Pod Insights Success Story with Scott D. Clary Lessons - Optimizing Diet for Muscle Preservation and Brain Health | Dr. Layne Norton - Founder of BioLayne About this episode ➡️ Like The Podcast? Leave A Rating: https://ratethispodcast.com/successstory In this "Lessons" episode, Dr. Layne Norton, founder of BioLayne, debunks diet myths and highlights the science behind long-term weight management, muscle preservation, and the connection between diet and brain health. Explore the principles of adherence, the value of meta-analyses, and the best dietary practices for sustainable results. ➡️ Show Linkshttps://successstorypodcast.com YouTube: https://youtu.be/6zg6wiJmViAApple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/dr-layne-norton-founder-of-biolayne-the-science/id1484783544Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/episode/27zz6uh0sOVfAsU6EglRoQ?si=faf8e581dcfa43d9 ➡️ Watch the Podcast On Youtubehttps://www.youtube.com/c/scottdclary
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Today's success story podcast is brought to you by Vanta. Now, listen up, this matters for your business. In today's digital landscape, security isn't optional. It's essential. Without it, deals stall, sales cycles stretch out, and scaling becomes really difficult. Why? Because investors, customers, partners, they all expect businesses to demonstrate strong security practices before they commit to anything. And if you can't prove trust, you lose opportunities. So whether you're a startup founder, trying to land that first big client, or an established company scaling your security program, Vanta helps businesses of all sizes prove they're trustworthy by automating compliance across 35 frameworks like SOC 2, ISO 27001, and HIPAA. The exact certifications your prospects,
0:45 Speaker 00 your customers are demanding. And here's why you need to pay attention. Vanta gives you back precious time you're currently wasting on compliance. Their platform automates up to 90% of the tedious compliance work, and it helps you respond to those endless security questionnaires up to five times faster. And they also connect you with experts to get your security program running immediately. And the results, they speak for themselves. A recent IDC report found that Vanta customers achieve over $535,000 per year in benefits, and the platform pays for itself in just three months. So join over 10,000 global companies like Atlassian, Cora, and Factory, who use Vanta to manage risk and prove security in real time. And don't miss this. For a limited time only, my listeners can get $1,000 off Vanta. That's real money back in your pocket.
1:30 Speaker 00 Visit vanta.com/scott now before this offer expires. That's V A N T A dot com slash Scott for $1,000 off. In this lessons episode, discover the truth behind popular diets and what actually leads to long-term success. Learn why adherence matters more than the diet itself, the power of meta-analyses in nutrition research, and key factors for muscle retention and weight maintenance.
2:04 Speaker 00 Well, it seems like when you look at all the different types of diets, so you look at the the high carb, low fat, you look at the low carb, the higher fat and like more traditional keto, if you look at intermittent fasting, these are almost just psychological tricks to to promote a certain diet that you can adhere to for a long term. Is that is that more or less?
2:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, so there was actually a really, a really telling study. It was it was called, it was a meta-analysis. So a meta-analysis, just so people understand, is not a study in and of itself. You're not recruiting subjects or anything like that. What you're doing is you are scouring the entire database of research and you're looking for studies that fit your, what you call inclusion criteria, right? So basically, these, this particular meta-analysis, I forget the exact inclusion criteria, but I think they were looking for, you know, studies looking at weight loss diets in humans
3:06 Speaker 01 that tracked, I think, weight loss over three months, six months and two years. And there were some other inclusion criteria as well. And basically, they're including any studies that fall into this. And then, and they have certain exclusion criteria. Like, again, I'm not certain, I'm not saying that these were the exact exclusion criteria. But like, for example, some studies will say, you know, we didn't take people with heart disease. We didn't take people with type 2 diabetes, you know, like that sort of thing, right? I'm not saying that was the case for this study. I'm just saying you can set whatever criteria you want. So you include all the studies that fit that criteria. And what you try to do then is basically combine all those data points to try to come up with a consensus of what the research says for your particular research question.
3:50 Speaker 01 So it's a very powerful tool because a lot of times you can take, you know, individual nutrition studies and randomized control trials. It is very, very difficult to get randomized control trials that last longer than a few months with any kind of reasonable amount of control. So, for example, if you want a really highly controlled study, you have to pay people. Like you, like you can't just have that much control over people's lifestyle. People will be like, okay, sure, I'll do that. You know, I'll go sit in food jail for, for six months, you know? So, I mean, there was a, a study recently where, um, I can't remember the exact study, but basically they paid people like seven hundred dollars, seven to eight hundred dollars
4:34 Speaker 01 for like over a hundred thousand participants or, or no, sorry, sorry, sorry. Seven, eight hundred dollars per participant and the total ended up being like several hundred thousand dollars they had to pay out. And all they were doing was monitoring people over like a six month period. Like they weren't even like forcing them to eat the meals that they wanted. They just told them what to do and like had them come in and take measurements and stuff. So the point being it's really, really hard to get long, multi-year randomized control trials with a high degree of control. And so the ones that are, do have a high degree of control end up being very few subjects. Right? So the power of a meta-analysis is you've combined all these. You can take, you know, a study, they only have twenty or thirty people.
5:19 Speaker 01 But once you do a meta-analysis, you may have thousands of data points. So it really can be a powerful tool.
5:24 Speaker 00 I was gonna say you have to be careful for, uh, searching for studies that also support what you're looking for because I, I know that you can find studies on anything to support almost any conclusion.
5:32 Speaker 01 Right, right. And again, that's why meta-analyses are so powerful because I always tell people, I don't care about single studies. I mean, I may get like excited about how well a study was done or how tightly it was controlled or whatever, but I will very, very rarely make. Uh, strong statements about one study. I'll usually say this study suggests this. Here's how it fits with the rest of the evidence. Well, we probably need more research and I will say that almost every time, right? So that's why meta-analyses are so powerful because it's not one study, it's multiple studies. Now, it's important to read because you can do a bad meta-analysis as well. Because there are meta-analyses with like two studies or three studies. Um, you know, especially if research is emerging, that's not necessarily a knock on the meta-analysis.
6:17 Speaker 01 If the studies don't fit the inclusion criteria, there may only be that many studies. Um, but again, in this one, they were looking at 14 different like popular diets. And how they, you know, their effects on weight loss over like six months, a year, two years.
6:35 Speaker 01 And what they found basically is in the long term, over two years, all of them were equally favorable at promoting, facilitating long-term weight loss. There really wasn't much difference. But when they took people and stratified them from least adherent to most adherent, regardless of diet used, there was a linear effect on their results. So basically, the most adherent people got the best results regardless of diet used. So what that says to me, especially based on another meta-analysis, kind of what I was talking about. Uh, this one from 2017 by Kevin Hall, where they looked at, um,
7:16 Speaker 01 low carb versus low fat diets, uh, when protein was equated and when calories were equated and when meals were provided to the participants, so actually a high degree of control. And they found that there was no difference between fat loss between these groups, really. Um, so taking all those things together, I look at that and say, well, the best diet is probably the one that you could stick to as an individual. And we look at adherence, adherence appears to be very individual because they even looked at, hey, did any of these diets tend to have better adherence than others? And the answer is no. Um, there doesn't really seem to be one diet that pops up as, as being better for adherence. But for individuals.
8:01 Speaker 01 You'll hear individuals say, "Man, I did time restricted eating. It felt like I wasn't even dieting. You know, it was so easy for me." Or, "I did low carb. It felt easy." "I did plant-based. It felt easy." "I did flexible dieting. It felt easy." So, if you want to lose fat, um, you have to, you have to restrict in some way. But you should probably pick the form of restriction that feels the least restrictive for you. Because most people think about a diet just as a diet and they don't think about it as a lifestyle. And that's why the weight loss recidivism rates, which is basically relapsing to previous weights after weight loss,
8:42 Speaker 01 are like eighty, ninety, even high percent, even higher if you look out past five years. So what it really says is whatever diet that you're choosing to use to lose weight, those habits and behaviors you build, you better be able to maintain them because weight maintenance is actually more difficult than weight loss.
9:06 Speaker 00 A huge shout out to Federated Computer for supporting today's episode. Let me explain why I love Federated Computer, why they are friends of success story. They are changing the way businesses buy software because we all need software to run our businesses. I don't care what kind of business you're building, but the best business software doesn't have to cost thousands of dollars each month. So Federated Computer replaces a lot of the software that you're using right now. Let me explain. The average, typical Federated Computer customer saves seventy-five percent or more on their software bill and gets great software, top-notch customer service and support, and a software solution that is uniquely installed for your business without any sort of surveillance or breaches of privacy. For example, if you use Google for email, Salesforce for CRM,
9:51 Speaker 00 Slack for team chat, List Monkey for customer acquisitions, and Airtable for data management, with a team of ten, you'd save nine thousand dollars per year on software costs by switching to Federated Computer. They replace all of those. And what's wild is that the cost of Federated Computer doesn't grow as your team grows. You can use Federated Computer savings to grow your business rather than feed the woke Silicon Valley software companies.
10:16 Speaker 00 The Federated Computer team literally invented cloud software. They actually have the patents to prove it and they are taking a hammer to the ridiculously high prices of business software that all entrepreneurs are suffering from. Federated Computer, they've been a longtime supporter of SuccessStory. They're offering 30% off their already low prices when you use the coupon code FREELANCE. So go to www.federated.computer to begin saving 75% or more on your monthly software costs. That's www.federated.computer. These folks are gonna do you a big favor. Check them out. So on that point, when you're talking about all these different types of diets,
10:56 Speaker 00 is there any type of diet that is not just for fat loss, but for muscle preservation and/or cognitive performance that could be optimal? Or does it still follow that exact same trend?
11:08 Speaker 01 I can't really speak to the cognitive because it's not really my area. What I will say is if you see people lose body fat following healthier diet practices, you do tend to see better cognition. I will say there appears to be a link between the gut and the brain. You don't fully understand it yet. So I will say eating sufficient amounts of fruits and vegetables and enough dietary fiber is pretty much the best way to have a healthy gut microbiome. And that may be important if it ties into cognition, but I wouldn't say that there's strong direct links between the two yet, although I haven't looked really hard at it either. So it could be there and I'm just not aware of it.
11:53 Speaker 01 When it comes to muscle retention, really what you're looking at is getting enough protein in and then resistance training. If you do those two things, you're doing 90% of the work. There is some data that suggests that a ketogenic diet specifically may not be optimal for lean mass retention compared to a diet that has sufficient carbohydrate. That is mechanistically, that's probably because carbohydrates release insulin.
12:25 Speaker 01 Insulin has a inhibitory effect on what we call proteolysis, which is basically muscle protein breakdown, right? So that is probably why. And then we do see that in the randomized control trials too, especially a randomized control trial by Kevin Hall, where they took people and put them on a ketogenic diet, compared it to eating like a sufficient amount of car- or not a sufficient, because there's no requirement for carbohydrates, but like a high carb, low fat diet. And they found that their urinary nitrogen excretion was higher. And they had, they lost more lean mass over the course of the RCT. So urinary nitrogen, basically why that's important is because
13:10 Speaker 01 protein is the only nitrogen containing macronutrient there is. The nitrogen component is what makes it unique. And so we can look at how much nitrogen appears in your urine. We can also look at how much you're taking in. And we can come up with like a pretty good idea of like, whether or not you're in a positive or negative nitrogen balance. And if you're in a negative nitrogen balance, that's a pretty good indicator that you're probably losing lean tissue. So I, I'm not saying that you can't gain muscle on a ketogenic diet, because I know people will misinterpret what I'm saying and make it black and white and go to extremes. You could absolutely gain muscle on a ketogenic diet. But when they compare them straight up to diets equal in protein
13:54 Speaker 01 that are non ketogenic, the non ketogenic diets tend to do a little bit better. Again, it's not a massive difference in lean mass retention. So I, I wouldn't tell anybody, hey, like if you have success on a ketogenic diet, that's easy for you to adhere to. I'm not saying don't do it because you're just going to strip off a bunch of muscle. But is it the best thing for muscle retention? Not based on the, the data we have.
14:18 Speaker 00 Thanks for tuning in. If you found this valuable, don't forget to hit that subscribe button so you never miss an episode. And if you want to dive deeper into this conversation, check out the links in the description to watch the full episode. See you in the next one.
Previous Israa Nasir - Psychotherapist, Speaker & Entrepreneur | Reclaiming Your Time and Emotional Energy Next Lessons - Navigating Pregnancy and Work | Stephanie Kramer - Chief Human Resources Officer at L'Oréal Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated