Pod Insights Throughline California's 'Bum Blockade' About this episode The story of the Los Angeles police chief who, faced with one of the largest internal migrations in American history, tried to close California's borders to stop it.
To access bonus episodes and listen to Throughline sponsor-free, subscribe to Throughline+ via Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org/throughline.
See pcm.adswizz.com https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.
NPR Privacy Policy https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy
Transcript 7,502 words · 27 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 This message comes from Schwab. At Schwab, you can get everything from self-directed investing to full-service wealth management, all in one place. No matter your investing goal, life stage, amount to invest, or know-how, you can invest your way with Schwab.
0:17 Rund Abdelfatah? Hey, everyone. Before we start the show, you may have heard that President Trump has issued an executive order seeking to block all federal funding to NPR. This is the latest in a series of threats to media organizations across the country.
0:31 Speaker 02 Millions of people, people like you, people like me, depend on the NPR network as a vital source of news, entertainment, information, and connection. We are proud to be here for you. And now, more than ever, we need you to be here for us.
0:50 Rund Abdelfatah? It's time to join the movement to defend public media. Visit donate.npr.org. And if you already support us via NPR Plus or another means, thank you.
1:01 Speaker 02 Your support means so much to us now more than ever. You help make NPR shows freely available to everyone. We are proud to do this work for you and with you.
1:14 Rund Abdelfatah? Now, on to the show.
1:41 Speaker 03 The only time that I really remember that I was scared was that dark thunder.
1:47 Rund Abdelfatah? Oklahoma, April 14, 1935.
1:52 Speaker 04 We could see it coming.
1:54 Speaker 03 It rolled in like smoke, almost.
2:01 Rund Abdelfatah? On the horizon, a wall of black dust, over 500 feet tall, stretching as far as the eye could see.
2:13 Speaker 04 It would be just that quiet.
2:19 Speaker 03 The neighbors said there was birds flying into that storm.
2:23 Rund Abdelfatah? And, uh... That storm hit.
2:36 Rund Abdelfatah? Sixty mile per hour winds.
2:42 Rund Abdelfatah? You couldn't see your hand in front of your face. The storm ripped through six states, from Nebraska to Texas. In some places, total darkness lasted an hour.
2:57 Speaker 03 Black, whole black. It was as black as the ace's face.
3:09 Speaker 02 It was a day that haunted the minds of those who lived through it. They called it Black Sunday.
3:20 Speaker 03 You just felt like you were going to choke, you know? That dust was just, you couldn't hardly breathe.
3:25 Speaker 05 If you knew anything about the scripture, you know what it says? The moon will turn dark and this, that, and the other. So we just had the feeling that this is the end of time.
3:34 Speaker 03 I thought that was the end of the world.
3:38 Speaker 02 The very next day, a journalist coined a new term to describe what was happening across the Great Plains. He called it "The Dust Bowl." What you just heard were oral histories conducted with people who lived in the heart of it.
3:55 Speaker 03 That those dust storms just devastated the country.
4:01 Speaker 05 They were perpetual, and you can depend on it.
4:04 Rund Abdelfatah? The dust was relentless and inescapable. It covered every inch of people's homes. It choked the crops. It filled people's lungs, causing hundreds, maybe thousands, of people to die from dust pneumonia. The Dust Bowl made the Great Plains nearly uninhabitable.
4:24 Speaker 03 So many of them left. No, he is. Went to California.
4:43 Speaker 06 Lots of folks back east they say leaving home every day feeding the hot old dusty way to the California line.
4:51 Rund Abdelfatah? Woody Guthrie, the Dust Bowl troubadour, immortalized this time in song.
4:56 Speaker 06 Across the desert sands they roll getting out of that old Dust Bowl. They think they're going to a sugar bowl, but here's what they find.
5:05 Speaker 02 Looking east from Los Angeles, the city's top brass began to panic. The Dust Bowl migrants were not the kind of people they wanted coming to their shining city, so they began to hatch a plan to stop them.
5:21 Speaker 06 Now the police at the port of entry say you're number 14,000 for today. Oh, if you ain't got the do re mi force, you ain't got the do re mi.
5:36 Rund Abdelfatah? I'm Rund Abdelfatah.
5:38 Speaker 02 And I'm Ramtin Arablouei.
5:40 Rund Abdelfatah? Today on the show, producer Anya Steinberg tells the story of one of the largest internal migrations in American history and the rogue police chief who tried to close California's borders to stop it.
5:54 Speaker 06 California is a garden of Eden, a paradise to live in or see. But believe it or not, you won't find it so hot if you ain't got the do re mi.
6:14 Speaker 07 Hi, this is Kyle from Boystown, Nebraska. You are listening to Throughline from NPR.
6:20 Speaker 08 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Capella University. You know that feeling when there's a spark building inside you? That you were meant for more? That's your own drive pushing you towards what's next. Capella University gets that. With their FlexPath learning format, you can set the pace and earn your degree without putting life on pause. You've built experience and know what you're capable of. Now, this is your time to turn that momentum into more. The only real question is, what can't you do? Learn more at capella.edu.
6:58 Speaker 08 This message comes from Live Right, publisher of John U. Bacon's New York Times bestseller, The Gales of November, a chronicle of the S.S. Edmund Fitzgerald's 1975 shipwreck. "Never has it been told better than by Mr. Bacon in this colorful book," writes John J. Miller of The Wall Street Journal, while author Hampton Sides proclaims it's destined to be a classic. The Gales of November, now in paperback.
7:23 Speaker 00 This message comes from Jerry. Many people are overpaying on car insurance. Why? Switching providers can be a pain. Jerry helps make the process painless. Jerry is the only app that compares rates from over 50 insurers in minutes and helps you switch fast with no spam calls or hidden fees. Drivers who save with Jerry could save over $1,300 a year. Before you renew your car insurance policy, download the Jerry app or head to jerry.ai/npr.
7:54 Speaker 09 Part One: The Great White Spot.
8:02 Speaker 09 It's a balmy February day in Los Angeles, California.
8:08 Speaker 09 The year is 1926, just a few years before the Dust Bowl begins. And Detective Lieutenant James Davis--
8:16 Speaker 10 Otherwise known as Two-Gun Davis because of his incredible marksmanship--
8:20 Speaker 09 is sitting at his desk at the Detective Bureau office.
8:24 Speaker 10 A very proper man.
8:26 Speaker 09 Just then, a reporter barges through and informs the 36-year-old Davis that he's just been named the interim chief of the Los Angeles Police Department.
8:42 Speaker 09 Davis blinks in surprise as he realizes that he's now in charge of all police officers in the nation's so-called "Wonder City" that's quickly becoming a shining metropolis, driven by the riches and glamour of Hollywood, oil, and real estate for whoever can afford it.
9:05 Speaker 10 Davis started his life very poor.
9:07 Speaker 09 Born in 1889 in Texas.
9:10 Speaker 10 To a strict Methodist mother.
9:12 Speaker 11 Once, as a youngster, I found a pack of playing cards. I took them home and asked my mother what they were. She told me and hurriedly threw them in the fire.
9:24 Speaker 09 Davis's upbringing shaped his worldview.
9:26 Speaker 10 He lived a lifetime of sobriety.
9:28 Speaker 09 This is Bill Lasher, author of The Golden Fortress: California's Border War on Dust Bowl Refugees.
9:34 Speaker 10 He was a very brusque, very authoritarian man.
9:40 Speaker 09 At age 16, he ran away from home. For a while, he farmed and worked hard labor jobs. Then he joined the army and was stationed in the Philippines.
9:50 Speaker 10 In the army, brought discipline to his life, a sense of order and stability.
9:55 Speaker 09 The military was a good fit, but once he left the army, his future was less clear. So, like many others, he migrated to California.
10:04 Speaker 10 And arrived in Los Angeles penniless and unsure what he was going to do next.
10:10 Speaker 09 He was so poor that all he had to wear was his army uniform. Until he heard about a new opportunity with the LAPD.
10:19 Speaker 10 He signs up and gets work as a beat officer.
10:25 Speaker 09 But it doesn't go well.
10:28 Speaker 09 He gets kicked out. He drifts for a while, traveling across the US doing odd jobs, but then?
10:35 Speaker 10 He writes a letter to the then-police chief, asking for another chance.
10:41 Speaker 09 And he gets it.
10:44 Speaker 09 In 1912, he returns to the LAPD. After a while, he's placed on the vice squad.
10:51 Speaker 10 He was an early drug warrior. He saw it as a moral contagion to be the drug addict.
10:58 Speaker 12 The underworld fears, but does not hate him. He'll play square, his victims tell you.
11:05 Speaker 09 Close your eyes and imagine a cop from a film noir movie. Well, that's pretty much James "Two-Gun" Davis.
11:12 Speaker 10 He is known for sort of daring raids on things like drug dens and vice dens.
11:19 Speaker 12 His friends call him Jim, and his enemies give him lots of elbow room.
11:24 Speaker 10 At one point, he like swung through a window to, you know, arrest some criminals.
11:29 Speaker 09 And the local papers, like the LA Times, eat it up.
11:33 Speaker 12 He's got guts, is the consensus of opinion among the gentry that ought to know.
11:39 Speaker 09 The press is obsessed with him. They wax poetic about his, quote, "eyes blue and keen," and his, quote, "thick, wavy hair."
11:48 Speaker 12 He knows what it is to have the muzzle of a revolver pressed against his rib.
11:52 Speaker 10 He believes maybe there's some fights, maybe there's some people hurt, but if he gets those criminals, it's okay.
12:02 Speaker 09 In 1921, after years of paying his dues in the rank and file, the higher-ups at the LAPD finally start to take notice of Davis. They give him his first promotion.
12:14 Speaker 10 Then it's like wildfire.
12:15 Speaker 09 Davis moves fast.
12:17 Speaker 10 Bust after bust after bust.
12:18 Speaker 09 He becomes head of the vice squad.
12:20 Speaker 10 Promotion after promotion after promotion.
12:22 Speaker 09 Until that fateful day in 1926, when he learns that he's been chosen as the interim chief of police. Shortly after, Davis gets the job for good, and he immediately starts to reshape and modernize the force into a more...
12:38 Speaker 10 Professionalized, standardized, uniformed police force.
12:43 Speaker 09 Under his watch, LAPD officers have to look a certain way.
12:47 Speaker 10 He enforces, wearing the uniform of a certain militaristic style.
12:52 Speaker 09 And they have to know how to use their guns.
12:55 Speaker 10 He insists that members of LAPD are top marksmen.
13:02 Speaker 09 Davis is a showman when it comes to his raids, but he's making all these other changes quietly.
13:08 Speaker 10 He is what the LA Times describes as "soft-spoken and hard-fisted." This is the picture that his friends will paint you of the youngest chief of police in the history of the city. That soft-spokenness, that idea that he's not saying anything, but he's taking action, is the image that he wants the entire police force to promote.
13:35 Speaker 09 LA civic and business leaders, as well as the press, like the LA Times, applauded his efforts. He was exactly the kind of police chief they wanted running LA, because they had plans for what this up-and-coming city should look like and be like.
13:52 Speaker 13 New friends and their money. Its resources are unlimited. Its wealth untold. Its possibilities unsurpassed.
14:02 Speaker 10 Especially through the 1920s, a lot of the leadership of the city is wanting it to be sort of a beacon that literally they articulate as the "white spot" of the United States.
14:13 Speaker 09 Yeah, you heard that right. The white spot.
14:17 Speaker 13 The prosperity of this great white spot is the talk of the country.
14:23 Speaker 09 Even though LA was formerly part of Mexico and continued to be a vibrant, multi-ethnic city, a lot like it is today, it didn't matter. It was about the image of what it could be, more than the reality.
14:37 Speaker 13 Los Angeles is the great white spot on the industrial map of the United States. Cash in on this great era of prosperity.
14:46 Speaker 14 Los Angeles very quickly recognized that its key to prosperity lay in advertising and promoting images.
14:56 Speaker 09 This is Mark Wild, a history professor at Cal State Los Angeles.
15:00 Speaker 14 The Los Angeles Times put out something called a mid-winter edition every late January, early February, right in the teeth of the winter for the Northeast and the Midwest. And they would send it out, and it would be full of pictures of people sitting in their gardens, growing these huge oranges, these huge fat babies on the lawn. And they'd say, "You know, it's 75 and sunny here in Los Angeles. Why don't you come out?"
15:21 Speaker 10 This image becomes produced of a city of empty land, of a place where anyone, the right kind of person, and there is a, there's a very clearly articulated idea of people with money already, who can come and invest and build on this quote unquote "empty land" that's in Los Angeles.
15:42 Speaker 14 The business plan is to promote it as a place of prosperity, to promote it as a place of good investment. And a corollary to that is that there is a docile, willing workforce that's not going to cause trouble.
15:55 Speaker 09 Which was an important bit of marketing. Because in recent years, labor organizers had taken aim at big business across the country. There were headlines about unrest, disruptions, sometimes even violence. L.A. was like, "No, no, none of that here."
16:14 Speaker 14 And the city government is really in tune with promoting those interests and making sure that the image persists and that it's not threatened by working-class communities, immigrant communities that might be engaged in activities that would undermine it.
16:33 Speaker 09 And Davis, the crusader against vice, becomes a symbol of this effort.
16:38 Speaker 10 And he's constantly talking about the threat, about the external threat to Los Angeles, whether it's from drug users or quote unquote "vagrants" or communists or perceived communist labor agitators. This idea that people with ill intent are coming from one source or another to harm the safe and orderly process of life in Los Angeles.
17:04 Speaker 09 For Davis, that threat had to be dealt with by any means necessary.
17:12 Speaker 09 As one columnist put it.
17:13 Speaker 15 Davis, quite honestly and sincerely believes that the country would be better off if the whole question of constitutional rights was forgotten.
17:22 Speaker 09 To do this, he ramped up the work of the LAPD's nascent Los Angeles Intelligence Squad.
17:28 Speaker 14 Better known as the Red Squad.
17:30 Speaker 09 Which, as its name implies.
17:32 Speaker 14 Engaged in a number of activities, including surveillance. Red Squad of Police in City Augmented. They would spy on people who were suspected of radical activities.
17:44 Speaker 09 And keep tabs on suspected communists and labor organizers.
17:49 Speaker 14 Reds arrested after rioting.
17:51 Speaker 09 But it wasn't all in the shadows. The squad also knew how to put on a show to make it clear who did and didn't belong in LA.
18:00 Speaker 16 Quick arrests have been ordered to forestall any anti-American move.
18:06 Speaker 10 They would engage in public intimidation. They would clear demonstrations. They would bully people. They like to pull out their batons and crack heads.
18:16 Speaker 09 Police Chief James Davis had his critics, but they didn't slow him down.
18:21 Speaker 10 Until there's a kidnapping in early 1928.
18:28 Speaker 09 Mother believes her son kidnapped.
18:31 Speaker 17 The mystery surrounding the case of Walter Collins, nine years of age, remains impenetrable, police say.
18:40 Speaker 09 In March 1928, a young boy named Walter Collins goes missing. And for months, the LAPD cannot find him. It's a bad luck, and the pressure on the LAPD keeps growing. But then one day, the boy shows up in Illinois.
19:00 Speaker 17 Collins youth found in East.
19:03 Speaker 09 Mother hears good news. His mother immediately sends the money to have Walter brought back to her in Los Angeles. But when they reunite, she looks at the child and says, "That's not my son." And the LAPD is like, "Yes, he is." And when she insists that he's not...
19:21 Speaker 10 They arrest her and commit her to a mental institution.
19:26 Speaker 10 This causes eventually a tremendous scandal when it turns out that they haven't caught the kidnapper.
19:32 Speaker 09 And they haven't found Walter either. The boy they brought back is an imposter, a runaway pretending to be Walter.
19:44 Speaker 09 There's a huge fallout. People are angry at the LAPD.
19:52 Speaker 16 Remove from office, Chief of Police James E. Davis, on the grounds of incompetency, inefficiency, and failure to properly enforce the laws.
20:02 Speaker 09 Tensions continue through 1929. And then?
20:11 Speaker 09 The stock market crashes.
20:13 Speaker 10 And that begins the Great Depression.
20:16 Speaker 09 Everything is in chaos.
20:20 Speaker 09 And shortly after the market crash, Davis loses his job as the police chief.
20:29 Speaker 09 But before long, he'll get another chance.
20:47 Speaker 18 This is Jose Hernandez from California, and you're listening to Two Line from NPR.
20:51 Speaker 08 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from BetterHelp. Your brain has limited storage, so why is it still holding on to that embarrassing moment from years ago? BetterHelp is an online therapy platform that gives you space to talk about what's taking up too much of yours. BetterHelp is now in-network with more than 125 health plans, with mini co-pays as low as $15 for eligible members. And if you don't have eligible insurance, you can still get 20% off your first month. Visit betterhelp.com/NPR. Cost and coverage may vary. Discount cannot be combined with insurance. This message comes from Capella University. You know that feeling when there's a spark building inside you?
21:35 Speaker 08 That you were meant for more? That's your own drive pushing you towards what's next. Capella University gets that. With their FlexPath learning format, you can set the pace and earn your degree without putting life on pause. You've built experience and know what you're capable of. Now, this is your time to turn that momentum into more. The only real question is, what can't you do? Learn more at capella.edu. This message comes from Mint Mobile. Ditch overpriced wireless and get premium wireless for less. Go to mintmobile.com/switch to see which plan works for you.
22:16 Speaker 09 Part Two.
22:19 Speaker 09 California is closed.
22:24 Speaker 19 I remember it blue every day.
22:28 Speaker 19 Sometimes in the mornings, you could see the imprint of your head on the pillow. Would have been that dusty.
22:37 Speaker 09 In the 1930s, the Dust Bowl and the economic devastation of the Great Depression wreaked havoc on the lives of people across the country, but particularly the Great Plains.
22:48 Speaker 14 It's the South, it's the Northern Plains. Lots of farmers lose their farms or become convinced not to farm anymore because prices crash.
23:00 Speaker 20 I think there's a lot of desperation.
23:02 Speaker 09 This is Alisa Minoff. She's Director of Economic Security and a Senior Fellow in Policy History at the Center for the Study of Social Policy. And she wrote her PhD dissertation all about internal migration during this time period.
23:18 Speaker 20 By the mid-1930s, there've been so many bad years that people sort of lose hope in being able to sustain themselves on the farms.
23:26 Speaker 09 Once bustling family farms fell silent. And nearly a quarter of the country's workforce was unemployed.
23:34 Speaker 04 So many people were down on their luck, didn't have anything to eat, no job. You couldn't buy a job, you couldn't get a job.
23:40 Speaker 09 By 1940, 2.5 million people had moved out of the plains states. And over 300,000 of them made their way to California. Entire families packed up their belongings and hit the road.
23:55 Speaker 20 What would strike us about it today is that the journey was long, much longer than, you know, driving down Route 66 today.
24:08 Speaker 09 Route 66.
24:13 Speaker 09 In 1930, the Mother Road, as John Steinbeck would later dub it in his novel, The Grapes of Wrath, was over 2,400 miles long and stretched from Chicago all the way to Los Angeles.
24:26 Speaker 14 You had a steady stream of people coming across and oftentimes these broken-down-looking jalopies with all their, you know, life's possessions piled on top of them, families with kids. And that procession was real.
24:41 Speaker 09 The journey was difficult and lonely.
24:45 Speaker 20 As people passed from one town to the next, they were likely to have experienced xenophobia. Local sheriffs in these towns that people passed through were very intent on ensuring that families moved on and did not stay.
25:04 Speaker 21 All a transient hears is no work, no relief. Keep moving.
25:12 Speaker 20 And that really only sort of foreshadowed the difficulties they would have once they arrived in California.
25:25 Speaker 17 Is this the dumping ground for the country's unemployed? L.A. Times, 1932.
25:32 Speaker 14 In overall terms, migration to California slows.
25:36 Speaker 09 But people are still coming in. It's just not the kind of people Los Angeles city leaders wanted to attract.
25:44 Speaker 14 From the perspective of L.A. civic leadership, the character, the makeup of that population changes dramatically. There's a lot more folks coming in looking for work without capital. They're not going to be buying a home. They're not going to be moving into these middle-class districts. They're desperate.
26:03 Speaker 09 At first, there's a lot of sympathy for these migrants.
26:07 Speaker 14 Los Angeles had this network of support for destitute people. And so you had a lot of the missions and settlement homes and different types of institutions that would cater those folks sort of in downtown L.A.
26:21 Speaker 09 This was the case in cities across the country.
26:24 Speaker 14 The understanding basically was we were taking care of our own people. The care for these folks was really the duty of the communities in which they resided.
26:32 Speaker 09 But the Depression changed everything.
26:35 Speaker 14 Things got so tough, so quickly, so many people lost their jobs, lost their homes, lost their way of livelihood, that it swamped this private network of support that had existed. Completely overwhelmed the community chess organizations, the soup kitchens. There was just no way they could handle it.
26:56 Speaker 14 And so, as the decade progressed and the Great Depression continued, folks began to try to find ways to try to manage this burden. And one of the ways for communities where people were coming in was to try to exclude folks who they would claim didn't belong.
27:13 Speaker 09 And an easy target was all the newcomers driving into LA on Route 66.
27:20 Speaker 14 Some folks began to say, alright, folks who aren't working now, they have different options. Maybe they should be getting back to work, and if they aren't, then why not?
27:31 Speaker 09 Newspapers and politicians at the time often referred to these migrants as indigents, vagrants, transients, or bums.
27:39 Speaker 14 People are exhausted, and I think some of their sympathy is starting to run out.
27:48 Speaker 09 In 1933, LA elects a new mayor. His name is Frank Shaw, and he has a reputation for being anti-migrant.
27:58 Speaker 10 Shaw advocated for a county-wide anti-indigent ban in the 1930s in sort of the early days of the Depression.
28:04 Speaker 09 But there's a catch.
28:06 Speaker 10 The problem is that Shaw was born in Ontario, Canada.
28:10 Speaker 09 Shaw is Canadian. He is ironically a migrant himself. And also...
28:16 Speaker 10 There's not good evidence that his parents ever had him or his brother naturalized.
28:22 Speaker 09 And if that's the case, it means he's not actually eligible to be LA's mayor. It's a scandal in the making. And when Harry Chandler, the publisher of the LA Times catches wind of the story, he sees an opportunity. He goes to Shaw and says, let's make a deal.
28:39 Speaker 10 As the story goes, at least, he agrees to hold back these reports that are alleged to prove that Shaw is in fact a Canadian. And in exchange, he gets Shaw to agree to reinstall Davis as chief of police.
28:54 Speaker 09 James Davis, as in the recently fired police chief, who tends to play it loose when it comes to people's civil rights, all in the name of preventing crime.
29:04 Speaker 10 Chandler and others, people in the Los Angeles Chamber of Commerce, want someone like Davis, who isn't as concerned about the criticisms that happen with anti-labor activity, to be there at the head of LAPD.
29:16 Speaker 09 And it works. Davis is reinstated as the LAPD's chief of police, with the express purpose of picking up where he left off.
29:26 Speaker 10 The gloves are off, I guess. And he runs with it. Davis hits the ground running.
29:31 Speaker 09 It's not long before the Red Squad, the anti-communist policing unit, is again starting to infiltrate.
29:38 Speaker 10 Political movements and things like that, and starts to try to smear people perceived to be labor agitators.
29:46 Speaker 11 War, war to the finish. War in which every radical head will be stomped back into the earth as quickly as it rises.
29:57 Speaker 09 And of course, Davis keeps the interests of Chandler and the other business leaders of LA in mind. And they, in turn, scratch his back.
30:05 Speaker 22 We appreciate that Chief Davis and his coworkers in Los Angeles are fighting the battle of all of Southern California when they hold firmly in check the subversive activities of radical agitators.
30:20 Speaker 14 The Los Angeles Times, which as much as anyone really supported them, would report how they were sort of controlling the Reds and getting rid of the criminals and all of that.
30:30 Speaker 16 Suppression of violence commended. Colonial War Society praises Chief Davis and local police force.
30:37 Speaker 09 This time around, Davis gravitated to the attention. He wanted everyone to know that he meant business.
30:44 Speaker 14 He was a very media-friendly person. He loved to take pictures of himself looking tough, pointing guns at the camera. He really embraced the image.
30:54 Speaker 09 The state's incoming migrants quickly became the focus of his policing work. By the mid 1930s, these efforts were particularly pointed at single men, which Davis and critics would call hobos or vagrants.
31:09 Speaker 14 Those were the folks who were considered a threat. They're unattached, they're potentially prone to criminality, they're prone to labor disruption. And if you have a single male who doesn't have a family to provide for, no children to provide for, all those types of responsibilities tend to engender not only sympathy but responsibility.
31:31 Speaker 09 Speaking to a group of Hollywood women in 1934, Davis made it clear that his fight to rid the city of vagrants was an extension of his work to rid the city of communists.
31:41 Speaker 11 Americans are asleep. In two to six years, communism will be a reality in the United States if drastic steps are not taken to check it.
31:54 Speaker 09 Davis and LA's business elites feared that poor migrants coming into the state were more likely to join a labor movement or vote for socialist ideas, which they saw as a growing threat in California.
32:07 Speaker 23 We mean mass production under modern conditions. The land, the workers are to have the best land and the factory workers the best machinery.
32:17 Speaker 09 In 1934, Upton Sinclair.
32:20 Speaker 14 Most famous as a muckraking journalist. He wrote a book called The Jungle about the Chicago meatpacking industry.
32:27 Speaker 10 And until very recently, a socialist.
32:30 Speaker 14 He runs in the Democratic Party. And to everybody's shock, he wins the Democratic primary and he runs for the governor of California. And he devises a plan called Epic.
32:42 Speaker 23 And poverty in California.
32:45 Speaker 09 This is Upton Sinclair, speaking later in his life about his upstart campaign.
32:50 Speaker 23 And of course, Epic suggests something important and something wonderful.
32:56 Speaker 14 And this stuns the civic leadership in Los Angeles and across the state. They're scared to death because these policies seem to reflect a direct assault on business as usual.
33:09 Speaker 10 They fear that their hold on power is going to falter.
33:17 Speaker 09 So they get to work on a smear campaign to discredit Sinclair.
33:22 Speaker 14 They develop a message to counter Sinclair's campaign. They paint him as a radical. They paint him as a leftist.
33:29 Speaker 09 They even suggest he's a Russian agent.
33:32 Speaker 24 I'm going to vote for Upton Sinclair. Will you tell us why? Upton Sinclair is the author of the Russian government and it worked out very well there and I think it should do here.
33:41 Speaker 14 And then they enlist the Hollywood studios who obviously want a part of this as well.
33:45 Speaker 09 A lot of Hollywood bigwigs do not want radical politics. They want a nice, business-friendly LA. So they chip in and help produce so-called newsreels that would run before feature films at movie theaters.
33:59 Speaker 14 They create these fake newsreels. They have these actors hired to portray unemployed workers coming into California, riding the rails and saying, "I'm coming to California because I heard Upton Sinclair is going to be governor. And once he's in there, I'm going to be able to take advantage of these great resources that are going to be able to provide for me."
34:17 Speaker 03 California is going to be fair to poverty and everybody gets things for nothing.
34:23 Speaker 09 Upton Sinclair tries to fight it, calling it the lie machine. But it's a loud and inescapable campaign.
34:32 Speaker 14 And it works. He's defeated fairly easily.
34:40 Speaker 09 James Tugan Davis is watching this election unfold. He sees the growing fear of migrants, and he gets an idea. On February 3rd, 1936.
34:54 Speaker 10 135 officers in squads of 7 and 7 leave Los Angeles. They drive to 16 stations around the state of California. So, anywhere where there's a domestic state line.
35:11 Speaker 14 Arizona, Nevada, all the way up to the Oregon border. So he spread them out along this huge border, hundreds of miles long.
35:18 Speaker 10 Alongside highways and near rail crossings.
35:21 Speaker 14 And he arranged for all of them to be deputized by the local police or sheriff's office up there.
35:28 Speaker 10 To legally work as law enforcement officers in those counties.
35:33 Speaker 09 The papers call it "The Bum Blockade." And all along the California border, LAPD officers set up and wait.
35:51 Speaker 07 Hello, my name is Jeff Cooper from Bozeman, Montana. I love through line, usually listen to it on the way home from skiing with my two young daughters, or you'll catch me listening to it on the way to my job as a flight paramedic. Keep up the good work, I love through line, and it's a great show. Thank you.
36:11 Speaker 08 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Capella University. You know that feeling when there's a spark building inside you, that you were meant for more? That's your own drive, pushing you towards what's next. Capella University gets that. With their FlexPath learning format, you can set the pace and earn your degree without putting life on pause. You've built experience and know what you're capable of. Now, this is your time to turn that momentum into more. The only real question is, what can't you do? Learn more at capella.edu. This message comes from Live Right, publishers of John U.
36:52 Speaker 08 Bacon's New York Times bestseller, "The Gales of November: A Chronicle of the S.S. Edmund Fitzgerald's 1975 Shipwreck. The Gales of November," in paperback wherever books are sold.
37:05 Speaker 00 This message comes from Jerry. Noticing your car insurance rate creep up even without tickets or claims? You're not alone. That's why there's Jerry. Jerry handles the legwork by comparing quotes side by side from over 50 top insurers, so you can confidently hit buy. No spam calls, no hidden fees. Jerry even tracks rates and alerts you when it's best to shop. Drivers who save with Jerry could save over $1,300 a year. Don't overpay. Download the Jerry app or visit jerry.ai/npr today.
37:39 Speaker 13 Part Three. That Do Re Mi.
37:51 Speaker 21 While the worker on the survey observed the officers, about half the automobiles were allowed to pass without any inspection.
37:58 Speaker 09 In 1936, the California state government released a nearly 400-page report on migrants to the state. And an entire section of it was devoted to surveyors' eyewitness accounts of the LAPD's border blockade.
38:16 Speaker 21 A beautiful new Packard sedan with four passengers was signaled to pass. The officer turning to the worker, remarking, "We would make enemies if we stopped people like that."
38:37 Speaker 21 A 1929 Ford Roadster, dripping water and oil with a homemade trailer attached, came to a stop under the canopy. The police beckoned them to halt.
38:49 Speaker 14 They would try to discourage people who looked like they were very poor from coming into California.
38:54 Speaker 10 It's being enforced very subjectively.
38:58 Speaker 21 The old car was lacking paint in spots, spattered with oil-soaked dust, and probably not washed for a year or so.
39:05 Speaker 10 If it's a rundown car, it might be stopped. A man traveling alone is more likely to be stopped.
39:21 Speaker 21 The family totaled nine. The oldest boy, 18, sat alone in the middle of the trailer. Heaped around him for what appeared to be all the worldly possessions the family owned.
39:32 Speaker 10 Questioning them, asking why they're coming into state, where they're coming from, who they are, what their name is. Proof of work, proof of means, or proof you have somewhere to go.
39:41 Speaker 21 A check with the police revealed that the family were coming to California for the first time to see the wife's sister. They had $30 in cash. The captain of the highway patrol informed the travelers that it would cost $20 to clear the licenses on the car and trailer. For 10 minutes or so, the scene was tense. The mother clutched her baby girl to her as she broke out in sobs. The boys sat quietly, staring into space, waiting for their parents to decide. The father, unshaven and unwashed, silently took his place behind the wheel. The battery was low, and the motor did not respond, but when it did, it sounded as if
40:22 Speaker 21 it too was undesirable and in need of assistance. The father turned the Ford around, and the family of nine went back over the road they had traveled, having denied police the privilege of fingerprinting them as not wanted in California.
40:45 Speaker 09 Surveyors' reports of the blockade told a story of inconsistency. The police stopped hitchhikers, cars, trains, and buses coming into the state. In some places, migrants were fingerprinted, and those prints were sent off to LA and to Washington DC to check for a criminal background. Some were detained in local jails. Others were just turned around and sent back across the state border.
41:16 Speaker 09 To pull off the blockade, from a legal standpoint, the LAPD was relying on an anti-indigent state law that had been passed in 1933.
41:25 Speaker 14 That prevented the importation of people into the state, quote unquote, "likely to become a public charge."
41:31 Speaker 09 A "public charge," meaning they would be a drain on the city's coffers.
41:36 Speaker 14 So the law itself is sort of representing that ideology, and that then becomes the legal justification for the bum blockade. They weren't trying to stop all migration into California. They were trying to stop certain people from coming in.
41:51 Speaker 09 As soon as the LAPD's border blockade was rolled out, it made headlines.
41:57 Speaker 16 Most public officials chatter at length in print about the desirable things they are going to do. A few do things first and talk about them afterward. While the interminable talkers at Sacramento are fuming and spluttering, 136 of the city's finest are on the job, turning back undesirables.
42:15 Speaker 14 I could find people who both supported and opposed it.
42:19 Speaker 16 Hobos of America will fight in the courts, if necessary, to preserve their constitutional rights in this city's current Border Patrol campaign against indigent transients.
42:28 Speaker 14 The debate turned on a question of character of the blockade's targets. Were they victims of economic circumstance who deserved sympathy? Or were they arriving due to some cultural or moral flaw? Were they unwilling to work?
42:49 Speaker 22 Why should California become the stamping ground for undesirables? Professional bums, men and women who come here merely to live off others?
42:59 Speaker 14 The phrase that Davis often used was "won't workers," that they refused opportunities that were available to them in their home communities or in other parts of the country, and that therefore, we did not owe them entry.
43:15 Speaker 09 In this sense, the blockade was building on sentiments that already ran deep. Cities and towns had always struggled with the question of what to do when desperate people showed up on their doorsteps. And anti-vagrancy laws had existed since before the US was even founded. In the 1930s, LA wasn't even the only place that tried out a blockade.
43:37 Speaker 20 There were similar actual border blockades.
43:41 Speaker 09 The governor of Florida had sent the state police out to the state's border two years before the LAPD's blockade. But still...
43:49 Speaker 20 The LA border blockade attracts a huge amount of attention because of the theatricality of it.
43:56 Speaker 09 In some places, Police Chief Davis's blockade became a laughingstock. On the border with Nevada, some men from Reno put up a sign mocking the blockade that said, "Stop: Los Angeles City Limits." Backlash against the blockade spread, and it was reported out in newspapers across the region.
44:17 Speaker 12 "Bum blockade is merely LA publicity," says Oregon Governor Martin.
44:22 Speaker 09 A California state senator called the program...
44:25 Speaker 12 "Damnable, absurd, and asinine."
44:28 Speaker 09 Some of the sheriffs in border towns refused to deputize Davis's officers.
44:33 Speaker 12 "I do not intend to place county officers and taxpayers in a position which almost certainly would lead to lawsuits."
44:40 Speaker 09 And a newspaper publisher near the border of Nevada said...
44:43 Speaker 15 "People here are anything but friendly to the plan. In fact, they don't like it a bit. So far, they think it's just a lot of hooey."
44:54 Speaker 09 In the pages of the LA Times, Davis was given space to defend his blockade, and to keep people updated on how he thought it was going.
45:03 Speaker 17 "February 5, 1936."
45:06 Speaker 11 "I doubt if the people so ready with criticism of this plan know the facts. The hordes of indigents are coming with the idea of getting on relief rolls, begging, or stealing."
45:18 Speaker 17 "February 10, 1936."
45:22 Speaker 11 "Within 36 hours after placing a blockade, the tide of forging floaters was turned."
45:32 Speaker 09 And on February 12th, he took to the airwaves.
45:38 Speaker 25 Los Angeles Police calling all cars, attention all cars, call cat 116. Be on the lookout for Eddie Griffith. Described as American 823.
45:49 Speaker 10 Calling all cars was this sort of predecessor to shows like Dragnet and other cop shows.
45:55 Speaker 09 The show was based on real cases from the LAPD.
45:59 Speaker 10 It's sort of a propaganda machine for the LAPD.
46:02 Speaker 25 And now we present Chief James E. Davis of the Los Angeles Police Department. Good evening, friends.
46:10 Speaker 09 That week, Davis had a special story prepared for critics of his blockade.
46:15 Speaker 25 The killer, whose career of crime will be unfolded for you here this evening, was a typical migratory criminal who entered the state in the parlance of a hobo.
46:29 Speaker 09 The killer, a man named Eddie Griffith, had embarked on a crime spree, traveling from Seattle to California by hitchhiking and riding the rails.
46:38 Speaker 25 He came into California without money, without any visible means of support. He sought to forage in green pastures, even if he had to rob and kill to do so.
46:49 Speaker 09 And before he launched into the story, Davis made his case.
46:54 Speaker 25 Tonight's story is the true story of one migratory indigent whose criminal career, under a proper fingerprint and border patrol program, might have been lived in the bud.
47:06 Speaker 09 If something like his border blockade had existed, Davis said Eddie Griffith never would have made it to California. The only hitch was, there was no Eddie Griffith. The story wasn't true.
47:22 Speaker 09 It was a dramatized version of a couple of police cases stitched together and embellished. And the same was starting to seem true of the entire premise of Davis's border blockade. His claims about hordes of dangerous migrants storming the border were seeming flimsier each day.
47:44 Speaker 12 While Los Angeles city cops huddled in the High Sierras, engaged in a "war to save California from the hobos", a checkup showed the war was dying out due to an almost complete lack of hobos.
47:58 Speaker 20 Police Chief Davis claimed that they turned away thousands of migrants at the border. I think that's hard to verify.
48:06 Speaker 14 They only actually stopped a small number of people.
48:11 Speaker 09 On March 17th...
48:12 Speaker 20 The Attorney General of California finally issues an opinion and says that, "No, the police chief cannot do this."
48:21 Speaker 09 Calling the blockade unconstitutional. He says...
48:25 Speaker 16 "Organized government, state, county, or municipal, should not attempt the achievement of a laudable purpose by unlawful means."
48:34 Speaker 20 California is one state in a sisterhood of states.
48:38 Speaker 16 "As other states must do unto California, so must California do unto them."
48:45 Speaker 09 By the end of March, things were looking grim for the blockade's future. The ACLU had organized a lawsuit against the blockade, which newspapers reported was only dropped after police intimidated the lead plaintiff. Bad press about the blockade continued to pile up. Most of all, it was expensive. And so, in early April, after a little over two months, the blockade ended. Its demise came quietly, without any fanfare or headlines in the paper.
49:20 Speaker 14 I think it was fairly obvious to most people at the time that this was for show, that this was not making an appreciable difference in migration into the state. Lots of people were still coming in. It was fairly easy to get around the blockade if you needed to.
49:37 Speaker 20 Looking back from the perspective of history, no, it was not effective.
49:47 Speaker 09 In 1938, James Davis's career as police chief ended. For good this time. He was forced to resign after it was revealed that he'd helped cover up the bombing of a private investigator who'd been looking into corruption in the LAPD. Davis spent the final years of his life sailing aboard a tuna trawler and collecting his pension. Meanwhile, California's attitude towards migrants changed.
50:26 Speaker 14 With the arrival of World War II, suddenly, everything slams into reverse.
50:33 Speaker 09 The US starts ramping up the war effort in 1940, sending supplies to Allied forces in Europe.
50:39 Speaker 14 Suddenly, California and many other places state want as many migrants as possible because of the building war effort. And so, communities that might have wanted to exclude people before are now desperate for them.
50:54 Speaker 09 And in 1941, a Supreme Court case would cement that change. Edwards v. California. The case revolved around a 1933 law, the same anti-indigent law that Davis used as legal justification for his blockade. The plaintiff had been caught bringing his brother-in-law, who had no job and no money, into California. And the justices ruled unanimously in his favor.
51:23 Speaker 12 It is a privilege of citizenship of the United States to enter any state of the Union.
51:31 Speaker 14 We can no longer have any of these laws prohibiting interstate migration of citizens.
51:37 Speaker 12 If national citizenship means less than this, it means nothing.
51:43 Speaker 14 And so that eliminates that law precisely because of national defense, that this may be a barrier to sending labor to places where we're going to need it in case of a national emergency.
51:55 Speaker 12 The Constitution was framed upon the theory that the peoples of several states must sink or swim together, and that in the long run, prosperity and salvation are in union and not division.
52:14 Speaker 09 In some ways, Davis's legacy, the border blockade, lived on. Just maybe not with the effect he intended.
52:25 Speaker 20 It really did lead people to try and interrogate the rights that they instinctively felt were being violated by the blockade. People said, "If citizenship means anything, it means that I should be able to move about the United States and to be treated like I belonged where I ended up."
52:52 Speaker 14 I think the blockade shows the malleable definition of who deserves to belong or not belong in a community. Different people can come under attack, even those that you wouldn't expect, like native-born white American citizens. The instrumental morality of attitudes towards migrants and homeless people depending on social demand, it really does turn a dime.
53:36 Speaker 06 You want to buy you a home or farm? That can't deal nobody harm. Or take your vacation by the mountains or sea. Don't swap your old cow for a car. You better stay right where you are. You better take this little tip from me, 'cause I look through the want ads every day. But the headlines on the papers always say, "If you ain't got the do re mi, boys, you ain't got the do re mi." Why, you better go back to beautiful Texas, Oklahoma, Kansas, Georgia, Tennessee.
54:16 Speaker 06 California is a garden of Eden, a paradise to live in or see. But believe it or not, you won't find it so hot if you ain't got the do re mi.
54:38 Rund Abdelfatah? That's it for this week's show. I'm Rund Abdelfatah.
54:42 Speaker 02 And I'm Ramtin Arablouei, and you've been listening to Throughline from NPR.
54:46 Rund Abdelfatah? This episode was produced by me.
54:48 Speaker 02 And me, and.
54:50 Speaker 26 Lawrence Wu.
54:51 Speaker 13 Julie Kane. Anya Steinberg. Casey Minor. Christina Kim.
54:56 Speaker 21 Devon Katayama.
54:57 Rund Abdelfatah? Irene Noguchi. Voiceover work in this episode was done by Mark Roth, Kevin Jones, Tessa Hall, Ari Steinberg, Bergen Hoff, and Alice Oriola.
55:09 Speaker 02 Thank you to Johannes Derge, Edith Chapin, and Colin Campbell.
55:14 Rund Abdelfatah? Special thanks to Shelley Lemons, Steve Kite, and the Oklahoma Oral History Research Program at Oklahoma State University for access to the Dust, Drought, and Dreams Gone Dry collection, to Ludlow Music for permission to use Woody Guthrie's "Do Re Mi," and to the Boulh Art Research Library at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art for their recording of Upton Sinclair.
55:39 Speaker 02 Fact checking for this episode was done by Kevin Vocal. The episode was mixed by Robert Rodriguez.
55:45 Rund Abdelfatah? Music for this episode was composed by Ramtin and his band Drop Electric, which includes.
55:51 Speaker 26 Navid Marvi. Cho Fujiwara.
55:53 Speaker 22 Anya Mizani.
55:56 Speaker 02 And finally, if you have an idea or like something you heard on the show, please write us at throughline@npr.org. And make sure to follow us on Apple, Spotify, or the NPR app so you never miss an episode.
56:11 Rund Abdelfatah? Thanks for listening.
56:28 Speaker 08 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
Previous Motherhood Next The Tax Collector Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated