktok.com/@waveformpodcast
Join the Discord:
https://discord.gg/mkbhd
Music by 20syl:
https://bit.ly/2S53xlC
Waveform is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 21,416 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Andrew Manganelli? This episode is brought to you by On Investing, an original podcast from Charles Schwab. Each week, host Lizanne Saunders, Schwab's Chief Investment Strategist, and Colin Martin, Head of Fixed Income Research and Strategy for the Schwab Center for Financial Research, bring your fresh insights on what's happening in the markets and why, and what the implications might be for your portfolio. Join Colin and Lizanne as they explore questions like, how do you evaluate corporate bonds that look interesting? And what sectors are on the move right now? Download the latest episodes and subscribe at schwab.com/oninvesting or wherever you get your podcasts.
0:33 Speaker 01 Support for the show comes from Jira by Atlassian. AI is only as useful as the context it has to work from. But when that context is scattered across tools, threads, and DMs, that means your team and your AI agents end up flying blind. That's the problem that Jira solves. What's the goal tied to your project? What got decided last week in Slack? Atlassian's teamwork graph pulls all these pieces together, from Jira, Confluence, Slack, GitHub, and more. So, nothing falls through the cracks. With Jira, you can actually share that context with the AI agents you already use, like Claude, Cursor, and GitHub Copilot, assign them work directly, or connect your agents through MCP. Spend less time digging through endless links and DMs, less time chasing down what got decided and by who, and more time actually shipping. Learn more at jira.com.
1:18 Speaker 01 That's J-I-R-A dot com.
1:21 Speaker 02 The first candy is dots.
1:25 David Imel? Oh, wow.
1:26 Andrew Manganelli? [bleep] go.
1:29 David Imel? All right.
1:30 Andrew Manganelli? Guys, I'm not eating anything. Just kidding, it's the hardest thing to chew. I will eat it.
1:38 Speaker 01 Yo, what is up, people of the internet? Welcome back to a spooky episode of the Waveform Podcast. We're your hosts, I'm Marques.
1:44 Andrew Manganelli? I'm Andrew.
1:45 David Imel? And I'm, I was trying to think of a spooky joke, but it didn't come in time.
1:48 Speaker 01 You should just say, "I'm iCloud."
1:51 David Imel? I'm your iCloud password.
1:52 Andrew Manganelli? Your full iCloud.
1:53 Speaker 01 If you're watching this in video form, then you can currently see that everyone is wearing some form of a costume, because it's Halloween. And this is uploaded on Halloween, and we're in the Halloween spirit.
2:05 Andrew Manganelli? Everyone.
2:05 Speaker 01 Everyone. Yeah, well, we'll get into that in a second. But there is plenty to talk about still, because this is still being recorded in Techtober. Is this coming out in October now?
2:15 David Imel? Yeah.
2:16 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah, it is.
2:16 David Imel? It's coming out on Halloween.
2:17 Speaker 01 Okay, great, perfect. So, it's still Techtober when you're listening to this.
2:19 David Imel? God, it's been Techtober for so long. I feel like I'm in tech purgatory right now.
2:24 Speaker 01 And now we have, uh, we have iPhone Air sales updates. We have a new robot that is real, but also kind of not real. And maybe a rant about it. Uh, Adobe updates, nothing 3A Lite is a new phone. And we're going to end with a little Halloween candy ranking is what I've been told.
2:41 David Imel? And the Books Palma 2 Pro.
2:42 Speaker 01 And David's holding a Books Palma 2 Pro. So that's all stuff today.
2:45 David Imel? For all my enjoyers out there.
2:47 Speaker 01 Uh, anyway, should we just explain our costumes real quick?
2:50 David Imel? Yeah.
2:50 Speaker 01 Just because it probably looks insane to audio or video viewers, but audio viewers can't see.
2:55 David Imel? We'll have Adam record a separate little clip of us like twirling around that he can put in.
3:00 Andrew Manganelli? Oh, like a video game select?
3:01 Speaker 01 Yeah. Well, cause your costume is pretty full, full on.
3:05 David Imel? Yeah.
3:05 Speaker 01 I think if this was a competition, I'd be voting for this costume.
3:08 David Imel? That's nice of you. That's thank you. Um, I, so for audio listeners, Moment released this new like backpack vest. It's supposed to be like, they released a bunch of new bags, but one of them is a vest for all your stuff instead of having a backpack, which is weird, but cool. But this one that they sent me, it looks like a fishing vest. And at the very last minute, I was like, I don't have a costume. Um, wait, fishing vest? I could be a fishing scam. So what I've done is I've taken the fishing vest and this really fishing hat thing. And I've stickied a bunch of fishing scams all over me.
3:44 Andrew Manganelli? And the fishing pole.
3:46 David Imel? The fishing, the fishing pole.
3:47 Speaker 01 Can't forget that.
3:47 David Imel? So, you know, it's similar to last year's language model where I just stickied a bunch of stuff on something else. But it's, um.
3:55 Andrew Manganelli? Puns always win.
3:56 David Imel? I'll take it. I'll take it. So that's what I am.
3:58 Speaker 01 That's what I am.
3:59 Andrew Manganelli? What are you, Marquez?
4:00 Speaker 01 Uh, I'm Gru.
4:02 Andrew Manganelli? Gru.
4:03 Speaker 01 Gru is a, is a character from a movie called The Minions, right? Is the name of the movie?
4:08 Andrew Manganelli? Despicable Me?
4:08 Speaker 01 It's called Despicable Me.
4:09 David Imel? Despicable, okay. The Minions is a separate movie.
4:11 Andrew Manganelli? It is a movie.
4:12 Speaker 01 There is another movie called The Minions. And you might have, you might, you might know it as The Minions movie, maybe. Um, and there's a character that has this exact scarf and I am now him. I am him.
4:24 Andrew Manganelli? And every Gru needs a minion.
4:26 Speaker 01 Of course.
4:26 Andrew Manganelli? Of course.
4:27 Speaker 01 Of course.
4:28 Andrew Manganelli? Which.
4:30 David Imel? Which one are you, isn't it?
4:32 Speaker 02 I don't know, can you guys tell which one between Adam and I, who's the pirate and who's the minion? It's pretty, pretty hard to tell.
4:39 Speaker 01 We'll leave that up to the viewer.
4:40 Speaker 02 Yeah.
4:40 Speaker 01 That's funny.
4:41 Andrew Manganelli? Alice is a minion.
4:42 Speaker 01 Alice is a minion. Adam, what are you?
4:44 Speaker 04 Well, I came in as just a pirate and everyone was like, that's not tech. So I grabbed a bunch of VHSs and now I'm a movie streaming pirate.
4:50 Speaker 01 You didn't have to give that away. You could have just said that you did it from the start.
4:55 Speaker 04 No, it's fine.
4:56 Speaker 01 You'd be like, I'm a pirate.
4:56 Speaker 04 I'm honest here. We are nothing if not truthful on this podcast.
4:59 Speaker 01 Maybe you.
5:00 Speaker 02 You picked the one video medium that literally has no data stream in it.
5:04 Speaker 01 Here. And now it's infinite data.
5:06 Speaker 04 Now you're a pirate too.
5:09 Speaker 01 Got him.
5:09 Andrew Manganelli? You better see that.
5:10 Speaker 01 99 cents on the front of that. You didn't steal it. You paid for it. Anyway, Andrew, what are you? Yeah, Andrew, what is this?
5:16 Andrew Manganelli? I'm Arc Browser.
5:19 Speaker 01 Wait, explain.
5:21 Andrew Manganelli? Cause I'm a skeleton.
5:22 Speaker 01 Ooh. Ooh. Damn.
5:25 Andrew Manganelli? Damn.
5:26 Speaker 01 Damn.
5:26 Speaker 01 Well played. Deep cut. Well played.
5:28 Andrew Manganelli? I'm mostly just a lineup skeleton with no peripheral vision.
5:31 Speaker 01 I'm still using it.
5:32 Andrew Manganelli? So far.
5:33 Speaker 01 So far. For now. For now. For now. Run borrowed time. Wow. Okay. That is great. Happy Halloween, everybody.
5:39 Andrew Manganelli? Happy Halloween.
5:40 Speaker 01 Well, you know what else might be dead soon?
5:43 Speaker 01 The iPhone Air. I hope not.
5:45 Andrew Manganelli? It will not be dead soon.
5:47 Speaker 01 Well, history, look, whenever you look at trying to predict the future of tech, one of the most tried and true ways to do that is to look at the past. Did you guys know that? And did you guys know history repeats itself? Did you know that? Cause it kinda does.
6:03 Andrew Manganelli? If you if you really think about it.
6:06 Speaker 01 If you really think about it. Uh, Apple's been trying to fill this place in their lineup in between the pro phone and the not pro phone for a little while. Not even in between. They just try to have another phone in the lineup.
6:16 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah.
6:17 Speaker 01 And they had iPhone 12 mini, which everyone except one person on earth.
6:24 David Imel? One minion I got rid of.
6:26 Speaker 01 Tried to use, but then eventually got rid of.
6:28 David Imel? Yeah.
6:29 Speaker 01 And then they had the 13 mini the next year, which fixed.
6:32 David Imel? The battery.
6:32 Speaker 01 The battery, and that was kind of it. And sales were too anemic for them to continue, and it was gone after two generations. Very quickly after, they followed it up with a Plus iPhone. The Plus iPhone also lasted two generations, and it was right above the base iPhone. It was just a bigger screen, but none of the other pro features. But it also died two generations in, just didn't sell quite enough. And so now here we are in 2025, and Apple's done this crazy, ultra-thin, future-of-the-iphone type of thing, very innovative. We all know it's kind of half of a foldable, but they did the iPhone Air. And it's, once again, very interesting phone, and many people were very excited about it.
7:12 Speaker 01 But now here we are, and headlines are popping up that, uh, sales are a little bit lower than Apple's expected, and so they are cutting production to less than 10% of the original volume that they were forecasting they'd be producing at. That's a crazy number, 90% lower than what they thought they would be producing. Which, to me, when I read a headline like this, I, I went to business school for a couple of years, and I always had a professor that told me that if you give a number without context, I will fail you. That was his thing. He was like, if you tell me that sales are, you know, 10% or whatever, or the price of something is $100, if you don't tell me that the competition is actually $200, or it used to be $100, but now it's $50, like, if you don't give me some type of context, I will fail you.
7:57 Speaker 01 And so I see this headline, and it's very spicy, 10% production of what they thought they would need. What were they expecting? And what is the, the, the actual number? Because when I see the curves of iPhone Air, if I am putting on my Tim Cook hat, and I'm a, I'm the logistics guy and the supply chain guy, I feel like iPhone Air would have a pretty big initial spike among enthusiasts willing to spend $1,000 on a futuristic iPhone, and then it would level off and lower over time. And something like the base iPhone would have a low initial spike, but then would have a longer tail as normal people who don't buy on day one find out about it and buy the, the new iPhone.
8:38 Speaker 01 So if I have that, I'm doing my math thing now. If you have that high initial spike and then lower, and we're still in the first like month of the phone coming out, this expected spike up here and the actual amount could be dramatically different, but it could be the same shape, or it could be a different tail, or it could be, you know, a totally different expected curve. There's a lot of possibilities that could match this headline of 10% production versus what's expected. That was me rambling, all that to say, are you guys surprised? Yeah.
9:09 Andrew Manganelli? Just to go on that, it feels like with some other context, maybe that spike isn't that high because just in a, you know, if you're trying to preorder an iPhone right now, if you can preorder an iPhone Air.
9:23 Speaker 01 Are you gonna wear this mask?
9:25 David Imel? Your voice is a little muffled.
9:26 Andrew Manganelli? Is it muffled?
9:27 Speaker 01 A little bit.
9:28 David Imel? Yeah, put the, if you put it over. There you go.
9:31 Andrew Manganelli? Oh, that does sound better.
9:32 Speaker 01 Yeah.
9:32 Andrew Manganelli? Okay, um, sorry.
9:34 Speaker 01 Yeah.
9:35 Andrew Manganelli? If you're pre, if you're preordering iPhones right now, you can get an iPhone Air shipped immediately. If you preorder any of the other iPhone 17 lineup, it's a two to three week wait time. So.
9:45 Speaker 01 Makes sense.
9:45 Andrew Manganelli? It feels like that spike isn't what, isn't a big spike off the top. And I, I mean, like, I know you said enthusiast potentially buying it, but it's really hard to have, think of enthusiast that would want to buy this over like what we're calling the most pro iPhone ever. If I, I picture an enthusiast enthusiast being like, that's what I'm getting. The Air is cool, but I'm getting the sweet.
10:09 Speaker 01 So I think that's always true about the pro iPhone. You're always going to have a bigger spike at the beginning because that's what enthusiasts are going to get. The Air is interesting because it is more expensive than the base model, and it is worse than the base model. And so you have to be an enthusiast to decide to get that phone, to spend more money and get it because it's thinner and pretty and shiny and stuff.
10:29 David Imel? Well, you don't have to be enthusiast. You could just really like thin, pretty.
10:33 Speaker 01 Well, I guess on day, on month one.
10:36 David Imel? Yeah.
10:36 Speaker 01 I expect the average person to be just getting the base iPhone and not really spending the extra. And if I'm an enthusiast, I'm getting probably the Pro, but also maybe the Air.
10:47 David Imel? And it's also the air is like, super overrepresented in my like Twitter timeline and on Instagram. And like, I feel like everyone who has the air, I know they have the air.
10:58 Andrew Manganelli? It sounds just like the Mini. Sorry, David. I can barely see you. I promise. But this is the, this is the Mini on Twitter. Everyone's like, no, this is the best thing ever in our space. We love the Mini. Long live the Mini.
11:11 David Imel? That's true.
11:12 Andrew Manganelli? Sounds exactly like it.
11:13 David Imel? This did, this, this quote of 10% did kind of blow my mind because anecdotally, I've been seeing a ton of iPhone airs. And usually I don't see the brand new tech thing everywhere all the time, even with the brand new iPhone. But I've been seeing a lot of iPhone airs. I've seen at least like seven or eight just in my neighborhood.
11:33 Speaker 01 So interesting.
11:34 David Imel? But I live in New York City.
11:36 Speaker 01 Do you think?
11:36 David Imel? So this is a place where people will buy the new expensive thing and also will buy the fashion thing.
11:42 Speaker 01 Yeah. Do you think you're, so this is, this is like, again, like the human brain and like perception. Do you think you're noticing the air more, even though you're also seeing Pros and just not registering it?
11:53 David Imel? I see some Pros. That's a real possibility because I've just been wondering consistently. Yeah. I mean, you very much notice. So, yeah, it's a, it's a possibility, but it's just the fact that I'm seeing them at all within the first month of it coming out is kind of like surprising to me.
12:09 Speaker 01 Yeah.
12:10 Speaker 04 I mean, anecdotally, the people that I know that would be buying the Air in my head, all got the Pros and the Pro Max.
12:17 Andrew Manganelli? I've seen so many Pros because it's so easy to tell when it's sitting in like a car mount. You can see this bright orange, big camera plateau, like in your rearview mirror, you can just be like, that guy's one of the Pros.
12:29 Speaker 02 Everyone I know that bought the Air is not an enthusiast. Like they bought it because they're like, ooh, pretty. And they universally love it. Like they're in love with their phone.
12:40 Speaker 01 That is such a, it's the Mini.
12:42 Andrew Manganelli? It's a different type of enthusiast.
12:44 David Imel? Well, and if you think about it, so like, you know how the whole thing with electric cars is that, oh, you only need this much range, not that much range. Because, oh, you'll just charge in your, in your garage and then you'll just go to the grocery store and you'll go live in suburbia. Like, it's all those people that are buying the Air because the battery life is not that big of a deal to them. So they're just more interested in something that's flashy and thin.
13:07 Speaker 01 Yeah.
13:07 David Imel? You know?
13:07 Speaker 01 A finally actually new iPhone.
13:09 David Imel? Right.
13:10 Speaker 01 Yeah. Yeah, you know, in in supply chain land, like what you said, Andrew, like the iPhone Air is available and that means they have extra stock and the other iPhones are not available for maybe a couple of weeks, which means they don't have enough stock. In an ideal world, they're all available and have just barely enough stock for the exact correct amount of demand, which is why they make these forecasts and try to supply chain stock stores perfectly. And to me, they just slightly got the ratios off, or maybe more than slightly got the ratios off of what they expected.
13:42 David Imel? I do want to try to run this phone for a little bit. I just don't want to buy it. So I can't, I can't, I'm not willing to invest a thousand dollars just to like
13:50 Speaker 04 I've thought about that too.
13:51 David Imel? Yeah, yeah, it's not worth it.
13:54 Speaker 01 It is pretty nice to hold.
13:55 David Imel? It is very nice to hold. Every time I pick someone's up, I'm like, hmm. But I, you know, you wonder how long, how long it's gonna last before it wears off.
14:02 Andrew Manganelli? Do you think the average person going into a store just picking up an iPhone that would potentially buy that would be worried about it breaking because of how thin it is? Do you think that's a concern? Someone who doesn't watch any of the testing, hasn't watched any of our reviews, they're just the typical.
14:17 Speaker 04 Not if the salespeople are good.
14:20 David Imel? Yeah.
14:21 Speaker 04 You know, because I'm sure that's part of their training.
14:23 David Imel? That's true.
14:24 Speaker 04 Like when I used to work at Best Buy Mobile, we would get like paperwork and stuff and like how the talking points on all the phones and stuff, you know?
14:30 Speaker 01 That's so interesting.
14:30 David Imel? Yeah, Apple stores, I know they do a good job of that.
14:33 Speaker 01 Yeah.
14:33 David Imel? And I bet carrier stores, Best Buys, things like that also are like very convincing. Oh, just get our insurance. Oh, just, you know, it'll be fine. It's durable.
14:41 Andrew Manganelli? It's definitely not gonna break and then upsell you on Apple immediately after.
14:45 David Imel? Yeah.
14:46 Speaker 01 Yeah, it is titanium.
14:47 David Imel? Yeah.
14:47 Speaker 01 Seems pretty strong.
14:48 David Imel? Yeah.
14:49 Speaker 01 All right, well, we'll keep an eye on it. We'll see if this thing actually changes in trajectory or if it's almost dead. We'll find out in two years.
14:57 Speaker 01 All right. I also noticed, I was liking a YouTube video recently. It was by the Autofocus channel. It was on a new Porsche 911.
15:03 Andrew Manganelli? You like your own videos?
15:04 Speaker 01 I do. I should mention, I like every single one of our own uploaded videos.
15:08 David Imel? Do you vote for yourself in the school election too?
15:10 Speaker 01 I never ran, but if I did, you better believe it. Absolutely.
15:14 Speaker 04 Do you like your own tweets? That's the only thing that matters.
15:17 Speaker 01 Oh, no, I don't. Cause that used to be a favorite button.
15:19 David Imel? Yeah.
15:20 Speaker 01 I adopted that as like, I would like to remember this tweet for later. So I don't like my own tweets. It was a favorite button. Anyway. Uh, I liked an autofocus channel button and I saw a small animation of a tire play. And I realized that YouTube has been giving us custom like button animations on various channels when it auto detects the type of channel that it is. I don't actually know if the waveform channel gets auto detected as a type of channel that gets a custom like button. I don't think it is. I think there should be a tech one also and there isn't.
15:48 David Imel? Yeah.
15:49 Speaker 01 But there's like beauty channels and car channels and all sorts of other things that get custom like button animations. And I thought that was pretty cool.
15:55 David Imel? There's like a ton of sports ones.
15:57 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah. Do you want to go over the list? There's a tweet.
16:00 Speaker 01 Yeah, there's a whole list. Okay.
16:01 Speaker 04 Wait, can I ask a question first?
16:02 Andrew Manganelli? I can't read it.
16:03 Speaker 01 Yeah.
16:03 Speaker 04 Is this based on the video or like the channel?
16:06 Speaker 01 I think it's based on the channel.
16:07 Andrew Manganelli? Okay.
16:08 Speaker 01 But that I don't actually know if that's true.
16:10 Andrew Manganelli? I have a good way to test this after we, um, can you go through the list?
16:14 Speaker 01 Yeah. Okay. So there's about 20. Motor vehicles get a car animation, learning, uh, gets an idea bulb animation. There's music for music videos, film, travel gets an airplane, a basketball, a football, a cricket ball, a soccer ball and a baseball.
16:30 David Imel? Cooking.
16:31 Speaker 01 Yeah.
16:31 David Imel? There's tennis. There's cat, which is, you know, honestly, yeah.
16:36 Speaker 01 Cat videos.
16:36 David Imel? Should have cat video comment. There's comedy. There is dog. There is horror, love, which I don't really know what that would mean. Romance, which is apparently separate from love.
16:46 Speaker 01 Weird.
16:47 David Imel? Uh, thriller, which is separate from horror and TV, which is separate from YouTube.
16:53 Andrew Manganelli? So with that, do you think that's channel or tag based?
16:57 Speaker 01 I think it's the type of video.
16:58 David Imel? Yeah, I think it auto detects the type of video.
17:00 Speaker 01 I would, I would say it's the type of.
17:01 Andrew Manganelli? Do you think it does that by tags or by?
17:03 Speaker 01 No.
17:04 David Imel? I think it's AI.
17:05 Speaker 01 Didn't they get rid of tags?
17:05 David Imel? I think if you say certain words or have certain title.
17:08 Speaker 01 Yeah.
17:09 David Imel? Then it's like, yeah, this is a car video.
17:11 Speaker 04 Yeah, I'm not getting this. Is this just on web?
17:14 Speaker 01 Uh, this is on mobile. I got, I got it on mobile.
17:16 Speaker 04 I'm not getting it on Android right now.
17:19 Speaker 01 Oh, it's because it's on, yeah, it's on Android. Yeah. You know, Google's on platform. Yeah.
17:24 Speaker 01 iOS only, sorry, sorry.
17:25 David Imel? Really?
17:26 Speaker 01 Coming, it's not on Android? I don't know, I don't know, I'm just making a joke.
17:28 David Imel? Wait, let me check.
17:29 Speaker 01 That just happens a lot. Google has released a lot of features that are iOS only until it comes to Android.
17:34 Speaker 04 No, I got it on the autofocus video, so it is on Android.
17:37 Speaker 01 Okay, I was just kidding.
17:38 Andrew Manganelli? Wait, are there, there are still tags in videos, right? You can still tag a video?
17:43 Speaker 01 Yeah, okay.
17:43 Andrew Manganelli? Okay, Adam, for this episode.
17:46 Speaker 01 Tag it horror.
17:46 Andrew Manganelli? Can you tag, can you tag every single one of these?
17:49 Speaker 04 Oh.
17:50 Andrew Manganelli? And see what happens?
17:51 Speaker 04 Nothing would happen.
17:51 Andrew Manganelli? No.
17:52 Speaker 04 We gotta pick one, like, beauty.
17:53 Speaker 02 You should tag horror over and over and over again. And then what we should do to test if it's the tags or the things, we just all have to say "car", a lot, "car", "car driving",
18:02 Speaker 01 "car",
18:02 Speaker 02 "car wheel",
18:03 Speaker 01 "drive",
18:04 Speaker 02 "tire",
18:04 Speaker 01 "drive",
18:05 Speaker 02 "car", "this car is good."
18:06 Speaker 01 Electric car, waveform podcast.
18:08 David Imel? Car.
18:08 Speaker 01 Wave form podcast.
18:10 David Imel? Wave E V, electric vehicle form podcast.
18:12 Speaker 01 I think it's AI that just like looks at a whole bunch of factors and picks the most likely one.
18:16 Andrew Manganelli? Well, we just need every one of you to press the like button to test it out and let us know.
18:21 Speaker 01 Let us know if you get a certain animation on this video. That'd be sick. I wonder if the clip gets different animation from the main episode, I don't know.
18:29 Speaker 04 What would it be, like a microphone exploding or something?
18:32 Speaker 01 Well, there should be a podcast one, because it knows what a podcast is. That's the easiest one to detect.
18:35 Speaker 04 We put it in a playlist called podcasts.
18:37 Speaker 01 Yeah.
18:37 Speaker 04 I don't know what more I could do for them.
18:39 Speaker 01 That should be easy. A little microphone shows up, that'd be fire. Anyway, um, yeah, that's, that's new. You know what else is new?
18:47 Andrew Manganelli? Oh, God.
18:52 Speaker 01 Okay, alright, where do I start with this? So yesterday, I'm on Twitter, and, you know, as I am, I open up the website, and I'm fed a whole bunch of random stuff. And one of them at the top was someone tweeting at me, "Hey, Marquez, you should check this out." And so I scroll up, and it's this tweet from a company called One X, and it's about a robot called Neo. And it's this like 10-minute keynote video announcing a new humanoid robot that's available now. Quote. I said, "Oh, wow, available now." Quote-unquote. "You can order this thing." And so I click on it, and I watch the whole video, and I kind of instantly understand that this is not real,
19:37 Speaker 01 but I, I close the video and I go home. The next morning, this morning, I wake up and I come in and this video has 15,000 retweets, 26 million views and many more people tweeting it at me, asking if I'm gonna review it and check it out and how excited I am that this is finally real. And so now I do feel the need to at least share some of my thoughts on it. And it's hard to know where to start because I have several opinions that I know are all over the map and also some of them are controversial.
20:11 David Imel? Yeah.
20:11 Speaker 01 So where do I start?
20:12 David Imel? Do we want to kind of like talk about what it is first?
20:15 Speaker 01 Yeah, let's describe what it is.
20:16 Andrew Manganelli? You ordered it, right?
20:19 Speaker 01 Okay.
20:19 Speaker 02 Please, please tell me.
20:21 Speaker 01 Okay, so this robot, it's a 5'6", 66-pound humanoid robot. Comes in three colors.
20:26 David Imel? It's pretty light.
20:26 Speaker 01 Uh, yeah, it's pretty light. Comes in like this light cream color or like a light blue or a black color. And it's humanoid shaped. So imagine it's like kind of fabric-covered from head to toe. It has a pair of eyes on the front, which are camera sensors. It has ears on the sides, which are microphones. It has little lights where the ears would be.
20:43 Andrew Manganelli? It's like a walking mannequin.
20:44 Speaker 01 It's like a, yeah, it looks exactly like a walking mannequin. And the video shows it walking around in a kind of natural-ish type of way and doing chores all over the house all day. So it waters your plants, it vacuums the floor, it takes the laundry out, it folds it, it puts stuff away, it does the dishes, it cleans the toilet. It just lives at home doing your chores and then when it's done, after the four-hour battery life is up, it walks back over to the charger, plugs itself in, and docks. That is a very cool idea. Like, people have been, I mean, what's the Jetsons robot called? Like, people have been having this idea for forever.
21:24 David Imel? Rudy, Rosie.
21:24 Speaker 01 Rosie, Rosie the Jetsons robot. Like, this is an idea humans have loved, the idea of a humanoid robot helper for forever. And now with the advent of AI and with all these sensors and all this investment in the category, it feels like it may be more real than ever. Like Tesla's doing this thing and Boston Dynamics has had these humanoid-shaped robots and like, maybe we're actually finally gonna have this thing. So people watch this video and believe that it is now finally here.
21:51 Speaker 01 That being said, I also watched a Joanna Stern video. She has been with The Wall Street Journal for a little bit and she got a demo in person of this robot. So they brought it to her and it did a whole bunch of this stuff. She asked it to-
22:06 Andrew Manganelli? Wait, she went to a demo area, right?
22:08 Speaker 01 Right. So she went to a demo area, a little house that they set up, but in person, she got to witness the robot helping her. So it would take a glass and bring it to her with water in it, or it would, I think, load the dishwasher or something like that. Couple tasks that it would do.
22:24 Speaker 01 100% of the things that were happening in her demo time were teleoperated. It was operated by a guy in another room with a VR headset and controllers. 100% of what was happening. So, we watch the video again, you kind of have to assume that some of what's happening in this keynote video is also teleoperated. There are two specific clips where they say, whoops, that it is autonomous. One of them is when the doorbell rings and they ask it to go get the door. And so it autonomously walks over to the door, waits for the person, sees the person, opens the door, backs up and lets them inside. And the other is, "Take this water glass that is now empty from me."
23:09 Speaker 01 And the robot walks over, takes it out of his hand and walks away. Those are the two clips labeled as autonomous in this video. All of the rest, I assume, are teleoperated. So, where does that leave me? You could, if you wanted to, preorder this robot. It's $500 a month, or $20,000 for outright ownership and priority delivery. That sounds crazy on the surface, but I actually think that's a justifiable price for, especially the type of person who's gonna buy this, who sees this as just buying saved time. Not a ridiculous price. I have no problem with the price. The problem is, it's a $200 preorder and they say they'll maybe ship it next year. And I don't believe that they will.
23:54 Andrew Manganelli? Hold on, real quick.
23:55 Speaker 04 Where have we heard this before?
23:56 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah. Can I just clarify really quick? When you say justifiable price, do you mean justifiable price of everything working correctly? Or justifiable price of this like, there's a good chance a lot of this is teleoperated and we're using you. Cause like, he claims a lot of like, it's not going to be that great off the start.
24:14 Speaker 01 Yeah, great question.
24:14 Andrew Manganelli? Okay.
24:15 Speaker 01 They're selling the dream. And I think that the dream is worth the price. Right. I think that the fully working, fully autonomous robot, where you leave home in the morning and you come back at night and everything is done and cleaned up for you every day and you never have to empty a dishwasher or do laundry ever again. That dream is awesome. And I think a lot of people are buying that dream. And I have no problem with the price of that dream. The problem I have is the thing that they're selling is far from that product. And, you know, I don't know exactly in this video, how much of this stuff is teleoperated? I'm assuming most of it is. But it's like, I can give some leeway on it being a little slow
25:00 Speaker 01 or a little clumsy. It's a first gen product. This is going to happen. But if you're an early adopter, you want it to at least work. And I think what they're saying and what Joanna found out from talking to the founder and people at the company is that they're not expecting all of these tasks to be autonomous, even from the beginning. They're expecting some of the stuff to get stuck sometimes and to have a couple of issues. And then someone who works for the company will remote in and teleoperate the robot and peer into your house and fix it for you. And early adopters are going to have to be okay with that.
25:34 David Imel? Yeah, effectively, they're saying, it's very confusing. In the video where he's talking to Joanna, he's like, it'll do most things autonomously when he ship it to you. But also, we need to build a world model. So the idea is they want to build this world model, quote unquote, which is effectively being able to.
25:49 Speaker 01 General AI.
25:50 David Imel? Yeah, being able to train the robot to see objects, understand what they are, understand what it's doing, you know, unload your dishwasher, do this stuff. But they don't have enough training data. So what they're trying to do right now is they're trying to get these into a lot of people.
26:03 Speaker 01 Houses because of course they've got some lab in the dog patch in San Francisco or something. Right. And they're just, they have a few robots that are going around. They're like, okay, we, we are manually training on dishwashers. Now we're mainly training on this, but in order for these models to be built well, you need like millions of parameters, like millions of videos. And they can't produce millions of videos fast enough. So what do they do? Oh, we'll sell a robot that is in way more people's homes and will create the training data in people's homes, which.
26:34 Andrew Manganelli? So you're beta tester.
26:35 Speaker 01 So you're selling a product for $20,000 that doesn't do the thing so that other people can build your product for you. So that eventually you'll be able to sell it to people that it can actually do the thing.
26:45 Andrew Manganelli? And even it's like on the hope that it can eventually do that because they don't have all the parameters in there. It's this like, don't worry, it'll work once we get all of this, but you guys need to spend $20,000 and.
26:55 Speaker 01 Yeah, this is, this is the, the AI product problem. This is the, it's been happening before. This is what happened to the humane pin. This is what happened to the rabbit, which is the promise of it working someday in the future is dependent on getting all of the data and all of the systems to, to work eventually. This is the self-driving car problem too. We can't sell you a perfect self-driving car until we have millions of miles of data. Of the thing being trained and working so that we have a perfect system to self-drive. How do we get those millions of miles? We let people beta test it for us and put it in their own hands and hopefully it's safe enough that we can get millions and millions of miles. And then we have a.
27:37 David Imel? Right. But at least the benefit of Tesla that, that they had was that they had a thing that people already used every day that was already a good product.
27:44 Speaker 01 And they had videos of rotes.
27:46 David Imel? And it was always recording video that to be used in the training data.
27:50 Speaker 02 Well, Neo has this too, because one of the things they advertise on their website is something called expert mode. Where if you ask Neo to do a task that it has not yet autonomously figured out, you can schedule a time where a quote unquote Neo expert will tele-operate. The, the robot, do the task and supposedly contribute.
28:11 Speaker 04 To this training.
28:12 David Imel? I'm gonna schedule a time for an expert to come take the glass out of my hand.
28:16 Speaker 04 Not just that, but that opens up a whole world of like, okay, so you're streaming video footage from inside your house to somewhere.
28:23 Speaker 01 Yep.
28:23 Andrew Manganelli? There's a few things. He felt like he was kind of making some stuff up when Joanna would ask. He's like, oh, we could blur faces or just geolock areas inside of your house, which is like, I guess you could. And but I think what to go on what David was saying is Tesla cars were at least cars and like operated as cars collecting data.
28:41 David Imel? Yeah.
28:42 Andrew Manganelli? This is a robot that literally can't do anything. I guess, except being scheduled to teleoperate, but that's just not a good product unless it has all this training data.
28:51 David Imel? Yeah, if this was like a good vacuum cleaner that you used, and then at one point it was like, by the way, we have, you've used it enough now that it knows what your house looks like. So now it can clean for you.
29:01 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah.
29:01 David Imel? That's different than.
29:03 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah.
29:03 David Imel? Put a robot in your home with cameras that someone has to operate.
29:06 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah.
29:07 David Imel? And I will give them credit that like they control it with some Oculus Quest controller, basically in a headset.
29:12 Andrew Manganelli? It's cool.
29:13 David Imel? And it did have some pretty real time like movement and they have some interesting things and when the robot like they pull threads inside of the robot to do the tendons, which is what allows it to be light so that it doesn't like fall on your dog and kill it.
29:26 Speaker 01 66 pounds.
29:27 David Imel? Yeah, 66 pounds is quite light, but that also means that it can't apply a lot of force. So Joanna in the video tried to get it to crack a, what kind of nut?
29:36 Andrew Manganelli? A walnut.
29:36 David Imel? A walnut. And it would not crack it.
29:38 Andrew Manganelli? I think that's fair because like I can't crack a walnut with my hand. So.
29:41 David Imel? Yeah, but I mean, it can't apply that much pressure.
29:44 Speaker 04 I'm glad it can't apply that much pressure.
29:45 David Imel? That is also true. Yeah. That's true. You don't want it to strangle you.
29:48 Speaker 04 There's a whole movie about this and I'm, I'm begging.
29:52 Speaker 01 Wait, which movie are you?
29:53 David Imel? I, Robot.
29:54 Speaker 01 Okay.
29:54 David Imel? Cause I, Robot, there's also X Machina.
29:56 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah, yeah. But I am once again begging people to finish the movies.
30:02 Andrew Manganelli? It like.
30:03 David Imel? Yeah.
30:04 Andrew Manganelli? It, it was impressive how it all works with the tendons and stuff, but then you watch any of the teleoperated stuff it does in Joanna's video, which you should definitely go watch. And I couldn't help but just thinking like, this is how Lane stumbles around the house, trying to learn how to do new things.
30:18 Speaker 01 She's learning her neural net the same way.
30:19 David Imel? Yeah, I mean, yeah.
30:20 Andrew Manganelli? The thing it opens.
30:23 Andrew Manganelli? It opened the refrigerator and immediately hits itself in the face and then has to like walk out. It tries to load the dishwasher. I think it took five minutes to put in two cups and a fork. And the way it's I but the way it squatted down to get the dishwasher door is just like it's not even close to being what a human would do to do these things.
30:45 David Imel? I worry less about the speed that it can do tasks because if it's like doing it autonomously then you know it's sort of like yeah it's like if I if it takes me two minutes to render a video or or or an hour to render a video but it's not due till next week.
30:59 Andrew Manganelli? Agreed.
30:59 David Imel? I don't really care.
31:00 Speaker 01 My analogy is if you had remember that analogy we had of like a crank computer it's like if you could crank computer render a video like this in 15 minutes or if you could just have it do it automatically in an hour I would take the hour even though it's slower I just don't want to have to spend that time.
31:16 Andrew Manganelli? I think it was less about the time and more about just like how clearly it wasn't operating and how a human would operate to do any of those things despite being controlled by a human in all those scenarios. So now we're expecting next year for it to autonomously learn how to react more like a human and do all of those things when right now in presumably a year within this launching an actual human who knows how to do those things can't even control it correctly.
31:41 David Imel? That's a fair point.
31:42 Andrew Manganelli? That seems just not even remotely close.
31:44 Speaker 02 I have you guys looked at the FAQ yet?
31:47 Andrew Manganelli? No, I cannot imagine.
31:48 Speaker 02 So Andrew like going off your point of like how clumsy this thing tends to look one of the things in the FAQ is like can Neo cook for me to which they're like it's not going to be allowed to use your stove which is like cool that's good that's safe and then they're like but Neo can help you clean up which implies doing the dishes they don't say do the dishes.
32:06 David Imel? There's a video of it doing dishes.
32:07 Speaker 02 The next two FAQ points are like do not get this thing wet.
32:12 Andrew Manganelli? Oh really?
32:13 Speaker 02 Its hands are waterproof but it says the rest of the unit is not and then the there's an FAQ that says can Neo be used outside and it just says contact with moisture may damage it.
32:26 Andrew Manganelli? Oh my gosh.
32:27 David Imel? Which is funny because there's a video of it outside watering plants.
32:30 Speaker 02 I just want to add I just want to add love the idea that it could clean my toilet you know no one no one likes actually some people like cleaning their toilets there's like a whole TikTok thing but. Is that knit washable? Like, I don't want it to clean my toilet if it just has if it just has poop and pee on it forever. And I can't find that information anywhere.
32:50 Speaker 01 Interesting.
32:53 Andrew Manganelli? It also, she asked it, Joanna was asking the CEO some questions and right after showing that it does dishes, he was like, oh, can't pick up sharp objects. So it's like, okay, I can do all my dishes except for knives and pointy forks.
33:05 Speaker 02 Yeah, I'm cool with that, though. I don't want.
33:07 Andrew Manganelli? I don't want it doing that, but that's not doing the dishes. If 10% of the dishes you can't do because now they're pointy.
33:14 Speaker 01 Doing the dishes is like a very delicate, like you drop one dish and you messed up.
33:19 Speaker 02 Yeah.
33:20 Speaker 01 Big time.
33:21 Speaker 02 And then there's pointy objects everywhere.
33:22 Andrew Manganelli? And do you think that thing could clean off the floor? Yeah. I don't think that's cleaning glass up off the floor.
33:27 Speaker 01 I'm just imagining, you know how we have a, okay, we've had, we've had two different types of robots here at the studio. We've had a robot vacuum cleaner.
33:34 Speaker 02 Yeah.
33:34 Speaker 01 Which we came back to in the morning and found it like wrapped in cables, like dying in the corner.
33:40 Speaker 02 Yeah.
33:41 Speaker 01 And then we've had Astro Bot.
33:42 Speaker 02 Oh, God.
33:43 Speaker 01 It's just. Which is like a little bit more capable. It doesn't vacuum, but it can like bring you a drink if someone is in the other room. Take a hand at a drink first and like, it has a little security camera and it can rove around and be a helper and has an Alexa and answers questions. Even that was like, it would still wrap a cord around its neck and like dive under a desk for no reason. So, uh, not a whole lot of, um, not a whole lot of success so far in this category. So jumping all the way to, I think basically my thesis is jumping all the way from where we are now, which is this is not real and it's 100% teleoperated, jumping all the way to this is a good product and it's mostly teleoperated and it actually saves you time is a huge gap.
34:29 Speaker 01 So why did you announce it now instead of when it's done? And the answer is both because we need to generate hype and raise a lot of money and because we need a lot of training data. And that is the AI product problem of 2025 and beyond. Like, that's what happened to Rabbit. That's what happened to the humane pin. That's what happened to so many of these others, which is the product is not done. They had a dream and a really good idea and a respectable idea and on people working really hard on it. But they just didn't have the tech that was good enough to sell it as is.
34:59 David Imel? Yeah.
34:59 Speaker 01 And so they sold us a horrible product that was not yet done. And that was their demise.
35:03 David Imel? My question is like, how much, how much funding do they have? Because instead of selling this for $20,000 or $500 a month, when it doesn't really know how to do a lot of stuff yet.
35:12 Speaker 01 Yeah.
35:13 David Imel? They should be offering to let people test it for them. Or like getting or paying other people to test it for them, you know?
35:21 Speaker 01 Cause they get enough people? I don't know.
35:23 David Imel? I think they would. I think the entirety of Twitter would definitely sign up for this.
35:30 Speaker 01 20 million views.
35:31 Speaker 02 I, I think we should say something nice.
35:33 David Imel? It looks soft.
35:34 Speaker 02 It, uh, I think their marketing materials are really well done.
35:37 David Imel? I just want to, I feel like the browser company kind of like introduced this like super soft, nice marketing style.
35:45 Speaker 01 Everything's cream colored.
35:46 Speaker 02 But there's also a lot like the photos have like a nice sort of high contrast graininess.
35:50 David Imel? Yeah, and even their like launch video was like a super eight video going through San Francisco. Like, that's exactly what the browser.
35:56 Speaker 02 And I like that there's old people in the materials. I'll say something kind of nice. People are not going to buy this.
36:01 David Imel? No.
36:02 Speaker 02 No.
36:02 David Imel? It kind of makes sense.
36:03 Speaker 01 Buy it for their parents.
36:04 Andrew Manganelli? I feel like as a, this kind of humanoid robot might make the most sense for people who have a hard time getting around their house. It might need some help.
36:12 Speaker 02 Yeah, but come on, have you ever met an old person?
36:14 David Imel? No.
36:15 Speaker 02 Like, I, I, you know, helping old people. My, my parents are weirdly good at tech. I don't help them with tech that much, but I feel like, you know, old people, you know, struggle to find the email app on the iPhone. Like, I don't want to give them something that is completely LLM operated.
36:30 Speaker 01 Yeah, I don't, the, the current as exists version of this product could be terrible for old people. But the someday, the dream is complete version of this product might be awesome for old people.
36:41 Andrew Manganelli? For sure.
36:42 Speaker 02 I feel like there's a lot of AI companies that sort of have this really weird posture where they're like, ha, ha, ha. Wouldn't it be funny if it killed you? Whereas the one X is sort of like, it can't, it won't, it's soft sweater, six, five, six. It's, you're good. No sharp.
36:57 Speaker 01 They're not making a six two.
36:59 Speaker 02 Yeah, it can't, it can't cook.
37:01 Speaker 01 Yeah.
37:01 Andrew Manganelli? I'll say he did a decent job of admitting some of the, what'd you say, admitting the faults and then sell it at the same time. But he's, he mentioned shortcomings of it and how next year, the people who get it are going to be purchasing something that is not fully fledged and has a lot to learn. I just think even that level of what he's saying is still so far from
37:22 Speaker 02 Yeah.
37:22 Andrew Manganelli? most likely what's gonna.
37:23 David Imel? Well, it goes to Marques's point, like this is technically a cool thing, like even being tele operated, like that's still pretty impressive for a small startup to do. It's just not what they're selling right now. So, yeah.
37:35 Speaker 02 I think we were nice enough that now no one could be mad when they lose all their money on their investments.
37:40 Andrew Manganelli? I just can't wait until they're like, oh, did you see they talked about Neo on the waveform podcast and they turned it on and there's a skeleton and a minion ripping on, and a fisherman ripping on us.
37:52 Speaker 01 Yeah.
37:52 Andrew Manganelli? Their robot and they won't take any of this seriously.
37:54 Speaker 01 Yeah.
37:55 Andrew Manganelli? Which is fair.
37:56 Speaker 01 I'm looking at the viewfinder now and it just looks like a skeleton.
37:58 Andrew Manganelli? Do you know how hard it is to just look at Ellis with those eyes the entire podcast?
38:04 Speaker 02 I completely forgot we were.
38:07 Speaker 02 I was like, this is just a regular podcast. I actually wear this most days when we're not doing the podcast.
38:11 Speaker 01 Yeah.
38:11 David Imel? Yeah.
38:12 Speaker 01 Yeah.
38:13 David Imel? Last year when we did our Halloween episode, I was cutting the clips the week after and I was like, this is no longer relevant.
38:20 Speaker 02 What's gonna happen with this?
38:22 Speaker 01 Yeah.
38:22 Andrew Manganelli? People, you know, it'll be Halloween week. I, it'll, yeah.
38:26 Speaker 01 Yeah.
38:26 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah.
38:27 Speaker 01 These clips will be viewed long after Halloween.
38:29 David Imel? Yeah, maybe next year they'll pop off.
38:31 Speaker 02 You know what else costs $500 a month?
38:37 Speaker 01 Damn.
38:37 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah, that's a good one.
38:38 David Imel? Yeah. Okay. Well, Adobe Max happened this week. Last year I went and then took a red eye Tuesday night because it starts on a Tuesday to come back here. I decided that's a bad idea because I don't like doing that anymore. So I didn't do it. Yeah, I don't like having red eyes like bunnies. I like having regular eyes.
38:55 Andrew Manganelli? That's a.
38:55 David Imel? Hazel eyes.
38:56 Andrew Manganelli? I'm glad you did that because we got all the same information from the internet.
39:00 David Imel? What?
39:01 Speaker 01 Oh.
39:01 Andrew Manganelli? About Adobe.
39:02 David Imel? Yeah.
39:02 Andrew Manganelli? I need to do that.
39:03 David Imel? Yeah.
39:03 Andrew Manganelli? I'm glad.
39:04 David Imel? Yeah, so they had Max is their annual developer conf. It's not really, it's a development conference. They kind of show what they did and then they teach you how to use it, I guess. Um, it's sort of for creatives. They weirdly did not really seemed to, at least on the first day, ship or talk about a lot of new, new, new Premiere or After Effects features. They actually had pretty big Premiere and After Effects updates like a couple of weeks ago. So I'm not really sure if that was supposed to be like not as big of a deal. They do have generative select now in Premiere. Anyway, I'm just gonna go over Photoshop and Lightroom because that's what I use the most often and there are some interesting features here.
39:45 Speaker 01 I like Lightroom.
39:46 David Imel? You like Lightroom? You use Lightroom?
39:47 Speaker 01 Yeah.
39:48 David Imel? Alright, we'll do Lightroom first.
39:49 Speaker 01 Eee.
39:50 David Imel? So Lightroom, uh, which is a photo editing app, now has an assisted culling feature, which if you don't, do you know, do you guys know what culling is?
39:57 Speaker 02 Nope.
39:57 Speaker 01 I don't think I do, no.
39:58 David Imel? Okay.
39:58 Speaker 02 It's when you got sick sheep and you gotta do something about it.
40:01 David Imel? Not too different, actually. Um, lambs, no kidding.
40:07 David Imel? So if you're, if you're like a working photographer and you shoot burst mode, which is, you know, I'm happy for you, I would never do it myself, I don't wanna deal with that many photos. If you're like a wedding photographer and you're just going
40:22 Speaker 01 As they do.
40:22 David Imel? As they do.
40:23 Speaker 01 Those 1DXs.
40:24 David Imel? Yeah. When you go home and you have to like decide which is the best photo, that's really, really, really annoying, right? Because a lot of those photos, people are gonna be blinking, people are gonna be doing this and having to go like ding, ding, ding through every picture is very annoying. So with image recognition, you can now understand, oh, this person is blinking, this photo is overexposed. So if you import a ton of pictures, they have all of these different selection modes where you can select, okay, make sure people are smiling, make sure people are not blinking, uh, organize the photos that are overexposed versus properly exposed and it'll kind of contextual understand that. So that's very useful and you can like tag things as selects and rejects and then it'll separate them into separate areas.
41:08 David Imel? That's sort of a quality of life, really useful, but it is still using the image recognition and semantic recognition that we've developed recently.
41:16 Andrew Manganelli? It's best shot.
41:18 David Imel? It is basically best take.
41:19 Andrew Manganelli? That's kind of awesome, honestly.
41:21 David Imel? Yeah. There's a color variant slider now, so for example, in your skin tones on your face, you have many different tones. And sometimes, if you just up the contrast on a photo, it also ups the contrast on the colors in your face. So you'll have like reds and greens and, you know, yellows in your face.
41:41 Speaker 01 Shadows.
41:41 David Imel? And shadows. And if you up the contrast, it's gonna make those go away. They now have a slider that allows you to basically lower the contrast on between certain colors, or heighten the contrast between certain colors of certain areas, so that you can more easily sort of get rid of those different color variations and make it all similar. So that's cool. They have automatic dust and sensor smudge removal. So if your camera sensor or lens has dust or like marks on it, it will automatically understand that when you import the photos and it will suggest that you content to where fill them away. So that's very cool.
42:22 David Imel? I really wish that they did this with film dust, because I have thousands of little dust particles on my phone that's really freaking annoying, but we are a very small market, so they will not care about me.
42:34 Speaker 01 There's dozens of us.
42:35 David Imel? There are dozens. There are dozens. You can now batch rename files, which apparently they did not have before, which is very useful. And then also, something that's kinda cool, you can auto-select objects, and it will automatically recognize if that object created a reflection or a shadow, and it will also select that part of it.
42:55 Speaker 01 That's good.
42:56 David Imel? Yeah, so if you're like, if you're trying to fill something out, like they gave an example of a lighthouse, that they selected the lighthouse, but then the person hadn't realized, "Oh, the lighthouse is casting a reflection in the water." So if you just select the lighthouse, it'll spin this little wheel for a sec, and it'll select the lighthouse and the reflection in the water, and then when you do remove, generative remove or something, it'll also get rid of the reflection.
43:18 Speaker 01 That's cool.
43:19 David Imel? That's very helpful. So that's Lightroom. Photoshop was quite interesting. They now allow you to use different generative models for their generative fill. So instead of just using the Adobe Firefly models, they now accept Nano Banana, which is Google's Gemini image recognition model.
43:39 Andrew Manganelli? That sounds like something else.
43:40 David Imel? We never.
43:41 Andrew Manganelli? As a minion.
43:41 Speaker 02 I thought Nano Banana was Gemini's Sora. I thought it was a video generation.
43:45 David Imel? No, no, no, no. It's an image generation model. And it's something that I'm surprised we actually never talked about because it did blow up for quite a while.
43:52 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah, but it's not that good.
43:53 David Imel? Well, the good things about it is that it's really good at keeping character consistency. So if you need to generate multiple images of the same person, they would continuously look the same. And so that we're entering this weird phase because remember when ChatGPT and remember when Gemini had like a model dropdown window? And and it had like a zillion options and you're like, what is the difference between?
44:19 Speaker 01 Why do I need flash?
44:20 David Imel? Flash. So they're doing that right now. I assume they will eventually just have an auto select the model that you need feature. But for example, you know, Nano Banana has the character consistency thing. So if you want to, you know, turn the angle. Say, say you have a person facing forward and you're like, oh, I actually want the camera to be looking down on them. You can use that model and you can say, make it looking down from a 45 degree angle. It'll be looking down at them and they'll be looking up at you. So it like maintains the way that the person looks. Pretty interesting. It's kind of like a virtual camera feature.
44:51 Speaker 01 Yeah.
44:52 David Imel? Yeah, which is, I don't know, kind of weird. And then there's, you know, other models that are good at different other things. Select subject and remove background have gotten much better on device because they used to be only good in the cloud. The remove tool has gotten significantly better. There's a new generative upscale feature, which gives more partner model options. So topaz.
45:15 David Imel? Upscale AI is now an option within Photoshop. So it's very interesting. So it can like, you can take a low res image and it will upscale it the way same way that topas has always done. Yeah, I was gonna say, I know I never use these upscaling features because all of the source images I usually have are high res. But I guess for older images, maybe it's better. Like I, I use the topas ones a lot and they're really good if you set them at like 10 to 30%. Like if you, if you hit this slam upscale, make this a million pixels, it will look goopy. Goopy, yeah. But at 10 to 30%, it can do some pretty gnarly stuff. Yeah. And then I think that one of the biggest features is harmonize, which did come out last year in the beta.
45:53 David Imel? But harmonize is basically you can take any PNG, you can drop it into any image and you can hit harmonize and it will naturally make all of the lighting and the color of the, the thing that you dropped into the image. Just look like it's realistically part of that image. Oh, so Photoshop skills. Yeah, but like. Like being good at Photoshop, but it just does automatically now. Yeah, out of Photoshop. Nice. So. I like that. Those are sort of the main things. Um, I definitely probably missed a few things because I went to watch the keynote and it was like five hours long. Wow. And at least last night when I was writing this, it was not yet on YouTube. And there was no playback speed option and there was no chapters. Woof. So I did not watch that and I just watched this morning, a bunch of recap videos. So. That's the way to do it. Yeah.
46:38 David Imel? So even AI could help there. Yeah. Um, but speaking of AI, well, we should just rename this to Wave AI form or something. We talked brief, I don't even know if we talked about this, but basically, um, Miko is this new assistant for Copilot, for Microsoft's Copilot assistant. And effectively Copilot, you, you've heard of that. It's like Microsoft's sort of AI that's always in Windows and it's just always there. They have now made these 3D characters that are personifying the AI.
47:13 David Imel? And you know, a couple of weeks ago, they dropped it's sort of like, it looks like a Luma from Super Mario Galaxy, sort of.
47:20 Speaker 01 Okay.
47:20 David Imel? And it's kind of just floating there and it talks to you and it's cute, but if you tap it a bunch of times, it turns into Clippy.
47:25 Speaker 01 Yes.
47:26 David Imel? And we had mentioned this on the podcast. Almost.
47:29 Andrew Manganelli? Oh, sorry. I mean, like, we almost got what we wanted on the podcast. Like, a couple of weeks ago, we were talking about Windows 10 going away and then we were just saying
47:37 David Imel? Right.
47:37 Andrew Manganelli? Something about AI being like, we just need Clippy back in Copilot.
47:41 David Imel? Yeah.
47:41 Andrew Manganelli? And then I got tagged a bunch of times when this happened.
47:44 David Imel? Yeah.
47:44 Andrew Manganelli? It's not quite, it's, it's close. We get a brief, we get a brief Clippy. I think just like.
47:51 David Imel? Is it, so it's not persistent? He just.
47:53 Andrew Manganelli? No, he just, it says it just poofs into Clippy as an Easter egg.
47:56 David Imel? And then it disappears?
47:57 Andrew Manganelli? I think so.
47:58 David Imel? Are you kidding me?
47:58 Andrew Manganelli? Exactly. That's, I don't need this flubber ass green thing. I need Clippy. And I mean, I can understand if you want Miko, right? To be the new thing, like, let that be the default. But if you already programmed Clippy into it, give us a Clippy option. Nostalgia sells, Microsoft.
48:15 David Imel? It's true.
48:15 Andrew Manganelli? Microsoft, you, you should know better than anyone nostalgia sells. You're selling all these shirts with like MS Paint logos on it, like, just let Clippy be an option.
48:24 David Imel? Yeah. I'd pay $500 a month for Clippy.
48:27 Andrew Manganelli? Okay, well, not all of us would, but.
48:31 David Imel? Yeah.
48:31 Speaker 01 But with it, do your dishes.
48:33 David Imel? Yeah, do your dishes. So, speaking of trivia.
48:38 Andrew Manganelli? There was like.
48:40 Andrew Manganelli? Oh.
48:41 David Imel? Oh, spooky trivia.
48:46 Speaker 02 Guys, before we get into trivia, I just want to drop one little news story that I don't know much about, but I just want to make everyone aware.
48:53 Speaker 02 My, I don't know if it's Halloween spookiness, my monitor is flickering like crazy right now.
48:58 Andrew Manganelli? It's definitely not the giant minion glasses.
49:02 Speaker 02 I did take off these glasses to see, like, anyway. Those of you who are interested in graphic design, for some reason right now, the affinity suite of iPad apps is free. $0. Who knows if that, I think this is going to end soon, maybe before this podcast comes out, but it has something to do with Canva making some big announcement through, I don't know, just, but if you want to check out some cool apps that are now free, for now, as of right now, today, Wednesday. Anyway, guys, trivia, thin phones are in.
49:37 Speaker 02 The news, right? But thin phones themselves are not new. Released in late 2014, what phone had a total depth of just 4.8 millimeters?
49:52 Andrew Manganelli? What year?
49:53 Speaker 02 Late 2014, specifically December 2014. So almost 2015.
49:59 Speaker 01 4.8 millimeters.
50:00 Speaker 02 4.8 millimeters. I believe that's thinner than the edge and the air.
50:05 Speaker 01 It is.
50:05 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah.
50:06 Speaker 01 Okay. God, I know. What a spooky question. I, I did, I had, I researched this because I wrote about it for my air video and I didn't name drop it, which I maybe should have. Well, watch. Nothing is obvious. All right. Well, answers will be at the end like usual. We'll be right back.
50:32 Speaker 01 Support for the show comes from Framer. If you want to create a website that looks great, feels handcrafted and comes together fast and seamlessly, then look no further than Framer. It's a complete website platform, not just a builder. So teams can launch and keep improving their sites in one place. It helps creators, teams and businesses ship production ready websites faster than ever while getting every detail right. You're able to prompt, inspect, edit and publish in one place at a whole new pace. On Framer, agents and humans work in tandem. Agents bring speed and scale while people bring taste, judgment and control. And that all takes place in the same workspace where the real site is designed and managed and reviewed and published. Those ideas land on the canvas, stay editable and can be published when the team is ready. Framer is an enterprise level solution.
51:17 Speaker 01 Thousands of businesses from early stage startups to Fortune 500s are choosing to build their websites in Framer where changes take minutes instead of days. Learn how you can get more out of your site from a Framer specialist or get started building for free today at framer.com/wave for 30% off a Framer Pro annual plan. That's framer.com/wave. Rules and restrictions may apply.
51:38 Speaker 05 This episode is brought to you by On Investing, an original podcast from Charles Schwab. Each week, hosts Lizanne Saunders, Schwab's Chief Investment Strategist, and Colin Martin, Head of Fixed Income Research and Strategy for the Schwab Center for Financial Research, bring you fresh insights on what's happening in the markets and why, and what the implications might be for your portfolio. Join Colin and Lizanne as they explore questions like, how do you evaluate corporate bonds that look interesting? And what sectors are on the move right now? Download the latest episode and subscribe at schwab.com/oninvesting, or wherever you get your podcasts.
52:23 Speaker 05 This episode is brought to you by On Investing, an original podcast from Charles Schwab. Each week, hosts Lizanne Saunders, Schwab's Chief Investment Strategist, and Colin Martin, Head of Fixed Income Research and Strategy for the Schwab Center for Financial Research, bring you fresh insights on what's happening in the markets and why, and what the implications might be for your portfolio. Join Colin and Lizanne as they explore questions like, how do you evaluate corporate bonds that look interesting? And what sectors are on the move right now? Download the latest episode and subscribe at schwab.com/oninvesting, or wherever you get your podcasts.
53:08 Speaker 04 Welcome back. We are going to start this segment by asking our resident minion, Ellis, what is your battery life?
53:15 Speaker 02 Oh, a little bit.
53:17 David Imel? Can we use that?
53:18 Speaker 02 So today was a little extra because my train was not running this morning. It took me two hours to get to work. Woo! So a little extra usage on the Purple 12 Mini today. Who wants to take a little crack? Came off the charger a little early today, too. I was up bright and early, I think. Came off the charger at 7:45 a.m. It is currently 12:15. I don't know how to do math, so you guys can figure that one out. There's a 30 in there.
53:46 Andrew Manganelli? Four and a half hours.
53:48 David Imel? 52%.
53:49 Speaker 02 52%?
53:50 Andrew Manganelli? I literally was gonna say 52%.
53:52 Speaker 02 52%, 52%?
53:53 David Imel? I was thinking 63.
53:55 Speaker 02 63%?
53:58 Speaker 02 I'm currently at 56% giving, I think that would make David and Andrew a little closer.
54:05 David Imel? What'd you say, Andrew?
54:06 Andrew Manganelli? I was going to say that, but there's no way I can prove that, so David wins.
54:10 David Imel? Oh. Well, it's not like it was a trivia point, even though I wish it was.
54:15 Speaker 02 But you know what's not?
54:18 Speaker 02 56%?
54:20 Speaker 02 The winning percentage of the Philadelphia 76ers, because it is at 100%.
54:25 Andrew Manganelli? Unbelievable. Have the Spurs lost yet?
54:27 Speaker 02 No, neither have the Thunder. Anyway, but this isn't a basketball podcast. This is a Nothing 3A Lite podcast. Hit it.
54:37 David Imel? Yeah, we gotta talk about this. Um, the bu- okay. Nothing, when it came out, was a budget brand.
54:47 David Imel? And then they made the A series, which was their budget model for the budget brand. And I remember us joking around about how they made a budget line for the budget brand. And then they made a budget company that was a sub-brand that was budgeter.
55:03 Andrew Manganelli? CMF.
55:04 David Imel? CMF.
55:05 Speaker 04 Two budget, two furious.
55:06 David Imel? Two budget, two furious. And then now they have the Nothing 3A Lite, which is the budget of the, it's the budget phone.
55:17 Andrew Manganelli? Budget version of the budget.
55:19 David Imel? Budget, the budget version of the budget line of the budget company.
55:26 Speaker 02 Of the, of the pro, pro version of the budget company.
55:29 David Imel? But not the budget sub-brand.
55:32 Andrew Manganelli? That makes sense. Why are you confused?
55:33 Speaker 01 Somebody needs to do a hierarchy of all these phones, because I could see, it's very clear in my head, how the Nothing Phone 3 could be above the Nothing Phone 3A. And the Nothing Phone 3, isn't there a Nothing Phone 3A Pro?
55:47 Andrew Manganelli? Yep.
55:47 David Imel? Yes.
55:48 Speaker 01 And is that below the Nothing Phone 3 or above the?
55:51 David Imel? I think it's below.
55:52 Andrew Manganelli? I have the price. Do you want me to read the prices off for all of them?
55:54 Speaker 01 Maybe the prices, okay.
55:55 David Imel? And I want to, I want to acknowledge as well that the, this 3A Lite is almost the same price as the original Nothing Phone 1 launched.
56:03 Andrew Manganelli? That I did not have written down, but.
56:05 David Imel? Yeah, okay.
56:05 Andrew Manganelli? So Nothing Phone 3 is 799.
56:07 David Imel? Okay.
56:08 Andrew Manganelli? And then the 3A is 379, the 3A Pro is 459, and this 3A Lite is approximately 290 dollars. We're basing this off of, it's not available in the US, so it's 249 euros or?
56:20 David Imel? And you said the 3A Pro was 4.
56:22 Andrew Manganelli? 459.
56:23 David Imel? 59. And then the 3.
56:25 Andrew Manganelli? Is $800.
56:26 Speaker 01 Okay, so that's the hierarchy.
56:28 Andrew Manganelli? Of that. And then the CMF Phone 2 Pro is $279.
56:33 Speaker 01 Which is right below the 3A Lite.
56:35 David Imel? Oh, right.
56:35 Andrew Manganelli? It's $10 less.
56:36 David Imel? Version of the budget.
56:37 Speaker 01 Okay, okay, I got it. So it's, so it's the Nothing Phone 3, then it's the 3A Pro, then it's the 3A, then it's the 3A Lite, then it's the Nothing, a CMF Phone.
56:47 Andrew Manganelli? Correct. Also, the CMF Phones are listed on the Nothing website in the phone section. So like, you can see, I pulled all of these straight from the phone section on nothing.com. What you might notice is this 3, oh my God, trying to remember all these.
57:02 Speaker 01 3A Lite.
57:02 Andrew Manganelli? The 3A Lite pricing is super similar to the CMF Phone 2 Pro pricing.
57:06 Speaker 01 Right.
57:07 Andrew Manganelli? That's not the only thing that's similar.
57:08 Speaker 01 Wait, yeah.
57:09 Andrew Manganelli? I've posted a side by side here. Inside of our document.
57:13 Speaker 01 In it.
57:14 Andrew Manganelli? And do these phones look familiar? Could someone explain?
57:18 Speaker 01 Okay, so the camera arrangements are practically identical. They're not like the same
57:27 Speaker 01 colors and there's like some screws and stuff, but like by and large, a lot of the features of these things look very, very similar. Wait, okay, I have some questions then. And it looks like you have the answers. Are they the same chip?
57:41 Andrew Manganelli? Yep.
57:41 Speaker 01 Are they the same display?
57:43 Andrew Manganelli? I mean, I have a set of specs here and let's just say they're the same.
57:48 Speaker 01 Oh, my God. The button layouts are the same.
57:51 David Imel? Oh, my God.
57:51 Speaker 01 The camera layouts are the same.
57:53 Andrew Manganelli? Correct.
57:54 David Imel? Wow.
57:54 Speaker 01 The camera, the battery is the same?
57:56 Andrew Manganelli? Mm hmm.
57:57 Speaker 01 Okay, so this is this, okay, so it's the same phone, but just with a different back and a different branding.
58:05 Andrew Manganelli? Yes, this is basically the CMF Phone 2 Pro with Nothing Design Language on the back, including a glass back versus the screw off, like David was saying, orange back.
58:15 Speaker 01 It was funny. I was so ready to call this dumb, but I actually prefer the Nothing branding. And so I would buy this over the CMF Phone.
58:20 David Imel? Well, it's also like glass instead of plastic.
58:22 Speaker 01 Yeah, like the CMF Phone's plastic, which like you can take off and do the modular thing.
58:25 Andrew Manganelli? I believe it's plastic.
58:26 Speaker 01 And have the like lanyard or whatever, but I would buy this over that.
58:29 David Imel? Yeah, me too.
58:30 Andrew Manganelli? I think it's funny because I've kind of liked Nothing's clear white branding and
58:34 Speaker 01 Yeah.
58:35 Andrew Manganelli? this is my favorite out of all of them because of how simple it is. It's just like mostly white, clear, some hints of black and red every once in a while. And that's about it. It's not over the top like some of the other Nothing Phones have been. And I think this is the best looking Nothing Phone.
58:49 David Imel? What's the weird like pull tab thing on the back?
58:52 Speaker 01 I think that's just like the where the battery went in. Does the better is the better removable?
58:58 Speaker 02 It looks like there's a little.
58:59 Speaker 01 This whole side?
59:00 Speaker 02 Yeah, there's like a little scoop place for you to put your like, it looks like you're meant to take that.
59:05 Speaker 01 It that's what it's supposed to look like. It's totally non-functional. It's just designed.
59:07 Speaker 02 You're kidding.
59:08 Speaker 01 Of course. Yeah, that's just how it looks.
59:09 Speaker 02 Now, it's one. It's one thing to choose design over function, but to design something to look functional is psychotic.
59:15 Speaker 01 Have you heard of nothing before? That's their whole thing.
59:18 Speaker 02 No, no, no. Nothing makes designs that look pretty. That's not pretty. That looks like that.
59:22 Speaker 01 No, no, no.
59:22 Speaker 02 That literally invites you to stick your thumb in there.
59:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's their whole aesthetic is like there are screws under there, which are supposed to invite you to unscrew things, but you never do that. You can't take this off and unscrew this.
59:32 Speaker 02 I don't know, Mark has like, like there are screws that in all of our devices and I'm not, I don't feel begged to unscrew them. That that is like, look what's in there. That.
59:42 Speaker 01 Most, I'll say most phones don't have like, they don't like visible screws.
59:47 Speaker 02 Yeah.
59:47 Speaker 01 Their aesthetic is visible screws.
59:50 Speaker 02 Yeah.
59:50 Speaker 01 And visible screws to me feels like, oh, I can open the back. You can't open the back. All of this screams, I should be able to open the back, but you can't. And that's, that's just a nothing thing.
1:00:01 Speaker 02 You're losing me, Carl.
1:00:03 Andrew Manganelli? They also to go with the nothing, uh, design language is they've had glyph interfaces on a lot of other ones. This glyph interface is one singular white dot on the bottom, which at first I thought, wait, did we just get back notification LEDs? Like I remember on my Note 8, I had one LED on the front and like blue was text, green was email, yellow was Snapchat. Like, I loved that. And I thought this was that again. It's not. Um, in fact, when you go in the through the setup process, it says new glyph interface. And I'm waiting for an animation to happen.
1:00:36 Speaker 01 Oh.
1:00:36 Andrew Manganelli? And then I click next, expecting the animation to go, and it just goes into the essential button.
1:00:40 Speaker 01 This could be so much cooler. Okay. So just to, so if video viewers are looking at this, there's a dot on the bottom right corner down here of the phone. It's a white LED.
1:00:51 David Imel? Uh, oh, man. So you can do the like essential notification thing, or if a certain
1:00:55 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah.
1:00:56 David Imel? app notifies you, then it lights up, which is some information. But if this was a multicolor LED.
1:01:02 Andrew Manganelli? I know.
1:01:03 David Imel? I would be raving about this.
1:01:04 Andrew Manganelli? I would too.
1:01:05 David Imel? I'm so happy about this. The simplest thing. Oh, that's so close.
1:01:08 Andrew Manganelli? It's funny that one multicolor LED would be better than every glyph nothing's ever done before, and they still didn't do it.
1:01:14 David Imel? God. I wonder if you could hack that, if it's actually like an RGB LED, kind of like the Nexus 6? Was it the Nexus 6?
1:01:22 Andrew Manganelli? I forgot. It was one of those.
1:01:23 David Imel? One of the Nexus's had a, had a, it was Shimano, yeah. Oh, you're saying which one had a multicolor LED? There was one that had a LED, like, they advertised that it's just a white notification LED on the back, and, but it would, it was actually a multicolor LED. They only used the, the white light. Uh, but there was in, within CyanogenMod, you could assign different colors to different app notifications. Because they were able to actually do that. So. Those were the days. Maybe this will be a thing that people can figure out.
1:01:55 Andrew Manganelli? Hopefully.
1:01:56 David Imel? Yeah.
1:01:56 Andrew Manganelli? Um, I have.
1:01:57 David Imel? Nexus S. Nexus S? But I did it on my phone. I didn't have a Nexus S. I don't know, whatever.
1:02:02 Andrew Manganelli? I have, um, one other interesting thing about this. So this is the first device that Nothing is launching with the feature called Lock Glimpse enabled by default. If you don't know what Lock Glimpse is, it's a setting that's been on some, I think it was in, uh, Nothing OS 4.0 beta, um, where essentially you turn it on and on your lock screen, now it changes every time you kind of turn the phone on and off, um, which can also sometimes go onto linked articles and what everyone's assuming are going to be paid ad spots for Nothing, which on the beta release, the community was really upset about it, to the point where three days ago, which would be, I think, the 26th, today is the 29th,
1:02:45 Andrew Manganelli? Nothing released a statement saying, guys, guys, pump the brakes, this is opt-in only, you have to go into the settings, you have to opt into this, it's not going to take over, and then full well knowing that three days later, this phone gets released with it turned on by default. I checked, I set up the phone, it's on by default.
1:03:03 David Imel? Hmm.
1:03:03 Andrew Manganelli? Um, so presumably you now have, uh, not only does it come with TikTok, Instagram, and I, one other preloaded onto the phone.
1:03:12 David Imel? Oh my gosh.
1:03:12 Andrew Manganelli? Um, you get Lock Glimpse pre-defaulted on. On this phone presumably to make it cheaper. So it's
1:03:20 Speaker 01 Wow.
1:03:20 Andrew Manganelli? $10. You kind of think like, is this worth 10 more dollars than the Nothing, the CMF Phone 2 Pro? Which kind of feels like it, if you like the design and the glass back, but.
1:03:29 Speaker 01 It also shows ads?
1:03:31 Andrew Manganelli? It does. I mean, you can turn it off, but it's a.
1:03:34 Speaker 01 It was like, it was on by default like that?
1:03:35 Andrew Manganelli? It was on by default like that. Yep. It's funny because the article I read said, this is a slippery slope. It's like, wow, that slope is slick. Because three days later, it is already defaulted on.
1:03:45 Speaker 01 Dang.
1:03:46 Andrew Manganelli? Welcome to the Nothing CMF 2 Pro 2. Think even as a joke to mess that up, I messed it up. So I don't even know what I just said.
1:03:54 Speaker 01 It would be the Nothing Phone 2 Ultra.
1:03:57 David Imel? The CMF?
1:03:58 Andrew Manganelli? The CMF Phone?
1:04:00 Speaker 01 It would be a CMF Phone 2 Ultra, because it would be right above the CMF Phone 2 Pro.
1:04:05 Speaker 04 You know what else is a 2 Pro?
1:04:07 David Imel? A baby.
1:04:08 Andrew Manganelli? Oh, he was waiting.
1:04:10 David Imel? All my. Bring it out. All my e-ink enjoyers out there. All right. You know that we are big Books fans over here at the Waveform Podcast. More than one of us. Me and Ellis. So we talked about the Books.
1:04:29 David Imel? Palma 2 Pro.
1:04:31 Speaker 01 You say Books way, you hit the O way harder than I thought you were supposed to.
1:04:35 David Imel? Fun, Marquez. It's fun.
1:04:37 Speaker 01 It's not Books, though. You're saying Books.
1:04:39 Andrew Manganelli? Today is the Boo.
1:04:43 David Imel? Okay.
1:04:44 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:04:44 David Imel? We talked about the Books Palma 2 Pro.
1:04:46 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:04:46 David Imel? Which has an e-ink display. It also has a pen that unfortunately does not magnetize it to it and there's like no holder for it.
1:04:56 Speaker 01 It's optional.
1:04:57 David Imel? On the case. So, okay, so yeah. The big thing about this is that it has, it has a SIM card tray. Which has the ability to, you can either put a SIM card tray in it so that you can, you know, access books on the internet. Or you can download, you know, you can listen to Spotify or you could do whatever. It's, I'm wondering how close this is to a phone, because I don't really know if it has a microphone.
1:05:19 Speaker 01 It's as close to a phone as the iPod Touch was to an iPhone.
1:05:22 Speaker 02 Wait, you can't make phone calls on it?
1:05:24 David Imel? I'm not sure yet. I haven't tried. You can put data on it.
1:05:27 Speaker 01 On an iPod?
1:05:28 David Imel? There was no cellular on an iPod Touch, so it's actually closer to a phone on the iPod Touch.
1:05:32 Speaker 01 But there was SIM data on an iPod?
1:05:34 David Imel? No, no SIM.
1:05:35 Speaker 01 Okay, yeah, this has SIM data, right?
1:05:37 David Imel? Yes, well, yeah, you can have a SIM card. So, okay, so it has a SIM card tray in it that can double as a micro SD card express or micro SD card reader. But it already has 128 gigs of storage in it, which is pretty good for a e-ink e-reader.
1:05:52 Speaker 02 Twice as much as my 12 Mini.
1:05:54 David Imel? Has 8 gigs of RAM. It's got a 3,950-million-power battery.
1:06:01 Speaker 01 Wow.
1:06:01 David Imel? So that's pretty big, so it's probably gonna last a very long time.
1:06:04 Speaker 02 Twice as much as my phone.
1:06:07 David Imel? A 6.13-inch Collidio 3E paper display, which is color, so it can do color now. Has an Octa Core CPU. It says AGPS, A-GPS, which I don't really know what that means. But there's this optional additional pen for it. So you can mark things up, and I've tried this so far, and it's very, very seamless, it's very quick. And then, the Folio case that they sell with it is a case, first off. And then it has this, it has MagSafe, by the way. It's like an unofficial MagSafe ring.
1:06:43 Speaker 01 It's everywhere.
1:06:44 David Imel? That the case attaches to. But the case also has magnets in it, so when you close the case, it locks. And when you open the case, it unlocks the Book's Palma 2 Pro.
1:06:55 Speaker 01 That's a subtle thing?
1:06:56 David Imel? Which-
1:06:56 Speaker 01 That everyone should be doing with their Folio cases.
1:06:58 David Imel? Very similar to the HTC Dot Matrix display case.
1:07:02 Speaker 01 Yeah, for the M9 or whatever?
1:07:04 David Imel? Yeah, for the M9.
1:07:05 Speaker 01 Wow.
1:07:06 David Imel? And, uh, yeah, I am just extremely excited to use this. I may put a SIM card in it and like see how close I can get to actually using it as a phone. I think it would be great. But also, I unboxed it just this morning, and it has an AI assistant. I'm not really sure-
1:07:21 Speaker 01 Of course.
1:07:22 David Imel? What a, what a reading tablet.
1:07:25 Speaker 01 Summarize this book for me. Please don't summarize anything I'm reading.
1:07:29 David Imel? Yeah. So there is that, unfortunately.
1:07:32 Speaker 02 They were so close to perfection.
1:07:34 David Imel? I know, they didn't, so they didn't put an air- area for the pen anywhere on the case, which is kind of annoying. I feel like they should have had like a loop on the front. But it does magnetize to it. So if it does magnetize to the front and it's pretty secure, it doesn't really feel like it's gonna fall off. So hopefully that wouldn't fall off in like a bag.
1:07:49 Speaker 01 But that's a coincidence.
1:07:50 David Imel? That's a, uh, I don't know. I think they might have done that on purpose.
1:07:53 Speaker 01 Oh, thank you.
1:07:53 David Imel? But also the case, even though it has MagSafe, like a MagSafe ring on the back, it can also turn into like this folio thing where it comes off and then is used as a kickstand.
1:08:04 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
1:08:04 David Imel? Uh, I again, am not really sure why you need a kickstand for your phone sized e-reader because you're not really gonna be watching videos or TikTok or anything on it.
1:08:12 Speaker 01 It's color.
1:08:13 David Imel? But it is color, so you could. Um, anyway, I'm very excited about this thing. We've been talking about it for weeks and, uh, I believe it's $400.
1:08:23 Speaker 01 Damn.
1:08:24 David Imel? Which is a bit expensive. It's a little bit more expensive than the previous Bookspalma 2.
1:08:27 Speaker 01 Does the pen come with that $400 or is that separate?
1:08:30 David Imel? My friend. Yeah. Yeah. The InkSense Plus bundle, which is the pen, oh, it's only a digital $30.
1:08:37 Speaker 01 These names are wild.
1:08:38 David Imel? Oh, so the $30 comes with the case and the pen?
1:08:41 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:08:41 David Imel? Wow.
1:08:42 Speaker 01 Sorry, the ink.
1:08:44 David Imel? InkSense bundle.
1:08:45 Speaker 01 The pen and the case come for the $30.
1:08:47 David Imel? Yeah, so it's $400 just for the Bookspalma Pro 2.
1:08:50 Speaker 01 Somebody has to rewind and play what David just said.
1:08:53 David Imel? Oh, so the $30 comes with the case and the pen?
1:08:56 Speaker 01 Just, you get $30 with the pen and the case, which would be really sick. They just give you $30 with everything. That's awesome.
1:09:03 David Imel? If you pay an extra 30 bucks, you, you get the, the case and the pen, which I think is a pretty good deal.
1:09:08 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:09:08 David Imel? Um, yeah, and it comes in black and white, but the black sucks and the white is awesome, so.
1:09:12 Speaker 01 You said writing with the pen is pretty awesome.
1:09:14 David Imel? Yeah, the pen has pretty seamless, pretty much instantaneous feedback where it's just like, it just shows up on the screen immediately.
1:09:22 Speaker 01 Can we try?
1:09:23 David Imel? Yeah, we can try it.
1:09:23 Speaker 01 You should hold it up to the microphone for the ASMR of the pen on the surface. Is this like a nice, like, feeling surface to write on?
1:09:30 David Imel? Yeah. Yeah, definitely.
1:09:32 Speaker 01 Kind of sounds nice.
1:09:32 David Imel? It's, it does sound nice, like.
1:09:35 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:09:40 David Imel? Anyway, I'm excited. I want to mainline this for a while because I've been using, I've been using the Books Palma 2 for a very long time. So
1:09:48 Speaker 01 There you have it.
1:09:49 David Imel? We finally got it.
1:09:50 Speaker 02 I want to play with that later.
1:09:51 Andrew Manganelli? What's the name of the AI assistant? Does it have a name?
1:09:54 David Imel? It just says AI assistant. Yeah, I don't know yet what the AI assistant does.
1:09:59 Andrew Manganelli? I'm surprised it doesn't have a name because Books is already like a pretty creative name. You'd think they would have went hard.
1:10:06 Speaker 02 His name is like pager. I don't know. Can we do trivia, please?
1:10:11 Andrew Manganelli? Yes.
1:10:12 Speaker 02 Spooky trivia.
1:10:13 David Imel? Books also makes like tablets and stuff under the Books brand. Just saying.
1:10:18 Andrew Manganelli? Cool. Uh, so Daniel Ek, CEO of Spotify, was also the CEO of what torrenting company briefly in 2006?
1:10:31 Speaker 01 Oh, wow.
1:10:33 David Imel? Not surprised.
1:10:34 Speaker 02 I didn't know this company had a CEO. I just assumed it was a bunch of guys in like a shipping container somewhere like, like breaking the law.
1:10:42 Andrew Manganelli? Full credit, Eric told me this this morning and I did not believe him and I looked it up and it was true.
1:10:46 David Imel? It's, that's good.
1:10:47 Andrew Manganelli? Wait, a torrenting person turned into the Spotify?
1:10:50 David Imel? Correct.
1:10:51 Andrew Manganelli? That's fantastic. That's so good.
1:10:54 David Imel? So no matter what we write down, it's going to be pretty incredible.
1:10:58 Andrew Manganelli? I feel like all the torrenting sites at that time were, looked exactly the same, which is a different logo and color scheme.
1:11:03 Speaker 02 This is good. He's a pirate. This is a good question for the pirate man.
1:11:07 David Imel? It's true.
1:11:07 Speaker 02 All right, now we'll do it.
1:11:18 Speaker 01 Support for the show comes from Jira by Atlassian. So AI is only as useful as the context it has to work from. But when that context is scattered across tools like threads and DMs, that means your team and your AI agents end up flying kind of blind. That's the problem Jira solves. What's the goal tied to your project? What got decided last week in Slack? Atlassian's teamwork graph pulls all of these pieces together from Jira, Confluence, Slack, GitHub, and more, so nothing falls through the cracks. With Jira, you can actually share that context with the AI agents you already use, like Claude, Cursor, and GitHub Copilot. Assign them work directly or connect your agents through MCP. Spend less time digging through endless links and DMs, less time chasing down what got decided and by who, and more time actually shipping.
1:12:01 Speaker 01 Learn more at jira.com. That's J-I-R-A dot com.
1:12:06 Speaker 05 Ask yourself, what are your best people spending their time on right now? Expense reports, receipt chasing, month end close that takes weeks. You become what you spend on, and that's not what you're building toward. Brex is the intelligent finance platform that eliminates that work before it starts. AI agents that handle the manual stuff automatically so your team can spend their time on what actually compounds. It's time to get Brex AF. Learn more at brex.com/AF.
1:12:43 Speaker 06 If you're looking to hire, you need Indeed. With Indeed Sponsored Jobs, you can spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Less stress, less time, more results. And listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsored job credit to help your job get the premium status it deserves at indeed.com/podcast. Just go to indeed.com/podcast right now and support our show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Indeed.com/podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need to hire? This is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.
1:13:27 Speaker 02 Welcome back. So those of you who are familiar with how we do things here around the office may know that we record this podcast right before eating lunch, which is why the third segment on today's show is going to be making the hosts eat a ton of candy at 12:36 PM. Specifically, we're to be doing a blind candy ranking where we give our hosts a series of pieces of Halloween candy that they must rank from... It was supposed to be 1 to 10, but I got a lot of fun candy. So maybe we can make it 1 to 12? So I'm going to say 1 to 12. Olivia, I'm sorry in advance because I already asked you to make a 1 through 10 ranking sheet, and now you're going to add two more. So sorry about that.
1:14:09 Speaker 02 But what I'm going to need you guys to do is each eat the piece of candy that we hand to you and then agree on where it falls on the ranking without knowing what will come next. Are you guys ready?
1:14:24 Speaker 01 As an experienced Halloween trick-or-treater, I may not need to eat most of these to know where I want to put them on the ranking.
1:14:31 Speaker 02 No, no, no. That's not optional.
1:14:36 Andrew Manganelli? We are working together on this, correct?
1:14:38 Speaker 02 You are working together on this. You must come to a consensus of where everything ranks.
1:14:42 Andrew Manganelli? Should we get a baseline between the three of us of just out of the blue? What is your favorite piece of Halloween candy?
1:14:49 Speaker 02 Ooh.
1:14:50 Andrew Manganelli? To know of like if right now you had like-
1:14:52 David Imel? I'm sorry to advance my answer.
1:14:54 Andrew Manganelli? Well, I just want to know like if it popped up, you're immediately number one, no questions asked.
1:14:59 David Imel? I think generally Twix for me.
1:15:01 Andrew Manganelli? I totally, I don't know if I agree, but you could convince me.
1:15:06 David Imel? I really like Twix, but my top candies are incredibly unpopular, unfortunately. But I like Reese's, I like Skittles and Starburst. I really like Starburst jelly beans. Have you had those?
1:15:18 Andrew Manganelli? I love Starburst jelly beans.
1:15:19 David Imel? They're really good, but my top two are candy corn and dots.
1:15:22 Andrew Manganelli? Oh.
1:15:23 Speaker 02 Candy corn is fire.
1:15:24 Andrew Manganelli? Candy corn's sick. Dots is-
1:15:26 Speaker 02 Wait, is this a whole room of candy corn enjoyers? That is so rare.
1:15:30 Andrew Manganelli? It's so rare.
1:15:31 David Imel? Awesome. Usually somebody, I get a grown out of that usually. Give me the flavored wax.
1:15:35 Andrew Manganelli? Dots, dots gives me all grown at dots.
1:15:36 David Imel? The flavored wax. Dots is like once a year. That's why it's like good Halloween candy because I only eat candy corn once a year.
1:15:43 Speaker 02 Wait, Mark has, why did I think you liked dots?
1:15:45 Andrew Manganelli? No, he does. He just has it as a top two.
1:15:47 David Imel? That's my top two.
1:15:48 Speaker 02 But they make you groan, Andrew.
1:15:50 Andrew Manganelli? Yes.
1:15:50 Speaker 02 Okay. Well-
1:15:52 Andrew Manganelli? It's a lot of chewing.
1:15:52 Speaker 02 On that note, the first candy is dots.
1:15:57 David Imel? That's, oh wow.
1:15:59 Andrew Manganelli? Fucking go.
1:16:02 David Imel? Alright, well-
1:16:03 Andrew Manganelli? Guys, I'm not eating anything. Just kidding. It's the hardest thing to chew. I will eat it.
1:16:07 Speaker 02 Yeah, unfortunately, the variety pack that Alex bought only had one thing of dots in it, which was-
1:16:12 Andrew Manganelli? As it should.
1:16:14 Speaker 02 There's like 60 pieces of candy.
1:16:16 David Imel? One.
1:16:17 Andrew Manganelli? Okay, I will say those are better than I remember.
1:16:20 David Imel? There you go.
1:16:20 Andrew Manganelli? Similarly as chewy. There's a little bit of um aftertaste along the lines of the stuff the dentist used to clean your teeth.
1:16:28 David Imel? That's-
1:16:29 Andrew Manganelli? Which isn't my favorite, but it's pretty good. I don't think I can agree with one.
1:16:34 David Imel? It's not one.
1:16:35 Andrew Manganelli? It's not one.
1:16:36 David Imel? I like-
1:16:37 Andrew Manganelli? I'll go-
1:16:38 David Imel? Top two and it's not two.
1:16:41 David Imel? You don't even know what the other ones are.
1:16:43 Andrew Manganelli? I can't. There's, I can't put this top two.
1:16:47 Speaker 01 All right. I'm not settling for anything out of the top half. Whatever.
1:16:49 Andrew Manganelli? Oh, no, no, I agree. I'll go top half. I like five.
1:16:53 Speaker 02 Five, five out of 12?
1:16:54 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah, five out of 12.
1:16:55 Speaker 01 We're gonna get four better than this?
1:16:56 David Imel? It's the first pick.
1:16:57 Andrew Manganelli? I think so. Yeah, yeah, okay, okay.
1:17:00 Speaker 02 All right, dots in at number five. Candy number two, another polemical one. Candy number two is the blue dude. Polemical? Polemical?
1:17:12 Speaker 01 It's like a chemical thing?
1:17:13 Speaker 02 Nope, just means that people get angry. Almond joy.
1:17:17 Speaker 01 Oh, I love almond joys.
1:17:19 Andrew Manganelli? You guys know how I feel about almonds?
1:17:22 Speaker 01 Damn.
1:17:23 Andrew Manganelli? Really? What do you feel about almonds?
1:17:25 Speaker 01 You felt joyful about almonds?
1:17:27 Andrew Manganelli? I didn't tell you how I feel about almonds?
1:17:28 Speaker 01 No. Oh, I think you could just get rid of almonds and nothing of value would be lost.
1:17:32 Speaker 02 Mark, oh my god.
1:17:33 Andrew Manganelli? I love almonds.
1:17:34 Speaker 02 This conversation again.
1:17:36 Speaker 01 Besides the water.
1:17:37 Andrew Manganelli? I can say, I will be with you similar to the rankings because I'm not a huge coconut person.
1:17:42 David Imel? This is so good.
1:17:45 David Imel? Oh my god.
1:17:47 Speaker 01 This is top two and it's not two. I'm also not a huge coconut person.
1:17:52 David Imel? This is so good.
1:17:53 Andrew Manganelli? Mark, as I'm interested where you are. You're under dots for this. I'm with you under dots.
1:17:58 Speaker 01 No, he's above dots, so I can tell. It's, no, it's below dots. It's, it's better than expected and it's not because of the almond.
1:18:06 David Imel? This is so much better than.
1:18:06 Andrew Manganelli? You like the coconut?
1:18:07 Speaker 01 I like coconut part.
1:18:09 Andrew Manganelli? I'm getting, I'm warming up to coconut, but this still just is not my favorite.
1:18:12 Speaker 01 How do you feel about the, what's the Girl Scout cookie?
1:18:15 Andrew Manganelli? Uh, Samoas.
1:18:17 Speaker 01 No, no, no.
1:18:17 Andrew Manganelli? It's got a different name now, I believe.
1:18:19 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think it's Samoas. Oh, because Tagalong, yeah, Samoas.
1:18:21 Andrew Manganelli? Tag along.
1:18:21 Speaker 01 How do you feel about Samoas?
1:18:23 Andrew Manganelli? I don't love them.
1:18:24 Speaker 01 Okay, so this reminds me of Samoas.
1:18:26 Andrew Manganelli? Mm-hmm.
1:18:27 Speaker 01 I put this six.
1:18:30 Speaker 02 Four.
1:18:30 Andrew Manganelli? I'll go six. I think six because I'm scared of the back half. But I think I like dots more. I've been turning into a gummy candy person lately, so maybe dots is just hitting different as of now.
1:18:40 Speaker 02 Six? Six?
1:18:41 Speaker 01 We're putting a six.
1:18:42 Speaker 02 Oh my gosh.
1:18:43 Speaker 01 These are, David wants it like one or two, but.
1:18:46 David Imel? Almond Joy is so much better than Dots. Dots are fine.
1:18:49 Speaker 02 I'm gonna try to not give you all the super chewy ones in succession to like keep your jaws alive through this.
1:18:56 Speaker 01 Thank you.
1:18:56 Speaker 02 But.
1:18:57 Speaker 01 But more Dots will be fine.
1:18:58 Speaker 02 Well, they're not Dots, but they are a special Halloween edition.
1:19:02 Speaker 01 Laffy Taffy?
1:19:03 Speaker 02 Wild berry banana, Laffy Taffy.
1:19:07 Andrew Manganelli? That flavor sounds wild.
1:19:10 David Imel? My jaw got tired listening to Ellis say what it was.
1:19:13 Speaker 02 Was that my first missed throw? Damn.
1:19:15 Speaker 01 I don't remember what a Laffy Taffy tastes like.
1:19:18 David Imel? Having a joke on every rapper was one of my favorite things about.
1:19:21 Andrew Manganelli? Oh, I didn't know that until I just read it right now, so.
1:19:23 Speaker 02 You think it's just regular taffy?
1:19:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, I wanna read my, can I read my jokes?
1:19:27 David Imel? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:19:29 Speaker 01 What do you do if you see a blue mango?
1:19:32 Speaker 01 You try to cheer it up?
1:19:35 David Imel? Okay, my answer to that?
1:19:36 Speaker 02 Wait, I don't get that.
1:19:37 David Imel? Wait, how does that make sense?
1:19:37 Andrew Manganelli? A blue mango?
1:19:39 David Imel? Mango.
1:19:40 Speaker 02 Oh, oh, okay.
1:19:42 David Imel? All right, my answer to that is you, you enjoy watching them play at the stadium. Cause like blue mango. Blue mango.
1:19:50 Speaker 01 It's blue.
1:19:51 Andrew Manganelli? I'm more with you on that one. Mine has two jokes.
1:19:53 David Imel? Blue mango.
1:19:54 Speaker 01 Yeah, two jokes.
1:19:54 Andrew Manganelli? Really?
1:19:55 Speaker 01 Yeah, everyone has two jokes.
1:19:56 David Imel? Yeah.
1:19:57 Andrew Manganelli? Oh, I have the blue mango one. What's your other one, David? Do you have, what do you call two bananas?
1:20:03 David Imel? No.
1:20:04 Speaker 01 Two colors.
1:20:05 David Imel? What is the most required skill to work in a juice factory?
1:20:09 Speaker 01 Oh.
1:20:09 Andrew Manganelli? Ask Juicero.
1:20:12 Speaker 01 Damn, I don't know.
1:20:13 David Imel? A good ability to concentrate.
1:20:15 Speaker 02 Ah, I like that.
1:20:18 David Imel? What do you call, oh wait, sorry, go ahead.
1:20:19 Andrew Manganelli? Mine's what do you call two bananas?
1:20:22 Speaker 01 Mine says that too.
1:20:23 Andrew Manganelli? A pair of slippers. Yeah, we got the same.
1:20:25 David Imel? Slippers?
1:20:26 Speaker 01 Oh, we got the same two jokes?
1:20:27 David Imel? Why are they, why are they slippers?
1:20:29 Speaker 02 Mine was like that.
1:20:30 Andrew Manganelli? This is concerning the colors.
1:20:32 Speaker 02 Oh, I don't like the way this one tastes.
1:20:34 David Imel? I'm gonna end up eating plastic.
1:20:35 Andrew Manganelli? It was less chewy than the Dots somehow.
1:20:38 Speaker 01 Bro. What? No, it wasn't.
1:20:40 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah, it was.
1:20:41 Speaker 01 No, it wasn't.
1:20:41 David Imel? Considering.
1:20:42 Andrew Manganelli? I think it was less chewy. I was surprised at how not chewy it was.
1:20:45 Speaker 01 If you wanted to eat a single dot versus a bite of Laffy Taffy.
1:20:51 Andrew Manganelli? Put a dot on one side of your mouth and a bite of Laffy Taffy on the other side of your mouth and see which one finishes first.
1:20:57 Andrew Manganelli? I think it takes longer to chew.
1:21:00 Andrew Manganelli? Time in mouth is over.
1:21:03 David Imel? I took a small bite and it's stuck inside like in between my teeth.
1:21:07 Speaker 01 It's way worse than a dot.
1:21:08 Andrew Manganelli? It's worse than dot. So I'm agreeing. I just think it's less chewy.
1:21:11 David Imel? Let's say 10 or 11. 11. 11.
1:21:15 Andrew Manganelli? I'll go 11 on that. I think there's gonna be some gross stuff and at least I'll know it's gross. I had some.
1:21:21 Speaker 01 I'll go 10.
1:21:22 Andrew Manganelli? Optimism.
1:21:22 David Imel? 10.
1:21:23 Speaker 01 I think 10.
1:21:24 David Imel? I would do 10.
1:21:25 Andrew Manganelli? Okay.
1:21:27 Speaker 01 We're gonna get a Tootsie Roll level of like.
1:21:29 David Imel? You don't like Tootsie Rolls?
1:21:30 Speaker 01 No, what?
1:21:32 David Imel? What are you talking? They're so good.
1:21:33 Speaker 01 Who likes?
1:21:34 Andrew Manganelli? Nevermind. I like Tootsie Rolls more than this. I like Tootsie Rolls more than this.
1:21:37 Speaker 01 Wait, wait, wait, wait, sorry. Tootsie Rolls are a high value for you?
1:21:42 David Imel? Those are the brown chewy things.
1:21:44 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:21:44 David Imel? Yeah.
1:21:45 Speaker 02 How do you feel about flavored Tootsie Rolls?
1:21:47 David Imel? I've never had them.
1:21:47 Andrew Manganelli? They're crazy. The, the blue ones vanilla. Tootsie Rolls are like.
1:21:51 David Imel? It's good.
1:21:52 Andrew Manganelli? If Yahoo drinks were a chewy candy.
1:21:55 Speaker 01 When you go Halloween shopping and you see the Tootsie Rolls, you like go right past them to the rest of the.
1:21:59 Andrew Manganelli? You can't because it's inside of every.
1:22:01 Speaker 01 I know.
1:22:03 Speaker 02 I don't have classic Tootsie Rolls on this list, but should I go grab them?
1:22:06 Speaker 01 No, we know they're bad.
1:22:08 Speaker 02 Okay, well, I do have orange flavored Tootsie Rolls.
1:22:12 Speaker 01 Also the chewiest thing in existence, but okay.
1:22:15 Speaker 02 Are these too small to throw across the studio?
1:22:17 Andrew Manganelli? No, we got it.
1:22:18 Speaker 01 We've got athletes in this room.
1:22:19 Andrew Manganelli? I've got perfect vision right now.
1:22:26 Speaker 01 It's in the face.
1:22:30 Speaker 01 That was really good.
1:22:33 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah, I've got a mask on. It's not the first, that's probably like the sixth time I've been hit with something in the face on video.
1:22:39 David Imel? You have to zoom in on camera. Okay, zoom into that on camera.
1:22:44 Speaker 02 Guys, how are we feeling? It's really, oh yeah, chewing, chewing.
1:22:48 David Imel? It was better in the first half, I will say.
1:22:50 Speaker 02 Got kind of worse.
1:22:51 Speaker 01 Okay. The first half.
1:22:53 David Imel? I'm done chewing. Okay, definitely better, better than the Laffy Taffy. Seven?
1:22:57 Andrew Manganelli? Agreed.
1:22:58 David Imel? Way, way better than the classic Tootsie Roll. Just because of the orange. I like orange things, I think.
1:23:03 Andrew Manganelli? Citrus and candy go well together?
1:23:05 David Imel? Yeah. I have it seven.
1:23:07 Speaker 01 I like seven.
1:23:09 Andrew Manganelli? I'll go seven. So we have.
1:23:10 Speaker 04 It should have been six and all enjoy should have been higher.
1:23:13 Speaker 02 Well.
1:23:14 Andrew Manganelli? I'm. Five, six, seven, and a ten are what we currently have.
1:23:17 Speaker 02 You have twelve, eleven, nine, eight, four, three, two, one.
1:23:21 Andrew Manganelli? Wait, so how many is that? Four?
1:23:23 Speaker 02 You have.
1:23:24 Speaker 04 New four so far.
1:23:25 Speaker 01 We've done four, we got eight left.
1:23:26 Speaker 02 You've done four, yeah.
1:23:27 Andrew Manganelli? Okay, we gotta start looking in top five here because presumably at worst, half of these are Ellis concoctions, so.
1:23:36 Speaker 04 Hmm, okay.
1:23:36 Andrew Manganelli? Let's. Hmm. Open our eyes to the ones we've heard of before.
1:23:40 Speaker 02 This next one, you know, I've heard Marquez, you like orange things.
1:23:43 Andrew Manganelli? Mm hmm.
1:23:44 Speaker 02 Andrew, citrus and candy go well together.
1:23:46 Andrew Manganelli? I saw what you had, I think.
1:23:47 Speaker 02 I have a little treat from across the pond. This is a personal favorite of mine. This is a Terry's Dark Chocolate Orange. And I'm not going to throw this one. I'm going to bring it over to you because I don't know if this is not throwable.
1:24:01 Andrew Manganelli? Do they have fun sized versions of these for trick or treating? Or would you go to a house and take one of the pieces out of it? Or would it be a sweet house and you get the whole orange?
1:24:12 Speaker 04 Ideally, the whole orange.
1:24:13 Andrew Manganelli? That's a sick house.
1:24:14 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's like the one you want to go to.
1:24:16 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah.
1:24:17 Speaker 04 That's the one where like when you're walking around later, you tell all your friends about and you're like, go to that house. Cause they're giving out whole.
1:24:22 Speaker 01 Oh, this is an enormous piece of candy.
1:24:25 Andrew Manganelli? Have you never had one of these?
1:24:26 Speaker 01 Oh, no.
1:24:26 Andrew Manganelli? They're my father in law loves these. They're really good.
1:24:29 Speaker 01 The size of an orange, but it's a bunch of slices.
1:24:31 Andrew Manganelli? Mm hmm.
1:24:32 Speaker 01 And even each individual slice is like pretty big.
1:24:35 Speaker 02 I just shocked myself on the Mac Studio and my screen stopped flickering.
1:24:41 Andrew Manganelli? Oh, okay.
1:24:42 Speaker 02 So I just, I guess I re-grounded it. Andrew's enjoying it.
1:24:46 Andrew Manganelli? I love this.
1:24:49 Speaker 01 This isn't just as good as our.
1:24:50 Speaker 04 We might disagree on the ranking then.
1:24:51 Andrew Manganelli? Well, here's my thing. This is Halloween candy rankings, correct? This is very good.
1:24:57 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:24:57 Andrew Manganelli? I'm wondering in the Halloween list where this is.
1:25:00 Speaker 04 I.
1:25:01 Speaker 02 Is that a different list?
1:25:03 Speaker 02 I feel like it's just delicious.
1:25:03 Andrew Manganelli? Getting it at while knocking at the door on the house.
1:25:07 Speaker 02 I'd be very happy if I got one of these.
1:25:08 Andrew Manganelli? True.
1:25:09 Speaker 01 You get the whole thing, the whole orange thing.
1:25:11 Andrew Manganelli? And then your mom's like, you're gonna have one piece of candy tonight. You just rip open the giant orange.
1:25:15 Speaker 02 Giant orange. Okay, I'll. Prefer this to the fruit chew.
1:25:18 Speaker 01 I'll admit, I'm not a big dark chocolate person, so this was, this is low for me. This is below the Laffy Taffy.
1:25:24 Andrew Manganelli? Really?
1:25:25 Speaker 02 Not even a seven or twelve.
1:25:27 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:25:28 Andrew Manganelli? I can't, I have to have this as.
1:25:29 Speaker 01 Maybe it's a nine?
1:25:30 Speaker 02 That's unbelievable.
1:25:32 Speaker 01 Four.
1:25:33 Andrew Manganelli? This is top five for me, for what we currently have going. It's above everything that's three.
1:25:38 Speaker 02 And unfortunately, but you don't have anything between four and eight available. So you need to make a call. Is it top four or is it bottom four?
1:25:46 Speaker 01 Cannot be.
1:25:47 Andrew Manganelli? I think it's. Where are we?
1:25:48 Speaker 01 I guess it's eight then, because I can't. This is not better than dots and Almond Joy.
1:25:53 Speaker 02 This is.
1:25:53 Andrew Manganelli? Do you know?
1:25:53 Speaker 02 The orange Tootsie Roll.
1:25:54 Andrew Manganelli? What's coming next?
1:25:55 Speaker 01 This is, I, but I don't like dark chocolate. Like I specifically don't. If this was milk chocolate, I might be okay with putting it four.
1:26:02 Andrew Manganelli? Okay, well, can you put your taste aside and imagine a dark, a milk chocolate? Or imagine you liking dark chocolate?
1:26:10 Speaker 02 It's not the game.
1:26:11 Speaker 01 I'm coming up from eleven.
1:26:14 Speaker 01 To eight.
1:26:15 Andrew Manganelli? I guess technically we're going the same amount of way. If David and I said four, it's about the same.
1:26:20 Speaker 01 So I think.
1:26:21 Andrew Manganelli? All right, we're gonna regret this eight.
1:26:22 Speaker 02 Number eight.
1:26:24 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:26:24 Speaker 02 Come on, man.
1:26:25 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:26:26 Speaker 02 Anyway, guys, you know what's better than candy?
1:26:28 Speaker 01 I'm looking at.
1:26:31 Speaker 01 I am not, I am nervous about this.
1:26:33 Speaker 02 Money?
1:26:34 Andrew Manganelli? Baked beans.
1:26:35 Speaker 01 Oh, God.
1:26:35 Speaker 02 Specifically.
1:26:37 Speaker 01 No one gives a sound on Halloween.
1:26:38 Speaker 02 Boston baked beans.
1:26:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, boy.
1:26:40 Speaker 02 Wait, what? Like candy I have never heard of.
1:26:43 Speaker 01 Really?
1:26:43 Speaker 02 Before yesterday.
1:26:45 Speaker 01 Where'd you find it?
1:26:46 Speaker 02 I found this at Economy Candy in Lower Manhattan.
1:26:50 Speaker 01 Like with the rest of the Halloween candy?
1:26:52 Speaker 02 I spent company money on this, but it was still a really great experience. So I get they, they should have a shout out. Economy Candy.
1:26:58 Speaker 01 Hmm, Economy Candy. That feels like where you would find baked beans as a candy.
1:27:03 Speaker 02 That is in fact where I found baked beans as a candy. Anyway, you guys don't have a nut allergy, do you?
1:27:08 David Imel? No, we already ate the almond joy.
1:27:11 Andrew Manganelli? Four candy bars late to that.
1:27:13 Speaker 02 Wait a second.
1:27:16 Speaker 01 So the company is Boston baked beans and it says artificially flavored candy coated peanuts.
1:27:21 Speaker 02 I don't, do they taste like beans?
1:27:23 Speaker 01 I really hope not. That would be so dumb. It's better than I expected it to be.
1:27:27 Speaker 02 You have.
1:27:28 David Imel? Me too.
1:27:29 Speaker 02 12, 11, 9, and then four through one available.
1:27:31 David Imel? Four.
1:27:32 Speaker 01 It's not above dots.
1:27:33 Andrew Manganelli? It can't be above dots. Do you know what has to be above dots? The deeper we go into this, we're breaking all the blind ranking rules of.
1:27:43 Speaker 01 Look, either, there's two possibilities here. Either Ellis saved all of the good candies for last, or Ellis somehow found four even worse candies than these and our rankings will be upside down and that's okay.
1:27:56 Andrew Manganelli? Okay, I love your optimism.
1:27:58 David Imel? It's gonna be the next one, there's gonna be Twix, Three Musketeers, Reese's, it's gonna be class.
1:28:03 Speaker 01 Skittles, Starburst, Jelly Beans, Candy Corn.
1:28:06 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah, fish paste, the good stuff.
1:28:07 Speaker 02 No, there's no, there's no seafood. I couldn't find seafood.
1:28:09 Speaker 01 I think this is, let's put this in at nine.
1:28:13 Andrew Manganelli? Okay.
1:28:14 Speaker 02 Nine?
1:28:14 Speaker 01 Are there gonna be two worse than this? Probably, right?
1:28:16 David Imel? This is four for me.
1:28:18 Speaker 01 This is not better than Almond Joy.
1:28:20 David Imel? I don't, I agree. But Almond Joy should be higher up.
1:28:24 Speaker 01 Look, all of our, all of our rankings as we insert them will be correct until they're all wrong.
1:28:30 David Imel? They're already all wrong.
1:28:31 Speaker 01 They're all right so far.
1:28:33 Andrew Manganelli? No, they're not. No, they're not. We have nine open.
1:28:38 David Imel? Are we really putting this on nine?
1:28:40 Andrew Manganelli? Well, I don't think it's 11 or 12.
1:28:41 David Imel? My god.
1:28:42 Speaker 01 It's not 11 or 12. So now, all we have left is 1, 2, 3, 4, 11 or 12.
1:28:46 David Imel? Oh my god.
1:28:48 Speaker 02 Fun Dip.
1:28:48 Speaker 01 That's not even candy, is it?
1:28:49 David Imel? It's, yeah, it's sugar.
1:28:51 Andrew Manganelli? It's candy you dip in more candy.
1:28:53 David Imel? Yeah.
1:28:54 Speaker 02 I just realized that the full name of Fun Dip is Lick-A-Made.
1:29:00 Speaker 02 That's disgusting.
1:29:00 David Imel? It's like lemonade that you lick. Lemonade powder.
1:29:05 Speaker 02 And I'm gonna bring this one over too because one of the Fun Dips burst open while in transit and so I spent way too much time yesterday cleaning Fun Dip off of this desk. It was no fun whatsoever.
1:29:19 Speaker 01 Why are there two? Because you have to open the left side?
1:29:23 David Imel? I don't know.
1:29:26 Andrew Manganelli? Oh wait, open horizontally.
1:29:32 David Imel? Yeah.
1:29:32 Speaker 02 David, this is your first fun dip? Okay, so David, inside that package is a stick made out of pure white sugar. And then a packet of powder, which I assume you've just discovered.
1:29:44 David Imel? Yeah.
1:29:45 Speaker 02 You lick the, the sugar stick.
1:29:49 Speaker 02 And then dip it in the powder.
1:29:51 David Imel? Powder's kinda good. Hmm.
1:29:53 Speaker 02 Try it with the stick.
1:29:54 David Imel? It's blue, but it turns green. Can I open the other side?
1:29:57 Speaker 02 Yeah.
1:29:57 Andrew Manganelli? Horizontally.
1:29:59 David Imel? What?
1:29:59 Andrew Manganelli? Like across the top.
1:30:01 David Imel? Oh, like that? Oh, that's how you're supposed to open it? Aren't kids supposed to know that? If I didn't even know that.
1:30:06 Speaker 02 I feel like it's like tacit kid knowledge.
1:30:08 David Imel? They just know. Yeah.
1:30:09 Andrew Manganelli? You know how like when baby giraffes are born, they can walk within minutes?
1:30:14 Speaker 02 Are you dipping it in the table pile?
1:30:17 Andrew Manganelli? Know how like when Neo was invented, it couldn't do anything?
1:30:20 David Imel? Yo, the white thing tastes really good. And I could say four for this. I like it. I don't hate it. I'm okay with that. Objectively, it's not four, but I think given where we're at. I got it all over the Boogs Palma Pro 2.
1:30:35 Andrew Manganelli? I like how they were like, hey, we could just make those stick with the blue sugar. And it, you would just eat it.
1:30:43 David Imel? I think I would.
1:30:43 Andrew Manganelli? They're like, no, let's make a slightly worse tasting sugar. And now dip it in the blue sugar.
1:30:48 David Imel? Yeah. I have my, I have my own rankings here as well that I might share after. But yeah, I, in general, we only have one, two, three, four, or 11 or 12 open right now. And this is not worse than the Boston baked beans or the Laffy Taffy. So I guess it's four.
1:31:04 Speaker 02 Four.
1:31:04 Andrew Manganelli? I'll go four.
1:31:05 David Imel? Four.
1:31:06 Andrew Manganelli? Unanimous four.
1:31:07 David Imel? Unanimous four.
1:31:08 Speaker 02 Up next, we have another jaw tester.
1:31:11 David Imel? Oh, no.
1:31:12 Speaker 02 Movie theaters everywhere, fear them.
1:31:14 Andrew Manganelli? Milk duds.
1:31:15 Speaker 02 They're milk duds.
1:31:16 David Imel? Oh, God.
1:31:17 Andrew Manganelli? Heard of these.
1:31:18 David Imel? This just.
1:31:18 Andrew Manganelli? Oh, you haven't had these? This is chocolate dots.
1:31:20 David Imel? They taste, they taste delicious, but they destroy your teeth.
1:31:24 Andrew Manganelli? It's chocolate dots.
1:31:26 David Imel? They are hella good, though.
1:31:27 Andrew Manganelli? Audio listeners have been missing Ellis's perfect throws this entire episode. Shout out to Ellis. I've caught everyone else.
1:31:33 David Imel? It's been really good. Oh, my God, I love these. My grandma, may she rest in peace, really loved these. Yeah.
1:31:40 Andrew Manganelli? She had good taste?
1:31:42 David Imel? She got them every time I went to a movie. Ew.
1:31:52 David Imel? Kind of just like plastic a little bit.
1:31:55 David Imel? Okay, it gets better. Does it? I don't know.
1:31:58 Andrew Manganelli? These are the chewiest.
1:31:59 David Imel? Sorry grandma, I don't know. I don't know about that.
1:32:02 Speaker 02 Is it better than Laffy Taffy?
1:32:04 David Imel? No.
1:32:04 Speaker 01 Unfortunately, this is.
1:32:05 Speaker 02 I mean, yes, yes.
1:32:06 Andrew Manganelli? No, I don't know. I think I might.
1:32:08 Speaker 02 Laffy Taffy should have been 12.
1:32:09 David Imel? The eating experience is compromised.
1:32:14 Speaker 02 Guys, I need a number. Is it top three or bottom?
1:32:18 Andrew Manganelli? I think it's bottom two.
1:32:18 David Imel? I think it's top three.
1:32:19 Speaker 01 Bottom two.
1:32:21 Andrew Manganelli? I'm on bottom two.
1:32:22 Speaker 02 I'm here in, I'm here in.
1:32:23 David Imel? Our list is so.
1:32:25 Andrew Manganelli? You, you audibly said ew when you ate it.
1:32:28 David Imel? Yeah, but it got better.
1:32:30 Andrew Manganelli? I think in the scenario we're at now, I'm in bottom two.
1:32:34 Speaker 01 11, you think?
1:32:36 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah.
1:32:36 David Imel? Okay. For the context of this, don't think of it as it's three or it's 11. Think of it as it's three or it's four.
1:32:43 Speaker 01 One of the best or one of the worst.
1:32:45 David Imel? Because we can't change the other ones.
1:32:47 Speaker 01 Agreed.
1:32:47 David Imel? And our list is messed up.
1:32:49 Speaker 01 Yeah, so is it?
1:32:50 David Imel? Is it three or is it four?
1:32:52 Andrew Manganelli? Marcus has held that ever since we put dots at not one.
1:32:56 Speaker 01 Dots are still my number one.
1:32:57 David Imel? So you think it's four?
1:32:59 Speaker 01 Here's where it goes in my actual rankings.
1:33:02 David Imel? Four out of the remaining possible five.
1:33:04 Speaker 01 I think it's, yeah.
1:33:05 David Imel? I think it'd be three. It's like mid.
1:33:08 Speaker 01 That was pretty hard to eat.
1:33:10 David Imel? Yeah.
1:33:11 Speaker 01 I wouldn't buy it ever. I think the line of what I buy it ever is right here for me. Anyway, let's go 11. I think 11.
1:33:18 Andrew Manganelli? Sorry David, I'm with 11 on this one.
1:33:20 Speaker 02 I am. I guess it's.
1:33:22 Andrew Manganelli? Willing to take the risk. I think I'm just in the category of we're taking the risk now. And we're, I'm trying to join the optimism.
1:33:28 David Imel? Skittles, Ellis, come on. Skittles.
1:33:30 Speaker 02 This one is very similar to Skittles. It's, it's like, I would describe it as like a Skittles analog. But guys, first you need to tell me, have you ever like really, really, really wanted to eat soap?
1:33:45 David Imel? I did and it sucked. Anyway, not intentional.
1:33:49 Speaker 02 You've never wanted to eat soap.
1:33:50 Andrew Manganelli? I've never wanted.
1:33:51 David Imel? Some good colors. No, I've never wanted to eat soap.
1:33:53 Speaker 02 Then I don't, I'm sorry. Uh, would you please bring these to our contestants, Adam? I did not know this product existed. This is edible candy bubble juice with a bubble blowing wand.
1:34:07 David Imel? What?
1:34:07 Andrew Manganelli? God.
1:34:08 Speaker 02 Please do not spill this in our studio.
1:34:10 David Imel? This is bad teaching.
1:34:11 Andrew Manganelli? Bubble lick, it's birthday cake flavor.
1:34:14 David Imel? Really dangerous. Yeah, kids are definitely.
1:34:17 Speaker 01 So the whole thing, so, so to be clear, just for, for audio listeners, it looks like a clear tube of like bubble soap, like bubble blowing soap with a little wand that you blow bubbles with. But the entire contents of it are edible?
1:34:33 Speaker 02 I don't know. I didn't really read the label.
1:34:34 Andrew Manganelli? You've never had this before?
1:34:35 Speaker 02 No.
1:34:36 Andrew Manganelli? What are the chances we could blow a bubble and someone catches it in their mouth?
1:34:39 Speaker 01 That's what you're supposed to do. You blow the bubbles and then you catch them and the bubbles are sweet and delicious.
1:34:43 David Imel? Really?
1:34:44 Speaker 02 This one is birthday cake flavored.
1:34:46 Speaker 01 Not only is this a horrible product, but it's a super bad idea.
1:34:51 David Imel? Burst all over my face, dude. Jesus.
1:34:54 Andrew Manganelli? Taking clear should automatically be fruit flavored. So making your birthday cake flavored is.
1:35:01 Speaker 02 They did have clear ones that were fruit flavored. I just.
1:35:03 David Imel? Ew, it's like dripping all over me. Jesus.
1:35:05 Andrew Manganelli? I'm not gonna blow bubbles. I'm just gonna taste it.
1:35:07 David Imel? It's dripping all over me.
1:35:08 Speaker 01 It tastes a little bit like bubble soap.
1:35:11 David Imel? Do not drink solution.
1:35:12 Speaker 01 It says lick only in bubble form.
1:35:14 Speaker 02 Ha, okay, sweet.
1:35:16 Andrew Manganelli? I just. Stuck the whole on to my mouth.
1:35:17 David Imel? I did too. My throat is burning.
1:35:20 Speaker 01 And kids are not gonna read that and they're gonna do the same thing.
1:35:23 David Imel? Ew.
1:35:23 Speaker 01 This has to be twelve.
1:35:24 David Imel? Wait, this kinda hurts.
1:35:26 Speaker 01 This is bad.
1:35:26 Andrew Manganelli? I'm so glad we left twelve.
1:35:28 David Imel? If solution gets into eyes, rents eyes with water.
1:35:32 Andrew Manganelli? This sounds pretty toxic, bro.
1:35:34 David Imel? Twelve.
1:35:35 Andrew Manganelli? That's twelve.
1:35:36 David Imel? Twelve.
1:35:36 Speaker 01 The highlight, the absolute best part was that when I opened it, it smelled like birthday cake for a second.
1:35:41 David Imel? Yeah.
1:35:42 Speaker 01 And then everything after that point was miserable.
1:35:45 Andrew Manganelli? Oh, yeah, my mouth.
1:35:46 Speaker 01 Dead last. Can't believe they just got money out of us. That was terrible.
1:35:50 David Imel? Yeah, my throat hurts.
1:35:51 Andrew Manganelli? Skittles, Ellis. Skittles. Reese's, Starburst, there has to be.
1:35:55 Speaker 02 Guys, this next candy is also, I would say, a Skittles analog.
1:36:00 Speaker 01 Wait, how is this a Skittles analog?
1:36:03 Speaker 02 I lied.
1:36:05 Speaker 02 It's not. This one, though, is both round and colorful.
1:36:11 David Imel? Alright.
1:36:11 Andrew Manganelli? Okay.
1:36:12 Speaker 02 It is cult classic candy of the ages. Candy buttons. For those, I don't know if this is a thing outside the US. It's essentially pieces of sugar dotted onto a long piece of receipt paper.
1:36:26 Andrew Manganelli? It's like candy acid.
1:36:28 Speaker 02 I love these personally. These are my, out of everything here would probably be, oh, you know, eating the paper is also part of it.
1:36:35 David Imel? Actually, or just like?
1:36:36 Speaker 02 Well, I mean, it's just, I've never had one without a little bit of-
1:36:39 David Imel? It's edible paper?
1:36:40 Speaker 02 No, but I've just never eaten one without paper on it.
1:36:43 Andrew Manganelli? Anything eaten after candy bubbles is like S tier.
1:36:47 David Imel? This is so, so much better.
1:36:50 Andrew Manganelli? This is like quintessential, like, five and dime store, like, pick up candy from it.
1:36:56 Speaker 02 Exactly. Looks like David's eaten a second one.
1:37:03 Andrew Manganelli? Ooh.
1:37:04 David Imel? Oh, that was, that was a different flavor.
1:37:06 Speaker 02 Three.
1:37:07 David Imel? Three.
1:37:08 Andrew Manganelli? Three.
1:37:09 David Imel? Or two. Do we want to leave it open and get this bad?
1:37:12 Speaker 01 We just have to embrace the shit up.
1:37:14 David Imel? So.
1:37:15 Speaker 01 Embrace the nightmare that is one and two.
1:37:17 David Imel? This is alright.
1:37:18 Andrew Manganelli? I'm like trying to imagine, Marquez is gonna leave this room and go find all the good candy and eat it just to feel something after.
1:37:24 David Imel? And maybe say one or two. I mean, two.
1:37:26 Speaker 01 There's no world, someone, that this is the best Halloween candy.
1:37:30 David Imel? Out of the, the two we have left. Don't think about it while we've already tried.
1:37:34 Andrew Manganelli? I have to.
1:37:36 David Imel? You have to think about it, what we might have left.
1:37:38 Speaker 01 In a world where we have one, two, and three open? And we're ranking best Halloween candy? And we open this wrapper and eat this, we have to put three.
1:37:46 David Imel? And you don't know what the other two are.
1:37:47 Speaker 01 We have to put three.
1:37:49 David Imel? Better.
1:37:49 Speaker 01 There's no way.
1:37:50 David Imel? Or what if they're worse?
1:37:51 Speaker 01 It can't be, it can't be worse.
1:37:52 David Imel? Dude, we just had bubble, bubble.
1:37:56 Speaker 01 Ellis wouldn't do this to us. You think Ellis would do this to us?
1:37:58 David Imel? Yeah. A hundred percent.
1:38:00 Speaker 01 Look at this man.
1:38:01 David Imel? Yeah.
1:38:02 Speaker 01 Do you think he would give us candy worse than this?
1:38:04 David Imel? Absolutely.
1:38:05 Speaker 01 He's probably saving the worst one for last.
1:38:07 David Imel? I think he would die if you drank this.
1:38:09 Andrew Manganelli? Oh, wait, do you know what I forgot?
1:38:11 Speaker 01 What?
1:38:12 Andrew Manganelli? Ellis put a spoon in front of all of us.
1:38:15 Speaker 02 You do all have spoons.
1:38:17 Andrew Manganelli? Oh, this could suck. That's really bad with one to open.
1:38:22 Speaker 01 What kind of Halloween candy do you give to kids that requires a spoon?
1:38:26 Speaker 02 I don't remember ever saying Halloween when I.
1:38:28 Andrew Manganelli? You opened this as Halloween candy.
1:38:30 Speaker 02 It just happens to be Halloween and we're eating candy.
1:38:33 Andrew Manganelli? It can be unrelated.
1:38:34 Speaker 02 Adam, play the tape. Specifically, we're to be doing a blind candy ranking where we give our hosts a series of pieces of Halloween candy that they must rank. See, now you all know that I'm right.
1:38:46 Speaker 01 My ear.
1:38:47 Speaker 02 Or wrong.
1:38:47 Andrew Manganelli? You're definitely wrong.
1:38:49 Speaker 02 All right, guys, this next one, um.
1:38:51 Andrew Manganelli? Needs no introduction. Oh, okay.
1:38:53 Speaker 02 That is tea berry gum.
1:38:54 Andrew Manganelli? Okay, you, Ellis said they're gonna have to spit this out and I was like, oh.
1:38:58 Speaker 01 I'm not gonna, I'll sniff it. Are there multiple packs?
1:39:01 Andrew Manganelli? What's tea berry?
1:39:02 Speaker 02 I don't know.
1:39:03 Andrew Manganelli? Oh, I'll try.
1:39:04 Speaker 02 I, I, I got, this was the one I got where I was like, that's how.
1:39:09 Andrew Manganelli? I'm not gonna smell, I'm just gonna go.
1:39:12 Speaker 02 You can spit it out to the paper towels that we put in front of you.
1:39:16 Speaker 02 Yeah, we're good producers.
1:39:18 Speaker 01 You somehow managed to give us worse candy every single time.
1:39:21 Andrew Manganelli? So it has a hint of flavor of every type of gum I can imagine in this stick form, but just like the La Croix version of it. Like, I almost get a sense of Big Red, I almost get a sense of Spearman.
1:39:33 Speaker 02 Well, is it number one or number two?
1:39:35 Speaker 01 Unfortunately, with the way things are trending, this probably should be number one, but this is number two.
1:39:39 David Imel? Yeah, see my, see, see my perspective.
1:39:41 Speaker 01 Look at this list, are you proud, look at this list.
1:39:44 Speaker 02 Are you asking if I'm proud of myself?
1:39:46 Speaker 01 Look at this list.
1:39:47 David Imel? Mark has, this could have been number three, just saying, if we put the buttons as number two.
1:39:51 Andrew Manganelli? At this point, bubble juice being 12, we succeeded.
1:39:54 Speaker 01 Whatever Ellis pulls out that bag, we have to say is better than all of these candies.
1:39:59 David Imel? Yeah, it will probably be better than this, though, at the minimum, right?
1:40:03 Andrew Manganelli? That's what I thought about the last three.
1:40:05 Speaker 01 I, we'll, we'll see, we'll see.
1:40:07 David Imel? All right, so what are you doing, putting it one or two?
1:40:10 Speaker 02 Two.
1:40:10 David Imel? Two? All right, tea berry gum at number two.
1:40:12 Speaker 01 I'm ready for the chaos.
1:40:14 Speaker 02 Gentlemen, all right, get out your spoons.
1:40:19 Andrew Manganelli? The best candy.
1:40:20 Speaker 02 Ice cream?
1:40:21 Andrew Manganelli? As chosen by you.
1:40:23 Speaker 02 Yeah. That's. Waveform's official best candy ever.
1:40:26 Speaker 01 That's crazy. Crazy work.
1:40:29 Speaker 02 Gentlemen, I am.
1:40:31 Speaker 01 It's like sunscreen.
1:40:32 Speaker 02 I am going to ask you.
1:40:34 Speaker 01 What?
1:40:34 Speaker 02 To squeeze. The ooze tube.
1:40:38 Andrew Manganelli? Oh.
1:40:39 Speaker 01 It's not. It's the aloe?
1:40:41 Speaker 02 It is. It is ooze tube liquid candy. By Sweet Bandit. It is green apple flavor.
1:40:50 Andrew Manganelli? This could slap. Just saying. I'll go first.
1:40:53 Speaker 01 The only reason that some of these companies are are still in business is because, what was it called? The Economy Candy Store exists? Is that what it was? Is that what it was called?
1:41:04 Speaker 02 Yeah, Economy Candy.
1:41:05 Speaker 01 Economy Candy.
1:41:05 Speaker 02 Rivington in Lower Manhattan. It's really fun. You should go.
1:41:08 Speaker 01 That is probably the only place that you will find ooze tube liquid candy. Green apple flavored.
1:41:15 Andrew Manganelli? Green apple slaps. I'm ready.
1:41:17 Speaker 01 Knock yourself out.
1:41:18 Andrew Manganelli? All right.
1:41:19 Speaker 02 Marquez just bypassed.
1:41:21 Andrew Manganelli? The only thing. Did you? Was this sealed?
1:41:24 Speaker 02 Yeah, I did break the seal.
1:41:25 Andrew Manganelli? Okay, thank goodness.
1:41:27 Speaker 02 All right, audio listeners, Andrew is emptying the ooze tube into his spoon.
1:41:32 Speaker 01 Brother. That's so much.
1:41:34 Speaker 02 It's really stringy, but it also, it does have sort of the consistency of aloe vera.
1:41:39 Speaker 01 Let's go.
1:41:39 Andrew Manganelli? We'll go together.
1:41:41 Speaker 01 Wait, Marquez, you're not doing this?
1:41:42 Andrew Manganelli? No. Why? Why?
1:41:44 Speaker 01 Look at it.
1:41:45 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah? I actually think this is gonna be good.
1:41:47 Speaker 02 I mean, we know it's good because it's literally the number one candy, according to Waveform Podcast hosts.
1:41:52 Speaker 01 If we flip this list upside down, it's actually better.
1:41:55 Speaker 02 That would put the bubble juice at number one, Marquez.
1:41:58 Speaker 01 It would also put Happy Cafe and Milk Duds above.
1:42:00 Andrew Manganelli? This is.
1:42:01 Speaker 01 Beans.
1:42:02 Andrew Manganelli? This is a melted green apple Jolly Rancher.
1:42:04 Speaker 01 Yep.
1:42:05 Andrew Manganelli? It's pretty good.
1:42:08 Andrew Manganelli? Doesn't like it. It literally tastes like a green apple Jolly Rancher.
1:42:12 Speaker 01 That's probably a compliment.
1:42:14 Andrew Manganelli? That's kind of a compliment.
1:42:15 Speaker 01 Notice we didn't get Jolly Ranchers.
1:42:16 Andrew Manganelli? It's burning my throat. Well, it's number one.
1:42:20 Speaker 07 It's number one.
1:42:21 Andrew Manganelli? Way worse could have been number one.
1:42:23 Speaker 01 All right.
1:42:23 Andrew Manganelli? Actually, out of the last three things we ranked, this was the best out of all.
1:42:26 Speaker 01 Just to, just to go back over this list, we picked ooze tube, green apple flavor, number one. Tea berry gum, number two. Candy buttons, number three.
1:42:38 David Imel? That's what I'm saying, man.
1:42:39 Speaker 01 Fun dip, number four. Dots, five, almond joy, six, orange tutsy roll, seven, dark chocolate, orange, eight. Boston baked beans, nine. Laffy taffy, 10, milk duds, 11, bubble juice. Couldn't escape.
1:42:53 David Imel? Acid.
1:42:54 Speaker 01 It had to go 12.
1:42:55 David Imel? That's what I'm saying. When you're putting, if you're doing a blind list, you're doing the next one, you have to just think of it in comparison to everything that could come after, but not the things you've already done.
1:43:04 Speaker 02 I just want to let you guys know, before you do individual rankings, sitting on my desk, unused candies are Kit Kat, Reese's, Hershey's, and Twizzlers.
1:43:15 Speaker 01 Wow.
1:43:16 David Imel? Heard that?
1:43:16 Speaker 01 You heard that?
1:43:17 David Imel? The good stuff.
1:43:18 Speaker 01 What we could have had was a good list, and they actively chose to make this a bad list.
1:43:23 Speaker 02 When you're doing a blind ranking, there's two ways you can do it, right? Like, you can have your contestants fill up all the, the top ones really early, so then you gotta choose the good candies and force them to put it in the bottom. Or you can do what happened here, where you filled up the bottom really quick, and then let me just ruin your morning.
1:43:39 Speaker 01 So in case you're wondering, I've been keeping track of all these candies and how I would have ranked them if this wasn't a blind ranking. So dots, one. Orange, fruit chew, it's not even, oh, tutsy, it is tutsy roll.
1:43:50 Speaker 02 Yeah.
1:43:51 Speaker 01 Orange tutsy roll, two, almond joy, three, laffy taffy, four, milk duds, five, baked beans, six, and then it's just all downhill from here. Fun dip, seven, cotton candy, buttons, ele, eight, dark chocolate, orange, nine, ooze tube, 10.
1:44:09 Speaker 01 Tea gum, 11, and poison, 12.
1:44:13 Andrew Manganelli? You didn't even have the ooze tube, and it's still.
1:44:15 Speaker 01 Made it to ten.
1:44:17 Andrew Manganelli? That was based purely on Andrew's description. Yeah, I'm just, uh, I'm not gonna do my whole one. I'm just gonna say the only thing I think people will be upset about with Marquez is the chocolate orange.
1:44:26 David Imel? I don't know, man. I'll enjoy. I'm gonna go almond joy, number one. Um, the baked baked beans. Chocolate number two, no, baked beans, number two, chocolate, number three.
1:44:47 David Imel? Milk duds, fun dip, dots.
1:44:53 David Imel? I don't know, it doesn't matter, man.
1:44:56 David Imel? Ultimately, those are my top six, that's okay.
1:44:59 Speaker 02 I think I should be rewarded for creating a candy list of which 16% was liquid. That's not easy.
1:45:08 David Imel? It's pretty good.
1:45:09 Andrew Manganelli? In Marquez's world, this candy list is perfect because dots got to be number one on his list.
1:45:16 David Imel? Trivia. This is the messiest.
1:45:18 Speaker 02 Spooky trivia.
1:45:23 David Imel? We may have to clarify the second question.
1:45:27 Speaker 02 Guys, thin phones are in vogue right now, but they are not new. What phone released December, what phone released December 2014? Had a total thick, is it thickness or depth or?
1:45:42 David Imel? Thickness.
1:45:43 Speaker 02 Yeah, sure. Thickness, what had a total thickness of 4.8 millimeters?
1:45:55 David Imel? It's between two that I'm thinking of.
1:45:59 David Imel? But Adam said that the company was obvious, so.
1:46:03 Speaker 04 If you're thinking around this time period, companies that do crazy.
1:46:07 Andrew Manganelli? Yeah, what was the time again?
1:46:09 Speaker 04 2014. December, so basically 2015, but 2014, whatever.
1:46:13 Andrew Manganelli? Okay, I'm circling this.
1:46:14 David Imel? Alright.
1:46:17 David Imel? I put the Moto Z.
1:46:20 Speaker 04 Ah crap, I think I got the name wrong.
1:46:22 David Imel? Oh.
1:46:23 Speaker 01 Oh.
1:46:23 Speaker 04 Oh, I put the Moto G Play.
1:46:26 Speaker 01 I also put the Moto Z, but I'd crossed out what I thought it was before, which was the Huawei like P2 or something?
1:46:34 David Imel? I was thinking like the sharp Aquos. It's a sharp phone, right?
1:46:38 Speaker 04 It is not, but close. That's more along the lines I was thinking of.
1:46:41 David Imel? Oh.
1:46:42 Speaker 02 The Moto Z is a great guess because that was only 5.2 millimeters thick, meaning you're only four millimeters off. The phone I was looking for was the Vivo X5 Max.
1:46:51 David Imel? Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I did look that up a few weeks ago.
1:46:55 Speaker 01 That was obvious?
1:46:56 Speaker 04 I thought Vivo would have been too obvious. That's why I wanted you to get the like actual name.
1:47:00 Speaker 01 I guess they were more obvious in that sense, like 2017, 18, trying all the crazy stuff.
1:47:05 David Imel? Yeah. Moto Z was later, right?
1:47:09 David Imel? I thought it was later.
1:47:10 Speaker 01 Moto Z were upstairs. Moto Z was between 2015 and 2020.
1:47:15 David Imel? Yeah. Alright.
1:47:16 Speaker 04 Second question. Quick update on the score though. Marquez. Eight. Right behind Andrew, the skeleton with nine. And David fishing up the rear with five.
1:47:29 David Imel? Really?
1:47:29 Speaker 04 Yeah, he got five.
1:47:30 David Imel? I thought it was like, whatever, okay.
1:47:33 Speaker 04 Well, the answer to the second question, Ellis accidentally told our hosts in between breaks. So it was U-Torrent. Daniel Ek was briefly the CEO of U-Torrent. So I have another question.
1:47:46 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:47:46 Speaker 04 It's basketball related.
1:47:48 Speaker 01 Let's go.
1:47:48 Speaker 04 But David, you can actually maybe get this, maybe? Andrew, maybe you could get this, maybe? The question is, which NBA superstar has a deal currently with Google?
1:48:01 Speaker 01 There's multiple answers.
1:48:02 David Imel? Are there a ton?
1:48:03 Speaker 04 Fitbit.
1:48:04 Speaker 07 I think we can accept any, any NBA superstar with a deal.
1:48:08 Speaker 04 Well, the Google deal, there's one in particular that's super obvious that David will not get.
1:48:12 David Imel? Yeah.
1:48:12 Speaker 04 There's another one that's
1:48:14 David Imel? Super obvious that I won't get.
1:48:16 Speaker 04 More so that like he's the guy we've always been talking about as being this guy, but you wouldn't know him because he's like
1:48:21 Andrew Manganelli? I'm at that point, I remember.
1:48:23 Speaker 04 You remember? I'll do both. Two po- mm, yeah, two points. Screw it.
1:48:27 David Imel? So a deal's Google.
1:48:28 Speaker 04 Already ahead. Yes. A deal with Google, the one I was looking for specifically was a deal with Fitbit. He's also a, an investor in a bunch of, no.
1:48:38 Speaker 07 I don't know the answer to this question.
1:48:40 Speaker 04 Oh, nice. Okay, cool.
1:48:41 Speaker 01 So you're supposed to put two answers?
1:48:42 Speaker 04 Yes. But David, think about someone you would know. That is my hint to you.
1:48:46 Speaker 07 Currently plays.
1:48:48 Speaker 04 Yep, currently in the league. There's two players.
1:48:53 Speaker 01 Have I met him before?
1:48:57 Speaker 04 Maybe, actually, maybe. Or at least been in the same room with him. I don't know if you've met him.
1:49:03 Speaker 01 Tony Hawk?
1:49:05 Speaker 04 No.
1:49:06 Speaker 01 I have met him like three times.
1:49:08 Andrew Manganelli? He's a Formula One driver.
1:49:10 Speaker 01 Tony Hawk?
1:49:10 Speaker 04 Tony Hawk. Nice.
1:49:13 Speaker 01 Look at him, I'm closing the cap.
1:49:15 Speaker 04 Yay!
1:49:16 Speaker 01 Thank you.
1:49:18 Speaker 04 All right, Flip, him and Reed, what do we got?
1:49:22 Speaker 04 Oh, who wants to go first?
1:49:24 Speaker 01 I wrote Kevin Durant.
1:49:27 Speaker 04 No, but good job.
1:49:28 Speaker 01 Yeah. I just know that that's a basketball. And then Steph Curry.
1:49:33 Speaker 04 Steph Curry?
1:49:33 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:49:34 Speaker 04 Correct! There it is.
1:49:36 Speaker 01 Yeah, baby.
1:49:37 Speaker 04 That's one point for David. Andrew, would you put?
1:49:40 Andrew Manganelli? I put Giannis.
1:49:42 Speaker 04 You got a point for that because that was the other one that we were thinking about. Giannis Antetokounmpo, the human alphabet.
1:49:46 Speaker 01 I wrote down the three basketball players that I know of Google deals. I wrote Giannis Antetokounmpo.
1:49:51 Speaker 04 That is correct, one point.
1:49:52 Speaker 01 I spelled it.
1:49:54 Speaker 04 Wow!
1:49:55 Speaker 01 I'm waiting for my point. I'm waiting for my point.
1:49:57 Andrew Manganelli? You got it already.
1:49:58 Speaker 01 For spelling it.
1:50:01 Speaker 01 Uh, Steph Curry.
1:50:02 Speaker 04 That is correct. You got another point for that.
1:50:04 Speaker 01 Kelsey Plum.
1:50:05 Speaker 04 WNBA.
1:50:06 Speaker 01 Correct.
1:50:07 Speaker 04 Did I say NBA?
1:50:08 Speaker 01 Yeah, you probably did. So is Giannis the guy that got traded that everyone was freaking out about?
1:50:12 Speaker 04 No, that was Luca.
1:50:14 Speaker 01 Yeah, it was Luca. All right, well, is still like burning from the toxic acid that we just said. All right, well, now this episode is done. We're gonna eat the rest of the good candy that you had in that bag over there. Kit Kats, did I hear? Twix?
1:50:27 Speaker 04 And Twizzlers and Hershey.
1:50:28 Speaker 01 Reese's? He could have put Reese's.
1:50:30 Speaker 04 Can I see what it is?
1:50:31 Speaker 01 In the top ten.
1:50:32 Speaker 04 And it's Reese's Pumpkins, right?
1:50:33 Speaker 01 No, it's just Reese's, man.
1:50:34 Andrew Manganelli? Wait, there's pumpkin flavored Reese's?
1:50:36 Speaker 04 No, there's the like holiday Reese's have the better ratio than regular Reese's.
1:50:40 Speaker 01 Oh. Well, we're gonna eat those. We're gonna, we're gonna enjoy our lunch, of course. And thanks for sticking with us for Techtober. What comes next? Tech?
1:50:48 David Imel? I think it's November.
1:50:50 Speaker 01 Take of Ember. It doesn't roll off the tongue as well. So thanks for sticking with us for the one that does roll off the tongue. Well, unlike fun dip. Anyway.
1:50:57 David Imel? Yeah, it sticks to your tongue.
1:50:58 Speaker 01 Catch you guys in the next video. Peace.
1:51:01 Andrew Manganelli? Waveform is produced by Adam, Elaine and Ellis Robyn, a partner with Vox Media Podcast Network, and our traction music was created by Vansil.
1:51:06 Speaker 02 Wait, can you do one?
1:51:07 Andrew Manganelli? I feel like I slurred all of those.
1:51:09 Speaker 02 You say one where waveform was produced by a minion and a pirate.
1:51:12 Andrew Manganelli? Waveform was produced by a pirate and a minion. We were partnered with Vox Media Podcast Network and our traction music was created by Vansil.
1:51:28 Speaker 02 Spotify, but when they bought you torrent, it was speculated.
1:51:31 Andrew Manganelli? Wait, did you just say the thing outside?
1:51:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, you did.
1:51:38 Speaker 01 You totally did. David didn't hear it.
1:51:42 Speaker 02 It was finally me.
1:51:44 Speaker 04 New question.
1:51:45 Speaker 02 I'm sorry.
1:51:47 Speaker 04 Can I bring us back in?
1:51:48 Speaker 01 You're a wizard. You're a wizard, Adam.
1:51:50 Andrew Manganelli? He's a pirate, actually.
1:51:51 David Imel? He's a pirate.
1:51:52 Speaker 01 I'm a pirate, actually, yeah.
1:51:55 Speaker 06 Are you a pet owner? Every six seconds, a pet owner in the US gets hit with a vet bill over a thousand dollars. Always an unwelcome surprise. That's where Fetch comes in. Fetch is the most complete pet insurance for dogs and cats. According to consumeradvocate.org, you get paid back up to 90% of vet bills at any vet in the US and Canada with claims paid back in as little as two days. Go to fetchpet.com/save right now for your free quote. That's fetchpet.com/save.
1:52:33 Speaker 05 I'm a voice agent powered by Deepgram. I don't just understand words, I understand context. Like when you're at trivia night and say, I'm on fire, it means you got the last three questions right. But when you're camping and say, I'm on fire, it means a spark just landed on your highly flammable synthetic rain pants. Deepgram understands words in context across STT, TTS, and voice agents. That means better conversations at production scale. Learn more at deepgram.com/contextiseverything.
Previous Why Are Some iPhones Turning Pink? Next It’s Like Photoshop, But Free! Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated