‘Ali’ With Bill Simmons, Chris Ryan, and Van Lathan
Hosted by Bill Simmons and Chris Ryan
- 1h 56m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
The hosts dissect the 2001 film Ali, directed by Michael Mann and starring Will Smith. Chris Ryan calls the opening twenty minutes the best any filmmaker has assembled, weaving Sam Cooke, Malcolm X, and Emmett Till into a single sequence. They debate whether the film is a sports biopic, a star vehicle, or a Mann movie about institutions crushing an individual. Bill Simmons identifies defiance as the theme; Van Lathan frames it as a story about what greatness cost Ali. The film's flaws are catalogued: a three-year time jump, missing dates, a score that pulls you out of the period, and Ebert's two-star review calling it a eulogy rather than a celebration.
The cast discussion highlights Jamie Foxx's Bundini Brown as the moment that introduced him as a serious actor, Mario Van Peebles' Malcolm X as the vehicle for the film's political content, and Jon Voight's unrecognizable Howard Cosell. Will Smith's physical transformation is praised, though the hosts note he performs best when not attempting the Ali voice. The episode also covers the film's development history—Spike Lee and Oliver Stone were both attached—and the box office result: $110 million budget, $87 million gross, losing money partly because the 2 hour 40 minute runtime limited daily screenings.
- The opening twenty minutes of Ali covers eighteen aspects of American life and is considered the most rewatchable sequence in the film, making it the reason viewers keep returning. 13:28
- Will Smith delivers his strongest performances in Ali when he is not speaking in the Ali voice, with physicality and reactions carrying key scenes. 33:17
- The essential question for any biopic is what it cost the subject—what love, relationships, and personal peace were sacrificed to achieve greatness. 57:29
- Michael Mann's imperial phase ran from Last of the Mohicans through Heat, The Insider, and Ali (1992–2001), four films with no obvious connection but shared thematic threads. 29:14
- Ali cost $110 million and grossed $87 million, losing money partly because its 2 hour 40 minute runtime limited it to two daily screenings instead of three. 55:27
Highlights
- 13:28
Opening Twenty Minutes as Symphonyinsight
Chris Ryan calls the opening twenty minutes the best any filmmaker has put together, covering eighteen aspects of American life with Sam Cooke, Malcolm X, and Emmett Till all interwoven in a single sequence.
- 15:29
The Real Man Beats the Fairy Taleinsight
Van Lathan argues Mann's thesis is that the real Muhammad Ali—burdened by government pressure, personal failings, and family problems—is more interesting than the fairy tale version people want to believe.
- 22:44
Malcolm X Carries the Political Weightinsight
The film channels the entire racial reckoning of the 1960s through Mario Van Peebles' Malcolm X rather than news footage, and the scene where Ali confronts Malcolm in Africa is called devastating.
- 33:17
Smith's Strongest Moments Are Silentinsight
Van Lathan argues Will Smith delivers his best work in the film when not attempting the Ali voice, with his physicality and reactions carrying scenes like seeing Malcolm X or the Terrell Wayan confrontation.
- 57:29
What Did It Cost Youstrategy
Van Lathan frames his single question for any biopic as what did it cost you—what love, what personal situations, what skeletons were left behind to achieve greatness—and argues this is what Ali is really about.
- 1:03:10
Van Lathan names the Bundini belt-selling scene and Ali watching Foreman knock out Frazier as his two favorites, calling the latter such a real scene where you feel everything is lined up.
- 1:38:18
Ali Visits the Setstory
Bill Simmons recounts that Will Smith avoided meeting Ali for months, then seven months into filming Ali visited and Smith did his trash talk for fifteen minutes, impressing Ali enough to ask why nobody told him he was so crazy.
- 1:41:22
Hitch as Smith's True Peakdebate
Van Lathan argues that Hitch, not Ali or Independence Day, represents Will Smith at his absolute peak because it is him directly demonstrating his star power without relying on big alien conceits.
About this episode
The Rewatchables ain't easy. The Rewatchables is real. And real… is a mother-fucker. Bill, Chris, and Van revisit Michael Mann’s 2001 film ‘Ali’ starring Will Smith, Jamie Foxx, and Jon Voight. Producers: Craig Horlbeck, Chia Hao Tat, Eduardo Ocampo, and Matt Pevic Try ZipRecruiter FOR FREE at https://ziprecruiter.com/REWATCHABLES Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
22,415 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Sports Biopics
- Michael Mann
- Will Smith
- Boxing Films
- Muhammad Ali
- Film Analysis
- Hollywood Casting
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated