Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode of True Crime All The Time examines the September 2022 murder of 44-year-old Stephanie Pavlons in Waukesha County, Wisconsin, and the subsequent conviction of her long-term boyfriend, Matthew Pahl. Hosts Mike Ferguson and Mike Gibson break down the twenty-year on-and-off relationship, the extensive documentation of domestic abuse that Stephanie kept in her journals and photos, and the circumstantial evidence that led a jury to convict Pahl of first-degree intentional homicide in just under an hour. Despite an undetermined medical cause of death due to decomposition and a defense arguing suicide or natural causes, prosecutors built a compelling timeline linking Pahl's medical appointment to the location where Stephanie's remains were found.
- Extensive documentation, including journals, daily planners, and photographs of injuries, can provide crucial insight into a victim's ongoing experience of domestic abuse. 22:26
- Circumstantial evidence combined with digital footprints, cell phone pings, and suspicious search histories can successfully prove guilt even when a medical examiner cannot determine an exact cause of death. 13:33
- Controlling behavior in a relationship often escalates into deadly violence when the abuser perceives a loss of control or realizes the victim is attempting to leave. 24:28
Chapters
- 0:00Podcast Intro and Sponsor Ads
Hosts introduce the episode and play brief sponsor advertisements before diving into the case.
- 2:26Episode Overview and Host Catch‑Up
Mike Ferguson and Mike Gibson greet listeners, discuss their upcoming cleanse, and set the stage for the true‑crime story.
- 5:44Case Introduction: Stephanie Pavlons
The hosts introduce the murder case of Stephanie Pavlons, outlining the discovery of her remains and the key facts of the investigation.
- 8:41Discovery of the Body and Initial Evidence
The episode explains how the remains were found, the role of tattoos in identification, and early forensic challenges.
- 12:02Suspect’s Early Defense Claims
Matthew Pahl’s statements about Stephanie’s mental health, a purported suicide note, and his lack of evidence for arrest are discussed.
- 15:15Forensic and Digital Evidence Analysis
The hosts review surveillance footage, phone pings, and digital searches that link the suspect to the crime scene.
- 21:04Prosecution’s Narrative of Domestic Violence
Prosecutors argue that ongoing abuse led to a fatal strangulation, citing journals, photos, and the purse‑strap theory.
- 26:40Defense Strategy and Reasonable Doubt
Defense attorneys highlight the undetermined cause of death, potential suicide, and lack of DNA evidence to create doubt.
- 35:11Expert Testimonies and Contested Evidence
Key experts testify on medical, forensic, and canine evidence, with both sides challenging each other’s findings.
- 58:20Trial Proceedings and Jury Verdict
The episode covers the trial timeline, jury deliberation, and the swift conviction of Matthew Pahl for first‑degree homicide.
- 1:01:17Episode Introduction and Context
Hosts set the stage for the discussion on Stephanie Pavlons’ case.
- 1:01:59Hosts Reflect on Control Dynamics
Hosts discuss how controlling relationships deteriorate over time.
Highlights
- 5:44
Construction workers posting signs in Waukesha County discovered mummified human remains in a wooded area near a doctor's office.
- 7:43
Documented Physical Abuseinsight
Stephanie Pavlons kept detailed journals and photographs documenting years of physical abuse and feeling hopeless in her relationship with Matthew Pahl.
- 11:57
Suspicious Boyfriend's Claimsstory
When questioned by police, Matthew Pahl claimed he had not seen Stephanie for weeks and alleged she was struggling with severe depression.
- 15:53
Overlapping Cell Phone Pingsdata
Surveillance and cell phone records placed both Stephanie and Matthew near the orthopedic doctor's office on the morning she disappeared.
- 19:47
Pre-Discovery Searchesinsight
Web history showed Matthew searching for obituaries and articles about a dead body found by construction crews days before her body was identified.
- 36:46
A K-9 officer testified that his dog alerted to the back of Matthew's Toyota Tacoma truck, indicating the scent of human remains.
- 58:28
Swift Guilty Verdictstory
After a trial featuring extensive circumstantial and digital evidence, the jury took less than an hour to convict Matthew Pahl of first-degree intentional homicide.
Quotes
“Stephanie's mother told WISN that the medical examiner called her with autopsy results two weeks before the charges were filed.”
Unnamed speaker · 14:22 “The prosecution acknowledged that their case was mostly built on circumstantial evidence and that Stephanie’s cause of death was still unknown.”
Unnamed speaker · 21:04 “him to kill Stephanie. Ramirez said, "He killed her and left her to rot in the woods,"”
Unnamed speaker · 1:01:43 “they never end up well. I truly believe that in this case, Matthew was a narcissist and”
Unnamed speaker · 1:02:22 “And he could not allow that to happen. That's what I truly believe.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:02:47 “I had a feeling, Gibbs, that, that I was loved in many parts of Canada.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:04:08
Sponsored segments
- Aura Frames 0:00–1:22
- Trivapro 1:22–1:50
- Quince 16:28–17:37
- Vinted 17:50–18:54
- Shopify 34:42–35:09
About this episode
In August 2022, 44-year-old Stephanie Pavlons vanished from Waukesha County, Wisconsin. Weeks later, construction workers discovered her remains in a wooded area near a medical office. Stephanie had been in a troubled, on-again, off-again relationship with her longtime boyfriend, Matthew Pahl, and her journals revealed a disturbing history of abuse and fear. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the murder of Stephanie Pavlons. As investigators pieced together Stephanie's final movements, surveillance footage, cellphone records, and suspicious internet searches raised troubling questions. But with no definitive cause of death, could prosecutors prove what really happened to Stephanie? You can help support the show at patreon.com/truecrimeallthetime Visit the show's website at truecrimeallthetime.com for contact, merchandise, and donation information An Emash Digital production See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript
9,624 words · 5 speakers
Topics
- Wisconsin
- True Crime All The Time
- Waukesha County
- Canada
- TCAT
- Orthopedic Associates of Wisconsin
- QuickTrip
- Winnipeg
- Manitoba
- Nova Scotia
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated