Pod Insights Table Manners with Jessie and Lennie Ware Jonathan Groff About this episode This week for our NYC series we have the star of stage and screen, Broadway legend - and newly Tony nominated - Jonathan Groff joining us! Fresh from opening night of his brand new - and already 6 time Tony nominated - show Just In Time, Jonathan joined us at The Standard High Line for lunch. We heard all about what it’s like playing the iconic Bobby Darin and how the play came to be. We also talked about Jonathan growing up on a farm in Pennsylvania, figuring out his sexuality, working as a waiter in NYC, audition rejections, Frozen 3, and his deep love of Beyoncé. Just In Time has just opened at the Circle In The Square Theatre in NYC, and you don’t want to miss seeing him shine! Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript 11,020 words · 12 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 A rug shouldn't just fit your room. It should make your home feel finished. Ernesta creates designer-quality rugs, custom-fit to the exact size of your space, so every room feels beautifully pulled together. Explore Ernesta's range of options, all ready to be custom-cut, finished, and delivered to your door in as little as two weeks. Start with five samples for just $10 and get $50 toward your rug when you order. Visit ernesta.com today. That's E-R-N-E-S-T-A dot com.
0:31 Speaker 01 When you're running a growing business, the right systems can unlock your full sales potential and make fulfilling every order effortless. Switch to ShipStation before peak season so you're prepped and ready before the rush hits. ShipStation connects Shopify, Amazon, TikTok Shop, and over 200 more marketplaces with one platform that does it all. You can manage orders, sync inventory, track returns, all automatically. Everything your operation needs, all in one place. Upgrade your shipping operations to stress-proof your biggest sales days and capture every bit of potential revenue. Go to shipstation.com and use code AUDIO and get 30 days free.
1:01 Speaker 00 Confidence. It's listening to your gut. It's moving forward even when the path ahead is unclear. For nearly 160 years, Pacific Life has helped people keep their promises, building confidence for generations. Whether you're confident in your financial future or just beginning to envision it, we're here to help. Ask a financial professional how. Pacific Life: The Power of a Promise. Pacific Life Insurance Company, Omaha, Nebraska, and in New York. Pacific Life and Annuity, Phoenix, Arizona.
1:35 Speaker 02 Most AI knows data. Toast IQ knows restaurants. It helps turn Detroit 75's numbers, plus what works across thousands of restaurants, into insights we can actually use. That's AI that's worked a double without a lunch break. Visit toastapp.com to learn more. Pay testimonial from an actual Toast customer.
1:59 Jessie Ware? Hello and welcome to Table Manners. I'm Jessie Ware and I'm here with Mum. And we are in a suite today at the Standard High Line.
2:05 Speaker 04 And it's very sweet.
2:06 Jessie Ware? It's got a round bed.
2:07 Speaker 04 It's got a round bathtub.
2:09 Jessie Ware? Yeah. It's got a round dinner table.
2:11 Speaker 04 Around everything, darling.
2:13 Jessie Ware? Um, we've got the view of the Statue of Liberty right out there on another sunny day in New York.
2:17 Speaker 04 The windows in every room are enormous. So you have the best view of the city I've ever seen. The skyline is just magnificent.
2:27 Jessie Ware? I'm so excited to be in New York again.
2:29 Speaker 04 Yeah, the cosmopolitans are better here. There's a lot of dogs. The blossom is out.
2:35 Jessie Ware? Yeah, the blossom is killing me.
2:36 Speaker 04 And the weather is gorgeous.
2:37 Jessie Ware? It's been fabulous.
2:38 Speaker 04 It's been the best. And also, we went last night to something really fantastic.
2:43 Jessie Ware? Well, the guest that we have on today is our friend Jonathan Groff, who we went to see his opening night last night.
2:50 Speaker 04 Just in time.
2:51 Jessie Ware? He's playing Bobby Darin. Bobby Darin, if you don't know who Bobby Darin is, he was a very famous... Yeah, but like, a lot of people...
3:00 Speaker 04 Well, they need to mug up on their bloody American history.
3:04 Jessie Ware? Listen, Jake Cohen is in the room because he's helped us with letting us use his kitchen today and also done the suite. So Jake, come on the mic for a second. Have you heard of Bobby Darin?
3:14 Speaker 05 I have no idea.
3:15 Jessie Ware? Exactly. But you'd know, "Dream lover..."
3:19 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
3:20 Jessie Ware? Not Mariah.
3:21 Speaker 04 "Mac the Knife."
3:22 Jessie Ware? "Splish splash, I was taking a bet." No, "Mac the Knife"? Somewhere...
3:29 Speaker 05 Yes, of course, of course, of course.
3:31 Jessie Ware? Okay, so he was like a crooner?
3:33 Speaker 04 Oh, the shark has...
3:35 Speaker 05 You got me on that one song.
3:36 Jessie Ware? Okay, fine.
3:37 Speaker 05 I'll take, I'll take the L on the rest.
3:39 Jessie Ware? So Jonathan Groff plays Bobby Darin. He's absolutely fantastic in it.
3:42 Speaker 04 Who was an amazing crooner, sang jazz classics and really was famous by the time he was 20.
3:50 Jessie Ware? But died very, very early.
3:52 Speaker 04 April 37.
3:54 Jessie Ware? But let's talk about the menu whilst you're here. Thank you very much for providing your kitchen, but also a delicious suite. So for savoury, we've done the Zuni Cafe, which probably feels quite blasphemous because we're in New York and it's a kind of, it's synonymous with San Francisco. Zuni Cafe.
4:11 Speaker 05 God forbid you do a Waldorf salad.
4:14 Speaker 04 God forbid.
4:16 Jessie Ware? God, that would have been a good idea. Um, so I've done the roast chicken and bread salad with currants and.
4:24 Speaker 04 Pine nuts.
4:25 Jessie Ware? Pine nuts and spring onions and it's delicious. It smells really good. And then you've done.
4:30 Speaker 05 A very simple pudding.
4:32 Jessie Ware? We appreciate.
4:32 Speaker 05 If you can even call it pudding, I love it. I just, anytime I'm around you, everything is pudding. These are really fun. It's just you stuff dates with halva and then cover them with dark chocolate and flaky sea salt.
4:44 Jessie Ware? Delicious.
4:44 Speaker 04 Oh my goodness.
4:45 Speaker 05 Little sweet, little salty, little nutty.
4:48 Jessie Ware? Do you keep them in the freezer?
4:49 Speaker 05 I keep them in the fridge.
4:51 Jessie Ware? Okay.
4:51 Speaker 05 Freezer, Lenny will definitely lose a tooth if we keep, if we freeze.
4:55 Speaker 04 My veneers darling, you're considering my veneers.
4:58 Speaker 05 Yes. No, the fridge is perfect.
4:59 Jessie Ware? See, I've done, I've done dates with peanut butter, but the halva is really, that feels slightly more luxurious.
5:05 Speaker 05 A little bit.
5:05 Speaker 04 Did you make it into a paste?
5:07 Speaker 05 No, I just crumble it and just like shove it in. There you go.
5:11 Speaker 04 As the actress said to the bishop.
5:13 Speaker 05 That's my other, those are my two things that I've taken away from the two of you this week. It's like, everything is pudding and what the.
5:20 Speaker 04 Actress said to the bishop.
5:21 Speaker 05 Actress said to the bishop.
5:23 Jessie Ware? It's kind of, that's what she said.
5:24 Speaker 05 I know, I know, I'm obsessed.
5:25 Speaker 04 It's gonna be on my tombstone.
5:26 Jessie Ware? Do you think, do you think you'll be using as the actress said to the bishop at the clubs this weekend?
5:30 Speaker 05 Yes, with a fake British accent.
5:32 Jessie Ware? Okay, fine.
5:34 Jessie Ware? Thank you for, for your services today.
5:36 Speaker 04 Thank you for everything.
5:38 Jessie Ware? So for people that don't know who Jonathan Druoff is, well, how dare you, but he is probably one of the, the most beloved Broadway stars. You may have heard his voice in Frozen, cause he plays Kristoff in Frozen. He also was in the first cast of Spring Awakening. He was also in Glee. He's been in every kind of, very important musical.
5:59 Speaker 04 Theatre.
6:00 Jessie Ware? Theatre moment in the past decade. Hamilton, he played King George.
6:06 Speaker 04 Merrily we roll along.
6:06 Jessie Ware? Merrily we roll along. He won his first Tony.
6:09 Speaker 04 I first heard of him because your sister had an incestuous relationship with him when he played her brother in the TV series Boss.
6:17 Jessie Ware? Yes.
6:18 Speaker 04 And she said, I'd met this adorable, wonderful actor, Jonathan. And then you got to know him and he then used your song in Looking.
6:30 Jessie Ware? Yeah, we became friends. I think my record, first record hadn't even come out. So we've been friends for about 15 years, I think. It's just mad. And he's just a fabulous human being. He's gorgeous, he's brilliant, he's so talented. And I can't actually believe he's coming over after his opening night to come on Table manners. But here we are, Jonathan Groff coming up on Table manners.
7:04 Jessie Ware? Cheers.
7:05 Speaker 06 Cheers.
7:05 Jessie Ware? Jonathan Groff on Table manners, finally.
7:07 Speaker 06 Cheers, I'm so excited to be here.
7:10 Jessie Ware? You're the hardest guy to get, Jonathan.
7:12 Speaker 06 Oh, come.
7:12 Jessie Ware? You are. You're always on the stage, winning Tonys and shit. Yeah, congratulations.
7:18 Speaker 06 I'm always in the theatre.
7:18 Jessie Ware? You are, darling.
7:19 Speaker 04 Can we just say, last night.
7:21 Speaker 06 Oh.
7:22 Jessie Ware? That was fantastic.
7:24 Speaker 04 It was breathtaking.
7:25 Speaker 06 Thank you so much. It was so, I spotted you, top of act two, dream lover. I'm looking for my dream lover and then I was like, there they are. And you gave me the cutest, like.
7:37 Jessie Ware? Yeah, it was a little peck.
7:38 Speaker 06 It was a little peck. It was really cute.
7:40 Jessie Ware? Okay, good, fine, good.
7:42 Speaker 06 You were sitting really close.
7:44 Speaker 04 I know, so close.
7:45 Speaker 06 Whoa.
7:46 Speaker 04 We're doing all the clapping.
7:47 Jessie Ware? Sadly, I didn't get any spit, though.
7:49 Speaker 06 You didn't.
7:51 Jessie Ware? I'm sick about that.
7:52 Speaker 06 Listen, we've got all morning, I could spit.
7:57 Speaker 06 We're in this hotel room.
7:58 Jessie Ware? How, how are you?
8:01 Jessie Ware? This was an opening night last night.
8:02 Speaker 06 Last night, yeah.
8:03 Jessie Ware? It was fantastic, just in time. You're playing Bobby Darin.
8:06 Speaker 06 Yes.
8:06 Jessie Ware? You are so fantastic in the role.
8:10 Speaker 06 Thank you.
8:11 Jessie Ware? But it's also, it's like a night with Jonathan Groff and Bobby Darin.
8:15 Speaker 04 Yeah, it is.
8:16 Jessie Ware? It's in the basement of Wicked, which is so bonkers to me.
8:20 Speaker 04 Beautiful theatre, though.
8:22 Jessie Ware? But you've made it like the Copa.
8:23 Speaker 06 Theatre, the circle and the square, yeah. This, we, we've been developing this show for eight years. So how am I feeling? It's like, it's eight years in the making.
8:31 Jessie Ware? Right.
8:32 Speaker 06 Like, a couple hours before we, we started last night, I was just like weeping.
8:37 Jessie Ware? Really?
8:38 Speaker 06 I was like openly weeping, like, at, like, at one point, I was just standing in the centre of the dressing room, about a half an hour before the show, and my door is open and I was just like. And David, one of our stage runners, was like, are you just in here crying? I was like, yeah, it's like, this is, this is eight years of wishing and wanting and working and trying to make this happen. And this conceit, because I was asked to do this night of Bobby Darin music at the 92nd Street Y here in Manhattan.
9:07 Jessie Ware? Right.
9:08 Speaker 06 And this amazing director, Alex Timbers, came on to direct it. And we were reading about Bobby Darin and Oscar nominated actor Grammy.
9:17 Jessie Ware? What was he Oscar nominated for?
9:19 Speaker 06 Captain Newman M.D.
9:20 Jessie Ware? Was this the one where he was in with Sandra Day?
9:23 Speaker 06 No, that was, that was come September, which was his like, sort of first, first movie. But he, he was like, he actually wanted to be an actor first before a singer. But he was, won Grammys and, and music producer, like prolific career, but by all accounts, his magic, he was at the height of his powers at the center of a nightclub floor. And he was best known for this relationship with the audience. Sammy Davis Jr. famously said, the only person I won't follow is Bobby Darin.
9:53 Jessie Ware? Wow.
9:53 Speaker 06 Because, partially because of this electricity he had with the audience. So eight years ago, we're reading all this stuff about him and I offered up, I'd love it if I could start the show as myself.
10:03 Jessie Ware? Yeah.
10:04 Speaker 06 Because even if I'm playing the character of Bobby Darin, there's like the artifice of character between me and the audience. If I could start as myself and create that, connect that like, um, thread between us.
10:18 Jessie Ware? It's an intimacy as well, yeah.
10:19 Speaker 06 There's intimacy, yeah. Start with that and then we can collectively go back and experience the story of Bobby Darin together. Could we do that? And, and then we brought on these amazing writers, Warren Light and my dear friend, Isaac Oliver, and they like cracked it. They found a way to write me as me and then transition us into Bobby Darin. And so it ends up being kind of this like. Super intimate experience between the performers and the audience.
10:47 Jessie Ware? And I thought it was really beautiful how at the beginning, you are Jonathan Groff. You you talk about it, you you you take us into the world of Bobby. But at the end, it's like you and Bobby are the same person.
10:57 Speaker 04 Yeah.
10:57 Speaker 06 Wow.
10:57 Jessie Ware? When you when you speak at the end and you say, you know, this is a gift and like and you're on. You were right by your dad at this point when you said this line. I don't I can't remember the line.
11:06 Speaker 04 I'm gonna cry now.
11:07 Jessie Ware? And it was so powerful and you could just see how much joy you were having as Jonathan, but also it was it was beautiful.
11:15 Speaker 04 We we a lot of us were crying.
11:17 Speaker 06 Oh, my god.
11:18 Speaker 04 I was crying in the audience.
11:19 Jessie Ware? It was really beautiful.
11:20 Speaker 04 And people, when we went to the bathroom at halftime, people say I cried right the way through it. It was one of the.
11:26 Speaker 06 I love that you call it halftime because that's what my dad calls it too. It's like a sports thing. Yeah.
11:30 Jessie Ware? It's a really special show and I don't want to reduce it. It feels like by reducing it to calling it a jukebox musical, which I don't know why that's the.
11:38 Speaker 04 Why do they call it that?
11:39 Jessie Ware? Because it's songs. Were there any original songs in there?
11:43 Speaker 06 So he wrote like half of those songs, Bobby Darin did, like he wrote Dream Lover. He wrote Splish Splash. He wrote Things. He wrote Rainin. So it's and and he wrote Eighteen Yellow Roses about sending Sandra Dee's mother and then Sandra Dee Eighteen. So weirdly, it's like in some ways, as we were through the years developing, we were like, wow, it's like he. He was writing such autobiographical material. And it's partially why it doesn't just feel like a jukebox musical. Because they are the hits of his career and of his life. But they also were coming from his soul and they were coming from his life story. And he was such a kind of an enigmatic performer.
12:23 Speaker 06 So there's like this energy about him and his life that it is it is a biomusical and we're using the hits of his life. But there is something about his artistry that that connects all of those dots in a really unique, specific way.
12:36 Jessie Ware? Yeah. So your parents were sitting behind us.
12:39 Speaker 06 Oh, my god.
12:39 Jessie Ware? And they were so proud. I asked your mom if she could sing.
12:44 Speaker 06 What did she say?
12:45 Jessie Ware? She said, well, not like that.
12:47 Speaker 04 Not like that.
12:48 Speaker 06 Oh, interesting answer, Jules.
12:49 Speaker 04 Your dad, your dad didn't confirm that he could sing.
12:53 Speaker 06 No, he famously says like, I don't sing. His dad, my grandfather, who died on my 10th birthday, was a Mennonite preacher and wanted to be an opera singer, but had to do the dairy farmer thing. But he would like shake the rafters in the church.
13:08 Jessie Ware? That's so interesting. My grandfather was a synagogue. And never got to really do it.
13:13 Speaker 04 Because they wanted him to be an opera singer.
13:16 Speaker 06 No way. There's that interesting thing of like religion and performance and like Jesus versus Judy kind of energy of like, are you?
13:27 Jessie Ware? Jesus versus Judy.
13:27 Speaker 06 That's Sherri Renee Scott, who's half Mennonite. She's a Broadway performer. And in her one woman show, she was like, growing up, it was always like Jesus versus Judy. Like, I wanted to be a performer, but I was also told to be humble and not step out of, you know, to like not be front and center.
13:44 Jessie Ware? Can we talk about the dinner table? Growing up?
13:47 Speaker 06 Yeah.
13:48 Jessie Ware? Pennsylvania?
13:49 Speaker 06 Lancaster, Pennsylvania.
13:50 Speaker 04 Were you on a farm?
13:52 Speaker 06 Sort of, yeah. So, so like, the house that I grew up in is surrounded by cornfields. So it's all Amish farms around us.
14:01 Speaker 04 You're kidding?
14:02 Speaker 06 Yeah, like horse and buggy, no electricity. I mean, we had electricity, but it's like, the, you know, videos of my brother and I like running through the cornfields. And there was our, our house in the middle of those cornfields. And then my dad trained and raised his horses for a living. And so he had a horse farm like 20 minutes from where our home was that we would like play on as kids.
14:25 Speaker 04 How many horses?
14:27 Speaker 06 Well, he, so he had like, I mean, at the height of his like career, it would be like 50 horses on this horse farm. Now it's four. He's 72, he's still training the horses and going to the races. And my dream is to turn his horse farm into an artist retreat. And I'm gonna build a house on his horse farm this year. And I want to turn the barns into creative spaces. Because growing up there as a kid, that's where we put on like The Wizard of Oz when I was four and I was Dorothy and my brother was the Tin Man. And every time I go home, I feel that fertile, creative. And there's something about the Amish farmland because it's like,
15:08 Speaker 06 Impeccable, the cornfields and the tobacco fields, it's like, really like beautiful. And it's like honoring nature, but it's also the respectful touch of the human hand. And they, it's like tractors, but it's like, it's like, it's like with horses, horse drawn. It's old fashioned, yeah, there's something really kind of primal and, and like, like fertile about the land there that makes me feel really creative.
15:34 Speaker 04 Did you live off the land then?
15:36 Speaker 06 Not at all, no, yeah, we were like, I was also scared of the horses.
15:40 Speaker 04 Oh, so you do not ride?
15:41 Speaker 06 I, I learned how to ride for a movie. And I invited my dad to the set, the day that I was riding the horse, because I was so proud. But like, growing up, you know, we were like shoveling the horse shit out of the stalls. And I was scared the horses were gonna kick me and, and our mom like put the fear of God in us about getting hurt by the horses. And when you're scared of horses, they get, you know, they're really sensitive. I love them from afar, but I'm not.
16:06 Speaker 04 But did your dad wear like a cowboy outfit and chaps and things?
16:11 Speaker 04 I just wonder. Because of, no, because of his riding horses and training them.
16:18 Jessie Ware? Why does he need to wear chaps?
16:19 Speaker 04 Because I thought they did, when they were riding on horses with saddles.
16:23 Speaker 06 They do, no, you're right, like cowboys, they do.
16:26 Jessie Ware? We wear jockers.
16:28 Speaker 04 It's not just on OnlyFans, Jesse.
16:33 Jessie Ware? Lenny.
16:36 Speaker 06 Lenny.
16:38 Jessie Ware? Honestly, every, every gay man wants Lenny to live with him in New York City.
16:43 Speaker 06 I believe that.
16:44 Jessie Ware? It's like, Jake Owen's like, don't worry, Lenny's staying with us next time.
16:47 Speaker 04 So did he wear a cowboy hat?
16:49 Speaker 06 So, so I'm, I'm, I'm not describing it well enough, because it's like, he trained and races horses, but it's harness racing. So it's, he's not on the back of the horse, he's in the cart behind the horse. So he had an outfit, like a jockey outfit, that was like a onesie, like a onesie. But not, like, he's not on a saddle on the, on the, riding a horse in that way.
17:14 Speaker 04 So he was training the horses to do this kind of chariot kind of cart racing?
17:19 Speaker 06 Exactly, exactly, which they still do.
17:21 Jessie Ware? That's quite niche.
17:23 Speaker 04 But where do they do this racing?
17:26 Speaker 06 It is quite niche.
17:28 Speaker 04 Why are they doing this?
17:29 Speaker 06 I know, in New Jersey.
17:31 Jessie Ware? Gladiator just came out, so like, they did it in that maybe, did they?
17:35 Speaker 06 I know, it's a really niche and, and with the onslaught of off-track betting and, uh, what is this called?
17:43 Speaker 04 Oh, so you bet on it?
17:43 Jessie Ware? You bet?
17:44 Speaker 06 Oh, yeah.
17:45 Speaker 04 Oh, wow.
17:46 Speaker 06 This was complex.
17:47 Jessie Ware? Okay, now I'm in.
17:48 Speaker 06 Yeah, yeah, right?
17:49 Jessie Ware? Yeah.
17:49 Speaker 06 And this was complex for my dad because he grew up Mennonite and with the father who's a Mennonite preacher.
17:54 Jessie Ware? Can you explain what Mennonite is?
17:56 Speaker 06 Mennonite is like watered-down Amish.
17:58 Jessie Ware? Okay, got it.
17:59 Speaker 04 Crikey.
18:00 Speaker 06 I know, yeah, so they can ride, they can drive cars. It's almost like Footloose, where like, there's no, it's a kind of religious and there's no dancing and you wear kind of plain clothes. My grandmother had a little covering.
18:12 Speaker 04 Do you celebrate birthdays and things?
18:14 Speaker 06 You celebrate birthdays, but it's like...
18:16 Speaker 04 Christmas?
18:18 Speaker 06 You celebrate Christmas, but it's like, it's more religious-focused and, and very humble, like kind of farm-humble, you know, no one, it's like, it's, it's just like, um, kind of basic.
18:31 Jessie Ware? So, growing up gay?
18:33 Speaker 06 Yeah.
18:34 Jessie Ware? Was that a conflict within your world of, yeah, your community?
18:39 Speaker 06 Yeah, it's interesting. So my, so my dad was Mennonite, my mom grew up Methodist. When my, so my dad was supposed to take over the dairy farm and be, and like do the cows, but he didn't like cows and his, his passion became horses, which was then horse racing, which is betting and gambling, which is not so like, accepted in the Mennonite church. So he married my mom and then he started going to the Methodist church, which is what I was raised in, which is more kind of like, it's a little less, little less like conservative.
19:11 Jessie Ware? Right.
19:12 Speaker 06 Um, a little looser, but still like...
19:14 Speaker 04 Still quite conservative, yeah.
19:16 Speaker 06 But still religious, yeah. And I remember being 10 years old and the, with the preacher talking about like, gay being wrong and all of that. And my, my parents never said like, being gay is wrong. We never really talked about it, but it was always in the air. Obviously, there was in church, they were talking about it and... It was just the culture, like it wasn't until Will and Grace came out. That I started to see like, oh, wow, okay, maybe there, maybe there's. That was a huge sort of like touchstone for me, or when I started doing community theater in Pennsylvania. And started meeting gay people, I started to understand like, oh, you can be gay and be happy.
19:59 Speaker 06 And not, and not die of AIDS. It was like gay, gay meant like to, to me, growing up. Wrong, and it meant like death, and it meant it's like something to be afraid of. But in a, and I didn't come out until I was twenty three. And I, I didn't really, I had no sex during high school. I was sort of asexual. I wasn't, I didn't have girlfriends. But I was just really into theater.
20:29 Speaker 06 And very focused on my, my craft of acting. And then I moved to New York and I had my first boyfriend who was my roommate. And we were together for three and a half years in the closet, the whole time, all during Spring Awakening. Even though I was in New York and surrounded by people that were out and. Still, I wasn't quite ready and it wasn't until I. Left Spring Awakening that I came out to my parents and. My friends and then started living my life, but it took a while to kind of.
21:02 Speaker 06 Come to terms with it and it really wasn't until Looking, actually. That I was working on that show and living in San Francisco that I really felt that I. Fully started to embrace who I was. When I came out when I was twenty three. I was like, okay, I, I'm gonna come out. But I still feel a lot of shame and I still wish that I wasn't gay. Still wish like if I could change this, I would. But at this point, I know that I can't, so I'm gonna come out because. It feels insane to be twenty three years old and hiding who I am, so I, I came out, but. It wasn't until I was in my late twenties that I really started to love that part of myself.
21:39 Jessie Ware? So, so you have this kind of, this pull for New York. You moved to New York quite young, don't you? And Will and Grace, New York, all of this. But then you still have this affinity with Pennsylvania.
21:52 Speaker 06 Yeah.
21:52 Jessie Ware? Because you, what do you love about your memories of childhood and particularly around food? You know, because obviously you haven't completely shunned that world. You love it and you're nostalgic for it and all of that and inspired by it.
22:06 Speaker 06 It's such an interesting thing because I feel like I, there's like videos of like my parents. My mom let me dress up as Mary Poppins when I was three years old for Halloween. And there's a video of me with like lipstick and a carpet bag that, you know, my mom obviously helped facilitate. This three year old being in full kind of impeccable drag on my grandparents' Mennonite farmhouse. She drove me over there before we went trick or treating and Wade, my grandfather's going, oh, Mary. Mary. And I'm there like, and he doesn't understand how funny it is, Mary, and I'm going to be gay.
22:48 Speaker 06 I feel like if they had thought in any way, there was like just this beautiful kind of like ignorance that they had, that my, that my parents had of like.
22:58 Speaker 04 Or innocence.
22:59 Speaker 06 Innocence.
23:00 Speaker 04 Yeah.
23:00 Speaker 06 Innocence, exactly. Thank you. That's like a, that's a more generous way of putting it. It's like, this is just what Jonathan wants to do, so we're going to do it. They weren't, it would never have occurred to them that this was going to be a reflection of my sexuality in any way whatsoever. So there was this freedom that I had. If they had, if my, if my mom, if someone had told her like, he's going to be gay. This will like be a pathway to that. She might not have, because that homophobia and that racism and all of that is very just embedded in the culture there. It's a very kind of, you know, conservative area. There's not a lot of outside people in the place where they live.
23:42 Speaker 06 It's just sort of like innocent, an innocent pocket of Pennsylvania. And so I sort of, so what I love about Pennsylvania is, is my first memories are like.
23:55 Speaker 06 Oxygen of freedom and creativity and being Dorothy in my dad's barn and like all of that when I go home, I still feel that. And then right next to that, I also feel the I see the Trump flags and all of the kind of like staunch conservatism and the and the homophobia and the racism and the and they're both they're both sitting there. And I think part of part of me needed to leave and come to New York. Yeah, like on the surface, it was because I wanted to come here to to make a dream come true. And this is this is what I wanted to do. And I love it here. And I feel very at home here.
24:37 Speaker 04 Is this your home?
24:39 Speaker 06 Yes.
24:39 Speaker 04 More than LA?
24:41 Speaker 06 Oh, yeah, I don't live in LA.
24:42 Speaker 04 Ever?
24:43 Speaker 06 Ever. I was there like for five years or so. But but no, yeah, New York is my home and also Pennsylvania. I I in 2019, I went back and bought a house in Pennsylvania because I I felt like once I came here and I sort of was able to become who I was, then I felt like I was ready to go back home and be who I was there. Could I be who I was there?
25:08 Speaker 04 And can you?
25:11 Speaker 06 It's not easy.
25:12 Speaker 04 Mm hmm.
25:13 Speaker 06 But yes, and it takes a lot of presence of mind to go home with love and acceptance. Like, for example, in in March of last year, there was a drag queen story hour in our local library in Lancaster that got bomb threats and they had to cancel it. And my friends that still live there reached out to me and they were like, Jonathan, this fucked up thing is happening. And I was doing merrily. We roll along at the time. But I made a date in the autumn in September of of last year to go there and host the drag queen story hour to like read to like make it happen there. And so we did the drag queen story hour and then we did a pride event that night.
25:59 Speaker 06 Hundreds of people at this pride event. And these like drag queens that live in Lancaster. And this, this trans couple that have been married for 25 years. And this trans woman has just transitioned and came out five years ago and they live in Lancaster. And I'm meeting all of these incredible people in this conservative town that I didn't know they were there when I was there. And it's so cool to go back now and find my tribe there. And, and still be there with my family. And so it's been a really fascinating, like,
26:39 Speaker 06 five or so years of integrating back and trying to like, reach back in a way and, and redefine what that area means to us. Part of why I went to make that artist retreat on my dad's farm is to, is to bring that energy. Cause I was kind of afraid to go back. But then I realized, no, I, I belong here too. And it's actually essential that I go back and I stick my pride flag in the cornfields of Pennsylvania. But it's, it's heated. It's also heated.
27:13 Jessie Ware? Can you tell us about a memorable dish from your childhood?
27:17 Speaker 06 Yes, okay.
27:18 Jessie Ware? So it's you and your brother, your mom and your dad. Who was cooking?
27:22 Speaker 06 So it's the pumpkin pie. Uh, the pumpkin pie, yeah. My mom's, as I salivate as I think about it.
27:29 Jessie Ware? Are you hungry now?
27:30 Speaker 06 I'm always hungry.
27:31 Jessie Ware? Okay, great.
27:31 Speaker 06 This is the other thing. It is?
27:33 Jessie Ware? Yeah, this is the podcast.
27:34 Speaker 06 Yeah, great. Okay, amazing.
27:35 Jessie Ware? Right. Oh, it's here?
27:37 Speaker 06 Oh my god, you just made it.
27:39 Jessie Ware? Oh my, we're not just having fries, but that is a great.
27:41 Speaker 06 But that's a great.
27:42 Jessie Ware? Thank you, my darling. Whilst you talk about your memorable dish, I'm gonna fix the salad and you can shove a fry in your mouth.
27:49 Speaker 06 Oh my god, okay, great. Look at that mountain of fries.
27:51 Speaker 04 I know. So does your mom make pumpkin pie just for Thanksgiving or on special occasions?
27:58 Speaker 06 Literally salivating as you're saying it. Yes, she does. It's, it's always for Thanksgiving. And then occasionally for, also for Christmas, but it's always for Thanksgiving. And it's her, the secret to her pumpkin pie is that she uses squash.
28:14 Speaker 04 Not pumpkin.
28:15 Speaker 06 Not pumpkin.
28:16 Speaker 04 Yeah.
28:16 Speaker 06 So it's like a squash pumpkin pie. And it's got a kind of, kind of like thick consistency. It's like, it's like, and not in any way mushy. There's like a, it's like a solid. It's almost like a, like a cheesecake, like a really thick cheesecake level of solidness.
28:36 Speaker 04 But you'd have pumpkin pie with your savory or with your dessert?
28:40 Speaker 06 That's the dessert, yeah.
28:41 Speaker 04 Oh, it's as a dessert.
28:41 Speaker 06 It's the dessert.
28:42 Speaker 04 Does she put marshmallows or anything?
28:44 Speaker 06 So she puts the, like, she brings out the Cool Whip. It's so basic, but she has Cool Whip. Cool Whip, but I, I never have it with the Cool Whip because I like just the pumpkin pie itself. It's a homemade crust.
28:56 Speaker 04 Yeah.
28:57 Speaker 06 With the pumpkin pie. And then everyone else is usually like putting, like, spreading Cool Whip on top and that's all.
29:02 Speaker 04 Is that a neutral flavor or do you have flavored Cool Whip?
29:07 Speaker 06 My god, the, the way that you.
29:08 Speaker 04 Is it white?
29:09 Speaker 06 The way that you say.
29:11 Speaker 04 I don't know what the.
29:11 Speaker 06 You don't know what Cool Whip is?
29:12 Speaker 04 No.
29:13 Speaker 06 Okay, oh yeah, I guess it's maybe like an American thing.
29:16 Speaker 04 Is it kind of like imitation cream?
29:19 Speaker 06 Yeah, yeah.
29:20 Speaker 04 So it's.
29:20 Speaker 06 Am I grossing you out right now?
29:22 Speaker 04 No, no, no, I kind of like.
29:23 Speaker 06 You know what it's like?
29:24 Speaker 04 That synthetic cake.
29:26 Speaker 06 Yes.
29:26 Speaker 04 The stuff they put on cake.
29:27 Speaker 06 Well, it's a, it's like a little bit more, it's a whipped whipped cream.
29:31 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
29:31 Speaker 06 Yeah, it's like a whipped cream.
29:32 Speaker 04 Is it slightly sweet?
29:34 Speaker 06 It is, yeah, yeah.
29:35 Speaker 04 So what would be Thanksgiving dinner? Turkey?
29:39 Speaker 06 Oh, yeah, okay.
29:41 Speaker 04 From a local farm?
29:42 Speaker 06 Yes, turkey, turkey from like the local grocery store.
29:46 Speaker 04 Corn-fed, obvi- obviously.
29:48 Speaker 06 Come on.
29:51 Speaker 04 Yelling.
29:51 Speaker 06 I'm corn-fed, you know what I'm saying?
29:53 Speaker 04 You're corn-fed darling, yeah, absolutely.
29:55 Speaker 06 Corn-fed boy. It would be the turkey that she's, that she's putting in the oven. It would be the mashed potatoes that she's making. She also does like a really intense applesauce that my dad does not like because she puts a lot of cinnamon in the applesauce.
30:11 Speaker 04 Lovely.
30:12 Speaker 06 Yeah, salvating again. And then my aunt will bring.
30:17 Speaker 06 This actually might be my, my favorite thing is um baked carrots with like so much cheese in the carrots and this like breadcrumb.
30:28 Jessie Ware? I never thought of doing that with carrots.
30:31 Speaker 06 Oh my god, it's so good.
30:32 Jessie Ware? Is it delicious?
30:33 Speaker 06 It's so good. It's like a cream and a cheese mixed with like uh the carrots that are like chopped up like this. And then there's, and then there's like the bread, like the bread, you know, like on sometimes on mac and cheese. It's almost like mac and cheese, but with carrots.
30:48 Jessie Ware? How fabulous.
30:48 Speaker 06 Yeah, that one's really good. Look at this gorgeous plate of food.
30:52 Jessie Ware? Hey, listen.
30:53 Speaker 06 You've been slaving away.
30:54 Jessie Ware? It's, it's, it's, I, I would have liked a little bit more chicken juice on it, but it's a, it's the Zuni Ca- oh, like San Francisco, Zuni Cafe. Do you remember the Zuni Cafe? Did you ever go?
31:04 Speaker 06 Of course.
31:05 Jessie Ware? The chicken and bread salad. It's a recreation of that, which actually now I think about it was quite perfect for this. But you may break your veneers on the um. I won't. On the thing.
31:14 Speaker 06 Wait, that they do at the.
31:16 Jessie Ware? At the cafe, but I wanted more chicken juice.
31:19 Speaker 06 Who made this right now?
31:21 Jessie Ware? I did.
31:21 Speaker 06 You made this.
31:23 Jessie Ware? No, it's come from Upper East Side.
31:25 Speaker 06 You made this and brought this to this.
31:28 Jessie Ware? Yes, so it's not perfect, but it will kind of, it's the best we can do in a, in a, in a situation.
31:34 Speaker 06 I am completely blown away right now.
31:36 Jessie Ware? It may need some more dressing or it may need less.
31:38 Speaker 06 May I have your plate to, to give you some of this?
31:41 Jessie Ware? Just a little, thanks.
31:42 Speaker 06 I'll be mother. Isn't that a saying in England when you pour the milk into the tea? Can I get?
31:46 Jessie Ware? Is that, is that a thing? I'll be mother. I don't know. I've never heard that expression.
31:50 Speaker 06 Chelsea, where you, I know I'll be mother and you don't know I'll be mother?
31:53 Jessie Ware? I don't know I'll be mother.
31:57 Speaker 06 You don't know I'll be mother?
31:58 Jessie Ware? I know mother, but I don't know I'll be mother. That's pouring the tea, darling.
32:04 Jessie Ware? Oh my god, so many funny.
32:06 Speaker 06 I'll be mother. That's like, yeah, when you, when it's like, it's like a, I mean, I'm, I'm sort of like not using it in the correct way because I don't think it works for dish of food, but maybe it does.
32:23 Speaker 07 There are two types of business owners. Those who are busy and those who want to be busy. Toast is designed for both with tools to keep you humming and help turn grind into growth. That's how you turn busy into business. Toast, built for busy.
32:38 Speaker 00 Confidence. It's listening to your gut. It's moving forward even when the path ahead is unclear. For nearly 160 years, Pacific Life has helped people keep their promises, building confidence for generations. Whether you're confident in your financial future or just beginning to envision it, we're here to help. Ask a financial professional how. Pacific Life, the power of a promise. Pacific Life Insurance Company, Omaha, Nebraska, and in New York. Pacific Life and Annuity, Phoenix, Arizona. Standard-sized rugs shouldn't be the standard. Get a custom-sized rug that actually fits with Ernesta.
33:19 Speaker 00 In as little as two weeks, Ernesta cuts, finishes, and delivers your rug straight to your door. No more awkward sizing, just a designer-quality rug made to work within your space perfectly the first time. Visit ernesta.com to explore Ernesta's full range of custom-sized rugs and get $50 towards any style when you order five samples for only $10.
33:42 Speaker 08 Cash now, more later, from Open Door. Gives you cash upfront for your home, plus all the profit later. That's no chaos now, no cash left behind later. Skip the showings now, pocket extra profit later. This is so simple now, this is so awesome later. Or sell fast now and pop the champagne later. Cash now, more later. Now available nationwide.
34:04 Speaker 09 Start your offer at open door dot com slash ACAST. Profits calculated after fees and costs. Eligibility and offer price may vary.
34:17 Speaker 06 This is so good and it's so healthy.
34:20 Jessie Ware? Well, I thought about you with your voice because I'm so impressed because you were like, no dietary's and I'm like, he's on Broadway tonight, like, and here's you with an aperol. Your seconds will be the Negroni. You're the easiest customer.
34:35 Speaker 06 See if I make it to that, I'm hoping. I'm high homes.
34:38 Jessie Ware? Great, good. I'm glad. I'm sad for the audience tonight.
34:43 Speaker 04 I think this is a great recipe.
34:45 Jessie Ware? It is a great recipe, but I've done it before and there's a little bit more jus.
34:48 Speaker 06 Delicious.
34:49 Speaker 04 I don't hate this anymore, it'd be oiling.
34:53 Speaker 06 I agree. I'm not wanting more sauce.
34:55 Jessie Ware? So, we ask all our guests what their last supper would be.
35:00 Speaker 06 Yes, okay.
35:01 Jessie Ware? Start at main, pudding, drink.
35:04 Speaker 06 Okay, so the first thing that's coming up for me.
35:06 Jessie Ware? Yeah.
35:07 Speaker 06 I'm 19 years old.
35:08 Jessie Ware? I feel like I'm in therapy with you.
35:11 Speaker 06 I do too.
35:11 Jessie Ware? That felt very much, okay, great, I like this.
35:13 Speaker 06 I'm 19 years old, I'm waiting tables at the Chelsea Grill of Hell's Kitchen on 9th Avenue between 46th and 47th Street, and my staff meal, which you would get one for every shift.
35:28 Speaker 04 The family meal, did they call it?
35:29 Speaker 06 Yeah, exactly. You could pick whatever you wanted off the menu.
35:33 Jessie Ware? Oh, okay.
35:34 Speaker 06 And so I, yeah, it wasn't like they were making it and handing it out. It was like, you get to pick one thing, and I would eat the Penne Ale of vodka with chicken.
35:44 Speaker 04 Mmm, with chicken?
35:46 Speaker 06 I know, yeah.
35:47 Speaker 04 I've never had Penne Ale of vodka with chicken.
35:50 Jessie Ware? Was chicken on the side or?
35:51 Speaker 06 In it, like, mixed up in it.
35:53 Jessie Ware? Was it delicious? Obviously.
35:55 Speaker 06 There was something, it's my last supper and it's like, it's, you know, it's not even necessarily the, I think what it would bring back for me if I was eating it as my last supper is that feeling of like...
36:09 Speaker 06 Bone exhaustion of waiting tables and like that was all I ate all day. Where you're like, that's just, that's like the meal. And there was something about, I'm salivating as I think about the the like vodka sauce that was in this particular, the way that the chef would do it. It was just, it made me feel so comforted. In a time when you move to the city and you're like, what am I doing here? And the constant rejection of auditions and waiting tables and an array of like kind people and rude people and tipping and not tipping. And I would sit with that pasta and that chicken and it would like
36:53 Speaker 06 make me feel home or like comforted. There was like a great comfort in eating that meal. So that would be my last supper.
37:02 Jessie Ware? Did you get rejected a lot? I don't feel like, I don't believe this.
37:05 Speaker 06 Oh my god, oh yeah. Oh yeah. Hundreds of auditions. I would go to open calls. You know, I moved here when I was 19 and I would
37:15 Speaker 06 I would go, yeah, I would, sometimes I would go, cause like at the regional theaters, they'll do like days for dancers and then the next day it's a singer call and there's the callbacks. And some days I would, one day I would go to like the dancer call and I would get cut. And then I would call myself back to sing and go to the singer call for the same theater.
37:33 Jessie Ware? Me again.
37:33 Speaker 06 Yeah.
37:36 Jessie Ware? Did it ever work out?
37:37 Speaker 06 Uh, not, it didn't, it didn't work out a lot. And the, the job I got my equity card on, I waited for over two days to be seen for the show, Fame, Fame the Musical at North Shore Music Theater. I waited all day on Saturday. I waited all day on Sunday. And then at the very end, they were seeing people that weren't in the union. And I brought my trumpet, cause there was a character that played the trumpet and I played the trumpet when I was in middle school. And so I was like trying, you know, pounding the pavement, like they say, trying to get jobs.
38:08 Jessie Ware? And now you have things written for you and developed for you. Like just in time. How far you've come, girl.
38:15 Speaker 04 Yeah.
38:17 Speaker 06 Twenty years later.
38:18 Speaker 04 Are you still going to be Kristoff if they make another?
38:21 Speaker 06 I hope so.
38:21 Jessie Ware? Yeah, of course. Have you started doing the Frozen three?
38:25 Speaker 06 I've heard it's happening. They've announced it. They said it's happening.
38:28 Jessie Ware? Okay.
38:28 Speaker 06 But I haven't seen the script or I don't know anything about it yet. Jennifer Lee, who directed, co-directed and co-wrote Frozen one and two, is a dear friend. I set her up with her husband.
38:43 Jessie Ware? Well, then you have to be in the third.
38:45 Speaker 04 Of course you'll be in it.
38:46 Jessie Ware? That'd be, that would be very good, Lou. Yeah. That'd be very, yeah, well done, Jonathan.
38:52 Speaker 04 Very good.
38:53 Jessie Ware? Forget about the trumpet.
38:56 Speaker 04 Just match, mate.
38:57 Speaker 06 Forget about that. Yeah, that was my, that was my first of three marriages that I set up.
39:04 Jessie Ware? Oh. So you're single. But you're single.
39:09 Speaker 06 I'm so single.
39:10 Jessie Ware? What's going on then, Jonathan?
39:11 Speaker 04 Yeah, what is going on?
39:12 Speaker 06 I don't know. I don't know. It just hasn't worked out.
39:15 Speaker 04 The most gorgeous face and eyes.
39:16 Speaker 06 Oh, my God.
39:17 Speaker 04 Sit there on his own.
39:18 Speaker 06 That's so sweet of you to say that. It just hasn't worked out.
39:22 Jessie Ware? But you're fine.
39:23 Speaker 04 It will.
39:24 Speaker 06 I am, I'm, I, I, I enjoy being alone. I love being in love. But it just hasn't, it hasn't panned out.
39:33 Speaker 04 Yeah, but you've, it's not like you've never been in a relationship.
39:36 Speaker 06 No, no, I've had great relationships. Yeah. It's, yeah, it's just, it's one of those, it's just one of those things. I feel like timing is such a big part of relationships. And the last couple that I've sort of like had, it, there was something about it just like wasn't the right time.
39:58 Speaker 04 But you're also working every night because you're in the theatre.
40:01 Speaker 06 That's part of it, too.
40:02 Speaker 04 It's difficult, don't you think?
40:05 Speaker 06 I also really like.
40:08 Speaker 06 I love what I do so much.
40:10 Speaker 04 Yeah.
40:11 Speaker 06 And it's a huge.
40:12 Speaker 04 All consuming.
40:13 Speaker 06 Yeah, it's just a big passion.
40:15 Speaker 04 Yeah.
40:15 Speaker 06 And finding someone that understands that and can like exist with that with me has been challenging.
40:27 Speaker 04 It's tough.
40:27 Speaker 06 Yeah.
40:29 Speaker 04 And it was, it's going to be all lunch dates at the end, isn't it?
40:32 Speaker 06 That's exactly right.
40:34 Speaker 04 He's out every night.
40:35 Speaker 06 That's exactly right.
40:36 Speaker 04 Maybe you need to find some really good lunch spots, romantic lunch spot. Where are some of your lunch spots in New York?
40:46 Speaker 06 Oh, my God, great question.
40:51 Speaker 06 The, the, well, Westville is a chain in the city that I like, I'm such a basic, I'm such a basic queen.
40:59 Speaker 04 Okay.
41:00 Speaker 06 Westville is like a chain in New York that I often order from or go to lunch to. It's just sort of like basic protein, vegetables, whatever, healthy, clean eating. Since February, since the beginning of February, when we started rehearsal for Justin Time for the first time, I did a meal delivery service.
41:22 Speaker 04 Ah.
41:23 Speaker 06 So for the last three months, I've had breakfast, lunch and dinner.
41:26 Speaker 04 Delivered.
41:27 Speaker 06 Delivered in a little cardboard thing.
41:29 Speaker 04 I'm so sorry, Jonathan, so depressing. The meal's in a cardboard box.
41:34 Speaker 06 I know, it's, I'm, I'm.
41:36 Speaker 04 Have you got a good one, though?
41:37 Speaker 06 It's so good, yeah.
41:38 Speaker 04 Oh, that's all right, then.
41:39 Speaker 06 It's called Daily Dose, they like, it's, it tastes amazing.
41:42 Speaker 04 Daily Dose?
41:43 Speaker 06 Yeah, I also am such a like, basic person. I, I love a great meal, but I can eat anything.
41:52 Speaker 04 Anything.
41:53 Speaker 06 Rubbish, yeah, were you gonna say rubbish?
41:54 Speaker 04 No, but which, which protein would you have, which would be your?
41:58 Speaker 06 God, you are so cute.
41:59 Speaker 04 Do the protein thing, which I don't understand. Well, no, it's literally just chicken, fish or, you know, yeah. But which would be yours?
42:06 Speaker 06 Steak.
42:06 Speaker 04 Um. Steak.
42:08 Speaker 06 Oh, no, which would be mine?
42:10 Jessie Ware? Chicken, because you're lean and you're a gay man and you're on stage and you have to be in your bathrobe.
42:14 Speaker 06 And a vodka soda, just gay water and chicken.
42:18 Jessie Ware? We call it a skinny bitch.
42:19 Speaker 06 A skinny bitch.
42:20 Jessie Ware? Yeah, skinny bitch.
42:23 Speaker 06 I know, my drink is whiskey. That's like, that's the one, that's my like go to.
42:27 Jessie Ware? Oh, you're surprising me.
42:29 Speaker 06 Well, during the day, I mean, I'm kind of a garbage pale alcohol drinker. I will literally drink anything. During the day, it's more this.
42:36 Jessie Ware? Fine, gorgeous.
42:37 Speaker 06 In the evening, I'll go for a Negroni, but.
42:39 Jessie Ware? Sure. Lachim?
42:41 Speaker 06 Lachim, we opened the show.
42:42 Jessie Ware? What's your whiskey?
42:45 Speaker 06 Okay, so I'm, I am, I am very basic queen as well, and then I'm obsessed with Beyonce. I would say that Beyonce is my, I'm wearing a Beyonce shirt right now.
42:56 Jessie Ware? Is every gay man obsessed with Beyonce?
42:58 Speaker 06 Beyonce, yes. I would say that Beyonce is the closest thing to religion that I have for myself. I, I'm so deeply obsessed, so.
43:10 Jessie Ware? Have you met her?
43:11 Speaker 06 She came to see Hamilton.
43:14 Speaker 06 And it was.
43:15 Jessie Ware? What did you do? Did you meet her?
43:21 Jessie Ware? Did you freak out? Speak.
43:22 Speaker 06 I can't, I couldn't speak. I couldn't speak.
43:26 Speaker 06 Like, so many famous people came to see Hamilton.
43:28 Jessie Ware? And it was amazing.
43:30 Speaker 06 It was an amazing show. It was an amazing experience.
43:32 Jessie Ware? And you had this comedy role.
43:33 Speaker 06 Yes, yes.
43:35 Jessie Ware? It was not the main role, but you made every second. It was fantastic. You were King George.
43:40 Speaker 06 King George, yes.
43:41 Jessie Ware? Amazing.
43:42 Speaker 06 And the, like, famous people would come and it would be like, which ten, from the, from politics, from music, from film, from theater, it was like from every walk of the, of the, of every industry. It was like, all these people were coming to see Hamilton. And two times, and so after the show, it was like fifty people on stage, the whole cast and whatever. It was every single night. So many people. It was, it was so strange.
44:08 Jessie Ware? The hottest ticket.
44:09 Speaker 06 Yeah, it was crazy.
44:10 Jessie Ware? When you were performing, if you looked out, could you spot them?
44:13 Speaker 06 No.
44:14 Jessie Ware? Is that good?
44:15 Speaker 06 It was good for me, yeah. Yeah, the lights continued. Unlike just the time where I can, literally, I could see them.
44:21 Jessie Ware? Yeah.
44:21 Speaker 06 You like kissing me with your mouth, which was heaven. And now I'm learning to love all of that. Two times, two people came on stage and everyone was silent. And it was when Obama came to see Hamilton and was on stage and you could hear a pin drop. And when Beyonce and Jay-Z came to see Hamilton and they were on stage.
44:43 Jessie Ware? When you say onstage, it means after the show.
44:45 Speaker 06 After the show.
44:46 Jessie Ware? They come and meet you onstage.
44:47 Speaker 06 Exactly.
44:47 Jessie Ware? They didn't like do a number.
44:48 Speaker 06 Yeah, yeah, exactly.
44:49 Jessie Ware? Barack is coming and doing like.
44:51 Speaker 06 He's so fierce.
44:52 Jessie Ware? Not gonna do it. Fine, shut. Yeah, he's not gonna do that.
44:55 Speaker 06 That would be amazing.
44:56 Jessie Ware? Yeah, okay.
44:59 Speaker 06 And Beyonce was there and I was kind of hanging back, letting everybody talk to Beyonce.
45:05 Jessie Ware? That's chic of you.
45:06 Speaker 06 Well, you know, like you said, I'm in it for nine minutes, like the one, like the white guy from Hamilton is not who like Beyonce and Jay-Z are trying to meet. So I'm like letting it all happen. And she was speaking to Pippa and Jasmine and Renee, who were playing the Skylar sisters. And then they kind of walked away and there was this moment where she was like.
45:27 Speaker 06 Okay, like it was kind of like a transitional moment. And I went in there. And I was like, hi, I'm Jonathan. I'm just sad to say I'm such a huge fan. And she took my hand and she said, were you the king?
45:45 Speaker 06 And I said, yes. And then she said, I'm gonna steal your walk. And she backed up like six feet and did an impression of the way that I walked onto the stage.
45:59 Jessie Ware? She'd washed your whole body.
46:01 Speaker 06 And, yes, and then. I was like, I was like. And then she said, and when you exited and you moved your shoulders, but not your head. You were your own turntable. There's a turntable on the stage. And I was like, I, I, I went.
46:24 Speaker 06 I just moaned and then she looked me up and down and said, I saw everything.
46:31 Speaker 06 And the next night, and I knew when she did the impression of the walk out, I I kinda knew what she was talking about. That was something I was conscious of. But the next night, I was on stage, I was doing it, and I was leaving the stage. I was like, oh my god, I am, I didn't even consciously know. I would do this thing where I would turn my body, and I would keep my head forward, and I would find one head, because I couldn't quite see faces, and look them up and down, and then exit. Was something that, it was like, I was doing as the character, but I wasn't consciously thinking. And it's, it's a nanosecond of a moment. And that, I was like Beyonce's eye,
47:11 Speaker 06 that she spotted that and collected it, and then delivered it back to me was so mind blowing. It was mind blowing.
47:21 Jessie Ware? That's a great Beyonce star. Um, we need to get back to your last supper.
47:26 Speaker 06 Okay, yeah, oh right.
47:27 Jessie Ware? We got your main. Hell's Kitchen.
47:30 Speaker 06 Penjellavaka with chicken.
47:31 Jessie Ware? Chelsea Grill.
47:32 Speaker 06 Yeah.
47:33 Jessie Ware? What's your starter?
47:36 Speaker 06 The salad at Gemma. What's it called? Like, it's, it's like an Italian name, but it's got, it's like, I'm salivating.
47:45 Jessie Ware? You salivate a lot, the wet performer.
47:47 Speaker 06 I'm a wet man. The fluids come. What can I say?
47:54 Speaker 06 It's got like anchovies on it, it's got kale. It's got, it's got, I wanna say like pomegranate maybe in it? There's like a fruit element? And like a, like a cheese on it as well. I can't remember the name of it. But it's a starter salad at Gemma. That would be my starter.
48:13 Jessie Ware? So we've got starter at Gemma.
48:15 Speaker 06 Leading into the Penjellavaka, that's gonna be so good.
48:17 Jessie Ware? Fabulous. Then we going for the pudding? Is it gonna be your mum's pumpkin pie?
48:21 Speaker 06 Yeah.
48:22 Jessie Ware? And what drink? Are we going for whiskey?
48:27 Speaker 06 I can only have one drink with all of this.
48:29 Jessie Ware? No, you can have whatever you want.
48:30 Speaker 04 Keep going all day.
48:33 Speaker 04 I would if I were going on a death of a.
48:34 Jessie Ware? That's what Lenny's been doing all week.
48:37 Speaker 04 Quite honestly, yeah. Whatever gets you through, darling.
48:40 Speaker 06 Whatever gets you through. Talk about it. Um, I think I would start with an Aperol spritz.
48:48 Jessie Ware? Okay.
48:49 Speaker 06 I would move to like a full bodied red for the Penneola vodka with chicken. And then I would go to like a
49:00 Speaker 06 um, Boulevardier.
49:02 Jessie Ware? What's that?
49:03 Speaker 06 Which is like a, it's like a whisk, it's almost like a Negroni with whiskey.
49:07 Jessie Ware? Ooh.
49:08 Speaker 04 Have you heard of this?
49:09 Jessie Ware? No.
49:10 Speaker 06 I think it's Campari and whiskey and sweet vermouth.
49:15 Jessie Ware? That's a bit me.
49:16 Speaker 04 Where have you drunk this?
49:17 Speaker 06 Celebrating again.
49:17 Jessie Ware? Oh, my God.
49:18 Speaker 06 Celebrating for the Boulevardier. That was the COVID, the drink I learned about in COVID. I also do love a paper plane.
49:25 Jessie Ware? What's a paper plane, babe?
49:26 Speaker 06 Paper plane is like a whiskey Aperol drink.
49:30 Jessie Ware? Well, you like a shit mix, don't you? So, so Anna Wintour was in the audience last night. Are you getting an invite to the Met or anything?
49:39 Speaker 04 You must be going.
49:40 Jessie Ware? She just saying how you looked in a suit.
49:42 Speaker 06 She, she, like, she's a huge, she's at every opening night, by the way. I mean, I'm honored that she was there, but it's not, it wasn't just for our show. She is such a theater queen and theater supporter. And she goes to every opening night.
49:57 Jessie Ware? Fantastic.
49:58 Speaker 06 And she supports and loves the theater and her daughter, Bee.
50:02 Speaker 04 Who was with her, I think.
50:03 Speaker 06 Was she with her last night?
50:04 Speaker 04 Well, she had a daughter with long dark.
50:06 Jessie Ware? Yeah, that's me.
50:07 Speaker 04 Yes, I thought it was her daughter.
50:09 Speaker 06 Okay, I love Bee. Bee, I've known, we were, we're around the same age. I sang at Bee's wedding.
50:15 Jessie Ware? Oh, wow.
50:16 Speaker 06 And Bee came to see our Bobby Darin night at the 92nd Street Y eight years, or seven years ago. And Bee was one of the first people that said, this needs to be a Broadway show.
50:28 Speaker 04 Like, what, like? She was very smiley.
50:30 Speaker 06 Oh, yeah.
50:31 Speaker 04 Yeah, she smiled throughout. I watched, yeah.
50:34 Jessie Ware? I have to say, Jonathan, I don't think many performers could do what you did last night. And yes, the, the, the cast is incredible, but that ease that you put everyone in when they watch you perform, it's. You're untouchable in that sense, like it's just, it's a joy to watch you.
50:52 Speaker 04 And it's an amazing.
50:52 Jessie Ware? And to enjoy you and to see you enjoying yourself and it's just.
50:56 Speaker 04 But I think you make such an amazing connection. People feel connected with you.
51:01 Speaker 06 I just love it so much and I I really love the audience. I love the audience. I love the attentive audience. I love the sleeping audience member. I love the coughing audience member. I love the audience member where the cell phone's going off. They're there. They're there. And I remember feeling this a lot during Merrily, like the more I do it and the more experiences I have on Broadway, the more I love them. And the more I I like, respect them and the more gratitude. I feel more gratitude now than I than I ever have. For them, it's like to to spend money to buy a ticket.
51:44 Speaker 06 You know, it's like with all of that with our phones and our computers and everything to go. And I'm sure you feel this way too when you do a concert. It's like these people are coming out to have a live experience and it's just so, it's such rare air in our in our culture and in our world.
52:01 Speaker 04 Not in New York.
52:02 Speaker 06 I mean, it's, you're right. No, it's Broadway. Like it is. It's a part of like this city. It always has been. But in the in in just like where we're moving with AI and with, you know, just even even the time that we were in in the pandemic and we got really attached to how we can survive with our screens. There's just, there's this magic about the live experience and like some nights I dance with the audience and a couple of times people refuse to dance with me.
52:30 Jessie Ware? Oh, so how do you deal with that?
52:31 Speaker 06 And I love them too. So I just sit next to them and I put my arm around them and sing them a song. It's like, to me, the audience can do no wrong. And it's and and and it's like it the the love. Like surprisingly, I'm sort of surprised by it. It just gets deeper and bigger. It's such a cool.
52:50 Speaker 04 It's because you respect your audience. What you're talking about is respect and they feel it.
52:55 Speaker 06 Exactly.
52:56 Speaker 04 And appreciated.
52:57 Speaker 06 And maybe it's because I also, I love being in the audience. I love, I love being in the audience as much as I love being on stage.
53:04 Jessie Ware? So we're gonna give you some pudding now. Well, dessert. Pudding. Jake is. Jake is. Jake, get on the mic and tell us, tell Jonathan what it is, please.
53:13 Speaker 06 How to Jake. Squeeze, get on the mic.
53:16 Speaker 05 I'm gonna sit on Lenny's lap.
53:17 Speaker 06 Yes.
53:19 Speaker 05 We've got halva stuffed dates covered in chocolate, a little flaky salt.
53:24 Speaker 05 A little easy, quick.
53:25 Speaker 06 Wait, say it again.
53:26 Speaker 05 Halva stuffed dates.
53:28 Speaker 06 Halva?
53:28 Speaker 05 Halva. Like the sesame candy?
53:31 Speaker 06 I have no idea what halva is.
53:32 Speaker 05 Beautiful. So imagine like cotton candy, but made with sesame. So like pretty much like blend sesame.
53:41 Jessie Ware? Let's go.
53:44 Jessie Ware? How wet can you get on there?
53:45 Speaker 06 Oh, we're all gonna have one.
53:47 Jessie Ware? They look beautiful.
53:48 Speaker 05 Thank you.
53:49 Speaker 06 Okay, here we go.
53:52 Speaker 06 My god.
53:54 Speaker 05 It's always the first bite.
53:57 Jessie Ware? Thank you, Jake, and that was the best.
53:59 Speaker 05 My pleasure.
54:00 Speaker 06 So good.
54:01 Speaker 04 Jonathan, once you'd done looking and you kind of were more out as a gay man, did you think that would alter people's perspective and that you wouldn't be able to play straight parts? Was that a worry?
54:16 Speaker 06 Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, I, when I, when I came out publicly, I came out of the closet publicly when I was twenty
54:26 Speaker 06 three or twenty-four and I was dating this actor who just passed last year named Gavin Creel.
54:34 Speaker 06 And.
54:36 Speaker 06 He was leading this march on Washington for gay marriage. He started, he co-founded this organization called Broadway Impact. And he took all these buses from New York to Washington DC for this part of this march. And we were dating each other at the time and I was so in love with him. And I was out to my friends and family, but I just, the occasion to come out publicly had not happened yet.
55:00 Speaker 06 And it then there it presented itself in Washington DC in that moment in an interview. And I remember the moment of like looking over at him and he had a bullhorn. Like he was like, like crowd control over here, orchestrated this whole thing. And I remember feeling like the love that I feel for him is so much deeper than any job I could ever wish to have. And making the choice, I'm gonna choose love over whatever idea of what I would want my career to be. I'm gonna come out of the closet. Cause it did feel like in, in two thousand and eight or nine, that that was the case at that time.
55:39 Speaker 06 That you, that you were making a choice to either be in the closet and have more opportunities in your career or come out and have a, and have less opportunities. And I, I made that decision with love and I was like, I'm not gonna be in film and television and I, I'm okay with that. I'd rather be in love and be myself. And so I made that choice then, and then Looking happened of like five years later. And when that opportunity came up, I thought, wow, okay. I'm really driving the nail into the coffin here of like ever playing anything, anything other than gay. Yeah. And I felt like, yeah, cause it's one thing to be out of the closet
56:23 Speaker 06 and then it's one thing to like anally douche on film for all to see.
56:28 Speaker 04 Yes.
56:29 Speaker 06 To really sear it into people's minds that I am a homosexual. And I thought, I really, Andrew Haig, who directed the movie Weekend, I just loved his movie so much. And Michael Lannon, who created that show, I just really believed in what they were doing. And I felt like this means more to me than. Some idea of what could be and really thought, I'm okay with it. I'll just be gay and everything. It's fine. And then these, these opportunities in the last 10 years that have happened, like Mindhunter and the Matrix movie and even playing in Merrily We Roll Along, this straight, even though it's a musical, a sauna musical written by gays, this like straight leading man character and now Bobby Darin,
57:14 Speaker 06 never would have imagined that I would get these opportunities. And so it's, it's like, it speaks to the time that we're in. In, in, in 2025, like there's still so much more to go, obviously. But there has been this wave of progress that's allowed me to have this career. And it's, it's total timing, luck of timing. But I, I really was, was consciously making the choice to be myself and make the sacrifice as the, or not even make the sacrifice, but just you choose your path. And I, these, these opportunities that have come after making those choices have been a total surprise to me.
57:53 Jessie Ware? Before we let you go to stage, can you give us a nostalgic taste that can transport you back somewhere, happy or sad?
58:07 Speaker 06 Okay, it's, it's black raspberry ice cream at the Creamery on Main Street in Strasburg, Pennsylvania. Yeah. Where I was like, that was, that was like the, I can imagine, I can smell the waffle cone. This is like, I'm maybe three, four or five years old. I can smell the waffle cone and I can see, it was also my dad's favorite flavor of ice cream. So it's, I can see the like, purple was also my favorite color as a kid. So I can see the like cartoon of the black raspberry, like purple thing in the waffle cone.
58:49 Speaker 06 I can smell the cones being made in the Creamery. And then having the cone with my dad, the taste of the black raspberry ice cream, like a kind of like pure childhood memory.
59:04 Jessie Ware? Jonathan Groff, I don't want to let you go. No. But we must let you get to.
59:07 Speaker 06 You never have.
59:08 Jessie Ware? You're a dawning fan.
59:09 Speaker 06 But in a profound way, you're never letting me go.
59:11 Jessie Ware? No, I'm not.
59:11 Speaker 06 Because we're lifers.
59:12 Jessie Ware? Yeah, we are.
59:13 Speaker 06 We're lifers.
59:14 Jessie Ware? Thank you for doing the podcast. Yeah.
59:15 Speaker 06 Thank you for having me. What an honour.
59:18 Jessie Ware? You can come again whenever you want.
59:19 Speaker 06 Oh, my gosh. Please.
59:21 Jessie Ware? And best of luck for the rest of the run.
59:23 Speaker 06 Thank you.
59:24 Jessie Ware? It's so fantastic. And we can't wait for you to win that Tony Award for this.
59:28 Speaker 06 Oh, my gosh. Thank you so much for having me. It's such a pleasure to sit and chat with you. Thank you so much for coming to opening night. It meant the world to have you there.
59:35 Jessie Ware? I loved it.
59:50 Jessie Ware? I loved Jonathan Groff so much. Me too. He's heaven. Absolutely gorgeous. I think he's so generous when he talks. Oh. And he tells you things about himself in a very honest way. I feel like regardless of if you're a musical theatre fan or not, like to be able to watch Jonathan Groff on stage, he's a legend already on stage. If you get the chance to come and see him as Bobby Darin in Just in Time, you really should. It's a really, not that he needed a career-defining performance, but this is just, it's completely charming and brilliant and an exciting production. And you can just see how much fun they're having with it. And I actually really think I'm going to come back and see it again.
1:00:35 Jessie Ware? Can I come? Yeah, yes. Yes, you can. Jake wants me back. No, I know. I know. And that's the reason I won't be allowed in the apartment unless you're on with Lenny. Please go and see Just in Time. It's at the Circle in the Square on Broadway, and it's absolutely brilliant. It's a gorgeous theatre as well. Yeah, it's fab. Thank you for listening. We'll be back with another New York special next week.
1:01:33 Speaker 10 Hi, I'm Laura Adams, host of Money Girl, where I help my listeners make empowered choices. Women are increasingly driving household financial decisions, yet many say they don't feel fully prepared for the choices ahead. When you're making choices for a future decades away, confidence matters. And confidence comes from knowing a promise will be kept. For nearly 160 years, Pacific Life has helped generations protect what matters today and prepare for tomorrow with life insurance and lifetime income solutions. Pacific Life keeps its promises, so you can keep yours. Ask a financial professional
1:02:14 Speaker 10 about how Pacific Life can help you create a more confident financial future. Pacific Life Insurance Company, Omaha, Nebraska, and in New York. Pacific Life and Annuity, Phoenix, Arizona.
1:02:29 Speaker 11 Hi, it's Danny Pellegrino from Everything Iconic. 12 celebrities, one Don, and cold hard cash. From the producers of The Traitors comes The Mob, a new Hulu original series. The iconic Parker Posey hosts this unique reality competition show where 12 celebrity contestants shake down in an Italian villa to win a share of up to $250,000. Watch The Mob, now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus for bundle subscribers. Terms apply.
1:03:00 Speaker 01 When you're running a growing business, the right systems can unlock your full sales potential and make fulfilling every order effortless. Switch to ShipStation before peak season so you're prepped and ready before the rush hits. ShipStation connects Shopify, Amazon, TikTok Shop, and over 200 more marketplaces with one platform that does it all. You can manage orders, sync inventory, track returns, all automatically. Everything your operation needs, all in one place. Upgrade your shipping operations to stress-proof your biggest sales days and capture every bit of potential revenue. Go to shipstation.com and use code AUDIO and get 30 days free.
1:03:30 Speaker 08 Cash Now, More Later from Open Door. Gives you cash upfront for your home, plus all the profit later. That's no chaos now, no cash left behind later. Skip the showings now, pocket extra profit later. This is so simple now. This is so awesome later. Or sell fast now, and pop the champagne later. Cash Now, More Later. Now available nationwide.
1:03:53 Speaker 09 Start your offer at open door dot com slash Acast. Profits calculated after fees and costs. Eligibility and offer price may vary.
Previous Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco Next Matthew Broderick Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated