Pod Insights Talking Real Money - Investing Talk Whole Lotta Questions About this episode This Friday Q&A episode of Talking Real Money features a surge in listener questions, covering key retirement and investing topics including IRA inheritance strategies, borrowing in retirement, how to find fiduciary advisors, the powerful tax advantages of HSAs, pension timing decisions, and whether Robinhood’s 2% IRA transfer bonus is worth the trade-offs. Don emphasizes simplicity and tax efficiency—favoring IRA rollovers over inherited structures for spouses, cautioning that borrowing becomes harder in retirement, praising HSAs as one of the best tax-advantaged tools available, encouraging aggressive Roth saving to bridge early retirement gaps, and warning that “free money” incentives like Robinhood’s may come with hidden costs, particularly through payment-for-order-flow execution.0:05 Shift to podcast-only boosts listener call volume2:26 Spousal IRA decision: inherited vs rollover strategy5:59 Why rollover IRAs usually win for older surviving spouses6:26 Borrowing in retirement: income limits and lender challenges8:03 Alternative borrowing strategies and why cash often wins9:07 How to find fiduciary advisors on the website10:16 HSA explained: triple tax advantage and retirement use12:41 Pension planning and early retirement trade-offs14:08 Why delaying pension and Social Security pays off15:35 Roth IRA as a bridge strategy for early retirement18:33 Robinhood 2% IRA transfer: risks vs reward19:49 Payment-for-order-flow and why execution quality matters21:54 Final thoughts: simplicity, discipline, and avoiding gimmicksQuestions? Comments? Click!
Transcript 0:05 Speaker 00 Your guides to a really great financial future. Tom and Don are talking real money.
0:11 Speaker 01 Well, it looks like our move to podcast only, at least in terms of questions, is paying off because our inflow of questions, particularly the kind I like best, the recorded ones, is way up, which means in this episode, I can fit six in. Maybe more, but I'm going for six. That's what I've decided already. I've got six already and I don't pick them out. I just take them in order. Whatever order they come in, I take them. Now, bear in mind, if there is a technical glitch, you may not hear it, but if there's a technical glitch, I don't know what happened. So you're going to have to re-record it. If you don't hear your question after a while, and you recorded it with your voice,
0:55 Speaker 01 you didn't hear it on any of the Friday podcasts, then try another one. Just go to talkingrealmoney.com, click on the button that says, "Ask a question", and then record your question. And I'll put it on a future Friday podcast. And it's usually only a few weeks out. Max about three to four weeks out, so it's not a long wait. Send them all in at talkingrealmoney.com. And also, I wanted to remind everybody that now you can get the Kindle edition of my book from my 2022 edition of my book, Financial Physics, F Y S I C S. And you can read it for free if you're a Kindle Unlimited member. So that's a deal.
1:39 Speaker 01 And you can also buy the book, the paperback one. But here's the trick. When you go to Amazon to look for these and you type in Financial F Y S I C S, it will correct it to P H Y. And then it'll say, "Did you really mean F Y?" And you have to click yes, and then it'll give you the right book. It's, their thing is a little confused. I've tried to clear it up, but it's not working. So anyway, that's what I have for you. I have a bunch of calls. I have a bunch of questions. I'm Don McDonald. This is the Talking Real Money Friday Q and A Podcast. And again, send those questions in at talkingrealmoney.com on the Ask a Question or the Contact Form. You can also call us at 855-935-TALK.
2:22 Speaker 01 That's 855-935-8255 with your questions. It's So easy, so many ways to do it. Now, let's get to the first question of the day.
2:33 Speaker 02 Good morning, Don. This is Dan from Minden, and I have a question regarding IRAs. My father recently passed away. He was approaching 95, so he's 94. My mom is 87, and so my mom is looking at taking my dad's IRAs and rolling them over into her name. The question I have is that the company that they're working with, which I believe is Fidelity, has put forward two different options.
3:13 Speaker 02 One, that they could be treated as an inherited IRA, or it could be treated as a rollover IRA and roll it over entirely into my mom's name. My understanding is that, based on her age, it's better to do it as a rollover. And again, my understanding is that with the inherited, that makes more sense if you're under the age of 60. I don't quite understand why that's the case, so I'm curious to get your take. And then the other thing is that if my mom were to treat it as an inherited IRA, does the 10-year rule apply?
3:54 Speaker 02 Or is it just treated as an inherited IRA, and then when my mom passes and that is then passed on to her children, do the children then have to honor the 10-year rule? All right? I appreciate your time.
4:11 Speaker 01 I think without Congress, we'd probably be out of business. These things are so confusing. Let me try to make it as simple as possible. The simple answer is, taking the inherited IRA is almost always, in this kind of a situation, with an 87-year-old beneficiary, the better option. Because it's going to mean she'll just continue withdrawals at her life expectancy, and that should mean smaller withdrawals on an annual basis. They should be larger if she takes it as an inherited IRA.
4:51 Speaker 01 And the inheritance thing from her to you guys really cinches the deal because if she takes it as an inherited IRA and you then inherit the inherited IRA, then you're gonna have to take it out at the same rate she has been taking it out. Therefore, you're better off too if she rolls it over. The rollover option is the better option. Paying less in taxes, more flexibility, better situation for those who might inherit it if she doesn't draw it down, which she probably won't. So, um, yeah, you as beneficiaries would get the 10-year rule when you got it because
5:34 Speaker 01 it was her IRA, not an inherited that she started taking under the inherited rule. So it's all very confusing and frustrating, but I gotta tell you, if this was my mom, I would suggest that she keep it as a rollover IRA, that she make it a rollover IRA because the inherited IRA is more complicated, has more taxes, is more restrictive, and there's really no meaningful benefit to it. So that to me is the best advice. Thanks for your question. It was a good one, and now we'll grab another one on our way to getting six questions in this week.
6:10 Speaker 03 Hi, Don. This question is one that I tried to leave a few weeks ago, but I think there was an error with the system. It concerns being able to get credit for purchases in retirement. I'm thinking in this case about our ability to get loans for a car or maybe a house in retirement. I'll have a pension that covers our basic living expenses as well as investment accounts in a 401 and a Roth. Since we have great credit now, can we expect our ability to get a loan in the future to be the same or diminished or maybe even problematic? So the rest of the question is, how do lenders consider income when it comes to somebody who's retired?
6:49 Speaker 03 Our total income in retirement will be probably 70 to 80% of what I earned while I was working. Thank you, and I appreciate you taking the question.
6:58 Speaker 01 Retirement does impact your ability to borrow for a number of reasons.
7:04 Speaker 01 Your income, as you just mentioned, it's going to go down. So your debt to income ratio is going to change. It means you can borrow less. Also, a lot of lenders don't take into account the value of assets because assets can fluctuate. Sometimes they'll impute an income to the money in your retirement plans and your other savings and investment accounts. But others may not impute anything to that and may ignore it completely, which they can do. They're going to be more conservative because you don't have the ability to take on another job, or at least they think it's less likely that you will.
7:45 Speaker 01 So mortgages, they say, are one of the hardest, are harder to get and one of the hardest things to get when you're in retirement. Shorter term loans are easier. What some people do is they borrow differently. They borrow against their portfolio, for example.
8:03 Speaker 01 Or you want to find a borrower who lets you impute an income, who lets you say, well, I'm going to be pulling 4% out and count that as your income in calculating the debt-to-income ratio. So it's tougher, yeah. It's going to change. And that's why it's very typical for retirees who've saved a lot of money to just pay cash. And, you know, it actually, unless you get like a great mortgage rate, a 2% mortgage rate, in most cases, just paying cash is the better way to go. Thanks for the question. Here's the next one that came in at TalkingRealMoney.com on the contact form or the Ask a Question form.
8:47 Speaker 04 Please tell me where on your website I can find the names of Bellevue and Greater Seattle fee-based-only advisors. I would appreciate it. Thank you.
9:04 Speaker 01 Much like Santa Claus and Miracle on 34th Street. Yes, we do give you the names of some Gimbel's people. We're the Macy's and then of course they'd be Gimbel's.
9:15 Speaker 01 If you haven't watched the movie, it's, that's right over your head. Anyway, it's pretty easy to do. You just go to TalkingRealMoney.com, the website, and you'll see a button in the Talking Real Money Quick Links area that says Find a Fiduciary. Click on that. Scroll down the page a little bit. On the right-hand side, you'll see a section that says Check out these Advisors. And these are some advisors that we looked at, that we believe act as fiduciaries all the time, have a fair fee structure, that don't offer actively managed funds. We're pretty sure they don't. We don't know that for a fact. We're not recommending them. We don't know everything. We just check them out. And so we've got a few there. And of course, we included our firm in there because we do recommend us.
10:00 Speaker 01 We recommend us. So yeah, check it out. TalkingRealMoney.com. And then look on the very, very first page at the button that says Find a Fiduciary. Then scroll down. You'll see Check out these Advisors. The button says A Few Good Ones. Click on that and there's the list. Thanks so much for your question. Here's our next one.
10:22 Speaker 05 Hi, guys. This is Tom from Maryland. I heard a caller from a recent podcast dial in and as he was listing his assets, he listed his HSA as an asset with about $65,000 in it. I'm wondering, how do HSAs fit into overall retirement planning? I've never really bothered to look into it. I know I could go to YouTube and watch a couple of videos, but I'd rather hear you guys talk about it on the podcast. Thanks.
10:48 Speaker 01 HSAs are the most amazing thing out there and they'd be amazing for me if I wasn't such a dummy and then signed up for Medicare Part A at 65, which messed me up, which means I can't, even though I'm on private insurance, I can't use an HSA. Darn it. That was my stupidity. I didn't think. HSAs are amazing. You get a tax deduction on the money you put in. Just wonderful. Then you get tax-free growth, potentially. You can get tax-free growth if the money is used for medical expenses. And what is one of the biggest expenses in retirement? Medical expenses. So you save that.
11:31 Speaker 01 Triple tax advantaged account where you got a deduction and you get tax-free growth and you spend that in retirement on your medical expenses instead of spending taxable money or money from your IRA that's going to be taxed or money from your Roth that didn't get a tax deduction. So they're just absolutely wonderful. They can cover, they can cover your, they can pay your Medicare premiums. They can pay, they can pay your deductibles and your copays and your dental and your vision care. They can, to some extent, even go toward long-term care. All of that, absolutely tax-free.
12:10 Speaker 01 And then if you use it for other things, you can use, you can after 65, uh, pay taxes on it. But again, you're going to pay medical expenses. I guarantee you're going to have substantial at times, medical expenses in retirement. So that's what it's best for. Love them to pieces. Wish I had one. Thanks so much for your question. We still have two more left to go. Look at us. Send them in talkingrealmoney.com or call us at 855-935-TALK.
12:41 Speaker 06 Hello, Tom and Don. I am 35 years old.
12:46 Speaker 01 Young.
12:46 Speaker 06 And my employer offers a pension.
12:49 Speaker 01 Wow.
12:50 Speaker 06 Could you describe or maybe have a podcast for your listeners about pensions? Most of the information I hear is related to 401Ks or portfolios and stocks and bonds. Specifically, if I work till age 66, my pension would provide me with about 80% of my normal working wage. Social Security would make up the difference. And I should have about 100% of my normal working wage at the time of retirement.
13:31 Speaker 01 Wow, lucky.
13:31 Speaker 06 This makes it pretty easy to decide at age 66, it would be okay to retire, since the combination of the two, social security and pension, would equal to 100%. But as I try to solve this for ages 62 to 65, things aren't so easy. The combined total of pension and social security is less than 100% at those ages.
13:59 Speaker 06 My pension is reduced by about 7% each year I retire before the normal working age of 66. What percentage do you guys recommend a person retiring at?
14:16 Speaker 06 Lastly, if I want to invest into a Roth IRA to make up the percentage amount, what should I invest in? With my age, I still have about 30 years or so of working left.
14:30 Speaker 06 Thanks.
14:31 Speaker 01 You can afford at your age to be aggressive. I mean, I would, I would look at a DFAW, an AVGE, these total stock market funds where you own the whole stock market. Yeah, they're going to fluctuate a lot, but you're going to be buying in when they're down and that's what you want. You want, you want, you're going to be averaging in as you earn money and as you put money into your Roth. And I do believe the Roth is the solution to your dilemma. Because here's the deal. You're looking at this the right way. You, you're going to lose 7% every year you take it early. That's too much to give up because that's a guaranteed return on your money. Just waiting is a guaranteed return.
15:15 Speaker 01 You can't get a guaranteed 7% these days and probably not in the future. So it pays to wait on the pension until 66. And it pays to wait on social security until 70. So here's what you should do. We need to sort of calculate this backward. Determine how much money you're going to need and you could draw, if you wanted to, you could pretty much draw all of it down. I wouldn't do that. I would keep some of the Roth IRA for, you know, other needs down the road. But you could conceivably between 62 and 70, that eight-year period. Use just the Roth IRA money to live on or other monies you've saved and you'll be surprised.
15:57 Speaker 01 You will have saved a lot of other money that you didn't even think about more than likely. So here's how you should look at it. Oh, and by the way, this is a rough, rough, rough look at it because you didn't give me the numbers. If I'd had the numbers, I could probably get a little closer, but what you, what you need to do is contribute as much as you can to your Roth, as much as you can afford. And if you can afford all the way to the max every year, whatever that max is, because remember that max adjusts for inflation, which is a good thing because you have to adjust for inflation because we don't know what inflation is going to do to the current income in the future. But you basically need an eight-year bridge plan.
16:41 Speaker 01 So if you put
16:45 Speaker 01 $400, $500 a month into a Roth IRA, starting at age 35, and you earn just about 6% per year, and you're making $100,000 a year, that's what you have to replace, then you'll probably have enough at age 62 to replace that income, retire at 62 and replace that income. Again, we don't know what the future is going to bring. We don't know what the rates of return are going to be, but the reality is that is a great bridging strategy. And that's why I say save as much as you can afford to save. Don't, uh, don't go easy on yourself early on because the more you save when you're young,
17:29 Speaker 01 the less you have to do when you're older. So max it out now. Put other money away if you can, even if it's in a taxable account, because if you buy good ETFs in a taxable account, they can grow tax-deferred, can. So it's not precise, but you're on the right track. I see what you're trying to do and it's absolutely doable, but I would do two things. I would contribute a lot now as much as I can. I would wait until 66 to take the pension and I would wait until 70 to take social security. Because remember, you're only going to be filling for four years.
18:06 Speaker 01 At the whole income, once you start taking the pension at 66, you're only going to be filling in that 20% hole and that's going to be small. And if this goes well, which it should, if you save a lot, then you also have extra money in retirement for other needs. So you've got to just do the best you can because we don't know the future, but you're on the right track. Thanks so much for your question. And now folks, here's the last one of this question laden show. Came in from TalkingRealMoney.com, of course, on the ask a question button there.
18:38 Speaker 05 Hey, fellas, been listening for a long time and appreciate the information you all offer and I appreciate Tom's entertainment value.
18:46 Speaker 01 Sounded like quotes around that.
18:48 Speaker 05 I know you talked about this recently, but I'm just trying to circle back to it. Hopefully you're willing to do this. Robinhood, they're offering 2% on IRAs transferred to, from another brokerage to Robinhood. Trying to figure out if that's, if there's any red flags with that, specifically Robinhood as a custodian and whether or not there's some extra inherent risks with having Robinhood as a custodian versus say Fidelity or Vanguard. I can't, yeah, I can't figure it out. Thanks, appreciate it. Bye.
19:27 Speaker 01 I can, I can figure it out. It's pretty easy, actually. Fidelity, you mentioned them, great example. They don't rely on what is called payment for order flow for much of their profit. They are so big that they can just live on spreads. Payment for order flow means that some other market maker is paying Robinhood and Robinhood relies heavily on payment for order flow. They're paying them to execute their trades on Robinhood. They're saying, we're going to give you a little money if you execute our trades on your platform.
20:06 Speaker 01 And they are going to try to get the best deal for themselves as the market makers, not for the clients. So on some securities, particularly lightly traded ones, you might get worse prices. That could detract. You have to also be part of their gold club, but that's only 60 bucks a year. You have to leave it there for a very long time, and some people like to have the freedom to move. Um, but if, if, if you don't trade much and if you're using only securities that are heavily traded so that the spreads are very tiny and there's not going to be a much incentive to pay for order flow.
20:46 Speaker 01 It can be okay, particularly if, you know, you're talking a substantial amount of money. You know, where these, where these become five-figure amounts. I mean, if it's three-figure amounts, their, their annoyances and their extra gold club fees are going to eat up some of that and it makes it not worth it. But if we're getting into high four, five-figure amounts, yeah, it might be worth it if you can put up with some slight annoyances. They do, and oh yeah, don't trade, don't trade because they, they're not going to get you the best pricing. Well, you don't want to trade anyway. It's just a bad idea to trade. But yeah, it's free money and I know it's tempting. I even thought about it.
21:31 Speaker 01 It's free money. I went, but then I went, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. Uh, it's some free money, but hmm, is it worth the hassles and the potential headaches? And I just decided it wasn't. Sometimes it just pays to sit tight. That's what I'm doing with my Schwab account. So thanks for the question. It was a good one. Thanks for all your questions. They were all good ones. And we really appreciate you asking them. And we very much appreciate you listening to our podcasts, which are five days a week. We make a lot of podcasts every week so that you can stay informed about money and we try not to
22:12 Speaker 01 be annoying. We, yes, we are part of an investment advisory firm, but we don't plug our firm very often. Yeah, we do sometimes, but even then it's more as a tool to help you. It's not as a way to get you into an office or to get you onto a call so that we can twist your arm and, and make you feel bad about not becoming a client, which we don't do. We do help everybody who asks, free. Honestly, ask anybody who's been helped. They'll say, yeah, it was free. And there's no high-pressure sales pitch, and you can get that help by going to TalkingRealMoney.com and clicking on the button that says "Meet an Advisor." Otherwise, if you just want to ask questions,
22:55 Speaker 01 go to TalkingRealMoney.com and click on the "Ask a Question" button, or the "Contact Us" button, and ask those questions, or call 855-935-TALK, 855-935-8255. And if you do want to help us out, tell people about the podcast. That's the thing that you can do most for us. That's the thing that really helps us the most, growing the podcast. One, it makes us feel good, and two, it makes everything we do worthwhile. So, please do that, and thanks for being a part of Talking Real Money.
23:32 Speaker 07 The opinions and views expressed on this podcast were current on the date recorded. Opinions, estimates, forecasts, and statements of financial market trends that are based on current market conditions constitute our judgment and are subject to change without notice, including any forward-looking estimates or statements which are based on certain expectations and assumptions. Although information and opinions given have been obtained from or based on sources believed to be reliable, no warranty or representation is made as to their correctness, completeness, or accuracy. Information presented on the podcast is not personalized investment advice from Appella Wealth. The views and strategies described may not be suitable for everyone. This podcast does not identify all the risks, direct or indirect, or other considerations which might be material to you when entering any financial transaction. Past performance does not guarantee future results, and profitable results cannot be guaranteed. We hope you realize that the information provided on Talking Real Money is for informational,
24:16 Speaker 07 educational, and hopefully enjoyable purposes only. The podcast is not trying to get you to buy or sell any financial products or securities. Instead, the program is provided as a public service by Appella Wealth, a fee-only registered investment advisor. Please see Appella Wealth ADV Part 2A on our website for information regarding Appella's fees and services. Appella Capital, LLC, DBA Appella Wealth, is an investment advisory firm registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission. The firm only transacts business in the states where it is properly registered or excluded or exempt from registration requirements. Registration with the SEC or any state securities authority does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Appella does not provide tax or legal advice, and nothing either stated or implied here should be inferred as providing such advice. Thanks for listening, and please visit TalkingRealMoney.com for more information and important disclosure related to performance of any specific index
25:01 Speaker 07 or fund quoted in this podcast. And the lawyers get richer.
Previous Simple Beats "Smart" Next Miss a Stock... Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated