Skip to content

677. USA: The Star-Spangled Banner (Part 1)

The Rest Is History

Hosted by Dominic Sandbrook and Tom Holland

1h 10m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Dominic Sandbrook and Tom Holland trace the origins of the Star-Spangled Banner through the War of 1812, the British bombardment of Fort McHenry in September 1814, and the life of Francis Scott Key, the slave-owning Maryland lawyer who watched the attack from a British ship. They cover the four reasons the war broke out, the failed American invasions of Canada, the British Chesapeake Bay Campaign, and the specific events of the 25-hour bombardment that produced 700 rockets and 1,500 shells but only four deaths at the fort.

The central argument concerns the line "no refuge could save the hireling and slave." Sandbrook presents evidence that Key was referring to escaped African American slaves who had joined the British Corps of Colonial Marines, rather than merely using Revolutionary-era rhetoric about British soldiers. He details Key's ownership of eight slaves, his anti-abolitionist prosecutions in the 1830s, and his role in the American Colonisation Society. Tom Holland pushes back, noting the Revolutionary-era usage of "slave" for British subjects, and the two settle on genuine ambiguity. The episode also covers the song's English tune, its 19-semitone vocal range, its 1931 adoption as the national anthem, and its many controversial performances from Jose Feliciano to Colin Kaepernick.

The episode is notable for its myth-busting (the envelope story, the flag being shot at) and for the abolitionist counter-version written in The Liberator in 1844, which Sandbrook reads in full.

  • The "hireling and slave" line in the Star Spangled Banner likely refers to escaped slaves who joined the British Corps of Colonial Marines, not just British soldiers. 39:44
  • The Star Spangled Banner's tune is an English song called The Anacreontic Song, written in 1775 by John Stafford Smith. 28:28
  • The flag in the anthem was 42 feet by 30 feet, made by Mary Pickersgill over six weeks for $405.90. 21:04
  • The Star Spangled Banner demands a vocal range of 19 semitones, which even some professional singers cannot achieve. 57:10
  • Abolitionists wrote their own version of the Star Spangled Banner in 1844 in The Liberator, turning the final lines into a bitter indictment of slavery. 1:06:01

Highlights

  • 19:01

    Bombardment Numbers Reveal Ineffectivenessdata

    The British fired 700 rockets and 1,500 shells over 24 hours but killed only four people and wounded 24, because Fort McHenry's powerful artillery forced them to stay at the limit of their range.

  • 21:04

    The Flag's True Historystory

    The 42-by-30-foot flag was commissioned by Major Armistead as a symbol of defiance, made by Mary Pickersgill and her family over six weeks using 300 yards of English wool bunting. A smaller storm flag flew during the bombardment; the big one was raised at dawn.

  • 23:07

    The Envelope Myth Bustedinsight

    Historian Mark Clegg established that envelopes were not in common use in 1814, so Key could not have written the poem on the back of one. He used high-quality note paper he carried for the prisoner negotiations.

  • 28:28

    The English Tune Behind the Antheminsight

    The melody is The Anacreontic Song, written in 1775 by John Stafford Smith for a London music club. It was not a bawdy drinking song but a classical-style piece performed with harpsichord accompaniment. By 1820, at least 80 different songs used the same melody.

  • 39:44

    Hireling and Slave: A Real Disagreementdebate

    Holland argues the words are Revolutionary-era insults for British soldiers and Hessian mercenaries. Sandbrook counters with evidence of escaped slaves joining the British and Key's own anti-abolitionist record, but concedes the ambiguity is genuine.

  • 41:50

    Arming the Escaped Slavesstory

    Rear Admiral Cochrane ordered all male runaway slaves armed in red uniforms as the Corps of Colonial Marines. They saw action in Virginia and some participated in the burning of Washington. Cochrane refused to return them after the war; many settled in Trinidad and are still called Americans.

  • 57:10

    Why the Anthem Is So Hard to Singdata

    The melody demands a range of 19 semitones, which even some professional singers cannot achieve. This was the biggest objection to making it the national anthem, alongside its British origin and war-celebrating content.

  • 1:06:01

    The Abolitionist Counter-Antheminsight

    In 1844, activist E.A. Atlee published a version in The Liberator that turned the final lines into an indictment: "doth our star-spangled banner yet wave, O, the land of the free and the home of the brave?" Sandbrook notes the bitter irony that Key's own targets wrote back.

About this episode

How did the War of 1812 result in America’s national anthem, the Star Spangled Banner? Who came up with it? And, why does this origin story make the anthem so controversial? Join Dominic and Tom as they launch into the first episode of their Football World Cup special, with the story behind America’s national anthem, and its secret story. _______ *Father’s Day discounted gift memberships available here. Treat your dad to ad-free listening, early access to full series, bonus episodes, and much more.* Join The Rest Is History Club: Unlock the full experience of the show – with exclusive bonus episodes, ad-free listening, early access to every series and live show tickets, a members-only newsletter, discounted books from the show, and access to our private Discord chatroom. Sign up directly at the⁠restishistory.com⁠ To read our new newsletter, sign up at: therestishistory.com/newsletters _______ Lloyds. 250 years on and still backing the nation's aspirations. Advertise with us: Partnerships@goalhanger.com _______ Twitter: @TheRestHistory @holland_tom @dcsandbrook Video Editors: Jack Meek, Harry Swan + Adam Thornton Social Producer: Harry Balden Producers: Tabby Syrett & Aaliyah Akude Senior Producer: Callum Hill Executive Producer: Dom Johnson Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript

0:00
1:10:44

12,302 words · 7 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • National Anthems
  • War of 1812
  • Slavery in America
  • Francis Scott Key
  • Fort McHenry
  • American Music History
  • Civil Rights
  • British-American Relations

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated