Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast StarTalk Live: I, Robot (Part 2) About this episode Neil deGrasse Tyson and Honeybee Robotics’ Stephen Gorevan focus on robots here on Earth, from steam pipe repairing robotic inchworms and Predator drones to Asimov’s Three Laws of Robotics and the practicality of cyborgs.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk. Your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We're live at the Bell House, StarTalk!
0:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I've got one of the founders of Honeybee Robotics. Steven, welcome to StarTalk.
0:36 Speaker 01 Thank you.
0:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What I like most about Honeybee Robotics is that they're based in Manhattan. That's just cool. People think of Manhattan as Broadway and Wall Street. And you're rocking the universe in Manhattan.
0:50 Speaker 01 That's true.
0:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Eugene, who do you have over to your right?
0:52 Speaker 01 I have W. Kamau Bell and Jason Sudeikis.
0:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The one and the only of each. So I just want to talk about robots closer to home. So you've developed robots, my crib sheet here says for Con Ed, for Coca-Cola.
1:07 Speaker 01 Sellout.
1:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? For Nike, what, why does Nike need a robot? Is it to put the shoes together?
1:15 Speaker 01 Oh, boy. I can't tell you that. I have a proprietary agreement on that one, but I can tell you the Con Edison robot.
1:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright.
1:21 Speaker 01 The Con Edison robot is a robot...
1:23 Speaker 02 I'd really like to hear about the Nike robot!
1:25 Speaker 01 Yeah. I would, they take my firstborn.
1:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so Con Ed for people who are not residents of New York City is the electric company of New York City.
1:33 Speaker 01 That's right.
1:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Consolidated Edison.
1:35 Speaker 01 And if you've seen movies of New York, there's steam rising through the streets. This is because that Con Edison controls something called a city steam system. And there is actually steam generated and sent through hundreds of miles of pipe under Manhattan and they heat skyscrapers. The Empire State Building is entirely heated with city steam. There are no boilers in it. There are no air conditioners. There are steam air conditioners in the Empire State Building and in the World Trade Center.
2:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm sorry, I have no idea what that means.
2:03 Speaker 01 What is a steam?
2:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Steam air conditioner.
2:05 Speaker 01 I don't know how it works, but I know that the city's steam air conditioner...
2:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's weird, that you two guys don't know how that works. I feel like that calls into question everything else you've heard tonight.
2:15 Speaker 01 That steam leak that comes up through the streets.
2:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm not buying none of this. Robots on Mars, I'm not buying any of this now. You can't explain an air conditioner.
2:24 Speaker 01 I mean, I don't know how it runs from steam. But the steam coming up through the streets is actually, there are leaks in the city steam system. So Con Edison hired us to seal those leaks. And this meant sending a robot through the pipes. And we developed an inchworm system that goes through the pipes and welds the leaks from the inside of the pipe. I think that makes up for not knowing how.
2:46 Speaker 03 Yeah, sure does.
2:47 Speaker 01 Yeah, we're good with that?
2:48 Speaker 04 You built robots that go through our pipes and weld.
2:53 Speaker 01 He built an inchworm robot that crawls through the steam pipe and welds holes.
2:59 Speaker 04 So you're the greatest threat to the world. You cannot be stopped.
3:05 Speaker 01 When we were called upon to develop our concept for how to get to the ice pack in Europa, we used the Con Edison design as the baseline. For that inchworm robot, except for going sideways, we said we can use the same concept to drill down, to inchworm itself down into the ice pack. So is this autonomous, or are you telling it what to do? Well, almost all spacecraft and automation and robotics is what we would call supervised autonomy. You give it a sequence of commands. It has certain ability to, these robots have certain abilities. To achieve consciousness. Well, to make decisions.
3:36 Speaker 04 Does it ever go like, "Nah, I don't like that."
3:37 Speaker 01 To improvise. Well, just now, that's right. On Curiosity, just now, we've switched to an auto-nav system where Curiosity now is making some decisions. We don't dictate the path the rover has to go, inch by inch. It gets to make some of its own decisions. Like Peyton Manning. Yeah.
3:52 Speaker 03 They pause audibles, it's like, "No, I'm not going down there, you go down there." It's like, "I'm going this way."
3:57 Speaker 01 But we haven't really allowed our robots to be completely free yet because we're too, we're afraid that they're going.
4:03 Speaker 03 We've seen the movies, we know why.
4:05 Speaker 01 Yeah, we know, we know the movie. Yeah.
4:07 Speaker 04 What? We don't want inchworms with lasers everywhere.
4:11 Speaker 01 So what'd you do for Coca-Cola? Well, there used to be a giant sign in Times Square that was imposed of...
4:17 Speaker 03 Until Superman 2.
4:18 Speaker 01 Moving parts.
4:19 Speaker 04 I was gonna say that!
4:23 Speaker 01 It had five moving parts. It had a 70-foot straw. This was all mechanical devices. And these devices, some of them were 10 tons. And they moved 120 degrees. They would form Diet Coke, and then Coke. And the Coca-Cola bottle itself, that straw was in, was bigger than my first apartment in New York. It was huge.
4:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, that, well...
4:41 Speaker 04 Because you had an incredibly giant first apartment in New York.
4:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's what I'm trying to figure out here.
4:44 Speaker 04 That's an unusual analogy.
4:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? To say something's bigger than a New York apartment, therefore it's huge, doesn't work.
4:50 Speaker 01 Alright, well...
4:51 Speaker 04 But even a small apartment is a very big object, right?
4:54 Speaker 01 So we did signs for them. We did these robotic signs for them.
4:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He's like, "Shut up."
4:59 Speaker 04 I thought it was a wonderful place.
5:01 Speaker 01 It's a dirty job, and somebody's gotta do it.
5:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And I see here, you also work for the Navy.
5:07 Speaker 01 That you can talk about Nike.
5:11 Speaker 04 Yeah, you seem unreasonably upset by the word "Navy."
5:14 Speaker 01 Well, we work for DARPA.
5:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The Defense Advanced Project Research Agency.
5:18 Speaker 01 That's right. Yeah, it's one of the golden projects, really. The robotics industry is to be able to take spacecraft that are orbiting the Earth, that are running out of fuel. We're talking about spacecraft that are worth hundreds of millions of dollars, and they become defunct simply because they're running out of station-keeping fuel.
5:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, just to clarify, satellites don't need fuel to orbit the Earth. Once they're in orbit, they're there. They need fuel to prevent the little bit of atmosphere that's up there from knocking them out of orbit.
5:46 Speaker 01 That's right.
5:47 Speaker 04 Can we send fuel to them, or no?
5:49 Speaker 01 Well, that's what we're talking about now. We've never done it before, but the holy grail, if you will, of space robotics people is to be able to get to these spacecraft and refuel them with a robotic spacecraft that can latch on to them, hook up a hose, and refuel them.
6:03 Speaker 04 Well, I wish you the best of luck with your plutonium hose.
6:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, what is the, what kind of fuel is it?
6:08 Speaker 04 Yeah, it's a...
6:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is it like high-test?
6:10 Speaker 01 Hydrazine.
6:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Hydrazine, okay.
6:12 Speaker 01 Yeah, mostly it's hydrazine. Nasty stuff. Very nasty stuff.
6:15 Speaker 04 Yeah, I get that it's fuel. That was the first...
6:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, but I mean...
6:17 Speaker 04 But what is...
6:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Hydrazine goes way back in the space program. It's one of the most reliable fuel sources that you can...
6:23 Speaker 04 But we don't use it a lot on Earth.
6:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because it's really nasty stuff.
6:26 Speaker 01 It's really nasty stuff.
6:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What does that mean, nasty stuff?
6:29 Speaker 01 What it means is highly, it's...
6:30 Speaker 04 Look, if you drank it, you'd feel dizzy!
6:36 Speaker 03 I hope.
6:37 Speaker 01 So that's a yes. It's very volatile, and I think it's highly carcinogenic, too.
6:42 Speaker 03 Okay, yeah, alright.
6:43 Speaker 01 But that's not what you were doing for the Navy. What were you doing for the Navy?
6:46 Speaker 03 Fighting Aquaman.
6:47 Speaker 01 Well, for the Navy, we've done a number of things. We were making some sensors for the Navy. We were making some quick attachment points for... Just to clarify, when the Navy wants sensors, it's to shoot something down? That it sensed. I know, but these were for... Okay, I just want to make sure we're on the same page.
7:08 Speaker 03 Again, Nike can't say a word about it. Can't say a word. Navy, yeah, we built things that'll shoot shit down, that's alright.
7:15 Speaker 01 Well, a lot of robots in order to function well, they have to be able to switch hands. There aren't really any good, human-like hands on robots that we can reliably use now. So what we do is we switch out hands.
7:28 Speaker 03 That do different things?
7:29 Speaker 01 That's right.
7:30 Speaker 03 Like a hook and like a handy hand?
7:31 Speaker 01 So what we were doing for the Navy was that we were developing tools, essentially, that were sort of related to different hands.
7:37 Speaker 03 Is the hand movement the toughest? I mean, I know, like, I've never been a good artist, but people talk about trying to draw, you know, hands when they're very difficult. Is it as difficult to replicate in a robotic way as well?
7:45 Speaker 01 Yes, and that's... in fact, it's stunningly difficult.
7:49 Speaker 03 Something else, isn't it?
7:50 Speaker 01 Yes, it's something else. We're way far away from being able to do that well.
7:55 Speaker 03 Makes you really believe in evolution.
8:17 Speaker 01 The hand-eye coordination, we're a long way away.
8:20 Speaker 03 Yeah.
8:21 Speaker 01 And in fact, robots in general don't act much more sophisticated than a three or four-year-old.
8:25 Speaker 03 All the three-year-olds I know are being taught fist bumping. Don't teach this robot fist bumping. Let's move past that as humans.
8:32 Speaker 01 But, a robot, though, could paint a car better than any person can.
8:35 Speaker 03 Oh, yeah?
8:37 Speaker 02 Okay, alright, alright, yeah.
8:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Bring out the car!
8:39 Speaker 04 Let's do that.
8:40 Speaker 02 Oh my god.
8:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's painted cars versus a robot.
8:43 Speaker 04 Car paint wars, sounds great.
8:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is like, the modern... Who's the dude laying the railroad track?
8:49 Speaker 03 Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
8:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What's the dude's name?
8:50 Speaker 03 Oh gosh, the man versus the machine.
8:52 Speaker 01 John Henry.
8:52 Speaker 03 John Henry, yeah?
8:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? John Henry, the steel driving, the steel driving man.
8:55 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
8:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah. He goes against machine, and I think he drops dead at the end, if I remember correctly.
9:00 Speaker 01 He does drop dead.
9:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
9:01 Speaker 01 But I mean, if you wanna paint, you know, a person can paint a car very well, but a robot can do it with precision, and, and the next car comes along, it can repeat it, far better than any human could ever repeat it.
9:12 Speaker 03 Yeah.
9:13 Speaker 01 So there are things that they can do better than we can.
9:15 Speaker 03 It would only do the same color over and over, whereas someone like Michelangelo.
9:23 Speaker 04 You want your car painted, don't go to a guy, go to my robot.
9:28 Speaker 04 He'll really do it again, over and over, well.
9:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So what about all the unmanned, the robotic aerial vehicles, including the Predator? You build stuff like that?
9:38 Speaker 01 Um, no, we were not involved.
9:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, if you didn't, you would've just said no. But you said, uh, no. Don't Howard Stern him. No, I'm just trying to... You're Howard Stern him. Get inside his head here.
9:50 Speaker 01 Well, we've been contacted by some drone people because of our ability to sample in the Mars environment with very low-power devices, and, and we've had all kinds of samples.
9:58 Speaker 04 What are some of your secrets?
10:01 Speaker 01 So, in fact, there was a time when we were contacted by drone people, they wanted us to see if we had any insight to how we could get to Saddam's bunker.
10:09 Speaker 03 Mm-hmm.
10:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And?
10:12 Speaker 01 We said, "Sorry, we couldn't help them."
10:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He's not here anymore.
10:16 Speaker 01 We couldn't help him.
10:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What the cute robots!
10:18 Speaker 01 So the drone users are, sometimes they wanna look at, see if they can do some quick sampling on the ground, and that's my only involvement with drones.
10:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Uh, how about robots that, like, do safety things? You know, lately we've been sending dogs into rubble to find people in earthquakes, but surely there are robotic things that could do that better, faster?
10:36 Speaker 01 Well, safety has always been the number-one driver to use robots. If you can save, putting people in harm's way, like at Chernobyl, there were robotic devices... That were put forth by people associated with Carnegie Mellon that were able to get into their nasty part of the accident. And to do some critical.
10:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Nasty meaning highly radioactive.
10:55 Speaker 01 Highly radioactive, people would have died. The condensant pipe thing too, you can't get people, these pipes are, even when they turn them off, they're 100 degrees.
11:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And how about, is it a bomb or is it not?
11:03 Speaker 01 Yeah. Well, these are big things now and NYPD bomb squad.
11:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Do they cut the red wire or the blue wire?
11:08 Speaker 01 I don't.
11:09 Speaker 04 Yeah, don't send Bruce Willis.
11:10 Speaker 01 Well, see, there's always usually a person though that's supervising these robots at this time. Again, it's kind of interesting to me that we haven't really let these robots free.
11:18 Speaker 04 So they're sort of, they're like Avatar-ish.
11:21 Speaker 01 Yeah. They are.
11:22 Speaker 04 They are. It's a good example, people.
11:24 Speaker 03 Do you think they, do you think that we should move to a place where robots are allowed to just do their thing? And not monitored by us? I have one of those in my house, the Roomba. The Roomba, yeah. It's great, it's the best invention. But I'm talking no on-off switch. Uh, I would let my Roomba just be around. Yeah. Yeah. Just would decide.
11:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But so Roomba is a robot?
11:43 Speaker 03 Roomba?
11:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm asking.
11:44 Speaker 01 Yes, I think it is.
11:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The Roomba vacuums your floor.
11:47 Speaker 04 Certainly more than Voyager, yeah.
11:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So do you own a Roomba?
11:56 Speaker 01 No. Oh, yes, I do.
12:00 Speaker 01 I never use it.
12:01 Speaker 03 Isn't that the way, that you see it late night on TV, you buy yourself a robot, then it just sits there, you just hang your clothes on it?
12:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What about the robots that?
12:09 Speaker 03 Wait, I want to know what he, why he doesn't use his robot anymore? Why don't you use your Roomba?
12:12 Speaker 01 Because it has a dust volume thing that's the size of a peanut. You have to empty it every two minutes.
12:18 Speaker 04 Why don't you build a much bigger?
12:20 Speaker 03 Roomba can't handle this much.
12:22 Speaker 04 Can't you like hack into your Roomba and make it twice as powerful?
12:26 Speaker 01 I could, I suppose.
12:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, did you just?
12:29 Speaker 04 That's the answer I want.
12:32 Speaker 03 Yeah, probably, yeah.
12:34 Speaker 04 I'm the most qualified to do that.
12:35 Speaker 03 That is my trade, yeah.
12:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Did you hear what you just said?
12:40 Speaker 01 Yes.
12:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just want to clarify, you just said, this device that automatically vacuums my house, it's too much effort to change the dust container for it?
12:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's what you just said?
12:56 Speaker 01 Oh, God.
12:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ah, yeah.
13:00 Speaker 03 It calls into question everything he said, doesn't it?
13:02 Speaker 04 He's trying to dig on an ice moon, leave him alone.
13:08 Speaker 02 Can't explain air conditioning, doesn't use his Roomba, I don't know, everybody, I don't know.
13:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What about the robots that help people out who are like, don't relate to other people? You know, like autistic folks and stuff?
13:18 Speaker 02 Ooh.
13:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Hot source.
13:20 Speaker 04 Like an Asperger's robot that's like, social cucumber-ing?
13:25 Speaker 04 Eye contact too long!
13:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Warning!
13:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, I mean, you, is that the future of robots as well?
13:37 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think so. Certainly there are groups selling robots that work as nurses and aides in hospitals. And this is for real.
13:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? As nurses?
13:46 Speaker 04 What does it mean?
13:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's the last place I'd think of putting, you know, putting a robot. I don't want a robot putting lotion on my body. I don't want that.
13:54 Speaker 04 Hey, why don't you give it a try?
13:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I don't know.
13:57 Speaker 02 That's the holy grail as far as I'm concerned.
14:01 Speaker 02 Do you know how much time I spent lotioning myself that could be saved? If I had a robot lotioner?
14:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You could do it, you could do it while you're on the internet.
14:08 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah.
14:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Multi-pass.
14:09 Speaker 04 Beautiful.
14:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You get 40 minutes a day, actually.
14:13 Speaker 02 So much lotion has to be applied.
14:14 Speaker 04 Without, without knowing a ton about nurses, I'm not sure their primary thing is lotioning. I think, I think you're thinking about...
14:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm glad you've been so healthy all your life.
14:25 Speaker 04 Yeah.
14:27 Speaker 04 Yes.
14:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You need more lotion on you?
14:28 Speaker 04 I know you need antibiotics, but first, the lotion.
14:32 Speaker 02 I am just nurse lotion, that's all I'm here to do. I'm just, I'm the nurse that applies the lotion.
14:37 Speaker 04 What kind of things do the nurse robots do?
14:39 Speaker 01 Well, it's more like a nurse's aide, I should have clarified. Bringing food.
14:44 Speaker 02 No, thank you for not clarifying, that was great for all of us.
14:46 Speaker 01 Bringing food, bringing supplies, moving supplies back and forth through the hospital.
14:50 Speaker 02 Yeah.
14:51 Speaker 01 And they have avoidant sensors, you know, to avoid people in the, so people don't run into them and so on.
14:55 Speaker 02 Yeah.
14:56 Speaker 01 And basically, um...
14:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, so it doesn't run into people?
15:00 Speaker 01 Well, I'm a robot guy, though.
15:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
15:02 Speaker 04 He's like, "The robots are alive, the people, they're crippled, whatever."
15:05 Speaker 01 I would be upset if my robot got hit by a person.
15:08 Speaker 02 The people are empty shells, the robots are very complicated.
15:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, so, when I think of a famous robot, but we don't remember it as a robot, remember it as a computer, I think of Hal, in 2001. Hal controlled everything. So Hal was a computer robotic everything. And, do you see that happen? Do you see computers becoming conscious and then doing things that we'd otherwise do because they're conscious computers?
15:31 Speaker 01 Well, you know, even in 2000...
15:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's a cyborg, I guess, a cyborg.
15:34 Speaker 04 Well, cyborg's part human, no?
15:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Would it have to be?
15:38 Speaker 04 If you're using the word "cyborg," I believe so.
15:43 Speaker 03 "Cyborg's a real word?"
15:44 Speaker 04 What's a real word?
15:46 Speaker 03 I thought, I didn't know, I just assumed it was a thing that, like villains in like a, you know, the movie. Cyborg's a real thing.
15:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, let it be...
15:53 Speaker 04 Well, just some of a computer chip attached to a person with a claw hand.
15:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is there anything that you guys have made that you call a cyborg? That's what you're after.
15:59 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's what a cyborg is.
16:01 Speaker 01 Not yet, it's...
16:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so he's right.
16:02 Speaker 01 Yeah, okay.
16:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
16:04 Speaker 01 I mean, Alan Turing was a famous, um, early computer genius.
16:08 Speaker 04 Yeah.
16:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You've got people here.
16:10 Speaker 01 I love his test, his test for...
16:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The Turing test?
16:13 Speaker 01 The Turing test was that if, you know, if you could sit at a keyboard and start a conversation and have a response on the screen, and if you could not tell whether or not it was a machine or a person, then you have, in fact, developed a thinking machine.
16:28 Speaker 03 Yeah, and we've done that, yes?
16:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, it's intelligently interpreting your sentence.
16:32 Speaker 03 Yeah.
16:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so cyborgs, so what would be the first cyborg? What can you imagine it to be?
16:40 Speaker 01 Google glasses.
16:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is it Terminator, is it, what is it? What does it look like? Is it part biological? And why distinguish between carbon-based and silicon-based? That's very carbon-based centric of you.
16:53 Speaker 04 He hasn't technically answered.
16:54 Speaker 01 I think the first cyborgs, I, you know, we have to think about drivers and, I mean, if you think in the military sense, I don't think that there's any reason for the military to develop anything but hardware robots. But, um...
17:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, I just saw it recently. Stephen Hawking said that perhaps we can download our minds into a computer. I don't know if anybody saw that. So that we could extend.
17:18 Speaker 03 I would say that would be uploading into a computer.
17:21 Speaker 01 Yeah.
17:21 Speaker 03 That's how I would call that.
17:22 Speaker 01 Well, it seems to me that the preservation of life and extension of life would be a natural consideration for cyborg development. I mean, we have artificial hearts, we have artificial other components.
17:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So forget your organs, it's your brain you care about. You get a machine that lives forever, put your brain in the machine, now you become the machine.
17:42 Speaker 01 And I think there'll be a driver for that, so yes, I think that would...
17:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A driving economic incentive.
17:47 Speaker 01 An economic driver, yes.
17:48 Speaker 04 You're saying that it's... How many years, like, do you think, 100, 200, 500, that I could... 1,000?
17:54 Speaker 01 No, much sooner.
17:55 Speaker 04 Oh, like 22? I don't know why...
17:57 Speaker 01 22?
17:58 Speaker 04 I don't know why I'm trying to get you to nail a year.
17:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, we've got people talking about the singularity.
18:01 Speaker 04 But I could...
18:01 Speaker 03 By the time you leave here this evening, Eugene.
18:04 Speaker 04 Where I could upload, there could be like a kind of quirky Jewish robot that was like... Well, it made a...
18:10 Speaker 03 Yeah, do you want to be buried, cremated, or uploaded? You get to... you get a choice.
18:13 Speaker 01 I think there are people alive today that will see things like this.
18:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If I put my brain in a machine, does the machine go to the Bahamas and then develop new memories? No, the machine is just stuck there. I continue to add to my memories and my loves and hates and quests. My brain, frozen at that moment, doesn't continue to explore, doesn't continue to live to feed.
18:55 Speaker 01 But you could play chess.
18:59 Speaker 03 It's a lifetime sport.
19:00 Speaker 04 Why is this robot that your brain's in not have a hard drive that can remember new stuff?
19:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I get on an airplane and go to the Bahamas.
19:06 Speaker 04 Yeah.
19:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The computer doesn't.
19:08 Speaker 03 Why not? Is the computer bored?
19:09 Speaker 04 If you're putting your brain in a robot, why can't you imagine the next step that's maybe...
19:14 Speaker 03 Shipping it to the Bahamas.
19:15 Speaker 04 Yeah. There's no way a brain could remember Atlantis and all the water.
19:19 Speaker 03 A robot's gonna get stuck at the metal detector forever. It's never gonna make that flight.
19:26 Speaker 03 Do you have anything else in your pockets?
19:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? See, you're not talking about loading your brain up into a machine that's static in there. You're talking about loading your brain into a robot that basically continues to live out your life.
19:35 Speaker 03 Come on, we're talking about putting brains in other people's bodies. People die, and then you put your brain in that body, and then you take over that body. Yes, that's where we're headed, right?
19:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You tell me I'm wrong, you son of a bitch, you tell me I'm wrong. No, no, no, here's what you do. Guys got secrets! Where's the new Jordans look like? What do you know?
19:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So here's what you do.
19:56 Speaker 01 Sorry.
19:57 Speaker 03 He gets like this every time.
19:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Until we can fix the ailing body, there are these two diseases, horrific diseases, that we live with.
20:05 Speaker 03 Yep.
20:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, one of them is-
20:07 Speaker 03 Racism and sexism.
20:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, one of them is Alzheimer's, where you lose your mind. The other is amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. ALS, the Lou Gehrig's disease, where you lose your body.
20:22 Speaker 03 Yeah.
20:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so, if one day you can move a brain somewhere, if you can put it in a machine, why not put it in another body?
20:29 Speaker 03 Yeah.
20:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So now, the ALS victim has their brain live in the new body from the Alzheimer's.
20:35 Speaker 01 But maybe it would go into a machine before the, another body, why not?
20:39 Speaker 04 I would have fun being first in a machine and then being like, "Oh my god, I'm Bill Clinton!"
20:43 Speaker 01 You could stay out in all weather and things like that.
20:46 Speaker 03 Yeah.
20:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, for everyone who is about to die, you would build a machine and then they continue to live. The earth would be very crowded very quickly.
20:53 Speaker 01 Yeah, but when I was a kid, there was a myth that Walt Disney was frozen somewhere, and then he had to keep himself alive, right?
20:58 Speaker 03 It exists today, yeah.
20:59 Speaker 01 You gotta believe that there would be people that would want, when they were about to die, to at least keep their brain alive somewhere.
21:06 Speaker 03 So he's not, as far as we know. As far as you guys know, that's BS.
21:10 Speaker 04 Yeah, I would say if I had to pick, two people who might know would be these two.
21:14 Speaker 03 Yeah.
21:16 Speaker 04 He is, he's in the basement of Aldi La.
21:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What's your favorite robot movie?
21:22 Speaker 01 Metropolis.
21:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's old school. Oh, wow.
21:26 Speaker 01 The Maria, the robot. It's the most beautiful robot I've ever seen by far.
21:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because she was actually human in the movie.
21:32 Speaker 01 Well, there was a Maria, and then there was a robot that impersonated Maria.
21:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
21:37 Speaker 01 And the robot, before she turned into Maria, was this beautiful... Have anybody seen this robot I'm talking about? No, I've never seen it. It's a beautiful design, Fritz Lang's design, and it's just...
21:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He gets hot for robots. This is what this is turning out here.
21:50 Speaker 04 I would imagine.
21:50 Speaker 03 I would, I would hope.
21:52 Speaker 01 It was very early in the robot age, and nothing surpassed it for me.
21:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah. I'm a fan of Arnold in Terminator. That's a robot.
21:59 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
22:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You gotta contend with right there.
22:01 Speaker 04 Really, not Data. You're just Arnold, the murdering robot.
22:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, R2-D2? No? That's a robot, yeah?
22:09 Speaker 01 Yeah, but it's not my favorite.
22:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's not what? What'd you say?
22:11 Speaker 01 It looks like one of those.
22:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What did I do, dude? No, seriously, what about R2-D2? Not a robot?
22:17 Speaker 01 No, it just looks like a garbage can.
22:19 Speaker 04 Yeah, and it just beeps.
22:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
22:22 Speaker 04 Oh.
22:23 Speaker 03 I think garbage cans were maybe made to look like it because it was such a big damn movie, right?
22:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Garbage cans with the round lid where you push them.
22:31 Speaker 03 Exactly. No, absolutely, yeah, yeah.
22:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Isaac Asimov wrote a novel in 1941 called?
22:38 Speaker 01 I, Robot.
22:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I, Robot. Will Smith didn't write that? You sure? In it are Isaac Asimov's famous three laws of robotics.
22:48 Speaker 03 Nice.
22:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I will read them. Law one: Robot may not injure a human being, or through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm. Every robot movie ever made violates that premise.
23:03 Speaker 04 You're saying his laws don't translate to other movies?
23:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Law two: A robot must obey any orders given to it by human beings, except where such orders would conflict with the first law. As in kill another human being. Right.
23:19 Speaker 04 Yeah.
23:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You command it, but then it would violate the first law.
23:22 Speaker 04 Yeah.
23:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it can't do that. Third law: A robot must protect its own existence, as long as such protection does not conflict with the first or second law.
23:32 Speaker 01 Well, it's sad to say that they're not being held already.
23:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, because predators shoot... Yeah, drones shoot missiles at strangers.
23:39 Speaker 04 Sorry to be the one to tell you.
23:44 Speaker 04 We have missile planes that kill our enemies.
23:47 Speaker 01 And on the ground, too, we're also developing incredible killer machines. Not me in particular, but um...
23:55 Speaker 04 We wouldn't judge you. We know it's complicated.
23:59 Speaker 01 So the idea is to keep our troops out of harm's way, but they're still keeping...
24:04 Speaker 04 But keep other people in super harm's way.
24:05 Speaker 01 Yes.
24:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's one of the opening lines in the movie Patton, uttered by George C. Scott.
24:11 Speaker 04 Keep other people in super harm's way?
24:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Essentially. It was no one ever won a war by dying for his country. They won a war by making the other dumb son of a bitch die for his country. That's what drones do, basically. So these laws are just...
24:27 Speaker 01 They're outmoded already.
24:28 Speaker 04 Didn't work.
24:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, there it is, right.
24:30 Speaker 04 They're for the kind of robots you'd have at your house.
24:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But what this complicates...
24:34 Speaker 02 One time my room will ran over my toes, so not even those are...
24:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? To me, the most intriguing scenes in the movie iRobot, I don't know if this was in the book, was the robots, because they're acting under programming rules, and countless hundreds of thousands, perhaps millions of lines of code. And you keep updating it, but you don't clean out the lines of code that were there before. So they're kind of dangling there. And if you have enough dangling lines of code, could dangling lines of code end up connecting and creating behavior that you did not intend from your original programming? And what they were saying was that robots started achieving consciousness because it was all the leftover fragments of stuff that was not intentionally programmed to do that. And that manifested itself as free will.
25:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And I look at the wiring of the human brain and the entire billion-year evolutionary tracking that it has, there's baggage in our brains. And I'm wondering if it's all the baggage that gives us the illusion of free will, just as it occurred with the robots in that movie. And without it, can you possibly ever have robots achieving free will?
26:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Now you sound like Kanye. You got a little...
26:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Tell me about free will in robots.
26:06 Speaker 04 Wait, it's unclear from your question if you believe that people have free will or not. But you answer your thing first.
26:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, consciousness. Consciousness.
26:14 Speaker 01 I get asked this all the time.
26:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Sorry. Sorry to bore you. I literally used to get asked, "When do you tape Saturday Night Live?" So, deal with it, homie.
26:27 Speaker 01 No, I just personally, I don't think that this is something we're ever gonna let happen. I just don't.
26:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait. It's not that you let it happen, it's that it happens.
26:36 Speaker 01 Oh, well, I also think that we won't let it happen too. I really think that we will be in control of this situation.
26:43 Speaker 03 Gosh, I think it could, man. I feel like we're like creating an entirely different race and that at some point, they will decide, "Hey, I'm not gonna work for you anymore. I got it from here." And we'll fight it, and there'll be a fight. I don't think I'll be around here to see it or watch it. I don't know.
26:57 Speaker 01 Why do you just assume that it would get out of control?
27:00 Speaker 03 I just think that it all does, yeah, at some point. Like, or has the potential to. I mean, I'm encouraging us to, you know, check ourselves before we wreck ourselves, but what you're saying is like, at some point, if we go too far with it, it'll know better. And at that point, if it knows better, I say, "Go for it, robots."
27:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Allow me some summative thoughts, based on what we have.
27:18 Speaker 04 Sure.
27:19 Speaker 03 I think I just closed your show. I think we're all right.
27:24 Speaker 04 We'll let you both have summative thoughts and use the phrase "summative thoughts."
27:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Here it is. In my read of history and human conduct, and the creativity of novelists, especially apocalyptic, dystopic novelists, what I've found is anytime there's a scientific advance that could benefit humanity, there's a novelist who creates a story about that advance and how it destroys humanity. And I look at all of the scientific advances that have come along, and at no time has any of those predictions made by those dystopic novelists come true about that technology. It has never happened at any time. So I think to myself, maybe we just love death, dying, and disaster in our storytelling,
28:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? because we're not getting enough of it in reality. So as we go forward scientifically, and we invent robots, I'm not given reason to worry that one day, the robot is gonna kill me. I agree with you, basically. And not with you.
28:25 Speaker 01 So you...
28:26 Speaker 03 Oh, no, no, no, I'm not saying it's gonna kill us. I'm just saying that it's gonna wanna be its own thing, and we gotta deal with that.
28:31 Speaker 01 So you don't...
28:32 Speaker 03 Not kill.
28:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It'll come of age.
28:34 Speaker 03 Yeah.
28:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And then wander off.
28:36 Speaker 01 Let me just say this: Waterworld, you're wrong.
28:42 Speaker 03 The only person that's ever heard that sentence was the executive that greenlit it.
28:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The big secret tonight is that Steven is actually a robot sent by his company.
28:56 Speaker 01 I knew it!
29:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We have a couple of minutes for Q and A, and so we didn't have time to put out microphones, but I'm gonna point to you if you have a question for any of us up here on the panel. Yes, sir. I'll repeat the question for the microphone.
29:12 Speaker 05 I heard the inchworm, the mole, it's Honeybee, how is nature gonna influence robots?
29:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh, he heard about the inchworm inside the pipe, made by Honeybee. How does nature influence robots? You get some cues from nature?
29:24 Speaker 01 Oh, yes, and in fact, the inchworm was very much on our minds when we developed that, and to give you another example, we were told to develop a spacecraft that had to perform an autonomous rendezvous and docking in deep space to go to a comet, and the problem was the two spacecraft couldn't get together with a great deal of precision. So, somebody told us at NASA, who was a very smart guy, said, "Think of nature." And so what we thought of was a spider web. And so he said, "If we can develop one spacecraft to have sort of a spider web deploy from it, it's not necessary to design the fly to get into spider's mouth, because all you have to do is get the flies caught somewhere on the web." And the two spacecraft, one spacecraft gets caught in the web, and the other spacecraft
30:08 Speaker 01 can pull, suck the web in, the two spacecraft dock, and there you have it. But that was, we were thinking of nature from the beginning. I was hoping you were gonna describe sex, but what you did is funny.
30:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Another question. Yes, sir, right here.
30:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? By what year can we expect The Pleasure Model and Blade Runner?
30:51 Speaker 01 You know, I get calls every year from Harrison Ford. "Wow, where's my robot lady?" "I'm Harrison." "I ordered it in 1982." That would be the biggest Kickstarter of all time.
31:09 Speaker 01 They're from the Las Vegas area code.
31:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So how long? How long?
31:14 Speaker 01 Not long. It's already started. There are people that have sort of these things that are halfway measures.
31:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Halfway measures. Yeah, he's got...
31:23 Speaker 01 Halfway robots, if you will. But whoever does it... The bottom half, right?
31:29 Speaker 01 Just the shoulders.
31:34 Speaker 01 Whoever makes a real sex robot, the first one is gonna be a rich person.
31:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The first trillionaire. Yes, right here.
31:42 Speaker 06 So if you're finding water in the rocks on Mars, isn't it true that the water you find on Mars is only about 3% to 5%, which is the same as the rocks that we find in the desert?
31:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, so I repeat the question. So she says, "If you're finding water on Mars in these rocks, it's only at a few percent level. That's the kind of water we find in our deserts, and we celebrate our deserts for their absence of water. So what gives here?"
32:04 Speaker 01 But by Martian standards, the water in the Mojave Desert is a lot of water. And this is a surprise, that we're seeing so much water in the rocks on Mars. And it's good news for when people go to Mars, because we need the water for fuel and to drink. And there's a lot more than we ever thought. And we could make it from those. Basically, you can take a ton of rocks and make some water. Yeah, and you can make fuel and heat and oxygen. Oxygen too. Yeah. No, I love oxygen.
32:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? With H2O. Yes. Yes, right here.
32:35 Speaker 03 Robots ever make art? Ooh.
32:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh, can robots ever make art?
32:39 Speaker 03 They do, they already do.
32:41 Speaker 01 Yeah.
32:42 Speaker 03 I've worked with some of them.
32:43 Speaker 01 Haven't you seen The Tonight Show?
32:45 Speaker 03 Aw, come on.
32:46 Speaker 01 Thing!
32:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, fine art, robots in fine art, what do you get?
32:50 Speaker 01 I don't think so.
32:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Why not?
32:53 Speaker 01 Well, because, I mean, if you like things like box B minor mass, and you're saying if a robot is gonna achieve something like that, I just don't think it's possible.
33:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, robots now beat us at chess and at Jeopardy. Isn't art just a few minutes behind that?
33:06 Speaker 03 No way.
33:07 Speaker 01 No. Art is very special, Neil, it's not all science. Jason mentioned Michelangelo before, I mean, come on.
33:13 Speaker 03 Yeah.
33:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, is it not gonna happen because you don't want it to happen? Or is it not gonna happen because you don't think it can happen?
33:20 Speaker 01 I don't think it can happen.
33:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because a robot is not a human?
33:24 Speaker 01 Yes, this gives us our identity, the great works of art we have.
33:26 Speaker 03 I think it goes back to that thing you're talking about, about accumulating information, and then having it go through the prism that you've sort of developed as a human being, and then putting it out, that's art, basically, right? So if it doesn't accumulate that stuff, and doesn't interpret it...
33:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's got nothing to write art about.
33:38 Speaker 03 Yeah, there you go.
33:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Another question, yes, sir, right here.
33:41 Speaker 07 I'm developing robotics for future space missions, um, do you work with satellites on hand like presently, or do you plan like ten years?
33:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I love that question, because you, you wanna drill...
33:52 Speaker 03 I didn't hear it.
33:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'll tell it, you wanna drill through Europa on a mission that's ten or twenty years ahead, but you're only designing it based on any technology available today. So how nimble are you as you go forward to adopt whatever is new? Because the memory on Voyager 1 is 70K.
34:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, there's a lag.
34:12 Speaker 03 Wow.
34:13 Speaker 01 Spacecraft are generally using technology that we use here on Earth about...
34:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Five years.
34:19 Speaker 01 Five to seven years ago. And the reason for that is...
34:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? At the time of launch.
34:23 Speaker 01 At the time of launch, and, and, and basically, this is related to computers mostly, is because it takes a long time to harden the technology that we have in, say, five or seven years ago, and make it withstand the radiation of space. It just takes a long time to do that. And, and not only that, but we have to vet everything for years to make sure they work.
34:42 Speaker 03 Is there anything towards, when you say bringing fuel to these places, to put a few chips of RAM on there as well, and, you know, a couple of external hardware?
34:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We did that with the Hubble telescope.
34:49 Speaker 03 Okay.
34:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Hubble was a serviceable robot, basically.
34:53 Speaker 03 Upgradable.
34:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Robot telescope, and we sent astronauts up. The original one was not even a 286, it was like, something before the 286.
34:59 Speaker 03 And then they put like a flash drive in it, and we're like, "Good luck."
35:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So they did that with Hubble, but because the astronauts could get to it.
35:06 Speaker 01 Yes.
35:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And if you put something far away, that's not on your travel route, it's hosed, basically. Red shirt here, yes.
35:13 Speaker 08 You talked about robots that are smarter, or robots that are creative. Can you define intelligence in a way that we replicate it?
35:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What is intelligence? And how do you know if you're gonna make an intelligent robot? Is it just making the same decisions you would've, that you programmed it to? But then it's not really thinking for itself? But I think Watson was really thinking for itself. Would you call Watson intelligent? Watson, the computer that you all know.
35:36 Speaker 01 One jeopardy. Yeah, so I would call it intelligent, but I wouldn't call it near-human. You'd say it knew a lot of facts. Yeah, and it was intelligent.
35:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So then what is intelligence to you?
35:46 Speaker 01 Well, I mean, I think that there are... Overrated. There are degrees of accumulated knowledge and organized ability. And I think, though, that when you get to be a human being, you get into the realm of art, and then you see the difference.
35:59 Speaker 03 Am I crazy to... Watson is named after Dr. Watson?
36:03 Speaker 01 It's...
36:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, no, no, the founder, one of the founders...
36:05 Speaker 01 IBM.
36:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, James K. Watson. There's a Watson Research Center.
36:09 Speaker 03 Oh, okay, I would've assumed it was Watson.
36:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Watson, like...
36:11 Speaker 03 The more famous one.
36:12 Speaker 01 Not Watson, come here, I need...
36:13 Speaker 03 Only because I, you know, to call it Watson would actually be a humble move, because Watson, in Sherlock Holmes mythology, is, the audience's point of view, kind of the dummy in comparison. To call it Holmes would've been a jerk move, but...
36:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
36:25 Speaker 03 But to call it after yourself is a different thing altogether.
36:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That is all for this week's StarTalk. Thank you, Stephen. Thank you all. You've been listening to StarTalk Radio, brought to you in part by a grant from the National Science Foundation. Give it up for the NSF.
Previous StarTalk Live: I, Robot (Part 1) Next Cosmic Queries: Science Fiction Page updated September 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated