Pod Insights Talking Real Money - Investing Talk Retirement Quiz About this episode Tom takes a Wall Street Journal retirement-account quiz while Don gleefully plays game show host, leading to a surprisingly useful (and occasionally chaotic) discussion of HSAs, Roth IRAs, Trump accounts, 529 plans, contribution limits, and retirement withdrawal rules. The episode then pivots into listener questions about ACAT transfer anxiety during market volatility and a blistering takedown of indexed annuities, including misleading “bonuses,” surrender charges, and the illusion of “market returns without risk.” The show wraps with a spirited rebuttal to a listener defending annuities and a reminder that insurance companies aren’t charities—they’re math machines built to profit from your longevity assumptions.0:05 Wall Street Journal retirement-account quiz begins1:06 Admitting financial advisors don’t know everything1:50 AI voices, digital immortality, and cloned Don4:01 HSAs and the “triple tax advantage”5:20 Roth vs. traditional IRA tax treatment6:34 Employer matches and “Trump accounts”7:46 529 contribution-limit confusion8:47 IRA contribution eligibility and earned income11:17 Rule of 55 for penalty-free 401(k) withdrawals12:37 Trump accounts requiring U. S. stock index funds14:25 Expanded 529 eligible expenses under new law16:06 Listener question about ACAT transfer anxiety during volatility18:24 Why missing a few market days usually doesn’t matter20:57 Indexed annuity “bonus” pitch dismantled23:17 Why Don despises most insurance investment products24:27 Listener challenges the show’s annuity criticism26:12 Why annuities and bonds are not equivalent28:09 Long-term market assumptions vs. fear-based selling29:22 Appella’s free portfolio-review philosophy29:51 Immediate annuity math and the “you’re getting your own money back” argument31:23 Why insurance companies usually win the longevity bet32:15 Mattress-money analogy for annuity payouts32:59 Closing thoughts and growing podcast downloadsQuestions? Comments? Click!
Transcript 0:05 Speaker 00 Your guides to a really great financial future. Tom and Don are talking real money.
0:12 Speaker 01 Well, the results of the survey are in and podcast listeners love quizzes. You do like your quizzes. It's why we occasionally find a quiz somewhere online and go, that's an interesting quiz. Let's see how smart the talking real money audience really is. Today's topic from the Wall Street Journal. How well do you know your 401ks, 529s and HSAs? And we're going to take the quiz. Well, not we, just Tom. Hi, everybody, I'm Don.
0:44 Speaker 02 I love this.
0:45 Speaker 01 That's Tom.
0:47 Speaker 02 What a great, let's quiz Tom. That's, I'd love that. Yeah, perfect.
0:51 Speaker 01 Yeah. All of America likes that.
0:54 Speaker 02 Except for Tom.
0:56 Speaker 01 Tom, you don't count.
0:58 Speaker 02 Okay, and in complete and, you know, in fairness, you sent this to me. I read it.
1:05 Speaker 01 So you, wait a minute, you had an advantage.
1:08 Speaker 02 I did have an advantage and here's part two of that. I, there were some I didn't know the answer to. I won't lie. I mean, I read it and thought, I kind of know that.
1:16 Speaker 01 That is part of the charm of talking real money. And what sets us apart is that we don't know everything. And when we don't know, we either make a mistake and correct it, or we say, I don't know.
1:28 Speaker 02 Yeah, well, that guy, remember one guy we did, I think I told him I didn't know. And he wrote me later and said, I can't believe you didn't know that blah, blah, blah. Like, well, I don't know all the, like, it was, it was the obscure social security. If I do this, what about that thing? I like, I don't know that.
1:42 Speaker 01 I think they think that we're AI, maybe.
1:46 Speaker 02 Let me tell you that, I'm a long way from that, so.
1:49 Speaker 01 We're connected to this huge server farm somewhere in Nevada.
1:54 Speaker 02 That sounds good. Can I be outside in Nevada too? That'd be better.
1:58 Speaker 01 Well, that's the thing later. This is my plan for, uh, for after, uh, death is I'm just gonna AI myself.
2:05 Speaker 02 So your brain will still be functioning?
2:07 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'm gonna be on a server.
2:09 Speaker 02 Will the voice still be there?
2:10 Speaker 01 What?
2:11 Speaker 02 Will the voice still be there?
2:13 Speaker 01 I've already, I've already AI'd my voice, dude.
2:16 Speaker 02 Of course you have.
2:17 Speaker 01 I have. I've created an AI clone of my voice. It could be some, it could be AI actually doing the show right now and you wouldn't know. Yeah, actually you would, because it doesn't sound like me all the time. It sounds basically like me reading a book. That's what it sounds like.
2:33 Speaker 02 Well, I know how well you read. So, all right, so go ahead.
2:36 Speaker 01 Are we ready?
2:37 Speaker 02 I'll be your guinea pig. Why not? Hit me.
2:38 Speaker 01 Okay.
2:39 Speaker 02 Yeah.
2:39 Speaker 01 I'm not even gonna use the game show sound effects this time because they were cheesy.
2:43 Speaker 02 I like those.
2:44 Speaker 01 Oh, I could throw them in maybe later. I don't know.
2:46 Speaker 02 Dating game maybe or something?
2:49 Speaker 01 Oh, Lord, he's doing it to me now. I gotta figure this out. Uh, let's see, what do we got? I gotta change screens. Uh, okay, here we go. Is it working? Oh, I didn't have it on the right screen. Okay, never mind. That would be this one.
3:08 Speaker 01 Welcome to the quiz, ladies and gentlemen. I don't know what that was.
3:14 Speaker 02 Some applause. Sounded good.
3:15 Speaker 01 Do we have anything else? We have this. No, we don't have that.
3:21 Speaker 02 Monday Night Football intro, Dating Game.
3:23 Speaker 01 Oh, we have this.
3:24 Speaker 02 Jeopardy.
3:28 Speaker 02 And that's your final answer, Tom? Crickets.
3:32 Speaker 01 All right, so I, I thought I had game show music, but apparently I do not. Oh, now that's the game show crowd. That's the right answer. What's this one? Oh, I know what that one is. Let's try that. Is it playing?
3:49 Speaker 01 No, that's waiting for you to answer. All right. We're not ready for this. Sorry. Sorry you had to hear that, but I'm not editing it out.
3:56 Speaker 02 Behind the curtain there.
3:57 Speaker 01 Let's go to the question, shall we?
4:00 Speaker 02 Yeah, okay.
4:02 Speaker 01 I just need to move along. Question one.
4:06 Speaker 02 Yeah.
4:06 Speaker 01 Tom.
4:07 Speaker 02 Yes.
4:08 Speaker 01 Which account type offers the most tax advantages?
4:12 Speaker 02 The most tax advantages.
4:14 Speaker 01 Most tax advantages.
4:15 Speaker 02 Yep.
4:16 Speaker 01 Health savings accounts, Roth IRAs, 401Ks, or all of the above?
4:25 Speaker 02 Okay, so the most tax advantages.
4:28 Speaker 01 The most tax advantages.
4:30 Speaker 02 I believe would be health savings accounts because you get a tax break when you put the money in.
4:35 Speaker 01 Right.
4:36 Speaker 02 That's one. Number two, it grows tax deferred. And number three, you can take it out and pay yourself back for medical expenses or pay medical expenses. So I think it's, I think it's three.
4:48 Speaker 01 It's a triple tax benefit. That is the, that is the correct answer.
4:54 Speaker 02 All right. That probably ends my run for successful answers too, by the way.
4:59 Speaker 01 Congratulations.
5:00 Speaker 02 I think it's underutilized, by the way. I think most plans now have it. I'm doing it. I love it. So.
5:05 Speaker 01 Well, don't be a dummy like me and take Medicare at 65 and take Part A because you think, why not? Because you can't do HSAs with your employer anymore, darn it.
5:17 Speaker 02 Anyway, so, okay.
5:18 Speaker 01 Question two.
5:19 Speaker 02 Yeah.
5:20 Speaker 01 Both Roth and traditional retirement accounts grow with tax advantages. But how do they differ? This is a multiple choice. You don't even have to think of the answer. A Roth is funded with contributions you've already paid taxes on, and withdrawals are typically tax-free. With traditional accounts, you can deduct contributions from taxable income and must pay taxes on withdrawals. That's A. B, Roths are exempt from required minimum distributions. The, those with the traditional have to start taking them out at 73. Or C, workers who want to contribute the maximum to a retirement savings account can accrue more wealth in a Roth than a traditional account. Or D, all of the above.
6:02 Speaker 02 Okay, so I, this is kind of an odd one. I mean, because what they're saying is if you put money in a Roth, does it, does it grow more? Well, does it? I mean, it grows more tax-free.
6:17 Speaker 02 They're accruing more wealth, that's kind of a misleading statement.
6:20 Speaker 01 It's all of the above.
6:21 Speaker 02 It is all of the above.
6:23 Speaker 01 The reason why is that, uh...
6:25 Speaker 02 Because a Roth is tax, you're taking the money out, it's tax-free.
6:28 Speaker 01 Right, because you could put a maximum of 24.5 in a traditional...
6:32 Speaker 02 Right.
6:34 Speaker 01 But up to 24.5 after paying taxes in a Roth, so it's the after-tax.
6:38 Speaker 02 Yeah.
6:39 Speaker 01 It's kind of a weird question, you're right.
6:41 Speaker 02 Again, some of these, no offense, just not that well-written, but good information nonetheless, so, okay.
6:47 Speaker 01 All right, which accounts require employers to offer matching contributions? Trump accounts, 401Ks, HSAs, or none of the above?
6:55 Speaker 02 Require?
6:56 Speaker 01 Uh-huh.
6:56 Speaker 02 None.
6:58 Speaker 01 Well, that was fast, okay, that's the correct answer, wait.
7:00 Speaker 02 I don't think, I don't think anything's required.
7:04 Speaker 02 I think here we get match for the HSAs and the 401Ks, I believe.
7:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, but it's not required.
7:11 Speaker 02 It's not required.
7:12 Speaker 01 Right.
7:13 Speaker 02 No.
7:14 Speaker 01 All right, which of these, which...
7:17 Speaker 02 Can we dispel one more, kind of, because this is still semi-mine, Trump accounts have nothing to do with your employer.
7:23 Speaker 01 No.
7:24 Speaker 02 I think your employer can make contributions, if I remember right.
7:26 Speaker 01 Like, any, anybody I think can, but...
7:28 Speaker 02 Right, yeah.
7:29 Speaker 01 And we're still calling them Trump accounts, I thought we had decided on calling them 530s.
7:33 Speaker 02 Yeah, I just did a call with a guy yesterday, calls them youth retirement plans, or something, YRPs, or youth retirement account, YRA. Yeah, maybe we came, did we come up with that, YRA, anyway?
7:41 Speaker 01 Well, one of our listeners came up with the idea of calling them 530s, which is what their tax code is.
7:45 Speaker 02 Okay.
7:46 Speaker 01 Anyway, moving on.
7:48 Speaker 02 Yeah.
7:48 Speaker 01 Which of, which type of account has no IRS mandated dollar contribution limit? 530s? HSAs? Roth IRAs? Or 529 plans?
8:00 Speaker 02 Okay, so for full disclosure, this is the one that I read and I said, "I don't know." Uh, so, pre-program, I told Don, "I don't know." And then, because I looked it up, and I was like, "I, it doesn't make sense." Because they're, they're, on a 529...
8:16 Speaker 01 Yeah.
8:16 Speaker 02 There's no IRS limit, this is a little bit trick question.
8:20 Speaker 01 No federal limit.
8:21 Speaker 02 There is a state limit for all these states that sponsor these plans. Remember, these are, 529 is a state-sponsored plan.
8:29 Speaker 01 And the limit, but the limit is up to 600,000...
8:31 Speaker 02 Well, it depends on the state.
8:32 Speaker 01 Depends on the state, that's the highest, I think that's Vermont or somebody.
8:35 Speaker 02 So, the answer is... None.
8:39 Speaker 01 The answer is no. Well, the answer is nine 529s. Which type of account has no IRS mandate?
8:44 Speaker 02 No, no limit. Pardon me. Yeah. 529. So, yeah.
8:47 Speaker 01 Which account type is not correctly matched with its standard 2026 contribution limit? 401ks have a limit of 24.5. Trump accounts have a limit of 12.5. IRAs have a limit of 7,500. HSAs have a limit of 4,400 for self-coverage and 87.50 for family. That's a complicated question.
9:07 Speaker 02 Can you hit a buzzer and just say, I don't know, because I don't know?
9:11 Speaker 01 Uh, the, well, the answer is, uh, Trump accounts have a limit of 12.5.
9:18 Speaker 02 That's 5,000, right?
9:19 Speaker 01 No, 12,500.
9:22 Speaker 02 Well, it says is not correctly matched, but here it says it does have a limit.
9:26 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's right. So that they don't, right. So they have a limit of five, not 12.
9:29 Speaker 02 It's 5,000 a year.
9:31 Speaker 01 Right.
9:31 Speaker 02 Yeah.
9:32 Speaker 01 It's a terrible question.
9:33 Speaker 02 And, okay, number two, who knows anything about the IRAs? And I mean, there's so little, little information about them yet.
9:41 Speaker 01 But this one's actually a pretty good one.
9:43 Speaker 02 Okay.
9:43 Speaker 01 This one's a pretty good one.
9:44 Speaker 02 All right.
9:45 Speaker 01 Because I think this is a general knowledge question that people should, should know. They probably don't. What do you need to have to contribute to an IRA account?
9:54 Speaker 02 Ah, this is actually a little tricky. So, yes. I knew this one.
9:58 Speaker 01 A, taxable earned income.
10:00 Speaker 02 Uh huh.
10:01 Speaker 01 B, legal status as an adult. C, automated contributions. Or D, a W2.
10:11 Speaker 02 Yeah. Okay. So the answer here is taxable earned income. You don't have to have a W2. You don't have to be an adult. And automated contributions has nothing to do with anything. That's just a red herring.
10:22 Speaker 01 That's a canard. That's something.
10:24 Speaker 02 Yeah. So, but yeah, this is tricky because.
10:28 Speaker 02 This come up before. Can you, can you go mow somebody's lawn and then say, yeah, I mowed this lawn and put it in your Roth IRA? I wouldn't do it personally because I think it's risky, but you could.
10:40 Speaker 01 But you could.
10:41 Speaker 02 You could.
10:42 Speaker 01 And you definitely could if the person, if you, if they gave you a 1099.
10:49 Speaker 02 Oh, then yeah, no question. Sure. But do your neighbors often give you a 1099?
10:53 Speaker 01 The kid, what's the form you, it's W4, what, what's the?
10:58 Speaker 02 W2 would be.
10:59 Speaker 01 No, no, no. The one that you give to a, a W9, is it a W?
11:03 Speaker 02 W, isn't, no.
11:05 Speaker 01 No, for 1099 income. I think it's, I can't remember. See, this is the problem. I can't remember all the IRS numbers. It's like 529s and 530s. Which, why do they number stuff? Maybe Trump account is a better name. At least we know what it means.
11:20 Speaker 02 But in this case, the bottom line is it's a little gray.
11:24 Speaker 01 Yeah. What is the earliest age the tax code allows penalty free withdrawals? Not without the 10% penalty from a 401k, assuming a person leaves the company and needs the money for any purpose. What is the earliest age a 401k can be withdrawn after you leave the company? 55, 59 and a half, 62, or 65?
11:49 Speaker 02 I believe if you leave the company.
11:51 Speaker 01 Leave the company.
11:53 Speaker 02 And agree to, is it take an equal amount? You can take it at 55 without penalty.
11:59 Speaker 01 You don't even have to agree to an equal amount.
12:01 Speaker 02 Oh, okay. What's that? There's that rule too, the one with the?
12:04 Speaker 01 That's the, for IRAs.
12:06 Speaker 02 Okay.
12:06 Speaker 01 Substantially equal contribution, distributions over your life expectancy.
12:10 Speaker 02 Okay, so 55, I think is correct.
12:11 Speaker 01 55 is the correct answer. Thank you, studio audience.
12:16 Speaker 02 I'm now old enough to start drawing money from my, from my IRA and my 401k.
12:20 Speaker 01 You can take, you can take it all out. You just go right ahead. You're good. You are so old, you can do pretty much anything you want.
12:28 Speaker 02 And basically get away with it.
12:30 Speaker 01 Except not hurt. That's the only thing you can't not do.
12:34 Speaker 02 Got that covered in spades.
12:35 Speaker 01 Yeah. Which type of account requires investing in stock index funds?
12:41 Speaker 02 Now, listen to the word requires.
12:43 Speaker 01 Requires investing. You must invest in stock index.
12:47 Speaker 02 It's not even, it should have been more specific, which we'll talk about here in a moment.
12:51 Speaker 01 Okay, but, but which type of account? 401ks?
12:54 Speaker 02 Yep.
12:55 Speaker 01 529 education accounts?
12:57 Speaker 02 Yep.
12:57 Speaker 01 Trump accounts?
12:59 Speaker 02 Yep.
12:59 Speaker 01 Or HSA's health savings accounts?
13:01 Speaker 02 Okay, so the previously mentioned Trump account is the only one that requires. And by the way, it's not just stock index funds, it's US stock index funds.
13:12 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
13:13 Speaker 02 Which is just, I guess, America first, weird, but anyway, so.
13:18 Speaker 01 Okay.
13:19 Speaker 02 The only one, by the way, the others.
13:20 Speaker 01 We know why.
13:21 Speaker 02 The other ones, you can do anything you like with, the 529s or 401ks. I recommend.
13:25 Speaker 01 And that's all, and the qualifier in this is that it's only.
13:28 Speaker 02 Required.
13:29 Speaker 01 Until they're 18.
13:32 Speaker 01 After they're 18, they can do anything they want with it.
13:35 Speaker 02 That's true.
13:36 Speaker 01 It's just for the first 18 years of life. Very strange. The rules are very strange.
13:42 Speaker 02 Again, and this came up recently with somebody.
13:45 Speaker 01 Kind of strange, when you think about it.
13:47 Speaker 02 I don't know that we needed it, but I, but I was forced to admit that anything, anytime there's more publicity about saving for the future, I guess that's good news, right? We'd something, we should be doing more.
13:58 Speaker 01 There's the other thing, that we're all selfish, take the free money.
14:02 Speaker 02 Yeah. I'm only out of, I only missed that by like 67 years. I was very close.
14:07 Speaker 01 Yeah, but your granddaughter nailed it.
14:09 Speaker 02 She nailed it. She's got her 1K coming, so.
14:13 Speaker 01 There you go. Final question.
14:15 Speaker 02 Fi- oh, thank goodness.
14:16 Speaker 01 Final question.
14:17 Speaker 02 Yes, okay.
14:18 Speaker 01 Oh, sorry, you didn't like the quiz that much? Okay, well.
14:21 Speaker 02 A lot of people happy for that, okay.
14:23 Speaker 01 There.
14:25 Speaker 01 You know, you think you won the over the audience and then they turn on you.
14:28 Speaker 02 Like that.
14:30 Speaker 01 Yeah, just like that. Under the tax cut Trump signed into law last July. What expenses now count as covered for the purposes of taking money tax free out of a 529 plan, an education plan?
14:46 Speaker 01 Is it K to 12 tutoring? Is it fees for APSAT or ACT tests?
14:55 Speaker 01 Is it C, K-12 books and supplies? Or D, all of the above?
15:01 Speaker 02 And this is one that's changed in the last decade.
15:05 Speaker 01 Yeah.
15:05 Speaker 02 Yeah, I believe, and I know you're gonna, you won't have any trouble correcting me if I'm wrong, but I believe it's all of the above, right?
15:12 Speaker 01 That is the correct answer, Tom.
15:15 Speaker 02 Okay, now I can't retire.
15:17 Speaker 01 Wait, I hit the wrong button again. I'm not good at this. I should never be the producer of a game show.
15:22 Speaker 02 You're the guy in the booth.
15:24 Speaker 01 I'm the guy in the booth doing a bad job.
15:26 Speaker 02 That's right, Tom. You just won. Because that's, yeah, that's one they changed about, I think about a decade ago, which allowed you to use the money for, for kids. I thought it was.
15:35 Speaker 01 It used to be.
15:36 Speaker 02 I thought it was only high school, but I guess it says K through 12.
15:38 Speaker 01 No, it used to be just college and then it went to, to under college, pre-college, whatever they call it. It's not undergrad because that's college. It's under.
15:49 Speaker 02 All right, you ready for me to ask you some questions now, my friend?
15:52 Speaker 01 No, no, no, I am not because.
15:55 Speaker 02 Shoes on the other foot now, huh?
15:57 Speaker 01 I think, I think, I think we need you to, I think first we probably should get you to take a caller.
16:01 Speaker 02 Ray from Royalton, Vermont. How are you, Ray?
16:06 Speaker 03 Doing well, Tom. Thanks.
16:08 Speaker 02 My pleasure to have you on.
16:11 Speaker 03 Yeah, thanks. I had a question about getting over my anxiousness about doing a transfer from one account to another. Recently, there was a big update in the market and I had put in a ACAT transfer request from TIA, the Fidelity, and it didn't go through. And so seeing the market move that much to Dow in that case, of course, I know logically it shouldn't make any difference outside of the time that the money would be out of the market, but it made me nervous.
16:49 Speaker 02 Yeah, this is, and so TIA, oftentimes, our experience, and we primarily work with our clients at Charles Schwab. So TIA and Charles Schwab don't get along all that well. And man, it may be the same with Fidelity. I don't know. You mentioned ACAT, the Automated Customer Account Transfer, which is a system of financial custodians that work together to try to make these things faster. And oftentimes, if you're moving money from an ERISA plan, like a 403B, 401K, to Schwab, it could be as quick as five days. So that, just as a background, that's an important thing to know.
17:32 Speaker 02 And then the question kind of is what I'm getting from you as well. But if I do that, then I'm going to be out of the market for a period of time. And that could work against me. Is that what I'm hearing?
17:43 Speaker 03 I know it doesn't maybe make any rational sense. But as Don would say, you know, this is the part of my brain that's overthinking it.
17:53 Speaker 02 Yeah, no, I think.
17:59 Speaker 02 And it has been, you know, kind of, even though I think I did just read a piece, that volatility actually year to date is less than what we would expect. It feels like more. Certainly in March, we had a pretty big down month. And then April, pretty big up month. So it's been kind of back and forth. But remember, on a day-to-day basis, the market has a very small bias to more up days than down days. You got to get into, you got to get into months before you really, I think it's 75% of the months are up and 25% are down. It's about the same when it comes to years. It's about three out of four years, the market's up and a one quarter when it's down. We all have to keep that in mind. And back to your kind of apprehension.
18:43 Speaker 02 Because this does come up, as I said, for us, because not everybody sort of plays in the same sandbox when it comes to moving money around. And we can do it generally pretty quickly. But sometimes it takes longer. You've got to remember that you're a long-term investor. I know that. And by the way, thank you for listening to us and being so kind to outreach to us on a regular basis. You're a long-term investor and you're as likely to miss a down day as you are up days, et cetera. And we just all have to sort of say, you know, I'm making this move because I want to move my money here. I'm making it, you know, now because it's the right time to do it. And I never really advocate one time over another because there really isn't a period of time where it's, we can sort of guarantee that the market's going
19:26 Speaker 02 to do any such thing. And I'm going to, you know, sort of take whatever it gives me, remembering that again, done properly, these transfers should take, you know, as few as five days and maybe a couple of weeks at the outside if they're done right. If they're outside of ACAT, it could take a little bit longer. But generally, it's about that period of time and we all have to deal with that. There's nothing, there's no way really around it.
19:54 Speaker 03 Do you think there's a little bit that is unique to TIA because they do not, they will only do outbound requests?
20:03 Speaker 02 Well, they are, yeah, they're kind of on their own. They don't, I know, for example, TIA does not accept any Schwab paperwork. You have to, if you're moving money from TIA to Schwab, you got to use their paperwork. A little unusual, you know, they're going to tell you it's for the protection of the client. Okay. Well, I'm all in favor of protecting the client. So it makes it a little more difficult. I get that. But again, I wouldn't, I think you're right. I think it feels emotional in some ways. And it's really something that, not unlike what the market does on a short-term basis, sort of out of our hands.
20:40 Speaker 03 Appreciate it.
20:40 Speaker 02 I hope that helps, Ray. Thank you so much again for listening and for reaching out to us. And it's great to chat with you here on Talking Real Money.
20:49 Speaker 01 And if you want to send us questions or ask questions or get on the air with Tom, all you have to do is go to TalkingRealMoney.com, click the Ask a Question button and type it in. That'll get you to Tom. Speak it in. That'll get you on the Friday Q and A podcast. But either way, we're going to try and get your questions answered because answering your questions is our favorite thing to do. We like it so much better than game shows. Correct answer. Thank you.
21:14 Speaker 02 All right. Uh, here's our, here are the questions for today, Don. You ready?
21:21 Speaker 02 Hi, Don. I'm 77 and retired. I have a million dollars in my traditional IRA, taking RMDs. I've been presented with an opportunity, an option.
21:30 Speaker 01 Oh, gosh, this scares me.
21:32 Speaker 02 They convert the 1 million within two years by taking out a fixed index annuity, athen. The company will provide me $170,000 upfront as a bonus. At my bracket of 33%, surrender period's 10 years. Each year, the policy fee is 0.95 for 10 years. Is this wise to consider? The athen proposal.
21:54 Speaker 01 Hmm, hmm, okay. So much wrong with this. One, that bonus is a lie. Uh, that bonus only applies. It raises the value, the value, which is a nebulous figure anyway, because it no longer has any value when or if you turn it into an immediate annuity. You start taking in, you give up the money to the insurance company. So basically, they're giving themselves a made up bonus check to, to the insurance company, not to you. And they claim they're going to pay you an income based on that. But what they do is just internally adjust the figures so that they don't really give you money. They just make it appear like they do.
22:36 Speaker 01 Uh, and the problems with indexed annuities are legion. I mean, there's so many problems with these things. One, they claim they're something they can't be, that they, they return what the market does and they do it with no risk. It's a lie, it's a lie, it's a lie. That's a lie. Um, they give you a portion, and I do mean a portion, and generally it ends up being a tiny portion of the, the overall average returns of the market, some market, some weird index that they made up. When they have a 10% surrender charge, that means the agent, the agent who's selling it to you is getting a commission somewhere between 8 and 10%.
23:17 Speaker 01 Where's that money coming from? The fact that they're not going to give you that much money. I pretty much despise every single insurance investment known to mankind. The only thing that I might consider in a certain situations is putting the money into an immediate annuity if you need an absolutely set amount of income for the rest of your life or your life and your spouse's life. That's the only time, and even then, I would try and talk you out of it.
23:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, I guess for me, Pam, on this, and thank you for your question, is why you would want to do this at age 77? Because why are we annuitizing the money? Is it the fear of the market?
24:05 Speaker 01 No, no, no, she's not annuitizing yet. She's indexed.
24:07 Speaker 02 Well, no, I know. Why would you want to buy one? Why would you want to buy one now?
24:11 Speaker 01 Probably because the pitch is, we're going to give you the returns of the market with none of the risk.
24:15 Speaker 02 All right. I see that.
24:17 Speaker 01 Because it's not, she's not, she's not annuitizing it. But what I'm saying is the only time you get that bonus is if you annuitize.
24:23 Speaker 02 And when would she annuitize? I mean, not that you're old.
24:26 Speaker 01 She's already 77.
24:27 Speaker 02 77, I mean, it's kind of like, how many more years you go? Anyway, okay. So, so in, with that in mind, we have a unfavorable comment from Kenyon in Roseville, Minnesota. He says, "I don't own any annuities and no one in my family works for the insurance industry. I certainly agree with you about the insurance industry selling too complex and opaque products. However, on this show, you repeatedly made a claim that is just as misleading and downright false. A number of times, you stated that if you die before you start receiving funds from the annuity, the insurance company gets to keep your money. That is patently false."
25:06 Speaker 01 Okay, one, let's start right there. We never said that. Ever. Ever. If you annuitize and you've got no riders that pay out a certain amount to, you know, to your heirs or you get back something, if you annuitize and then you die the next month or the next year, but you have to annuitize, the money belongs to the insurance company, generally speaking.
25:37 Speaker 02 That's right. So, but so just to be clear.
25:40 Speaker 01 We never said that.
25:41 Speaker 02 We never said that about before you actually start taking money back. Um, he goes on, "They pool your money to pay people who do not die before receiving their money, some of whom will live to be centurions. The insurance company is trying to make money between what they've offered in payments versus what they can earn on largely safe investments." Yeah, we get all that. Which brings me to my second more minor quibble. Good use of words. You discussed how earning 6% a year return, you'd be much better off in the market than in an annuity. You're comparing apples and oranges. A person may choose to buy an annuity to remove the market risk from their portfolio. So you really should compare the annuity payments versus US bonds. That's the only investment that truly removes market risk. We could make an argument there too, by the way.
26:25 Speaker 01 Oh, wait, no, hold on. Got it, got it, got to challenge this. They are, you want to talk about apples and kumquats? Talk about comparing an annuity to a bond because you still own the principal with the bond.
26:37 Speaker 02 Thank you.
26:38 Speaker 01 With the annuity, you no longer own the principal. Basically, the amount over and above the income stream from a safe security like a treasury, that amount is your capital plus whatever they're making, plus whatever their profit is coming back to you.
26:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's good. Um, and there's, if you have a fixed annuity, technically that should be lower risk than a bond, technically. But it's not because what's backing it up. But anyway, um, let's see. So it says, "The only investment that truly removes..." And why we talk about that. "I agree that statistically, a person is likely to be better off in the market." I'm assuming you're referring to stocks there, "than in an annuity." However, there's no guarantee we won't have another period like 1929. "To blithely say that you can make 6% a year clearly ignores both the history of your returns for the US market and the potential that our future returns could be even worse." While I certainly don't invest like this is a likely outcome, it's a potential outcome that should not be brushed over lightly.
27:37 Speaker 01 Again, you're, we're gonna, I can't let this, this assumption, and this is the insurance company speaking. Really, you're, you're, you're their puppet in the way you're stating this. When you annuitize an annuity, it is not a 6% return on your money because you no longer own your money. Your money is no longer making you money. The insurance company has said, give us all your money and then we're going to pay you a monthly check equivalent to 6% of the amount you gave to us forever.
28:09 Speaker 01 It's not the same.
28:11 Speaker 02 No, it's not the same. So, um, and, and back to the kind of the market assumptions. All we're doing is looking back and saying for a long period of time, by the way, it made far more than 6% a year. You're right. Future could look completely different. We don't know. So, thank you, by the way, for listening. Thank you for taking the time to write us.
28:29 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah, we appreciate it.
28:30 Speaker 02 All those have been writing and calling us. Thank you for all that. It's been tremendous the last few weeks. And guess what? Some, some, sometimes you write me these, I don't know, 1,500 word, I'm taking social security here and I'm doing this and this and this. The reality is we can't really do those questions on the show because it just, it just, it's too involved. It's too long. And, um, what you really need at that point is to talk to an advisor. And I know you sit at home and go, that's where they start to sell me something.
29:03 Speaker 01 That's what, hey, and that's the case with 99% of companies.
29:07 Speaker 02 I understand that, that, that, that, that you feel pressure for that. And that's why, since we started the once Vestry, which by the way, one of my son's 33 year old friends brought up recently, I was faint, I said, wait, you remember Vestry? That's so nice of you. Uh, anyway, that's why when we started Vestry, we said, and we've said it publicly since for our near 20 years, we'll help anybody. We'll help you free. We'll help, we'll analyze your portfolio for you. We'll give you all the information you need to make good decisions. And it's as simple as reaching out to us and asking for help. And we love it. So take advantage of that.
29:45 Speaker 01 And by the way, before we go, while Tom was flapping his lips, I was actually researching. Good, good, good cover for me. Thanks, Tom.
29:54 Speaker 02 I appreciate it.
29:56 Speaker 01 Because I, I didn't remember the exact number.
30:00 Speaker 01 But let's say you're 65 years old.
30:06 Speaker 01 And you put a million dollars into an immediate annuity, paying you 6% per year or $60,000.
30:14 Speaker 02 Not making you, paying you.
30:15 Speaker 01 Paying you $60,000.
30:18 Speaker 02 Yes.
30:20 Speaker 01 If, if you only live until 81,
30:28 Speaker 01 you have made no money on your money. Zero. You just got your million dollars back. If you live until 83, now you've started making money.
30:42 Speaker 01 It takes 17 years before the annuity, before the insurance company actually has to pay you anything they're making on your million dollars, basically, essentially. They're just giving you your money back for the first 11, I mean, the first 17 years. They're giving you your money back.
31:00 Speaker 02 That's not part of the pitch, I presume, that they don't.
31:02 Speaker 01 They don't tell you that part of the pitch, because that would kill the pitch. Do you think, do you think annuity sales would, would, would, would rise or fall? If everybody who was buying an immediate annuity was told, well, if you die before 81, 82, then we really didn't pay you a darn thing, except your money back.
31:21 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's, it's, it's, again, you've said this as well. Insurance companies are profitable. Insurance companies are profitable because the odds that they've figured out, the ones selling the products, are in their side.
31:35 Speaker 01 And let me put it another way, just for, for, for those of you who didn't get it yet, because we've said it about 10,000 times. Take a million dollars. Put it under your mattress, hope no one breaks into the house. Put it under your mattress. Every year, pull $60,000 out from under the mattress. Okay? Spend it. Enjoy it. You will not run out of money as long as you don't live past 82. Start taking it at 65.
32:06 Speaker 02 Well, unless we have your home address.
32:09 Speaker 01 Well, yeah, that's what I'm saying, short of a burglar.
32:11 Speaker 02 Okay, you didn't mention that.
32:13 Speaker 01 Yeah, otherwise, otherwise, I can literally tell you that you won't run out of money. You will be absolutely safe as long as you die by age 82. You're in good shape. And no risk, no risk, except burglar risk.
32:29 Speaker 02 Don't smoke in bed either. Be bad.
32:31 Speaker 01 Does anybody smoke anymore?
32:33 Speaker 02 I don't think so. Remember when fires used to start that way?
32:36 Speaker 01 Oh, my God. Houses used to burn down all the time back in the days of smokers.
32:41 Speaker 02 Yeah. No, it's pretty, pretty hard to find one here in the great state of Washington anymore.
32:45 Speaker 01 So don't invest in fire departments.
32:47 Speaker 02 Probably not.
32:48 Speaker 01 All right. Fire suppression gear. Thanks for being here. We appreciate you. Go to TalkingRealMoney.com to ask all your questions. Keep listening, keep telling friends, because the numbers are going up. Our downloads are just looking lovely, folks. Thank you. And keep, keep, keep doing it. I'm Don, that's Tom, we're Talking Real Money.
33:08 Speaker 04 The opinions and views expressed on this podcast were current on the date recorded. Opinions, estimates, forecasts, and statements of financial market trends that are based on current market conditions constitute our judgment and are subject to change without notice, including any forward-looking estimates or statements which are based on certain expectations and assumptions. Although information and opinions given have been obtained from or based on sources believed to be reliable, no warranty or representation is made as to their correctness, completeness, or accuracy. Information presented on the podcast is not personalized investment advice from Appella Wealth. The views and strategies described may not be suitable for everyone. This podcast does not identify all the risks, direct or indirect, or other considerations which might be material to you when entering any financial transaction. Past performance does not guarantee future results, and profitable results cannot be guaranteed. We hope you realize that the information provided on Talking Real Money
33:51 Speaker 04 is for informational, educational, and hopefully enjoyable purposes only. The podcast is not trying to get you to buy or sell any financial products or securities. Instead, the program is provided as a public service by Appella Wealth, a fee-only registered investment advisor. Please see Appella Wealth ADV Part 2A on our website for information regarding Appella's fees and services. Appella Capital LLC, DBA Appella Wealth, is an investment advisory firm registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission. The firm only transacts business in the states where it is properly registered or excluded or exempt from registration requirements. Registration with the SEC or any state securities authority does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Appella does not provide tax or legal advice, and nothing either stated or implied here should be inferred as providing such advice. Thanks for listening, and please visit TalkingRealMoney.com for more information and important disclosure related to performance
34:36 Speaker 04 of any specific index or fund quoted in this podcast. And the lawyers get richer.
Previous From Funds to Crypto Next Active Management Myth Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated