Pod Insights The Case Of 8 | Doctor’s grave warnings to Erin About this episode There were tears in the courtroom as children of the deceased lunch guests shared their stories. Plus, a Leongatha doctor described his attempts to convince Erin Patterson of the seriousness of her situation - and potentially her children’s conditions - after she presented to hospital complaining of diarrhoea.
In today’s episode, Kristian Silva and Stephen Stockwell also answer questions about the taste of Erin’s beef wellington, the timing of her dehydrator dumping, and why witnesses aren’t giving their opinion on Erin’s guilt or innocence.
If you’ve got questions about the case that you’d like Kristian to answer in future episodes, send them through to mushroomcasedaily@abc.net.au mailto:mushroomcasedaily@abc.net.au
-
It's the case that's captured the attention of the world.
Three people died and a fourth survived an induced coma after eating beef wellington at a family lunch, hosted by Erin Patterson.
Police allege the beef wellington contained poisonous mushrooms, but Erin Patterson says she’s innocent.
Now, the accused triple murderer is fighting the charges in a regional Victorian courthouse. Court reporter Kristian Silva and producer Stephen Stockwell are on the ground, bringing you all the key moments from the trial as they unravel in court.
From court recaps to behind-the-scenes murder trial explainers, the Mushroom Case Daily podcast is your eyes and ears inside the courtroom.
Keep up to date with new episodes of Mushroom Case Daily https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/mushroom-case-daily, now releasing every day on the ABC listen app.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:16 Speaker 01 Scared and alive or dead? That was the ultimatum given by a very concerned doctor to Erin Patterson. I'm the ABC's court reporter, Christian Silver.
0:25 Speaker 02 And I'm Stephen Stockwell. It is Wednesday, the 7th of May, and we've just seen things wrap up for day six of Erin Patterson's murder trial. Welcome to Mushroom Case Daily.
0:35 Speaker 03 The prosecution argues she had travelled to nearby Lock and Altrim, where there'd been sightings of death cap mushrooms.
0:42 Speaker 04 She told doctors she fed her children leftovers but scraped the mushrooms off.
0:47 Speaker 05 Police allege Ms Patterson refused medical treatment for both herself and her children.
0:52 Speaker 04 Ms Patterson admits she lied to police about foraging for mushrooms and getting rid of the dehydrator.
0:59 Speaker 02 Christian, you are fresh out of court after a day of hearings in Erin Patterson's trial. Can you give us the breakdown or a quick, sort of quick wrap of what we heard today?
1:10 Speaker 01 It was a pretty busy day in court, Stocky. We saw some security footage and we also heard a triple O call played to the court. The footage showed Erin Patterson trying to leave the Lee and Gatha Hospital just a couple of days after the lunch took place. We also heard evidence from Dr Chris Webster, one of the first medical experts who saw Erin Patterson. We also heard from more members of the extended Patterson and Wilkinson families, and some of it was pretty emotional.
1:45 Speaker 02 Yeah, it was quite an emotional day. I want to spend a bit of time talking about what it would have been like for the family members to, to give evidence today. I thought some of that was, was really interesting. But you talked about the hospital and some of the doctors who are giving evidence today, doctors from the Lee and Gatha Hospital. This is the hospital that was caring for Ian and Heather Wilkinson, and also that Erin Patterson showed up to.
2:05 Speaker 01 They were the first doctors that were called on to treat Erin Patterson. So Dr Chris Webster was called to the stand. So. On the morning of July thirty one, twenty twenty three, this is two days after the lunch. He was aware that Don and Gail Patterson were also sick. So he knew that four people from this lunch were not doing well. And then when Erin Patterson turned up to the hospital and said, I've got gastro. It didn't take long for him to put the pieces together and realise she's the fifth person.
2:36 Speaker 02 Yeah, this is the, this is the other person that we've been talking about from this lunch.
2:39 Speaker 01 This is the chef. And at this point, um, the suspicions being raised that the mushrooms might be the thing that has made everybody sick.
2:47 Speaker 02 Hmm.
2:47 Speaker 01 So Webster on the stand today said that he told Erin Patterson that he was concerned that she might have suffered from a death cap mushroom poisoning. And he has asked her to, to stay there because he wants to get her straight into treatment. Um, he also asked her where she got the mushrooms from and she said Woolworths. So anyway, Dr Webster said that he went off to attend to another thing quickly. And before he knew it, Erin Patterson had discharged herself from the hospital against medical advice. And we were actually shown some security footage of this.
3:26 Speaker 02 This is the first time we've seen any video played in this trial, right?
3:29 Speaker 01 I believe so. So to describe what we saw, um, Erin Patterson was wearing a surgical mask. She's in a red jumper, a beige coloured pants and some brown, black sandals. And she's seen walking up to the door of the hospital to leave. And this is just minutes after she's turned up.
3:49 Speaker 02 Hmm.
3:49 Speaker 01 Um, another doctor is seen kind of trying to stop her from leaving. You can tell that she's encouraging her to stay, even though you can't hear the audio.
3:58 Speaker 02 Hmm.
3:59 Speaker 01 And Erin actually reaches over and hits the button to open the automatic door.
4:04 Speaker 02 Oh.
4:04 Speaker 01 And, um, in the end, she doesn't actually leave straight away. Um, what she does is she's given a form to sign and then she signs it and walks off. So anyway, um, Dr Webster.
4:19 Speaker 01 Then finds out that she's gone and he's really panicking at this point. Very concerned for her welfare. This is what he told the court. And he rang triple O in the hope that the police might actually be able to locate Erin Patterson and bring her back to hospital because he was so worried that she might go down the same path as the Wilkons and the Pattersons, who by this point were not doing well at all.
4:46 Speaker 02 Yep. And did we also hear the triple O call in court today?
4:51 Speaker 01 We heard the triple O call and we can hear Dr Webster introduce himself to the call operator. He says that there's been this lunch and that several people have suffered from a suspected poisoning. And then he tells the triple O caller, one of the people has discharged herself against medical advice. She was only here for five minutes. Um. He says her name's Erin Patterson and he asks if the police can go and find her. And in the end, what happens is Erin Patterson actually returned to the hospital after about 90 minutes. So the police didn't need to go and forcibly bring her back.
5:30 Speaker 01 But what the police did do when they got to her house is they were able to find some of the beef Wellington leftovers in a bin and that was collected and actually brought back to the hospital.
5:43 Speaker 02 Yep. Um. When Erin came back, we also heard about how she was also a bit reluctant for her children to come to the hospital as well. She didn't want to take them out of school. Um. At the time, she didn't want to worry them. And um, and Dr Webster had a pretty, I don't know, I guess, pretty blunt response to that, right?
6:01 Speaker 01 Dr Webster wasn't mucking around and he again explained to Erin Patterson how serious this situation was in his mind. This is according to his evidence in court today. Uh. He said that Miss Patterson told him her children had also eaten leftovers of the beef Wellington, but not the mushrooms. So Dr Webster said he inquired about where the children were. She told them they were at school and he said he stressed the importance of getting the children to a medical facility. And he said Erin was reluctant to inform the children. And I said it was important. And then she was concerned that they were going to be frightened. And there was this ripper quote from Dr Webster.
6:46 Speaker 01 He told Erin Patterson in regards to the kids, they can be scared and alive or dead. That is a pretty powerful way of putting things. And Dr Webster said that she started to understand the importance of contacting them. And then she indicated it would be done. As we know, the kids were eventually checked out um and taken to hospital. And prosecutors say that the results showed they were fine.
7:13 Speaker 02 Yeah.
7:14 Speaker 01 Um. I mentioned a moment ago about how some of those leftovers were brought to the hospital.
7:20 Speaker 02 Mm hmm.
7:20 Speaker 01 We also saw um security footage of one of the doctors sifting through them. Um. So she pulls it out of a brown Woolworth's shopping bag. And initially it's like this kind of brown sludge stuff.
7:37 Speaker 02 Hmm.
7:37 Speaker 01 Um. Probably about the size of an index finger.
7:40 Speaker 02 Mm hmm.
7:40 Speaker 01 And then she pulls out this second bigger bit, and that's the beef Wellington pastry.
7:44 Speaker 02 Right.
7:45 Speaker 01 The doctor's seen, um, the doctor's wearing gloves, by the way, I should say, yes. Uh. The doctor pulls out her phone, snaps a photo um and then puts it back in the bag. So that was another bit of footage we saw.
7:57 Speaker 02 Yep. And one of the interesting things, and something I want to mention at this point, is that um we're describing the exhibits because we don't have access to them at the moment. So we're not seeing them, you're seeing them in court, but they're not being released um for other people to see. So that's why we're going through the process of describing them. We might get access to them later.
8:13 Speaker 01 I really hope so. So in some cases, the exhibits are released uh as the court case progresses. Unfortunately, that's not happening in this case. All of the media outlets are obviously very keen to get a hold of these exhibits so we can show people at home what we're seeing and what we're hearing. So as soon as we can bring those exhibits to you, we will definitely be doing it.
8:35 Speaker 02 Yep. At this point, we know, we heard today at least, a lot of the results in the medical tests that were being done on Dawn and Gal Patterson and Ian and Heather Wilkinson and how they were progressing and what symptoms they were experiencing and all of that. And we also heard a bit about some of the medical tests that Erin had done and the results were quite different.
8:57 Speaker 01 Several doctors have been giving evidence yesterday and today about the medical conditions of the four other guests. And in short, their conditions declined really badly. They have liver problems, organ failure, all the stats look really bad. And we know how it ended for three out of the four.
9:21 Speaker 02 Hmm.
9:22 Speaker 01 We got some information about Erin's results, and this is just from the Lee Engatha Hospital. She was checked out later at another hospital, but we focus on Lee Engatha for now. Dr Veronica Foot said medical tests conducted on Erin Patterson indicated regular blood pressure and temperature, but an elevated heart rate. But that eventually settled as well. And she said other tests which were looking for electrolyte disturbances yielded reassuring results. So while Erin Patterson's medical tests were not looking that concerning, at the same time, the other four were really going downhill.
10:01 Speaker 02 Hmm. As well as a lot of the doctors giving evidence today, we also heard from some of the children of Gal and Dawn Patterson and Ian and Heather Wilkinson. The one that stuck with me the most was Anna. She's the youngest daughter of Gal and Dawn Patterson. And she was someone that the court heard was actually quite a good friend or close friend of Erin Patterson for a period of time. She-
10:23 Speaker 01 A long time?
10:23 Speaker 02 Yeah, a long time. Her and Anna were pregnant at the same time. Their children were born just a couple of days apart. Erin read a Bible passage out at Anna's wedding. What was it like in the courtroom as both of them were in there together?
10:36 Speaker 01 It was really hard to see how difficult it was for Anna. She was almost in tears just after giving- The oath.
10:45 Speaker 02 Hmm.
10:46 Speaker 01 So barely a minute or two in the witness box. And she became emotional as she described um the pain that her parents were suffering while in hospital. And you could see while she was saying this, that Erin Patterson also feeling quite emotional. It was, it was really obvious and I really felt for Anna, like at times she would clutch her chest and pause. And it was really, really hard for her. And when she finished her evidence, um there was a supporter in the courtroom who sort of put an arm around her. And that was kind of nice to see, just, just a little moment of, of support to say, well done for getting through that.
11:31 Speaker 01 Because it must be so difficult for these kids to, to talk about such a traumatic experience.
11:38 Speaker 02 Hmm. That was one of the things I was thinking as, you know, she was giving evidence and while seeing another one of their, their sons give evidence as well. Um, and it's, yeah, I know that the purpose of this isn't to ask them how they feel about their parents passing away. But it just, it's, I find it quite jarring just at how cold the lines of questioning are as they're being talked through all this and asked these questions.
11:58 Speaker 01 It's kind of goes back to, remember back at the very beginning of the trial when the jury's told to dispassionately
12:05 Speaker 02 Hmm.
12:05 Speaker 01 weigh up the evidence.
12:06 Speaker 02 Yep.
12:07 Speaker 01 That's kind of what this is. It's like, there's no real room for feelings. It's just about the cold, hard facts and what can be proven beyond reasonable doubt.
12:15 Speaker 02 That's exactly it. And it was nice, nice to hear you say that there was the supporters in there. We've also seen, you know, a number of the Patterson and the Wilkinson families in court over the last couple of days as well, supporting each other through this.
12:26 Speaker 01 They're occupying um a good ten to fifteen seats of the courtroom. So they're definitely turning out to support each other each day.
12:33 Speaker 02 It is nice to see that kind of support in the courtroom. Obviously a really difficult time for these families. So to have, you know, the family there would be so, so helpful to get through something like this. Um, the, the inbox of Mushroom Case Daily uh continues to expand. Uh, we love hearing from you. We've had so many wonderful messages. Uh, mushroomcasedayly at abc.net.au. Um, we have a question here from um Jano. Um, they're wondering why the witnesses such as Ian and Simon not being asked things like, do you believe the poisoning was intentional and why?
13:05 Speaker 01 All of the allegations made by the prosecution have got to be backed up with evidence. So let's take Ian, for example, he's been asked in detail about what was said to him or what he was made aware of before the lunch, things that were said at the lunch and even afterwards. But asking him about his opinion, if that can't be backed up with with evidence, isn't really going to cut it to prove anything to the level that's required in a court. So people are asked about what they saw and heard, but not really about their opinion or about the vibe of things.
13:45 Speaker 02 Yeah, I feel as though I can't attribute this to a certain situation, so I'm going to be incredibly vague, so our lawyers don't hit me on the knuckles. But I feel as though I've heard Justice Beale in some situations, just sort of reminding witnesses, just to go, oh no, just just stick to your facts.
13:59 Speaker 01 Justice Beale has said to some of the witnesses to talk about what was said, not what they think someone meant.
14:07 Speaker 02 Another question here from Emma, this is actually irrelevant to some things we heard today, so great timing on your question, Emma. She is interested to know if Ian was asked about the taste of the beef Wellington. I would have thought that it would have been important. Did they continue to eat it even though it tasted a bit weird or they did it, did they eat it out of politeness or in fact because it tasted good?
14:26 Speaker 01 Well, we know that Don Patterson ate one and a half servings. His wife only ate a third to a half, depending on who you ask. Ian and Heather both ate their full servings. I don't remember if Ian was asked about the taste of the beef Wellington, but we have heard evidence from several people who spoke to Heather Wilkinson shortly after the lunch, where she was raving about the beef Wellington and today, two of her friends from church.
14:58 Speaker 01 Said that she called the Beef Wellington beautiful and delicious. And this was in the hours after consuming the meal, obviously unaware that what was inside of her was a ticking time bomb and that within a week she'd be dead.
15:12 Speaker 02 Yep, yep. Um, Laurie's asking, uh, is interested in the timeline of when Erin took the dehydrator to the tip. Um, how does that fit into the lunch when people go into hospital, when people passed away?
15:24 Speaker 01 Let's try and step through it methodically. So the lunch is on a Saturday afternoon.
15:29 Speaker 02 Yep.
15:30 Speaker 01 By the following morning, the Sunday, all the guests are feeling sick.
15:34 Speaker 02 Yep.
15:36 Speaker 01 By the Monday, Erin Patterson has presented to hospital.
15:39 Speaker 02 Mm hmm.
15:40 Speaker 01 The prosecution in their opening said that Erin Patterson went to the tip on the Wednesday.
15:48 Speaker 02 Mm hmm.
15:49 Speaker 01 Two days after that, the guests start dying. Two died on the fourth of August and one on the fifth of August.
15:56 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's the Friday and the Saturday of that week. Um, we are continuing to follow up questions that, um, we have had in the past. One in particular is from Joanne, who was asking about the dessert for the Beef Wellington lunch. Um, we, I think it was a couple of days ago, maybe an episode last week, we found out that it was a, a fruit platter and a cake. Uh, and Joanne wanted more detail, uh, on the type of cake. Uh, so Joanne, we have continued to, uh, to bring you these details. Today we heard, uh, that the cake was an orange cake.
16:24 Speaker 01 Yes, that came from Anna, uh, one of the children of Don and Gail.
16:29 Speaker 02 Yep, yep. And, um, we've had a lovely email here from Bob, um, who is living in the foothills of the French Pyrenees at the moment and is waiting up each evening for the arrival of the latest episode. Thank you for staying up late for us, Bob. Um, they get into their electrically warm beds and hang on every word and sound, which is very kind. Uh, they're off tomorrow to start a walk on the Camino for a couple of weeks and repeat this, repeat this ritual for as long as they can access ABC Listen. Thank you for the ABC Listen plug, Bob. Uh, I appreciate that. Uh, they're going to be heading home to their place in Lismore in about a month or so. And Bob's question is whether there will be an outcome or a verdict before then.
17:03 Speaker 01 Before the end of the month.
17:04 Speaker 02 Hmm.
17:04 Speaker 01 Well, the trial's set down for five to six weeks, so probably not.
17:12 Speaker 01 I guess you never know with these things, but I would imagine we'll get to the end of the case early mid-June.
17:20 Speaker 02 Yep, we'll keep you informed, Bob. Keep listening as soon as we know more.
17:23 Speaker 01 And hello to everyone else who's listening overseas as well. Thank you for joining us.
17:27 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely. If you're listening from overseas, let us know. And if you're writing us an email as well to mushroomcasedayly@abc.net.au, let us know where you're listening from. Give us a shout out. We'll shout out your town, your suburb, your locale, just to let you know, you know, so you've got a bit of credit for your local area. And yeah, please keep sending us your questions and your emails.
17:45 Speaker 01 As we approach the end of the week, Dr Veronica Foote, one of the doctors who was at the Lee and Gatha Hospital who treated Aaron Patterson, will continue her evidence tomorrow. And there might be some more witnesses after that.
17:58 Speaker 02 Please make sure you track down Mushroom Case Daily on the ABC Listen app and hit follow. And if you're on the Listen app, you're in for a little treat because you actually get our episodes half an hour earlier than you do on any other app you're listening to. So if you need a little extra bump to get behind the ABC Listen app, there you go.
18:20 Speaker 01 Mushroom Case Daily is produced by ABC Audio Studios and ABC News. It's presented by me, ABC Court reporter Christian Silver, and producer Stephen Stockwell.
18:29 Speaker 02 Our executive producer is Claire Rollinson, and props to Christian's boss Sarah Gensh and Audio Studios manager Eric George, and our true crime colleagues, Tim Roxburgh, Rachel Brown, and Yasmin Parry for helping make this show a reality. This episode was produced on the land of the Gunai Kurnai people.
18:49 Speaker 04 You've been listening to an ABC Podcast. Discover more great ABC podcasts, live radio and exclusives on the ABC Listen app.
Previous 7 | Lunch survivor Ian Wilkinson speaks Next 9 | Erin Patterson in tears during daughter's evidence Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated