Vision Pros Live Podcast
Original podcast
Where to listenCopy share link
What is your vision ? Featuring Roy Baumeister. Podcast Session 1.
3,356 words · 3 speakers
Well, please share with me more details about your book.
All right, uh, so issues of human free will, something we've been talking about for centuries and arguing back and forth. Um, I really tried to take a fresh look at it more from a science point of view. Uh, arguing about the philosophical issues is not something we can do experiments on, but it strikes me, I've talked to many scientists who accept the idea of free will and many who say, no, no, there could not be any such thing. And what strikes me is they have the same understanding of how behavior is produced. Uh, they, uh, they both believe even that the human mental system by which our minds
and brain cause us behavior, uh, that this is unique in the world. No other animal has anything like this with, um, you know, understood moral responsibility and laws and governments and economic systems and all these complicated things that we do. Um, so they're just arguing about whether this marvelous new newly evolved evolutionary system deserves to be called free will. So that's a terminological issue, what I'm trying to get to. Let's understand the scientific problem is how does this marvelous thing work? What sets apart, sets us apart from the other animals? One, for example, is we can project into the future and simulate, well, if I do this,
it will lead to this and then they'll do that and then this and so on. And ultimately, oh, no, I don't want it to end up that way. So how about if I do something else and then they'll react this way and then, and so on. Project these multiple simulations of the future and then bring the result back to the present and use it to guide our behavior. Being able to do that, you know, certainly makes you freer than if you're not able to have this kind of thinking. So that's, that's one important advance and, uh, understanding how the human mind integrates across time, that's, that's one aspect of it.
Another is that ideas can cause behavior, that we change how we act based on abstract understanding of moral principles, or as I said, just the laws of the land, or promises you made a long time ago, or religious ideas, or political ideals. So, that's another advance that makes us freer in our actions than animals who cannot do any such thing.
In my own lab work, what led me into it was the limited willpower finding. I called it in the scientific literature, it's called ego depletion. And it shows that after you... that willpower is... there is such an energy resource in the self, and after you use it, say by resisting temptation, or making some hard decisions, or whatever, then you have a bit less for a while. So that's a time of vulnerability, when you might give in to temptation, or let someone talk you into something, or do something that you might regret later on.
So, you know, that was sort of the lead-in for me. If you read the philosophy books about free will, they talk about self-control is important, and they talk about rational choice of making good decisions, that's important too. But they had no way of showing these two are connected, because philosophers just work with ideas and theories very carefully. Whereas we, in the psychology laboratory, we can show that after you make a lot of decisions, your self-control is worse. And vice versa, after you exert self-control, you start making decisions in a more casual, superficial manner, leading to not doing what's really best for you in the long run.
So, that's the kind of thing we feature in the book. To give a people idea, in practice, well, the moral agent is one where I'll do that. We know what's right and wrong. We don't always do it right, but but often we do. We let those things influence us. If we're gonna go on something more questionable, we think about how can we justify it and explain it to other people, things like that. Economic marketplace is another thing unique to humans, where we exchange money. And Matt Ridley, in his recent book, said, this is not a new thing. Trade is ten times older than farming. I mean, we think farming is, you know,
the dawn of civilization ten or twelve thousand years ago. And to think ten times that old, a hundred thousand years ago, there's evidence that humans were already trading things. So economic agent has to understand ideas of quantity, how much, how many fish fur, how many beaver pelts, or whatever it is that you're, whatever that you're trading. It's a form of cooperation. We forget that. It's easy to think, well, in the marketplace, the seller wants a higher price, the buyer wants a lower price, so they're they're fighting back and forth. But what we miss out in that is that they're both better off. The seller wants to sell, the buyer wants to buy.
And if they can find a place where their their acceptable prices overlap, they're both happy, they're both they're both better off. Human evolution, the basis of my thinking is the human mind was made by by nature for culture. It was created by evolution, of course. But the way we evolved was to organize our society with these these things like economic marketplaces and moral systems. Cooperation and and communication are the the two ways that the human mind is really far advanced from any other animals. It's obvious with with communication, all human societies have language. Nobody's ever found an exception. And no animals have anything that lingers.
And say, okay, that counts as a language, you know, they do bark and squawk and then they communicate a little bit with each other. Uh, but nothing like a, like a human language. So, you know, this is one of the essential features that makes us human and. Culture is a system for communicating and cooperating.
Yeah.
Uh, like I said, the marketplace, they're both better off if they can trade.
Yes, yes. And the book's name is The Science of Willpower and Self-Control. Is that correct?
It's called The Science of Free Will.
The Science of Free Will. Okay, my apologies.
I'll just, I actually had an earlier book called Willpower. I wrote with John Tierney, who was the New York Times Science Writer, and the book was actually a, a bestseller and. It was on the New York Times charts for a dozen, a couple of months, Amazon and so on. Uh, so that really summarized other scientific work about self-control and limited willpower. So the. The free will thing is it's just taking the argument a big step further. Saying, what does this tell us about the, the basic nature of the human mind?
Okay. And when you decided to write these books, tell me about your vision.
Okay, so you don't actually mean my eyes.
I could see those.
Okay, I was saying I had the.
No, you mean like the, the idea vision.
Well, the, the exciting thing about a problem like Free Will is, is it's one of the classic debates and it goes to. What kind of creatures are we? And, and um, given the unusual career I've had in psychology, I think I'm in. In a unusually good position to really ask and try to answer some of those questions. So. Uh, cause I've, I've studied many different areas of psychology. I write what scientists call literature reviews where instead of doing an experiment yourself, which you know might take a year, you go and read all the experiments that other people have done and try to put them together and you can address big questions like that. So what is the essence of being human? That's that's that's one of those.
And certainly whether we have free will in the sense we can choose to act differently in the same situation and alter and adjust our behavior, including based on ideas and how we imagine the future, things like that. That that's really an important aspect of the human of the human mind.
So that's the vision was to really try to to understand that.
I'm sorry, I'm sorry. My my security guard is barking. One more.
All right, so we're back on my sincere apology. I'm so sorry. Of course, that will be edited out and everything else. We were, of course, speaking about your book, The Free Signs of Free Will, and we were just talking about how we as humans can utilize free will, willpower to to actually direct us into where we're going or how we see
how we see life. That's what I took from our discussion because I realized that we don't we don't normally think about things like that. I think we're just doers and we're not really sitting here thinking about things like that. And when you decided to write this book and the other book that you have written, what what more do you want us to learn or people to learn or even the viewers to learn about this?
Well, the limited aspect of willpower is important to understand and to manage.
Getting someone that just on a podcast, let me.
We got all over the place today, Roy.
I know, I know. This is my friend from France has been trying to call me.
So let's go back to what else do people want to know.
It's, it's clear, as you said, good self-control and rational decision-making, enlightened self-interest. All of these help you to live a better life and to be more successful. Early in my career, for example, I studied self-esteem because there was a period when we thought, oh, the big problem in life is people don't have enough self-esteem and that makes them not take chances or whatever, but that didn't work out very well. Self-esteem is more a result of success in life than a cause of it. It makes you take a more optimistic spin. If you have high self-esteem, you like, you like yourself better, but you don't actually do any better.
Whereas self-control, very much the opposite. Self-control measured early leads to success later. There are these studies in Britain where they tracked thousands and thousands of people over many years. And the kids who were rated as having better self-control by their teachers when they were nine years old, end up having a better employment history as adults and being less likely to be cigarette addicted smokers and various other things, earn more money in life, more popular, better relationships.
So I came away from all that with my advice to parents and teachers and coaches and things. Forget about self-esteem, concentrate on building self-control. That's really uh what produces the best results in the in the long run.
Roy, and I'm I'm so eager to ask you, with all of these words and self-control and willpower and everything that you're saying, how does that play a part now that social media is all in our faces?
Yes, well, a lot of us are thinking about that. You know, things have been changing so fast. We don't have all the data and all the information uh that we want, but I I think people are making a pretty good case that that the sustained attention is much more difficult. It's more of the what they call the monkey mind that it jumps around because, you know, he's getting uh things clamoring for your attention and anytime you get bored for a moment, uh you can go onto your phone and check your your social media presence or play games or uh text some friends or do email. Uh so um you're always involved. I'm writing a big
review article on that where we've been reading lots and lots of the scientific studies. Uh the idea uh which seems to be holding up is that the the the human self, you know, the psychological I forget, isn't isn't fully there when you interact online as much as when you're interacting with a person face to face. We spend a lot of time engaged in social action, interaction when we're physically alone. Right? Since that's what I'm doing now.
Nobody else uh here, uh but we're communicating. I spend a couple hours a day on email, which is even less. I mean, here you and I can at least look at each other's pictures of our faces and respond in real time, whereas email, you know, you send it off and uh somebody might respond tomorrow or maybe not till next week and uh so there's there's there's less engagement. Makes people somewhat less inhibited. Uh so when you're not in person, people are more likely to bring up a lot of other ideas and yeah, criticize and so on. Um, but the ideas tend to be of lower quality.
Um, and uh, you're just throwing out a lot more stuff. Um, I think people are starting to realize too that that the the physical safety feeling from interacting online. It is compensated for a great deal of danger. If you say the wrong thing or write the wrong thing, it it will stay out there forever. I was uh, I spent this past semester at Harvard and uh, there's some news stories about people who were accepted, you know, it's a big, a big moment in a kid's life to get accepted to uh, certainly with the very best universities in the world. And then they found out that they said something objectionable back when they were fourteen or fifteen and,
you know, just clowning around or whatever, but they put something on a post that, oh, and then Harvard cancels their admission, you know, that's such a uh, uh, that's a lot of responsibility to put on a kid to realize everything I say could come back to haunt me in the future and and really derail my career plans.
Absolutely. And you know, it happens in careers, you know, at employment and jobs and it's all over the place. And then you deal with things like that. And then I, as I think about what we're speaking about, self-control goes out of the window. Uh, I really think that it's um,
going back to that and learning all of this, this would be great to learn prior to starting to post and saying what you're saying. But I think it's back to free will. How do you define free will?
All right, well, a lot of the argument's been about how to define it. So, I use a scientific definition that a bunch of scientists and philosophers came up with a few years ago, which is just the ability to act differently in the same situation.
Hmm, that was clear cut and to the point. I like it.
Yeah, I mean, there are other people think it means you're a soul reaching into the brain and causing behavior without any physical action or anything like that. And so a lot of scientists don't believe it when it's defined in those terms, and I guess I agree with them. But in terms of being able to act differently in the same situation, to be flexible, that's really good. You know, you can see why that evolved and why that's especially important in culture where we're creating multiple situations for ourselves all the time, whether it's recording this at Christmas, whether you're shopping for presents and deciding what of
all the possible things you could get, what do you want to get for people? Or you're saving money for the future for you can so you can buy a house or send your children to college or or have enough money when you retire. All sorts of things like that require an advanced mental capacity to deal with them. And the same with performing your roles in a society. I mean, chimpanzees are our closest relatives. They don't have any restaurants. They like cooked food when we cook it for them, most animals do. But no animals have mastered cooking, whereas pretty much all human societies do. And cooking is much healthier.
It vastly reduces the amount of energy you you you need in order to digest the food. Chimpanzees, I read somewhere they they spent six hours a day chewing. That is because they're eating they're eating raw meat and they have to chew it down. Well, you know, eating saves us from that. And also, we can go out to a restaurant and have different kinds of food and so on. But, you know, if a chimpanzee went in there, we're just grabbed food off of the plates of other patrons, wouldn't understand the rules of how to order and wouldn't pay for the meal and so on. And so the whole business model wouldn't wouldn't work. It's it's our shared understanding of these things that enables us to to cooperate in
this way. It's a, you know, it's like trade, the the restaurant wants you to buy a meal from them, and you want to buy a meal from them. And so if it works, you're both you're both better off. So it's a form of of cooperation. But you have to have an advanced enough free will to understand the rules, to obey them, play your part, do what you're supposed to, and then take advantage of it.
Absolutely. You have such knowledge and experience in this. What's your why? What's your big why?
Well, uh, the, uh, a while ago, I set myself the goal of trying to understand what the human life is all about. Uh, yeah, I was raised by some parents who had certain very strong views and and I rebelled against those, and so I didn't feel loyalty to those, but, uh, you know, they had some good points too, so I didn't just go to the opposite and, uh, and I said, oh, you know, people can talk me into things. I, I really wanna learn to be very disciplined in my thinking, wanna explore both sides and and come away with a big understanding of, of, of what, why we're here and what we're doing and what we're supposed to be doing and um, why, why society is the way it is. So,
Uh, that's my quest for the big picture and, uh, yeah, maybe I'll make it, maybe not. I've made some progress.
Yes, yes. And as you continue on and, and the world changes, I think you'll have more work to do.
Because
Yes, yes, well, fascinating new things. I mean, thirty years ago, nobody knew we'd be debating whether the internet was bad for kids or, uh,
Um, or, you know, new forms of, of warfare and, uh, uh, all sorts of, uh, things. I mean, other problems go back, but, uh, you know, the global economy is also a fairly modern uh, development.
It's been, among other things, it's done, it's, it's reduced warfare. It's, uh, nations discovered it was better to, to trade with each other than to send armies to destroy each other's, uh, cities.
That itself has been been improved. So anyway, things do do keep changing, but but there is a fundamental human nature that doesn't change as fast.
Thank you for being here today. I'm really happy that you tuned in to Vision Pros Live. I'm looking forward to seeing your reactions as these episodes continue to move forward. This is going to get more and more fun. We'll have more and more engagement as well. We'll invite people to participate in the show and thank you for giving us your time and attention. Have an excellent time building out your vision and becoming a vision pro yourself.
Page updated November 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated