Pod Insights The Vergecast The best streaming services in 2023 About this episode What are the best streaming services in 2023? Nilay, Alex, and David decide in the most chaotic way possible: with draft-style picks. The crew debates the best roster for the future of entertainment — from Netflix to Hulu to HBO Max to a few surprises. Who is the MVP, and who gets snubbed? Find out in our inaugural Vergecast streaming draft.
Read more: theverge.com/streaming-wars
Vote for us in the People’s Voice Webby Awards for Best Technology Podcast: http://bit.ly/3moCTDs
Email us at vergecast@theverge.com or call us at 866-VERGE11, we love hearing from you.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 11,668 words · 10 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:03 David Pierce? Welcome to The Vergecast, the flagship podcast of rabbit ear antennas. I'm your friend David Pierce and I am doing maybe the weirdest thing on my to do list in a while. I am reordering all of the apps on my Roku. I have 94 things installed, it looks like, which is A, way too many, and B, total chaos because everything is in a totally bonkers order and I can't find anything. So I'm moving stuff around, trying to get all of my important services up to the top. It is way, way too much work. It's like six button clicks every time you want to even just move an app, which is why it's taken me months to finally get fed up enough to do it, but I'm doing it. Anyway, today's show is actually all about these streaming services. We've been trying for a while to figure out a good way to answer a really simple but really important question.
0:48 David Pierce? What are the best streaming services? So we picked the most subjective, most chaotic way we could think of to actually answer that question. Neelai, Alex and I are going to draft streaming services and see who picks the best roster for the future of entertainment. That's the whole show today and it's coming up in just a second. But first, I have to figure out whether Hulu or ESPN Plus belongs on the second row of my Roku. This feels like a surprisingly big decision. This is The Vergecast. See you in a sec.
1:17 Speaker 01 When it comes to your business, you want cards and tools you can trust. Amex Corporate helps put you in control. Set custom spend parameters to help fit your business needs and quickly issue unlimited corporate cash back cards. All backed by best in class fraud protection and the powerful backing of American Express. Get started at go.amex slash Amex Corporate. Terms apply.
1:44 Speaker 02 When it comes to AI, there is what we could do and what we should do. What will we decide? I'm Kimberly Nevela, host of the Pondering AI Podcast from SAS. Every episode, I sit down with innovators, researchers and technologists to consider the questions that come after the AI breakthroughs. Questions that don't have easy answers but need to be asked. If you're curious or concerned about AI, join me as we challenge assumptions and ponder the issues together. Find Pondering AI wherever you get your podcasts.
2:22 David Pierce? Welcome back. This is the Great Verge Streaming Draft of 2023, which I'm saying so that it sounds like an annual thing, so that we require ourselves to do this every year from now on. Neelai Patel, hello, and welcome to the draft.
2:36 Nilay Patel? I've tried to pull that trick so many times. There are so many things we don't do every year that I've insisted that we're gonna do every year, but we're gonna do this every year.
2:43 David Pierce? Yeah, we're gonna do this every year. It's gonna be great. Alex Cranz, hello.
2:45 Alex Cranz? What happens if all of the streaming services die next year? Will it just be super competitive?
2:51 David Pierce? There's like a 60% chance that none of these things will exist a year from now. We'll be picking Go90 again.
2:57 Nilay Patel? Yeah.
2:57 David Pierce? It's gonna be great.
2:58 Nilay Patel? The only thing on my list is Quibi, y'all. Let's be honest.
3:01 David Pierce? I'm not gonna lie, the word "Quibi" appears in my notes somewhere in all the crap that I did for this, but we'll come to that later. Okay, so, let me just quickly explain how this draft is gonna work, and then we'll get into it. We're gonna do five rounds, and we're doing a snake draft. So the person who picks first, then they go second, then they go third, and the person who picks third then picks fourth. So we're going around and around. We're gonna pick 15 total things over the course of this, and the idea is that whatever you pick is what you're stuck with for the next 12 months. Imagine it like you're drafting a team, right? This is your exclusive five streaming services for the next year. I will take any single subscription as one draft pick. So you can draft the Disney bundle as one thing, because that is one thing with one price. But also, you can draft
3:44 David Pierce? Disney Plus and ESPN Plus and Hulu as their own things, because you can pay for them separately. That's the only one like that that I can actually think of, but if there are others, feel free and try to convince me otherwise. But what you can't do is the like, Amazon channels, like subscribe to stars through here thing, because that's a separate thing that you pay for separately. So, one bill, one price, one pick.
4:05 Alex Cranz? Do, like, adjacent services count?
4:09 Alex Cranz? Things that are like streaming, but maybe don't have their own content on them, or a lot of their own content.
4:16 David Pierce? Sure. If you want to pick Plex is the answer to your question. If you want to pick Plex, knock yourself out. That's an awful draft pick. You can't just pick Plex. You gotta pick, Alex has to pick her own Plex server. Right. I pick my Plex server. Yeah, that I will allow. And as for what counts, any streaming service counts, free, paid, whatever. It just has to be primarily about entertainment. I'm gonna do my best to keep track of the cost of all these things. And one fun wrinkle that I just came up with is whoever spends the least money in these five picks gets one extra free bonus pick at the end. Do you understand that the last pick of this draft is a punishment? You get to have another streaming service. Instead of five streaming services, you get to have six. You can pick, I don't know, Quibi.
5:00 David Pierce? Punishment, not a reward. Yeah, you're not wrong. If there are any disputes, Andrew, our producer, is in charge.
5:06 Speaker 06 Thank you, David.
5:07 David Pierce? He rules and his word is final. He's the commissioner of our league. All right, Andrew is here to pick the draft order. None of us know the draft order, because as far as I know, there isn't one yet.
5:18 Alex Cranz? Andrew, give it to me. Give it to me. I deserve it.
5:20 David Pierce? Andrew, you're gonna tell us who's picking first, second, and third. What do you have for us?
5:24 Speaker 06 Okay, so Neelai responded to your message in Slack first today. So Neelai's gonna go first.
5:32 David Pierce? Oh, what a surprise. Give the boss the first pick in the draft. What a shocking twist. Everybody's boss gets to go first.
5:38 Alex Cranz? This commissioner's terrible.
5:40 David Pierce? That's right. I'm the Dallas Cowboys, baby.
5:44 David Pierce? You can't run this league without me.
5:46 Speaker 06 And then Alex is gonna go second.
5:48 Alex Cranz? Yes.
5:49 Speaker 06 And David is gonna go third, because he's the host.
5:51 David Pierce? This sucks. I don't want to do this anymore. David, trades are allowed, man. I bet I'm still gonna get my first pick at third, so this is fine. Andrew, do you have another song for us? It's go time.
6:04 David Pierce? All right, Eli Patel, you're on the clock. First pick?
6:07 Nilay Patel? TikTok.
6:08 David Pierce? Wow!
6:08 Nilay Patel? Zero hesitation, TikTok.
6:10 David Pierce? Explain.
6:10 Nilay Patel? Wow. It provides the most value for the zeroest of dollars. It is the only streaming service that reliably produces videos of trucks jumping over things and into rivers. That's very important to me. And I don't know if it's gonna get banned or not, but I wanna be, I wanna be on the ride if that's gonna happen.
6:26 David Pierce? Well, so that's the, this is like the most high-risk, high-reward pick ever, right? Because there's a decent chance that literally it will not be available to you when we do this draft again in 12 months.
6:35 Nilay Patel? Yeah, and you know what? Sometimes you gotta draft a quarterback who's definitely gonna get hurt. You know what I'm saying? Like, I just think about where do I spend the most time? It's TikTok. As we go through the draft, I think this choice will be rewarded. I might not need any other picks.
6:51 David Pierce? Okay, so my reasoning for being anti-TikTok as the first pick is that there's no, like, prestige TikTok is like not a thing. And like, what I want from one of my picks here, and maybe I'll get it later, but is the like, cultural relevancy of something where it's like, everybody's very excited about the most recent episode of Succession, and you're gonna have to watch it in two-minute increments, cobbled together across the internet.
7:16 Nilay Patel? Well, I do have other picks, right? Like, I can pick Alex's Plex server. Second, we have not, actually, this is a rules clarification. Am I still allowed to buy things?
7:26 David Pierce? Oh, yes, you are allowed to buy things.
7:28 Nilay Patel? Like, I can rent movies.
7:29 David Pierce? We'll leave like, the voodoos of the world separate. If you wanna pay four bucks to rent a movie, that's allowed. That exists outside of this.
7:38 Nilay Patel? I'm ever more comfortable with this choice.
7:40 David Pierce? Interesting, okay. Alex, what do you think? Good choice, bad choice?
7:42 Alex Cranz? Terrible choice. Just...
7:45 David Pierce? Why?
7:45 Alex Cranz? I watched TikTok last night while I was watching Succession, and that was a bad choice.
7:50 David Pierce? That might be a proof of Eli's point. You might have just proved Eli's case.
7:55 Alex Cranz? Basically, it was a bad choice. So like, I'm trying to have less TikTok in my life.
8:01 Nilay Patel? That's fair. No, that's fair. You gotta cut back.
8:03 David Pierce? Alex, let's go. Second pick. What do you have?
8:06 Alex Cranz? Oh, it's HBO Max.
8:07 Nilay Patel? Whoo.
8:07 David Pierce? Okay.
8:08 Alex Cranz? I'm coming out the gate strong. I'm aggressive.
8:11 David Pierce? All right, defend.
8:13 Alex Cranz? Because succession. But also, I watch a lot of stuff on HBO Max. There's a lot of good content on it, as long as it survives. So I've got this for like, what, another month?
8:24 Nilay Patel? Immediate theme in this draft of, I need to ride this out while it lasts.
8:28 Alex Cranz? Yeah. So I'm gonna enjoy it for a month. I'm gonna watch, you know, maybe re-watch Warrior, re-watch Sex Lives of College Girls, whatever that show's called. That sounded really bad saying it out loud, but it's gonna be a great time for the next month.
8:43 David Pierce? Okay, here's a philosophical question. Are we streaming services with ads, people, or spend the extra $5 for no ads, people?
8:51 Alex Cranz? Oh, this is with the extra $5. I don't do ads.
8:54 David Pierce? Okay, so we're spending the money to not get any ads?
8:57 Alex Cranz? Yeah.
8:57 David Pierce? Unlike Neelai, who says, just give me every ad.
9:00 Nilay Patel? Scroll up, I am, man. Don't worry about it.
9:02 Alex Cranz? Every 30 videos, just, there's your ad.
9:05 Nilay Patel? You got a MagSafe charger? This is the best ad targeting you can do.
9:08 David Pierce? Neelai, are you an ads person? Do you pay for no ads?
9:11 Nilay Patel? Oh, yeah, I pay for no ads everywhere.
9:12 David Pierce? Okay.
9:13 Nilay Patel? Which is funny, because we run an ad-supported website. Please don't skip over the ads in this podcast.
9:17 David Pierce? But also pay for all of our paid things.
9:19 Nilay Patel? Yeah.
9:19 David Pierce? Those don't have ads.
9:20 Nilay Patel? Maybe I'm trying to bring these ideas together as much as I can.
9:24 David Pierce? Verge Plus.
9:25 Nilay Patel? That's my last pick. If I win this bonus pick, I'm picking that, because it doesn't cost any money. Because it doesn't exist. You see the logic here.
9:32 David Pierce? Alex, what do you do with the fact that the HBO Max app is like a horrible pile of garbage that doesn't work 40 to 60% of the time?
9:39 Alex Cranz? I just like, close my eyes and think of the good content that I'll get to when I eventually find it and the app works.
9:46 David Pierce? You watch TikTok until the page loads.
9:48 Alex Cranz? Just avert my eyes, and I press go, and 30 minutes later, maybe my show plays, and I'm really excited. And that, like, once that 30 minutes hits, then I've got like, you get all those old movies, because they have like, the whole, they have all the Turner Classic stuff.
10:02 Nilay Patel? This is a strong pick because of the catalog, for sure.
10:04 Alex Cranz? Yeah, it's all about the catalog for me. And the app is like, just an unfortunate byproduct that I have to deal with.
10:11 Nilay Patel? Also, whenever you want, you can watch a square version of Justice League.
10:17 Alex Cranz? That's all I've, that's what I'm gonna do right after this. Because it's my first pick. I can watch it anytime.
10:23 David Pierce? Yeah, HBO Max was gonna be my second pick, specifically because it is like, when you make a list of like, relevant cultural shows that people care about, they are overwhelmingly on HBO. It's insane. So by not having HBO Max, Neela, you and I are just resigned to being sort of social outcasts.
10:38 Nilay Patel? Don't worry, I got a Plex server coming up.
10:42 David Pierce? Alex is gonna rip everything from HBO Max to her Plex server. Problems solved.
10:47 Alex Cranz? Would never do that. That's wrong.
10:49 David Pierce? Okay, so I'm up third, and for my third pick, I get my first pick, which is YouTube. This is the easiest decision of all time. I cannot believe neither of you picked YouTube. It's $22.99 a month for YouTube Premium, which is insane, and which I did not realize I'd been paying all this time, because they raised the price.
11:05 Nilay Patel? Yeah.
11:06 David Pierce? And which is, yeah, it's outrageous. That's like the family plan. It's ridiculous.
11:09 Alex Cranz? What do you get for that?
11:11 David Pierce? So you get no ads, which is great. You get background listening. You get a music service for free, which is compelling. And now I don't have to pick Spotify or Apple Music or anything else, because I just have YouTube Music and all the music streaming services are the same. So it's kind of like getting two picks in one. But also, it's like, YouTube, over the last like 12 months for me, has become the place I go when I don't know what I want to watch and I just have like 15 minutes to kill. And I think part of this is I just had a kid, so I, my windows of time to just sort of sit and do nothing, went from being like hours long to like minutes long. But it's like, highlights of soccer games that I missed, because I have a small child, and Hot Ones interviews is basically like my entire YouTube algorithm right now. And it's great.
11:55 David Pierce? And I have, I have nothing against it. It feels like it is the biggest one. It's also the only one of our three so far that will probably still exist 12 months from now. So I feel very good about that. I'm honestly shocked neither of you picked this. I felt like YouTube was like the obvious first choice.
12:09 Nilay Patel? It would have been my, if I hadn't gotten, if I hadn't gotten TikTok, I would have gone YouTube Premium.
12:14 David Pierce? Good. All right. Well, then I also get the fourth pick. Because of the way this draft works.
12:19 Alex Cranz? Yeah.
12:19 David Pierce? Andrew, I've come around. I've decided you were right to give me the third pick. Thank you.
12:22 Nilay Patel? That was a secret.
12:24 David Pierce? Wow. So there's three I can choose from here, and I'm gonna, this is the, I'm gonna regret this choice, but I'm gonna make it. I'm gonna pick Peacock.
12:31 Alex Cranz? Ooh.
12:33 David Pierce? Which I would not have expected to do, but the honest truth is Peacock is where The Office is, and it's where Parks and Rec is. And for me, that is like 45% of my TV viewing between those two shows. And the other 45 exists on another service that I hope I get to pick later, but it's just that. Like, Peacock has some nifty stuff with live TV. They have some sports. They're starting to grow. But it is like fundamentally, it is the place where The Office is, and I have to have the place where The Office is on my list. I already regret this choice. As I'm saying this, I drafted this too high.
13:05 Nilay Patel? Disclosure.
13:06 David Pierce? Oh, yeah.
13:07 Nilay Patel? Peacock is operated by NBC Universal, which is owned by Comcast, which is a minority investor in Vox Media, our parent company. David, I hope you got some sort of kickback for this miserable choice.
13:18 Alex Cranz? I think this is a good choice. This is, this is like, if you watch a lot of TV, Peacock is a very solid choice.
13:24 Nilay Patel? I think what we're, we're gonna discover in this is that some of you watch vastly more television than I do.
13:29 David Pierce? That's probably, that's probably true. But no, for me, it's like, I dabble in lots of TV, and then I have like four shows that I cycle between over and over and over and over again. And two of them are The Office and Parks and Rec, both of which are on Peacock. And I think I can reliably say both of which are never leaving Peacock because they are part of the company that owns Peacock. So I'm not afraid that six months from now, they're just gonna suddenly disappear, unlike on some other services that have gained and lost my shows.
13:55 Alex Cranz? Until Peacock dies and they have to like sell to another company.
13:59 David Pierce? There is that. But Peacock's doing kind of well. It went from being like a total disaster to like a kind of meh success-ish.
14:09 David Pierce? It's like, it's like trending in the right direction from really bad to kind of bad. It's like, you know, in Arrested Development, they go from like a sell to a don't buy, and they're like thrilled about it. Like, that's Peacock.
14:20 Nilay Patel? Yeah, I just think you're gonna find yourself using the custom video player UI that they developed for no reason. And you're like, this is my third pick? Like, that's just how that's gonna feel for you.
14:31 David Pierce? Yeah. If the spacebar on my iPad doesn't pause your video player, you've done it wrong. And Peacock has done it wrong. All right, Alex, you're up next.
14:41 Alex Cranz? I don't think this is gonna shock anybody, but Paramount Plus.
14:44 David Pierce? Wow, that does not shock me.
14:45 Nilay Patel? Wow, the reaches in these rounds are out of control.
14:49 David Pierce? I had that so much lower on my list.
14:52 Alex Cranz? I get Star Trek. Love a Star Trek. I get most of Yellowstone, the good, the good versions. Evil, that's lovely, the good fight, a bunch of like random CBS stuff like Ghosts. And most importantly of all, 60 Minutes.
15:06 Nilay Patel? So you're buying shows?
15:07 Alex Cranz? Yeah, yeah, I'm, I'm all about the shows.
15:10 Nilay Patel? Okay.
15:10 Alex Cranz? For the most part. I got, I got some others here, but for the most part, it's about like the shows for me. But like, it's like Peacock where you get a bunch of live stuff too. So, so I can like watch live news if I need to, that sort of thing. And then I gotta see what's gonna happen on Picard next week. Like, I can't, I can't lose that.
15:28 Nilay Patel? I mean, I guess like saying you're buying shows, like at the end, we're all just buying content. Yeah. Like, no one's like, I'm buying this for a great UI. Like, it's all content. But you very specifically are like, these four shows are why I'm drafting this service.
15:40 Alex Cranz? A hundred percent. Also, like, the Peacock UI is fine. It's better than HBO, kind of.
15:46 David Pierce? In that, like, the app loads from time to time. Yes.
15:49 Alex Cranz? Yeah, like, once you actually use it, it's miserable and I hate it. But otherwise, it's, it's, it does the job.
15:56 David Pierce? So I will say, when I first did my rankings, I had Paramount Plus really, really, really low. And then the final four happened, and the Masters happened, and both of those things only streamed on Paramount Plus. And all of a sudden, it's like, as a person who also likes to watch like Champions League soccer, like Paramount Plus has a sneaky amount of like really good, really high-end sports that for me are like, I actually don't subscribe to Paramount Plus. And there were a couple of times, the last couple of weeks, I almost did, and I suspect I'm gonna end up having to do so.
16:27 Alex Cranz? You'll, you'll like it.
16:29 David Pierce? Even though I don't care about Star Trek. Like, to me Paramount Plus is just like, where do you go if you like Star Trek? And there's lots of those people, and I am not one of them.
16:34 Alex Cranz? Yeah, it's, it's, there's a bunch of other stuff. Like, obviously, the Star Trek is really big right now at the moment for me. But for the most part, it's all of the other content that I, I watch. And now I can keep up with everybody in, in, at home who all watch Yellowstone and all of those shows. So I can like have conversations with my family. That's very exciting.
16:54 David Pierce? That's real. Okay, here's the rules question. Are you paying $9.99 a month for just Paramount? Or are you paying $11.99 a month and also getting Showtime?
17:03 Alex Cranz? Oh, $11.99 a month.
17:04 David Pierce? Yeah, that's the, yeah, that's the easiest trade up of all time. That's just the price for Yellowjackets, right? You pay $2 a month to watch Yellowjackets?
17:10 Alex Cranz? Hundred percent.
17:11 David Pierce? That's how they make billions. Yeah. I'm so sorry.
17:17 Alex Cranz? So smooth.
17:19 David Pierce? Okay, so you take Paramount Plus and Showtime for $11.99 a month. I actually think that was a pretty good pick. Neelai, you're up. What do you got?
17:26 Nilay Patel? Oh, this is hard. I can go two ways.
17:28 David Pierce? Well, okay, and you're gonna get a pick and then we're gonna take a break and then you're gonna get another pick, so.
17:32 Nilay Patel? Oh, yeah, no, no, that's actually super easy then. Disney Plus.
17:35 David Pierce? Okay, why?
17:36 Nilay Patel? Child.
17:40 Nilay Patel? Child, Bluey. I'm, I'm, I'm drafting Bluey.
17:43 David Pierce? This is the Bluey pick.
17:44 Nilay Patel? Very specifically, Bluey, Frozen, Moana. Like, this stuff just flows through the house like water. Also, it is like the single app on her iPad that I trust. In like, in any way, shape or form. Like, YouTube Kids is just a disaster clown car situation. She loves it, but you've taken it off the board, right? Because you took YouTube totally off the board, so YouTube Kids went for the ride.
18:09 David Pierce? Right.
18:10 Nilay Patel? So you gotta, the kid pick has to be D+.
18:12 David Pierce? Okay, so, and also, well, I was, I have two follow up questions. One is, are you just taking Disney Plus or are you taking the bundle and also getting Hulu and ESPN+? It's more expensive, but you get more stuff.
18:24 Nilay Patel? I'm taking the bundle.
18:26 David Pierce? Okay.
18:26 Nilay Patel? Hulu's fine. Actually, my question is, if I take the bundle, you can still pick Hulu, right?
18:31 David Pierce? That's right.
18:31 Nilay Patel? Okay, so yeah, I'm taking the bundle, not totally strategic. If I was taking it totally off the board, zero. Like, that's just draft strategy, right?
18:39 David Pierce? Sure.
18:39 Nilay Patel? But there's, you know, Hulu has a reasonably good catalog. It's got some movies on there. The real thing I'm taking is ESPN+, which has the one show I watched during football season more consistently than anything else, NFL Primetime, which is great.
18:52 Alex Cranz? Yeah, you two are the two people I know that are like ESPN plus.
18:55 David Pierce? It's great.
18:55 Nilay Patel? Yeah, but it's just for one show.
18:58 David Pierce? Do you want to watch college softball on a Saturday afternoon? Like, they got you.
19:01 Nilay Patel? Yeah.
19:01 David Pierce? Four nine nine a month. Let's go. Also, you just made an interesting point, which is you sound like a person who would be against doing what everybody thinks is going to happen, which is that Disney just pulls all of the Hulu stuff into Disney Plus because it's a better, more successful app. Anyway, but it sounds like in the like, it's the one app I trust on the iPad vein. Maybe you don't want that to happen.
19:21 Nilay Patel? I, we can age gate it already. So like, she's already got the kids version of D plus, which is like, there's a lot of age gates built into it. Like, they know that their audience is kids. So I'm not worried about the catalog and the app expanding because I think that Disney, of all companies, will be good at knowing that my daughter is five, you know? Like, it's, it's actually hard for her to get some movies, like some Pixar movies are rated PG, and she can't get them in her version of D plus. Like, we have to use my account. So I'm not so worried about that. I do think, like, the reason I was like, whatever on Hulu is like, Hulu will go away before TikTok goes away.
19:56 Alex Cranz? Oh, really?
19:58 Nilay Patel? Yeah, it will outlast us all. Those are the only two outcomes.
20:02 David Pierce? Season 61 of The Handmaid's Tale coming soon.
20:05 Nilay Patel? Exactly. Like, every one of its corporate owners has tried to kill Hulu, and it has survived. It has outlasted all of them. But I think in this particular round of the streaming wars, neither Disney nor Comcast really wants it to exist. It just seems like the, if you're taking it, you should take it as part of this bundle. But it's a, it's a risky early round pick right now.
20:26 David Pierce? Alex, what do you think? This would have been my next pick, so I'm, I'm very on board for this. Alex, what do you think?
20:30 Alex Cranz? I mean, I assumed one of you with children was gonna pick it. So I was just waiting for one of you with children to pick it. I, I don't need a lot of the stuff on there.
20:38 David Pierce? It does kind of feel like if you don't have kids or care about Marvel and Star Wars, Disney Plus is actually like mostly useless to you. But if either of those things apply to you, it is like the most important thing in the universe.
20:50 Alex Cranz? Yeah, it's like, I can just go see those movies when they come out. And like, the TV shows have all been fine.
20:55 Nilay Patel? People should know that if I could draft Disney Plus without drafting Star Wars, I would do it. If I could just leave that on the table, it would be fine. This is very much the Bluey draft pick. And if you have a child, you know how important this pick is.
21:09 David Pierce? That's fair. All right, we're through two rounds. We should take a break and then we're going to do the rest. Let me just recap the first two rounds. So after two, after two rounds, Neelai has picked TikTok and the Disney bundle, which is Disney Plus, Hulu and ESPN Plus. Alex has HBO Max and Paramount Plus slash Showtime. And I have YouTube and Peacock. I feel like I'm losing so far, I would say. I also just want to say, I was so thrown off by not getting the first pick, you guys. Like, it's, it's bad. It's going bad for me, but I'm gonna, I'm gonna come back strong from the break. I also just want to say, we are six picks in and no one has picked Netflix. And that's kind of wild.
21:45 Nilay Patel? Yeah.
21:45 David Pierce? But I suspect that's coming up soon. Let's take a quick break and then we'll get back into it. We'll be right back.
21:58 Speaker 02 When it comes to AI, there is what we could do and what we should do. What will we decide? I'm Kimberly Nevela, host of the Pondering AI Podcast from SAS. Every episode, I sit down with innovators, researchers and technologists to consider the questions that come after the AI breakthroughs. Questions that don't have easy answers, but need to be asked. If you're curious or concerned about AI, join me as we challenge assumptions and ponder the issues together. Find Pondering AI wherever you get your podcasts.
22:29 Speaker 07 Ask yourself, what are your best people spending their time on right now? Expense reports, receipt chasing, month end close that takes weeks. You become what you spend on, and that's not what you're building toward. Brex is the intelligent finance platform that eliminates that work before it starts. AI agents that handle the manual stuff automatically so your team can spend their time on what actually compounds. It's time to get Brex AF. Learn more at brex.com/af.
23:07 David Pierce? All right, we're back. Round three, streaming draft. Andrew, do you have any more music for us?
23:15 David Pierce? It's the Virgus streaming draft. Coming at you live from New York City. Brought to you by Monster Ed.
23:24 David Pierce? All right, Neelai, round three.
23:26 Nilay Patel? This is my reach. This is the one that is, it's an obvious bad idea, but I'm doing it. Cause it's gonna blow the cost structure for me. It's, it's, it's over. There's no way I'm getting the bonus pick after this. YouTube TV with Sunday Ticket.
23:42 Alex Cranz? That's expensive, right?
23:43 Nilay Patel? It's like 80 bucks a month, plus like $300 to, for Sunday Ticket and Red Zone.
23:48 David Pierce? Yep.
23:49 Alex Cranz? Per month or just?
23:50 David Pierce? It's, it's $72.99 a month right now for just YouTube TV. Because the price goes up like every three to four days. And Sunday Ticket, they just announced yesterday, as this goes live, the price for Sunday Ticket is gonna be $289 in a pre-sale and $389 if you buy it during the season. Are you sure? You're, you're sure about this pick?
24:09 Nilay Patel? Yeah, I mean, they got me. What, what am I gonna do? I mean, I will say, Alex brought up Yellowstone. I watched all of Yellowstone on our YouTube TV. Cause Paramount Channel's in there, so you can just like DVR it and skip the ads. It is an election year. I feel like I'm gonna watch, end up watching a lot of CNN. I appear on CNBC. Sometimes my wife likes to watch me on television. Like, I can concoct argu-, it's like mostly nonsensical arguments, right?
24:33 David Pierce? Yeah.
24:33 Nilay Patel? But I can concoct arguments for the value of, of live cable television. But if not for Sunday Ticket, I would not be drafting this high. It's Sunday Ticket that I'm drafting.
24:42 David Pierce? Yeah, it's football. For me, it's Red Zone. Just the, the like, that's the only way I watch football anymore. And there's a lot of money I would pay and do pay every year to do it. But I can do it through YouTube.
24:53 Nilay Patel? Yeah, right. You can, you can buy the Red Zone channel through YouTube.
24:56 David Pierce? Right.
24:56 Nilay Patel? You already have it.
24:56 David Pierce? Right.
24:57 Nilay Patel? Again, I'm off the cost curve. It doesn't even matter, but I'm buying the version that comes with Red Zone. Cause there's a cheaper one that doesn't.
25:02 David Pierce? Yeah, you really did just kind of give yourself an insurmountable lead in the spending a lot of money every month. $73 a month.
25:10 Nilay Patel? All, all the rest of mine are gonna be free. Free V, baby, let's do this thing.
25:14 David Pierce? Is the YouTube TV over like Hulu with live TV or any of those other ones just purely it's it's football?
25:19 Nilay Patel? Yeah, I can't imagine why I would pay for the one without football. I think that's YouTube's calculation here.
25:25 David Pierce? I was gonna say, I feel like you just explained why YouTube spent all this money on football.
25:28 Nilay Patel? Also, I mean, I've used the other ones. They're fine. I think the YouTube TV interface is better. It doesn't matter. Like, yeah, it's football. I'm buying football.
25:35 David Pierce? Alex, did you have live TV on your list at all?
25:38 Alex Cranz? Kind of.
25:38 David Pierce? I feel like if you don't care about sports, why would you?
25:40 Alex Cranz? I mean, I've got Paramount Plus. I've got another pick potentially, but yeah, I don't really care about sports, so I don't really care about most live TV.
25:48 David Pierce? The $75 a month for live TV is not blowing your mind?
25:51 Alex Cranz? No.
25:52 David Pierce? Okay.
25:52 Alex Cranz? I just pirate it. I mean, I can just watch it over the air. Over the air.
25:58 David Pierce? You haven't drafted your Plex server yet. Don't forget. It's still out there. All right. Well, then let's move on. What's your next pick?
26:04 Alex Cranz? Okay, this one's a toughie. I'm gonna do something really, speaking of live TV, I'm gonna do something really cheap. I'm gonna do not Plex, but Channels, which is a DVR service, because it can work with TV Everywhere. So anything that potentially is TV Everywhere accounts, I can DVR those.
26:21 Nilay Patel? But then you need a cable subscription.
26:23 Alex Cranz? Not necessarily. It's not just cable. It's a bunch of other stuff, too.
26:26 Nilay Patel? Oh, I see.
26:27 Alex Cranz? So I think it might work with Paramount Plus. I can find out. But then it also gives me all the live TV and it gives me access to like Tubi and all of those things, which gives you CNN and all of that.
26:37 David Pierce? Yeah, wait, so explain how Channels works for people who don't know. This is, this is like deep streaming nerd stuff. You gotta, you gotta walk us through it.
26:44 Alex Cranz? So it's basically a DVR service and you can plug in, if you've got a HD home run tuner, you, you just plug that in and it automatically pulls down anything you get over the air and you can DVR that. But you can also attach M3U playlists, which is what Tubi and Pluto and all of those free services offer. So you can then have all of those channels as well and just like watch all of the channels like you watch normal TV. So I can watch all of the Carol Burnett show I want and that's all I care about in the world.
27:18 Nilay Patel? This is a power move.
27:20 David Pierce? This definitely like violates the spirit of the game, but I like it. So we're gonna allow it.
27:24 Nilay Patel? Yeah, this is great. You should definitely draft a kicker in the first round. Like, I don't know.
27:29 David Pierce? Yeah, I'm just drafting all the teams all at once.
27:33 Alex Cranz? Yeah, all of them. It's it's an absolute cheat. And if you tell me no, I'll I'll accept it. I'll accept it.
27:39 Nilay Patel? No, this is absolutely. This is a paid streaming service. It's in the rules.
27:42 David Pierce? Yeah, this totally counts.
27:43 Alex Cranz? Yeah, it's a paid service and it requires way more work and effort than any of the other ones we've discussed here so far.
27:50 David Pierce? I've never gotten past the sort of like initial setup hurdle of channels because it is, like you said, you need special hardware. You need to like have done real work to get it set up. Once it's like up and running, is it easy or do you have to like Tamagotchi style tend to your channels?
28:04 Alex Cranz? Yeah, it's totally easy. Like I was getting, there was some sport. I don't remember which one that my brother couldn't get with FiOS at his house, but I could get it over the air. And so I just sent him the code, like the IP address for my server. And he was just watching his sport live and was totally fine. And he lives many miles away from me, so it works super, super easy. Once you get it set up.
28:30 David Pierce? I mean, I do feel like anything that starts with the phrase, I sent him the IP address of my server. Is objectively not super, super easy.
28:38 Alex Cranz? Yeah, it was just like a phone number. He was just like, I need a number for this. What's the number? And I send him the number and he's like, okay, done.
28:44 David Pierce? That's fair. Type these numbers.
28:46 Alex Cranz? Yeah, so it works. It works great.
28:49 David Pierce? Okay.
28:49 Alex Cranz? But you do have to get it set up.
28:50 David Pierce? We should probably should have said at the top that we all get the the over the air broadcast channels for free. Right? That's there's just you can't help but have those. They're just there.
28:59 Nilay Patel? Yeah, you can't draft an antenna.
29:01 David Pierce? Yeah, right. You can't draft an antenna. You just have one.
29:03 Alex Cranz? So I'm just, I'm just enjoying all of them, waiting for ATS 3.0, ATSC 3.0 to save our lives. It's never gonna happen.
29:11 David Pierce? I look forward to you drafting ATSC 3.0 every draft for the next 20 years.
29:17 Alex Cranz? You're just throwing away all of your picks on that one. Oh.
29:20 David Pierce? I get two picks now and I have three that I'm choosing from and I need the two of you to help me. We're just going to talk through this together.
29:26 Nilay Patel? Well, I'm your enemy.
29:27 David Pierce? No, just we're just, we're gonna talk this through. It's ultimately my decision and I know you're lying to me, so it's we'll get there. So there's Netflix, there's Amazon Prime Video, and there's Discovery Plus. These are the three I'm debating between.
29:40 Nilay Patel? Wow.
29:40 Alex Cranz? Really?
29:41 David Pierce? These are all the kind of like, volume plays, right? Like, Prime Video just has a billion movies to watch. Most of them are bad, but they're there. Netflix has infinite stuff, including like, every bad reality show that I like right now. And then Discovery Plus is basically, for me, it's like the HGTV and murder shows for my wife service. So these all kind of serve the same purpose.
30:05 Alex Cranz? But you already have YouTube, right? Like, YouTube has all the HGTV kind of shows, only they're made by, they're like, uglier, because they're made by just a dude in his house.
30:15 David Pierce? Yeah, there's just worse. Like, I have watched a lot of the Architectural Digest celebrities show you their house tours. Love those videos.
30:22 Alex Cranz? Yeah.
30:22 David Pierce? But sometimes I want to see people try and fail to flip their own house. It's very important to me. I think I have to pick Netflix here, just because Netflix is like,
30:32 Alex Cranz? Yeah.
30:33 David Pierce? It's both a giant of the space and also just has a mountain of content that really nobody else can touch.
30:39 Nilay Patel? This is your background music choice. This is what you're saying. You just want stuff that's on.
30:43 David Pierce? Yeah, this is my like, something good to watch, but I don't have a specific desire for what I want to watch. Because the flip side is like, Apple TV Plus is still sitting there, right? And Apple TV Plus is like, three shows that I love, and that's it. That's the whole service.
30:58 Nilay Patel? Yeah, that's the, I'm drafting content. This is, this is why I asked Alex that question earlier, right? Like, you can either draft content, or you get to this point and you're like, just stuff.
31:07 David Pierce? Yeah, and I think, I think for me, I'm still in the just stuff mode. I just don't have enough show loyalty, is the thing that I'm realizing. Like, I don't have that many things that I care so much about that I can't like...
31:20 Nilay Patel? I mean, I used the first pick of the draft on stuff. Like, that's what TikTok, it's just stuff. Like, I get, I feel you.
31:26 David Pierce? I think what I'm gonna do here is I'm gonna do Netflix, and I'm gonna do Discovery Plus. And I now have just several lifetimes worth of relatively mediocre stuff to watch. And also, whenever the next Squid Game comes out, I have that.
31:40 Nilay Patel? Disclosure, we, I'm a Netflix EP. The show's called The Future of, and David should watch it. It's very good.
31:46 David Pierce? I can watch it now. I'm the only one of us who's allowed to watch it from now on. Yeah, so there we go. I took it. I have Netflix. This is good. I feel better now. I was doing bad after two rounds. Now I feel like I'm winning.
31:56 Alex Cranz? It wasn't even on my list.
31:57 David Pierce? Netflix wasn't on your list?
31:58 Alex Cranz? It wasn't even on my list.
32:00 David Pierce? Wow.
32:00 Alex Cranz? I got really mad. They canceled some show I liked, and so I stopped watching it for like three weeks. And I was like, oh, I don't actually miss it that much.
32:08 David Pierce? So that has been consistently my thing. I will say, the reason I was bummed to not get HBO Max was that it's really the only one that I would like, super, super notice if I didn't have it anymore.
32:19 Alex Cranz? Yeah.
32:19 David Pierce? All the rest are like varying levels of good shows, but HBO Max is the one that's like, like I watch Succession religiously. And almost all of the shows that I watch religiously on purpose are on HBO, which is crazy and wild and kudos to HBO for continuing to be the only one to do that. But yeah, Netflix is like, it's just a lot of stuff and it's better stuff than most of the other company's stuff, but it's still just stuff.
32:43 Alex Cranz? Yeah.
32:43 David Pierce? So I think, I feel good about that. I'm taking Netflix for 20 bucks a month and Discovery Plus for seven bucks a month. And now my wife has all of the murder documentaries she could possibly want. You're welcome, Anna. I love you.
32:54 Nilay Patel? Here's a question. Did you expect Netflix to fall this far? I definitely did, is what I'll tell you. I have, it's on my list, but like, it was like a late round, nice to have pickup.
33:03 David Pierce? Well, so that was the thing that was most surprising to me in going through this was how few incredibly compelling reasons there were to pick Netflix, like.
33:13 Alex Cranz? Yeah.
33:13 David Pierce? And this is the thing we've talked about a lot on this show, right? Like Netflix is great at having lots of shows and being available everywhere and its app works pretty well, but they're still in search of like the things that draw people to come to it on purpose and really like create cultural moments. They have, they've had some wins, like Squid Game was huge. Tiger King was huge. Like they have these beats.
33:34 Alex Cranz? Wednesday.
33:35 Nilay Patel? Yeah, Stranger Things, Wednesday, Outer Banks. Like if you're a teenager in America, you're, they've got you.
33:41 David Pierce? I've been watching The Night Agent recently. It's very good. It's just the like pulpy spy show, but it's excellent. But yeah, I don't know. I just feel like part of this, I'm definitely holding out hope that the next Gray Man movie on Netflix is better than the first one because I love that book series and I hate that movie.
33:55 Nilay Patel? No, no, they, they, this whole thing that they do where they're like, rich people make movies for lots of money. The Rock, you have an idea. Put Gal Gadot, like, stop it. Like, you don't know what you're doing.
34:05 David Pierce? Yeah, none of them have been any good.
34:06 Nilay Patel? What was the Michael Bay one with the numbers in the title?
34:09 David Pierce? Oh, was it Six Underground?
34:11 Nilay Patel? Yes, the numbers in the title. That's what I got for you.
34:14 David Pierce? That movie, like, the description of Six Underground is, like, meant for me specifically as a person.
34:21 Nilay Patel? Yeah, and you don't have any recollection of that happening to you at all?
34:24 David Pierce? No, I really don't. It was, it was bad, is all I remember. But I feel good about picking it up here, because I feel like I'm always gonna have something to watch, and it'll always be fine.
34:32 Alex Cranz? Totally adequate content.
34:34 David Pierce? All right, so now we are, we are into round four already. Alex, you're up next. What do you got?
34:39 Alex Cranz? Ooh, I'm gonna go Criterion.
34:41 David Pierce? Oh.
34:42 Alex Cranz? I pay for it already. I really enjoy it. It's probably got the best set of Hong Kong action films that you can find in streaming. It's really hard to find those in streaming. And it's actually got a whole bunch of them, especially, like, a bunch of Michelle Yeoh stuff is just popped up on there. It's got a lot of, like, old classic musicals, which, that's like, some people watch YouTube, I just go and, like, watch specific dance scenes from old classic musicals, and I can just do that on Criterion. And it's got a bunch of documentaries, like, I'm enjoying my choice.
35:13 David Pierce? This is a good pick. I didn't even have Criterion on my list, but that's, that's a really good pick. And Criterion also does a really good job with, like, they have a lot of bonus features, they do cool, like, behind-the-scenes stuff. It's like, it is probably, like, the film buffs' most film buffiest.
35:28 Alex Cranz? Yeah, there's, like, a ton of movies on there I will never, ever watch, but I like that I could if I really wanted to. If I wanna go watch some French New Wave, I can do that. I'm not going to, but I like that I know I can.
35:40 David Pierce? But you can. Neela, did you have Criterion on your list?
35:44 Nilay Patel? I did not.
35:44 David Pierce? Yeah, you should have waited on Criterion. It's a good pick, but I had not even, it had not even occurred to me to think about it.
35:49 Nilay Patel? Once we get in these rounds, it's all bets are off. Like, Alex is just off in the woods. She's like, all right, channels in the Criterion streaming service.
35:54 Alex Cranz? Like, whee, over in a corner. I'm having a great time.
35:57 Nilay Patel? No, it's, it's an excellent pick, by the way. I think that's very smart.
35:59 Alex Cranz? It's just a big nerdy art pick.
36:02 David Pierce? And ironically, maybe the single most likely candidate to still be around a bunch of years from now? Like, I don't know if I would pick against Criterion in this longevity fight.
36:12 Alex Cranz? Yeah, because they got killed once and they came back. Like,
36:14 David Pierce? Yeah.
36:15 Alex Cranz? They're gonna, they're gonna live forever now.
36:17 David Pierce? People still like black and white movies, including my father-in-law, who every time we go visit is like, have you seen this movie from 1936? And I'm always like, nope, I haven't seen it. And he's like, well, let's watch it tonight. So I'm getting a film education. It's lovely. All right, now, O'Neil, you get two now.
36:33 Nilay Patel? Wait, I feel like this is unfair because you and I keep getting two in a row and Alex is going in between us.
36:37 Alex Cranz? I'm like, hi.
36:37 David Pierce? Yeah, but it means we have to wait longer.
36:39 Nilay Patel? Yeah, I feel like this draft order makes more sense when you have more people.
36:42 David Pierce? I will say, I think Alex has gotten every single thing she wanted so far.
36:49 Alex Cranz? You guys are off in sports land over there and I'm a little gremlin.
36:52 Nilay Patel? I'm like doing strategy. All right, I have a rules question. You said this about YouTube, that you get a music service for free. Are we only drafting video services or do I have to put a music service in the mix?
37:05 David Pierce? If you want a music service, you can draft a music service.
37:07 Nilay Patel? But if I don't, like, are we just assuming that everyone has a Spotify subscription on the side? Or if I don't draft one, do I not listen to music?
37:14 David Pierce? If you don't draft one, you get ad-supported Pandora. That's, that's, that's the baseline.
37:19 Nilay Patel? All right, just, I, that was important because you, you took YouTube Music.
37:22 David Pierce? Yeah.
37:23 Nilay Patel? All right, then I'm taking Apple Music. Easy.
37:25 Alex Cranz? I knew I should have picked that last.
37:27 David Pierce? Why Apple Music?
37:28 Nilay Patel? I'm an Apple Music person. I, I, I think the interface is calmer. It doesn't seem like the music industry is perpetuating some sort of three-card Monte situation with me every time I open it.
37:38 David Pierce? Fair.
37:38 Nilay Patel? I like that they have lossless. I can't tell you if I can actually hear it or not, but I like that it's there. It's like a binky for me. And, you know, I'm an old head, so it sort of seamlessly imported my iTunes library from way back. Then I still just like gaze upon it from time to time.
37:54 David Pierce? Yeah, how much of the music service choice is like inertia as opposed to anything else? Because I even had this thought when I picked YouTube and got YouTube Music. I was like, ugh, do I still need to pick Spotify? Because I've like had Spotify for 10 years and it's going to be a gigantic pain in the ass to switch. Is it just the switching costs? Like, if you were starting over, would you still pick Apple Music?
38:14 Nilay Patel? Well, it depends. I think that switching cost, it's not money, right? It's like, well, have my music. Like, I'm not a curated playlist person unless I'm just like yelling at a voice assistant to start playing some music, you know?
38:26 David Pierce? Sure.
38:26 Nilay Patel? I'm like, I'm gonna listen to this album. I want to listen to these songs. So there's just a part of me that's very much, it's hard to switch unless you know that I want the entire, like, Clash catalog, the entire Cure catalog. Like, I'm still there. I'm still doing that thing. And so if that was easier, I would happily switch. But having like open an app and like, Go tell it which 18 records I want to pre-populate and have downloaded again is a very high switching cost and I don't have to pay it with Apple Music.
38:53 David Pierce? All right, Neelai, you have another pick, but we're gonna pause between your picks again. We're gonna take one more break and then we're gonna come do the last round and then all the insane cleanup we have to do to make any of this make any sense. We'll be right back.
39:16 Speaker 08 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing and wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash Apple Watch Series 12.
39:46 Speaker 01 If you're looking to hire, you need Indeed. With Indeed sponsored jobs, you can spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Less stress, less time, more results. And listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsored job credit to help your job get the premium status it deserves at indeed.com/podcast. Just go to indeed.com/podcast right now and support our show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Indeed.com/podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need to hire? This is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs.
40:35 David Pierce? All right, we're back. Let's just recap. We've done four rounds. We have one more round to go. So far, Neelai has picked TikTok, the Disney bundle, YouTube TV, and Apple Music. And just based on my math here, is spending like a little over $100 a month so far. So, great job.
40:51 Nilay Patel? I'm living the brand name lifestyle, man. I'm the luxury mall.
40:54 David Pierce? You really are. You, it's really true. Alex has picked HBO Max, Paramount Plus/Showtime, the Channels app, and the Criterion Collection, because Alex exists on a different planet from the rest of us.
41:05 Nilay Patel? Alex lives in Brooklyn.
41:08 David Pierce? And Alex is spending in the realm of like $45 a month, somewhere in that range. I have YouTube, Peacock, Netflix and Discovery Plus because I live in the Midwest.
41:20 David Pierce? I am, I am an American mom.
41:24 Alex Cranz? You got the little haircut to the side.
41:26 David Pierce? Yeah. And let's see, I'm spending 60 bucks all in. So I would say it's very unlikely that Neelai loses the who spends the most. So congrats to Neelai already. And now we are on to our fifth and final round. Neelai, you're up. What do you got?
41:41 Nilay Patel? All right, I'm picking between two. They're radically different, but I'm gonna do it. I'm just gonna say this out loud. I'm picking my buddy Vipin's Plex server.
41:51 Nilay Patel? It's really good. I can just text him.
41:53 David Pierce? Tell us about Vipin's Plex server.
41:55 Nilay Patel? So I've known Vipin for a long time. He's, uh, he's been running this thing for a long time. He has, it's all automatic. It's all legal content. It's just Linux distributions.
42:02 Alex Cranz? Yeah.
42:03 Nilay Patel? And whenever I want a new Linux distribution, I just text him and it appears.
42:08 Alex Cranz? Channels does that too.
42:10 David Pierce? You don't have to ask questions about where they come from.
42:12 Nilay Patel? Look, every now and again, I'm like, oh, I need the latest version of Red Hat.
42:17 Nilay Patel? Vipin's daughter is about the same age as my daughter. So it's, it's often that he has the same, uh, needs of Linux on his Plex server.
42:26 David Pierce? How are Vipin's metadatas?
42:29 Nilay Patel? My understanding is that, uh, much of the metadata cleanup you need to reliably distribute Linux around your home is automated.
42:39 David Pierce? Sometimes you just want to watch Linux. You know what I mean? Sometimes it's Friday night and you just want to put on Linux and watch it for two hours.
42:45 Nilay Patel? Every now and again, you're just like, oh, yeah.
42:46 Alex Cranz? Are you paying for Plex Pass?
42:48 Nilay Patel? Uh, no, no, no, no, no.
42:50 Alex Cranz? So is it no offline?
42:51 Nilay Patel? No, no, this is just a, this is just a cleanup pick at the end here. You know, you draft your first round quarterback and you pick one in the seventh round just to put some competition and make sure that's what, that's why I'm doing this.
43:02 David Pierce? I like it. What was your other choice if you didn't pick that?
43:05 Nilay Patel? Hilariously, randomly, Sirius XM.
43:07 David Pierce? What?
43:08 Nilay Patel? Yeah. And that's straight up, there's like three shows that Becky listens to that are only on Sirius.
43:14 David Pierce? You just almost picked Apple Music and Sirius XM back to back. Do you live in a car?
43:18 Nilay Patel? I picked the general hilarity of the Linux conversation over the actual need of making my wife happy.
43:25 David Pierce? What does she listen to on Sirius?
43:26 Nilay Patel? There's like a bunch of comedy podcasts that she listens to on Sirius. They're only on Sirius. So she like, that's why we have it. And then I do actually live in the car. And so I listen to a lot of Sirius in the car.
43:34 David Pierce? What's your go to? What do you listen to? Are you a yacht rock guy?
43:38 Nilay Patel? Not yacht rock. Lithium, the obviously the alternative rock. Oh, and First Wave.
43:43 David Pierce? Nice.
43:44 Nilay Patel? You can tell where my music tastes like fully lie. The other thing that's completely insane to do. If you have a Sirius subscription, you spend a lot of time in the car and you just need voices. Is you can listen to CNBC as an audio stream. And that is the most insane podcast that you can listen to. Like Jim Cramer at eight in the morning, just like yelling about money is like, I definitely don't feel sleepy. I'll tell you that much.
44:09 David Pierce? It's Jim Cramer saying, look at this chart and you saying, Jim, I can't.
44:12 Nilay Patel? Exactly.
44:13 David Pierce? Can't see the chart.
44:14 Nilay Patel? It is a vastly different experience to listen to it as an audio feed in the morning.
44:17 David Pierce? Okay. I just want to say about Sirius XM that I bought a car. Which meant that I got three free months of Sirius XM, which I used zero times because I couldn't even figure out how to set it up. And then since it elapsed, I would say I either get a phone call or a piece of physical mail from Sirius XM asking me to resubscribe every single day. And I have now become resolute that I will never, ever, ever listen to Sirius XM as long as I live. I refuse.
44:43 Nilay Patel? Yeah. I mean, but I'm commuting from the woods to the city once a week. So I spend five hours in a single day in the car often. And it's like, great. Like, why? Like, honestly, for the purpose of this draft, that's very utilitarian. Like, we're making entertainment here and it's Vip and Splex server.
44:58 David Pierce? Which I'm assuming is free. Vipin doesn't charge you server fees.
45:01 Nilay Patel? Again, we're friends for a long time. It all evens out in the end.
45:04 David Pierce? All right.
45:05 Nilay Patel? I've bought him a lot of drinks over the years.
45:07 David Pierce? We're putting a zero next to Vipin's place server. We'll put 99 cents because you have to buy him a beer every once in a while. It costs 99 cents a month.
45:14 Nilay Patel? All right.
45:14 David Pierce? All right. Last pick. Alex, what do you got?
45:18 Alex Cranz? What's the, what's the Apple service thing that's the Apple Music and the Apple TV?
45:22 Nilay Patel? Apple One.
45:23 David Pierce? Apple One.
45:24 Nilay Patel? That's good.
45:25 David Pierce? That's a good pick.
45:25 Alex Cranz? Going to spend a bunch of money and do that one because I too like Apple Music more than Spotify and Apple Music Classical. I've actually been using that way more than I thought I would. And then I think Apple TV is like, it's got good content.
45:40 David Pierce? What do you watch? What are your shows?
45:42 Alex Cranz? Really into Dickinson. I loved that when it came on. Severance, For All Mankind, The Morning Show. I don't watch The Morning Show. That's a lie. But it's there. Ted Lasso.
45:53 Nilay Patel? I haven't watched a season of Ted Lasso. I think that says a lot. It hasn't even occurred to me to spend time doing it.
45:58 Alex Cranz? Yeah.
45:58 David Pierce? It's fine. It's a, it's a show. You know what is good is Hello Tomorrow.
46:02 Alex Cranz? Is it actually good?
46:03 David Pierce? Weird, but delightful. I've only watched like four episodes, but it's very good. Shrinking, also very good. This is the thing about Apple TV Plus. It doesn't have that much stuff, but it's like, good show to bad show ratio is probably higher than any other platform I can think of.
46:17 Alex Cranz? Like Dickinson is a show I will, I will re-watch. It's one of my re-watch shows at this point. I just, I love it. And then For All Mankind, like, it's great. You watch people get progressively worse makeup as they pretend to age 10 years every season and then go into space with iPods. It's rad.
46:32 David Pierce? Alex, that was a really good pick. I'm sort of annoyed because you also, for Apple One, you get Apple Arcade and you get a bunch of iCloud storage that you will never use. But that's a, that's a pretty good pick.
46:42 Nilay Patel? If I, if iCloud storage isn't, then Alex is finally, with the last pick, snaked the most important pick in the draft.
46:50 Alex Cranz? Yeah, you guys are all going to be getting that obnoxious iCloud notification now.
46:55 Nilay Patel? I don't think iCloud storage counts. Like, if not, we need to redo this whole.
46:59 David Pierce? I'm going to take Dropbox Business as my last pick. Okay, so.
47:04 Alex Cranz? What's your final one?
47:05 David Pierce? I have two left on my list, which serve very different purposes for me. One is Amazon Prime Video, which was what I was gonna pick if I didn't get YouTube, because it's another one that's just like a big bunch of content plus of music services for free. So that was exciting. And then there's Hulu with Live TV, which I wanna pick because I like Hulu, because it also has a couple of my like endlessly rewatched shows, and because I need live sports. I think I'm gonna pick Hulu. I think Hulu with Live TV, which is 70 bucks a month, it comes with, well, okay, here's a rules clarification question. If I sign up for Hulu with Live TV, I also get the Disney bundle. I like back into the Disney bundle. Does that count?
47:43 Nilay Patel? Wait, there's no way to get Hulu with Live TV without getting Disney Plus?
47:46 David Pierce? No, you just get it for free. It's 70 bucks a month. Like, they're just, they're like, sure, have Disney.
47:50 Alex Cranz? You have so much money.
47:51 Nilay Patel? Yeah, I mean, I think this is allowed.
47:53 David Pierce? Okay, good.
47:53 Nilay Patel? I came at Hulu the other way. But if I hadn't blown the salary cap with Sunday Ticket, we would be competing here, and I think it would be fair.
48:01 David Pierce? Okay, all right, good. I buy it. Then, yeah, I'm taking Hulu with Live TV, 70 bucks a month. I get Disney Plus, I get ESPN Plus, I get New Girl, which is just about to leave Netflix, and go to Hulu, which is another one of the shows I've watched 700 times. Schitt's Creek is there. It's another one I've watched.
48:14 Nilay Patel? Oh my god, this is an incredible sleeper final pick.
48:17 David Pierce? Oh, yeah. I feel really good about this.
48:18 Alex Cranz? But like, Neelai and I both have access to that. He can just hit up his buddy.
48:23 David Pierce? Can I just get Vipint? My last pick is Neelai giving me Vipint's number.
48:29 David Pierce? That's my final pick.
48:30 Nilay Patel? All that's on there is Linux, you guys.
48:33 Alex Cranz? Just love that red hat.
48:36 David Pierce? I really, like, I did not mean to do this. I accidentally ended up with like the most down-the-middle set of streaming services. This is really upsetting. All right, so we have done five picks. Congratulations to everybody. We completed the draft. Andrew, do you have a cool last sound for the end of the draft?
48:59 David Pierce? Andrew, you've been keeping track of everything. All the math, all the money totaled up for us. How are we doing?
49:04 Speaker 06 Okay, so Neelai, despite picking two streaming services that did not cost any money, collectively, 104.98.
49:13 Alex Cranz? A month.
49:14 Speaker 06 Plus the 289.
49:16 David Pierce? Right.
49:16 Speaker 06 For the Sunday ticket, which would be 393.96. One-time payment of that 289, but still. Alex, it's lowest here at 63.92.
49:28 David Pierce? Good work.
49:29 Alex Cranz? Frugal.
49:29 Speaker 06 David, you really added it up with Hulu at live TV, coming at 129.95.
49:35 Nilay Patel? Whoa.
49:36 Speaker 06 A month.
49:38 Nilay Patel? I got, I got football and a kind of cheaper monthly.
49:43 David Pierce? Picking Netflix was a mistake, now that I'm looking at it. 20 bucks for Netflix was a bad use of 20 bucks a month.
49:49 Speaker 06 YouTube Premium Family is a lot of money.
49:52 David Pierce? Yeah, but, but the reason, okay, let me defend family real fast. I don't have to watch ads, even when Anna wants to watch YouTube, which is worth the extra money.
50:02 Speaker 06 That's true.
50:02 David Pierce? But, okay, so that means Alex, you get, you get the free pick here at the end.
50:06 Alex Cranz? Ooh.
50:07 David Pierce? Anything you want. Sky's the limit.
50:09 Alex Cranz? Okay, does this one count? Libro.fm?
50:12 Speaker 06 Oh my God, Alex.
50:13 Alex Cranz? I gotta read my books.
50:15 Speaker 06 So it's an audiobook service?
50:16 David Pierce? Doesn't count.
50:17 Alex Cranz? Doesn't count? Okay.
50:18 David Pierce? I don't know why. It just, it just doesn't. I just can't.
50:20 Speaker 06 Wait, is that's an audiobook streaming service? Or is that just like a, like a book?
50:24 Alex Cranz? It's an audiobook service and you get like a credit to buy a book each month.
50:29 David Pierce? No.
50:29 Alex Cranz? Okay. All right, cool. Well, that's great. I still, I still can read books on my own time. I didn't make sure I was gonna be allowed to read books. Um, what's the Microsoft, the Microsoft streaming cloud thing for games?
50:42 David Pierce? Oh, that's interesting.
50:44 Alex Cranz? I like, I think of it as Microsoft X Cloud, but whatever it's actually called now, that one.
50:48 David Pierce? I just call it Game Pass. I think it has a more complicated name, but everybody just calls it Game Pass.
50:52 Speaker 06 Yeah.
50:52 Alex Cranz? That's a good, that's also a good way to put it. Yeah, Game Pass.
50:55 Speaker 06 So you ended up with the two game services with Apple One, you got Apple Arcade and now you're going with Game Pass?
51:00 Alex Cranz? Yeah, and then I play the other games while I'm watching my Criterion.
51:04 Nilay Patel? Really good wildcard pick at the end, man.
51:07 David Pierce? That is a really good pick.
51:08 Alex Cranz? Cause it's either that or Plex, but I already did Channels, which gives me the same benefit as Plex, but a better DVR layout.
51:15 Nilay Patel? Yeah.
51:15 Alex Cranz? Stuff still sometimes adds to it when I don't DVR it. It's wild. It's crazy.
51:19 Nilay Patel? Does it? This means that Amazon Prime went completely unpicked.
51:22 David Pierce? Yeah.
51:23 Nilay Patel? Which I, I think is not totally surprising.
51:26 Alex Cranz? How often are you like, oh man, I just really gotta watch like Extraction, but even more boring and on a worse you I.
51:34 Nilay Patel? Again, because Becky is so into comedy, every now and again, there's like one comedy special on Amazon Prime.
51:40 Alex Cranz? Yeah.
51:41 Nilay Patel? Like that's it.
51:41 David Pierce? I'm really angry at this pick, Alex. That was a really good pick that I feel like I, if I had thought of that, I probably would have picked a while ago. Game Pass is good. And also like a strong future bet. Like if we come back and the question is like, how did all our bets do?
51:53 Alex Cranz? Yeah. Game, Game Pass is gonna exist.
51:55 David Pierce? Yeah.
51:56 Alex Cranz? Like the majority of mine will still be around, except for probably my first two, maybe.
52:01 Nilay Patel? I feel great about my draft. This is a good, it's a, this is a solid year ahead.
52:05 David Pierce? On my list, the only things that went unpicked that I still have on my list are, nobody picked Prime Video, nobody picked Spotify, which is very interesting. Um, we're all happy with our other weird services or Free Pandora. And, and then I have a bunch of like, I wrote down, you know, Free V and Tubi and Pluto TV and the Roku Channel and all that stuff and Sling and nobody picked any of that. I'm not super shocked.
52:28 Alex Cranz? But see, I get, I get the Roku Channel because it does an M3U playlist, so I can watch it anytime on Channels.
52:35 David Pierce? Yeah.
52:36 Nilay Patel? Here's what I'm saying. If this draft had had like two or three more people in it, I think the drafting around those channels would have been intense. Especially because then they would have been how you would strategically have lowered the cost to try to get that extra pick.
52:50 David Pierce? All right. Well, next year, we'll, this draft will include 13 people. We're gonna have a 32-team draft next year. And everybody gets five picks. It's gonna get outrageous.
52:59 Nilay Patel? Although I will say, even in this draft, David, I felt as though I was stealing picks from you and I don't think I did that really, except maybe for Sunday Ticket. Neither of us was competing with Alex. No. No one was really competing. Alex is fully trust the process, like whatever was going on over there.
53:15 David Pierce? I will say, I was hoping that my three and four picks were going to be YouTube and TikTok. That was going to be the turn I made at three and four. I thought one of you would take HBO, one of you would take Disney, and I would get YouTube and TikTok and just like laugh at you old people about how I understand the future. And it didn't really work out that way, unfortunately.
53:31 Nilay Patel? And no one took Instagram reels?
53:32 David Pierce? Well, you took TikTok, so you basically took Instagram reels.
53:36 Nilay Patel? But if you want, if you wanted that thing, Instagram, right? You want diet TikTok, you take Instagram reels.
53:42 David Pierce? True.
53:42 Alex Cranz? I like that I'm not going to know anything about the real world ever with my picks. I don't know what's happening in the world.
53:49 David Pierce? Which is not that different from what you came into this with, so you're good there.
53:52 Alex Cranz? I've learned nothing about the draft in this whole process, and I'm not going to with my picks.
53:58 David Pierce? All right, we should go. We're going to do this again next year, and we're going to have to come up with some score by which we see how we did this year. Also, today, as this show goes live, there's an event at which HBO Max and Discovery Plus may cease to be what they currently are. So this might all get real weird, real fast. But we'll have lots more to talk about. Thank you both for doing this. This was very fun.
54:17 Alex Cranz? This is great.
54:18 Nilay Patel? Yeah, super fun.
54:25 David Pierce? All right, that is it for The Vergecast today. Thanks to Neelai and Alex for being here and going through this crazy process with me. And thank you so much for listening. There's a whole lot more from this conversation and all of our streaming coverage on theverge.com. We put some links in the show notes, but there's all kinds of stuff all over the website. And I really, really, really want to know what you think of our picks. Who won the draft? What was the most surprising undrafted service? What obvious stuff did we miss? Who's the stupidest of the three of us? You can email us all of your thoughts at vergecast@theverge.com or call the Vergecast hotline, 866-VERGE11. We'd love hearing from you, and I want to hear all of your thoughts on the streaming draft, including ideas for next year, because, like I said, I intend to do this every year until the heat death of the universe. This
55:10 David Pierce? show is produced by Andrew Moreno and Liam James. Brooke Minter is our editorial director of audio. The Vergecast is a Verge production and part of the Fox Media Podcast Network. We'll be back on Friday with Neelai and Alex to talk about what's going on with Elon Musk and Twitter, electric cars, Microsoft Teams, and a whole bunch of other stuff. See you then. Rock and roll.
55:33 Speaker 02 When it comes to AI, there is what we could do and what we should do. What will we decide? I'm Kimberly Nebula, host of the Pondering AI Podcast from SAS. Every episode, I sit down with innovators, researchers, and technologists to consider the questions that come after the AI breakthroughs. Questions that don't have easy answers but need to be asked. If you're curious or concerned about AI, join me as we challenge assumptions and ponder the issues together. Find Pondering AI wherever you get your podcasts.
56:04 Speaker 09 As a pioneer in the organic and natural food industry, the Whole Foods Market philosophy is rooted in a shared connection to people and to the planet. From farmland to stores, its products have always been a symphony of colors, textures, and flavors. In addition to its national brands, Whole Foods Market's team of local foragers continually scours the country to bring over 60,000 emerging and local products to its shelves each year. And they work with credentialed experts and top-of-the-line makers to offer customers the best possible variety. Shop Whole Foods Market in-store or online.
Previous Twitter blue check chaos and CarPlay squabbles Next HBO vs. Max and Twitter vs. Substack Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated