Pod Insights Stuff You Should Know Selects: How ESP Works (?) About this episode Even though almost half of Americans believe in it, ESP usually is treated as a load of bull by skeptics. But some respected researchers have dared to apply the scientific method to investigate ESP and a few have found some surprising results. Find out all about it with Josh and Chuck in this classic episode.
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 10,743 words · 10 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human.
0:04 Josh Clark? Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota Ford ability, and it starts with a great deal on an off-road-ready Tacoma or half-ton Tundra, two of Toyota's longest-lasting trucks, combining power for work, tech for adventures, and style in between. And they're built on a reputation for quality and reliability, which is why Toyota trucks are known for holding their value, which could mean big savings when it's time for your next Toyota. So get a great deal today and a great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for more. Toyota, let's go places. Introducing Voices of VivGart. VivGart is also known as its generic name, Fgart Tigamod Alpha F Cab, and this new show features firsthand stories from people living with a rare disease.
0:45 Josh Clark? Hosted by Andrew Stratton, these perspectives highlight that life is more than a moment, a condition, or a tough day. Living with a rare disease can be challenging, but it does not define the Voices of VivGart. In these episodes, they share their stories, from diagnosis to working with their care team on their treatment plan. Listen to Voices of VivGart on the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
1:08 Speaker 02 Do you ever feel like your computer is tracking you? Well, it's not. It's your browser following you. But not if you come back to Firefox. Firefox blocks the trackers automatically, doesn't follow you from site to site, and supports the ad blockers other browsers dropped. Plus, you can switch AI on or off when its intelligence is acting too artificial. And switching? Totally painless. Your bookmarks, passwords, and browsing history come right with you. Come back to Firefox. Visit firefox.com.
1:39 Josh Clark? Hey, guys, it's Josh, and for this week's select, I've chosen our 2015 episode on ESP. It's a really good one. We talk about all sorts of things about ESP, including the science. And I know what you're thinking. You're thinking, science and ESP? Yes, indeed. And that's one of the things that makes this episode so cool. So I hope you will open your mind, tune in, turn on, drop out, keep on truckin', and enjoy this episode.
2:12 Speaker 00 Welcome to Stuff You Should Know, a production of iHeart Radio.
2:21 Josh Clark? Hey and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh Clark. There's Charles W., Chuck Bryant, and Jerry's over there. I didn't even have to look.
2:30 Speaker 03 Why?
2:30 Josh Clark? I just knew.
2:32 Speaker 03 Uh, yes, and dudes and dudettes, we are in our new studio.
2:37 Josh Clark? Yeah, can you tell? Does it sound different?
2:39 Speaker 03 It's the very first one, and it's tiny.
2:43 Josh Clark? Wait, what do you mean it's the very first one?
2:45 Speaker 03 Very, very first podcast that we've recorded in here.
2:47 Josh Clark? Oh, gotcha.
2:48 Speaker 03 Yeah.
2:48 Josh Clark? Yeah.
2:49 Speaker 03 Uh, I was gonna say, I said tiny, but it's not tiny. It's cozy, but it is all, uh, all ours.
2:55 Josh Clark? Yeah.
2:56 Speaker 03 All ours.
2:57 Josh Clark? Everybody else at House of Works doesn't really know that yet, but they will.
3:01 Speaker 03 Uh, yeah, because when, uh, we actually have butt detection, and when someone sits down in these seats that aren't us, they get a shock.
3:07 Josh Clark? Yeah, and plus an alarm goes off at our desks.
3:10 Speaker 03 Yeah, what's that called? DMR?
3:11 Josh Clark? TMI.
3:12 Speaker 03 Oh. Uh, how are you, sir?
3:16 Josh Clark? I'm pretty good.
3:17 Speaker 03 I feel like this is fancy. This is our first real, like, studio. That's not true.
3:22 Josh Clark? Uh, no, I'm trying to remember. The last one was, no.
3:26 Speaker 03 But it's not a utility closet. It's not a lactation room.
3:29 Josh Clark? It's not, yeah.
3:30 Speaker 03 It's not a murder room.
3:31 Josh Clark? It's not in, like, an office with, like, desk, like, office furniture?
3:35 Speaker 03 Yeah.
3:36 Josh Clark? It's a, it's a studio that was built out for the specific purpose of recording podcasts.
3:41 Speaker 03 Yep, all we have to do, uh, is put up our Aaron Cooper originals, the artwork.
3:45 Josh Clark? Got a couple of those waiting to go.
3:46 Speaker 03 And, uh, we gotta work on the lighting in here a little bit.
3:49 Josh Clark? Yeah.
3:50 Speaker 03 Jerry said she's gonna hang some china balls for us.
3:53 Josh Clark? Yeah, she keeps pushing the china balls.
3:56 Speaker 03 Um, so anyway, enough about that. We just wanted to say we're super excited to be in our new office and our new studio.
4:02 Josh Clark? It does feel good.
4:03 Speaker 03 Yeah.
4:04 Josh Clark? Kudos for that intro.
4:07 Speaker 03 Yeah.
4:09 Josh Clark? Uh, I'm not gonna say that I knew you were gonna say that.
4:13 Speaker 03 Yeah, I was gonna say that, too.
4:15 Josh Clark? I knew that you were thinking of saying that, Chuck.
4:18 Speaker 03 Yes, uh, ESP.
4:21 Josh Clark? Do you believe in ESP?
4:23 Speaker 03 No.
4:24 Josh Clark? No, not at all.
4:26 Josh Clark? What do you think it is? Because surely, I mean, just about anyone could agree that humans have some sort of ability somehow to make good guesses or to predict the future, whatever you want to call it. Do you agree? Or do you think it's strictly just us selectively paying attention to random instances over others?
4:48 Speaker 03 I think it's that. And as we'll talk about, I think it's the, just the nature of coincidence is going to happen because so many things happen every day that something is bound to seem like something you dreamed about the night before at some point in your life.
5:09 Josh Clark? Yeah.
5:10 Speaker 03 But the other millions of dreams you have that don't, I think those are the ones that are the tell.
5:16 Josh Clark? I got you.
5:17 Speaker 03 You know? Do you?
5:20 Josh Clark? I don't know. Like, I want to. I spent so many years of my life believing in stuff like that. And wanting to go to Duke University to study at their parapsychology department.
5:31 Speaker 03 Did you really?
5:32 Josh Clark? Yeah. You know, believing in ghosts and all this. And just that's how I spent my childhood, just reading about stuff like that voraciously.
5:39 Speaker 03 So Ghostbusters really did a number on you?
5:42 Josh Clark? Yeah.
5:42 Speaker 03 Yeah.
5:43 Josh Clark? Yeah, when that came along, I was like, this was made for me.
5:46 Speaker 03 Yeah.
5:47 Josh Clark? But as an adult, it's not so much that I believe in ESP. It's more that I refuse to just utterly disbelieve in the possibility of it.
6:01 Speaker 03 Sure. Okay.
6:02 Josh Clark? You know what I mean?
6:03 Speaker 03 Yeah, I got you there because we don't know everything about everything yet.
6:06 Josh Clark? Right.
6:07 Speaker 03 But, yeah, I'm in the other camp. And I'm not even going to say the skeptic camp because those people just bug me.
6:14 Josh Clark? Has a bad name, due to some bad apples. Not all skeptics.
6:18 Speaker 03 No.
6:19 Josh Clark? But there are some that are horses' asses.
6:23 Josh Clark? Can we say that?
6:25 Speaker 03 I don't know.
6:25 Josh Clark? We'll find out.
6:26 Speaker 03 Um, all right, well, let's talk about, and I thought this was interesting because I never knew that ESP is just a big collective term for all manner of paranormal phenomena, which you could also call psi.
6:41 Josh Clark? Yeah, and so a dude named JB Rhine,
6:43 Speaker 03 Yeah.
6:43 Josh Clark? who we'll talk about later, he coined ESP.
6:45 Speaker 03 The granddaddy.
6:46 Josh Clark? Uh huh, and then in the 40s, another guy coined the term psi. And psi is the, a Greek letter, and it's equated with psyche or the soul.
6:55 Speaker 03 Yeah, PSI.
6:56 Josh Clark? And the reason that the guy chose psi is because he felt ESP suggested it was something supernatural.
7:03 Speaker 03 Yeah, sure.
7:04 Josh Clark? And psi, he felt suggested that this is a normal part of humanity, we just don't understand it.
7:10 Speaker 03 It's, it sounds like science.
7:13 Josh Clark? You're right.
7:14 Speaker 03 Um, but there are several categories of ESP. Um, and this is the one I never knew the actual definitions for these. I sort of just threw them all in a bag together.
7:24 Josh Clark? Mm-hmm.
7:24 Speaker 03 Uh, you have telepathy, and that's when you can, you know, you're over there reading my thoughts.
7:29 Josh Clark? Yes.
7:29 Speaker 03 Like Chuck is really not happy to be in the new studio.
7:31 Josh Clark? That's not true.
7:32 Speaker 03 He'd rather be at home on the couch.
7:34 Josh Clark? I'm reading your thoughts right now, and I know that you like this place.
7:36 Speaker 03 Oh, okay. Well, you're, you're a telepath.
7:39 Josh Clark? Right.
7:39 Speaker 03 Uh, clairvoyance, which is the ability to see events or things, objects, happening somewhere else at the same time. So, are you do, are you clairvoyant?
7:49 Josh Clark? I am. I'm seeing your couch right now, and I'm seeing it's not that comfy.
7:53 Speaker 03 Yeah.
7:54 Josh Clark? So you're not missing that much at the moment.
7:56 Speaker 03 I know, somewhere Jonathan Strickland is waxing his head. His bald head.
8:01 Josh Clark? That's just a logical assumption.
8:03 Speaker 03 Okay. Uh, then we have our precogs, precognition, that's when you see into the future. Uh, retrocogs, retrocognition, you can see into the distant past.
8:12 Josh Clark? That's, there's another, um, that's a widely accepted definition of retrocognition.
8:18 Speaker 03 Yeah.
8:18 Josh Clark? Like seeing, you know, a cave, like tuk tuk running around with the dinosaurs like you do, which I guess never would have happened.
8:25 Speaker 03 Yeah.
8:25 Josh Clark? Um, but there's another term for retrocognition, whereas Something in the future affects something in the past. So a decision you make in the future.
8:34 Speaker 03 Yeah.
8:35 Josh Clark? Affects your past. And an example given is that you have a dream about a dinosaur. Now, let's say a spotted dog.
8:45 Speaker 03 Okay.
8:45 Josh Clark? And then the first thing the next morning, you go outside to water your lawn and the same spotted dog or a similar spotted dog walks by. The idea isn't that that was very coincidental or that you had ESP in your dreams.
8:58 Speaker 03 Yeah.
8:59 Josh Clark? But that you seeing that dog in the morning affected your dream the night before.
9:04 Speaker 03 Oh, okay.
9:05 Josh Clark? So that's another definition that's emerging for retro cognition.
9:08 Speaker 03 Gotcha.
9:08 Josh Clark? That's getting a lot of traction because of the stuff we're finding on the quantum scale.
9:12 Speaker 03 Huh.
9:13 Josh Clark? Just weirdness like that.
9:15 Speaker 03 All right, then you have your mediumship and that's Ms. Cleo, who can channel dead spirits.
9:20 Josh Clark? Yeah, I forgot about her.
9:22 Speaker 03 And then you have-
9:22 Josh Clark? I wonder how much money that woman grossed in the 90s.
9:26 Speaker 03 She made a lot of dough.
9:27 Josh Clark? I hope so.
9:28 Speaker 03 Yeah.
9:28 Josh Clark? I mean, she was working hard. She had a finite window of opportunity and she worked that whole time. She didn't like buy a sailboat and sail around the world after like her first million, you know? Like, she worked.
9:41 Speaker 03 So you're not in the camp of like she's taking people's money and taking advantage of people?
9:46 Josh Clark? Uh, I see that argument.
9:48 Speaker 03 Sure.
9:48 Josh Clark? For sure. I also see like if people want to spend their money on that and they get something out of it, knock yourself out.
9:54 Speaker 03 All right. And then you have psychometry, which is the ability to read info about a person place by touching the person or object. And that's what I like to call the dead zone.
10:07 Josh Clark? Right.
10:08 Speaker 03 Christopher Walken, he would place his hands on you and he would see something.
10:11 Josh Clark? Man, I think we talked about it recently, about how that movie holds up still.
10:16 Speaker 03 Yeah.
10:16 Josh Clark? It's such a good movie.
10:18 Speaker 03 Yeah, it really is good. Chris Walken.
10:20 Josh Clark? There's another one, Chuck, called telekinesis, which is like Yuri Geller stroking a spoon and it bending.
10:29 Speaker 03 Right.
10:30 Josh Clark? Like being able to manipulate matter, just using a light toucher of your mind.
10:36 Speaker 03 But there is no spoon.
10:39 Josh Clark? Yeah, wasn't that from Matrix?
10:41 Speaker 03 Mm-hmm. Um, alright, so basically, uh, like you said, JB Rhine is the, the granddaddy of all this. And he actually started studying, I mean, he was a legitimate scientist, he wasn't some quack. And, uh, this was in the 1930s where he started at Duke University studying para- parapsychology, basically.
11:02 Josh Clark? And, uh, he wasn't the first, he was one of the first, um, laboratory experimenters in academia to really study psi, right? Before him, probably about forty or so years before him, William James and some of his pals at the Society for Psychical Research.
11:19 Speaker 03 Oh, right.
11:20 Josh Clark? Um, really laid the groundwork for applying the scientific method to the study of paranormal phenomenon.
11:27 Speaker 03 Yeah.
11:27 Josh Clark? And they did two things. They outed frauds, like fraudulent mediums, like, uh, very famously Madame Blavartsky.
11:35 Speaker 03 Oh, yeah.
11:36 Josh Clark? But then they also investigated ones like, they approached them typically with like an open mind.
11:41 Speaker 03 Yeah.
11:41 Josh Clark? Um, and if they found somebody that they just couldn't explain, they would, they studied them. So they were, they were studying each one with an open mind and the ones they figured out were frauds, they outed as frauds. The ones they figured out, uh, couldn't quite explain.
11:56 Speaker 03 Yeah.
11:57 Josh Clark? They sought to investigate scientifically rather than just saying, "Oh, they're a fraud somehow."
12:01 Speaker 03 Right.
12:02 Josh Clark? So that was the groundwork of the study of psi.
12:04 Speaker 03 What was, uh, Madame Blavartsky's deal of the Coney Island Blavartsky's?
12:09 Josh Clark? She was, um, she actually, she, she was almost a cult leader. You could argue she was. She, um, she created, um, oh, man, it's called like theodism, I think?
12:21 Speaker 03 Uh-huh.
12:22 Josh Clark? Which is, um, it was, it was almost a cult, it was a huge, um, movement in the 19th century where like you'd go to like a seance and there was a medium there and they would channel like the spirits of the dead, relatives of people who were there holding hands in the circle and stuff like that. And she gained a lot of power and wealth and prestige until she was outed as, as a fraud. And I don't remember the, the, um, it's theosophy, that's what it is, not theo- theoism. Theoism has to do with Theo Huxtable.
12:56 Speaker 03 Did you see The Source Family, by the way, that documentary?
12:59 Josh Clark? No, I haven't.
13:00 Speaker 03 About the LA cult in the 70s?
13:02 Josh Clark? I saw the icon on Netflix and it clicked. Is it good?
13:06 Speaker 03 It's really good. And it's awesome, actually. I recommend everyone see it. It's one of those where like they interview a lot of them today and they weren't like, you know, they didn't commit suicide. Like, everyone was like, it was pretty great.
13:20 Josh Clark? Oh, yeah?
13:21 Speaker 03 Yeah, they're all fine. They're all just a bunch of hippies still.
13:23 Josh Clark? They were out in LA?
13:24 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, right in Hollywood.
13:25 Josh Clark? There was one in, um, there was a documentary I saw about a cult in Miami. And they were like, super fundamentalist Christian.
13:36 Speaker 03 Yeah.
13:36 Josh Clark? But they also were, um, the basis of their religion was formed on pot, too.
13:41 Speaker 03 Well, that's what The Source Family was.
13:43 Josh Clark? I wonder if they were related?
13:45 Speaker 03 Well, it was the 70s.
13:46 Josh Clark? Yeah.
13:47 Speaker 03 There were a lot of pot cults, I bet.
13:48 Josh Clark? But did they turn into like huge pot dealers?
13:51 Speaker 03 No, I don't think so.
13:52 Josh Clark? This cult did.
13:53 Speaker 03 They had a band, though, and the-
13:55 Josh Clark? Called The Source?
13:56 Speaker 03 Mm, you know, I can't remember the name of the band, but it's pretty interesting to listen to.
14:01 Josh Clark? Manhattan Transfer?
14:02 Speaker 03 Yeah, that was it. It's a really good documentary, though. It's just funny to see all these people now. They're like, it was awesome.
14:08 Josh Clark? Yeah.
14:08 Speaker 03 Had a lot of sex and smoked a lot of weed.
14:10 Josh Clark? Yeah, that's kinda what this one did, too. They, these guys didn't seem to have a lot of sex, though. They were like real, like, um, compartmentalized gender-wise and like male dominance and all that, but they just smoked a ton of pot all the time, including their little kids.
14:24 Speaker 03 Oh, well, that's not good.
14:25 Josh Clark? Like, like, four-year-olds smoking pot.
14:27 Speaker 03 Oh, that's terrible.
14:28 Josh Clark? Yeah, it was in the documentary. It's worth seeing. I don't remember what it's-
14:31 Speaker 03 You had me up. You lost me there.
14:33 Josh Clark? I lost everybody there in that documentary.
14:35 Speaker 03 Yeah. Um, all right, so back to this ESP thing.
14:40 Josh Clark? JB Rhine?
14:41 Speaker 03 Yeah, JB Rhine. Well, basically, there's a, there's a lot of different outlooks on what ESP might be. Um, some people think that everyone's got it, but some people, um, it just pops up every now and then. Um, like, I might have a dream that comes true or whatever. Uh, other people think that only certain people have it. They have this, the gift, as they say.
15:03 Josh Clark? Right.
15:04 Speaker 03 Uh, and that they have to be in this special, like, you know, mental state to access it.
15:09 Josh Clark? The shenan?
15:11 Speaker 03 The shitting. And then other folks say that everyone has that potential, but, um, some people are just like in tune with it. And some people aren't.
15:18 Josh Clark? Right. And you fall in the none of those three camp.
15:22 Speaker 04 Yes.
15:24 Josh Clark? So we'll talk a little more about some ideas of what ESP is right after this.
15:44 Josh Clark? Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability. And it all starts with a great deal on a truck from your local Toyota dealer.
15:53 Speaker 04 That's right. Make a smart buy on the off-road Ready Tacoma or half-ton Tundra, two of Toyota's most capable and longest-lasting trucks, built with the strength for the tough jobs, the tech to power your next big adventure, and the rugged style for everything in between.
16:06 Josh Clark? Or discover Toyota's off-road lineup, including the iconic 4Runner and Land Cruiser, designed to go beyond the everyday. And with Toyota's proven reputation for quality and reliability, plus hybrid power on many models, you can get more for every mile and drive for less along the way.
16:22 Speaker 04 That's right. And long after you leave the lot, your Toyota keeps delivering with great resale value. So you could trade in for more when you're ready for your next Toyota. From a great deal today to a great value tomorrow, a Toyota is right for you. Shop toyota.com for deals and details, or stop by your local Toyota dealer today. Toyota, let's go places.
16:45 Speaker 05 Hey, it's Niall Rogers, host of Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series. I'm driving across the country, meeting some of today's most fascinating artists. We're exploring the stories before the moment that changed everything. This week, I'm joined by Miguel.
17:03 Speaker 06 Man, I'm a black and Mexican kid from San Pedro, and I grew up in Inglewood as well. I never liked to be boxed in. Both of my parents colored outside of the line. I mean, even them being together at the time in LA was just not typical. And so I think that has always been a part of my DNA. There's a defiant something in me that feels like... What we get to do with what we're given that's greater than us is to maybe connect people to ideas that they wouldn't naturally, you know, connect to. That's really me. I'm just kind of like defiant with love, though.
17:39 Speaker 05 Experience Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series on the iHeartRadio app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
17:56 Josh Clark? So Chuck, you said that basically how people see ESP is either everyone has it, some people have it, or no one has it, basically.
18:08 Josh Clark? Whether you're a skeptic or a believer.
18:10 Speaker 03 Right.
18:11 Josh Clark? If you are a believer in ESP and somebody comes to you and says, "Okay, explain ESP." Like, what is it?
18:18 Speaker 03 Right.
18:19 Josh Clark? There's actually a couple of very common suggestions or proposals.
18:24 Speaker 03 Yeah.
18:25 Josh Clark? One made sense for a while.
18:27 Speaker 03 Right.
18:27 Josh Clark? Before we knew a little more about the brain. And that was that ESP was some form or fashion of the electromagnetic spectrum.
18:37 Speaker 03 Yeah.
18:37 Josh Clark? That we were receiving information from outside of our usual senses.
18:43 Speaker 03 Yeah, and like you said, it fell out of favor because, basically, it didn't explain anything about how it moves through time, or it didn't pick up on some special part of your brain that, like, receives this message.
18:58 Josh Clark? Yeah, and there was a, did you see that study I sent you that was, I think, from 2010 where they put people in an MRI and then showed them different pictures or whatever?
19:11 Josh Clark? And they did, they showed, like, I put you in the Wonder Machine.
19:16 Speaker 03 Okay.
19:17 Josh Clark? And now I'm showing you a picture of the flower. And that's it.
19:20 Speaker 03 Okay. It's lovely, except it sounds like a German rave.
19:24 Josh Clark? Okay, a little bit. But that would be the non-ESP stimuli, the control group.
19:31 Speaker 03 Yeah.
19:31 Josh Clark? To test ESP and to see if the brain reacted differently and then to see if there was a part of the brain that's picking up on ESP. I would show you the flower and then in the other room, I would also show Emily that flower.
19:44 Speaker 03 Oh, right.
19:45 Josh Clark? And have her think about it.
19:46 Speaker 03 Yeah.
19:46 Josh Clark? And send you the thought of that flower. So you're getting ESP stimuli and then non-ESP stimuli. And from the MRI, they showed that the brain didn't react differently.
19:58 Speaker 03 Gotcha.
19:59 Josh Clark? So it suggests that there isn't a sensory organ or region of the brain that's responsible for picking up ESP, which doesn't debunk the possibility of ESP.
20:09 Speaker 03 Yeah.
20:09 Josh Clark? It just undermines the idea that there's a region of our brain that would be responsible for picking that up.
20:14 Speaker 03 Plus, if Emily's over there, my first guess is gonna be dog every time. And it's flower and then it's not gonna...
20:20 Josh Clark? Well, it wasn't about guessing, it was just to see, like, showing you the ESP version.
20:26 Speaker 03 Right.
20:26 Josh Clark? And then the non-ESP version of the same thing. So you weren't guessing. Do you understand?
20:31 Speaker 03 Yeah, I get it now. I would've guessed dog or wine.
20:34 Josh Clark? There wasn't guessing.
20:36 Speaker 03 I still would've guessed. Emily thinks she has the gift a little bit, so she would've been disappointed.
20:41 Josh Clark? She's got the chin?
20:42 Speaker 03 Yeah, a little, she thinks.
20:44 Josh Clark? Yeah.
20:45 Speaker 03 But I think she's just super observant and intuitive.
20:48 Josh Clark? Well, that's definitely one explanation for it.
20:51 Speaker 03 Yeah, which we'll get to, of course. So these days, there are other theories, one of which is that, it's called spillover, that there's basically another dimension that doesn't, you know, have our laws here and our dimension.
21:07 Josh Clark? Yeah.
21:07 Speaker 03 And that sometimes stuff just sort of spills over from that and we see the future or the past.
21:13 Josh Clark? Yeah. And if you're a skeptic, you probably just pulled a decent-sized clump of your hair out of the side of your head at that one.
21:20 Speaker 03 Yeah, because this is something you can't prove, obviously. It's like completely...
21:26 Speaker 03 And of course, they'll say, "Exactly."
21:28 Josh Clark? Yeah.
21:29 Speaker 03 You know?
21:29 Josh Clark? Yeah, and I think I got the impression from this article that they were making that point, like, science is just chasing its tail and trying to explain ESP because it's not currently capable.
21:40 Speaker 03 Yeah.
21:41 Josh Clark? And science goes, "It doesn't work like that."
21:44 Speaker 03 Yeah.
21:44 Josh Clark? You know?
21:45 Speaker 03 Yeah.
21:45 Josh Clark? At least with the electromagnetic spectrum explanation, it was pointing to something that we already know exists, right? It's just that there's no way to show that we would be getting, how we would be getting information from it. Because the electromagnetic explanation?
22:06 Speaker 03 Yeah.
22:06 Josh Clark? It basically says, if you compare it to other findings from ESP, it makes even less sense.
22:13 Speaker 03 Right.
22:13 Josh Clark? Because with ESP, one of the hallmarks of it is that, no matter whether you're out there, outside of the studio-
22:19 Speaker 03 Sure.
22:20 Josh Clark? -thinking about wine, or a dog, or something-
22:23 Speaker 03 Yeah.
22:23 Josh Clark? -and I'm picking up on it, or if you're in China, and I'm here, and we're doing the same thing, the signal doesn't weaken at all.
22:32 Speaker 03 Yeah, and that just flies in the face of all we know about electromagnetic waves.
22:35 Josh Clark? Right, exactly.
22:36 Speaker 03 No good.
22:36 Josh Clark? Right. So there's a lot of things wrong with the proposals of what ESP is.
22:42 Speaker 03 Uh, yeah, but you know, the reason why people still believe in this stuff is because of either hearing a story about their friend who said, you know, "Listen to this crazy thing happen."
22:52 Josh Clark? Right.
22:52 Speaker 03 Or experiencing it themselves in some way or another, having a dream that something similar happened, and all of a sudden, you're like, "Hmm, I might have the gift."
23:00 Josh Clark? Exactly.
23:00 Speaker 03 Or it popped up in me, you know, briefly, at least.
23:03 Josh Clark? And there's a, I mean, there's a lot of evidence of strange and unusual occurrences-
23:12 Speaker 03 Sure.
23:13 Josh Clark? -that support the idea of ESP.
23:15 Speaker 03 Yeah.
23:15 Josh Clark? Um, this article gives a really good one, about an 1898 book called Futility-
23:21 Speaker 03 Yeah.
23:21 Josh Clark? -that was written by a guy named Morgan Robertson, right?
23:24 Speaker 03 Mm-hmm.
23:24 Josh Clark? And in it, the guy details this book, or this boat, called the Titan-
23:30 Speaker 03 A ship.
23:30 Josh Clark? Yeah, a ship.
23:31 Speaker 03 A boat.
23:32 Josh Clark? A big old boat.
23:33 Speaker 03 Yeah.
23:33 Josh Clark? Um, which is sailing across the Atlantic, and hits an iceberg at night, and sinks, and a bunch of people die because there weren't enough lifeboats.
23:43 Speaker 03 Yeah.
23:43 Josh Clark? And this is 1898, and if that sounds familiar, the Titanic did the same exact thing. The Titanic, not the Titan-
23:49 Speaker 03 Yeah.
23:50 Josh Clark? -did the same exact thing 14 years later.
23:52 Speaker 03 Yeah, uh, if there, there are a bunch of similarities. Um, the Titan struck an iceberg in the book on the starboard side on an April night in the North Atlantic off the coast of Newfoundland, and the real Titanic struck an iceberg on the starboard side in April in the North Atlantic off the coast of Newfoundland.
24:09 Josh Clark? And the starless night?
24:10 Speaker 03 I don't know about that.
24:12 Josh Clark? Okay.
24:13 Speaker 03 Uh, they were both said to be unsinkable. Um, more than half of the passengers of the Titanic, uh, perished and more than half of the passengers and crew on the Titan perished. So there's all these things in there, but you do a little more digging and you find out that Robertson was, uh, he was a seaman and he knew a bunch of this stuff and it's not unreasonable to think at the time they wanted to build the biggest ships and the word Titan would be a great name back then for a super big ship.
24:43 Josh Clark? Right.
24:44 Speaker 03 And that sailing route, uh, was a common one and there were icebergs and April might have been a common month for that kind of, uh, voyage. So all of it can be explained away, kind of, um, but it is definitely something you look at and go, ooh, interesting.
24:59 Josh Clark? It is interesting and it's amazing coincidence and it focuses the, uh, attention and captures the imagination. Um, but then, yeah, once you hear about Robertson's background, it becomes slightly less impressive. So then kind of to, oh, over the years, that little kernel got erased and added to it was that this idea for this book came to him in a trance, which bolsters the ESP.
25:23 Speaker 03 Yeah. Is that true or has that just been added, uh?
25:26 Josh Clark? I'm sure it was added over the years.
25:28 Speaker 03 Okay.
25:29 Josh Clark? Which is a big problem with this kind of anecdotal evidence is that, you know, it gets embellished and there's flourishes added.
25:35 Speaker 03 Urban legendized.
25:36 Josh Clark? Yeah, exactly. And, uh, it's just, it's not enough that this is a really interesting, unique.
25:41 Speaker 03 Right.
25:42 Josh Clark? Circumstance or coincidence or whatever. There has to be this extra layer of proof, like it came to him in a trance.
25:51 Speaker 03 Come on.
25:51 Josh Clark? Yeah.
25:52 Speaker 03 Um, so back to Rhine. He did some, um, like I said, in the 1930s, he started studying this stuff, uh, with one of my favorite inventions, um, by his colleague Carl Zinnor. Uh, of course, if you've seen Ghostbusters, he was using. He was using a version of Xener cards.
26:10 Josh Clark? Right.
26:10 Speaker 03 The shapes weren't all exact. I think there was one that was different in Ghostbusters. But the original Xener cards were, it was a deck of 25 plain white cards with, each of them had one of five symbols, a circle, a plus sign, a square, a star, five pointed star, and the three wavy lines.
26:31 Josh Clark? Hmm, like water, a river.
26:34 Speaker 03 Is that what that is?
26:34 Josh Clark? Maybe.
26:35 Speaker 03 Okay. And the idea is that, just like in Ghostbusters, you hold it up and ask the, you know, not showing them the card, uh, obviously, not the symbol, and say, "What do you see?" And they say what they see, and then you record after the deck how many they got right.
26:51 Josh Clark? Right, but the person holding the card is supposed to be thinking about what they're seeing.
26:55 Speaker 03 Sure.
26:56 Josh Clark? So that the other person, the target, the receiver, can pick it up telepathically.
27:04 Speaker 03 Yeah, and I did, they have these online. I took the test yesterday.
27:07 Josh Clark? Uh huh.
27:07 Speaker 03 And I went through the 25 deck and I only got six out of 25, and at the end it just said, "You are not a psychic."
27:15 Josh Clark? Oh, really?
27:16 Speaker 03 Yeah, I thought it was kinda funny.
27:17 Josh Clark? Statistically speaking, for just one trial, that is more than chance. You did better than chance, so maybe you do have a touch.
27:25 Speaker 03 Six of, what would chance be, I guess?
27:27 Josh Clark? Chance would be, if there's five different ones.
27:30 Speaker 03 It'd be 20%?
27:31 Josh Clark? Uh huh.
27:31 Speaker 03 And so this was six of 24 would be, uh, is that 25%?
27:37 Josh Clark? No, that's, uh...
27:38 Speaker 03 No, that's less.
27:39 Josh Clark? Yeah. No, you did six of 24. You did 24 or 25?
27:44 Speaker 03 25.
27:45 Josh Clark? So five of 25 would be chance.
27:48 Speaker 03 Okay, so I got one more?
27:49 Josh Clark? Yeah.
27:50 Speaker 03 Well, and I think like, three of the first eight or so, or six, I got, and I was like, "Oh, I've got the gift."
27:57 Josh Clark? Right.
27:57 Speaker 03 But I didn't know, like, it's randomly generated, and so it's not like someone was on the other side thinking of that card. So I literally, I was like, "What do I do?" I was like, "I'm just guessing."
28:07 Josh Clark? So that brings up some interesting stuff, like, there's, there's evidence that when a machine is involved,
28:15 Speaker 03 Yeah.
28:15 Josh Clark? that there is no telepathy, there would only be clairvoyance, right?
28:20 Speaker 03 Yeah.
28:20 Josh Clark? So, I mean, if, if, if telepathy is you picking up what's in someone else's mind, and the computer is mindless, then you shouldn't be able, what you were saying, like, you should, it shouldn't, you should not be able to know what Xener card it's going to pick next, right? But there have been investigations using computers and using machines that show above chance.
28:43 Speaker 03 Yeah.
28:44 Josh Clark? That there is some sort of weird interaction.
28:46 Speaker 03 Like a random number generators?
28:48 Josh Clark? Yes.
28:48 Speaker 03 Yeah.
28:49 Josh Clark? So Princeton University has a department called the Princeton Engineering Anomalies Research Department, PER, right?
28:55 Speaker 03 Of course.
28:56 Josh Clark? And PER has been doing studies for a couple of decades. They've done millions of trials.
29:01 Speaker 03 Yeah.
29:01 Josh Clark? And basically, they'll say, this is a random number generator, or this, this machine operates randomly, or whatever. We want you to think of a number, and we want to see if you can influence the numbers that this computer spits out.
29:14 Speaker 03 Oh, so you're thinking of the number, then the, you're, okay, that makes sense.
29:18 Josh Clark? Like, the human is trying to affect the
29:20 Speaker 03 The computer.
29:20 Josh Clark? The output, the behavior of the computer. Of course, if you're sitting across the room, or in another room, thinking about a number that a random generator should put out, it should have zero effect whatsoever.
29:33 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's a computer.
29:34 Josh Clark? The weird thing is, is what Princeton has found, is that, yes, over enough trials, you, there is a slight, very slight, but measurable effect that human thought has on a random number generator.
29:48 Speaker 03 Come on.
29:48 Josh Clark? It's, it's on Princeton's website, and this is stuff that, like, is apparently accepted in the, in the scientific community, that the, the, um, trials that they are running are so widespread and so repeatable, and have been done so many times, that the data that they're coming up with is, is, it's significant.
30:08 Speaker 03 Well, Ryan, with his Zinn and Card experiments in the 30s, did find that some people, um, got what they thought were pretty impressive results, like, you know, a few, I can't remember their names, but
30:21 Josh Clark? Hubert Pierce.
30:22 Speaker 03 Was he one of them?
30:22 Josh Clark? He was the one.
30:23 Speaker 03 Well, how many, what was his percentage?
30:25 Josh Clark? He had one where he got, um, remember how you got three in a row, and you were like, oh my god?
30:30 Speaker 03 Yeah.
30:30 Josh Clark? He got 25 in a row once.
30:32 Speaker 03 What?
30:32 Josh Clark? 25.
30:34 Speaker 03 Come on.
30:35 Josh Clark? No, I'm not kidding. He was also documented as selecting 558 correct out of 1850, which is, the odds of that happening by chance
30:46 Speaker 03 Yeah.
30:46 Josh Clark? were 22 billion to 1.
30:48 Speaker 03 Now, were these the early experiments?
30:50 Josh Clark? Yes.
30:50 Speaker 03 Because, okay, because I did read that, and this seems like, I can't believe he didn't check this, but apparently the early cards were a little translucent.
31:00 Josh Clark? Oh, really?
31:01 Speaker 03 Yeah, some of them were, and then he corrected for that, and the percentages went down. And then they, I know other scientists said that you are somehow influencing with your body tell.
31:14 Josh Clark? Right.
31:14 Speaker 03 Like, basically, you don't have a good enough poker face.
31:17 Josh Clark? Yeah, in the earliest Ryan experiments with the Zenner cards, he would hold the card up.
31:21 Speaker 03 And go square.
31:22 Josh Clark? And he'd be making eye contact. Right, the guy, yeah, the guesser would be like, is it the wavy line? And yeah, he'd start shaking his head, almost impersonating. But he, that's called sensory leakage, where you, the person who is holding the card and knows what the card is.
31:43 Speaker 03 Yeah.
31:43 Josh Clark? Somehow, there's some detail about your face that when you do 1,000 trials with somebody.
31:50 Speaker 03 Yeah.
31:50 Josh Clark? They start to pick up on, and it affects their guess, it influences their guess. So to correct for that, to control for that.
31:57 Speaker 03 What's it called?
31:59 Josh Clark? Sensory leakage.
32:00 Speaker 03 Gross.
32:01 Josh Clark? Isn't that gross?
32:01 Speaker 03 Yeah.
32:02 Josh Clark? They came up with something called the Gansfeldt experiment.
32:06 Speaker 03 Ah, yes, the German Gansfeldt. That means whole field in German, and that is when they started putting people, they would start depriving their other senses, basically.
32:19 Josh Clark? Right.
32:19 Speaker 03 They would be in a, like, a dimly lit room with red lighting, and they would have white noise, and they would have their eyes covered with these special glasses.
32:30 Josh Clark? Or ping pong balls cut in half, like Kermit the Frog.
32:33 Speaker 03 I guess later on, they said, we should just make some glasses.
32:35 Josh Clark? Exactly. We've got the funding.
32:37 Speaker 03 So basically, the idea was, let's rule out any of that gross sensory leakage.
32:45 Josh Clark? Yeah, which smells.
32:48 Josh Clark? So, yeah, apparently, later on in Ryan's experiments, after he started controlling for stuff, the percentages started to drop.
32:58 Speaker 03 Yeah.
32:58 Josh Clark? Of correct guesses.
32:59 Speaker 03 And he got sad.
33:01 Josh Clark? He was also, he's generally a respected researcher.
33:05 Speaker 03 Yeah.
33:05 Josh Clark? For a couple of reasons. One, whenever he did, whenever evidence of like some sort of bias or fraud or something was brought to him, he corrected for it.
33:16 Speaker 03 Yeah, he wore glasses and a white coat.
33:18 Josh Clark? Right, that was another one.
33:20 Speaker 03 Uh huh.
33:21 Josh Clark? But also, he was daring enough to stake his entire career on a field of study.
33:30 Speaker 03 Yeah.
33:30 Josh Clark? That will get anybody mocked.
33:32 Speaker 03 Yeah, sure.
33:32 Josh Clark? Publicly, privately, can really shut down a lot of opportunities for you. This guy and his wife, Louisa Rhine, both dedicated their careers to establishing the field of parapsychology and really studying it.
33:47 Speaker 03 Yeah.
33:47 Josh Clark? Rather than just walking away from it.
33:49 Speaker 03 Yeah, I don't think he was like, I really want to prove this is true, was he?
33:53 Josh Clark? Uh, yes, he did.
33:55 Speaker 03 Oh.
33:55 Josh Clark? That was, that was a huge criticism of him.
33:58 Speaker 03 Gotcha, he wanted to believe in it.
34:00 Josh Clark? He was a definite believer.
34:01 Speaker 03 Oh, okay.
34:02 Josh Clark? He was quoted by, I don't know what the guy's deal was, but one day he was visited by one person and the interviewer who went on to write a paper, I think in Scientific American, to expose him.
34:15 Speaker 03 Yeah.
34:15 Josh Clark? He said, he kept a file of people, of the results of tests where people he suspected were purposefully getting things wrong because they didn't like him.
34:27 Speaker 03 Uh.
34:28 Josh Clark? To mess with his data.
34:29 Speaker 03 Yeah.
34:29 Josh Clark? He just took those and never published them. He didn't include them in the.
34:33 Speaker 03 Gotcha.
34:33 Josh Clark? The results, which would definitely affect the number of correct hits, right?
34:38 Speaker 03 Yeah.
34:39 Josh Clark? That was a huge criticism. That's not good science at all.
34:43 Speaker 03 No.
34:43 Josh Clark? But he was definitely a believer, which was another criticism of it. But he was daring and he did, there was another story where, it's called the Levy affair, where a guy named Levy, who was an electrical engineer working in the lab.
34:55 Speaker 03 Yeah.
34:56 Josh Clark? Unplugged. I guess a sensor that would correct negative hits for a little while during a trial.
35:04 Speaker 04 Yeah.
35:04 Josh Clark? So that all that were recorded for a little bit were positive hits. And so, and then he plugged it back in. Well, this one guy saw what the guy was doing and went to Ryan, and Ryan went to the guy Levy and said, "Did you do this?" And Levy said, "Yes." He's like, "You're fired." And just like threw the results away and all that. So he wasn't like, he was a true believer, but he wasn't just some like outright fraud.
35:25 Speaker 04 Right, right.
35:26 Josh Clark? But he was, and still is, under the microscope as much as probably any researcher in all of academia ever has been.
35:34 Speaker 04 All right. Well, right after this break, we'll talk a little bit about what skeptics say about ESP.
35:50 Josh Clark? Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability. And it all starts with a great deal on the truck from your local Toyota dealer.
36:00 Speaker 04 That's right. Make a smart buy on the off-road Ready Tacoma or Half-Ton Tundra, two of Toyota's most capable and longest-lasting trucks, built with the strength for the tough jobs, the tech to power your next big adventure, and the rugged style for everything in between.
36:13 Josh Clark? Or discover Toyota's off-road lineup, including the iconic 4Runner and Land Cruiser, designed to go beyond the everyday. And with Toyota's proven reputation for quality and reliability, plus hybrid power on many models, you can get more for every mile and drive for less along the way.
36:28 Speaker 04 That's right. And long after you leave the lot, your Toyota keeps delivering with great resale value. So you can trade in for more when you're ready for your next Toyota. From a great deal today to a great value tomorrow, a Toyota is right for you. Shop toyota.com for deals and details, or stop by your local Toyota dealer today. Toyota, let's go places.
36:51 Speaker 05 Hey, it's Nile Rodgers, host of Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series. I'm driving across the country, meeting some of today's most fascinating artists. We're exploring the stories before the moment that changed everything. This week, I'm joined by breakout singer-songwriter Alex Warren.
37:12 Speaker 07 I'm like a kid when I play music and I make music and I'm constantly asking questions. You know, whether it's an instrument I haven't played, or it's a melody that seems foreign. You know, there's every night you play a show and it's the same set, but it's not the same show. At a certain point, your brain kind of goes on autopilot. When I'm in the studio, or if I'm making music, that's where that curiosity kind of comes back, you know? I haven't lost it yet, but I'm also on my sophomore album, so, and you, you obviously are an expert here.
37:37 Speaker 05 Experience Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series on the iHeartRadio app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
37:54 Speaker 03 All right, Josh, one thing you'll hear skeptics say a lot is extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
38:00 Josh Clark? Yeah.
38:01 Speaker 03 And I have to agree with them.
38:02 Josh Clark? Yeah.
38:03 Speaker 03 And it is an extraordinary claim here, and so far, there hasn't been extraordinary evidence. And one of the things I pointed to earlier that I think is what's going on, if you look at statistics, you look at 6 billion people on planet Earth, and them thinking a gazillion things each day, and that is scientific, by the way.
38:25 Josh Clark? Gazillion?
38:27 Speaker 03 At some point, somebody is going to think something that it mirrors something that happens in the near future, and it's just chance and coincidence.
38:35 Josh Clark? I have a great example of that, man.
38:37 Speaker 03 Okay.
38:38 Josh Clark? It happened this very morning.
38:39 Speaker 03 What?
38:40 Josh Clark? Yeah, I did. Um, I was at the printer, you know, we just moved offices. And I was at the printer and I had like an extra piece of paper that I didn't need and I realized like we have no paper recycling here. So on my way back-
38:52 Speaker 03 Not yet, that is. Everyone out there is like, what kind of office would not have recycling?
38:56 Josh Clark? Right, we just said, we have a, we have a fifty-five gallon drum that we throw stuff into, that's, it catches on fire.
39:02 Speaker 03 Yeah, and then we send it out to see-
39:03 Josh Clark? We have a burning drum, that's what it's called.
39:05 Speaker 03 No, we're getting those soon.
39:06 Josh Clark? Um, right, and we are getting them soon. I know this because on my way back to my desk, I popped into Izzy, the IT guy who's also the head of all recycling and stuff here.
39:16 Speaker 03 Sure.
39:16 Josh Clark? I was like, Izzy, we need a, a paper recycling bins by the printer. And he goes, I'm writing an email right now to everybody-
39:25 Speaker 03 Yeah.
39:25 Josh Clark? About that very thing.
39:27 Speaker 03 You almost did your Izzy impression.
39:28 Josh Clark? Yeah, it was close. Um, and so like, I thought about it, that's pretty amazing.
39:35 Speaker 03 Yeah.
39:36 Josh Clark? You know, but it was about nine in the morning, and this is a company-wide email. So it'd be something that Izzy would probably knock out about that time.
39:44 Speaker 03 Yeah.
39:45 Josh Clark? The reason I was thinking of is because I was just at the printer.
39:47 Speaker 03 Yeah.
39:48 Josh Clark? We just moved into this office and we didn't have bins yet, so it was still a potential thing for somebody to be thinking about or doing or writing an email about.
39:56 Speaker 03 Yeah.
39:57 Josh Clark? Um, and so there's all these different, really overlooked variables or factors to this whole thing that, that you don't think of. Instead, it just seems like an amazing coincidence or ESP.
40:08 Speaker 03 Right.
40:08 Josh Clark? To me, the really significant thing was that I happened to be researching ESP while this happened.
40:14 Speaker 03 Right.
40:15 Josh Clark? That's what really kind of stood out to me.
40:17 Speaker 03 Yeah.
40:17 Josh Clark? But if you really kind of look at it, like, there's a finite amount of things that people could think about in any given day, in any given context, in an office or something like that.
40:26 Speaker 03 Yeah.
40:27 Josh Clark? Like, had, had I been a goat at a petting zoo and I went over and, um, talked to the cow and the cow was writing the email about recycling bins.
40:37 Speaker 03 Uh huh.
40:38 Josh Clark? Maybe, but we're in an office, I'm talking to the guy about recycling bins. There's just a lot of stuff that you kind of, once you take that into account, it becomes less amazing. Like, like the, the guy writing the Titan Titanic book.
40:52 Speaker 03 Yeah, you know what used to happen to me now that I think of it is, um, I used to, and this, it's weird, it was only with phone landlines, it hadn't happened with the cellphone. But I used to, like, know the phone was gonna ring right before it rang.
41:04 Josh Clark? Oh, yeah.
41:05 Speaker 03 Like, almost go to reach for it. Um-
41:09 Speaker 03 And it, I mean, it's not like it happened all the time, but it happened enough times where I was like, huh, that's weird.
41:13 Josh Clark? Sure, I know what you're talking about.
41:14 Speaker 03 But I, and that was all it was to me. I was not like, I have the gift.
41:18 Josh Clark? But think about it, in that respect too, you know fifteen, twenty people. So was it you knew who was calling, or just that the phone was about to ring?
41:26 Speaker 03 No, just that it was about to ring.
41:28 Josh Clark? Oh, yeah, that is weird. You definitely do have ESP.
41:30 Speaker 03 Yeah.
41:33 Speaker 03 Um, or maybe, I don't know, maybe the phone made a little tick noise right before it rang that I didn't pick up on.
41:40 Josh Clark? Yeah.
41:41 Speaker 03 But only subconsciously, you know?
41:42 Josh Clark? Well, that's another explanation for it.
41:44 Speaker 03 A tick noise, I don't know.
41:45 Josh Clark? That, um, right, that, um, there is, uh, subliminal stuff in the environment. That is just too weak in nature for us to pick up on consciously, but our unconscious does, or our subconscious does. Which frankly opens up a whole other can of worms, you know? Uh, as far as, you know, how real is that kind of thing? There, but probably a little closer to reality is the idea that, um, our attention isn't focused on everything that we're picking up at all times. Like, like I see your beard and I see your shirt and everything, but I'm still also picking up like sensory information from like Jerry's computer that I can see in my peripheral vision or whatever. My attention isn't focused on it, but my brain is still receiving information.
42:30 Josh Clark? So the idea that our brains can put it together, all this information that we're not aware consciously that we're receiving.
42:36 Speaker 03 Yeah.
42:36 Josh Clark? Um, but we're still getting impressions from it. That's, uh, that, that could be a great explanation for ESP as well.
42:44 Speaker 03 Yeah, and you know what? Now that I think about it, the fact that it's never happened with my cellphone sort of makes sense because maybe there, it was a mechanical function, a, a landline ringing.
42:54 Josh Clark? Yeah, like you said, a click or a tick, but I think you meant like a click.
42:57 Speaker 03 And it wasn't even the, the newer model, this was back in the day when it was like.
43:01 Josh Clark? Princess phone.
43:01 Speaker 03 Uh, yeah, a ringing like bell.
43:03 Josh Clark? Sure.
43:04 Speaker 03 So maybe that does explain it.
43:06 Josh Clark? Yeah, I, I've got another good example that I came across in researching this. Um, let's say that, uh, you and I are hanging out.
43:13 Speaker 03 Yeah.
43:13 Josh Clark? And you're humming, uh, "Baby, I'm a firework," right? Just over and over again.
43:19 Speaker 03 I don't know that song.
43:20 Josh Clark? But I'm reading, uh.
43:21 Speaker 03 Yes, you do.
43:22 Josh Clark? No, I don't.
43:23 Speaker 03 Yeah, you do.
43:23 Josh Clark? Who is it?
43:24 Speaker 03 Katy Perry.
43:25 Josh Clark? I don't know Katy Perry. Anyway, um.
43:27 Speaker 03 Although I will have to say I did love that halftime show.
43:30 Josh Clark? It was great.
43:31 Speaker 03 Well, it was, it was hysterical.
43:33 Josh Clark? What's up with the sharks being a meme now? I didn't think they were really significant.
43:38 Speaker 03 And she looked like she worked at corn dog on a stick.
43:40 Josh Clark? I don't know what that is. I thought all corn dogs were on sticks.
43:43 Speaker 03 Nah, it's that place in the, or, uh, hot dog on a stick, maybe it was called. That place in the mall where they wore those big giant, uh, pinwheel colored hats. No, I don't know anything about Katy Perry, but it was the funniest, most, like, the crazy just kept coming and coming and coming. And I was like, this is the best thing I've ever seen.
44:00 Josh Clark? So.
44:01 Speaker 03 Anyway.
44:01 Josh Clark? In this universe, you're well aware of Katy Perry and her song Firework, and you're humming it to yourself. But I'm sitting there reading, uh, The New Yorker.
44:09 Speaker 03 Yes.
44:10 Josh Clark? And I'm engrossed in it, and not, I don't notice that. You get up to go make some nachos, and you come back in, and you catch my attention because you're, you're coming back in with some nachos, and they smell awesome. And now my attention is directed to you, and you're still humming Firework, right?
44:25 Speaker 03 Right.
44:25 Josh Clark? And I'm like, I was just thinking about that song Firework. I had that in my head. How crazy. We must be connected. I didn't realize that you had been humming it earlier.
44:35 Speaker 03 Sure.
44:35 Josh Clark? And beneath my awareness, I, I picked it up, although, once I became aware that you were humming it, it seemed to me like I had ESP.
44:45 Speaker 03 Well, yeah, and that ties into another explanation, is that people who do seem to have that gift are just really, really hyper observant on minute details. Like, the same people that can pick up on micro expressions.
44:59 Speaker 03 They might feel like they have the gift because they're just really in tune to what's going on around them, and not just, you know, like a big lunkhead walking around.
45:07 Josh Clark? So a lot of people who believe in ESP say, yes, we agree with that, especially parapsychology researchers. And there are still plenty of respected ones out there. There's a guy named, um, Daryl Bem.
45:19 Speaker 03 Yeah, I saw that thing you sent. He, he's been doing this for a while now.
45:23 Josh Clark? Yeah.
45:23 Speaker 03 Legitimately.
45:24 Josh Clark? We should talk about him, but there, to, to button up that point, there is, um... A lot of parapsychologists, or even just plain old psychologists who are researching ESP.
45:35 Speaker 03 Yeah.
45:35 Josh Clark? Um, who say, yes, that definitely, most likely accounts for almost all of it.
45:42 Speaker 03 Right.
45:43 Josh Clark? And that's good for us to be thinking about that. And that in and of itself deserves like academic inquiry and research, right?
45:49 Speaker 03 Yeah.
45:50 Josh Clark? But, there are still some experience, experiments that are being produced by guys like Daryl Bim, that um, are showing some weird results that go beyond this kind of explanation.
46:01 Speaker 03 Yeah, and, and one of the prob, well, we'll talk about the problems with even this research, um, about it being reproducible in a second, but, he did a couple of experi, this is from NPR, um.
46:11 Josh Clark? Yeah, Krowich wrote this.
46:13 Speaker 03 Oh, really?
46:14 Josh Clark? Yeah, from, from, from Radiolab.
46:16 Speaker 03 Nice, I didn't know that. Um, these are the two that he pointed out. He did nine different experiments, but um, the two that he highlighted was uh, at Cornell, which is where Bim is a, uh, is, does his work, right?
46:28 Josh Clark? Yeah, and he's a, again, a very respected psychologist.
46:32 Speaker 03 That's right.
46:32 Josh Clark? And this study that, of these experiments was published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, which is a respected journal.
46:40 Speaker 03 Yeah. Um, so they, the first one was a computer quiz. They took a hundred students, fifty males and fifty women. And um, basically, they showed a computer screen with two little curtains on it, side by side, and said, behind one is nothing, a, a brick wall. And behind the other is something sexy.
47:01 Josh Clark? Yeah.
47:02 Speaker 03 Some kind of, you know, I, I was about to call it pornographic, but who knows, maybe it's art. Nakedness.
47:09 Josh Clark? Eroticism.
47:09 Speaker 03 Eroticism.
47:10 Josh Clark? Yeah.
47:11 Speaker 03 Gross. Um.
47:14 Josh Clark? Does that just make you feel like your dad saying it or something?
47:16 Speaker 03 Yeah, well, this room's too small for you to say this kind of thing. Um, so, basically, he would say, you tell me, um, what, what you think you're going to see. And they were all hooked up to uh, to machines to read the, you know, their, what's going on in their body, of course.
47:31 Josh Clark? Right.
47:31 Speaker 03 And um, you would think it would be a fifty fifty result, but, they actually got a fifty three point one percent result for the, uh, what uh, Krowich calls erotic stimuli.
47:43 Josh Clark? Right.
47:44 Speaker 03 Um, and basically, they.
47:49 Speaker 03 They think, or at least that's what Bem thinks, is that one possibility is if there is, if they think they're gonna see something erotically stimulating, then it got passed back through time.
48:02 Josh Clark? Yeah, that's kinda his position, is that retro cognition thing.
48:05 Speaker 03 Yeah.
48:06 Josh Clark? That they somehow, their future selves who saw the erotic image was stimulated enough that that stimulation traveled backwards three seconds and influenced their choice.
48:17 Speaker 03 Because they would, they would be slightly stimulated physiologically, right, before they guessed. And he said before the computer even chose which, which one to show.
48:27 Josh Clark? Right, they, right, they were making their choices often correct before the computer chose to show an erotic or non-erotic image. And fifty-three percent, it doesn't sound like much, but Krowich points out a couple of things. One, that when the, there was a control group that was shown just non-erotic pictures.
48:46 Speaker 03 Yeah.
48:46 Josh Clark? They did forty-nine point eight percent correct, which is chance, fifty-fifty.
48:51 Speaker 03 And they were all not happy.
48:52 Josh Clark? Right.
48:53 Speaker 03 They were like, I don't wanna be the control.
48:54 Josh Clark? They're like, can we get a little steamier in here? But, and he also pointed out that fifty-three percent, fifty-three point one to be specific, doesn't sound like much, but apparently, that's a point-two percent chance where, on a scale between zero and one.
49:15 Speaker 03 Yeah.
49:15 Josh Clark? Where zero is, it's not gonna happen, and, and one is that it's definitely gonna happen.
49:20 Speaker 03 Yeah.
49:21 Josh Clark? And apparently, as far as correlation goes, or links between two things, something affecting another, a point-two is about the same as the link between aspirin and heart attack prevention, the link between calcium intake and bone mass, the link between secondhand smoke and lung cancer.
49:41 Speaker 03 So, things that are touted as like, pay attention to this.
49:45 Josh Clark? Yes.
49:45 Speaker 03 Yeah.
49:46 Josh Clark? Yeah, yeah, exactly. So, so, stuff that we accept, there's like, yeah, yeah. If you're around secondhand smoke, you, you can get cancer from that.
49:52 Speaker 03 Interesting, but this is probably poo-pooed.
49:54 Josh Clark? Has the same, exactly.
49:55 Speaker 03 Yeah.
49:55 Josh Clark? It is. And later on, a meta-analysis of Bem's experiments, some other experiments that were carried out afterward, and then some other experiments all grouped together, a meta-analysis showed that they, they weren't...
50:11 Josh Clark? It wasn't statistically significant if you took all of the existing body of literature of these experiments.
50:18 Speaker 03 Right.
50:18 Josh Clark? But it was a new scientist article and it was pretty cool. In the comment section, somebody said, "Yeah, it's not reproducible, but a lot of science isn't reproducible." And it reminded me of our scientific method episode.
50:33 Speaker 03 Yeah.
50:33 Josh Clark? Where like apparently a lot of trials that pharmaceuticals are based on aren't reproducible. Wasn't it like 50% of them or something like that?
50:43 Speaker 03 Yeah, which doesn't surprise me, of course.
50:44 Josh Clark? Yeah.
50:44 Speaker 03 All right, and then there was this other experiment that I need you to explain to me because I didn't understand it.
50:50 Josh Clark? Okay, you ready?
50:51 Speaker 03 Like, I got the first part, but I didn't, it didn't make sense to me.
50:54 Josh Clark? Because it's a little mind-blowing.
50:55 Speaker 03 Yeah.
50:56 Josh Clark? So, you know how like if you are studying something?
50:59 Speaker 03 Sure.
51:00 Josh Clark? And you write it down?
51:01 Speaker 03 Yes.
51:01 Josh Clark? It gets in your brain a little more?
51:03 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah.
51:03 Josh Clark? So that when you're tested on it later, you will recall it more easily?
51:08 Speaker 03 Yeah, that's a common study method, write something down.
51:11 Josh Clark? Okay, so Bem carried out a very simple experiment that did the opposite of that. First, he showed some people a bunch of words, 48 random words, I think nouns like tree or something like that.
51:23 Speaker 03 Yeah, and he told them to visualize it though, right?
51:25 Josh Clark? Right, so they saw all 48 words and thought about them.
51:28 Speaker 03 Not visualize the letters, but visualize the thing.
51:30 Josh Clark? Right.
51:31 Speaker 03 Like, see the tree in your head.
51:32 Josh Clark? Yeah, just to kind of try to memorize all 48 words.
51:36 Speaker 03 Yeah.
51:37 Josh Clark? Then the computer randomly selected 24 of those words.
51:41 Speaker 03 Okay.
51:41 Josh Clark? And then, after they'd done that, Bem gave them a test of recall to see how many they recalled, right?
51:48 Speaker 03 Yes.
51:49 Josh Clark? So the people had to type out the words they recalled.
51:53 Speaker 03 Yeah.
51:54 Josh Clark? Then, after that, the computer randomly selected 24 of the 48 words for the people to type, after they'd already taken the test of recall.
52:05 Speaker 03 Yeah.
52:05 Josh Clark? And those 24 words are the ones that people more consistently got right on the earlier test.
52:13 Speaker 03 Oh, okay.
52:14 Josh Clark? So, it's another example of that retro cognition, that these people getting the words in their heads after the test somehow went backward.
52:23 Speaker 03 Yeah.
52:24 Josh Clark? And influenced their recall and memory.
52:26 Speaker 03 Gotcha.
52:27 Josh Clark? For the test that they took before they... Learn them.
52:31 Speaker 03 That makes more sense.
52:32 Josh Clark? A little.
52:33 Speaker 03 Yeah, it is a little, but see, time travel melts my brain, too.
52:36 Josh Clark? Right, so this guy published this stuff in like 2010.
52:39 Speaker 03 Yeah.
52:40 Josh Clark? And like it was, it made a huge, huge splash, huge criticism. The, the academic journal was criticized. And Ben was, you know, pilloried and all that, but he still, you know, put out these, these very reproducible, understandable, simple exercises that still showed statistically speaking, there were some significant results that went beyond chance.
53:02 Speaker 03 So when it comes to debunking ESP, one thing that you're not gonna, you know, you said fraud, you're not gonna see a lot of people call researchers outright frauds, because that's just sort of a dangerous thing to say.
53:16 Josh Clark? Sure.
53:16 Speaker 03 It's not nice. But there are people out there who, I guess, are criticized for, you know, basically trying to call out, and this is something completely different, but these, these onstage psychic shows.
53:29 Josh Clark? Like crossing over with John Edwards.
53:31 Speaker 03 Yeah, like, it's easy to pick those people out and say, "You're a big fraud, and this is not true, of course, and all you're doing is cold reading." Cold reading, we talked about in the animal, pet psychics episode.
53:44 Josh Clark? Right.
53:45 Speaker 03 That's basically when you get up on stage and you say, "Sir, I'm sensing someone, you're having some trouble with, with another man in your life, with the name of J, or, or is it H, or O?"
53:59 Josh Clark? Maybe P.
54:00 Speaker 03 Or maybe it's P. "Yes, P, my, my boss."
54:03 Josh Clark? Peter.
54:04 Speaker 03 Yes, yes, exactly. And that's all a cold reading is, is throwing out these really broad things that anyone can latch on to.
54:09 Josh Clark? Right.
54:09 Speaker 03 So it's really easy to call those people out, and there's a guy, sort of a guy famous for doing that, his name is James Randi, and he's famous for his offer of one million dollars.
54:22 Josh Clark? Right.
54:23 Speaker 03 To anyone that can prove their psychic ability, which of course, no one stepped up to do that. But then he gets poo-pooed a little bit, like, you're just making a mockery of... Trying to legitimately disprove something.
54:36 Josh Clark? And mockery is absolutely the right word.
54:38 Speaker 03 Yeah.
54:39 Josh Clark? And to me, the presence of mockery indicates the absence of objectivity.
54:44 Speaker 03 Yeah.
54:44 Josh Clark? Right? So like what you're dealing with then with a guy like that is a set of beliefs, a belief system running up against another belief system.
54:53 Speaker 03 Right.
54:54 Josh Clark? Just like a couple of religions or something like that. It's not objectivity against fraud or anything like that. It's belief against belief or something.
55:03 Speaker 03 Yeah.
55:03 Josh Clark? Um, and, and yeah, the idea of lumping together John Edwards with Daryl Bem.
55:10 Speaker 03 Yeah.
55:10 Josh Clark? Is just, that's, you know, fraudulent in and of itself.
55:14 Speaker 03 Yeah, that's just, they call that theatrics, just like the onstage theatrics of a stage psychic.
55:19 Josh Clark? Yeah, so.
55:20 Speaker 03 And I believe, I totally agree.
55:22 Josh Clark? Yeah.
55:22 Speaker 03 You know?
55:23 Josh Clark? I, I do too. I think there's a definite room for a healthy scientific inquiry into just about anything, whether skeptics believe in it or not.
55:33 Speaker 03 Sure. If you can get some funding for it, who cares?
55:35 Josh Clark? Nice.
55:37 Speaker 03 That's my motto.
55:38 Josh Clark? Uh, you got anything else on ESP?
55:40 Speaker 03 Uh, let me think.
55:43 Josh Clark? Hmm.
55:44 Speaker 03 No.
55:45 Josh Clark? I've got, uh, one more thing. I found, I came across a 1990, I think, five Nightline with Ted Koppel.
55:52 Speaker 03 Yeah.
55:53 Josh Clark? Where, um, the news broke that the CIA had been studying ESP and trying to do remote viewing what Ronson was talking about in The Men Who Stare at Goats.
56:01 Speaker 03 Oh, yeah, John Ronson.
56:02 Josh Clark? When it finally became declassified in 1995, Ted Koppel did like a 20-minute Nightline segment on it. Totally worth watching. It's some pretty softball questions, but Robert Gates, who would later become the, the, um, head of defense.
56:17 Speaker 03 Yeah.
56:17 Josh Clark? He's on there just basically trying as politely as possible to show that he does not believe in any of this, even though he was a former CIA director. And, um, it's just neat.
56:27 Speaker 03 Plus you get to watch Koppel again.
56:29 Josh Clark? Right. He was a great news man.
56:31 Speaker 03 Yeah, I miss those dudes. I miss, uh, I was just thinking yesterday about, uh, Brokaw.
56:37 Josh Clark? Yeah, rather.
56:38 Speaker 03 I was, I was always a Brokaw man.
56:40 Josh Clark? Did you? I, I liked Peter Jennings, he was great.
56:43 Speaker 03 Yeah, I don't even know.
56:44 Josh Clark? All of them were great.
56:45 Speaker 03 I don't even have any idea who does Night in the News now, I don't watch it.
56:48 Josh Clark? It was Brian Williams until about a day ago.
56:51 Speaker 03 Did he get fired?
56:52 Josh Clark? He, like, got.
56:54 Speaker 03 I, I know the whole kerfuffle, but he didn't get fired for that, did he?
56:56 Josh Clark? I, I, I'm using my ESP to predict that by the time this came, this comes out, he will not be there anymore.
57:03 Speaker 03 Wow.
57:03 Josh Clark? I think this is getting big quick.
57:05 Speaker 03 Interesting.
57:06 Josh Clark? Yeah, Twitter's involved.
57:07 Speaker 03 Oh, man.
57:10 Speaker 03 The Twitter takedown.
57:11 Josh Clark? Yeah. Uh, if you want to know more about ESP, uh, the internet was virtually set up for you to go find out more about it. Um, you can start by typing ESP in the search bar at howstuffworks.com. Since I said that, it's time for listener mail.
57:26 Speaker 03 Yeah, before we do listener mail, I just want to give a quick shout out to my buddy Isaac McNary. Uh, if you remember, I did a Judge John Hodgman episode with Emily, in which I did a bad home renovation. And, um, this dude, Stuff You Should Know listener from Kansas, carpenter, master carpenter, said, "Hey, man, I'll come and stay with you and help you do your, your, uh, project there, right?" And I said, "This sounds crazy." And he actually came and did it. And it looks awesome.
57:55 Josh Clark? Yeah.
57:55 Speaker 03 And he's a super cool guy, and if you're in Kansas, the, near El Dorado, Kansas, there's no better guy to hire.
58:01 Josh Clark? The fabled city of El Dorado, Kansas?
58:04 Speaker 03 It's El Dorado, actually.
58:05 Josh Clark? Okay.
58:05 Speaker 03 He has to point out. But, um, not only is he a great carpenter and a cool guy, but he works with a nonprofit called Outreach Program. Uh, and you can find it at outreachprogram.org, where they're basically feeding the world.
58:18 Josh Clark? Oh.
58:18 Speaker 03 They package food and they, they get people together in a room and package these mass quantities of food to send to, uh, other countries and, uh, feed the hungry.
58:27 Josh Clark? Gotcha.
58:28 Speaker 03 And he's just a really good dude. So, thanks to Isaac for that. And my kitchen looks looking good. So again, for his nonprofit, that is outreachprogram.org. And if you need a great carpenter and you're in Kansas, check out retrofit remodeling.
58:42 Josh Clark? Nice.
58:43 Speaker 03 All right, listener mail. I'm gonna call this Pronunciation Help. Hey, guys, I'm a botanist and just wanted to throw you a rope to help you out with pronouncing plant family names. All plant family names end in A-C-E-A-E.
58:59 Josh Clark? Oh, yeah, I thought I got that wrong.
59:01 Speaker 03 It is a mess of vowels, guys. When you read it, you should just imagine you are spelling ACE as in A-C-E. So when you read a plant family name, just break off
59:13 Josh Clark? Oh, yeah, A-C.
59:13 Speaker 03 the A-C-E and read the first part and then spell A-C-E. So the plant family for poison oak is Anacardia Anacardia C-E. So it's just Anacardiaceae. I remember it by imagining the aneurysm and cardiac arrest I would have if I fell into it. A-N-A-C-A-R-D-I.
59:39 Josh Clark? What?
59:40 Speaker 03 Well, she spelled out Anacardi.
59:42 Josh Clark? Oh, gotcha.
59:42 Speaker 03 The first two, first letters from each of those words. Anyway, guys, I love your podcast. Find it endearing when you two puzzle out on pronunciations.
59:50 Josh Clark? A-C-E.
59:51 Speaker 03 A-C-E.
59:52 Josh Clark? That's good to know.
59:52 Speaker 03 Yeah. So I love you bunches. And that is from Jane. And she said, PS, in Europe, they pronounce plant families completely differently. Other parts of the US.
1:00:02 Josh Clark? A-E-C.
1:00:04 Speaker 03 Other parts of the US might have other conventions, but the above pronunciation is standard in California.
1:00:09 Josh Clark? Oh, well. Okay.
1:00:14 Speaker 03 What?
1:00:15 Josh Clark? A-C-E.
1:00:15 Speaker 03 A-C-E.
1:00:16 Josh Clark? If you want to let us know something that we should've known before we even recorded, but you're generous enough with your time and effort to correct us, I guess is a way to put it.
1:00:28 Speaker 03 Sure.
1:00:29 Josh Clark? We, that was very helpful. Thanks a lot, Jane. If you want to be like Jane in other words, you can send us an email to stuffpodcast@iHeartRadio.com.
1:00:40 Speaker 08 Stuff You Should Know is a production of iHeartRadio. For more podcasts, iHeartRadio, visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows.
1:00:56 Josh Clark? Buy smart, drive for less and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability. And it starts with a great deal on an off-road-ready Tacoma or half-ton Tundra, two of Toyota's longest-lasting trucks, combining power for work, tech for adventures, and style in between. And they're built on a reputation for quality and reliability, which is why Toyota trucks are known for holding their value, which could mean big savings when it's time for your next Toyota. So get a great deal today and a great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for more. Toyota, let's go places.
1:01:27 Speaker 09 Breathe in and reset with Lincoln Rejuvenate, an available multisensory feature in the 2027 Lincoln Navigator SUV. Experience the luxurious massage, visuals, and sense to help you relax in the driver's seat. It's your time for a reset. Visit lincoln.com to learn more. Lincoln Rejuvenate does not operate unless the vehicle is in park. When the vehicle is off or if any doors open, do not use the feature in a closed garage or in other enclosed areas. See owner's manual for important operating instructions. Lincoln and Navigator trademarks of Ford and its affiliates. All rights reserved.
1:01:57 Speaker 00 This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.
Previous VH-1: MTV for Your Parents Next [Insert Your Own Catchy Title About Younger Dryas Here] Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated