Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast StarTalk Live! SF Sketchfest About this episode Where did we come from? Are we alone? Explore these questions with guest host Bill Nye the Science Guy, co-host Eugene Mirman and their guests comedian Dave Foley and SETI Institute Sr. Astronomer Seth Shostak.
(Warning: Since this show was recorded live before an adult audience in San Francisco, be prepared for some suggestive language and humor.)
Read more and listen to the full track: http://www.startalkradio.net/show/startalk-live-sf-sketchfest/
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk. Your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:24 Eugene Mirman? Welcome to StarTalk Live!
0:32 Eugene Mirman? Very special edition from San Francisco Sketch Fest.
0:39 Eugene Mirman? It is my great honor to bring on your guest host for this evening, the amazing Bill Nye the Science Guy!
0:59 Bill Nye? So it's great to see you all, thank you so much for coming. I am here on behalf of my beloved dear colleague Neil deGrasse Tyson.
1:10 Bill Nye? But tonight, we are gonna talk about some serious business. The search for extraterrestrial intelligence.
1:20 Bill Nye? And you could say, "Well, that's crazy." Or you could say it's serious business. And to that end, we have the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence Institute, the SETI Institute's senior astronomer, give it up for Mr. Setz Shostak!
1:44 Bill Nye? And then, as though it's not funny enough, people.
1:49 Bill Nye? A former colleague, coworker of mine, for those of you who never miss an episode of Stargate Atlantis, from Kids in the Hall, Dave Foley!
2:09 Bill Nye? So, no, it's great to see you all. And we're gonna talk about something very serious and remarkable and cool and something that, in my opinion, which as you know, is correct, will, dare I say it, change the world. There are two questions, two questions deep within us, two questions each and every one of you has asked at some point in his or her life. Where did we come from? Why are we here? And, well, that's pretty close. But of those of you listening on the radio, he said, "Why are we here?" And I think this is a sketch fest and you bought admission ticket and you came, you
2:52 Bill Nye? have to take that up with the people you're sitting with. Where did we come from and are we alone? And if you meet somebody who says, "I've never asked those questions," they're lying. Okay? So, it's, it's an exciting time and this is something that goes back all of my academic life. I'm talking about since somewhat before kindergarten. I've wondered these questions. And we have here a guy that really tries to answer this question for real. Seth.
3:22 Eugene Mirman? Dave Foley.
3:25 Bill Nye? So Seth, what is it you do exactly?
3:28 Speaker 03 We're trying to find out if there are any cosmic confreres, if there's any cosmic company out there. Not just aliens, not just pond scum on Mars, dead or alive, but are there any people or things or Klingons or intelligences that are at least as clever as, you know, the average resident of the Bay Area?
3:46 Bill Nye? So how would we go about doing it?
3:47 Eugene Mirman? Are you looking for the Grateful Dead in space?
3:52 Speaker 03 You know...
3:56 Bill Nye? Seth, how do you go about actually looking for extraterrestrial intelligence, actually?
4:00 Speaker 03 This is something you can use at your next cocktail party. There are only three ways to look for aliens that we're using today. One is to just go there and try and find them. That, that only works if you're going nearby. I mean, you might go to Mars and maybe you find pond scum. But on, on the other hand, you could probably go to your bathroom and find pond scum, so that's around the bathroom. That's one way. The second way is build a really big telescope and look at the light coming from some planet around some godforsaken other star, split up that light with a prism, look at that... is this getting too technical? And, and then...
4:28 Eugene Mirman? Not yet.
4:29 Speaker 03 All right.
4:31 Eugene Mirman? What is this prism you talk of?
4:33 Speaker 03 Yeah, prism.
4:34 Eugene Mirman? Are you saying prison wrong?
4:38 Speaker 03 You split it up with a prism, and then you look for things like oxygen or methane. You know, if you find a lot of that, you know, that's right. Twenty-one percent of the air in this room used to be oxygen before you guys got here, and that's because there's life on this planet. So that's scheme number two. Scheme number three, which is what we do, we train big antennas on the sky, hoping to imitate Jodie Foster by finding a signal.
5:01 Speaker 03 Coming from intelligent species, intelligence means you can build a radio transmitter, and you should probably ask the person sitting next to you, "Hey, can you build a radio transmitter?" And you'll know what you're sitting next to.
5:13 Bill Nye? So how long have you been at this? How, how? How long have you been at this, Seth?
5:19 Speaker 03 What? This search, somebody's been at this search for a long time. I think it's in 1960, Frank Drake did an experiment.
5:25 Bill Nye? Frank Drake? Who is Frank Drake?
5:27 Speaker 03 Frank Drake. Frank Drake is a, an astronomer. He did the first experiment along these lines, back in 1960, before most of you were born, was after I had reached middle age. 1960, he used an antenna in West Virginia, I want to emphasize that, West Virginia, he pointed at a couple of nearby stars, hoping to hear signals from E.T.
5:45 Bill Nye? And did he?
5:46 Speaker 03 He did hear a signal, turned out to be the US military. That did not count as intelligence.
5:54 Bill Nye? You grew fascinated with this at some point?
5:56 Speaker 03 Yeah.
5:57 Bill Nye? Something happened to you? You're an astronomer.
5:59 Speaker 03 Yeah. Lots of cheesy sci-fi films when I was a kid. Think about it. Aliens are terrific bad guys to the movies, right? And when the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991, you know, all the handy bad guys kind of went away. But aliens, you can, you can make them-
6:12 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, now we have no more enemies, so that's good.
6:14 Speaker 03 That's right.
6:15 Bill Nye? Yeah.
6:17 Speaker 03 Terrific.
6:18 Bill Nye? So, why did you decide to do this with your professional career?
6:22 Speaker 03 Well-
6:23 Bill Nye? Because in a sense-
6:23 Speaker 03 You could have been a chef!
6:26 Bill Nye? Let me say, in a sense, you've been looking for several years. 1960 is getting to be quite some time ago.
6:32 Speaker 03 That was Frank Drake. No, I didn't get into this until quite a bit later, 1981.
6:36 Bill Nye? Yeah, okay, since 81. What are we now? We're some other bigger number, right?
6:40 Speaker 03 Something, yeah.
6:41 Bill Nye? So, you haven't heard anything.
6:43 Speaker 03 It's the American education system. Yeah.
6:46 Bill Nye? Hey, I can do a little bit of...
6:50 Speaker 03 Yeah. Calculus. No, no, no, look, look, look, look, look. The point is, it's a special moment in time. I mean, you know, everybody thinks they're living in a special moment of time. They probably thought that, you know, in the year 1000. God, it's a special moment in time, Bob.
7:02 Eugene Mirman? Those people are idiots.
7:03 Speaker 03 Well... Look what's gonna happen in this century, that you're gonna see. One is, we finally understand biology. So, a lot of diseases you're worried about now, you won't be worrying about in 50 years. The second thing is, we're probably inventing our own successors. We're making thinking machines. I don't know how you feel about that. I'm not sure how I feel about it. But that's this generation. And the third thing is, we're gonna, I think, find that you have some company out there.
7:27 Bill Nye? How do you say that now?
7:29 Speaker 03 Just the way I said it. But if you ask...
7:31 Bill Nye? Oh, I see. Let me rephrase that for you. You'll die, takes it in the gut.
7:41 Bill Nye? So, Seth, what's a reasonable population of nearby stars in distance of light years?
7:47 Speaker 03 Well, just consider our galaxy, the Milky Way galaxy. There are like a couple of hundred billion stars, okay? The number of planets is probably close to a trillion. Within a thousand light years, that's not very far, I got that on my Honda. A thousand light years, there are on the order of, you know, millions and millions of stars.
8:05 Bill Nye? Okay, so here's what I'm saying to you. We're listening for one that has been broadcasting for the last thousand years, right?
8:12 Speaker 03 Uh, not necessarily, but you have to assume that if they're a thousand light years away, they broadcast something there, you know, come join the Klingon book club or something. And maybe for only 10 minutes, and it arrives today when you happen to be looking, that's good enough.
8:25 Eugene Mirman? If we were to broadcast something with our current technology, how long would it take for somebody a thousand light years? It'd be a thousand...
8:31 Speaker 03 Years.
8:32 Eugene Mirman? Years? That would be, meaning that's the speed sound would travel?
8:35 Bill Nye? Uh, the speed of light.
8:36 Eugene Mirman? Or signals. Will they be the speed of light, but would a signal travel at the speed of light?
8:40 Bill Nye? Yes.
8:40 Speaker 03 If it's a light signal.
8:41 Eugene Mirman? If it's a light signal.
8:43 Bill Nye? No, Eugene.
8:44 Eugene Mirman? I'm just saying, explain it to someone who maybe didn't major in anything to do with science.
8:50 Bill Nye? Can you pick one?
8:50 Eugene Mirman? I'm hinting at it with my idiocy.
8:54 Bill Nye? So, radio waves and light waves go the same speed.
8:57 Eugene Mirman? Ah, I caught you in a piece of information I like.
9:03 Bill Nye? So, but this, you guys, this goes way back. Dave?
9:06 Speaker 04 No, I was gonna say, I actually heard you interviewed recently where you said that we may have gone silent now because we're all broadcasting digitally and the digital signals don't propagate through space.
9:17 Speaker 03 I hope I didn't say that. It is true, it is true, right? And I don't know, how many, how many of you have rabbit ears on the top of your TV set? The thing is that we're shutting down the big towers, you know, the red and white antennas on the outside of town because, in fact, you're getting all your information digitally, or you will soon enough, you'll just have, if you don't already have this. You have a fiber optic that comes into your house, you get your internet, your TV, your phone. Some of you have this already. That's the way we're going. So, a lot of TV broadcasting will go away, that's true. But, there is the but, is that some things aren't going silent, like the radars down at the San Francisco airport. You're probably not gonna shut those down.
9:52 Speaker 04 Yeah.
9:52 Speaker 03 Yeah, right.
9:53 Speaker 04 Unless they shift, you know, GPS.
9:54 Speaker 03 I don't know how, well, GPS is all very...
9:56 Eugene Mirman? In the hot 94.5.
9:58 Bill Nye? That's what's going on now. But this search, people have been fascinated with this for centuries, yes?
10:04 Speaker 03 It does. The ancient Greeks thought about it too. They thought everything they could see in the sky was inhabited.
10:09 Eugene Mirman? Were they all murdered? For saying it out loud? So, this is when thoughts were murdery.
10:17 Bill Nye? So, but that was in Greece, in Greece, some people, they voted and they had democracies and stuff, so... But Seth, why did they think that? You've given this some deep thought, it is to be expected.
10:28 Speaker 03 I'm not sure I have. I haven't thought too much about why the Greeks believed that. The Greeks were kind of upbeat, you know? They figured, you know, we're here, there's stuff up there. They came up with nifty ideas like the atom and geometry.
10:40 Speaker 04 And sodomie.
10:40 Speaker 03 And science, yeah, right.
10:45 Eugene Mirman? He said that, and he's right.
10:49 Bill Nye? So, well, that couldn't be the only people that had that idea.
10:53 Eugene Mirman? No, but they were the first to perfect it.
10:55 Speaker 04 They were just really, really good at it.
10:57 Bill Nye? So...
10:58 Speaker 04 First thing was they, you know, the tunics were just perfect for it.
11:02 Bill Nye? First of all.
11:04 Speaker 04 Yeah.
11:08 Bill Nye? When you say tunics, do you mean togas?
11:11 Speaker 04 No, tunics, not togas. Togas, that's all drapy. A tunic, it's a nice, tidy little number that your slave boy would wear.
11:19 Bill Nye? So...
11:23 Bill Nye? Alright. Of course, the Greeks were upbeat about it, right?
11:28 Speaker 04 Yeah.
11:28 Bill Nye? But Galileo, then his contemporary Bruno, Bruno was burned at the stake over this business, right?
11:34 Speaker 03 Well, he was burned at the stake, that's true. Kind of a bummer for Bruno, but the facts are...
11:38 Bill Nye? Giadon!
11:39 Speaker 03 Well, our burner for Bruno, how's that? But the reason he was incinerated, actually, wasn't because he said that there was a multiplicity of worlds. He did say that, you know, undoubtedly.
11:48 Bill Nye? So that was what, that's 16...
11:50 Speaker 03 1600 he was burned.
11:51 Bill Nye? 02, yeah. He was burned at the stake for suggesting, no, not for suggesting.
11:55 Speaker 03 No, not for suggesting. That wasn't what got him burned.
11:57 Eugene Mirman? Did they burn him for a different reason?
11:59 Speaker 03 They did.
12:00 Eugene Mirman? Because...
12:01 Speaker 03 What reason? They burned him for heresies against the church. Sorry, but...
12:05 Eugene Mirman? So that was unrelated to saying there's alien life? So, one, he's like, "Alien life", and they're like, "Fine", and then he's like, "Your god not totally real, not fine."
12:15 Speaker 03 You get the drift.
12:16 Speaker 04 Yeah. So he deserved to be burned, is what you're saying?
12:21 Eugene Mirman? He did do a Bernie thing.
12:23 Speaker 04 Yeah.
12:24 Bill Nye? So Bruno did not have a telescope, did he? Did he look through Galileo's telescope?
12:29 Speaker 03 No, no, no. He was burned in 1600. Galileo turned a telescope to the sky in about 1609.
12:33 Bill Nye? But was he influenced by Bruno's trauma?
12:36 Speaker 03 Bruno Flambay? No, uh, I don't thi... I don't thi... I don't think he was, no.
12:42 Bill Nye? But that's the case where this was a military instrument, a telescope.
12:46 Speaker 03 But keep in mind, I mean, Galileo wasn't looking for life in space. He just took this toy that came out of Holland. He didn't invent the telescope, of course. Dutch probably did that. Yeah, but he built one.
12:55 Bill Nye? His crowd?
12:56 Eugene Mirman? He was the first person to point it not at the ground?
13:01 Speaker 03 You were the first person out to point it at the neighbors. That's what he did. He pointed it up.
13:05 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
13:05 Bill Nye? There's your whole tunic thing, yeah.
13:07 Speaker 04 People are remarkably stupid.
13:11 Bill Nye? So, Galileo looks at this thing and did he speculate that there was life on the moon?
13:16 Speaker 03 Well, you know, in the beginning, he was just sort of astounded to find that, for example, the moon wasn't perfect because, you know...
13:21 Bill Nye? It's all beat up.
13:22 Speaker 03 The theologians had said, "Yeah, it's all beaten up." And you see these dark areas and they kind of look like oceans. And he thought, "Well, maybe, maybe, maybe." But it was actually a guy by the name of, you know, Johannes Kepler. I guess his buddies called him John. Kepler actually looked...
13:35 Speaker 04 I always called him Kepi.
13:37 Speaker 03 He thought he saw buried cities on the moon. I mean, for a long time, the moon was believed to house sentient beings.
13:44 Bill Nye? But then, this goes on for another century. Huygens comes along, thinks that there's life everywhere, right?
13:50 Speaker 03 Not Huygens, but Herschel. Maybe you mean...
13:52 Bill Nye? Herschel, Herschel.
13:52 Speaker 03 Yeah, William Herschel.
13:53 Bill Nye? It's a blur.
13:54 Speaker 03 Bill Herschel, probably the greatest astronomer who ever lived, actually. And that Herschel thought there were inhabitants on the sun or just beneath the luminous layer of the sun. That turns out to be wrong.
14:04 Bill Nye? Probably, yeah. Probably.
14:06 Eugene Mirman? Wait, are you saying he was the greatest astronomer?
14:10 Eugene Mirman? I'm not denying it. I'm just asking for a second reason other than he thought people lived under or in the sun.
14:18 Bill Nye? We call it a follow-up in journalism.
14:20 Eugene Mirman? I get that I didn't know that signals are the... anyway, but, uh...
14:24 Speaker 03 I could show you number two and then you'd understand.
14:26 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
14:26 Speaker 03 Okay.
14:26 Speaker 04 The second greatest astronomer thought his shoes could sing opera.
14:32 Speaker 03 But...
14:33 Bill Nye? Whoa, what?
14:35 Speaker 04 True story.
14:36 Bill Nye? Really?
14:37 Speaker 04 True story.
14:38 Bill Nye? I heard that. Yeah, I heard that. I heard on the radio.
14:41 Speaker 03 Yeah. Well...
14:42 Eugene Mirman? But what was great that Herschel did?
14:44 Speaker 03 Yeah, well, I was gonna get to that.
14:45 Eugene Mirman? Or Huygens.
14:47 Speaker 03 Herschel, Herschel. Herschel had a telescope good enough to look at Mars, everybody's favorite inhabited planet, Mars. And he could see the white, you know, polar caps at the top and the bottom and, you know, the tilt of the...
14:58 Bill Nye? The caps are made of dry ice, frozen carbon. There's some water ice, yeah.
15:01 Speaker 03 There's some water ice, too. But whatever. I mean, it has, you know, seasons because the axis is tilted.
15:06 Bill Nye? Eugene's just nodding along, "Yeah."
15:08 Eugene Mirman? Yeah. "Yeah, dry ice, whatever, anyway."
15:12 Speaker 03 The length of a day on Mars, 25 hours. He gave a talk to the Royal Society, I think it was 1784. 1784, this is just at the end of the American Revolution. 1784, and he says that the Martians probably enjoy a lifestyle, or a climate at least, rather similar to our own.
15:33 Bill Nye? Really?
15:34 Speaker 03 Yeah, he said that to the Royal Society.
15:35 Bill Nye? But if we go there now, it's 20 below on a summer day, and there's nothing to breathe. Which you would notice, you would notice that. And you could say the same about certain times of year in Oakland.
15:52 Speaker 03 Not anymore.
15:53 Eugene Mirman? But, wait, my question of, so what makes him particularly great? Is it that he was the first to postulate, or the first to look at Mars?
16:01 Speaker 03 No.
16:02 Eugene Mirman? I'm asking.
16:02 Speaker 03 No, he wasn't the first.
16:03 Speaker 04 What was he right about?
16:06 Bill Nye? Since he was the greatest.
16:07 Eugene Mirman? I get that, first of all, he sounds awesome. And he sounds creative, but yeah, what did he, was he ever like?
16:15 Speaker 04 He sounds high.
16:18 Speaker 03 I'm gonna tell you, but this is too much of a straight line for you.
16:21 Eugene Mirman? That's fine.
16:21 Speaker 03 Okay. He found Uranus.
16:26 Eugene Mirman? I'll leave it alone.
16:27 Bill Nye? Not trivial, not trivial.
16:30 Speaker 04 I prefer the old pronunciation.
16:33 Speaker 04 From when you and I were children.
16:36 Bill Nye? So, these are telescopes from a long time ago. We have, we have modern telescopes. And people look out there, and they observe planets. And they can infer from here that these places are probably inhabitable. But what does it take to be habitable?
16:54 Speaker 03 Well, that's actually a good question, because all we know is what it takes for life like our own to be habitable. So you have to start there, because you don't have any other data points. But that means, yeah, maybe something to breathe, but not necessarily. I mean, if you dug a hole one mile deep here, it'd take you all night. But if you did that, and you pulled up the muck at the bottom, and put it under a microscope, you'd see, you know, microbes.
17:15 Bill Nye? That don't need air to breathe.
17:17 Speaker 03 They don't need air. They don't need sunlight, no photosynthesis, I mean, they're alive, but they're down there. So, there's no good definition of life, right? You might think of Justice Potter, talking about pornography, "I'll know it when I see it." Life is kind of the same way, right?
17:31 Eugene Mirman? It can definitely high-five.
17:34 Eugene Mirman? I think we can all kind of agree that it's not like everybody can go "Yeah!" But what else?
17:40 Speaker 04 And you know what? And if it leaves you hanging, it is dead to me.
17:48 Bill Nye? Well said, Dave. And so with that, ladies and gentlemen, if you're listening, you're listening to Sketch Fest from San Francisco at the Marine Memorial Auditorium, Marine Memorial Theater. And this is StarTalk Radio Live, and we will be right back.
18:27 Bill Nye? Welcome back to StarTalk.
18:33 Bill Nye? Yes! StarTalk Live, as you may infer, at the Marine Memorial Theater, San Francisco, California. It's Sketch Fest. So Seth, I very much enjoy and am fascinated by the history of the search for extraterrestrial things, especially the speculation about what's living elsewhere. But what's going on now in the search?
18:56 Speaker 03 What's going on now is that we're continuing to do radio searches, in other words, using big antennas to try and eavesdrop on ET.
19:04 Bill Nye? Where are these antennas?
19:05 Speaker 03 Well, the ones we use are about 300 miles north of where we're all sitting here tonight in San Francisco. So they're up in the Cascade Mountains. They're there not because of the cuisine. They're there because, in fact, it's shielded by these mountains from all the, you know, radio noise from the San Francisco.
19:19 Bill Nye? It's really effective, in our modern world of today in which we now live, that this Hat Creek Valley is noiseless or quiet?
19:26 Speaker 03 It's not noiseless, but it's not because of noise from cities like San Francisco, actually. It's noisy simply because we now have telecommunications satellites wheeling overhead all the time. And of course, they have transmitters, and, you know, that gets down the valley. Good wheeling, yeah.
19:42 Bill Nye? Except they're in outer space, so they just go...
19:44 Speaker 03 Yes.
19:47 Speaker 04 Because in outer space, no one can hear you "Boop, boop."
19:51 Bill Nye? Exactly. So Seth, in our first, in our first segment, you asserted, you claimed that in the next 25 years, we're gonna get a signal?
20:02 Speaker 03 Well, I didn't say that, but I will. Yeah.
20:05 Bill Nye? Well, how are you gonna say that?
20:07 Speaker 03 Well, no, I, I said in this century, but I, I think, I think your number's a good one. I think the next couple of dozen years may do it. And if you wanna know why I think that,
20:15 Bill Nye? Yeah, well, kinda.
20:16 Speaker 03 I mean, maybe, maybe you do.
20:18 Eugene Mirman? We're all fairly curious.
20:21 Speaker 04 I think Bill's ready to punch you over this.
20:23 Bill Nye? Yeah. Not over this.
20:30 Speaker 03 Okay, well, it's like looking for a needle in a haystack if somebody said, "Look, you know, there's a needle in a haystack over there." And you wanna make an estimate, "How long's it gonna take me to find that needle?" It only depends on three things. How big is the haystack? How fast are you going through the hay? And how many needles are in there? Now, in the case of looking for ET, we know how big the haystack is.
20:47 Bill Nye? It's pretty fast-talking. So say it again?
20:49 Speaker 03 If there isn't any other intelligent life in the galaxy, I mean, why look at another galaxy, right? I mean, it's like saying, "You think there are any other mammals in North America? And if it turns out there aren't any, then it doesn't really pay to also look in South America." Okay, I'll, I'll finish this up. This, this idea is, it's too complex, apparently, but you, look, so you need to know, how big is the haystack? How fast are you going through it? How many needles are in there? In the case of looking for ET, the haystack is our galaxy. Let's look in our galaxy.
21:15 Bill Nye? 200 billion stars.
21:16 Speaker 03 Roughly, plus or minus three. Right. How, how fast are we going through the hay? That we know. That's, that's a technical question. And we know how quickly we'll go through the hay for the next 10 or 20 years as well. That you can sort of predict.
21:28 Bill Nye? How fast is that? A star a second?
21:31 Speaker 03 And no, nothing like a star a second. But the speed actually follows something that's a very famous relationship here, near the Silicon Valley, namely Moore's Law. In other words, it doubles in speed every 18 months. So that will continue for another decade or two. The only thing you don't know is how many needles are in there. I mean, you know how many aliens are in there. But there are people who've guessed, like Carl Sagan has guessed, Isaac Asimov guessed, you know? Frank Drake has guessed.
21:54 Bill Nye? Have you guessed? Eugene?
21:57 Eugene Mirman? I have, I have 80, but what's your guess? That's gonna be more accurate.
22:02 Speaker 03 Eighty may be good Eugene, I mean, I don't know. But if it isn't at least a few thousand, then this is gonna take longer. But, if it's as many as ten thousand, right?
22:11 Bill Nye? Ten thousand stars with planets that are habitable and so on.
22:15 Speaker 03 And not only habitable, but there's some inhabitants that are broadcasting.
22:18 Eugene Mirman? But they'd have to be at our level of technological advancement.
22:21 Speaker 03 No, they can be more advanced.
22:22 Eugene Mirman? Oh, I'm sorry, but they couldn't, how much less than us could they be?
22:25 Speaker 03 Not much, nothing.
22:25 Eugene Mirman? Okay.
22:26 Bill Nye? Fifty years.
22:27 Eugene Mirman? We're, we're the basic.
22:29 Speaker 03 We're the dumbest.
22:29 Eugene Mirman? We're the people who are like years in negatives.
22:31 Speaker 04 At least be at like Marconi phase.
22:34 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
22:34 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, not even that.
22:35 Speaker 04 Or Tesla, if you wanna really be honest about it.
22:37 Eugene Mirman? They would have to have...
22:39 Speaker 04 Marconi was a fucking asshole.
22:40 Bill Nye? Tesla, Tesla had a belief in this, yeah?
22:45 Speaker 03 He did. Tesla thought he'd heard the Martians.
22:47 Bill Nye? Nikola Tesla. After whom, what's a Tesla, anyone?
22:51 Speaker 03 They named him after a car.
22:52 Bill Nye? Weber per square meter.
22:54 Eugene Mirman? A delicious salami?
22:57 Eugene Mirman? I know that's not true, Jesus bebel.
23:00 Bill Nye? It's good with sauerkraut, but he was a guy who, after whom we have a magnetic unit of flux named, yes? And he was the guy who pioneered alternating current transmission right through the air and all, everybody's just gonna glow.
23:13 Speaker 03 Yeah.
23:13 Bill Nye? And along with that, he speculated.
23:15 Speaker 03 Well, he built this big tower for his wireless power transmission scheme, which by the way, did work. The trouble is, it also conveyed power to your hair and everything else. But, but he eventually built the generators, you know this, at Niagara Falls. That was the important thing, for Westinghouse. Bit of electrical engineering history to, it's, it's, it's, good for what's left of your soul.
23:34 Bill Nye? Yes.
23:35 Speaker 03 Right, that's right.
23:36 Speaker 04 And he and Edison were dread enemies.
23:38 Speaker 03 That's true.
23:38 Bill Nye? Yeah.
23:39 Speaker 03 Yeah.
23:39 Eugene Mirman? Killing elephants left and right.
23:42 Speaker 03 Yeah. That's, you know, it's a bit apocryphal, but okay, okay. Anyways, Tesla had this big tower outside, in Colorado, I think it was Fort Collins, but anyways. And the idea was he was doing these experiments, and he found, he found these signals coming in on it, radio signals. And he thought, these are the Martians. It was sort of jumping to conclusions. Probably they were what are called whistlers, which are caused by electrical storms that just produce, you know, electromagnetic disturbances. Radio waves in the atmosphere that propagate around.
24:09 Bill Nye? Like from lightning, while you're, while you're producing light.
24:12 Speaker 03 Not the Martians, it was lightning.
24:14 Bill Nye? You produce sprites and radio waves and stuff. So, he was wrong about that.
24:19 Speaker 03 He was wrong about that, yeah.
24:20 Speaker 04 And that's why he was the greatest astronomer ever.
24:26 Bill Nye? So Seth, I remember very well. I was in Carl Sagan's astronomy class.
24:36 Bill Nye? I know some of you are skeptical. I'm sure it was some sort of clerical error at the university. But I was in the class and they speculated at that time that about 1 in 100 stars would have planets. And now we speculate that every star has a planet. Or 2, or 8, or more.
24:54 Speaker 04 And that 1 out of 5 has an Earth-like planet.
24:56 Bill Nye? Is that right Seth? Is that a current number?
24:58 Speaker 03 There was indeed a result announced a couple of months ago. Dave's right. This was an analysis...
25:04 Bill Nye? You don't have to sound so...
25:07 Speaker 04 That's why I am a terrible astronomer.
25:17 Speaker 03 This was an analysis done by some guys at a state institution across the bay here. The name escapes me. But they published this result. They did a preliminary analysis.
25:27 Bill Nye? If you're scoring along with us, it's University of California, Berkeley?
25:30 Speaker 03 Yeah.
25:30 Bill Nye? Not everybody's here.
25:33 Speaker 03 And their estimate was that Sun-like stars, maybe 30, 40% of them might have an Earth-like world. 20 to 40%. Red dwarf stars, which dominate the heavens.
25:42 Bill Nye? Dominate!
25:43 Speaker 03 The little runty guys. Somewhere between maybe 15% and 40, 50% of them might have a habitable planet. So, bottom line, you average it all together, you weight by the number.
25:53 Bill Nye? You can't see it, he's waving.
25:54 Speaker 03 Dave is right. Roughly 1 in 5 stars will not only have a planet, but a planet that might be salubrious enough for you to go into the business of constructing condos on it. Because it would have, you know, liquid oceans and maybe some air.
26:05 Bill Nye? So if you have 200 billion stars in our galaxy, that's... well, that's a lot of habitable planets.
26:13 Speaker 03 40 billion.
26:14 Bill Nye? 40 billion in our galaxy.
26:16 Speaker 03 Right.
26:16 Bill Nye? So you start doing the universe, you get into hundreds of billions.
26:19 Speaker 04 And then it's just whether intelligence evolved on any of them.
26:22 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
26:23 Speaker 03 And life, for that.
26:24 Speaker 04 Yeah.
26:25 Bill Nye? No one's gonna make a joke.
26:27 Eugene Mirman? Are you saying that it's not alive? Is that a fear? That sounds like something we should be afraid of.
26:34 Eugene Mirman? A planet that evolved a dead intelligence?
26:38 Speaker 03 Well, Eugene, look at it this way. I mean, we said earlier that one of the great advances of this century, probably the thing that people will remember the most about this century, if they remembered at all, is that we invented thinking machines. Now, a lot of you think, "I ain't ever gonna do that." I think it'll be Lindsay Lohan. You might, yes. You will, but not 500 years from now. But, once you do that, once you build a thinking machine, the first thing you ask is, "You designed something smarter than you are." And then you ask that machine, "You designed something smarter than you are." And, within 20 years, you have a machine that's smarter than all humans altogether. So, the scenario-
27:08 Bill Nye? Like, that's a good thing?
27:09 Speaker 03 I don't know. I don't know if it's a good thing, but it's an inevitable thing. And, the point is, that most of the intelligence out there is probably synthetic, and probably in their, you know, synthetic brains somewhere, they're like, "Oh, yeah, yeah. Somewhere back in the past, we were soft and squishy and organic. That must have been terrible."
27:25 Eugene Mirman? Oh. Wait, so you're saying whatever life was there died, but had first created something smart that kept creating smarter things, and now-
27:32 Speaker 03 They don't have to die.
27:33 Eugene Mirman? They don't have to die, but they might have.
27:35 Speaker 03 They could be kept around as like cats.
27:36 Eugene Mirman? Oh, wait, so there might be a lot- oh, so there- but, anyway, there could be super smart intelligence that is artificial, that has now moved on. Another planet had a singularity.
27:44 Bill Nye? So, Seth, is this a just-so story, that, in other words, we build computers so we infer that, we figure that somebody else, everybody else is building computers, building machines smarter than they are?
27:54 Speaker 03 Yeah, you're right. That maybe it's a just-so story, and maybe 99 out of 100 of them don't do that. They just sit around with their wheeze, or contemplating their navel, or whatever they're doing. Okay?
28:04 Eugene Mirman? Those are the only two options.
28:10 Eugene Mirman? "What is my navel? Ooh. I can play golf."
28:14 Speaker 03 That's great, Eugene. You just simplified my life.
28:17 Eugene Mirman? Yeah. Yes.
28:19 Speaker 03 Okay.
28:19 Bill Nye? Just a little.
28:20 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, but if one of them does it, you see, that intelligence becomes so incredible that it really doesn't matter what the others do.
28:27 Bill Nye? Yes, so, tell us about that. We- what happens to the Earth when we get a signal?
28:33 Speaker 03 Well, most people, you walk the streets of San Francisco, and you ask people, "What do you think would happen if scientists 300 miles north of you pick up a signal?" Most people say, "Well, the government would shut it all down."
28:45 Eugene Mirman? Really? They'll give you a 90-minute speech about organic food. They're monsters.
28:53 Speaker 03 That's what the public thinks. They think it would all be kept quiet. And when I ask them, "Why do you think that?", they say, "Because the public couldn't handle the news." "Do, do, do, do, do, do, do, do, do." Could you handle the news if you picked up your newspaper tomorrow? You won't do that. Picked up your browser tomorrow and you read, you know, "Scientists find signal coming from 800 light-years away", would you say, "That's it? I'm not going to work today"? Is that what you do? Yeah. Would you riot in the streets? No, you wouldn't do any of that. We have historical precedent. You wouldn't do that. It would just be a very interesting story.
29:21 Bill Nye? Are you sure we wouldn't have to burn somebody at the stake?
29:24 Speaker 03 Oh, yes. Somebody would, somewhere, but...
29:27 Eugene Mirman? We would murder One Direction.
29:34 Eugene Mirman? And then move on.
29:40 Bill Nye? So...
29:42 Eugene Mirman? Because then our hearts were good.
30:04 Bill Nye? Welcome back to StarTalk Radio Live.
30:10 Bill Nye? I'm Bill Nye the Science Guy, sitting in on a four-legged stool for my esteemed colleague and dear friend Neil deGrasse Tyson. Yes!
30:22 Bill Nye? So Seth, deep within, you know, one might ask, astronomers have been looking at the heavens for a long time. You guys have been looking at the heavens for 60 years. Is that accurate? 50-something years?
30:34 Speaker 03 Mm-hmm.
30:34 Bill Nye? And this, you haven't heard a thing. And this gets back to Fermi's Paradox. If they're out there, why haven't you heard from them?
30:42 Speaker 03 Well, I don't know if everybody in the audience knows Fermi's Paradox unless they're related to the guy. But Fermi was having lunch with a couple of physicists, and at some point between two bites of a tuna fish sandwich, he says, "So where is everybody?". And he wasn't referring to the lack of company at the lunch. What he was referring to was the fact that the time that it would take to colonize the galaxy, if that's on your agenda. If you're the Klingons and you decide you want to colonize the galaxy, and even if your rockets aren't all that fast, but if you stay at it, you can do it in, you know, a few tens of millions of years, maybe 30, 40, 50 million years.
31:14 Bill Nye? It's like that.
31:15 Speaker 03 Now, that's a long, yeah, that's a long time if you're waiting for a bus from San Francisco. But that's not very long. Compared to the age of the galaxy. So what he was saying is, if there really are advanced societies out there, some of them, one of them, would have colonized the entire galaxy by now. We see no evidence of that, and that's why I said, "So where is everybody?" At which point he let the subject drop.
31:35 Speaker 04 And ruined lunch.
31:39 Bill Nye? No, well, I'm, no, I'm, I'm, I'm still enjoying that lunch. Seth, tell us, what happens to the Earth when we get a signal? I claim it would, dare I say it, change the world. It would be, humans would be humbled yet again.
31:56 Speaker 04 But already, most people believe aliens are already visiting the Earth. The majority of people...
32:02 Speaker 03 But it's not the majority.
32:03 Bill Nye? You're talking about...
32:04 Speaker 03 A third, a majority of Americans.
32:05 Bill Nye? You guys are talking about the History Channel, right?
32:08 Speaker 04 Believe that aliens visit here, yeah.
32:11 Bill Nye? How many people watch that show? How many people watch that show?
32:16 Speaker 04 Which one?
32:17 Bill Nye? Ancient Aliens.
32:18 Speaker 04 Ancient Aliens, oh, those are horrible, yeah.
32:20 Eugene Mirman? Isn't there a show called Misinformation?
32:22 Speaker 04 But if we, if we heard that there were, if we got proof that there were aliens, I think most people would just go, "Well, yeah."
32:29 Speaker 03 Well, that, that may be part of the reason why they wouldn't riot in the streets.
32:31 Speaker 04 Yeah.
32:32 Speaker 03 Right, I mean, we're all, they're already here.
32:34 Speaker 04 Then people are fat and lazy.
32:37 Speaker 04 It's not like the old days, when they'd riot in the streets.
32:41 Speaker 03 Apparently, there were never those old days, really. I mean, so what would actually happen is, it would simply be a very interesting story. If you could understand anything they were saying, now that would be good, because, remember, they can't be less technically advanced than you are, because then they're not making any radio waves that we could pick up. So they're at least at our level, and it's very unlikely that they're within 100 years of our level. They'd be thousands, millions, conceivably billions of years more advanced. Suppose you could get information from a society that's millions of years more advanced than ours. Right, "Here's the cure for death, here's how to get along," whatever. Now, would that be interesting, or would you say, "No, I'm just gonna riot in the streets"?
33:16 Eugene Mirman? That is a very hopeful view. We were like, "Here's, uh, how to avoid death and all that," but they could also come here and be like, "You now do all our chores."
33:25 Speaker 04 It's people, it's people! What, what if they show up here at the same time that the Lakers win a championship?
33:34 Speaker 04 And they think the riot is about them?
33:38 Bill Nye? Well, there's no shortage of unrest. No. Well. Thank you Eugene, but you know, if you're not sure.
33:45 Eugene Mirman? No, but how close, so how close is, in light years, is the closest inhabitable planet?
33:51 Speaker 03 We don't know, but, take that number.
33:53 Eugene Mirman? And double it?
33:54 Speaker 03 One out of five. No, you could, you could.
33:57 Eugene Mirman? I'll double anything, you just give me an hour.
33:59 Speaker 03 Alright.
34:04 Eugene Mirman? Not a real thing, go on.
34:06 Speaker 03 Yeah, okay. Well, I mean, all you need is at least five star systems, and now you have a good chance for one habitable planet, and five star systems, you'll find those within ten, twelve light years.
34:16 Eugene Mirman? Oh, really?
34:18 Bill Nye? Wow, that's, that's right down the galactic street.
34:21 Eugene Mirman? So wait, you don't even need to fold space, you, they could, they really could have...
34:25 Speaker 03 Well, let me just tell you how long it takes to go ten light years at the speed of a NASA rocket, okay?
34:30 Eugene Mirman? Oh, probably at least two weeks, maybe years.
34:35 Speaker 03 You're right, it is years, it's about...
34:38 Eugene Mirman? Well, it's also weeks.
34:39 Speaker 03 Yes.
34:41 Eugene Mirman? I'm not technically wrong, it's just very inefficient.
34:47 Bill Nye? The number gets big, that's all.
34:49 Speaker 03 Well, there's no way you could get the answer wrong, that's true, it, it takes about, what does it take, seventy thousand, a hundred thousand years to go to the nearest star at the speed of an astronaut.
34:58 Bill Nye? That's even if you punch it.
35:00 Speaker 04 Yeah, but we know for a fact that one advanced civilization exists, us.
35:04 Speaker 03 Well, by our own definition.
35:06 Speaker 04 Yeah.
35:07 Eugene Mirman? We do have microphones.
35:08 Speaker 03 Yeah.
35:09 Eugene Mirman? So that's not bad. And look, no wires. What? Yeah. Why, this is witchcraft! And we can tell horses to go left, so we're really pretty good.
35:22 Bill Nye? Ki-ha! So...
35:27 Bill Nye? So, it is one thing to speculate on intelligent life and hope that we will find intelligent life, but I for one, am thoroughly charmed by the idea that we go to Mars on a summer day near the equator where there's some subterranean, sub-sand glacier on Mars that's oozing some crazy, super salty water out there, and we find some Martian microbes, right? It would change the world. People would ride in the streets, pitch works, the government wouldn't let them know about it, but with that said...
35:59 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, if we found the flu on Mars, we would kill each other.
36:04 Eugene Mirman? I would kill everyone here.
36:07 Speaker 03 Yeah, what, you know Eugene, we've run that experiment and it turned out you didn't kill him. Because in 1996, biggest science news story in the entire year, a little Martian meteorite, you may remember this, ALH84001. Came from Mars and landed in Antarctica where it was very easy to find because it's on top of the snow, right?
36:24 Speaker 04 Or a mischievous child left it. My first thought would be, "Why am I in Antarctica?"
36:35 Bill Nye? Because we're exploring.
36:38 Speaker 04 Well, I don't.
36:39 Bill Nye? Yeah, what would people do?
36:41 Speaker 04 I'm from Canada, I don't go anywhere colder than Canada.
36:44 Bill Nye? Is there such a place? Enlighten us.
36:50 Eugene Mirman? But did this rock have things we thought were life but really aren't?
36:54 Speaker 04 There was a micro, a fossilized microbe.
36:56 Speaker 03 Right, right. The claim was, the claim by some guys at NASA and also Stanford University.
37:00 Speaker 04 And President Clinton.
37:01 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
37:02 Speaker 03 Well, Clinton made the announcement, that's true.
37:04 Eugene Mirman? By sex addicts and nerds, go on.
37:06 Bill Nye? You got a problem with that?
37:11 Speaker 03 That there was life.
37:12 Eugene Mirman? Both are wonderful.
37:15 Speaker 03 That there was life in this rock, or dead life, I mean it was dead, but, it was dead, Jim. But it was a little microbe and the claim was, it was a Martian from four billion years ago. All right? This was, front page, above the fold, giant font, news in the New York Times, for three days, four days running.
37:31 Eugene Mirman? Liberals.
37:32 Speaker 03 So... But people didn't riot in the streets.
37:37 Speaker 04 No, no.
37:38 Eugene Mirman? No, they just found out it wasn't true.
37:40 Bill Nye? But it was fascinating because it's not unreasonable that life started on Mars, this is, you guys, it's extraordinary, but it's not crazy to suggest that life started on Mars when Mars was very wet. And then they got hit with an impactor. I mean, I'm sure it was excited also.
38:05 Eugene Mirman? You are all a bag of perverts!
38:11 Speaker 04 I didn't know science was so dirty.
38:13 Eugene Mirman? Any chance, any tiny!
38:18 Bill Nye? Hey, that's your problem.
38:21 Eugene Mirman? Yes, I know!
38:22 Bill Nye? Okay, so, this thing is, uh, it gets hit with an impactor, three billion years ago, the stuff's thrown into space, it gets in, a few bits of it get in this extraordinary mathematical thing called a human orbit, yeah? And, except it's in outer space, so it goes
38:39 Bill Nye? and lands on the earth, and you and I are somehow descendant from a Martian microbe. And let me just say,
38:48 Bill Nye? it would be an extraordinary discovery about the course of events, it would really be something. And so, along this line, if we are all descended from a common ancestor, which seems a reasonable conclusion when you look at your DNA and all those, uh, the primitive life forms, like, anyone? My old boss?
39:10 Eugene Mirman? Ted Cruz!
39:12 Bill Nye? And so, so, it is another question though, could have life started a second time? Or the time before us, here on earth, and it's, if we just had the right place to look, we would find the so-called second genesis?
39:27 Speaker 04 We are the aliens we're looking for.
39:31 Eugene Mirman? Boom!
39:35 Speaker 04 And that theory has, is called, what is it called?
39:38 Bill Nye? Second genesis?
39:39 Speaker 04 No, this theory that, that life came here from, uh, from space.
39:42 Bill Nye? Pan-fermia. Trans-fermia.
39:44 Speaker 04 I know!
39:52 Bill Nye? Dave Foley, ladies and gentlemen!
39:56 Bill Nye? Check your servers, try the chicken.
39:58 Eugene Mirman? The Loki of words!
40:02 Bill Nye? Trans-fermia to send seeds across, in Latin.
40:06 Speaker 04 Yeah.
40:11 Bill Nye? But it is, it is a remarkable thing and it's worth studying here on Earth. So Seth, you are affiliated, you do a lot of work with astrobiologists, yes?
40:23 Speaker 03 Yeah, we have a lot of astrobiologists, yes.
40:26 Bill Nye? But is, do you feel they have, did they inform your work at all, listening for radio and light signals and so on?
40:32 Speaker 03 Well, in the very general sense, I mean, they're trying to define, you know, what life is, how you might look for it, I mean, it's easy enough to, you know, look for, for big things, but for small things, and probably most of the life in the universe is microscopic.
40:45 Bill Nye? There are more bacteria in your tummy than there are people on Earth.
40:50 Eugene Mirman? Really?
40:50 Bill Nye? Yeah.
40:51 Eugene Mirman? I believe you.
40:53 Bill Nye? Yeah, really.
40:54 Eugene Mirman? Wait, earlier, other than, of course, high fives, what are some of the, what are some of ways that you could categorize something being alive?
41:00 Speaker 03 It's, it's actually quite hard to do, I mean, you can say, if you pick up your 10th grade biology book, if you still have that, and you open it up, it starts out with a definition of, "Well, life has metabolism and life reproduces."
41:11 Bill Nye? Homeostasis.
41:11 Speaker 03 All this stuff. Yeah, whatever.
41:13 Bill Nye? Keeps itself.
41:14 Speaker 03 But it, you know, you can, you can think of examples of things that fit the definition but aren't alive, right? Things like mules, they don't reproduce, it turns out, but they're, you wouldn't, you know, contest the fact that they're alive, right? Fire reproduces, but it's not alive, so there's no good definition for life. The current working definition, if it evolves in a Darwinian fashion. What? That isn't even true. Probably not.
41:41 Bill Nye? What if it's in a Freudian fashion, or?
41:44 Speaker 03 Yeah. So that makes it hard to build an experiment to look for life.
41:47 Bill Nye? So, when we think of life, you're talking, like, there's living things in nuclear reactors, there's living things that eat the lenses of telescopes, fungi, so it could be just something we can't even, we literally can't imagine at this point.
42:01 Eugene Mirman? But can we hear more about things being alive inside nuclear reactors?
42:06 Bill Nye? Yeah, there are bacteria that, that make a living in nuclear reactors. They, I haven't, I've never really spoken with them, but they...
42:15 Speaker 03 Well, you can speak, they're called Radiodurans, you can speak with them, they just don't talk back.
42:20 Bill Nye? So, along this line...
42:23 Bill Nye? Suppose we have microbes on Mars and we're gonna go looking for them. As soon as you send anything there, uh, there's a good chance that we are gonna contaminate Mars and it won't be the good old ecosystem that it was, right?
42:37 Speaker 03 There is some danger there. There are people who worry about that, too, actually. Uh, NASA has an Office of Planetary Protection and I know you're gonna say something.
42:46 Eugene Mirman? No, I think it's fine.
42:47 Speaker 03 Okay, alright.
42:50 Bill Nye? It seemed like the kind of thing you-
42:51 Eugene Mirman? I think it's fine to protect planets.
42:54 Eugene Mirman? I think it'd be dangerous to send kale to Mars. What if they're like, "This is amazing," but then they develop weird problems. Go on.
43:03 Bill Nye? What? Really?
43:05 Eugene Mirman? It's possible. Too much kale is not good, people. Be careful. I'm warning you, San Francisco.
43:13 Bill Nye? It's, it's everywhere. So the Planetary Protection Office, you know, we used to just bake spacecraft. Take the Viking spacecraft, put it in an oven and presume that you would kill everything. But now our electronics and other, uh, we don't wanna be annealing radioactive material and so on.
43:31 Speaker 03 You can't kill it all. But so far, isn't Mars-
43:33 Eugene Mirman? It's just kind of shitty. I mean, is it really a problem if we contaminate it?
43:39 Speaker 03 Yeah, it is. It might be a problem, not because you, you, suddenly you would see, you know, mold all over Mars, in that, but the point is that they fall down there on the surface of Mars and Mars doesn't have any, you know, ozone layer and as a result, they get cooked by the ultraviolet. So, yes, it probably contaminates the area right next to the spacecraft, but you walk a block away and it's pristine Mars.
44:02 Bill Nye? The other thing, though, for, in the case of Surveyor, which was, um, there were a couple of surveyors sent to the moon. There was speculation, by the way, when I was young, if we landed on the moon, I say "we," uh, professional astronauts landed on the moon, they would sink into dust like quicksand. And so Surveyor spacecraft landed first, these footpads, pictures of the footpads, all fabulous. And then guys went over there in their car, their lunar rover car. By the way, that car is worth millions of dollars and it's not even locked.
44:39 Bill Nye? It's sitting there on the, they're sitting there. Okay, and they, they went over there and unscrewed some stuff and brought it back and there were bacteria alive. And people speculated that these bacteria had survived on the surveyor spacecraft from, for three years on the lunar surface. But the problem was, probably Dr. S., is this correct? That it was stuff that contaminated, the guys just handling it contaminated and they fooled themselves.
45:09 Speaker 03 I've talked to people at the planetary protection office and they say that it's most likely that it was contamination introduced bringing the thing back to Earth. Who knows? Microbes are tough. I talked to an astrobiologist about this, I did once, I said, if you, if you take, I asked if you'd take all the biota on Earth and throw it onto Mars and come back a year later, will any of it still be alive? And his answer was yes. He said, there's certain microbes, particularly if they can just get underneath the sand a little bit and protect themselves from the ultraviolet, yeah. They're tough.
45:38 Eugene Mirman? Those are called communists.
45:39 Bill Nye? Really?
45:40 Speaker 03 It's a red plant?
45:41 Bill Nye? So, so what?
45:46 Bill Nye? This is cool. So what? What's so, what is so fantastic, seriously, everybody, about this pursuit, to me, is that it's optimistic. There's this thing within us that, that the future's gonna be better and we're gonna build spacecraft and we're gonna look out there and find out what's going on because the more we learn about our solar systemic neighborhood, the better off we're gonna be. And the more we learn about radio signals in our galaxy, the better off we're gonna be. And that is still something that I, I think drives all of us, is this, this optimism through space exploration.
46:34 Bill Nye? Guys, this has been a fabulous evening.
46:38 Bill Nye? Thank you all for coming here at the Marine Memorial Theater in San Francisco, California, Sketch Fest 13.
46:47 Bill Nye? The guests have been fantastic. Dave Foley.
46:53 Bill Nye? Eugene Mirman.
46:58 Bill Nye? Seth Jostak.
47:01 Bill Nye? I've been your host, Bill Nye the Science Guy. Fly safely and goodnight.
Previous Cosmic Queries: Gravity Next Reporting on Science (Part 1) – extended with Elise Andrew of IFLS and Bill Nye Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated