Pod Insights True Crime All The Time Joel Guy Jr. About this episode Joel Guy Jr murdered his parents just after Thanksgiving in 2016. The crime scene that was discovered was horrific, and like many killers, this guy was sloppy and left behind a wealth of evidence.
Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss Joel Guy Jr. He was 28-years-old when he murdered his parents. He had never worked a day in his life, and his parents had financed almost 10 years' worth of his college education. But, they had decided enough was enough, and Joel Jr. just couldn't live without the money.
You can help support the show at patreon.com/truecrimeallthetime
Visit the show's website at truecrimeallthetime.com for contact, merchandise, and donation information
An Emash Digital production
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript 10,506 words · 2 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Every good true crime story has a twist. DraftKings Casino has a spin. Flex spins let you spin your way. Didn't see that coming. That's because flex spins are exclusive to DraftKings. New casino players pay $5 and get 1,000 total flex spins, including 100 lightning link spins. Unlock 50 spins a day at varying values for the first 20 days. You decide where the story goes next. Download the DraftKings Casino app. Sign up with code TCAD and spin your way. The crown is yours. In partnership with DraftKings Casino. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER in Connecticut. Help is available for problem gambling.
0:40 Speaker 00 Call 888-789-7777 or visit ccpg.org. Please play responsibly. 21+. Physically present in Connecticut, Michigan, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and West Virginia only. Void in Canada. Eligibility restrictions apply. Non-withdrawable spins issued at 50 spins per day for 20 days. Valid for select games only and expire each day after 24 hours. Spins values vary. See terms at casino.draftkings.com/promos. Ends November 22, 2026 at 11:59 PM Eastern Time.
1:20 Speaker 00 Hey everyone, it's Fergie here. I'm on vacation. Gibby's on vacation. He's in Greece, probably eating a bunch of good food. I'm heading to Jamaica for my daughter's wedding. So I'm probably there right now, but we didn't want to leave everybody hanging. So we wanted to put out a true crime all the time, an unsolved episode. This true crime all the time is a Patreon episode. I think we did all the way back in 2020, but at least you have something to listen to. And for 99% of you, you've never heard it. Speaking of that, if you're not signed up for Patreon, now is a great time. Enjoy the episode.
2:40 Speaker 00 Hello everyone and welcome to our 51st Patreon episode. I'm Mike Ferguson and with me as always is my partner in true crime, Mike Gibson. Gibby, how are you?
2:50 Speaker 01 Hey man, I'm doing okay. How about you?
2:52 Speaker 00 I'm doing well. You know, it seems strange to announce who we are to our Patreon folks.
2:56 Speaker 01 That's right. We just should say what, uh, this is me and that's him.
3:00 Speaker 00 And you know who we are, but
3:02 Speaker 01 Exactly right.
3:03 Speaker 00 You know, I'm like, I have a routine.
3:05 Speaker 01 I know.
3:06 Speaker 00 If I don't do the routine, I get off track.
3:09 Speaker 01 That's why you won't let me do it in reverse. Cause you know, it's gonna throw you off.
3:13 Speaker 00 Yes. You've been asking to do that for some reason. I have no idea why, but you told me you can speak backwards, which I thought was strange. Sound like a record.
3:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, kinda like my, for my dyslexia or my
3:29 Speaker 00 Dyslexia.
3:29 Speaker 01 Dyslexia.
3:31 Speaker 00 I should say, oh, okay. All right. Here we go. Right out of the gate. So you and I are taping, uh, the Wednesday before Thanksgiving.
3:42 Speaker 01 We are.
3:43 Speaker 00 Obviously this episode will come out Saturday night. Um, so we can't, I can't ask you how your Thanksgiving was because I don't know. But I will say I'm excited. My daughter's home from college and so, um, and it's just the four of us. We have a lot of family that's out traveling.
4:00 Speaker 01 Gonna make it nice.
4:00 Speaker 00 It is. It's, it's gonna be really nice. Just the four of us. Uh, we don't get a lot of that. So whenever we do, I'm, I'm very happy.
4:09 Speaker 01 Little, little movie trivia night or game or something.
4:12 Speaker 00 Something. We don't know.
4:13 Speaker 01 Yeah.
4:13 Speaker 00 We don't know. Maybe some hunter killer.
4:16 Speaker 01 Ah.
4:16 Speaker 00 Cause I got, I got one of those upstairs, but I do want to wish everybody a, a happy Thanksgiving. Those of you who celebrate it.
4:23 Speaker 01 Yeah.
4:24 Speaker 00 Let's go ahead and give our Patreon shout outs. We had Nicole Munoz.
4:28 Speaker 01 Munoz.
4:29 Speaker 00 Morbid God.
4:30 Speaker 01 What's going on, Morbid?
4:31 Speaker 00 Ayla.
4:32 Speaker 01 Hey, Ayla.
4:33 Speaker 00 Karen Nix.
4:33 Speaker 01 Well, thank you, Karen.
4:34 Speaker 00 Molly Powell.
4:36 Speaker 01 Well, thank you, Molly.
4:37 Speaker 00 Tabitha Churchward.
4:39 Speaker 01 What's going on, Tabitha?
4:40 Speaker 00 Natalie Pastura.
4:42 Speaker 01 Oh, Pastura.
4:43 Speaker 00 Ryan Hope.
4:44 Speaker 01 What's going on, Hope?
4:45 Speaker 00 Lisa Marie Hawkins.
4:47 Speaker 01 Hey, Lisa Marie.
4:48 Speaker 00 Georgia Penny.
4:49 Speaker 01 Hey, appreciate that, Penny.
4:50 Speaker 00 Michelle Bennett.
4:51 Speaker 01 Well, Bennett.
4:52 Speaker 00 Randy Zair.
4:55 Speaker 01 Almost like saying Randy Sayers, but Zair, yeah.
4:58 Speaker 00 Who's Randy Sayers?
4:59 Speaker 01 Isn't that the famous football player? Am I way off?
5:01 Speaker 00 It's Gale Sayers.
5:02 Speaker 01 Close. It's his, it's his, it's his third cousin from his mom's side.
5:07 Speaker 00 Randy, Gale.
5:09 Speaker 01 Yeah.
5:09 Speaker 00 What, what's the difference? Adam Reeves.
5:11 Speaker 01 What's going on, Reeves?
5:13 Speaker 00 Nicola Furlong.
5:14 Speaker 01 Hey, Nicola.
5:15 Speaker 00 Melanie Hotten.
5:16 Speaker 01 Hey, Melanie.
5:17 Speaker 00 Martins Julie.
5:19 Speaker 01 Well, thank you. Appreciate that, Martins.
5:21 Speaker 00 I always think like sometimes the names are backwards and it could just be how somebody entered them in.
5:29 Speaker 01 Could be.
5:29 Speaker 00 To the Patreon system, but I don't know. May not be.
5:33 Speaker 01 May just be their first name.
5:34 Speaker 00 Could be. Kelly Geis.
5:36 Speaker 01 What's going on, Kelly?
5:37 Speaker 00 And last but not least, Kimberly DeBean. That's it.
5:41 Speaker 01 The Bean?
5:42 Speaker 00 Yeah, I thought there was something to come after that, but that's it.
5:44 Speaker 01 The Bean.
5:45 Speaker 00 The Bean. Then if we go back into the vault. This week, we selected Kate Fleming.
5:50 Speaker 01 Thank you, Kate.
5:51 Speaker 00 Yeah, we appreciate all the support. We always do. It's amazing. All right, Gibbs, are you ready to get into this Patreon episode?
5:58 Speaker 01 I'm ready.
5:59 Speaker 00 We're headed to Tennessee to talk about Joel Guy Jr.
6:05 Speaker 01 Yeah.
6:05 Speaker 00 This is a guy who murdered and dismembered his parents at Thanksgiving time in 2016. So, like I said, this episode comes out a couple of days after Thanksgiving. So I feel okay with telling the story. I wouldn't want people listening to it, you know, right before Thanksgiving.
6:23 Speaker 01 Yeah.
6:24 Speaker 00 You know, hopefully by the time you're hearing this. All the turkeys kind of cleaned up. Your family is gone.
6:31 Speaker 01 Yeah.
6:31 Speaker 00 They've left and, and you can just listen to the story.
6:36 Speaker 01 You're just laying on the couch relaxing.
6:37 Speaker 00 Yeah. Now I will say it's a pretty brutal one. There's no doubt about that. Joel Guy Jr. Was born on March 13th, 1988 to Joel Senior and Lisa Guy. He had three sisters. I didn't find a whole lot about his childhood. This isn't really a childhood type story.
6:55 Speaker 01 Right.
6:56 Speaker 00 But some of the sources said that, you know, he had sisters, some called them half sisters. It was kind of hard to tell. He graduated high school, went on to college. But unlike you Gibbs, you know, he wasn't earning his degrees at in record time.
7:12 Speaker 01 It's hard to do that, you know?
7:14 Speaker 00 Well, not everybody can be like you.
7:16 Speaker 01 Absolutely not.
7:17 Speaker 00 Let's, let's just get that out there right now. I was not like you. I was no Doogie Howser. I will admit that.
7:23 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:24 Speaker 00 So this guy attended a few different colleges and you know, he spent like nine or 10 years in college without really accomplishing what he wanted to do. That's a long time.
7:38 Speaker 01 It is, but there's other people that go through that.
7:41 Speaker 00 Yeah, I was gonna say it, it happens to people.
7:44 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:44 Speaker 00 Especially, um, if you don't know what you want to do.
7:49 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly.
7:50 Speaker 00 Right? Going into college, number one, college can be tough for many, many people.
7:54 Speaker 01 It can be.
7:55 Speaker 00 And sometimes it's really hard to figure out, okay, what do I want to do? And you might try this and you go down a path of maybe a whole year and decide, I don't like this at all.
8:06 Speaker 01 Right.
8:07 Speaker 00 So you switch and, and I get four, five, six years. Now nine or 10, you know, you should be a plastic surgeon, doctor. At one point I think he was trying to be a plastic surgeon.
8:18 Speaker 01 There's some people just like to be a full-time, all the time student, you know?
8:22 Speaker 00 And I, I think, okay, that may have been him.
8:26 Speaker 01 Yeah.
8:27 Speaker 00 Bounced around a little, but it's one of the things that caused tension in, in the household because Joel Senior and Lisa, his mom and dad, they paid for his tuition, you know, the entire time.
8:42 Speaker 01 Oh, well, that's, that could be a problem. I mean, look, I. I still don't know what I want to do when I grow up.
8:48 Speaker 00 Yeah, you'll figure it out.
8:49 Speaker 01 Yeah.
8:49 Speaker 00 Someday.
8:50 Speaker 01 Yeah.
8:50 Speaker 00 Someday. I think you should be a spokesman, maybe for AARP. That would be a good goal.
8:55 Speaker 01 It could be.
8:57 Speaker 00 You could be one right now.
9:00 Speaker 00 You don't need to wait.
9:01 Speaker 01 That's true. I've already hit that. I already.
9:04 Speaker 00 I know.
9:04 Speaker 01 Went over that threshold.
9:05 Speaker 00 But you know, as a guy who has one daughter getting ready to graduate.
9:11 Speaker 01 Yeah.
9:11 Speaker 00 From college and another one who's going next year. Okay, I can understand kind of the financial implications of college. I understand the equation.
9:24 Speaker 01 Yeah.
9:24 Speaker 00 You know, it's, it's tough. You want to help your kids out, but dad gone, man. You look at the bills of some of these colleges and you're like, who am I Rockefeller?
9:36 Speaker 01 They think you are.
9:37 Speaker 00 They think I am.
9:38 Speaker 01 Yeah.
9:39 Speaker 00 But you do what you can, right? I think that's what every parent strives to do. Okay, you can't pay for everything. Not everybody can. I get that. We try to help out as much as we can. Now, they were paying for the whole thing is, is what I understood, everything I read for nine or 10 years. And there'll be more that comes out about.
10:01 Speaker 01 They're probably like.
10:01 Speaker 00 The financial piece.
10:02 Speaker 01 Maybe this is the year. Maybe this is the year that he's gonna.
10:06 Speaker 00 I'm sure every year they were thinking that. It, it came out later at trial that, uh, Joel Guy Jr. had gotten into some legal trouble. While he was at LSU, that's one of the colleges he went to. And his parents even took out a mortgage to help him out of this legal trouble. So, I mean, they were behind him 100%. They were, you know, trying to help him succeed, no doubt. But as Thanksgiving 2016 approached, you know, there was a lot going on in the Guy family. Joel Senior was six year, one years old and had recently lost his job at an engineering firm. I think he had a really good job. I think he was making, you know, some good bank.
10:49 Speaker 01 We had to if he was, uh, put that university bills.
10:52 Speaker 00 Yeah. And because he wasn't the only child, there were other. You know, kids involved, you know, in the mix too. Fifty five year old Lisa worked at another engineering firm. She wasn't an engineer. I don't know the exact title of her job. My understanding was that she stayed home with the kids and then once they got to be a certain age, you know, she went out and she got a job, but she was helping support the family as well. I just know that there was a lot in the research about the fact that she didn't make as much as he did.
11:27 Speaker 01 Right.
11:27 Speaker 00 She wasn't a full blown engineer and I think he was so. But the pair had been married for like 31 years. They had six grandchildren.
11:37 Speaker 01 Wow, big family.
11:38 Speaker 00 Well, those are expensive too. Kids are expensive. Grand, I don't have grandchildren yet. Find me some wood, please, but I know they're expensive as well, can be. So what happened was the couple made the decision to sell their family home in West Knox County and try to retire to a home in, I think it was Rogersville, Tennessee.
12:02 Speaker 01 Okay.
12:03 Speaker 00 And this was a home, I think, that was in the family.
12:05 Speaker 01 Oh.
12:06 Speaker 00 Maybe had been left
12:07 Speaker 01 Nice.
12:08 Speaker 00 to them or something.
12:10 Speaker 01 Limited mortgage, probably.
12:11 Speaker 00 Probably maybe no mortgage.
12:13 Speaker 01 Yeah, that helps out when you lose your job that you don't have to worry about a mortgage.
12:16 Speaker 00 Well, especially if you're trying to retire.
12:17 Speaker 01 Yeah.
12:18 Speaker 00 Kind of hard to retire when you got a big ass mortgage payment.
12:21 Speaker 01 Exactly.
12:22 Speaker 00 That's for sure.
12:25 Speaker 00 So, you know, this family had been in the home for years. So I think Gibbs, from what I read, everything I read and what friends and family said, obviously later on, was that the couple was really looking forward to this 2016 Thanksgiving. I mean, I always look forward to Thanksgiving, but this one, I think they were looking at it as kind of a really big deal.
12:52 Speaker 01 The last one in the family house with everybody together.
12:55 Speaker 00 Maybe the last time we're all gonna be together. I don't know, but for sure, the last time we're all gonna be together in this house.
13:02 Speaker 01 Yeah.
13:02 Speaker 00 And that would be a big deal.
13:04 Speaker 01 It would be. It's a lot of memories right there.
13:05 Speaker 00 Yeah, you think about the, the house that you raised, you know, all your, your kids in and.
13:11 Speaker 01 Yeah.
13:12 Speaker 00 Man, yeah, I think about at some point selling this home and it's gonna be tough. I've lived here 20 years.
13:20 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
13:21 Speaker 00 So essentially both of my kids, it's the only house they really ha- have ever, um, known.
13:28 Speaker 01 And I know it's rougher when you think about the six years I've been coming here.
13:30 Speaker 00 It is. All those memories.
13:32 Speaker 01 Really what holds you back.
13:34 Speaker 00 Uh, I would be a trillionaire if I had all the money back that I've spent on your dinners for the last six years.
13:41 Speaker 01 I, I would pay. I would. I would.
13:43 Speaker 00 You say that after the meal has already been consumed.
13:46 Speaker 01 Yeah. I don't, I just don't, I really honestly, I don't know where my wallet is. I, I had it.
13:51 Speaker 00 It's never here. It's never with you.
13:53 Speaker 01 Yeah, I might've left it on my, uh, kitchen counter.
13:55 Speaker 00 I think is, is the thing.
13:57 Speaker 01 Yeah.
13:57 Speaker 00 So the other thing is the house was already up for sale and I think it was already sold, actually.
14:02 Speaker 01 Just needed to close.
14:03 Speaker 00 Yeah, I hadn't, I don't think it had closed yet. So like we said, last Thanksgiving, you know, in this house, the kids were already out of the house. They were living on their own. So Joel Guy Jr. was 28 years old at this point, unemployed and living in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, where he had attended Louisiana State University.
14:27 Speaker 01 Yeah.
14:29 Speaker 00 The sources were kinda all over the map. You know, some said that he dropped out in 2015. Later on, sources said that he was a student at LSU. Some referred to him as a non-matriculating student.
14:47 Speaker 01 Matriculating.
14:48 Speaker 00 And, and I, I don't know, was he enrolled, but he wasn't take, I don't know. Who knows?
14:53 Speaker 01 Yeah.
14:54 Speaker 00 He wasn't getting all that far is what it sounds like.
14:58 Speaker 01 Maybe he's, maybe he's enjoyed the campus life.
15:01 Speaker 00 Well, who do, who wouldn't?
15:03 Speaker 01 You know, the campus life.
15:04 Speaker 00 If mom and dad are footing the bill and you don't have any financial responsibility.
15:11 Speaker 01 Yeah.
15:11 Speaker 00 Really to, to speak of, who wouldn't wanna stay in college, man? College is awesome.
15:16 Speaker 01 Yeah. I think there's been a few movies made about, uh. About that.
15:20 Speaker 00 About college?
15:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, about be being in college for longer than the normal.
15:24 Speaker 00 Yeah, okay.
15:25 Speaker 01 Three to five years.
15:26 Speaker 00 Yeah, maybe, uh, I mean, I'm thinking Animal House.
15:29 Speaker 01 Oh, for sure.
15:30 Speaker 00 I'm also thinking that what's that one where they they don't actually go back to college per se, but they start the fraternity?
15:37 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah, yeah. What is that?
15:38 Speaker 00 With Will Ferrell and and all those guys?
15:40 Speaker 01 Yeah.
15:41 Speaker 00 Vince Vaughn.
15:42 Speaker 01 Vince Vaughn.
15:43 Speaker 00 It's a good movie.
15:43 Speaker 01 Old school.
15:44 Speaker 00 Old school.
15:45 Speaker 01 Yeah. And Ryan Reynolds is one where he plays a long time.
15:49 Speaker 00 Van Wilder?
15:50 Speaker 01 Van Wilder.
15:51 Speaker 00 Sure.
15:51 Speaker 01 Yeah.
15:52 Speaker 00 So I mentioned this financial situation, right? There are a lot of sources that said Joel senior losing his job and really kind of everything they had going on with that was a determining factor in Joel senior and Lisa coming to the conclusion that they they had to cut Joel junior off.
16:15 Speaker 01 Yeah.
16:15 Speaker 00 At a certain point, if you don't have the money, you can't do it.
16:19 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, you say, look, son, we're coming up on year 10.
16:23 Speaker 00 Yeah.
16:24 Speaker 01 We're gonna have to let you go at this point.
16:26 Speaker 00 Yeah, this it's a very important part of the story. There are, there were some reports that there were emails, maybe shown at trial.
16:36 Speaker 01 Yeah.
16:36 Speaker 00 That went back as far as maybe 2012, 2013, where Joel senior was emailing Joel junior and saying, hey, what's going on? We can't keep this situation going.
16:49 Speaker 01 Right.
16:50 Speaker 00 But for whatever reason, they didn't cut it off. It went, you know, maybe three or three or four years after.
16:57 Speaker 01 Strange what you do for your kids when you know that you probably should stop doing whatever you're doing.
17:01 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
17:02 Speaker 01 But you continue doing it because.
17:04 Speaker 00 They're your kids.
17:05 Speaker 01 Your kids.
17:06 Speaker 00 Yeah, you you want to help your kids. I I get that. So Joel Jr. Drove up from Louisiana for Thanksgiving in his 2006 Hyundai Sonata, the same exact model that that you drove over here today.
17:23 Speaker 01 It's amazing model, man.
17:24 Speaker 00 2006.
17:25 Speaker 01 Yeah.
17:26 Speaker 00 Why, why get something new? Uh, his half sisters, I, I'm gonna call him his sisters because I'm really on the fence with that. It was, it was not apparent in the reporting. They drove in for Thanksgiving as well. This is gonna be the whole family together.
17:43 Speaker 01 They're all there at the La Casa.
17:44 Speaker 00 And from what the sisters would later tell investigators, Thanksgiving went off without a hitch. It went well. A good time was had by all.
17:54 Speaker 01 It wasn't like that, uh, movie with, uh, Holly Hunter and, uh, the guy played, uh,
18:01 Speaker 00 Did you just go?
18:02 Speaker 01 Yeah, he had a little circle on his chest. Robert Downey Jr.
18:05 Speaker 00 I have not seen a movie with Robert Downey Jr. And-
18:08 Speaker 01 Plays that movie Marvel with the whole-
18:09 Speaker 00 Oh, I've seen Iron Man.
18:11 Speaker 01 Iron Man, yeah.
18:12 Speaker 00 I don't, I've never seen a movie with Robert Downey Jr. And Holly Hunter.
18:16 Speaker 01 Oh yeah, it's called, uh, it's a Thanksgiving movie.
18:19 Speaker 00 It's, it's called, it's a Thanksgiving movie. That's what they named it? It's a Thanksgiving movie.
18:25 Speaker 01 Home for the holidays, I think. Maybe I'm wrong.
18:28 Speaker 00 Hmm, that sounds like a Christmas movie.
18:30 Speaker 01 No, it's a Thanksgiving only movie. It's hilarious. It's hilarious, man.
18:33 Speaker 00 I've never seen, I've never even heard of it.
18:36 Speaker 01 Yeah. If you've never seen it, you gotta watch it.
18:38 Speaker 00 I will watch it.
18:39 Speaker 01 Yeah.
18:40 Speaker 00 Um, when I watched the Incredible Mr. Limpet.
18:44 Speaker 01 Oh, this is, this is, I don't know if it's better.
18:48 Speaker 00 Now you're in a, a real conundrum.
18:50 Speaker 01 Tough one. No, you're have to catch it out.
18:52 Speaker 00 It's a real Sophie's Choice you got, you got going on there. So the big thing, right? They have the, the dinner.
18:59 Speaker 01 Yeah.
18:59 Speaker 00 Everything is fine.
19:01 Speaker 01 That's good.
19:01 Speaker 00 Good time had by all.
19:03 Speaker 01 Yeah.
19:04 Speaker 00 And even the sisters would later say, everybody was normal.
19:09 Speaker 01 Everybody, hey, had their stretchy pants on, they were happy.
19:11 Speaker 00 Yep. And, but they all left, right? The sisters, they all left after Thanksgiving. While Joel Jr. Stayed behind for the weekend. The Knoxville News Sentinel reported that according to Knox County Sheriff's Office Major Michael McLean. Sometime between Friday night and midday Saturday. They believe that Joel Jr. Attacked his parents with a knife, possibly tortured them. And dismembered their bodies, leaving remains in various rooms of this 2,300 square foot home. He said that the door was left unlocked and they believed, right at this time,
19:55 Speaker 00 as the reporting was coming out, that it was, it was Joel Jr. And he drove back to Louisiana.
20:02 Speaker 01 Let me think, how could I stay in college a little bit longer? Oh, I don't know. Let me take this knife and murder my parents? That's gonna let me stay in college longer?
20:10 Speaker 00 Yeah, we're gonna have to get into that. And you know, this wasn't really a long drawn out investigation. It didn't take long at all for the authorities to link Joel Guy Jr. To the murders. The Knoxville News Sentinel reported that Knox County Sheriff's Detective Jeremy McCord. Went to the guy home after they received a report from Lisa Guy's employer that said, she didn't show up for work after Thanksgiving, the Monday after Thanksgiving.
20:41 Speaker 01 That's a concern.
20:42 Speaker 00 Yeah. And I think they got blown off at first. I read in one paper that they weren't happy. The police weren't taking it seriously because she had some kind of big time meeting. That she would have never missed on Monday.
20:58 Speaker 01 No doubt she would have been there.
20:59 Speaker 00 So they ended up calling or going up the chain.
21:03 Speaker 01 Yeah.
21:03 Speaker 00 And getting somebody that would take them seriously.
21:08 Speaker 00 And that led to this Jeremy McCord guy.
21:13 Speaker 00 Going out to the home and he said the for sale sign was still in the yard when he got there around noon on Monday. So still, you know, everything happening very quickly. Thursday is Thanksgiving. They believe the murders happened Friday, Saturday. Obviously, nobody knows until Monday that anything's wrong because she doesn't show up for work. McCord later testified that he could feel heat emanating from a doorway and he caught a whiff of chemicals in the air.
21:45 Speaker 01 Not good, potentially not good.
21:47 Speaker 00 But yeah, I would say probably never good.
21:51 Speaker 01 Yeah.
21:52 Speaker 00 I have a real sensitive nose, so I don't, my wife likes to burn a lot of candles.
22:00 Speaker 01 Yeah.
22:00 Speaker 00 Dry and she has these plug in sense things that spray.
22:07 Speaker 01 Oh, mist every now and then?
22:08 Speaker 00 Oh, my gosh. And if she puts it in a room that's too small, she put one in the laundry room a couple of weeks ago and I thought I was going to have an attack. It was an attack on my senses to walk through the garage.
22:23 Speaker 01 Just make this place smell good.
22:24 Speaker 00 Yeah.
22:25 Speaker 01 I mean, it does smell good up there, by the way. It's like a cinnamon.
22:28 Speaker 00 I get it.
22:29 Speaker 01 Field right now.
22:30 Speaker 00 I get it. Yeah. My wife's already got the Christmas decorations out.
22:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, I seen that.
22:34 Speaker 00 Sometimes it's too much. Sometimes it's too much. So.
22:38 Speaker 01 What I didn't see was my present, but go ahead.
22:40 Speaker 00 No, no, you won't see that.
22:41 Speaker 01 Yeah.
22:43 Speaker 00 Especially now, maybe never. This guy also said that he saw groceries spilled on the floor in the foyer. He later said in court that he was afraid something bad had happened to the guys. And so he didn't want to wait for a warrant. And, you know, obviously you can get into that whole thing of probable cause, or, you know, you see something that allows you to not have to get a warrant. When he searched the home, he found what was an unimaginable scene. He said there was blood everywhere. It was on the carpet. It was up all the walls.
23:23 Speaker 00 He found Lisa Guy's severed head in a pot of boiling liquid on the stove. He found Joel Guy Senior's severed hands on the floor of the bedroom. And he found both of the couples severed torsos in plastic containers in the bathroom.
23:45 Speaker 01 Blood of anger.
23:46 Speaker 00 Well, yes, on the part of the person who did it.
23:49 Speaker 01 Yeah.
23:50 Speaker 00 Absolutely. I also think it's kind of a tough day to be this police officer.
23:55 Speaker 01 Really tough. It's gonna be hard to not recall that again and again and again.
24:00 Speaker 00 Yeah, you're gonna have to live with that. He also stated that he saw scissors and clothing that appeared to have been cut from a body as well as a large knife. He saw bottles of peroxide, bleach, acid, and rubbing alcohol. He said he could smell the stench of death mixed with these chemicals.
24:20 Speaker 01 If you want to vomit.
24:21 Speaker 00 It does, but it's really painting a picture.
24:24 Speaker 01 Sure, sure is, yeah.
24:25 Speaker 00 You know, the smell. You're finding a head boiling on the stove. Severed, you know, hands, torsos. Rough day.
24:37 Speaker 01 Extremely.
24:38 Speaker 00 For this individual who, you know, was the first on the scene and found everything. Major Michael McLean told the Knoxville New Sentinel that Joel placed pieces of the bodies in an acid-based solution in an attempt to destroy evidence.
24:55 Speaker 01 Okay.
24:56 Speaker 00 He said that the solution that he used was composed of normal household chemicals and didn't require any special knowledge of chemistry. The type of stuff that you could buy straight off the internet.
25:09 Speaker 01 Well, can't you get off the internet?
25:10 Speaker 00 Well, yes, that's true.
25:12 Speaker 01 Yeah.
25:12 Speaker 00 It's a little scary, I think.
25:14 Speaker 01 Really scary.
25:14 Speaker 00 And that's not, we're not even talking about the dark web. I don't fully understand the dark web.
25:20 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
25:21 Speaker 00 But only explained by what I've seen in movies and stuff. But it sounds like you can get just about anything you want.
25:28 Speaker 01 You can.
25:29 Speaker 00 Off there.
25:29 Speaker 01 Yeah.
25:30 Speaker 00 I don't even think he's talking about that. I just think he's talking about Amazon. You can go on Amazon, buy all these chemicals, put them together and...
25:38 Speaker 01 Definitely surprising what you can get off of that site.
25:41 Speaker 00 Well, but they're not made for that.
25:43 Speaker 01 No, no, no.
25:43 Speaker 00 Obviously, they have real intended purposes.
25:46 Speaker 01 But if you know how to use certain things or look up...
25:49 Speaker 00 On, yeah, you can Google all just about anything, right?
25:53 Speaker 01 Yeah.
25:53 Speaker 00 That, that, that's a scary thing. The information is great.
25:56 Speaker 01 Right.
25:57 Speaker 00 The ability that we have, right? The information at our fingertips is great. The problem is if you have someone who's intent on doing something bad, they can get that information that they need pretty quickly.
26:12 Speaker 01 Exactly.
26:12 Speaker 00 You know, how to make a, a, a pipe bomb. I'm sure it's out there. I've, I've never looked for it.
26:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's out there.
26:19 Speaker 00 Okay. I, I will take your word for it, but you know, the, the, what, what was the bombs they used in Columbine? With the, um, the pressure cooker.
26:29 Speaker 01 Pressure cookers?
26:29 Speaker 00 Pressure cooker bomb.
26:30 Speaker 01 Boston Marathon too.
26:31 Speaker 00 Yes, that, that type of stuff scares me.
26:33 Speaker 01 It's all out there, man.
26:34 Speaker 00 That it's all out there, but you know, it's kind of the, the price that you pay for having the information, the good type of information.
26:44 Speaker 01 Right.
26:44 Speaker 00 You're gonna have to live with that.
26:46 Speaker 01 Freedom of information.
26:47 Speaker 00 Being out there as well. The Knoxville News Sentinel reported that Lisa and Joel Guy Senior were last seen alive on Friday when they moved a boat to a relative's house. So this is the day after Thanksgiving. The house is sold. They haven't transferred ownership yet. They're still moving some stuff out. Right? I did talk about the house already being sold.
27:09 Speaker 01 You did.
27:10 Speaker 00 They're planning on moving. Apparently the new owners, the people that bought the house, they showed up while the forensic team was processing, were moving evidence.
27:24 Speaker 01 Can you imagine?
27:25 Speaker 00 No.
27:25 Speaker 01 Wow.
27:26 Speaker 00 You know, I, again, I have no idea who bought this home.
27:29 Speaker 01 Right.
27:29 Speaker 00 It, it could have been their dream home. Right? They're, they're moving from this or their first home. I don't know. But when you find out that not only were two people, not only did two people die.
27:42 Speaker 01 You're right.
27:43 Speaker 00 There, cause that to me would be something to process.
27:47 Speaker 01 Sure.
27:48 Speaker 00 We're talking about they were murdered and not only that, they were dismembered.
27:54 Speaker 01 Yeah.
27:55 Speaker 00 In a very gruesome fashion.
27:58 Speaker 01 And found in different parts of the house.
27:59 Speaker 00 Yeah.
28:00 Speaker 01 Not one central area, but. Unfortunately scouted about.
28:04 Speaker 00 I, I think, I think we gotta figure out how to back out of this sale.
28:08 Speaker 01 Right.
28:09 Speaker 00 And we'll find something else.
28:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, cuz I'll never use that oven.
28:13 Speaker 00 No.
28:13 Speaker 01 Again.
28:14 Speaker 00 The stove, the bathtub, we'll find out a, a lot of places were, uh,
28:21 Speaker 00 were used.
28:22 Speaker 01 Yeah.
28:22 Speaker 00 For things that you would never wanna have to think about again.
28:25 Speaker 01 Enough bleach in the world.
28:26 Speaker 00 Especially every time you used it.
28:28 Speaker 01 Yeah.
28:28 Speaker 00 Where every time you stepped foot in that house.
28:30 Speaker 01 I just, I just wouldn't wanna be in that house anymore.
28:32 Speaker 00 No, absolutely. I, I can't imagine anybody would.
28:35 Speaker 01 Yeah.
28:36 Speaker 00 So I said it didn't take long, right, to link Junior to the murders. By that Tuesday, the day after his mom didn't show up for work, he was arrested outside of his apartment by Knox County Sheriff's Officers. So they went down to Louisiana. That's where he was living. They were joined by members of the East Baton Rouge Parish Sheriff's Office, the FBI, Andy Swatting.
29:04 Speaker 01 Had full force ready to go.
29:05 Speaker 00 Well, they weren't messing around.
29:06 Speaker 01 No.
29:07 Speaker 00 Um, now, when he was arrested, it was noted that he had, um, wounds to his hands. And we'll talk about those, um, well, let's talk about now. Basically, what prosecutors later said at trial was that these wounds were slices.
29:26 Speaker 01 Yeah.
29:27 Speaker 00 That he suffered to his hands while he was struggling with his dad.
29:32 Speaker 01 Cause his dad just wasn't gonna give up.
29:33 Speaker 00 No, and there was a lot in the information about the fact that his dad was bigger than him.
29:40 Speaker 01 Yeah.
29:40 Speaker 00 You know, his dad was not a guy that he was just going to overpower.
29:45 Speaker 01 Yeah.
29:45 Speaker 00 You know?
29:46 Speaker 01 Obviously, probably had to take him by surprise or some.
29:49 Speaker 00 You know, I.
29:50 Speaker 01 Type of force.
29:50 Speaker 00 I'll tell you what, Gibbs, I don't care, you know, fifty-five, sixty years old, some guys just have strength.
29:58 Speaker 01 Yeah.
29:59 Speaker 00 And maybe a 28 year old poses no shot at overpowering them. Now it can work the other way.
30:07 Speaker 01 They can.
30:08 Speaker 00 Easily, because we we lose muscle mass as we as we get older and all of that stuff. But I've known some guys in their 50s, even into their 60s, who were, I call it farm strong.
30:19 Speaker 01 Right.
30:20 Speaker 00 Because of where I where we live.
30:22 Speaker 01 Sure, yeah, yeah.
30:22 Speaker 00 A lot of guys that I played basketball with when I was young, 40s, 50s and 60s, they would show up at open gym to play with this.
30:30 Speaker 01 Right.
30:31 Speaker 00 And these guys, their hands were like vices. If they got a hold of the ball, there was nothing you could do because they worked in concrete. They worked laying bricks or they worked on the farm, baling hay or whatever it was.
30:48 Speaker 01 I can crack a walnut between my middle finger and my index finger.
30:51 Speaker 00 Okay, I thought you were gonna go somewhere else with that. I can pick up a cord now. I thought you were gonna go in a completely different direction.
30:59 Speaker 01 Yeah.
31:00 Speaker 00 So how does one find out that they can crack a walnut between two fingers that shouldn't be used to crack a walnut?
31:06 Speaker 01 I just did one day. I wanted to see if I could do it.
31:07 Speaker 00 All right.
31:08 Speaker 01 Yeah.
31:08 Speaker 00 So you've got some digit strength is what you're telling me?
31:11 Speaker 01 Yeah.
31:12 Speaker 00 So Joel Guy Jr. was charged with two counts of first degree murder. This happened in 2016, but his trial didn't begin until late 2020. And this delay in large part seemed to center around a bunch of challenges by his public defenders on evidence searches. We'll get into a little bit of of what the those were, but they challenged everything, right? The search of his stuff at the house where the murders occurred. He said, well, he wasn't a resident, so they didn't have any right to do it. They challenged the searches
31:52 Speaker 00 in Louisiana at his apartment. It was a battle that dragged on for years. And then obviously, once it finally got settled, they could move forward with the trial. But you know, even before that prosecution came out and said that they would not seek the death penalty, even though a lot of outlets reported that Guy wanted it. He asked for it.
32:16 Speaker 01 He did.
32:17 Speaker 00 We've heard that before.
32:18 Speaker 01 Yeah, sure.
32:19 Speaker 00 You know, I don't understand it other than I think there are people who just say, I don't want to spend the rest of my life in prison.
32:28 Speaker 01 He was 28 years old. So,
32:30 Speaker 00 Yeah.
32:31 Speaker 01 you know, it's a long time to spend in prison, the rest of your life.
32:35 Speaker 00 It is.
32:36 Speaker 01 At that age.
32:37 Speaker 00 It is. So a jury of five men and seven women would decide his fate. It was reported by the Knoxville Sentinel that this was one of the first trials and definitely one of the most serious ones to be held in Tennessee since the pandemic started in earlier in March.
32:56 Speaker 01 Okay.
32:57 Speaker 00 So, you know, we're in that timeframe, right? 2020. How many cases have we talked about where trials got pushed back, got pushed back? Apparently, you know, he had tried to delay the trial, citing his concerns about the pandemic. Sure, he was really worried about COVID.
33:17 Speaker 01 Especially since he wanted to
33:20 Speaker 00 Die.
33:20 Speaker 01 Die. So why would you care? But okay.
33:23 Speaker 00 We know.
33:24 Speaker 01 Yeah.
33:24 Speaker 00 We know what he was trying to do. And I'm not making light of COVID at all, or the pandemic, but we know what this guy was trying to do. So one of his sisters came out against the delay. And according to the Tennessean, she appeared by video link in court from her classroom. She was a teacher.
33:44 Speaker 01 Yeah.
33:44 Speaker 00 And she told the judge, Judge Sword, that she was back to work. Her children were attending school despite the pandemic. She said, the world is continuing. Why shouldn't the trial continue?
33:59 Speaker 01 Good point.
33:59 Speaker 00 Y'all are affecting the lives of other people. Yeah. I mean, it is a good point. I understand there were definitely precautions put in place, but the judge ultimately denied his request for a delay. So authorities laid out their theory before the trial even started. And basically it was simple, right? They said that Lisa and Guy senior told Joel junior that they were going to cut him off financially. And so he decided to kill them and try to get money from their deaths.
34:33 Speaker 01 Cause he really thought that one through and that was going to work out in his favor.
34:36 Speaker 00 It was pure greed, right?
34:37 Speaker 01 Right. I mean, we know he's not the, I was gonna start to say, you know, he's really not the smartest guy. I was gonna say that because he's hasn't, he doesn't really ever finish anything.
34:48 Speaker 00 Yeah, it, it was said that he was competent. I saw one word used that academically, he was competent. He wasn't the head of his class. He wasn't an overachiever or anything like that. But obviously he graduated high school and went to college and, and did that stuff.
35:09 Speaker 01 I call them floaters.
35:10 Speaker 00 Floater? He was a floater?
35:12 Speaker 01 He was just gonna float through life as long as he could.
35:14 Speaker 00 Oh, I definitely think it by the end of this, it, that will become apparent.
35:18 Speaker 01 Yeah.
35:19 Speaker 00 Yeah, there, there's no doubt about that. So just before the trial was set to start, he essentially fired his attorneys and he made a motion to represent himself.
35:29 Speaker 01 Oh.
35:30 Speaker 00 Which I know you always love.
35:31 Speaker 01 Yeah.
35:31 Speaker 00 You get a kick out of that.
35:32 Speaker 01 That goes so well.
35:34 Speaker 00 And so they, they went back and forth on that, but it came out in the end that he really only wanted to represent himself on one issue. And it was this motion to force the state to execute him if he was found guilty.
35:50 Speaker 01 Okay.
35:50 Speaker 00 He really wanted to die if he was found guilty.
35:54 Speaker 01 Yeah, please don't make me stay in jail, prison for a lifetime.
35:57 Speaker 00 For, for a lifetime. So he, from what I understood is the public defenders wouldn't file it. And so that's what he had the, the beef with.
36:06 Speaker 01 Yeah.
36:06 Speaker 00 But once the judge kind of talked to him about it and they came to this understanding that that was really the only thing he was worried about. The judge said, okay. When it gets to that point, you can represent yourself and file your own motion. And so he allowed the public defenders to defend him.
36:25 Speaker 01 Yeah.
36:25 Speaker 00 And his trial, um, and his defense attorneys didn't make a bunch of motions. Basically to try to keep, um, people from testifying, his, some of his sisters.
36:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'm sure it wasn't going to be good for him.
36:41 Speaker 00 No, no, because, and we'll talk about it maybe when we get to trial, but you know, they're, they're going to say some of the things that we've already said, their parents were, were going to cut him off.
36:53 Speaker 01 Yeah.
36:54 Speaker 00 And, and some things like that. He also tried to keep out of evidence, a recording of a, a jail phone call between himself and a guy named Michael McCracken. I don't really know who Michael McCracken is. The papers didn't say, you know, what relationship the two had, but on this, he, uh, supposedly admitted to the murders.
37:17 Speaker 01 Cause I guess he can't see that sign above the phones that says, this call is being recorded.
37:22 Speaker 00 Yeah, never. People never see it. They never think about it. So I, I said that authorities originally came out and said that he decided to murder his parents after they said that they were going to cut him off. When they got time for, to, for trial though, prosecutors presented evidence that Joel Guy Jr. had a notebook in his backpack, which kind of detailed out, um, how to commit the murders. And he had it at the time that they all ate Thanksgiving dinner.
37:55 Speaker 01 Oh, so like they're eating dinner. He's over there just like taking little notes and they're like, oh, look, he's studying for his test.
38:02 Speaker 00 I don't think he was writing in the journal. I just think he had it with him. But, but what that means, right? Once that revelation comes out, it means that he had already made the decision to kill. Now maybe he knew.
38:15 Speaker 01 Premeditated.
38:16 Speaker 00 Yeah. Oh, we're going to talk about premeditation a lot.
38:18 Speaker 01 Yeah.
38:19 Speaker 00 But maybe he already knew that his parents were thinking about cutting him off. His, his dad for sure had brought it up before. But later at trial, prosecutors told jurors that Joel Guy Jr. began to plan the murders as early as November 7.
38:35 Speaker 01 Oh, weeks.
38:36 Speaker 00 Weeks.
38:37 Speaker 01 That time. Yeah.
38:38 Speaker 00 Weeks before Thanksgiving. But I want to talk about this notebook, right? It was introduced at trial. It was a huge piece of evidence. And I want to read just some of the entries from just one page of it. It's a little lengthy, but it sheds so much light. And, you know, all the papers mentioned that the prosecutors, they just kept bringing this notebook up. They called it a book of premeditation is basically what they called it in court. So these are just bullet points that he had written down.
39:10 Speaker 01 Right.
39:11 Speaker 00 Minimize things I touch throughout visit. Wear gloves and socks to prevent fingerprints and footprints. Drop something down the garbage disposal to break it. Get him on the ground. Kill him with the knife. Clean up the mess from him before she gets home. Kill her with knife. Take dog with you. Place her in the shower. Turn on hot water to get rid of forensics. Remove her clothes and take with me. Place him in plastic bin and use it to get him into the upstairs bathroom. Cut off his arm and plant his flesh under her fingernails.
39:54 Speaker 00 Place her hand with his DNA so that his DNA is not washed away by the shower. Wipe down kill room. Set her phone to send me a text message on Sunday to prove that I was in Baton Rouge when she was still alive. So again, these are just some of the ones.
40:15 Speaker 01 Right.
40:15 Speaker 00 I just cherry picked out some of the entries that he had in, that he had in there.
40:20 Speaker 01 Disturbing.
40:21 Speaker 00 Oh, very disturbing. I mean, according to the USA Today, there were five pages of this stuff in this notebook. The entries were very detailed and covered every little precise detail on how to commit the murders, how to dismember the bodies, how to dissolve them, and even how much he would profit from his parents' life insurance policies.
40:49 Speaker 01 Well, of course, he did his homework.
40:51 Speaker 00 Yeah, he did.
40:53 Speaker 01 Yeah.
40:54 Speaker 00 It's a scary thing. There were even balance sheets that kind of showed his parents' assets and life insurance policies. The Knoxville New Sentinel reported that Lisa's insurance policy was structured so that her son and her husband would split the proceeds if she died first. If her husband died first, then he would get it all.
41:17 Speaker 01 There you go.
41:18 Speaker 00 So, you know, when I read that, it does kind of make more sense that maybe these three sisters were half-sisters belonging to his dad.
41:28 Speaker 01 Right.
41:29 Speaker 00 And that he was his mother's only biological child.
41:34 Speaker 01 Right.
41:35 Speaker 00 When you read the structure of the life insurance policy, that does make, that does make some sense. But I just read, you know, these things, right? It's kind of a to-do list. You and I talked last week about people who make to-do lists and like to check them off.
41:52 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
41:52 Speaker 00 But I think there's a couple of things that you definitely see here. One is premeditation. I think that that's a no-brainer. If you're a killer and you want to leave evidence of premeditation, just do what this guy did. Just write down in a notebook every single thing that you plan to do.
42:11 Speaker 01 And save it.
42:13 Speaker 00 And save it. The other thing you see is, is just how callous that this guy was.
42:18 Speaker 01 Extremely.
42:19 Speaker 00 I mean, as I was kind of reading those, you know, I'm, I'm, we always talk about the question, how could someone do something like this, like what we just talked about to their apparent, their parents? How could you even sit down and write this stuff out?
42:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, three weeks ahead of time.
42:40 Speaker 00 Thinking that I'm going to carry these acts out against my parents.
42:45 Speaker 01 Yeah.
42:46 Speaker 00 It's just, it's just so callous. And the way, the way that he wrote it was, you know, kill her.
42:52 Speaker 01 Yeah.
42:52 Speaker 00 Do this to him.
42:54 Speaker 01 Very cold.
42:54 Speaker 00 Very, very cold. And, you know, one thing that I really found interesting is that it came out in court that investigators found this backpack at his parents' house after the murders in the room where he was sleeping. So here's the part that, well, besides murdering your, his parents, I just could not understand. When you think about this notebook.
43:20 Speaker 01 Okay.
43:20 Speaker 00 Five detailed pages.
43:22 Speaker 01 Yeah.
43:23 Speaker 00 This guy went through all of the trouble in planning to write down all of these entries to follow in a notebook. And you said, okay, write it all down.
43:35 Speaker 01 Yeah.
43:35 Speaker 00 Save it. Then after he commits the murders, he leaves the backpack with the notebook inside.
43:43 Speaker 01 Why?
43:44 Speaker 00 Doesn't make any sense.
43:45 Speaker 01 Does not.
43:46 Speaker 00 Right? There were even entries about burning down the house to get rid of evidence, which we know he didn't do.
43:53 Speaker 01 Right.
43:53 Speaker 00 Now prosecutors would later assert that the only reason he didn't follow his own entries was because of the injuries to his hand.
44:03 Speaker 01 From his dad.
44:04 Speaker 00 Right. He somehow got sliced in this tussle with his dad and they thought that that was the reason why he couldn't follow through on, you know, all of the things that he had in his, his notebook. It was also reported during the trial that while he was in jail, you know, he's a, he's awaiting trial, he tried to collect on the life insurance.
44:28 Speaker 01 Really?
44:29 Speaker 00 Yeah. He wrote to the life insurance company, I hereby assert the continuing validity of my claims to the insurance proceeds totaling $696,666.68 plus applicable interest.
44:48 Speaker 01 So not only is he trying to get the money, he wants interest on top of that?
44:51 Speaker 00 Yeah.
44:52 Speaker 01 Wow.
44:53 Speaker 00 Yeah. While he's
44:55 Speaker 01 On trial.
44:56 Speaker 00 Waiting to go on trial for the murders. And, you know, I guess he spent a lot of time corresponding with this life insurance and it actually turned in, I didn't go into it in detail, but it actually turned into kind of a courtroom battle as well with the insurance company saying, well, we know we got to pay someone.
45:17 Speaker 01 Right.
45:18 Speaker 00 But we don't want to pay him. And what he would say is that until I'm a convicted murderer, that rule doesn't kick in, so you should pay me.
45:29 Speaker 01 Yeah.
45:30 Speaker 00 And it was a back and forth and, I mean, they never did, but he kept pressing it and pressing it.
45:37 Speaker 01 Yeah. Well, scary.
45:39 Speaker 00 So, you know, when you, you know, we're not going to get real in depth with the trial, but suffice to say, it was pretty hard for him to get out from under this notebook, right? It was very detailed.
45:52 Speaker 01 Yeah.
45:53 Speaker 00 Not only gave the reasons for the murder, but also how it was to be committed. And, um, most of the, the paper said that his defense team, they didn't ask a lot of questions, they didn't really present evidence.
46:11 Speaker 01 Yeah.
46:13 Speaker 00 I don't know what they could have done.
46:14 Speaker 01 Yeah, it didn't look good for him from the get go. So what are you going to do to?
46:17 Speaker 00 Right.
46:18 Speaker 01 I don't think you want to give them anything more than they already have, and you could risk that by going too far with your.
46:26 Speaker 00 Well, my, my kind of thought was you're probably not going to ask too many questions of these witnesses because you don't want to hear what they have to say.
46:34 Speaker 01 Exactly.
46:35 Speaker 00 None of the questions or none of the answers, I should say, are probably going to paint your defendant in a good light. Now, you can be crafty in the questions, but you also, you have some people who can be real crafty with their answers.
46:49 Speaker 01 Exactly.
46:50 Speaker 00 So I kind of get it. I think they were, they were in a tough spot.
46:53 Speaker 01 Oh, for sure.
46:54 Speaker 00 No doubt about it. Prosecutors told the jury that Joel Guy Senior sustained 42 wounds. Lisa sustained 31, and we talked about it, right? This was a very gruesome scene that jurors had to hear about. And you know that the prosecution had to lay it all out there, every single nasty detail.
47:17 Speaker 01 For his family to hear.
47:20 Speaker 00 Well, yeah, I mean, but I think also you want to paint this guy truly as the monster he is.
47:30 Speaker 01 Oh, absolutely. This is the time to do it.
47:32 Speaker 00 So as much as you would really hate for these jurors to have to kind of see all these pictures and hear all the details, you kind of got to do it.
47:42 Speaker 01 This is your one opportunity to put the cases forward as best as you can.
47:46 Speaker 00 Yeah, and you want them to see him as the absolute monster that he was. His sisters testified against him, as did some other people. Like I said, we're not going to go into a lot of detail about the trial. I wanted this episode to be a little bit shorter just because it's Thanksgiving week.
48:05 Speaker 01 Yeah.
48:06 Speaker 00 I got four things to, to edit.
48:08 Speaker 01 Right.
48:09 Speaker 00 But I also thought this was a very fascinating case.
48:13 Speaker 01 It is.
48:13 Speaker 00 But again, I want to go back to the, the notebook, right? Such a huge piece of evidence. Basically what the prosecutors did with it is they would read entries out of the notebook and then they would tie evidence that they had to the entry.
48:31 Speaker 01 Right.
48:32 Speaker 00 So one would be like, um, get sledgehammer, crush bones. Well, they found a sledgehammer at the scene.
48:40 Speaker 01 Yeah.
48:41 Speaker 00 So pretty easy to tie those two together. Another red get killing knives. They found the knives at the scene.
48:48 Speaker 01 Everything was lining up.
48:50 Speaker 00 Yeah, and, and, you know, just like leaving the notebook. It seems to me as though he followed some of the instructions that he had written down, but he didn't really follow any of the instructions regarding cleaning up, disposing of clothes.
49:07 Speaker 01 Get rid of the notebook.
49:08 Speaker 00 Get rid of the notebook, disposing of the bodies, you know? And, and you kind of have to think about, okay, why was that? Was it as the prosecutors asserted that, okay, he got his hands cut up? And he just couldn't do certain things? Or was it that he got to a certain point in this whole nastiness? And just was like, I can't do this anymore.
49:35 Speaker 01 Right, yeah.
49:35 Speaker 00 I don't know. I don't know that he, he's ever said anything about it. He didn't take the stand, so.
49:42 Speaker 01 It's a possibility, though.
49:43 Speaker 00 There's, I thought, maybe, maybe it was. Because he would have sustained those cuts before he did some of the, the nasty things that, that he did. So he was able to, to use his hands at that point. So I wasn't sure about that. The Knoxville News Sentinel reported that Prosecutor Sanchez and Nacios told jurors in their closing arguments that the guys were planning to retire. And they were planning to quit paying their son's bills. Joel Guy Jr. Was then 28 years old, had never held the job, and had been taking college courses for a decade.
50:23 Speaker 01 Wow.
50:24 Speaker 00 By that point.
50:25 Speaker 01 Sure, yeah.
50:26 Speaker 00 You know, so they're, they're trying to hammer home the reason why him being cut off would be devastating to him. The guys wanted to retire and they deserved to retire. The motive is pretty apparent in this case. It's money, half a million dollars in life insurance proceeds. That's what this case is about. They brought up that date, November 7th, as the date when he decided to kill his parents. And they backed it up by, you know, telling and showing the jury that's when he started going out to, um, different stores and buying knives, chemicals.
51:06 Speaker 01 Yeah.
51:07 Speaker 00 Plastic sheeting, all the stuff that Dexter.
51:10 Speaker 01 Would have bought.
51:11 Speaker 00 Would have bought, would have had on him all the things that this guy would have needed to carry out his plan. And they obviously had done all the research and investigation. By this point, they had the receipts. They, they could tie him to all of this stuff. And that's really how they came up with the November 7th date. You don't go out to buy all the stuff that you eventually use in a murder, if you're not already planning on, you know, doing something pretty bad.
51:40 Speaker 01 That was definitely true.
51:42 Speaker 00 Now, speaking of Dexter, I think anybody who has watched that show kind of knows that Dexter went out of his way, right? He might buy plastic sheeting here.
51:53 Speaker 01 Yeah.
51:53 Speaker 00 He's gonna buy something else in a much different place at a different time.
51:59 Speaker 01 Yeah. That's why Dexter was Dexter.
52:02 Speaker 00 Yeah, part of the reason why maybe he got away with it as long as he did.
52:06 Speaker 01 Right.
52:07 Speaker 00 I also think about Breaking Bad. You know, Walt kind of did the same thing.
52:12 Speaker 01 He did.
52:13 Speaker 00 He wouldn't buy all of his supplies at one store. So he didn't have a big shopping cart full of everything that he needed to make the meth. He'd buy a little, you know, he'd buy one thing here and one thing over here.
52:25 Speaker 01 Not to set off any radars.
52:26 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah. Guy Jr.'s public defenders. Like I said, they, they really presented no evidence on his behalf. Joel Jr. Didn't take the stand, already said that. Really, all his defense team tried to do was to call into question any forensic testing and tell the jury that this wasn't a man set on committing two murders. And they, they tried to back that up by saying, you know, he was happy at Thanksgiving. Even his sisters said he was happy at Thanksgiving.
53:00 Speaker 01 Yeah, but they don't know, what was he thinking before he got there, right?
53:04 Speaker 00 Yeah.
53:05 Speaker 01 Those weeks that added up to Thanksgiving.
53:07 Speaker 00 Well, also, if your plan is to wait for everybody, you know, a lot of the family to leave.
53:14 Speaker 01 Yeah.
53:15 Speaker 00 And you're planning on doing this the next day, the day after, are you gonna sit there and be sullen and nasty?
53:21 Speaker 01 No.
53:21 Speaker 00 No, you're gonna put on your happy face, which is actually what the prosecutors came back and said.
53:27 Speaker 01 Sure.
53:27 Speaker 00 You know, he put on an act because that's what he wanted his sisters to think. Hey, he's doing good. He's happy. He's in a good place.
53:36 Speaker 01 They got his sisters to leave.
53:37 Speaker 00 I think they were gonna leave anyway, but they got them not to think or, you know, question what's going on with Joel Jr.
53:46 Speaker 01 Right.
53:47 Speaker 00 No, he seemed, he seemed fine.
53:48 Speaker 01 Even normal.
53:49 Speaker 00 We're not worried about him. But really, you know, when it comes back to the defense, kids, what could they do with this kind of mountain of evidence against them? Attack the science, the testing, which the defense attorneys always try to do, and then use the old, the old, use his own sister's testimony kind of against him.
54:12 Speaker 01 Yeah.
54:12 Speaker 00 In saying that he seemed fine at Thanksgiving. Oh, well, then he, he couldn't be a murderer.
54:20 Speaker 01 Yeah.
54:21 Speaker 00 But we know that's not true.
54:22 Speaker 01 That's not true. Exactly right.
54:23 Speaker 00 His trial only lasted four days. Pretty short.
54:26 Speaker 01 It is short.
54:27 Speaker 00 After three hours of deliberation on Friday, October 2nd, 2020, the jury found him guilty of two counts of first degree murder, three counts of felony murder, and two counts of abuse of a corpse. Judge Sword imposed an automatic life sentence with the possibility of parole after 51 years for each of the murder convictions.
54:52 Speaker 01 Okay.
54:53 Speaker 00 We already knew he wasn't going to get the death penalty.
54:55 Speaker 01 Right.
54:55 Speaker 00 They weren't even going after that, but they didn't rule at the time, or the judge didn't rule at the time whether these sentences were going to be consecutive or concurrent. That's a big deal.
55:09 Speaker 01 It is a big deal.
55:10 Speaker 00 Right. Concurrent, still a life sentence. You're still not coming up for parole for 51 years.
55:16 Speaker 01 Yeah.
55:17 Speaker 00 He's gonna be, what, 79 years old?
55:20 Speaker 01 Yes.
55:21 Speaker 00 No, no, I'm sorry. Because by, no, well, it goes back.
55:25 Speaker 01 It goes back.
55:25 Speaker 00 It goes back. So 79 years.
55:27 Speaker 01 Yeah.
55:27 Speaker 00 Old, 80 years, whatever, give or take. So basically, what the judge said was that he was gonna have a hearing later on to determine it. That hearing, as reported by the Knoxville News Sentinel, was held on November 19th. And at the hearing, the judge ruled that the life sentence, sentences were to be served one after another.
55:50 Speaker 01 Okay, so two life sentences?
55:52 Speaker 00 Yeah, but to me, the parole.
55:55 Speaker 01 Right.
55:56 Speaker 00 Is the big deal.
55:57 Speaker 01 Yeah.
55:57 Speaker 00 Right? Because now, does that mean you're not eligible for 102 years?
56:02 Speaker 01 That's how I look at it.
56:03 Speaker 00 Because it's not concurrent, it's consecutive.
56:06 Speaker 01 Right.
56:07 Speaker 00 Either way, it doesn't seem as though this guy will probably barring some type of appeal or something happening, I just don't think he'll ever get out.
56:17 Speaker 01 No, I don't think so either.
56:18 Speaker 00 And I don't think he should get out, you know? I would have been okay if they would have gone after him for the death penalty, if he would have, you know, ultimately been executed, I would have been okay with that. I'm totally fine with a life sentence. What I would not want is for this individual to really ever re-enter society, ever.
56:43 Speaker 01 No, you shouldn't.
56:45 Speaker 00 You know, the judge also tacked on an additional four years for abusing a corpse, but he, he really chastised this guy. He called the crime pure evil overkill. That sounds like something you would say.
56:59 Speaker 01 I would.
56:59 Speaker 00 Because you do like to talk about overkill.
57:02 Speaker 01 I say it a lot.
57:04 Speaker 00 The judge said, "This is the most extreme abuse of a corpse case I've seen in 25 years, and I hope it's the most serious that I'll see in my career." It was bad. I don't know how many judges have seen that type of stuff.
57:19 Speaker 01 Yeah, I wouldn't want to see those photos, those videos of the crime scene, none of that.
57:23 Speaker 00 I mean, judges see a lot of really bad stuff.
57:26 Speaker 01 They do.
57:27 Speaker 00 We always talk about juries. We don't really talk about judges that much because it's kind of their job. But I think it's got to be rough on them to see so much carnage and, and death and just bad people doing bad things. He also said, "I don't see potential for rehabilitation of Mr. Guy. I was watching him during the trial. He showed absolutely no remorse or despair over seeing what he had done. Quite frankly, Mr. Guy, you look like you're kind of proud of what you've accomplished." And I thought that was a very interesting statement by the judge.
58:09 Speaker 01 Sure.
58:10 Speaker 00 You know, if you think about it, the judge is kind of watching the defendant.
58:15 Speaker 01 Yeah, observing for sure.
58:17 Speaker 00 Observing everything that's going on throughout the trial. And at the end of it, he's basically saying, you know, hey, sit, we sat here for four days. I've watched you, and not just the four days, because they had a lot of other hearings and things.
58:33 Speaker 01 Yeah.
58:34 Speaker 00 He's saying, you're a POS, you've been a POS, you'll always be a POS.
58:38 Speaker 01 Yeah.
58:39 Speaker 00 There's, you know, whatever rehabilitation efforts there might be in prison, they're not going to work for you.
58:46 Speaker 01 No.
58:47 Speaker 00 Is essentially what the judge is saying.
58:49 Speaker 01 You're a.
58:50 Speaker 00 Or he doesn't believe they were.
58:51 Speaker 01 Helpless cause.
58:52 Speaker 00 Incorrigible.
58:54 Speaker 01 Incorrigible?
58:56 Speaker 00 What is?
58:57 Speaker 01 Incorrigible?
58:58 Speaker 00 In what?
58:59 Speaker 01 That's what it sounded like to me.
59:01 Speaker 00 Who said what?
59:01 Speaker 01 I don't know. Where what? Who was on first?
59:04 Speaker 00 Incorrigible. Um, yeah, he just basically came out and said it.
59:08 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
59:08 Speaker 00 But, you know, we've heard that as well. The no remorse thing we hear all the time.
59:13 Speaker 01 Sure we do.
59:14 Speaker 00 Especially with serial killers, because I don't think there is any remorse. Most likely in a lot of them, there's no empathy.
59:20 Speaker 01 No.
59:20 Speaker 00 Um, speaking of empathy, I'm watching the patient.
59:26 Speaker 01 Yeah.
59:26 Speaker 00 With my wife.
59:27 Speaker 01 Yeah.
59:28 Speaker 00 And we're almost done. We're like, I think we just finished episode eight. There's 10 episodes. And he talks a lot about empathy.
59:36 Speaker 01 Yeah.
59:36 Speaker 00 And that, you know, that young guy, he is really good actor. He does a really good job of kind of portraying what I think kind of a serial killer or a lot of serial killers are like.
59:50 Speaker 01 Right.
59:51 Speaker 00 You know, it's like he doesn't understand what someone else is going through or and doesn't care.
59:57 Speaker 01 Care, does not care.
59:58 Speaker 00 And you can see it, this actor does a pretty good job.
1:00:01 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:00:02 Speaker 00 Um, I recommend it if, you know, I haven't seen the whole thing, so I don't know how it's going to end.
1:00:06 Speaker 01 It is good.
1:00:07 Speaker 00 But don't give it away.
1:00:08 Speaker 01 Well, that doesn't give it away. Ends good. It's a good ending. Doesn't mean it's.
1:00:12 Speaker 00 Now you're giving more away. Now it's a good ending?
1:00:14 Speaker 01 It's a bad ending. I don't know. It's an ending.
1:00:16 Speaker 00 Don't give anything. No, but I do. I really, I think he does a pretty good job of kind of putting it out there of what at least I think.
1:00:27 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:00:27 Speaker 00 A lot of killers would be like in real life. He's, he's a little obsessive compulsive.
1:00:33 Speaker 01 He is.
1:00:34 Speaker 00 You see him every now and then like straightening things up and I'm not giving anything away, but, um, yeah. Yeah, I got it. But that's it, man. That's it for our episode on Joel Guy Jr. I just found it to be such a, such a waste.
1:00:52 Speaker 01 Oh, for sure.
1:00:53 Speaker 00 You know, on all fronts. It sounds like this guy kind of just wasted his life. He was aimless. You called him a floater.
1:01:01 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:01:02 Speaker 00 His parents gave him so much.
1:01:04 Speaker 01 Well, the opportunity.
1:01:05 Speaker 00 They were paying for him to try to make something out of his life. And for whatever reason, he never seemed to quite get there. And then at the first inkling that, okay, they're not going to help me anymore. Instead of, you know, putting on his big boy pants and saying, all right, I gotta get a job. If I want to go to school, I gotta get a job, pay for myself, maybe take out some loans, do whatever I gotta do. No, he went as some people do, this route of what's the easiest way?
1:01:44 Speaker 01 Yeah, let me take a shortcut.
1:01:46 Speaker 00 Yeah. Where's, where's, what's the shortcut? So that I can get my hands on, on a bunch of money. The sad thing is the shortcut involves killing your parents? These people that have been behind you your whole life?
1:01:59 Speaker 01 Right.
1:01:59 Speaker 00 And that's your first thought. It's unbelievable to me.
1:02:02 Speaker 01 It is. But like you said, all this stuff happens. It's, it's a, to me, it's just a nightmare that it happened the way it happened.
1:02:13 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:02:14 Speaker 01 You know, just.
1:02:16 Speaker 00 And it was like the, the judge said, going on about how's one of the worst cases he's ever seen. I mean, dismembering your mom.
1:02:24 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:02:24 Speaker 00 And dad and.
1:02:25 Speaker 01 Dad on the pot on the oven.
1:02:26 Speaker 00 Oh, just, just nasty stuff.
1:02:29 Speaker 01 Happy Thanksgiving.
1:02:30 Speaker 00 Happy Thanksgiving, but that's why I, I wanted to do it once Thanksgiving was over.
1:02:34 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:02:34 Speaker 00 You notice I didn't put it out last Saturday.
1:02:36 Speaker 01 Right.
1:02:37 Speaker 00 You know, I didn't want people thinking about that as they were, you know, kind of going in for the turkey. Now you and I have to because we're taping the day before Thanksgiving, but that's just on us.
1:02:49 Speaker 01 Just watch out when you reheat your leftovers.
1:02:51 Speaker 00 Exactly. But that's it. We love you.
1:02:54 Speaker 01 We do.
1:02:54 Speaker 00 We appreciate everything you do for us. We'll be back next Saturday with um with our normal weekly sneak previews.
1:03:02 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:03:03 Speaker 00 And then I think the Patreon episode next month is probably gonna come out early.
1:03:09 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:03:10 Speaker 00 I think because we're trying to take a vacation.
1:03:13 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:03:14 Speaker 00 Trying to take a week off, so may try to get it done early.
1:03:17 Speaker 01 I get to go with you now?
1:03:17 Speaker 00 No, you do not.
1:03:18 Speaker 01 You just said we.
1:03:19 Speaker 00 We, as in separately, we are taking a week off and uh.
1:03:25 Speaker 01 You keep, you know, changing it up.
1:03:27 Speaker 00 I can barely afford this vacation as it is, man. I definitely cannot afford to fly your ass all the way to Orlando and and pay for your park tickets and all that.
1:03:38 Speaker 01 You take care of all that. I'll get my own breakfast.
1:03:41 Speaker 00 Actually, that's that's saying something because I don't know when the last time you were at Disney.
1:03:47 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:03:48 Speaker 00 But the food is outrageously expensive.
1:03:50 Speaker 01 The hotel we're at, is it gonna be free continental? Oh, well, I mean, maybe rethink that.
1:03:55 Speaker 00 No, this is not the Holiday Inn Express or the the Clarion that you stay at all the time.
1:04:00 Speaker 01 Get a little box of cereal with some milk.
1:04:02 Speaker 00 On uh on business. It's not one of those business hotels.
1:04:07 Speaker 01 That's a problem.
1:04:08 Speaker 00 Now, every meal is gonna be eight million dollars.
1:04:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, that's because the pancakes have to look like a certain, you know, personality at the park.
1:04:16 Speaker 00 That we can't name for trademarking for.
1:04:18 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:04:19 Speaker 00 All right, we will talk to you next week.
1:04:22 Speaker 01 See ya. Bye.
Previous Aaron Goodwin Next Arlis Perry Page updated October 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated