Pod Insights Stuff You Should Know Selects: How Personality Tests Work About this episode For millennia, we have tried to put human personalities into neat types, an effort psychology took up early in its history in an effort to legitimize itself. But is the idea of types – which all personality inventories are based on - flawed to begin with? Find out in this classic episode.
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 10,598 words · 7 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human.
0:04 Josh Clark? Buy smart, drive for less and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability and it starts with a great deal on an off-road ready Tacoma or half ton Tundra, two of Toyota's longest lasting trucks, combining power for work, tech for adventures and style in between. And they're built on a reputation for quality and reliability, which is why Toyota trucks are known for holding their value, which could mean big savings when it's time for your next Toyota. So get a great deal today and a great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for more. Toyota, let's go places.
0:35 Speaker 02 This is the story of the one. As a shipping manager, he's running the dock, stocking supplies and making sure every order goes out on time. And Granger helps him stay prepared. From shipping supplies to PPE to hand tools, he counts on Granger to keep products moving and trucks rolling. So his operation runs smoothly, no matter the shift. Call 1-800-GRANGER, click Granger.com or just stop by. Granger, for the ones who get it done.
1:05 Josh Clark? Hey everybody, it's me, Josh. And for this week's select, I've chosen our August 2017 episode on personality tests. It turns out that the vast majority of them, maybe all of them, are scientifically faulty to at least some degree. And some of them are just outright made up. This can be a real problem if they're being used to diagnose you with a mental illness or hire or fire you or put you in jail. And that actually happens. So dig into this deceptively interesting episode and enjoy it. And I'm an ENFP, by the way.
1:43 Speaker 00 Welcome to Stuff You Should Know, a production of iHeart Radio.
1:52 Josh Clark? Hey, and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh Clark. There's Charles W. Chuck Bryant. There's Jerry over there. And this is Stuff You Should Know.
2:01 Speaker 03 Yeah, just a couple of. I T J S's.
2:08 Josh Clark? I don't remember what I am. We've taken it before. HowStuffWorks hosted it years back. Do you remember?
2:14 Speaker 03 Yeah, we had, like many companies do, as you'll see, we had, when we were under Discovery's tender wing, they paid for someone to come to our office and administer the Myers-Briggs personality test.
2:27 Josh Clark? At gunpoint.
2:28 Speaker 03 Yeah. I don't remember, but I'm pretty sure I was an ENFP.
2:34 Josh Clark? I don't remember what I was. I'll probably say like three different things as we go through this one.
2:40 Speaker 03 Like, just looking at it again, I'm pretty sure I was an ENFP.
2:44 Josh Clark? Okay.
2:44 Speaker 03 P stands for Pisces.
2:46 Josh Clark? Right. Or Pooper.
2:49 Speaker 03 Yeah.
2:51 Josh Clark? Let's see. Extroverted, intuitive.
2:55 Speaker 03 Okay.
2:57 Josh Clark? What is the F stand for? Feeling Pooper.
3:01 Speaker 03 This is a spoiler. Yeah, Feeling Pooper.
3:03 Josh Clark? So we're, what we're talking about, it sounds like we're saying strings of letters. They actually do make sense if you're familiar with what Chuck just said, the Myers-Briggs type inventory, which if you are in corporate America and have been a part of corporate America for more than probably three years, there's probably a pretty good likelihood that you've taken the Myers-Briggs type inventory.
3:27 Speaker 03 For sure.
3:28 Josh Clark? Like, it's really widespread.
3:30 Speaker 03 Yeah, people love it.
3:31 Josh Clark? I saw something like 13% of companies in America use it. That's a lot.
3:37 Speaker 03 Yeah, was it 89 of the Fortune 100 use it?
3:41 Josh Clark? Right. And then I saw another stat. It was from 2001, though, so I'm not sure how current it is.
3:48 Speaker 03 Well, 16 years old.
3:50 Josh Clark? Right. But they said that the
3:55 Josh Clark? I think British companies, somewhere between 10 and 40% of British companies use them.
4:01 Speaker 03 All right.
4:02 Josh Clark? So, I mean, it's, who knows? It's a pretty wild guess, it sounds like, but.
4:07 Speaker 03 I wonder if they have their own?
4:08 Josh Clark? It's, uh, no.
4:10 Speaker 03 Same one?
4:10 Josh Clark? The Myers-Briggs test, they don't call it a test, as we'll see.
4:14 Speaker 03 Sure.
4:14 Josh Clark? But the, the test, um, is, it's worldwide. It's translated into tons of different languages. They, and no, it's, it's the Myers-Briggs test. And there's tons of knockoffs.
4:26 Speaker 03 Oh, sure.
4:26 Josh Clark? There's tons of personality tests in general, which really is the, uh, larger umbrella that the Myers-Briggs test falls under. But it's probably the most famous of all time, at least as far as pop culture goes.
4:38 Speaker 03 Yeah, we're gonna hit on everything from Rorschach to the Myers-Briggs.
4:42 Josh Clark? Sure.
4:43 Speaker 03 But.
4:43 Josh Clark? We're gonna hit on them.
4:44 Speaker 03 But the MBTI definitely, um, is more the focus of this one because of its ubiquity.
4:50 Josh Clark? Right, because most people know it. And because it's, uh, one of the overlooked pastimes in the United States to take potshots at the Myers-Briggs type inventory.
5:01 Speaker 03 Sure.
5:02 Josh Clark? It's fun.
5:05 Speaker 03 So categorizing one's personality is nothing new, uh, and that's what these tests aim to do. For various reasons, which we'll go over later, but, um, going back, and this was a Grabster article, correct?
5:20 Josh Clark? That's right.
5:21 Speaker 03 So you know it's good.
5:22 Josh Clark? Yep.
5:23 Speaker 03 And Grabster was just on our show in Toronto.
5:25 Josh Clark? Yeah, he was.
5:26 Speaker 03 For the second time.
5:27 Josh Clark? He stood up and like, did that victory shake?
5:30 Speaker 03 Oh, did he do that?
5:31 Josh Clark? No, he didn't.
5:31 Speaker 03 Oh. I'm a big fan of that. That's old school.
5:34 Josh Clark? Oh, it is. It's a good way to go. It looks like you should be wearing those dolphin shorts and just having crossed the finish line and you're doing that.
5:43 Speaker 03 So, yeah, it's, it's nothing new, trying to categorize personalities. Um, way back in the day, uh, I know on our, um, Grave robbing, live grave robbing episode. We talked about the four humors.
5:54 Josh Clark? Right.
5:54 Speaker 03 And we've talked about them before, um, before medical science was kind of a real thing.
6:02 Josh Clark? There was an early attempt.
6:03 Speaker 03 Yeah. They talked about the four fluids, or the four humors, black bile, yellow bile, phlegm and blood. Uh, and an imbalance in those will cause disease, but they were also, and this is something I didn't know, these are also linked to, uh, corresponding personality types.
6:21 Josh Clark? Right. Yeah. So like the word melancholy in English, it's an adaptation of the Greek words, I believe, for black bile.
6:33 Speaker 03 There it is.
6:33 Josh Clark? And melancholy personalities were associated with an overabundance of black bile. And, um, basically you're melancholy, you're, you're a depressed person, or you're very reserved or quiet. And for thousands of years, people thought, guy's got a lot of black bile.
6:50 Speaker 03 Yeah.
6:51 Josh Clark? That explains his personality. The other ones are pretty, pretty, um, interesting too, like phlegmatic.
6:59 Speaker 03 Uh, phlegmatic?
7:00 Josh Clark? I've seen phlegmatic, I've heard phlegmatic.
7:02 Speaker 03 Oh, really?
7:03 Josh Clark? I've seen it too.
7:04 Speaker 03 So like when you cough something up, do you call it phlegm?
7:07 Josh Clark? Sometimes.
7:08 Speaker 03 Or just phleg?
7:08 Josh Clark? Depends. If it had like a lot of extra chunks in it, it's phlegm.
7:12 Speaker 03 Oh, gosh.
7:13 Josh Clark? But phlegmatic, I say phlegmatic.
7:15 Speaker 03 Uh huh.
7:16 Josh Clark? Uh, that's very laid back. Did you know that?
7:19 Speaker 03 Uh, well, yeah, cause I looked all these up.
7:20 Josh Clark? Oh, okay.
7:21 Speaker 03 Um, cause sanguine is one of my favorite words.
7:24 Josh Clark? Yeah.
7:25 Speaker 03 Um, and that's, this is Hippocrates, by the way, he, he kind of further refined these concepts of the temperament. So melancholic, phlegmatic, sanguine, and what is it? Caloric.
7:36 Josh Clark? Yeah. Caloric.
7:38 Speaker 03 Yeah.
7:38 Josh Clark? Caloric.
7:40 Speaker 03 Caloric.
7:40 Josh Clark? Caloric is like irritable and short and terse and curt.
7:45 Speaker 03 Yeah.
7:45 Josh Clark? But the thing is, there's something weird here, right? If you are a thinking human being.
7:53 Speaker 03 Yes.
7:53 Josh Clark? Who is not in a vegetative state right now.
7:55 Speaker 03 Correct.
7:56 Josh Clark? And for all we know, at this point in medical science, maybe even if you are in a vegetative state, you're probably thinking, uh, it doesn't seem like anyone I've ever met is just phlegmatic, or just choleric, or just sanguine.
8:13 Speaker 03 Yeah.
8:13 Josh Clark? Or just melancholy. Sometimes I'm all for those things. Sometimes I go through those things all four in a day, depending on how weird the day is.
8:22 Speaker 03 Sometimes I go through all four of those within the course of one happy hour.
8:25 Josh Clark? Sure, okay, right. And, and that's kind of the point here, and it's also the basis of any criticism from this moment in the podcast here on out, is that this whole thing that started back with the four humors and continues on to this day in the guise of personality tests.
8:43 Speaker 03 Yeah.
8:44 Josh Clark? Is an attempt to take a human personality and say, you're this.
8:49 Speaker 03 Yeah.
8:50 Josh Clark? You're this one type. You're this type. This is your type. This is what you're like, right?
8:55 Speaker 03 Yeah.
8:55 Josh Clark? And the human personality is just too complex, too squishy, too jelly-like to be boxed into one thing like that.
9:03 Speaker 03 Yeah, and we'll get into all the criticisms, but that definitely is the leading criticism that is, uh, well, we'll save that.
9:10 Josh Clark? Okay. That was a tease.
9:13 Speaker 03 It was a good tease.
9:14 Josh Clark? It was a phlegmatic one.
9:15 Speaker 03 Uh, all these classifications, though, um, that we talk about now are, uh, or most of them at least, are derived, uh, laid at the feet of one man, one Carl Jung.
9:26 Josh Clark? Yeah.
9:27 Speaker 03 Who wrote a book called, uh, Psychological Types.
9:31 Josh Clark? How do you say it, though, in, in German?
9:33 Speaker 03 I don't know.
9:34 Josh Clark? It's, um, oh, where is it? Let me see. Oh, there it is. I, I can't even begin to do it.
9:41 Speaker 03 Uh, psycho, psycho, sorry, psychologisches?
9:46 Speaker 03 Yish, psychologisch, typen.
9:49 Josh Clark? It's not bad.
9:51 Speaker 03 It's so tiny, that was the problem, cuz you-
9:52 Josh Clark? Oh yeah, I do ten point. I don't like to waste paper.
9:55 Speaker 03 Well, you know me, I'm-
9:57 Josh Clark? You do like sixteen point, Times New Roman?
9:59 Speaker 03 I love paper, and I don't wanna waste it, but I also have to do my job.
10:05 Josh Clark? Sure.
10:06 Speaker 03 Maybe I should go double sided, but then my highlighter gets in the way.
10:09 Josh Clark? Oh yeah, it'd be a problem.
10:11 Speaker 03 Oh man.
10:12 Josh Clark? Everything would be highlighted. You might as well just dip the whole page in yellow ink or something.
10:16 Speaker 03 Yeah, exactly. So anyway, Jung wrote this book, that book, in nineteen twenty-one in German, and had it translated to English a couple of years later.
10:26 Josh Clark? Mm-hmm.
10:26 Speaker 03 And he created these four categories, sensation, intuition, thinking and feeling.
10:34 Josh Clark? Right.
10:36 Speaker 03 So those were his four that, kind of, most of these modern tests are based on in some way or another.
10:41 Josh Clark? Yeah, and it's really almost impossible that, I guess we could just save all the criticisms for the end and just pile them on, but it's really tough to talk about this stuff and not like, as you present one fact, talk about the problem with that fact as it relates to modern incarnation. What do you think we should do? Should we just save them like you say? Cuz I can bite my tongue.
11:05 Speaker 03 Yeah, let's save them.
11:06 Josh Clark? Okay.
11:06 Speaker 03 And then you can just like-
11:08 Josh Clark? I'm not even trying, like, I'm not, I'm not going crop circle here. I'm just saying, like, there's just, there's just a lot wrong with this. But even before Jung, who created these, the, the concept of, the modern concept, I should say, of personality types, and he created the idea of introvert and extrovert, which, say what you will about Jung, and a lot of psychologists have a lot to say about him.
11:30 Speaker 03 Yeah.
11:30 Josh Clark? Not necessarily the nicest things to say, but introversion and extroversion is so widely accepted-
11:38 Speaker 03 Yeah.
11:38 Josh Clark? Inside and out of the field of psychology that, I mean, if that were his only contribution to the field, that's, that's enough to engrave it on your tombstone, for sure.
11:49 Speaker 03 Yeah, and each of those four psychological types he was talking about are modified by whether or not you're introverted or extroverted.
11:58 Josh Clark? Right.
11:58 Speaker 03 So they all kind of work together to box you in.
12:00 Josh Clark? That was like the, right, that was the main thing, is how you, how you approach life as introvert or extrovert, and everything else is like a sub- Kind of a subsection of that or something?
12:10 Speaker 03 Yeah, and, and one of the issues with this, and I don't think this is part of the criticism, but-
12:15 Josh Clark? I was gonna say, I thought we were saving him.
12:17 Speaker 03 He was, uh, this was based on his ideas. It wasn't like he had all this research and all this data. He, he was a deep thinker and he sat around and, and thought of these things.
12:30 Josh Clark? Right, exactly. And then he wrote entire books based on them.
12:33 Speaker 03 Yeah.
12:34 Josh Clark? But he's a very well-respected psychoanalyst and he was part of the early movement for psychoanalysis with Freud. They were, they were colleagues, although Jung was much younger. But they eventually said, "I don't like you anymore, we're parting ways." But as, as all, as psychoanalysis was really kind of establishing itself, and if you want to know more about that background and the origin of psychoanalysis, go listen to our How PR Works, the live show.
13:03 Speaker 03 Yeah.
13:04 Josh Clark? We talked a lot about that. But as this was going on, and it was starting to kind of dominate the field of psychology, there was a whole other movement, a parallel movement, that said, "You know what? We think all that's a little mushy. We like the idea of being able to quantify psychology."
13:22 Speaker 03 Yeah.
13:23 Josh Clark? And so even before Jung, there were guys like Alfred Binet, who was one of the indirect fathers of the intelligence test.
13:31 Speaker 03 Yeah.
13:32 Josh Clark? IQ test. A pair of researchers named Gray and Wheelwright, and plenty of others who wanted to say, "No, no, no, no. You can study psychology, you can study things like the human personality, and you can typify them, you can add numbers, you can quantify this stuff. And in doing so, we will prove psychology as a science as well." So this, this whole movement to typify people and put them into convenient, almost numerical categories-
14:04 Speaker 03 Yeah.
14:04 Josh Clark? Came out of this urgent need to, to establish a scientific basis for psychology.
14:11 Speaker 03 Yeah, and Jung, uh, he's kind of laid the table for this and many years later, although not that many, um, there was a woman named Catherine Cook Briggs.
14:21 Josh Clark? Yeah.
14:22 Speaker 03 Uh, and she was working on this with, uh, her daughter, uh, one Isabel Briggs Myers.
14:28 Josh Clark? Uh huh.
14:29 Speaker 03 Think you see where this is going.
14:30 Josh Clark? I do.
14:31 Speaker 03 Uh, this is post-World War II when they, women were kind of, for the first time, really going, uh, into the workforce in full.
14:38 Josh Clark? Mm-hmm.
14:38 Speaker 03 Uh, and en masse. And so they thought, well, maybe we can put together some personality types to find out, um, what kind of jobs these women might be suited for, what types of jobs they might enjoy.
14:49 Josh Clark? Right.
14:50 Speaker 03 Um, so they started working together on this and, um, as legend has it, the, the mom, Catherine, uh, Briggs, Cook Briggs, she was doing her thing and then saw Jung's works and said, I gotta start over. This is, this is the stuff.
15:08 Josh Clark? She had already been working on a personality test.
15:10 Speaker 03 Yeah.
15:10 Josh Clark? But apparently, according to the legend, threw her work into the fire.
15:15 Speaker 03 Yeah.
15:15 Josh Clark? Said, I'm starting from scratch.
15:17 Speaker 03 It's all dramatic.
15:18 Josh Clark? She was a voracious reader, uh, especially of, um, the psychology, the new psychology books that were coming out of Europe, right?
15:26 Speaker 03 She didn't read Jung?
15:27 Josh Clark? She did.
15:28 Speaker 03 Well, eventually, but.
15:29 Josh Clark? Yeah, and then.
15:30 Speaker 03 Seems like it kind of came along later.
15:32 Josh Clark? Well, so, yeah, there's a, there's kind of a weird discrepancy in the history and I don't know if it's just it hasn't been covered right, or if there is a weird discrepancy, but supposedly she initiated it. And so it would have been contemporary or shortly after Jung's psychology or personality types.
15:50 Speaker 03 Yeah.
15:50 Josh Clark? Was translated into English in 1923.
15:53 Speaker 03 Mm-hmm.
15:54 Josh Clark? So, but it was her daughter Isabel who really, uh, took it and ran with it because of World War II and the need for, uh, women in the workplace.
16:02 Speaker 03 Correct. Uh, so they, you know, kind of kept some of Jung's stuff built on that. They kind of stripped some of it away. Uh, most notably, a lot of the unconscious stuff. And they might've thought that was a little too weird for, you know, the modern American workforce.
16:19 Josh Clark? Yeah.
16:20 Speaker 03 Uh, so what they ended up coming up with was the, the MBTI, Myers-Briggs Type Indicator.
16:26 Josh Clark? Right.
16:26 Speaker 03 Very famously.
16:27 Josh Clark? Yeah, and they had a, they had a publishing arrangement with one group. I can't remember what they were called, but they thought it didn't do very well. And then in 1975, they went with another publisher, CPP. And they're the current publishers of the Myers-Briggs
16:41 Speaker 03 Yeah.
16:41 Josh Clark? Type Indicator. And since then, it, that's when its ubiquity like just really spread, was starting in the seventies. And, and now it's just, it's basically married to corporate America.
16:54 Speaker 03 Should we take a break?
16:55 Josh Clark? Sure.
16:56 Speaker 03 Go get married to corporate America?
16:57 Josh Clark? Yeah, as if we aren't already.
17:00 Speaker 03 All right, we'll come back and we'll talk a little bit about personality tests in general, and then focus in a little more on the MBTI.
17:18 Speaker 04 This live check-in is brought to you by State Farm. Porque el bienestar de tu familia también merece protección. Okay, real talk. I'm about to become a dad again. And wow, it hits different the second time. Hi, I'm Wilmer Valderrama, and I've done, you know, I've done the red carpets, the long days on set and all that. But nothing prepares you for that moment when you're building a crib and you realize you're building a future. Familia is everything to me. The laughs, the chaos, the unconditional love, but also the pressure. La responsabilidad. If you're stepping into something big right now, starting a family, getting engaged, moving cities, you're not alone. Take one step at a time. Why breathe?
18:01 Speaker 04 Be present and lean into the people. They've got your back. Y disfruta. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there.
18:10 Speaker 05 Hello, hello. I'm Malcolm Gladwell, host of Smart Talks with IBM. Imagine your business depends on a system you didn't build and don't fully control. For years, it works perfectly. It's fast, reliable, affordable. So over time, more and more of your operations rely on it. Then one day, the terms change. What once felt flexible now feels difficult to leave. Moving to another provider or bringing those capabilities back under your own control could take years, cost millions, and disrupt the business in the process. That's the challenge of digital sovereignty. Businesses today rely on all sorts of third-party systems: cloud platforms, data pipelines,
18:54 Speaker 05 AI models, software tools. Most days, these systems operate quietly in the background. But when something changes, like costs go up or rules shift, organizations are forced to confront how much control and flexibility they actually have. So to understand the challenge up close, I traveled to Paris to speak with IBM's Ona Paula Assis and Axe as CIO, Giovanni Daniele, two people who think about these questions every day.
19:26 Speaker 05 Hear the full conversation at ibm.com/smarttalks or wherever you get your podcasts.
19:46 Speaker 03 All right. So personality test is just, there are many, many ways you can get evaluated psychologically by a professional. This is just one way.
19:57 Josh Clark? You can get your head measured with calipers.
20:00 Speaker 03 In fact, in the day, they did that, right?
20:01 Josh Clark? They'd give you a bunch of drugs and see what you do. There's a lot of ways.
20:06 Speaker 03 But these tests generally, as Grabster points out, falls into a couple of types: projective and objective. Projective tests are things like the Rorschach test, where you're shown something. Uh, some kind of stimulus and it's open to interpretation and you tell them what you think about it. And someone sits back very quietly and taps on a pad of paper and makes an evaluation.
20:30 Josh Clark? Very interesting.
20:31 Speaker 03 And then objective are more like these personality tests. They're standardized assessments that people use. And while it's subjective, what you put down, they are then evaluated again by a professional.
20:45 Josh Clark? Right, but ultimately that objective name is a bit of a misnomer because on the end of it, it's still interpreted by a person.
20:54 Speaker 03 Yeah.
20:54 Josh Clark? Which is therefore makes it subjective.
20:57 Speaker 03 Right.
20:57 Josh Clark? And which, depending on who you ask, is the fatal flaw of all personality tests.
21:02 Speaker 03 It should be the, uh, like, uh, good songs from the seventies had a little parenthetical at the end of the title.
21:07 Josh Clark? Right.
21:07 Speaker 03 It should just say subjective also.
21:09 Josh Clark? Right.
21:10 Speaker 03 In parentheses.
21:11 Josh Clark? Baby.
21:15 Speaker 03 So the big five are, and, and this is, the big five, I get the feeling are the psychological tests that, that legit psychologists are more in favor of over something like the MBTI. Is that right?
21:29 Josh Clark? Yeah, it's not just, there's tests to suss out the big five. The big five are the personality types that the field of psychology has come up with.
21:36 Speaker 03 Well, yeah, but the tests that, that you utilize that.
21:39 Josh Clark? Right.
21:40 Speaker 03 They kind of think are more legit than the MBTI.
21:42 Josh Clark? Yeah, there's not a psychologist alive who uses the, the MBTI in their regular practice.
21:48 Speaker 03 Oh, I bet there are.
21:49 Josh Clark? Not, not, not that, not that are speaking up.
21:52 Speaker 03 I guarantee you there's someone out there.
21:54 Josh Clark? Yeah.
21:55 Speaker 03 Sure.
21:55 Josh Clark? It's a freewheeling type. Where's she?
22:00 Speaker 03 Uh, so the big five are extroversion, agreeableness, openness to experience, uh, conscientiousness and neuroticism.
22:09 Josh Clark? Right.
22:09 Speaker 03 Sounds like it could be like a dating site thing that you fill out.
22:12 Josh Clark? It's funny, every time I see or hear the word neuroticism, a bell goes off in my head. Like ding.
22:20 Speaker 03 Just a silent bell?
22:21 Josh Clark? Yeah.
22:21 Speaker 03 Oh, I don't know what that means.
22:24 Josh Clark? I don't either, but it draws my attention to it.
22:27 Speaker 03 So some of these tests, I mean, it depends on what it is. They might not all call them by those exact words, but they're generally using, they call them, you know, like I said, the big five.
22:38 Josh Clark? Yeah, and I was, I was looking into that big five and this, this site, I can't remember what it was called, but they were basically, they were going over it, like extraversion is again, just part of the scientific literature at this point.
22:51 Speaker 03 Yeah.
22:52 Josh Clark? Agreeableness is like whether you're, how sympathetic or kind or affectionate you are.
22:57 Speaker 03 Yeah.
22:57 Josh Clark? Conscientiousness is are you organized, are you thorough, are you the type who shows up on time? That kind of thing.
23:02 Speaker 03 Yeah.
23:03 Josh Clark? Neuroticism, which is some kind, sometimes called emotional stability. How tense are you? How moody? How anxious? Ding.
23:13 Josh Clark? And then like openness to experience, right?
23:15 Speaker 03 Yeah.
23:16 Josh Clark? They sometimes call that intellect slash imagination. Do you have wide interests?
23:20 Speaker 03 Yeah.
23:20 Josh Clark? Are you an imaginative person? Are you insightful? And this, this site really went to a lot of pains to point out that what you would call these things, the big five personality traits are, as far as a psychologist is concerned, just one dimension of you, the human being.
23:39 Speaker 03 Yeah.
23:39 Josh Clark? And that to get a clearer picture of you, they would also need to study your motivations, your emotions, your attitudes, your abilities, your self-concepts, your social roles, autobiographical memories, your life stories. And if you start to put all these things together, then you can start to kind of approximate the person's personality.
23:57 Speaker 03 Yeah.
23:58 Josh Clark? But it would just, it, it takes a lot of study of an individual and these different components that make up their personality to get a clear picture. So I don't think there are any psychologists walking around saying, the big five personality types are like the beginning and end of a personality.
24:14 Speaker 03 Right.
24:14 Josh Clark? It's just, if you put them together, you have a, just a sketch of somebody's personality and you, you should go much deeper if you're analyzing someone.
24:23 Speaker 03 Yeah, I think, I used to think this stuff was a lot neater when I was younger. And now it kind of gives me a little anxiety.
24:30 Josh Clark? Oh, yeah?
24:31 Speaker 03 Yeah, like I just, I don't know, as far as doing this to myself, and I still enjoy therapy. Like, that's different, but I don't know, because every single one of these, I like, my answer would be, well, it depends.
24:42 Josh Clark? Well, I think, I think also, though, and I don't mean to speak for you, but one of the issues that's, that's comes up for me is if somebody goes to you and says, you know, you, you, you rate pretty high on the spectrum of neuroticism. Like, that's, obviously, you're gonna obsess about that kind of stuff, especially if they're right.
25:02 Speaker 03 It can make you neurotic.
25:03 Josh Clark? But, yeah, it's, it's a boundary that somebody has just established for you that you may need, feel the need to stay in. Because that's the boundary that you're bound by, whether you are or not.
25:15 Speaker 03 Like, this is my box.
25:16 Josh Clark? Right.
25:17 Speaker 03 I'll live in it.
25:18 Josh Clark? That would be the reason it raises anxiety for me.
25:20 Speaker 03 Yeah, well, my whole thing, like I said, though, is just depends. Every single question that I would get asked, well, not everyone, sometimes I'm pretty, like, set on something, but usually I'd say, I don't know, depends on the scenario.
25:32 Josh Clark? Right.
25:33 Speaker 03 Am I more prone in a crowd to do X or Y? Maybe.
25:38 Josh Clark? Right.
25:38 Speaker 03 Maybe not, depends on my mood.
25:40 Josh Clark? So, one, one, with these other personality tests, and, and the whole field in psychology of studying traits, personality traits, in a quantitative way is called psychometrics.
25:54 Speaker 03 Yeah.
25:55 Josh Clark? So, with these tests, the more sophisticated ones, if they had a test taker like you, they're designed to get around that. So, they're gonna ask a bunch of different questions about the same thing, but in different ways, coming from different directions. So that eventually, if you put all of them together and run them through a statistical analysis, they're actually gonna come up with your genuine answer, which is kind of one way or another.
26:20 Speaker 03 Right.
26:20 Josh Clark? The other way that they get around this, that kind of... Hemming and hawing, I guess, is by placing it on a spectrum. You're not being lumped into one category or another. It's here's one end of the spectrum. Here's the other end of the spectrum. And based on your answers, you fall somewhere around the middle. Like, almost everybody does.
26:41 Speaker 03 Right.
26:42 Josh Clark? If you look at psychometric tests, a legitimate psychometric test is going to basically look like a bell curve.
26:48 Speaker 03 Yeah.
26:48 Josh Clark? Where most people are going to be distributed toward the middle.
26:51 Speaker 03 Yeah. I think what, that's why it gives me anxiety. It's like, what's the point? Don't box me in.
26:57 Josh Clark? It's a great question.
27:00 Speaker 03 Well, I think the second half of this is a lot of what's the point?
27:03 Josh Clark? Yeah.
27:03 Speaker 03 You know? So, looking, speaking on these tests to see if it's actually, if there is a point, if it's a valid thing to do. There are a couple of measures that one must look at and that psychologists do look at. Is it valid and is it reliable? Valid in the sense that it really is a pretty good reflection of Josh or Chuck.
27:25 Josh Clark? Right.
27:25 Speaker 03 Or whoever. And is it reliable? So if we take this test tomorrow or a different test that's just, you know, maybe different questions, will it reproduce the same result?
27:37 Josh Clark? Right.
27:38 Speaker 03 And that's a big deal. Like, if you're talking science.
27:41 Josh Clark? Right.
27:41 Speaker 03 And you're trying to have a foundation that says, no, this is science. It's not just a bunch of questions, hippie dippy questions that we're asking. If you really want real data and science behind it, you have to be able to reproduce it.
27:54 Josh Clark? Right. One of the other things, too, that these tests are designed to do is to weed out fakers.
28:02 Speaker 03 Right.
28:03 Josh Clark? We'll talk a lot more about the Minnesota multi-phasic personality inventory, which is one of the big ones.
28:11 Speaker 03 Yes.
28:12 Josh Clark? Probably the most taken personality test in the world.
28:15 Speaker 03 Yeah.
28:16 Josh Clark? And it has a lot of built-in mechanisms and apparently is really good at detecting people who are faking, they're faking a mental illness, or who are trying to pretend that they aren't suffering from a mental illness.
28:30 Speaker 03 Yeah.
28:30 Josh Clark? It's really good at detecting that because it's so exhaustive. And using statistical analysis, if somebody is skewed really far one way or skewed really far the other, they're just immediately exposed as...
28:45 Josh Clark? Gaming the test as best they can.
28:47 Speaker 03 Yeah, in one way they do that, which is in its own way, its own little psychology experiment, at least, is by telling you we have ways.
28:57 Josh Clark? Right.
28:57 Speaker 03 Like you will be rooted rooted out and we will know.
28:59 Josh Clark? Exactly.
29:00 Speaker 03 So they tell people that beforehand. So you're more inclined to just be like, all right, well, screw it. I'll tell the truth.
29:05 Josh Clark? Right. Especially when they're sitting there like clearing the air out of a syringe.
29:12 Speaker 03 That's creepy.
29:13 Josh Clark? It is.
29:14 Speaker 03 All right. So let's get back to CPP and the MBTI. The Consulting Psychologists Press.
29:23 Josh Clark? Right.
29:23 Speaker 03 And the Myers-Briggs, we'll just keep calling it a test, even though they say it's not a test.
29:27 Josh Clark? It's a it's a type inventory.
29:29 Speaker 03 Yeah. So we'll just go ahead and break down the deal here. There are. The the object is to sort you into one of 16 different types, personality types, based on which side of four pairs or dichotomies that you're going to fall on. And those are, at the very base, you're either introverted or extroverted, like we said, E or I.
29:51 Josh Clark? Yeah.
29:52 Speaker 03 Sensing or intuition, S and N. And these words, they sound a little confusing. Like, what the heck does a sensing person mean?
30:01 Josh Clark? Yeah.
30:01 Speaker 03 It means you like the big data and empirical data and a lot of information.
30:07 Josh Clark? Right. Whereas intuition is like you just go with your gut. That's how you prefer to be.
30:12 Speaker 03 Correct.
30:13 Josh Clark? Right?
30:13 Speaker 03 The next we have thinking and feeling, thinking being more focused on logic. Did I say logic with a T?
30:22 Josh Clark? Sure.
30:23 Speaker 03 And objectivity. And then if you're feeling, you're going to be more interested in in relationships and harmony among your group.
30:32 Josh Clark? Those two are pretty straightforward.
30:33 Speaker 03 Yeah, I think so.
30:34 Josh Clark? And then lastly, there's judging and perceiving. Those are, that's a dichotomy. Judging is where you you prefer schedules, you prefer decisiveness. That's how you kind of approach life.
30:49 Speaker 03 Yeah.
30:49 Josh Clark? And perceiving is where you're just kind of like, whatever. Yeah, I'm not too worried about it.
30:54 Speaker 03 Yeah.
30:55 Josh Clark? That's almost kind of like the difference between the type A and type B personalities, which by the way was made up by a pair of cardiologists.
31:04 Speaker 03 Oh, really?
31:04 Josh Clark? Whose work was later secretly funded by the tobacco industry, who were looking for anything to explain heart attacks besides smoking. So they funded type A and type B personality research for years.
31:17 Speaker 03 Interesting.
31:18 Josh Clark? Yeah, it really is. There's a, just as an aside, there's a really interesting Price, I think, yeah, Price nomics article.
31:29 Speaker 03 On type A and type B?
31:30 Josh Clark? Yeah, just look it up. I don't remember the name.
31:32 Speaker 03 All right.
31:34 Speaker 03 So when you sit down to take one of these not tests with a series of questions that you answer.
31:40 Josh Clark? I think they call them instruments, by the way. Psychometric instruments.
31:45 Speaker 03 Which are basically a series of questions on a piece of paper.
31:47 Josh Clark? Yeah, it sounds like a test.
31:50 Speaker 03 They will say things like, Ed has some good examples here. When you go on a trip, do you want everything planned out in advance? Or would you rather just take each day as it comes, do whatever you feel like?
32:01 Speaker 03 Pretty straightforward kind of stuff.
32:02 Josh Clark? Right.
32:02 Speaker 03 And then they also have things like word pairs, just to see literally what word you like better, like compassion, foresight, like which word do you like better?
32:15 Josh Clark? Carrots or fruit?
32:18 Speaker 03 Fruit.
32:19 Josh Clark? Fruit, yeah. It's just prettier.
32:21 Speaker 03 It is.
32:22 Josh Clark? So I'm looking back here, I just want to say, so I think.
32:28 Speaker 03 You trying to figure out what you were?
32:29 Josh Clark? Yeah, I think E N F P, maybe? I think.
32:34 Speaker 03 That's what I was. We weren't the same thing.
32:36 Josh Clark? I don't remember. Yumi and I got the same thing. She found an old email, but she forgot to tell me what we were.
32:41 Speaker 03 Oh, really?
32:42 Josh Clark? I really, I don't know.
32:46 Josh Clark? Problem is, would we still be the same today?
32:49 Speaker 03 Yeah, and I think if I'm not mistaken, didn't we have this up on a big board in the office?
32:53 Josh Clark? For a while? I think so, yeah.
32:54 Speaker 03 That seems like a, Jerry's nodding, that seems like a breach of protocol.
32:58 Josh Clark? Sure.
32:58 Speaker 03 Like privacy.
33:00 Josh Clark? Yeah, well, again, being forced at gunpoint to do it was just from the start.
33:04 Speaker 03 I remember it was kind of fun. I had a fun day.
33:06 Josh Clark? We'll talk about that as well.
33:07 Speaker 03 Um, so it's gonna cost you, if you just do this as a single individual, um, not meaning, not married, but just a person. About fifty bucks, um, although they should charge more if you're married. It's more complex test. Uh, about fifty bucks. If you want an hour of feedback, that'll cost you an extra hundred. Uh, if you want a career report all typed up, uh, that'll be sixteen ninety-five.
33:30 Josh Clark? Yeah.
33:30 Speaker 03 And if you, um, this is fifteen hundred dollars for a onsite training class. Is that like what we had?
33:36 Josh Clark? So this is a, this is not very well explained. If you want to administer the Myers-Briggs personality or type inventory.
33:45 Speaker 03 Yeah.
33:45 Josh Clark? You can get certified. It's a four-day training course.
33:48 Speaker 03 Oh, okay.
33:49 Josh Clark? And you pay fifteen hundred to sixteen hundred dollars.
33:51 Speaker 03 Oh, that's what that is.
33:52 Josh Clark? You cannot legally administer this test, or you're infringing on their copyrights.
33:56 Speaker 03 Right.
33:56 Josh Clark? Unless you are certified by CPP to do this.
34:00 Speaker 03 And we should do it with one another on the air and risk a lawsuit.
34:03 Josh Clark? Well, yeah, well, you probably got a suit already with that one question you asked out loud.
34:08 Speaker 03 Which one? Oh, just the one?
34:09 Josh Clark? Yeah, when you go on a trip, do you want everything planned out in advance?
34:13 Speaker 03 I just made that up.
34:14 Josh Clark? Oh, good job, good job.
34:15 Speaker 03 I got that from, uh, Travelocity.
34:17 Josh Clark? Nice, okay. Yeah, that little gnome whispered it in your ear.
34:20 Speaker 03 That's right.
34:21 Josh Clark? But so you, you, uh, would go and get certified, and then now you can go around to businesses and say, hey, uh, do you want to know more about your employees? You want to know who's good at what?
34:32 Speaker 03 Right.
34:32 Josh Clark? Let me come give, uh, the Myers-Briggs type inventory to your, your, um, employees and it'll be wonderful, right? So that's how the whole process goes. You pay to become certified, and then you go become something of a, an evangelist for the Myers-Briggs test, and you sell the test. You basically become a salesman as well.
34:53 Speaker 03 Mm-hmm.
34:54 Josh Clark? It's a, it's a very interesting, um, dynamic that they have going.
34:58 Speaker 03 That is. It's a good word, dynamic. Um.
35:03 Speaker 03 They want to point out that the person taking the test is the expert.
35:11 Speaker 03 And they also use this metaphor of handedness, which I didn't fully understand. They say things like, it feels more comfortable to sign your name with your dominant hand, but technically you can sign with your non-dominant hand if you need to.
35:23 Josh Clark? Right.
35:23 Speaker 03 I'm not sure what they're trying to prove there.
35:25 Josh Clark? They're trying to say that despite the MBTI pigeonholing you fully in one category or another, rather than on a spectrum, they're saying that category that it's pigeonholing you into is actually just your preference. It's not you specifically, it's just.
35:44 Speaker 03 Your incline predisposition.
35:45 Josh Clark? Yeah, you tend to be an extrovert, but of course, everybody likes their own personal alone time. So yeah, you're going to be an introvert once in a while, but you're an extrovert more than than other times.
35:57 Speaker 03 Yeah, because I can't sign my name with my left hand. That, I didn't like that analogy because it literally, I can barely hold a pen with my left hand. I'm seeing you're doing it right now.
36:10 Josh Clark? Wow, that's pretty bad.
36:11 Speaker 03 If I tried to do it, it would look like a, a three-year-old with arthritis has tried to like scribble it out.
36:19 Josh Clark? Mine, mine looks like UDM.
36:22 Speaker 03 UDM?
36:23 Josh Clark? UDM.
36:25 Speaker 03 UDM?
36:25 Josh Clark? Yeah, UDM. It's my signature with my left hand.
36:30 Speaker 03 And they do, they do try and point out, like you said, that
36:36 Speaker 03 it's interesting because they box you in, but at the same time, they're saying, but you know, like you said, it's just predisposition. Don't really think of it about you being this type of person, even though you are an ENFP.
36:50 Josh Clark? Right.
36:51 Speaker 03 Like you said, it was earlier, it was almost numbered. I mean, it is, it's lettered.
36:55 Josh Clark? Right. This is a different way of quantifying it.
36:58 Speaker 03 Yeah.
37:00 Josh Clark? But without numbers. All right. You want to take a break? And then come back and, and maybe do a little criticism?
37:07 Speaker 03 Yeah.
37:07 Josh Clark? Okay.
37:29 Speaker 05 Literalmente, un momentico para ti. How's your corazón feeling today? If it's a little tired, a little oof, you're not alone. Have you eaten algo rico, taken a deep breath? Maybe even turned off your phone for cinco minutitos? I promise, the memes will still be there. Sometimes self-care isn't candles and meditation. It's just saying no. It's drinking a little bit of agua. It's letting yourself rest sin pena. You don't have to prove anything today. Just be, breathe. Estas haciendo lo mejor que puedes. And yes, that's enough. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there.
38:06 Speaker 04 Hello, hello, I'm Malcolm Gladwell, host of Smart Talks with IBM. I spoke with IBM's Ana Paula Acees about what digital sovereignty actually means in the age of AI.
38:17 Speaker 00 AI now moves from somebody operating a system to the technology actually making decisions. So you have to have a much better visibility of what AI is touching, data it is accessing, and where.
38:33 Speaker 04 Hear the full conversation wherever you get your podcasts.
38:48 Josh Clark? All right, Chuck, like I said, it's kind of a pastime in the United States to tee off on the Myers-Briggs type inventory.
38:56 Speaker 03 Yeah, this is not us here. This is a
38:57 Josh Clark? No, this is us talking about other people teeing off on it.
39:00 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's widely been criticized over the years from psychologists and, well,
39:08 Speaker 03 amateur know-nothings like us.
39:11 Josh Clark? Sure.
39:12 Speaker 03 One of the big criticisms is that companies use this stuff in hiring and firing and promoting.
39:20 Josh Clark? But even the Myers-Briggs people, CPP, say, like, don't do that.
39:24 Speaker 03 Well, I know, but they say that, but then don't go to an office and get hired by a corporation to administer it.
39:31 Josh Clark? Right, or go sell your services, you know?
39:34 Speaker 03 Yeah.
39:34 Josh Clark? Yeah, agreed. And that's part of the problem. To me, that is more
39:42 Josh Clark? Um, the corporation's fault.
39:46 Speaker 03 Mm hmm. Well, sure.
39:47 Josh Clark? Like, if you have an HR person who's like, diehard believer in the MBTI.
39:54 Speaker 03 Yeah.
39:54 Josh Clark? And will hire or fire somebody based on their MBTI type.
39:59 Speaker 03 Mm hmm.
40:00 Josh Clark? Fire that person.
40:01 Speaker 03 Yeah.
40:02 Josh Clark? Because you have a real dum-dum on your hands.
40:04 Speaker 03 They're a DD.
40:05 Josh Clark? And they should not be responsible for people's livelihoods.
40:09 Speaker 03 Yeah.
40:09 Josh Clark? Even, I don't think they would put it quite in those terms, but even the Myers-Briggs people say like, you shouldn't use this for hiring or firing. And yet, yes, some people do. Some people swear by this. The impression that I have is that the Myers-Briggs people tend to think of this as more like a team-building exercise.
40:30 Speaker 03 Right.
40:31 Josh Clark? Or where like a certified MBTI administrator can come to your place, get all your employees together, and they find out like all their personality types. And by the way, there's not a single negative personality type. And all personality types are equal.
40:49 Speaker 03 Sure.
40:49 Josh Clark? So everybody gets a participant ribbon in the form of their personality type.
40:53 Speaker 03 Yeah.
40:53 Josh Clark? And, um, but at the same time, and this seems to be the crux. At the same time, everybody's finding out like, oh, you're a little different than me, and I'm a little different than you.
41:03 Speaker 03 Yeah.
41:04 Josh Clark? And we all have differences and different perspectives. So let's celebrate that and let's respect one another's differences. And there is the actual point, from what I understand, of the Myers-Briggs type inventory and taking it in a corporate setting.
41:19 Speaker 03 That's what stands out to me as what happened with us was.
41:22 Josh Clark? Right.
41:23 Speaker 03 I remember it kind of being a fun day.
41:24 Josh Clark? They were like tootsie rolls.
41:26 Speaker 03 Yeah, we all goofed off and had a good time. And the person leading it, if they're good at what they do, which this person was, is always. You know, it's always kind of a fun person and cracking jokes and they don't take it too seriously.
41:38 Josh Clark? Right.
41:39 Speaker 03 None of us took it too seriously. And we all had a good time and it did, it was very much like a team building thing.
41:46 Josh Clark? Right. So as long as there's like a wink, wink, nudge, nudge kind of thing.
41:49 Speaker 03 Yeah.
41:50 Josh Clark? And the people who take it, actually take it seriously are taken off to the side by their HR rep to say like, no, this is a a little less serious than you're taking it. Then it's fine. But yes, once you start deciding people's fate based on this, then you have real problems because as just about anybody will tell you, the Myers-Briggs type inventory is based at best on some shaky science, if at all. If you go back to the very beginning, it's based on the theories of Carl Jung, which have never been based on science. They were basically personal observations by Jung. And the psychology community has disavowed Jung in large part.
42:30 Josh Clark? So therefore, anything based on his teachings and theories is by proxy disavowed as well. But if that weren't enough, psychology as a field loves going after the Myers-Briggs type inventory. Just loves it as totally baseless scientifically.
42:46 Speaker 03 All right. So we've got shouldn't use it to hire and fire in corporations or give promotions.
42:54 Josh Clark? Right.
42:54 Speaker 03 We have not based on real science and scientific data.
42:59 Josh Clark? Right.
43:02 Speaker 03 These four dichotomies are problematic in and of themselves because
43:07 Speaker 03 everyone is on a spectrum. You can't say like, you know, you answered these 10 questions. So you're either this or you're that.
43:14 Josh Clark? Right.
43:16 Speaker 03 And when one of the rebuttals, because I think Ed interviewed someone from CPP, right?
43:21 Josh Clark? Yeah.
43:22 Speaker 03 One of the rebuttals about being a non-repeatab
43:27 Speaker 03 Experiment of sorts is like, hey, yesterday I was an ENFP and today I'm this. They'll say, well, you know what, if you had different answers, that means you were sort of on the cusp, right there in that center line on some of these questions. And you might've just leapt over to that other side, which means you're basically kind of down the center. Yet they don't have a categorization.
43:49 Josh Clark? Right.
43:49 Speaker 03 For down the center.
43:50 Josh Clark? Yeah, because depending on, as Ed puts it, you could answer all 24 questions on the feeling side.
43:58 Speaker 03 Yeah.
43:58 Josh Clark? And you're going to get the same result as somebody who answered 11 questions for thinking and 13 questions for feeling.
44:04 Speaker 03 Right.
44:05 Josh Clark? Same thing, you're still both an F in that respect. And I saw elsewhere, it put like, if the Myers-Briggs test measured height, you would either be tall or short.
44:15 Speaker 03 Yeah.
44:16 Josh Clark? You could say, well, actually, I'm right there in the middle. And they'd be like, well, that's short.
44:20 Speaker 03 Right.
44:20 Josh Clark? Or for you, it's short. For the guy who is the same exact height, they're tall.
44:25 Speaker 03 Right, and trust me, nobody that's 5'10" likes to be considered short.
44:29 Josh Clark? Right.
44:29 Speaker 03 I can say that from experience.
44:31 Josh Clark? Because you're not, you're in, you're average.
44:33 Speaker 03 I'm average.
44:33 Josh Clark? Right, so.
44:34 Speaker 03 I like being average.
44:35 Josh Clark? The fact that there isn't a spectrum is one thing that really makes it in stark contrast of other, much more widely accepted psychometric instruments.
44:47 Speaker 03 For sure. Ed also points out too, the Grabster, that there, the construction of the instrument itself is problematic. Because one, like we talked about, it's self-reporting. Anytime you're self-reporting, there's going to be some weird bias in there.
45:04 Josh Clark? Sure.
45:04 Speaker 03 Just almost impossible to avoid 100%.
45:07 Josh Clark? That's right.
45:08 Speaker 03 And the other one is that, he says, a couple of these dichotomies are entangled, which I never really thought about that, but that's a pretty good point.
45:17 Josh Clark? Yeah.
45:18 Speaker 03 So judging-perceiving scale are correlated with answers on the sensing-intuition scale. And if you, like, those should be separated out, for sure.
45:30 Josh Clark? For sure.
45:31 Speaker 03 I don't know why they don't.
45:34 Josh Clark? I don't either.
45:34 Speaker 03 You know?
45:35 Josh Clark? Because they've really put a lot of work into this.
45:37 Speaker 03 Yeah. I mean, it's not baked in stone from the 1940s and 50s and 60s, is it?
45:43 Josh Clark? No, it's not. And even while they were creating, it was an ongoing exhaustive process that Mrs. Briggs and Mrs. Myers engaged in.
45:53 Speaker 03 Yeah, we don't want to give, they spent decades on this.
45:56 Josh Clark? Yes.
45:56 Speaker 03 It wasn't like something they threw together.
45:57 Josh Clark? No, the problem is, is they, they did it backwards. They came up with the personality types and then set about
46:04 Speaker 03 Right.
46:05 Josh Clark? creating the test that would detect these personality types, rather than going out and testing people, seeing what personality types emerged, and then figuring out a test to find that in other people. They did it backwards.
46:17 Speaker 03 That's a good point.
46:17 Josh Clark? It was based on Jung, but it was not for lack of trying. Like, as a matter of fact, one of the first things they did after they, they started to really establish the test, was they, they managed to administer it to like 5,000 George Washington University medical students.
46:31 Speaker 03 Uh huh.
46:32 Josh Clark? And they, they took those results and tracked the students to see what fields of medicine they went in. They like really worked on this. I wrote an article in the Washington Post where this, I think Isabel Myers's son remembers, their vacations were basically like fact finding missions all around the country. Like, they would go administer tests, like, everything was about this test, and they worked on it for decades. So, yeah, the problem is, it was just, it's just not based on science. They didn't follow the scientific method.
47:05 Speaker 03 Yeah.
47:06 Josh Clark? So, sci- so, science kind of poo-poos the MBTI. But wait, wait, wait, get back here, because a lot of these criticisms fall just as easily on every other psychometric test around.
47:22 Speaker 03 Well, yeah, and that's one of the things that, I can't remember who was interviewed in here, but, in one of those other articles you sent, one of the Myers, or, I don't know if it was, or maybe it was a Rorschach defender.
47:35 Josh Clark? Right.
47:37 Speaker 03 Said, you know, like, everyone, yeah, it was Rorschach, like, everyone's always picking on Rorschach.
47:41 Josh Clark? Right.
47:41 Speaker 03 When all of these psychological tests are You know, subject to criticism.
47:48 Josh Clark? They are.
47:48 Speaker 03 You know?
47:49 Josh Clark? I think it's really easy for to tee off on Rorschach as well, because, I mean, we're talking inkblots, man. It is the epitome of subjective self-reporting. You're saying, I, uh, let's see, in this one, I see mom's boobs. Uh, yeah, mom's boobs in that one, too.
48:07 Speaker 03 This one is dad's boobs.
48:07 Josh Clark? Right, exactly. So, and then from that, it was strictly up to, uh, initially Rorschach, who I think came up with this test in 1915, 1917.
48:17 Speaker 03 Was the name Herman?
48:19 Josh Clark? Uh, I think so. He's a Swiss psychiatrist.
48:22 Speaker 03 Herman Rorschach?
48:22 Josh Clark? It was, it was initially up to him and then later on his followers to interpret this, which is basically like interpreting dreams.
48:32 Speaker 03 Yeah.
48:33 Josh Clark? And, um.
48:34 Speaker 03 So subjective.
48:35 Josh Clark? Totally subjective, from beginning to end. And then in, I think, 1975, a guy at Bowling Green State University, uh, which is right outside of Toledo,
48:46 Josh Clark? came up with this, a really exhaustive interpretive test that sought to quantify Rorschach answers.
48:56 Speaker 03 Yeah, John Exner.
48:57 Josh Clark? Yeah.
48:58 Speaker 03 Uh, and it was a test called the Comprehensive System, uh, 140 components. And in this article you sent, they said that Rorschach was probably going away, um, had it not been for Exner's accompaniment, um, with this other process.
49:14 Josh Clark? Right, and even today, he's got an institute in Asheville that's dedicated to the Rorschach test, right? So, one thing I've noticed from researching this is each of these personality inventories has like its adherents and its detractors.
49:30 Speaker 03 Yeah.
49:30 Josh Clark? And just judging from the outside, it looks a lot like cults.
49:34 Speaker 03 Yeah.
49:34 Josh Clark? Gathered around their various idols, right?
49:37 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's interesting.
49:38 Josh Clark? There's like the original figurehead who came up with it and everybody worships them. And then he's attacked by these other followers who have a very similar figurehead.
49:45 Speaker 03 Yeah.
49:46 Josh Clark? Who came up with something very similar, but it's just different enough that, that there's a huge chasm between the two. And there's a lot of dogma surrounding it. But, uh, the Rorschach test in particular is apparently well-known to give wildly inaccurate results.
50:01 Speaker 03 I took one today.
50:02 Josh Clark? Did you?
50:03 Speaker 03 Online.
50:03 Josh Clark? How'd you do?
50:04 Speaker 03 Uh, I got two out of 10, which means, um, I was only two. Two away, whatever that means, from being labeled like a psychotic.
50:14 Josh Clark? So, yeah, there was a-
50:15 Speaker 03 You get four out of 10, I think.
50:16 Josh Clark? There was a- oh, really?
50:17 Speaker 03 I think that's what it said, yeah.
50:18 Josh Clark? Wow, that's close.
50:19 Speaker 03 And this is an online test. I don't know if it's like how true it was to the original.
50:24 Josh Clark? I gotcha.
50:25 Speaker 03 Or maybe the original.
50:26 Josh Clark? Yeah, could be. And then they have a algorithm that runs the analysis for you?
50:31 Speaker 03 I kept seeing all kinds of things when I looked at it. And I've never done an inkblot test. I would say, "Oh, that looks like a bat." And then they'll say, "No, it's like two bunnies." And then, "No, it looks like a cool Mardi Gras mask."
50:41 Josh Clark? Did it- did they move to you? Did you see colors?
50:44 Speaker 03 Well, some of them were colored.
50:45 Josh Clark? Oh, okay.
50:46 Speaker 03 Most of them were black. And they had a- the one I took had a one and a two, like, um, what do you see? And what's like a secondary thing that you see?
50:55 Josh Clark? Right.
50:56 Speaker 03 So, you know.
50:57 Josh Clark? Supposedly, people who are supporters of the Rorschach test say, "No, man, there's- we don't know how it's working, but if you see movement in the Rorschach inkblot, it's suggestive of depression or something like that." And they say statistically it's correlated. But like I was saying, it's also notorious for giving incorrect results.
51:16 Speaker 03 Yeah, like saying you're- you have a mental illness.
51:18 Josh Clark? Right, okay. So, there was this study in 2000 that was given to like 100 mentally sound elementary school kids.
51:26 Speaker 03 Yeah.
51:27 Josh Clark? And some like high percentage of them came back as borderline psychotic because of the Rorschach test, right? And it's hilarious to hear stories like that. Like, I'm laughing inside right now. But, um, the problem is, is you're at the very least being labeled as psychotic.
51:44 Speaker 03 Sure.
51:45 Josh Clark? Not a label you want in society.
51:47 Speaker 03 No.
51:47 Josh Clark? And it was because of this inkblot test that's 100 years old.
51:51 Speaker 03 Yeah.
51:52 Josh Clark? And then, secondly, these tests are also being submitted and accepted as evidence in criminal trials.
52:00 Speaker 03 That's the biggest part.
52:01 Josh Clark? Child custody cases?
52:03 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, they're- they're still given real weight and like- Lives are changed and ruined based on looking at 100-year-old inkblots.
52:11 Josh Clark? Yes.
52:11 Speaker 03 And a person's subjective analysis of that.
52:14 Josh Clark? That's not okay.
52:15 Speaker 03 No, this, um, Howard Garb in this one article you sent, he's a co-author of What's Wrong with the Rorschach. And he is head of psych- or at least at the time of this article, he may still be head of psychological testing for the Air Force. Uh, he said that even with Exner's comprehensive system, he said only 10% of his system even meets the most basic scientific standards. And um, they did the examined data of over 30 different Rorschach studies. And he said, they all have a tendency to label healthy people mentally ill.
52:47 Josh Clark? Right.
52:48 Speaker 03 And if you're trying to get custody of your kid, or if you are on trial as a criminal, like it's just, that's the last thing you need.
52:55 Josh Clark? Yeah.
52:55 Speaker 03 Is somebody's subjective opinion of, is it a bunny or is it a bat?
53:01 Josh Clark? Oh, he said a bat. Take that kid.
53:03 Speaker 03 You know?
53:03 Josh Clark? Quick.
53:04 Speaker 03 Kid's like, I like bunnies.
53:07 Josh Clark? The um, another one that that we have to talk about is the MMPI, now the MMPI dash two, I think as of 2012, they revised it dramatically.
53:17 Speaker 03 Yeah, does this one, is that right? It has over 500 questions?
53:21 Josh Clark? Yeah.
53:21 Speaker 03 Wow.
53:22 Josh Clark? Some of them originally were about like your bowel movements.
53:25 Speaker 03 Okay.
53:26 Josh Clark? Um, really nutso questions that supposedly really got to the heart of whether you were mentally disturbed or not, right?
53:36 Speaker 03 Yeah.
53:36 Josh Clark? And it was created at the University of Minnesota in the 40s by a psychiatrist and a neurologist, I believe. And they hit upon a pretty clever idea. They said, we're not going to interpret the results, right? And say, you know, oh, this person said that they do feel like smashing something sometimes.
53:57 Speaker 03 Yeah.
53:57 Josh Clark? And that means this. Instead, we're going to come up with this test of like 504 questions. And we're going to give it to the patient or the family and staff of a mental hospital who we're sure are sane. And we're going to take their answers and they're going to become our control group, our baseline.
54:18 Speaker 03 Yeah.
54:18 Josh Clark? So then anybody who takes this test, we're going to compare the test taker's answers to the sane control group's answers. And, you know, depending on how it relates to the sane control group, they're either mentally ill or not.
54:32 Speaker 03 You better have gotten that control group right.
54:33 Josh Clark? Well, that's the thing.
54:34 Speaker 03 To begin with.
54:35 Josh Clark? So, a group of like, family and friends in Minnesota is the picture of sanity throughout the world is the basis of this test. That's a huge problem with it to begin with.
54:46 Speaker 03 Yeah.
54:46 Josh Clark? But apparently, a lot of people say like, no, it really has, it does a pretty good job of sussing out mental illness.
54:54 Speaker 03 Yeah.
54:55 Josh Clark? Um, it's also really good at detecting faker, faking one way or the other.
54:59 Speaker 03 Yeah.
55:00 Josh Clark? Um, but it's, it's too invasive. And when companies use it for hiring and firing, it's way too invasive. And apparently lawsuits have been filed against companies for using it.
55:11 Speaker 03 Well, I think that, um, most people are far more, um, troubled than they ever let on in life.
55:23 Josh Clark? Sure.
55:23 Speaker 03 And, um, part of success in life comes down to how good you are at, um, covering that up, or hiding it, or dealing with it and processing it.
55:37 Josh Clark? Yeah, that's optimal.
55:37 Speaker 03 Coming to terms with it. Um, it's just to find a core group that are quote unquote, sane, normal people.
55:47 Josh Clark? Right.
55:47 Speaker 03 Um, it's just, you're starting off with a, a problem, if you ask me.
55:52 Josh Clark? A faulty premise, right?
55:53 Speaker 03 Yeah, it just, there's no way. Like, everyone has their issues, their deep, dark, uh, things that their brain that they don't want anyone to know. Sometimes even the people closest to them don't even know.
56:05 Josh Clark? Yeah. And actually, you, you're in agreement with this, a sociologist named William White, who criticized the MMPI as a, a tool that helped to create and perpetuate the oppressive group think of mid-century organization man.
56:22 Speaker 03 Yeah.
56:22 Josh Clark? Where it's basically like, here is what we think is normal. Anything outside of that is abnormal. And we're not going to hire you because you don't fit into this picture of normalcy, which is basically white crew cut Minnesota.
56:33 Speaker 03 Yeah.
56:34 Josh Clark? From the 40s.
56:35 Speaker 03 Right.
56:35 Josh Clark? That's the picture of normalcy. That's highly debatable.
56:39 Speaker 03 Uh, the other thing I thought was interesting is a lot of skeptics and critics point to things like the MBTI, uh, and saying, this is just like astrology.
56:49 Josh Clark? Yeah.
56:49 Speaker 03 It's really no different than reading your horoscope, because it's all positive psychology. Um, at the end of a, of a Myers-Briggs, um, non-test.
56:58 Speaker 03 No one walks away feeling bad usually. It's all sort of positive wording and like, like this is what you are. You're just this. So kind of don't worry about it. The same way you read your horoscope in a, in a given day. I mean, how many horoscopes say like, um, today you, you will be prone to depression and wonder what it's all about.
57:19 Josh Clark? Right. Maybe you should work on your core character because people don't like being around you that much. You don't hear that kind of stuff.
57:26 Speaker 03 No.
57:26 Josh Clark? But that taps into what's called the Forer effect. F O R E R. There is a psychiatrist named Bertram Forer.
57:33 Speaker 03 I thought this was so interesting.
57:35 Josh Clark? He, he, well, take it. It's pretty interesting stuff.
57:37 Speaker 03 Well, I mean, basically didn't he give the same? He had people take these tests and then gave all of the people the exact same assessment.
57:45 Josh Clark? Right.
57:46 Speaker 03 But telling everyone it was tailored for them, their own personality assessment. And I think the people who just thought it was favorable were like, this is great.
57:53 Josh Clark? Well, it was favorable. He actually called it from daily horoscopes.
57:57 Speaker 03 Well, yeah, but what were they responding positively to?
58:00 Josh Clark? Well, they, it was.
58:01 Speaker 03 Whether or not they wanted to feel that way about themselves?
58:03 Josh Clark? It was a positive assessment. There was nothing negative in there. So it was all positive stuff. Like you have a lot of unused potential, that kind of stuff. Stuff people wanted to identify with, right? So the more flattering it was, the more likely the people were to say, this is an accurate assessment of me.
58:19 Speaker 03 Oh, okay.
58:20 Josh Clark? So despite the fact that it was the same one given to the entire class, he took their answers and threw them out and said, here's your assessment. It was the same one for everybody.
58:27 Speaker 03 That's about right.
58:28 Josh Clark? It got like an 85% accuracy from the class as a whole.
58:31 Speaker 03 Well, that's what I wanted to do was about the 15% where those people just super honest.
58:35 Josh Clark? Maybe.
58:36 Speaker 03 And like, no, this really.
58:37 Josh Clark? No, people actually don't like being around me. I'm using all of my potential and they still don't like me.
58:43 Speaker 03 Yeah, that's what I couldn't figure out. But I guess that makes sense. There are people out there that are, I think I would be one of those that would be like, this isn't right.
58:50 Josh Clark? Yeah.
58:51 Speaker 03 I'm not like that.
58:52 Josh Clark? Sure.
58:53 Speaker 03 You got anything else?
58:54 Josh Clark? I think not.
58:56 Speaker 03 This is a good one. We've been, we've been wanting to do this for a while.
58:59 Josh Clark? Yeah. This is a special request by me.
59:02 Speaker 03 And others.
59:05 Josh Clark? Uh, if you want to know more about personality tests, well, you can go take them online. They're kind of huge right now. Uh, find out what kind of, um, hobbit you are. I don't know.
59:16 Speaker 03 What box do you live in?
59:17 Josh Clark? Yeah. And in the meantime, you can type personality test in the search bar at houseofworks.com. And since I said that, it's time for listener mail.
59:28 Speaker 03 The only thing that should live in a box is
59:32 Speaker 03 temporary housing for a pet frog.
59:35 Josh Clark? That's not bad. Or the stuff you find in a tree hole that Boo Radley left for you.
59:40 Speaker 03 Yeah, that can live in a box. Uh, hey, guys. Feel compelled to write you today to tell you how grateful I am for your show and praise your good work. Recently became a listener and I'm working my way through the entire archive. Think a lot of folks might be able to relate to this. Until recently, I found out I found it really hard to relax and suffer with anxiety. Two months ago, I read an article basically pointing out how our obsession with being productive and associated guilt is a modern phenomenon. I think that for sure, you know?
1:00:10 Josh Clark? Yep.
1:00:10 Speaker 03 Although I had heard this before, something really clicked in my head. So I decided to abandon guilt and embrace relaxation, taking control of my own stress levels. You guys have been a big part of this. I have taken the time to slowly potter around my flat, go for walks while listening and learning to your fascinating podcasts, and they've lifted my mood. I feel mentally healthier than I ever have before.
1:00:32 Josh Clark? Nice.
1:00:32 Speaker 03 Although the content of what you discuss might not always be positive, the way in which you explain them and your own views personally revive my hope in humanity.
1:00:40 Josh Clark? That is ridiculously flattering.
1:00:42 Speaker 03 Isn't that nice?
1:00:42 Josh Clark? Yeah.
1:00:43 Speaker 03 I guess I should also mention that a big part of my tackling anxiety levels has been to abandon watching television.
1:00:49 Josh Clark? And fistfuls of psychotropic drugs.
1:00:52 Speaker 03 I would be really interested to know if there's been any research conducted into the effect TV has upon our lives. Oh, I'm sure there has been.
1:00:58 Josh Clark? Sure.
1:00:59 Speaker 03 I haven't owned a TV for many years, but my partner has since subscribed to an online provider. And I realize how watching TV has not helped my anxiety. I also remember reading that after TVs became mainstream in Bhutan, their crime rate went up something like 700%. Might prove an interesting topic for a future show.
1:01:17 Josh Clark? Yeah.
1:01:18 Speaker 03 Anyway, sincerely grateful. Keep it up. I'm now recommending your shows to as many people as I can. Big love from the UK, Mac.
1:01:25 Josh Clark? Thanks a lot, Mac. That was great. We hear from a lot of people, actually, who say that we help them with their anxiety. No idea how, but it doesn't matter. So, thank you.
1:01:34 Speaker 03 Yep.
1:01:35 Josh Clark? Yep. If you want to get in touch with us like Mac did, you can send us an email to stuffpodcast@iHeartRadio.com.
1:01:45 Speaker 00 Stuff You Should Know is a production of iHeartRadio. For more podcasts, iHeartRadio, visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows.
1:02:01 Josh Clark? Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability, and it starts with a great deal on an off-road-ready Tacoma or half-ton Tundra, two of Toyota's longest-lasting trucks, combining power for work, tech for adventures, and style in between. And they're built on a reputation for quality and reliability, which is why Toyota trucks are known for holding their value, which could mean big savings when it's time for your next Toyota. So get a great deal today and a great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for more. Toyota, let's go places.
1:02:32 Speaker 00 She's been thinking about this sleepover all week, but I think about her food allergies all the time. Fortunately, her doctor prescribed Zolair, omalizumab. It's proven to significantly reduce allergic reactions if a food allergy accident happens.
1:02:45 Speaker 05 Zolair 150mg is a prescription medication used to treat food allergy in people one year of age and older to reduce allergic reactions due to accidental exposure to one or more foods. While taking Zolair, you should continue to avoid all foods to which you are allergic. Don't use if you are allergic to Zolair. Zolair may cause a severe, life-threatening allergic reaction called anaphylaxis. Tell your doctor if you ever had anaphylaxis. Get help right away if you have trouble breathing or if you have swelling of your throat or tongue. Zolair should not be used for the emergency treatment of allergic reactions, including anaphylaxis. Zolair is for maintenance use to reduce allergic reactions, including anaphylaxis, while avoiding food allergens. Serious side effects such as cancer, fever, muscle aches and rash, parasitic infection, or heart and circulation problems have been reported. Please see zolair.com for full prescribing information. Ask an allergist about Zolair.
1:03:28 Speaker 05 This is an advertisement for Zolair, paid for by Genentech and Novartis.
1:03:32 Speaker 06 This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human.
Previous Pop Tarts: No Fruit Necessary Next AM Radio: Solid Gold Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated