Pod Insights Voices of Search // A Search Engine Optimization (SEO) & Content Marketing Podcast Who's Going to Dominate Search in the AI Era? About this episode AI agents will replace most human web navigation within two years. Killian Dunne from Telepathic, an AI search specialist, explains why traditional SEO fundamentals remain essential before advancing to AI optimization strategies. He outlines the maturity progression from basic SEO implementation to AI search sophistication, emphasizing that indexation, crawlability, and site health must be mastered first. The discussion covers strategic timing for enterprise AI search adoption and identifies specific scenarios where high-tech startups might accelerate their AI optimization timeline. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 The Voices of Search Podcast is a proud member of the I Hear Everything Podcast Network. Looking to launch or scale your podcast? I Hear Everything delivers podcast production, growth, and monetization solutions that transform your words into profit. Ready to give your brand a voice? Then visit ihereverything.com. Welcome to the Voices of Search Podcast, a member of the I Hear Everything Podcast Network. Ready to expedite your company's organic growth efforts? Sit back, relax, and get ready for your daily dose of search engine optimization wisdom. Here's today's host of the Voices of Search Podcast, Tyson Stockton.
0:43 Speaker 01 The way people discover products, services, and brands is changing fast. AI assistants, generative answers, agent-led interfaces are quickly replacing traditional search as a starting point for a user's journey. Nearly 60% of US adults visited a page with AI-generated summer within the first month of 2025. That stat signals a massive behavioral shift. If the front door of your business is now an AI interface, how do you compete? How do you stand out when search becomes more of a conversation? You're listening to the Voices of Search Podcast. My name's Tyson, and today I'm excited to be joined by Gillian Dunn, founder of Telepathic. Telepathic helps brands build AI-native SEO tools that help e-commerce and SaaS brands gain visibility in emerging
1:26 Speaker 01 search platforms like ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity. Today, Gillian and I will explore who's going to dominate search in an AI area and how your brand can be one of them. Gillian, welcome to the podcast.
1:37 Speaker 02 Yeah, thanks for having me. Great to be here.
1:39 Speaker 01 Now, obviously, this has been a heavy conversation, not just here on the podcast, but in the industry. So we all know our world and SEO is changing, the way people are engaging with search engines is changing. Maybe to kind of just set the stage for the listeners, like, how are you seeing this evolution? And how are you seeing the changes in the space that we compete in?
2:01 Speaker 02 Yeah, there's so much. I think it's like arguably one of the most rapidly changing industries at the moment. And so kind of everyone is scrambling to keep up and to understand what to do. And it's been chaotic, I think, for everyone. At the same time, I think maybe it's helpful for for people to zoom out a little bit and think instead of kind of zooming in on the details and saying, okay, kind of like, how are things different this week from last and thinking more about where I think it's going and what's the direction of things? And working under the assumption that this change isn't going to stop, and if anything, it might even accelerate further. The trend broadly is that AI agents are becoming more and more dominant and will be more heavily involved in more of the buying journey. I think the biggest trend at the moment is that buying journeys are being compressed.
2:46 Speaker 02 This has been happening for a long time. And it started off like, let's say, as we kind of move from a sort of a sales-led go-to-market where you'll have someone pop on a bunch of different calls to kind of go through a buying purchase and down to things kind of like product-led growth became very popular where you could actually access a product when they're talking to a human. And we're seeing that happen more and more, that friction is being removed. And that's, yeah, that's that's taking a big leap forward now with ChatGPT, where so much of that discovery process can happen in various different AI search tools. And so the work required to make your choices to what buy, it could be a software product or e-commerce product or anything, is being cut down so much. So it's very interesting. Lots is going on.
3:29 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, I feel like it's it is a very exciting time for the industry. Obviously, you have a lot of, you know, in some cases, more fear, panic of the changes, but I feel like that change is something that like, at least was one of the attractions to SEO or search for myself, where it's like, you want to have that evolving landscape and that added complexity of change. So it's like, I feel like it's something that as an industry, we should be pretty well prepared for operating in that state of change. And I love the advice too of like, not getting hung up in defining strategies necessarily for today with.
4:10 Speaker 01 The rate of change, but more of the kind of Gretzky quote of like where the puck's going versus where it is. But maybe kind of before we get too far into the future, I want to like just double back a little bit on kind of your comment about like the buyer's dream being compressed. Like, is that from your perspective? Because with each, I don't know, prompt or query, the user's gaining like a broader sense of the answer, the context, or like, what, what do you feel like is fueling that compression?
4:43 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think I'm more efficient at finding the information we need. So instead of having to look through lots of different pages and instead of having to have the search and explore lots of different options. The fact that AI search tools can be very specific at giving us a very direct answer to the very specific question that we have. It means that we find out exactly what we need. It probably ultimately means that we're also overlooking a bunch of different areas when we make a purchase. We're now not finding out about anything we might have come across, but not actually looked for when buying something. But yeah, there's a lot of kind of consequences to that. And I think this is even taking a huge leap forward already in the last
5:24 Speaker 02 few days. Just yesterday, there was OpenAI's Day and they've announced a kind of AI Apps SDK. And essentially this allows you to do push your app in ChatGPT that can be used directly from ChatGPT. And this has huge consequences as well. This is a huge cost to the buying journey as well. It makes that process even shorter again, where you don't even need to kind of like navigate to a website. You don't even need to go through a lengthy signup process. Instead, you can access, let's say, the examples they gave were like Zillow or Coursera or a bunch of other tools directly from ChatGPT. And so now you're, the effort required to get the value of an app is just, just plummeting down.
6:07 Speaker 01 And I feel like another illustration of that could also be, and I forget the date that it was kind of announced, but like Etsy's kind of partnership with OpenAI from, you know, making purchases from it. When you're thinking about establishing a strategy moving forward, so it's like, you know, we're coming into Q4 here. People are starting to start their annual planning for next year. I feel like it's a good moment to to reset and to be thinking about like, you know, what does that roadmap and strategy look like in 2026? What would be kind of like the parameters of where we compete or the world that you see it?
6:51 Speaker 01 That you would be strategizing for looking into 2026?
6:56 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah, there's a lot. I think like, let's say for the Etsy example, so Etsy are the kind of first case they're rolling out with. I know they work very closely with Shopify as well, so that will definitely come soon. I think, let's say for like that e-commerce case, what's happening is that your products can be found from even more places now. So we've got like kind of search everywhere optimization has been a common phrase. I think that's becoming everywhere is becoming even more broad, even more comprehensive. And so I think the win is to make sure that when you're describing yourselves and describing your products, that is a really kind of high quality description such that when that gets applied elsewhere, that's used in lots of different contexts.
7:37 Speaker 02 So I think what's important there is like really in-depth descriptions, being really thorough with details, being really unique as well in anything you describe, let's say like, I don't know, it's for a very particular context, a very particular use case or and so on. For an e-commerce context, if you can kind of find a way that your particular product can match queries that others might not be thinking about, then that's definitely a win. So I think broadly, most product descriptions are probably too short and too vague. And I think we will see a big trend towards the opposite of that. We've already seen it a little bit with Amazon search optimization. If you look at a product on Amazon, it's super in-depth. It's it's a bit gross and maybe that will be a trend as to how things go.
8:19 Speaker 02 But they put in so much work into putting in all the right keywords and all the right terms that could possibly catch up to become your top result. And I think that will need to be done as well for AI search as well for e-commerce.
8:32 Speaker 01 Amazing. And so just to elaborate a little bit further than that. So basically, with the customization, with the personalization that comes with like an LM or AI-led interface, you're kind of calling out the example of like within like a product page or something, having those unique specifics that then allows like we want some of these tools and systems to pick up on why it may be a fit for a niche problem use case rather than just kind of the broad catch-all kind of generalist. And in kind of like the progression of that, I would assume like
9:13 Speaker 01 content agents and having like specialized maybe content agents based upon personas to write different portions of content, like is that partly how you see like the development of those pages is through both like the application of these tools in order to compete in them as well? Like, because I assume like with that level of customization, obviously, there's a lot of legwork. So then the advantage of using some of these like kind of specialized systems and tools would have a, you know, a strong place.
9:46 Speaker 02 Yeah, exactly. I think maybe a good phrase is almost like product enrichment, which we're helping with already in terms of essentially taking a product that you have, maybe you could upload like a description or even images and so on, a video, whatever it is, and then turning that format into a format that's really easily digestible and searchable for AI. Because it seems like Andy's based on what the kind of what we found from our own data and from the documentation that kind of OpenAI uses and so on, and some of the other providers is they're very much prioritizing kind of like how closely your search term matches their query. And so how closely your description matches what was asked. And so that means that things that
10:28 Speaker 02 Google gave so much attention to, like EAT and domain authority and all these sort of things, they don't have that level of sophistication. Or maybe they might kind of kind of hop on the backs of Google for their kind of search parameter. But essentially, it means that how reputable your brand is, is becoming a secondary priority to how closely does your wording match the wording the customer is looking for.
10:51 Speaker 01 I feel like it's also kind of like painting the narrative of like, we're moving into this like agents as a primary user. And it's like, I mean, in some ways, it's almost like a chicken before the egg scenario. Cause it's like, obviously you're needing them to respond and you're needing to basically like interact well with that in order to reach that end user. But like, how does your focus maybe shift or change? Like, are you still saying in SEO, we've always been like follow the user, follow the user, what's best for the user? Does this like have a paradigm shift to that kind of like classic SEO narrative of like chasing the user rather than the search engine?
11:33 Speaker 01 Like, how does this kind of impact the way you view that kind of like primary optimization efforts?
11:40 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's interesting. And I think the basics are still follow the user, but there might be a kind of next level or sort of like once you've kind of served that basic tier, then I think there is a potential scenario quite soon where we'll have a bit of a Wild West like we had with Google before, where companies will be quite spammy and we'll, we'll game the system a bit. And I think there'll be ways of using software to find quantity and quality until eventually quality drops. I think that will trend towards that relatively soon. So starting to see early signs of that. And I think there will be a relatively spammy phase that enters soon and then it'll be up to the AI search tools to adapt to that.
12:24 Speaker 02 But also, I'm curious for your thoughts as well. I like, do you, do you think it's better to be very user centric or search centric? Or what have you found from the people you've spoken to?
12:34 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, it's a little bit of both in my mind. Like, I think to your point, like your ultimate north star should still be the user because even if you're needing to act through like these agents to be present and kind of just to like have a seat at the table, so to speak, you're still then looking at like a traditional consumer behavior element. And I see like a lot of the strategy of search shifting More towards those like traditional fundamentals of like consumer behavior as like or like textbook kind of like. I don't know. I want to say it's just like theories, but it's like more of that kind of like foundational element.
13:15 Speaker 01 I do think that to your point, like we need to be thinking in a broader sense. And when we're looking at, you know, whether it's performance tracking and things like that level of variance of user experience. Will only continue to progress and change. And I think from that, you're still aiming at the user. It's more of like, okay, I just need to get on, get on the field, get like a seat at the table. Which, you know, you still have fundamental things that we've been working with in search for a long time. Such as indexation health, what's, you know, I mean, there's been a lot of talk lately about.
13:57 Speaker 01 JavaScript rendering again. So it's like, even though the world's changing rapidly, it's like, we're still hitting back on these same kind of like. Principles and conversation that we've been having. It's just, you know, a new flavor to it, a new twist to it. So I'm very much in the belief that like the fundamentals of the game has not changed. The same kind of characteristics and elements that have fueled strong performers in search, I think are there. It's just now the strategy shifts a little bit, the tactics shift a little bit, like how you're prioritizing after it will shift. But it's not necessarily saying like my approach from like a baseline is changing.
14:41 Speaker 01 So I think like user still remains your north star. Now you kind of just have another layer in between in reaching that end user.
14:50 Speaker 02 Yeah, like there, there haven't been that many usability studies yet on, on AI search. Like I think. Kevin Indak from Growth Memo, he's done a good one, but like there aren't many. So it's still, there's a lot of research to be done as to sort of. How is user behavior and actually receiving these changes and are people happy with them? What, what's the kind of common flows? And in that search journey.
15:13 Speaker 01 Which, I mean, this is slightly off topic, but I've been like really curious on this one. So I'd love to hear your thoughts on it, too. It's like, so we all know, and like with, whether it's the DOJ trials or Google's API leak, Navboos, we know engagement metrics are used like within it. Obviously, it makes a ton of sense. It's almost like a grading system. I feel like on, did they get the results right from like a ranking order? But as more and more of that experience is happening within the actual interface, how would those KPIs of Navboos then kind of evolve? Like, are we still looking at things like click through rate from the SERPs, time on page, depth into the site?
15:58 Speaker 01 Or will it be a little bit more of time on page from within the actual search experience? And so I'd be curious to see like, what are your thoughts on how user engagement metrics would be used from Google or emerging kind of like AI search engines?
16:20 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's really interesting. And I think like, there's maybe a question as to, one, how will the KPIs you should track evolve? Versus the second question of how will the KPIs people actually mostly do track evolve? I think in terms of what we should, we should still like do our best to tie it to revenue and do our best to maybe be a bit more open minded as to what to go for. So I think like general visibility and impressions and kind of like maybe brand sentiment overall will become more and more important. But I think there is a risk that SEOs, particularly those who are inexperienced or kind of are under pressure, might optimize for some of the wrong things. I think a few years ago, we saw a trend where a lot of marketing was kind of being replaced
17:04 Speaker 02 with sales, like kind of AI SDRs and SDRs generally, and kind of like optimizing to, most investment that would have gone to marketing went to sales. And there was kind of a year of the brand crisis, as they say, in sort of 2024. I think TrustRadius said this, where basically a lot of companies were Optimizing for yeah, sales essentially because the ROI was much more measurable and the results weren't necessarily better. But I was saying, hey, if I put this money into outreach or this money into um generating leads or um or our sales funnel. Cool, we can really easily attribute that. Whereas in marketing, okay, hey, let's say our brand has gotten better.
17:44 Speaker 02 That's really, really tough. And so I think companies will need to be a little bit patient and say, hey, uh, that we're going through discovery phase. We're gonna try some experiments. We want to stand out and we have to kind of like put our best foot forward, but attribution is going to be more tough. There are more places that people are looking and because searching is becoming more love friction, I we're seeing that instead the number of places we are searching is increasing. So it's not necessarily, we've probably heard like, it's not necessarily that Google's traffic isn't really down. Instead, it's just overall search traffic has increased. So the pie has gotten, Google haven't lost their their portion of the pie, the overall pie has gotten bigger and added to. So it means that for a buyer, they are looking in more places.
18:27 Speaker 02 They have more touch points before um they make a decision, which makes things like attribution a nightmare. What's a common flaw that we hear about a lot is um users will do nearly all of their research process in ChatGPT or Perplexity or wherever. And then cool, found my brand of choice, I'll type it into Google. Google that gets the direct referral and the attribution goes to Google. But in fact, it was um a bunch of other sources and and so on. So it's gonna be really tough. I think it's gonna be a tougher. It's very interesting to see how it evolves.
18:58 Speaker 01 Okay, so like to that last point, and I I completely agree where it's like, even in my own behavior, like I'm doing a lot of that discovery phase within an AI interface, doesn't matter, ChatGPT, Gemini, AI mode, whatever. But like from that, if we go kind of back to like earlier of like optimizing or strategizing for today versus tomorrow. If I'm looking at the operation of things today, I would be saying like, okay, within those AI experiences, there's gonna be more of a traditional marketing advert. Kind of strategy where I'm looking more for that kind of brand reputation, sediment towards it,
19:41 Speaker 01 general presence, but it's like, in my mind, it's like a little bit of like a branding play where you're hitting a wide audience. Yeah, you're having very specific use cases to show up to those unique kind of prompts and complexities to it. But then you still have the tail end that is that direct point of purchase, lower funnel type query that's going to be like your money pages or whatever, like high converting product pages, things like that. With kind of like the progression of agents, people making purchases, and I assume, you know, we're on the cusp of having more advertisements within these like experiences. Do you see that strategy kind of like shifting
20:25 Speaker 01 over like this next year? Or like, do you think like, yeah, that's probably the place that we're going to be in for the next 12 months? Or like, when do you think we need to re-question that kind of like tail end bottom funnel presence on traditional versus like in these newer experiences?
20:46 Speaker 02 I think there definitely will be a questioning phase. I think what like the the methods that exist now in terms of like running kind of high, high scale simulations or experiments with with very long tail searches does work now. It works well. We've seen, we've seen it be very successful. And I think that will continue for a fair while, like, like, not super soon will that get replaced, but I do think it will be replaced. Maybe like a year or something like that sort of timeline. I think the the kind of interesting aspect of of like where this is going is a lot of talk is about, okay, hey, how will like, how will my my query be really personalized to me? I think like
21:28 Speaker 02 lots of tech bros I talk to and so on saying, hey, these AIs will have full context on you and they'll be able to know exactly what you need and you just need to basically do almost nothing and it will, it will find the right product for you. And less of a believer. Of that, I don't think personal context is that easy to extract. The good example is Google. Google has absurd levels of context on us. And the path of sophistication that's gotten to is search history. Have you written the exact same term in? Then, okay, yeah, we'll put in that term again. That's it. I think there's a degree of people not wanting it, but there's also a degree of it's really hard to extract what is meaningful from all of your previous activity. It's becoming easier, but still really, really hard. And so I think that personalization aspect will be tough.
22:13 Speaker 02 What I do think might be interesting, and this is probably where these AI search tools could become huge cash cows, is if they start extracting moments when you show that you are really high intent. And then flag that person for you as being a potential buyer. Let's say, hey, I I need a personal bank. And someone searches, I'm looking for a personal bank for someone in my demographic. And you show a really high intent level for that, then if they lock that in your system and and share that data with, it could be Chase or Mercury or whoever. That's that's stupidly useful information for those companies. And I could easily see companies paying huge amounts of money for that. And I could imagine that lots of the AI search tools will be willing to share that information.
22:58 Speaker 02 So I don't necessarily think search will be hugely personalized, but I think intense signals from that could definitely be extracted from that.
23:06 Speaker 01 That makes a lot of sense. I feel like we keep kind of seeing this like pendulum swing where like as we're discussing this, like we're highlighting essentially this like, I think like it almost reminds me of like a resurgence of like relevance factors over like authority. Where it's like, there's going to be more customization, there's going to be more context in the prompt. So then, you know, there's potential for a greater variety. You hit it on earlier, product enhancements, content enhancements that are going to speak to those unique kind of applications or like use cases. Is, you know, swinging back more towards this like relevance piece? Do you see like it coming back around where it's like?
23:52 Speaker 01 Systems go down the path of having something hyper, hyper relevant to the user, the query, the prompt. But then at some point, there's going to need to be this like pendulum swing back to like authority, credibility, like some of these like E A T type factors. Like, how do you see kind of like that authority playing like down the road?
24:16 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely. I think um I think it's it's still will be super important. I think SEOs will still need to think about all those relevant factors like the like what they've done for Google for so long. Um I think, yeah, like we're seeing it with kind of um OpenAI pairing with, let's say, the Google or Bing and so on, and um Anthropic with Brave. Essentially, this is just a way of extracting uh Google or Brave's E A T model. They're just extracting uh um this ranking system of domains and so on. They already um have access to all the information they need. They already have access to to like they can already scan a bunch of different places for,
24:56 Speaker 02 let's say, real time information, but the key is actually choosing what is the most valuable, most credible, and that credibility algorithm, as we know, is really sophisticated. And so kind of climbing on the back of that, I think, is is important. And so um I think a lot of the still still the same practices that SEOs must do will continue in terms of uh backlinking and in terms of increasing visibility across a bunch of different social platforms. And in terms of having uh clear signals that people like engaging with what you're doing. So let's say low bounce rates and so on. Uh I think these will all still be really crucial.
25:30 Speaker 01 Absolutely. One other piece, like as we look into how, you know, how everything's changing and evolving. There's been this, you know, trend over the years and like more recently where although Google is still sending, you know, more traffic to the open web, more and more of that traffic is being captured by like the top players and the big brands in the space. And Rand's done a fair amount of research on it. It's been a conversation for quite some time. One of the things I think is particularly interesting. About these shifts is it feels like for some of the like maybe smaller brands that are able to mobilize,
26:11 Speaker 01 move quickly, get a jump on kind of this new direction, they can get an inside lane. So it's almost like there's an open angle for more competition within search. Do you see this as like a kind of a continuation that hey, like with all of this hyper specialization, there is an opportunity for more diversity amongst websites, rankings. Like it's not just going to be like the big box players that are dominating the search results, but like more room for variety of players. Like, do you see that kind of continuing in that direction? Or do you think like we are going to still see this like dominance of big brands within search?
26:57 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think AI search has definitely helped smaller brands. There is less emphasis on traditional brand credibility than there was. And I think this will decline a bit, where essentially big brands will eventually stabilize, will figure out what works as well, and there'll be some degree of consistency. And they'll kind of catch up and find all the best practices and have the resources to be more sophisticated when they figure out what works best. But I think there will be a phase of months and small number of years where small brands definitely can get a head start and definitely can capture a bunch of the low hanging fruit.
27:39 Speaker 02 So I think it's particularly important for small brands to lean into the AI angle, yeah.
27:44 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's like that that open inside lane, I agree. Like it only feels like it's going to be open for a short period more. It's like search has become so much more general, I think, in a lot of conversations. Like I've heard more executives, CMOs, CEOs asking questions about search. And I think, one, it's a great opportunity for SEOs from a career perspective because you have this added awareness. But it's like that kind of angle before everyone's kind of all moving in this direction feels like it's only going to be open for for so long.
28:24 Speaker 02 Absolutely, but I think it's a great opportunity for SEOs as well because I think almost all parts of marketing are converging towards this area. Like, I think AI search is eating into all facets of marketing. It could be like documentation, or it could be even like kind of website optimization and so on. And it could be e-commerce and even some aspects of sales. All of these are getting eaten into by AI search. And so SEOs who are forward-looking have a huge opportunity to expand their domain responsibility. And so I think the trend is that SEOs are becoming a lot more strategic, a lot more kind of like
29:06 Speaker 02 research-based, as opposed to necessarily doing a lot of manual work and doing a lot of execution work. The research phase is particularly important. And that's the result of that, I think, is a lot of the hires that are made for SEO are becoming more and more senior, which is a great thing and means that there's an opportunity for top SEOs to get compensated with responsibility and payment and so on really well. So I think as a trend, SEO is becoming more high-level and sophisticated and so on, which is really cool to see.
29:35 Speaker 01 Hundred percent. And I mean, anecdotally, I feel like last year when we did our SEO jobs study where we looked at like, you know, what SEO jobs there were, what were the trends in it. Of course, there's some areas that were decreasing. And I know, you know, there's a lot of SEOs out there that, you know, have been looking for quite some time. But like the areas that we saw growth were in those more senior director and above type positions. And so I think although there's a lot of competition out there, there is like a glass half-full component of some of the roles leveling up, having that more kind of higher ceiling almost like in the industry.
30:15 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think it's also becoming more technical as well. And there's more need to run very specific experiments where there's a very narrow question that needs answering. And having the tooling or access to the tooling and the understanding to be able to find that answer is becoming a huge win.
30:33 Speaker 01 Absolutely. And pace that we need to be operating in with that. It's like the pace of those tests and experiments is just going to further increase in my mind. Well, with that, that's going to wrap up this episode of the Voice of Search Podcast. Thanks again to Killian Dunn from Telepathic for joining us. If you'd like to contact Killian, you can find a link to his LinkedIn profile in the show notes or go on over and check out his company's website at itstelepathic.com. If you haven't subscribed yet and want a daily stream of SEO content marketing knowledge in your podcast, hit the subscribe button on your podcast app or on YouTube and we'll be back in your feed soon. So with that, that's all for today. Thanks for stopping by and we'll see you in the next episode.
Previous Will email marketing will outperform paid search ROI over the next 12 months? Next Will a smaller handful of Brands dominate the AI Search era Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated