
685. Hamilton: Duel to the Death (Part 3)
Hosted by Dominic Sandbrook and Tom Holland
- 1h 15m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode of The Rest Is History covers the duel between Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr on July 11, 1804, at Weehawken, New Jersey. Dominic Sandbrook narrates the full story from Hamilton's background as an orphan from Nevis who became Washington's aide and Treasury Secretary, through the Federalist-Democratic Republican rivalry of the 1790s, to the personal feud that culminated in the fatal shooting. Tom Holland reads Hamilton's farewell letter to his wife Eliza, written a week before the duel.
The hosts examine the ambiguity of what actually happened: Hamilton's second Pendleton claimed Hamilton aimed above Burr's head and never fired, while Burr's second Van Ness said Hamilton fired first and missed. Sandbrook argues Hamilton most likely did fire and deliberately miss, as he stated in a pre-duel letter, and that Burr then waited and shot him. They discuss the code duello, the hair-trigger pistols (possibly the same ones that killed Hamilton's son Philip in 1801), and the cultural context of dueling in early American politics.
The episode closes with Hamilton's death on July 12, his burial at Trinity Church, and Burr's subsequent fall from grace: a treason trial that failed for lack of evidence, exile in England, and his death in 1836, where he reportedly said that if he had read Laurence Stern more and Voltaire less, he would have known the world was wide enough for Hamilton and him.
- The vast majority of duels in early America—probably nine out of ten—did not end in anyone dying, as the pistols were designed to be inaccurate and most affairs of honour were settled before a shot was fired. 52:44
- Hamilton agreed to the duel not because he wanted to fight but because he believed public opinion would require it if he wished to remain politically useful in the crises ahead. 39:06
- The pistols Hamilton chose for the duel may have been the same ones his son Philip used in his own fatal duel three years earlier, a detail the hosts find deeply ominous. 49:39
- Historians remain divided on whether Burr deliberately killed Hamilton after Hamilton deliberately missed, with Joseph Ellis arguing Burr was justified and Ron Chernow calling it murder. 1:00:35
- Burr's final words, reportedly made while bedridden and reading Tristram Shandy, were that if he had read Laurence Stern more and Voltaire less, he would have known the world was wide enough for Hamilton and him. 1:10:51
Highlights
- 3:18
Hamilton's Farewell Letter to Elizastory
Tom Holland reads Hamilton's farewell letter to his wife Eliza, written a week before the duel, in which he says his love for her and his children would have been enough to avoid the confrontation but it was not possible without sacrifices that would render him unworthy of her esteem.
- 24:05
Hamilton's Scathing Letters on Burrdata
Hamilton wrote to friends in December 1800 and January 1801 calling Burr a profligate, a bankrupt, and a voluptuary, saying his only plan was getting power by any means and keeping it by all means, and that he would attempt a usurpation.
- 36:50
Philip Hamilton's Fatal Duelstory
In November 1801, Hamilton's son Philip challenged George Ica to a duel. Hamilton advised Philip to miss on purpose, but both men stood frozen for a minute, then Ica fired and Philip died. The doctor present was the same one who would attend Hamilton's own duel three years later.
- 41:38
Hamilton's Plan to Throw Away His Fireinsight
In a pre-duel statement, Hamilton wrote that he had resolved to reserve and throw away his first fire, and even his second, giving Burr a double opportunity to pause and reflect. Some historians see this as a press release designed to make him look like a martyr after his death.
- 49:27
The Ominous Choice of Pistolsinsight
The pistols used in the duel belonged to Hamilton's brother-in-law John Barker Church, who had himself fought a duel with Burr in 1799. The hosts note they may well be the same pistols Hamilton's son had used in his fatal duel three years earlier.
- 54:39
The Duel as It Actually Happenedstory
In the musical, Hamilton fires into the sky and Burr shoots him. In reality, two shots were fired within seconds of each other, Burr was unscathed, and Hamilton was hit just above his right hip, the ball ricocheting off his rib through his diaphragm and liver into his spine.
- 1:01:04
Did Burr Deliberately Kill Hamilton?debate
The hosts debate whether Burr knew Hamilton was deliberately missing. Joseph Ellis says Burr was within his rights under the code duello; Ron Chernow says the 12-foot miss made it obvious and Burr shot him dead like a dog. Jeremy Bentham later said Burr told him he was sure of being able to kill Hamilton and thought it little better than murder.
- 1:10:51
Burr's Final Regretinsight
At the end of his life, bedridden after strokes and reading Tristram Shandy, Burr reportedly said that if he had read Laurence Stern more and Voltaire less, he should have known that the world was wide enough for Hamilton and him.
About this episode
How did Alexander Hamilton go from impoverished orphan to one of the most important figures in the creation of the American constitution? Why was his relationship with Thomas Jefferson so strained? And, what happened in the famous duel that would ultimately claim his life…? Join Dominic and Tom as they discuss one of America’s most fiery founding fathers: Alexander Hamilton, and his duel with Aaron Burr. Join The Rest Is History Club: Unlock the full experience of the show – with exclusive bonus episodes, ad-free listening, early access to every series and live show tickets, a members-only newsletter, discounted books from the show, and access to our private Discord chatroom. Sign up directly at therestishistory.com. To read our new newsletter, sign up at: therestishistory.com/newsletters _______ Lloyds. 250 years on and still backing the nation's aspirations. _______ Advertise with us: Partnerships@goalhanger.com _______ Twitter: @TheRestHistory @holland_tom @dcsandbrook Video Editors: Jack Meek, Harry Swan + Adam Thornton Social Producer: Harry Balden Producers: Tabby Syrett & Aaliyah Akude Senior Producer: Callum Hill Executive Producer: Dom Johnson Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
13,883 words · 7 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- American History
- Dueling Culture
- Federalist Party
- Early Republic
- Political Rivalry
- Code Duello
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated