Pod Insights The Case Of 02 Kumanjayi Walker | A cop tried for murder About this episode Four days after shooting Kumanjayi Walker, Zachary Rolfe was charged with murder. Two years later he was in the Northern Territory Supreme Court arguing against that charge.
In this episode, reporter Melissa Mackay describes the unusual series of events that surround this high-profile trial, and talks through the key arguments each side made to the court before the jury found Mr Rolfe not guilty.
If you have any questions you'd like Melissa and Stocky to answer in the final episode of this series, please email thecaseof@abc.net.au mailto:thecaseof@abc.net.au.
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders are advised a deceased person's name is used in this episode.
The Case Of is the follow-up to the hit podcast Mushroom Case Daily, and all episodes of that show will remain available in the back catalogue of The Case Of.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Start the new year in the right headspace with some great conversations. We've curated episodes on motivation, health, addiction, relationships, confidence and mindset just for you.
0:14 Speaker 01 Saying to myself, you've had a pretty good life, so not a bad way to die surfing. And then I thought, no, not today. You know, it's my family that brought it back.
0:22 Speaker 00 Search Conversations Podcast with Richard Fieglar and Sarah Konoski on the ABC Listen app.
0:29 Speaker 02 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:36 Speaker 03 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander listeners are advised that this episode contains the name of an Aboriginal person who has died.
0:52 Speaker 03 A pair of scissors, three gunshots and a cop charged with murder. Zachary Rolfe fought that. Lawyers combed over the detail of Kumunjo Walker's death with his family and the country watching. I'm Stephen Stockwell, welcome to the case of Kumunjo Walker. This is chapter two.
1:14 Speaker 04 Constable Zachary Rolfe fatally shot the 19-year-old. Sometimes I think about how he must have felt in his last moments. Was he scared?
1:23 Speaker 05 And I can promise you, consequences will flow.
1:26 Speaker 06 Constable Rolfe has pleaded not guilty to one charge of murder.
1:29 Speaker 07 Prosecutors took the case to the High Court. There's been a huge outpouring of grief.
1:34 Speaker 04 An organisation with significant hallmarks of institutional racism.
1:38 Speaker 08 When? We are going to get justice. When?
1:50 Speaker 03 In our last episode, we painted a picture of the night in November 2019 where Zachary Rolfe shot Kumunjo Walker. The ramifications for this happened almost immediately and someone who was there at the time when this happened and has joined us for this series of the case of is Melissa McKay. And Melissa, you know, you would have seen the reaction to this so quickly, right?
2:17 Speaker 06 Yeah, absolutely. It became very clear very quickly that there were going to be two very binary sides to this case. There was going to be supporters of Constable Zachary Rolfe and supporters of Kumanjayi Walker and his family and his community.
2:36 Speaker 03 Um, yeah. In, in this episode, we're going to look at the murder trial of Constable Zachary Rolfe. Um, that is an unusual situation in and of itself, having a police officer charged with murder uh, over a shooting while they'd been on duty. So we'll explore all of that. And also look at how that trial unfolded, what the arguments from the prosecution and what the defence were. And it kind of building to what was a really dramatic moment in that trial. And Mel, you're talking about these kind of two sides that have formed through this process, but while people formed opinions in this quite quickly, Mel, um, Zachary Rolfe was charged with murder quite quickly too. It was like, you know, less than a week, four days, right?
3:18 Speaker 06 Yeah, yeah, it was four days um, after the shooting that, that Zachary Rolfe was charged with murder and it was about 24 hours after um, members of the government and the police commissioner had uh, been to Yundamu um, to, to speak to the community and sort of try to address their concerns about what they had just been through.
3:42 Speaker 03 What, what happened during those visits?
3:45 Speaker 06 So we saw the then um, police commissioner, Jamie Chalka, head to Yundamu with the then chief minister, Michael Gunner. They addressed um, members of the community who were obviously very distressed. A lot of them had, had witnessed the shooting. Um, they had also just been, as we spoke about in the last episode, had just been through um, the loss of uh, an elder in the community. And a lot of people were really confused about what had happened and they wanted to know where the police investigation was at. In, in sort of a, a moment, I suppose, of trying to um, calm uh, community concerns.
4:30 Speaker 06 The chief minister, Michael Gunner, said that there would be a police investigation. Then there would be a coronial investigation and that consequences will flow as a result of that investigation.
4:44 Speaker 03 It seems like a really big call for like for the chief minister to make at a time like that.
4:51 Speaker 06 Yeah, and those those comments went on to to sort of follow Michael Gunner for the rest of his political career. Um, that consequences will flow comment, um, you know, was was reiterated by Zachary Rolfe's lawyers. It was used um later as as an argument to say that there had been uh corruption and and political interference uh with the with the investigation. It's important to note that there was an ICAC investigation into that incident and and that there has been no evidence of political interference uh found.
5:35 Speaker 03 And I guess the the thinking behind that, right, is the timing of it. You know, the reason that people looked at that so closely was, you know, we have the the then chief minister saying consequences will flow and, you know, we talked about how quickly Zachary Rolfe was charged with murder following the shooting. It was four days and it was like with the following day from from when the chief minister said that, right, that that Zachary Rolfe was charged.
5:55 Speaker 06 Yeah, yeah, it was it was quite quick.
5:57 Speaker 03 Hmm, yeah, and I mean, the the sort of the unusual process doesn't end there because, I mean, am I right in thinking that that he was he was granted bail, which in itself is unusual, people charged with murder, but not only that, but it was done like over the phone?
6:13 Speaker 06 Yeah, it was done over the phone. So Zachary Rolfe was refused police bail, uh but he was granted bail by a judge over the phone um out of court, which is something that I had never seen before um as as a court reporter, to see someone charged with murder uh not have to.
6:35 Speaker 06 Face court the following day to to make an application for bail.
6:39 Speaker 03 Yeah, wow. And I mean, you know, there's plenty of unusual parts of this, but I mean, did we have Zachary Rolfe arrested by the people that he was working with? Because, you know, he's he's a policeman. And, you know, it's the police that arrest people, right? So is it his mates, colleagues that are doing this?
6:56 Speaker 06 Technically, it was it was his colleagues, yeah, but it wasn't his colleagues in Alice Springs.
7:02 Speaker 03 Right.
7:02 Speaker 06 Um. And this sort of also then kind of fed into that that that argument by Zachary Rolfe and his supporters that there had been some kind of interference or some kind of, um, you know, issue with with this early investigation was that he was flown to Darwin from Alice Springs, um, where he was ultimately arrested.
7:31 Speaker 03 Yeah.
7:31 Speaker 06 Um. He said that at the time he thought he was being flown to Darwin, um, you know, to to to get him out of that Central Australian environment, um, you know, to to look after his his mental health after this critical incident. Um, but he was then ultimately arrested um, by police officers in Darwin uh in in front of his mum.
7:56 Speaker 03 Oh, wow. Um, that is another just kind of twist in in this story as well. Um, I mean, something I've noticed about the courts is that you will be expecting something to start on one day and it won't quite work out that way. You get pushed back, you'll get pushed back, you'll get pushed back. I mean, what were some of the things that were holding up this proceeding? Because there seems to be this kind of like obstacle course on the way to the trial.
8:20 Speaker 06 Yeah, absolutely. Well, we had, um, initially, there was this argument from Zachary Rolfe's lawyers to have the case moved from Alice Springs to Darwin. Uh, that was one of the first applications that that they made, um, pretty immediately, um, arguing that there had been so much media coverage of the shooting that there was no way he could have access to a fair trial in Central Australia.
8:44 Speaker 03 Hmm.
8:44 Speaker 06 Initially, that was knocked back. All of the sort of local court, the lower court proceedings did happen in Alice Springs. So we had the committal hearing. Um, ultimately, the the trial was uh was set.
9:00 Speaker 06 Then there was the argument again to move the trial itself to Darwin. That was successful. The trial was moved to Darwin. We then had a trip to the High Court. There was arguments over what defences were going to be available to Zachary Rolfe.
9:16 Speaker 03 Hold up a second. So this was on the way to trial, just broadly challenged all the way to the High Court. So there was like, this was going right to the top.
9:24 Speaker 06 So the High Court argument happened before the trial.
9:28 Speaker 03 Hmm.
9:29 Speaker 06 Um, to, to narrow what defences were going to be available to Zachary Rolfe when he faced a jury.
9:40 Speaker 03 And when you say like ruling out a defence, I mean, there's, there's lots of different types of defence. The one that I'm immediately thinking of is like self-defence. And I can't imagine that was the, what was ruled out. But I mean, what would they, what was the discussion they were having in the High Court?
9:52 Speaker 06 So there's this element um in Northern Territory legislation, which was interpreted one way um by Zachary Rolfe's lawyers to mean that, that essentially any police officer who was acting in good faith in their role as a police officer was immune to prosecution, essentially for anything that they did on the job. And prosecutors wanted to make sure that Zachary Rolfe couldn't use that argument.
10:27 Speaker 03 Right.
10:28 Speaker 06 So that's a very simplistic way to put it, but essentially we, we had to go to the, to the High Court for the High Court to rule on essentially the scope of that argument. Um, that delayed the trial itself because that, you know, that was pretty critical to the way the trial was going to run.
10:51 Speaker 03 Right, okay, so he couldn't run the the good faith defence, but I mean, the terrible example I gave was the self defence defence, and then he was still able to run that one, right?
11:00 Speaker 06 Yes, he was still able to run the self defence defence. So there were still defences available to Zachary Rolfe throughout his trial. It was this good faith defence that was that was ruled out.
11:13 Speaker 03 Yeah, okay, great, thank you. It's a level of detail and the sort of lawyering that I really appreciate learning about on the case of, because it is real classic lawyering, something like that, going all the way to the High Court to to split hairs over different parts of legislation. Mel, the first thing that happens at a trial is the the impairment of the jury, obviously, but then also the the openings of the of the arguments, both prosecution and defence. They're kind of laying out their their cases for this. And this is often where we get so much detail about what has happened, and it's the first time often we're able to report on some of that detail as well. So, you know, it's a really big part of a trial.
11:55 Speaker 03 I mean, what did you what did you learn or what did you see in the openings of the the murder trial for Zachary Rolfe?
12:02 Speaker 06 The prosecution began their opening statement with the body worn footage of the shooting.
12:08 Speaker 03 So it was played to the court?
12:09 Speaker 06 It was played to the court, and and that was the first time that a lot of people had seen it.
12:15 Speaker 03 Hmm.
12:16 Speaker 06 And this was something that people beforehand, before the trial, you know, the the conversations on the street were, well, you know, it'll all be in the body worn.
12:26 Speaker 03 And Mel, I mean, this is a courtroom that, you know, does not just have, you know, Zachary Rolfe in it, doesn't just have the lawyers in it, doesn't have the jury, there's also members of the family of Kumanjayi Walker in that room, you're in there, the media's in there. What was it like seeing that video?
12:45 Speaker 06 It was pretty shocking and I remember there being a, a warning before the video was played that this footage was very confronting and that it was about to be played to the court. And there were several members of Kumanjayi Walker's family who left the room. Um, you know, it, it was, it was simply too, too distressing and too traumatic um to watch, especially given that we watched it over and over throughout the course of the trial.
13:20 Speaker 03 Yeah, I, I mean, how did they spell out the case against Zachary Rolfe? What were the kind of, the, the claims that they were making, the allegations they were making at this stage of the trial?
13:29 Speaker 06 The Crown case relied quite heavily on the 2.6 seconds between the first shot and the second and third. And so we saw in their opening statement, not only the body worn footage in full, but they also broke it down frame by frame. They slowed it down. They showed what they said was the difference in circumstances between the first shot and the second and third, which were the two shots that the, that the murder charge relied on.
14:02 Speaker 03 Yeah, right. I mean, we spoke about this in, in the first episode of this series. You know, there were the three shots that were taken. There was the first shot. There was that two and a half second pause, which again seems like it might be a short time, but kind of feels longer when you, when you time it out. Um, and what had changed in those moments? So that was what the prosecution was pulling apart. They were like, look, this first shot, that's one thing. These other two shots, that's potentially something else.
14:26 Speaker 06 Exactly. That was the Crown case, was that there had been a fundamental change in circumstances between that first shot and the second and third. And it was that second and third shot that the Crown argued were murder. And if not murder, they were manslaughter or engaging in a violent act causing death. So while Zachary Rolfe was charged with murder, there were also these two backup charges, uh, which were available to the jury at that point too.
14:55 Speaker 03 Right. And so the prosecution had spelt that out at the early stage of the trial. They've said, look, if it's not murder, we also think it could be manslaughter or engaging in a violent act causing death.
15:04 Speaker 06 Exactly.
15:05 Speaker 03 Right. Zachary Rolfe in this trial, in the trial where he's been accused of murder and is answering, you know, the various evidence that's presented, he has his own legal team. He was actually represented by David Edwardson, KC. It's actually Matt Wright's barrister, so it's a name that the case of listeners may be familiar with from the case of the Crock Wrangler. He's delivering an opening address to the jury as well, just kind of like, you know, basically kind of laying out often their side of the story. What was he saying? What was he doing in his opening?
15:35 Speaker 06 So David Edwardson, KC, delivered his opening address, which was a lot shorter than the prosecution's. And he reiterates the fact throughout his opening that he doesn't have to prove anything. Zachary Rolfe himself doesn't have to prove anything. The onus is on the Crown to prove Zachary Rolfe murdered Kumanjayi Walker, not for Zachary Rolfe to prove that he didn't. And David Edwardson's style, which listeners might remember from the case of the Crock Wrangler, his style is very theatrical. He sort of delivers his addresses as if he's telling a story.
16:19 Speaker 06 There's always a through line for his opening address and his closing address. And in this case, his through line was that knife equals gun. He said that this was something that would loom large throughout the trial, essentially arguing that Zachary Rolfe was trained as a police officer to respond to a knife or an edged weapon, such as a pair of scissors, with his gun. That police officers were trained to meet an edged weapon with lethal force.
16:55 Speaker 03 Yeah. And, you know, we were talking about, you know, the prosecution case, which is that, you know, the intention had changed in the time between the two shots. There was, you know, the first shot was one thing, the second shot was this other thing. And, you know, the defence is obviously saying, look, the whole thing is self-defense. He was following his training, doing his job. I mean, did the prosecution accept that Rolfe was justified in firing his weapon at any stage?
17:21 Speaker 06 The first shot was seen as essentially as justified by the prosecution. The the charges related only to the second and third shots because a- as we touched on, the the Crown argued that the situation had changed between the first shot being fired and the second and third. And the way that they showed that or the way that they argued that was that in the 2.6 seconds between the first shot being fired and the second, Kumun Jai Walker had gone from being on his feet, standing face to face with Zachary Rolfe and his partner, Adamie Burl,
18:05 Speaker 06 to being on the ground with Adamie Burl, Zachary Rolfe's partner, sort of on on top of him, attempting to to put him into handcuffs.
18:17 Speaker 03 Yeah, right. And I mean, as you were talking about with David Edwinson, Casey's opening, he's made this point that it's not up to him to prove anything. It's up to the prosecution to prove its case against Zachary Rolfe. Um, how was it trying to do that? Was it was it just the body worn footage? What was some of the key evidence that was being put forward to to kind of back them up?
18:38 Speaker 06 We saw the body worn footage over and over and over again throughout this trial. Um, it was it was interesting because the prosecution relied quite heavily on the body worn footage. But the defence also relied quite heavily on the body worn footage. And keep in mind, we had the body worn cameras of both Zachary Rolfe and his partner, as well as other officers from the I R T who were there in Yundmu at the time. Obviously, no one's body worn was quite as clear as the two police officers who who were in the room. Um, but the Crown relied quite heavily on.
19:16 Speaker 06 The body worn by slowing it down and showing the jury frame by frame how things were moving. Whereas the defence used the body worn to argue how quickly everything had unfolded and also argued quite a lot that the body worn camera didn't show everything.
19:37 Speaker 03 Right.
19:37 Speaker 06 And that there were limitations to what was, what was in the body worn.
19:42 Speaker 03 Hmm. Yeah. And I mean, you know, you talk about the kind of the, the two approaches to time almost in that situation, right? You've got the, the prosecution slowing this thing down, showing each moment as it's kind of like in its own entirety, in its own moment. Um. And then you have the, the defence showing it, you know, probably in real time, right? And it's just like this, this all happens so quickly. Uh. And then, you know, that kind of being put to the jury. I mean, you know, what, what happens? What, what did you see after the shooting, after Kumun Jai Walker's on the ground? Was that something that was talked about very much?
20:16 Speaker 06 Yeah, there was also this argument around whether or not Kumun Jai Walker was still a threat to the police officers when he was on the ground. There was, there was this whole argument around, you know, the hand that he had the scissors in, whether or not that arm was pinned underneath his own body when he had been taken to the ground by police. The defence argued that, no, his arm was not fully pinned to the ground, that it was, that he was not, you know, that the police, in, in the police speak, that the threat had not been incapacitated at that point.
20:55 Speaker 03 Hmm.
20:56 Speaker 06 Whereas the prosecution argued that in the moment that Kumun Jai Walker had been taken to the ground by the police officers, that his arm was pinned under his body and he simply could not have been a threat to either Zachary Rolfe or Adam E. Burl.
21:12 Speaker 03 Hmm.
21:13 Speaker 06 Whereas the defence argument was that he, he was trying to stab Adam E. Burl after he had stabbed Zachary Rolfe.
21:21 Speaker 03 Hmm. And I mean, Mel, something I'm interested in is how were, you know, the kind of the two people involved in this kind of characterized during this trial? How was Kumun Jai Walker spoken about? And, and how was Zachary Rolfe kind of painted by, by both the prosecution and the defence as they were working through the kind of the, the main heart, the main bulk of this trial?
21:40 Speaker 06 It was really interesting for a lot of the trial because there were also, there were so many suppression orders um over certain elements that were happening outside of what was being put to the jury. And so what we heard throughout the trial about Kumanjayi Walker, particularly from the defence, was, you know, we heard a lot about his, his criminal history and there was a lot said about the fact that he had, you know, stabbed Zachary Rolfe with this pair of scissors and that he had wielded this axe against other police officers two days earlier. And so he was very much characterised, particularly by the defence, as
22:22 Speaker 06 a violent offender, as a, a threat uh to these police. And that he was capable of using lethal force against police officers.
22:35 Speaker 03 What did we hear in the trial about the, the injuries that Zachary Rolfe suffered, you know, as, as this happened, as, you know, as he was stabbed with these scissors by Kumanjayi Walker?
22:45 Speaker 06 We saw, this was the first time that we, we saw the pictures of uh the, the wound that, that Zachary Rolfe had uh had suffered on, on that night. We'd heard a lot in the lead up about Zachary Rolfe having been stabbed uh by Kumanjayi Walker, which triggered uh his response to use his, his weapon. And so we saw uh for the first time evidence around exactly the, the impact of that. There was ultimately a three millimetre puncture to Zachary Rolfe's shoulder that didn't require stitches.
23:27 Speaker 03 Right. And, I mean, you know, we talked a bit about how Kumanjayi Walker was characterised in the trial. What about Zachary Rolfe? How was, how was he spoken about, you know, for, you know, for the main body of the trial?
23:39 Speaker 06 The prosecution characterised Zachary Rolfe as someone who was reckless, as a police officer who hadn't followed his training, who had sort of rushed into this situation with Kumanjayi Walker. The defence characterised Zachary Rolfe as a hero, as someone who was protecting himself and protecting his partner from Kumanjayi Walker who had just stabbed a police officer with a pair of scissors.
24:11 Speaker 03 Yeah, right, okay. Mel, did the court hear any evidence or was there any challenge to whether Zachary Rolfe really did follow his training?
24:21 Speaker 06 Yeah, there was, and there was this senior Northern Territory police officer, Andrew Barham, who was one of the Crown witnesses, who really challenged a lot of Zachary Rolfe's decisions on the night. He was used as the person to explain where things had gone wrong on that night. And this is, you know, one of those senior police officers that I, I think, you know, was, was one that Zachary Rolfe was sort of implying, you know, didn't know what it was like for, for the men and women on the ground anymore, you know. Andrew Barham, the crux of his evidence essentially was that Zachary Rolfe should
25:01 Speaker 06 never have put himself in the situation that he was in, in House 511 on that night anyway. He should never have gotten so close to Kumanjayi Walker in that moment, that there should have been, you know, a cordon and contain sort of approach by the police officers on that night to try and coax Kumanjayi out of the house, or that they shouldn't have gone into those houses, searching for him in the way that they did, because there were other people around. And so he, his evidence was quite strong in the sense that he was arguing that Zachary
25:43 Speaker 06 Rolfe hadn't followed his training on the night of the shooting.
25:48 Speaker 03 Hmm, right. And I mean, Mel, this case, as we've spoken about, really comes back to the timing of the shots fired on that night. Now, according to the prosecution, the first one was justified, but the second and third shots that come a couple of seconds later constitute murder. I mean, is that kind of what the prosecution was relying on?
26:10 Speaker 06 Pretty heavily, that was, that was a lot of it. There was also this argument around whether or not the scissors that he was armed with could have possibly killed Zachary Rolfe or Adamie Burl. And the prosecution argued that, no, that they, that they couldn't have, that the tips of the scissors were too blunt, they were rounded. They, they argued that they couldn't have killed Zachary Rolfe or Adamie Burl, whereas the defence characterised this, this attack with the scissors as one which could have been lethal.
26:52 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's, it's so interesting to hear the kind of descriptions of these people, of Zachary Rolfe and of Kumaja Walker in the courtroom, as they're being talked about in this trial, in this instance, in the trial sense, because the way that they're talked about in the inquest that we'll get to in a couple of episodes' time, Mel, is, is so different. You know, often the same details but talked about in a very different way. But I mean, you know, in, in the case of this trial, of Zachary Rolfe's murder trial, I mean, he's in the room watching all this unfold, right? Like, he's there, hearing all of this being said about him.
27:26 Speaker 06 Yeah, Zachary Rolfe was, as we, as we spoke about, Zachary Rolfe was on bail this whole time. So he was coming and going from the Supreme Court Building every day. He was walking through town to get from his hotel in the CBD to the Supreme Court Building in the CBD every day. He would walk in with his lawyers, with his supporters, with the Police Association every morning, and he would walk back every afternoon. And throughout the trial itself, because we were still in the middle of, of Covid restrictions, Zachary
28:09 Speaker 06 Rolfe was sitting in the public gallery of his own murder trial.
28:13 Speaker 03 Really?
28:14 Speaker 06 This is something I had never seen before and, and obviously, you know, things with, with Covid were unprecedented. So, you know, the, the court had to kind of scramble to, to figure out how to socially distance a jury because if one juror got Covid, the whole case, which had already been delayed several times, would have, would have been thrown into absolute disarray. So to sort of get around that, the court separated the jury across, you know, the jury box and the dock where the accused would usually sit.
28:57 Speaker 03 Hmm.
28:58 Speaker 06 So half the jury was on one side of the room, the other half were on the other side of the room. There was nowhere for the accused to go, other than the public gallery, behind his lawyers, in front of journalists, next to his parents and Kumajai Walker's family.
29:19 Speaker 03 Wow. Oh my God. That is just a kind of incredible situation to be in. And I guess it kind of points to just the strangeness that we're dealing with through Covid, but also the, the kind of incredible nature, you know, in so many ways of this trial as well, right?
29:36 Speaker 06 Absolutely. I mean, this was a, this was a man who we had already seen bailed immediately after being charged with murder and was then walking through town to get to his murder trial every day. Um, was sitting in the public gallery of his own murder trial. You know, this, this trial went for about six weeks.
29:59 Speaker 03 Hmm.
30:00 Speaker 06 Everyone was sort of milling about the courthouse during breaks, to the point where in the foyer of the Supreme Court building, there were sort of almost two distinct camps which developed. We had Kumajai Walker's family sat around one group of couches, journalists sat around another group of couches, and then we had Zachary Rolfe and his team sitting in another area of the Supreme Court foyer.
30:37 Speaker 06 It was just a very strange situation um to be in. And, you know, during these breaks, people are sort of trying to avoid one another, but also, you know, politely saying hello or politely saying good morning, you know. Zachary Rolfe would walk into court every morning and he would give a wave to the police officers who were sort of standing guard outside of the Supreme Court building. He would give a fairly polite good morning to all of the journalists who were waiting out the front of the building for him every day.
31:18 Speaker 06 Um, you know, there were times where his parents and his lawyers would interact with with members of the media and members of the public who were in the building.
31:30 Speaker 03 Yeah, right. You know, when we see a trial like this, what what happens, the way it unfolds is that kind of prosecution is is kind of running it. They're they're they're sort of dictating the the the speed, the witnesses, everything that's coming forward as the the case unfolds i- in the main. Um, how did it feel when when the kind of when the prosecution rested their case after they'd called their their last witness?
31:53 Speaker 06 It was really sudden to to see and and to hear the the Crown very calmly say, that is the Crown case. Um, it was really strange to have to have gotten to that point after so long. You know, finally, sort of hearing i- i- in open court, the allegations against Zachary Rolfe in full. And, you know, we'd seen the body worn camera footage over and over um of this incident, but there was still the defence case to come.
32:28 Speaker 03 Yeah, and tha- that's the thing, right? Like, you don't know what is going to happen in these cases. You know, the prosecution calls all their witnesses and then the defence may have some witnesses to call as well. And there is this huge question that kind of hangs over over a murder trial about whether or not the accused will give evidence, that is, in this instance, Zachary Rolfe. What were you expecting at this point? You know, the prosecution closes their case. I I know there would have been conversation around with with the media team or the various media crews about whether or not Zachary Rolfe would would give evidence. What were you thinking?
33:01 Speaker 06 I had no idea whether Zachary Rolf was going to give evidence or not. It's a huge risk, right? And there had always been, you know, this, this rumour, I think, at least among court reporters, that you only ever call the accused if you think your case is going really poorly.
33:23 Speaker 03 Hmm.
33:24 Speaker 06 Um, and so no one really knew where this was going to go. And because of how big of a risk it is, no one really thought that Zachary Rolf was going to get in the box.
33:38 Speaker 03 Yeah. Be back in your feed on Tuesday next week. I'll give you a little spoiler at this point. Mel, what ends up happening?
33:47 Speaker 06 Zachary Rolf was called to give evidence.
33:50 Speaker 03 It's a kind of incredible turn of events in a murder trial. So, yeah, we'll be back in your feed on Tuesday. Mel, thank you so much for, for taking us through the first part of this trial.
33:59 Speaker 06 Thank you.
34:00 Speaker 03 We'll have all the details of what evidence Zachary Rolf gave in his murder trial and, and the verdict that the jury ultimately delivered in our next episode. Make sure you grab yourself the ABC Listen app. It's the best place to listen to episodes of The Case Of. And if you have any questions that you'd like Mel or I to answer, let's be honest, it will be Mel, please email us, thecaseof@abc.net.au and we'll collate them all together for an episode where we ring Mel back and, and answer all of your questions when we wrap up this series. Be back in your feed on Tuesday.
34:37 Speaker 03 The Case of Kumunjo Walker is produced by ABC Audio Studios and ABC News. It's reported by Melissa McKay and presented by me, Stephen Stockwell. Our supervising producer is Greg Muller and our executive producer is Claire Rawlinson. Thank you to senior lawyer Jasmine Sims and to senior cultural adviser Muriam Korowa for their help making this series. This episode was produced on the land of the Gadigal and Moruntri people.
Previous 01 Kumanjayi Walker | The night of the shooting Next 03 Kumanjayi Walker | Police brutality or just doing the job? Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated