Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast StarTalk Live! Let’s Make America Smart Again (Part 2) About this episode Our mission to Make America Smart Again continues with the conclusion of our show from the Count Basie Theatre. Ft. Neil Tyson, Eugene Mirman, Sen. Cory Booker, science policy advisors John Holdren and Jo Handelsman, Ophira Eisenberg, Baratunde Thurston. #LMASA
NOTE: StarTalk All-Access subscribers can watch or listen to this entire episode commercial-free. Find out more at https://www.startalkradio.net/startalk-all-access/
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk. Your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We are live at the Count Basie Theater, Red Bank, New Jersey.
0:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? StarTalk.
0:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Let's make America smart again.
0:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright.
0:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so Joe, what more advances are coming down the pipe? What can we look for?
0:47 Speaker 01 Well, I think one of the big areas that I'm excited about is microbiology because we're starting to understand that not only the human body, but all ecosystems on Earth are driven in part by their microbiomes, which means their collection of microorganisms.
1:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The microorganisms that live on you and in you.
1:03 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly.
1:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Like mostly, probably in your intestines.
1:06 Speaker 01 Right, that's where a lot of them are, but also the skin, the ears, every orifice of the body.
1:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is nasty.
1:13 Speaker 01 No, no.
1:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And I'm thinking, you know, you tell anyone under 30 that everyone over 50 at one time would walk into something called a phone booth and take the receiver and put this side to their ear and this side to their mouth, where 100 other people had done it that day. So now you have shared earwax and mouth spittle.
1:37 Speaker 01 But, that illustration...
1:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There's no but to that, that's just nasty.
1:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Maybe that's why the older generation doesn't have all these allergies and diseases. We're like, steeped in germs.
1:50 Speaker 01 Well, and that's right. And it points to exactly the issue that most microbes are not germs. They're not harmful to us. There are only about 80 species of germs, and there are thousands, if not millions, of other species of microbes. And so, we don't think of them as the good guys, but in fact, they're keeping us healthy, controlling our behavior, controlling our vulnerability to disease all the time.
2:14 Speaker 02 But even, I mean, I've read a lot of the research on this. I mean, even things like depression and a lot of things that we've been thinking have other active, actually, our gut microbiome is affecting so much of our well-being, how we're dealing, fighting cancer.
2:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's a whole frontier now.
2:29 Speaker 02 It is an amazing frontier.
2:30 Eugene Mirman? Wait, that it has to do with depression?
2:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
2:33 Eugene Mirman? Tell me.
2:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? She was telling me backstage.
2:36 Eugene Mirman? I'm very curious.
2:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're telling me the microbes in my body are affecting the... Shoot. I gotta say this. I gotta say this because it was so cool. She was saying that there's some, you correct me if I'm wrong, I know I'll get some of this wrong. She was saying that there are microbes in you that actually like chocolate and communicate this fact to your, to your eating desires, and you say, gee, I want some chocolate, when in fact, it's your microbiome that's asking for it.
3:03 Speaker 01 That's right. We're totally driven by our bacteria. Absolutely.
3:08 Speaker 02 But I hate to tell you this, I mean, this, everything I'm reading is, there's good gut bacteria and bad gut, and the bad gut bacteria really breathes off of empty carbohydrates and things like that. But if you really want to breed better gut bacteria, you need to eat more fiber, more vegetables, more, more plant-based diet.
3:26 Speaker 04 Five people are pro-fiber.
3:28 Eugene Mirman? Flapping for carrots, bunch of jerks.
3:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, tell me about this, this gene editing tool, CRISPR, that I've heard. That's an acronym, right?
3:37 Speaker 01 Yep.
3:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because this sounds like it's the future of all biology.
3:40 Speaker 01 Well, I think it's very important because it lets us make very, very precise changes in genes or around genes.
3:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is a tool for, in the laboratory.
3:49 Speaker 01 That's right.
3:50 Speaker 02 That can never go wrong.
3:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? (laughter)
3:54 Speaker 04 Photoshop for genetic.
3:57 Speaker 04 What we could do wrong with that?
3:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What could go wrong? So, is there a biologist concerned about the ethics of that? Making new life or altering life to your own whims?
4:09 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, I think that was a big issue when John and I were in the White House, was trying to figure out what are the limits to what we're comfortable with. And one that was clear, and the President said this in his policy, was that we're not going to edit the germ line, which means the embryos that are forming. So, we're not going to create heritable changes in people in the test tube.
4:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Heritable would mean the ability to transfer that from one generation to the next?
4:37 Speaker 01 That's right.
4:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right.
4:39 Speaker 01 And so, we're thinking more in terms of what used to be called gene therapy, where regular tissue, not your sexual tissue, but your skin, or your heart, or your lungs, would be modified. So, it would only have an effect in your lifetime. But that hasn't stopped the Chinese from doing exactly the experiments we decided not to do, and affecting embryos, and having gene changes that will be passed on.
5:04 Eugene Mirman? Do we have super soldiers?
5:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I saw that movie.
5:07 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, but it sounds like it might be real.
5:11 Speaker 05 Or at least, people that live off of chocolate only. That'd be cool.
5:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, I mean, it seems to me, you can, if you can modify the individual, you can, you know, we joke about this, and I'm not even a fan of it, but people are imagining, if you're going to live on Mars, just genetically modify you so that everything that's different about Mars is okay for your genetically modified body. And that way, you don't have to live in a hab module. That's an extreme case, but clearly, you could use this to cure us of our traditional diseases.
5:43 Speaker 01 Right. And so, the human body has evolved over many millennia to be what it is today, with a few mistakes, certainly, but we haven't evolved to be on Mars. So, I don't think we're just going to make a few tweaks.
5:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I just put that out there, because people occasionally talk about it. But is this real, and is NIH funding this research? And does Congress know about this? And are they behind it?
6:04 Eugene Mirman? Are you learning about it now, here?
6:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, yeah, he's kind of saying, taking notes.
6:08 Speaker 04 And have you watched Westworld?
6:12 Speaker 05 And can we delete the Republican gene?
6:19 Speaker 04 Edit, oh, Vera, edit.
6:21 Speaker 05 Sorry, sorry. I know that's mind controlled, and I'm for it.
6:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, what is, so, so is there a, an awareness of the value of that, of that power?
6:35 Speaker 02 Incredibly.
6:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The good value of that power?
6:37 Speaker 02 Yeah, incredibly so. It's not to where I would want it to be. I would like us to get back to being a science, technology, innovation, leading nation. And, and that's my frustration is, the excitement that I get when I hear a scientist like this talk about what is possible. I wish we could somehow, sort of, expand the moral imagination of this country about what we are capable about in terms of leading the human race into a, into a safer, to a stronger, to a more prosperous world for all of us. And, and that's the challenge we have right now. I get back to this idea of what I think you play a good role in, and we all have to accept responsibility in doing, is we all, we can't expect the world to change unless we're willing to change, and be a part of that change, and lead that change. And so,
7:22 Speaker 02 we all should be excited about science, excited about innovation. The more we get excited about it, the more that will ripple out. The more we demand our elected leaders are, the more, more likely they are to respond to our demands.
7:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so what do you see are the, are the barriers between that goal and, sort of, making America smart, in a way that we become wise, wise shepherds of our future?
7:49 Speaker 02 Well, look, I, I want to be very blunt. We are going to have some very tough fighting years ahead of us. We've got three-plus years now of a president who has made it clear on many of these issues that he is contrary, you know, that the Chinese made up global warming. You saw what the values of his budget he put forward. And so, much of what I'm doing in Washington right now, still looking for partnerships across the aisle to get things done, but I'm preparing to fight a president that I think wants to take our, our country backwards in terms of science, innovation.
8:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, but, but, so I, I don't beat politicians over the head, you know why? Because they're elected by an electorate, right?
8:29 Speaker 02 Right.
8:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so, you can beat them on the head, but, and even get rid of them, but then there's the matter with the electorate that voted for them in the first place.
8:37 Speaker 02 Right.
8:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so your gripe is not actually with the president, your gripe is with the 60 million people who voted for him.
8:42 Speaker 02 No, no. In fact, hold on. I don't think we get anywhere as a country when we are in the course of demonizing each other. I think what we need to do-
8:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, I see this as a matter of education. If it's a matter, if you're saying, if you're actually saying, "This policy will harm these people and they don't know it," then somebody's got to educate them.
9:03 Speaker 02 Right, and I'll give you two quick examples. One is, this is why the science march is so important. Because when you saw the-
9:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Eight people are going to the-
9:11 Speaker 02 When we saw the- I was down in Washington for the women's march, and people didn't march around saying, "Get-" you know, there wasn't people with signs like, "Be Republicans." In fact, I bumped into women that were Republicans there, that were against a lot of policy issues. But a lot of this is just-
9:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I saw no anti-Republican signs, at all.
9:29 Speaker 02 No, not one.
9:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And there were a lot of innovative signs.
9:32 Speaker 02 The March on Washington, you had people like Strom Thurmond, literally the longest filibuster in the senate, is a racist rant by a man trying to block the civil rights legislation. But the March on Washington, listen to the speakers, John Lewis, Martin Luther King, they weren't speaking against those folks, they were calling to the moral imagination of this country. And what my frustration is, is often, we are not engaged, we luxuriate in this incredible nation. We have the four most powerful words you can say as a human being. In fact, only four and a half percent of humanity can say, "I am an American." And that comes because of the labors and the sacrifices and struggles
10:12 Speaker 02 of generations before. And this generation, we see what happens when we disconnect. We see what's happening in Washington as a result of people not voting. I saw this one pie graph, you know, fifty, you know, what is it, sixty million people voting for Hillary Clinton, fifty-seven for Donald Trump, million voting for Donald Trump, and seventy-four million other people, like, "Oh my god, look what just happened."
10:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? (laughing)
10:33 Speaker 02 You know, and so, and so, I'll give a very real example of the EPA and what's happening right now. This isn't because of Donald Trump. This was happening under a great president that wished he could change it. We in our nation right now were Ronald Reagan reauthorized and Mitch McConnell voted for a simple solution to clean up superfund sites. These are corporations that create the most toxic spots in all of America. There's a superfund in every state. Unfortunately, New Jersey has the most of them. Now, that has-
11:07 Eugene Mirman? Lucky you.
11:09 Speaker 02 That has lapsed, that funding has lapsed. Because this congress now, suddenly, not like Reagan, not like the old Mitch McConnell, decides not to reauthorize the cleanup for that. So there's all of these so-called orphan sites. There's no corporation anymore to go after to clean them up. But now we have something called data. When I was mayor, I learned this real quick. A lot of people coming to me, a lot of promotion, and I said, "Look, in God we trust, but everybody else bring me data. If you're not a deity, then show me the numbers." Well, now we have longitudinal data from Princeton University about what are the long-term effects of living around a superfund site. And we now know that if you have a child around a superfund site, there's about a 20% more likely of an increase in autism, 20% more likely of an increase in birth defects.
11:53 Speaker 02 So talk about a threat to our children. This isn't the Russians or ISIS coming. This is problems we have right here in our country that the only thing that's allowing these to proliferate. I have two superfund sites in Newark that are close to where I live, but the only thing stopping us from doing something is decisions being made in congress. But most of us don't even know that fact.
12:14 Speaker 04 But we also, look, we have the gene editing, so we can just get that deployed there first.
12:18 Speaker 02 I guess what I'm saying is that my, this is the greatest country on the planet Earth. I don't care what Donald Trump says, "We need to make it great again." We are an amazing country with reservoirs of love and goodness and kindness, but something is missing. And it was missing in the 1960s, too. It took geniuses. I remember Martin Luther King, if you know the history, the Taylor branch. He comes out of Birmingham jail after writing one of the greatest pieces of American literature, "The Letters from the Birmingham Jail." But he was failing. Two young people with an imagination, Dorothea Cotton and James Bevel, came up to him and said, "Hey, you're failing here, let us try something different." And the thing they did different was to organize other young people, ages 8 to 18, to march against Bull Connor,
13:01 Speaker 02 to create the spectacle of 10, 12, 14, 16-year-olds marching. And what Bull Connor did, he sprayed them with water hoses, the next time, he released dogs on them. But suddenly, people sitting home in Iowa and New Jersey saw this spectacle going on. Literally, the Soviet Union was making fun of our democracy on the front pages of their newspapers. And it so awoke that reservoir of love in this country. Within days, segregation fell in Birmingham, because this country, when they decide to do something, nothing can stand in our way. And so the challenge is, now... It just sounds like you gotta sink really low before you do something. I think what we need to do is find creative ways, I mean you jokingly said Snapchat about it, but I'm sorry. No, no. I've done the political-
13:46 Speaker 02 You should do it. I've done, yes, I've done the political science research about what influences people to act. And did you know the most persuasive thing to get your friends to vote? Is knowing if they're voting or not. Is literally talking to your circle of friends, more than one of my campaign commercials in New Jersey. If somebody says, "Hey, everybody, I met Cory Booker, he's a great guy, vote for him." That's far more persuasive than anything I could put on TV or anything I can do. We have so much power. And so this is my thing, I don't think we need to light rivers on fire.
14:19 Speaker 04 That was his idea. I'm not crazy. Whose idea was that?
14:22 Speaker 02 It was a Russian that said that.
14:23 Speaker 04 Who Russian said that?
14:24 Speaker 02 I don't think we need to do it, I think it's effective.
14:29 Speaker 02 What we need to do is ignite our own spirits and I promise you that that light will cast away some darkness. I just think we all need to say, "What can I do different this year around issues that I care about? Whether it's science, or super funds, or space exploration. Pick something and be a patriot with love in pursuit of that end. And you will make more of a change than you could ever imagine.
15:20 Speaker 02 What I want to know now is beyond. Do we have the policy in place to-
15:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Invent the future, or again, we're only reacting to bad things that have happened in the past. So, John, let me begin with you. How much duties of your office was to have people think about tomorrow?
15:39 Speaker 06 A lot. And in fact, you have on your list, space exploration. When we entered office, we knew we had a challenge in space exploration because a lot of the science had gone out of NASA, a lot of the advanced technology had gone out of NASA. We had to rebalance NASA. We said we were putting the science back in rocket science, in fact.
16:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Did it work?
16:01 Speaker 06 And, you know, we had a bit of a struggle.
16:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's a no?
16:05 Speaker 06 It worked. I'm sorry, it worked. We did rebalance NASA, and a lot of good stuff got done.
16:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just to be clear, you were in Washington for eight years.
16:14 Speaker 06 Eight years.
16:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Like, that's like, longer than any science advisor ever in the history of the universe.
16:19 Speaker 06 Well, of course, the history of the science advisors doesn't go back quite as far as the history of the universe. It goes back to the last term of Franklin D., well, the second-to-last term of Franklin D. Roosevelt. So, but I was the longest-serving science advisor in that jury.
16:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay. So, you had perspective?
16:41 Speaker 06 Well, sure. And of course, like everybody else, and like you, I had been watching. I was a space geek when I was a little kid. I was making solid fuel rockets out of my mother's used lipstick tubes when I was nine. They went about a hundred feet in the air. But, yeah, I'd been watching it for a long time, and it was a pleasure to have the opportunity working with President Obama and working with Charlie Bolden, the NASA Administrator, to get some things done.
17:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You made rockets out of lipstick tubes?
17:10 Speaker 06 No.
17:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Did that hurt your background check?
17:12 Speaker 06 When they did the background check, and they found out that you blew things up as
17:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? a kid?
17:15 Speaker 06 Well, yeah, it was a bit of a problem, but they decided to let me through.
17:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You made rockets out of lipstick tubes?
17:21 Speaker 06 Little solid fuel rockets, yeah. I had chemistry set ingredients that made the solid fuel. I made time fuse, burned an inch a minute, so I could get away before it went off.
17:32 Speaker 05 Next time I see sixteen-year-old boys in Sephora, I'll know what they're up to.
17:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? One hundred and one things to do with lipstick tubes.
17:42 Speaker 05 That's amazing.
17:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, I'm sorry, I was very distracted by that.
17:46 Speaker 06 I apologize, it was my fault.
17:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, okay, I think I'm back on track.
17:50 Speaker 06 But we did, we did get a lot done in reshaping the priorities in NASA. More investments in the technologies that would be needed to go to Mars. You know, a lot of people are saying, "Why don't we go to Mars tomorrow?"
18:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
18:03 Speaker 06 Let's put the money in, and you know Neil as well as I do, that we don't yet have the technologies to send people to the surface of Mars and bring them back. Of course, there are some who are willing to take a one-way trip, and some others who would be my candidates for a one-way trip.
18:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We have a one-way trip.
18:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, you're citing NASA in response to my question about the future. Is NASA the repository of our future hopes among agencies?
18:30 Speaker 06 No, it's only one. It just happens to be a particularly evocative one, and one that still, by the way, inspires young people in the way almost nothing else in science does. At the big science fairs we've had in Washington, the two exhibits that always attract the most attention are NASA and robots. Those are the two that really do it, that get kids going about science and technology.
18:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, how do you draw the line between the research you do that helps invent a future and the research that Congress will tell you you shouldn't be doing because corporations should be doing that as part of their R and D? Where's that line? It's gotta be somewhere in there.
19:09 Speaker 06 Well, there is, there's a fairly obvious line. In fact, the corporate sector funds more than two-thirds of all the R and D in this country, but they fund less than half of the basic research, the fundamental research that's the seed corn from which all the future applies.
19:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The long-horizon research.
19:26 Speaker 06 And the reason the private sector doesn't do that is perfectly understandable. Time horizon is too long, the risk is too high, the return is too uncertain, and they're not sure that if there's a breakthrough from this basic research, that they, the corporation that paid for it, will get the benefits.
19:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But I always hear in Congress...
19:44 Speaker 06 And the result is, the government needs to do it. The government needs to do that sort of basic research, they need to fund it.
19:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
19:49 Speaker 06 But it won't get done.
19:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? When that happens... Congress stands up and says, "Why is taxpayer money being wasted on this research that has no application to any known thing on earth?"
20:00 Eugene Mirman? What are examples of some of this terrible research?
20:03 Speaker 06 Well, yeah, then I'll give you some. The nature of basic research is you can't tell where it's going to go. Great example, Charles Townes, who got the Nobel Prize for thinking up the science behind the mazer and then the laser, had no idea, when he did that work, that 50 years later, lasers would be the way we do eye surgery, cut metal, copy documents, play movies, measure distances. None of that was obvious at the time the work was done.
20:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We even measured the distance to the moon with lasers.
20:33 Eugene Mirman? I think lasers are worth it. Yeah. Just my opinion.
20:38 Speaker 06 There's another great example. There was a science project funded by the National Science Foundation many years ago, was called "The Sex Life of the Screwworm."
20:48 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
20:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Of the Screwworm?
20:50 Speaker 06 Of the Screwworm. The Sex Life of the Screwworm.
20:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's a worm? That's a real worm?
20:54 Speaker 06 A real worm.
20:55 Eugene Mirman? Guess what it does?
20:56 Speaker 06 And there was, a lot of fun was made of this in the Congress. I think it got Senator Proxmire's Golden Fleece Award, in fact.
21:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The award given to the greatest waste of taxpayer money.
21:09 Speaker 06 The greatest waste of taxpayers' money. And the fact is, the Screwworm was a livestock pest that did some $100 million worth of damage every year to the livestock industry in the United States. And this basic research on the sex life of the Screwworm led to a means of biological control of the Screwworm, which basically eradicated it as a livestock pest.
21:29 Speaker 04 Was that immense savings to the US economy? Was that just a marketing failure, though? Like, shouldn't it have been called, like, "Save Our Agriculture Business Research"? Because you can't vote against that.
21:39 Speaker 06 The people doing the research didn't know that that would be the outcome. That's the nature of basic research. And then they put condoms on the Screwworms.
21:47 Speaker 04 Save sex for Screwworms, better agriculture for America.
21:53 Speaker 06 The solution was actually somewhat similar to that. Really? The solution was releasing sterile males, because it turns out that the Screwworm only mated once, the female only mated once. And if the female mated with a sterile male, then...
22:05 Speaker 04 She was done.
22:06 Speaker 06 No offspring. And so the idea was, you just release it.
22:13 Speaker 04 You just release a ton of sterile males.
22:15 Speaker 06 Yeah.
22:15 Speaker 04 And, and the screw worm goes out of business.
22:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I can't believe we just spent 10 minutes talking about the screw worm.
22:21 Eugene Mirman? They do the same thing in Skidmore, actually.
22:23 Speaker 04 I apologize.
22:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, that's fine.
22:26 Speaker 04 You asked for an example.
22:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But we know, Corey, that there are people who don't, in Congress, both sides of the, both branches, that don't appreciate this.
22:36 Speaker 02 Absolutely. There's people that don't.
22:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How do we get them to appreciate it?
22:40 Speaker 02 Again, that's the, that's the political process. That's the sort of sausage making or screw worm funding process.
22:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's not just education. It's not just examples like this.
22:50 Speaker 02 No, it's not.
22:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Why can't, why can't he stand up, give that example? I give three others, and they, these are tangible examples. Why doesn't that convince people? Is there missing part of the K-12 education where the receptors aren't there for, for examples that might change their mind?
23:08 Speaker 02 Again, it is a, this is a process in which there's tons of competing demands, and there are people that are dead set against this kind of science research and, and don't get the larger picture.
23:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is it because they dug in their heels, and that's it?
23:20 Speaker 04 That, look, with respect, Neil, I think...
23:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, I don't ever want you to respect me. Just bring it out.
23:26 Speaker 04 Then with...
23:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'll take care of you later.
23:28 Speaker 04 Then with extreme disrespect. You're, you're coming at this as a scientist, and you're leaning on these facts as if facts have ever always been enough. Any parent knows that you just tell the kid a fact once, why don't, why do they keep misbehaving? I told them, if this happens, this will be the consequence. But we do it, because we have emotions, and we have tribalism, and want to feel a sense of belonging. So I think some of these reasons that people are being obstinate, information alone is never enough to close a case. And so it's, it's an important first step, but you've got to build some layers on top of that telepathy.
24:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay. In the day, it was called an ass whipping.
24:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's how you convince someone. If the data didn't otherwise work. I'm just curious about that. There are other branches of NASA, of the government, other than NASA. I don't know if they were in your portfolio, but DARPA is something we've always heard of. Defense, Advanced Research Projects Administration.
24:25 Speaker 02 And there's DARPA E.
24:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Huh?
24:27 Speaker 02 There's DARPA E.
24:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Which is?
24:29 Speaker 02 Which I'm very interested in. It's about, it's investments in alternative energy.
24:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So E for energy?
24:34 Speaker 02 Yes.
24:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So these are funded by the Department of Defense?
24:38 Speaker 02 Yes.
24:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
24:39 Speaker 06 Now, ARPA E is funded by the Department of Energy.
24:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, but they're both, neither of them are in OSTP's portfolio?
24:45 Speaker 06 Oh, they are.
24:46 Speaker 01 Oh, they are.
24:46 Speaker 06 OSTP has oversight of all the science and technology.
24:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No matter who's doing it?
24:50 Speaker 06 No matter who's doing it.
24:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, okay.
24:53 Speaker 06 And we work together with the departments and agencies in developing the president's budget.
24:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So tell me about robots. You said robots get everybody's attention at the science fairs.
25:04 Speaker 06 Yeah, absolutely.
25:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And I know DARPA's been making some robots.
25:07 Speaker 06 Absolutely.
25:13 Eugene Mirman? Made it sound naughty, but anyway.
25:16 Eugene Mirman? Would it help to just reframe all our science as a weapon?
25:20 Speaker 02 Yes. But, but look, I mean, one of the reasons why we can get a lot of very good research done through the Department of Defense, because it's often easier to get people to fund the Department of Defense than it is to get them to fund some of these other agencies.
25:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because they're invoking the "I don't want to die" urge.
25:36 Eugene Mirman? If the screw was a weapon, there'd be no problem.
25:40 Speaker 02 There is a battle going on right now about defense spending versus domestic spending. And this idea of should there be parity in the increases and the like. But I just have a question, because I've got two scientists here, and something I've read a lot about, when you talk about larger planetary threats, isn't there a real threat of an EM pulse, for example, a naturally occurring one, that could really knock out America's infrastructure?
26:06 Speaker 06 Yes, is the short answer.
26:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah. You happy now?
26:09 Speaker 02 I'm not happy. I'm one of these people that wants to see more infrastructure.
26:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Tell everyone about an EM pulse.
26:14 Speaker 06 No.
26:15 Eugene Mirman? Wait, is the Matrix real it?
26:19 Speaker 02 Right, the Matrix had, and Ian Puls to get rid of the...
26:23 Eugene Mirman? Robot squids that he...
26:24 Speaker 02 The squiddy, the squiddy thing, what were they called? The sentinels. You guys didn't see the Matrix?
26:29 Speaker 06 Oh my god. So there are two kinds of electromagnetic pulse. One is if you explode a nuclear bomb in the atmosphere, among many other things, it generates a pulse of electromagnetic energy that can fry the electronics in your cellphone and your car's ignition, in the controllers of the electricity grid and so on. So that's one of the many good reasons not to explode nuclear weapons in the atmosphere.
26:52 Eugene Mirman? Is that it will ruin your phone.
26:54 Speaker 06 It will ruin your phone.
26:55 Eugene Mirman? It will ruin, like you would need a new phone.
27:00 Speaker 06 But, uh...
27:01 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
27:02 Speaker 06 The, uh...
27:03 Speaker 02 Didn't the Nokia 7 have one of these? Yeah. No, Samsung 7.
27:07 Speaker 06 Samsung. But the natural version of an electromagnetic pulse is when a solar storm...
27:15 Speaker 02 A solar flare.
27:16 Speaker 06 A solar flare throws charged particles in the direction of the earth, and they interact with the earth's magnetic field in a way that generates a pulse of electromagnetic energy at the surface. And that too can fry your phone, your electricity grid, and everything else.
27:34 Eugene Mirman? Has that ever happened?
27:35 Speaker 06 It has happened.
27:36 Eugene Mirman? On a massive scale?
27:37 Speaker 06 It happened in Canada.
27:38 Eugene Mirman? Thank goodness.
27:39 Speaker 06 It's happened in modern times, it happened in a part of Canada.
27:42 Eugene Mirman? Ottawa?
27:43 Speaker 06 But it also happened, there was an event in the late 19th century...
27:47 Speaker 02 1860s, right?
27:48 Speaker 06 That if, that was so severe, it knocked out telegraph over a very large area, but there wasn't much electrical equipment in those days. And so it didn't do that much damage. But we know that if an event of that magnitude occurred today, it would be devastating.
28:05 Speaker 02 Could cripple our country.
28:06 Speaker 06 And as a result... So where at war with the sun? As a result of that possibility, we have invested now substantial effort in trying to build a multi-pronged strategy to protect us from those kinds of events. That strategy, that strategy includes sensors on the Discover satellite to give us early warning. The strategy includes the ability to disconnect parts of the electricity grid on warning very quickly. But there are other things that we should be doing, and that the study recommended that we do, that we're not yet doing.
28:38 Speaker 02 Right.
28:39 Speaker 06 And that's something that I'm very glad you're interested in.
28:40 Speaker 02 No, this is my point, these are things I read, there's too much I read that I get now worried about. Okay, but that's not all you should be worried about. So...
28:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, we should be worrying about that as a globe.
28:50 Speaker 01 Yeah, when's this happening?
28:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We don't know.
28:54 Eugene Mirman? Is it on Artie Brown?
28:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Not predictable. So, so there's not only that, there's, there's always talk about AI running amok. And does the United States have a major investment in this, the future of this technology?
29:08 Speaker 02 So we've basically gone from The Matrix to Terminator now, but keep going.
29:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
29:13 Speaker 04 Both happy movies.
29:14 Eugene Mirman? Can we just ask the regular, like, in my regular life, about how scared should I really be? Like, uh, I got one out of 10. Like, uh, six?
29:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, well, let me get, so AI, let me ask you this. I, we had Ray Kurzweil as a guest on StarTalk, and I was delighted by that conversation because I'd only known of him from what other people wrote, and I finally got the horse's mouth, and, and I love the guy to no end. Uh, just, he's a deep thinker, he's brilliant, and so what I ask, there's a lot of talk about connecting human biology to the internet in some way, so that your brain is now actively processing the world. And do you see this biologically as a real thing coming down the line?
29:58 Speaker 01 I think so. I don't think it's-
29:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes?
30:00 Speaker 01 Yes. I don't think it's imminent. I, I think that's way, ways off.
30:05 Speaker 02 But we're steps, we're steps there already. There's, there's biologics you can put inside of yourself, they're gonna be able to monitor, distribute medicine, all, your doctor could literally sit at a computer. Uh, we're, we're getting close to that and be able to deliver you doses of medicine based upon the information they're getting over distances about what's happening inside of your body.
30:23 Speaker 01 And that's precision medicine. We were talking about it before.
30:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, so, but how, but AI now is making decisions that I didn't authorize. Right? So, the big fear is that AI, a- a- and I tweeted this once, I said, "We better behave because when AI achieves consciousness, we want to give it as fewer reasons as possible to exterminate us." Okay? So-
30:48 Speaker 02 People are clapping for extermination by AI.
30:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, I think they agree.
30:52 Speaker 02 They're like, "Don't worry, Arnold will save us." So is there an agency that's thinking about AI? Surely the
30:59 Speaker 01 John Siri.
31:00 Speaker 02 Okay.
31:01 Speaker 06 Yeah, I mean, we had many, many meetings in the White House about AI, many of them including President Obama, who's very interested in it and concerned about it.
31:10 Speaker 02 Did he write a paper on it?
31:11 Speaker 06 It has an upside. It has an upside in terms of increasing the capacity to get a lot of important things done. It has a downside, like many technologies. If it's misused, if it evolves in a bad direction, it could be problematic. And so the question is, how do you manage the evolution of this technology in a way that gets the benefits while minimizing the dangers? But my own view is that the dangers, as we currently understand them, are being overstated. The proposition that computers are going to become, in some general sense, smarter than humans sometime soon, is not believed by many of the experts in the field. There are some who think it will happen.
31:56 Speaker 06 There are many who think it won't happen. That doesn't mean we shouldn't be vigilant and trying to figure out how to make sure that AI doesn't evolve in a way that takes over our lives.
32:05 Speaker 02 But can I tell you where AI scares me right now in Israel? Is that our enemies, sorry Eugene, like Russia.
32:13 Eugene Mirman? I'm a US citizen, just to be clear.
32:17 Speaker 02 Sorry.
32:18 Eugene Mirman? I mean, I'll blend in if they win, but...
32:28 Speaker 02 This is, so we have a real problem in this country with cyber attacks. And one of the reasons, one of the areas in which AI technology is now being used, look, Russia and China will never beat us, tank for tank, worship for worship. We spend more money on military, have a bigger military, the next six, seven countries combined. But where they can now offer a threat, we just saw this with a massive cyber attack, is with what the advancements are being made in hacking and that kind of technology. And AI is being used... Invested in and explored by the Chinese and the Russians as a way of having a far more intelligent way where the computer can itself begin to learn about what the defenses are of a system and better break into them.
33:12 Speaker 02 And so when you see our competitors, and remember it's not just Russia, it's China who's doing extraordinary jobs stealing business technologies and the like, using these very sophisticated AI, blockchain, all these new next generation sort of technologies and innovations against us and beating us to the punch. It's a massive vulnerability for our nation that we should be very aware and be concerned about.
33:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that would come under the Department of Defense. But the Department of Defense, other than the DARPA and the DARPA-E, is not really as equipped, it seems to me, to attract the best and the brightest to solve that problem.
33:48 Speaker 06 Well, I don't think that's quite right. The Department of Defense includes the National Security Agency. National Security Agency employs more PhD mathematicians than any other organization in the world.
33:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There you got it.
33:59 Speaker 06 They are thinking about AI extensively, as is DARPA, which has a lot of smart folks as well. I'm not saying there's no problem. I agree with the Senator, this is a big risk. It's a big area of competition. Our adversaries are very busy. We're very busy too, by the way. And AI can be used to defend our cyber systems, just as it can be used by our adversaries to attack them. So this is an ongoing tension.
34:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So we can put our AI against their AI and then just let them fight and we go off and go to the park?
34:29 Speaker 06 Yeah, that would be good.
34:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Let me just get into your lives for a moment. Each of you left academic posts to serve in the White House. And you became a sort of a citizen scientist servant of needs. What each of you, what drove you to do that?
35:00 Speaker 01 Well, for me, there were two factors. One was John Holdren, the other was Barack Obama.
35:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, okay.
35:06 Speaker 01 They were totally impressive intellects, committed to science. And I think John convinced me when we first talked about the position that working for this president would be a privilege beyond all else for a scientist, and he was right. It was an honor to work for a president who cared so much about science.
35:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, nine years ago, what were you thinking?
35:34 Speaker 06 Well, first of all, I had had the good fortune to meet President Eisenhower's second-term science adviser, George Kistie Akowski, when I was 29-years-old. And he became one of my mentors, and I learned a lot from him about his service for Eisenhower. Then I met Jerry Wiener, who was JFK's science adviser, and he became a mentor. And I ended up knowing every science adviser to every US president from Eisenhower on. And so I had a secret ambition, as a result of all those interactions, that I might someday be a president's science adviser, and I just happened to luck out and get the best president in modern times to be the science adviser too.
36:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If there were a president who you didn't like, but asked you to be his or her science adviser, what would you say?
36:25 Speaker 06 Well, it would depend on the president.
36:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Why? If you're asked to advise them, why should it depend on the president? It depends on you.
36:32 Speaker 06 No, you have to believe that the president will listen. You have to believe that the president is interested, that he's not just trying to check the box.
36:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, wait. If you're not an adviser at all, if you're not even in the room, they're clearly not listening to you because you're not in the room.
36:47 Speaker 06 No, that's true.
36:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So then, there's a chance they'll listen to you if you're in the room.
36:51 Speaker 06 You have to figure out whether you're going to be more effective advising this particular president, or more effective pursuing the same issues from outside.
36:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? From outside.
37:00 Speaker 06 You have to make that decision.
37:01 Eugene Mirman? It can't always work to yell "science" into a wig.
37:03 Speaker 02 But can I just say something about these two doctors that's extraordinary, and people should recognize this? The whole idea of our country in the Declaration of Independence, which, this genius document, but frankly, had flaws. It was, you know, referred to Native Americans as savages, and all the flaws of the genius of the writers at the time, that they had flaws, but they kind of came to a conclusion at the end. Where they basically said for this country, the idea of this nation, which was not founded like other countries, because we all look alike, or pray alike, or descended the same way. This was, the idea of this country was the first nation of ideas and principles. And that's a tenuous, especially then, it was a tenuous way of forming a nation. And so what these two doctors really represent to me is, what our founders said is gonna have to happen.
37:47 Speaker 02 If this country is gonna make it, they basically said, we have to have an unusual commitment to each other that goes beyond just tolerating each other, or kind of admiring each other. They basically said, we have to commit to each other, and this is the final words of the Declaration of Independence, we must mutually pledge to each other our lives, our fortunes, and our sacred honor. And it's something we all should think about. Are we living our lives this way? These folks, and they're very humble, but trust me, they could have probably made a lot more money.
38:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yep.
38:19 Speaker 02 A lot more resources.
38:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You don't get rich working in government.
38:22 Speaker 02 You do not get rich. But these are folks that said, you know what? My love of this country, my sacred honor, my commitment of my fortune, will be to this nation's goodness. And it's been those folks, who are those irrational people throughout history, who may not even make it into the history books, but have had consistently had this commitment. Those people that built the greatest infrastructure this nation has ever known, most of them whose names aren't known, the Underground Railroad. Those people who, I can't name the people, who whether they stormed beaches in Normandy, or sat in laboratories, designing technologies, innovations that I use every day, but I take it, I take for granted. And so I just wanna thank them publicly, because they don't often get a moment like this before a huge audience.
39:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Hardly ever.
39:04 Speaker 02 Hardly ever, to get the kind of gratitude and celebration that we do. So thank you very, very much.
39:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So let me, let me just go down the line here, before we close this out. And just, one by one, if you could, what would be your recipe for making America smart again? Just Eugene.
39:36 Eugene Mirman? Hi, I don't know what he said.
39:41 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, I guess, um, I guess voting. Voting. Voting for science, and also I think things like the science march, I think. I think being active and being... I'm optimistic in the end. I think that you can forward good things and over time, it will work, is sort of, so I think, science marching. These immigrants are so hopeful. I am very hopeful. I'm also sitting on a stage with you guys joking around, so I totally believe it. Immigrants, they get the job done. I believe in the American dream. I adore it. Uh, Ofira.
40:19 Speaker 05 You know, I think we, we talk a lot about, um, like right now, everyone's stressed out by what's going on, and they're like, "How am I gonna deal with the climate?" Self-care. "I'll go to do some meditation and yoga." I think we have to stop focusing on ourselves. I think we have to focus on other people and our community, and think outside of ourselves more often, and think about, um, how we are together, rather than just laying down and going, "10 minutes of headspace is gonna make it all better."
40:53 Eugene Mirman? John.
40:55 Speaker 06 I'm gonna build on what Ofira has said, and suggest, as I've done elsewhere, that everybody who is in science, in technology, or who cares about science and technology, should tithe 10% of their time, whatever else they do, tithe 10% of their time to talking with other people, to engaging on how and why science and technology matter to our society, to our well-being, to the world, what science is, how it works, what the sources of credibility in science are, and why we need to preserve and protect science. We need all of us to be better storytellers about this, to be activists, to be engaged in the policy process.
41:38 Eugene Mirman? Citizen activists.
41:41 Eugene Mirman? Babatunde.
41:44 Speaker 04 Thank you for having me here. No, I'm serious. It's been an incredible honor to be onstage with these civil servants, whether it's the comedic arts or the arts and sciences, and I'm humbled to be a part of this. I want to echo what Eugene said. I happened to be at a meeting of the organizers of the science march, and one of them cited a Niels Bohr quote, quantum physics pioneer, and I'm going to paraphrase it, but he essentially described science as the steady reduction of prejudice. And if you think about what science actually is, you constantly challenge what you think to be true and replace it to what you know to be true. And if you're not constantly challenging, that's not science. So we've been challenged up here. I encourage folks out there to do it. And I think what's coming up with the science march, whether it's before, during, or after,
42:29 Speaker 04 is a testament to something much larger than the politics of the moment. It's about the larger pursuit of science, which is the reduction of all of our prejudices.
42:42 Speaker 01 One of the things I found really striking today was when we talked about things that excite the public about science, it was either because of fear or inspiration. And I think we need to find a way to explain science and teach science in logical ways, not fear-mongering, but that either incite fear or people's imaginations and inspiration. And it can't be just discovering new planets and discovering new cures. It has to go way beyond that to all of science. And I don't know how to do that, but I would challenge all of us to think about that. How do we inspire people about the fundamental quest for knowledge, which is the basis of science?
43:31 Speaker 02 I guess I just would encourage people to, as Eugene said, to be people of hope. But what I mean by that is, I think this last 100 days has been some of the most hopeful period in my time as a senator. And it's not because the situation looks great, but I spent eight years living in these high-rise projects in Newark, and the tenant president there, who had her son murdered in the lobby of the building which I lived in... She was one of the most hopeful people that I met. And basically, what she taught me was that hope doesn't exist in the abstract. It's always a response to despair. It's saying that despair will not have the last word. And that hope also is not a being word. You don't just sit in a state of being that's hope. Hope isn't active, it's a fighter.
44:14 Speaker 02 It is constantly working to create that belief that you haven't surrendered. And so, my hope is that I've seen the greatness of my country, whether it was the Women's March, or how that healthcare bill, which was so awful, was beat back, not by politicians, but by a public, Republican and Democrat, who just said, "There's no way we're gonna tolerate that." And so, right now, my prayer is that everybody remembers those ten-two-letter words. That this country will succeed or fail based on those ten-two-letter words. And those ten-two-letter words is, "If it is to be, it is up to me." I have gotta be an agent of hope. And that's sort of my parting.
44:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If I could offer some final reflections here. You guys said almost everything I would have said. So, you really left me with nothing. I got nothing now. But let me share with you. Personally, I try not to have hope. Because hope is the confession that you have no control of the outcome. And I don't ever wanna cede that to a word. I wanna say to myself, "There's an outcome that I have some access to, some control over." And let me reiterate again why I don't beat back politicians. There's something else deeper than that. And in our K-12 system, what do we do?
45:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I think we view students as these vessels, where you unzip their brain, their head, and pour information in for 12 years. And then you zip it back up, hand them the diploma, and send them off. And so, we think that being educated is knowing stuff. When somewhere in there, one ought to be taught... How to question knowledge? How to evaluate information and evidence? These are the foundations of science. We don't even have to call it science. Let's just call it curiosity. Because what is a scientist but a kid who never really grew up?
46:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, it's a kid who, who in adulthood retained childlike curiosity. And when you retain childlike curiosity, anything that happens before you is up for questioning. And you say, "Well, why are you doing it that way? Can it happen this way?" Well, let me research that. And if you, in addition to being trained how to think about information, you're, if somehow we can retain your curiosity from childhood through adulthood, retain that curiosity, then you become lifelong learners, lifelong inquisitors. Because we will spend many more years outside of school than in school. How many people do we know, if not among ourselves,
47:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? the last day of school, you take your books, throw them into the air and say, "School's done." As though that's the state you want to be in, where you no longer have to learn? That's a failure in the educational system. You should come out of school and say, "Gee, I'm still curious. Can I go back in? Or is there some ways I can keep learning?" And I think that if we breed an entire generation of people that are curious into adulthood, then you will never elect someone who just states things that are not true. That kid, that would never happen, okay?
47:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because if you build into the system curiosity. And where does the politics come? The politics layers on top of that. Alright, so you don't say, "There is no global warming." We know there is. Alright, so now that we know there is, let's have the polit- the political conversation. Are there carbon credits? Do you fu- do you, uh, uh, subsidize? Or do you put up tariffs? That's where the politics needs to happen. Not at any level below that. So my sense of this is, if you want to make America great, you first have to make it smart. And to make it smart... We have to retain the curiosity that we all had as children.
48:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And that way, we can turn a sleepy country into an innovation nation. Amen.
48:38 Speaker 07 Red Bank, New Jersey. This has been StarTalk. And I've been your host, Neil deGrasse Tyson. And my guests, Bob Attende, the senator, Joe, John, and Peter. Yugi. Thank you all, New Jersey.
49:02 Speaker 07 As always, keep looking up.
Previous #ICYMI - Slam Dunk Science (Part 1) Next #ICYMI - Slam Dunk Science (Part 2) Page updated September 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated