Skip to content

The Epic Movie Draft

The Big Picture

Hosted by Amanda Dobbins and Sean Fennessey

1h 54m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

In honor of Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey, Sean Fennessey and Amanda Dobbins conduct the first epic movie draft with guest Chris Ryan. Before the draft, they cover Sam Neill's death at 78, the live-action Moana remake's $125 million loss, and the Digger trailer. Sean notes that Moana's audience has aged out—kids who were eight in 2016 are now 18—and that The Rock's filmography since 2016 contains no film approaching a lower mid-tier Schwarzenegger. Sean argues Disney's live-action remakes eroded what was special about the studio by remaking its own films with human actors, a strategy that produced $800 million for years but is now failing.

The draft spans seven categories: Odyssey-inspired epics, epic best picture winners, biblical epic, romantic or war epic, biopic epic, movies exceeding three hours, and wildcard. Debates arise over eligibility—Kingdom of Heaven in the biblical category, JFK as a biopic versus a three-hour film, and whether a 110-minute Last of the Mohicans qualifies as epic. Sean co-programmed a Criterion Channel series of seven Odyssey-inspired films, including The Searchers and After Hours, which he references as eligible picks.

Picks range from Lawrence of Arabia and Seven Samurai to Kill Bill: The Whole Bloody Affair and Carlos. Amanda argues Godfather Part Two is more epic than Part One due to its flashback structure, while Sean defends Amadeus as a dual biopic. The episode closes with honorable mentions spanning Gone with the Wind, The Ten Commandments, and Tarkovsky's Andrei Rublev.

  • The live-action Moana remake made $43 million in the US and $95 million worldwide, with a reported $125 million loss to Disney, partly because the original's young audience has aged out. 8:55
  • Sean argues Disney's live-action remakes eroded the studio's creative identity by remaking its own films with human actors rather than adapting pre-existing stories. 17:33
  • The epic movie draft uses seven categories: Odyssey-inspired epics, epic best picture winners, biblical epic, romantic or war epic, biopic epic, movies exceeding three hours, and wildcard. 34:23
  • Sean co-programmed a Criterion Channel series of seven Odyssey-inspired films including The Searchers, Sullivan's Travels, and After Hours, all eligible in the draft. 26:08
  • Chris picks Kingdom of Heaven director's cut in the biblical epic category, which Sean initially rejects on theatrical-release grounds but allows after confirming a 2005 Lemley Fairfax screening. 1:28:11

Highlights

  • 4:22

    Sam Neill's Death and Careerstory

    Sean reflects on Sam Neill's death at 78, listing his 1990s films including Jurassic Park, The Hunt for Red October, In the Mouth of Madness, The Piano, and Event Horizon. He calls Neill a metronomic actor capable of both subtlety and going full crazy.

  • 8:53

    Moana's Box Office Collapsedata

    Sean reports Moana made $43 million domestically and $95 million worldwide, with $125 million lost to Disney. He attributes the failure to the original's audience aging out and the film being rushed to fast-track Moana 2.

  • 10:18

    The Rock's Filmography Since 2016data

    Sean reads out Dwayne Johnson's complete filmography since the original Moana: 15 films including Fast and Furious, Jumanji, Black Adam, and Red One. Chris notes none approach a lower mid-tier Schwarzenegger film.

  • 17:31

    Disney Remakes Eroded the Brandinsight

    Sean argues Disney's live-action remakes took movies they already made and remade them less good with human actors, eroding 80-90 years of creative identity. He says the strategy should end.

  • 26:08

    Criterion Channel Odyssey Seriesstrategy

    Sean co-programmed a seven-film series on the Criterion Channel of Odyssey-inspired films: The Searchers, The Darjeeling Limited, Sullivan's Travels, Walk About, The Straight Story, After Hours, and O Brother Where Art Thou.

  • 36:20

    Lawrence of Arabia as the Benchmarkinsight

    Chris picks Lawrence of Arabia as the number one seed, calling it a true heavyweight champion of global filmmaking. Sean notes Nolan and Tom Holland screened the Sony print before making The Odyssey as a benchmark.

  • 55:41

    Malcolm X as Biopic Epicinsight

    Chris picks Malcolm X, praising its ability to take a life from youth to death without feeling like Wikipedia. He highlights how the film's color scheme and musical identity shift across decades to track Malcolm's changing consciousness.

  • 1:33:51

    Carlos as Wildcard Pickinsight

    Chris picks Olivier Assayas's Carlos, calling it one of the most breathtaking hybrids of mini series and film. He notes its British post-punk soundtrack and its depiction of the rolling out of the sixties into the seventies.

About this episode

Sean and Amanda are joined by Chris Ryan for their first ever (and potentially last) Epic Movie Draft, in anticipation of Christopher Nolan’s ‘The Odyssey’. Before kicking things off, they react to legendary actor Sam Neil’s passing, Moana’s opening weekend box office bomb, and the trailers released for ‘Digger’ and ‘Dune: Part Three’. Then, they debate what it is exactly that makes a movie “epic” and draft some incredible films from a myriad of different categories. (0:00) Intro (1:47) We went to Canada (3:27) Sam Neill’s passing (7:12) ‘Moana’ bombs at the box office (and Disney's live-action future) (17:04) ‘Digger’ trailer reaction (22:11) ‘Dune: Part Three’ trailer reaction (24:58) ‘Odyssey’-inspired epics series on the Criterion Channel (27:00) What makes a movie epic? (33:20) The Epic Movie Draft (1:39:15) Honorable mentions and draft recap Hosts: Sean Fennessey and Amanda Dobbins Guest: Chris Ryan Producer: Jack Sanders Production Support: Lucas Cavanagh It’s on Prime. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript

0:00
1:54:34

22,435 words · 8 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Epic Film
  • Movie Draft
  • Box Office
  • Disney Remakes
  • Film History
  • The Odyssey
  • Dwayne Johnson
  • Sam Neill

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated