Can Beauty Make Us Good?
The Permanent Questions With David Brooks
Hosted by David Brooks
- 1h 16m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
In this episode of The Permanent Questions, David Brooks talks with literature professor and humanist Elaine Scarry about the enduring nature of beauty, how we perceive it, and whether experiencing beauty makes us better people. They discuss Scarry's 1999 book, On Beauty and Being Just, exploring how beauty acts as a wake-up call to perceptual care, counters injury, and underpins our concepts of symmetry and justice. The conversation touches on diverse forms of beauty, from mathematics and nature to literature and human connection, while confronting both the historical backlash against beauty in the academy and the modern challenges of cynicism and artificial intelligence.
- Train your perceptual acuity by actively paying attention to the astonishing plenitude and fine color gradations in the world around you. 3:28
- Recognize that encountering beauty acts as a life-saving force that deepens attention and counters aversive injuries. 13:16
- Orient your life toward infinite goods like beauty, meaning, and connection rather than finite pursuits like status or power. 28:50
- Counteract cynicism by cultivating love for the world, utilizing aesthetic appreciation to restore trust and resilience. 22:00
Chapters
- 0:00Podcast Intro and Theme Announcement
David Brooks introduces the episode’s focus on beauty and its humanizing power, setting the stage for a conversation with Elaine Scary.
- 0:45Defining Beauty in Modern Academia
Elaine Scary explains her 1999 book and her defense of beauty against the academy’s assault, framing beauty as a central aesthetic value.
- 2:00Personal Encounters with Beauty
Brooks shares moments of awe at beautiful scenes, while Scary recounts how repeated exposure to beauty sharpens perception over time.
- 3:30Beauty’s Impact on Perception and Emotion
The discussion turns to how beauty heightens perceptual acuity and emotional granularity, linking aesthetic experience to cognitive awareness.
- 8:00Evolutionary Roots of Beauty
They explore how evolutionary pressures for symmetry and health may underlie universal beauty standards and moral intuitions.
- 16:00Beauty’s Therapeutic and Healing Power
They review studies linking beauty to faster recovery, moral health, and the restorative effects of beautiful environments.
- 30:12Beauty, Morality, and Social Justice
The conversation examines whether beauty can foster virtuous behavior and influence justice, referencing philosophers and historical examples.
- 49:47Teaching and Cultivating Aesthetic Taste
Brooks and Scary discuss methods for educating taste, the role of exposure, and the balance between universal and personal beauty.
- 54:04Closing Reflections on Beauty’s Role in Life
The episode concludes with final thoughts on how beauty shapes identity, community, and the pursuit of a meaningful life.
- 55:03Augustinian Order of Loves and Moral Disordering
Brooks introduces Augustine’s hierarchy of loves, illustrating how misplaced priorities lead to disordered behavior and moral failure.
- 56:23Beauty’s Influence on Perception and Inner Moral Beauty
Speakers debate how physical beauty can mislead us, yet often prompts a deeper search for inner moral beauty and ethical reflection.
- 59:26Children’s Stories and the Beauty–Ugliness Narrative
The hosts explore how fairy tales and literature use beauty and ugliness to teach moral lessons about inner worth versus external appearance.
Highlights
- 2:40
Living Without Aesthetic Awarenessstory
David Brooks confesses to being an aesthetic philistine during the writing of his first book in a dank, mildewed basement, oblivious to his surroundings.
- 4:39
Expanding Color Granularityinsight
Elaine Scarry describes how reading Tale of Genji prompted pools of color in her mind, illustrating how humans develop an awareness of color and beauty over time.
- 6:24
Raising Perceptual Acuityinsight
Encountering beauty raises the observer's standard of perceptual care, teaching us to pay closer attention to everyday things in the world.
- 10:04
Symmetry Across Disciplinesinsight
Symmetry and proportion are core concepts shared across mathematics, music, dance, human faces, and the physical universe.
- 14:34
Green Windows Speed Recoverydata
Patients recovering from surgery in hospital rooms with windows overlooking a green grove healed much more quickly than those looking at a brick wall.
- 18:38
Miniature Tapestries in Prisonstory
Women in a Romanian prison survived by weaving tiny one-inch tapestries from threads pulled from their undergarments and giving them to each other.
- 40:05
Loss of Symmetrical Thinkingdebate
Elaine Scarry argues that the United States has lost the ability to think symmetrically, citing extreme wealth gaps and disproportionate military power bases.
- 1:03:21
Rejecting AI Generated Poetryinsight
Elaine Scarry asserts that learning a poem was written by AI makes it feel dead in the heart, proving that human origin is crucial.
Quotes
“And if you count gray tones, it's closer to a million.”
Unnamed speaker · 4:04 “And half of them had a window that looked out onto a green grove and the other half had a window that looked out onto a brick wall.”
Unnamed speaker · 14:34 “And that that is a profound effect, that you actually undergo this launch from what you thought was the center of the world, off to the periphery, and you're really happy about it.”
Unnamed speaker · 32:07 “I'm a big Augustineian, and his whole moral system is built around that there's an order of loves.”
David Brooks · 55:03 “And I like this concept of desire as self-transcendence.”
David Brooks · 56:01 “That is, we assume the person will have inner beauty, and then if they don't, we feel this is a sham.”
Unnamed speaker · 57:07 “And by the end of the 20 minutes, I saw not a blue painting, I saw 800 different kinds of blue somewhere in there.”
David Brooks · 1:06:17 “I do think the constant act of experiencing beauty over years, over decades does enlarge the soul and does make us kinder towards others, more considerate towards others, and greater in our longing for the good.”
David Brooks · 1:15:38
Sponsored segments
- Lexus 0:05–0:14
- Lexus 25:58–26:32
- On Solid Ground 26:24–26:57
- Yale 46:22–46:38
About this episode
What is beauty? Is it really “in the eye of the beholder,” or is it an objective quality that exists in the world? Is it a mere decorative feature of life, or does it have something important to tell us? These are enduring human questions, but ones that the art world and the academic humanities—the natural custodians of beauty—gave up answering for a long time. In this episode, David Brooks talks to the Harvard professor Elaine Scarry, whose now-classic book On Beauty and Being Just brought the subject back to serious attention 25 years ago. David and Scarry discuss the ladder of loves, the universal appeal of symmetry, and why even prisoners at Guantánamo want to look at pretty pictures. - - - Get more from your favorite Atlantic voices when you subscribe. You’ll enjoy unlimited access to Pulitzer-winning journalism, from clear-eyed analysis and insight on breaking news to fascinating explorations of our world. Atlantic subscribers also get access to exclusive subscriber audio in Apple Podcasts. Subscribe today at TheAtlantic.com/Listener. “The Permanent Questions” is produced and edited by The Atlantic in partnership with Yale University. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
12,756 words · 6 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Jane Eyre
- Harvard University
- Planet Visionaries
- On Beauty and Being Just
- National Geographic
- Jane Goodall Institute
- Rolex Perpetual Planet Initiative
- Honnold Foundation
- De Musica
- Catholic University
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated