Pod Insights Throughline How the Supreme Court claimed supreme power About this episode The Supreme Court's 2025-26 term has been punctuated with some high-stakes cases: birthright citizenship, voting rights, presidential powers and consequential civil rights cases. Some of the most anticipated and significant cases have yet to be decided. As the justices make the final sprint to the end of the term in early July, we take stock of how the Supreme Court evolved from the weakest branch of government to the powerhouse arbiter it is today. This episode originally aired in 2020.
Guests:
Larry Kramer, former dean of Stanford Law School and author of The People Themselves: Popular Constitutionalism and Judicial Review
Rachel Shelden, associate professor of History and director of the George and Ann Richards Civil War Era Center at Penn State University, and author of The Political Supreme Court
Lucas Powe Jr., professor of Law and Government at the University of Texas
Support shows like Throughline with NPR+. Sign up today at plus.npr.org.
See pcm.adswizz.com https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.
NPR Privacy Policy https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 This message comes from iXL, a learning platform for helping kids build confidence and get up to speed fast. One subscription covers math, science, and reading for all children in a household. Receive 20% off at ixl.com/NPR.
0:16 Rund Abdelfatah? Hey, it's Rand. As the clock ticks down to the close of the Supreme Court's 2025-2026 term, and we await the justices to hand down nearly two dozen more rulings by early July, the most anticipated of which involved birthright citizenship, the counting of mail-in ballots, the president's power to remove any official, and state bans on female transgender athletes, we thought it would be helpful to share a through-line episode from our archives that tells the story of the Supreme Court, how it evolved from the weakest branch of government to the powerhouse arbiter it is today.
1:01 Speaker 02 There is with a 2-0 pitch. And this ball smashed. High and deep to center field. It is one!
1:11 Speaker 03 That ball driven to right. Is it fair? It is a home run!
1:20 Rund Abdelfatah? When I was growing up, I remember my dad having this strange love of baseball.
1:28 Rund Abdelfatah? He was new to this country. Everything about it was foreign to him.
1:35 Rund Abdelfatah? Different food, different languages, different politics. But baseball? That made sense.
1:42 Speaker 03 There's a drive to right center field by Piazza. His first major league hit. He'll go into second.
1:49 Rund Abdelfatah? He didn't know all the rules necessarily, but he got the basic gist of it. One person throws the ball, the other tries to hit it. And the person behind the plate, behind the catcher, the person calling the strikes or balls.
2:03 Rund Abdelfatah? That's the umpire.
2:07 Rund Abdelfatah? The arbiter of justice. What he says goes. No questions asked. Well...
2:15 Rund Abdelfatah? Most of the time.
2:23 Rund Abdelfatah? But even when people don't like the ump's call, they have to live with it or get thrown out.
2:32 Rund Abdelfatah? That's just the way the game was set up.
2:39 Rund Abdelfatah? But this isn't an episode about baseball.
2:42 Speaker 04 Justice Ginsburg, will you raise your right hand and repeat after me?
2:46 Rund Abdelfatah? This is an episode about the Supreme Court.
2:50 Speaker 05 I, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, do solemnly swear
2:55 Speaker 04 that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States.
2:59 Rund Abdelfatah? Which some people like to think of as America's umpire.
3:02 Speaker 05 Judges are like umpires.
3:11 Rund Abdelfatah? Calling the shots for the country, no questions asked, right?
3:17 Rund Abdelfatah? The death of Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg has forced abortion rights advocates to face their biggest fear. And this is just one of several hot-button
3:26 Speaker 02 issues like health care and voting rights that could now be transformed for decades to come.
3:32 Speaker 02 The president vowed to go to the Supreme Court to dispute the election count. The court has the power of life and death. The more the court expands into every area of American society, the bigger ticket item it becomes. Because of this kind of power, the leanings
3:46 Rund Abdelfatah? of a new and ninth justice are so crucial.
3:51 Rund Abdelfatah? You're listening to Throughline from NPR.
3:53 Speaker 03 Where we go back in time?
3:56 Rund Abdelfatah? To understand the present.
4:03 Rund Abdelfatah? The Supreme Court as America's umpire may not be a perfect metaphor, but it gets at a really important point. Nowadays, the Supreme Court has the final say over so much of our lives, which hasn't always been the case. For most of our history, people thought of the Supreme Court as like the coach, with some say over the flow of the game, but definitely not the final say. Okay, we're gonna stop with the baseball metaphors now.
4:32 Speaker 06 Thing is too many baseball metaphors. Anyway, in the beginning, back in 1787, when the framers of the Constitution were designing how this federal government would work, you know, three branches, checks and balances. The way they saw things, the president controlled the army, Congress controlled the money and the courts, the judiciary. Well, as Alexander Hamilton put it,
4:56 Speaker 02 "The judiciary, on the contrary, has no influence over either the sword or the purse, no direction either of the strength or of the wealth of the society, and can take no act of resolution, whatever."
5:12 Speaker 06 In other words, without the sword or purse, the Supreme Court didn't have much power to enforce its decisions, making it the least dangerous and least powerful branch.
5:23 Speaker 02 There was just no notion that it would be powerful. It wasn't yet in really anybody's imagination that they had to worry about.
5:29 Speaker 06 That's Larry Kramer.
5:31 Speaker 02 Formerly the dean of Stanford Law School. And I wrote a book called The People Themselves: Popular Constitutionalism and Judicial Review.
5:40 Speaker 06 So the framers came up with Article III.
5:44 Speaker 05 The Constitution in Article III gives Congress the power to shape what the federal judiciary is.
5:51 Speaker 02 "The judicial power of the United States shall be vested in one Supreme Court."
5:57 Speaker 05 There's a Supreme Court and any other courts that the Congress at the time wanted to create.
6:03 Speaker 06 Being a Supreme Court Justice in these early days wasn't glamorous. I mean, the original Supreme Court didn't even get its own building.
6:12 Speaker 05 The Supreme Court is going to be situated in the basement of the Capitol. And that gives you a sense, actually, of the hierarchy of what people at the time thought about the Supreme Court.
6:23 Speaker 06 By the way, this is Rachel Shelden.
6:26 Rund Abdelfatah? I'm a historian of politics, law, and the Constitution in the 19th century. And her book, The Political Supreme Court, will be published later this year.
6:40 Speaker 05 They sat at individual desks as opposed to sort of what we assume today of that sort of long bench. They did not have separate offices the way that we think of today.
6:51 Rund Abdelfatah? And that was only when they were in Washington DC, where they spent just some of the year. The rest of the time, they were doing this thing called riding circuit, meaning they would basically travel around the country.
7:04 Speaker 05 A judge would, in fact, yes, ride around horseback, or really in a carriage, and go from town to town where the circuits were held.
7:12 Rund Abdelfatah? And they would preside over trials. Keep in mind, there wasn't a vast web of federal judges around the country that could filter some of these cases for the court like there is today. So the Supreme Court justices rode around and handled things themselves.
7:29 Speaker 05 At the end of the day, the justices would, you know, take off their judge hat. They would go and stay in their boarding houses.
7:37 Rund Abdelfatah? These boarding houses were typically shared with the lawyers who were trying the cases.
7:42 Speaker 05 Getting to know the town, spending time with the political folks who are around. Lots of the lawyers who tried cases in front of the circuit courts tended to be state legislators.
7:53 Speaker 02 Everything's a lot looser than it subsequently becomes.
7:58 Speaker 06 At this time, politics and the Supreme Court were very intertwined. The justices saw no separation between the two.
8:06 Speaker 02 They viewed themselves as perfectly capable of participating in political debate as judges.
8:11 Speaker 06 In fact, the court was so political that many of the justices just saw their job as a stepping stone in their quest for political power. They didn't hang around that basement for very long, if you know what I mean.
8:27 Rund Abdelfatah? But some people, even then, had a different vision for the court. They wanted the court to be taken seriously, to reign supreme. And over the next 200 years, that vision would slowly be realized.
8:47 Speaker 06 I'm Ramtin Arablouei.
8:48 Rund Abdelfatah? I'm Randa Abdel Fattah.
8:50 Speaker 06 And on this episode, we're diving into the long, complicated political history of the highest court in the land, the Supreme Court of the United States. How did it become America's umpire? And when did it get the final say on human rights, health care, and even who we choose as president?
9:36 Speaker 00 Hi, this is Ellie, and I'm calling from Washington, DC. And you're listening to Throughline from NPR. Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from iXL, a learning platform for helping kids build confidence and get up to speed fast. One subscription covers math, science, and reading for all children in a household. Receive 20% off at ixl.com/npr.
10:04 Speaker 05 The 2026 midterm elections are upon us. On November 3rd, voters will determine what the next two years of their local leadership and the balance of national government will look like. Listen to the NPR News Now podcast for all the updates you need ahead of and after November 3rd from NPR News.
10:26 Speaker 02 I'm Kevin Roos. And I'm Casey Newton. And together, we've been tech journalists for decades. Now, we're your hosts of Machine Gods, a new podcast from NPR that makes sense of what AI means for your work, your life, and all of our futures. Twice a week, we'll be exploring the biggest moves in tech and give you unmatched access to the real titans of industry. Listen to Machine Gods from NPR on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
10:52 Speaker 02 Part one. Who's say is it anyway?
11:00 Rund Abdelfatah? We start our story with a contested presidential election, the election of 1800, one of the most partisan showdowns in our country's history.
11:10 Speaker 02 It's the most divisive period in American history, except for the Civil War and possibly today.
11:16 Rund Abdelfatah? The country was still pretty new, and everybody was trying to figure out how this democracy thing was going to work. Things like trade, taxation, foreign relations, state versus federal power.
11:28 Speaker 02 It's a period of a lot of turmoil, and there's essentially one huge division around which the political parties form.
11:37 Speaker 06 The United States didn't start out with any political parties, no teams. But competing visions of government were pulling people apart, which led to the creation of these two parties.
11:49 Rund Abdelfatah? The Federalists, the party of incumbent President John Adams, and the Democratic-Republicans. Always confusing because it has both Democrat and Republican in it. The party of candidate Thomas Jefferson.
12:01 Speaker 06 These parties had radically different outlooks on government.
12:04 Speaker 02 Almost all of the debates are around, what is it that we mean by, you know, they would have said republicanism, we would say democracy. That is to say, how popular is it supposed to be?
12:17 Speaker 06 The Democratic-Republicans were fans of popular politics.
12:21 Speaker 02 This is our law.
12:22 Rund Abdelfatah? Allow more power to grow up from the people themselves.
12:25 Speaker 02 Final interpretation rests with us in the community.
12:29 Speaker 06 Jefferson famously said,
12:31 Speaker 02 "I hold it that a little rebellion now and then is a good thing and as necessary in the political world as storms in the physical."
12:42 Speaker 02 The much more conservative Federalists pushed back in all sorts of ways, interpreting the Constitution in ways that would limit the capacity for popular politics to grow.
12:52 Rund Abdelfatah? The Federalists wanted more stability, and they thought in order to get that, the federal government ought to have more power. They believed their still very young country needed a strong centralized government with lasting institutions that would be around much longer than elected officials, institutions like the courts.
13:11 Speaker 06 The Federalists were the party of power throughout the 1790s. But in the election of 1800, they faced defeat. Adams lost the race, and Jefferson became president.
13:23 Rund Abdelfatah? So Congress becomes Democratic-
13:26 Speaker 00 Like Republican and you have Jefferson in the White House.
13:30 Speaker 06 But as outgoing president, John Adams' term was coming to an end. He and his party made one final power grab.
13:39 Rund Abdelfatah? Adams nominated a bunch of Federalist judges at the very end of his term, so-called Midnight Judges, as well as a new Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, John Marshall.
13:55 Speaker 00 He becomes sort of the foundational Chief Justice in terms of thinking about development of the court as an institution.
14:03 Speaker 02 Marshall's a straight-up Federalist. He was Secretary of State for John Adams, and then he made him the Chief Justice.
14:10 Speaker 00 He's now in control of only one branch with the Federalists in charge.
14:15 Speaker 06 As Chief Justice, John Marshall made a lot of symbolic changes to the Supreme Court.
14:21 Speaker 00 So the story goes that Marshall wore a black robe at his swearing-in and that after that, this became common practice. There was a degree to which some people did not like to see Supreme Court justices in robes at all, thinking of it as a royal court as opposed to sort of a democratic body.
14:44 Speaker 00 He wants all the justices to board together and to work together. He is a big proponent of having unanimous opinions. He thought that that had the tendency to make the court seem more important.
14:58 Speaker 06 Marshall dreamt of a Supreme Court with national authority, a Supreme Court that gets to interpret the Constitution, basically be the umpire for the entire country.
15:11 Speaker 02 He believes in judicial supremacy.
15:13 Speaker 00 Which is much more what we accept today. The idea that the Supreme Court is the final arbiter of constitutionality.
15:21 Rund Abdelfatah? This idea, judicial supremacy, gives the Supreme Court final say over what's constitutional and what's not. And then, everybody has to do what they decide, the law of the land.
15:34 Speaker 06 But again, this was a dream.
15:37 Rund Abdelfatah? It's just not how things work then.
15:41 Rund Abdelfatah? But there was this other thing, a much more restricted power that was on the table: judicial review.
15:49 Speaker 02 So judicial review is the notion that in a case before it, the court can say whether a statute that is raised in the case is in fact constitutional and therefore enforceable.
16:00 Rund Abdelfatah? The court gets to decide what's constitutional in a case, but the ruling doesn't extend beyond that specific case. So it's the law of the case, but not the law of the land.
16:12 Speaker 02 The whole idea of judicial review without judicial supremacy is that you have three co-equal branches, each with equal authority to interpret the Constitution.
16:20 Speaker 06 Remember, that was how the federal government was designed to work. No one branch was supreme over the others, so they could all keep each other in check.
16:30 Speaker 00 Marshall himself was interested in having more of that supreme power for the court, but he also understood it was not possible. He operates in this world in which he knows he's a minority, especially when the Democratic-Republicans, led by Thomas Jefferson and James Madison, are in power.
16:49 Speaker 06 Plus, there was some personal beef.
16:51 Speaker 00 Marshall and Jefferson were cousins. They famously did not like each other.
16:57 Rund Abdelfatah? In 1803, the Cousins, Chief Justice John Marshall and President Thomas Jefferson, met in court, going head to head in a case called Marbury versus Madison.
17:12 Speaker 00 Probably the most famous decision and sort of the beginning of most constitutional law experiences is Marbury versus Madison.
17:21 Rund Abdelfatah? We won't get into all the details of the case, but in short, the Jefferson administration was being sued for refusing to acknowledge some of those midnight judges that John Adams had appointed right before leaving office. William Marbury was one of them. He and the other appointees were able to take the case directly to the Supreme Court, thanks to a provision in a federal law that Congress had passed more than a decade earlier. And Marshall saw this as an opportunity.
17:50 Speaker 00 He sees this as a Situation in which he needs to preserve the power of the court that had existed and try to grow it in opposition to the other branches of government.
18:01 Rund Abdelfatah? Marshall wanted to flex his authority as the head of the judicial branch, but...
18:06 Speaker 02 He knows if he actually tries to order Jefferson, Jefferson's going to ignore him. So that will make the court look weak.
18:12 Speaker 06 Remember, the court didn't have the power to enforce its decisions. No money, no army. It all depended on how much the other branches chose to respect its decisions.
18:24 Rund Abdelfatah? But there was one tool that Marshall could use, the power of judicial review.
18:32 Rund Abdelfatah? Up to this point, judicial review had only been applied sporadically. But in Marbury v. Madison, John Marshall formally established it.
18:42 Speaker 06 It was a calculated trade off. Marshall was like, fine, we know we can't force these appointments through, but you know that provision in the federal law Congress passed? The one that allowed Marbury to bring the case directly to the Supreme Court? Well, we've decided that provision is unconstitutional. We, the Supreme Court, have the power to interpret the Constitution in any case, state or federal, even if that means overriding an act of Congress. We have the power of judicial review. It is emphatically the duty
19:16 Speaker 02 of the Judicial Department to say what the law is. It's one of those instances of playing politics. So he finds a way to say, you know, we don't have jurisdiction. I can't tell Jefferson what to do, but I'm going to tell you, he violated the Constitution. This was wrong. The government of the United States has been emphatically termed a government of laws and not of men. It becomes the first case in which the Supreme Court strikes down a federal law for violating the Constitution.
19:44 Rund Abdelfatah? In other words, this is the first time the Supreme Court flexed its power to say that what another branch of the federal government wanted to do was not constitutional.
19:55 Speaker 06 It was the moment when judicial review, which had been around but heavily debated, solidified as part of the court's power. This case would reverberate for centuries to come.
20:09 Speaker 02 For somebody reading it at the time, it's screamingly clear that he is not pushing the Judicial supremacy position and is backing away from it, which of course he had to do because it would not have been acceptable at the time.
20:23 Speaker 06 So while this was an important win for the court, it was a long way from Marshall's ultimate goal, judicial supremacy, the court as umpire with final say. He was a visionary though, and he knew he had to play the long game. During his three decades on the bench, he helped plant the seed of what the court could be and the amount of power the Supreme Court could have in the future.
20:48 Speaker 00 In the next iteration of the court where Roger Taney becomes Supreme Court Justice, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, tends to be a little bit less involved in striking down laws. They don't strike down a federal law again until Dred Scott v. Sanford in 1857.
21:09 Rund Abdelfatah? Dred Scott was an enslaved man who was suing for his freedom.
21:13 Speaker 02 As the controversy over slavery in the territories heats up, there are people who start to say, why don't we have the Supreme Court settle this? Like, wouldn't that be great if the Supreme Court settled it?
21:21 Rund Abdelfatah? Before we get into the case, let's set the scene. This is more than 50 years after Marbury versus Madison, and by now, the country had more than doubled in size. Louisiana, Indiana, Mississippi. Adding a dozen states to the Union. Alabama, Maine, Missouri. It's the decade leading up to the Civil War. Abolition is the defining debate of this time, and with the Dred Scott case, the court was about to wade deep into that debate.
21:54 Speaker 06 Dred Scott was born into slavery in Virginia, and he was moved around a lot. First to Alabama, then to Missouri, both slave states, and then on to Illinois, a free state, and then the Wisconsin Territory, where slavery was forbidden by the Missouri Compromise of 1820. After returning to Missouri, Scott filed suit in court for his freedom, claiming that because he'd lived in a free territory and state, he was now a free man, a US citizen. The case eventually made its way to the Supreme Court.
22:29 Speaker 00 Taney is going to give the ultimate determination, but it takes a while. They start, they evaluate what they ought to do over the course of not just, you know, a few months.
22:42 Speaker 06 But over a year. And while the case is being determined, members of the court are in discussion with politicians in the area. Finally, the court came to a decision.
22:57 Speaker 02 The long trumpeted decision of the Supreme Court in the Dred Scott case was pronounced by Judge Toney yesterday, having been held over from last year. And the court holds that Scott cannot be a citizen because he's black. And Africans can never be citizens.
23:17 Speaker 02 They had no rights which the white man was bound to respect, and that the Negro might justly and lawfully be reduced to slavery for his benefit.
23:26 Rund Abdelfatah? The court's opinion was an outright racist endorsement of slavery throughout the country. It denied all black people, enslaved as well as free, any chance at citizenship.
23:38 Speaker 02 It is too clear for dispute that the enslaved African race were not intended to be included and formed no part of the people who framed and adopted this declaration. It seems to like give the South everything it wanted. There's a huge explosion in the North. And this sets off all kinds of anger among quite a few people. Republicans, at this point, a new party that want to eliminate slavery from the territories with the idea that eventually it would die out. The Supreme Court of the United States has polluted its garments in the filth of pro-slavery politics.
24:18 Speaker 02 From this day forth, it must stand as a self-disgraced tribunal. And from this day forth, it will be one of the great and leading aims of the people of the free states to obliterate this shameful record and undo what has been done.
24:36 Rund Abdelfatah? This is from an article in the New York Tribune, one of the largest newspapers aligned with that new political party, the Republicans. And one of the most vocal critics of the decision, a rising star in the Republican Party, was a former congressman from Illinois named Abraham Lincoln. Lincoln is very unhappy.
24:56 Speaker 00 And he says that this is a conspiracy to extend slavery across the United States. He believes Dred Scott was wrongly decided. He also believes that it does not have to be permanent law.
25:13 Speaker 06 After becoming president, Lincoln, as the executive, basically just ignores the Supreme Court and its rulings. During the Civil War, as his power grows, their power wanes. And by the end of the war, abolition has become the law of the land. And the court's decision in Dred Scott puts them on the wrong side of history.
25:33 Speaker 02 Dred Scott certainly hurts the court's credibility for a good generation. Takes them a while to rebuild credibility after that.
25:45 Rund Abdelfatah? When we come back, the Supreme Court fights to restore its legitimacy as a president challenges its power at every turn.
26:19 Speaker 02 This is Jose Santana from Delta, Connecticut. And you're listening to Fro Line from NPR. I really love you guys. Thank you for bringing so much information to us. Bye.
26:37 Speaker 02 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
26:41 Speaker 00 This message comes from iXL, a learning platform for helping kids build confidence and get up to speed fast. One subscription covers math, science, and reading for all children in a household. Receive 20% off at ixl.com/NPR.
26:57 Speaker 05 This election season, let the NPR Politics podcast save your time and your sanity. We'll help you understand key races, which polls you can safely ignore, and what might happen if power shifts in Congress. Our short daily episodes come out every afternoon, so you can spend less time scrolling through each chaotic news cycle. Make NPR Politics your hub for midterm election coverage. Follow our podcast on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
27:21 Speaker 02 American journalist Austin Tice vanished in Syria over a decade ago. For years, we've been searching for him, and now we finally have some answers. This is the prison that Austin was in. Oh my god, we found Austin's file. Listen to Where Is Austin Tice? From NPR's Embedded and BBC Radio 4, on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. Part Two: The Switch in Time Saves Nine.
27:57 Speaker 03 I am prepared, under my constitutional duty, to recommend the measures that a stricken nation in the midst of a stricken world may require.
28:08 Speaker 06 On March 4, 1933, President Franklin D. Roosevelt took office, and he was up against the worst economic disaster in American history.
28:19 Speaker 03 In his inaugural address, the biggest applause line was not, "We have nothing to fear but fear itself," was instead that I may have to take on the powers of a wartime president. Broad executive power to wage a war against the emergency as great as the power that would be given to me if we were in fact invaded by a farm fall.
28:52 Speaker 04 He has a mandate, which is to do something about the Great Depression.
28:56 Speaker 03 Prosperity is just around the corner, say the hopeful headlines. But around the corners wind the lengthening breadlines, and a whole new class of citizens appears in American society: the new poor. You've got unemployment running at 25%. Not since the Civil War has such pressure, political, economic, social, centered on the White House.
29:21 Speaker 03 And so Roosevelt pushes through the First New Deal,
29:26 Speaker 03 and the court strikes it all.
29:35 Rund Abdelfatah? By this time, the Supreme Court was beginning to find its voice again, to come out of the shadows.
29:41 Speaker 06 But you can't expect to be taken more seriously and expand your power if you're stuck in a basement. Construction on a new Supreme Court building was underway when Roosevelt took office.
29:53 Rund Abdelfatah? And not long after Roosevelt tried to pass the first New Deal, the court moved into its fancy new building.
30:01 Speaker 02 Amid the architectural glories that grace our nation's capital, the United States Supreme Court Building is one of the most imposing, a worthy meeting place for the highest tribunal of the land.
30:12 Rund Abdelfatah? This was a real step up from their old basement quarters. It's big, regal, like something out of ancient Greece, with a wide oval plaza, tall imposing columns lining the front, marble statues on either side, and a staircase, perfect for a Rocky-style training montage welcoming you to the entrance, which is inscribed with the words "Equal Justice Under Law."
30:38 Speaker 03 There's a statement in The New Yorker in 1935 as this new Supreme Court building, the current marble palace, is open for the justices. And the quip was, "The new building has wonderful, large windows to throw the New Deal out of."
31:00 Speaker 03 My name is Lucas Powe Jr. I'm a professor of law and government at the University of Texas. My specialty is the United States Supreme Court.
31:12 Speaker 06 Okay, so why were the newly enthroned Supreme Court justices so staunchly against Roosevelt's plans?
31:19 Speaker 06 Well, first of all, this was still a conservative court, and they didn't like his populist agenda. And second, Roosevelt was dramatically expanding the power of the presidency as they were trying to expand their power. But Roosevelt was like, OK, you want to fight? I'll give you a fight.
31:38 Speaker 02 He begins using all the old themes that had been there all along, pushing back that the court doesn't have this authority, shouldn't have this authority, that it shouldn't be able to strike these laws down in this way.
31:49 Rund Abdelfatah? Roosevelt was determined to push through a second New Deal, which he saw as the only way to rescue the country from the ongoing depression. Congress was on board. The only thing that stood in his way was the Supreme Court, which was threatening to strike down that deal, too.
32:06 Speaker 02 And he's putting more and more pressure on the court, and they're still holding out to do it.
32:10 Rund Abdelfatah? It was like a game of chicken. Who would blink first? Eventually, Roosevelt reached his breaking point.
32:17 Speaker 03 The President of the United States.
32:19 Rund Abdelfatah? And decided to reset the rules of the game.
32:22 Speaker 03 I want, as all Americans want, an independent judiciary as proposed by the framers of the Constitution. He proposes a plan to add new justices to the court. What is my proposal? It is simply this. Whenever a judge or justice- It would allow a new justice, for every justice over the age of 70 not retiring. And at that time, the court was the oldest in American history, and that would have given Roosevelt six new appointees for a 15-member court. I seek to make American democracy succeed.
33:05 Speaker 03 You and I will do our part.
33:08 Speaker 02 It's disingenuous. You know, everybody understands why he's really doing it.
33:12 Speaker 03 He was going to point yes men to the court. And there's a cartoon of that era that shows you a jury box when everyone is filled with an image of FDR voting aye. And that's what people feared would happen, Republicans especially.
33:32 Speaker 02 It's not particularly popular, but it is still a huge amount of pressure on the court because he's Roosevelt and he's got a lot of political capital to use.
33:42 Speaker 03 You know, it's a warning shot that you've gone too far.
33:47 Speaker 02 And it's working its way through Congress and it's not clear what's going to happen.
33:52 Speaker 06 Roosevelt's court packing plan set off a heated debate in Congress. But this wasn't the first time a president had proposed changing the number of justices on the court.
34:02 Speaker 02 Turns out right now to be the last time, but it wasn't the first time at all, right?
34:06 Speaker 06 Back in 1801, John Adams did it right before leaving office.
34:10 Speaker 02 They shrunk the court from six to five so that Jefferson wouldn't get to make any appointments.
34:14 Speaker 06 But Congress increased the number to seven. Then Andrew Jackson added a couple and Abraham Lincoln added one more.
34:22 Speaker 02 Congress increases its size from seven to 10.
34:24 Speaker 06 Under Andrew Johnson, it shrunk.
34:26 Speaker 02 To seven so that he won't get any appointments.
34:29 Speaker 06 In 1868, Ulysses Grant was elected.
34:32 Speaker 02 They increase it again to nine.
34:34 Speaker 06 And it stayed there till Roosevelt came along.
34:37 Speaker 02 Roosevelt was the last serious effort. No one had ever doubted its constitutionality.
34:45 Speaker 06 And the way Roosevelt saw it.
34:47 Speaker 02 The court had this outmoded, outdated interpretation that did not fit the modern world at all and that there was no way that theirs should be the final and binding interpretation. So how do you push back at them to get them to stop striking down laws? You use the tools the Constitution provides, which include that the political branches get to decide how the court is made up. So I'm going to add some justices. It's a way to turn it around. They're all just ways of pushing these controversies back out to the people who are the ultimate deciders. People themselves are actually the interpreters of their own Constitution.
35:26 Speaker 06 With the court packing plan on the table, the future of the court was uncertain. And after months in limbo, the court retreats.
35:36 Speaker 03 The court packing plan just scared the hell out of the justices and caused what the best con law professor at the time, Thomas Reed Powell, said, "The switch in time that saves nine as the court changed."
35:54 Rund Abdelfatah? In 1937, Roosevelt's Second New Deal was upheld. Case after case came before the court, and they basically just greenlit everything: a minimum wage, social security, the right of workers to unionize. And not long after...
36:11 Speaker 02 One of the five justices who were the conservative majority holding this all back, Van de Vanter, retires in the middle of all this, and Roosevelt is able quickly to replace him. So now, he's got the law that he wants, the court has retreated, he's got the court that he wants, so he lets the Court Packing Plan go. He doesn't need it. He's gotten what he needed. And in the next couple of years, the rest of them retire, and he's able to appoint other justices.
36:32 Rund Abdelfatah? So Roosevelt did get the court he wanted, just not in the way he expected.
36:38 Speaker 03 From the time of the Court Packing Plan onward, the court simply rubber stamps the federal government. Whatever the federal government does, the court is going to approve.
36:52 Rund Abdelfatah? But the court's bid for judicial supremacy wasn't over just yet.
36:58 Rund Abdelfatah? Tucked away in one of the cases decided by this court was a footnote that said...
37:03 Speaker 02 "We are reserving heightened judicial entanglement in a certain number of areas." And they refer to discreet and insular minorities and the protection of individual rights.
37:13 Rund Abdelfatah? Individual rights: life, liberty, the pursuit of happiness.
37:17 Speaker 02 Nobody paid much attention to that footnote, because in 150 years before then, none of those issues had actually been major issues in constitutional law. So it'd be like me saying, "I'm gonna let you control the whole house, but I'm gonna keep this corner over here." Like, "Fine, keep that corner. What do I care?"
37:33 Rund Abdelfatah? To be clear, that corner was the civil rights corner.
37:37 Speaker 02 And then, what the Warren Court does is pick that up in ways that actually nobody had really thought would happen, and runs with it. Takes those doctrines and turns them into major issues of constitutional law for the first time.
37:57 Speaker 06 When we come back, we enter the Warren Court era, and the battle for judicial supremacy reaches a tipping point.
38:16 Speaker 02 This is Dano from Phoenix, Arizona, and you're listening to Throughline from NPR.
38:22 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from iXL, a learning platform for helping kids build confidence and get up to speed fast. One subscription covers math, science, and reading for all children in a household. Receive 20% off at ixl.com/npr.
38:43 Speaker 02 This week on Up First, we're in the final days before the midterm elections. And this is one of the wonderful things about politics, one of the wonderful things about humanity. We have all this data. We have all this information, and nobody really knows what's gonna happen. We're gonna follow it day by day, through Election Day and beyond. And you can listen to Up First every morning on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. Midlife brings a lot of changes. Your Turn with Alison Aubrey is a new podcast to help you navigate the twists and turns. From health and relationships to creativity and purpose, we can help steer your next chapter with Your Turn with Alison Aubrey. Find it on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
39:30 Speaker 02 Part Three: The Ceiling and the Floor.
39:37 Rund Abdelfatah? Little Rock, Arkansas, and the first phase of the trouble. The white population are determined to prevent colored students from going to the school their own children attend. Picketing the school, they crash for the park. Little Rock, Arkansas, September 25, 1957. An angry mob stands outside Central High School, a formerly all-white school, waiting to see if nine black students will show up. Mini Jean Brown Tricky was one of those students.
40:04 Speaker 03 The world came to Little Rock to see what would happen.
40:10 Rund Abdelfatah? Years of rising tensions had led to this moment. Here is the sequence of events in the development of the Little Rock.
40:17 Speaker 06 Little Rock School case.
40:20 Speaker 06 In 1952, the issue of school segregation went to the Supreme Court in the case Brown v. Board of Education. A lawyer named Thurgood Marshall, then the chief attorney for the NAACP, argued for the plaintiffs. He argued that segregation in schools was a violation of the 14th Amendment of the Constitution, and the court unanimously agreed. They ruled that segregation in public schools was unconstitutional.
40:50 Rund Abdelfatah? Now, states across the country had to figure out a way to integrate their schools, which made a lot of people, especially in the South, really angry. They resented the idea that the federal government could just come into their state and tell them what to do.
41:13 Speaker 03 We are going to maintain segregated schools down in Dixie.
41:18 Speaker 06 And that included Little Rock.
41:23 Speaker 06 In 1955-
41:24 Speaker 03 The Little Rock School Board approved a moderate plan for the gradual desegregation of the public schools in that city.
41:32 Speaker 06 But white community members refused to carry out that plan, so the courts pushed back. The Supreme Court issued a follow-up decision, known as Brown II, ordering school districts to integrate. And in Arkansas, a federal district court judge followed up with another order.
41:52 Speaker 06 Still, the community resisted vocally and sometimes violently.
42:01 Speaker 03 It's just chaos in the Little Rock schools, and it's impossible for the students to attend.
42:14 Speaker 06 And the protesters got backup from the governor of Arkansas.
42:17 Speaker 02 The governor calls out the National Guard. They're not going to allow the integration to take place.
42:21 Speaker 03 If it interferes for a time with certain other liberties, then that has always been the case. Which reminds me of a statement of Abe Lincoln one time when he said, "If I tried to answer all the charges that come to this office, that I might as well close up shop for any other business. That if I am right, then all the things they say don't matter in the end."
42:46 Rund Abdelfatah? As pressure mounted to carry out the court's order, a mob formed outside the high school. Little Rock became a tinderbox, ready to ignite at any moment. And by September 1957, President Eisenhower decided he had to step in.
43:03 Speaker 03 Our personal opinions about the decision have no bearing on the matter of enforcement. Responsibility and authority of the Supreme Court to interpret the Constitution are very clear. Mob rule can not be allowed to override the decisions of our courts. Phase two. President Eisenhower sends troops of the 101st Airborne Division of the United States Army to Little Rock by night. They are to keep order and to see that the law of the land is obeyed.
43:37 Rund Abdelfatah? Nine black students escorted by federal troops prepared to enter Central High School. They would come to be known as the Little Rock Nine.
43:55 Speaker 03 It's early morning in Little Rock, and a new school day is dawning.
44:05 Speaker 03 What about you, sir? Do you think the colored students will show up? If I got anything to do with it, they won't show up. They meet here and are conducted to school by the Army to make sure of their safety.
44:20 Rund Abdelfatah? This was an important moment for the Supreme Court. The President had sent in federal troops to defend their decision, to back up their authority, but the drama wasn't over.
44:32 Speaker 06 A few months later, the Little Rock School Board petitioned to postpone their integration plan. That case, Cooper v. Aaron, eventually made its way to the Supreme Court. And the Supreme Court, feeling bold, decided that the state of Arkansas wasn't allowed to undermine their ruling in Brown v. Board. And then...
44:53 Speaker 03 They go way beyond that.
44:56 Speaker 02 The Court, for the first time, explicitly asserts that it is supreme in the interpretation of the Constitution.
45:02 Speaker 03 It was a claim of judicial supremacy, the likes of which had never occurred at the Supreme Court.
45:09 Speaker 02 And cites Marbury.
45:11 Speaker 03 Marbury versus Madison says it's the function and duty of the Supreme Court to interpret the Constitution, but it didn't say everybody's bound by it.
45:21 Speaker 02 Right, but the Court takes a sentence out of context. So there's the famous line in it where Marshall says... It is emphatically the duty of the Judicial Department to say what the law is.
45:33 Speaker 06 As we learned earlier in the episode, what that meant in 1803 was that the Court could decide what the law is only in the case at hand. But in 1958, the Court was asserting that it had carte blanche power. A decision in one case applied to everyone, everywhere in the country. In other words, judicial supremacy.
45:55 Speaker 03 We set the floor and we set the ceiling.
46:01 Rund Abdelfatah? Thing is, not everyone was bought into the idea of judicial supremacy yet.
46:06 Speaker 02 It's greeted with widespread skepticism because remember, most of the people on the left had fought the earlier court battles. They were Roosevelt people, and the idea of judicial supremacy was anathema to their understanding.
46:18 Rund Abdelfatah? How could they give final say power to a court that had stood in the way of so much legislation they believed in?
46:24 Speaker 02 But there is a new generation of rising liberals who, seeing an activist liberal court, like, love this. So they embrace the idea of judicial supremacy because they're looking at a court that's enabling them to do all sorts of things that they think are good and right and important.
46:42 Speaker 03 I believe that we can and that we must restore integrity in government and the confidence of people in the integrity of their government.
46:55 Rund Abdelfatah? This is the voice of Earl Warren. He was chief justice of the court during both Brown v. Board and Cooper v. Aaron, which marked the beginning of what would come to be known as the Warren Court era. And over the next decade, the 1960s, under his leadership, the court will expand its power like never before. I think on this day, many of us didn't realize just how important our movement with those people.
47:25 Speaker 03 The real invader is integration. Unless we integrate, we shall very quickly. The people will get to the promised land. My eyes have seen the glory of the promised land.
47:44 Speaker 03 The 60s are a time of incredible ferment because African-Americans in the South are starting to demand the rights that the Constitution gave them a century earlier. You've got Martin Luther King. You have demonstrations. You have citians. You go to a counter and sit down beside him. You cause no violence. You're friendly. It sort of helps to project the idea that here sits beside me another human being. And the South is fighting to maintain white supremacy.
48:27 Speaker 03 Well, it's just not the things we're used to down here. I mean, because I wasn't raised with them. I never have lived with them, and I'm not going to start now. And the court is at the forefront of the national government in trying to bring civil rights to the fore.
48:45 Rund Abdelfatah? Remember that footnote in the case back in the Roosevelt era? The one about the civil rights corner being reserved for the Supreme Court to look at cases in which civil rights might have been denied? Well, during the 1960s, the Supreme Court started getting case after case relating to civil rights issues. And in case after case, the court ruled in favor of expanding civil rights nationwide. It was slowly setting the precedent on the most important issue of the day.
49:15 Speaker 06 And the real tipping point came in 1963. President Kennedy is reported to be fighting for his life in a Dallas hospital, but reports conflict. CBS says he is dead. After John F. Kennedy was assassinated, Lyndon B. Johnson replaced him as president.
49:34 Speaker 03 When Lyndon Johnson takes the presidency, he tells the country that the legacy of John Kennedy is civil rights, and to cement it, we need the Civil Rights Act. This Civil Rights Act is a challenge to all of us. Something that Kennedy might not have been able to get passed, but Johnson is able to get passed. To go to work in our communities and our states, in our homes and in our hearts, to eliminate the last vestiges of injustice in our beloved country.
50:10 Speaker 03 And the Court can look at the Civil Rights Act and say, "We were right, and now Congress agrees that we were right."
50:21 Rund Abdelfatah? A decade after Brown v. Board, Congress and the President were agreeing with the vision first proposed by the Court: A desegregated nation with equal rights for all.
50:31 Speaker 03 The Court is identified quite properly as the vanguard in civil rights among the branches of government. So it's a tremendous validation by Congress of what the Court had been doing. And Lyndon Johnson, at one time, a couple of years later, stated, "Never in American history have the three branches of government worked so well together." You have each of the branches of government doing what it can do to further the national interest.
51:07 Rund Abdelfatah? In other words, there was no pushback. All three branches had the same shared goals, which meant they weren't going to stand in each other's way.
51:15 Speaker 06 And just as fast as the federal government's power was growing, state's power was shrinking.
51:22 Speaker 03 There's no doubt that the Court has very little respect for states' rights. So what you have is a nationalization of criminal procedure, forcing a number of states, all of a sudden states, a number of northern states, to change the way that they do business.
51:46 Speaker 03 Furthermore, the Court, for the first time, gets involved in elections.
51:52 Speaker 04 This is a voting rights case. It's brought here on a--
51:58 Speaker 03 It says that, you know, it's not a problem for the federal judiciary to evaluate state and federal elections.
52:06 Speaker 04 They are the intended and actual victims.
52:10 Speaker 04 of a statutory scheme which reduces their right to vote to about 1/20 of the value of the vote given to certain rural residents.
52:22 Speaker 03 And then that turns out to be one person, one vote?
52:27 Speaker 06 One person, one vote. In a series of Supreme Court cases that came to be known as the apportionment cases, the court decided that electoral districts had to be divided up according to population size.
52:40 Speaker 04 We're not arguing for absolute mathematical equality here. We're asking for the reasonable equality required for the 14th Amendment.
52:47 Speaker 06 Therefore, making each district roughly equal in population, which meant black voters would be more fairly represented in their districts.
52:56 Rund Abdelfatah? In the eyes of liberals, the court was behind a lot of the success of the civil rights era. And by the late 1960s, any doubts they'd had about judicial supremacy were pretty much gone.
53:08 Speaker 03 Liberals, a big skeptical of the court from the New Deal period, are changing. Hey, this is working.
53:17 Rund Abdelfatah? Plus, there was now a black Supreme Court justice, the first ever.
53:22 Speaker 04 Historians will note this hour at the White House. In a Rose Garden ceremony, a 58-year-old great-grandson of a slave is nominated by President Johnson to be a Supreme Court justice. He is Solicitor General Thurgood Marshall, acknowledged the best-known Negro lawyer of the century.
53:38 Rund Abdelfatah? As for conservatives who hated the decisions of the Warren Court, they were still totally fine with the principle of judicial supremacy. They were just biding their time till the court flipped conservative again.
53:51 Speaker 06 So for the first time in American history, there was consensus across the board that the Supreme Court should have the final say over the Constitution.
54:01 Speaker 02 So that settles that who has final authority debate. And the debate shifts from who has final interpretive authority, now everybody says it's the court, to how the Constitution should be interpreted.
54:22 Speaker 04 At almost midday Eastern time, NBC News projected Richard Nixon, the 37th President of the United States. It was so close, it took forever, but he won it.
54:31 Speaker 06 It was, again, one of the closest elections in American history. After Richard Nixon, a Republican, was elected President in 1968, the tables began to turn on the court. Over the next few years, Earl Warren and several other liberal justices would leave the court, and Nixon would replace them with more conservative justices.
54:53 Rund Abdelfatah? As the Warren Court era wound down, the court tried to advance individual rights. Its swan song was Roe v. Wade, in which the court ruled that restricting access to safe and legal abortion was unconstitutional.
55:09 Speaker 03 Roe versus Wade is the last gasp of that reforming liberalism.
55:19 Rund Abdelfatah? And from that point on...
55:21 Speaker 02 It's been a steady march to the right in terms of the court's ideology. The irony is, the subsequent courts have been using the Warren Court's credibility, the court's credibility from the Warren Court, to undo everything the Warren Court accomplished over the last 50 years. So, most of what the court has done has been trying to reverse decisions and trends and bodies of doctrine that the Warren Court set into motion.
55:46 Speaker 03 Fortunately, they're saying, "You guys showed us how to do it, now we're gonna do it our way." You had your Warren Court, we want our Warren Court. And that may be what the three Trump appointees to the Supreme Court will provide, that now the Republicans may have their Warren Court.
56:09 Speaker 02 And it doesn't matter whether it's a liberal court like the Warren Court, a moderate court like the Burger Court, or a conservative court like the Rehnquist and Roberts Courts, all of them have been the same in this, which is they just keep expanding their power because there's nobody pushing back.
56:40 Rund Abdelfatah? That's it for this week's show. I'm Randa Abdel Fattah, and you've been listening to Throughline from NPR. This episode was produced by me, Ramtin Arablouei, and Jamie York, Lawrence Wu, Laine Kaplan-Levinson, Julie Kane, Victoria Whitley Berry,
56:55 Speaker 02 Parth Shah.
56:56 Rund Abdelfatah? Thank you to Austin Horn, Travis Lux, Pranjali Shah, and Jess Berry for their voiceover work. Thanks also to Irene Noguchi, Julia Redpath, Yolanda Sangwene, Beth Donovan, Leanna Simstrom, and Anya Grunman. Our music was composed by Ramtin and his band Drop Electric, which includes Navid Marvi,
57:16 Speaker 03 Sho Fujiwara,
57:17 Rund Abdelfatah? Anya Mizani. If you have an idea or like something on the show, please write us at throughline@npr.org or leave us a review on Apple or Spotify. Thanks for listening.
57:38 Speaker 02 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Bombas. For every item purchased, they donate an item to someone who needs it. Bombas customers have powered over 200 million donations. Go to B-O-M-B-A-S dot com slash NPR for 20% off your first purchase.
57:59 Rund Abdelfatah? Midlife brings a lot of changes. Your Turn with Alison Aubrey is a new podcast to help you navigate the twists and turns. From health and relationships to creativity and purpose, we can help steer your next chapter with Your Turn with Alison Aubrey. Find it on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
58:17 Speaker 00 Support comes from NPR sponsor AARP.
Previous Captain America and the nation's conscience Next Prosperity gospel and the American dream Page updated October 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated