Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast StarTalk Live: The Particle Party (Part 2) About this episode The StarTalk Live “Particle Party” celebrating the discovery of the Higgs boson continues with Neil deGrasse Tyson, Bill Nye the Science Guy, CERN physicist Kyle Cranmer, comic co-host Eugene Mirman, Sarah Vowell and Scott Adsit.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk. Your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:22 Eugene Mirman? Welcome to another super fun-filled evening of StarTalk.
0:32 Eugene Mirman? It is now my great pleasure to bring out Neil Tyson.
0:45 Eugene Mirman? Sarah Vowell.
0:54 Eugene Mirman? From 30 Rock, Scott Adsit.
1:03 Eugene Mirman? And Neil?
1:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to the Particle Party.
1:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And...
1:10 Eugene Mirman? Nerds!
1:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The Particle Party is gonna be all about the Higgs boson.
1:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm feeling it. I can only take you so far in that subject. We had to go to the folks who really do this work, and we went to NYU. Professor Kyle Cranmer, come on out.
1:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How you doing, man? He is one of the scientists who works at CERN. Okay, so...
1:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, and I got a blank chair here. Join me in the warmest New York welcome for the man I call Sir William to the rest of the world. He is Bill Nye!
2:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So let's get this particle party started. You may remember, the date was July 4th. I tweeted that morning. I don't know if you saw it. My tweet was, "On the day America chooses to declare its own greatness, July 4th, Europe, who had just announced the discovery of the Higgs particle that morning, Europe reminds us how much America sucks at science."
2:50 Bill Nye? Wow.
2:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm just saying. You know, we could have done that.
2:55 Bill Nye? What, you mean the US could have done it by building the Superconductor Super Collider, but it was cancelled in 1993?
3:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
3:01 Bill Nye? 3+ times the energy?
3:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, so what's happened?
3:04 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, Kyle.
3:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What the hell's wrong with you physicists?
3:07 Speaker 03 I was still in high school.
3:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh.
3:10 Eugene Mirman? Ooh, I'm Doogie Howser of physics.
3:15 Speaker 03 No, actually, I was just graduating and on my way, and I was going to school in Texas even in college, and I would go to Waukesha Hachy and was excited about it until it turned out...
3:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's where they were digging the hole for the Super Collider.
3:27 Speaker 03 That's right. Before they made the world's largest mushroom farm.
3:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Underground, yes. So now you're like, full-up physicist, you've been a professor of physics at NYU for five years, you got your PhD here, but you were in residence at CERN. CERN stands for what?
3:41 Speaker 03 The Center for European Research Nucleaire, in French, so, you know, all the acronyms are backwards.
3:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, so let's get a primer going here. I want us to understand the structure of nature, okay? So, last I looked, we had four forces, so remind us of what the forces are.
3:58 Speaker 03 Right, so there's gravity that we...
3:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Gravity that we all know and love.
4:00 Speaker 03 We all know and love.
4:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Do you guys know and love gravity?
4:02 Speaker 04 Yeah, like, see?
4:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, good. Okay.
4:06 Speaker 03 She's an experimental...
4:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is radio, let the record show.
4:10 Bill Nye? And that's pretty far from the microphone. It was a sheaf of papers that was pulled to the floor.
4:14 Speaker 04 I dropped it to the floor and it fell there.
4:18 Bill Nye? But wait, there's more. Not only was the paper pulled toward the floor by the gravity of the earth, the earth was ever so slightly pulled up.
4:26 Eugene Mirman? Could you feel it? Could you feel it? We were all... And may I ask, what stopped the papers from going through the stage?
4:32 Speaker 03 That's a very good question. It was largely the electromagnetic interaction that binds atoms together. Yeah.
4:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's another force, electromagnetic.
4:40 Speaker 03 That's right. It's also what's... There's lights that are shining on us right now, why your cellphone works, why pretty much all of chemistry...
4:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I said it's two forces.
4:48 Speaker 03 That's right. And then the other two are things that most people aren't familiar with.
4:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Such as?
4:52 Speaker 03 They're inside the nucleus of an atom. There's one called the strong nuclear force.
4:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I bet it's strong.
4:57 Speaker 03 Yeah, that's right. You can actually tell a riddle that a lot of people would know. You know that positive charges want to repel each other, and you know that atoms have a lot of protons in them. So why don't those protons just fly apart? The strong force.
5:09 Bill Nye? Where'd they get the idea for the name?
5:11 Speaker 03 Well, I think it's because it's really strong. Yeah.
5:15 Bill Nye? And it's a force.
5:16 Speaker 03 And then there's the weak force. And that one has to do with things like radioactivity and why the sun burns and things like that.
5:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait. Why the sun gives you a sunburn? Or why the sun itself burns?
5:25 Speaker 03 They're sort of related.
5:31 Bill Nye? One thing leads to another, after all. But do you use the verb burning when it's fusion in a star?
5:37 Speaker 03 Yeah, no, we talk about stars burning their nuclear fuel.
5:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, so do chemists just want to kick your ass for saying that? Because burning is a chemical reaction, not nuclear.
5:46 Speaker 03 It is, but you know...
5:47 Bill Nye? Wow, we're geeking out.
5:48 Eugene Mirman? I don't know what you're arguing about.
5:52 Eugene Mirman? You're both mad at the word burning, apparently. And Neil's mad on behalf of people who aren't here.
5:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, so now we got 12 particles.
6:01 Speaker 03 Yeah, so the reason the chemists are really mad is they have a chip on their shoulder that the periodic table is not the right way to think about the universe and what it's made out of. It was really 12 fundamental particles.
6:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, there's a posse gathering here for you later.
6:16 Speaker 03 It's great. It's just not the fundamental picture that we have. The fundamental picture that we have is much more concise. We only have 12 fundamental particles, and everything in this room is really just made out of three of them.
6:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so give us the inventory.
6:27 Speaker 03 There are six quarks, and there are six other things which go into the...
6:31 Eugene Mirman? Do you not know what they are?
6:35 Eugene Mirman? I don't know what they are. You're like, there's six warts and there's a cheese and then...
6:41 Speaker 03 There are things like the electron, which are called the leptons. Everything's got on at the end, so it's not the Higgs boson, it's the Higgs boson.
6:48 Bill Nye? Leptons, which include?
6:50 Speaker 03 Electrons, and then there are sort of heavier brothers, the muon and the tau, which you may not have ever heard.
6:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Tau doesn't end in an "on", just in case.
6:58 Speaker 03 Tau on.
7:01 Bill Nye? But leptons would include positrons.
7:04 Speaker 03 Right, and all of these 12 have antiparticles, so antimatter...
7:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So 12 particles have another 12 antimatter counterparts?
7:10 Speaker 03 That's right, but we don't really count them as 12 more, because they're just so related to the other ones that we just group them together.
7:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so it's like the good particle and the bad particle?
7:19 Eugene Mirman? It's like Owlman to Batman.
7:22 Speaker 03 Wow.
7:24 Eugene Mirman? Sorry. I'm gonna leave now.
7:29 Speaker 03 You're speaking to a very narrow nerd audience in a very narrow nerd audience.
7:33 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, but there's like one person who's like, "Oh, boy."
7:38 Speaker 03 And that's me.
7:41 Bill Nye? What does Owlman do? What has he got going?
7:43 Eugene Mirman? He's from an alternate evil universe.
7:45 Speaker 03 In the modern DC Universe, there's an Earth 2, an alternate reality, where Batman's counterpart would be Owlman, who is part of the Injustice League, am I right?
8:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And now, there are the force-carrying particles. What do you got there?
8:08 Speaker 03 That's right. So each of the forces have these force-carrying particles, so that for the electromagnetic interaction, the particle of light is called the photon. The other ones have, you know, not-so-great names. So the weak force has the W and Z bosons, which...
8:21 Bill Nye? Where does Z come from?
8:23 Speaker 03 Because it happens after W, I guess. I don't know.
8:25 Bill Nye? Doesn't happen right after W.
8:27 Speaker 03 Yeah.
8:29 Bill Nye? It's coming. I can feel it coming.
8:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? W, X, Y, Z.
8:32 Bill Nye? And then right there.
8:32 Speaker 03 I'm a scientist, not a...
8:34 Eugene Mirman? Neighbor.
8:34 Speaker 03 Person.
8:35 Bill Nye? An alphabetician?
8:36 Eugene Mirman? You're telling us how it is. You didn't make up these mistakes.
8:40 Speaker 03 That's right.
8:42 Speaker 03 And then you'll like this one, the strong force, since it's so strong, has the gluon.
8:46 Bill Nye? I like gluon.
8:47 Speaker 03 Yeah, for obvious reasons.
8:49 Eugene Mirman? Now I get why science is not popular.
8:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Kyle, this seems like a profound absence of literacy among physicists.
8:59 Eugene Mirman? It does sound like it was all made by child geniuses.
9:05 Speaker 03 Well, the quarks is at least a reference to a poem, right?
9:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah. Oh, to Finnegan's wake, actually.
9:12 Bill Nye? But that aside, what are the 12?
9:13 Speaker 03 Electron, the muon, and the tau. And then they have things called neutrinos associated to them, so there's...
9:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Electron neutrino, tau neutrino, muon neutrino.
9:22 Speaker 03 Exactly. And then there are the quarks, so there's the up and the down, the charm and the strange, and the top and the bottom.
9:28 Bill Nye? And which of these 12 is considered the Judas particle?
9:35 Bill Nye? He was framed.
9:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, on top of all of these 12 particles, there's a God particle.
9:40 Speaker 03 Well, actually, all we know right now is it's a god-like particle. There's another particle which is sort of key to this whole story that we have.
9:47 Bill Nye? The keyon.
9:48 Speaker 03 Yeah, the keyon.
9:51 Speaker 03 That's actually the best proposal I've heard for a different name. Yeah, so there's this particle which is why we're here today called the Higgs boson. And it's key to like the consistency of this whole picture. And if it wasn't there, none of the theory would hold together. You know, we were talking about atoms and like why this piece of paper didn't go through the floor. If there was no Higgs boson, atoms wouldn't form in the same way and the universe would just look nothing at all like we know it to be. Well, we couldn't observe it. We wouldn't be here. That's what I'm saying.
10:19 Eugene Mirman? Because there'd be no mass, right?
10:21 Speaker 03 There would be no floor for the non-paper to not go through.
10:23 Bill Nye? But hold it. This verifies or helps enhance the veracity of a theory.
10:29 Speaker 03 Yes.
10:30 Bill Nye? Like, the universe is probably okay the way it is whether or not we called it the Higgs and whether or not we built this thing and went looking for it, right?
10:36 Speaker 03 Well, we just wouldn't understand it. I mean, yeah, I mean, the universe is here, obviously, but, uh...
10:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You still don't understand it if you're calling it a Higgs-like particle.
10:43 Speaker 03 Right. Now, that's just conservatism on the side of the scientists. You know, we already...
10:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You could tell us, you could...
10:48 Speaker 03 That's right.
10:50 Bill Nye? This is... We're at five sigma, though, right?
10:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's the Higgs. You could leave your error bars outside and just talk.
10:57 Speaker 03 No, there's no...
10:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're among friends.
10:58 Speaker 03 There's no doubt that there's a new particle. Even the director of CERN has now used the word "discovery," which is the first time we've used that since 1995. And this is the most significant discovery in my lifetime. So this is a high watermark for particle physics.
11:10 Bill Nye? A hand for Kyle, people.
11:16 Speaker 04 So, when you say "high water mark", so on that day, what were the parties like?
11:23 Speaker 03 Right. Well, at NYU, we had about 25 people at 3 o'clock in the morning, and, you know, we had several bottles of champagne, so it was good. Is that the latest you guys have ever stayed up? And also, the day before the announcement at CERN, Fermilab also made an announcement that they were seeing hints to the Russian- Fermilab outside of Chicago. Exactly, and the data that they had collected prior to having been shut down, which was roughly a year ago. Fermilab's been shut down. Well, the lab is running, but the large accelerator that does this kind of physics is off. Why? Stem cells. I mean, the- The funding was stopped. I mean, I think it was seen that it had sort of reached its-
12:03 Bill Nye? Limit of its power, of its acceleration.
12:06 Speaker 03 We were getting too close. Yeah, exactly.
12:09 Bill Nye? If only they'd used their acceleration for goodness. So, let me ask you this, Kyle, if I may. Is it not a coincidence that this announcement was made on the 4th of July?
12:20 Speaker 03 I think it was avoidable coincidence. It was an avoidable coincidence. It was both a coincidence and an avoidable coincidence. The situation was- I have no idea what that sentence means.
12:30 Bill Nye? It means they could have avoided it.
12:32 Eugene Mirman? They could have done it a different day, but also, it's fine.
12:37 Speaker 03 You don't think they were sticking it to America? It's a mystery wrapped in a riddle.
12:41 Eugene Mirman? Not sticking it to America. America can now celebrate finding God and 4th of July.
12:46 Speaker 03 Right. I mean, the situation was that we got a lot more data, a lot faster than we expected to, and no one expected we were going to be claiming discovery now. We thought it was going to be more like December or January time. But the accelerator ran so well, we got so much data, that right before this major conference being held in Australia, everyone kind of clued into the fact that we were likely going to claim discovery. And CERN didn't want it to be announced in Australia. They wanted to have it on their home turf. And there was basically no time between when everyone was flying over to Australia and the time that that decision was made. So, I think it could have been held on the 3rd, which would have been nice. I mean, there were certainly things in the media, but there was- it didn't make nearly the splash.
13:26 Eugene Mirman? I can't believe Geneva didn't celebrate our 4th of July properly.
13:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Finish telling me why you're calling it a god particle.
13:35 Speaker 03 The story of the name comes partially from a book that Nobel laureate Leon Letterman wrote, which is called "The God Particle." Originally, the name was chosen partially by his publicist and editor, and there's a story that he wanted to call it "The Goddamn Particle" because it's so hard to find. But clearly, god particle sells a lot of books. There are a lot of people, including myself, that aren't very happy with using that word. It looks like there's some sort of competition with science and religion or something.
14:01 Bill Nye? That would never happen.
14:10 Eugene Mirman? Science is co-opting god now.
14:13 Speaker 03 Right, so I think the thing that is true is that, you know, the universe would just look nothing like it does if this particle didn't exist. So is this something that tells us why there's something instead of nothing? Some people go that far. I just did. You did. The people that think a lot about string theory and things like that, there is a tie-in here in terms of why we're here and what it means to exist, and the Higgs has a very big role to play in that whole story.
14:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Why was it so hard to find?
14:40 Eugene Mirman? Had you looked under the table.
14:44 Speaker 03 It's somehow related to this mystery of quantum mechanics, which is that when you put something together, you know, nature in its most fundamental way has this funny probabilistic, like, "Why is it so hard to flip a head six times in a row?" or something like that, and it's just a...
14:58 Eugene Mirman? You mean of a coin?
15:00 Speaker 03 Of a coin.
15:01 Eugene Mirman? Just clarifying.
15:06 Eugene Mirman? They're easy to flip a head six times. Harder with a coin.
15:12 Bill Nye? So, anyway, you go to do experiments, and they don't always come out exactly the same way because nature has a probabilistic, a statistical feature.
15:20 Speaker 03 Right, and we can't control it at all. Yeah, we have no ability to control this part.
15:24 Bill Nye? It is precisely explained by...
15:26 Speaker 03 Quantum mechanics predicts what should happen, and it tells you you're gonna have to try really hard.
15:30 Speaker 04 So you're doing the experiment. What does that entail? Like, you push the button.
15:37 Speaker 03 And the monkey comes out.
15:39 Speaker 04 Like, what happens?
15:41 Speaker 03 Outside of Geneva, there's this ring under the ground that's about 17 miles around, and it's filled with superconducting magnets and all sorts of wizardry.
15:49 Bill Nye? Engineering.
15:51 Speaker 03 Engineering wizardry.
15:55 Bill Nye? That's alright, Mr. Scientist.
15:56 Eugene Mirman? There's a 17-mile ring made out of Harry Potter's.
16:00 Speaker 03 So, the one ring. Yeah, so, and it whizzes, uh... One ring to... With wizards, that's ruling all of you, right now. And it whizzes these particles around, they're called protons, at essentially the speed of light. And they collide at a couple spots inside of this ring where we have these huge particle detectors, which basically act as like big digital cameras. And when these particles run into each other, it's so hot, it's like the moment's after the Big Bang. And there's enough energy to ignite the production of new particles. So it's not that it's breaking apart, it's actually making new particles. And you have a chance, a very small chance, to make a Higgs boson.
16:36 Speaker 04 And so how many times did they have to do this?
16:39 Speaker 03 I looked this one up beforehand, so that I'd be prepared, so that... You work there. What do you mean you had to look it up? You're with people who are inventing the thing. No, no, I just, I tried to come up with some good ways to describe it. So, for the scientists, we had 10 to the 15, so that's one with 15 zeros behind it collisions. That'd be quadrillion. Yeah, so that's a million-billion collisions that we've had in the last two years. And of that, we made basically thousands-ish of Higgs bosons.
17:07 Eugene Mirman? And that's particle...
17:08 Speaker 04 Wait, you've made thousands of them, and you're just now saying...
17:15 Eugene Mirman? That's why he was like, "We could've mentioned it July 3rd."
17:21 Speaker 04 Well, you're basically like in a cop show. The coroner shows up, and the cop is like, "What's the cause of death?" And there's like, a guy with his head bashed in, and there's a shovel. And the coroner refuses to make a finding, until he gets back to the lab, even though clearly the guy's head was bashed in with a shovel. There's just something about scientists that you...
17:41 Speaker 03 Right, now, so to put it into perspective, if you took a large Olympic-sized swimming pool, and you filled it with sand, there would be trying to find a thousand red-colored sand grains in a swimming pool full of sand. So that's our job.
17:53 Eugene Mirman? That sounds harder than the...
17:55 Speaker 03 Harder than the puzzle.
17:56 Eugene Mirman? Than the shovel.
17:59 Eugene Mirman? It sounds doable, and I would have maybe told people July 2nd about it, but...
18:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Tell me about superconducting wires, and superconductivity in general.
18:16 Speaker 03 To get a particle that's going at nearly the speed of light to turn a corner isn't easy. And so you need a really...
18:23 Bill Nye? Tell me about it.
18:26 Bill Nye? I've talked to 'em, and I've talked to 'em. But there's a method, right? A technique?
18:31 Speaker 03 Yeah, basically you need powerful magnets. And the way you make powerful magnets is you need a lot of electrical current.
18:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, you need a magnet because a charged particle that's moving responds to the magnetic field.
18:41 Speaker 03 It will curve.
18:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You will curve that particle.
18:43 Speaker 03 That's right. That's how like the old-fashioned TV sets worked, in the big, you know, CRT-type...
18:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You know what I used to do when I was a kid? You'd take a magnet up to the tube?
18:51 Speaker 03 Right, exactly.
18:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you could totally mess with the faces on the screen.
18:54 Eugene Mirman? Parents loved that.
18:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Sometimes it left a permanent impression on the screen.
18:59 Bill Nye? They thought that was cool.
19:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But these are beams of electrons, and they would avoid the magnetic field. It was like early Photoshop, you know, where you could like, mess with...
19:08 Bill Nye? But I gotta say, the origin for me is cooler than that. So Michael Faraday, 1831, has got the magnet in the coil of wire that's connected to another coil of wire, and the compass moves.
19:18 Speaker 03 Right.
19:19 Bill Nye? And the woman comes up to him and says, "Of what use is it?" And he says...
19:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? "Of what use is a newborn baby?"
19:24 Bill Nye? Yes. Newborn babes, not that useful.
19:29 Speaker 03 But, you know, to make these incredibly powerful magnets, you need a lot of electricity, a lot of current. And the way you get that is by using superconducting cables.
19:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And what is superconductivity? It's a new superhero. I'm superconduct... you know, I mean, I could be that...
19:43 Speaker 03 It's basically a wire that when you get it really, really cold, it has no resistance. Not just a little resistance, no resistance whatsoever.
19:50 Bill Nye? And that is a quantum mechanical effect.
19:52 Speaker 03 It's a quantum mechanical effect also. To do it, though, you have to be sitting about 2 degrees above absolute zero. So this is colder than deep outer space.
20:00 Eugene Mirman? What, like 1.9 Kelvin?
20:02 Speaker 03 Bingo!
20:03 Bill Nye? Wow!
20:04 Eugene Mirman? Yeah!
20:06 Speaker 03 Nailed it!
20:08 Bill Nye? It was a wrist flip, you know, the hockey player skating backwards, just poof, just put it right in.
20:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Kyle, the universe is warmer than that, at 2.73 degrees.
20:17 Speaker 03 That's right, exactly. Deep space, like in the middle of outer space, it's warmer than it is in the middle of the LHC. The LHC, as far as we know, is the largest and coldest extended structure in the universe.
20:30 Bill Nye? Okay, so you get this thing, really cold, fabulous coils of wire, you buy a tank of hydrogen?
20:38 Speaker 03 Liquid helium. We have some very large fraction of the world's helium supply, as it's earned.
20:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The Macy's Day Parade has the rest.
20:45 Bill Nye? Yeah, that's right, yeah.
20:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
20:47 Bill Nye? A result of nuclear, yeah, fission. So, then we have a tank of hydrogen, and we electrostatically get these...
20:54 Speaker 03 Oh, to make the, that's right. Yeah, we use hydrogen to get to seed the beam itself, the beam of particles, you just take pure... To seed the beam.
21:01 Eugene Mirman? What does it mean to "seed the beam"?
21:04 Eugene Mirman? I mean, I know how it feels, but what does it mean?
21:11 Speaker 03 I walked right into that one. It's amazing, for the complexity of this whole thing, the beginning is really just some...
21:17 Bill Nye? Scuba tank.
21:18 Speaker 03 It's a scuba tank, and the guy goes, "Psst", that's it.
21:20 Eugene Mirman? Like Sarah was saying, where you just press a button. It sounds like a valve more.
21:24 Speaker 03 Yeah, exactly.
21:25 Eugene Mirman? And then it sprays what, hydrogen?
21:27 Speaker 03 Yeah, a little hydrogen.
21:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's your source of protons.
21:29 Speaker 03 That's our source of protons.
21:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Themselves comprised of three quarks.
21:33 Speaker 03 Three quarks, two ups and a down.
21:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Two ups and a down?
21:36 Speaker 03 That's right.
21:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so, that's where you get your protons, because the hydrogen nucleus is a proton.
21:42 Speaker 03 That's right.
21:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so now you got 'em. You got your superconducting coils.
21:47 Speaker 03 Right.
21:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You get high current going through, you get high magnetic field, you're curling these babies, you're accelerating these babies, don't you have another beam going the other way?
21:57 Speaker 03 Exactly, yeah. So there's, the magnets actually have two holes drilled in them, and there's two different magnetic fields, and we have to get, you know, all of this working together.
22:05 Bill Nye? So, if I want to get these things going very near the speed of light, I time the, uh...
22:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Current.
22:11 Bill Nye? Sign, the current, on these magnets, bloop, bloop, bloop, bloop, in sequence, right, in fantastically fast sequence.
22:17 Speaker 03 That's right.
22:18 Bill Nye? Now, let me ask you this. So...
22:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Bill gets ghetto on Kyle.
22:27 Bill Nye? Let me ax you this. I bring you to Brooklyn and now you're like, "Brooklyn in the house." Brooklyn, okay, I'm impressed with Brooklyn, but I grew up in the city of Washington, okay? When I was in junior high, a guy got shot. Okay, now everybody's doing it, but it was new, alright?
22:48 Bill Nye? Alright, how do we then get the particles going as fast, or nearly as fast as light? I believe I know the answer, but how can we time the magnets to keep up with those? Like the greyhound chasing the rabbit?
23:00 Speaker 03 So, you know, like if you use your cellphone, there's electromagnetic waves, right? There's all sorts of waves going back and forth between your phone and the cell tower.
23:07 Bill Nye? Microwaves.
23:07 Speaker 03 Microwaves. So we use essentially the same kind of idea, they're just very, very, very intense. So there's some sort of wave that's traveling along this beam, and that's what gets them going faster, and then we have big magnets to help them turn. To get the beam to be very intense, we have to add more and more protons. It's amazing, because it's sort of like trying to merge lanes on a freeway, except for you're driving at the speed of light. The engineers at CERN are so good at what they do, that they can merge lanes from, protons from the booster accelerator into the big accelerator, and put them in the same little bucket that you have.
23:39 Bill Nye? Do the beams go around each other like braids? Of Holla spiral? Yeah, but really, like Holla. That's accurate.
23:49 Speaker 03 So the way that the LHC works, they're just really two different beams that are right next to each other. They don't really circle around each other, but they do try to recycle the magnetic field from one to the other, so that you don't need twice as much electricity.
24:02 Bill Nye? By the way, how much electricity does CERN use when it's cranked? Does Geneva dim when they flick the switch?
24:09 Speaker 03 Well, we have a deal that we basically only run-
24:11 Bill Nye? He didn't just say no. He's gotta like, explain.
24:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome back to StarTalk Radio. I'm your host Neil deGrasse Tyson. You're listening to our show recorded live at the Bell House in Brooklyn, New York on July 17th, 2012. Along with Eugene Mirman, Scott Adsit, and Sarah Vowell. Onstage with me that night were Bill Nye the Science Guy and Kyle Cranmer, particle physicist. In this next segment, Kyle explains how much energy it takes to run the experiments at CERN that led to the discovery of the Higgs boson.
24:51 Speaker 03 It's equivalent to a small city, the amount of power that's required. A lot of it is going into accelerating the particles and even more goes into keeping this ring so cold. It's like a huge air conditioner.
25:01 Eugene Mirman? Well, that's... Wait, you were saying, so it gets much hotter than the sun, right? Like millions, thousands or millions of times hotter than the sun?
25:09 Speaker 03 You know, it's...
25:10 Eugene Mirman? Either way, say twice, that sounds very hot to me. So 1.9 Kelvin is cold enough to keep it from blowing up the Earth? Is what you're saying? Or melting the Earth? Or what's going on?
25:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, wait. Let's pick that up.
25:22 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, why aren't we all dead from your dumb experiment asshole?
25:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, Kyle, let's back up, Kyle. Answer me truthfully. Are you making many black holes at CERN?
25:35 Speaker 03 As far as we know, no. But we actually...
25:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How comforting! As far as we know, we don't think we're making Earth destroying black holes.
25:44 Speaker 03 Right, exactly. If it does happen, we'll all be the first to know. That's right.
25:48 Eugene Mirman? Actually, Europe will.
25:51 Eugene Mirman? Fools.
25:52 Speaker 03 Six hours earlier. No, I mean, we aren't making anything that's like a black hole like you think of it, like something in the center of our galaxy swallowing up stars. That is not happening. That is definitely not happening.
26:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're making a different kind of black hole. A more sinister kind of black hole.
26:07 Speaker 03 We might make the sort of quantum mechanical version of a black hole, which is very tiny and, you know, is not going to hurt you.
26:12 Eugene Mirman? Can it erase your memories if it's in your brain?
26:16 Speaker 03 That is one of the future applications that we talk about.
26:20 Speaker 05 Not scared.
26:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's what you talk about in the coffee lounge? We know you're talking stuff in the coffee lounge.
26:28 Speaker 03 There's a lot of coffee, it's her.
26:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You wield more power than any scientist that wielded before.
26:32 Speaker 04 Can you guys just sit around and talk about like, how can we weaponize this?
26:35 Speaker 03 Yeah, no, I think for the most part, you've got a pretty pacifist crowd, it's her.
26:40 Bill Nye? But everybody notice what an undertaking this is. They're powering a small city to send a scuba tank of hydrogen in a giant ring to unlock the next secret of the universe. That is pretty cool. I have to say, that is a remarkable use of our intellect and treasure. It's pretty cool.
26:57 Speaker 05 So do you guys, when you hit the button on the accelerator, do you like, then wait for the moment when they collide, or is it just instantaneous? Or is it like a, here they go, ahh!
27:08 Bill Nye? Yeah, yeah.
27:10 Speaker 03 Well, the very first collisions, there are great photos of people when they saw the very first collisions, and it was just, you know, thousands of people throughout the laboratory, just, you know.
27:19 Bill Nye? How long did it take you to throw the switch?
27:21 Speaker 03 The beams were going, and then at some point, they have to bring the beams, quote, "into collision," you know, so they have to try to steer the beams so they collide with each other.
27:28 Bill Nye? They boost a magnet or something?
27:29 Speaker 03 They can steer where the beams go with these magnets, and it's very hard, because the beam of particles is thinner than a human hair, so it's incredibly tiny, and then to get them to collide...
27:37 Eugene Mirman? Because it's a proton.
27:39 Speaker 03 Yeah.
27:40 Eugene Mirman? So it's a lot thinner, right?
27:41 Speaker 03 Well, no, it's all...
27:43 Eugene Mirman? I'm just asking, I don't know.
27:46 Speaker 03 No, no, you're right. So there's a whole lot of protons. So one proton is incredibly small, but the beam of protons is...
27:52 Eugene Mirman? Oh, it's a bunch of protons, like eighty, maybe even ninety.
27:56 Bill Nye? Well, a few thousand after a year, right?
27:59 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah.
28:00 Eugene Mirman? Does it never stop? Did you guys just flip the switch one day and then just keep collecting?
28:03 Speaker 03 It basically runs almost all year long. We have a deal that we don't run during the winter, because that's when Europeans heat their houses, where Americans usually cool their houses in the summer. So the electricity load in Switzerland is mainly during the winter.
28:16 Speaker 05 So they're going around that all the time?
28:18 Speaker 03 I mean, the numbers are just mind-boggling. So they're running essentially constantly. The particles collide forty million times a second.
28:25 Speaker 05 What, and that's every second? Or is it when you choose to flip a switch and say, oh, now we're merged?
28:29 Speaker 03 Essentially, constantly for two years, with some shutdowns.
28:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Forty million times a second for two years?
28:34 Speaker 03 That's right.
28:35 Bill Nye? You got a problem with that?
28:36 Speaker 03 Yeah, so it's phenomenal. And each one of these collisions, you know, there are thousands of particles produced flying into our detectors. We take sort of a three-dimensional digital photo of what happens. Each one of those is sort of similar to like a really nice digital camera in terms of the file size.
28:51 Eugene Mirman? Bragger.
28:52 Speaker 03 Forty million of them a second. So it's like if every American got a nice digital camera and took a photo every second and tried to upload it to Flickr. That's what the amount of data that we have to deal with.
29:03 Speaker 04 Is it hard to say psyched, like after the 20 millionth one? Are you kind of like, "Yeah"?
29:07 Speaker 03 Yeah, well, you know, most of them aren't so exciting, but then you see one that looks like the Higgs.
29:12 Speaker 05 And how do you know when you've got something interesting? I mean, there's, you can't go through 20 million photos.
29:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Before you answer that, I just want to clarify here. You're smashing protons, then the proton disappears. Because the particles become energy, and then the energy becomes particles again.
29:27 Speaker 03 That's right. It's, you sort of...
29:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This equals mc squared writ large.
29:32 Speaker 03 Exactly.
29:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? At the focus of these two colliding beams.
29:35 Speaker 03 That's right.
29:36 Speaker 05 Neil is taking his pants off right now. You can't see it.
29:44 Speaker 03 No, it's, it's fine.
29:45 Speaker 05 Writ large.
29:47 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's basically E equals mc squared is happening twice.
29:58 Speaker 03 Usually you think about nuclear bombs or nuclear power.
30:01 Eugene Mirman? Love it.
30:02 Speaker 03 Yeah, you take a little, you take a little bit of mass and you turn it into a whole lot of energy. What we do is we take a lot of energy and we make a very little bit of mass. So there's this brief period where the protons collide. There's so much energy that it just sort of vaporizes into this funny quantum mechanical, funny, effervescent state that can crystallize into some new kind of particle, some new very massive particle that hasn't existed since right after the Big Bang. And then that thing doesn't last for long, and it decays.
30:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How long?
30:31 Eugene Mirman? Hour, two hours?
30:33 Speaker 03 Yeah. No, it's funny. Yeah, I mean, the numbers, there are things like 10 to the minus 23 seconds and things like that. So very, very, very small numbers.
30:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you get excited about this.
30:42 Speaker 03 Look at him.
30:44 Eugene Mirman? You love watching Higgs particles die, you monster.
30:49 Bill Nye? So, how exactly do we detect these things?
30:52 Speaker 03 Right, so it's there for just a split second, or not even, and then it decays, and it can decay in a lot of different ways. So, one way that it can decay is into two particles of light, two photons. And then these particles fly and hit our detector.
31:05 Bill Nye? Which is like a solar cell of some sort.
31:07 Speaker 03 It's similar to that, I mean, in the sense that when a photon hits it, it leaves some energy, and we measure that energy. You know, we sort of surround this interaction point with all sorts of sensitive detectors.
31:16 Bill Nye? And these things are huge, like 10 stories high, right?
31:18 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's like the size of a six-story building, full of electronics, yeah. So, they're enormous. And they're 300 feet under the ground, so the civil engineering involved in actually making this thing was also just fantastic.
31:29 Bill Nye? Right on. Now, it gets radioactive, right? Like, you can't be around it.
31:32 Speaker 03 I mean...
31:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, did you have your kid before you started working at CERN? When was your kid born?
31:38 Eugene Mirman? You don't want to make him angry.
31:48 Speaker 03 CERN is very careful about the radioactivity. We make some particles, like neutrons, that make things radioactive, and so we have to be careful.
31:56 Bill Nye? So, when you say be careful, does the detector zone, the six-story-high, concrete tub, become radioactive?
32:02 Speaker 03 It does, you know, there's like a half-life associated to it, but to get down there...
32:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That would be a yes.
32:06 Speaker 03 Yes, it does. And there are retinal scanners, you know, normal people can't go down there, and even...
32:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Only radioactive people can go down there.
32:11 Speaker 03 Only radioactive people, yeah.
32:13 Eugene Mirman? So, people will... Meaning people whose eyes have been pre-approved.
32:15 Speaker 03 That's right, that's right.
32:16 Bill Nye? So, people wear dosimeters, badges to detect radiation?
32:19 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's very heavily regulated.
32:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You have dosimeters?
32:21 Speaker 03 Sure.
32:22 Eugene Mirman? What's a dosimeter? Not that I don't know.
32:25 Bill Nye? No, it's not a hard word.
32:27 Speaker 03 Not that kind of dose, yeah.
32:28 Bill Nye? It's a dose meter. Measures the dose of radiation.
32:31 Eugene Mirman? Oh, okay.
32:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I have an issue with dosimeters.
32:34 Bill Nye? Because you... Who doesn't?
32:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You know, no, no, no, it tells you how sterile you have become. Why is that useful? It's after the fact. You turn it in at the end of the day, and they measure it.
32:47 Bill Nye? Are you joking?
32:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, I'm serious!
32:49 Bill Nye? Well, dude, the world's full of radiation. I mean, I'm not Mr. Nuclear, but...
32:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It should tell me, like, while it's happening.
32:54 Bill Nye? Well, it tells you while it's happening in the geologic scheme of things. Every day, you get some. No, but I mean, compared to the half-life of radon gas, it's pretty good.
33:06 Eugene Mirman? Where do you get?
33:08 Bill Nye? From Brits.
33:08 Eugene Mirman? You're talking about this like it's annoying and it happens at Starbucks.
33:12 Bill Nye? Well, it does.
33:14 Eugene Mirman? Like, where you're like, "I just want a latte."
33:16 Bill Nye? Well, it's a little bit.
33:17 Eugene Mirman? They're telling me I'm sterile.
33:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, let's back up a few months. Why should we believe this news report? When not many months ago, CERN released a news report about faster-than-light neutrinos. That was then later retracted.
33:36 Speaker 03 Yeah, now, that's a good question. I'll say that around the physics department at NYU, there were, you know, lots of discussions about this. And a lot of theorists that are like, "I cannot believe that they published this paper. I cannot believe CERN made any news about this." You know, it's clearly wrong. Einstein told us this, everything we know about the world's this way. But it's not the first time that experimental science has turned everything we think we understand about the world on its head. And that's how science works. You do experiments.
34:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It might have been true.
34:05 Speaker 03 It could have been true. If you saw how it was presented at CERN.
34:08 Bill Nye? That was cool.
34:09 Speaker 03 It was like, we are coming to the scientific community to say that we see this thing that we don't understand. We spent six months checking and cross-checking and doing everything that we could, and we can't figure it out, so we're bringing it to you.
34:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You sent neutrinos to Italy.
34:23 Speaker 03 Underground, through the ground.
34:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Through the ground. And it got there faster than the speed of light.
34:28 Speaker 03 By just a very, very small.
34:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And what I heard that they knew it was wrong because nothing arrives early in Italy. Okay? That's what I heard. I don't know.
34:40 Speaker 05 So Kyle, does that mean that it arrived before it was sent?
34:43 Speaker 03 No, not before it was sent, yeah.
34:45 Bill Nye? That's a pretty good question, though. That's pretty cool.
34:48 Speaker 03 Actually, you know, I should say that that's relative.
34:52 Bill Nye? No, but my understanding, they were using clocks from global positioning satellites, and they didn't take into account there is a difference from one to the other.
34:59 Speaker 03 Oh, no, that stuff was taken into account very, very carefully. The very sad part is that after all of this thorough checking, the problem was the dopiest of possible problems, it was a loose cable.
35:09 Bill Nye? Oh, it's... All failures are mechanical failures.
35:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So the engineers messed up?
35:14 Bill Nye? Yeah. I gotta tell ya, in my old business, connectors are troublesome.
35:18 Speaker 03 Right. There was a father-son story there. Carlo Rubia, who won a Nobel Prize and was a famous particle physicist...
35:25 Bill Nye? What was his specific discovery?
35:26 Speaker 03 He was involved in the discovery of the W and the Z, and he really kinda pushed the idea of having these colliders in the first place.
35:32 Bill Nye? Where was that and when?
35:33 Speaker 03 That was at CERN in the 80s. But his son was on the experiment that reported the faster-than-light neutrinos, and he was on the experiment that then followed up and said, "No, they're not going faster than the speed of light, so you can only imagine what their Thanksgiving conversations are like."
35:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? When we come back, we're just gonna talk about where we go from here. What is the future of the Higgs particle? Will it have any application at all? Or is Europe wasting its $10 billion to keep you employed? When we come back to StarTalk Radio!
36:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? StarTalk Radio is brought to you in part by a grant from the National Science Foundation.
36:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? As always, I sign off by bidding you not only farewell, but encouraging you to keep looking up.
Previous StarTalk Live: The Particle Party (Part 1) Next Cosmic Queries: Telescopes Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated