Pod Insights The Rewatchables ‘Basic Instinct’ Live From SF With Bill Simmons, Chris Ryan, Mallory Rubin, and Van Lathan About this episode Have you ever rewatched a movie on cocaine, Nick? Live from San Francisco, Bill, Chris, Mal, and Van record the pod of the century after revisiting Paul Verhoeven's 1992 erotic thriller ‘Basic Instinct’ starring Michael Douglas, Sharon Stone, Jeanne Tripplehorn, and George Dzundza.
Producers: Craig Horlbeck, Chia Hao Tat, Eduardo Ocampo, and Matt Pevic
Try ZipRecruiter FOR FREE at https://ziprecruiter.com/REWATCHABLES
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 20,035 words · 6 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Bill Simmons? This episode is brought to by Ethos. As a parent, life insurance feels like a no-brainer. It just gives me peace of mind knowing my family will be taken care of. And Ethos makes getting it fast and easy. Apply online in minutes. Get up to 3 million in coverage with no medical exam, just a few simple health questions. Take 10 minutes to get covered today with life insurance through Ethos. Get your free quote at ethos.com/rewatch. That is E-T-H-O-S dot com slash rewatch. Application times may vary. Rates may vary.
0:33 Speaker 01 For adults with Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis symptoms, every choice matters. Tremfya offers self-injection or intravenous infusion from the start. Tremfya is administered as injections under the skin or infusions through a vein every four weeks, followed by injections under the skin every four or eight weeks. If your doctor decides that you can self-inject Tremfya, proper training is required. Tremfya is a prescription medicine used to treat adults with moderately to severely active Crohn's disease and adults with moderately to severely active ulcerative colitis, serious allergic reactions, increased risk of infections, or lower ability to fight them, and liver problems may occur. Before treatment, get checked for infections and tuberculosis.
1:17 Speaker 01 Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu-like symptoms, or need a vaccine. Explore what's possible. Ask your doctor about Tremfya today. Call 1-800-526-7736 to learn more, or visit tremfyaradio.com.
1:54 Bill Simmons? All right.
2:08 Bill Simmons? Last time you heard this song, it was a cocaine threesome in a bathroom, followed by some dancing. And now, we are here, you horny motherfuckers.
2:23 Bill Simmons? Let me introduce the Rewatchables cast. First of all, thank you, everybody, for coming out tonight. This theater's awesome. Thank you. I love that third deck up there, it's great.
2:33 Bill Simmons? First off, he's the curator of the White Girl Hall of Fame. He's currently hosting a record 17 different Ringer podcasts. The next mayor of Los Angeles, Van Lathan.
2:56 Bill Simmons? You know her as the mother of dragons. She's a woman who really likes hands and fingers. She's almost definitely gonna violate a public obscenity law tonight. Mallory Rubin.
3:16 Bill Simmons? He's the five-time Rewatchables MVP.
3:21 Bill Simmons? He's the man who turned March into CR Month. He's the author of three books about medals. CR himself, Chris Ryan.
3:37 Bill Simmons? And over on the side, for the first time ever joining us for a live show, our producer, the guy who's taken over this podcast after I'm found naked and dead like Johnny Bosz, Craig Hornbeck.
3:52 Bill Simmons? Yeah. All right. Did you like that, CR?
3:56 Chris Ryan? I do. I like the idea also that you're not killed by a beautiful blonde, but by a Lakers fan.
4:02 Bill Simmons? Thank you. Let's talk most San Francisco movies ever.
4:06 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
4:06 Speaker 03 Wow.
4:07 Bill Simmons? CR? We talked about this earlier. I think the necessities are hills.
4:13 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
4:13 Bill Simmons? Water.
4:14 Chris Ryan? Sure.
4:15 Bill Simmons? Shots of the bridge and nice real estate. Anything else? What do you got?
4:20 Chris Ryan? I just think that the sky, the light, the fog, there's like an atmospheric element that San Francisco movies tend to bring into play. I mean, you've got some real... We were talking about how hard it is to move anything off of Mount Rushmore for these.
4:33 Bill Simmons? Yeah, so we got, we were thinking like movies that actually use the city. And it's really cool doing this, you know, in San Francisco, obviously. Movies that make you feel like you're in San Francisco. My four are Basic Instinct, Vertigo, Bullitt, because of the car chase, and then 48 Hours, my favorite movie ever. Van, what else would you put in there? Because I could offer you Mrs. Doubtfire.
4:56 Speaker 03 Yeah.
4:56 Bill Simmons? I could offer you The Rock, Pacific Heights, The Game. Anything else?
5:00 Speaker 04 What about like Dirty Harry, right?
5:02 Bill Simmons? Could offer you Dirty Harry.
5:03 Speaker 04 Dirty Harry was here. Yeah, man. As a matter of fact, I just want to let you guys know, they're lying about your city. When I came out here, I expected to see Batman patrolling the streets, like, it's fucking gorgeous.
5:19 Bill Simmons? Yeah, honestly, San Francisco's back. We walked from our hotel to the Giants game last night. San Francisco's in great shape. I don't, not listening to the buzz anymore.
5:31 Chris Ryan? Philly's lost.
5:32 Bill Simmons? Mallory.
5:33 Speaker 03 Tough for CR.
5:36 Chris Ryan? See you guys in around October, or not. Yeah.
5:38 Speaker 03 Yeah.
5:39 Bill Simmons? What else do you have for San Francisco movies?
5:40 Speaker 03 Naturally, you're missing a little bit of a genre presence. No Ant-Man, you know?
5:45 Bill Simmons? There you go.
5:45 Speaker 03 You didn't have the MCU on your list. Planet of the Apes, no? Star Trek?
5:50 Bill Simmons? Planet of the Apes is a good one.
5:51 Speaker 04 Star Trek.
5:51 Bill Simmons? Yeah. That's good. What's your favorite?
5:54 Speaker 03 I have a similar Mount Rushmore to you, I think. I'd say it's probably Bullitt, Zodiac, this movie, Basic Instinct, and Mrs. Doubtfire, for me.
6:05 Bill Simmons? Craig, you're the only one that grew up here.
6:07 Speaker 05 I grew up in the East Bay, but yes.
6:12 Bill Simmons? Wow. All right, so what's the most San Francisco movie ever?
6:17 Speaker 05 For me, growing up, Mrs. Doubtfire, for sure.
6:19 Bill Simmons? Okay, all right. Well, we have a more important Mount Rushmore. The erotic thriller, Mount Rushmore.
6:26 Speaker 03 Oh, yeah. Boy.
6:27 Bill Simmons? Which, the unassailable choices are Body Heat, Fatal Attraction, Basic Instinct, and Unfaithful. Unfortunately, we have the Mother of Dragons here to weigh in. Is that the right four? Is there anyone else you would put in? Nine and a half weeks? What else?
6:40 Speaker 03 Well, we've done three of those four together.
6:42 Bill Simmons? We sure have.
6:42 Speaker 03 For rewatchables, and now we're doing this one together for the second time.
6:46 Speaker 05 Yeah.
6:46 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
6:47 Speaker 05 That's right.
6:48 Bill Simmons? A rematch.
6:48 Speaker 03 So that's nice. Yeah, that's how three of the five of us got through the first month of COVID, was learning how to podcast remotely, talking about this movie. Very normal podcast experience.
6:58 Bill Simmons? It was on Zoom, three weeks after COVID started. I honestly don't even remember one aspect of what happened.
7:02 Speaker 03 I remember that Chris kept saying, "I'll do that if I ever see you guys again in person."
7:09 Speaker 05 Yeah.
7:09 Speaker 03 Right? He was using the pandemic as a shield to make all of these declarations about how he'd start wearing deep V-neck sweaters.
7:16 Speaker 05 With no t-shirt under it.
7:17 Speaker 03 And doing cocaine in the bathroom stall at the nightclub.
7:21 Bill Simmons? So, Van, this movie...
7:23 Speaker 04 Show me the nightclub. You know, the night's young.
7:27 Bill Simmons? This movie jumpstarts the erotic thriller, Skinamax era.
7:31 Speaker 04 Yeah.
7:32 Bill Simmons? Which I guess technically starts with Night Eyes in 1990 with Andrew Stephens. I know you own it on 4K Blu-ray.
7:38 Speaker 04 Yeah, of course.
7:40 Bill Simmons? Silk stockings on CBS, no nudity, but very important.
7:43 Speaker 04 I got more of this, yes.
7:44 Bill Simmons? Basic Instinct, we have Shane and Tweed, and Shane and Worry are about to come into our lives.
7:48 Speaker 04 All of them.
7:49 Bill Simmons? What else do you remember from this era?
7:50 Speaker 04 I remember, like, staying up late, making sure that my parents were asleep. I was by myself, having a great time. Emmanuel, all the different Emmanuels. I have a list later. Yeah, I know. I'm not by myself. But, you know, Red Shoe Diaries, you fucking freak you.
8:07 Bill Simmons? Red Shoe, yeah.
8:09 Speaker 04 All of that stuff. Because what happened was, this is prestige freak shit, Basic Instinct. That's not, I could get to that, right? That was in a movie theater. But then the freak shit that came on later on, you know, that was the stuff that was accessible to me. And that's what really made me a man.
8:26 Bill Simmons? CR and I have had very different experiences with this movie because I saw this movie in college by myself in Worcester, Massachusetts during the day.
8:35 Speaker 04 Wait a second.
8:36 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
8:37 Speaker 04 Don't let that slide.
8:38 Speaker 03 Yeah.
8:39 Speaker 04 I saw this movie in college by myself.
8:42 Speaker 03 Yeah.
8:42 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
8:43 Speaker 04 Every...
8:43 Bill Simmons? I had some time after class.
8:45 Speaker 04 Every story he tells from him in college, "Ah, it was me, House, and Joe King. We were all hanging out." But he made them motherfuckers leave.
8:53 Bill Simmons? It was a solo.
8:55 Speaker 03 How many empty seats between you and the next guy who was also jerking off throughout the entire movie?
9:02 Speaker 04 Extra butter.
9:03 Bill Simmons? I don't remember a lot, other than that there were no couples. And I'm gonna say between 16 and 18 guys soloing in different spots in the theater.
9:14 Speaker 03 There you go.
9:15 Bill Simmons? And it just, the feedback or the stuff that was coming out about this movie. First of all, we knew like the nude scenes were off the chain. We knew Sharon Stone was the lady from Total Recall and some Action Jackson movies we liked. And then there was supposedly this, this female frontal thing that you didn't know what it was. So it was a little like the, the shark and jaws waiting to see what was gonna happen.
9:40 Chris Ryan? Yeah. But if you didn't know you were gonna get a shark in jaws, like it was just a rumor.
9:45 Bill Simmons? Yeah. And I honestly, CR, this movie went way further than I was prepared. But you saw it younger than me, because you're younger than me.
9:53 Chris Ryan? Yeah, we, we, we were like Dan Orlovsky breaking down tape with this once this hit the video stores. There was a lot of missing copies of this. And there was a lot of probably like, you know, manipulating the tracking on your VHS machine. So this was, this was a Hall of Fame rental.
10:11 Bill Simmons? How did this help you through puberty?
10:14 Chris Ryan? I was thinking about this. Sharon Stone, 86 through 92, is like, her and Cathy Ireland are the bird and magic of my sexual awakening.
10:26 Bill Simmons? Who would you throw in, Vin?
10:28 Speaker 04 I got a list.
10:31 Speaker 04 Alright, so, um, at the bottom of the list, all the ladies from the various Emanuel movies. Emanuel Queen of the Desert, Emanuel in Space, Black Emanuel, Emanuel in Bangkok. They had Emanuel for every fucking flavor that you needed. Alright, number four, Sharon Stone in Basic Instinct.
10:48 Speaker 03 Yeah.
10:48 Speaker 04 Number three, Robin Givens in A Rage in Harlem. Number two, Janet Jackson in The Pleasure Pentacle Video.
10:53 Speaker 03 Okay, yeah.
10:55 Speaker 04 Number one, Pam Grier, Foxy Brown. My mom, that's what I'm talking about. My mom actually made me get into Pam Grier and Foxy Brown. My mother suggested I watch that, you know why? Because of Basic Instinct.
11:07 Speaker 03 Yeah.
11:08 Speaker 04 My mom thought that she was gonna lose me to the white women. And she was like, so she was like, thought she was raised in Cuba Gooding Jr. And she goes,
11:18 Speaker 04 "You ever seen Foxy Brown?" Cause she knew those could be back to the black side of the situation. Shout out to mama.
11:25 Bill Simmons? Mission accomplished. Well, we have a Rewatchables Award named after a character in this movie that Catherine Trammell, would you throw your life away for this obvious stay-away award? CR, if someone said to you, "I'm writing a book about a podcaster who falls in love with the wrong woman", and it was Sharon Stone in this movie, are you just like, "I'm gonna be dead in four weeks"?
11:47 Chris Ryan? I mean, it's less than four weeks. I think that this movie actually has multiple candidates for this, though. Like, watching it this time around, I would toss it all away for Beth. I mean, that's...
11:56 Speaker 03 Yeah. What about Roxy?
11:58 Chris Ryan? Beautiful lady, but also a free therapist, you know?
12:01 Bill Simmons? Right. And Roxy.
12:02 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
12:03 Speaker 03 And Roxy, of course.
12:05 Speaker 04 It's easily Roxy, man.
12:07 Bill Simmons? So, I was gonna talk about this later, cause we gotta get into Sharon Stone. But Roxy just comes and goes. She's in this movie, and she's the cop stripper in Days of Thunder. Never seen again. You look at her IMDB, it's like, she, she just, I don't know what happened. But if you just saw this movie, you would've... I thought she was gonna be as big of a star as Sharon Stone, or at least close.
12:27 Speaker 03 Oh.
12:28 Bill Simmons? No? At least for me.
12:30 Speaker 03 If you saw this movie now, you definitely would think that's a person who's gonna be responsible for generating a lot of memes.
12:36 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
12:36 Speaker 03 Which is powerful in its own way. But Sharon Stone, you watch this movie and you're like, this is the most powerful force of nature, like a hurricane in human form. That's not exactly what Roxy is giving. She's giving...
12:48 Bill Simmons? Yeah, Roxy provoked different emotions.
12:50 Speaker 03 Let's hit the dance floor.
12:51 Speaker 04 You know, I never went for the Sharon Stone types.
12:56 Chris Ryan? In, you mean the Catherine Trammell types, or just Sharon Stone?
12:59 Speaker 04 No, what I mean is that, like, you go to the club with your boys.
13:03 Bill Simmons? I'm gonna buckle up.
13:04 Speaker 04 And everyone goes, "Yo, we gotta have this girl." I would always look at her friend. I'd be like, her friend is the one that's not getting any attention. She's looking at her friend on the dance floor, she's pissed off. She's like, "Look at all them motherfuckers looking at her, I wish I was her." And then I come over and I validate her. I go, "Girl, you are her."
13:24 Speaker 04 That's Roxy.
13:28 Chris Ryan? Somebody just needed to validate her, yeah.
13:34 Bill Simmons? A quote in this movie about the Sharon Stone character, Mallory. I love it. She's got a hundred million bucks, she fucks fighters and rock and roll stars, and she's got a degree in screwing with people's heads. And that's not the craziest thing said about her during this movie.
13:47 Speaker 03 No, or the craziest thing that she says. I mean, the quotes in this movie are astonishing. One of the wonderful colleagues, Elizabeth, live events head at Rockstar, our own Rockstar, hasn't seen this movie. We were backstage with her and I was thinking, wouldn't it be fun if we did like a, is this a real quote from this movie game with her, right? Because like, you could break out, "Have you ever fucked on cocaine, Nick? It's nice." And then you could break out, "There's cum. All over the sheets." Right? And you would get like forty-five lines deep.
14:21 Chris Ryan? No, that's not how he says it.
14:23 Speaker 03 All over. There's no way. Before he got off, impressive.
14:28 Bill Simmons? That would've been a fun game show.
14:30 Speaker 03 We could've gone a hundred fifty lines deep before we even had to put the first fake quote in there. It's amazing.
14:35 Bill Simmons? Elizabeth does the live shows for us, and she always watches the movie. On the flight to the location. And we were like, no, no.
14:44 Speaker 03 You need a privacy screen.
14:45 Bill Simmons? Please no.
14:48 Bill Simmons? Who is, like, what actress now, Van, would be the Sharon Stone that you would cast in this movie?
14:53 Speaker 04 Interesting question.
14:54 Bill Simmons? Because this does feel generational, right? Like, we go through, because there was a Kathleen Turner face, or she would have been in it.
15:01 Speaker 04 So, this movie came out at a different time, okay? We have penises now. This movie came out when we had dicks.
15:10 Speaker 03 Yeah.
15:11 Speaker 04 Completely different. We didn't have to pretend like it was something nice about what was happening. It was aggressive. It was primal. Now, I'm trying to think, who could bring that energy? Who could like, who could do that and like, not give a fuck? You know, not care? Maybe like, Margaret Qualley? Maybe she's a little bit like that, you know? I don't know. It's different now, because if you make the movie now, everyone's gonna be so self-aware of everything that's happening. This movie kind of like, careens through its plot with reckless abandon, and it doesn't really care what anyone thinks about it. It would be difficult to like, cast somebody in that role and have them just be completely free.
15:45 Speaker 03 I know we like, always end up picking the same person, but is it not Sydney Sweeney?
15:52 Speaker 03 Is it not?
15:53 Bill Simmons? I mean, obviously, she could pull it off.
15:56 Bill Simmons? I think, so.
15:59 Speaker 04 Wow, you got to pull Sydney Sweeney.
16:01 Bill Simmons? Here, here's the difference, though, with Sharon Stone and why this movie was so important, where she had popped in stuff, but we didn't really have a history with her.
16:08 Chris Ryan? She was good, too. She was like, she had been in a bunch of stuff. She was in Action Jackson.
16:12 Bill Simmons? Yeah, and I remember like, she was in A Reconcilable Differences, which is a great divorce movie, which is not available anywhere. But she was in that in like, 1982. And for 10 years was just bouncing around. What was the?
16:25 Chris Ryan? She was in a Buffalo Law with Steven Seagal.
16:27 Bill Simmons? Yeah, she was in a Seagal movie, and just, Total Recall was probably the biggest movie that she was in, right? She's great in that. So, this was kind of her moment. I don't know who that actress is now.
16:37 Speaker 04 The point, the point is, is that like, at this juncture in her career, she was hungry enough to do a movie like this and not hold anything back. So, if we talk about- actresses that are in that situation. Now, we're gonna talk about more established actresses, but like, this is like a controversial role. You have to really go a lot of places that, you know, could end up really being combustible for your career like it was for Elizabeth Berkeley in Showgirls, or could make you like it did for Sharon Stone in Basic.
17:03 Bill Simmons? So they, they get Michael Douglas for fourteen million dollars for this movie, and then he gets kinda semi-approval for who the female star's gonna be. Sharon Stone was the thirteenth choice. She made five hundred thousand dollars, which was, uh, less than fourteen million.
17:19 Speaker 03 In, in part, though, because of what you're just saying, right? Like, he really wanted somebody who was equally famous and renowned to kind of, they were anticipating that it would be controversial, right?
17:28 Bill Simmons? He wanted Kim Basinger, right?
17:29 Speaker 03 Yeah, he was like, I need somebody who's gonna be able to shoulder the load of the, the blowback.
17:34 Chris Ryan? And I do remember, like, you can see it now when you've.
17:37 Speaker 03 Plenty of blowback in the movie.
17:39 Chris Ryan? When you go on and read about, like, it's released now, she's such a wild card, 'cause she's kinda like, I have nothing to lose, so she's saying crazy shit in interviews. And she was, you know, her, her vibe is not like, I'm a well-established star, I know exactly what I'm doing. She's kinda like, I'm blowing this pot stand before we, I get outta here.
18:00 Bill Simmons? Well, they offered it to Michelle Pfeiffer, who said no, and thank God, 'cause I think that might've actually killed me. If she was in this movie, I'd be dead. I don't know who's hosting this, it wouldn't be me, it would be somebody else. See, are Sharon Stone not nominated for an Oscar for this movie?
18:18 Chris Ryan? Uh, yeah, I'm sorry, bro.
18:22 Bill Simmons? I'll give you the nominees.
18:23 Chris Ryan? Please do.
18:23 Speaker 03 Okay.
18:24 Bill Simmons? Emma Thompson wins for Howard's End, Catherine Deneuve for Endogene? Is that how you say it?
18:30 Chris Ryan? Imogene, sure.
18:32 Bill Simmons? Mary McDonnell for Passion Fish, Michelle Pfeiffer for Love Field, and Susan Sarandon for Lorenzo's Oil.
18:41 Speaker 03 Interesting.
18:41 Bill Simmons? I think we could've stuck Sharon in there, guys. I don't know. Like, who else could've done the, this movie made three hundred and fifty-six million dollars.
18:49 Chris Ryan? This is a useful place to ask this, do you take this movie seriously?
18:59 Bill Simmons? I don't.
19:00 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
19:02 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
19:03 Bill Simmons? I think it's a great time. My wife hates it because I love Thorne. It's, you said, you've said this a million times. It's a vibes movie.
19:10 Chris Ryan? It is a vibes movie, for sure.
19:11 Bill Simmons? Yeah, I like being in San Francisco. I like watching them smoke. I like the nightclub scene.
19:17 Speaker 03 Yeah.
19:18 Bill Simmons? I like, Michael Douglas, who we're gonna get to in a second, it's in the running for funniest performance of the 90s.
19:24 Speaker 03 It's amazing. It's historic.
19:25 Bill Simmons? He doesn't know it's funny, but everyone else knows it's hilarious. And it's just a fun movie to hang out with.
19:32 Chris Ryan? This run of Paul Verhoeven movies works because even Paul Verhoeven is like, we need to make this funny movie incredibly seriously.
19:41 Bill Simmons? Right.
19:41 Chris Ryan? Starship Troopers is kind of the same thing. I think they all know they're in this insane movie about bugs.
19:46 Bill Simmons? I don't think Douglas does.
19:48 Chris Ryan? What's that?
19:48 Bill Simmons? I don't think Michael Douglas knows that this is funny.
19:50 Chris Ryan? I think Michael Douglas knows. I think he's like, for this to work, I have to 100% commit. But if you read that script, you're like, this is bullshit and it's hilarious.
20:00 Bill Simmons? He's 47 when he makes the movie.
20:03 Speaker 04 Wow, I still got time.
20:04 Chris Ryan? Wow.
20:07 Speaker 03 Yeah. Boy.
20:12 Bill Simmons? Probably should have been a younger actor would be my take.
20:16 Speaker 04 Come on, man.
20:17 Speaker 03 No.
20:17 Speaker 04 What are you talking about?
20:18 Bill Simmons? You say no on that?
20:19 Speaker 03 Well, first of all, I support an age difference, as you know, you know, among consenting adults. But I, I think there's something about Nick being in like a midlife crisis that's actually pretty important. He's had a marriage. His wife killed herself. He has committed four shootings in five years.
20:38 Speaker 04 He was undercover.
20:39 Speaker 03 He has to have the runway to have lived that much life, you know?
20:42 Speaker 04 You can't have like a 25-year-old whippersnapper on the force. You need somebody with some redneck ledger in there.
20:47 Bill Simmons? Yeah, yeah.
20:48 Chris Ryan? Here's the thing. He is one of the biggest movie stars who throughout his career routinely takes a chance with the way the audience sees him. And is like, I don't mind playing the hero who's a piece of shit.
20:59 Speaker 03 Yeah.
21:00 Chris Ryan? And he, no, he's like, not, he's the main star of Wall Street. You know, he is, does these things where he's like, I'll push my My boat out and make sure we people have a really provocative experience.
21:10 Speaker 03 When you say like how the audience sees him, do you mean specifically him walking toward a bathroom?
21:14 Chris Ryan? Twinging his ass cheeks together.
21:16 Speaker 03 With his strom, um, swinging under his ass.
21:18 Chris Ryan? So that his balls don't swing, yes.
21:19 Speaker 04 And like, consider the time, right? So you're in a Mel Gibson, Kevin Costner, which we're gonna talk a lot, little bit about that later, time where all of those guys are kinda competing to be the all-American movie star. And really, his lane is being the freak. He's a fucking freak.
21:38 Chris Ryan? A yuppie freak.
21:39 Speaker 04 Disclosure, he's a freak in this, he's a fucking freak in Fatal Attraction. This motherfucker's a freak. And no, and no one else really wants to do it. He'll do it, he's great at it, and he kinda makes his career, at least the second half of it on that.
21:52 Bill Simmons? We've, he's been in a lot of rewatched those movies. He's not anyone's favorite actor, but he's been in a ton of everybody's favorite movies.
22:00 Chris Ryan? It would be weird to be a Michael Douglas superfan.
22:02 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
22:03 Speaker 04 This is my guy. Me and Mike.
22:06 Bill Simmons? But I mean.
22:06 Chris Ryan? My site, MikeyDougFan.com.
22:10 Bill Simmons? From eighty-four on, he rips off From Mates in the Stone, Jewel of the Nile, Chorus Line, Fatal Attraction, Wall Street, wins the Oscar. Black Rain, War of the Roses, Basic Instinct, Falling Down, Disclosure, American President, Ghost in Darkness, The Game, Perfect Murder, Wonder Boys, Traffic.
22:26 Chris Ryan? You're fucking crazy.
22:28 Speaker 04 That is, um, that's amazing work.
22:31 Bill Simmons? And very good work.
22:32 Chris Ryan? American President is the weird movie in that group.
22:35 Speaker 03 Yeah.
22:36 Bill Simmons? Right.
22:36 Chris Ryan? I keep waiting for the American President to be like jerking off under the Resolute Desk, but he's like, no, I'm just a really good guy.
22:42 Bill Simmons? It's in the, it's on the extended Blu-ray.
22:45 Speaker 03 Yeah, director's cut.
22:46 Bill Simmons? Craig, you're, you're younger than us. What's your relationship with Michael Douglas? Just, what, just wandering into this after the fact? I don't even think I have one. I, I don't know what to go to Michael Douglas role.
22:56 Chris Ryan? I asked my wife, Liz, I'm like, what's your opinion on Michael Douglas? Like, did you ever think he was hot? And she's like, honestly, no, he's just kind of a creep.
23:04 Chris Ryan? Was Michael Douglas ever like a top three love interest in Hollywood?
23:08 Speaker 04 Man, let me tell you something.
23:09 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
23:10 Speaker 04 My mom, I was about to say, my mom used to look at Bayla Traction and be like, "Mm, mm, mm." I see what she was going on about. Look at that.
23:19 Chris Ryan? Could you say he's Harrison Ford, Dark Side Harrison Ford? No way.
23:22 Speaker 03 No, because Harrison Ford is god tier. You can't say anyone is any version of Harrison Ford.
23:26 Chris Ryan? I asked the wrong person.
23:27 Speaker 03 Get the fuck out of here.
23:28 Chris Ryan? What are you thinking?
23:29 Speaker 03 What's wrong with you? But Harrison Ford, Costner, Douglas, Gere, those were the men who my mom was like obsessed with and loved. And, uh, Michael Douglas was the one who didn't quite catch for me in terms of being like sexually obsessed with him. Though I will tell you guys that when I booted up this movie to prepare, to re-watch it, to prepare for this live show, you know, there's a pretty famous moment in this movie that I think a lot of people pause on, right? You might, well, it'll come up tonight, I think. I had paused at a different moment. I booted up the director's cut and it was at 1 hour, 11 minutes and 43 seconds, which is the side cock shot during the fuck of the century scene.
24:12 Speaker 03 So I guess that was where I had just checked in, booted it up at some point, taken a look, paused it, left. And there it was, waiting for me.
24:19 Chris Ryan? Do you think that was in between the two re-watchables?
24:22 Speaker 03 That seems right. Probably. Yeah. I mean, it was six years ago, the last re-watchables. I've definitely looked at that since. No question.
24:38 Bill Simmons? I thought we were gonna do side cocks later.
24:41 Speaker 03 Well, we can, we can go back to them. Don't worry.
24:45 Bill Simmons? One thing about Douglas, because he was also a producer.
24:48 Speaker 03 Yeah.
24:48 Bill Simmons? Really good timing on when to jump in on a movie that's kind of paralle- paralleling whatever's happening in real life. Like, even you go back to China Syndrome, which he's in, which was like right whenever. Everyone's afraid of nuclear war in the late 70s. Wall Street is the greed is good. Basic Instinct, big fear of AIDS, early 90s. And he, one of the, in the research, one of the things he really wanted to do with this movie was push the envelope sexually the other way in movies. And then Disclosure was another one with Workplace.
25:18 Chris Ryan? Sure.
25:18 Bill Simmons? Brass movie. He just, over and over again, had really good taste.
25:22 Chris Ryan? Sure. That's one way of putting it, yeah.
25:23 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
25:24 Speaker 03 A framing, yeah.
25:27 Bill Simmons? Mallory saw, what was the documentary you saw with the storyboarding?
25:31 Speaker 03 Oh, yeah. There's a bonus featurette called, I believe, Blonde Poison? Yeah. Blonde Poison, The Making of Basic Instinct, which is about 30-ish minutes. A good chunk of it at the end is about actually the protests of the film.
25:48 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
25:49 Speaker 03 By LGBT groups. And I would say the first, like, 15 to 18 minutes before that are largely Paul Verhoeven.
25:57 Bill Simmons? The director.
25:58 Speaker 03 The director, talking about how he just insisted very clearly that everybody understood that they had to be naked in the movie and that they had to follow the exact game plan for the sex scenes because he had diagrammed them very precisely. And then intercut with his commentary.
26:14 Bill Simmons? I'm gonna hold up one for you guys.
26:17 Speaker 03 Yeah.
26:19 Bill Simmons? Paul Verhoeven's work, right there.
26:21 Speaker 03 Pretty special. Pretty special.
26:23 Bill Simmons? So he storyboarded the entire thing.
26:26 Speaker 03 Yeah.
26:26 Bill Simmons? They spent five days filming Fuck of the Century.
26:29 Speaker 03 Five, yeah.
26:29 Bill Simmons? Because he was so concerned that they were gonna make him cut stuff and make it an X rating, or whatever. He wanted to be covered in every way, shape, or form.
26:37 Speaker 03 Yeah.
26:38 Bill Simmons? And they filmed for five days, 10 hours a day. A 90-second sex scene?
26:44 Speaker 03 Ah, if you're watching the director's cut, it's a little longer.
26:47 Chris Ryan? Yeah. And also, Michael Douglas and Sharon Stone, apparently, were not, like, super close during the making of this, which makes it all the more interesting.
26:54 Speaker 03 Close in what way?
26:55 Chris Ryan? Well, I mean, I think that there wasn't a lot of coffee corner, like, just chit chat about, like, real.
27:00 Speaker 04 He didn't want it to be in the movie.
27:01 Chris Ryan? Was that?
27:02 Speaker 04 Yeah. Like, they had gone through a bunch of people and he was concerned because he's making this movie where he's gotta play a killer, coke-addicted cop. And he wanted an A-list actress to share that burden with him and get it over the finish line. And all of them looked at the script and was like, "You fucking crazy? I'm not doing this." And so then, like, they got Sharon Stone, but he was a little bit trepidatious about it.
27:26 Bill Simmons? Man, I hesitate to ask you this.
27:31 Bill Simmons? If you were filming with Sharon Stone for five straight days for 10 hours a day, just with small genital pads on, how would that go by like Wednesday?
27:42 Speaker 04 Well, see, I always wondered this, cuz like...
27:45 Speaker 03 First of all, you have to respond and say the genital pad wouldn't be small. He set you up there. You have to come in and say that. But they were also not wearing genital pads. They are famously completely naked filming this.
27:56 Speaker 04 Oh, so they're naked filming?
27:57 Bill Simmons? I thought they did have...
27:58 Speaker 03 No.
27:59 Chris Ryan? Also, to Mal's point...
28:01 Speaker 03 Watch this featurette. Here's a quote. From the director of this movie. "I wanted to really see oral sex. I wanted to see how he sucks her tits. I wanted to see all that."
28:17 Bill Simmons? Thank you, everybody. Goodnight.
28:22 Bill Simmons? I don't know how they do it. I guess that's why they act for a living. They really...
28:25 Chris Ryan? None of us have seen this behind the scenes, and I'm not entirely sure she's not like making this up. Because I looked for it online, and I was like, huh, block poison. I can't find this.
28:36 Speaker 03 I'll send it to you.
28:37 Chris Ryan? Yeah, please do.
28:38 Speaker 03 Just like I said, I sent you those storyboard pictures, yeah.
28:40 Chris Ryan? The weird thing is also, there's like stories that the actors sold that Verhoeven was like... He would be like, okay, here's what we're gonna do. Here's the blocking. And then they would show up day of, and he would be like, "Psyche her all my new storyboards." And he would be like, calling hot routes on Gene Triplehorn.
28:57 Chris Ryan? I don't know. I technically have heard, but yeah.
29:01 Bill Simmons? Verhoeven, Robocop, Total Recall, Basic and Sticks, Starship Troopers. Just four of the many. Just a pervy Dutch guy. I think would be the best way to describe him.
29:13 Bill Simmons? Love pushing the envelope. Love to put stuff in there, kinda making fun of Americans, and we didn't realize it as we loved the movies. Didn't realize he was flipping it on us. What's his, what's his apex mountain for movies, CR?
29:26 Chris Ryan? I think in retrospect, it's Starship Troopers.
29:28 Speaker 03 Yeah, I, I think so.
29:29 Chris Ryan? In some ways.
29:29 Speaker 04 Really?
29:30 Chris Ryan? I think that has like a better reputation than Basic Instinct.
29:33 Bill Simmons? Interesting. What do you think, Ben?
29:34 Speaker 04 I think it's easily Basic Instinct. I think it's not even close. I think Starship Troopers has, he has this ability to elevate, I guess, what people would consider to be like trash or really accessible kind of stories. But Basic Instinct was a cultural phenomenon. It was a movie that like legitimately, my mom and them went to see it and they came back and it was like, girl, was he just stabbing with that ice pick? What's going on? Like, it was a movie that you absolutely had to talk about. And really, as much as Fatal Attraction got this genre started in a, in a mainstream way.
30:08 Bill Simmons? Definitely did, yeah.
30:09 Speaker 04 This kind of solidified the genre as a moneymaker and as something that could like be star making for Sharon Stone. Like, you would approach these movies differently after Basic Instinct, because you know that doing one and taking the risk and taking the chances in like putting yourself out there on film like that could end up in making you a star, which is what this movie did for Sharon Stone. So she did all of this stuff and then it paid off. So I think this is probably his magnum opus, in my opinion.
30:38 Bill Simmons? I also think it's fair to say that there weren't really characters like this until this movie. Like, these kind of powerful female in control of the relationship, like this-
30:50 Speaker 04 Look at Susan B. Anthony over here.
30:53 Bill Simmons? This became something that a lot of movies tried to do, but I don't know who tried to do it before this movie. I can't really think of one. Can you, CR?
31:02 Chris Ryan? A femme fatale like this? No, not, I mean, like, not this explicitly and this violently.
31:07 Bill Simmons? Cause like Body Heat did it, right?
31:08 Chris Ryan? Sure.
31:08 Bill Simmons? That was 10 years earlier. And there's some other ones over the years, but I, I think this jumpstarted then. What was interesting about this movie is all the ripoff terrible movies that tried to-
31:18 Chris Ryan? Yes, some of which Sharon Stone participated in, yeah.
31:21 Bill Simmons? Yeah, Sliver. I've seen them all. I know Van has them all on Blu-ray. This movie had people protesting various parts of it, like they couldn't even decide what to protest. Sharon Stone hosted SNL in April 92 and six people disrupted that and actually disrupted the monologue and they had to like, uh, change it. But people are pretty pissed off for a variety of reasons about this movie. Joe Esterhaus was the writer.
31:52 Bill Simmons? $3 million got for the script. There's a bidding war from Carol Coe Productions. So if anyone has ever listened to the Rewatchables, probably our favorite production company.
32:00 Chris Ryan? More or less, yeah.
32:01 Bill Simmons? Done a lot of Stallone, Segal, Arnold Schwarzenegger classics, basic instinct.
32:04 Chris Ryan? Funding from...
32:05 Bill Simmons? Craig's nodding happily over there.
32:06 Speaker 05 Lot of cocaine, yeah.
32:08 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
32:09 Chris Ryan? Esterhaus is basically in a competition with Shane Black, who we just talked about on Nice Guys. He, these two are like basically trading back and forth the like all-time richest screenplay deal for like five years.
32:21 Bill Simmons? Right. And then Esterhaus gets mad because Verhoeven's putting all this extra stuff in the movie, ends up walking off the set. $49 million budget made $353 million, the fourth highest grossing movie of 1992.
32:35 Speaker 05 That would be 800 million today.
32:38 Chris Ryan? This would be Project Hail Mary today.
32:41 Speaker 03 Amaze, amaze, amaze.
32:43 Speaker 04 For an aggressive, R-rated erotic thing.
32:46 Bill Simmons? Well, so this is an interesting topic. Could this happen anymore? Do people want to be in a movie theater watching people fuck like this for $350 million?
32:55 Speaker 04 Like because of Craig's generation.
32:58 Chris Ryan? No, no.
32:58 Bill Simmons? Yeah, it's Craig's generation.
33:00 Speaker 04 We were doing, I can't remember what movie we were doing.
33:02 Speaker 03 Bunch of prudes.
33:03 Speaker 04 And this was the time, you know, after Craig said that he would shoot somebody in the heart and that changed my opinion of him forever. But we were watching a movie and Craig said, "There were just titties in the movie for no reason."
33:17 Speaker 04 And I was thinking to myself, "How much fucking distance is it between me and Craig?
33:23 Speaker 04 Whenever titties show up, I am happy to meet them."
33:28 Speaker 03 I agree.
33:29 Speaker 04 And Craig was uncomfortable with it. Thank you.
33:33 Speaker 05 Well, and now 200 movies later, I'm like bummed when there's no nudity in a movie.
33:39 Bill Simmons? Yeah, we've dreamed of that.
33:40 Speaker 05 Come on.
33:42 Bill Simmons? Film score got an Oscar nomination, Jerry Goldsmith. Jan DeBott worked in the cameras.
33:48 Speaker 04 Jan DeBott?
33:49 Bill Simmons? Yeah, yeah. Little Jan, couple of years for Speed.
33:53 Bill Simmons? Craig. 112 minutes, plus 22 on the Horrill Beck's. Craig thinks every movie should be 90 minutes.
33:58 Speaker 05 22 over par.
34:00 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
34:00 Speaker 05 But you can kind of skip right to the sex scenes now. It doesn't really matter how long it is, you know? Everything's, everything's clipified now, you know?
34:08 Bill Simmons? Yeah, that second half of the movie probably could be tightened, I would say.
34:12 Chris Ryan? Also, the last 25 minutes of this movie, you're like, what the fuck is happening?
34:17 Speaker 04 It turns into a whodunit. By the way, the movie would have been longer if Shooter could last. Shooter has a premature ejaculation problem.
34:25 Chris Ryan? Oh, yeah.
34:26 Speaker 04 Shooter's in it, ah!
34:28 Bill Simmons? Uh, here comes Nine Minute Van weighing in.
34:30 Speaker 03 Nine Minute Van!
34:32 Speaker 04 At minimum.
34:35 Bill Simmons? Do we know?
34:35 Speaker 04 At minimum, ladies.
34:36 Bill Simmons? Do we know he had a premature, or was it just edited that way? Thank God we have Mallory here to answer the question.
34:41 Speaker 04 If I would have been him, I'd have been like, ay, yo, on God, like, for real, for real, for real? Like, give me at least two extra minutes so people know how I move out here in this motherfucker. You know what I'm saying? I can't have people thinking that the credits gonna roll, I'm gonna be popping before it's, you know what I'm saying?
34:55 Speaker 03 The Beth scene, unfortunate in many respects, including this one, very quick. But the Catherine scenes, I don't know. I think, like, we see her orgasm so many different times, including from the single most memorable part of the movie, which is him going down on her, maintaining eye contact the entire time and going cross-eyed, like he's trying to, like, identify a unicorn in a magic eye painting.
35:19 Chris Ryan? I'm just like...
35:22 Chris Ryan? When I see, when we do these, I never, ever, ever want to have sex again. Like, every time we do, like, a Muppet version of someone going down on something, it just kills me.
35:37 Speaker 03 But then he's on top, the back scratch, then she's on top, right? So we're, we're going through some pretty protracted sequences there.
35:45 Speaker 04 Like, he went down on her, like, girl, you think I wasn't gonna do this, did you?
35:48 Speaker 03 I know, he was really impressed with himself.
35:50 Speaker 04 Yeah, he was.
35:52 Speaker 03 Yeah, and then he watched his own blowjob in the, the mirror. Where are you guys on bedroom ceiling mirrors?
35:58 Chris Ryan? What, what part of the podcast is this?
36:01 Speaker 03 What do you think?
36:03 Speaker 04 I always, like, see myself and like, yo, nigga, you need to work out.
36:11 Speaker 04 Like, we had gone to the islands, and my titties lay to the side.
36:24 Bill Simmons? It was one of, during the MTV Cribs era, it was one of those when somebody had the bedroom mirror, you really knew some freak shit was going down. It was always a red flag.
36:34 Speaker 03 Or they wanted you to think that.
36:36 Bill Simmons? Yeah, it was one or the other. It was definitely a statement. Uh, speaking of statements, Roger Ebert.
36:44 Speaker 03 Yeah.
36:45 Bill Simmons? Two stars.
36:47 Speaker 03 What a mess.
36:48 Speaker 04 You can't boo, y'all can't boo Raj, man.
36:51 Speaker 03 Yes, they can.
36:52 Bill Simmons? He said, "The film is like a crossword puzzle. It keeps your interest until you solve it."
36:58 Bill Simmons? "And then it's just a worthless scrap with the spaces filled in."
37:02 Speaker 04 God damn.
37:03 Bill Simmons? I don't want to give him a fuck you Raj, but I'm gonna give him like a borderline fuck you Rush. Just a whiff. I don't like that. Two and a half, give it a two and a half, come on.
37:14 Chris Ryan? I'm surprised he didn't give it a two and a half. Like, two is like, this is a very well-made movie, even if you think it's absolute garbage.
37:20 Speaker 05 I think he was just really upset by the ending mainly. I think he kinda liked it, but he was upset about the ice pick at the end.
37:25 Bill Simmons? He just knocked the star off at the end.
37:26 Speaker 04 The reason why the review surprises me is because the movie takes itself very seriously. And it's well-made, well-acted, and well-crafted. There's some really insanely well-crafted scenes here. It's not throwing anything away. So you would think that he would respect the craftsmanship a little bit more than like what he did.
37:43 Speaker 03 It's a pretty like critically derided film.
37:46 Speaker 04 It is.
37:47 Speaker 03 I mean, a lot of the reviews are bad. It's adored by the public, right? But it's not like everybody, it's not like Raj was on an island with that.
37:55 Chris Ryan? No, it's tough. Like, there's like Sharon Stone talks about like thinking like, "I've made, like, I've done it. I made double indemnity. People are gonna love this."
38:02 Speaker 03 Well, wait till she hears this podcast. Then she's gonna know that's true.
38:07 Bill Simmons? This episode is brought to you by ZipRecruiter. If I had to pick the greatest movie of my lifetime, I was born 1969. Man, I'm old. I think the greatest movie is The Godfather. For all the great actors that were in it, that they caught at various stages of their career, Brando, Al Pacino, James Caan, Robert Duvall, Coppola, who had, you know, was not really on the map yet. You have this famous, famous book, and they somehow pull all of it off. And the big thing is that movie just infiltrates pop culture from the day it comes out in 1972, all the way through to now, in all these different ways. And that
38:49 Bill Simmons? is why I think it's the greatest movie of my lifetime. Finding someone or something that's perfect for you, like The Godfather, isn't always easy. If you're hiring, I'm sure you know exactly what I'm talking about. You have to go through hundreds of resumes just to find one person, which is exhausting unless you use ZipRecruiter, because you can try it for free at ziprecruiter.com/rewatchables. Using its smart matching technology, ZipRecruiter does most of the work finding qualified candidates for your role. And it now has a new feature, that's right, new feature, that pushes candidates who are interested in your job to the top of your list. So you're talking with people who have the skills and passion that you're looking for. First, cut through the standard and get to the
39:34 Bill Simmons? standouts with ZipRecruiter. Four out of five employers who post on ZipRecruiter get a quality candidate within the first day. And now you can try it for free at ziprecruiter.com/rewatchables. That is ziprecruiter.com/rewatchables. Meet your match on ZipRecruiter. Well, so for the rewatchables, if you haven't heard any of the pods we've done, we do categories to break down the movie. First category is most rewatchable scene.
40:12 Bill Simmons? We'll give you some runner-up nominees.
40:18 Bill Simmons? Incredible opening murder scene, right into the police showing up.
40:24 Bill Simmons? And dialogue that goes, "There's cum stains all over the sheets."
40:30 Bill Simmons? So, let's talk about it now.
40:32 Speaker 03 I would love to.
40:33 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
40:35 Bill Simmons? Johnny Bos, just that night, no maid.
40:37 Speaker 03 No, there is a maid. This is part of what? I have to sit on unanswerable questions.
40:41 Chris Ryan? She's a rather rotund maid. They even pointed out.
40:42 Speaker 03 Yeah, she's 54 and 240, and so they say she couldn't be the murderer, which is pretty fucked up, honestly. Not the only fucked up thing in the movie, but...
40:50 Bill Simmons? Because they blew like this, and it's, it looks like a sundae.
40:53 Speaker 03 It loo-, it looks like... Is everyone tracking Artemis right now, the NASA photos? Bos's sheets under the black light look like the face of the moon that NASA is currently showing us. Splattered craters everywhere.
41:09 Chris Ryan? So, he either is Mount Vesuvius.
41:12 Speaker 03 Right.
41:12 Chris Ryan? One night only, or...
41:15 Speaker 03 He's never washing his sheets.
41:16 Chris Ryan? His bedroom is a no-go zone for the maid. And those sheets have not been changed in weeks.
41:22 Speaker 03 Yes. I think it's that.
41:23 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
41:24 Bill Simmons? Dan, do you have a theory? I bet you do. On the sheets with the no maid, or just...
41:30 Chris Ryan? Is it one night?
41:31 Speaker 04 There's a gentleman by the name of Peter North, who, throughout the course of his career, was able to set records. And if you guys don't know who he is, you'll be amazed. And so, when I think of this movie, I think about talent, not necessarily about, like, function. So, it wasn't the fact that he was doing it a lot. It was like, when he was doing it, I'm talking about fucking fire hose.
41:53 Bill Simmons? So, my question is, if you're getting stabbed to death with an ice pick as you're coming...
41:58 Speaker 03 Yeah.
41:59 Bill Simmons? Is that like a triple cum shot? Sorry to be crude, but that's... If the maid's not coming, that has to be the only other explanation.
42:08 Speaker 03 I just don't think the human body contains that much ejaculate at one period of time, whether or not you're-
42:14 Speaker 05 Wait, though-
42:15 Speaker 03 Have Sharon Stone thrusting on top of you-
42:17 Speaker 05 Why are you gonna tell us about our-
42:18 Speaker 03 And you're about to be stabbed 31 times with an ice pick.
42:19 Speaker 05 Not to get too graphic here, but like, isn't-
42:22 Speaker 03 I think it's fine, go ahead.
42:23 Speaker 05 Isn't Johnny Bos inside Catherine Tramell?
42:26 Speaker 03 Yes, yes.
42:27 Speaker 05 Why is there semen everywhere?
42:28 Chris Ryan? I think the idea also is they have done it multiple times that night. That this is like, it's Johnny Bos's fuck of the century, you know?
42:38 Speaker 03 That's right. Cocaine on the penis, so...
42:41 Bill Simmons? Anyone second guessing their decision to come tonight, or?
42:44 Speaker 03 I'm having a great time.
42:46 Bill Simmons? I think you guys knew what you were coming for. The woman in the opening scene, by the way, was Sharon Stone.
42:52 Speaker 05 It didn't seem like it, though.
42:53 Bill Simmons? Because they have her hair covered, but it is her and Verhoeven.
42:56 Speaker 05 Almost seems like she's in a wig. They put her in a blonde wig, I think, to make you think it could be- Somebody else, yeah. Yeah.
43:01 Speaker 03 There's some pretty clear indicators, but-
43:04 Bill Simmons? CR, would you wanna go this way? If like, you could pick 10 different ways to die with the Johnny Bos being the top 3?
43:10 Chris Ryan? I would be, I would be so thrilled to find out what the other ones would be that would top this.
43:15 Bill Simmons? Yeah, okay.
43:16 Speaker 03 This is like the Tyrion Lannister. You know, how he's always saying he wants to go with a belly full of wine and some lips around his cock? Like, it's the Johnny Bos.
43:26 Bill Simmons? Another quote from this scene, "He got off before he got off."
43:30 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
43:31 Bill Simmons? That's where you know you're in the right hands. Next scene, the first visit to Sharon Stone's house.
43:36 Speaker 03 Incredible.
43:37 Bill Simmons? Catherine Tramell. We get a great, great Bay Area drive. Amazing house.
43:42 Speaker 03 Gorgeous.
43:43 Speaker 05 Fantastic.
43:44 Bill Simmons? I'm gonna give this the Den of Thieves Benihana Award scene stealing location, CR, unless you wanna jump me.
43:49 Chris Ryan? This is the nightclub.
43:51 Bill Simmons? Really nice, good deck.
43:53 Speaker 03 Great deck.
43:55 Bill Simmons? And-
43:56 Chris Ryan? Great deck.
43:57 Speaker 03 Great deck.
43:57 Speaker 05 Great deck.
43:58 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
43:59 Speaker 05 Insane deck.
44:00 Chris Ryan? Great landscaping.
44:01 Speaker 03 Yeah.
44:01 Bill Simmons? Girthy dick.
44:02 Speaker 03 It is impressive landscaping.
44:05 Bill Simmons? Catherine Tramell comes in throwing 120 miles an hour right away. "I wasn't dating him, I was fucking him."
44:11 Speaker 03 Man.
44:11 Bill Simmons? "What are you, a pro?" "I'm an amateur." "I wasn't in the mood last night, are you sorry he's dead?" "Yeah, I liked fucking him."
44:18 Speaker 03 Incredible.
44:19 Bill Simmons? She's just throwing him off left and right.
44:22 Speaker 05 Bill's talking this way.
44:23 Bill Simmons? Doesn't seem that upset.
44:25 Speaker 03 Well, she's, that's part of the appeal of Catherine as a character is she is so utterly in command and assured. And there's something disarming and terrifying about it, but also something so appealing. So like the whole movie, the thriller, the erotic thriller aspect is a cat and mouse chase where like the mouse wants to be caught so that he can fuck Catherine, right? And you have to understand that like immediately, which you do.
44:51 Bill Simmons? Then we have another rewatchable scene, the second house visit to the car ride, which includes her changing. That's how we know she's not wearing underwear. They're in the car. I don't smoke. Yes, you do. I quit. Congratulations. All of a sudden she has cigarettes. What's your new book about? A detective. He falls for the wrong woman. What happens? He kills her. Douglas is like, I'm fucking in. This is, I am all the way in. Good shot of, what part of San Francisco are we in there?
45:25 Chris Ryan? Well, they were driving up to Stinson, but the house in real life was in Carmel, but they're driving up to Stinson Beach, which shouts out Scott and Natalia got married in Stinson Beach. They're here somewhere. There they are.
45:36 Bill Simmons? Next scene is the police room scene.
45:38 Speaker 03 Yeah.
45:40 Bill Simmons? One of, I think the most famous scenes of the 90s. And we also have Newman from Seinfeld, the Nettie Harris from Major League in there.
45:48 Speaker 03 Sure do.
45:48 Chris Ryan? The factoid, which I don't know if it's true that Spielberg hired him off of this is unreal. That was Steven Spielberg's takeaway from this scene. Jurassic Park, I got that guy.
46:02 Bill Simmons? Right. What are you gonna do? A recipe for smoking? Good line. Johnny liked to use his hands too much. I like hands and fingers. Another quote. Have you ever fucked on cocaine, Nick?
46:19 Speaker 03 It's nice. Iconic.
46:22 Chris Ryan? It's not how she says it. It'd be funny if she did. She's like, it's nice. She just turns into Borat for a second.
46:33 Bill Simmons? Borat, basically.
46:35 Speaker 03 My wife. It's nice.
46:38 Chris Ryan? He's dead.
46:39 Bill Simmons? And then we get the
46:43 Bill Simmons? Leg cross, which became.
46:46 Chris Ryan? Iconic. Highly controversial.
46:47 Bill Simmons? The most famous moment of the 90s in a movie? I'm trying to think what's bigger.
46:53 Chris Ryan? Uh, Miggs? From Silence of the Lambs? Alright, is that like 80s?
46:57 Bill Simmons? Biggest holy shit moment?
46:58 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
46:59 Speaker 04 It's tell, I was like, I remember my dad, rest in peace dad. Dad was like.
47:06 Speaker 04 That, uh, boy? Go back a couple of seconds, nah?
47:12 Speaker 04 I, I honestly think, and when I watched it, I caught it, I've never looked. This is one of the, this is one of the most well-written scenes of the 90s.
47:21 Bill Simmons? Hmm.
47:21 Speaker 04 Um, so when you think about the movie, right? The movie is about basic, the movie, you guys think I'm about to be freaky? I'm about to be like, okay, can I, let me cook for a second? The movie, Basic Instinct, it's about primal urges, right? Things that you cannot control.
47:36 Bill Simmons? Yep.
47:37 Speaker 04 But the movie only works if you understand how dangerous Catherine is.
47:43 Speaker 03 Yes.
47:44 Speaker 04 And how much he can't resist her. So that scene is in conflict because that scene has to establish how dangerous she is. But it also can't betray the fact that we see how dangerous she is. All of these police officers see how dangerous she is. And he still has to be primarily drawn to her. So she has to go there and be smarter than everybody in the room.
48:10 Bill Simmons? By the way, so does the audience.
48:11 Speaker 04 Exactly, right?
48:12 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
48:13 Speaker 04 Exactly, for us as well. She has to go there and be smarter than everybody in the room. But if she is smarter than everybody in the room, it breaks the deal with the audience because then you go, well, we know that she's the murderer. We know that she's gaming them. Why would he still want her? Then she lets that thang out.
48:31 Speaker 03 Yeah.
48:33 Speaker 04 And let me tell you something right now, to all the ladies in the audience. If you want to end the arri- the, the argument or the speculation, let that thang out.
48:44 Speaker 04 If you let that thing out, you win. All right? Stop playing the game. I wanna play MLB. Let that thing out. He off the game. Okay? And so, when that happens, that reinjects this primal urge into the scene, and it completely wipes his mind, and our mind, and everybody else. He gotta go get that thing.
49:06 Speaker 03 Yeah.
49:07 Bill Simmons? And Newman violated some HR laws, I think. Newman's like...
49:12 Speaker 03 Well... I was gonna hit this in Unanswerable Questions, but he's not in the movie after that? It's like, did seeing Catherine's vagina kill him? Yeah, he had a fucking heart attack. Did the SEC DA drop fucking dead in the bathroom stall, cranking one out 10 minutes after that? Everyone else is looking at the lie detector and is like, "You can beat the machine." "No, you can't beat the machine." And Newman is dropping dead after having seen Catherine flash in. So he's not in the director's cut?
49:43 Bill Simmons? No.
49:43 Speaker 03 It's just, he makes an early impression, and that's it. I think Van's point is really important, cuz like, there are five dudes in that interrogation for no reason other than that every... She, like, they're all rapt, right? And so, the fact that the trick of that, in addition to the very obvious one, is that she is like in command and there in her power, even though she is so clearly should be the one who's like, "What is happening here?" Even the way that scene is lit, the way it's staged, like, that doesn't look like an interrogation room at all, right? It looks like she's like on display at a gallery.
50:16 Bill Simmons? So, there was controversy about that scene.
50:18 Speaker 03 Yes.
50:19 Bill Simmons? That we should mention. She said it was filmed without her knowledge, and it turned into a he said, she said. I forget what year this started.
50:26 Chris Ryan? In her memoir, Sharon Stone says that they asked her to take her underwear off because it was affecting the lighting.
50:33 Speaker 05 Which, I mean...
50:34 Chris Ryan? Yeah. And then, she saw a cut, and her and her lawyer, Marty Singer, were gonna basically stop the movie from coming out. They were gonna... And then she just... But then she was like, "You know what? Like, I signed up for it. That is me." And she decided to do it, but not without reservations.
50:52 Bill Simmons? And then it wasn't in the script either. And Berhoven, pervy Dutch guy, remembered something similar happening when he was in college and decided to weave it in. Anyway.
51:04 Chris Ryan? Cool college story.
51:05 Bill Simmons? Yes. Record scratch.
51:09 Bill Simmons? Quick, quick one.
51:11 Chris Ryan? I was in college and she took that thing out.
51:14 Speaker 03 And I stopped playing MLB the show.
51:16 Chris Ryan? I stopped playing FIFA and that is the end of the argument.
51:19 Speaker 04 Thing out. Child, ladies.
51:21 Bill Simmons? Van's down with the Dutch. The car chase is really good, just wanted to mention that.
51:26 Speaker 04 Really good.
51:26 Bill Simmons? She kinda does some in the car chase.
51:28 Speaker 04 Yeah.
51:29 Bill Simmons? Come on, shoot her.
51:31 Speaker 04 She was in a Porsche or something like that.
51:33 Speaker 03 A Lotus.
51:34 Speaker 04 A Lotus.
51:35 Bill Simmons? Nick stops by Catherine's place and she uses the ice pick and does the, uh, how much coke should you do, Nick? You're gonna make a terrific character. She's making out with Roxy in front of him. That scene's good.
51:44 Speaker 03 Yeah.
51:45 Bill Simmons? The Catherine.
51:46 Speaker 03 And all the papers are there, right? So he starts to realize in that sequence, like, how much she knows about him, how she's studying him.
51:52 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
51:52 Speaker 03 Yeah.
51:53 Bill Simmons? And then she stops by Nick's place, she does the ice pick thing for him.
51:57 Speaker 03 Shoot her.
51:57 Bill Simmons? He's, now he's smoking cigs. You know the wheels are coming off. He's drinking, he's ordering doubles at the bar, he's smoking. And now we're going to my favorite scene. Nick goes to the nightclub.
52:11 Bill Simmons? We get the song we played earlier, Blue by, what was that band? Latour?
52:15 Speaker 04 Latour.
52:16 Bill Simmons? Latour?
52:16 Speaker 04 Yeah. Latour.
52:17 Bill Simmons? Uh, Nick's the oldest guy in the club by, I'm gonna say, 16 years.
52:23 Bill Simmons? He's wearing a v-neck shirt that his aunt gave him for Christmas in 1985.
52:28 Speaker 03 It's crazy.
52:29 Bill Simmons? He's like, "I'll wear this, I haven't worn this yet." And, uh, goes into the bathroom, which is, has, has anyone ever been in a bathroom like this? There's 50 people in the bathroom. They're all doing cocaine, they're playing like cards. I don't know, what bathroom is this?
52:44 Speaker 03 Most of the characters on Industry, we were talking about this last night. This is like, this is like a regular third episode of a season of Industry. Yeah.
52:52 Bill Simmons? I don't know, Van is fucking quiet right now. I'll just, just tell you. So Van, you...
52:57 Speaker 04 What happened?
52:58 Bill Simmons? Okay.
53:00 Bill Simmons? Roxy is throwing, I think, 130 miles an hour in this scene.
53:05 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah.
53:05 Bill Simmons? The catcher's mitt actually breaks.
53:07 Speaker 04 Yeah.
53:07 Bill Simmons? She breaks the mitt.
53:08 Speaker 03 Yep.
53:09 Bill Simmons? And Douglas is, I, again, I'll put this against Jim Carrey in Dumb and Dumber. I'll put this against Mike Myers in So I Married Naxberger. Name a funny movie. Nothing's funnier than... Than Douglas in this scene, trying to be sexy, I'm not too old to be here, dance guy.
53:29 Bill Simmons? It's really special.
53:30 Chris Ryan? The only thing that could have been funnier is if he danced. But he makes the choice to be like, what would this guy do at this club, seeing all this shit? This is like every primal instinct coming out, and he's just like, I would just stand there.
53:44 Bill Simmons? So, so you're watching, you're like, this has to be the unintentionally funniest thing that's gonna happen with Michael Douglas in this movie. Think again. Because we go to the sex scene, where he also gets up after and wins the William Peterson, honestly dude, I'm not sure we needed to see your balls award.
54:04 Bill Simmons? Does it twice, does the walk, talks to Roxy, does the let me ask you something Roxy, man to man. Then does the pivot and does another walk. He's like, did you see my balls throwing butt crack? Yeah, here they are again.
54:18 Speaker 03 Yeah.
54:19 Bill Simmons? He's just feeling it.
54:20 Speaker 03 And the side dick before that.
54:23 Bill Simmons? So this is what happens when you've made 10 straight years of hundred billion dollar movies. You just start walking around in the bathroom.
54:32 Bill Simmons? This is just the tour de force. Anything to add, Mal, before we move on?
54:35 Speaker 03 Hmm, I think this is a very important scene. We've talked about the side dick, the oral sex face, watching the blowjob in the mirror. I think the fact that in terms of just actually the clues, not that you're really thinking about the clues, but it is like beat for beat, parallel to what we saw in the vase scene. So you're very titillated by what you're seeing, but you're like, is he gonna get stabbed by an ice pick, right? And like even the folds of the bedding. Yeah, the, the headboard has like the slats so that she can tie him up, breaks out the Hermes or Hermes, as it is called in this film. Astonishing stuff, scarf out and ties him up. It's just start to finish, pretty incredible.
55:15 Speaker 03 The tearing of the, the back flesh, I think that these are some of the most guttural orgasm sounds ever committed to the public record on film. And, you know, when I was younger, watching this for the first time, I was like, it reminds me of. How I think people today read like Fourth Wing or Court of Thorns and Roses and they're like, I'm taking notes. Okay, this is how you could do something to like lead to a 27-page chapter about going down on your girlfriend on a throne. Got it. Okay. Like, people were watching this, studying it, trying to learn, not you.
55:45 Chris Ryan? Like, the girlfriend is also like a dragon fairy, right?
55:49 Speaker 03 Yeah, well, there are fairies in Court of Thorns and Roses. I can tell you've read them, dragon riders in Fourth Wing. And then you watch this now as like a middle-aged person. And like the angling of the back, I'm like, is she about to like turn into Nagini? Like, I just worry about everybody's pain. I see them looking into the mirror up top. I'm like, if I had that now, I would just say like, are my hips properly aligned? So that I'm not gonna wake up with lower back pain? It's a very different relationship as you age.
56:22 Chris Ryan? It's an amazing athletic performance.
56:24 Speaker 03 It is. It is.
56:31 Bill Simmons? Yeah, I don't know what his dick looks like the next day, but it's not going straight.
56:36 Bill Simmons? There's definitely a couple turns.
56:39 Speaker 04 For sure.
56:42 Bill Simmons? I have two more scenes. Nick goes see Catherine the next day. And she kinda deflates the balloon a little bit.
56:48 Speaker 03 Yeah.
56:49 Bill Simmons? Roxy didn't know what she was in for. Oh, she's seen me fuck other guys, just like sticking it to him. I told her I thought it was the fuck of the century. I thought it was a good beginning.
56:58 Speaker 04 Say, Nick came in that bitch like he was the man.
57:01 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
57:02 Speaker 04 I thought it was the fuck of the century. Is he still wearing the sweater or did he change? I can't remember if he wears the sweater.
57:07 Speaker 03 Yeah, he's the bomber, he is the bomber.
57:09 Speaker 04 All of a sudden, he's become Danny Zuko. Like, he went from being like a regular cop to now he's the coolest motherfucker in the world. She's like, yo, dog, pump the brakes. I used to fuck a boxer. Like, you know what I mean? It's like, get the fuck out of here.
57:25 Bill Simmons? And then...
57:27 Bill Simmons? Just the ending with the twist where you think she's gonna kill him. I think those are all the rewatchable scenes. What do you got, CR? What's your most rewatchable?
57:34 Chris Ryan? Nightclub, 100 out of 100. I mean, the sex scene's cool, but like, the nightclub has so much going on. I love that the drug dealer gets to dance with them, that he's like, "Yeah, you know, like, here's some coke. Can I join?"
57:46 Speaker 04 Hey, that black guy is in every 90s movie. For some reason, they got a nigga with a flat top and a vest, no shirt, who knows all the choreography to everything. Isn't, that guy comes back, Glenn Plummer plays that guy in Showgirls. He comes back, he's dancing with a random white girl, he's...
58:11 Speaker 04 I'm telling you, that guy, I never saw him in Baton Rouge.
58:16 Bill Simmons? So we all have the nightclub scene, or what do you have, Mel?
58:18 Speaker 03 I think it's fuck of the century. I've, across the course of my life, diagrammed that like I'm scoring a baseball game.
58:24 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
58:24 Speaker 03 Like, that's, it's gotta be that.
58:26 Speaker 04 So we're not gonna bring up-
58:27 Speaker 03 But nobody's picking the interrogation scene. Wow.
58:30 Speaker 04 The interrogation, mine's the interrogation scene, but like, also, but like, the Triple Horn scene, right, which is obviously a very... I mean, come on, man. We're, it's a controversial scene.
58:41 Bill Simmons? It's problematic.
58:42 Speaker 04 Yeah, it's a, it's a, it's a, it's a very problematic scene, but like, he runs, that's the first time we really see them together.
58:49 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
58:49 Speaker 04 And it's like, very, it shows that legitimately, the moment that he meets Catherine, his character changes immediately. He becomes like, once again, more primal, like more driven by whatever this thing is in his body that he can't control.
59:03 Bill Simmons? What's the most 1992 thing about this movie? What do you have, CR?
59:08 Chris Ryan? That's got Bart Simpson on a keychain.
59:10 Speaker 03 Yeah. Yeah. Mistaken for a gun at the end.
59:15 Chris Ryan? And he gets fucking killed.
59:18 Bill Simmons? You have one, Ben?
59:19 Speaker 04 Yeah, so in this movie, only the attractive people have sex. So there are a bunch of people in the movie, but only the people that look good having sex. If they made this movie right now, there'd be a random scene of Haas hitting someone from the back.
59:37 Speaker 04 Like, but in this movie, like, the desirable people, desirable people, they have sex, and everybody else is a bunch of fucking pastrami-eating cops that get to go, "Oh, you fucked that last night's shooter?" We like, like, but in this now, we have democratized sex scenes. So Haas would've got to get down with some Haas and Roxy would've had their little situation if it was happening today.
59:59 Chris Ryan? This is an amazing point, because to the guys on the force, Nick is Austin Butler. Like, they're so fucking gross. They're like, they're even happy when they're like, "Nick is breaking every law, but goddamn, man."
1:00:15 Bill Simmons? I have a couple of 1992 things. Quitting cocaine for three months?
1:00:20 Speaker 03 Yeah, yes.
1:00:27 Bill Simmons? Those green police computer screens really bring me back to the 90s, when you're just trying to read your... I honestly, you'd go blind if you looked at those things for too long.
1:00:35 Chris Ryan? But some of the prompts they're writing there are kind of ChatGPT, where they're like, "What about 1967?" And it's like, "Oh, okay."
1:00:45 Bill Simmons? Calling a condom a rubber?
1:00:48 Chris Ryan? Sure.
1:00:49 Bill Simmons? Felt very 90s to me. I don't think, do we say rubber in the same way anymore?
1:00:55 Speaker 04 That's a question for you, I was 12.
1:00:59 Bill Simmons? And then Sharon Stone hosted the April 1992 Saturday Night Live to promote this movie with musical guest Pearl Jam. Their first SNL performance.
1:01:10 Speaker 03 Look at that.
1:01:11 Bill Simmons? And they look like they're like 22 years old. So there you go. What's age the best? All the San Francisco location stuff. By the way, I was warned by multiple people not to say San Fran. Apparently, it's an annoying habit. The San Francisco people don't like... So do you have a nickname for San Francisco, or no? Frisco?
1:01:34 Bill Simmons? SF? What do you say, Craig?
1:01:38 Speaker 05 SF, probably?
1:01:42 Bill Simmons? So when someone says San Fran, you're just like, fuck this person.
1:01:46 Speaker 04 So I fucking said it. And by the way, fuck you guys. I was like, I said it and Logan's right there. I was trying to like, shout out, everybody, give it up for Logan Murdock.
1:01:56 Speaker 03 Oh, yeah.
1:01:58 Speaker 04 But like, I said it when I was trying to fucking compliment y'all, City. Nobody told me that shit. I didn't get the email. So Frisco, The City, all of that shit, shout out to y'all.
1:02:06 Bill Simmons? I like SF. We mentioned this earlier for What Saves the Best, one of the great cigarette smoking movies ever made, Sierra.
1:02:13 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
1:02:13 Bill Simmons? Who would you give if we could only hand out one Sean Penn, I brought my own pack award for excellence in non-screen smoking? Would you go Stone or Douglas?
1:02:23 Chris Ryan? Douglas, because you can see that the cigarette is the highway to hell for him.
1:02:28 Speaker 03 Oh, interesting.
1:02:29 Chris Ryan? I feel like it's the cigarette that unlocks everything.
1:02:32 Bill Simmons? I have more What Saves the Best, but what do you got now?
1:02:34 Speaker 03 Well, I just, I'm shocked you didn't say the first shot of Catherine on the deck that we spent so much time talking about.
1:02:40 Bill Simmons? It's a good flick.
1:02:41 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:02:42 Chris Ryan? It's a good flick.
1:02:42 Speaker 03 Draws your attention to the jagged rocks, the danger of the person and the setting, all of it. Um, let's see, the score you already mentioned is quite good. The dong, the nudity, the explicit sex, Sharon Stone, we've talked about all of it, I think. I think the way props are used, like objects, you mentioned the key ring, obviously the ice picks, the hand ties, the ceiling mirrors, the matching picassos. There are these like little aspects of every setting that really become central drivers of the plot in a nice way.
1:03:10 Speaker 04 I got one.
1:03:10 Bill Simmons? Yeah?
1:03:11 Speaker 04 Uh, men fucking with women who will eventually destroy them. So...
1:03:18 Speaker 04 This movie should be required viewing for anyone who's thinking about dating a Kardashian, Timmy?
1:03:27 Speaker 04 I know it seems good now, brother.
1:03:29 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:03:30 Speaker 04 But I was there for nine years, it's not gonna work out.
1:03:34 Bill Simmons? I had Johnny Baz's Apartment, which has a Picasso.
1:03:40 Speaker 03 Yeah, Catherine has a Picasso.
1:03:41 Bill Simmons? And also no maid service.
1:03:42 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
1:03:45 Bill Simmons? I'd like, I really like Michael Douglas. I have down his hesitation. I can't believe this broad laugh that he does where he's just like.
1:03:55 Chris Ryan? Drinking a paper cup of water.
1:03:56 Bill Simmons? Yeah, yeah, he's like his, his little weird flirty thing. Something Nick Catherine exchanges. Fuck like minks, raise rug rats, live happily ever after. Like, there's just like good screenwriting stuff in this. And then, uh, Mal, I can't believe you didn't mention this. Well, she got that Magna Cut and Loudy pussy on her that.
1:04:12 Speaker 03 Done fried up her brain. Yeah.
1:04:16 Bill Simmons? Just some of the George Zunza. He plays, he plays Gus.
1:04:20 Speaker 03 Incredible.
1:04:21 Bill Simmons? Gus, like, you know, he's dead the moment you see him. You're like, ah.
1:04:23 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
1:04:24 Bill Simmons? This guy's overweight, he's a buddy. He's gonna drink too much. He'll, he'll make it. You do the pool. He's gonna be 18 minutes left, he'll be dead. You know what's happening. Pretext San Francisco.
1:04:35 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
1:04:35 Bill Simmons? I would also put in there, San Francisco.
1:04:39 Bill Simmons? I used to come here a lot in the 90s because some of my best high school, college friends lived here. And San Francisco was fucking awesome in the 90s. And it was, it was a great place for young people. It was just, it was really cool. And obviously has gone through a lot of transformations over the years, but just seeing it. Don't make a face, man.
1:04:59 Speaker 04 I'm saying you're buying into the propaganda. The fucking shit is beautiful. I seen that fucking building.
1:05:04 Speaker 03 Gorgeous city.
1:05:06 Speaker 04 What's that, what's that pointy building? What's it called? The pointy one? From Star Trek. Do y'all know the name of the, the pointy one? I seen that bitch. Transameri, whatever the fuck. I like, I saw that. I was like, yo, man, this shit is crazy.
1:05:21 Bill Simmons? Are we done with What's Ate The Best? Can we move on?
1:05:23 Chris Ryan? I had one thing, which was, it takes, like, for me, it took a bunch of viewings to notice this. Is there is a brief moment when Douglas goes to Beth's house. He's like, come in and she's like, oh, my lock is broken.
1:05:38 Speaker 03 Yes.
1:05:38 Chris Ryan? And it's like, basically, the only detail you get that Catherine has set Beth up. This entire time and is like placing articles in her house and shit.
1:05:48 Speaker 03 Gotta put that revolver behind the bookcase.
1:05:50 Chris Ryan? Change your locks, maybe, but like, it's a great, otherwise, the whole movie almost falls apart at the end. Which it kinda does anyway.
1:05:58 Bill Simmons? Did you have another? Great shot, Gordo, for best shot.
1:06:01 Chris Ryan? Uh, there's a bunch of really cool shit in here. Yon de Bon's really good, but the push in on Catherine saying, "I'd have to be pretty stupid to write a book about killing and then kill him the same way I described in my book."
1:06:11 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
1:06:11 Chris Ryan? And she's saying it to the audience where it's like, almost breaking the fourth wall.
1:06:15 Bill Simmons? Right. Uh, we have, we don't get to give this out a lot, the Amanda Dobbins Award for best piece of real estate. Catherine's house.
1:06:23 Speaker 03 Yes.
1:06:23 Bill Simmons? Uh, so the exterior's in Stinson Beach and then the interior stuff was in Carmel by the sea, which is not that close to here. Um, about 35 mil right now for this one. Um, great bay window, great deck, easy access to a completely scary beach.
1:06:40 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
1:06:40 Bill Simmons? That you just felt you could die as you're going on a walk. Uh, CR, you have a flex category. What do you got?
1:06:46 Chris Ryan? Yeah, I mean, you guys tell me, I feel like the Ed Norton reverse dunk award, "Did this movie need a random sports scene?"
1:06:54 Chris Ryan? There's a little bit of Niners, like, at the end, like, at the diner and stuff, but could we not get George Seifert in this movie somehow? Because you were still cooking back then.
1:07:05 Bill Simmons? What do you mean, like, Nick goes to, like, a Niners practice? And has, like, young Montana thoughts?
1:07:10 Chris Ryan? Like, Gus has lost a ton of money on the Niners or something.
1:07:13 Speaker 03 Yes, yeah.
1:07:15 Speaker 04 Oh, I got one. Karen used to fuck somebody on the Niners. Maybe Ca- oh, Karen.
1:07:20 Bill Simmons? Catherine.
1:07:21 Speaker 04 I'm drunk. Catherine used to, like, oh, white woman, Karen, whatever. Um, so she used to fuck somebody on the Niners, so they go to interview him, and it's Jerry Rice.
1:07:32 Chris Ryan? And the name of her new novel is Rice.
1:07:35 Speaker 04 Right.
1:07:35 Bill Simmons? Yeah. Mallory, you don't get a flex because you have your own award. The Mallory Rubin Award for, "Did this movie need a better sex scene?"
1:07:44 Speaker 04 Oh, shit.
1:07:45 Speaker 03 Okay, well, like, a third of the runtime is sex scenes, basically, right? We have the opening buzz scene, we have Nick, I'll incorporate some just nudity that's very central as well, Nick watching Catherine change in the mirror for the first time, the Nick Beth rape scene, uh, we could make that better by not having it or not doing it that way, I'd say. Um, Nick watching Catherine change again through the large, beautiful picture. Windows that you were just commenting on with the real estate, right? And reasonable to assume that she knows he's there. So put a pin in that. I'll be coming back to that in a second. We've got the fuck of the century. The fireplace chaise scene. So this, this, we enter a different point in the movie now where we're like not seeing the sex.
1:08:25 Bill Simmons? Right.
1:08:25 Speaker 03 This is the like.
1:08:26 Bill Simmons? They warn us out.
1:08:27 Speaker 03 Make love to me. And then we cut and they're cuddling in front of the fire. It's like, this is not the movie that I signed up to watch. Why am I not seeing every second of that? And it ends up being very relevant because that's when she's planting the Lisa nuggets about Beth in this vulnerable moment. Then we get Catherine at Nick's apartment, some nudity. And then again, we don't see the sex scene. Insane. Then we cut to them cuddling in the window nook.
1:08:51 Bill Simmons? Didn't have enough sex.
1:08:51 Speaker 03 I think that there are a couple of opportunities in the established sequence of the film to just show us all of the sex again, which I would have supported. And then of course, the final sex scene, which once again mirrors the Bosbeats, spine bending maneuvers and then the forward thrusts. And then like, okay, she didn't kill him. So here are my suggestions. Give us the full sex scenes in the ones we cut away from. The make love to me, fireplace chaise and the window nook. But I think for like the fourth or fifth rewatchables in a row. So this is something I'm going to reflect on later. I would like to suggest that the movie include a masturbation scene. Because it actually doesn't make sense that that's missing. And I think when Nick follows.
1:09:33 Bill Simmons? Nick has calluses.
1:09:34 Speaker 03 Well, yeah, I'm like, how is, how does Nick's dick have skin on it? If his hand has that many calluses on it? Like use some lotion, my guy, come on. But I'm talking about Catherine, naturally. He follows her home. Someone said yes.
1:09:48 Bill Simmons? Somebody said yes.
1:09:49 Speaker 03 Fellow visionary. Fellow visionary. He follows her home and he, she is, she just immediately gets undressed, drapes her open, giant window. She definitely knows he's there because he is the worst tail in the history of tails.
1:10:05 Bill Simmons? Yeah, he really is. He's terrible.
1:10:06 Speaker 03 At no point in the movie does he follow somebody and they don't know that he's behind them. So she knows he's there and purposefully she gets undressed in front of the window, leaves the lights on, and then as she walks away, turn the lights off, which I think is confirmation that she knows he's watching. There's a couch right there. Go for it. Right?
1:10:24 Bill Simmons? You throw, so you throw some solo action.
1:10:27 Speaker 03 Yes.
1:10:28 Bill Simmons? And then we mix in a Newman scene as well. Oh, Newman solo action.
1:10:32 Speaker 04 Well, let's see it.
1:10:33 Speaker 03 Yes.
1:10:33 Speaker 04 Let's see it.
1:10:34 Speaker 03 A real toss up. Let's either see Newman jack off or Catherine masturbate.
1:10:39 Speaker 04 I'm going.
1:10:40 Speaker 03 Or Splendid on her couch, either.
1:10:42 Speaker 04 Honestly, yeah, I've never seen anything like that before, yeah.
1:10:46 Bill Simmons? Oh, my god.
1:10:49 Bill Simmons? Pulling the back roll.
1:10:52 Bill Simmons? We don't get to give this award out. Craig, you were here when this award was created. The Steven Seagal Hard to Kill Award for Did This Movie Need a Better Intimacy Coordinator?
1:11:02 Speaker 03 Clearly, yes.
1:11:03 Speaker 04 Paul Verhoeven is the intimacy coordinator.
1:11:05 Bill Simmons? I'm gonna say yes on this.
1:11:07 Speaker 04 Yeah, I'm gonna say yeah. I'll give this a yes.
1:11:09 Bill Simmons? Yeah, okay. Butch's Girlfriend Award for Weak Link of the Film.
1:11:13 Chris Ryan? I got this one, and it really jumped out at me. What the fuck is Hazel Dobkins doing in this movie?
1:11:18 Speaker 03 Oh, this is mine, too.
1:11:19 Chris Ryan? Unless you subscribe to the online theory that she is the mastermind of this entire film.
1:11:25 Speaker 03 Oh.
1:11:26 Bill Simmons? Oh.
1:11:26 Chris Ryan? And that that's why Catherine seems so deferential towards her, and she's often at the house when Nick arrives. It's like Hazel's like in the background.
1:11:33 Speaker 03 Yeah. What message boards are you on?
1:11:35 Chris Ryan? R slash Basic Instinct. And, no, but it's like, it's either one or the other. She's either like, they kind of wrote her into the movie and kept her like appearing throughout it, or she is the Joker.
1:11:50 Bill Simmons? What do you think of that, Van?
1:11:52 Speaker 04 What do you mean?
1:11:53 Bill Simmons? Hazel Dobins being the Joker.
1:11:55 Speaker 04 Yeah, I don't know. But like, you know, I'm thinking about a lot of stuff in this movie. I'm processing as we're talking. Like, when we were talking about the sex scenes and Hazel, I looked at the sex scenes. I really thought that this was the way white people had sex back in the day. Because I look at her now, and all of her riding skills, they're completely obsolete now.
1:12:17 Speaker 04 We have new technologies. She wasn't making no circles. She was just going crazy. And then like when you, when you, when you see Showgirls, it's the same thing. When you watch Elizabeth Berkley in Showgirls, she's in the pool, and she's actually like she's on a bucking bronco and I, I, I fucking spasming and shit like that. But like, anyway.
1:12:41 Speaker 03 I had Hazel questions as well, because I think it's one of the more puzzling aspects of the plot. I hadn't considered, I didn't know this was a theory. I hadn't considered the Joker thing, but I think another bit of evidence to support this theory is that Hazel canonically killed her husband and three children. Yes. Right? She is a mass murderer, a child slayer, and it is established on the aforementioned computer that she was in jail for nine years for that.
1:13:06 Chris Ryan? Yeah. Roxy killed her brother and is out after six.
1:13:10 Speaker 03 That's also insane. She slit their throats with a razor and she's like, "I put in a couple of years. I'm good."
1:13:15 Bill Simmons? I had that in Picket Nets. It seemed like, I would say a short prison sentence for wiping out your family.
1:13:21 Speaker 03 It's crazy.
1:13:21 Speaker 04 Hold on, hold on. This is the two Americans thing. That Trax kill her whole family. She gets out nine years. I know niggas in jail 55 years for weed. That's real. Feel guilty.
1:13:33 Speaker 03 Isn't the weak link of the movie the DNA evidence thing, though? Like, it's actually like, I agree that we just want to watch the movie and have fun, but it is actually disqualifying, borderline disqualifying. Like, DNA evidence had been in practice since the 80s. This movie is set in 92. There's just absolutely no reason.
1:13:49 Chris Ryan? Those guys, here's the thing, those guys were just like...
1:13:50 Speaker 03 Every single murder involves every bodily fluid that you could possibly excrete. How are they not finding the killer?
1:13:58 Bill Simmons? Can I counter this?
1:13:59 Speaker 03 Please.
1:14:00 Bill Simmons? Because I had this in What Stage Is the Worst, not Weakest Link.
1:14:03 Speaker 03 Okay.
1:14:04 Bill Simmons? Just because 10 years later, the DNA she's done in five minutes. But if you remember the OJ trial in 95, people still, we barely knew what DNA evidence was, and people like, didn't even really believe it.
1:14:15 Speaker 04 Well, because he didn't do it. Anyway. But no, but the DNA is kind of...
1:14:27 Bill Simmons? So you're going to the sun?
1:14:28 Speaker 04 Like, the DNA is kind of rendered default by the fact that she admits that she had sex with the guy.
1:14:33 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
1:14:34 Speaker 04 But she says that she had sex with him, and she says over and over again that they had sex. So her being connected to him is not necessarily...
1:14:41 Bill Simmons? But the fingerprints on the ice pick, like, there's stuff that they would...
1:14:44 Speaker 03 She's not covered in like, blood? Her clothing doesn't have a trace of the blood of her slain victims.
1:14:51 Chris Ryan? She's often freshly showered when he comes over.
1:14:52 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
1:14:53 Chris Ryan? Like, she's...
1:14:53 Speaker 03 That's, I don't think that's how it works.
1:14:55 Chris Ryan? I'm just saying.
1:14:55 Speaker 03 If you commit a murder one day, as a friend and person who loves you, don't just shower and think you're gonna get away with it. You need to clean up more fully.
1:15:03 Speaker 04 That's so funny getting a call from CR like 2:30, Van.
1:15:06 Speaker 03 I took a shower, I'm fine.
1:15:07 Speaker 04 Come downtown, I did something I wasn't supposed to do, man.
1:15:11 Chris Ryan? Bring a bar of Irish Spring.
1:15:16 Chris Ryan? That's just, get me out of this.
1:15:19 Speaker 04 I would help you.
1:15:19 Chris Ryan? This is, so what's each the worst for me? I don't, I don't know if that's...
1:15:22 Bill Simmons? Wait, I'm not, I gotta do my weak link.
1:15:24 Chris Ryan? Oh, you gotta do your weak link, sorry.
1:15:25 Bill Simmons? By the way, Van, I think you'd be one of my three calls. I don't know where you rank.
1:15:30 Speaker 04 Hey, bro, whose car are we taking?
1:15:34 Bill Simmons? Um...
1:15:35 Speaker 04 You call me, I'm with it.
1:15:39 Bill Simmons? So I had a, I had a less auspicious weak link. So Nick, Michael Douglas's character, attacks Nielsen, the internal affairs guy, that he gave up the files, right? It's in front of like 30 cops.
1:15:52 Speaker 03 Yes.
1:15:52 Bill Simmons? Has to be restrained, he's like ready to fight him. Six hours later, the guy's shot in the head. And they're like, hey shooter, we're gonna need your gun.
1:16:01 Chris Ryan? Bill.
1:16:01 Bill Simmons? He's not in jail?
1:16:02 Chris Ryan? I'm so glad you brought this up.
1:16:04 Bill Simmons? At that point, he's locked up, right?
1:16:06 Chris Ryan? This is what I don't think you caught in that scene where he goes into Nielsen's office. When he goes into Marty's office and he starts like jumping on him, Marty's boss pulls a gun and fucks him in the back of the head.
1:16:18 Speaker 04 He puts it to his head, dude. What the shit is happening?
1:16:22 Chris Ryan? So it's just funny. There are no rules in the SFPD.
1:16:26 Speaker 03 Yeah, crazy.
1:16:27 Speaker 04 The SFPD is going nuts. They take the gun, put it, "Hey, do something to him, I'll blow your fucking head off, shooter."
1:16:34 Chris Ryan? That's Internal Affairs.
1:16:36 Speaker 03 It's insane.
1:16:36 Chris Ryan? There's no fucking laws, man.
1:16:40 Bill Simmons? What a movie. All right, What's Age of the Worst, what'd you have, Sierra?
1:16:43 Chris Ryan? Uh, well, so What's Age of the Worst is the fact that we know too much. We would be talking about DNA evidence.
1:16:49 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:16:50 Chris Ryan? After David Simon, we know way too much about law enforcement storytelling. Back then, they were like, "Yeah, three months ago, this narc killed two tourists while he was high on code. Now fucks his therapist. Let's promote him to homicide detective. And have him drive the suspect, who the two of them have been making fuck me eyes at each other throughout this completely inappropriate interrogation."
1:17:13 Speaker 03 Did you know each other?
1:17:14 Chris Ryan? Yeah. My idea is, Nick, find out where Catherine leads.
1:17:19 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
1:17:20 Chris Ryan? And then he abandons his responsibilities altogether. It's fucking amazing.
1:17:25 Speaker 03 Crazy.
1:17:25 Chris Ryan? Watching it at the time, I was like, "This is incredible." Watching it now, you're like, "I think there would probably be some reviews."
1:17:32 Bill Simmons? We mentioned the first sex scene is, uh, I gotta say, problematic now, but in 1992, wasn't not problematic. Like, it was a big thing when it happened, with him and Gene Triplehorn.
1:17:43 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah.
1:17:44 Bill Simmons? It's just a weird choice, I don't really get it. So, this really bugs me. This is, could be a nitpick, but it's really What's Age of the Worst. So, they put together that Gene Triplehorn also went to college with Sharon Stone's character, and they put the photo ID. And she's got a blonde wig in the photo ID, but it's the exact same photo as her now.
1:18:04 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:18:05 Bill Simmons? And it was like, "This movie costs $59 million?" And they're just like, "Hey, what are we gonna do with the photo?" And they just, like, photoshopped? I don't, I just don't understand it. It's such an unforced error.
1:18:16 Speaker 03 Great one.
1:18:17 Bill Simmons? What else did, do you have any What's Age of the Worst fan?
1:18:20 Speaker 04 No, I was all about the way Sharon Stone was riding dick.
1:18:23 Bill Simmons? Did you have any more, Mel?
1:18:24 Speaker 03 I think that the, we've alluded to this, but like, the, beyond just the general kinda shoddy work from the SFPD, uh, the solving of the murder, it, they're like, that jacket fit.
1:18:39 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
1:18:40 Speaker 03 So it was back-
1:18:41 Chris Ryan? She's got a bunch of articles in her drawer.
1:18:43 Speaker 03 The jacket that says where she works on the back of it, which is definitely a choice you'd make as a murderer.
1:18:48 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
1:18:48 Speaker 03 Fit. So it's her. I mean, that's just absolutely ludicrous.
1:18:52 Bill Simmons? I had a, I had that in nitpicks, but the same thing, they go to the- They go to Beth's kitchen drawer, they open up, there's all this scrapbook stuff.
1:19:00 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:19:01 Bill Simmons? And the guy goes, "Well, I guess that's it."
1:19:03 Speaker 03 Yeah, Walker's like, "Kitchen drawer." Yeah. Yeah.
1:19:07 Bill Simmons? Tony, go it in, guilty.
1:19:10 Speaker 03 Serial killers always keep a full binder of chronologically ordered incriminating evidence in their kitchen drawer. Always.
1:19:19 Bill Simmons? Crazy.
1:19:19 Speaker 03 Always. The speed of the elevator in that sequence, also ridiculous. And the fact that Nick has just had this very dramatic moment where he's like, looking at the two covers, "Oh, which will they go with?" And he sees the paragraph about the detective's partner being found in the elevator. And then Gus shows up and is like, "Bud, I got a call from Catherine's freshman year roommate. Let's go." And Nick's like, "Sounds good. That all seems credible. Let's do it." And then he's like, "I'm just gonna go inside a few floors up the elevator that you just read about." And Nick's like, "Cool. Good luck."
1:19:49 Bill Simmons? Yeah. He just read the page on the printer.
1:19:52 Speaker 03 And then he's killed shortly thereafter in the exact scenario that was described in the pages he just read. Nick, terrible. No one's like, Beth doesn't have blood on her hands at the end?
1:20:02 Bill Simmons? I had a...
1:20:04 Speaker 03 Crazy.
1:20:04 Bill Simmons? The last 40 minutes is the What's Age the Worst. They kinda yada yada some of this stuff, but I love this movie, but...
1:20:10 Speaker 03 That's crazy. If you stab someone with an ice pick that many times in the jugular in an elevator, you have some blood on your hands.
1:20:17 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
1:20:17 Speaker 03 With some.
1:20:18 Bill Simmons? And then I had the rip-off erotic thrillers that came after this that were all pretty bad. I think the worst one's probably Color Night, especially because Bruce Willis pool penis on a 70-foot screen. Wasn't really looking for that in 1995.
1:20:33 Speaker 03 Well.
1:20:35 Speaker 03 To each their own.
1:20:36 Bill Simmons? I'm really excited for this next category. The rough-lo-hander Rubenek Partridge overacting award obviously goes to Michael Douglas, who has... He does this thing where he says the line, but then yells the last two words. So it's like, "Who has access to my goddamn files?
1:20:55 Bill Simmons? What is this, some kind of joke?"
1:20:59 Bill Simmons? This was his angry Michael Douglas.
1:21:00 Speaker 04 Stop fucking riding me, man!
1:21:01 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
1:21:02 Speaker 04 I'll get your fucking teeth in!
1:21:05 Bill Simmons? I just love it. All right, Vance flex. So you have to... How would Van Lathan get out of this one? Which is an award we have sometimes.
1:21:13 Chris Ryan? So as Beth or as Nick?
1:21:15 Bill Simmons? I think you could be, you could be any of the three characters here. How would Van get out of this one? Pick a character and go.
1:21:21 Speaker 04 I'm getting out of what, though?
1:21:23 Bill Simmons? I don't know, how would Van Lathan get out of this? All right, you're Beth, how about you're Beth?
1:21:27 Speaker 04 So I'm Beth? Well, I'm gonna be Nick, right?
1:21:29 Bill Simmons? Okay, be Nick.
1:21:32 Speaker 04 So I'm Nick and, and, you know, they're asking me like why I'm hanging around Catherine. Well, the reality is this, you say I don't read enough. The woman's an author, okay? You say I play the game too much, you say that I'm too obsessed with the dog, you say I'm on the computer too much. This woman's an author, she's written books. These books are very well regarded. And what I'm trying to do is deepen my understanding of literature. Now, here's the deal. If this was a male writer, you wouldn't have any problem with it.
1:22:00 Chris Ryan? That's right.
1:22:01 Speaker 04 If it's a female writer. So while you're looking at me, what I think you actually need to look at is the mirror. Because the reality is, this is a woman, so you feel threatened. I don't feel threatened around women because I empower women. I believe in female writers, I believe in female creators, and this is a female creator. I believe in her, so I'm gonna keep hanging around her. You deal with your things. Talk to Dr. Crossman on Thursday.
1:22:32 Bill Simmons? Nails it every time.
1:22:34 Speaker 04 Gaslight.
1:22:35 Bill Simmons? The CR, the CR thinks Luke Wilson could have been Harrison Ford at hottest take award.
1:22:42 Chris Ryan? So I was working on something, I told you earlier, I was like, I have a hottest take, but I haven't landed the plane yet. I think the planes still circle in the airport. Is this movie a perverted man's version of Gilligan's Island, where the professor is caught in between the psychosexual dealings of Ginger and Mary Ann? Or the CR is pandemonying to the audience award for safest home field take? San Francisco is the best.
1:23:07 Speaker 03 Movie City.
1:23:12 Bill Simmons? The suck up take, I like it. Now, do you have one?
1:23:16 Speaker 03 I think Catherine is a pretty generous murderer.
1:23:22 Speaker 05 Oh, yeah.
1:23:25 Speaker 03 I mean, cocaine on the penis.
1:23:30 Speaker 03 Sure, you're alive to see the ice pick penetrate your nose, your neck, a couple other parts of your body, but you're shooting your load inside of her while it's happening.
1:23:41 Speaker 03 Not a bad way to go.
1:23:43 Bill Simmons? Yeah, that's fair.
1:23:44 Speaker 03 Thoughtful.
1:23:45 Speaker 05 You could just kill them.
1:23:46 Speaker 03 Exactly.
1:23:47 Bill Simmons? What do you got, Ben?
1:23:48 Speaker 04 Uh, you scratched my back during the fuck section, it's over, okay? I like.
1:23:56 Speaker 04 I know that like, I've had this conversation since 99. Hey, bro, I was in that shit like crazy, dawg. She was scratching my back. I'm like, that's it, it's over, it's done. I don't even like spicy food. I don't like pain. You scratch, it's like, you like, you bite my neck too hard. Hey, yo, on God, though, I feel you. Chill. All right? She scratches his shit like Wolverine and seeing Magneto.
1:24:18 Speaker 03 Yes.
1:24:19 Speaker 04 And this motherfucker's like, ah, god, whatever. Hey, what the fuck is wrong with you? It's true what they say about you. Nah, don't scratch my shit.
1:24:31 Bill Simmons? Mine, I don't know how to prove this. I think this is the single worst cop performance ever by a cop in a movie.
1:24:38 Speaker 03 Yes.
1:24:39 Bill Simmons? So, we get to meet Nick. He's off cocaine for three months.
1:24:42 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:24:43 Speaker 03 Yeah. Yep.
1:24:44 Bill Simmons? Three months. Celebration, let's have a party. He's killed four tourists in the last five years.
1:24:50 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:24:50 Speaker 03 Yes.
1:24:51 Bill Simmons? But each time was, it was undercover for drugs, so it's fine. Somehow got promoted as CR mentioned. He's asked to trail this suspect, immediately falls in love with her and goes down this psychosexual path, loses his mind, loses his badge, and then ends up shooting his girlfriend.
1:25:13 Speaker 04 Murders his therapist.
1:25:14 Bill Simmons? After he let his partner go up to reenact the page of a book that he just read.
1:25:20 Speaker 03 Crazy. Let go, get killed.
1:25:22 Bill Simmons? Yeah. Shoots his girlfriend, and then somehow gets away with. And he's back on the streets. I mean, this is like the real Dirty Harry. This is it.
1:25:32 Chris Ryan? This is Dirty Harry.
1:25:33 Bill Simmons? He was like Lousy Harry.
1:25:33 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
1:25:35 Bill Simmons? Terrible cop. Casting what ifs, we mentioned Kim Basinger. Meg Ryan turned it down. Gina Davis turned it down. Ellen Barkin, I'm amazed she turned it down. Meryl Hemingway turned it down. And then it was Demi Moore versus Sharon Stone and Sharon Stone won.
1:25:53 Chris Ryan? By far the funniest casting what if is that Emma Thompson auditioned for Catherine.
1:25:59 Bill Simmons? Yeah, I didn't know what to make of that. Did you believe that?
1:26:01 Chris Ryan? She said, I auditioned for Catherine. Yeah.
1:26:04 Bill Simmons? Allegedly, in one of the original scripts, Nick Curran was originally a lesbian cop, written with Kathleen Turner in mind, and then they switched it.
1:26:13 Bill Simmons? Paul Verhoeven was supposed to direct Black Rain.
1:26:16 Chris Ryan? Oh shit.
1:26:16 Bill Simmons? Which will be on the rewatchables at some point in 2026.
1:26:19 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
1:26:20 Bill Simmons? But dropped out to do Total Recall. And then, I thought this was amazing. Verhoeven wanted Tom Berenger for Robocop and Basic Instinct, and Berenger's like, no, thanks. You're a weird pervy Dutch guy, and I don't want to do a movie with you.
1:26:34 Chris Ryan? I'll be doing Sniper instead. Yeah.
1:26:38 Bill Simmons? Milos Forman was the first choice to direct and do it. And then, I don't know what to believe with who is considered for Nick. It's basically every white actor from 1982.
1:26:47 Chris Ryan? The two other ones that were really big were Linda Fiorentino as Beth. And this is insane, but Brooke Shields is Roxy.
1:26:57 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:26:57 Bill Simmons? Saw that.
1:26:59 Chris Ryan? You don't want to comment?
1:27:02 Bill Simmons? It's just, there's no way. It's, she just never would have done it. Best That Guy Award, Newman ineligible. Groundhog guy, the Groundhog Day guy. Stephen Tobalski, he's ineligible.
1:27:15 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:27:16 Bill Simmons? Dicky Greenleaf's dad, the principal headmaster from Son of a Woman, James Rebhorn. Ineligible.
1:27:23 Chris Ryan? Why is he ineligible?
1:27:25 Bill Simmons? Cause he's James Redburn. Go ahead Craig.
1:27:28 Speaker 04 Man, we're getting real, real, real weird with that guy.
1:27:31 Chris Ryan? The fact that you have to say the guy from Groundhog Day.
1:27:35 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:27:35 Chris Ryan? Means he's that guy.
1:27:38 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:27:39 Bill Simmons? I think Roxy wins the that guy award.
1:27:41 Chris Ryan? No.
1:27:41 Speaker 04 Ah, fuck all that.
1:27:42 Chris Ryan? No.
1:27:42 Bill Simmons? Cause if you see her, you'd think it's Roxy.
1:27:44 Speaker 04 No, it's not her, no.
1:27:45 Chris Ryan? You're changing the definition of that.
1:27:47 Speaker 04 But that guy is like, not even, you're not even committing to him.
1:27:50 Chris Ryan? That guy means you've seen him so many times and you're like, that guy. We never see Roxy again, except for days of thunder.
1:27:55 Bill Simmons? It's like, days of thunder.
1:27:56 Speaker 04 Right, it's like.
1:27:57 Speaker 05 Who would the most amount of people in this room be like, oh, that guy? When they see him on screen?
1:28:02 Bill Simmons? So probably James Redburn. That's fine.
1:28:04 Speaker 04 What about, okay, so the sheriff, okay? Jack McGee.
1:28:10 Speaker 03 Yes.
1:28:10 Speaker 04 Who plays the sheriff, he's also in, in, um, in, in Scrooge.
1:28:14 Chris Ryan? Bruce A. Young, who is the guy who says he had a minute amount of cocaine on the penis and in the lips.
1:28:20 Speaker 04 Chelsea Ross.
1:28:22 Bill Simmons? Listen, I'm a team player, you can give it to whoever you want. Can we give Roxy the Dionne Waiters award then?
1:28:27 Speaker 03 Definitely.
1:28:27 Bill Simmons? Okay, thank you.
1:28:28 Speaker 03 No question.
1:28:29 Bill Simmons? Is this a Hall of Fame Dionne Waiters performance?
1:28:31 Chris Ryan? I've recently become really obsessed with these Instagram videos where it'll be like, Kam Chancellor being like, when I was out there, I was looking to kill. And then a fucking Drake song drops and it's just Kam Chancellor hits for like two and a half minutes. They should make one for Roxy. Just with her footage and basic instincts. Oh, I forgot where I was.
1:28:52 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
1:28:52 Chris Ryan? My bad.
1:28:56 Bill Simmons? Recasting couch director city. So Hazel Dobbins, does the character work better if it's just Jacqueline Bisset? Just throwing that out there. Wow, dead silence from the crowd.
1:29:08 Bill Simmons? Let's walk through Tom Cruise as Nick.
1:29:10 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
1:29:10 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:29:11 Bill Simmons? Let's just.
1:29:12 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:29:12 Bill Simmons? I don't want to get in the car with this, but let's take a stroll around the block. Little younger. I think he brings the same amount of unintentional comedy.
1:29:22 Speaker 03 Definitely.
1:29:23 Bill Simmons? There's probably a running scene at one point.
1:29:24 Speaker 05 Probably across the Golden Gate.
1:29:26 Bill Simmons? Right, he's running the Golden Gate for no reason at all.
1:29:29 Speaker 03 Yes, yeah.
1:29:31 Speaker 05 He's running to Stinson Beach.
1:29:32 Bill Simmons? We'd. We'd get to watch him smoke.
1:29:36 Speaker 05 I'll see you there.
1:29:37 Speaker 04 I'll run.
1:29:38 Bill Simmons? We'd get to watch him smoke. Nothing would be funnier than Tom Cruise ripping off Marlboro Reds.
1:29:43 Speaker 03 That'd be great.
1:29:44 Bill Simmons? Him trying to have sexual chemistry with Sharon Stone, who's like working overtime. I would love that.
1:29:49 Chris Ryan? Him nude talking to Roxy in the bathroom.
1:29:51 Bill Simmons? Yeah, nude Tom Cruise.
1:29:54 Chris Ryan? Let me ask you something, Rocky.
1:29:56 Speaker 03 Man to man.
1:29:57 Bill Simmons? Him in the nightclub scene? Like, he's definitely like, I'm fucking.
1:30:00 Speaker 04 In the nightclub scene. He's going to fucking dance.
1:30:03 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
1:30:03 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:30:04 Speaker 04 He's not gonna be able to stay away. The beat's gonna fucking completely destroy him.
1:30:07 Bill Simmons? Now, I don't know if you want to imitate Tom Cruise in the cunnilingus scene.
1:30:15 Bill Simmons? This has turned into ET. It's like ET coming out of the closet. I don't know, I.
1:30:22 Speaker 03 I can see it.
1:30:22 Speaker 04 I see what you're saying.
1:30:23 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:30:24 Bill Simmons? So would you go Cruise or Douglas if you had to redo this? I feel like I would go Cruise.
1:30:29 Speaker 04 Oh, you gotta go Douglas, man.
1:30:31 Bill Simmons? What do you think, Craig?
1:30:33 Chris Ryan? Stick with Douglas.
1:30:34 Bill Simmons? All right, fine. Uh, Craig, you have a flex category.
1:30:38 Speaker 05 Um, Vincent Chase Award, are we sure this character was actually good at his job? Catherine Tramell.
1:30:43 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:30:44 Speaker 05 Fantastic planner, messy killer. Reckless stabber. Thirty-one stabs on Johnny Bosz. Why? Why do you thirty? Act like you've been there before. Jesus Christ. He's dead after five.
1:30:59 Chris Ryan? I thought you were actually gonna say, we don't know what kind of writer she was?
1:31:02 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:31:03 Speaker 05 That too.
1:31:03 Speaker 03 Well.
1:31:03 Chris Ryan? I know she was fast because she would just like be like, I'm off Bosz, I'm on to Nick, shooters, Doug. Now we're going on to the next one.
1:31:10 Speaker 05 Also, in the script, it says only 16 stabs. For some reason, it up to the double, the 31 in the real movie.
1:31:16 Speaker 03 There is when she gives the, the copy of the, the first, the book about the kid who killed his parents in the plane crash. It, there's like a Newsweek blurb on there about what a masterpiece it is, and it does say on the top, best seller.
1:31:29 Speaker 05 Oh shit.
1:31:30 Chris Ryan? All the more reason why it would be hard for her to be a mass murderer.
1:31:33 Speaker 03 I mean, it's so real.
1:31:35 Speaker 05 Leaving the ice pick and the scene of the, like she's just buying ice picks every week.
1:31:38 Speaker 03 That's her whole game, right? It's like, it's the taunt. Yeah, there are the, you know, a buck forty at Kmart.
1:31:43 Speaker 05 Bloody ice picks around? No regard for DNA? Messy, reckless. I don't like it.
1:31:49 Speaker 05 She shoots Nielsen in the head in broad daylight in a car?
1:31:53 Speaker 03 She got away with all of it.
1:31:54 Bill Simmons? Ben, if you were dating her, when you went to bed at night, would you check in different parts of the bed for the ice pick? Just to make sure, or would you just let it go?
1:32:02 Speaker 04 No, when you date crazy, you like.
1:32:04 Bill Simmons? You buy in.
1:32:05 Speaker 03 I would have like a metal detector that like works like a Roomba.
1:32:11 Speaker 03 Going around looking for an ice pick all over.
1:32:13 Speaker 05 Did you guys see that Sharon Stone, literally as she was stabbing Bill Cable, the guy who played Johnny Boss? Stabbed him so hard it went through the blood pack and pierced his skin and he went to the hospital.
1:32:23 Speaker 04 Too much.
1:32:24 Bill Simmons? Wow, she was really committed.
1:32:25 Speaker 04 Get off me.
1:32:26 Bill Simmons? Quick half-assed in our research, no body doubles used in any sex scenes.
1:32:30 Speaker 03 Yep.
1:32:32 Bill Simmons? We mentioned the five days to film the big sex scene. Douglas declined to go full frontal.
1:32:37 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
1:32:37 Bill Simmons? In the film, which apparently he had in his contract.
1:32:40 Speaker 03 The patriarchy is so real. My God.
1:32:43 Speaker 05 Well, in my contract, I'm not doing it. I'm not doing it.
1:32:46 Speaker 03 Side dick though, so.
1:32:47 Bill Simmons? The first sex scene with, with Douglas and Triplehorn.
1:32:53 Bill Simmons? It was the rehearsal scene and creepy perv Verhoeven was like, that was good. Let's keep that as the main. And they didn't even know they were filming it as the real scene. Pretty weird. Strange guy. And then in Hollywood Animal, Joe Esterhaus's book, he claimed that he slept with Sharon Stone after the movie came out. That was in the book.
1:33:12 Speaker 05 Sure he did.
1:33:13 Bill Simmons? Yeah, I don't think he was.
1:33:14 Chris Ryan? Esterhaus wrote this movie over the course of 10 days with no outline while listening to the Stones, which is a great euphemism for on cocaine.
1:33:24 Speaker 03 Yeah. You can't tell.
1:33:28 Chris Ryan? And then in the making of, I had to bring this up, is Verhoeven describes Nick as, quote, "A cop who has gone through some bad times and has done some things that we might consider wrong."
1:33:42 Bill Simmons? Including four murders.
1:33:43 Speaker 03 Incredible.
1:33:44 Speaker 04 You know what category we didn't do? We didn't do, "Does this movie need more black people?" No, it's a killer cop on this. He killing everybody.
1:33:54 Bill Simmons? Apex Mountain is another category we do where we decide if this was the peak of somebody's something.
1:34:03 Speaker 05 Got it.
1:34:03 Bill Simmons? Controversial character category. Michael Douglas, I'm gonna say no.
1:34:07 Speaker 04 Nah.
1:34:08 Speaker 03 No, no.
1:34:08 Bill Simmons? Sharon Stone, yes.
1:34:09 Speaker 03 Yes.
1:34:10 Speaker 04 Yeah, for sure.
1:34:10 Bill Simmons? Joe Esterhaus, yes. Ceiling sex mirrors?
1:34:15 Speaker 03 Could be.
1:34:15 Bill Simmons? Oh, has it been done better than this?
1:34:17 Chris Ryan? Do you think that this is maybe the end of the peak of ceiling sex mirrors?
1:34:21 Bill Simmons? I know, Cribs brought it back.
1:34:23 Chris Ryan? Cribs brought it back?
1:34:25 Bill Simmons? I think like three members of the Trailblazers had the ceiling mirrors. I remember, Zach Randolph definitely had it.
1:34:31 Speaker 03 Love it.
1:34:33 Bill Simmons? San Francisco movies, probably not.
1:34:35 Speaker 04 Probably not, yeah.
1:34:38 Bill Simmons? Erotic thrillers?
1:34:39 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:34:39 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:34:40 Chris Ryan? Yes.
1:34:40 Bill Simmons? I'm gonna say yes, alright.
1:34:42 Speaker 03 Freeze frame moments? Like moments you pause on in a movie?
1:34:45 Bill Simmons? Side dick freeze frame?
1:34:46 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:34:48 Speaker 03 Yeah, Phoebe Cates.
1:34:50 Bill Simmons? What is it for Gene Triplehorn? Cause it's probably The Firm, right?
1:34:52 Speaker 03 The Firm, yeah.
1:34:53 Chris Ryan? Waterworld? Isn't that like right around this time? Isn't 92's kinda like, breaks out?
1:34:59 Bill Simmons? Coke and Jack Daniels?
1:35:01 Chris Ryan? Oh, sure.
1:35:03 Speaker 03 Got Pepsi in the fridge.
1:35:04 Bill Simmons? Elevator murders, I'm gonna go dress to kill.
1:35:08 Bill Simmons? Gratuitous male actor ass shots? I think maybe?
1:35:11 Speaker 04 Oh yeah, so there was a whole competition. So look, bust this. So, you like... So he had to show his butt. He had no problem.
1:35:19 Bill Simmons? Right.
1:35:20 Speaker 04 He was in a white butt competition.
1:35:22 Bill Simmons? Right. This was the apex of white butt competitions.
1:35:25 Speaker 04 Mel Gibson's butt, Lethal Weapon. Kevin Costner's butt, Robin Hood. Bruce Willis's butt later on in Color of Night. Douglas was like, you know what? I got the ass. Douglas the Stallion.
1:35:35 Bill Simmons? Got to do it.
1:35:36 Speaker 04 I'm gonna show y'all that I got that nasty. He had to show his butt. He probably wanted to show it.
1:35:40 Bill Simmons? He lost 25 pounds for the film in the movie.
1:35:42 Speaker 03 He looks great.
1:35:44 Chris Ryan? That shape of his life.
1:35:45 Bill Simmons? Uh, we don't get to give this award all the time, but it's the Floyd Gondoli.
1:35:50 Speaker 04 Hold on for a second. Apex Mountain. I got a couple of things.
1:35:52 Bill Simmons? Oh, what do you got?
1:35:53 Speaker 04 Ice picks.
1:35:54 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah.
1:35:56 Speaker 04 Apex Mountain, Ice Picks.
1:35:58 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:35:58 Speaker 04 Thank you.
1:36:00 Bill Simmons? The crowds are plotting Ice Picks. What's happened to all of you? We've corrupted you in less than 90 minutes.
1:36:06 Speaker 04 Ice Picks, fucking your therapist? I think this is like way up there, fucking your therapist right here.
1:36:10 Bill Simmons? Not Sopranos?
1:36:11 Speaker 04 Also, well, the Sopranos, they never fuck.
1:36:14 Bill Simmons? Fantasy scene.
1:36:14 Speaker 03 Yeah, the fantasy.
1:36:16 Chris Ryan? Did they fuck Princess Prin- Princess Tides?
1:36:18 Speaker 03 I thought you said the Princess Bride.
1:36:20 Chris Ryan? I did for a second, yeah. Did Stre- Streisand and Nolte have sex in Prince of Tides?
1:36:27 Bill Simmons? I honestly, CR, you got me on this one. Haven't whipped that one out in a while. Woman on top?
1:36:36 Speaker 04 Woman on top. Woman on top.
1:36:38 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:36:38 Bill Simmons? You know, it might be because of the murder part.
1:36:41 Speaker 04 Ladies, get loud for that. We know y'all like that shit. It only actually feels good to y'all. But like, it, it, like, like.
1:36:47 Speaker 03 Oh, Adora, yeah.
1:36:49 Speaker 04 Like, woman on top, like, this is, she, when she wants to exert her power, she flips over and that's how she does her thing, woman on top.
1:36:56 Bill Simmons? The Floyd Gondoli butter in my ass and lollipops in my mouth award for something I just enjoy. Here you go, CR. For me, it's.
1:37:05 Chris Ryan? Cops getting in too deep.
1:37:07 Bill Simmons? Now I'll leave it go a little further. When an unraveling and supposedly sober cop shows up at the police bar and orders a double.
1:37:15 Speaker 03 Yeah, yes.
1:37:16 Bill Simmons? And multiple cops go, oh no.
1:37:18 Speaker 04 There he is.
1:37:20 Bill Simmons? Nick Strickin' again. I'm in every time. I just love it. Uh, do you guys have any for that or should we keep going?
1:37:26 Speaker 04 Uh, uh, not wearing any underwear. So look, um, I love this, okay? Who told women they had to wear underwear? Men. Don't listen, okay? Let that thing out. You see what I'm saying? And also, I'm gonna be honest with you guys. I like doing it, okay? Last year I got a wax job.
1:37:47 Speaker 03 Yep.
1:37:48 Speaker 04 What's going on right now?
1:37:50 Speaker 03 He chronicled this on his podcast.
1:37:53 Speaker 04 Last year I got a wax job.
1:37:54 Speaker 03 It was very memorable.
1:37:55 Speaker 04 She waxed the entire thing and like, like, three-quarter way through the wax, she goes like, "I love what you do," and I'm like, "This is a little weird, but that's okay."
1:38:03 Speaker 03 Oh, no.
1:38:03 Speaker 04 And after that, it's just, it feels sexy, dawg.
1:38:16 Chris Ryan? That is probably closer to the Floyd Gondoli, like, essence of this category than we ever get, so.
1:38:22 Bill Simmons? Craig's on, Craig's on LinkedIn right now.
1:38:26 Bill Simmons? Looking around.
1:38:31 Bill Simmons? We don't get to give this award out very much, the He Got Game Hooker scene for most awkward scene if someone randomly walks into the room. There's like five different scenes where your mother-in-law's coming down and you thought she was asleep.
1:38:46 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
1:38:47 Bill Simmons? Yeah. Pick a Knits.
1:38:51 Bill Simmons? Why didn't Johnny Bos's corpse have a rigor mortis boner?
1:38:59 Chris Ryan? Did it?
1:38:59 Bill Simmons? You want me to Google it?
1:39:01 Speaker 03 It didn't.
1:39:02 Bill Simmons? I mean, that's why you have the computer.
1:39:06 Bill Simmons? When you die, don't you just die? Like, everything's intact?
1:39:09 Chris Ryan? I don't know if it's like getting frozen in carbonite, like.
1:39:15 Chris Ryan? It's like the second your heart stops, you're like.
1:39:23 Bill Simmons? Are we sure it's not, though?
1:39:26 Chris Ryan? Do we have a doctor in the house?
1:39:29 Chris Ryan? It is a thing, a death erection.
1:39:32 Speaker 03 But he doesn't have an erection.
1:39:36 Bill Simmons? Thank you. No. Thank you. Third deck, thank you.
1:39:42 Bill Simmons? We, how did Hazel Dobbins get out of jail? I just, nine years. She served her time. Four, a husband and three kids gone. Uh, let's let her out. I have a few more, but CR, you have any?
1:39:55 Chris Ryan? I mean, when does Catherine write?
1:39:57 Bill Simmons? Oh, I had this too. She wrote Shooter in two weeks.
1:40:01 Chris Ryan? Yeah, she writes Shooter in a matter of weeks and she boasts, most of the time is having sex, doing cocaine or driving around San Francisco.
1:40:08 Bill Simmons? Or hanging at a Nick's doorstep, waiting for him to come home.
1:40:11 Chris Ryan? Hey, got you a house plant.
1:40:13 Bill Simmons? Prolific writer.
1:40:14 Speaker 03 Yeah, she's a genius. She is.
1:40:17 Speaker 04 Okay, I got one.
1:40:18 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
1:40:19 Speaker 04 So after the first time they have sex, you know, this big, he spoons her. Nigga, is your girl now?
1:40:30 Speaker 03 But he's in love with her.
1:40:31 Speaker 04 Nah, fuck all that. Nah, spooning is for Sunday. We watching Avengers Endgame on TNT. It takes up the whole fucking afternoon. You do not spoon the psycho killer girl that you are investigating. He wants, he nuzzles up next to her, puts his hand over, she calls him, what the fuck is up with you, homie? Like, he ain't got no homeboys? You're spooning? That quick? Simp ass motherfucker.
1:40:55 Bill Simmons? CR?
1:40:57 Chris Ryan? That was, my picking nit was really about Catherine's writing.
1:41:00 Bill Simmons? Mal, you have any?
1:41:01 Speaker 03 Uh, I think the fact that Nick gets hit by a moving vehicle, that Roxy drives a Lotus into him and he is unaffected. He like shakes his head once as he gets behind the wheel. Like, that's the concussion protocol. One head shake, no blood, no injuries. No damage to the car, which of course then will be damaged when it fall, rolls over the cliff, killing Roxy, who has no injuries. No blood on her, despite the car being destroyed.
1:41:30 Bill Simmons? All internal injuries.
1:41:31 Speaker 03 Yes. Crazy, ludicrous.
1:41:35 Chris Ryan? Why did Johnny Bosz give all of his money to her? Why was she the only one available to get the hundred million dollars?
1:41:42 Bill Simmons? Was that who she got? I thought she got it from her parents.
1:41:44 Speaker 03 Yeah, inherited from the parents.
1:41:45 Chris Ryan? I thought it was Boz's money went to her after he died. No, maybe he gets hit off, but she gets some, but she's rich because of her parents.
1:41:51 Speaker 03 Because of killing her parents.
1:41:53 Bill Simmons? So Beth.
1:41:55 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:41:56 Bill Simmons? As a nitpick.
1:41:58 Bill Simmons? She falls for the broke cocaine-using alcoholic with one friend who shoots people randomly once a year and just had his wife kill herself? And she's like, "When you going to dinner tonight? Would you like to come?"
1:42:09 Speaker 03 Her dying words are, "I loved you."
1:42:12 Bill Simmons? Yeah, like, this was it for Beth? This guy's 20 years older than her?
1:42:16 Speaker 03 She's a psychiatrist, so this is like, this is her cocaine, right? Like, a good time every night with Nick.
1:42:22 Speaker 04 This is consistent, though.
1:42:24 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:42:24 Speaker 04 So, in The Departed, she falls in love.
1:42:27 Bill Simmons? Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:42:28 Speaker 04 Like, in The Sopranos, there's always this thing between Melville, like, "What's going on with these therapists?" I think they like that type of dumbass shit.
1:42:35 Bill Simmons? They like the danger.
1:42:38 Bill Simmons? Any more nitpicks? Because I'm gonna move on. Uh, sequel, prequel, prestige, TV, all black cast or untouchable? I'd like to at least walk through all black cast. What is... Because I feel like they have tried to make versions of this. What's... Is it, has, there's the one with, uh... What's, I'm trying to think. Help me out.
1:42:59 Speaker 04 Okay, what you talking about? Which one? Like, obsessed?
1:43:02 Bill Simmons? No, it's the one with Ally Larder.
1:43:04 Speaker 04 Oh, obsessed. That's the call obsessed with Beyonce. Beyonce's the motherfucker, and, um, and Idris Elba.
1:43:09 Bill Simmons? There's another with Megan Good, but they haven't...
1:43:12 Speaker 04 Megan Good, there's one...
1:43:13 Bill Simmons? They never really pulled it off.
1:43:14 Speaker 04 They haven't really pulled it off. There's a thin line between love and hate, which actually takes place in the Bay. Like, with, like, with Martin Lawrence and Lil Whitfield and stuff like that, it's tough. We don't, we don't like depicting our sisters like that, you know what I'm saying? Our sisters don't get obsessed and shit like that.
1:43:26 Bill Simmons? Prestige TV, could that work?
1:43:28 Speaker 03 Definitely.
1:43:30 Chris Ryan? Only to explain the ending. I would, I don't, I mean, I guess you could, you could do it as prestige TV. I, I will note that...
1:43:36 Bill Simmons? Would you go backwards to Berkeley with Beth and Catherine?
1:43:39 Chris Ryan? I would go back to the Manny Vasquez years.
1:43:40 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:43:41 Chris Ryan? The boxing. I'd make a boxing show with Catherine as, as his girlfriend. But, you know, they, they made Basic Instinct 2, much maligned.
1:43:48 Bill Simmons? It's horrible. Please don't rent Basic Instinct 2.
1:43:51 Chris Ryan? And a year ago, uh, Joe Esterhas, who is 80, reportedly sold a screenplay to Amazon for $2 million that was going to be an anti-woke reboot of Basic Instinct, because Basic Instinct is too woke.
1:44:07 Chris Ryan? And he gave this quote. "To those who question what an 80-year-old man is doing writing a sexy erotic thriller, "the rumors of my cinematic impotence are exaggerated and ageist. "I call my writing parter," all caps, "the twisted little man, "and he lives somewhere deep inside me. "He was born 29, he will die 29. "And he tells me, 'Sky high up!' "to write this piece and provide viewers with a wild and orgasmic ride." Do you want to see this?
1:44:44 Speaker 03 Yes.
1:44:46 Bill Simmons? We should have made you read that as Vincent Hanna. Is this movie better with Wayne Jenkins, Fergie the florist, Zane Lowe, or somebody else here?
1:44:59 Chris Ryan? Nick, man. "From nights of cocaine-fueled sex to days of shooting tourists, "you've done it all. "So what is it that gets you fired up? "Could it be the bestselling author of mass-market paperbacks "uncrossing her legs in the interrogation room? "And where does Nick Curran go from here?"
1:45:21 Speaker 03 Incredible. Incredible. Amazing. I was hoping you would do Wayne. Give us a quick Wayne. Here's the contacts. Catherine is on a book.
1:45:35 Chris Ryan? Goddamn!
1:45:36 Speaker 03 She's on a book tour. She's gone to Baltimore on her book tour. Go.
1:45:40 Chris Ryan? What is she doing in Baltimore?
1:45:41 Speaker 03 On a book tour for her bestseller.
1:45:43 Chris Ryan? Oh, I was just gonna say, if Wayne was Gus, it would be like, "Goddamn, Nick, you got sweetie birds flying around your head!"
1:45:53 Speaker 03 Give us magical, loud pussy in a Baltimore accent. Do it.
1:45:58 Bill Simmons? He's not prepared for this.
1:46:00 Speaker 03 Going down to the ocean, hon.
1:46:02 Bill Simmons? Can I give you, um, Ryan Ruko?
1:46:06 Speaker 03 Please, sure.
1:46:07 Bill Simmons? Announcing the first scene of the movie? Catherine's writing and now she's reaching back. Is she going for the ice pick? You bet.
1:46:18 Bill Simmons? Shout out to Ruko. Just one Oscar, who gets it?
1:46:22 Speaker 05 Stone.
1:46:22 Speaker 03 Sharon Stone.
1:46:23 Bill Simmons? All right. We all agree. Probably an answerable questions. Dan, was it a big deal when Manny the boxer died in the ring in 1984? Like, cover of Sports Illustrated?
1:46:33 Speaker 05 Had to be a huge deal, right?
1:46:35 Bill Simmons? Like, led SportsCenter?
1:46:36 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:46:37 Bill Simmons? Yeah, I felt like it was a big deal, too.
1:46:40 Chris Ryan? That was also another really weird cop moment, is when they're like, "Maybe if she put on Afro and did blackface, she could be Magna." I'm like, "What the fuck are you talking about?"
1:46:49 Bill Simmons? See? I was gonna let it slide.
1:46:55 Bill Simmons? How long did they date after the movie ended?
1:46:57 Speaker 03 Well, how long till she kills him, right? Because that's the answer.
1:47:00 Bill Simmons? Like, is Nick still alive in 1995?
1:47:04 Speaker 03 No.
1:47:04 Speaker 05 No.
1:47:04 Speaker 03 No, Nick's-
1:47:05 Bill Simmons? No.
1:47:05 Chris Ryan? Nick has died of a massive cocaine-induced heart attack.
1:47:08 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:47:09 Speaker 05 Yeah, he mentions Rugrats at the grocery store later that day, and she stabs him, I think.
1:47:15 Speaker 03 If he doesn't retract the Rugrats line, because she's like, "I hate Rugrats," she kills him right then and there. No question. So, it's gotta be just a matter of days. I'm always on the unanswerable questions and how long does he last front. Like, at what point is he like, "Let me see some more of your pages about this detective, so that I can just avoid the exact scenario"
1:47:36 Bill Simmons? Right.
1:47:37 Speaker 03 "that you have crafted and live a little longer." But he doesn't ask.
1:47:40 Bill Simmons? I think they, I think Montana goes to the Chiefs, Nick unravels, he's back on the coke, and then she just kills him because he's annoying.
1:47:49 Chris Ryan? He just never believes in Steve Young.
1:47:50 Bill Simmons? Yeah, she just had it. She stabs him to death.
1:47:53 Bill Simmons? Should she have just killed him at the ending?
1:47:56 Bill Simmons? Is that a better ending?
1:47:58 Speaker 03 No.
1:47:58 Chris Ryan? I think it would be like-
1:47:59 Bill Simmons? If she murders him and that's the end of the movie?
1:48:02 Chris Ryan? I don't think it would be like a fun theater going experience if the last thing you see is Michael Douglas dying. Maybe it would be just.
1:48:10 Speaker 04 If the movie ends not with his actual death, but with her grabbing the ice pick, like actually grabbing the ice pick, then you leave on something a little bit more.
1:48:20 Bill Simmons? Can we do like the Sopranos ending?
1:48:21 Speaker 04 Kind of same.
1:48:22 Speaker 03 I like it, I like it just like it is because it's there, she reaches for it, then she retracts. So there's enough to like, I mean, you wanted to debate whether.
1:48:31 Chris Ryan? I was curious, I mean, like, I think, I, I, I weirdly like, there's 8% of me that's like, but Beth could have done, could have done it. And Catherine also could be crazy.
1:48:41 Speaker 03 The ice pick's just there.
1:48:42 Chris Ryan? At the same time.
1:48:42 Speaker 03 Yeah. I like that this is your like spinning top at the end of Inception.
1:48:46 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
1:48:46 Speaker 03 You're like, was it moving?
1:48:47 Chris Ryan? It's haunted me for 30 years.
1:48:50 Bill Simmons? Secret handshake club memorabilia you'd want from this movie? A copy of Love Hurts by Catherine Wolf?
1:48:55 Speaker 03 Ooh.
1:48:56 Chris Ryan? V-neck.
1:48:57 Speaker 03 Shooter.
1:48:57 Bill Simmons? The V-neck sweater.
1:48:58 Chris Ryan? Yeah, the V-neck.
1:48:59 Bill Simmons? Would you wear it?
1:49:00 Chris Ryan? I mean, if I had it, yeah.
1:49:03 Bill Simmons? What do you have, Craig?
1:49:04 Speaker 05 Um, those, those giant red like semen glasses that he wears.
1:49:08 Speaker 03 Yeah, yes.
1:49:10 Speaker 05 Imagine I just got those on when you come over?
1:49:12 Speaker 03 Great one.
1:49:13 Speaker 05 You know what these are from?
1:49:14 Speaker 03 Great one.
1:49:14 Speaker 05 Johnny Bows's apartment.
1:49:15 Bill Simmons? They're called the semen glasses. New from Chrome Hearts. Um, what would you have, Ben?
1:49:22 Speaker 04 I want the ice pick.
1:49:22 Speaker 03 Yeah, of course. It's gotta be the ice pick. Or the mirror, ceiling mirror.
1:49:25 Speaker 05 Mal, the storyboards.
1:49:27 Speaker 03 Well, I mean.
1:49:28 Bill Simmons? Oh my God, the storyboards.
1:49:30 Speaker 03 That would be great. I would frame them and I would display them tastefully next to my ceiling mirror.
1:49:35 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:49:37 Bill Simmons? The Coach Finstock Mr. Miyagi Award for Best Worst Life Lesson. I think it's, it's actually worth it to risk it all for the fuck of the century. I think is the lesson of this movie. I think Nick wins. Gets a girlfriend, breaks up with somebody he didn't really like that much anyway, gets out of a murder investigation. Gets rid of everybody at work that that he kinda hated. Big dub.
1:50:00 Speaker 03 She's loaded, she's got money, beautiful properties. I think the life lesson is wash your sheets.
1:50:05 Chris Ryan? Yeah.
1:50:08 Speaker 04 I think the life lesson is what Ha said. That's her pussy talking. It ain't your brain.
1:50:18 Speaker 04 That happens.
1:50:19 Bill Simmons? CR, what do you got for a double feature choice?
1:50:20 Chris Ryan? Jagged Edge, another Joe Estero House thriller, and it's also set in San Francisco.
1:50:25 Bill Simmons? I like that movie. I had Total Recall.
1:50:27 Speaker 04 Oh.
1:50:28 Speaker 03 Fatal Attraction.
1:50:29 Bill Simmons? Double ver- oh, Fatal.
1:50:31 Speaker 04 I had Body of Evidence.
1:50:33 Speaker 03 The Douglas.
1:50:33 Speaker 04 Which is the bad version of this movie.
1:50:35 Bill Simmons? That movie's awful.
1:50:36 Speaker 04 With Madonna and Willem Dafoe, which is interesting because the masturbation scene that you say that you want it.
1:50:42 Speaker 03 Yeah, sure.
1:50:43 Speaker 04 They actually do that in Body of Evidence.
1:50:46 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:50:46 Speaker 04 And Willem Dafoe is completely unprepared for it. Madonna just fucking goes for it, and he doesn't know what to do. The Green Goblin is like, what?
1:50:55 Speaker 03 Works every time.
1:50:56 Bill Simmons? It's a really horrible movie. Uh, who won the movie of Sharon Stone?
1:50:59 Speaker 03 No question.
1:51:00 Bill Simmons? Um, all right, we've never done this on a live show. Craig, we always go to him at the end to see what he thought of the movie, but you'd already seen this one.
1:51:07 Speaker 05 Well, because we did this five years ago. That's when I watched it. But I don't think you asked me on that on that show. Uh, this movie is just elite entertainment. We just, we didn't know how good we had it in the early 90s. Like, it's crazy to me that this movie was reviewed poorly, like, compared to what we have now. This movie looks fantastic, it has like an elite actor, great performance. It's based off nothing, huge star in it, made $400 million. Like, this would be the achievement of the fucking decade if this movie came out right now.
1:51:35 Speaker 03 Yeah, agreed.
1:51:37 Bill Simmons? All right.
1:51:37 Speaker 03 There we go.
1:51:41 Bill Simmons? I would also, uh, it's a very good 4K Blu-ray.
1:51:44 Speaker 03 Yes.
1:51:44 Speaker 04 I bet.
1:51:45 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
1:51:46 Speaker 03 Physical media era, yeah.
1:51:48 Bill Simmons? For the San Francisco scenes.
1:51:51 Speaker 03 Yeah. Yeah.
1:51:52 Speaker 04 No, but in all seriousness, though, one reason why this movie holds up, or it's so good, or you can watch it now and digest it so easily, is because San Francisco is a character in the movie.
1:52:02 Speaker 03 Yes.
1:52:03 Speaker 04 And we're not making as many movies where Los Angeles, San Francisco, San Diego are characters in these movies. And they are just like, those cities are immaculate in terms of the way you can film them. You can't fake it. Beautiful, yeah. You can't fake San Francisco. And so like, with that going away makes you have to make this movie, like, in fucking Atlanta or something like that, the volume or something.
1:52:25 Speaker 03 Basic instinct in the volume would be pretty funny.
1:52:27 Speaker 04 It's fucking stupid, right?
1:52:28 Speaker 03 That's its legacy, but also, you know, Michael Douglas saying, "I don't remember how often I used to jerk off, but it was a lot." Also important.
1:52:37 Speaker 04 Calluses.
1:52:37 Speaker 03 San Francisco's beauty and that, yeah.
1:52:39 Speaker 04 Yeah, you don't want to have calluses, that's bad.
1:52:41 Bill Simmons? Yeah.
1:52:42 Speaker 04 That'll hurt your guy.
1:52:43 Bill Simmons? Yeah, you guys take San Francisco for granted because you live there, but this city's awesome. And it's a really, really,
1:52:52 Bill Simmons? really, uh, really great movie location city. When you even walk around, you kind of feel like you're in a movie when you're here with all the hills and everything. If I lived here, the power walking, I was telling them, my legs, my legs would be like Adrian Peterson. I would, I would just be, I'd be in the greatest shape of my life. That guy would live here. Um, listen, thanks for coming out, we had a great time.
1:53:13 Speaker 03 Thank you.
1:53:14 Bill Simmons? This theater is awesome.
1:53:21 Bill Simmons? We, uh, we love this theater, so we're gonna come back. But thanks for having us, thanks for coming out. Have a great rest of the night, thank you.
Previous ‘Eddie and the Cruisers’ With Bill Simmons, Chris Ryan, and Van Lathan Next ‘Kindergarten Cop’ With Bill Simmons and Kyle Brandt Page updated October 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated