Pod Insights The Case Of 04 Wheelie Bin Murder | Geoffrey’s last day About this episode On Thursday the 18th of August 2022, Geoffrey McLean played golf and spent time at the pub with friends, but after 5pm no-one could raise him. The prosecution alleges this was because he'd been murdered.
In this episode, Adelaide court reporter Eva Blandis explains what the last contact with Geoffrey McLean was and what the forensic pathologist found when he examined his remains.
If you have any questions you'd like Eva and Stocky to answer in future episodes, please email thecaseof@abc.net.au mailto:thecaseof@abc.net.au.
The Case Of is the follow-up to the hit podcast Mushroom Case Daily, and all episodes of that show will remain available in the back catalogue of The Case Of.
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 Hi, it's Sam Hawley from ABC News Daily, the podcast that brings you one big story affecting your world each weekday in just 15 minutes.
0:12 Speaker 01 The idea of regime change being affected from the air, it's got no precedent. Netanyahu and Trump's theory that Iranians will see the weakness of the regime and rush to replace it. I'm sceptical of all of that, I really am.
0:24 Speaker 00 Join me for ABC News Daily. Find us on ABC Listen.
0:29 Speaker 02 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:46 Speaker 03 On the day the prosecution says Geoffrey McLean was killed, he played golf in the morning, went to the pub and was messaging a friend in the afternoon until, all of a sudden, he stopped replying. I'm Stephen Stockwell and just a warning, we'll be discussing some graphic scenes in this episode. This is episode four of the case of the wheelie bin murder.
1:06 Speaker 04 A gruesome discovery on vacant land in Adelaide's north. Police say the remains belong to missing man Geoffrey McLean.
1:14 Speaker 03 When Geoffrey's body was located, it had been dismembered. It was located in a wheelie bin.
1:18 Speaker 00 Four people have been arrested in relation to his death. A woman who's accused of murdering her ex-partner. They're hopeful they can provide relief to his family.
1:29 Speaker 03 Since our last episode, we've had a more complete picture of Geoffrey McLean put before the courts. This is a man whose torso ended up in a wheelie bin in a vacant lot. And we've learnt more about what happened to him before his death and also how he might have died. We're very lucky to have Eva Blandis back with us for this episode, ABC Court reporter in Adelaide. Welcome Eva.
1:48 Speaker 05 Hi, Stocky.
1:50 Speaker 03 Eva, it's been a little while since we've caught up. Could you take us through some of the key evidence before we jump into this episode?
1:56 Speaker 05 Yeah, so the last little while, we've heard a lot from police who attended at those assaults that we've heard about before. Those are the assaults before the alleged murder. So there are three different assaults. We also heard from the friend who last had communication with Geoffrey McLean on the day the prosecution alleged he died or was killed. We've also heard from the pathologist who looked at his torso once that wheelie bin was discovered, and we've heard some of his theories as to what happened.
2:33 Speaker 03 Thank you, Eva. Very much looking forward to diving into what we've learned about Geoffrey McLean's cause of death in this episode as well. I mean, it's such a brutal murder that we are discussing in this podcast. And yeah, the way that Geoffrey McLean's body was found in the in the wheelie bin is, you know, kind of horrific. And I'm keen to understand a little bit about why we have to go into this kind of detail in court as well throughout this episode. So we'll come to that a little bit later in the app. But first, I'm keen to kind of step back. Eva, as you mentioned in our first episode, we heard about these previous assaults on Geoffrey McLean. Now, he had been living with Cherie Glastonbury at this point. And one night, a man breaks in and hits him in the head with a log splitter,
3:15 Speaker 03 which is like a really kind of thick axe. It is a brutal attack. Geoffrey McLean survives that. Police attend the house. They come up to Cherie Glastonbury's property. What do they find?
3:29 Speaker 05 We actually got a really good description of what this scene was like and what it was like for the police who first arrived. So they come to the door. Cherie Glastonbury answers. Geoffrey McLean then comes to the door as well. He comes out of the bedroom at the front of the house. They're obviously explaining what's happened. Geoffrey McLean is obviously injured, so he's instructed to go sit down in the lounge room. We've heard that there was blood found on the inside of the wooden door. There was blood in the hallway, smeared on the walls, and there was also blood in that lounge room as well. So there was a lot going on in this scene, and we really did get a colourful description of it.
4:10 Speaker 03 Yeah. How is Geoffrey McLean in this moment? He's just been hit in the head with a log splitter, like I described, you know, kind of almost like a cross between a sledgehammer and an axe. Is he all right?
4:21 Speaker 05 Yeah, well, we didn't actually hear anything about how he was. We did, though, hear from the police officer who was first on scene in um his cross-examination by Cherie's lawyer. We did hear that um Cherie appeared frantic.
4:37 Speaker 03 Um, yeah. I mean, it was a a pretty confronting scene. I imagine we heard in the openings that the prosecution alleges someone comes into that house and, yeah, while Geoff McLean is is sleeping on the the couch in in part of it, um has a log splitter kind of thrust into the into the side of his head, which would be um, yeah, pretty confronting. I mean, we have so much evidence relating to this interaction being presented to the court. There's a lot of police witnesses that are kind of the ones who were who were talking through this. As you described, you know, we had the police officer who who gets to the house and and takes us through this scene. How is all this evidence being presented to the court and shown to the jury?
5:16 Speaker 05 So we're getting a lot of police officers coming to give evidence. So they're usually the people who are first on scene or crime investigators. So they're sort of able to set that scene and with them coming to give evidence, they're also having documents tended through them. So these may be photos of the scene, maybe body worn vision from their body cams. And then those photos, when they're tended through these witnesses, they're given to the jury. So the jury can then reference them and they sort of get that bundle of photographs. There's no books, so to speak. It's just more of a bundle of photographs and they keep them for the rest of the trial. So they can go back to them whenever they want to.
5:56 Speaker 03 Gotcha. And they've got, yeah, like, it's like physical copies of this. I know in the trial of Aaron Patterson, they were, the jury was using iPads and, you know, documents would be kind of uploaded and pushed to the iPad throughout the trial. In in this trial, it's like physical documents kind of being handed to the jury. Is that right?
6:11 Speaker 05 Yeah, that's right. Really, we're in that stage at the moment in the trial where we've got all of that sort of. That starting point, all of that stuff tended, just to sort of help, I think, set a scene and get the jury to understand what they're dealing with.
6:24 Speaker 03 Yeah, and in this instance, you know, when we're looking at the House of Cherie Glastonbury, who is the woman accused of murdering Geoffrey McLean, along with Mark Murphy, also accused of murdering Geoffrey McLean, what evidence is being tended here? Are we getting, you know, body worn footage of the police walking through this house? Are we getting crime scene photos? What are you, what are you seeing?
6:44 Speaker 05 Yeah, so we're getting some body worn, but the majority of what is being tended at the moment are those crime scene photographs. And there's a lot of them. We also have to remember, you know, when these people are taking these photos, they don't know what's going to be relevant. So there are a lot of miscellaneous photos of, you know, all sorts of random things. We spoke about in one of our last episodes that there was a stormtrooper in one of the rooms. So obviously that's not relevant that we know of, but, you know, there are a lot of photos to go through to sort of set the scene.
7:16 Speaker 03 Yeah, absolutely. I guess crime scene investigators trying to capture the entirety of that because, yeah, as you say, they've got no idea what may or may not be important later down the track. I mean, there was a lot of conversation about the log splitter at this point of the trial. There was all this talk about who touched it, who moved it. What was going on here? What was, what was being talked about?
7:38 Speaker 05 So the police officer was questioned about where he saw the log splitter. He was also questioned about whether he touched it or moved it. Then we also heard the forensics expert being questioned about that too, whether he touched it or moved it, where he saw it, and where the photos that he'd taken of it showed that log splitter.
7:58 Speaker 03 Interesting, because, I mean, we heard in the openings that the prosecution alleges that Cherie Glastonbury did move, or did at least touch the log splitter at some point after Geoffrey McLean had been hit in the head with it. The prosecution's allegation is that Cherie Glastonbury had enlisted Mark Murphy, also accused of the murder of Geoffrey McLean, to hit Geoffrey McLean with the log splitter. And after Geoffrey McLean had been taken to hospital, Cherie Glastonbury allegedly re-enters the house. Unattended by police and then when she emerges, um, you know, as we've kind of heard discussed here, prosecution allegation is that the the logs was in a different location. You know, I guess through the various evidence that would have been presented, the jury gets a look at where the logs bit was, you know, potentially on the body cam footage of one
8:42 Speaker 03 of the police officers and then in the photos of the forensic guy who was going through the house. So, yeah, really interesting to hear kind of how that unfolded in court. Eva, I mean, you know, knowing that that's a point that the prosecution is getting into and is alleging because of its openings. I mean, was there much cross examination of the witnesses around this evidence?
9:04 Speaker 05 So there's been a little bit from the defence. We're mainly hearing from Cherie Glastonbury's lawyer as well as Mark Murphy's lawyers. We heard some cross examination of a police officer who attended the scene when Geoffrey McLean's car was set on fire. So this is sort of a separate little incident. She was cross examined by Cherie Glastonbury's lawyer, Mari Shaw, who asked why she hadn't saved her body worn footage. So, um, there was a bit about that and about the fact that yes, she likely would have had it on, but if you don't save it, you know, that day or that morning, then you can't recover it.
9:47 Speaker 03 Right.
9:47 Speaker 05 So there was a few questions about that, um, and about how you don't have a sort of an actual video conversation with these people on that day. So it's just her recollection rather than that video footage.
10:01 Speaker 03 Yeah, got it. Eva, in our last episode, we were talking about one of Geoffrey McLean's friends. It was the first time I'd really heard much about who he was. I mean, we've talked kind of a lot about him, but something I I notice when we're covering trials like this is often the victim does get a bit lost because you're talking kind of about elements of them so much and not so much about who they were as a person. And we did hear from another one of his friends over the last week, someone who's actually known him for for quite a long time, right?
10:29 Speaker 05 Yeah, so we heard from Stuart Caponia, who's known Geoffrey or knew Geoffrey for about fifteen to sixteen years. They'd met while playing golf, um, and he called him by the nickname Macca. So it was, yeah, quite nice to sort of get more of a picture of who Geoffrey was through a long term friend of his.
10:49 Speaker 03 Yeah. What did we hear from Stuart Caponia? What did he, what sort of evidence was he, was he giving? What was he being asked about?
10:55 Speaker 05 So he was mainly talking about that last day that Geoffrey McLean was seen alive. So we talked about that, I think it was in the last episode. So um he joined him and his other friend and played golf that morning on August eighteenth, twenty twenty two. He did also say that he saw Geoffrey McLean take meth that day through an ice pipe. So we had previously heard that Geoffrey's behaviour became a little bit more erratic and and his other friend assumed that's what had happened.
11:26 Speaker 03 Hmm.
11:27 Speaker 05 Then they sort of go their separate ways. So we heard before that Geoffrey McLean went to the Mawson Lakes Hotel. So Stuart Capunia didn't go there, so they separate, but they're in contact throughout that afternoon.
11:40 Speaker 03 Right, okay.
11:41 Speaker 05 And there are quite a lot of messages over over that afternoon. It's all about Geoffrey McLean trying to to buy some meth. And there's talk about bank account details and there are calls and there are texts. So there's a lot going on in that period.
11:56 Speaker 03 Right, and so Geoffrey McLean is, you know, Stuart must be a contact of his or somebody who uses to buy meth. And so he's messaging Stuart basically saying, hey, look, can you get me some meth? What are your bank details? I'll send you the money, et cetera, et cetera. Is that is that what's going on here?
12:09 Speaker 05 Yeah, so there's that back and forth about drugs.
12:11 Speaker 03 Yeah, how long does it go for?
12:13 Speaker 05 So there's about four hours-ish of of that back and forth about trying to buy those drugs. There's an ongoing conversation there and then it just sort of stops.
12:23 Speaker 03 Oh, it's so just like, just nothing. Had they resolved, had he bought the drugs at that point?
12:29 Speaker 05 No, so we actually got to the point, we heard that Stuart Capunia was almost home to get his bank account details to send to Geoffrey, for then Geoffrey to send the money.
12:41 Speaker 03 Hmm.
12:41 Speaker 05 Um, and the last communication they had was just before Stuart got home. And then by the time he was ready to give that information, Geoffrey was not responding.
12:53 Speaker 03 And the prosecution is alleging this is the point where Geoffrey McLean is murdered, right? Is this is this the window they're pointing to?
13:01 Speaker 05 Yeah, so this is the window they're pointing to. So he's last seen at that hotel. Um, and then the last communication that he has with Stuart Capunia or with anyone that we know of is at four forty five that afternoon.
13:13 Speaker 03 Right, does Stuart try to raise him at all? Does he like keep messaging back, try to call him or anything?
13:18 Speaker 05 Yeah, so he last hears from Geoffrey at four forty five. So that's the last time we actually hear from him.
13:24 Speaker 03 Hmm.
13:24 Speaker 05 He then tries to call Geoffrey at four fifty two P M.
13:29 Speaker 03 Hmm.
13:29 Speaker 05 And gets nothing. He then tries over and over again, trying to get in touch with him, whether that's through text message or call. There are a few voice messages left, but he gives up about eight o'clock.
13:42 Speaker 03 Yeah, incredible to kind of get that detail, I suppose, from the last person to have communication with Geoffrey McLean before his death. He's not seen again until his body is found in a wheelie bin, in a vacant lot a couple of months later. If we spoke a bit about the kind of the state of Geoffrey McLean's body in our last episode, when we were hearing from some of the forensic folk who were tasked with, you know, examining the evidence in the wheelie bin when it was taken back to to be kind of investigated and, you know, learnt a bit more about. We've now heard from the man who examined the body of Geoffrey McLean. This is the forensic pathologist. This would not have been a pleasant job.
14:20 Speaker 05 No, quite gruesome. So Neil Langloyes, he's a forensic pathologist. So he was that one that looked at that wheelie bin and really examined it quite closely.
14:32 Speaker 03 Hmm.
14:33 Speaker 05 We heard him describe the weight of the wheelie bin being eighty five kilos. Now, to keep in mind, the weight of the torso was sixty two kilos.
14:43 Speaker 03 Right.
14:44 Speaker 05 And the body was really badly decomposed, as we've heard, and there were a lot of decomposition fluids. So there was a lot going on in that bin. And he also mentioned there were some maggots. Because, as we know, that body had been in that bin for a very long time out in the elements. So, yeah, there's a lot there.
15:08 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, two months between Geoffrey McLean going missing and this body being recovered in the vacant lot. Yeah, a long time for the body to be sitting in that bin. And, I mean, Eva, we talk about things like decomposition fluids, which is not a word I thought I would be ever having to really say at all. The detail of this is so gruesome, it is really full on. I mean, why is this stuff that is being put before the jury at all?
15:33 Speaker 05 It's important for the jury to sort of understand the whole scene. And you never know what's going to be important or what the jury might think is important.
15:43 Speaker 03 Hmm.
15:43 Speaker 05 Um, and as we know anyway, and we've, we've heard in previous episodes, Justice Kimber is very, very understanding that thi- that this is not a nice thing for the jury to hear. Um, so there is sort of still that standing invitation for any of those jurors to put their hand up and take a moment to sort of gather themselves if it's too, too gruesome.
16:07 Speaker 03 Yeah, okay, great. Um, I might take advantage of that at some point as well, if I ever feel like we're, uh, we're going a little bit, uh, too gruesome. Um, but I feel like I've kind of been steeled for, for where we're going to go next and brace to kind of learn a bit about what, um, we heard from this forensic pathologist. What did he tell the jury? What was he able to learn about the body of Geoffrey McLean?
16:27 Speaker 05 So it was quite difficult, as you can imagine, but he said he was able to um, conclude that Geoffrey McLean's head was severed from roughly halfway down his neck. Now, he wasn't able to say whether it was cut off while Geoffrey was alive or, or after he, he was killed because of the decomposition. So it made it quite difficult.
16:53 Speaker 03 Hmm.
16:54 Speaker 05 But he's also said that the arms were cut from the top of the biceps and the legs were severed from around the mid height of the thigh. So again, same thing, can't conclude if that was before or after death. But he was able to make the conclusion that it would require soaring motion to make those cuts, whether dead or alive.
17:17 Speaker 03 Okay, yeah, right. Was it hard for him to do much with the body in, in such an advanced state of decomposition?
17:23 Speaker 05 Yeah, it, it sa- it sounded like it. He said he wasn't able to get much blood from the torso, um, but he was able to get a small amount from his heart and the remains of the legs.
17:36 Speaker 03 What was he able to find out? I mean, obviously not much blood, so it's going to, I guess, imagine being a challenge for kind of toxicology results and things like that. Was he able to learn much at all from what he had?
17:47 Speaker 05 Yeah, so there wasn't enough blood there to check for the drugs, a- any drugs in his system.
17:54 Speaker 03 Right.
17:54 Speaker 05 But he was able to take a sample from his liver and from that sample, there was some meth in there, about 1.3mg per kilogram.
18:06 Speaker 03 Mm-hmm.
18:07 Speaker 05 Um, there was also some diazepam and some nor diazepam.
18:11 Speaker 03 Right, okay, got it.
18:12 Speaker 05 But he said there was no information to say that insulin contributed to Geoffrey McLean's death. Um, he said the only thing that they could submit to see whether there was insulin in his system would be the vitreous humour of the eyes. So that is of course not available in this case, as we only had Geoffrey McLean's torso. So there was no way to confirm or exclude that insulin was the cause.
18:41 Speaker 03 Right, yeah, I mean, you know, no heads, no arms, no legs, just the torso, uh, which is what this examination was on. Even that insulin reference is kind of interesting. Um, I mean, we heard a little bit about insulin in the openings, is that, is that where this is coming from?
18:56 Speaker 05 Yeah, so in the prosecution opening, we heard that it will be alleged that a bag of insulin pens were found at Cherie Glastonbury's house. So this was during one of the police searches, I think it was in, from memory, it was in her kitchen.
19:11 Speaker 03 Mm.
19:11 Speaker 05 So we've sort of just got some details about there ever being a presence of insulin in this case, um, and then just that line of questioning, but we are yet to hear any evidence about those pens.
19:24 Speaker 03 Yeah, we also heard in openings about some kind of secret recordings that the police did on the house of, uh, Mark Murphy and Peter Murphy. Mark Murphy, uh, also accused of the murder of Geoffrey McLean and Peter Murphy accused of assisting an offender. That's Mark Murphy's twin brother. Were they talking about insulin as well?
19:42 Speaker 05 Yeah, so these recordings, these listening devices which were allegedly put in their house, we are yet to hear those recordings, but we did hear in the opening that the prosecution will allege that there were discussions about the breakdown of insulin.
19:59 Speaker 03 This feels like a whole bunch of loose threads. But I feel like also in the openings, there was a reference to a hot shot as well. Is that something to do with insulin too?
20:10 Speaker 05 So in the opening, it was alleged that Cherie Glastonbury had spoken to her cellmate about how the cause of death may have been determined from the torso alone and why dismemberment may have occurred. She allegedly commented that cutting off the arms would be so you can't tell if someone has been given a hot shot. Again, this evidence hasn't been brought before the jury yet, but this is what the prosecution alleged in their opening.
20:37 Speaker 03 Right, okay, got it. Thank you. If you're listening to this and you're a little bit confused about it, don't worry. I think everyone probably is a little bit confused about it, including the jury. Um, there's a lot to unfold in this trial still and just wanted to make sure that you had all the context of basically insulin reference or any kind of like drug overdose references as well that we've heard from so far to to kind of have that clear in your mind. I mean, Eva, we had this forensic pathologist, you know, examining Geoffrey McLean's body. What did he determine around cause of death?
21:07 Speaker 05 He wasn't actually able to determine anything really. Um, he was able to find that he had aortic stenosis. He can't exclude the possibility that Jeffrey died of it, but he said he found it's more likely he died with it than of it. So we were able to to hear a little bit about that. But as we heard, that there wasn't a lot there to work with. So, um, it was really hard to make any solid conclusion.
21:41 Speaker 03 Um. Yeah, I mean, we're talking about um the body of someone who's been in a we've been for weeks at this point, right? So would not have been a lot that I suppose the lawyers could have could have done with that. Um. Eva, appreciate you taking us all the way through that as well. Um. We do have some questions that are coming in to the case of at abc.net.au. Um. Most of the questions about the case of the we've been murder are when is the next episode of the case that we've been murdered? So um pleased to be able to answer that one with just an entire episode of this series. So hopefully we've quenched your thirst with this episode. Uh Eva, we do have a bunch of other ones that I'm keen to get into though. First one here from Ellen. Ellen's from Melbourne and writes in uh just asking about
22:21 Speaker 03 our repeated use of the term tumultuous to describe what sounds like a history of family violence between the deceased and the accused. Ellen asks, you relying on this language because it is what is arising slash being used in court? Ellen, that is pretty much where I'm getting it from. Yeah, so that is the word that has been used by the prosecution to describe the relationship between Cherie Glastonbury and Geoffrey McLean. Um. And they've also, as we've mentioned, you know, referenced other police attendances at the property as well. So that one point where police attended or prosecution alleges that police attended and saw bruises on Cherie Glastonbury at that point. Uh Eva, anything you were you've been thinking or had thoughts on around that?
22:59 Speaker 05 Just sort of the, yes, that's the term we've heard um said by the prosecution. So we're also using that term and that's as far as we can go at the moment.
23:10 Speaker 03 Um Eva, another one here, uh this falls into a category I like to refer to as uh more of a statement. Um. Usually we're asking for people to send in questions to the case of at abc.net.au. But reflections and thoughts are also very welcome. And that is one that we have here from Bernhard, who's written in from High Demarche Island. Uh. He writes, just in case it's of interest to anyone, Justice Kimpa, who's the judge presiding over this case, played two games of God's grace and glorious game, otherwise known as cricket, for South Australia in the Sheffield Shield thirty years ago. Um. Bernhard hopefully notes that he is a quick tragic uh in case there was any question about that from the fact that he has presented to the case of. So uh Bernhard. Really appreciate you getting in touch with such a wonderful fact.
23:54 Speaker 03 We all now know a little bit more about Justice Kimber and we'll be sending the lawyers to you if this somehow prejudices this trial, which hopefully it doesn't because the jury hasn't heard it. But I feel like it's kind of not relevant at all. So we'll see how we go. If you have a question or a thought, please get in touch. You can write to us at thecaseof@abc.net.au. Eva is here, ready and waiting to answer all questions about the case of the Weeleybin murder. We also have Liz and James ready and waiting to answer any questions around the case of the two intruders. You're all fully aware of my very complicated filing system, four emails, so nothing will get lost. So please get in touch. Eva, what have we got coming up next? Where are we going next in the case of the Weeleybin murder?
24:35 Speaker 05 So we're going to be hearing some more about those alleged attacks before Jeffrey's disappearance. And then we will hopefully eventually get to those listening devices that were put in the home of Peter and Mark Murphy. So we're sort of getting into more of that sort of stuff, which will be very, very interesting.
24:55 Speaker 03 Yeah, I'm looking forward to exploring that a little bit more as well. You know, this case and this trial is not without its delays, as we've talked about in our last episode, in the ceremonial courtroom or one of the bigger courtrooms in Adelaide that occasionally gets used for other purposes. So coming and going a little bit from the case of the Weeleybin murder at the moment, but endeavouring to have you episodes probably once a fortnight or so. And in the meantime, back in your feed with episodes of the case of the two intruders. So make sure you grab yourself ABC Listen. It is the best place to listen to The Case of, as well as a whole bunch of other wonderful ABC content. If you're not using ABC Listen, if you're using another third-party podcast platform, please leave us a rating and a review. It makes it so much easier for people to find us.
25:36 Speaker 03 And we'll be back in your feed on Thursday with an episode of The Case of the Two Intruders.
25:48 Speaker 03 The Case of the Weeleybin Murder is produced by ABC Audio Studios and ABC News. This episode was reported by Eva Blandis and presented by me, Stephen Stockwell. Our supervising producer is Greg Muller and our executive producer is Claire Rawlinson. This episode was produced on the land of the Gana and Moruntri people.
Previous 02 The Two Intruders | The secret kitchen drawer Next 03 The Two Intruders | The defence case emerges Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated