Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast StarTalk Live! Sociology and the Human Condition About this episode Neil deGrasse Tyson and Eugene Mirman investigate the human condition with the help of bestselling author Malcolm Gladwell, sociologist Dr. Alondra Nelson and comedian Wyatt Cenac. Recorded live at NYC’s Hammerstein Ballroom.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk. Your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now. I'm your host Neil deGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist, and this is StarTalk. The topic is sociology. So, to anchor some of the academic foundation of this, I want to bring out the woman who is the first appointed dean of the Division of Social Sciences at Columbia University, Professor Alondra Nelson. Come on out.
0:45 Speaker 01 Hello.
0:46 Speaker 02 Hi.
0:47 Eugene Mirman? It is now my great pleasure to bring on a very funny man. He was the correspondent on The Daily Show, Wyatt Sinak.
1:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And who else but the five-time New York Times bestselling author of all manner of sociological phenomena, Malcolm Gladwell. Malcolm, come on out. So Malcolm, I love your storytelling. You highlight things that go on in our culture, in our society, you make us think, and this is always good. So, I don't think at any point you say you comment on sociology, so since we have someone who does that academically, Alondra, could you just tell us, what is sociology?
1:40 Speaker 01 So sociology is the study of social life, how a culture develops, how social communities evolve.
1:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So not the individual?
1:47 Speaker 01 Not the individual in sociology, although in the social sciences, there are people like social psychologists and psychologists who are very much interested in the individual. But sociologists, the scale of life we write about is the group, the family, institutions, organizations.
2:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Malcolm, one of your most talked about books was titled Blink. It's an exploration of the effectiveness of decisions that people make on the spot, depending on what their life experience is that is behind it. And there's a story in there where you talk about your hair.
2:20 Speaker 02 Yeah.
2:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Could you, because I think all we needed here is like Questlove and we'll have the three biggest afros in the entire United States.
2:30 Speaker 02 Yeah. And then together we form Cornel West.
2:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, exactly.
2:36 Speaker 02 Most people don't know that Cornel West is a Voltron made of me, Malcolm Gladwell, and Questlove.
2:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So what happened, what happened with your hair?
2:46 Speaker 04 Well, through my mid 30s, I had my hair very short and then I grew it out until it was quite florid and I discovered what, of course, many, many others have discovered all along, when you start to appear blacker, the world changes, right? The way the world treats you changes quite dramatically.
3:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Are you asking me that or telling me from your own?
3:06 Speaker 04 Well, I'm sure you know this already, but I'd been passing very successfully for quite a long time and then all of a sudden there was some hint of doubt.
3:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? As your afro got bigger and bigger?
3:17 Speaker 04 As it got bigger and bigger and then it culminated, I started getting speeding tickets and I got pulled over on 14th Street, the cop car drove up on the sidewalk, they jumped out, they surrounded me and there was one black female cop and two white male cops and they were convinced that I was this rapist that they were looking for. I said, "Well, let's see the sketch," because I had the sketch. I was like, "I don't look like that at all. The only thing we have in common is we have the same hair." And the black female cop is like laughing and she's finding this quite hilarious. The two white guys are like, "No, no, no, we think it's you." It was like this long thing and I thought that was, A, weird, but B, that it was something that got me thinking about that phenomenon, that people, we jump to conclusions about
4:00 Speaker 04 each other all the time without realizing that we're doing it and that's where the book came from.
4:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, Alondra, what do sociologists say about this? Obviously, police interaction with citizens has been much in the news lately. Yes. But other than just getting it from the news, is there some like experiments done or research where you can help out this situation so it doesn't happen again?
4:22 Speaker 01 So we have the implicit bias test that psychologists do, right?
4:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's a fun test. I've taken it. It's online.
4:26 Speaker 01 You've taken the test. How racist are you?
4:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, I took it eight years ago, and I did it for the sexist, not the racist.
4:31 Speaker 01 Oh, OK.
4:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
4:32 Speaker 01 How biased are you? How, yes, prejudiced are you?
4:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I was like mildly. It tests your reaction time
4:37 Speaker 01 Yes.
4:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? to certain stimulus. And if you take a little longer, you're overcoming some mental block
4:42 Speaker 01 Sure.
4:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? against the expectation.
4:43 Speaker 01 Sure. So it's easy to think these are kind of innate, almost like reflexes, you know, almost like someone hitting your knee in that right spot and your leg popping up. But these are learned behaviors. So even that quick reflex is learned over time through processes of socialization. So we can recognize as human beings that we look differently, but it takes process of socialization through religion, through family, through the media, to learn what we're supposed to think about that. So we could have imagined a scenario in which someone said to Malcolm, "You look familiar," without having a sort of set of associations that quickly link together about what that's supposed to mean, right? And those kinds of quick associations are what we sociologists are interested in.
5:23 Eugene Mirman? So if we had policemen that were babies, they wouldn't have enough time to even develop any biases?
5:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If they were police from very young.
5:31 Eugene Mirman? No, if our police people were babies,
5:35 Eugene Mirman? they would just treat every situation as new.
5:38 Speaker 01 That is the, I think it's-
5:39 Speaker 04 Well, on that, along those same lines, I have often been arguing for that. Juries should never see the person that they are judging.
5:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You want to give people less information.
5:48 Speaker 04 Yeah. Once you learn all this stuff about implicit bias and how strongly our decisions are conditioned by just the way the person looks, it strikes me that we'd all be better off if the person who's on trial would be in another room. They would answer questions on email. You would have-
6:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Text, texting.
6:05 Speaker 04 Texting, whatever you want to do. Snapchat, so it'll just be gone the minute they- And then anything that identified their age, gender, or race would just be expunged from the record. Because we know, I mean, we look at the data and we see that a black defendant gets a very different treatment by the law than a white defendant accused of the exact same crime, right? So let's take it based out of the equation. I don't understand why there's such resistance to that notion.
6:28 Eugene Mirman? So make it more like The Voice.
6:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
6:34 Speaker 02 I'm okay with that.
6:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So the jury are in these big overplussed chairs. Then they rotate around when it's time.
6:42 Speaker 02 And at least one of them is Blake Shelton.
6:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So I remember maybe 10 years ago.
6:49 Speaker 02 Yeah.
6:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I saw this done with a classical music concert. Is this still in place?
6:55 Speaker 04 I read about this in Blink. So classical music had a problem with there were no women in major orchestras. And they would always say it's because they're not good at playing classical music. Women are inferior musicians.
7:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're talking about the virtuoso lead musicians?
7:07 Speaker 04 So this is the high-end orchestras. And then for a completely random set of reasons, started to do blind auditions, like The Voice. You can't see the person auditioning.
7:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They're just behind some kind of...
7:16 Speaker 04 Screen. And overnight, they started hiring women. And they realized that the reason they weren't hiring women was just because they had a set of associations about women in music that interfered with their ability to hear their music.
7:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Why don't you say because men are idiots? I mean, isn't that just the answer?
7:29 Speaker 04 Well, people are more in the grip of their biases than they want to admit. You know, which raises this additional question, which is, why do we ever need to see the person who we are auditioning for any position or job?
7:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You talk about in your book in Blink, someone who claimed they could tell you within a few minutes, tell a married couple whether they would be divorced within 15 years.
7:50 Speaker 04 Yeah.
7:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And they can do that in like a couple of minutes.
7:53 Speaker 04 Less than that.
7:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Less than a couple of minutes.
7:56 Speaker 04 Yeah. But that's with an extraordinary amount of training. There is a language to the muscles of the face. Whenever we express an emotion, that emotion is represented in an incredibly subtle way.
8:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Unless you're autistic.
8:08 Speaker 04 Yeah, then it would be less.
8:10 Speaker 02 Or a cat.
8:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's funny because anytime in a Disney movie, when they need to represent the emotions in an animal that doesn't otherwise express emotions that we would read, they give them eyebrows and the eyebrows move up and down.
8:26 Speaker 04 Yeah.
8:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, and so that's intriguing. The eyebrows apparently are a big cue. They're big enough for us to hand it to animals that don't have eyebrows.
8:34 Speaker 04 So the muscular positions your face takes are called action units. And action unit one, which is an unconscious signal of distress, is when the inner part of our eyebrows go up. Almost none of us can do this voluntarily. But if you watch a baby cry... The instant before they actually vocalize their cry, their eyebrows will go "doot", it's incredible. And once you notice that, once you realize that, you can watch someone, and if you ever hear someone absorb bad news, you will 99 times out of 100 see their eyebrows just go "whoop", and they have no idea they're doing that. But it makes you understand this is how- It's a fun game, do it to people. Give them terrible news. This is part of the arsenal that people use to tell when people are lying, right?
9:19 Speaker 04 If you say some horrible thing and your eyebrows are sitting like this, then that's a clue that the emotion may not be felt as deeply as they're claiming.
9:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, some people can read this with great precision.
9:31 Speaker 04 This is the work of a guy named Paul Ekman, yeah.
9:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay. If that works, it seems to me we could exploit that in almost every aspect of life and of society, but there's some famous failed examples of snap judgments, aren't there?
9:45 Speaker 04 Oh yeah, I mean, most of my book is about the failure of snap judgments. I'm much more impressed by how they mislead us than how they help us.
9:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, so in sociology, we can think of what goes on inside the person in reaction to an environment, and we can say, "That's not how you're supposed to behave", "Change", or we can say, "Let's design the environment to be different, and thereby fix it by changing the environment rather than by a re-education program." There's an example from my community with the Challenger disaster. As you may remember, what we learned was that there, in the solid rocket boosters, each shuttle system has two of them, they're held together in three segments or four segments, and those segments connect with an O-ring. And inside there, it's very cold. The fuel is kept very cold before it ignites. And so, if you take something rubbery like an O-ring
10:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? and you chill it down, its pliability and plasticity gets compromised. And so, it no longer would maintain a seal. So when these rockets launched, a leak broke out from where the fuel was being ignited, and then that ignited the main engine, and the whole thing exploded. And so, a tragic accident. But then they got to the bottom of it and said, "Okay..." Forget the failure. What was in the system that allowed the failure to come forward?
11:08 Speaker 04 Yeah.
11:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And what was the analysis of it?
11:09 Speaker 04 Well, this is one of my favorite pieces of sociology. There's a great sociologist called Charles Perrow, who wrote a book about what he called "normal accident theory." And the idea of normal accident theory is there are two kinds of disasters. There's a disaster that happens because people screw up. They make dumb or incompetent or corrupt decisions. And there's disasters that happen even though everyone is doing their job as their job is designed to be done. He calls those "normal accidents." And others argued, although he agreed with it, that the Challenger accident was an example of a normal accident. In other words, there wasn't something deeply screwed up in NASA that made that happen. That accident grew out of the culture of NASA.
11:54 Speaker 04 The way they thought about risk, the way different parts of the hundreds of different decisions that went into the Challenger rocket interacted in the moment.
12:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you're implicating a system in that case, not the individual?
12:06 Speaker 04 And when you think about the way we respond to a disaster, our first instinct is to-
12:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? To blame somebody.
12:11 Speaker 04 Blame somebody.
12:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, point your finger.
12:12 Speaker 04 And what Perrow is saying is there's no one, there's no individual to blame.
12:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Which is frustrating for everybody else.
12:17 Speaker 04 Very frustrating.
12:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Especially when you have caskets going by in a parade.
12:20 Speaker 02 Now, wait, when you say "the blame goes to the system," does that mean like the system that would say, "Oh, okay, we should use rubber O-rings," as opposed to some other type of material?
12:35 Speaker 04 I think the argument would be on a more abstract level than that, which is that each component in something like a rocket booster has to meet a certain level of specifications and operates within certain risk parameters. Use an acceptable level of risk and a certain number of redundant systems and-
12:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just to point that in any system such as that, the risk is never zero. So you have to upfront say- This is an acceptable level of risk. And we're going to try to keep everything above that. And if you go to zero, you'd have to launch them in a tank. And you can't.
13:07 Eugene Mirman? You would have to not go to space.
13:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, you would not go to space.
13:09 Eugene Mirman? You would have to trick them into thinking they're in space just as a goof.
13:13 Speaker 02 Or invite space to come visit you.
13:16 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
13:17 Speaker 02 There you go.
13:18 Eugene Mirman? Which comes with a bit of a risk.
13:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, Alondra, what do sociologists say about bureaucracies and systems? And the risk that some bureaucracies have to manage?
13:27 Speaker 01 So, there's the brilliant book that Malcolm in Part is referencing is by Diane Vaughn, who's a sociologist at Columbia. And part of what she's saying, to take it to one more level of abstraction, is that we create systems that are so complex that they become almost autonomous systems that we can't quite wrap our head fully around, right? So the technological systems themselves come to have a kind of agency of their own.
13:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They've achieved consciousness.
13:49 Speaker 01 Not quite, but close, right? And so, looking at one aspect of it, you have to look at the bigger system or organism or institution to understand. And that's why the blame doesn't lie with one person solely. The culture of the people working there, as well as the actual technological things happening.
14:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so somebody's got to change it. Has any of that been happening?
14:06 Speaker 01 So this goes back to your question about whether or not we can change people or we change the environment. This is a pas de deux. This is a dance, right? And so...
14:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Pas de deux?
14:13 Eugene Mirman? It is. I was going to say kind of a bit of a pas de deux.
14:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, that's what I was thinking.
14:16 Speaker 01 So you change the environment and you create the different dynamic that we then again may not understand.
14:22 Speaker 02 So it sounds like what you're saying is that for those who didn't like the way Lost ended, it's an institutional problem.
14:34 Speaker 02 You can't just blame the writer.
14:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait. But I pose the question to both of you here. If there isn't an individual to point a finger at, and it's institutional, isn't that way harder to rectify? Because then there's no accountability. If there's no accountability, then how does anything change? If you've built systems that are so large, they transcend the comprehension of the people even working there?
15:01 Speaker 04 Well, I'd say the opposite. I would say that if you have a society which insists on pointing the finger of blame at individuals every time something goes wrong, you're going to create a behavior on the part of individuals that is risk averse, that is defensive. It's far easier, I think, to say, "Look, we're not going to shame you publicly or string you up. We're going to say, 'Let's fix the problem on a broader level. Let's make it easier for you to do your job.'" Because I think most people in the world want to do their job well.
15:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I want to have institutions been doing this.
15:31 Speaker 01 Sure. I mean, institutions change. I mean, there's some classic examples from the business literature about how in Japan, this would have been in the 80s, just in time production, right? So you didn't have all of these cars and parts sitting in factories. You were able to sort of do them as you needed them, and you didn't have this back slot. So organizational change happens all the time.
15:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that was better for your cash flow because you didn't have this repository of inventory?
15:52 Speaker 01 Exactly, right.
15:53 Eugene Mirman? What was happening in Japan with cars?
15:56 Speaker 01 Just they got better at selling and making cars than we did in the United States because they went to a form of production that changed the organizational structure.
16:03 Speaker 04 I have a simpler example. You know, you were talking about police behavior earlier. There's a significant body of research which says that police officers in single-man squad cars behave better than police officers in two-man squad cars, which is contrary to what everyone thought before. But what we've discovered is that if you're by yourself, you are less likely to do something risky, and you slow down. If you've got a buddy with you, you are more likely to feel invulnerable and charge in. We don't want you to charge in. We want you to stop, think, call for help, and calm everybody down. When you're by yourself, you're in an institutional situation, well, that's easier to do.
16:41 Eugene Mirman? Is that why so many police are now on segways?
16:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just in the mall. I'm a mall cop.
16:48 Eugene Mirman? So calm and non-threatening it feels.
16:50 Speaker 04 You really can't go faster than eight miles an hour. Yeah.
16:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But it also perhaps accounts for why the buddy cop film is such a fertile genre, because they can each do crazy things with one another. That makes the story.
17:03 Speaker 04 Is there a famous cop movie where the cop is driving by himself?
17:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, maybe Dirty Harry. Did he have a partner?
17:09 Eugene Mirman? He probably shot him.
17:26 Speaker 04 Regardless of how talented you are, you can't be good at what you do unless you're willing to put in some work, right? So the interesting question is: What is the threshold level of work you have to put in to make the most of your talent? And that's, I think, where this idea that I talked about in one of my books, the notion of 10,000 hours, comes from.
17:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? 10,000 hours.
17:46 Speaker 04 So what they're saying is, it's not about you don't need to have talent. It is about expressing talent requires, we think, about this much work.
17:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So with or without talent, if you're not putting in 10,000 hours, you're not winning any contest.
18:00 Speaker 04 One of the foundational studies in this field was done of classical musicians. You look at the 30 greatest classical compositions of all time, and you ask the question: At the time the composer of that composition did their greatest work, how long had they been composing? And the answer is, in almost every case, they had been composing for at least 10 years, which is roughly 10,000 hours.
18:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because you have to sleep and go to the bathroom.
18:23 Speaker 04 So even Mozart, he doesn't do his truly great stuff until he's been composing for 13 or 14 years. I think he's composing by 6 or 7.
18:32 Eugene Mirman? Were those compositions at 6 or 7, meh? They're Dave Matthews-ish.
18:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So at 6 or 7, he was composing. People like citing that about him.
18:43 Speaker 04 But it's not good stuff until he's 22 or 23. What we associate with Mozart's genius is stuff that he produces 14, 15 years into his life as a composer, which is a fascinating and sobering thought.
18:57 Speaker 02 It's the same with Beyoncé. Nobody talks about the Destiny's Child song. But now they love her. Oh, now she's the queen.
19:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So we have the story of David and Goliath, which works on many levels. It's metaphor. But I guess you've thought about that story more than most people have.
19:17 Speaker 04 Well, there's just all this fascinating historical and anthropological literature on reinterpreting that story. There's all kinds of interesting points, but the most interesting of which is there are many medical experts who suspect that Goliath had a medical condition called Akromegaly, which would result in him being largely blind. So acromegaly is-
19:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, wait, it primarily results in you being huge.
19:41 Speaker 04 Yes, so it's-
19:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And then being blinded in some-
19:42 Speaker 04 It's a tumor on your pituitary gland which causes the pituitary gland to overexpress human growth hormone. So you're huge, but the side effect is that the tumor compresses your optical nerves so that you are profoundly nearsighted. So Goliath lumbering down the mountain to meet David is this terrifying figure, but he can't see David. He's a sitting duck. It's like, "Where are you?" In the biblical story, he keeps saying, "Come to me," which everyone always thinks is, "Come to me." It's not. It's like, "Come to me, I can't see you." I'm asking you. It's like, "Where are you?" Meanwhile, David's like lining him up with his sling, and the sling, by the way, is not a slingshot. It's a sling, which is one of the most devastating weapons of ancient times.
20:25 Speaker 04 You whip it around and around and around, and it has the stopping power of a 38 caliber handgun, a rock thrown from a sling.
20:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's not just the angular speed you can get out of your arm, there's an extra amount.
20:38 Speaker 04 You've got a pouch on the end of a long leather string, and you swing it around and around and around, and then you let one of the strings go, and the rock goes boom, like, it's like-
20:47 Eugene Mirman? And you probably practiced to get super good at it.
20:49 Speaker 04 And you've been practicing forever. I mean, this is-
20:51 Eugene Mirman? 10,000 hours, maybe.
20:52 Speaker 04 Yes.
20:53 Eugene Mirman? He was a serial killer. That's also left out from the Bible.
21:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, that's the, that's the Hippocrypha, that's where they get to.
21:03 Speaker 04 David has superior technology, and he's up against a blind man. So, you know, let's just be clear about who the underdog is in this particular story.
21:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you know what intrigued me? You know, you go to, I guess it's in Florence, you see the famous statue of David, and there he is, rather muscled, and you say, "Yeah, he's ready to kick some biblical behind right there." But you see other renderings of David by other artists, and he's shown to be frail and kind of very non-threatening.
21:33 Speaker 04 Yeah.
21:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But I was reminded that the story works.
21:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Not because David is some muscle fighter, but because his advantage is not his body. His advantage is his mind and his tools.
21:48 Speaker 04 And his audacity. He changes the rules and doesn't tell his opponent. They're supposed to have a knife fight, a sword fight. That's what the convention is. And David's like, "Yeah, I don't think so." And doesn't he thought-
21:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? With that high pitched voice too, yeah?
22:00 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's right. "Yeah, I don't think so." And does not disclose this to the other party in the conflict.
22:06 Speaker 02 So he brought a sling to a knife fight.
22:08 Speaker 04 He brought a sling to a knife fight.
22:11 Eugene Mirman? But once he killed Goliath, everybody was like, "No, that's fine." I mean, not the fight we were expecting, but I guess we'll leave.
22:17 Speaker 04 That's right, yeah, no, no.
22:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, did they cry foul?
22:19 Speaker 04 They cried, but they fled, is what they did. They were terrified.
22:23 Eugene Mirman? Why were they terrified? Because he was-
22:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Technology!
22:25 Speaker 04 I mean, David's a bit of a badass. I mean, he comes at this giant, changes the rules at the last moment, and then cuts the giant's head off.
22:33 Eugene Mirman? Oh, after he hits it, he cuts the head off?
22:35 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah.
22:35 Eugene Mirman? But didn't the people on the giant's team know the giant's basically blind?
22:39 Speaker 04 It's an interesting question. The Philistines' theory would have been, he's so terrifyingly big, it doesn't matter that he's largely blind.
22:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, I'd agree with that.
22:49 Speaker 04 And also, I love the metaphorical thing about, the giant is so often blind, right? I mean, that's so incredible when you understand that dimension of it, because, of course, the big lumbering guy is so full of himself and his size that he discounts the fact that he can see this far.
23:04 Speaker 02 Well, to me, what's incredible is that after he killed the dude, he was still like, "I'm gonna cut his head off." Like, that's incredibly rude and really time consuming. That's a special kind of crazy. Just sit there and, "Oh, all right." "You guys, you still wanna stick around?"
23:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Bone!
23:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, the metaphor here is the underdog, obviously.
23:38 Speaker 04 Yeah.
23:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, there's some inner support we want to give to the underdog. And I think some of that is what led to so much of the support that Pluto received. Because it's the littlest thing, you know?
23:53 Speaker 02 Way to lose them, Neil. Way to lose them.
23:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You can be the underdog, yet have some kind of hidden talent that expresses itself. The team you didn't think would win, the person who you didn't think was strong enough, quick enough. When they manifest their victory, is it because they actually had the 10,000 hours talent and didn't tell anyone? Or because they did something really clever, like what David did?
24:18 Speaker 04 I think what it tells us is that our definitions of what an advantage is are really narrow and incomplete. Business is a story about how size and resources are overrated, and imagination and audacity are underrated as competitive advantages. And I think that's something that we're always making this mistake, like, how many times have very large countries gone into battle with small countries and overestimated the importance of their own size and resources? And underestimated imagination and audacity, right? Happens every single time.
24:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All the time. So, Alondra, in society, the underdog has such value to us culturally.
24:59 Speaker 01 Yes.
24:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We praise them, we worship them, but only after they've really succeeded.
25:04 Speaker 01 Right.
25:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How many underdogs remain undiscovered?
25:07 Speaker 01 The underdogs usually get plowed over.
25:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, exactly. So the one that's not plowed over
25:12 Speaker 01 Yes.
25:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? becomes more famous than the people who they trumped.
25:16 Speaker 01 Right, because it fits into this kind of larger mythos that we have about individual effort and innovation, being able to do great things in the world. I think what Malcolm's book captures, you know, what we might call standpoint theory in sociology, or even thinking about W.B. Du Bois, the famous sociologist, idea of double consciousness, that if you have to live in the world and you have a disadvantage, then it gives you a Kind of advantage in the sense that you have a perspective or a purview that other people don't have access to. So you're always looking for other angles and other ways to try to make do with less. And so you see it even in the political structure. So in political science or in sociology, when you think about
25:55 Speaker 01 social movements, whether we're talking about Ferguson or the suffragettes, is that these are people who are locked out of a kind of mainstream system of electoral politics, in the case of the suffragettes, because they weren't allowed to vote, right? But that you take to the streets or you lobby or use these other avenues that are available to you to get the advantage.
26:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so you're saying that that which doesn't kill you makes you stronger.
26:17 Speaker 04 Sometimes.
26:17 Speaker 01 Or sometimes it plows you over.
26:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It actually kills you.
26:20 Eugene Mirman? If you have a way to organize.
26:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, it might kill most people.
26:23 Speaker 04 Yeah.
26:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But if it doesn't kill you, you're stronger and you have tactics, methods to have navigated that terrain to emerge with the talent or leadership that is expressed.
26:35 Speaker 01 Sure.
26:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But are you going to go so far as to say that we should put people through a system of stress and try to make sure they don't die? So that they come out of it as more resourceful human beings? Is there some desirable defect or disadvantage that we should seek? Malcolm, you've thought about this?
26:57 Speaker 04 Well, there's a lovely phrase on this very point that psychologists talk about, this notion of desirable difficulties. So that's what you're asking. Are there certain difficulties that are desirable? And the answer is...
27:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that the act of overcoming them makes you a greater?
27:08 Speaker 04 Yeah. The answer is yes, there are. But I don't know that desirable difficulties are always desirable for everyone. So for example, I talk about in my book, this really fascinating fact about dyslexia, that some portion of dyslexics are incredibly successful, not in spite of their dyslexia, but it is argued, I think, very convincingly, because of their dyslexia, that the act of overcoming dyslexia... Teaches them all kinds of things that are incredibly useful if you want to become an entrepreneur, for example. But that's not true of all of them. Right, so you're in this weird situation where there's a group of people, probably the majority, who absolutely are worse off because of their difficulty, and another group, probably in the minority, who are better off.
27:50 Speaker 04 So the question I ask in the book is, knowing that some portion of dyslexics are better off, but a larger portion are not, would you wish dyslexia on your child? Would you roll the dice? In other words, that your kid was in the small group-
28:02 Eugene Mirman? What's the percentage? Is it possible I have just like the tiniest bit of dyslexia? Just to give you that extra startup in life? Where you're like, "E's make no sense to me, but otherwise, I get it."
28:12 Speaker 04 I remember having a discussion with a general manager of a NBA team about Tracy McGrady. And he was saying, he had every talent you can possibly have as a basketball player. Who's Tracy McGrady?
28:24 Speaker 01 I'm like, I have to be the only one?
28:26 Eugene Mirman? No, I think Wyatt's the only one who knows.
28:28 Speaker 02 Yeah, he was like 6'8". He got like drafted out of high school, like at 18 years old. He could like move like nobody's business, and then went to the NBA and things just fizzled out.
28:40 Speaker 04 He had a very good career.
28:41 Speaker 02 He had like a good four years.
28:42 Speaker 04 And remember, the comment this guy made was, Tracy McGrady would have been better off if he'd been just a little bit less talented. In other words, the game came so easily to him, he never had to work at it in the same way as someone who had to-
28:53 Eugene Mirman? But didn't he have to kind of work pretty hard at it for those four years he was in the NBA? Or no, not even that?
28:57 Speaker 04 No, that's the whole point.
28:58 Speaker 02 Well, that it was just too easy. He became disinterested in trying hard.
29:04 Speaker 04 Yeah.
29:05 Speaker 02 Because there wasn't difficulty.
29:06 Speaker 04 This is a great question, and it's at the core of- We do things because they are hard, not because they are easy. We do, yeah. A lot of what makes us draws us to things.
29:13 Eugene Mirman? That's why I do surgery. I'm terrible at it, but I give it my all. But every now and then, you do pretty good. Thank you for my LASIK. He did it backstage with a candle and a flashlight. I need two light sources.
29:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, so, there the role of these disadvantages. I don't know that someone who has the disadvantage, if you said, if you could live your life over, would you want to remove the disadvantage? I'm wondering if most of them would say, "Yeah, no, take it away from me. I want a normal life."
29:48 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
29:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And that's an interesting, hard sociological question, right? Because people are what they are because they are what they are. I'm reminded of the person who might have come over as an immigrant and struggled in the street and did some clever things, started a business, became fabulously wealthy, but they were hungry for a lot of that time and then they have kids, and then they say, "I don't want my kids to struggle the way I did." And so they give the kids every advantage, and then the kids end up with no motivation at all. And they say, "Where did I go wrong? My kids had everything I didn't have." And the answer is, that's where they went wrong.
30:24 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, that's why you should always lock your kids up for most of their lives.
30:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But how about the advantages? We live in a stratified society.
30:34 Speaker 01 You're talking like a sociologist.
30:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, is that, these are the vocabulary coming out? So, we live in a stratified society, and that itself, I think, is not a problem. The problem would be if it's stratified and you can't move among strata. But to have strata, that's a normal feature of capitalist democracy. Okay, so, we know that Ivy League schools cost $60,000 and state schools cost $2,000 or $5,000.
31:00 Eugene Mirman? Not anymore.
31:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Not anymore.
31:02 Eugene Mirman? We know that the prices are different, but we don't know what those prices are. I think would be the accurate way to say it.
31:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thank you for reducing the precision to make a more accurate statement. That's good. So, my question for both of you, let me start with Alondra. What do sociologists make of this fact? Do the high privilege really make the difference that the price of it should indicate?
31:28 Speaker 01 So what we know in the sociological literature, there's been quite a lot on elite schools coming out in the last few years, is that it does make a difference. I mean, you create networks that are rich of people who are like you and also have access to other sorts of elite networks.
31:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And are rich.
31:42 Speaker 01 And are rich, often. And if you're not rich, you're allowed into networks often of people who are richer than you, right? So that helps with the mobility that you're talking about in a stratified society.
31:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
31:52 Speaker 01 That's part of the way people go up. But then you also learn things that are kind of intangibles, right? What the French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu calls cultural capital. So you learn in elite institutions how to be comfortable in the world, right? How to know how to use the right fork, have the right wines, be cosmopolitan, speak lots of different languages, right?
32:12 Eugene Mirman? That's my thing.
32:13 Speaker 01 And that's part of that, that's you. And so that actually also helps to build elite status and it eases, it's a sort of social lubrication in the world.
32:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, but it makes you-
32:21 Speaker 01 You can move about freely.
32:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It makes it easier for you, but plenty of people did not go to elite schools who have transformed this world. So-
32:28 Eugene Mirman? Or did and haven't.
32:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
32:30 Speaker 01 Yes, I think that's more likely the case. And we know about the ones, and we celebrate the underdogs who either didn't go to college or who didn't go to Ivies.
32:38 Speaker 04 It's funny, this morning I was sitting in a coffee shop and next to me, in the table next to me, there was a husband and wife. And they were arguing about their son, whether their son should go to college. They spent a good hour and a half on this subject.
32:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But you were in the coffee shop for an hour and a half.
32:52 Speaker 04 Listening to them.
32:52 Eugene Mirman? He's a sociologist, fearless person.
32:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, no, you were in the coffee shop for an hour and a half, listening to their conversation.
32:58 Eugene Mirman? Studying.
33:00 Speaker 04 I was so-
33:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Studying.
33:02 Speaker 01 It's ethnography, it's called ethnography.
33:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ethnography.
33:04 Speaker 04 Basically, they were arguing about whether their child should go to the University of Colorado, which was the worst one on their list. And the best one on their list was the lesser Ivy, it was like Dartmouth, right?
33:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
33:16 Eugene Mirman? Ooh, people.
33:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, wait.
33:20 Eugene Mirman? Fire.
33:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Not using their vocabulary.
33:23 Speaker 04 Their term.
33:23 Eugene Mirman? I mean, it's true.
33:26 Speaker 04 There's no difference. They're both elite, they're fine. What I object to is this sense that people start slicing these layers so fine that they will argue passionately with their husband for an hour and a half about the distinction between Dartmouth and Colorado. There's no distinction. Everyone at those schools is smart, the teachers are all great. The distinction is between that and something way down at the bottom. I mean, you don't see a bad school.
33:53 Speaker 01 Or between not going to college or going to college.
33:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Or going to college.
33:56 Speaker 01 There's data that you'll be...
33:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Those are the more blunt facts.
33:58 Speaker 01 Yes.
33:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
33:59 Speaker 01 We have data about income over time and these sorts of things, just by the fact of going the zero to one of college, no college.
34:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I want to lead off with a physics. If you imagine a round marble and you have sort of the bottom of a hill and you place a marble at the bottom of the hill, it'll stay there, obviously. If you displace it in any direction, it will return to the bottom of the hill. So a marble at the bottom of the hill, it's an equilibrium and if you displace it, it returns to that state. So we call that stable equilibrium. Whereas if you're at the top of a hill, you could balance that marble, but any displacement in any direction will send it completely away from that point. So that's an unstable equilibrium.
35:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And in astrophysical systems, physical systems in general, there are points where any movement in one direction sends it off to that direction basically on its own. With only the forces operating, it's sufficient to take it forever away from that point. So when we think of tipping points, there are systems, I gave a very simple example, but there are complex systems that might have tipping points and you don't always know what knob to turn to know when it's going to happen so that you can protect your own life and property and country against it. So tipping points have interesting meaning and relevance in my field, but I want to
35:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? hear it more in terms of social systems and social customs. What's a really good example of a tipping point that you could share with us?
35:54 Speaker 04 Well, it's funny, when you were talking about unstable equilibrium, I was thinking about that the marble on top of a mountain is an extraordinary metaphor for the Middle East right now, isn't it?
36:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Hmm.
36:04 Speaker 04 Right? I mean, relatively subtle changes have these completely unpredictable results.
36:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And huge. Unpredictable and huge.
36:11 Speaker 04 And huge results, and also, there is zero chance that the Middle East will return to its previous equilibrium.
36:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Mm-hmm.
36:18 Speaker 04 Right? Whereas, we are, in this country, we are blessedly in a stable equilibrium. You can push the marble in all kinds of directions, and we, pretty reliably, will return to... I am as amazed by the disequilibrium of the Middle East as I am continually heartened by how stable our equilibrium is.
36:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It may be even deeper than that. When I was younger, I played the game of Risk.
36:41 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm.
36:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The board game. The goal of the game is total world domination. And you have a certain set of armies, and you challenge other armies across borders. Every time you play that game, the Middle East is the most conflicted part of the board.
36:57 Speaker 04 Yeah.
36:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And there's no religion in the game, there's no death box, it's just dice and army thingies.
37:05 Speaker 04 Yeah.
37:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It made me wonder whether the instability in the Middle East is geographic. That here we are, humans, fighting wars, when we are victims of the land plates of Earth's crust. Because here we are in America, we got an ocean on one side, an ocean on another, 12 people who live north of us, in Canada, and we talk about that we're blessed with stability, we're blessed with two fricking oceans on either side! I'm screaming out, I'm just...
37:35 Speaker 02 Yeah. Are you suggesting that if the Earth were to tilt, where the Middle East then had, like, a climate more like Seattle, things would cool out?
37:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, it's not a matter of where it is...
37:50 Speaker 02 We don't have any neighbors.
37:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, it's not a matter of where it is in longitude and latitude, it's a matter of what is the juxtaposition of land masses, near you or far away from you? So, if we could influence continental drift in such a way...
38:06 Speaker 02 This is how you turn into Doctor Doom, isn't it?
38:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, think about it. I foresee a day.
38:14 Speaker 02 If somehow, we could do, not saying I'm doing it, but if I were, would you guys be cool with it? And join my army?
38:30 Speaker 02 You all get cool tunics.
38:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm just saying, I foresee a day where our technology becomes, achieves a level of power and influence over the Earth, so that geoengineering is just no different from building a dam, or...
38:46 Speaker 04 Well, you're already gonna see this with global warming, right? Global warming is essentially gonna do what you're talking about.
38:50 Speaker 02 Thank god.
38:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, it's gonna redraw the coastlines.
38:55 Speaker 04 Yeah, more than that, it's gonna have implications for culture, economy, for everything. It's like a do-over.
39:01 Speaker 02 Yeah. Canada and Maine are gonna be the only two places to really hang out.
39:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, but it gets me back to the point. If we are all fundamentally human beings, okay? As they say, "One bout of lost electricity away from behaving like cavemen", then is it futile to say that we can change the behavior of warring people when they could just simply be the victim of Earth's land masses?
39:28 Speaker 01 I think everything we know about the history of the world says that that's not true, right?
39:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Except the game of Risk.
39:35 Speaker 01 Well, here's the game.
39:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I play Risk. Go you try it. That wasn't just me every time, and I've been intrigued by this.
39:41 Speaker 01 I'm gonna suggest that the game of Risk example is about a self-fulfilling prophecy, which is a phrase that was created by Robert Merton, a Columbia sociologist, in the mid-20th century, and suggests that you don't know if it's gonna be true, but then it manifests itself as true, because you expect it to be true, because you change behaviors that make it true. So if we expect that the Middle East is always gonna be unstable, and you sit down with your popcorn and your beer and you play Risk, then your behavior is gonna be such, even if it's unconscious, that your Middle East is gonna be unstable, and you're game, game after game after game.
40:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm pretty sure, I didn't know anything about world politics at the time I was playing Risk. I was just trying to take over the world, but all the battles were... Don't be Doctor Doom in me again.
40:23 Speaker 02 I'm worried now.
40:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, so notes from your book. You said a tipping point depends on three things. Could you highlight that?
40:32 Speaker 04 On the nature of the message, the context of the message, and the messenger.
40:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you're gonna have all three to really have a good tipping point?
40:39 Speaker 04 Which is why it's hard. I mean, I think that a lot of things we think of as irreversible aren't. So, to go back to the Middle East for example. Twenty-five years ago, many of the countries in the Middle East that are now in the throes of religious fundamentalism were thought to be modernizing. And people would have said, "Modernization is something you can't go back." But actually, it's very easy for people to slip back into primal racist responses to things. It's like, "I would have thought we were past it, but we're not." So I think getting those three...
41:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're bumming us all out here, by the way.
41:11 Speaker 04 No, I am. Look, my point is that once you understand how hard it is to really have a permanent change in society, I think it changes your perspective on these sorts of things.
41:21 Speaker 02 Is that why you're so... like, when earlier we were talking about court cases were like the voice. Is that why you say, like, you wish that we did have things like that, where you took the messenger out of it, and you just had to see it on the context?
41:35 Speaker 04 Yeah. And also, you would do that because you would understand that the battle against any sort of prejudice isn't over. You can't wake up one morning and say, "Okay, we settled that, and now we can go forward." No, actually, as long as there are human beings, you're gonna have to take steps to protect us against our worst...
41:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's interesting you say that, because in science, we are self-aware that as scientists, we are human and are subject to the biases and temptation toward misrepresentation. We know this about ourselves, and so we've built in sort of error-checking mechanisms against our data. The fact that I would have a competitor who would do another experiment to see if bias exists in my data. And if it's revealed that it is, that is not good for my career. So, in that case, we're not trying to change the person. We're recognizing that, but the system has the error-checking mechanisms in it.
42:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, that's a way to not solve a problem, but to address it and minimize its impact. So, bringing all this together, if you could change something in society to make a better society tomorrow, Eugene?
42:49 Eugene Mirman? Just to reiterate, just quickly, what could be made better about society?
42:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's the question, yes. If you can control it.
42:57 Eugene Mirman? If I can control it?
42:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah.
42:58 Eugene Mirman? So we're assuming I don't.
42:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, yes, okay.
43:01 Eugene Mirman? Not offended.
43:04 Eugene Mirman? Well, I guess in terms of what Malcolm said, which is not necessarily listening to snap judgments, but I don't know how it works, but taking thought.
43:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So de-snappify people.
43:15 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, but, meaning I think a lot of the snap judgments, people think that they're actually, they're making the right decision, and they're not. Like, meaning they're actually, like, wrong about the situation.
43:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Do you want to undo that?
43:24 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, I want to do, yeah, I guess I would phrase it as undo the learned behavior that is inaccurate and makes them make the wrong decision.
43:32 Speaker 02 I think I would want to equalize the educational opportunities for everybody,
43:43 Speaker 02 regardless of where you are in the stratification, because it seems like, just what I've seen of, like, social science and stuff, they say that there's so many things that would be reduced, be it crime, be it, like, youth pregnancy, be it violence in society, by access to quality education, if everybody had that. So, I'd do that, maybe.
44:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Cool.
44:07 Speaker 02 And I'm saying that as somebody who barely got through college.
44:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, alright.
44:11 Eugene Mirman? You don't mean, like, the very poor, you mean, like, the fairly?
44:14 Speaker 02 I'm saying make, make the best schools worse. I'm saying trend everything down.
44:21 Eugene Mirman? Okay, good, good.
44:22 Speaker 02 Just to make it short. Yeah, it'd be too expensive for everyone to have computers, no. Take away all of the computers.
44:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, that's, that was your plan, okay, I didn't know. Alundra, what do you have?
44:34 Speaker 01 He took my answer, but I would add, let's care enough about each other that we all have healthcare.
44:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Healthcare, okay.
44:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Healthcare. Malcolm?
44:46 Speaker 04 I'd like the rest of the world to adopt what is beautiful about science, which is, when the evidence changes, it's okay to change your mind. Whoa.
Previous The Digital Revolution with Arianna Huffington Next StarTalk Live! Climate Change Page updated September 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated