Pod Insights Throughline The Lord Of Misrule (Throwback) About this episode By the time his book went to press in London, on November 18, 1633, Thomas Morton had been exiled from the Puritan colonies in Massachusetts. His crimes: drinking, carousing, and — crucially — building social and economic ties with Native people. His book outlined a vision for what America could become. A very different vision than that of the Puritans.
But the book wouldn't be published that day. It wouldn't be published for years. Because agents for the Puritan colonists stormed the press and destroyed every copy.
Today on the show, the story of what's widely considered America's first banned book, the radical vision it conjured, and the man who outlined that vision: Thomas Morton, the Lord of Misrule.
To access bonus episodes and listen to Throughline sponsor-free, subscribe to Throughline+ via Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org/throughline http://plus.npr.org/throughline.
See pcm.adswizz.com https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.
NPR Privacy Policy https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 At NPR, there's a little something for everyone. If you need advice for that big life change, try listening to Life Kit. If you want to know more about that new TV show, check out Pop Culture Happy Hour. And if you want to dive deeper into your favorite podcasts and enjoy perks like bonus episodes, archive access, and more, check out NPR Plus. Find out more and support the shows you love at plus.npr.org.
1:02 Speaker 01 In the year since the incarnation of Christ, 1622, it was my chance to be landed in the parts of New England where I found two sorts of people: the one Christians, the other infidels. These I found most full of humanity.
1:20 Speaker 02 It's the 1630s, and a man named Thomas Morton sits down to write a book, a book that almost changed America's origin story.
1:33 Speaker 01 If this land be not rich, then is the whole world poor?
1:37 Speaker 02 Morton journeyed across the Atlantic Ocean to New Plymouth, Massachusetts.
1:42 Speaker 01 The more I looked, the more I liked it.
1:45 Speaker 02 Except the pilgrims had gotten there first and had already set up one of North America's first European colonies. And Morton, by the time he writes his book, had already been kicked out of New England twice.
1:58 Speaker 01 The separatists, envying the prosperity and hope of the plantation at Merrymount, conspired together against mine host.
2:07 Speaker 02 The book tells his story.
2:10 Speaker 01 And made up a party against him, and mustered up what aid they could, accounting of him as of a great monster.
2:27 Speaker 02 On November 18th, 1633, the book went to the press in London.
2:36 Speaker 02 The title of that book was New English Canaan.
2:41 Speaker 03 As it's being printed.
2:42 Speaker 04 Full of lies and slanders and fraught with profane columnnes against their names and persons. And ye ways of God.
2:51 Speaker 03 The agents of the New England people go to the press.
2:56 Speaker 03 And they literally stopped the publication of it.
3:01 Speaker 03 And they destroy it.
3:08 Speaker 03 Sometimes we look at the past and we think it's all inevitable. What happened had to happen. And we forget how much individuals shaped what happened.
3:18 Speaker 02 This is Peter Mankell.
3:20 Speaker 03 I'm a historian of early America at the University of Southern California.
3:24 Speaker 02 And he wrote a book called The Trials of Thomas Morton: An Anglican Lawyer, His Puritan Foes, and the Battle for a New England.
3:33 Speaker 03 Central characters in this story, in the national story, are the pilgrims who go to Plymouth and the Puritans who go to Massachusetts Bay. And I think like anyone raised, reading American history, they had this very privileged position in American myth, American lore. And it was often tied in with the idea that, especially with the pilgrims, that they have come seeking religious freedom.
4:02 Speaker 02 A lot of us know that story isn't as clean as the textbooks say it is. But we're rarely taught just how contested the vision for early America was. Even the pilgrims and Puritans themselves disagreed about how to colonize America. There was and is no single story of the birth of this country. And the book that Thomas Morton wrote offered a very different version of what that very bloody beginning could have looked like.
4:31 Speaker 03 What became the very destructive relations between Europeans and Native Americans didn't have to happen.
4:37 Speaker 01 They died on heaps as they lay in their houses.
4:40 Speaker 03 People chose that course to happen.
4:44 Speaker 01 For in a place where many inhabited, there hath been but one left alive to tell what became of the rest.
4:53 Speaker 03 These were choices, not the sort of unmovable laws of history.
5:02 Speaker 02 Choices we are still reckoning with.
5:08 Speaker 02 Way before today's book bans, way before laws restricting what history can be taught in schools, there were people in America trying to suppress ideas and silence dissent. And at its core, it was a battle over what narrative and whose story would define what America is. The English colonists who arrived on Massachusetts shores went to great lengths to make sure their version of America would win. But one man, an outlier named Thomas Morton, stood in their way. This is a story of what could have been, a different version of America. On this episode of Throughline from NPR, the story of what's widely considered
5:50 Speaker 02 to be America's first banned book, the man who wrote that book, and the people who tried to stop him.
6:01 Speaker 05 This is Samuel Choi from San Diego, California. You're listening to Throughline from NPR.
6:09 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
6:13 Speaker 06 This message comes from Leaf Filter. You need to clean your gutters before they become a bigger, more costly issue. So let the pros at Leaf Filter handle that for you. You'll get a free gutter inspection and a no obligation estimate, plus a lifetime warranty and no clog guarantee. Right now, you can get up to 35% off when you go to leafffilter.com/npr. Restrictions apply. See rep for warranty and promotion details.
6:40 Speaker 07 Maya Higa built an animal sanctuary that's closed to the public but welcomes thousands of online visitors every day. All the silly things that animals do when we aren't looking, or when they think we're not looking, we can watch on the live cams. Ideas about understanding wild animals without getting in their way. That's on the TED Radio Hour podcast. Listen on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
7:04 Speaker 00 When it comes to the concept of IQ, who gets to be smart? President Trump and Silicon Valley are obsessed with measuring intelligence. But if AI is the ultimate
7:13 Speaker 07 Superintelligence, where does that leave the rest of us? I'm Brittany Luce. And I'm BA Parker. And together, we're exploring the history of intelligence testing. And the parameters around smarts, knowledge, and race. Listen to It's Been a Minute. And Code Switch. On the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
7:32 Speaker 02 Part one, Ghosts of the Clearing.
7:38 Speaker 02 It is a warm night in Massachusetts. The year is 1628.
7:51 Speaker 02 A group of men from one of England's first permanent American colonies, New Plymouth, are out on a hunt.
8:02 Speaker 02 They methodically cut through the shrubs, trees, and bushes in their way. They step over creeks. Their cotton shirts and pants are damp from the summer humidity.
8:15 Speaker 02 They're armed with at least one sword and probably guns. They were sent by their leader, William Bradford, the governor of Plymouth, to find a gathering of people, a threat, deep in the woods.
8:36 Speaker 02 As they journeyed deeper into the forest, the Christian men from Plymouth prepared themselves for what might await. Then I am afraid of evils come. Comfort me, but shall we be dead in myself? I am dying. William Bradford had warned them about what they would find, a rebel community led by a man named Thomas Morton, someone who Bradford later called...
9:01 Speaker 07 Lord of Misrule.
9:03 Speaker 02 Lord of Misrule.
9:05 Speaker 07 Maintained, as it were... A school of atheism.
9:08 Speaker 02 This is scholar Sarah Rivet, reading Bradford's exact words describing Thomas Morton and his followers.
9:16 Speaker 07 And after they had got some goods into their hands, and got much by trading with the Indians,
9:22 Speaker 07 they spent it as vainly in quaffing and drinking, both wine and strong waters in great excess.
9:37 Speaker 02 After hours of searching in the darkness, they finally arrive at a clearing. In front of them stood the rebels they were looking for. And they are shocked by what they see.
10:16 Speaker 04 They encountered crosswinds and many fierce storms by which the ship was mud-shaken and her upper works made very leaky.
10:25 Speaker 02 Eight years earlier, in 1620, about 100 colonists from England arrived in Massachusetts on a cramped wooden ship.
10:33 Speaker 07 Which is the Mayflower.
10:34 Speaker 02 The Mayflower.
10:36 Speaker 04 Having thus passed the vast ocean and that sea of troubles, they now had no friends to welcome them, nor inns to entertain and refresh their weather-beaten bodies.
10:48 Speaker 07 They arrive initially at the tip of Cape Cod. And a group of explorers from the ship go out and they explore the region.
11:01 Speaker 02 This is...
11:02 Speaker 07 Paula Peters.
11:04 Speaker 02 She's an independent scholar who's studied and written extensively about the early history of Massachusetts.
11:10 Speaker 07 My traditional name is Sankwaben. I'm a citizen of the Mashpee-Wampanoag tribe.
11:16 Speaker 02 Paula says that these English colonists from the Mayflower soon found a place to settle.
11:21 Speaker 07 They've encountered a village that is empty.
11:27 Speaker 02 The pilgrims who survived the voyage across the Atlantic Ocean were now determined to create a foothold in the Americas. They called their settlement
11:39 Speaker 02 New Plymouth.
11:42 Speaker 02 The primary vision was religious. They fled from England due to religious persecution. Pilgrims were similar to Puritans, English Protestants who viewed the Church of England as corrupt. And members of both groups came to Massachusetts. But while Puritans thought they could reform the church from within, the pilgrims were more radical. The pilgrims were largely considered separatists. And by separatist, it means that they wanted to separate out from the Church of England.
12:25 Speaker 02 The leader of the pilgrims was a man named William Bradford.
12:29 Speaker 07 William Bradford was one of the leaders who had left England because of the tyranny of the king.
12:43 Speaker 02 Bradford was 30 years old when he landed on Massachusetts shores. He was a stern, religious man who believed that he was on a holy mission.
12:53 Speaker 03 Bradford doesn't like misrule. Bradford likes rule.
12:58 Speaker 02 He came from a wealthy, land-owning family in England. And at a young age, he became inspired by Puritan beliefs. He dedicated himself to the settlement of Massachusetts. He became New Plymouth's governor and documented it all.
13:13 Speaker 03 And we know that because William Bradford, who's the governor and great historian of early Plymouth, writes his history.
13:36 Speaker 04 The place they fixed their thoughts upon was somewhere in those vast and unpeopled countries of America, which were fruitful and fit for habitation.
13:46 Speaker 02 These words are from William Bradford's book, Of Plymouth Plantation.
13:52 Speaker 04 Though devoid of all civilized inhabitants and given over to savages who rage up and down, differing little from the wild beasts themselves.
14:03 Speaker 03 The pilgrims, when they come over, in their rhetorical construction of their arrival, depict themselves as entering into a wilderness.
14:14 Speaker 04 What could they see but a desolate wilderness, full of wild beasts and wild men?
14:19 Speaker 03 And as Bradford would later write about it, they enter into this wilderness, a word he uses more than once, where they're surrounded by hideous beasts and hideous men. So they create this rhetorical moment of descending into this dark wilderness place, filled with menace.
14:49 Speaker 03 Though that's not true.
14:58 Speaker 02 For thousands of years, the area around New Plymouth had been inhabited by native people called the Wampanoag. What you're hearing is their music.
15:12 Speaker 07 There are about 2,000 Wampanoag, and that's a branch of the eastern Algonquian. And they had lived there for over 10,000 years, according to archaeological records. There were at least 69 coastal and inland Wampanoag villages that were thriving.
15:35 Speaker 07 Their livelihood consisted of farming and fishing.
15:39 Speaker 00 And they had a complex cosmology that included responsibility to all living beings.
15:45 Speaker 07 The coastal villages were places where families spent the summers. It was where they did their planting and then whatever they harvested from that would be what would get them through the winter. It was a really vital place.
16:04 Speaker 02 But then.
16:05 Speaker 00 In 1616, there was a plague.
16:21 Speaker 07 It spread terribly quickly from coastal villages in Maine all the way to the tip of Cape Cod.
16:30 Speaker 00 When Bradford and his crew arrived in 1620 on the Mayflower, they literally had to clear skeletons of native people from the land because so many died in this plague.
16:43 Speaker 02 The plague was said to have been brought by European traders and it devastated the Algonquin people, including the Wampanoag.
16:53 Speaker 00 Tens of thousands of eastern Algonquin died as a result of the plague.
16:59 Speaker 02 It became known as the Great Dying.
17:02 Speaker 07 When someone became ill, the families all gathered around that person to pray over them. So that probably made it spread even more quickly. The people just died so quickly that they couldn't even bury their dead.
17:24 Speaker 02 So this is what the pilgrims witnessed when they arrived.
17:28 Speaker 03 They go to a place that is already settled. There are cornfields right there. There are other Europeans who have described this place as a settled place. What a great port this would make if we could eventually come and take this place.
17:40 Speaker 02 The pilgrims met the surviving community of the Wampanoag people. They saw their villages. They knew this was their land, yet.
17:48 Speaker 03 The English see them as impermanent.
17:50 Speaker 02 Impermanent.
17:52 Speaker 03 The pilgrim construction of this is that they are agents of a divine plan. They believed in predestination.
18:00 Speaker 03 For whatever reason, God has sent them out into the wilderness. And they're to go into this place. And they are to live their life as they believe God is telling them to live it.
18:50 Speaker 02 Religion was not the only thing that inspired people to take on the long, treacherous trip from England to Massachusetts. Some came to pursue their desire for bounty and wealth. Even in its infancy, the business of America was ultimately business.
19:08 Speaker 03 About half of the colonists who've gone there aren't going there for religious reasons. They're going there to make money.
19:13 Speaker 02 And the money was in the fur trade.
19:16 Speaker 03 Europeans are obsessed with fur and what you can do with fur. And they're particularly interested in beaver. So there's sort of basically around this time, a real demand for beaver pelts in England and across much of Europe.
19:31 Speaker 02 In 1624, an English colonist arrived in New Plymouth, seeking to make his fortune in the fur trade. His name was Thomas Morton.
19:41 Speaker 03 He's probably born somewhere in the west country of England in the middle of the 1570s. We know that he trained for the law, and he is a lawyer. He doesn't make much of a mark in the historical record until he appears around 1620 in a legal case.
20:00 Speaker 02 That legal case is complicated, full of drama, and extremely petty. Basically, Morton started representing a rich woman whose husband had just died. He was hired to kind of sort out her estate. At some point while representing her, he starts a relationship with her and eventually they marry, which meant that as her new husband, he had access to the money her late husband left behind. Her children were obviously not very happy about that.
20:28 Speaker 03 I mean, they're really at each other. There are allegations of people, you know, shooting weapons and yada, yada, yada. I mean, the level of animosity is very high.
20:38 Speaker 02 Morton battled her children in court for years.
20:41 Speaker 03 And what it tells me about Morton is that Morton doesn't shy away from a fight. And that seems to be the personal characteristic that I take from this legal case that then becomes important through the rest of his life.
20:55 Speaker 02 The case was still ongoing in 1622, but Morton was gone. And not long after, he shows up in New Plymouth.
21:07 Speaker 03 Maybe he's on the lam, right? Maybe he says, okay, it's time for a new phase of my life.
21:13 Speaker 02 Morton was pushing 50 at this point, which for the 1600s is very late to start over. So Morton doesn't waste time. Almost as soon as he arrived.
21:24 Speaker 03 Morton leaves the cluster of pilgrims and he goes down to a sort of failing little trade post.
21:32 Speaker 02 Morton would later call this trade post Marymount.
21:36 Speaker 03 And so he moves in to this tiny little, this little, it almost feels like a clearing in the woods, you know, where they probably thrown up a few, you know, ramshackle cabins. And he gathers a few men around him as far as we can tell, all men, and not very many, like half a dozen guys.
21:54 Speaker 02 They're not very far from New Plymouth.
21:56 Speaker 03 And they decide they're going to make their fortune on the fur trade.
22:00 Speaker 02 Morton basically becomes the leader of Marymount and immediately makes decisions that show he was different from the pilgrims.
22:07 Speaker 03 What Morton figures out very quickly is that he can't succeed unless he establishes really good relations with native peoples. And though he is not. An unreligious person, religion does not seem to be at the forefront of his vision. At the forefront of his vision, and this may sound rather vague, is this idea of respect.
22:29 Speaker 02 Morton seemed to fundamentally respect the native community he was trying to do business with. The pilgrims, on the other hand.
22:37 Speaker 03 They were not as eager to embrace positive relations as Morton seemed to be.
22:43 Speaker 02 William Bradford, the governor of Plymouth, he was certainly not happy about Morton's approach.
22:49 Speaker 03 He singles out Morton for his, what Bradford sees as overly friendly relations with indigenous peoples.
23:03 Speaker 04 In order to maintain this riotous prodigality in excess, Morton, hearing what profit the French and the fishermen had made from trading guns, powder, and shot to the Indians, began to practice it hereabouts, teaching them how to use them.
23:20 Speaker 03 And one of the reasons that Morton comes to the attention of the pilgrims is he's competing with them for basically the supply of beaver to be found in southern New England in the 1620s.
23:33 Speaker 04 And here I must bewail the mischief that this wicked man began in this district, and which, continued by men that should know better, has now become prevalent, notwithstanding the laws to the contrary.
23:47 Speaker 02 Bradford viewed Morton as a sinful, godless man, who was basically a traitor. But he was also just afraid. The pilgrims were vastly outnumbered by the native people.
24:01 Speaker 03 And so when Morton is arming local natives with guns, this to the pilgrims just adds to their sense of doom.
24:19 Speaker 02 Initially, Bradford sent a letter to Morton requesting he stop trading with the native people. According to Bradford, this is how Morton responded.
24:29 Speaker 04 He answered as haughtily as before that the king's proclamation was no law, and asking what was the penalty. That if they came to molest him, let them look to themselves. He would be prepared for them. So they saw there was no way but to take him by force. They resolved to proceed.
24:53 Speaker 04 When I am afraid of evils to come, come for me by showing me that in myself I am dying.
25:03 Speaker 02 Coming up, the pilgrims arrive on Merry Mount.
25:15 Speaker 07 This is Deanne calling from Melbourne, Australia, on the lands of the Yellicott Willam clan of the Bunnarang people. You're listening to Throughline from NPR. Hey, it's Rund. Before we get back to the show, I want to take a quick step back and talk about what makes Throughline and everything you hear from NPR possible. It's you. Think of NPR as civic infrastructure, freely available to everyone. We can do this all thanks to your support. So on behalf of the whole team at Throughline, thank you for diving into history's incredible and complex stories with us each week. And a huge thank you if you already support this work through NPR Plus or by donating to
25:57 Speaker 07 your local station. Your generosity fuels one of the most trusted news sources in America today. If you haven't made the leap to contributing yet, Giving Tuesday is next week, so it's the perfect time to support what you love. Sign up for perks across more than 25 podcasts with NPR Plus today. It's a tax deductible donation that helps make the world a more curious place, so you can feel good about it while you enjoy sponsor-free listening and Throughline's monthly bonus episodes. Join us at plus.npr.org, or you can always make a gift at donate.npr.org. Thank you.
26:39 Speaker 06 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Leaf Filter. You need to clean your gutters before they become a bigger, more costly issue. So let the pros at Leaf Filter handle that for you. You'll get a free gutter inspection and a no obligation estimate, plus a lifetime warranty and no clog guarantee. Right now, you can get up to 35% off when you go to LEAFfilter.com/NPR. Restrictions apply. See rep for warranty and promotion details.
27:09 Speaker 01 On the latest Planet Money podcast, protesters in France are asking their government for more money for schools and for pensions.
27:15 Speaker 07 No, why not? There is a bunch of monna in the world. Don't say there is no money. There is so much money.
27:22 Speaker 01 She's right, there is money, but maybe not for France. Why does the market seem to be turning on France? And what can the rest of us learn from this? Listen to Planet Money on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. On NPR's Wild Card podcast, Esther Perel says confidence isn't about thinking you're perfect.
27:40 Speaker 07 Confidence is your ability to see yourself as a flawed individual. Yes. And still hold yourself in high regard. It's the ability to live with your imperfection that makes you confident. Watch or listen to that wild card conversation on the NPR app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
28:00 Speaker 03 Part two.
28:03 Speaker 03 Seventeenth century troll.
28:08 Speaker 01 Bright were the days at Marymounts, when the maypole was the banner staff of that gay colony. They who reared it, should their banner be triumphance, were to pour sunshine over New England's rugged hills and scatter flower seeds throughout the soil. Jollity and gloom were contending for an empire. Nathaniel Hoffer.
28:49 Speaker 03 The pilgrims, you know, getting word of shenanigans taking place at Merrymount, arm people to go into the town to arrest Morton and his fellows.
29:04 Speaker 03 And they are ready for what they think is going to be a battle.
29:09 Speaker 03 Drinking merry, merry, merry boys. They show up. Making garlic sprouts, bottles of... They find that these seven men are inebriated. Uncomforted heads and fear no hearts. The curse could be lifted to keep it warm. The only blood that is shed that day is when one of Morton's followers, standing up.
29:39 Speaker 04 One was so drunk.
29:40 Speaker 03 You can sort of imagine them standing up as these pilgrims are coming.
29:44 Speaker 04 So drunk that he ran his own nose upon the point of the sword that one held before him.
29:57 Speaker 03 There is no violence that takes place, but when the pilgrims get there, they find that not only have they erected this maypole, which they find offensive, they find salacious poems about, about the pilgrims, mocking the pilgrims.
30:13 Speaker 02 What kind of stuff is he saying about them? Like, what, what, what, what did he find worthy of, like, making fun of?
30:20 Speaker 03 He mocks their, their seriousness.
30:23 Speaker 01 Captain Shrimp.
30:24 Speaker 03 He mocks what he sees as their inability to enjoy life's pleasures.
30:30 Speaker 01 Troubling their brains more than reason would require.
30:33 Speaker 03 He's, he's messing with them. He's, he's, he's having sport with them.
30:37 Speaker 02 Yeah, he's trolling them. He's like a 17th century troll.
30:40 Speaker 03 He's trolling them.
30:48 Speaker 03 They arrest them. It's unclear what happens to the guys, you know, the other guys. And they take Morton and they put him on this place called the Isle of Shoals, which is off Portsmouth.
30:58 Speaker 02 A remote island.
31:00 Speaker 03 The exile.
31:02 Speaker 02 And he waits.
31:03 Speaker 03 A ship's gonna come, pick you up and take you back to England. You're gonna go to jail. Much to the pilgrim's disappointment, I have found no record of him being tried, going to jail. Instead, nope, Morton comes back.
31:18 Speaker 02 Back, first to Marymount, then to Boston.
31:22 Speaker 03 He said, I'm gonna try my luck with these people. And then he infuriates them for different reasons.
31:27 Speaker 02 And they torch his house and kick him out. In case you're counting, this is the second time Morton was exiled.
31:35 Speaker 03 So he's what, 50?
31:38 Speaker 02 Wow. So he's not like some kid, swashbuckling kid. He is a grown man. A grown man who ticked off the pilgrims and got sent away. But he's also not done with them.
31:52 Speaker 03 He goes back to England. And he starts to write a book.
32:02 Speaker 01 In the year since the incarnation of Christ, 1622, it was my chance to be landed in the parts of New England where I found two sorts of people.
32:12 Speaker 02 This is when he'd start to write New English Canaan.
32:15 Speaker 01 The more I looked, the more I liked it.
32:18 Speaker 02 It's what you might call a travel narrative, which at the time was popular for people who had traveled to the New World.
32:25 Speaker 03 It says, I went to this place.
32:26 Speaker 02 I met these people.
32:28 Speaker 03 Here's what I saw.
32:29 Speaker 02 And he divides New English Canaan into three books. So the first book is devoted to describing the native people. The second book is describing...
32:38 Speaker 00 Describing the natural landscape, but for the purposes of how to turn the land into commodity. So it's almost like he's setting up a sort of missed opportunity that then gets explained in book three, when he kind of articulates the kind of simplification of the pilgrims.
32:52 Speaker 02 Everyone who wrote these travel narratives was trying to be believed.
32:57 Speaker 03 They are writing books describing a world that the vast majority of English people are never going to see, have very little information about, and of which there are these competing claims over time.
33:07 Speaker 02 And as for William Bradford and Thomas Morton.
33:10 Speaker 00 It's hard to overemphasize how fraught their relationship was by this point.
33:16 Speaker 02 And so there's Morton, twice exiled, chip on his shoulder, riding away, trying to set the record straight as he saw it.
33:24 Speaker 00 There was a strong sense of historical narrative, a strong sense of, we are making history through this new world endeavor, and we have to record it.
33:35 Speaker 02 And he starts by describing who was there first. Morton's experience with the Algonquin people was welcoming.
33:43 Speaker 01 If anyone shall come into their houses and there fall asleep, when they see him disposed to lie down, they will spread a mat for him of their own accord.
33:55 Speaker 00 He has other moments like this, where he says that, in fact, the Massachusetts have more respect than the English.
34:02 Speaker 01 I have found the Massachusetts Indian more full of humanity than the Christians.
34:09 Speaker 00 And so he has several ways of kind of having a dig at the pilgrims by presenting the Massachusetts natives as more humble, more charitable, more respectful, and more humane.
34:22 Speaker 01 I cannot perceive that the separatists do allow of helping our poor, though they magnify their practice in contributing to the nourishment of their saints.
34:32 Speaker 02 Other times, it feels like he's just straight up making fun of the pilgrims.
34:36 Speaker 00 Poking fun is sort of one aspect.
34:38 Speaker 01 The setting up of this maypole was a lamentable spectacle to the precise separatists that lived at New Plymouth.
34:46 Speaker 00 He's also intensely critical.
34:49 Speaker 07 Of what he sees as the pilgrims sternness and kind of overzealousness and rigidness with trying to impose their religiosity on everyone in such kind of stringent ways.
35:03 Speaker 01 This harmless mirth made by young men that lived in hope to have wives brought over to them, that would save them a labor to make a voyage to fetch any over, was much distasted of the precise separatists.
35:17 Speaker 02 He tagged the government of Plymouth.
35:19 Speaker 07 He talks about the government's shambles.
35:22 Speaker 02 Even the town minister wasn't safe from his wrath.
35:24 Speaker 07 Anyone can be a minister, including a cowkeeper.
35:27 Speaker 01 The Church of the separatists is governed by pastors, elders, and deacons, and there is not any of these, though he be but a cowkeeper, but is allowed to exercise his gifts in the public assembly on the Lord's Day.
35:43 Speaker 07 It's a pretty derogatory, you know, kind of thing to say, where he just says anyone can be in charge.
35:51 Speaker 02 And just to be clear, we shouldn't really view Morton as some kind of hero. He was still participating in the colonization of Massachusetts, and he was at his core a businessman. A whole section of New English Canaan is devoted to financial and economic opportunities the New World has. But the book does present a different vision for what the inevitable relationship between colonists and native people could have looked like, a different vision for what would become America's future.
36:28 Speaker 02 And that brings us back to London, 1633, when people representing the colonies in New England shut the book down.
36:39 Speaker 02 There aren't a ton of details about what happened next, but we know the bookseller, Charles Green, recorded that he'd lost 400 copies of the book. When some few sheets of the said book were printed, it was And those sheets taken away.
36:57 Speaker 02 This event is widely seen as the first example in American history of a book being banned or oppressed. But Morton didn't give up. He kept looking for ways to get the book published. And in the meantime, he didn't just try to get back to the colonies. He wanted to take over.
37:17 Speaker 03 He is at this point in touch with another group of English people who think that they are the proper owners of New England.
37:27 Speaker 02 And so Morton joins the fight from London to colonize the colonizers.
37:32 Speaker 03 So what happens is that various people go to court and they try to get patents. They say, okay, this is English territory and can you allocate some of this? And so there are these competing companies.
37:43 Speaker 02 Remember, Morton is a lawyer.
37:45 Speaker 03 A useful lawyer.
37:46 Speaker 02 And he's a boss.
37:47 Speaker 03 A guy who's spoiling for a fight, who has courtroom experience.
37:51 Speaker 02 And so he ends up fighting on behalf of this group, this company, in front of the king's bench.
37:56 Speaker 03 One of the highest courts in England.
37:58 Speaker 02 And they win.
38:03 Speaker 02 The court essentially gives Morton and his allies the rights to colonize New England. The colonists already in Massachusetts basically ignore the court's order. So Morton and his allies decide to take it by force.
38:18 Speaker 03 To militarily invade to get rid of the colonists.
38:28 Speaker 02 The plan was to get 1,000 soldiers and arms on a boat and send it to Massachusetts.
38:34 Speaker 03 There is no doubt that they are literally deadly serious.
38:41 Speaker 05 A ship was now in building and near finished.
38:45 Speaker 02 An eyewitness account is our only record of what happened next.
38:49 Speaker 05 When God, that had carried so many weak and crazy ships thither, so provided it, that this strong new-built ship in very launching fell all in pieces.
39:07 Speaker 03 And it sinks in the docks before it ever leaves England.
39:14 Speaker 02 And that's it. The invasion fails. But Morton's book is still alive.
39:24 Speaker 02 Coming up, the book is published and Morton returns to New England for the last time.
39:39 Speaker 02 My name is Atal Osama. I'm from Denver, Colorado, and you're listening to Throughline
39:44 Speaker 00 from NPR.
39:59 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
40:03 Speaker 07 On a new episode of Your Turn with Alison Aubrey, two dream analysts explain the power of dreams as a guide for self-exploration. Sometimes dreams really contain the secret that we need to overcome difficulties, get unstuck, see a different way, and move forward. All this and more on Your Turn, available on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
40:27 Speaker 00 Hi, it's Terry Gross, host of Fresh Air. I interviewed John Turturro, and he was great talking about learning to be a pickpocket for a new movie and how growing up in a volatile home helped him as an actor.
40:38 Speaker 07 My brother said to me once, "I've given you a lot of material."
40:43 Speaker 07 And I said, "You know, you're really right. You're right." I said, "But at a high cost."
40:47 Speaker 00 Find it on the NPR app or wherever you listen to Fresh Air. This message comes from the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation, recognizing extraordinarily creative individuals whose ideas, solutions, and discoveries expand people's expectations of what's possible. Macfound.org.
41:12 Speaker 07 Part three, Third Time's the Charm.
41:23 Speaker 02 The ship has sunk. Morton lost yet another battle. But he didn't quit. Of course, he didn't quit. This is Thomas Morton we're talking about. Instead, he tried to publish his book a few years later, but this time in a different city.
41:39 Speaker 03 Morton's book has come out of a press in Amsterdam, sort of evading English authorities.
41:47 Speaker 02 Now, why Amsterdam? A couple of reasons. One is that Amsterdam was also a publishing center at the time, just like London was. And two, it would be far away from anyone trying to interfere. Morton had reason to be worried. New English Canaan laid out an alternative vision for how European colonists could coexist with Native people. But in the time that it had taken Morton to write and publish the book, relations between Massachusetts' Native communities and their pilgrims had only gotten worse.
42:19 Speaker 07 They had fled for religious freedom, but they did not afford that same religious freedom to the Wampanoag or to any of the indigenous people that they met. They considered them all to be heathens, and until they had been converted, they were not valued human beings. So that's where things began to fall apart.
42:45 Speaker 02 By the 1630s, English colonists were at war with a neighboring Native people called the Pequot. The war was brutal, and it led to a massacre.
42:59 Speaker 02 On May 26, 1637, a group of armed Puritan colonists attacked the village of Pequot people. After killing most of the Pequot defenders, the Puritans blocked the village exits and set everything ablaze, burning everyone alive inside, mostly women and children. The attack killed hundreds. Those who tried to escape were shot. Most of those who survived were sold into slavery.
43:40 Speaker 02 And it was around this same time that Morton's book finally reached Massachusetts shores.
44:10 Speaker 03 Someone gets that book and ships that book over to Boston. So by the time Morton then decides to finally return, the book has gotten there before he has gotten there.
44:27 Speaker 02 Morton returns to Massachusetts in 1643. He's in his 60s. And what he doesn't know is that the colonists already have his book. In reading it, they come to believe that
44:39 Speaker 03 Morton is trying to undermine them, tell the world what terrible people they are, and now they should get rid of them. But they don't quite know what to do with him because publishing this book isn't necessarily a crime. So they put him in jail and they sort of debate, what should we do with this guy?
45:02 Speaker 03 They refer to him as old and pathetic, right? He's poor. They say, we could beat him, right? They could literally physically beat him and keep him in jail. But what would be the point? He's this old man with no power. And so they decide, ah, let's exile him again.
45:18 Speaker 02 Not long after Morton lands in Massachusetts, he's arrested and exiled.
45:23 Speaker 03 But this time, rather than send him to England, he goes up the coast to this little place, Acemanticus. There's hardly anyone there.
45:30 Speaker 02 Which is present day Maine. There, he's surrounded by trees and left to be alone with his own thoughts.
45:37 Speaker 03 Morton goes there, and that's where he dies.
45:44 Speaker 02 But what about his book? What happened to all those original copies?
45:48 Speaker 03 We don't know. Most things from 400 years ago don't survive. Let's call it 200-plus books. There are about 20 left today.
45:58 Speaker 02 Whatever happened to the books? We don't know. But what's for sure is that Morton's ideas were enough to make him a serious threat, so much so that he had to be banished, not once, but three times.
46:10 Speaker 03 He is a threat because he represents a different way forward. A way forward that would not have surrounded a village, set it on fire, and shocked people as they came out. That he would have instead sought some other resolution. He has a radically different vision than the pilgrims had. So I think when he shows up again, even though he is, by their own admission, he is not a threat, but he does represent this idea. And that idea is different from their plan of colonization.
46:50 Speaker 03 I think that they hope to vanquish his ideas and to do that maybe symbolically by vanquishing his body. Now, they don't say all that, so I'm making certain inferences here. But I think that's the deeper meaning of that last exile. He represents a threat to a community that is still not as secure as it wants to be.
47:19 Speaker 00 I think New English Canaan is written with that sense of future generations in mind as much as the present day. And in fact, it is the legacy, more than his contemporaries, that constitutes his readership. Nathaniel Hawthorne, writing in the 1830s, is the major popularizer and discoverer of Thomas Morton and his legacy.
47:47 Speaker 02 The Scarlet Letter, you remember it? That one book we all had to read in high school. That was by the same guy.
47:54 Speaker 00 Hawthorne actually wrote an entire story called The Maypole of Marymount, in which he's clearly deeply engaged with the text and sympathetic to Morton's vision.
48:09 Speaker 02 This is Sarah Rivet, reading a passage from that story.
48:14 Speaker 00 "Old and young were gay at Merrymount. The young deemed themselves happy. The elder spirits, if they knew that mirth was but the counterfeit of happiness, yet followed the false shadow willfully."
48:29 Speaker 00 And he describes Morton and Merrymount, in contrast to the pilgrims, as a kind of war, that jollity and gloom were contending for an empire. You know, he really sees this as a deep debate between joy and gloom, between severity and a kind of fuller embrace of humanity and of life.
48:57 Speaker 02 And it wasn't just Nathaniel Hawthorne. In 1812, John Adams wrote to Thomas Jefferson about Morton's book, saying, "It is whimsical that this book, so long lost, should be brought to me." The two would later exchange a few more letters about the book. The ideas in New English Canaan rippled out for centuries. The poet William Carlos Williams wrote about it, the novelist Philip Roth, and others. The book changes how we understand what we consider to be America's origin story.
49:32 Speaker 00 It goes back to the counter-narrative. In the early years of the United States, there was a strong attempt to create a story of the rise of the young nation that was coherent and chronological and began with the pilgrims and the Puritans as a cohesive group. It was consciously constructed as such. And then here's the rise of this great democracy. There are a lot of reasons why that narrative is in place and actually continues to be part of the American story, but it is dangerous. It's a single story. It's never at any point in colonial or early national history was the United States quite that coherent. And
50:16 Speaker 00 so Morton's text is a really important counter-voice. No matter what he's saying, he's showing that the 17th century was multivocal, that people disagreed, that there was the possibility for dissent within these communities.
50:37 Speaker 02 That this is a very old practice, not just in the world, but in the US, or in what we now call the US, that somehow by banishing the idea, you're protecting the ideal.
50:48 Speaker 03 Yes, I think that's one of the most important reasons to study Thomas Morton's life. As I mentioned, the Puritans want to banish his ideas. If they can get rid of the book and they can get rid of him, then they can get rid of the idea. That is as ridiculous a concept in the 1630s as it is today. Banning books is such an insult to human intellect, that we are so afraid that someone's going to read something that we don't like, read something about an alternative lifestyle that is somehow not our own lifestyle, or not those of the book banners.
51:28 Speaker 03 Book banning flies in the face of not only my 21st century idea about why people should be able to read books, but it flies in the face of early Americans' ideas about the importance of ideas and being confronted with them and letting the marketplace of ideas, the discourse of how we do things, sort out the right way forward. Guess what? It doesn't work. Getting rid of the physical manifestation of an idea does not crush the idea itself.
52:04 Speaker 03 Morton's ideas don't die. Morton's story doesn't die. New English Canaan, despite the best efforts, doesn't die. It comes back.
52:25 Speaker 07 That's it for this week's show. I'm Randa Fatah.
52:28 Speaker 02 I'm Ramtin Arablouei, and you've been listening to Throughline from NPR.
52:33 Speaker 07 This episode was produced by me.
52:35 Speaker 02 And me and? Lawrence Wu.
52:37 Speaker 07 Julie Kane.
52:38 Speaker 00 Anya Steinberg. Casey Minor. Christina Kim. Devon Katayama. Peter. Balanon Rosen. Thomas Lu. Irene Naguchi.
52:48 Speaker 02 Fact checking for this episode was done by Kevin Vocal. The episode was mixed by Robert Rodriguez. Thanks to Johannes Dergi, Edith Chapin, Colin Campbell, and Anya Grunman. Thanks also to Neil Strickland, Chris Turpin, Thomas Lu, Peter Balanon Rosen, Devin Katayama, and Lawrence Wu for their voiceover work. Our music was composed by Ramtin and his band Drop Electric, which includes Anya Mizani. Navid Marvi. Cho Fujiwara. And finally, if you have an idea or like something you heard on the show, please write us at throughline@npr.org. Thanks for listening.
53:37 Speaker 06 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
Previous The Mother of Thanksgiving Next Seeking Asylum in the U.S. Page updated November 6, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated