Pod Insights Talking Real Money - Investing Talk Ep. 1946: The Index Ate Their Homework About this episode Active fund managers have a new explanation for years of underperformance: index funds have made their old job harder. Don and Tom examine that award-winning excuse, revisit how indexing reshaped the business, and return to the stubborn arithmetic—when active management charges more, matching the market still means losing to it after fees. Listener questions widen the lens. A UK investor wants to move from 60/40 to 50/50 without taking needless currency risk, while a family needs a sensible ...
Transcript 0:33 Speaker 00 Oh, don't I love AI. You know how much that would have cost back in the day?
0:39 Speaker 01 I remember the day when you, when I was in the radio business and you, they would bring to town a company that would go, you'd go out to pitch people and you would go out there and say, okay, Don McDonald, we could have a, we could have a rockin' jingle for you.
0:54 Speaker 00 I did it.
0:54 Speaker 01 And you'd write it and you'd send it to these people and then they'd get the choir together and record it. It would take months and thousands of dollars and then you get this production, so.
1:04 Speaker 00 Well, yesterday, for yesterday's show, I, I kiddingly at the end of the show said, I need a jingle for that. And so yesterday's show, if you haven't listened to yesterday's show, it now has a, a stinger at the end. Instead of me saying Talking Real Money, you may have heard it. So I thought, I wonder, I wonder if Suno, and by the way, for those of you who get freaked out about AI, Suno actually has paid licensing fees to Warner Music Group to use the feel of the music.
1:32 Speaker 01 I don't want, I didn't know Sumo because the rest, it scares me. Those guys are huge.
1:36 Speaker 00 No, not, not, not huge guys. Huge.
1:39 Speaker 01 Oh, I was like, I was starting to pound my life.
1:41 Speaker 00 Huge AI talent. I'm telling you.
1:43 Speaker 01 Yeah. It's coming for you. It's scary. That is scary.
1:46 Speaker 00 I may have a different themed intro now for every show.
1:51 Speaker 01 Wow. Can you do one that just says Tom and no Don on it? Could you make that happen?
1:55 Speaker 00 I didn't put Tom or Don in that jingle, but.
1:57 Speaker 01 Well, I think we should have one of us there. Ask AI which one they would prefer and we'll go from there.
2:02 Speaker 00 Yeah. I'm afraid my AI knows me better than it knows you, so it's gonna be a little biased. So I just want to be fair. Hey, everybody, welcome to Talking Real Money. We own that song, by the way. We own that song. That is, we own the rights to that.
2:18 Speaker 01 That's crazy.
2:18 Speaker 00 Isn't that amazing?
2:19 Speaker 01 Yeah.
2:21 Speaker 00 Uh, today, a lot of questions. So we're gonna get really, really quickly through our topic of the day, which is active managers.
2:33 Speaker 01 Let the whining begin.
2:34 Speaker 00 Looking for another excuse. They really are desperate to find a reason why they are no longer the cat's meow, or is it the cat's pajamas?
2:45 Speaker 01 I think it's, I think it's the pajamas in this case. You know, and the other thing that's fascinating about this, you see who the author of the study is?
2:52 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's a PhD.
2:54 Speaker 01 It's a student. It's a, it's a PhD, I mean PhD student, but you know.
2:58 Speaker 00 Yeah, no, she, yeah, right. I mean, but here's the thing about this study, this study, this was from Spencer Jacobs in the Wall Street Journal. He alluded to this. Uh, this study is another excuse as to why index funds, indexing has made active managers less useful. I think it's a good.
3:19 Speaker 01 And let's go back. Remember, let you go back about 25 years. One out of $20 was invested in index funds, something like that. It was a very small number.
3:29 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah.
3:30 Speaker 01 In stock and, and today it's one out of two.
3:32 Speaker 00 Well, it was considered un-American.
3:34 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly. It's commie. Uh, and you, today it's, you could argue a little, but it's about half of the money is managed using index or index-like products, right? Rules-based and blah, blah, blah. And so there's been a lot of whining and complaining by the active managers, because guess what? Their, their lifespan is gonna be, you know, less than the dinosaurs, because they're, they're going out fast. Um, and you didn't even need the cataclysmic event. So it's a fascinating thing that, uh, that there's this new study by Hannah Unterberg. Didn't we have Bessen Binder on one?
4:11 Speaker 00 Do you have somebody, do you have somebody calling?
4:12 Speaker 01 Yes, I do. So I didn't think you'd be hearing that.
4:15 Speaker 00 Is it important? I don't know.
4:16 Speaker 01 Well, it's my daughter. She's at the airport and they're leaving for the college orientation, so.
4:21 Speaker 00 Oh, the Broncos.
4:23 Speaker 01 Oh, I just, that pains me. You have no idea.
4:26 Speaker 00 Your daughter's about to become a Bronco.
4:27 Speaker 01 You have no idea.
4:27 Speaker 00 A Raiders fan gets to root for a Bronco.
4:30 Speaker 01 I can feel the hives every time you say that. Again, it just starts exploding.
4:34 Speaker 00 Your daughter's a Bronco. I love that.
4:36 Speaker 01 So there's a lot of discussion about how, how this happens, right? Why can't active fund managers, and we're talking about traditional active fund, picking stocks, timing markets.
4:49 Speaker 01 Being in sectors, finding a hot manager, all the things that were the kind of the way the industry really was until index funds came around and became more popular in the 80s, 90s and certainly
5:00 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's complicated, but it's an explanation.
5:02 Speaker 01 So now there's all these studies as to why they're underperforming.
5:05 Speaker 00 Okay, let me, wait, can I rephrase that?
5:06 Speaker 01 This one is a little hard to understand, I think.
5:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, of why they underproduce. So let me reword, please. It's excuse, not the why, but it's the
5:19 Speaker 00 Won an award.
5:20 Speaker 01 As I said, let the whining continue. Um, this is an award winning, they're calling it an award winning paper. I don't know what that means. I guess the paper that she wrote for, I guess of some kind.
5:30 Speaker 00 Okay, here, here's the thing. It's basically what it's saying is that because of the sheer weight of the index funds and index ETFs in the marketplace. It has made the market overall more efficient. There aren't the price discrepancies where people misprice securities like there used to be when there wasn't this behemoth that just bought stocks at market value. That there's no longer the inefficiencies that can be exploited by active managers. Now, active managers will say that differently. They will say that what the, what the indexes have done is kind of averaged out the market
6:12 Speaker 00 and taken away their ability to pick better stocks. But what I believe and what I think you'll find most of the academics believe is that the market has become better at taking all available information and coming up with a relatively fair price, thanks to indexing. It's not a, again, they're whining because they can't beat the market anymore. The best you can do is be the market and then if you charge extra fees, you lose to the market.
6:52 Speaker 01 Well, extra, I mean, single-digit basis points or hundreds of a percent, it's pretty small.
6:59 Speaker 00 So, basically, what it comes down to is the industry is trying to whine about the fact that it's not good at what it used to be apparently perceived to be good at. And that was an illusion because the market failed to be as efficient as indexes have forced it to be.
7:15 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I think the other part of all this is the active managers, they're not only mad about the fact that they've become far less significant than they once were, but they keep referring to the market as being broken, fundamentally broken, et cetera, et cetera, due to the fact that this money comes in every two weeks into 401ks, it buys index funds, and so they don't feel that prices are really, that people are really looking at the company one by one to say, well, is Microsoft really worth that much?
7:56 Speaker 00 Well, because what they're saying is the elite people aren't setting the prices.
7:59 Speaker 01 SpaceX and the rest of them, and so they're saying it's...
8:01 Speaker 00 They're not. They, the whole argument comes down to, are they smarter than the market? They believe they are, they just think the market is a bunch of stupid people.
8:10 Speaker 01 And that the pricing that you see now is because the, because people who are buying
8:15 Speaker 00 and selling stocks which are in the millions are stupid, because they're just buying the indexes. It's a spurious, twisted, convoluted argument that really doesn't hold a lot of, of weight. And we think is, is probably just, again, a whine. Now, we are going to take your questions, we're going to do a bunch of questions that Tom is going to read. That he got from TalkingRealMoney.com on the Ask a Question form.
8:45 Speaker 01 Yeah, from Seattle, Bill writes, "Comment, not a question. At age 50 or so, if you have a newborn and thereafter have any reason you take early social security, your child under the age of 18 can also receive a benefit. It may be substantial. It partly paid college tuition for my son." That is true, by the way.
9:06 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
9:06 Speaker 01 But I don't remember that being an issue on the show. Somebody else wrote, "Contact," it's Renee from Seattle, and thank you for all your comments. Renee from Seattle wrote, "Contact social security. My coworker discovered that when he started taking social security benefits at full retirement age, he was able to collect about 50% more of his SS benefit for his underage child until they reached a certain age." I think it's, she says 16, I think it's 18. I cannot remember the correct parameters.
9:35 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think it's 18, too.
9:36 Speaker 01 Yep, verify and share with your listeners, because I think I could have done this with my child, but I decided not to do it. And it does not reduce your benefit, by the way. It was only going to be a very short time in my house, anyway.
9:48 Speaker 00 Yeah.
9:49 Speaker 01 So, but yes, you can, those tricks still exist with social security, and they do not affect your benefit when you do take it for retirement.
9:59 Speaker 00 Strange trick. It's just an unusual kind of a thing, you think. Okay, now to real questions that came into TalkingRealMoney.com.
10:06 Speaker 01 This one comes from the UK.
10:08 Speaker 00 Oh, wow.
10:09 Speaker 01 United Kingdom, where they're celebrating their new prime minister, whose name I now forget, but it's the seventh in 10 years.
10:16 Speaker 00 Yeah, I can't remember his new name.
10:17 Speaker 01 Do you know the last time they had seven in 10 years?
10:21 Speaker 00 Uh, no, I don't.
10:23 Speaker 01 The time of the American Revolution.
10:25 Speaker 00 Wow.
10:26 Speaker 01 We're already independents, we wouldn't have to worry about it.
10:27 Speaker 00 That's because King George was going mad.
10:30 Speaker 01 He was, yeah, he was a little...
10:32 Speaker 00 Well, he was good at the beginning, and then he started going a little nuts. He had a brain condition of some sort.
10:37 Speaker 01 Is that what it was?
10:38 Speaker 00 Yeah.
10:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, okay, let's leave it at that. Don and Tom, greetings from the UK. I discovered your podcast three years ago.
10:44 Speaker 00 Oh, come on, do it with an accent. Tom and Don, greetings from the UK.
10:48 Speaker 01 After realize, realizing, realizing I'd previously watched Tom's videos with Mark Hebner. I did some work with Mark Hepner many years ago.
10:57 Speaker 00 Oh my god, those are old as the hills.
11:00 Speaker 01 But they're not up there anymore. He had to tear them all down. I asked him once what happened to them, but the FCC.
11:05 Speaker 00 The SEC said, "Take them down because that Tom guy is saying weird stuff."
11:10 Speaker 01 Making all this stuff up, probably. Uh, he says, "Those videos mark the beginning of my personal finance journey for which I'm very grateful." People sometimes ask, this would be a good, this would be a good.
11:20 Speaker 00 People sometimes ask.
11:22 Speaker 01 Yes. Why I listen to an American personal finance podcast.
11:26 Speaker 00 Why do I listen to, oh, let's do it. Why I listen to an American personal finance podcast.
11:30 Speaker 01 Bloody Americans.
11:31 Speaker 00 To a Great Britain program.
11:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, when our tax systems are so different. While the details differ, many of the underlying issues are remarkably similar. The decline of defined benefit pension schemes, that's true. I mean, that's global, I think, um, in the private sector. Concerns over the long-term funding of the state pension, and governments constantly tinkering with already overcomplicated tax systems. Boy, is that true. Wow. That's true everywhere. One of the things I enjoy most about your podcast is testing myself when you answer listeners' questions to see whether I can predict what your advice will be. Oh, by the way, this isn't one where he said, "Don will say I'm overthinking it." That was a later one, I think. Um, he's a big Dimensional fan with the help of Fee Only Advisor, moved the portfolio from Hodgkin to et cetera, et cetera.
12:19 Speaker 01 There's a question in here.
12:21 Speaker 00 Okay, but so far, so far, what he's talking about, it, we are seeing a globalization of investing, uh, where there are fewer differences between the types of investment vehicles available to investors globally, in every country practically on the planet it's happening. And that is such a good thing, where you can get Dimensional and Avantas and Vanguard and all of these products, almost anywhere on the globe. Oh my heavens, it's such a good day.
12:52 Speaker 01 Yeah, it is.
12:53 Speaker 00 Oh my heavens, it's such a good day.
12:56 Speaker 01 When I was in Italy, I looked it up for someone and there's an outfit called Interactive Brokers.
13:02 Speaker 00 They're everywhere, yeah.
13:03 Speaker 01 And you can buy pretty much everything. Now, in his case, he has to buy a British version of the Dimensional World Allocation 6040.
13:13 Speaker 01 And his question is, he kinda wants to move to a 50/50. He wants a bond fund to place in there or reduces exposure to the 60/40. He says Dimensional does not have a 100% bond fund available in the UK. And so, here's the thing, I don't know why you have to use Dimensional for that.
13:32 Speaker 00 No.
13:32 Speaker 01 You could own a Vanguard. I'm sure Vanguard's BND or similar is available globally. He wants to know, my over-complicating things, keep up the excellent work. Thank you, by the way, Charles, for all this. Yeah, probably. I mean, frankly, to move from a 60/40 to a 50/50, I'm not sure is that significant. It's
13:52 Speaker 00 It's not. And one of the ways you could do it is the British equivalent of a certificate of deposit, whatever that might be. That could be part of it. You could build it a CD ladder or a bond ladder. The, you can buy, let's see, the iShares US aggregate bond ETF, which is basically BND.
14:18 Speaker 01 Cheap, probably.
14:19 Speaker 00 Is available, yeah. It can be, it trades on the London Stock Exchange. It's S U A G and it's denominated in British pounds, but it trades the iShares US aggregate bond index. So it's US bonds, but in pounds.
14:36 Speaker 01 And you can, so you could still own the global 60/40 and then put this
14:41 Speaker 00 Yeah, if you want them in US bonds, because that's gonna be US bonds.
14:46 Speaker 01 No.
14:47 Speaker 00 The US dollar version, but see, that's gonna get you into currency exposure, which isn't a good idea. I'm not even gonna mention that. Not gonna mention that. Never mind.
14:55 Speaker 01 I think it's a pretty simple solution. I like the fact that you're keeping it simple to self-manage. It makes sense. And here's the other thing, Charles. Extremely sorry about the World Cup. Extremely sorry.
15:06 Speaker 00 He is actually sorry. He was rooting for Great Britain. He was rooting for England, not Great Britain. I'm sorry. Scotland has a team.
15:13 Speaker 01 Northern Ireland, etc.
15:15 Speaker 00 Yeah, and, but you know, the CD thing, I, I think that's a very good way to get a fixed income portfolio. The UK is, is, has, the bank instruments have bond in their name. They're called, I think, fixed term Bonds or fixed rate bonds, but they're from banks and they're insured up to 120,000 pounds per person, per institute, just like our CDs.
15:41 Speaker 01 Yeah.
15:41 Speaker 00 So, um, but.
15:44 Speaker 01 Ladder it up.
15:45 Speaker 00 Yeah, you could use, you could get a five-year ladder for the other 10%. What that adds is you've got the bonds in the, the, the regular fluctuating bond exposure in the dimensional fund, and this gives you non-fluctuating, a component that really doesn't fluctuate if you never sell.
16:02 Speaker 01 And what are you, what are you getting for a five-year CD right now?
16:06 Speaker 00 I'm averaging right about four. Yeah, I'm averaging four across my ladder.
16:10 Speaker 01 Nothing wrong with that.
16:11 Speaker 00 Uh, and it's locked in.
16:12 Speaker 01 Probably keeping up with inflation, probably.
16:14 Speaker 00 Barely, but probably.
16:16 Speaker 01 You know, you're not cutting your trees down the way Don does, you're probably okay. So.
16:20 Speaker 00 Got a new bid though, 3,600, feeling better.
16:22 Speaker 01 Oh, wow. That's major, can we say it, undercutting? Uh, sorry. Thank you, I'll be here all week. Um, from Mesquite Go Wisconsin, Roy writes, my daughter, 47, just profited $200,000 from a deal.
16:39 Speaker 00 Drug deal, what, I don't, did he say what kind of deal?
16:43 Speaker 01 Good point. Yeah, uh, she has a small Roth IRA, Roth IRA of 50K. She and her husband have an income of 160K. This sounds like one of those, you know, math problems or something. House payment is under a thousand.
16:56 Speaker 00 Is there a train involved going west?
16:59 Speaker 01 At three miles an hour, then you gotta go over the hill, that's gonna reduce it to one and a half. Um, she needs a car soon.
17:05 Speaker 00 Yeah. Well, she's got $200,000, she can afford a car.
17:09 Speaker 01 So how should she invest the 200, keeping in mind she needs a car soon?
17:13 Speaker 00 Anything she needs.
17:14 Speaker 01 I hope she's not gonna pay 200 for a car.
17:16 Speaker 00 Anything she needs for a car goes into high-yield savings.
17:20 Speaker 01 Yeah.
17:21 Speaker 00 Period.
17:21 Speaker 01 And that's still paying close to four, I think.
17:23 Speaker 00 No, you can get four.
17:25 Speaker 01 And I hope, by the way, new car today, I think I just read, the average is like 55K.
17:30 Speaker 00 Yeah, I gotta tell you, I, I am a huge fan of CarMax now. I love CarMax.
17:38 Speaker 01 I haven't seen him, is he on TV, is he a personality of some kind?
17:40 Speaker 00 Another bad dad joke.
17:41 Speaker 01 I'm sorry.
17:41 Speaker 00 Uh, I found CarMax, I compared CarMax and Carvana, I found their prices to be a little better at CarMax.
17:46 Speaker 01 Okay.
17:47 Speaker 00 CarMax actually has, uh, has really good service. I was surprised how good their service was. Um, so you can save a lot of money. My, my, uh, Armada is from CarMax and it's been a great car.
17:59 Speaker 01 And if I can make a suggestion around this?
18:02 Speaker 01 I got it a few years ago and I love it. The hybrids, I think, are just-
18:04 Speaker 00 Oh, I have a Honda hybrid. Love my hybrid.
18:06 Speaker 01 It's just so good. It's so good. And I buy gas once a month.
18:11 Speaker 00 Whether he needs to or not.
18:13 Speaker 01 What's that?
18:13 Speaker 00 Whether you need to or not.
18:15 Speaker 01 No, but it's nice. So, okay, so going back, you got 200K. First of all, I'd pay whatever taxes I owed on the deal. Get that out of the way.
18:23 Speaker 00 Unless it's an illegal drug deal and then-
18:25 Speaker 01 Well, then don't, don't-
18:26 Speaker 00 Maybe there aren't any taxes.
18:26 Speaker 01 Move it all into Bitcoin, hope for the best.
18:28 Speaker 00 Yeah, you know, buy a car wash and launder it.
18:31 Speaker 01 I forgot the car wash. That was great, dude.
18:34 Speaker 00 I know. What a great show.
18:35 Speaker 01 They open the storage bin and they have all that money there. I thought, God, what would you, that would just, but you can't do anything with it. That was the whole irony. That's fascinating. Anyway, so, um-
18:43 Speaker 00 You could take it to Panama, spend it down there. They're dollars denominated.
18:47 Speaker 01 How do you get it from here to Panama?
18:49 Speaker 00 A truck.
18:51 Speaker 01 Oh, I see. Like, drive it, put it in a truck-
18:52 Speaker 00 Right, drive it down through Mexico.
18:54 Speaker 01 That's true. You could bribe people.
18:55 Speaker 00 You got bribe money for all along the way.
18:57 Speaker 01 That's a good point. Yeah, okay. All right, there's your idea. Uh, 200-
19:00 Speaker 00 I have criminal, I have a criminal mind, apparently.
19:03 Speaker 01 Good, good for you. Gotta make a buck, kid. Um, okay, so let's assume, for sake of argument, that you're gonna spend, gosh, I hope it's not more than 50 on the car.
19:11 Speaker 00 50, 50. Let's say 50.
19:13 Speaker 01 Yeah. Then I would take, um, is it 7,500 per Roth now?
19:20 Speaker 01 Per year?
19:21 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think so.
19:24 Speaker 01 I would take 7,500 for each one of you, daughter and husband, and put that in the Roth IRA contribution for 2,026.
19:33 Speaker 00 Okay. Well, that sounds like, uh, that's good. And then the rest of it, just invest in your brokerage account.
19:38 Speaker 01 That's right.
19:39 Speaker 00 Based on your portfolio.
19:41 Speaker 01 Yeah. But Don's right. Put the, whatever you're gonna need for the car, whenever you're gonna need that, that should just be in high-yield savings. Don't mess around with that. Then I would do the Roth, no question. And then from there, I would open a brokerage account and invest the rest, yeah.
19:53 Speaker 00 All right. There we go.
19:55 Speaker 01 Muskego, we got you?
19:57 Speaker 00 We got it.
19:57 Speaker 01 Uh, we got more. You want more?
19:59 Speaker 00 I'm ready, sir. And by the way, it is 7,500, under 50, and 8,600, weird number.
20:06 Speaker 01 Wait, what?
20:07 Speaker 00 8,600 if you're 50.
20:09 Speaker 01 I remember this every year. That's just-
20:10 Speaker 00 I know.
20:11 Speaker 01 8,600?
20:12 Speaker 00 8,600.
20:12 Speaker 01 Gosh, I'm not sure I did that right for 20, I gotta look at that for 20, I think I did 8,500 for each one. Anyway, all right, um, Sharon writes from Bloomfield Hills, Michigan. Hi, Don and Tom. I'm retired from the federal government. Well, congratulations on that. I have a pension and $485,000 in my 401K. What funds, G, I think that's the government guarantee.
20:38 Speaker 00 That's the government fund, the special government fund. C, that's the S and P 500.
20:42 Speaker 01 Basically, yeah. They call it common stock, I think. S is small cap and I is international. What fund should I invest the money in? I don't need the money until three years.
20:54 Speaker 01 Wow.
20:55 Speaker 00 Three years?
20:56 Speaker 01 Really tough answer.
20:57 Speaker 00 Gee.
21:00 Speaker 01 Yeah, if you're gonna spend it all in three years, yes.
21:02 Speaker 00 Well, yeah, we don't know anything other than that. Said I need it in three years.
21:06 Speaker 01 Okay, but all right. That's funny. You gotta have a plan, Sharon. You gotta say, what rate of return do I need on this money for the long haul? Because you're just retired, you're probably still young. And how much volatility you're willing to accept to make that? Once you do that, then you can go back. By the way, it's pretty simple. The G fund would be your bond portion. And then I just divide the other three into thirds. One third large, one third small, one third international. Bing bang boom.
21:33 Speaker 00 I can't argue with that. That's good advice.
21:35 Speaker 01 Appreciate you not arguing.
21:36 Speaker 00 Simple, sane.
21:38 Speaker 01 Yeah. So, but you gotta first, you got, and by the way, we haven't promoted this in a long time. The risk quiz.
21:45 Speaker 00 Oh, that's true. Everybody should take the risk quiz. It's free. And you don't get like any, I know you think, well, you have to fill out some stuff, but you don't get solicited ever.
21:58 Speaker 01 You simply go to TalkingRealMoney.com, click on, it's a little harder to find now than it used to be.
22:02 Speaker 00 No, it's not. It's right there in that right column.
22:06 Speaker 01 I thought it was harder. It's not, but it's not at the top the way it used to be, I don't think.
22:09 Speaker 00 Oh, hold on, let me look. I don't remember, because you know.
22:12 Speaker 01 But the risk quiz is free and every person should take it because it helps you understand.
22:16 Speaker 00 It's in the right-hand column. There's a little place that says, what would you like to do? Meet an advisor, type your question, speak your question, take our risk quiz, watch retire me 2026, find an advisor, find a few good funds. Look at that. I made it so easy. It's a list.
22:30 Speaker 01 So then, then, and only then, can you decide. This is a question for every person who invests one dime. You gotta be able to answer those questions first, then you can invest. But as Don said, if you're gonna spend the whole 485 in three years, probably just all in the G fund.
22:47 Speaker 00 Yep.
22:48 Speaker 01 Which is a nice guaranteed fund. It's probably paying, I don't know, 4% or something right now, my guess. And it's all guaranteed, it never goes down.
22:56 Speaker 00 Yep.
22:56 Speaker 01 That sounds pretty good. I like that.
22:58 Speaker 00 Yep.
22:59 Speaker 01 Thank you for your question.
23:00 Speaker 00 It's a deal.
23:00 Speaker 01 Uh, let's see. Yeah, we got more from Tontogany, Ohio. Do you know Tontogany?
23:07 Speaker 00 No. Never heard of it. Do you know where it is?
23:10 Speaker 01 I do not. Ohio.
23:11 Speaker 00 I thought maybe you knew.
23:13 Speaker 01 Ohio.
23:14 Speaker 00 I don't even know how to spell Tontogany.
23:17 Speaker 01 Just as it sounds. T-O-N-T-O.
23:20 Speaker 00 Oh, Tontog.
23:21 Speaker 01 G-A-N-Y.
23:22 Speaker 00 Alright, I'm now gonna have to find out where the heck it is.
23:26 Speaker 01 And by the way, when we say this on the show, we're not meaning to insult you, we just don't know.
23:31 Speaker 00 I don't think people are in, I wouldn't be insulted if somebody said Celebration, Florida.
23:37 Speaker 01 They Duval, Washington? I consider that a bad one.
23:41 Speaker 00 I go to Google and I look up Tontogany, and the first thing that came up is a junkyard for old equipment. The historic, oh, it's the Historical Equipment Museum.
23:53 Speaker 01 The second largest in the country? Yeah, okay, never missed.
23:56 Speaker 00 It is in Wood County, Ohio. Uh, it's just up, it's just northwest of Bowling Green.
24:05 Speaker 01 Oh, okay. I know the part of the state.
24:07 Speaker 00 So, south of Toledo.
24:09 Speaker 01 Yeah. Gonna ask the question now?
24:12 Speaker 00 Yeah, of course. I was trying to help people out. Population 387.
24:17 Speaker 01 Okay, so now I can see why we wouldn't know it.
24:19 Speaker 00 Right.
24:20 Speaker 01 I wonder what the population of Duval is? It can't be more than maybe 1,000 people? Anyway, um, Lincoln says, "I'm planning for retirement with a $4,000 a month pension, 1,300 in social security, that covers most expenses at 65, and I have $700,000 in a traditional IRA. I asked AI for advice, it suggested turning on dividends for additional income in retirement."
24:45 Speaker 00 No.
24:45 Speaker 01 It said have 40% in SCHD.
24:49 Speaker 00 Ooh.
24:49 Speaker 01 Which is a dividend paying, um, stock, uh, ETF. 10% in JEPi, we know that one, J-E-P-I. 10% in JEPQ, J-E-P-Q. 20% in VGIT, which I do not know, and 20% in S-GOV, which is, uh...
25:09 Speaker 01 Bond fund. It stated the turning on dividends would pay two to three thousand dollars a month without ever having to sell shares.
25:17 Speaker 00 Wait a minute, how much does he have?
25:20 Speaker 01 Seven hundred, so let's see, let's just take it the low end, so that's twenty four a year on seven hundred. Yeah, um, hmm.
25:31 Speaker 00 All right, I put it into chat GPT. I said chat suggested dividend funds to a listener. Uh, and I said, is that terrible advice? Recommending dividend funds without understanding the listener's taxes, total portfolio, income needs and risk tolerance is lousy advice. Dividends aren't free money.
25:49 Speaker 01 Thank you.
25:52 Speaker 01 Yeah, AI, yeah, anybody else who runs around and tells you just get your five percent of your.
25:59 Speaker 01 You're limiting the exposure to the stock market.
26:01 Speaker 00 And it really depends a lot on the, we would need to know the exact question asked. Well, okay. You can change AI's opinion by asking the question in a certain way.
26:13 Speaker 01 Well, that's true. So, but, okay, but generally, here's what we suggest if you need to generate income from a seven hundred thousand dollar portfolio. Right?
26:23 Speaker 00 Okay.
26:23 Speaker 01 First, we're going to find out, as we said before, what your, you know, ability to take risk is, how much you can take up and down. Number two, how much money you need from the portfolio? Right? Does it need to be twenty four thousand a year? Right? Then we build the right portfolio. In other words, how much in stocks, how much in bonds, and at the end of every year or so, we're simply going to rebalance. This year we'd be selling things like emerging markets because they're way up above everything else. And putting that money in your pocket. Then we do the same thing a year later, basically. Sometimes we do it more often, can do it semi annually. But that approach, that total return approach, it turns out over time, has been better than harvesting.
27:06 Speaker 00 And it makes sense it should be. It should be from a, both a risk and a return standpoint better because you have greater diversification. The problem we, we as investors and apparently as AI.
27:18 Speaker 00 Assume that these dividend paying stocks, that the dividends they're paying are as safe as the income from high quality bonds, and it is not even close. Generally speaking, if a stock is paying a four or a five or a six or a seven percent dividend, these are companies that aren't in the best financial shape. They tend, good companies tend not to pay out a lot in dividends, because the more you pay out in dividends, the less you have to reinvest in your company and grow it.
27:49 Speaker 01 And remember, some of the reasons that dividend percentages are high is the stock price has gone down.
27:53 Speaker 00 Right.
27:54 Speaker 01 People have a tendency to forget, well, wow, what a ratio.
27:57 Speaker 00 So, and by the way, you're gonna get higher dividend paying stocks, generally speaking, in a value tilted portfolio anyway.
28:04 Speaker 01 Good, yeah.
28:05 Speaker 00 Because the lower prices are how value is determined. So, no, that was bad advice. Bad, bad, bad advice.
28:13 Speaker 01 Yeah. That, and that concludes our questions for today, sir. I know you're big on your jingles, and you got the whole group warming up in the back there, and they're ready to go, and...
28:21 Speaker 00 I do, I'm, I'm, uh, I'm just, you know, I'm fascinated to see how many different stingers and jingles we can, we can come up with.
28:29 Speaker 01 Well, I want one, when I think of the seventies jingles, I was thinking, Tom and Don on Talking Real Money, something like that. That's what I was thinking, but...
28:37 Speaker 00 Wow, that isn't nearly as creative as what we were working on.
28:41 Speaker 01 I know, well, that's, okay. I'm not the creative guy here, I'm the business guy. So, you're the creative guy.
28:46 Speaker 00 All right, so I'm gonna come up with, see, we had yesterday's stinger. I don't think I'll use it again today. I think I'll use... Hmm, this one.
29:02 Speaker 02 The opinions and views expressed in this podcast were current on the date recorded. Opinions, estimates, forecasts, and statements of financial market trends that are based on current market conditions constitute our judgment and are subject to change without notice, including any forward-looking estimates or statements which are based on certain expectations and assumptions. Although information and opinions given have been obtained from or based on sources believed to be reliable, no warranty or representation is made as to their correctness, completeness, or accuracy. Information presented on the podcast is not personalized investment advice from Appella Wealth. The views and... Strategies described may not be suitable for everyone. This podcast does not identify all the risks, direct or indirect, or other considerations which might be material to you when entering any financial transaction. Past performance does not guarantee future results, and profitable results cannot be guaranteed. We hope you realize that the information provided on Talking Real Money is for informational, educational, and hopefully enjoyable purposes only.
29:48 Speaker 02 The podcast is not trying to get you to buy or sell any financial products or securities. Instead, the program is provided as a public service by Appella Wealth, a fee-only registered investment advisor. Please see Appella Wealth's ADB Part 2A on our website for information regarding Appella's fees and services. Appella Capital LLC, DBA Appella Wealth, is an investment advisory firm registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission. The firm only transacts business in the states where it is properly registered, or excluded or exempt from registration requirements. Registration with the SEC or any state securities authority does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Appella does not provide tax or legal advice, and nothing either stated or implied here should be inferred as providing such advice. Thanks for listening, and please visit TalkingRealMoney.com for more information and important disclosure related to performance of any specific index or fund quoted in this podcast.
30:32 Speaker 02 And the lawyers get richer.
Previous Ep. 1945: The Big Question Pile Next Ep. 1947: Another Day of Q and A Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated