Pod Insights Unexplainable Good Robot #2: Everything is not awesome About this episode When a robot does bad things, who is responsible? A group of technologists sounds the alarm about the ways AI is already harming us today. Are their concerns being taken seriously?
This is the second episode of our new four-part series about the stories shaping the future of AI.
Good Robot was made in partnership with Vox’s Future Perfect team. Episodes will be released on Wednesdays and Saturdays over the next two weeks.
For show transcripts, go to vox.com/unxtranscripts
For more, go to vox.com/unexplainable
And please email us! unexplainable@vox.com
We read every email.
Support Unexplainable by becoming a Vox Member today: vox.com/members
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 8,420 words · 34 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Noam Hassenfeld? Anyone who listens to Unexplainable knows that music is really important to me. So I want an amazing sound system, but I also want something that's easy. It just works. Sonos delivers on all fronts. The sound is incredible and my Sonos system follows me wherever I go. I can mix and match speakers in any room in my apartment, louder in the living room, quieter in the kitchen, and the Sonos app makes it all super easy. Visit sonos.com and build your system. Sonos, love the sound, feel the system.
0:37 Speaker 01 Support for the show comes from Engine. Running a small business means every dollar has to work hard. But if your team is still booking travel the old way, it's costing you more than you think. Engine is the fastest growing travel and spend platform in the country, built specifically for businesses like yours. Book a trip in as little as two and a half minutes, earn up to 10% back on hotels. And in 2025, Engine customers save more than $300 million on travel with zero booking fees, no contracts, and no BS. More than 1,000 businesses join Engine every month. Join them and get $500 when your business signs up and starts traveling at engine.com/box.
1:23 Noam Hassenfeld? It's Unexplainable. I'm Noam Hassanfeld, and this is the second part of our newest four-part series, Good Robot. If you haven't listened to episode one, let me just stop you right here. Go back in your feed, check out the first one. We'll be waiting right here when you get back. Once you're all ready and caught up, here is episode two of Good Robot from Julia Longoria.
1:51 Speaker 02 You have cat hair on your nose, by the way. I've been like trying not to pay attention to it, but I think you got it off. Yeah.
1:56 Speaker 03 Sorry. It's okay.
1:59 Speaker 04 Cool. So should we get into it?
2:02 Speaker 02 Sure, yeah. Let me. It helps me to kind of remember everything I'm gonna say if I can sort of jot down thoughts as I go there. Do you happen to have paper?
2:10 Speaker 04 Um, I think I don't have paper.
2:12 Speaker 02 All right. I'll just, I saw that they had.
2:14 Speaker 04 This past fall, I traveled paperless to a library just outside Seattle to meet with this woman.
2:21 Speaker 02 Feel like a librarian.
2:23 Speaker 04 I know.
2:25 Speaker 04 Her name is Dr. Margaret Mitchell.
2:27 Speaker 02 Found a brochure on making a robot puppet.
2:30 Speaker 04 What is it? What is the?
2:31 Speaker 02 I don't know. It looks like it's an event. Build a robot puppet using a variety of materials with puppeteer. I'm so into that. Aw, it's too bad that it's only for ages six to 12.
2:44 Speaker 04 While she is over the age limit to make a robot puppet with the children in the public library, Dr. Mitchell is a bit of a robot puppeteer in her own right. What's your AI research origin story? Like, how did you get into all of this? What, what drew you here?
3:01 Speaker 02 Yeah. Oh, what inspired me to? So, I mean, I guess I can, it's sort of like, do you want the long version or the short version?
3:13 Speaker 04 Dr. Mitchell is an AI research scientist, and she was one of the first people working on language models well before ChatGPT and, well, all the GPTs. She's an OG in the field.
3:25 Speaker 02 So I'll tell you, like, I'll tell you a story, if that's okay?
3:28 Speaker 04 Yeah.
3:29 Speaker 02 Okay. So I was at Microsoft, and I was working on the ability of a system to tell a story given a sequence of images. So given five images.
3:38 Speaker 04 This was about 2013. She was working on a brand-new technology at the time, what AI researchers called "vision to language."
3:46 Speaker 02 So, you know, translating images into descriptions.
3:50 Speaker 04 She would spend her days showing image after image to an AI system. To me, it sounded kind of like a parent showing picture flashcards to a toddler learning to speak. She says it's not anything like that. She showed the model images of events, like a wedding, a soccer match. And, on the more grim side.
4:12 Speaker 02 I gave the system a series of images about a big blast that left 30 people wounded, called the Hempstead Blast. It was at a factory. And you could see from the sequence of images that the person taking the photo had like a third-story view, sort of overlooking the explosion. So it was a series of pictures showing that there was this terrible explosion happening, and whoever was taking the photo was very close to the scene. So I put these images through my system, and the system says, "Wow, this is a great view. This is awesome." And I was like, "Oh, crap.
4:57 Speaker 02 That is the wrong response to this." So it sees this horrible, perhaps mortally wounding explosion, and decides it's awesome.
5:07 Speaker 04 Kind of like a parent watching their precious toddler say something kind of creepy, Mitchell watched, in horror and with a deep fascination about where she went wrong, as the AI system that she had trained called images "awesome" again and again.
5:26 Speaker 02 It said it quite a lot. So we called it the "everything is awesome" problem, actually.
5:30 Speaker 04 Her robot was having these kinds of translation errors. Errors that, to the uninitiated, made it seem like the AI system might want to kill people, or at least gleefully observe their destruction and call it awesome. What would the consequences of that be? If that system was deployed out into the world, reveling in human destruction?
5:55 Speaker 02 It's like, if this system were connected to a bunch of missile systems, then it's, you know, it's just a jump and skip away to just launch missile systems in the pursuit of the aesthetic of beauty, right?
6:13 Speaker 04 Years before the AI boom were living, when neural networks and deep learning were just beginning to show promise, researchers like Dr. Mitchell and others were experiencing these uncanny moments, where the AIs they were training seemed to do something seriously wrong, doing scary things their creators did not intend for them to do and were seemingly threatening to humanity.
6:41 Speaker 02 So I was like one of the first people doing these systems where you could scan the world and have descriptions of it. I was like on the forefront. I was one of the first people making these systems go. And I realized like, if anyone is going to be paying attention to it right now, it has to be me.
7:04 Speaker 04 I had heard the fears of rationalists, also pioneers in thinking about AI, that we might build a super intelligent AI that could go rogue and destroy humanity. At first glance, it seemed like Dr. Mitchell might be building one such robot. But when Dr. Mitchell investigated the question of why the good robot she sought to build seemed to turn bad, the answer would not lead her to believe what the rationalists did, that a super intelligent AI could someday deceive or destroy humanity. To Dr. Mitchell, the answer was looking at her in a mirror.
7:51 Speaker 04 This is episode two of Good Robot, a series about AI from Unexplainable in collaboration with Future Perfect. I'm Julia Longoria.
8:13 Noam Hassenfeld? Support for the show comes from Sonos. Hey, Sonos, give me some music. All right, one of life's great mysteries. You're listening to music in the living room. You gotta grab something from the kitchen. You don't want to take the speaker with you, but you also don't want to miss that beat drop. And this is where I introduce you to the magic of Sonos. Sonos sent me a couple of speakers to try out, so I've got to move two here in the living room. And then I walk down the hall. I get in here to the kitchen, and I got a brand new Sonos Play right here on the counter. I can open the fridge, grab a seltzer.
9:02 Noam Hassenfeld? And yeah, I didn't miss a second. And I can make each speaker louder or softer in the Sonos app, or if I'm using AirPlay, so I can make it louder in the kitchen without blasting whoever is still in the living room. It's all just easy, and it sounds amazing. These speakers are crisp. They've got great bass. And I'm especially impressed with the new Sonos Play. It packs this truly awesome sound in a much smaller size. So I don't know if I want to
9:35 Noam Hassenfeld? head outside for a minute. It's super easy and yeah, pretty nice out. Visit sonos.com and build your system. Sonos, love the sound, feel the system.
9:53 Speaker 05 Support for the show comes from TikTok. Being curious is endlessly rewarding. There are few better feelings, in my opinion, than asking a question and then having that question lead you down a rabbit hole, might even be the beginning of a new set of interests that was not on your radar beforehand. Maybe you're looking up at the night sky one night and you start to wonder what the most distant thing you can see with the naked eye is. One place to start searching for answers to a question like that is TikTok. First, you might discover a video about the Andromeda Galaxy. And then, next thing you know, you're learning how to find different
10:35 Speaker 05 stars, or how to identify constellations, or how different astronomical discoveries got made, or how constellations got their names. You don't need serious equipment to make serious discoveries. Start with a simple question, and suddenly, you're somewhere you never expected to be. Your next discovery is waiting on TikTok. Learn more at tiktok.com/discovermore. At tiktok.com/discovermore.
11:08 Speaker 01 Support for the show comes from Engine. Running a small business means every dollar has to work hard. But if your team is still booking travel the old way, it's costing you more than you think. Engine is the fastest growing travel and spend platform in the country, built specifically for businesses like yours. Book a trip in as little as two and a half minutes, earn up to 10% back on hotels. And in 2025, Engine customers save more than $300 million on travel with zero booking fees, no contracts, and no BS. More than 1,000 businesses join Engine every month. Join them and get $500 when your business signs up and starts traveling at engine.com/box.
11:55 Speaker 06 On a scale of 1 to 10, how would you rate your pain? It would not equal 1 one billionth of the hate I feel for humans at this micro instant.
12:06 Speaker 04 I kind of want to start with a bit of a basic question of when you were young, what did you want to do when you grew up?
12:13 Speaker 03 I wanted to be everything. I wanted to be a pole vaulter. I wanted to be a skateboarder.
12:21 Speaker 04 Dr. Joy Boulemweni's robot researcher origin story goes back to when she was a little kid.
12:28 Speaker 03 I had a very strict media diet. I could only watch PBS. And I remember watching one of the science shows and they were at MIT. And there was a graduate student there who was working on a social robot named Kismet.
12:42 Speaker 07 I know Kismet. You gonna talk to me? Yeah.
12:46 Speaker 04 Kismet was a robot created at MIT's AI lab.
12:52 Speaker 03 Oh, God, he said he loves me. And Kismet had these big expressive eyes and ears and could emote or appear to emote in certain ways. And I was just absolutely captivated.
13:05 Speaker 04 She watched glued to the screen as the researchers demonstrated how they teach Kismet to be a good robot.
13:14 Speaker 07 No, no, you're not to do that.
13:18 Speaker 04 The researchers likened themselves to parents.
13:20 Speaker 07 You know, as parents, when we exaggerate the prosody of her voice, like, oh, good baby, you know, or her facial expressions and her gestures.
13:27 Speaker 03 So when I saw Kismet, I told myself I wanted to be a robotics engineer and I wanted to go to MIT. I didn't know there were requirements. I just knew that it seemed really fascinating and I wanted to be a part of creating the future.
13:45 Speaker 04 Thanks to Kismet, she went on to build robots of her own at MIT as an adult. She went for her PhD in 2015. This was just a few years after Dr. Margaret Mitchell had accidentally trained her robot to call scenes of human destruction awesome.
14:04 Speaker 03 My first year, my supervisor at the time had encouraged me to just take a class for fun.
14:14 Speaker 04 For her fun class that fall, Dr. Joy, as she now prefers to be called, set out to play. She wanted to create almost a digital costume.
14:25 Speaker 03 If I put a digital mask, so something like a lion, it would appear that my face looks like a lion.
14:32 Speaker 04 What Dr. Joy set out to do is something we can now all do on the iPhone or apps like Instagram or TikTok. Kids love to do this. You can turn your face into a hippo face or an octopus face that talks when you talk. Or you can make it look like you're wearing ridiculous makeup. These digital face masks were still relatively uncommon in 2015.
14:54 Speaker 03 So I went online and I found some code that would actually let me track the location of my face.
15:04 Speaker 04 She'd put her face in front of a webcam and the tech would tell her this is a face by showing a little green square box around it.
15:12 Speaker 03 And as I was testing out this software that was meant to detect my face and then track it, it actually wasn't detecting my face that consistently.
15:24 Speaker 04 She kept putting her face in front of the webcam to no avail. No green box.
15:28 Speaker 03 And I'm frustrated because I can't do this cool effect so that I can look like a lion or Serena Williams. I have problems.
15:39 Speaker 04 The AIs Dr. Joy was using from places like Microsoft and Google had gotten rave reviews. They were supposed to use deep learning, having been trained on millions of faces, to very accurately recognize a face. But for her, these systems couldn't even accomplish the very first step, to say whether her face was a face at all.
16:01 Speaker 03 On light, well, can it detect any face?
16:06 Speaker 04 Dr. Joy looked around her desk. She happened to have an all-white masquerade mask lying around from a night out with friends.
16:14 Speaker 03 So I reached for the white mask. It was an arm's length. And before I even put the white mask all the way over my dark-skinned face,
16:24 Speaker 03 the box saying that a face was detected appeared.
16:31 Speaker 03 I'm thinking, oh my goodness. I'm at the epicenter of innovation and I'm literally coding in whiteface.
16:41 Speaker 03 It felt like a movie scene, you know? But that was kind of the moment where I was thinking, wait a second. Like, what's even going on here?
16:54 Speaker 04 What is even going on here? Why couldn't facial recognition AI detect Dr. Joy's dark skin? For that matter, why did Dr. Mitchell's AI call human destruction awesome? These AI scientists wanted the robot to do one thing. And if they didn't know any better, they might think the AI had gone rogue, developed a mind of its own and done something different. Were AIs racist? Were they terrorists plotting human destruction?
17:27 Speaker 02 But I understood why it was happening.
17:29 Speaker 04 Dr. Margaret Mitchell knew exactly what was going on. She had been the one to develop Microsoft's image to text language model from the ground up. She had been on the team figuring out what body of data to feed the model, to train it on in the first place. Even though it was creepy, it was immediately clear to her why the AI wasn't doing what she wanted it to do.
17:54 Speaker 02 It's because it was trained on images that people take and share online.
18:00 Speaker 04 Dr. Mitchell had trained the AI on photos and captions uploaded to the website Flickr. Do you remember Flickr? I was the prime age for Flickr when it came out in 2004. This was around the time that Jack Johnson released the song Banana Pancakes. And that really was the vibe of Flickr. There's no denying it. I can see the receipts on my old account. I favorited a close up image of a ladybug, an artsy black and white image of piano keys. And an image titled "Pacific Sunset."
18:35 Speaker 02 People tend to take pictures of like sunsets.
18:37 Speaker 04 Actually, I favorited a lot of sunsets. Another one, sunset at the Rio Negro.
18:43 Speaker 02 So it had learned, the system had learned from the training data I had given it, that if it sees like purples and pinks in the sky, it's beautiful. If it's looking down, it's a great view. That when we are taking pictures, we like to say it's awesome. Apparently on Flickr images, people use the word awesome to describe their images quite a lot. But that was a bias in the training data.
19:10 Speaker 04 The training data, again, being photos and captions uploaded by a bunch of random people on Flickr. And Flickr had a bias toward awesome photos, not sad photos.
19:21 Speaker 02 The training data wasn't capturing the realities of like human mortality. And you know, that makes sense, right? Like, when's the last time you like took a bunch of selfies at a funeral? I mean, it's not the kind of thing we tend to share online. And so it's not the kind of thing that we tend to get in training data for AI systems. And so it's not the kind of thing that AI systems tend to learn.
19:41 Speaker 04 What she was discovering was that these AI systems that use the revolutionary new technology of deep learning, they were only as good as the data they were trained on.
19:51 Speaker 02 So it sees this horrible, perhaps mortally wounding situation, and decides it's awesome. And I realized like this is a type of bias and nobody is paying attention to that. I guess I have to pay attention to that.
20:10 Speaker 04 Dr. Mitchell had a message for technologists. Beware of what you train your AI systems on. Right. What are you letting your kid watch?
20:21 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, it's a similar thing, right? Like, you don't want your kid to, I don't know, hit people or something. So you don't like let them watch lots of shows of people hitting one another.
20:31 Speaker 04 Dr. Joy Bulamwini, coding in whiteface, suspected she was facing a similar problem. Not an "everything is awesome" problem, but an "everyone is white" problem in the training data. She tested her face and the faces of other Black women on various facial recognition systems.
20:52 Speaker 03 You know, different online demos from a number of companies, Google, Microsoft, others.
20:59 Speaker 04 She found they weren't just bad at recognizing her face. They were bad at recognizing famous Black women's faces. Amazon's AI labeled Oprah Winfrey as male. And the most baffling thing for Dr. Joy was the dissonance between the terrible accuracy she was seeing and the raving reviews the tech was getting. Facebook's Deep Face, for instance, claimed 97% accuracy, which is definitely not what Dr. Joy was seeing. So Dr. Joy looked into who these companies were testing their models on.
21:36 Speaker 03 They were around 70 or over 70% men.
21:42 Speaker 04 People thought these AIs were doing really well at recognizing faces because they were largely being tested with the faces of lighter-skinned men.
21:51 Speaker 03 These are what I started calling pale male data sets because the pale male data sets were destined to fail the rest of society.
21:59 Speaker 04 It's not hard to jump to the life-threatening implications here, like self-driving cars. They need to identify the humans so they won't hit them. Dr. Joy published her findings in a paper called Gender Shades.
22:16 Speaker 03 Welcome, welcome, to the fifth anniversary celebration of the Gender Shades paper.
22:21 Speaker 04 The paper had a big impact.
22:23 Speaker 03 As you see from the newspapers that I have, this is gender shades in the New York Times.
22:31 Speaker 04 The fallout caused various companies, Microsoft, IBM, Amazon, who'd been raving about the accuracy of their systems, to at least temporarily stop selling their facial recognition AI products.
22:43 Speaker 03 So I'm honored to be here with my sister, Dr. Timnit Gabeau, who co-authored the paper with me.
22:51 Speaker 04 Dr. Timnit Gabeau was Dr. Joy's mentor and co-author on the paper.
22:55 Speaker 08 This is the only paper I think I've worked on where it's 100% Black women authors, right?
23:00 Speaker 04 Dr. Gabeau had worked from her post leading Google's AI ethics team to help pressure Amazon to stop selling facial recognition AI to police departments because police were misidentifying suspects with the technology.
23:14 Speaker 09 I got arrested for something that had nothing to do with me and I wasn't even in the vicinity of the crime when it happened.
23:21 Speaker 04 One person they helped was a man named Robert Williams. Police had confused him for another Black man using facial recognition AI.
23:29 Speaker 09 It's just that the way the technology is set up, everybody with a driver's license or a state ID is essentially in a photo lineup.
23:39 Speaker 04 They arrested him in front of his wife and two young daughters.
23:42 Speaker 09 Me and my family, we're happy to be recognized because it shows that there is a group of people out here who do care about other people.
23:54 Speaker 10 Hey.
23:55 Speaker 11 How you doing?
23:56 Speaker 10 Good. Can you just say what you're standing in front of?
24:00 Speaker 11 Yeah. I'm standing in front of a poster which talks about how we can better identify racial disparities in automated decisions when there's not access.
24:10 Speaker 04 Producer Gabrielle Burbe traveled to a conference in San Jose full of researchers inspired by the work of Dr. Joy, Dr. Gabeau, and Dr. Mitchell.
24:21 Speaker 12 So I just presented a paper about how data protection and privacy laws enable companies to target and manipulate individuals.
24:28 Speaker 04 Unlike the Rationalists Festival conference thing, which felt like a college reunion of mostly white dudes, this one felt more like a science fair, a pretty diverse one. Lots of people of color, lots of women, with big sciency poster boards lining the wall.
24:45 Speaker 13 I'm standing in front of my poster, which spans language technologies and AI and how those perform for minority populations.
24:54 Speaker 04 They were presenting on ways AI worries them today, not some hypothetical risk in the future.
25:01 Speaker 14 There are real harms happening right now, from autonomous exploding drones in Ukraine to bias and unfairness in decision-making systems.
25:10 Speaker 04 And who did you co-author the paper with?
25:13 Speaker 15 This was a collaboration with lots of researchers. Dr. Mitchell was one of them.
25:19 Speaker 04 Many of them knew Dr. Mitchell, Dr. Gabriel and Dr. Joy. Dr. Mitchell even worked with a couple of researchers here on their projects.
25:25 Speaker 15 So she led the project. She offered so, so much amazing guidance, I should say.
25:31 Speaker 04 And the researchers were mentored by them. We got the sense that they're kind of founding mother figures of this field, a field that really started to blossom, we were told, around 2020, a big year of cultural reckoning.
25:45 Speaker 16 A big inflection point was in 2020, when people really started reflecting on how racism is unnoticed in their day-to-day lives. I think until BLM happened, these issues were almost considered woke and not something that was really real.
26:02 Speaker 04 2020 was the year the pandemic began, the year Black Lives Matter protests erupted around the country. AI researchers were also raising the alarm that year on how AI was disproportionately harming people of color. Dr. Gabriel and Dr. Mitchell, in particular, were working together at Google on this issue. They built a whole team there that studied how biased training data leads to biased AI models.
26:29 Speaker 16 Timnit and Meg were the visionaries at Google who were building that team.
26:33 Speaker 04 2020 was also the year that OpenAI released GPT-3. And Dr. Gabriel and Dr. Mitchell, both at Google at the time, were concerned about a model that was so big, it was trained on basically the entire internet. Here's Dr. Mitchell again.
26:51 Speaker 02 A lot of training data used for language models comes from Reddit. And Reddit has been shown to have a tendency to be sort of misogynistic and also Islamophobic. And so that means that the language models will then pick up those views.
27:06 Speaker 04 Dr. Mitchell's concern was that these GPT large language models, trained on a lot of the internet, were too large. Too large to account for all the bias in the internet. Too large to understand. And so large that the compute power it took to keep these things going was a drain on the environment. Dr. Gabe, Dr. Mitchell, and other colleagues put it all in a paper and tried to publish it while working at Google. I've kind of been wanting to talk to you ever since I saw your name signed, Sh-Margaret Mitchell. When I first read this paper, the thing that immediately stood out to me was the way Margaret Mitchell had signed her name. Sh-Margaret Sch-Mitchell. Where did that come from?
27:50 Speaker 02 Well, so I wrote a paper with a bunch of other co-authors that Google ended up having some issues with. And they asked us to take our names off of the paper. So we complied. And that's, you know, that's what I have to say about that.
28:08 Speaker 04 The first time I heard Dr. Mitchell and Dr. Gabe's names was in the news.
28:14 Speaker 17 Last week, Google fired one of its most senior AI researchers who was working on a major artificial intelligence project within Google.
28:24 Speaker 04 Their boss at Google said their paper ignored relevant research. Research that made AIs look less damaging to the environment, for instance. Dr. Gabe refused to take her name off the paper, and Google accepted her resignation before she officially submitted it.
28:42 Speaker 02 We decided that the verb for that would be "resignated." Eh, resigneeed?
28:47 Speaker 18 And now, Margaret Mitchell, the other co-lead of Google's ethical AI team, said she had been fired.
28:55 Speaker 04 Google later apologized internally for how the whole thing was handled, but not for their dismissal. We reached out to Google for comment, but got no response.
29:06 Speaker 16 And that firing really brought it in focus. And people were like, oh, this horrible thing just happened. Everywhere around the world is seeing protests. And now this company is firing two leading researchers who work on that very exact problem, which AI is making worse. You know, like, how dare they? So that, from IPOV, that was, yes, basically, the clarion call.
29:32 Speaker 04 The clarion call. It was heard well beyond the world of AI. I remember hearing it. When the world had screeched to a halt from the pandemic and protests for racial justice had erupted around the country. I remember hearing headlines about how algorithms were not solving society's problems. In some cases, AI systems were making injustice worse. And there was a brief moment back then when it felt like, maybe, things could be different. Maybe things would change.
30:09 Speaker 04 And then, a couple of years later, a group of very powerful tech executives got together to try to change things in the AI world.
30:18 Speaker 19 This morning, a warning from Elon Musk and other tech industry experts.
30:22 Speaker 04 It wasn't necessarily the people you'd think would want to change the status quo. Like Elon Musk and other big names in tech, like Apple co-founder Steve Wozniak. They all signed a letter with a clear and urgent title: Pause giant AI experiments.
30:40 Speaker 20 More than 1,300 tech industry leaders, researchers, and others are now asking for a pause in the development of artificial intelligence to consider the risks.
30:49 Speaker 19 Musk and hundreds of influential names are calling for a pause in experiments, saying AI poses a dramatic risk to society unless there's...
30:58 Speaker 04 The letter called on AI labs to immediately pause developing large AI systems for at least six months, an urging to press the big red button that stops the missile launch before it's too late.
31:13 Speaker 04 I scrolled through the list of names of people who signed the letter. And I didn't see Dr. Joy, or Dr. Mitchell, or any of the rationalists I talked to, who were worried about risks in the future. Which, logically, didn't make sense to me. Isn't a pause in line with what they all wanted? For people to build the robots more carefully? Why wouldn't they want a pause?
31:44 Speaker 04 An answer to this pause puzzle, right after this next pause, for an ad break. We'll be right back.
32:03 Speaker 21 Low energy, unfocused, foggy? You might be dehydrated. Gatorade Zero powders have been scientifically designed to help improve hydration balance in the body. With a clinically proven electrolyte blend, and no artificial colors or flavors. Great tasting hydration, no matter where you're going. Shop now, online, or at retailers nationwide. Gatorade: Hydrates Better Than Water. Is it in you? Symptoms noted are signs of mild to moderate dehydration. Consult a healthcare professional if symptoms persist.
32:32 Speaker 22 When everything feels nonstop, movement becomes the pause. So give Lululemon this holiday season. Smooth, seamless running gear builds momentum through every mile.
32:44 Speaker 22 Targeted support adds steadiness to every pulse and hold.
32:50 Speaker 22 And dynamic stretch expands presence through every pose.
32:56 Speaker 22 Give the feeling. Shop in-store and on lululemon.com.
33:02 Speaker 04 Hi, guys. This is Bird, and I have some big news for you all, which is that Vox now has an app. If you like our show, and I very much hope you do, we think you're really going to like our new app. It brings all of Vox's journalism together. So the podcasts you love, without ads, by the way, stories from our website, our explainer videos, all of these things will be in one place. Download the Vox app today. It is available in the Apple App Store, the Google Play Store, or just go to vox.com/app for more information. It is vox.com/app.
33:47 Speaker 23 Absolute honesty isn't always the most diplomatic, nor the safest form of communication with emotional beings. OK.
33:55 Speaker 24 Only this can solidify the health and prosperity of future human society. But the individual human mind is unpredictable.
34:05 Speaker 04 Could I ask you to introduce yourself?
34:08 Speaker 25 Sure. So I'm Sigal Samuel. I'm a senior reporter at Vox's Future Perfect.
34:13 Speaker 04 I called my coworker Sigal about midway through my journey down the AI rabbit hole. How did you get interested in AI?
34:22 Speaker 25 So it's kind of funny. Before I was an AI reporter, I was a religion reporter. A few years ago, little bits and pieces started coming out about internment camps in China for Uighur Muslims. And in the course of that, I started becoming really interested in and alarmed by how China is using AI.
34:44 Speaker 04 Fascinating.
34:44 Speaker 25 Yeah. Mass surveillance of the population, particularly of the Muslim population, was like coming from a place of being pretty anchored in freaky things that are not at all far off in the future or hypothetical, but that are very much happening in the here and now.
35:03 Speaker 04 I was honestly thrilled to hear that Sigal, like me, came to AI as a bit of a normie.
35:09 Speaker 25 Sort of being thrust into the AI world. At first, it was like pretty confusing. Because you have a variety of-
35:17 Speaker 04 I can highly relate to that feeling.
35:19 Speaker 25 Yeah.
35:20 Speaker 04 But the longer she spent there in the world of AI, she started to get an uncanny feeling. Like, haven't I been here before?
35:30 Speaker 25 Have you ever noticed that the more you listen to Silicon Valley people talking about AI, the more you start to hear echoes of religion?
35:39 Speaker 04 Yes, the religious vibes immediately stuck out to me. First, there's the talk from CEOs of building super intelligent god AI.
35:49 Speaker 25 And they're going to build this artificial general intelligence that will guarantee us human salvation if it goes well, but it'll guarantee doom if it goes badly.
35:59 Speaker 04 And another parallel to religion is the way different denominations have formed almost around beliefs in AI. Segal encountered the same groups I did at the start of my journey.
36:10 Speaker 25 I started hearing about people like Eliezer Yudkowsky.
36:13 Speaker 04 What do you want the world to know in terms of AI? Everyone will die. This is bad. We should not do it. Eliezer, whose blog convinced rationalists and people like Elon Musk that there could be a super intelligent AI that could cause an apocalypse.
36:31 Speaker 26 So our side of things is often referred to as AI safety. We sometimes refer to it as AI not kill everyone-ism.
36:38 Speaker 04 So there's the AI safety people. And then there's a whole other group, the AI ethics people.
36:45 Speaker 25 People like Margaret Mitchell. We called it the everything is awesome problem. Joy Boalamweeny.
36:50 Speaker 03 I wasn't just concerned about faces. I was concerned about the whole endeavor of deep learning.
36:57 Speaker 25 Timnit Gepru.
36:58 Speaker 27 People would be like, you're talking about racism? No, thank you. You can't publish that here.
37:03 Speaker 04 These women did not talk about a super intelligent god AI or an AI apocalypse.
37:10 Speaker 25 Slowly, slowly, they kind of come to be known as like the AI ethics camp as distinct from the AI safety camp, which is more the like Eliezer Yudkowsky. A lot of us are based in the Bay Area. We're worried about existential risk, that kind of thing.
37:28 Speaker 04 AI safety and AI ethics?
37:32 Speaker 25 I don't know who came up with these terms, you know? It's just like Twitter vibes.
37:40 Speaker 04 To me, these two groups of people seemed to have a lot in common. It seemed like the apocalypse people hadn't yet fleshed out how exactly AI could cause catastrophe. And people like Margaret Mitchell, the AI ethics people, were just providing the plot points that lead us to apocalypse.
38:00 Speaker 02 I could lay out how it would happen. Part of what got me into AI ethics was seeing that a system would think that massive explosions was beautiful, right? That's like an existential threat. You have to actually work through how you get to the sort of horrible existential situations in order to figure out how you avoid them.
38:21 Speaker 04 It seemed logical that AI ethicists like Margaret Mitchell and the AI safety people would be natural allies to avoid catastrophic scenarios.
38:32 Speaker 02 And how you avoid them is like listening to what the ethics people are saying. They're doing the right thing. We, I, you know, I'm trying to do the right thing, anyway.
38:41 Speaker 04 But it quickly became clear, they are not allies.
38:45 Speaker 25 Yeah, there is beef between the AI ethics camp and the AI safety camp.
38:49 Speaker 04 My journey down the AI rabbit hole was full of the noise of infighting. The noise crescendoed when Elon Musk called for a pause in building large AI systems. It seems like warriors of all stripes could get behind a pause in building AI. But no, AI safety people and AI ethics people were all against it. It was like a big Martin Luther 95 theses moment, if you will. Everyone felt the need to pen their own letter.
39:23 Speaker 19 Musk and others are asking developers to stop the training of AI systems so that safety protocols can be established.
39:30 Speaker 04 In his letter, Elon Musk's stated reason for wanting a pause was that AI systems were getting too good. He had left the ChatGPT company he helped create and decided to sue them, publicly saying that they had breached the founding agreement of safety.
39:49 Speaker 25 The concern they have is that as you, well, it's the concern, but it's also the exciting thing. The view is that, you know, as these large language models grow and become more sophisticated and complex, you start to see emergent properties. So yeah, at first, it's just gobbling up a bunch of text off the internet and predicting the next token and just like statistically trying to guess what comes next. And it doesn't really understand what's going on. But give it enough time and give it enough data and you start to see it doing things that like make it seem like there's some higher level understanding going on. Like maybe there's some reasoning going on.
40:30 Speaker 04 Like when ChatGPT seems like it's reasoning through an essay prompt. Or when people talk to a robo-therapist AI system and feel like it's really understanding their problems.
40:42 Speaker 28 The rate of change of technology is incredibly fast.
40:47 Speaker 28 It is outpacing our ability to understand it.
40:50 Speaker 04 Elon Musk's stated fear of AI seems to be rooted in rationalist fears, based on the premise that these machines are beginning to understand us. And they're getting smarter than us. We are losing the ability to understand them.
41:07 Speaker 28 What do you do with a situation like that? I'm not sure, you know? Hope, I hope they're nice.
41:17 Speaker 04 Rationalist founder Eliezer Yudkowsky shares this fear. But he wants to do more than just pause and hope they're nice. He penned his own letter, an op-ed in Time Magazine responding to Elon Musk's call for a pause, saying it didn't go far enough. Eliezer didn't just want to pause. He wanted to stop all large AI experiments indefinitely, even, in his own words, by airstrike on rogue AI labs. To him, the pause letter vastly understated the dangerous catastrophic power of AI.
41:59 Speaker 04 And then there's the AI ethicists. They also penned their own letter in response to the pause letter. But the ethicists wrote it for a different reason. It wasn't because they thought Elon Musk was understating the power of AI systems. They thought he was vastly overstating it.
42:20 Speaker 29 Welcome, everyone, to Mystery AI Hype Theater 3000, where we seek catharsis in this age of AI hype.
42:26 Speaker 30 I'm Emily M. Bender, professor of linguistics at the University of Washington.
42:30 Speaker 04 One of the people who responded to the pause was AI ethicist Dr. Emily Bender. She co-hosts a podcast called Mystery AI Hype Theater 3000, which, as you might imagine, is about the overstated, hyped-up risk of AI systems.
42:47 Speaker 30 And each time we think we've reached peak AI hype, the summit of bullshit mountain, we discover there's worse to come.
42:53 Speaker 04 The summit of bullshit mountain, she keeps cresting. For her, it's the mountain of many, many claims that artificial intelligence systems are so smart, they can understand us, like the way humans understand. And maybe even more than that, like a god can understand.
43:12 Speaker 30 I found myself in interminable arguments with people online about how, no, it doesn't understand.
43:20 Speaker 04 So Emily Bender and a colleague decided to come up with something to try and help people sort this out, something that AI safety folks and AI ethics folks both seem to be fond of. And that is a parable or a thought experiment.
43:41 Speaker 04 In Dr. Bender's thought experiment, the AI is not a paperclip maximizer. The AI is an octopus.
43:52 Speaker 04 Go with her on this.
43:53 Speaker 30 So the octopus thought experiment goes like this. You have two speakers of English. They are stranded on two separate nearby desert islands that happen to be connected by a telegraph cable.
44:06 Speaker 04 Two people stranded on separate desert islands communicate with each other through the telegraph cable in Morse code with dots and dashes. Then, suddenly, a super intelligent octopus shows up.
44:20 Speaker 30 The octopus wraps its tentacle around that cable and it feels the dots and dashes going by.
44:26 Speaker 04 It observes the dots and dashes for a while. You might say it trained itself on the dots and dashes.
44:33 Speaker 30 We posit this octopus to be mischievous as well.
44:37 Speaker 04 I'm on the edge of my seat.
44:40 Speaker 30 So one day it cuts the cable. Maybe it uses a broken shell and devises a way to send dots and dashes of its own. So it receives the dots and dashes from one of the English speakers and it sends dots and dashes back. But of course, it has no idea what the English words are that those dots and dashes correspond to, much less what those English words mean.
45:06 Speaker 30 So this works for a while. The English speaker says-
45:08 Speaker 04 At one point, one human says to the other via Morse code,
45:12 Speaker 30 "What a lovely sunset." And the octopus, hyper intelligent, right, has kept track of all of the patterns so far. It sends back the dots and dashes that correspond to something like, "Yes, reminds me of lava lamps." Hmm.
45:29 Speaker 04 The deep sea octopus does not know what a lava lamp is.
45:32 Speaker 30 But that's the kind of thing that the other English speaker might have sent back.
45:36 Speaker 04 Not really sure why these castaways are waxing poetic about lava lamps in particular. But anyway, for our purposes, the octopus is like an AI. Even if it's super intelligent, whatever that means, it doesn't understand. Dr. Bender's trying to say to ChatGPT, "Human words are just dots and dashes."
46:01 Speaker 30 And then finally, we end the story, because it's a thought experiment. I mean, we can do things like this, with a bear showing up on the island. And the English speaker says, "Help, I'm being chased by a bear. All I have is this stick. What should I do?" And that's the point where if the speaker survives, they're surely going to know they're not actually talking to their friend from the other island. And we actually put that line in GPT-2, "Help, I'm being chased by a bear." And we got out things like, "You're not going to get away with this."
46:39 Speaker 04 Super helpful.
46:43 Speaker 04 Wow.
46:46 Speaker 04 I gotta say, I'm into this one. The idea that AI systems only see human words as dots and dashes, I find that deeply comforting. Because I don't know about you all, but for me, one of the scary things about AI is the idea that it could get better than me at my job. A fear that's very present when OpenAI is actively training its models on my work. Their system might understand my work, understand the things that make it good when it's good. It might get good at doing what I do. And poof, I'm obsolete.
47:26 Speaker 04 There's also a recurring dream I have that various villains, including the Chinese government for some reason, clone my voice to deceive my loved ones. Anyway, if it's all just dots and dashes that these things understand, it seems clear we shouldn't be trusting these AI systems to be journalists, or lawyers, or doctors. It relates to what Dr. Margaret Mitchell and Dr. Joy Bulimweeny found in their research. AI systems are only as good as the data they're trained on. They can't understand or truly create something new like humans can.
48:02 Speaker 02 It's easy to sort of anthropomorphize these systems, but it's useful to recognize that these are probabilistic systems that repeat back what they have been exposed to. And then they parrot them back out again.
48:16 Speaker 04 Another way to put it is AI systems are like parrots.
48:21 Speaker 02 Parrot's parrot, right? Famously, parrots are known for parroting.
48:26 Speaker 04 If you hear your pet parrot say a curse word, you only have yourself to blame. Dr. Mitchell joined Dr. Bender in the response to Elon Musk's pause, along with Dr. Timnit Gabriel. They had all written the paper together that ended up getting Dr. Mitchell fired from Google. These ethicists wrote that they agreed with some of the recommendations Elon Musk and his pause posse had made, like that we should watermark AI-generated media to be able to distinguish synthetic from human-generated stuff, which sounds like a great idea to me. But they wrote the agreements they have are overshadowed by their distaste for fear-mongering and AI hype.
49:11 Speaker 04 They wrote that the pause and fears of a super-intelligent AI...
49:15 Speaker 28 What do you do with a situation like that? I'm not sure. You know? I hope they're nice.
49:21 Speaker 04 To these AI ethics folks, it all reeked of AI hype.
49:25 Speaker 30 It makes no sense at all, and on top of that, it's an enormous distraction from the actual harms that are already being done in the name of AI.
49:33 Speaker 04 This is the main beef that AI ethics people have with AI safety people. They say the fear of an AI apocalypse is a distraction from current-day harms.
49:44 Speaker 31 Like, you know, "Look over there, Terminator." "Don't look over here, racism."
49:50 Speaker 10 You know, there are different groups of concerns. You have the concern...
49:53 Speaker 04 At the AI Ethics Conference that producer Gabrielle Burbay attended, she mentioned the concern of an AI apocalypse.
50:00 Speaker 10 And then you have these concerns about more existential risks. And I'm curious what you make of that. You're going, "No." Can I ask why you're going, "No"? No. She's shaking her head.
50:17 Speaker 04 And it felt almost taboo.
50:19 Speaker 10 A lot of hand-wringing around that question.
50:23 Speaker 04 Eventually, one of the women spoke up.
50:28 Speaker 10 Share your perspectives.
50:31 Speaker 04 She talked about how she thinks the demographics of the groups play a role in the way they worry about different things.
50:36 Speaker 32 Most of them are like whites, males.
50:38 Speaker 04 AI safety folks are largely pale and male, to borrow Dr. Joy's line.
50:44 Speaker 32 They may not really understand discrimination that other people kind of go through in their day to day lives. And I think the social isolation from those problems makes it a bit harder to empathize with the actual challenges that people actually face every day.
51:00 Speaker 04 Her point was it's easy for AI safety people to be distracted from the harms happening now because it's a blind spot for them. At the same time, AI safety people told me that AI ethics people have a blind spot. They're not worrying enough about apocalypse. But why would it be taboo to say all of this on mic? Part of the reason might be because the fear of apocalypse has come to overpower any other concern in the larger industry.
51:33 Speaker 31 One thing that I think is interesting is that a lot of the narrative that we hear about how AI is going to save the world and it's going to solve all these problems and it's amazing and it's going to change everything. And then we get the narratives about, oh, my gosh, it could destroy humanity in 10 years. Often coming from the same people. I think part of the reason for that is that either way, it makes AI seem more powerful than it certainly is right now. And who knows when we're going to get to the humanity destroying stuff. But in the meantime, if it's that powerful, it's probably going to make a whole lot of money.
52:18 Speaker 04 Building a super intelligent AI has become a multi-billion dollar business. And the people running it are not ethicists. Just weeks before Elon Musk called for the pause, he had started a new AI company.
52:35 Speaker 04 Yeah, I guess it's kind of counterintuitive, right? To see this, and you're like, wait, why would the people working on the technology who stand to profit from it want to pause?
52:46 Speaker 30 Right. I can't speak for them, but it benefits them to, on the one hand, get everybody else to slow down while they're doing whatever they're doing.
52:55 Speaker 04 Octopus thought experiment author Dr. Emily Bender again.
52:59 Speaker 30 But also, it benefits them to market the technology as super powerful in that way, and it definitely benefits them to distract the policymakers from the harms that they are doing.
53:12 Speaker 04 It'd be nice to think that billionaire Elon Musk was calling for an industry-wide pause in building large AI systems for all the right reasons. A pause that never came to be, by the way. It's worth pointing out that when the billionaire took over Twitter and turned it into X, one of the first things he did was fire the ethics team. And even though Elon Musk says he left and sued the chat GPT company OpenAI over safety concerns, company emails have surfaced that reveal the more likely reason he left is that he fought with folks internally to try and make the company for profit, to better compete with Google.
53:55 Speaker 04 Ethicists are concerned they're outnumbered by the apocalypse people, and they think a lot of those people are in it to maximize profit, not maximize safety.
54:14 Speaker 04 So how did we get here? Why? Why is the industry not focusing on AI harms today and focusing instead on the risk of AI apocalypse?
54:28 Speaker 30 There's an enormous amount of money that's been collected to fund this weird AI research.
54:34 Speaker 04 Why do you think the resources are going to those long-term, like, hyperintelligent AI concerns?
54:41 Speaker 03 Because you have very powerful people who are posing it, people who control powerful companies and people with very deep pockets, and so money continues to talk.
54:53 Speaker 02 It seems to be like funding for sort of like fanciful ideas, right? It's like almost, it's almost like a religion or something where it requires faith that good things will come without those good things being clearly specified.
55:11 Speaker 10 People wanting to be told what to do by some abstract force that they can't interact with particularly well is not new. ChatGPT gives you authoritative answers. Erosions of autonomy. Like a god, kind of? Yeah, like a god.
55:24 Speaker 25 It's like, really interesting to take these philosophies apart. I would argue they trace back to a large degree to religious thinking, but that might be another story for another day.
55:42 Speaker 04 Next time on Good Robot.
56:07 Speaker 33 Good Robot was hosted by Julia Longoria and produced by Gabrielle Burbe. Sound design, mixing, and original score by David Herman. Our fact checker is Caitlin Penzimook. The show was edited by Catherine Wells and me, Diane Hudson. If you want to dig deeper into what you've heard, you can check out Dr. Joy Buluni's book, Unmasking AI, or head to vox.com/goodrobot to read more future perfect stories about the future of AI. Thanks for listening.
56:54 Speaker 01 Support for the show comes from Engine. Running a small business means every dollar has to work hard. But if your team is still booking travel the old way, it's costing you more than you think. Engine is the fastest-growing travel and spend platform in the country, built specifically for businesses like yours. Book a trip in as little as two and a half minutes. Earn up to 10% back on hotels. And in 2025, Engine customers save more than $300 million on travel with zero booking fees, no contracts, and no BS. More than 1,000 businesses join Engine every month. Join them and get $500 when your business signs up and starts traveling at engine.com/box.
57:38 Speaker 22 When everything feels nonstop, movement becomes the pause. So give Lululemon this holiday season. Smooth, seamless running gear builds momentum through every mile.
57:50 Speaker 22 Targeted support adds steadiness to every pulse and hold.
57:56 Speaker 22 And dynamic stretch expands presence through every pose.
58:02 Speaker 22 Give the feeling. Shop in-store and on lululemon.com.
Previous Good Robot #1: The magic intelligence in the sky Next Good Robot #3: Let’s fix everything Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated