The Case Of
Original podcast
Where to listenCopy share link
Take a peek into the world of a barrister who defends society’s most reviled characters.
4,118 words · 5 speakers
ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
So Erin Patterson has a team of people in her corner. They're fighting for her as she pleads not guilty to three murder charges and five attempted murder charges. They're her defence team and in this episode, we're going to find out how they're likely to be doing their job. I'm the ABC's court reporter, Christian Silver.
I'm Stephen Stockwell and this is Mushroom Case Daily.
So Stocky, both of us always get asked the same question when we tell people we make this podcast and that we're interested in the Erin Patterson case.
100% and that question is, without fail, every single time, did Erin Patterson do it?
Absolutely.
And I didn't know how to answer that at the start, but it's been, I don't know how many months now and I've just started telling the truth. I don't know.
And we don't know until this is all decided at the trial.
We have no idea, but as we look into the key voices in the room, like the prosecutors and the jurors, there's one group, the defence, who would have spoken to her the most about this.
Yeah, that's right. They're the people who are fighting in her corner. They're her closest allies. They're the people who are going to be fighting the charges that have been laid by prosecutors. And we wanted to give you an idea of what it's like to be in their shoes to work on a massive trial like this.
I'm Rishi Nethwani and I'm a barrister at the Victorian Bar.
How many murder trials would you have worked on, do you know?
In England, I think it was somewhere between 10 and 15. I can't give you an exact number. Not all go to trial. And then here, usually two or three a year. So roughly do the math, it's about 15.
Is that a lot? Yeah, that's pretty decent. Look, when it comes to these types of things, you've also got to look at the types of cases that barristers cover. So Rishi has become a pretty well-known figure around Victoria's court precinct in the last few years. He's had some pretty high-profile cases and clients too. I mean, he's represented Nicola Gobbo, a very polarising figure in the Victorian legal scene. He's also dealt with some pretty confronting murder trials. I can think of a few. There was one involving a guy who was found guilty of bashing a toddler to death. There was another one where a pretty infamous figure from a
gangland family, Ricardo Barbaro, stabbed his girlfriend to death. Yeah, and probably the one that sticks out to me in recent times has just been incredibly confronting was a case where a father assassinated his own daughter and son-in-law, and Rishi was acting for that man in a recent appeal.
Oh, wow. And Rishi, just to clarify, is a barrister. So that's a little bit different to like a normal solicitor. A barrister kind of works themselves. They're an expert in arguing in court. Is that right? They've got like the little wigs, the robes, all that kind of bit?
Yeah, I mean, they're seen as independent practitioners. On the robes, you do see them wearing robes. That is a common thing for barristers to do in Victorian courts. The wigs, not so much these days, less and less common, but occasionally, yep, you still do see them.
Yep, great. And someone like Rishi will be brought in by like a law firm that's acting on behalf of someone who's been charged with something like murder or terrorism offence, something like that. And his work would start well before the trial. He will be spending months, sometimes years, working with his clients, studying evidence, all that sort of thing.
You could have a murder case with just one or two witnesses and not much else to it, where you'd just be attacking two witnesses who might implicate your client. More often than not in murder cases, because the person's died, they can't be an eyewitness for obvious reasons. So they're more circumstantial, the cases. The prosecution and the police try and build blocks to try and suggest there's only one person responsible. And that's where there's a lot more work, because you have to take down each little block or look at which area is not completely correct. And so it depends, but sometimes they're massive. So the ones I've been doing more recently have months of preparation.
Yeah. Do you often find that you have just this huge brief of evidence almost kind of dumped on you when you're when you're working towards something like that?
Yeah, it sometimes can happen. Usually on a murder, you would have lead barrister, you'd have a junior barrister as well, and at least one solicitor. And depending on the size of the firm, you might have a couple of more. But, you know, you compare that to the other side. They've got two prosecution barristers, they might even have a third, they'd have an old army of the OPP lawyers who help them. They've got about a billion police officers and they've started from the beginning. And they know what there is whilst you're batting in the dark sometimes. So, you know, it's always us representing the little person against the state.
You're in the room on the on the first day. What's going through your head and what are you trying to make sure you're communicating and getting across in that room?
So day one is, look, when you're defending, it's usually quite difficult to, you don't argue your case until the closing address, which is right at the end, because there's set rules for when you're defending. So you know the prosecution goes first and it's supposed to be an opening, but the good prosecutors are in effect setting a narrative early on. And so you've got to take on that narrative. So what you're doing at the beginning is twofold. You do an opening which takes that on. But I've always had a basic rule and so do the team we work with. Where there's a jury, you want those people to buy into you and like you. And it starts from the beginning. And because if they like us, they're more
likely to like our client, whereas if they hate us, the same is to rub off on our client. So you're trying to get them on board, you know, be it charm them, jokes, whatever it is, but you've got to pitch it. And obviously it takes experience. But I usually am pretty sure that. The jury will like our team at least the same, if not more than our opponents. And that's always a start. And you'll get that as you go through the trial. So sometimes you'll play the fool or poke fun at yourself in front of them. But it's all part of endearing themselves with the jury.
It's not about making sure that they understand the evidence and can make the kind of correct decision on the weight of what's presented to them?
Well, at the beginning, it's very difficult for them to consider any evidence because day one, there is no evidence.
Over time, yeah, understanding the deficiencies in a witness and trying to make sure they really, really understand the burden of standard proof, which is the prosecutors bring the case, they have to prove it, and there's a lot riding on this.
When you cross-examine witnesses, what sort of preparation are you doing in advance?
There's quite a bit.
There's usually a pre-trial hearing. So you get a witness statement from the witness and you'll often get material that might undermine bits of what they say. You may also have other witnesses who say something different to them that you have sketched out. And then you've got all this other material from their pre-trial cross-examination, which is recorded. Now, there's a whole tactic that goes into the pre-trial cross-examination. Sometimes you don't play your hand. If they've lied in a statement, you want them to repeat it on oath. And then you've got them having repeated it twice and you can say, right, you said this on this occasion, this occasion, actually, the truth is this. And again, it's all part of the tactics. You might be really nice and soft and weak at the pre-trial cross-examination. This star witness might think they've got it over you.
So when they see you about to cross-examine them at the trial, they think this is going to be easy and then you show your teeth.
Wow.
And there's other ways. Sometimes I'll spend a day just setting up a witness so they think they're winning and being really soft with them. And then just at the end of day one, starting to give them a bit of a tickle and then by day two, we've destroyed them.
That is forthright. So there's a plan sometimes to set them up.
Oh, very much so.
Yeah. And are you, when you're preparing for that, are you almost playing out that scenario with your other colleagues, pretending to be that witness almost sometimes?
No, we don't really, I don't rehearse or practise. And it's not setting someone up in the sense of being any tricks. It's someone's lied. We can prove the lie. It's when to deploy the lie. And sometimes you leave it until very late in the piece.
To get that maximum effect to
Precisely.
To get the jury.
Well, because the problem is if you did it in a pre-trial, which is sometimes a year, 18 months before the trial, the effect is they've then got that year, 18 months to come up with a better answer in front of a jury. And it's the answer in front of the jury that's important.
What do you say to the clients when the jury's out of the room or even when the client's back in the cells, when court's not in session? How much contact do you have with them during a trial?
Quite a bit. I mean, up to that point, you've spent quite a bit of time with them. You know, usually I'm instructed on the murders from the very beginning. So you've almost had them for two, three years and you've got to know them. And you're checking in, keeping their feet grounded, whether it's a bad day or a good day. And, you know, they've got a lot riding on it. And that's why there's a team.
And these people, often the worst ones, especially on murder trials, they're hearing the most damning things said about them. What instructions do you give them about how to act in the dock and how to appear as basically their character is being torn to shreds?
Yeah, it's very difficult, isn't it? Because the problem with a, not the problem, but the way a criminal trial plays out, an accused person doesn't get to say anything until right at the end. So like I already discussed the opening, prosecution get to say how terrible this person is and the terrible the offence they've committed is. There's lots of evidence about it. And so they almost sit there pulling their hair out, thinking, oh my god, this is really bad. And you have to tell them, look, it's going to get better. There's our chance to cross-examine witnesses to show they're not telling the truth, and our chance at the interdoor closing. And on a day by day, you just have to tell them to act, you say act normally and naturally, but that's a bit artificial, isn't it? Because how many people
sit in the back of a room, have your name bandied about non-stop with jurors walking or staring at you? You know, it's difficult, but you just ask them to look normal and engage normally. And I try not to say too much to them.
Yeah.
Because the more you say, actually, you need to do this, you need to say this, in fact, people behave the reverse and then become more self-conscious. So you just, I usually say, just try and maintain normal eye contact. And it's difficult, but we'll make the jury aware it's difficult.
You know, talking about the people that you will be working with and representing, you know, while they're having awful things said about their character, you know, in some instances, they have done awful things. How do you reconcile your morals with standing up there and defending them, trying to pardon them in some of those situations?
Easily. I reckon, there's a couple of things. First is, I'm not representing the state. They've got, as we've said, two barristers, sometimes three, about a hundred billion OPP solicitors, about a thousand police officers all on their side, doing what they need to do. The whole process has to be fair, and people have to be properly represented, and the guilty are convicted and dealt with, and those where there is doubt acquitted. That's our system. And I'm there to look after those people who are accused, and will always do so with ease. You know, I've represented people accused of, and some convicted of, the most horrendous stuff.
Um. But I wasn't there to judge them. A jury will hear the evidence. They're saying they're not guilty and let the jury decide. I trust the system.
But surely, Rishi, there must be some cases where the client insists on pleading not guilty and you've seen the evidence. And it's obvious.
I don't know if it's it's obvious because, again, I wasn't there, you weren't there. The person accused is the one who will be able to tell you, look, I either did or didn't do this. And as you know, you say to them, we're obliged to, to every person, that this is how we think it's going to play out. These are the problem bits of evidence. If you lose, you get a much bigger sentence than if you plead guilty. If you plead guilty, you get a deal. But then the additional factor is the prosecution quite often overcharge things.
Hmm.
You know, so they might, for example, charge five murders when there's any evidence of one. And it makes a huge difference and then not be prepared to do deals or look at the evidence. You know, they just get carried away. So there's there's sometimes a lot in that. Sometimes they charge murder when it should be charged as a manslaughter. You know, it is. It's not as straightforward as either guilty or not guilty. It's a lot more nuanced and so we're there to look after and fearlessly defend.
When you've been representing some of these clients for a few years, building up to the trial and then, you know, going through the motions of the trial. How personally invested are you in what happens to this person?
You, it's it's it's that's multi-layered. You always, you build up a rapport with your clients. Um. You know, I've represented hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of people over the years and I don't think there are many. Um. That I didn't have a relationship, a good relationship with at times. Um. There's only one or two that you think are truly, truly, truly
bad people, you know. Most of them are just people who have made a mistake or committed an offence but have redeeming qualities like every human on earth. So, you know, you you can invest in some ways. I also hate losing, which is separate, the professional pride. So I always want to win.
But then I'm also a bit detached because I've done it for so long. You know, you can see, I, there's only been a few verdicts that have truly lived with me, where I thought the jury should never have convicted. Only two or three over a long period of time. On the others where if I can see how it happened and if the trial's fair, I deal with it because as I've said, this is about the system. We do our best to defend people and just believe in the jury system. And more often than not, I hope the juries get it right. Occasionally, I think.
There have been times when they haven't, but it is what it is.
It's really interesting to hear Rishi kind of like criticize a jury like that. Or, you know, sort of you point to examples where he thinks they've got it wrong. Yeah, I was expecting him to have this sort of, you know, quite lofty view of the judicial system and its infallibility or something like that. But yeah, it sort of challenges that.
Well, I guess it shows that he's invested in the process and invested in his work. And while there is a level of detachment, he doesn't like to lose. He's competitive, which is, which is definitely, you know, what you want. If you've got, you know, a case hanging over your head and you need someone to defend you. And thinking about that, you know, you've built up that connection with a client as a lawyer for perhaps a number of years. You've defended them throughout the trial. All the evidence has been aired and then the jury goes out to deliberate.
It's always the worst time. You get other work and you try and prepare other stuff, but it's a complete waste of time. Because you're in tender hooks, because we get a phone call. So we sit around and you get the phone call and you're like, is this it? No, it's not it. It's someone calling, you know, to try and sell me something. And then, oh, is this it? And then you go to court and you find out actually it's just a jury question. So it's tricky. And if we're nervous and anxious, just imagine how the accused feels. And, you know, I've done this so many times, but each time it gets you. You know, your mind's with whatever the verdict is.
When that jury walks in, people love to become like body, body language readers. Do you ever get a sense when they walk in that you know what that verdict's going to be? Or?
Sometimes, so the general, you know, the profession has a view. I think it's probably right if the jury are laughing and joking, you can hear them in their room after they've knocked on the door or buzzed. It's usually a good sign, you know, because people take very seriously if they're going to convict someone of murder. And then usually when they come into court, eye contact's interesting. So if the jury are looking at counsel on one side or the other, it's usually an indication. So the one I did in this, the jury came in, my solicitor and junior were both very anxious, as was I, but they were worried. And I looked at a cup and one of the jurors smiled at me straight away and I just said, yeah, we've won.
Wow. How do you feel after a win?
Good. The, the reality is you've run it because more often than not, there is a doubt and you just feel that the system has got it right. You feel like the jury have done their job and we've done our jobs. And, you know, when you, you lose, you're disappointed. But as I said earlier, if it was a fair trial and it was taken on and considered fairly and everyone behaved properly. And there was evidence to convict someone, I can reconcile it. But obviously when you win, you're delighted and then the next day I'm usually exhausted. It then hits me like a, a train and I probably need a few days downtime.
It must be an incredibly draining job, like the work you're doing, the people you're, you know, you're working with. You know, the weight that you take on as you're trying to, you know, keep these people's lives existing out in the community. It is so much work, going through all the discovery, preparing everything during the trial, living through that. What keeps you coming back?
It's a great job. It's, we were talking about the verdict and.
There is no better drama, I mean on any case, even on the small little cases. When a jury comes in and you're not sure what the verdict is in that moment. It's pretty electric in every courtroom.
We love it in the media.
It's unreal. It's an unreal, it's not my favorite part. My favorite parts are getting up to do a massive cross-examination of a big witness. Or my favorite's always the closing. I love a closing address because it's you and the jury, there's no one else. You know, it's me and them, that's it. And that's when if you've got a good relationship with them, you can see it and you know, there's a discussion and it's the structure of it, there's, you know, I'd like to tell stories, jokes, you know. It's just, and there's a rush when you're doing it. And you know, play with pauses, play with timing, speed, the whole thing, it's.
It's an art form, right?
It's just fun. It's just, it's a pretty cool job, isn't it? It's, and you know, I'd like to, we're at the coalface. Rather than picking up the paper the next day and reading about it, we're there, living it and it's, it's great. I mean, the responsibility is huge. But as long as, we always say, I certainly do that, I'll give this person the best chance of getting a not guilty because I can't predict the future and I'm pretty happy that we've achieved it most of, not all the time.
So I think Rishi is probably one of the first defence barristers I've had an extended conversation with. And somehow he was exactly what I expected, like, you know, incredibly smart. Um, you know, very calm, you know, really confident, really knows what he's doing and just kind of like loves the theatre and the drama of it all.
Yeah, I totally agree with that. And I think. What we've learned from Rishi is that while all of these cases heavily depend on the evidence and the law and the technicalities of what goes on in the courtroom, but let's not forget that there's also a real human side to this and it's about making those subtle connections with the jury. It's about making sure you can do all those intangible things to just try to sway the jury in your favour. Because that's what could make the difference, right? If you've got an entire jury but you've managed to really convince one person that the client is not guilty, even if all of the others in a murder case
believe that a client's guilty but one is steadfast that they're not, it's a hung jury. There's no majority decisions in murder cases in this state.
Yeah, it's like a real game of millimetres and Rishi seems to really kind of understand that and play that game, which is fascinating and was so wonderful to hear. So I would just like to say a massive thank you to Rishi Nathwani for making the time for this chat. Just some incredible insights. If you want to hear how the prosecution will run their case against the defence during this trial, or what it's like being a juror for a murder trial, check out the other episodes in our feed now.
And if you've got any questions about this case or the legal process, do flick us an email at mushroomcasetaily@abc.net.au.
And as this episode wraps up, make sure you grab your little nightmare cube out of your pocket, or your bag, and download the ABC Listen app. You can follow Mushroom Case Daily there so you don't miss any updates.
Mushroom Case Daily is produced by ABC Audio Studios and ABC News. It's presented by me, the ABC's court reporter, Christian Silver, and producer Stephen Stockwell.
Our executive producer is Claire Rawlinson, and props to Christian's boss, Sarah Gentsch, and audio studios manager, Monique Bowley. This episode was produced on the land of the Runjri people.
You've been listening to an ABC Podcast. Discover more great ABC podcasts, live radio and exclusives on the ABC Listen app.
Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated