Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast StarTalk Live! LIGO and the Black Hole Blues (Part 2) About this episode The conclusion of our show about the discovery of gravitational waves, featuring Neil Tyson, Eugene Mirman, cosmologist Janna Levin, LIGO astrophysicist Nergis Mavalvala, and Michael Showalter. Recorded live at the Count Basie Theatre, Red Bank, NJ.
Transcript 8,091 words · 12 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk. Your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We're live at the Count Basie Theater in New Jersey.
0:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is StarTalk. I've got Janna Levin, Professor of Physics and Astronomy, Columbia University and Barnard College. Did I get that right?
0:38 Janna Levin? Yeah, sounds good.
0:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You got it. We have Nerjas Mavvalala.
0:42 Janna Levin? I'm telling you right now, you're gonna get it right.
0:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? She's Professor of Physics at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and she is one of the world's experts on the detection of gravitational waves. And who do you have with us here?
0:57 Eugene Mirman? Uh, me?
0:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
0:59 Eugene Mirman? I'm Eugene.
1:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Eugene Mirman.
1:04 Eugene Mirman? Michael Showalter.
1:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Michael Showalter, thanks for being here, Michael. Michael, you're directing a movie now, right?
1:11 Speaker 03 Yes, I have a movie that's in the theaters as we speak, Hello, My Name is Doris, with Sally Field.
1:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Nice. As we speak?
1:21 Speaker 03 As we speak.
1:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Excellent.
1:23 Eugene Mirman? It's great, I went to see it.
1:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Cool.
1:26 Eugene Mirman? Okay.
1:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So what we're gonna... What I wanna know is, what's next? Okay, detect a few more gravity waves, first one, we're done. You know, just go out and have a beer.
1:38 Eugene Mirman? How can I make money off of gravitational waves?
1:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah. How... Why are they... Why should they matter to anybody?
1:45 Speaker 03 Can they be surfed?
1:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Surf? Well, I like that. Janet, can they be surfed?
1:49 Janna Levin? Uh, yeah, it would be pretty hard to surf them, but in some sense, that's kind of what the mirrors are doing, is they're kind of surfing the wave. So the mirrors are suspended so delicately in this instrument that when the wave passes, they just kinda bob, so that's kind of what they're doing.
2:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Cool.
2:05 Speaker 03 I mean, they don't...
2:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm into that.
2:07 Janna Levin? They don't ride it, so...
2:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, and so what happens next, Nerjas?
2:12 Speaker 04 Yeah, so the detection that we made was with a certain sensitivity on the instrument. The instruments are actually down right now since January for a few months where we're trying to make improvements. And the idea is that every time we make improvements, we improve the sensitivity and that allows us to look a little farther into the universe or to see fainter objects. And that's what we're trying to do. So my, over the next few years, we're gonna just keep walking the sensitivity down. It's just like with telescopes, you build better and better telescopes, you can see fainter objects, so we're trying to do the same thing.
2:48 Eugene Mirman? So what, so say you see all the waves, then what are we gonna do once we've seen all the waves?
2:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, wait, there's all the colliding black holes, but that's not the only stuff out there giving you gravity waves.
2:59 Eugene Mirman? Ah!
3:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Exactly, in fact, weren't there gravity waves in the early universe shortly after the Big Bang?
3:05 Speaker 04 There were.
3:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So why aren't you detecting those?
3:07 Speaker 04 Because they're too weak. So our detectors are not...
3:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's the Big Bang!
3:11 Speaker 04 It's the Big Bang, and...
3:13 Eugene Mirman? Should've been bigger!
3:15 Speaker 04 Yeah, so they are too weak, but there are many other kinds of sources that we could look for. We could certainly look for the same kinds of motions of orbiting neutron stars instead of black holes.
3:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So neutron stars are not as big a gravitational disturbance, but they still give you a gravity wave?
3:35 Speaker 04 That's right. They're cousins of black holes, basically, they're lighter, and they actually have more matter-like properties than what Jana described black holes are, which are regions of space that are really not matter-like. But in any case, so neutron stars could be colliding supernovae when stars sort of run out of their nuclear fuel and they explode as supernovae. That should give off copious amounts of gravitational radiation as well, so we should be able to see that.
4:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so this little, this gravity wave that you imitated...
4:08 Speaker 04 Uh huh.
4:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, with such precision and accuracy.
4:12 Speaker 04 Boo!
4:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No.
4:14 Speaker 04 Was the other way?
4:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No.
4:16 Eugene Mirman? Boo!
4:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No.
4:18 Speaker 04 Oh, it's the light eye!
4:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no.
4:20 Eugene Mirman? Wow!
4:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, I got this, I got this, I got this.
4:25 Speaker 04 Yes.
4:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh.
4:27 Eugene Mirman? Wow.
4:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's it. Wow. You're like a B plus, B plus?
4:30 Speaker 04 It's A plus.
4:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A plus, okay.
4:32 Speaker 04 Good.
4:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so...
4:33 Eugene Mirman? You can tour as an impersonator of a gravity...
4:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah. So, so, that took a certain amount of time to happen, alright? Like, fractions of a second.
4:45 Speaker 04 Yes.
4:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Now, suppose there are things that give you strong gravity waves, but take seconds, or minutes, or hours. Oh, do we have the power of detection to see those?
4:55 Speaker 04 So, our instruments are most sensitive, LIGO and sort of instruments on the earth are most sensitive to signals that are occurring at about 100 hertz. So, these are motions at about 100 times per second.
5:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Per second.
5:09 Speaker 04 Right.
5:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Hertz, from Heinrich Hertz.
5:11 Speaker 04 That's right.
5:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Famous German physicist.
5:12 Speaker 04 But the idea is of, so what sets the frequency of a gravitational wave is really the rate at which these black holes are moving around each other, or neutron stars are moving around each other. So, here's something really remarkable that, that it's really hard to wrap our heads around, but say the signal we saw. So, these were 30 solar masses, 30 times as massive as our sun, and they're whipping around at hundreds of times per second around each other. So, it's mind-boggling, and that's why they distort spacetime as much as they do.
5:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And just to be clear, the sun rotates, but it does so once in a month.
5:46 Speaker 04 Right.
5:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Now, you're talking about two objects, each 30 times more massive than the sun, revolving around each other...
5:53 Speaker 04 At 100, at a couple of 100 hertz, so...
5:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? 100 times a second.
5:57 Speaker 04 A second, yes, right.
5:59 Janna Levin? So, we have to just think also about the longer story of these black holes.
6:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What's...
6:06 Janna Levin? You're not buying it. I buy it.
6:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I just won't forget your face. You've given that face like eight times this evening.
6:11 Janna Levin? Yeah.
6:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The first time, it's, "Well, space and time are reversed." Give me that face.
6:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There's like a whole, there's a list, a laundry list of stuff that made that face.
6:22 Eugene Mirman? Yes.
6:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, I'm impressed by that. So, so, uh, here's something I know that happens in the universe, and it's gotta make an awesome signal, we just don't live long enough to hear it, and that's the collision of two galaxies. I'm betting that makes a nice signal, but that takes...
6:38 Eugene Mirman? Like a "wham!"
6:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But they take, you can calculate how long that takes, it takes like a half a billion years.
6:46 Speaker 04 Yes, and so those signals...
6:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're not hearing those signals.
6:48 Speaker 04 No, because they're not within the band of our, our instruments. You know, our instruments are not like...
6:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What you mean is you don't live long enough?
6:54 Speaker 04 Well, we don't live long enough, but even if we did, those signals, when those black holes are merging, would cause signals at frequencies that our instruments can't hear.
7:03 Janna Levin? LIGO is actually sensitive to the same frequency range as the piano. The black holes that collided were actually in the human auditory range, the sounds that they made. They didn't have to be rescaled, and so that is something that's just remarkable. That's what LIGO is sensitive to, just like you're talking about different telescopes. There's going to be different instruments that are sensitive to long, to longer, lower notes that the human ear can't hear.
7:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Are other LIGO centers that are being planned around the world, are they going to take you to other frequencies?
7:32 Speaker 04 No, so not, not, so the terrestrial detectors on the earth are really limited to having sensitivities that, it's pretty hard to make a sensitive detector below 10 hertz or so.
7:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I feel what's coming, you said detectors on the earth?
7:46 Speaker 04 Yes.
7:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so that means...
7:48 Speaker 04 That's space. Space.
7:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Space.
7:51 Speaker 04 So, so here's what you have to think about, on, on the earth, you can do well out to about 10 hertz, maybe if you really push it, you might get out to 1 hertz, so once per second oscillations of the wave, but at lower frequencies than that, you've got to get off the planet, and that means you've got to go into space.
8:09 Eugene Mirman? Tell me about it.
8:12 Eugene Mirman? So like, what can we do with this?
8:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If you go to space.
8:14 Speaker 03 You can make a sandwich with it.
8:15 Eugene Mirman? So like, it's a wave.
8:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Space, there's, uh, is it, Lisa, Lisa?
8:20 Speaker 04 Yes.
8:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Laser interferometric space.
8:24 Speaker 04 Space antenna.
8:24 Speaker 03 Is it a good, is it a good thing? Does it make you feel good?
8:29 Speaker 04 Yes, absolutely. You know, we're, we're.
8:32 Speaker 03 Like, is it a good thing that this happened?
8:34 Speaker 04 Yes, we're being bathed by these gravitational waves all the time, and that's what makes us so happy.
8:41 Eugene Mirman? I wish that was true.
8:45 Speaker 03 So that's what it is.
8:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The secret to happiness.
8:48 Eugene Mirman? But what can you, like, what, so what does this mean? Like, what does this discovery mean in terms of everything?
8:54 Janna Levin? Well, you know, this is, you have to realize that we can't see black holes with telescopes. We, I mean, we, we can only see, the reason why we argue that we're seeing black holes in the universe before this is because what we're really seeing is the black hole demolished something in its neighborhood. We don't ever actually see the black hole, right? So this is the first time.
9:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just be more precise. The black hole is essentially flaying.
9:17 Janna Levin? Right.
9:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The star that got too bulbous in orbit around it.
9:21 Janna Levin? Yeah, it's like pulling tufts of the star off like cotton candy, which then fall onto the black hole and become incredibly hot from the fall, collides with other material
9:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's what we see.
9:31 Janna Levin? That's what we see.
9:33 Eugene Mirman? So if it looks like someone's eating a sun, that's a black hole.
9:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Exactly, exactly.
9:38 Janna Levin? Right, if the sun slowly, like cotton candy, starts to splatter someplace, there's a black hole nearby. But, um, this is the first time in history that human beings have actually detected two bare black holes. Black holes with nothing around them. And you could argue, in some sense, it's the closest we've ever come to really, you know, the detection of black holes. And it's certainly the first time that we've detected two black holes colliding, because that is a completely dark.
10:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that's an, that's an important fact.
10:07 Janna Levin? Yeah.
10:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just in case it was not obvious to people. Anytime any one of us, we, the astrophysics community, said we have a catalog of black holes, we have a catalog of radiative.
10:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Signals coming from the matter descending into what we are pretty sure is a black hole. That's what the catalogues are full of.
10:26 Janna Levin? Yes, that's right. And it's excellent evidence. I mean, we see stars in the center of our galaxy orbiting a dark space. And you can tell from the orbit of the stars that the thing it's orbiting is four million times the mass of the sun, but it fits in about three sun widths. And it's dark. I mean, that's pretty good evidence for a black hole.
10:47 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, I mean, I'm convinced.
10:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So here's, let me offer a philosophical question. You detected what you expected to see. So, so could something have happened that you didn't have a template for that is going on in the universe and it remained undiscovered because you weren't even looking for it? Yet it, what's the word? It was invisible right before your eyes.
11:19 Speaker 04 Yeah. So we certainly, for the black holes, we looked in a number of ways. One of the ways we looked was what you mentioned, templates. What a template it searches is one where you figure out beforehand from theory like Janitor's of what the signal should look like. And then you try to match that predicted signal with what you see in your detector.
11:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You slide it along.
11:43 Speaker 04 Yeah. And when they match up, you say, aha, I have a black hole signal. So that's one way to look for the signal. But we also looked for signals in the, in generic ways where we don't make a prediction that the signal should look like the whoop sound that we hear. It could look, it could be a poop, tump, wrack, whatever it wants to be.
12:02 Eugene Mirman? I would like more examples.
12:05 Speaker 04 And we would still find those if, because those have, they represent some excess power relative to what the background of the detector is. So we looked in a number of different ways. Could we have missed something? Yes. But we didn't look just for the things we expected to see. We looked for other.
12:26 Speaker 03 So you're more, I'm not, I'm not joking.
12:29 Speaker 04 No, are you always joking, aren't you?
12:31 Speaker 03 This isn't a joke. You're more than pretty sure that what you heard was two black holes colliding?
12:36 Speaker 04 Yes.
12:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, but you've you've given me confidence that you might have detected something that you didn't understand because you understood your background levels very well and you look for things that just went above
12:53 Speaker 04 That's right.
12:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Or that that revealed themselves on that backdrop.
12:58 Speaker 04 That deviate from that average background.
13:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
13:01 Speaker 04 In both detectors. See, that's the most critical thing here.
13:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Gotcha. Well, here, what I want to know is because we take telescopes and we can put them in blank, empty areas and just look and see what shows up. And by doing so, we discover things like galaxies and and and we discover things. I don't know what this is. It doesn't it's not in any catalog. It's a new thing. So can you imagine what kind of new thing is out there that we haven't detected or even dreamt of so that the signal will come and you say, I am dumbstruck as to what this is in our universe?
13:39 Janna Levin? Well, if you think about Galileo, he was also only looking at what he knew. Okay? He was looking when he first pointed this telescope at the sky at the sunspots and at Saturn at the moon. So you could say, oh, my God, we knew those things existed. I mean, it was still huge and revelatory, but he didn't think, oh, I bet there are black holes out there and things called quasars, which are sending jets a million light years across. I mean, he didn't even have that vocabulary. So I think that's
14:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He didn't know about quasars? Was he an idiot?
14:05 Janna Levin? Yeah.
14:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, wait, wait. But he had the wherewithal to look at the sun and then say, wait a minute, the sun has spots on it. I've discovered something new that no one and we call them to this day, sunspots. Okay? That's how we roll in astrophysics. So, so, and he looks at the moon and he finds craters and mountains and valleys. Did not expect them, alright? So there's some things you can see and identify that you don't expect and they count as discoveries. I'm wondering, is there some astrophysical phenomenon? Because every 10 years, something shows up.
14:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Dark energy, dark matter, black holes, quasars, pulsars. Everything I just listed there showed up in a decade where before that decade, no one had any idea it even existed. An expanding universe, for goodness sake. So, I want to know that your telescope has the power of discovery that previous attempts to understand the universe have granted us.
15:16 Speaker 04 I think it does. I'll give you one example right now.
15:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You think it does?
15:19 Speaker 04 Well, I, history will tell if it did, right? I hope it does. But, look at these 30 solar mass black holes we detected. Look, this is the way discovery goes. You discover something and it only opens up new questions. We do not really understand how nature forms 30 solar mass black holes. We don't, we don't know how those are put together. And we've gotten the first snapshot into how that happens because we saw two 30 solar mass black holes merge and form a 60 solar mass black hole.
15:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so now there's a thing to talk about.
15:51 Speaker 04 Yes.
15:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That we had no way to talk about.
15:53 Eugene Mirman? If someone gives me 1 billion dollars, I'll get to the bottom of it.
15:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, so...
16:01 Eugene Mirman? In 50 years.
16:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How much more sensitive...
16:07 Eugene Mirman? But I promise to give it a real try.
16:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How, how, how much more sensitive do you have to be than a thousandth the diameter of a proton to detect stuff that happened at the Big Bang?
16:25 Speaker 04 So it sort of depends on exactly which theory of the universe's history you follow. But if you take the most standard theory of what's called slow roll inflation, it's about a factor of a million.
16:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh.
16:40 Speaker 04 It's a big factor.
16:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So a millionth of a thousandth of the diameter of a proton?
16:46 Speaker 04 Yes, but like I said, that's the most conservative version.
16:52 Speaker 03 I have a question. What are you guys talking about?
16:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, so wait, I'll catch up with you there in a sec. But I'm on a roll now. What is it about the Big Bang that you would be detecting?
17:12 Speaker 04 So what we really would be detecting are gravitational waves from the very early universe, which should have been around because just as spacetime had quantum fluctuations on it. So all of spacetime itself was ever so slightly popcorny or ripply. And those ripples, those early initial ripples, grew with the expansion of the universe.
17:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And they would have a signature?
17:38 Speaker 04 They would have a signature.
17:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, just to be clear, spacetime would have these ripples because the entire universe would have these quantum ripples because the entire universe was the size of quantum phenomenon at the very early universe.
17:53 Speaker 04 Yes, and then it grew.
17:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so quantum physics, the physics of the small, normally separate and distinct in our experience from the physics of the large, now influences the physics of the large because the large is small.
18:06 Speaker 04 Yes.
18:08 Eugene Mirman? I think the worst part is I followed that.
18:13 Speaker 03 I heard popcorn and then just totally...
18:19 Eugene Mirman? When I leave here, I'm gonna explain it to cats and they're gonna get it. I think I got it.
18:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, just to be clear, why it is we can detect something from the Big Bang at all? If the Big Bang happened 14 billion years ago? We can detect it because, because as we look out in space, we look back in time. And as you look 14 billion light years away, you are seeing objects being born at the beginning of the universe. And at a billion years from now, that horizon will be another billion years farther away from us. That stuff is now a billion years old. You'll see that boundary of objects being born.
19:09 Eugene Mirman? So we should start looking now?
19:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, there's stuff, as long as there are always matter being washed over by our expanding horizon, you will always see evidence of the birth of the universe. I see. And it's a profound fact. I get that. You get that? I do, I get it. But it's, it's a profound, it's, it's, it's like, holy shit! We, we, wait, it's like, wait, the universe, the timeline of the universe is being laid bare in front of us in every instant of every day. And the spooky part would be, the, the day, the big, the signature of the Big Bang disappears, because that would mean our horizon has washed over
19:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? the last, the last bastion of matter forming in this universe. And it goes into oblivion. And cosmology as we know it would end. But then what, what's, what, what is there then? I have no idea.
20:07 Eugene Mirman? And you think that's like something that'd happen in a few billion years or 100 billion years?
20:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Don't know!
20:12 Eugene Mirman? Do you have a guess? Your guess is pretty good.
20:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Uh, there are some guesses. The size of the actual universe beyond the horizon. If you're at a ship and you see your horizon, that's not the edge of the ocean. You know this, alright? You could like move and you see more of the ocean coming in. So, our horizon is forced upon us because light does not travel infinitely fast.
20:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because there's a place where the light is still just reaching us from stuff that was born 14 billion years ago.
20:43 Janna Levin? Well, here's a problem with that story in the future is if the universe is accelerating, that means the expansion's getting faster and faster in the future, which is actually what we see happening. Our universe right now is not only expanding, the expansion's getting faster. There will become a point in the future, if it continues like this, where not even light can outrace the expansion of the cosmos. And even if there is matter out there, even if the universe is infinite and the big bang happened infinitely everywhere, there will come a point where the light can't make it to us and the sky will go dark.
21:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? For how long?
21:16 Janna Levin? I'm always a bit of a downer at this stage of things.
21:18 Eugene Mirman? You mean the sun will go dark?
21:21 Janna Levin? Well, this is, you know, our sun is not, is not expanding with the expansion of the universe.
21:26 Eugene Mirman? Thank goodness.
21:26 Janna Levin? Yeah. So you know the Woody Allen line, he won't do his homework because he's worried that the universe is expanding and his mom's like, "You live in Brooklyn, Brooklyn is not expanding." So Brooklyn's not expanding and neither is the sun.
21:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Woody Allen remembering his childhood.
21:39 Janna Levin? Yeah.
21:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so, so she described a terrifyingly factually accurate future where, because dark energy is not only an expanding universe, but it's, it's an accelerating universe. And the idea that galaxies at the edge of our horizon, who send light in our direction, that light will never reach us because the fabric of the universe is expanding faster than the speed of light, and so it cannot overtake the expansion, the universe will start blinking off, one by one.
22:11 Eugene Mirman? I got it.
22:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Until the night sky has no light in it whatsoever.
22:18 Eugene Mirman? Oh, but that's in like...
22:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That will be the end of astronomy, the end of cosmology, the end of any attempt to understand anything beyond the events of Earth's surface. What's that? But then couldn't something else happen?
22:29 Janna Levin? Something else could happen, the dark energy could evaporate and the whole thing could start to slow down and we'd start to see the galaxies. Yay! Or came back.
22:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Or, which is a little more terrifying, I've read this, Janet, you got, help me out here, that we do not know how elastic space actually is. So that if the dark energy forces this acceleration on our expansion to some...
22:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Breaking point, maybe the fabric of the universe will rip instead of expand. And what would that rip look like?
23:06 Janna Levin? I mean, it might look like a quantum event where stuff is being created. So it's kind of like little mini Big Bangs almost. Like you're just tearing the fabric of spacetime and quantum particles are being created in this big rip.
23:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You sound like you just made that up in this moment.
23:21 Janna Levin? I'm not telling. How would you know?
23:23 Eugene Mirman? This would happen in like 2040.
23:27 Janna Levin? Well, here's the reassuring bit is that the future is much longer than the past. So we look back to the Big Bang and it's about 13.8 billion years ago. The future is like...
23:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Trillions, gazillions.
23:39 Janna Levin? Yeah, Googleplex, is that a thing? That's a number. It's a really big number.
23:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
23:44 Janna Levin? Uh, we have like roughly easily that many years in the future, even if we keep going exactly as we want.
23:50 Eugene Mirman? At that point, we'll find another universe.
23:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, I have to clarify.
23:53 Eugene Mirman? Okay.
23:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Our sun will not live that long.
23:55 Eugene Mirman? Well, we'll go somewhere else.
23:58 Eugene Mirman? I'm going to freeze myself and put it in a robot.
24:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How long will our sun live? The sun, we got about another five billion years on the sun.
24:05 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, yeah.
24:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, yeah, we're good.
24:07 Janna Levin? We're going to collide with Andromeda before then, right?
24:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, about the same time.
24:09 Janna Levin? About the same time?
24:10 Eugene Mirman? Oh, good.
24:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Striking.
24:11 Eugene Mirman? Have you picked out an outfit?
24:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So let me get back to Nergis here. Nergis, a lot of frontier engineering occurred to make this detection. Are there any obvious or not so obvious spinoffs that the public can look forward to?
24:31 Speaker 04 Yeah, so, I mean, I think...
24:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Home gravitation wave detectors.
24:35 Speaker 04 You know, absolutely. When you make a measurement at the level of 10 to the minus 18 meters, something good should come out of it.
24:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, I'm thinking.
24:44 Speaker 04 Yeah, so I think the two main technologies involved are lasers. If people wanted to make your own gravitational wave detectors, there's really only two things you have to do. Right? You have to make mirrors that are really, really still. Uh, that means you have to isolate them from all the vibrations of the ground. So vibration isolation systems. And then, once you've done that, you actually need something that helps you measure those tiny motions. And that's the laser light.
25:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, not the ruler.
25:11 Speaker 04 You know, the laser light...
25:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He wants the stapled ruler here.
25:14 Speaker 04 Yeah, but you know, I'll tell you something really fun, Michael.
25:18 Speaker 04 The laser light is our ruler. The wavelength of the light acts like the tick marks on the ruler for us. So it is actually acting in the same way. It is a ruler, really.
25:28 Eugene Mirman? It's a space ruler, Michael.
25:30 Speaker 04 It's a light ruler.
25:32 Eugene Mirman? A light ruler, a quantum light ruler.
25:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But tell me about the spin. I mean, surely there's something that's going to come out of this.
25:37 Speaker 04 Yeah, so, I mean, so the laser that we, the laser that was developed in university labs initially for LIGO eventually became a commercial product. You, in your lab, could buy one. And so that was a spin-off of a company that started, etc.
25:53 Eugene Mirman? And what would you do with it?
25:54 Speaker 04 You would do other experiments in measuring atoms, for example.
25:59 Eugene Mirman? Oh, OK.
26:00 Speaker 04 Or, I mean, you know, you could, you know, the kind of thing you like to do.
26:03 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, yeah. Cooking and measuring atoms. I have my hobbies.
26:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm just thinking, if I can make a sandwich with it, I want it. You have very low needs in this world.
26:14 Speaker 04 If you wanted a sandwich.
26:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
26:17 Speaker 04 That sat really, really still, didn't go anywhere. I know how to do it for you.
26:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? OK, great. I'll paraphrase Carl Sagan. Yes. When he says, "If you want to make a sandwich, you start with the Big Bang."
26:32 Speaker 04 It's true.
26:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I start with mustard.
26:38 Speaker 04 That was 13.8 billion years later.
26:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, you need your, you need your basic ingredients first. OK, I hear you, I hear you. That's all I'm saying. Which for me is mustard, rye bread. So, we've got to try to land this plane here. So, what's the, Nurgus, what's the future of gravitational wave astronomy?
26:58 Speaker 04 OK, so I think we're going to continue taking the sensitivity, you know, improving the sensitivity of the detectors. We have...
27:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How many, how many more powers of 10 sensitive can we get?
27:09 Speaker 04 I think powers of 10 are going to be hard in, in LIGO, in these four-kilometer-long facilities. I think we can probably do... Maybe another factor of three, five, maybe we'll eke out ten over the next ten, fifteen years, but not more than that, not powers of ten. I think personally, the next big news from gravitational wave detectors is going to be something like gravitational wave detectors measure a signal and scientists have no idea what it is.
27:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's what I want.
27:41 Speaker 04 That's what we all want.
27:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I want to stare at something and have no frickin' idea what I'm looking at.
27:45 Speaker 04 Absolutely.
27:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's a beautiful day in science.
27:48 Speaker 04 Exactly, and that, I think, will happen for the same reason you said it. It's happened with every telescope we've ever turned on.
27:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Contrary to what journalists report, they'll say, "Oh, scientists are, they have to go back to the drawing board, they're befuddled," as though that's a state of mind that we somehow want to resist. In fact, we seek out befuddlement, because out of befuddlement comes discovery. Janet, what's next up for you?
28:20 Janna Levin? Well, I think you're exactly right, and I know you were trying to get at this earlier. I mean, we're going to keep working on the things that we know, we understand, like the black hole collisions and this, it's going to be very exciting. But already, everyone's getting greedy for what is out there that we've never detected before. And we know that the universe is made of a significant amount of dark matter, which is just a proxy for something we don't know, a significant amount of dark energy, another proxy for what we don't know, the stuff that makes up this room, and everything, every telescope has ever detected in the history of the universe is less than four percent of what's out there. So this is an opportunity to detect dark stuff, the dark side of the universe, and so I would be...
29:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The dark side.
29:05 Janna Levin? I don't think I can do that.
29:09 Janna Levin? Here, I'll give you a space. We want to detect?
29:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The dark side of the universe, yes, okay.
29:14 Janna Levin? And that's going to be the thrill. Exactly what you were getting at earlier. What is out there that we haven't even thought of before?
29:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, that's curious. What you're saying is that we've been blind because we've only been seeing the light.
29:28 Janna Levin? There you go.
29:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh, I got a nod from...
29:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, do you have any concluding reflecting thoughts on what just happened?
29:46 Speaker 03 Oh, I mean fascinating stuff. Fascinating and perplexing and just glad that my children won't be around when we crash into Andromeda.
29:58 Speaker 03 Apparently.
30:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, unless you freeze them and then you thaw them out in time for it, yeah. Yeah, actually, it'll be a visual spectacle, but probably Earth will be safe. But you'll have much more to worry about with regard to the end of the sun.
30:12 Speaker 03 Right, but that's also not coming for a little while either.
30:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, five billion years, right. But they'll happen around the same time. But when the sun ends, it will expand so large that it will engulf the entire orbits of Mercury, Venus, and Earth. And Earth will be a charred ember spiraling down into the center of this crucible that we call the sun's nucleus.
30:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? By then, Earth will have vaporized after the oceans would have come to a rolling boil and evaporated into the atmosphere.
30:45 Speaker 03 I'm okay with that.
30:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And the atmosphere would have itself come to a rolling boil and evaporated into space before Earth itself vaporizes.
30:52 Speaker 03 That's fine.
30:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So have a nice day.
30:54 Eugene Mirman? Can we save the sun? Would that...
30:58 Speaker 03 If we blow on it, if we blow on it really...
31:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I think our power to travel to other solar systems might be greater than the need to have to save our sun by then, is my suspicion.
31:09 Eugene Mirman? Sounds good.
31:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah. So Eugene, you have any reflections?
31:12 Eugene Mirman? Oh, boy. Yeah, I mean, I guess I'm very curious about the 96% of the universe we haven't seen. So I'm very excited to learn a little bit more about that.
31:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, okay, cool.
31:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, we're in a field where we're actually, I don't want to call it proudly ignorant, but we're bluntly, we're frank about what we don't know. And it keeps us all humble on this frontier of search. If I can offer some reflections on this. You know, I didn't know until I saw the notes prepared for this, what LIGO cost over all those years. You added up taxpayer money, more than a billion dollars.
31:54 Eugene Mirman? But some of it's Italian taxpayers?
31:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, mostly, yeah, yeah, okay. Taxpayer money went in to detect the collision of black holes. And for many people, it's your tax money and you didn't even know it. Or you didn't explicitly vote for money that would be allocated to the National Science Foundation, which is the principal funder of this. And so, some will say, a billion dollars, we have problems here that we need solved. And I reflect on this just briefly, briefly. NASA is way more expensive than that. We're talking about a billion dollars over 30 years, 25. Divide that out.
32:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's the annual hit to the budget of the United States. NASA's budget is nearly 20 billion dollars a year. So, ground-based experiments only really get super expensive if you put them in space. That's where the real costs are. Now, to put that in context, take LIGO, a billion dollars spread over 25 years. Take the NASA budget, 20 billion dollars in a year. Go, take them both. Add them up, fine, right? Let's do that. And you know what you get? You get, you get one-half of 1% of your tax dollar.
33:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's what you get. That's, that's the hit to your tax dollar. When I hear people say, "Why are we spending all this money?" And I'm thinking...
33:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How much money do you think it actually is? And then they say, "Oh, I think you're spending probably 10% of my 20%." What a testament it is that NASA can spend one-half of 1% of your dollar, the NSF can spend a thousandth of that on your tax dollar, have the results be so visible, you think it's 10% of the tax dollar.
34:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I wanted to start a movement where federal agencies got an allocation of the tax dollar equal to what people thought they were getting.
34:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, I'll leave you with a thought. Whatever this costs, however much you think the money maybe should have gone somewhere else, okay, in a free country you have that right. I'm not going to even stop you from that right. But at the end of the day, I would pose you the question. That question is, how much is the universe worth to you? Thank you all for coming. Scott Talk!
34:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Count Basie Theater.
35:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So let's start, yes. Right over here.
35:12 Speaker 05 Hi, my name is Maria. I'm a senior at Point Beach. When you were talking about black holes earlier, you mentioned how light and all particles can fall in but never out, and how the temperatures inside increasingly get hotter and hotter to seemingly no end. So, given the theory that the Big Bang could have been, you know, was just a giant explosion, presumably it would have taken many, many, you know, the thousands of degrees to make the Big Bang happen. Is it possible that within a black hole, some sort of Big Bang could happen and an entirely new universe could be created in which life could theoretically exist one day?
35:49 Speaker 05 Do you want to try this? Oh, jeez.
35:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Man, you're blessed after that.
35:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Isn't the answer just yes?
35:57 Speaker 05 Yes.
35:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thank you. Yes.
36:03 Eugene Mirman? I was gonna guess that, now I regret it. I think that's a yes.
36:07 Janna Levin? Yeah, I mean, we really don't understand, we don't know that black holes are getting hotter or anything like that in the interior, but we do know that what the singularity conversation that we had earlier is a lot like how we talk about the Big Bang. The Big Bang seemed to be some kind of singularity. And that's not what we think will be the ultimate story. We think that as we understand quantum gravity, the idea that spacetime itself can have quantum properties and fluctuate, when we understand that the singularity will go away, but the idea that the interior of a black hole is very similar to the Big Bang will not go away presumably. So, yes, I mean, it is conceivable. That's why we think that although the black hole might be 200 kilometers on the outside, it could be as big as an entire universe on the inside.
36:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I will add that if you ask, if you look at all the mass in the universe and ask, "What size black hole would that much mass make?", that black hole is the size of the universe. And our horizon would be the mathematical equivalent of the event horizon of a black hole.
37:08 Speaker 05 Wow. Mr. Tyson, you're my hero.
37:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thank you. We've got a lot of people online. Let's see if we can do like a lightning round Q and A here, okay? See how many people we can get through. We've got like a few more minutes? We're, okay? Okay, okay. Yes, go! I'll make it quick. Why do gravitational waves travel at the speed of light? Go. Why?
37:32 Speaker 04 That's actually a prediction in Einstein's theory of general relativity. There are other theories of gravity where that would not have to be true. And in fact, that's one of the things we can test with our signals.
37:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Good. Next. Okay.
37:47 Speaker 06 So, if it requires an infinite amount of energy to reach the speed of light, and the universe is eventually going to be expanding faster than light, how does that work? And is it gonna create, like, new energy in the?
38:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, we got this. Jana?
38:04 Janna Levin? So, the fact that spacetime is expanding faster than the speed of light does not violate the principle that nothing can travel faster than the speed of light, because no information is propagating faster than the speed of light. It's really, that's the reason why you simply won't see other signals, because they can't outrace the expansion of the universe. So it really doesn't require, oddly, as much energy as you would think to make the universe expand faster than the speed of light. You can't make a particle do it, but you can make spacetime do it.
38:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, so in other words, the fabric of space can stretch faster than the speed of light, but you cannot move within that fabric of space faster than light.
38:38 Speaker 06 Thank you.
38:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, yes, right here.
38:40 Speaker 07 My name's Eileen, I'm a junior at Rutgers. My question is, what adaptations will have to be made to the detector in order to get it into orbit?
38:49 Speaker 04 Yeah, so that's not a short answer.
38:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, alright, next.
38:56 Speaker 04 But the idea is really just that you're really putting three mirrors out in space.
39:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, first, you don't have to create a vacuum, because space is already...
39:06 Speaker 04 Space has, you know...
39:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You get the vacuum for free.
39:08 Speaker 07 It's a little easier, yeah.
39:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, now, go on.
39:10 Speaker 04 So you put three spacecrafts out in space. They're spaced by five million kilometers, so that's about, that's a triangle. And each spacecraft has a mirror and a laser onboard. And so you're shooting a laser beam from one spacecraft to the other, where it's received, and you do that in a, you know, pair-wise across all of these three combinations.
39:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And then the wave comes by?
39:34 Speaker 04 And the wave comes by, and then the spacecraft just should change the distances between the spacecraft, and that should make the light travel time longer or shorter. And so the challenges there are just that these spacecrafts are kind of floating in space independent of each other, and how do you keep the distances between them still enough that when the gravitational wave comes by, you measure that?
39:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Cool. Next, over here, yeah.
39:59 Speaker 08 Hi, I'm Mike Frapriold. Uh, I was kinda curious.
40:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And what high school do you go to?
40:05 Speaker 08 A little past that.
40:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A little past that, alright.
40:07 Speaker 08 Um, I was kinda curious about how far away were the, um, the, uh, black holes spinning from each other when you first detected them?
40:14 Janna Levin? Yeah.
40:15 Speaker 08 Like, you saw them, like, when they collided, like, how far when they started to when they...
40:19 Janna Levin? It's a, it's a great question. Presumably, those two black holes were formed as deaths, dead stars, maybe billions of years ago. They were very widely separated. They were emitting extremely quiet gravitational waves, which caused them to spiral inward. So it could have been billions of years, or hundreds of millions of years at least, that they were doing this. So those gravitational waves were passing over the Earth this whole time incredibly quietly, and it wasn't until the final 200 milliseconds, when they were only a few hundred kilometers apart, orbiting each other near the speed of light, that it got loud enough to ring the detectors.
40:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And in fact, how, how much energy was released in that last fraction of a second?
41:00 Speaker 04 Ten to the forty-nine watts.
41:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, ten to the forty-nine, anything is big, but...
41:07 Janna Levin? Trillion, trillion, trillion.
41:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A squillion watts. Okay, so...
41:11 Speaker 04 Brighter than all the... Is that a lot, or a little?
41:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, no, no, so...
41:14 Speaker 04 It's brighter than all the shining stars in the universe for that brief instant. Oh, so that's a lot? Yeah.
41:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
41:23 Janna Levin? It's the most powerful event, uh, we've detected since the Big Bang.
41:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, sir.
41:27 Speaker 09 Ben from Ocean Township.
41:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright.
41:29 Speaker 09 Everything I've seen is explanations about the formations of stars, planets, the matter within the universe, but where did the space that everything goes in come from?
41:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Janet.
41:41 Speaker 09 Where did the infinite space come from?
41:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We got this. Janet, I got Janet. Why, why do you think I got her on stage here? Joe, where do you get the space from?
41:49 Janna Levin? This is a, this is a, an, not entirely understood question. Uh, when I first started learning about the Big Bang, we learned things like the universe simply didn't exist. No space, no time. The Big Bang was the creation of the space and time that we call our universe, in this quantum event that we don't fully understand, in fairness. But it could have been instantaneously infinite when the universe was created, or it could be that the universe, like... The earth is finite in size, that if we travel like in a straight line away from the earth, we're eventually going to come back to where we started. And that is a real possibility, but the more we understand pushing beyond Einstein's theory, the more we think maybe spacetime is this lumpy surface, and our big bang is
42:32 Janna Levin? simply one area that kind of caught fire, became a big bang, and looks like an entire universe. But it's certainly not the first time or the last time it has happened, and there might be an infinite number of universes out there.
42:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is kind of the multiverse.
42:44 Janna Levin? The multiverse idea.
42:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A version of the multiverse.
42:46 Janna Levin? Yeah, so the answer is, we don't really know.
42:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh yeah, so we don't know. That's the answer.
42:52 Janna Levin? That's the answer.
42:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
42:54 Janna Levin? That would have been faster.
42:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, it would have been faster.
42:58 Janna Levin? I admit, that would have been faster.
42:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If you could go straight to that, it would have been totally... Yes, right here.
43:01 Speaker 10 Hi, I'm Sarah. I'm a junior at Lacey High School, and I was wondering, you guys were talking about how the black holes were spinning in like fractions of a second's at a time, and how there was more and more gravitational waves being created. Is it possible that the ripples, the intensity of those ripples caused by the orbit of those black holes would actually cause a, like a rift in spacetime, and would that be possible?
43:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Jana. Oh.
43:29 Janna Levin? Nigga's?
43:30 Speaker 04 No, I think Jana should take this. Showalter?
43:32 Janna Levin? Um, that's a really, it's...
43:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because this was a serious disturbance.
43:43 Janna Levin? It was a serious disturbance, yet the black holes are so big that in some sense, the, while the power is huge, the gravitational waves themselves are not energetic enough to do what you're describing. However, you might ask if something more catastrophic could happen if you actually weirdly made the black holes really tiny, which is kind of a confusing difference. The smaller the black hole, sometimes, the more intense the gravity. So, we worry about things like black holes exploding from Hawking radiation and things like this, as the smaller they get, not the bigger they are. So we don't expect to see something like that in astrophysics. Big objects.
44:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, you worried about the universe ripping itself in part? She doesn't think that'll happen.
44:32 Janna Levin? Yeah.
44:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
44:34 Janna Levin? Like, when they turned on the Large Hadron Collider, we were pretty sure we weren't going to make any black holes.
44:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But, there was a really cool video. A YouTube video of the parking lot outside of the Large Hadron Collider.
44:45 Speaker 04 Falling into a black hole.
44:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, so, and they had a countdown clock to when they turned on the collider. And when they turned it on, all the cars fell into a black hole. It was very cool. It was very cool. Yes, over here.
44:56 Speaker 11 Hi, my name is Nicholas, and I'm in 3rd grade, and I'm from Seville, New Jersey.
45:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wow, that's cool. You're in 3rd grade?
45:03 Speaker 11 Yeah.
45:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, is this past your bedtime?
45:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because it's past my bedtime, that's what I tell. Well, thanks for coming out for this. My god, thanks. You like science and the universe and everything?
45:15 Speaker 11 Yeah.
45:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so do we. So, very cool. Okay, so what's up? I hope you better get extra credit for this in your science class.
45:22 Speaker 11 Yeah.
45:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, good.
45:23 Speaker 11 I was wondering if the placement of the detectors is strategic.
45:30 Speaker 04 Wow.
45:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh.
45:34 Speaker 04 That's a...
45:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So there.
45:37 Eugene Mirman? You just got into 4th grade.
45:40 Speaker 04 4th grade? 9th grade?
45:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so, explain the placement of the detectors.
45:46 Speaker 04 So, that's a great question. So, there are 2 detectors, and the best thing you could do if you have 2 detectors is to put them as far apart as possible. And what that does is 2 things. First thing it does is it keeps all the different noises that could be correlated between them, that could be the same in both detectors. It kind of makes that very hard when there are thousands of miles apart. So, that's the first thing that you want to do. You want to keep them far apart because of that reason. The other reason you want to keep them apart is, one of the things we haven't talked about is, gravitational wave detectors are kind of like our ears in another way, which is that they're not very directionally sensitive. So, if you hear a sound, you can kind of tell it came from this side of the room or that side of the room, but you can't tell exactly where it came from. And they're kind of like that.
46:29 Speaker 04 So, the further apart you put them, the more precision you have in reconstructing where the black holes in the sky were.
46:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is that like a triangulation?
46:38 Speaker 04 I think triangulation is the word for it. I was trying to avoid that for the 3rd grade, but I think you should...
46:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You think he would know what triangulation is? He just asked you about strategic placement of LIGO. Use the damn word!
46:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Triangulation, we got that? Okay, so, but that's for two detectors, but other detectors coming online around the world?
47:04 Speaker 04 Yeah, so there's one in Europe that should be on at the end of this year, maybe early next year. There's one under construction in Japan, there's another one that's planned and it should begin construction in India. So, eventually in the next five to 10 years, there will be multiple detectors. What that allows us to do is if you triangulate with multiple detectors, you can localize the source on the sky more precisely, that's the goal.
47:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And then maybe put your telescopes on it, but they probably won't see anything because we're detecting black stuff.
47:34 Speaker 04 For black holes, they won't see anything, but if you were to observe a pair of neutron stars colliding with each other, those should actually give off a flash of light, and so we should be able to see that.
47:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Very cool. So this thought given into not only the engineering, but the placement on Earth and around the globe. That was an awesome question, thank you.
47:56 Speaker 04 Yes, indeed.
47:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ladies and gentlemen, this has been StarTalk, right here in the Count Basie Theater. I want to thank you all for coming out tonight and helping us make our show. Thank you all, and thank you to the panel.
Previous Listening for Aliens, with Carolyn Porco - StarTalk All-Stars Next Putting Humans on Mars, with Mike Massimino – StarTalk All-Stars Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated