Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast StarTalk at BAM – Science is Everywhere (Part 1) About this episode Science really is everywhere. From the Big Bang to quantum mechanics to free will, we explore it all featuring Neil deGrasse Tyson, comic co-host Chuck Nice, physicist Brian Greene, neuroscientist Heather Berlin, and rapper Baba Brinkman. Recorded live at the Brooklyn Academy of Music.
NOTE: StarTalk All-Access subscribers can watch or listen to this entire episode commercial-free here: https://www.startalkradio.net/all-access/startalk-at-bam-science-is-everywhere-part-1/
Photo Credit: Elliot Severn.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk. Your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Brooklyn in the house.
0:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome. Everybody hear me? Welcome. Did you hear that? There you go. Brooklyn in the house.
0:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thanks for coming out and giving us your Friday night. This is a special presentation of StarTalk, StarTalk at BAM. And in this presentation, you're gonna get three versions of what our StarTalk franchise is all about. The first one lasting 30 minutes is StarTalk.
1:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? StarTalk flagship, alright, where I am the host and we have special guests talking about special topics. We then go to another 30 minutes featuring StarTalk All-Stars. And that's where we have a cadre of counterparts to me who are experts in other fields of science. And they each have their own sort of radio show with a comedian, similar format, but they get to do it their way. StarTalk All-Stars, you'll get a sampling of that for 30 minutes. And then we will end with one of our favorite new franchises of StarTalk, StarTalk Playing with Science, which is all about the science of sports. And tonight, we're gonna talk about the physics of figure skating.
1:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And we'll get back to that in a minute. But right now, we will begin StarTalk at BAM. I'll bring out my comedic co-host, the one, the only Chuck Nice. Come on out.
2:07 Brian Greene? What's up, buddy?
2:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, man.
2:08 Brian Greene? How are you, man?
2:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is my man.
2:10 Brian Greene? Hi, Steven. It's good to see you.
2:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Very cool. And so, tonight, we're gonna talk about the physics of the early universe. And I realized, this whole event was introduced as a radio love fest. But he didn't say it right. You gotta say, "a radio love fest." You gotta do that right.
2:34 Brian Greene? Yeah, exactly. I think you just made the universe pregnant.
2:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Love fest. Let me introduce a colleague and a friend, one of the smartest people on Earth, theoretical physicist, Brian Greene, everybody.
3:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Brian Greene, best known for sort of popularizing concepts like string theory and the multiverse.
3:12 Brian Greene? You just made string theory pregnant, man.
3:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Your bestselling author, The Elegant Universe, a beautiful book. That person read your book. Right there. That person read your book.
3:28 Brian Greene? I know, the rest of you are just posers.
3:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, that was followed with Fabric of the Cosmos.
3:35 Brian Greene? Yep.
3:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A beautiful book. Hidden Reality was a third book. And then you are a co-founder of the World Science Festival.
3:42 Brian Greene? That's right.
3:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A co-founder... It's a bit audacious to call it the World Science Festival?
3:47 Brian Greene? Well, we're gonna call it the universe, but, you know, pulled it back to world.
3:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, it's just great. It's the World Science Festival held in New York. That's just, I'm just saying, it's a...
3:56 Brian Greene? Also in Australia, so it is world in that way.
3:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay. All right. And co-founded with your wife.
4:02 Brian Greene? That's great.
4:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Very good. Smart man.
4:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How to keep that marriage going.
4:09 Chuck Nice? Yeah, there you go.
4:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Brian, what, there was recent news of the earliest star ever formed in the universe. So were you on top of that story?
4:23 Brian Greene? Been following it, yeah.
4:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, because what we know from, as astrophysicists, is you get the Big Bang, got that, okay? Then you have the cosmic microwave background, got that. But nothing's formed yet. You gotta make stuff that you can recognize in modern times, and there's this long period, hundreds of millions of years, where nothing is happening. And so we call that the cosmic dark ages. Did I say it right? Dark ages. And, let me hear dark.
4:51 Brian Greene? Dark ages.
4:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, there you go. You give them a B+?
4:54 Brian Greene? I'm gonna give them a B+. I'll work on it, I'll work on it.
4:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so the dark ages, before the first stars had formed. So there was the hunt, the eternal hunt, can we find that first star? And a recent news announcement said what?
5:09 Brian Greene? Well, there's now evidence that those first stars may have formed about 180 million years after the Big Bang, and it's hard to find them because they're not actually sitting out there waiting for us to see them directly. You have to find an indirect test to see their presence by virtue of their impact on their environment. And in a very clever experiment, that's what was done.
5:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And how'd they do that experiment?
5:33 Brian Greene? Well, you mentioned the cosmic microwave background radiation, right? I think, I mean, just, people know what that is, it's just here, yeah.
5:41 Chuck Nice? No, I mean, even if, listen, because, you know, there are some people, like, at home, listening, that may not know. So, you know, I'm just saying, you know, for their sake, maybe you should tell them.
5:55 Brian Greene? So this is, this is heat left over from the Big Bang. The Big Bang's very hot, as the universe expands, it cools down, but the heat doesn't disappear, it's still there. And indeed, we can see that heat coming to us through powerful satellite-born telescopes today. Now, that is a fantastic discovery in its own right, that won the Nobel Prize, the discovery of the microwave background radiation, but now imagine this.
6:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's won the Nobel Prize twice.
6:23 Brian Greene? That's true, yes, absolutely, yeah. The initial discovery and then a more refined version.
6:27 Chuck Nice? I gotta tell you, that's very good.
6:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, the same.
6:31 Chuck Nice? The same thing, just like. Five years later, oh my god, that was so, we should give it to him again.
6:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Give it to him again, right. So, no, it was a badass thing we found in the universe.
6:44 Brian Greene? Yeah.
6:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
6:45 Brian Greene? And it was found by mistake, right? Oh, so you do know about this, man, you said mistake before I did.
6:50 Chuck Nice? Oh, I didn't mean to.
6:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, yeah, so, so, how, so how did the, the cousin of my background tell us this?
6:59 Brian Greene? Well, the, the theory was that when these initial stars formed, they would be very large, much larger than the sun, and very hot, and they would have emitted a lot of ultraviolet radiation. And that radiation would have had an impact on the environment. A lot of hydrogen around, it would have ionized the hydrogen. Why does that matter? When you cause the hydrogen to change in that way, it has an impact on the microwave background radiation that otherwise would have passed through it.
7:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Passed through it with no incident.
7:29 Brian Greene? With no incident.
7:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And now it's got, it's, it's been perturbed.
7:32 Brian Greene? That's right, now, actually, some of it gets absorbed, which means when we look out, there should be missing parts of the spectrum.
7:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
7:39 Brian Greene? That are being absorbed by this hydrogen, which itself is being affected by these early stars.
7:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, we're not seeing the stars themselves, we're seeing us some kind of smoking gun of the stars?
7:49 Brian Greene? Yeah, we're seeing a shadow in some sense of the stars.
7:51 Chuck Nice? Oh, my god, it's just like the Russia investigation.
8:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Chuck, I didn't tell you the reason why we, we have such Big Bang expertise?
8:07 Brian Greene? Mm-hmm.
8:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is because we have both independently appeared on the Big Bang Theory.
8:13 Brian Greene? That's true, actually.
8:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Actually, I was only on once, were you on once or?
8:16 Brian Greene? Only on once, yeah.
8:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, they didn't invite you back?
8:17 Brian Greene? No, they didn't.
8:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, they didn't invite me back?
8:19 Brian Greene? Not by you either.
8:21 Chuck Nice? Welcome to my world.
8:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But I, I, I thought you did really well.
8:26 Brian Greene? I thought you did really well.
8:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, I, I, I'm so not an actor, and I, I depend on people allowing a little latitude for that cameo, non-actor, delivered lines.
8:37 Brian Greene? Yeah.
8:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You know, you say, okay, they're not really an actor, but we'll, we'll, we'll let it slide. You were good.
8:42 Brian Greene? Well, thank you, I appreciate that.
8:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And plus, Sheldon gave both of us a hard time.
8:46 Brian Greene? He did.
8:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right.
8:47 Brian Greene? He told me that I should give up physics and consider reading to the elderly, but he said, don't read your own books to the elderly.
9:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, he was pissed off that I was an accessory to the demotion of Pluto.
9:06 Brian Greene? Oh Pluto, yeah.
9:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, he said Pluto was one of his favorites.
9:08 Brian Greene? And you told him to get over it.
9:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, to get over it, yeah, yeah, yeah, but that it's, but he scripted to just get angry, so he just got angry.
9:17 Brian Greene? Yeah.
9:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, I couldn't rely on a natural response.
9:20 Brian Greene? That's because he's not real.
9:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Brian, so this early star, does it tell us something backwards towards the Big Bang that we should know about?
9:35 Brian Greene? Well...
9:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because you're a Big Bang guy.
9:36 Brian Greene? Yeah, it does, I mean, the curious thing is that the signal is stronger than the theory predicted, so the signal's there in the sense that you've got this missing part of the spectrum.
9:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you have people saying, "What would a first star look like? Let's map it out." Now you compare it, and now we got something stronger than that.
9:54 Brian Greene? That's right.
9:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that means you gotta go back and recalculate what?
9:56 Brian Greene? You've gotta tweak the theory, and people are suggesting that dark matter may play
10:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You see how we did that? Key role. You gotta tweak.
10:04 Brian Greene? Tweak.
10:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
10:05 Brian Greene? Right.
10:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So I don't know what he's cooking up, what he, he just tweaking stuff.
10:09 Brian Greene? But the tweak also kind of spilled over into the dark matter, so I'm not sure what this means.
10:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
10:16 Brian Greene? I don't know what either of you are talking about, that's fine.
10:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so what of the Big Bang do you have to tweak in order to allow our hypothesis to match the objects?
10:28 Brian Greene? Well, it may be that the dark matter interacts with ordinary matter in a way that differs from the conventional description. This is very speculative, we're right at the beginning of this kind of experiment.
10:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? At what point do you say, "I need to tweak my theories," and at what point do you say, "I need to throw out my theories"?
10:47 Brian Greene? Well, that's the art, that's the art of science, you know, and, you know, some people criticize scientists for sticking to theories long after the data seems to suggest that they really need to move on. People say that even about string theory, they're wrong, but...
11:04 Brian Greene? Yeah, so it's an art, and it's a personal choice.
11:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I've to his face, just to be clear. Because I'll say this again publicly. But I did really say this to his face.
11:14 Brian Greene? Oh snap.
11:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? When I asked Brian, I said, "Brian, I remember y'all from like from the, I'm that old, from the 1980s. Spring theory was being born." And I said, "Wow, this is great. A new understanding of the universe. General relativity married with quantum physics. A marriage that Einstein died trying to find. How soon will you have this?" He said, "We're about five years out." About five years. And then 10 years later. Uh, how, how far, what we down, another five years? And then 10 years after that. Just another five years.
11:46 Brian Greene? I'm consistent, hey.
11:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, wait, wait. So then it's like the year 2018. Brian, how about?
11:53 Brian Greene? About five years, I'd say something like that.
11:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How close are you to this? And it's like, so then I said, I said, "So, so Brian, why?" He said, "What's a hard problem?" So then I said, "Or, every one of you working on this problem is an idiot."
12:11 Brian Greene? He did.
12:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I said that to his face. "Brian."
12:14 Brian Greene? I'm gonna go with hard.
12:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? At what point do you, no, I said that, you know, jokingly. At what point do you say, "We're simply not smart enough to even answer the question we ourselves posed?"
12:30 Brian Greene? Yeah.
12:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Or do you just say, "It's hard." Because Einstein figured out general relativity, basically by his lonesome, in 10 years after he had special relativity.
12:40 Brian Greene? Yeah.
12:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you got, how many dozens of you guys? And...
12:43 Brian Greene? Yeah.
12:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? For 35 years.
12:46 Brian Greene? Yep, yep. Well, look, I gotta tell you, the reason I accepted to be on the show tonight is...
12:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, what?
12:54 Brian Greene? I'm finally willing. No, here's, here's the situation. If we were not making progress, then I wouldn't need you to tell me to give it up, right? I don't believe in reincarnation. I think you live once, and I don't want to spend my life working on a theory if I really don't think it has the promise to reach the goal that we have set for ourselves.
13:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you're honest with yourself?
13:15 Brian Greene? I'm totally honest, and but you need to...
13:16 Chuck Nice? We have so much in common, because I don't believe in it, because I don't want to be a turtle.
13:25 Brian Greene? Okay.
13:29 Chuck Nice? No, you said I don't believe in reincarnation. For some reason, I think I'm coming back as a turtle.
13:32 Brian Greene? I hear what you're saying, yeah, I got it.
13:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh!
13:34 Brian Greene? Yeah.
13:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, we both missed that.
13:35 Brian Greene? Went like this.
13:35 Chuck Nice? Yeah, yeah.
13:36 Brian Greene? You know.
13:36 Chuck Nice? Yeah, and you're the astrophysicist.
13:42 Chuck Nice? Because they got it.
13:43 Brian Greene? But here's the thing, before...
13:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They did not get that.
13:46 Chuck Nice? Oh, they got... Did you not get that?
13:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I was thinking...
13:51 Chuck Nice? Stupid people, you knifed!
13:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, I was thinking, the turtle was a reference to sort of the Hindu on the back of an elephant, and the elephant's standing on turtles, and his turtle's all the way down.
14:03 Chuck Nice? See, that's why you got doctor in front of your name. And I tell dick jokes.
14:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So... Well, back up, so...
14:20 Brian Greene? Where were we?
14:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I know exactly where we were.
14:22 Chuck Nice? I'm sorry, go ahead.
14:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I know exactly where we were. So, what I'm asking you, as a theoretical physicist, leading theoretical physicist, we have an observation, an astronomical observation, and it forces you to go back and re-tweak. Are you tweaking Big Bang? You tweaking quantum physics? You're tweaking... What are you tweaking?
14:41 Brian Greene? Well, in this particular case, you really are tweaking something that we yet don't understand fully, which is dark matter. So that's ripe for being tweaked. But look, there are other things...
14:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Dark matter is like mysterious gravity of the universe, and we have no idea what's causing it.
14:54 Brian Greene? But I'll give you another example, which has happened recently, right? There've been measurements of the rate of the expansion of space. And those measurements, very recently, are seeming to be incompatible with earlier measurements done in a different way.
15:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This had a whole other recent result.
15:10 Brian Greene? A whole other recent result, exactly. And this one, if it's correct, this is one that could really change our understanding of the early universe dramatically, right? In order to get the measurements that are done on the expansion of space, looking at the microwave background radiation, and those that are coming from looking at supernova explosions, to get those compatible, right now, is going to require... Perhaps tweaking the dark energy. It may require tweaking our understanding of the gravitational force. I mean, there are many things that may come into that particular reconciliation.
15:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Tweak our understanding of the gravitational force itself?
15:46 Brian Greene? Yeah, I mean, whenever you talk about dark energy, right? Everyone knows what dark energy is, yeah?
15:52 Chuck Nice? Well, I'm just saying, some people at home may not.
15:56 Brian Greene? Right, so this energy-filling space that we believe yields a repulsive gravity that's causing the universe to speed up in its acceleration.
16:04 Chuck Nice? When it theoretically should be slowing down.
16:09 Brian Greene? That's right, ordinary gravity pulls things together. It should be slowing down. The shock that we got in 1998 is that it's not slowing down in the rate of expansion. It's speeding up.
16:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Against the wishes of gravity.
16:21 Brian Greene? And, well, here's the thing. We didn't understand gravity well enough. Gravity can not only be attractive, it can be repulsive. And that really wasn't taken into account until about 1998 when it comes to cosmology. Now, the possibility is, maybe this outward push is itself getting stronger over time.
16:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so that means thinking it was one thing would be an incomplete understanding of that phenomenon.
16:46 Brian Greene? Yes, and that's what science is.
16:48 Chuck Nice? Which would actually change everything.
16:50 Brian Greene? But that's what science is.
16:51 Chuck Nice? Which is why you have to tweak string theory.
16:55 Brian Greene? Yeah.
17:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So if it affects gravity, then every moment of our models from the Big Bang forward would have to be rethought. Put back in the computers, say, "Now, what are you going to give me with this new understanding?"
17:11 Brian Greene? Literally, because these equations are so complex, there's so many features that come into play, that you have to put it on a computer and simulate and see what happens.
17:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so now, does that affect any thinking of what's going on?
17:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Before the universe began.
17:27 Brian Greene? Well, I mean, people play with those sorts of ideas. But it's hard to know if that question even makes sense, right? It makes sense to say, what happened before you were born? What happened before the Earth formed? Those sorts of phenomenon certainly were preceded by something else in the universe. But the Big Bang may have been not just the beginning of the universe as we think of it as stuff. It could have been the beginning of time itself.
17:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This past Sunday, we aired our, my interview with Stephen Hawking. Went to the dude's office in Cambridge. And one of, I asked him, what was around before the Big Bang? He gave an answer and nobody understood the answer.
18:02 Brian Greene? Yeah.
18:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So now, you check it out on, if you don't get, so, so.
18:07 Brian Greene? I have no idea what he was.
18:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What was he saying?
18:09 Brian Greene? I have no idea. I haven't seen the podcast.
18:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You gotta watch the show!
18:12 Brian Greene? Yeah, I will. Yeah, you didn't, you didn't prep me on this one.
18:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, no.
18:16 Chuck Nice? Allow me, allow me to explain what he was saying.
18:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so, no, but you can give me two or three ideas that people have about what preceded the Big Bang?
18:31 Brian Greene? Absolutely.
18:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Whether or not they're your idea.
18:32 Brian Greene? Yeah, I mean, uh, one idea is that the Big Bang may not have been a unique event. There may have been many Big Bangs, giving rise to many universes.
18:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We are one of those.
18:44 Brian Greene? And we're, and we're just one of those, sort of like a, a cosmic bubble bath of universes. And we're just one bubble expanding in that larger landscape of reality. If that's the case, then our Big Bang was not the beginning of everything. It was just an interesting event that we hold dear because it gave rise to us. But there would have been a time before it that wouldn't have been any more exotic than the time now.
19:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A time measured by some methods we have yet to divine, because every method of measuring time exists within this universe.
19:15 Brian Greene? That's right. So, um, the notion of a time going across all of the universe is a very difficult idea to make mathematical sense of.
19:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Like a meta-time.
19:25 Brian Greene? A meta-time of some sort, but people don't fully appreciate. But that wouldn't be time. It wouldn't be time to be experienced. You're absolutely right. You're absolutely right. So, in this universe, the fact that we can say that the universe has an age of whatever, 13.8 billion years, is only because our universe is highly symmetric. You look at one chunk of the universe over here and another chunk over here, and on average, their properties are the same. And if that weren't the case, there would be no notion of time across even our universe.
19:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because of this symmetry of appearance you're saying, we can justifiably say we are all experiencing the same age of this universe.
20:01 Brian Greene? That's right.
20:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But if we had looked over there, and stuff was being born, and over here, stuff was dying, out of proportion. We would be forced to say, there's not one coherent time across this spacetime continuum.
20:13 Brian Greene? Right. You see, because Einstein, as we're all familiar with, taught us that if you're moving, time ticks off at a different rate. If you're near a black hole, time ticks off at a different rate. So, you should ask yourself, when people say the universe is 13 billion years old, according to which clock? Right? If those clocks are moving, or if they're near a black hole or a strong gravitational field, they'll tick off time at different rates. And the way we get out of that conundrum is what you're saying. The overall uniformity means that on those clocks, that are experiencing basically the same physical conditions, they're gonna experience time the same way.
20:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I love your clock pantomime.
20:50 Chuck Nice? I love it too. Man, I have never in my life wished that I smoke weed more than I do right now.
20:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So...
20:57 Chuck Nice? Now I know why they do it, man.
21:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, we gotta land this plane. So, two final questions. So, if we're asking, what was around before the Big Bang? You say, maybe there was this bubble bath of Big Bangs. Then, that just pushes that question a little further. What was around before the bubble bath?
21:24 Brian Greene? Or, it may push it infinitely far back. That's a possibility too.
21:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Turtles all the way down.
21:28 Brian Greene? So, it could be turtles all the way down. But the other idea that does come out of string theory initially, is that maybe our universe is a slice of space, floating in a larger cosmos. Right? Higher dimensions of string theory allow for that freedom. So, our universe is like a slice of bread in a big cosmic loaf, that may have other slices, which would be other universes. I bring that up because there's a theoretical description...
21:54 Brian Greene? I'm gonna ignore these guys. So there's a...
22:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We were good at... Now we're like slicing the bread.
22:06 Brian Greene? All right, here.
22:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Now slice the bread, I got you.
22:08 Brian Greene? Right.
22:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? With this, the bread loaf universe, go.
22:10 Brian Greene? Exactly. And there's a way of describing the Big Bang where it's actually arising from the collision of these two universes. It's normally called the Big Bang, or it's called the Big Splat, right? So it's a little more evocative way of thinking about it. In which case, before the Big Bang, before the Big Splat, would just be these two giant sheets of space slamming into each other.
22:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And they create a yet a subsequent Big Bang.
22:33 Brian Greene? That's right. It's a cyclic universe. It happens over and over and over again through these collisions. So then what's before our Big Bang? It would just be an era of the universe, similar to this potentially, but was just a different part of the cycle.
22:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So therefore, and my last question to you. The very distant future universe, where we're accelerating at whatever rate it is, does what you're saying now affect that very distant universe?
22:59 Brian Greene? It can, absolutely. Because if, for instance, we're talking about a cyclic universe...
23:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, but my slice of bread is getting bigger.
23:05 Brian Greene? Your slice of bread is getting bigger, but that other slice may be coming toward you. So a trillion years from now, we may get hit again and be completely obliterated.
23:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How will we know if another slice of bread is coming towards us?
23:15 Brian Greene? That's the thing, we won't.
23:19 Chuck Nice? All I know is I am hungry right now.
23:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, Brian Greene, thank you for totally fucking with our heads here tonight.
23:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Brian Greene.
23:31 Brian Greene? That's awesome stuff, man. Thank you. It's phenomenal.
23:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So hang on for a second.
23:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So we're gonna wrap up this part of the show before I hand the baton over to neuroscientist Heather Berlin, one of our StarTalk All-Stars. And while she comes out, but before that happens, we are going to have a special musical interlude.
23:57 Brian Greene? Oh.
23:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Musical interlude.
23:59 Brian Greene? Oh, sweet.
24:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We are going to have a special performance by Baba Brinkman. Baba Brinkman, come on out!
24:08 Brian Greene? All right.
24:15 Speaker 03 Baba, you're a science rapper. I am a science rapper if such things do exist. That's a thing. It's a thing now. You will demonstrate that now. Let's all hope so.
24:29 Speaker 03 Alright.
24:32 Speaker 03 They gave me one song to demonstrate that science rap exists. And all this physics stuff is gonna mix with neuroscience. And pretty soon, we're gonna start talking about free will. And as a rap artist who's been at this for over a decade, you gotta get into freestyle. So I'm about to do a freestyle interpreting a lot of what was discussed for this last half hour. And I want you to think about this. Either every word they said and every word I'm about to say was predetermined since our Big Bang on our slice, or there is some kind of free will possible. Hit it.
25:09 Speaker 03 Now, I'm from Western Canada. When I was a young rapper, picturing myself on MTV. This is the rap I always pictured myself kicking. Listen to this lyric, it isn't freestylist written. I wrote it of my own free will. It was my decision, every intimate constituent. Part of it was deliberate. I considered how to script it and how to stand and deliver it. I wanted to get up on stage and do a lot of damage. And talk about how all the universes were like a big sandwich. And I could just step up here and do some things that are drunk on beats. And find out why astrophysics makes people feel hungry. That was forethought, but that doesn't mean nothing comes before thought. Look at the source of your thoughts. You might find the doors blocked.
25:53 Speaker 03 If every decision is made in a part of my brain that's invisible to me, that's will, but with a subliminal origin. I'm not thinking it's too free. See, I break it down. I show you the freestyle basics. You can't see me, all you can see is the imprint of my radiation. See what I'm saying? That's the way that I spit it with freestyle bars. Looking for me is looking for in the universe the first star. But what am I doing here? Why am I choosing to bust the rhyme? Am I a puppet on a string who could not have done otherwise? A slave to my subliminal abomination? The reptilian forces with no self-control Up in my neocortex, I can't stop I'm stuck here trying to bust raps I could no more stop than Neil could shave off his mustache I'm trying to figure that out Maybe perhaps it could happen
26:37 Speaker 03 But we're all stuck up in this quantum bubble bath I can't stop believing in the option to choose I couldn't stop if I wanted It's down to the molecules I choose Words and deeds, not wants and moods Freedom is like a muscle It's only strong when it's used I can't stop, well I probably could But I probably shouldn't Cause right now I gotta kick a rap And make it really good And maybe, maybe interpret everything That they talked about a second ago Alright, let's do a little rewind Y'all people could be checking the flow See, I'm gonna drop this and say everything clearly I'm five years from stardom Like Brian explaining string theory It's about to happen Any second is coming next Every word I spit is peer-reviewed Something you can check like the literature
27:20 Speaker 03 It's a freestyle now as I spit it at you Indeed, that's the place that I take it Breaking down the basics, yeah Check it out, freestyles, people always felt them I'm gonna get on the Big Bang Theory So I could get dissed by Sheldon, yeah One day, that's about to happen, that's the cameo Bubba Brickman coming through right now With nothing but a damaging flow Yeah, check it I'm gonna have to come sparking it I'm cooking It's not gonna get the same reaction As it did with Neil when I say "Is there a house full of Brooklyn?" No, I screwed it up, that's okay I'm just blazing them, that's the way that we say it Where I come from I'm Canadian, trying to bust the rap So I'm gonna say a shout out to the plaid shirt right there Me and him are repping the lumberjack some Can't stop believing in the option to choose I couldn't stop if I wanted
28:05 Speaker 03 It's down to the molecules I choose Words and deeds, not wants and moods Freedom is like a muscle It's only strong when it's used Well, I could stop I can stop if I want. The question is, why would I want to stop? I could stop, it's just not recommended. At least not till this song is ended. Because I spent a lot of time training my brain to rhyme at the drop of a dime. That's the kind of freedom I could claim as mine. Freedom isn't a metaphysical state at the level of atoms. It's a collection of talents. Each of us can develop and manage. Freedom evolved. Evolution gave us the building blocks. Absolute freedom, maybe not. But more than a digger waspin', more than prefrontal cortex lesion patients living today.
28:49 Speaker 03 I'll take the freedom I've got over the non-freedom of Phineas Gage. Freedom is having a brain that can reject options, detect imposters, dodge sucker punches like boxers. Freedom is having a brain that can navigate obstacles in a continuous exploration of the adjacent possible. A brain that's free enough to recognize goals and pursue them and recognize the reasons why, even if it's prone to illusions. Freedom, if you've got that kind of mind and it's at fault, congratulations. You can now be tried as an adult. Free will, it's similar to freestyle. It's a learnable system that's deterministic deep down. But even if every syllable has a physical cause, freedom is just the belief that I should still get some applause.
29:43 Speaker 03 Thank you.
29:43 Speaker 04 Oh my god!
29:46 Chuck Nice? Well done.
29:50 Chuck Nice? Fantastic, man.
29:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Baba.
29:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you gotta run, because where do you gotta be?
30:00 Speaker 03 Okay, so that was a piece from an Off-Broadway production I'm doing. Hip-hop theater, very inspired by Hamilton. It's called "The Rap Guide to Consciousness", and it's all neuroscience, cognitive psychology.
30:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you're performing that tonight? You gotta leave here tonight to perform that?
30:13 Speaker 03 The show starts in 45 minutes.
30:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, get the hell out of here at the Soho Playhouse.
30:18 Speaker 03 Soho Playhouse, hope y'all can come see it.
30:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Dude!
30:20 Speaker 03 Thanks for having me here, I appreciate it.
30:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Love you, man. All right.
30:24 Speaker 03 Thank you, Neil.
30:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Baba Brinkman!
30:34 Chuck Nice? That guy's my favorite rapper now. Jay-Z, suck it.
30:41 Chuck Nice? I ain't never heard Jay-Z say anything about his prefrontal cortex.
30:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There's some good vocabulary running down there.
30:50 Chuck Nice? Oh, man, that was serious, man.
30:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just to be clear, he did that in rehearsal.
30:55 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
30:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And 5% of it was the same. The rest was completely invented in that moment.
31:02 Chuck Nice? Yeah, it was unbelievable.
31:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What's a dude talking about my mustache?
31:06 Chuck Nice? See, he knew better than to do that in rehearsal.
31:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So our next segment is gonna be StarTalk All-Stars, where I take a backseat and we bring on the host, one of our many talented StarTalk All-Stars, neuroscientist Heather Berlin. Heather, come on out.
31:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Heather, it's your show.
31:40 Heather Berlin? Okay.
31:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Go for it.
31:42 Heather Berlin? All right, Neil, you can take a backseat and, uh...
31:44 Chuck Nice? Yeah, I don't think so.
31:48 Heather Berlin? You don't know me very well, Brian. You don't know me very well. So, welcome to StarTalk All-Stars at BAM. I'm your host, Heather Berlin. I'm a cognitive neuroscientist. I'm based here in New York at the Mount Sinai School of Medicine. So Neil, Brian, thanks for being my guests tonight. And we're gonna...
32:07 Chuck Nice? And Chuck, forget about you.
32:17 Heather Berlin? You're just ingrained in my mind. We've become one. We've become Chuck, my co-host, for bringing all of the wonderful scientific insights and comic relief. Thank you for being here.
32:27 Chuck Nice? So wonderful of you to say.
32:32 Heather Berlin? So we're gonna talk a little bit about the intersection between neuroscience and physics. Talk a little bit about consciousness, time, and free will. So we're just gonna keep it light. Light and easy.
32:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Free will.
32:47 Heather Berlin? Yeah. So...
32:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Not free willy. Right. Free will.
32:52 Heather Berlin? It's not that kind of show. We are gonna...
32:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That was a movie.
32:58 Brian Greene? I took that reference differently.
33:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That was a movie.
33:01 Chuck Nice? You know what's funny? I was thinking that. And I was like, nah, I better not say it.
33:06 Heather Berlin? I told you, we are one. You're like my subconscious that I just kind of try to keep it day, but it keeps coming up.
33:12 Chuck Nice? That's a very good plan, actually.
33:16 Heather Berlin? So actually, Brian, you once tweeted, you said, "Free will is the..."
33:21 Brian Greene? Wait, you're gonna quote a tweet of mine?
33:23 Heather Berlin? I am quoting a tweet.
33:24 Brian Greene? In front of this guy over here? That's like saying I play baseball in front of Babe Ruth, right? It's like saying I write music in front of Mozart, right?
33:31 Chuck Nice? All right, go ahead.
33:32 Heather Berlin? Your tweets matter. Your tweets matter.
33:34 Brian Greene? Thank you.
33:35 Heather Berlin? Free will...
33:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All tweets matter, yeah.
33:37 Heather Berlin? Not all tweets. Not all tweets.
33:41 Chuck Nice? Blue tweets matter.
33:46 Brian Greene? I had to do it, I'm sorry.
33:47 Heather Berlin? You got some red tweets in the house. Okay, so you said, "Free will is the sensation of making a choice. The sensation is real, but the choice seems illusory. Laws of physics determine the future." So...
34:01 Brian Greene? I had to say that.
34:02 Heather Berlin? You were compelled. It was determined from the Big Bang. What does physics have to say about free will?
34:11 Brian Greene? Well, it's not definite, because we don't fully know the laws of physics. But the laws of physics that we currently have at our disposal... Have no opportunity for intercession by human will, right? I mean, we are a collection of particles governed by laws that you can write down and fit on a T-shirt. And those laws don't at any point in the evolution of the particle say, "Hey, can you like tell me now what to do, person?" They just determine the future based upon what things were like in the past.
34:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But Brian, can't there be an emergent property of that collection of molecules that we can call free will? Just because, because the emergent property, if you know emergence, it's a feature of an ensemble that cannot be deduced by the study of the individual.
35:01 Brian Greene? Like ants.
35:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Like ants. You study one ant, you say, "Hi, ant," you'll shake your hand. You have no idea that a thousand ants together are going to make an ant mound.
35:09 Brian Greene? Right.
35:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Or a thousand termites make a termite mound.
35:11 Brian Greene? Right.
35:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Or that birds will flock. You have no way to predict that.
35:15 Brian Greene? So that one ant sounds like Woody Allen.
35:17 Heather Berlin? If free will doesn't exist at the level of physics, in other words, if it doesn't exist at the level of physics, could it not exist at the level of biology or say psychology?
35:27 Brian Greene? That's right. So it's a very good point, and it really depends on what your definition of free will is, right? Normally, the intuitive definition is, things could have been different, and I could have made a choice for things to turn out differently. And if that's your definition of free will, does that resonate with your perspective of free will? Then I don't see any way to square that with the laws of physics. Because anything that you do is your particles executing some kind of motion, and the motion of your particles in your brain and your body have no opportunity to allow you as a conscious being to direct them. What force could possibly that direction come from? Is it the electromagnetic force? Well, that one we understand from Maxwell.
36:12 Brian Greene? Is it the gravitational force? Hmm, we understand that one from Einstein. Is it the nuclear forces? Those we understand from the standard model of particle physics. What force could you possibly exert on your particles that goes against or goes beyond those that emerge from the equations of physics? That's the issue.
36:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Could our free will thrive in the probabilistic description of quantum physics?
36:34 Brian Greene? No.
36:37 Brian Greene? Not as we currently understand it. And that's a natural place.
36:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Don't make me fight you here on the stage.
36:42 Brian Greene? We've done this before.
36:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, we did, actually, yeah. I grabbed this lapel on stage once.
36:46 Brian Greene? But we both were wrestlers in high school. Different weight categories.
36:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, very different weight categories.
36:51 Brian Greene? But, um, but, uh, so, so it's, it's, I should have said it's possible, but I consider it highly unlikely. So, so there is a puzzle right now in quantum physics that has been on the table for 50, 75 years. And we don't know the answer to this puzzle. And that's why I have to couch my remarks with a little bit of uncertainty. And that puzzle is this. Quantum theory says that you can only predict the probability of one outcome or another, right? 50% chance electron here, 50% chance there. Yet, when we measure the electron, we always find it either here or there, right? One or the other. So how do you go from the fuzzy probabilistic haze of many possibilities to the single definite reality that we all experience in everyday life?
37:35 Brian Greene? We still don't know how to bridge that gap. So within that, if consciousness somehow plays a role in picking out one outcome from the probabilistic haze, then sure, then free will might come for the ride as well.
37:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There you go. So you just said, you just said, probabilistically, the particle can be here or there.
37:58 Brian Greene? Yes.
37:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But if you measure it, it is only in one place.
38:02 Brian Greene? Yes.
38:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So my act of thought
38:05 Brian Greene? Yeah.
38:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? is I want to go, I want a cheeseburger. That's the particle in this state. And I'm gonna say, I want a cheeseburger, bam! The particle's there.
38:14 Brian Greene? See, that's the part I don't buy, right there, you see? Because...
38:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Why are you poking your...
38:20 Brian Greene? Because it's random. There's nothing that you did to pick one outcome because you wanted it, because you willed it, because it was your desire. And yet, your intuition is you had the cheeseburger because you chose it. If it comes from a random process, it's like throwing the dice. And throwing the dice to get an outcome is not what we mean by free will.
38:41 Heather Berlin? Okay, wait. You physicists.
38:45 Chuck Nice? Sorry.
38:47 Heather Berlin? I'm gonna give you a neuroscientific perspective.
38:49 Chuck Nice? Oh, good.
38:50 Heather Berlin? Okay. So, from a neuroscientific perspective, first of all, what's happening at the quantum level doesn't really scale up to whether a neuron fires or not, right? I mean, that indeterminacy. But from experiments that we've done, starting in the 80s, Benjamin Libet did studies where he said to somebody, "Whenever you feel like it, just press this button." And he measured brain activation. And he found, and he said, even before they actually pressed the button, because that takes time to make the movement, "Just let me know where this little dot is on the clock when you feel the first inkling of the intention of wanting to move." And then what he found is about 350 milliseconds before a person even had that conscious intention, there was a gearing up of brain activation, right?
39:31 Heather Berlin? So then, leap forward to current times, we do neuroimaging experiments where we can say to a person...
39:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just so that people know, you measure people's brains for a living.
39:40 Heather Berlin? That's my job. That's what I do, yes.
39:43 Chuck Nice? I would be no help to you.
39:51 Heather Berlin? It's my unconscious here again. He's always button in and, you know. We need you, we need you. But you can measure it using a FMRI, which looks at blood flow to different parts of the brain.
40:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Functional magnetic resonance imaging.
40:04 Heather Berlin? Basically, looking at blood flow as a proxy to neurons fire. The blood is gonna go where the neurons are firing because they need energy. So we can say to you, "Okay, just choose left or right, or that hamburger or not."
40:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Cheeseburger.
40:15 Heather Berlin? Cheeseburger, sorry, cheeseburger.
40:17 Chuck Nice? He chose to put cheese on that burger!
40:23 Heather Berlin? We can say, we can predict up to 10 seconds before you even have the conscious inclination of your intention, which you're going to go, left or right, or cheese or no cheese, right? So at that level, I like to say, "Yeah, sure, we have free will, but we're just not conscious of it, right? The brain is making these decisions all the time, and we have this illusion of free will." But the question really is, is why do we have this illusion? Why did we evolve this illusion? Is it important? If we didn't have it, would it change our behavior?
40:54 Brian Greene? Yeah, I mean, it strikes me that it gives us that sense of control that presumably, out in the savanna, you know, 50,000 years ago, 100,000 years ago, made the difference between surviving and not. If you're invested in how things turn out and feel that your decisions can affect how things turn out, you're more attentive, you're more engaged. It's something that matters to you more, and presumably, something like that or some parallel story like that suggests why we have this illusion.
41:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you're less likely to be eaten.
41:25 Brian Greene? Yes, that's the point, that's the point.
41:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you both agree with one another, with each other, that from physics point of view, it's deterministic. You didn't use that word, but I'm putting it in your mouth.
41:40 Brian Greene? It's okay.
41:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
41:41 Brian Greene? Yeah, I mean, it's okay on the radio and live show, but I...
41:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so Heather, so your results are consistent with his, basically?
41:50 Heather Berlin? Yeah, yeah, yeah. I think from both a physics perspective and a neuroscience perspective, we come to the similar conclusion that it's an illusion, that free will is an illusion, even though we really feel like it's not. And actually, studies have been done, which when you tell people that free will is an illusion, and you start giving them subsequent tests, they're more likely to cheat on a math test, they're more likely to act unethically. So the fact that we have this belief, those who have had it actually are better able to survive in the system along the line.
42:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We're more likely to behave.
42:21 Heather Berlin? We're more likely to behave.
42:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If we think we're in control.
42:23 Heather Berlin? However, we also have evolved there to be cheaters, right? And they can win. And so if we were all cheaters, no one would win. But if we all...
42:30 Brian Greene? Just ask Tom Brady.
42:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And Chuck, he looked so deflated at the end of that game, right?
42:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He was sad.
42:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Heather, is there a...
42:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Let me ask you a blunter question.
42:57 Heather Berlin? Right.
42:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Does it even matter if... That you know this, if we all feel like we have free will? I want to believe that I go to school and get a good job and behave and I want to believe all that.
43:10 Heather Berlin? Well, I...
43:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you tell me I shouldn't believe it? That if I... If one day I end up in prison, that was predetermined from the Big Bang?
43:16 Chuck Nice? And wait, just as...
43:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're saying yes to that?
43:18 Chuck Nice? But wait, as an addendum to the... As an addendum...
43:22 Brian Greene? If you're gonna do what you're gonna do, there's nothing I can do to stop you.
43:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So if I kick your ass right now...
43:29 Brian Greene? That's it.
43:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That was predetermined...
43:30 Brian Greene? Then it was meant to be.
43:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? From the Big Bang.
43:32 Brian Greene? It was meant to be, my friend.
43:37 Chuck Nice? I don't know how this got so sexy.
43:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Plus, Brian, kicking one's ass is not a literal stick your ass in someone's to kick.
43:47 Heather Berlin? Well, I...
43:48 Chuck Nice? But wait...
43:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? From the hood, it means just winning a fight.
43:52 Chuck Nice? Oh.
43:57 Chuck Nice? But that predetermined...
43:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Actually, Brian was born and raised in New York City. So, went to Stuyvesant High School. So he's homegrown.
44:03 Chuck Nice? Oh, nice.
44:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Homegrown.
44:06 Chuck Nice? But wait, that predeterminedism that you were just talking about. Okay, let's say for instance that you do accept that and then that leads to fatalism. Was that also predetermined? So the fact that you were given this information that, well, I'm not really in charge of my own decisions. My brain is making these decisions based upon these neurosynaptic transitions that happen within my mind. And so I just let that happen and then I say, okay, because of that, I don't give a damn about anything. And I just let it all go. Was that predetermined?
44:35 Brian Greene? Yep.
44:36 Heather Berlin? Well, do you?
44:39 Heather Berlin? But also to put it in perspective...
44:41 Chuck Nice? Sorry, man. Okay. God, I'm gonna shoot myself tonight.
44:46 Brian Greene? But the, but the, but you see-
44:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, I gotta just let the record show. Chuck put out a really awesome question right there, and it just got a one-word answer. You could've at least stretched out your answer.
44:57 Brian Greene? I'm, I'm, well-
44:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Give a guy a break, you know?
44:59 Brian Greene? No, I'm happy to. So, so, you know, often people, when they encounter these ideas, and you must've heard this too, people say, "Okay, then I'm not gonna do anything, I'm gonna sit on my couch, and what does it matter?"
45:07 Chuck Nice? Fatalism.
45:08 Brian Greene? Right? But you see, that's a mixing of two distinct views on one question. You see, if you think that you're making a free choice to sit on your couch, then you feel like, "Well, now I am going to give in to this, and I'm just gonna sit there." But if you do that, it was determined. So, exactly what you're asking. If you choose to sit on your couch, it's not that you made a volitional choice, it was set in place. And if that's what was gonna happen, that's what's gonna happen.
45:35 Chuck Nice? So, but then, by, by that particular, uh, uh, measure, all information that we receive then predetermines everything that we do. That's really what you're saying.
45:46 Brian Greene? Yes, absolutely. Uh, and, and moreover, but, you know, to just give this a little bit more color, I think, you know, your view, Heather's view, and Baba's view-
45:55 Chuck Nice? Don't explain her view!
45:56 Brian Greene? Okay, I won't then. But, but what I heard Baba say.
46:01 Chuck Nice? Now, let me tell you something, Brian. Let me tell you something. I'm predetermined to say that!
46:08 Brian Greene? We spoke about this thing before we came out. But, uh, but Baba's, Baba's description, I think, really, uh, at least helps me, when I think in those terms, which is, it's not that free will is the intuitive one that we're talking about here. Free will really is the fact that we're able to carry out this amazing spectrum of behaviors. We can walk, we can talk, we can sing, we can come up with ideas. The fact that they had an earlier cause, maybe even back at the Big Bang, to me, it doesn't take anything away from creativity. It doesn't take anything away from originality. It doesn't take anything away from having a sense of authorship over your own actions, because you're the most immediate cause of those actions. They emerge through you, through your particles. Your particles in your brain are confi-
46:53 Brian Greene? Figured in such a way that when certain stimuli hit your body, you said and do certain things. The fact that it's determined, who cares?
47:01 Heather Berlin? So there's different views of free will. There's not just determinism and non-determinism. There's compatibilism.
47:08 Brian Greene? Which is what that is.
47:09 Heather Berlin? Yeah, and compatibilism is saying that the world, it is deterministic, but we also have free will within that because of these probabilities. And the other question, getting to what you were saying, is that, so then people throw their hands in the air, "Okay, if there's no such thing as free will, then I can do whatever I want. I can go murder someone. It doesn't matter, it was predetermined." However, however, we have also...
47:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? However, Chuck.
47:33 Heather Berlin? Evolved. However, that's really important. We have evolved the capacity to have self-control as other animals. But in particular, we have the largest percentage of prefrontal cortex than any other species, which is the part of the brain that has that ability to control our innate impulses. So we hold people accountable for their actions to the degree to which they have the capacity to have self-control. Therefore, children are less responsible for their crimes than adults or people who have prefrontal lesions or severe psychiatric illness.
48:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because children don't have a fully developed...
48:04 Heather Berlin? Prefrontal cortex. Until about the age of 25.
48:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And for guys, it's 35.
48:09 Heather Berlin? Yeah, it's a little bit, a little bit more.
48:12 Brian Greene? Or perhaps 70.
48:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Chuck, we gotta wrap it.
Previous #ICYMI - Hole-istic Golf, with Craig Davies and Sean Foley Next #ICYMI - Cosmic Queries: FIFA World Cup Edition Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated