Pod Insights Talking Real Money - Investing Talk AI Trading Trap About this episode AI-powered trading is the latest shiny object designed to make investors feel smarter while quietly encouraging more trading (and more profits for platforms). Don and Tom break down why letting an “AI agent” execute your personal market theories is just automated speculation—no edge, no accountability, and no evidence it works. They contrast this with decades of data showing that even professionals fail to beat simple index investing. The episode also tackles a listener question on Roth conversion timing (spoiler: don’t overthink it) and a new “no-dividend” ETF gimmick that raises more questions than it answers. The throughline: complexity sells—but simplicity wins.0:05 AI trading tools enter the mainstream—and why they’re a bad idea1:34 “Public” and AI agents: your ideas, their execution, your risk3:12 The illusion of having a “market edge”5:41 Removing emotion vs. removing common sense7:09 Robinhood déjà vu and engagement-driven trading10:15 The real goal: more trades, more profit (for them)11:12 Hedge funds, cheating, and Buffett’s famous bet12:51 Day trading data: ~1% succeed (barely)13:55 SPIVA results: active managers consistently lose15:21 Why your AI-powered strategy won’t beat the market16:22 Listener Q: Roth conversions and “dollar-cost averaging”17:19 What a Roth conversion actually is (and key rules)19:22 Why DCA is mostly a myth outside regular income investing20:23 Timing Roth conversions: sooner is usually better21:50 Listener Q: XDIV “no-dividend” ETF explained23:57 How dividend avoidance actually works (and doesn’t)25:10 Gimmick or innovation? Costs, tracking error, and taxes26:34 Why waiting years beats chasing new products28:00 Q1 performance: U. S. vs. globally diversified portfolios28:15 The real diversification lesson investors ignore29:27 Free portfolio review pitch (and karmic marketing)Questions? Comments? Click!
Transcript 0:05 Speaker 00 Your guides to a really great financial future. Tom and Don are talking real money.
0:12 Speaker 01 Hi, everybody. I'm Don. That's Tom. This is the Talking Real Money Podcast. And as always, we're going to share a little information about something in the financial world that we found interesting or stupid, or helpful, or inane, or, you know, whatever. It's just something that we thought you should know about and usually avoid because most things that we talk about are things that people want you to do, not for your benefit, but for theirs. And here's another fine example of a really ridiculous idea that will gain some traction for a while because it's got the buzz phrase in it, but is probably not a good idea for you.
0:56 Speaker 01 And that is using artificial intelligence as a means by which to play the stock market. Do we like it or do we not?
1:11 Speaker 02 Yeah, this one really rubs me the wrong way because it's such a blatant attempt to face off against, you know, Robin Hood, right? Uh, which has, you know, been the leader in dumb ideas. So, sorry, Robin.
1:26 Speaker 01 Well, dumb trading, yeah.
1:27 Speaker 02 Dumb trading and getting all excited about a win. Do they show fireworks when they show a loss too? Um, this is a company called Public.
1:37 Speaker 01 They show a hand coming up out of a grave and yanking you down into the earth.
1:41 Speaker 02 Or reaching into your wallet, taking money out. Public is rolling out a feature that allows customers to use.
1:47 Speaker 01 Wait, Public? Who's? The general public?
1:49 Speaker 02 The general public. Uh, this is a company, privately held brokerage firm, of course, that's going to allow you to use AI to automate your investing tactics and execute trades. Boy, does that sound good. AI agents, they say can be deployed.
2:04 Speaker 01 I don't have to do the work anymore?
2:05 Speaker 02 No, they will buy protective puts should you, should oil spike, hedging against potential stock losses, automatically sweep customers' cash into higher yielding assets like bonds. Um, they could put a 20% stop loss order. They could, all kinds of wonderful things. And here's the really great part of all this. You come up with the ideas. That's right.
2:27 Speaker 01 Wait, I thought they came up with the ideas.
2:28 Speaker 02 No, they just execute your amazing ideas. The, the guy who runs the place says you're building all this code essentially that's running your account under the hood. Um, this is a way that they can go after, as I see aforementioned Robin Hood, and I guess even Betterment does this stuff. They're calling it create customized indexes because there's so many parts of the market that are, you know, not utilized as indexes. Um, so what happens here is you type in the strategy or the investment thesis, then you refine it with parameters with a series of follow-up questions that they provide. They're going to ask you, what about this? What about that? Including which accounts the agent will trade from, which assets to buy or sell, and whether the trade will be one time or recurring. You getting this so far?
3:13 Speaker 01 Okay.
3:14 Speaker 02 Yeah.
3:15 Speaker 01 So I'm not, still not sure how this is doing something for me, but okay. So it's my idea.
3:20 Speaker 02 Yeah, your ideas, but give me an idea. What would be an idea for a, a trade that you, I mean, a, a market that you think you could trade and take advantage of the inefficiency?
3:29 Speaker 01 Well, I think, I wouldn't be me, but I think most younger people would be thinking, well, right now, they'd be thinking, give me a way to trade AI.
3:36 Speaker 02 Yeah.
3:37 Speaker 01 Give me an idea that's gonna, uh, for example, a family member who will remain nameless, who occasionally buys stocks in his play money account.
3:46 Speaker 02 Yeah.
3:47 Speaker 01 Uh, just bought stocks in four different companies that build data centers.
3:53 Speaker 02 So they're, they're, they're not looking for the gold. They're selling people the methods to go, to go mine the gold.
3:59 Speaker 01 Right, right. They're the ones in, in Sutter's, at Sutter's Creek. They're the Sutlers at Sutter's Creek. They're the ones who are selling the pans.
4:08 Speaker 02 That's right.
4:09 Speaker 01 To the guys who are mining the gold and.
4:11 Speaker 02 The shovels.
4:12 Speaker 01 Yeah. So they're likely.
4:13 Speaker 02 That's a great trade.
4:14 Speaker 01 Actually, maybe that's a great trade.
4:16 Speaker 02 It's a great trade. Because those are the people, by the way, in all of these speculative enterprises that generally end up making money. The rest of them, generally not.
4:24 Speaker 01 Yeah. If you want to buy gold, buy the gold mining stock.
4:26 Speaker 02 Exactly. Yeah. Which you and I own, right?
4:29 Speaker 01 We do, among other 10,000 other things.
4:32 Speaker 02 Yeah. A lot of ideas. But, so you come up with this great idea. By the way, maybe we should test that great idea out. The AI infrastructure trade.
4:41 Speaker 01 Oh, no. This is a family member's checking that out for us.
4:44 Speaker 02 Oh, okay.
4:44 Speaker 01 We'll, we'll find out how it does.
4:46 Speaker 02 And then you hire these people and they ask you more questions and you build this master investing thesis because, you know, people are really good at that.
4:58 Speaker 01 So now that you've done the thesis, you have a masters in investing?
5:02 Speaker 02 Apparently so. Then you give them your money and.
5:07 Speaker 01 Oh, well, that's the most important part of the whole equation.
5:11 Speaker 02 Absolutely.
5:11 Speaker 01 You give them your money.
5:13 Speaker 02 Hand it over.
5:14 Speaker 01 All right.
5:15 Speaker 02 So they don't have to reach in your wall and take it. Um, so you give them the money and then they go to work trading all this. They, they, they, they look at this, I imagine, moment by moment.
5:25 Speaker 01 So they're bopping in and out and.
5:26 Speaker 02 Yeah. So they're good. Cause, and, and, and, all kidding aside, they can do that more efficiently than you can. Or I can.
5:31 Speaker 01 Well, of course they can. No, literally they can.
5:34 Speaker 02 Yep.
5:34 Speaker 01 Because they don't need to take a nap or have lunch.
5:38 Speaker 02 Or, or feel a change or feel, oh, that doesn't feel good. I'm going to do this instead.
5:46 Speaker 01 They take the feeling.
5:47 Speaker 02 Yeah, exactly.
5:48 Speaker 01 Out of the process of trading.
5:51 Speaker 02 I love this quote from the CEO of Public says, "It can only do what you tell it to do." Quote, "There are no hallucinations." Now, there may be after you look at what the effect of the trade is. You may be.
6:02 Speaker 01 AI.
6:03 Speaker 02 It's, yeah.
6:05 Speaker 01 I mean, okay, if it does what you tell it to do, you could be hallucinating.
6:10 Speaker 02 That's what I'm saying. You may be later when you review all this. So, okay, so you put the idea in there. It figures out how to trade away on this idea. Okay, that's wonderful. By the way, they say they've tested the AI agent on eight Series 7 practice exams from the Securities Training Corporation. A qualification test for entry level brokers and it passed them all. Uh, the tool is already available to.
6:36 Speaker 01 Wait a minute, the Series 7 is just rote memory. I remember taking the Series 7. And what Dean Witter did at the time was they spent six weeks cramming knowledge into our brains so that we could pass the stupid test. And then we immediately forgot it all. I don't remember 90% of the Series 7. I don't.
6:56 Speaker 02 Exactly. So, uh, then, so they've tested this. So this is, this is back testing, Don. This is, this is, this is making sure that you're not doing anything that's too risky. Um, they're joining Robinhood, which I forgot this. They rolled out a feature among other idiotic things that they did that can build and execute trades based on text prompts. And breakdowns, portfolio performance, they'll do all that for you. I don't know how much they charge you for all that and I don't suggest it, but they will do all that for you. Um, this is, this is part of the, part and parcel of the whole idea that you have these great ideas, but you just don't know how to execute them. You just don't know how to take advantage of that great idea that no one else has.
7:41 Speaker 02 Oh, save for all the hedge funds that trade with the money. Et cetera, et cetera, actively managed, traditionally actively managed mutual funds or whatever. Um.
7:52 Speaker 02 This is, I just love this quote again from the CEO who will remain nameless. He says, "This is the very beginning of how you will see behavior shift."
8:02 Speaker 02 I don't know what that means.
8:03 Speaker 01 I don't, I was just gonna say, I have no idea what that means.
8:06 Speaker 02 I don't think he knows, but it sure sounds good. He says it's gonna essentially remake the world of wealth management and investment advice. Because you have these great ideas, these theses, and you're going to hand them to the AI, the brain, and the AI is going to trade your way to Nirvana.
8:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, and here's what's really interesting about the way public is set up. They're basically saying, well, we're not making the trades. We're not giving advice. We're not doing anything. We're just acting as a trading agent. You give us the parameters, we'll make the trades. Therefore, we're not responsible. That's what all that means. We bear no responsibility for your trading stupidity. That's on you. So they're not really doing anything for you, except maybe automating the button pushing.
8:57 Speaker 02 Well, and any, can you tell by what they're going to charge it? They're gonna charge per trade? They're gonna charge per chat bot? I mean, what are they charging?
9:07 Speaker 01 Well, it's probably gonna be, they're gonna, with whoever is doing the brokerage platform, I'm sure they're hiring that out, although they claim they are. Uh, they're gonna, it's just gonna be spreads. Because if you can get people to trade, move stocks on a rapid-fire basis, those spreads, which can, you know, are just for rapidly traded, although they're probably dealing with lightly traded stocks, so the spreads are bigger. They're, they're, they're cents on the dollar, but when you trade, you know, 20 or 30 times, those cents add up to a dollar.
9:40 Speaker 02 Well, remember, we looked at this once when we did a piece long ago on Robinhood, and the order flow, the amount of money they were making on this was in the hundreds of millions? It was a big number, right? People think, I'm not paying them anything. Oh, yes, you are paying them something. By the way, you know someone else you're paying when you do a lot of trading is the US government. There's going to be taxes on all this, so beyond the cost, there's taxation, of course.
10:06 Speaker 01 Well, and there's that, and then there's the, the, the, the general problem with this and things like Robinhood. They're designed...
10:16 Speaker 01 They're not designed to give you an edge or to help you make more money. They're designed like a video game or a television show to engage you, to draw you in. Because the thinking, and this is based on fact, you engage somebody enough, they'll use your platform, they'll make you money, lots and lots of money if you keep them engaged. And that's what public's all about. It's about keeping people engaged. It's not going to provide you with any kind of an edge, and they don't even claim to. They don't even claim to. It's really nothing more than a button pushing machine. That's all.
11:01 Speaker 02 But let's make sure that we go back and talk about this in a more general notion. Because there are people that do this for a living. They do it every day. They run things like hedge funds that I mentioned.
11:16 Speaker 01 And by the way, I want to add this to these people, these professionals, Tom. This is something we don't talk about very often. Professionals often get their edge by gaming the margins. And in layman's terms, we could call that cheating a little.
11:36 Speaker 02 Yeah.
11:36 Speaker 01 And that's known. That's a fact. I mean, come on. Stephen Cohen, poster boy for cheating. He even pled guilty to doing it.
11:46 Speaker 02 Yep. Couldn't trade anybody else's money for like, what, eight years?
11:51 Speaker 01 Yeah, now he's doing it.
11:53 Speaker 02 Family office, he's managing the money. So, okay, so those people have done that. And what's the track record of that? Well, the only real known track record we know is when Warren Buffett made the bet, the S and P 500 versus an aggregate of hedge funds. And guess what? The S and P 500 did better. We also know many studies, not just one, the majority of day traders lose money. And this is what this is. This is your ideas. This is your hunches. This is your, oh, this has got to work because they lose money.
12:23 Speaker 01 I just talked about this in a Friday Q and A podcast, the day traders. There were studies done in I believe it was Brazil and Taiwan. Really, really robust studies of day trading. And they found that about 1% of day traders made money.
12:51 Speaker 02 1%?
12:52 Speaker 01 About 1%.
12:53 Speaker 02 That's crazy.
12:53 Speaker 01 In one study, they found that most of that 1% in Brazil, I think it was Brazil.
13:01 Speaker 01 Made, they made money, but it was less than minimum wage for the amount of time they spent doing it.
13:06 Speaker 02 Wow. Okay, let's go on with that. So what about the traditionally actively managed mutual funds?
13:14 Speaker 01 Hmm, that's Spiva territory.
13:16 Speaker 02 Yeah, how do they do when they, when you just compare just owning the market? How do the really smart people with all the advantages, all the money, all the research, all the knowledge about companies, all the people they can call that are gonna, you know, usher you in for a tour of their building? Being a publicly traded companies, how do the traditionally actively managed mutual funds perform versus a buy and hold approach to just owning the market?
13:44 Speaker 01 Funny, just about a month ago, the latest Spiva study, the Standard and Poor's Index versus Active Scorecard came out. And it found that in 2025, the number of large cap US equity funds that underperformed just buying the S and P 500
14:07 Speaker 01 for one year, when you think they might actually stand a chance of outperforming in a single year, 79% underperformed.
14:16 Speaker 02 Sounds like 8 out of 10.
14:17 Speaker 01 79%, and the farther out you go, the more years you go out, the worse the track record becomes. Not the better, the worse, the larger the number of funds that underperform the indexes. And this is across the board in every category.
14:38 Speaker 02 It doesn't matter the type of stock. So now, do you believe your ideas, your hunches will, even with the help of AI, trading those hunches will do better? Now, AI can do, I think, really great things. Air travel, you know, workout routines, whatever it is, there's all kinds of great stuff that AI does, but I would not recommend you hire them as your stockbroker in, I don't recommend you hire any stockbroker, but in this case, I'd stay a long way away from this.
15:09 Speaker 01 Oh yeah, this is really interesting. I'm just looking at those large cap funds because that's a, that's a fair comparison to the S and P 500.
15:15 Speaker 02 Sure.
15:16 Speaker 01 And as I said, it was 79% over one year, right?
15:21 Speaker 01 Over 10 years, it's over 85%. Over 20 years, it's 93%.
15:31 Speaker 02 So we're over nine out of 10. Yeah. So, and remember, you got to pick those 10 before the 20 years.
15:38 Speaker 01 Right.
15:39 Speaker 02 Not after.
15:40 Speaker 01 Right.
15:40 Speaker 02 After, anybody can pick them. So, yeah, these are great ideas, as we like to say, Wall Street have 20 other ones every week.
15:49 Speaker 01 They're constantly cranking out new ideas because it, they want you to buy into whatever it is they're doing. And we're just not going to fall for it. And we're going to get accused of being Luddites and old fashioned and slow to change. We keep hearing it. You guys admit that you're slow to change. Yeah, we're slow to change because you better prove it. It's as if we, we are both from Missouri. I'm sorry, Missouri.
16:16 Speaker 02 Missouri.
16:17 Speaker 01 Show me.
16:17 Speaker 02 Yeah.
16:18 Speaker 01 Show me.
16:19 Speaker 02 Yeah.
16:20 Speaker 01 The money. Show me Tom's questions.
16:25 Speaker 02 Yes, a lot of questions.
16:26 Speaker 01 On pieces of paper.
16:27 Speaker 02 Keep sending them in.
16:28 Speaker 01 Not papyrus, actual trees.
16:31 Speaker 02 TalkingRealMoney.com. Steven writes us from Auburn, Washington. Don and Tom, Roth conversions two to three times a year up to the top of our current tax bracket as part of our current financial plan, which we built with a financial advisor a few years ago. I have had the practice of making these conversions only twice a year. Would it make sense to do these three or four times a year to dollar cost average, especially with so much volatility in the markets? I appreciate your insight and all you do for us. So Roth conversions three or four times a year. A lot of work for one thing.
17:05 Speaker 01 No, no. And here's the thing, I need, I want to remove. The idea, this dollar cost averaging idea from everyone's psyche.
17:14 Speaker 02 Well, I think you should go back and talk about where Roth conversion is first, then you can remove the idea.
17:18 Speaker 01 All right, okay, Roth conversion is where you take your regular IRA.
17:22 Speaker 02 Traditional.
17:23 Speaker 01 Traditional, and you, the one that you got a tax deduction for.
17:27 Speaker 02 Correct.
17:27 Speaker 01 And tax deferral.
17:28 Speaker 02 Yeah.
17:29 Speaker 01 And you convert that into a Roth IRA, which
17:31 Speaker 02 Sure.
17:31 Speaker 01 will never, ever have any taxes on it going forward, but you pay the taxes on all the money you take out of the IRA that you convert to the Roth.
17:39 Speaker 02 And want to make sure two things. Number one, you don't want to bounce yourself into a higher bracket when you do that, because remember, this is income.
17:45 Speaker 01 And he said that, right?
17:45 Speaker 02 Oh, he didn't say that, but we're saying that. Number two, you want to make sure you have the cash to pay that. You do not want to pay it out of the retirement account of which you're converting. So that would be a couple of things to pay attention to. The question on the table is not that. The question is, should I be doing this one time a year, two to three times a year, three to four times a year, because there's a lot of volatility in the market?
18:07 Speaker 01 Okay, and again, I'm going to go back to the, my big brain theory, that we have this big brain and it sits around sometimes and gets bored and tries to think of new ways to do stuff.
18:18 Speaker 02 Watch those bad documentaries on Netflix. Okay, got it.
18:20 Speaker 01 Yeah, it gets bored and it watches documentaries on Netflix. World War II documentaries on Netflix. Lots of those. I think we both run out of World War II documentaries.
18:28 Speaker 02 I know I have. You know how this comes out, so what are you doing?
18:32 Speaker 01 And, and the, the reason I think there are so many World War II documentaries is because there was a lot of film back then. You don't see as many Revolutionary War documentaries.
18:42 Speaker 02 I've seen George Washington.
18:43 Speaker 01 Because you're kind of lacking, you're lacking, you're lacking the action. You know, you don't have video. There's no, there was no, do you know there was no video of the Revolutionary War?
18:52 Speaker 02 The explosions weren't as big in the Revolutionary War.
18:54 Speaker 01 No, they weren't as big either.
18:55 Speaker 02 Thousand pound bomb being.
18:56 Speaker 01 Now look at them. Anyway, back to my point.
18:59 Speaker 02 Yes.
19:00 Speaker 01 The overthinking thing. Please banish this idea of dollar cost averaging from your psyche in every case except one. There's no such thing as dollar cost averaging out. There's no such, there, there's no sense in having money in a pool somewhere and then slowly dollar cost averaging it in. That's timing the market.
19:23 Speaker 02 You're doing that. You're dollar-cost averaging in.
19:25 Speaker 01 No, no, no, that's from earnings. I'm getting to that.
19:27 Speaker 02 Oh, okay, pardon me.
19:28 Speaker 01 I said, there's only one case.
19:30 Speaker 02 You're jumping ahead. Yeah.
19:31 Speaker 01 You're jumping. Oh, you jump ahead?
19:33 Speaker 02 Shocking.
19:34 Speaker 01 Uh, there's only one case. You dollar-cost average because that's the way you earn money. You earn money on a regular basis, and so dollar-cost averaging is a very effective way of forcing you to invest all the time. You just do it when you get it, and you take advantages of the ups and downs of the market. And if you're in the accumulation phase and the market goes down, you should be cheering, "Hooray!"
19:58 Speaker 02 More share prices at a lower price.
20:00 Speaker 01 Yeah.
20:00 Speaker 02 More shares at a lower price.
20:02 Speaker 01 But otherwise, you're kind of trying to time the market. You're saying, "Well, I've got it in cash. I'm gonna put a little in now and a little in later."
20:10 Speaker 02 I think it's one of those concepts should just be gone.
20:13 Speaker 01 Yeah, it should be gone, and it makes no sense for Roth conversions. Convert when you convert, because you're playing, you're swimming against the current.
20:23 Speaker 02 Yeah.
20:23 Speaker 01 Generally speaking, markets go up more than they go down. So if you delay, if you, if you, if you do it on January 1, odds are you're going to pay less in taxes, odds are, than if you do it on December 31, in most years. Not in all years, that's the problem. But you're swimming against that current.
20:47 Speaker 02 In about three out of four years, yes.
20:48 Speaker 01 Three out of four years, you will have a, generally speaking, you'll have a higher tax liability at the end of the year than if you did it at the beginning. So what you're doing is you're giving up a whole year of that tax-free growth. So no, it doesn't make sense.
21:03 Speaker 02 Yeah. Plus, as I said, that's a lot of work, three or four times a year.
21:07 Speaker 01 Yeah. So harder work, less money. Oh, wait, no, that's just a no-on-bolt count.
21:13 Speaker 02 If you're interested in that, we have employment here at Appalo Wealth. We'll talk to you about it. Sorry. Uh, Tim writes us from Cranford, New Jersey.
21:21 Speaker 01 I'm saying none of the managers actually listen.
21:23 Speaker 02 Thank goodness.
21:24 Speaker 01 Do they, do they listen? Do we know?
21:27 Speaker 02 Yeah, there's a few people that every once in a while say, "Hey, did you really say that?" And I say, "No, I didn't say that."
21:31 Speaker 01 And it's usually Tom, right? They go...
21:33 Speaker 02 I blame you generally, as you know, so...
21:35 Speaker 01 Did he really talk about a show about orgasms last podcast?
21:40 Speaker 02 Well, I was trying to boost our ratings a little bit. Uh, hello, Don and Tom. Thanks for taking my question. Please opine on X.
21:47 Speaker 02 D I V. X is in X-ray, D is in Don, I is in Indiana, V as in Vermont.
21:54 Speaker 01 I love the fact that he used the word opine.
21:57 Speaker 02 Yes, uh, you don't hear that enough. They call it a no dividend S and P 500 fund. My understanding is the fund buys S and P 500 funds, like VOO, and sells them the day before the X dividend date and then buys it back or a similar fund to avoid getting the dividend. Theoretically results in tax efficiency could make sense for someone who's trying to keep their annual income low, especially for Irma purposes. Please don't confuse this with X D I V that trades on the Toronto Stock Exchange, which has been around longer and shows up often on internet searches. X D I V, an ETF that is a tax efficient.
22:35 Speaker 01 The Round Hill S and P 500 No Dividend Target ETF.
22:40 Speaker 02 There you go.
22:41 Speaker 01 It's only been around for a few months.
22:45 Speaker 02 Oh, okay. So this is new.
22:46 Speaker 01 So it's brand spanking new. Now, how is it done so far? Well, it's in the S and P 500. It's lost money. Does that tell us anything? Heck, no.
22:57 Speaker 02 No.
22:57 Speaker 01 But, but you're trading one tax for another. Although, wait a minute, because it's an ETF, if they're taking capital gains, they probab- they may not be distributing those capital gains because they can keep them inside the portfolio.
23:15 Speaker 02 Oh.
23:16 Speaker 01 I hadn't thought about that. Huh. It's not expensive. It's really not. It's a fund of funds.
23:27 Speaker 02 Yep.
23:27 Speaker 01 So what they're doing is they're buying the, the State Street Spider, the S and P 500 fund, which has an expense ratio of two basis points. And they're adding six basis points for them. And then they've just created a computer program that basically sells pre-X dividend date and then buys back post-X dividend.
23:56 Speaker 02 Then you don't get the dividends to pay tax on.
24:01 Speaker 01 You don't get the dividends, but the dividends get, here's the thing about dividends that people don't understand. Dividends gradually get built into the price of the stock over the quarter.
24:10 Speaker 02 Most people forget that.
24:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, the stock price rises by the amount of that dividend and then on the date they go X dividend, they pay out that dividend, the stock price is reduced by the amount of that dividend. All the market movement is separate from that, but that's generally how this works. So in theory, you're not losing the dividend.
24:32 Speaker 02 This feels like a gimmick to me.
24:34 Speaker 01 It feels massively gimmicky.
24:36 Speaker 02 Yeah.
24:37 Speaker 01 They're not expensive. Oh, gosh, I, you know what?
24:43 Speaker 02 This would be the thing, I would have to look at this case by case to see if it really was going to help you when it came to paying the Medicare surcharge, IRMA, for example, that would have to be a one-off to look to see if it's really going to matter or not. And if it was, then maybe.
25:02 Speaker 01 Yeah. I'm all over the place on this one. I really am all over the place on this one.
25:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, because you're relying on that price appreciation, which isn't absolute. It's kind of supposed to be there, but we don't know that it's there. And, and what it also does is it, it creates potentially some tracking error.
25:27 Speaker 02 Well, it's gonna have tracking error, no question.
25:29 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's not gonna track the S and P 500 perfectly and
25:34 Speaker 02 May I make a suggestion here?
25:35 Speaker 01 There are costs to trading too, that could exceed, I don't know that they will, I'm saying could, exceed the meager tax benefits that you're gonna get in, unless you're just in a killer tax bracket.
25:48 Speaker 02 Remember when you referred earlier to something like we're slow to
25:51 Speaker 01 Overthinking it, we're overthinking it.
25:53 Speaker 02 Adopt things and doing that, maybe we should just wait a year, see what happens a little bit.
25:57 Speaker 01 Maybe we should wait like five.
25:58 Speaker 02 Okay, five years. Call us in five years.
26:00 Speaker 01 Gimmicks, I don't generally.
26:04 Speaker 01 I'm opposed to gimmicks because they tend to be good for the person who created the gimmick. More, and again, here's the other thing, over and above the S and P, we forgot about that. Your, your expense ratio is four times higher, even though it's very low. Four times higher than the S and P 500. So you're losing in trading costs. You're losing in the tracking error potentially, and you're losing in the, uh, the, the, the, the higher expense ratio.
26:34 Speaker 02 This is something that, again, I, and I already mentioned this, I would have to look at it case by case to see if it was really going to save you on Irma. If not, no way, because again,
26:45 Speaker 01 Well, and we can't tell that because we won't see what the tracking error looks like for a couple of years.
26:50 Speaker 02 Yeah, you'd have to look at it for a while. So I wouldn't run out and get this, like, I wouldn't run out and get a lot of things. Um, but maybe we could look at it down the road.
26:59 Speaker 01 And I want to know where people are getting these ideas. Where, you should tell us. I read on such and such.
27:06 Speaker 02 Yeah, this was on CNBC, guaranteed.
27:08 Speaker 01 This was on CNBC?
27:09 Speaker 02 Probably, yeah.
27:10 Speaker 01 Okay, here's the best way to avoid.
27:12 Speaker 02 I just said that.
27:12 Speaker 01 Oh, you don't know. And I wish people would tell us. But here's the best way to avoid these new ideas? Stop watching CNBC or Fox Business.
27:20 Speaker 02 Exactly.
27:20 Speaker 01 Solves so many problems. Right there, because most of the, nobody reads, nobody reads financial mags anymore. They're all dead. Except you.
27:30 Speaker 02 I still read them all. I love them.
27:31 Speaker 01 In paper, probably. Do you get the paper version?
27:34 Speaker 02 Uh, no, I don't get the paper. Well, Bloomberg doesn't do it anymore.
27:37 Speaker 01 Oh, they don't do the paper version anymore?
27:39 Speaker 02 Which I hate because I loved it.
27:40 Speaker 01 Oh, you love your paper.
27:41 Speaker 02 I still read the Wall Street Journal every day, paper.
27:43 Speaker 01 In paper? Do they still make that?
27:45 Speaker 02 They still make that. The trees are loving me for that. I want to mention something though, before we end this wonderful podcast, and that is the following. In the first quarter, if you owned US stocks, you lost somewhere around 7%.
28:00 Speaker 01 In the first quarter, yeah. Now, we don't know how you've done so far in the second quarter.
28:03 Speaker 02 No, but I will mention this. If you bought a diversified portfolio, US, international, emerging, small, blah, blah, blah, you broke even. If you lost-
28:15 Speaker 01 That's a big difference, by the way. That's huge.
28:18 Speaker 02 Here's the thing, not that we're any smarter than anybody else, but you need to know how your portfolio is allayed. In other words, is it properly diversified? And you know what? We do that free. We actually look at your portfolio. We'll do kind of an x-ray on it, tell you how diversified you are, how much you're paying others, how much risk you're taking.
28:37 Speaker 01 And Tom looks so good in that lead apron when he does that x-ray.
28:40 Speaker 02 God, let's not go there. Ah, so-
28:45 Speaker 01 Kind of like, it reminds me a lot of Dexter.
28:48 Speaker 02 That's very similar, actually. But you can do that, and here's how you do it. You just go to TalkingRoomMoney.com, click on meet an advisor, and it's not like we're not going to call you and say, "What do you need to do to move all your money today to here?" No. We actually do the review. You actually get an hour with an advisor, and we're going to tell you, here's the good, here's the bad, here's the ugly, and things you should pay attention to. But this is a clear example.
29:13 Speaker 01 There's some things you should be thinking about, too, going forward.
29:15 Speaker 02 Yeah. So, anyway, take advantage of that. And also, yeah, keep typing questions.
29:20 Speaker 01 A lot of people call and say, "Wow, it really helped, and darn it, you didn't try and sell me anything." No, that's not what we do. We don't need to. We're doing fine. It actually works. It's so funny how well karmic marketing, as I like to call it,
29:37 Speaker 02 Yes.
29:39 Speaker 01 succeeds.
29:39 Speaker 02 Continues to work.
29:40 Speaker 01 You just do, you do the right thing for people, and the right thing gets done for you. We've, I mean, we at Vestry and now at Appella are very successful, and we're successful by doing the right thing.
29:55 Speaker 01 Now, could we be
29:55 Speaker 02 Try that, American business.
29:56 Speaker 01 Could we be far richer if we sold index annuities?
30:00 Speaker 02 Ah, yes.
30:00 Speaker 01 Yeah. Would I sleep as well? Nah, even though my Apple Watch doesn't, says I sleep terribly, but I, I feel like I sleep fine. So what, what does it know? Anyway, you got questions for us? We love answering them on our podcast. You can do it in a, in a number of different ways. You can go to talkingrealmoney.com and type your question at the, at the ask a question button. You can record it with your microphone like this. You can use your phone and dial 855-935-8255 and ask a question. Any of those ways, we're going to get you on the, the podcast and we're going to try and help you do that thing that you really need to do, that it's hard to do and that's manage
30:43 Speaker 01 your money better because here's what we do. We spend all of these shows talking real money.
30:52 Speaker 03 The opinions and views expressed on this podcast were current on the date recorded. Opinions, estimates, forecasts and statements of financial market trends that are based on current market conditions constitute our judgment and are subject to change without notice, including any forward-looking estimates or statements which are based on certain expectations and assumptions. Although information and opinions given have been obtained from or based on sources believed to be reliable, no warranty or representation is made as to their correctness, completeness, or accuracy. Information presented on the podcast is not personalized investment advice from Appella Wealth. The views and strategies described may not be suitable for everyone. This podcast does not identify all the risks, direct or indirect, or other considerations which might be material to you when entering any financial transaction. Past performance does not guarantee future results and profitable results cannot be guaranteed. We hope you realize that the information provided on Talking Real Money
31:34 Speaker 03 is for informational, educational, and hopefully enjoyable purposes only. The podcast is not trying to get you to buy or sell any financial products or securities. Instead, the program is provided as a public service by Appella Wealth, a fee-only registered investment advisor. Please see Appella Wealth ADV Part 2A on our website for information regarding Appella's fees and services. Appella Capital LLC, DBA Appella Wealth, is an investment advisory firm registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission. The firm only transacts business in the states where it is properly registered or excluded or exempt from registration requirements. Registration with the SEC or any state securities authority does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Appella does not provide tax or legal advice and nothing either stated or implied here should be inferred as providing such advice. Thanks for listening and please visit TalkingRealMoney.com for more information
32:18 Speaker 03 and important disclosure related to performance of any specific index or fund quoted in this podcast. And the lawyers get richer.
Previous War vs. Markets Next Flood of Questions Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated