Skip to content

The $8 million AI music scam

The Vergecast

38m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode explores the novel criminal case against Mike Smith, who was sentenced to 18 months in prison for orchestrating an AI music streaming fraud scheme that generated nearly nine million dollars in royalties. The guest and host discuss how Smith leveraged early AI song generation tools like Boomi, distributed hundreds of thousands of tracks through fake artist personas, and used bot networks to artificially inflate stream counts. They examine the legal boundaries of streaming fraud, the challenges platforms face in policing AI-generated slop, and whether this high-profile conviction will serve as an effective deterrent or simply drive similar operations overseas.

  • Artificial streaming fraud involves using automated bot networks to loop songs on repeat and artificially inflate royalty payouts. 13:22
  • Mike Smith was ordered to repay $8,091,843.64 for his AI music streaming scheme. 11:59
  • Streaming services prohibit artificial stream inflation even when putting AI-generated music on platforms is technically allowed. 20:37
  • Platforms like Spotify have removed massive quantities of AI-generated tracks as the scale of slop has increased. 20:04

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Show Sponsorships and Host Introduction

    The episode opens with a series of sponsor messages before the hosts introduce the topic and the guest.

  2. 2:08
    Introducing Mike Smith and the AI Music Scam

    David Pierce sets the stage, explaining Mike Smith’s alleged scheme to generate millions in music royalties using AI.

  3. 4:55
    Mike Smith’s Early Career and Music Ambitions

    The conversation delves into Smith’s transition from healthcare to music, his early projects, and the challenges he faced as an aspiring artist.

  4. 12:18
    Construction of the AI‑Powered Streaming System

    Smith’s method of generating AI songs, creating fake artists, and using bot networks to inflate streams is explained in detail.

  5. 15:07
    Industry Response and Regulatory Challenges

    The episode examines how music platforms, regulators, and anti‑fraud firms are reacting to AI‑driven streaming fraud.

  6. 20:37
    Legal Fallout and Criminal Charges

    The hosts discuss the charges against Smith, the nature of the fraud, and the broader legal implications for streaming platforms.

Highlights

  • 4:01

    AI Agents Blocked By Banksinsight

    The host notes that JP Morgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon announced the company is blocking AI agents from conducting banking transactions on behalf of customers.

  • 5:18

    First AI Streaming Fraud Casestory

    The guest explains that Mike Smith's arrest marks the first criminal charges brought against someone for AI streaming fraud.

  • 12:18

    Early AI Song Generatorsinsight

    The guest and host discuss Boomi as one of the earliest AI song generation services used before tools like Suno and Udeo became popular.

  • 13:55

    Millions in Streaming Royaltiesdata

    The guest highlights that making millions of dollars from streaming services is an extraordinarily high amount given how little music streaming typically pays.

  • 19:52

    No Rules Against AI Musicdebate

    The guest and host point out that streaming platforms do not have rules disallowing AI-generated music, making the fraud charge dependent on botting rather than AI usage.

  • 25:45

    Avoiding Detection Abroadstrategy

    An anti-fraud executive noted that Smith made himself easy to find by staying in the US, whereas many grifters operate from beaches in places like Cambodia.

  • 34:47

    Prediction Markets and Streaminginsight

    The host and guest discuss how prediction markets have created a new incentive for users to artificially bot streams on Spotify to win financial bets.

Quotes

  • “I wound up finding the number was $8,91,843.64 was what the government ordered him to repay.”
    Unnamed speaker · 11:59
  • “So $8 million in the era of bajillion dollar valuations for AI companies might not sound like that much money, but music streaming pays nothing.”
    Unnamed speaker · 13:41
  • “The thing that they got him for, like the, the streamers do prohibit artificial like stream inflation.”
    Unnamed speaker · 20:37
  • “People are juicing their own streams, every, like, there was a whole kerfuffle over Drake and Kendrick Lamar and who was buying streams for what?”
    Unnamed speaker · 24:31
  • “I think most people work for the companies would say to your face, like, yeah, we're fighting.”
    Unnamed speaker · 36:46
  • AWS AI 0:00–0:31
  • On Investing 0:31–1:11
  • JIRA by Atlassian 1:16–2:05
  • blinds.com 15:35–16:39
  • Outshift 16:42–17:53
  • AWS AI 17:56–18:35
  • Rippling 31:59–33:08
  • JIRA by Atlassian 33:11–34:09
  • American Express 34:12–34:36

About this episode

A man named Mike Smith was recently sentenced to 18 months in prison, and a fine in excess of $8 million, for creating an AI system that faked billions of streams and earned him millions in royalties. Wired's Kate Knibbs explains how Smith pulled it off, how he got caught, and what this case means for the internet's growing slop problems. Vote for us in the Signal Awards! ⁠Vote Vergecast: Best Technology Podcast⁠ ⁠Vote Version History: Best History Podcast⁠ ⁠Vote Decoder: Best Business Podcast⁠ Further reading: ⁠Apple’s HomeView ad is confusing to everyone except parents | The Verge⁠ ⁠Ocarina of Time’s Switch 2 remake feels modern — and terrifying | The Verge⁠ ⁠We might not have to wait 13 years for the next GTA | The Verge⁠ ⁠Epic is bringing Fortnite to Linux | The Verge⁠ ⁠JPMorgan Chase is keeping AI agents out. | The Verge⁠ ⁠Wired: Spotify Confirms Streaming Fraud After Kalshi Trader Cries Foul⁠ Subscribe to The Verge for unlimited access to theverge.com, subscriber-exclusive newsletters, and our ad-free podcast feed. We love hearing from you! Email your questions and thoughts to vergecast@theverge.com or call us at 866-VERGE11. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript

0:00
38:00

7,348 words · 6 speakers

Topics

  • Spotify
  • Apple
  • Suno
  • Apple Watch Series 12
  • DistroKid
  • Internet of Cognition
  • Apple Home View
  • Udeo
  • Universal Music Group
  • Google

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated