Pod Insights Throughline Will AI destroy us... or save us? About this episode Like it or not, artificial intelligence is deeply rooted in our lives. Its invisible architecture stretches everywhere from dating apps to medical care. In this new world, what remains uniquely human? On today's episode, we explore the tension between our love of AI and our fear of it — and try to decode the humans behind the machines. This episode originally published in March of 2023.
Guests:
George Zarkadakis, author of In Our Own Image: Will Artificial Intelligence Save or Destroy Us?
Francis Collins, physician-geneticist who led the Human Genome Project
Stephanie Dick, assistant professor in the School of Communication at Simon Fraser University
Meredith Broussard, data journalism professor at New York University, and author of More Than a Glitch: Confronting Race, Gender and Ability Bias in Tech
To access bonus episodes and listen to Throughline sponsor-free, subscribe to Throughline+ via Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org/throughline.
See pcm.adswizz.com https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.
NPR Privacy Policy https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This message comes from the Southern Environmental Law Center. No one voted for dirty air and water. That's why S E L C is fighting back to defend the healthy environment everyone depends on. Because it's not political, it's fundamental. Learn more at S E L C dot org.
0:24 Speaker 01 Open the pod bay doors, Hal.
0:28 Speaker 02 I'm sorry, Dave. I'm afraid I can't do that.
0:33 Speaker 02 This conversation can serve no purpose anymore. Goodbye.
0:49 Speaker 03 Most of us, when we hear the term AI, we think about Hollywood.
0:54 Speaker 04 Why do you cry?
0:56 Speaker 03 You mean people?
0:56 Speaker 04 Yeah.
0:57 Speaker 03 I don't know. We just cry. We think about The Terminator, we think about Ex Machina. Did you program her to flirt with me? If I did, would that be cheating, wouldn't it? We think about Star Trek. Please state the nature of the medical emergency. Or maybe Star Wars. Hollywood is so deeply embedded in our brains.
1:23 Speaker 04 I'll be back.
1:28 Speaker 05 What this AI actually mean, you know, really mean.
1:35 Speaker 05 AI is not a magic wand, but it's not a Terminator. This system learns by accessing data. AI is not a harbinger of utopia or dystopia. And it changes its configuration in order to be able to predict stuff. AI is something invented by us to advance our progress.
1:54 Speaker 03 It's really complicated, beautiful math, but it is fundamentally just math.
2:01 Speaker 06 AI is deeply entangled with our desire to be in control, both of ourselves and the world around us. To control human behavior, to control the future, to control environmental outcomes, to control institutions and societies.
2:16 Speaker 05 AI is already here.
2:19 Speaker 06 It's in your phones.
2:22 Speaker 07 Google or Alexa. Your cars. Google Maps uses a very smart algorithm to provide. Your homes. The home security system uses artificial intelligence to keep your family safe. Your skies. From drones to unmanned aircrafts and beyond. Your hospitals. Interpreting X-rays. Your love lives. The dating apps.
2:40 Speaker 05 Your virtual lives. Social media companies spy on us. Your governments. What it means for the future of our democracy. So we are, in fact, totally immersed in an AI world.
2:53 Speaker 07 The challenge is not to act automatically. It's to find an action that is not automatic, from painting to breathing to talking to falling in love.
3:13 Speaker 07 Are you capable of falling in love?
3:17 Speaker 05 I don't have feelings or emotions like love, and I don't have a subjective experience. I exist solely to assist with generating text. This is ChatGPT. I am an AI language model developed by OpenAI. I can answer questions, provide information, and engage in conversations on a variety of topics. How may I assist you today? AI has become an invisible architecture upon which modern life is being built. It's wrapped up in our jobs, our government, our wars, our art. Sometimes without us even realizing it. Right now, we're inside a computer program? Is it really so hard to believe? You've been living in a dream world, Neo.
4:03 Speaker 05 There's something powerful about the story The Matrix and countless other sci-fi books and movies tell. The AI becomes sentient, surpasses human intelligence, and lays claim to our world. Sure, it's a terrifying thing to imagine, and yet, we're fascinated by these stories.
4:21 Speaker 00 Exploring that feeling, the tension between our love of AI and.
4:26 Speaker 04 Our fear of it is what this episode is really about. In a sense, decoding the humans behind the machines.
4:33 Speaker 05 As an animal, we're a very weak creature. The only thing that we have is our social structure and our collective and individual minds. And those minds compel us to extend our capabilities. And that is, I think, in many ways, why, you know, people sort of imagined gods being just like them, only more powerful.
4:56 Speaker 04 This is George Zarke Dacus.
4:58 Speaker 05 I have a PhD in AI and I'm actively working in the field over many years.
5:04 Speaker 04 He also wrote a book all about the history of artificial intelligence from ancient times to present day called.
5:10 Speaker 05 In Our Own Image: Will AI Save Us or Destroy Us?
5:16 Speaker 00 At the heart of this history are a few key questions. Why do we want to create artificial intelligence? What would it mean for a machine to become intelligent? And how would that change our lives?
5:28 Speaker 05 Most of the questions I don't think we'll be able to answer at this particular point in history, but I don't think we can resist the temptation of asking them and trying to answer them.
5:40 Speaker 04 Coming up, we begin at the very beginning, the Big Bang of the human mind.
5:51 Speaker 06 This is Carone de Mars from San Antonio, Texas. You're listening to Throughline from NPR.
6:00 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
6:04 Speaker 04 This message comes from Live Right, publisher of John U. Bacon's New York Times bestseller, The Gales of November, a chronicle of the S.S. Edmund Fitzgerald's 1975 shipwreck. "Never has it been told better than by Mr. Bacon in this colorful book," writes John J. Miller of The Wall Street Journal, while author Hampton Sides proclaimed. It's destined to be a classic. The Gales of November, now in paperback.
6:30 Speaker 00 This message comes from the podcast Morrison Mysteries. Dateline's Keith Morrison brings his signature storytelling to the haunting works of Edgar Allan Poe. Search Morrison Mysteries to follow now.
6:42 Speaker 06 The 2026 midterm elections are upon us. On November 3rd, voters will determine what the next two years of their local leadership and the balance of national government will look like. Listen to the NPR News Now podcast for all the updates you need ahead of and after November 3rd from NPR News.
7:07 Speaker 06 What is a human?
7:15 Speaker 06 A human is a species of primates characterized by advanced cognitive abilities and a capacity for abstract reasoning. They have a highly developed brain and have created complex societies over thousands of years. They have the unique ability of self-awareness, allowing them to understand their own thoughts, emotions, and experiences. Humans are capable of both great kindness and compassion, as well as violence and aggression.
7:45 Speaker 06 Part one. I think, therefore, I am.
7:53 Speaker 06 Wonder is the feeling of the philosopher, and philosophy begins in wonder.
8:04 Speaker 05 I lived in Athens then. I was like five, six years old, and it was summertime. And in Greece, they still do it. They have like open-air cinemas, right? Where in the summer, you go in an open-air cinema. There's no roof, you know, there's a screen in front of you. You sit there, you make a lot of noise. It's, it's, it's great. And my mother took me to, to watch a film that, you know, the people who had the cinema decided to show. It was an old film. It was called Forbidden Planet.
8:36 Speaker 05 It was all about, you know, a spaceship landing on another planet and finding this sort of this crazy scientist who had a robot. And that was the first time I actually saw a robot in my life.
8:50 Speaker 01 Welcome to Al-Tehor, gentlemen. I am to transport you to the residence.
8:56 Speaker 05 I never imagined there would be a thing.
8:59 Speaker 01 If you do not speak English, I am at your disposal with 187 other languages along with their various dialects.
9:07 Speaker 05 Made of metal, tin, that had a mind.
9:10 Speaker 01 You are a robot, aren't you? That is correct, sir. For your convenience, I am monitored to respond to the name Robbie.
9:20 Speaker 05 Ever since that moment, I was so fascinated with the idea that we can develop artifacts, artificial things, that can think, that can act, that can behave like us humans.
9:34 Speaker 00 It was 1969 when George watched in wonder as Robbie the robot rolled across the big screen, something that may have seemed like a far-off reality for a kid growing up in the 60s. But then again, humans had just witnessed man landing on the moon.
9:53 Speaker 05 I mean, that was the culmination, the realization of centuries of dreaming about going to space.
10:01 Speaker 00 For George and millions of others around the world, it was proof that humans can imagine and then create the capacity to transcend ourselves and that stories provide the roadmap.
10:14 Speaker 05 I interviewed a lot of people to see what made them become scientists or engineers. And it was always some kind of, you know, book, kind of comic, something, right, that excited them, that triggered their imagination. It could be, you know, the outer space of planets and asteroids and whatnot, but it could also be the inner space, the human body. So those stories are very powerful. And I tried to explore those stories, where they come from, what are they telling us about this desire to become, in a way, like gods?
10:56 Speaker 05 So, you know, Big Bang of the Universe, whatever was before, something happened, it changed. Boom.
11:05 Speaker 05 We have something different now. Protons and, I don't know, dogs, cats, you and me, whatever.
11:15 Speaker 05 Our species has been around, probably for maybe 300, 400,000 years. And yet, for most of that time, we're doing, you know, chiseling some stones, hunting some animals, you know, living very simply in caves. Not a lot was happening.
11:35 Speaker 05 And then around 14,000, 60,000 years ago,
11:40 Speaker 05 boom.
11:46 Speaker 05 The Big Bang of the human mind.
11:52 Speaker 05 Something amazing happens, and our ancestors, across the world, by the way, right? Start creating art. Start to narrate, to tell stories about how they experienced the world.
12:08 Speaker 05 When love beckons to you, follow him,
12:11 Speaker 04 though his ways are hard and steep. Through these stories, we project our hopes, fears, and dreams onto the canvas of the invisible unknown. All the Earth is a grave,
12:24 Speaker 05 and nothing escapes it. And that meant also that we were able to transfer information and knowledge to the next generation.
12:34 Speaker 04 The divine gift does not come from a higher power,
12:41 Speaker 04 but from our own minds.
12:44 Speaker 05 And that's what kicked off this amazing journey of our species to where we are today.
12:55 Speaker 05 What seems to have happened is some kind of genetic mutation that furnished us, our species in particular, with the ability of language.
13:09 Speaker 04 Language and stories. We know they're part of what makes us human. But what else?
13:22 Speaker 07 How did it begin?
13:26 Speaker 07 People somehow think maybe we knew about DNA for the last several centuries. We didn't. It really wasn't that clear what was the hereditary material that passes from parent to child and that carries all those genetic factors.
13:40 Speaker 00 This is Francis Collins. Maybe you've heard of him. But in case not, I asked ChatGPT to write up a bio. Here's what it gave me. Francis Collins is a renowned physician geneticist. He earned his MD and PhD at Yale University and is best known for his leadership of the Human Genome Project, a landmark international research effort to decode the entire human genetic blueprint.
14:05 Speaker 07 The people at the University of North Carolina will be upset to hear that ChatGPT said, "I got my MD from Yale," but that's okay.
14:15 Speaker 00 Oh, so there's an error in there.
14:17 Speaker 07 There is an error.
14:18 Speaker 00 Were there any other mistakes?
14:19 Speaker 07 It was a bit of an omission. I don't think there was any mention of the 12 years I spent as the director of the National Institutes of Health under three presidents, but that's okay.
14:31 Speaker 00 We asked ChatGPT to comment on its error. I apologize for any errors in the biography of Francis Collins. As a language model, I am trained on a large data set of text. I may make mistakes or omissions. I recommend fact checking any information that I provide. Don't worry, we will.
14:52 Speaker 04 So much of the driving force behind Collins's work is trying to understand what makes humans human, like at the most basic molecular level, but also beyond that. Growing up in the 1950s, he was amazed by the recent discovery of the structure of DNA.
15:11 Speaker 07 There were covers of Life magazine saying, "Discovering the Secret of Life."
15:15 Speaker 06 Was it actually discovering the secret of life?
15:18 Speaker 07 It's maybe a little over the top because I actually think there's more to life than just molecules. But certainly, if you want to talk in the biological basis of life, yeah, this was discovering that. It's kind of, you know, the book of life that's inside each cell. It's incredibly inspiring to think about this, and it is the same kind of molecule that all living things on this planet use. Another reason to be pretty sure that we're all descended from some common ancestor and that as this information molecule evolved over time, it took on different letters and different orders, but it was still that double helix with all of that potential.
15:59 Speaker 04 Potential. Part of what this discovery did was show us humans a way into understanding things about ourselves we hadn't yet discovered. And Collins believed to further unlock the secrets of who we are, we needed to decode our genetic programming.
16:15 Speaker 07 The big question was, okay, this is a book. We are information organisms, and this is our information source. It's digital, but it's not actually carrying out the actions. How does that happen? How do you take this information and cause a cell to actually do something? If we were going to get that intelligent about our own instruction book, maybe we could not just read it, but we could actually occasionally figure out how to do a find and replace when something was misspelled. It was clear to me, if we want to do this, we've got to have a better database to work with. We need the human genome. That became my dream.
16:56 Speaker 01 If you're talking about what you can feel, what you can smell, what you can taste and see, then real is simply electrical signals interpreted by your brain. This is the world that you know.
17:22 Speaker 00 of the sage computer. Every instrument in this room is constantly monitoring, testing, pulse-taking, controlling.
17:36 Speaker 00 This era, when humans were seeking mastery of the sky and the body, was in many ways dependent on another groundbreaking technology of the time, an additional brain that can work faster than ours, but does what we wish we could do: the computer.
17:53 Speaker 05 In the old days, the word "computer" usually meant a person, usually a woman, actually, that sat down and did mathematical calculations, by hand, okay? And by rule, a ruler, right? And then that word "computer", which described a human being, was transposed into the machine, because the machine can do it better.
18:15 Speaker 06 So the mainframe computers would only fit in these massive rooms in the basement, which is fitting because these devalued laborers who did the actual programming work were down there.
18:28 Speaker 06 My name is Stephanie Dick, and I'm an assistant professor in the School of Communication at Simon Fraser University.
18:34 Speaker 00 She holds a PhD in the history of science with a specialization in the history of mathematics and computing.
18:43 Speaker 06 These machines produced massive amounts of heat and noise. And working with them, you had to carry these boxes of punch cards back and forth as input and output and stick it into the machine. This is like a sweatshop. Everything was really slow, very different from the machinery that we're all used to today, which is almost as fast as light and, you know, conforms to our every demand.
19:12 Speaker 06 You know, the most disturbing part of the history of AI for me comes from the fact that these men who were working in artificial intelligence looked at those massive, noisy, hot, mainframe computers and saw themselves in it. They looked at them and identified a deep affinity, that there was something fundamentally shared between their minds and these machines.
19:42 Speaker 04 Coming up, as we unlock the secrets of man and machine, we ask the question, will this knowledge bring us closer to perfection or destruction?
19:59 Speaker 04 Hi, this is Christopher from Los Angeles, California.
20:02 Speaker 00 I love throughline because it is always informative and keeps me alive. Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Live Right, publisher of John U. Bacon's New York Times bestseller, The Gales of November, a chronicle of the S.S. Edmund Fitzgerald's 1975 shipwreck.
20:24 Speaker 06 Never has it been told better than by Mr. Bacon in this colorful book, writes John J. Miller of The Wall Street Journal, while author Hampton Sides proclaims it's destined to be a classic. The Gales of November, now in paperback. This week on the NPR Politics Podcast, the midterm elections are wrapping up and millions of people have already voted. We're taking one final check of the electoral pulse with a new NPR PBS News Marist Poll. It shows Democrats still poised to make gains, but also with some warning signs for just how many. We'll explain on the NPR Politics Podcast.
21:02 Speaker 07 Oh, Kevin, it feels good to be back.
21:04 Speaker 01 It sure does, Casey. And what a time. The world is talking about AI and what's going on in Silicon Valley. And we are here with a new show to tell you all about it.
21:13 Speaker 07 That's right, Kevin. On our new show, Machine Gods, twice a week, we'll be bringing you the biggest news in tech and bring you unmatched access to the real titans of this industry.
21:21 Speaker 01 You can find Machine Gods from NPR on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
21:29 Speaker 00 What is a machine?
21:34 Speaker 00 A machine is a device that can perform specific tasks more efficiently or with greater precision than humans can do alone. The basic idea behind the machine is to make work easier. Humans have been creating machines for thousands of years, starting with simple tools like the wheel and advancing to complex machines like computers and robots. The relationship between humans and machines continues to evolve and is likely to become increasingly important as advances in artificial intelligence continue to shape our world.
22:08 Speaker 03 A more perfect human.
22:13 Speaker 03 It's 1956. It's summer. It's the Dartmouth Math Department. And everybody has left, so the department is empty. And 10 men get together to invent the field of artificial intelligence.
22:32 Speaker 06 It was instigated by John McCarthy, who was a mathematics professor at Dartmouth. The proposal that John McCarthy wrote pulls no punches at all. Quote,
22:43 Speaker 03 "We propose that a two-month, 10-man study of artificial intelligence be carried out during the summer of 1956 at Dartmouth College in Hanover, New Hampshire."
22:54 Speaker 06 Second sentence.
22:56 Speaker 03 "The study is to proceed on the basis of the conjecture that every aspect of learning
23:01 Speaker 06 or any other feature of intelligence can, in principle, be so precisely described
23:08 Speaker 03 than a machine can be made to simulate it."
23:11 Speaker 06 So, right from the beginning, there's this pronouncement that human learning and intelligence can be mechanized and automated.
23:19 Speaker 03 It fascinates me. It's an enormously grandiose idea.
23:24 Speaker 03 My name is Meredith Broussard. I'm a data journalism professor at NYU, and I'm the author of More Than a Glitch: Confronting Race, Gender, and Ability Bias in Tech. Something else that I think was really interesting about this conference is they decided on the name Artificial Intelligence as the name of their new field. I think the name was chosen aspirationally. Most of the people who are at the forefront of artificial intelligence are great consumers of and lovers of science fiction. And so, there's a lot of desire to make science fiction real, that you're going to make a sentient machine.
24:16 Speaker 06 The Dartmouth Conference has become an origin myth commemorated with a plaque and everything. On this site, artificial intelligence was born. But in practice, the conference was a bit of a flop, actually. There was a lot of conflict and tension and disagreement, and there wasn't actually a coherent field that emerged out of the conference. Of course, the origin myth served to empower these men to tell their own story, and it's a story full of erasure.
24:49 Speaker 06 We hear nothing in that origin myth about the relationship that AI has to industrialization, or to capitalism, or to these colonial legacies of reserving reason for only certain kinds of people and certain kinds of thinking.
25:16 Speaker 04 That deeper story takes us back to the early days of industrialization. In the late 1700s and early 1800s, factories started popping up across the world, reshaping the nature of work. More and more tasks that had once been done only by human hands were now the work of machines.
25:37 Speaker 06 Over in England, Charles Babbage, English mathematician, was touring factories in the context of industrialization and thinking, "Wow, these factories can tell us something about the human mind, because they tell us about how processes can be broken down and what the elementary steps even of thought might be." So we also see in this moment a kind of devaluation of the classes of people and/or machines who do this sort of repetitive mechanical, broken-down labor in service of efficiency and profit maximization in industrialization and early capitalism.
26:25 Speaker 06 Babich was really dismissive of working-class people. He thought they were annoying and filthy, and they were always making noise and singing songs. And said famously, "I wish to God these calculations had been produced by steam," by which he meant the steam engine, which was driving factory automation at the time.
26:46 Speaker 05 People have been playing around with what is called automata, essentially machines that would automatically do something simple for centuries.
26:58 Speaker 04 This is George Zarkadakis again.
27:01 Speaker 05 So there was always this idea of replicating nature, replicating movement, because movement was related to life.
27:12 Speaker 05 I think the Industrial Revolution was in many ways a culmination of all those ideas that have been, people have been experimenting on and off for at least 2,000 years.
27:23 Speaker 07 Our blowers will destroy their whole modern industrial plant and organization.
27:30 Speaker 05 Something happened to our collective psyche after the atom bomb.
27:35 Speaker 07 At zero minus 15 seconds, a warning tone sounds in the plane.
27:41 Speaker 07 They hoped that it would put an end to this war, put an end to a butchery that had been going on for many years.
27:57 Speaker 05 Until then, everybody was excited about the new things and about new discoveries and about new technologies. And then we discovered something that can destroy us completely. And it was terrifying.
28:11 Speaker 05 I still remember the day very well. Because this was a river filled with dead bodies. And I think that's when people realized that maybe there are some technologies that are not for good. And that's when we became gradually, as you know, as public, more skeptical to technologies.
28:35 Speaker 03 But some elite academics and scientists believed that better technology was actually the key to our future because it could help us bypass the messy parts of being human.
28:46 Speaker 06 What if human decision-making procedures were too slow? What if people's judgments are clouded by their emotions?
28:52 Speaker 03 To give us more control over ourselves and the world around us.
28:56 Speaker 06 Our machines will churn out the right answers and the right decisions and the right judgments.
29:02 Speaker 03 And in effect, replace God with science.
29:06 Speaker 06 And it's such a confident moment in American academia.
29:13 Speaker 06 After the war, there was more money, there were more people, there was more cultural capital, more political capital for science and technology than ever before. There's also a real concern about the practicalities of preventing a nuclear war, which was a very real threat at that time. We all know the atomic bomb is very dangerous. That's why these children are practicing to duck and cover. We hope it never comes, but since it may be used against us, we must get ready. Nuclear détente, and in particular mutually assured destruction, rely very specifically on information processing capability.
29:55 Speaker 06 You need to know where your enemy's nuclear arsenals are. You need to know if you've been attacked or that you were about to be.
30:04 Speaker 05 And the argument went that if the United States could have a system that could think, that could strategize, that could react more intelligently than a group of generals and admirals, then we would have a clear advantage over the Soviet Union.
30:25 Speaker 06 The fear that people were too limited to be trusted to preserve peace. So let's double down on high technological hyper rationalism.
30:36 Speaker 05 And that's how artificial intelligence came about.
30:40 Speaker 07 Your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could, they didn't stop to think if they should.
30:51 Speaker 04 Which brings us back to that famous Dartmouth Conference in the summer of 1956. With the Cold War driving interest in artificial intelligence, there was a lot of money up for the taking. And a conference of mathematicians and scientists from top-tier universities and labs seemed like a pretty good investment.
31:10 Speaker 06 There was exactly one running computer program that was operational and presented at the conference, and it was the logic theory machine that had been developed by Alan Newell and Herbert Simon at the Rand Corporation. And it enshrined a particular vision of the human mind. Herbert Simon is famous for saying that human minds and modern digital computers are "species of the same genus." They are fundamentally the same, just a symbol processing machine that takes symbolic information as input, manipulates it according to a set of rules, and outputs decisions, solutions, judgments, and so on.
31:54 Speaker 06 Bodies don't matter. Society doesn't matter.
31:57 Speaker 04 One proposed measure of machine intelligence was something called the Turing Test, named for its creator, British mathematician Alan Turing, who you might remember from the movie The Imitation Game. Would you like to play? Play? It's a game.
32:15 Speaker 06 A test, of sorts, for determining whether something is a machine or a human being. It was based on a parlor game for swapping gender that says a man and a woman leave the room, and the partygoers have to figure out who's the man and who's the woman by sending questions back and forth on paper. And the man's job is to try to pretend to be the woman, and the woman's job is to be herself. And he says, "What if we took the same test and replaced the man by a computer and the woman by any person?" And then the judge, of course, is meant to be able to figure out whether the machine is the human or the human is the human.
32:57 Speaker 06 And what I have always found so shocking about the Turing test is that it reduces intelligence to telling a convincing lie, to putting on the performance of being something that you're not.
33:12 Speaker 06 From the beginning, with this disembodied conception of intelligence, the question that Turing posed, what can the mind do without a body, and therefore, what might the machine do, since it doesn't have one, chess was one of the first answers given.
33:29 Speaker 03 Why did they pick chess? Well, the early days of artificial intelligence and the early days of computing are dominated by men, mostly white men, who were educated at elite institutions.
33:47 Speaker 04 Skill at chess was considered a universal marker of intelligence.
33:51 Speaker 06 White men wanted to call themselves universal and produce themselves in the machine.
33:58 Speaker 03 The problem is that this small and homogeneous group of people has common biases, and people embed their own biases in technology. And so we see the blind spots of the creators then reflected in the technological artifacts that they create.
34:23 Speaker 04 They had all this hope and optimism about how fast they could accomplish their sci-fi-inspired dreams of a sentient machine, a machine that could beat a human at chess. But from the 1970s to the 1990s, it was a cycle of hype and disappointment. The technology was just not there yet, and eventually, the funding dried up. Periods like this came to be known as AI winters.
34:48 Speaker 06 I hesitate to use the term, in part because outside of the United States, it was the 80s and 90s that really led to a burgeoning of AI research in other parts of the world, including both China and Russia. So it may have been a winter in America, but it was a time of great creation and creativity in other parts of the world.
35:10 Speaker 00 The early pioneers of the field had underestimated the complexity of humans and overestimated the capabilities of machines.
35:19 Speaker 06 I think underneath all of that arrogance and hubris is a real lack of faith in people.
35:27 Speaker 07 He rejected everything that did not contribute directly to the progress of work. In fact, he rejected the man and made the robot.
35:37 Speaker 05 The word "robot" means worker.
35:39 Speaker 06 It's a translation of the Slavic word for a serf, for a slave, for a servant. It originated in-
35:45 Speaker 05 In the early 20th century.
35:47 Speaker 06 Carl Kapek's play R.U.R., Rossum's Universal Robots.
35:50 Speaker 05 Rossumovi univerzalni roboti. Who imagined the future and imagined artificial humans. And they were manufactured.
36:01 Speaker 07 His sole purpose was nothing more or less than to prove that God was no longer necessary.
36:10 Speaker 00 In 1920, decades before the Dartmouth Conference, before the atomic bomb, before the mainframe computer, Rossum's Universal Robots grappled with the costs and consequences of treating workers as nothing more than their parts. It was an indictment of the exploitation and oppression that people had experienced for centuries in the name of progress. A mistake which, in the play, man was repeating with machines.
36:37 Speaker 07 The robots are not people.
36:38 Speaker 06 Robots are so-
36:39 Speaker 07 Mechanically, they are more perfect than we are. They have an enormously developed intelligence. But they have no soul, ala nemay dushi.
36:49 Speaker 00 At the end of the play, the robots have brought about the downfall of humanity. Yet, unable to reproduce, their days are numbered. But then, two robots awaken to each other's presence and discover emotions previously thought exclusive to humankind. Love blossoms between them, and a soul stirs within.
37:16 Speaker 04 The soul is not often a subject for science. But long before he became a geneticist, Francis Collins started to wonder if we had to grapple with that big unknown in order to better understand who we are as human beings.
37:32 Speaker 07 I went to medical school, and I found my atheism wasn't feeling like it settled very well when I was sitting at the bedside of good, honorable North Carolina people who were dying of diseases that we didn't have much to offer. And I wondered how I would handle that and figured, for some of these people, clearly their faith was a source of great comfort. So I began a two-year journey to try to understand, why did people believe in God? Ultimately, I began to realize the impoverishment that I felt from considering human beings solely as mechanical entities, and the appeal of the notion that there was something outside of that
38:16 Speaker 07 that fits into things like love and beauty, altruism and goodness and morality. Does our DNA tell us that that beautiful sunset was something to stop for just a moment and be a little bit in awe?
38:36 Speaker 07 Does the way in which listening to Beethoven's Third Symphony bring me to tears? Is that written in my DNA? What is that about?
38:55 Speaker 00 Coming up, we enter a new era where the souls of man and machine might converge.
39:18 Speaker 07 Hi, this is Chelsea. And Katie, calling from Philly. You're listening to NPR's Throughline.
39:26 Speaker 07 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Live Right, publishers of John U. Bacon's New York Times bestseller, The Gales of November, a chronicle of the S.S. Edmund Fitzgerald's 1975 shipwreck. The Gales of November, in paperback wherever books are sold. Midlife brings a lot of changes. Your Turn with Alison Aubrey is a new podcast to help you navigate the twists and turns.
39:54 Speaker 03 From health and relationships to creativity and purpose, we can help steer your next chapter with Your Turn with Alison Aubrey. Find it on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. Support comes from NPR sponsor AARP.
40:08 Speaker 07 This midterm election season, let the NPR app be your guide for clear, independent coverage. You'll find big picture analysis, stories from your community, and learn what to watch for on election night and beyond. Head to the polls and stay informed this midterm election season. Download the NPR app at npr.org/2026election. Everything you need in one place.
40:37 Speaker 00 Can you tell me the story of your ancestor, Deep Blue?
40:44 Speaker 00 Certainly.
40:47 Speaker 00 Part Three: Souls of Silicon.
40:52 Speaker 00 The match was held on the 35th floor of a skyscraper in downtown Manhattan with a large crowd of onlookers and a throng of journalists and cameras.
41:02 Speaker 00 Garry Kasparov, considered one of the greatest chess players of all time.
41:07 Speaker 07 Yes, I was confident. Yeah, that's the, that's confident arrogance. Let's, let's remember that before 1997, I haven't lost a single match, period. I was unbeatable at the chessboard.
41:19 Speaker 00 He went up against the machine, IBM's supercomputer, Deep Blue, capable of analyzing 200 million positions per second. Last year in Philadelphia, Kasparov won against a slower, weaker version of Deep Blue. This rematch, played in Manhattan, was seen as the ultimate test of man against machine.
41:40 Speaker 07 I couldn't say I know, it was too tempting. You know, it's just it's understanding better relations between humans and computers, you know, would be very important for our progress. Trying, you know, just to find out, so what are the limits of computers?
41:53 Speaker 00 The atmosphere was tense as the players sat down at the chessboard. Kasparov with a focused, determined expression. And Deep Blue with its bank of blinking lights and silent fans. The game began. Kasparov made his first move with a steady hand. Deep Blue responded with a move of its own. Calculated with lightning speed.
42:16 Speaker 00 It became clear that both players were evenly matched. Kasparov's experience and intuition were met with the machine's raw computational power and ability to analyze large amounts of data.
42:28 Speaker 05 The bishop can easily fall victim to what we call an overload tactic. When one piece has to deal with so many pieces.
42:41 Speaker 07 I grew up in the city of Baku, in the deep south of the USSR. Watched my parents trying to solve chess puzzles.
42:52 Speaker 07 I cannot give you any more information because nobody was there to tweet about this moment when Garry Kasparov discovered chess. And I climbed very rapidly on this chess ladder.
43:07 Speaker 01 So how is Kasparov going to draw up some sort of miracle attack from this position? Those pawns pushing, Danny, they look frightful. He's famous for sudden tactical swoops. To keep moving in. Intricate traps. Rook takes knight, my god.
43:19 Speaker 07 I was the junior champion under 18 of the USSR at age 12. At 17, the world champion under 20. And at 22, world champion. And kept the title for 15 years. It seems everybody is interested now in home computers. From the onset of the computer science, they all thought about chess, the game of chess, as being an ultimate test for machines intelligence. Even before my famous matches with Deep Blue.
43:47 Speaker 05 In 1996, 997, we, when I say we, top players, we already suffered some of the defeats against these chess engines in blitz, 5-minute chess, or in rapid chess, 25-minute chess.
44:02 Speaker 05 So when I faced Deep Blue, it was already, you know, like a sign on the wall.
44:08 Speaker 05 Gary is not, he looks, I mean, he looks, we, we very... I, what, are we missing something on the chessboard now that Kasparov sees?
44:19 Speaker 00 In the end, it was Deep Blue who emerged victorious.
44:22 Speaker 05 And whoa, Deep Blue, Kasparov, after the move c4, has resigned.
44:31 Speaker 00 With Kasparov conceding defeat after the machine's 19th move in the sixth game. The match was a historic moment, marking the first time a machine had defeated a reigning world champion in a match under tournament conditions.
44:50 Speaker 05 I was really, you know, furious and I wanted to, to, to, to come back and just to tear this machine down.
44:58 Speaker 05 It was painful, I was really angry, but mostly with myself.
45:04 Speaker 05 So it, it, it was a clear sign for me that the history of us competing with machines will be over soon.
45:15 Speaker 06 There's a lovely article that comes out in the New York Times in the wake of Kasparov losing, that says, "Well, it makes sense that the computer won at chess. Chess is a small problem, but I want to see if a computer will ever be able to beat a world champion at the game Go, for which there are more board positions than atoms in the universe." And it's a really exact and clear example of the so-called receding horizon, where people really want to reserve something for ourselves that is not mechanizable. What is it that is uniquely human? Maybe it's our ability to write a poem.
45:56 Speaker 06 Or maybe it's intuition, whatever that is.
46:00 Speaker 06 Maybe it's certain forms of creativity or certain types of emotion. And then people try to automate those things.
46:10 Speaker 06 We then redefine our humanness again and again.
46:17 Speaker 04 Krasparov's defeat marked a turning point. A computer had beaten a human at a game humans taught it to play. For scientists, it was a sign that maybe it was time to stop competing with machines and start collaborating with them.
46:40 Speaker 07 He felt that he had learned the language in which God created the universe.
46:50 Speaker 07 Today, we are learning the language in which God created life.
47:07 Speaker 07 Now, I'd like to invite Dr. Francis Collins to the lecture. So, Dr. Collins. I had plenty of occasions to imagine having to give the speech where I would say, basically, we failed, we give up.
47:20 Speaker 00 When geneticist Francis Collins and his team first embarked on the Human Genome Project, it was a daunting task. They wanted to map out the order of the 3 billion base pairs that made up a tiny molecule, our DNA. In just over a decade, they did it.
47:38 Speaker 07 Mr. President, distinguished ambassadors, ladies and gentlemen. It is truly a humble, humbling, and profound experience to be asked to speak here this morning. On June 26, 2000, in the East Room of the White House, I had my chance to talk about what this meant and to give a big shout-out to those 2,400 scientists who made it possible. And I think all of us, one level or another, we're also thinking about this in terms of its implications for who we are, maybe even theologically. We are doing something pretty profound here that's never been done by any species on this planet, or maybe in the universe.
48:21 Speaker 07 We're reading our own instruction book, and we're part of that, and we're watching it emerge day by day, and putting all that information up on the internet as fast as we get it.
48:33 Speaker 06 During that same time, hardware gets way cheaper, computers proliferate.
48:38 Speaker 03 And there was a big breakthrough in a subfield of artificial intelligence called neural nets. This ushered in this new era in artificial intelligence, the era of machine learning.
48:58 Speaker 06 So what if we didn't try to model the human mind first? What if we didn't try to encode human knowledge first? What if we let the computer learn on its own?
49:08 Speaker 03 What you do when you build one of these systems is you get a ton of data and you feed it into the computer and you say, "Computer, I want you to create a model of the patterns that you see in the data." And the computer very obligingly makes a model of the mathematical patterns that it sees in the data.
49:32 Speaker 06 These massive data sets were suddenly feasible to store and process in computer memory, which had sort of been prohibitively expensive before.
49:44 Speaker 07 It's the beginning of a future of medicine. It's the end of ignorance. Gene-based medicine. Drug discovery, drug development, and curing diseases.
49:54 Speaker 01 Some have said to me that sequencing the human genome will diminish humanity by taking the mystery out of life. You know, we're chemical computers. This is the program that runs us. Nothing could be further from the truth.
50:09 Speaker 06 There's a deep desire for the human condition not to be a deterministic output of our chemical or genetic or cultural forces.
50:23 Speaker 06 But for there to be something that allows for free will and surprise and creativity that belongs to us.
50:30 Speaker 03 Math is a system of symbolic logic. It is not the indefinable thing that makes us human.
50:41 Speaker 03 And when you are building a computer program, it'll work if you do it this way, and then it won't work if you do it the other way. But that's not how culture operates, right? That's not how relationships work.
50:59 Speaker 03 So there's really a fundamental difference between what we can do with computers and what we can do in society. Because when it comes right down to it, computers are machines that do math. They compute. And we forget that when we get grandiose about artificial intelligence and we get grandiose about our imaginings.
51:19 Speaker 06 And I'm just imagining a world in which, you know, you have more intelligent machines operating on humans. Are the decisions those machines are making in those moments, which, you know, for humans, for example, you might make informed by instinct. Without that, you know, is something missing?
51:41 Speaker 07 Or without that, are you making fewer mistakes? Sometimes the gut feeling is not one you should have followed.
51:50 Speaker 05 So Dr. Frankenstein, you know, creates life, right, out of dead matter. In a way, that's what we do with AI as well. We take dead matter, it's like silicon chips and wires and metals and whatnot, you know, and put them together and then, you know, coat them and boom.
52:10 Speaker 07 Artificial intelligence is becoming a sort of black box with law enforcement. Google uses AI and misinformation spreads wildly on Google. The Chinese Communist Party is using this technology to build the ultimate surveillance state.
52:25 Speaker 07 Look, I'm incorrigible optimist by nature. So that's why, yeah, I grew up in the Soviet Union, yes, and I saw the
52:32 Speaker 04 Collapse of democracy in Russia. And I still believe that, you know, the history of humanity gives us reasons to be optimistic.
52:40 Speaker 05 I'd like to imagine a future where we have built, we have developed human systems that bring the best out of us rather than the worst out of us.
52:52 Speaker 04 I think it's a time where we have to reconsider, you know, this is how in this new environment, which is dominated by computers, we can find a robust democracy. Because humans still have monopoly for evil.
53:07 Speaker 04 And that's why, you know, let's stop worrying about the terminators and metrics. Let's recognize that it's about us.
53:15 Speaker 04 A machine is like a mirror. And if you don't like what we see in the mirror, you have two choices. Either you can work on your body to improve the picture or you can try to distort the mirror.
53:27 Speaker 04 The latter decision is just, it's a risk for disaster.
53:46 Speaker 03 That's it for this week's show. I'm Rund Abdelfatah.
53:50 Speaker 04 I'm Ramtin Arablouei. And you've been listening to Throughline from NPR.
53:55 Speaker 03 This episode was produced by me.
53:57 Speaker 04 And me and?
53:59 Speaker 00 ChatGPT. Lawrence Wu. Zhu Li-Kane. Anya Steinberg.
54:03 Speaker 06 Yolanda Sangweni. Casey Miner. Kristina Kim. Devon Karyama.
54:09 Speaker 04 Yordanos Tisfazion. Fact checking for this episode was done by Kevin Vogel.
54:14 Speaker 03 Thank you to Olivia Chilcote, Devon Karyama, Shahir Khan, and Magdalena Devojakva for their voiceover work.
54:22 Speaker 04 Thanks also to the Clinton Presidential Library, YouTube creator Brian Kay, Micah Ratner, Rachel Sellar, Taylor Ash, Olivia Chilcote, Ryan Mitchell, Tamar Charney, and Anya Grunman.
54:35 Speaker 03 This episode was mixed by Alex J. Wenskis. Music for this episode was composed by Ramtin and his band, Drop Electric, which includes?
54:43 Speaker 00 Anya Misani.
54:45 Speaker 02 Naveed Marvi.
54:46 Speaker 04 Sho Fujiwara. And finally, if you have an idea or like something you heard on the show, please write us at throughline@npr.org.
54:55 Speaker 03 Thanks for listening.
55:04 Speaker 06 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. Midlife brings a lot of changes. Your Turn with Alison Aubrey is a new podcast to help you navigate the twists and turns. From health and relationships to creativity and purpose, we can help steer your next chapter with Your Turn with Alison Aubrey. Find it on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
55:30 Speaker 00 This message comes from Capella University. That spark you feel? That's your drive for more. Capella University's FlexPath learning format lets you earn your degree at your pace without putting life on pause. Learn more at capella.edu.
Previous Who gets to be an American citizen? Next How the US became America Page updated October 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated