Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast Starry Starry Night with Roberta Olson, Jay Pasachoff, & Heather Berlin About this episode Can you hear colors? On this episode, Neil deGrasse Tyson and comic co-host Chuck Nice explore science through art in Van Gogh’s Starry Night with art historian Roberta Olson, astronomer Jay Pasachoff, and neuroscientist Heather Berlin.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk, your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is StarTalk. I'm your host, Neil deGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist. And today, we're going to talk about the universe in art, in art. Yeah, artists been touching the universe lately, and we're going to get some insights. Well, I've been doing it for quite some time, actually. We'll get some insights on that, but let me first introduce my co-host, Chuck. Nice, Chuck.
0:37 Chuck Nice? Hey, Neil.
0:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Chuck, all right.
0:39 Chuck Nice? I'm excited. Art and the universe. I feel as though I should be conducting this show with a fine Bordeaux in my head. You know?
0:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, actually, at art openings, they don't serve Bordeaux, they serve Merlot. That's the joke.
1:02 Chuck Nice? How garish.
1:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, that's the contrast, Joe Sixpack and Martin Merlot. See, that's how that goes.
1:12 Chuck Nice? I got you.
1:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, so, actually, you know, I think a lot about this stuff, but I don't claim any special expertise in it. And so, we've got two guests who are all in it. Let me first introduce a longtime friend and colleague and fellow New Yorker, and I think we even went to the same high school as each other. I've got Jay Pasachoff. Jay, welcome to StarTalk.
1:38 Speaker 02 Well, thank you very much. It's nice to see another Bronx High School of Science alumnus again.
1:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay. And you are the Field Memorial Professor of Astronomy, and you're Director of the Hopkins Observatory at Williams College. And I kind of sort of can claim I'm a graduate, because I was honored by an honorary degree several years back. So, thank you, guys, for voting me in.
2:02 Speaker 02 A well-deserved honor.
2:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In the club, in the club.
2:05 Chuck Nice? I'm sorry, Neil, that would only make you an honorary graduate.
2:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Damn, just, you know, Chuck.
2:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I worked hard for that honor. I sat by the phone and they called me.
2:18 Chuck Nice? Come on, you got enough degrees, you know that. It's better than being a dishonorary graduate.
2:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, there you go.
2:25 Chuck Nice? Indeed, indeed.
2:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And we've got with us an actual artist, art historian, and co-author of a couple of books with Jay, Roberta Olson. Roberta, welcome.
2:39 Speaker 03 It's thrilling to be here, Neil, and you're actually a neighbor of mine on Central Park West.
2:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, there you are as curator of drawings. That's a, that's a cool thing on your card. I curate all drawings, all attempts of people to represent reality and all that comes out of their head, even if it's not reality, I guess, in the drawings at the New York Historical Society across the street from the American Museum of Natural History in New York City. Let me just finish out your, your CV here. Professor Emeritus of Art History at Wheaton College. So that's the full sort of IDs for both of you. That, that's great. Now, the two books, one of them, when I first knew of your collaborations, it was Fire and Ice: A History of Comets in Art. And that's still on my shelf and I'd love that.
3:25 Speaker 03 And that was only me.
3:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, that was only you? Oh, my gosh.
3:28 Speaker 03 It was before that. And it was actually that, that was the reason why Jay and I met.
3:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that, that's the, that's the origin story of your publishing relationship. Wow, wow. Well, okay, so you've got, so, so, okay, so you've already had some astronomy chops, is what you're saying here.
3:50 Speaker 03 When I was teaching at Wheaton College, I was doing a two-week-long sort of investigation of Jato. And I looked at the Adoration of the Magi one time.
4:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Jato the artist, yes, okay.
4:04 Speaker 03 The artist who painted the Stravany Chapel in Padua. And in 1303 to 1306.
4:11 Speaker 03 And I looked at the adoration of the major and I asked my class, "Why is there a comet for the star Bethlehem?" No one could answer.
4:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, because if you draw the star Bethlehem, it's got like pointy, uh, spikes coming out of it. And if you draw a comet, people know what comets look like. You don't mistake a comet or a star.
4:32 Speaker 03 This is what's absolutely incredible. So I had to answer my students. You know, I was a good teacher. I am a good teacher. So I went to the New York Public Library and I spent months learning cometology. Also going through everything that had been published on Joddo. And Ecclesiastes was actually wrong. No one had ever identified that as a comet. So I thought, "Got to do something about this." Learned cometology and I thought, "All the art publications, two years hence." So I sent it to Scientific American, Unknown. And there were, there were no computers in those days. This is 1979.
5:14 Speaker 03 I got a letter back in two days and said, "We're going to put it in the next issue." Alright, there it was. And then the European Space Agency sent me a telegram and said, "We're flying to Halley's Comet in 1985, 86. Can we name the satellite Joddo?"
5:34 Chuck Nice? Yeah, so Neil, remind me never to get into an argument with Roberta. Roberta is just like, "I'll see you in two years after I learn everything about it, and you, sir, will be proven wrong."
5:49 Speaker 03 No, but at the time, this is, we're talking about 1979, there wasn't that much published. I mean, it's very different. We are filled with wonderful things today, but a glut of information. And in those days, it was much more manageable. And, uh...
6:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, you're leaving out an important piece of information here. If you do the 75, 76 year orbit of comet Halley, and you go backwards through time, it lands... At the time that painting was made, isn't that correct? So we can say that was probably Halley's Comet.
6:23 Speaker 03 Absolutely, you're correct. And we know from Giovanni Bellini's Chronicle, it was described exactly like Jado painted it. And he has the wonderful sweeping dust tail, and he does it in layers. He has the condensation around the nucleus and the coma. I mean, it's absolutely brilliant, layer upon layer. And it actually is... Artists are very intelligent. They layer things. And he put it where the star of Bethlehem usually is. But someone was advising him, and he did his Church Fathers. He read Origin and John of Damascus, because they described the star of Bethlehem in words that you, Neil, you Chalk, you Jay, everyone will look at and say,
7:06 Speaker 03 yes, that's a comet he's describing, not a star.
7:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah. Wow. Yeah, because, you know, we all share the same vocabulary. And if you're looking at stuff, it's going to come out that way. So this latest collaboration is... Let me make sure I get the title of that. Jay, what's the title of the book? Art...
7:25 Speaker 02 Well, the latest collaboration is Cosmos, The Art and Science of the Universe. But it started with Halley's Comet. A mutual colleague, the late Sam Egerton, a professor of art at Williams, invited Roberta to come up from... up to give a lecture. And I went to her lecture. And I heard that the first two thirds of her lecture and the first two thirds of my Halley's Comet lecture were similar. But of course, her last third was art and mine was science. And we were introduced at that point. So basically, since Halley's Comet came by in 1985, we've been working together.
8:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So what can the two of you say or reflect upon when you see artists reach for the universe as their sources of inspiration?
8:14 Speaker 03 Well, it's really an exploration again, and again, multi-leveled. Artists are basically searchers for meaning, just like astronomers. I mean, it's a different thing. Plus, both artists and astronomers are visual. And it depends on what area you're talking about. If you're talking about Babylonian seal engravers, they were reflecting the cosmology at the time and the belief in astrology. If you're talking about the 18th century in England, this was a time when people were really differentiating what was going on in the heavens. And scientists, astronomers, amateurs and professionals,
8:54 Speaker 03 and artists were both involved with sort of describing what they could see, because that was a different universe than we have today in the sense of what could be encompassed. Also...
9:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, but it's one thing to interpret the universe and then create some work of art that emanates from your own perspective. It's another thing, because I don't know how to draw, and I need you to draw what I see in my telescope. So you're kind of a substitute camera for me in that context. So, do you guys explore that distinction?
9:32 Speaker 03 Before photography, that was the case. And in fact, if you know Carolyn Herschel, she drew comets in her book of records. We know that actually Newton, Sir Isaac Newton, drew comets in his scribblings too, and in his notes. Astronomers, actually, and some of them wonderful, MacClure, have fabulous drawings, because before photography, you had to be able to draw, to remember something, to describe something. Because art is a visual language, and so you have that. But then art is also a symbolic image. And so if we jump to the fact of the universe is riveting, okay?
10:15 Speaker 03 Comets are riveting, the stars are riveting. And they also, shall we say, call forth speculation. Where are we going? Where have we been? Where are we going to? As Gauguin would say. They encourage speculative thought. Plus, before electricity... They were much more galvanizing. I don't know if you tried to see comet Neowise last year?
10:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, I did, of course. Who you think you're talking to here? Did I see comet Neowise?
10:46 Speaker 03 I had to sort of tweak you a little bit on that one.
10:51 Speaker 02 So one of the first things that I did with Roberta was when we noticed that in a book called the Nuremberg Chronicle from 1492, there were a number of pictures of comets, but one of them kept getting cited as the first drawing of a comet. And when we actually looked in the book, and this at that time, and free World Wide Web required my going to the Harvard Library to take the book out and page through, we discovered about a dozen pictures of comets. But then we realized that there were only four woodcuts. And they churned them every which way and just put them next to dates.
11:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wow.
11:32 Speaker 02 So that was not really a picture of...
11:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It wasn't an independent drawing. Oh, my gosh.
11:37 Speaker 03 They were stylized woodcuts. And so we heard that there were exemplars, which are plans for the books, you know, layouts, which were very ray-shared and had been lost in World War II. And we were able to go to Nuremberg, because the library had found them, and see how they plotted out both the Latin first and then the German editions in 1493. It was just fabulous.
12:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So just remind me, the Nuremberg Chronicles is a complete compilation of all knowledge up to that day, isn't that correct?
12:13 Speaker 03 That's right. And it's early in Knoblauch. It's very important. And it's a huge volume. But they tried to give the entire history of the world in terms of, you know, rulers and war.
12:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Everything, everything. It was just...
12:28 Chuck Nice? You know, Mel Brooks did the same thing.
12:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The same thing and it was really good, I have to say.
12:36 Speaker 02 But they reused woodcuts. Some of the pictures of cities were reused from one city to a different city. And we then did make this list in an article. We had a grant from the travel for collections from the National Endowment for Humanities to go see these exemplars. And they turned out to be really sketchy, just very rough pencil drawing. So there was clearly no accuracy in the depiction of the comments at all.
13:04 Chuck Nice? So, you know, with respect to that, are there times when, as Roberta mentioned earlier, the speculative nature, where we're going, what we're doing, which often leads to interpretation and the artist being able to expand what they're looking at?
13:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? See, that's what I want an artist to do for me, right?
13:23 Chuck Nice? Okay.
13:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because Jay, I get people write to me and say, oh, I saw this Hubble photo and I made this painting of the Hubble photo. I'm sorry, I don't need that. I got the Hubble photo. All right. So, so where, at what point did artists start putting their own paw print on the cosmic topic?
13:46 Speaker 02 Well, in fact, I think one of the reasons that the Hubble photos are so interesting to many people is that they have a public information division that colorizes the photos in weird and wonderful ways. And I've paid a lot of attention to the artistic versions. So, so in fact, I'd be very glad to have an oil painting of one of the Hubble photos on my wall. If any of the listeners here want to send us some copies, maybe three copies, please. One to Roberta, one to Neil and one to me. We have these wonderful false color things and now we're looking forward to the
14:28 Speaker 02 false color things that'll come out of the James Webb Space Telescope when that's launched in a few months. And that, in fact, is just going to work in the infrared, as certainly Neil knows very well. So there won't actually be the same high-quality, fine-resolution, visible light photos, but in false color, it'll all look great.
14:50 Chuck Nice? And Jay, let me just thank you for leaving me off the list, as I now sit without any Hubble oil paintings in my home. But maybe I'll go to Neil's and just look at his. Perhaps he'll keep it at the museum and I can see it there.
15:04 Speaker 02 Well, I actually have one page on my wall from the Nuremberg Chronicle that happens to have a comet in it, of course. So I'll make a copy of that, Chuck.
15:12 Chuck Nice? That makes up for it completely. Thank you. Thank you so much.
15:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Jay, you own so many antiquarian books. I'm disappointed you don't have your own Nuremberg Chronicles.
15:23 Speaker 02 There was a choice at one point, either Nuremberg Chronicle or getting something that was more straightforward astronomy. And I got the astronomy one, but I'm so sorry that I left the Nuremberg Chronicle.
15:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, I thought you might have said, "I could have bought the Nuremberg Chronicle or another house." Last I checked what these things are going for. We're going to take a break. We're going to take a break. When we come back, more with Jay and Roberta. Jay, pass it off. Roberta, also. We're talking about the history of astronomy in art on StarTalk.
16:13 Speaker 04 Hi, I'm Chris Cohen from Hallworth, New Jersey, and I support StarTalk on Patreon. Please enjoy this episode of StarTalk Radio with your and my favorite personal astrophysicist, Neil deGrasse Tyson.
16:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We're back, StarTalk. I got Chuck Nice, my co-host. We've got Roberta Olson and Jay Pasachoff, a fellow astrophysicist, and they're collaborators on projects that explore the intersection of art and science. And Roberta, we left off, you were gonna tell us when and where or how artists started making representations of the universe, an expression of how they see the world, rather than trying to duplicate what a photograph might do.
17:14 Speaker 03 Well, I think it starts, first of all, trying to capture in the Renaissance what people saw. For example, the Lorenzetti would look at meteor showers and put them in the Garden of Gethsemane when Christ was arrested and Judas betrayed him because it was chaos. It was a symbol. But it was a symbol everyone could understand because they had seen it and they were afraid when there were meteors falling. So that was a symbol everyone understood. And then I think by the time you-
17:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, just to be clear, at the time, they had no clue what a meteor was. So these were just falling stars.
17:46 Speaker 03 Falling stars, but they didn't know whether they were comets or meteors or whatever. They were not differentiated until the 18th century, really. So they were called things like falling stars, broom stars, hairy stars, and comete, by the way, is Greek for hairy star, which is why they were always satirized with long tresses. But then, after the Enlightenment had set in, when it was sort of, everyone had mastered depictions that were realistic, artists and also writers began to be very subjective. And I mean, you always had comets and meteors and other astronomical things used by Shakespeare, by Spencer, and they
18:27 Speaker 03 had all this incredible symbolic baggage. Artists began trying to express what they felt about life, the universe, their own-
18:38 Speaker 03 A view of things like William Blake, who holds the record of showing eighteen comets in his illustrations, and they're bizarre as all get out. Very personal. It was sort of a liberation.
18:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's how I, that's what I want. If I had a house artist, that's what I'd want them to do. You know, like the king has a, has like a court jester and a court. If I had an artist at my disposal, I'd want them to always interpret the world for me.
19:05 Speaker 03 And it's great. And it's, it's endless, like the universe. I mean, it can go on. I mean, obviously, everyone has a, a finite number of years. But they were very inventive. I mean, it was something that people had fun with. They also became vehicles for satirizing in the eighteenth century. When you had coffeehouses and they would have caricatures of people. You could do political caricatures. You could do anything. But remember, these were topical events. Everybody looked up. There was the sky. There was no TV. There were no computers. And this, and everything that happened in the sky was much brighter. And people were still afraid.
19:45 Chuck Nice? So the sky was, the, the sky is antiquity's television?
19:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, basically.
19:51 Speaker 03 And up until electricity, it was. And then you had people in the Victorian times. They would take transparencies and they would take pins and prick them, put them up to their kerosene lamps to try to duplicate what they had seen in the heavens.
20:05 Chuck Nice? Okay, I, I, I just gotta say this. But Roberta took us from ancient Babylon in the beginning, right? Up to the Roman Empire and Christ, right? Up to the seventeen hundreds. How much, where, where, how much history is in you?
20:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But when she went, then she went up to the Victorian times.
20:26 Chuck Nice? And then up to Victorian, yes.
20:27 Speaker 03 There's just endless amount of material. I mean, thousands and thousands and thousands of works that we could discuss.
20:34 Speaker 02 And Roberta notes them all, so.
20:38 Speaker 02 So that's what this new book is, basically. We've written a dozen or whatever articles over since Ali's comet came by in 1985, 86. And so we just had a chance that we have a dozen chapters, each on a different topic. Eclipse's meteors, uh, uh, comets, et cetera. In, in this new book with a lot of, with a few hundred illustrations showing samples from all these different periods of time.
21:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Chuck, when, when you said she knows thousands of years, I was gonna say we, we need a bigger boat, bigger format. So Roberta, I, I've done some, a little bit of my own homework. Nothing, I wouldn't call it scholarly homework, but just sort of casual homework while I'm, you know, uh, eating popcorn. And Van Gogh's Starry Night, The Starry Night, 1889. I've looked hard and I've not been able to find another work of art where the title is astronomical, even if there's astronomical things in the painting. Not only that, it's the, I have not been able to find a work of art where the title
21:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? is the background. So he's got, he's got a village, he's got rolling hills, there's a cypress tree. None of that is the title of that painting. It's called The Starry Night. So for me, it was, it felt like maybe the universe is becoming front and center and not just the wallpaper or whatever else you're drawing. So how, how much of what I just told you there will land on fertile ground and how much is just bullshit? And remember, he's not the least bit biased.
22:25 Speaker 03 I think that Van Gogh speaks to you and drew you in because what he has shown is an approximation of his emotional, uh, interaction with the universe. There are other works of art with titles that have, um,
22:44 Speaker 03 Astronomical features such as Millet's work, that's not Starry Night, but it's the same thing. It's a meteor shower, which Van Gogh may have known. But I think that Van Gogh was totally obsessed.
22:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I mean, at least four where the night sky is.
23:00 Speaker 03 With the night sky and actually one, an additional one, which people haven't commented on, which is known in about four versions. So there are five with one of four versions. And we're very lucky because he wrote to his brother Theo and told him everything. And he told him that he wanted to do a painting of the starry night. And nocturnes were very, very popular at this point in Paris and all over in England as well.
23:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But nocturnes, I think of nocturnes, I think of piano nocturnes. Is that what you mean or something else?
23:31 Speaker 03 Nocturne is a term for a night painting. And something done at night. And we know that he warmed up to this. And in fact, he wrote to his friend, the Belgian, Eugene Blach, that he wanted to paint this café terrace where they had been, that was the first one. And he painted the sky, and the café, by the way, is now named Café Van Gogh. It wasn't at the time, but everyone goes there on the Van Gogh tour to see it.
24:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Mm hmm.
24:01 Speaker 03 And the second warm up was the one that is, shall we say, over the Rhône. It's the view over the Rhône with the starry sky. And it's very near where he was living in all of the time. He was living in the Yellow House. And that one actually does have astronomical bodies you can identify it as part of the Ursa Major, the Big Bear, the part that the English call the plough and we call the big dipper. And, but it's reoriented. It's a marriage. It's not an actual topographical, shall we say, or skyscape
24:43 Speaker 03 view, because he's looking towards the southwest. And you can, by going there, you can figure out where the view was, because it looks very much the same in their pictures of it. He was actually painting the sky on the other side. So he married the two. And this sort of answers many of your questions.
25:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I mean, he lied. Just, just say.
25:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You can say it.
25:06 Speaker 03 It's artistic license. He manipulated things for feelings. He wanted things. And he wrote to his brother after Starry Night, he wrote, "I'm in dire need of religion." For him, if you think of Starry Night, you think of the blues. He appointed colors with certain emotions. Okay, this is post-impressionism. Blue was infinity. Blue was eternity. And he's speculating, just like you do when you look through a telescope. What's out there? What does it mean? Okay, where are we going? How does it relate to me? And people have spilled much ink about what we see in the sky. The only thing we can say for certain is that there is what he called the morning star,
25:50 Speaker 03 which was Venus, which apparently, according to astronomical calculations, was in its eighth year of the cycle, so it was extremely strong. But he distorts everything for a kind of wonderful orient, this glow around the morning star. And then, you can tell me, Neil, and they certainly can comment, and I'm sure Chuck would too, is that the spiral nebula, or as some people said, oh no, it's clouds in the mist cloak? And then down below on the horizon, is that the Milky Way? And then we have a crescent moon, but we know this painting was done in two days. It was done in two days. We know that from the letters to Theo.
26:33 Speaker 03 And the moon was gibbous at that point. It wasn't a crescent. So you'd say he's lying. He's manipulating it because you know the crescent moon is more interesting for most people who are not astronomers. Okay?
26:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, people hardly ever draw a gibbous moon. It's the saddest moon phase of them all. It's not a full moon and it's not a crescent. Like, what is that?
26:55 Speaker 03 Remember, astronomy at this time was very popular. In France, you had Flemarien, and you had Guillaume Maure. And Flemarien... Because he was so parapetetic, we don't know what Van Gogh saw.
27:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But just to be clear, Camille Flammarie, a highly prolific French writer of astronomical, but pop French writer of astronomical subjects.
27:16 Speaker 03 And everyone got it. But he had beautiful illustrations in his book as well. We know, for example, a contemporary, Gustave Marat, who has all his library preserved in his italie, which you can visit in Paris, had copies of Flammarie. Okay, so probably he thought, could he have seen drawings of of Lor Ross? And this is what makes art so fascinating. It's not a simple answer. And to unravel it, you have to do archaeology of all sorts. Jay and I know, we got Getty grants to do our book, Fire in the Sky: Comets and Meteors, the Decisive Century in British Art and Science. You have to go to the place and you have to find things that have never been published.
27:59 Speaker 03 And it's a, shall we say, a voyage of discovery. I mean, is it a voyage of discovery? It is. Is it archaeology? Yes, but it's finding things that haven't been there before so that you understand what the artist was exposed to. An artist is like a sponge. They take in all this stuff and they create something that is entirely different, entirely their own. And you may relate to it in certain ways. I may relate to it in certain ways.
28:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Robert, could you comment on the intensity of Van Gogh's colors? It's been rumored that he might have had some synesthesia, I think it's called, where you hear, you can hear color. You know, your senses are crosswired so that it may have manifested differently or more intensely within him. And because people always remark on the on the intensity of those colors. It's almost psychedelic.
28:54 Speaker 03 It is psychedelic. And in fact, he purposely chose complementary colors, like oranges and yellows with blues and greens. And then in The Night Cafe, and by the way, I should say something about gaslight. He does the same thing with gaslight that he does with Venus, the morning star. He makes it vibrate, so it's alive. Because for him, it's an emotional thing. Gaslight was new. And he wanted to juxtapose, in the café with the terrace, new gaslight.
29:25 Speaker 03 With the cosmic light.
29:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, now Jay, I ran some numbers on the starry night with the crescent moon. So according to Roberta, they know when it was painted. And of course, we would know the phase of the moon trivially upon getting the date. However, if we assume, if instead of that, you say, okay, here's the crescent moon. Here's Venus, the morning star, and about that angle to each other, and about that elevation above the horizon, I derived a date for that scene, and it's June 21st, 1889. And so, and the fact that Venus and the moon are at that very low angle to each other betrays the fact that he's at a very high northern latitude. So all of that sort of makes sense.
30:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And I'm, I'm wondering, maybe it didn't matter when he painted it. He saw that crescent moon and Venus had some other date. It would have to have been June 21st, and then put it in his painting.
30:23 Speaker 02 Well, there's, there's another Olsen, and I never get confused between Roberta Olson and Don Olsen.
30:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, Don Olsen at, at Texas.
30:30 Speaker 02 Don Olsen at Texas Tech actually uses all those positions of things and, and goes to the places with the students and figures out exactly when and exactly where people were standing and what direction they're looking at. And he's got a couple of books out about that that are very interesting.
30:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Mm-hmm.
30:51 Speaker 02 But the work with Roberta is more, is more art historical rather than, rather than positional.
30:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Positional, technical, right, right, right.
31:01 Speaker 03 But we know that he painted this on June 19th and worked on it for two days.
31:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, but that would be a crescent moon. Wait, wait, if you, if that's the date, it was a crescent, it wasn't gibbous, it was crescent moon.
31:10 Speaker 03 Then, the literature is bomb, Neil. Send me, what program did you use? And that's the wonderful thing about computers. You can program, you can program eclipse paths, you can do.
31:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, right. And, and I agree that nobody paints, hardly anybody paints gibbous moons. It's a sad phase, but.
31:29 Speaker 02 And I, and I learned from a colleague a few years ago that it's called gibbous because it give us more light.
31:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? When you combine high-tech with illiteracy, you get fascinating.
31:43 Speaker 03 You know that they examined the canvas, though, and they had said it's two days. He left holes in the canvas where he put in the astronomical phenomenon. He painted the foreground first and the cypress tree, which of course is a symbol of a cemetery and death as well as being evergreen. And notice how the cypress tree dominates.
32:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Completely.
32:08 Speaker 03 In a sense, it unifies heaven and earth. It is the cosmos. Because if you think of Humboldt, Unhumboldt and the cosmos, it also takes us down to earth.
32:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Van Humboldt was one of the first people to bring some intellectual harmonization to the fields of study of our place on earth and in the universe. You know, before that, there was this little thing going on over there, and this is happening over here, and this is happening on earth. And he's saying, maybe it's all part of one thing that we might call nature. So, yeah, I mean, people like that are not as much talked about because you can't point to the one thing they discovered that changed things. But he introduced a perspective that surely had deep influence culturally.
32:54 Speaker 02 Thank you so much for inviting us to be on Startalk.
32:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, this has been great. And so, Roberta, thank you, Roberta Olson and Jay Pasachoff. And you guys and your latest book, where can we find it? I guess just Amazon or who's the publisher?
33:10 Speaker 03 His reaction in London, and it's on Amazon, and it's in many bookstores.
33:15 Speaker 02 And the University of Chicago Press is the American distributor.
33:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The American distributor, okay. So, I've been delighted to have you guys on, and maybe we can do something like this again. We'll find some other art topics that would be in desperate need of illumination by you both. Okay, so we're going to take a quick break. And when we come back, we're going to analyze the neuroscience of art or what's going on in our brains when we do art and when we think about it. When Startalk continues.
36:16 Heather Berlin? Which is active when we are sort of focused inward, when we're daydreaming, when we're mind wandering, when we're not thinking about anything specific. And that's sort of where the creative juices come from, bubble up from.
36:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh.
36:30 Chuck Nice? The default work, the default.
36:32 Heather Berlin? Default mode.
36:33 Chuck Nice? Default mode. Oh, my God. That actually sounds like a tiny little hole in the back of your neck that you stick a paper clip and it resets you to factory settings.
36:46 Heather Berlin? On a way.
36:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You've been hanging around Macintosh products too long.
36:52 Heather Berlin? I mean, that's not too far off. It's kind of like when you go back to your baseline, to your basic brain state, when you're not taking in any information from the world that can kind of muddy the waters in a way. And then you stay there for a bit, and then there's something called the salience network, another kind of activation network in the brain that tells you what's important to pay attention to at any given point in time. So it'll either tell you, you can just go back to your default mode and hang out there, or there's something happening in the environment, you should switch your focus of attention outward. And when it tells you to do that, you go into what's called the central executive network, or the executive control network, which is looking out at the environment. It's more sort of logic, reason.
37:36 Heather Berlin? But you can switch back and forth between these networks. So we find that when people are in the creative process, they're going between this default mode network where ideas are bubbling up, but then you have to do something with them. You have to enact them. You have to give them some structure. So it's almost like default mode network is like being in an unorganized sort of dream state where anything goes, you can make novel associations between ideas, that's what creativity is.
37:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Can you fly? Can I even fly?
38:00 Heather Berlin? You could even fly.
38:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thank you.
38:02 Heather Berlin? But then you have to kick in the sort of more rational, logical parts of the brain that can organize it and structure it. So the process of creativity is switching between these networks. And we find in neuroimaging studies that more creative people have more connectivity between these networks, so they can switch in and out of them quicker.
38:21 Chuck Nice? Do they, do they, do they suffer anywhere because of the greater connectivity between those two?
38:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, what, what's the cost, what's the cost of that?
38:29 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
38:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's because, because if you connect to the dream state easily, maybe you're not fully connected to the real world at times when you might need to be.
38:40 Chuck Nice? Well, at least that's what I'm hoping.
38:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Trying to account for your own state of existence.
38:48 Heather Berlin? Well, I mean, on the on the plus side, people who are creative tend to have more flexibility, more adaptability. If you were to always stay in that sort of default mode network and have trouble switching states, you would have problems, right? That's people with schizophrenia who can't get out of that kind of a state. But in terms of the relationship between sort of, let's say, mental health issues and creativity, again, that's another myth that's been debunked. There's not, it's not any more significant, there's not any more prevalence of mental health disorders in creative people compared to the rest of the population. So we like to point to these particular cases that stand out, but that's very anecdotal.
39:28 Heather Berlin? On average, artists aren't necessarily more dysfunctional than your average, you know, Wall Street guy.
39:35 Chuck Nice? I'm gonna have to look for another excuse.
39:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, so Heather, are these literal electrochemical networks in the brain? Or is this an organizing, is this an organizing sort of heuristic accounting of what we see going on?
39:57 Heather Berlin? I think it's a little of both, but it's certainly, there are these networks that we all have in our brains that are going to be either active, activated or deactivated, depending on what we're doing.
40:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, but imagine the future where you find, you know where that network is. You go with some needle and inject it with extra electrochemical nodes. And then all of a sudden, a person gets more creative. If you can actually know and identify and isolate such networks in the brain.
40:24 Chuck Nice? But I was just gonna say this. As a person who dabbles in creativity, you can actually do that kind of to yourself right now. You know, there are times when you can, I can't say make yourself more creative, but there are times that you can deepen the creative mode. There are times when you can actually do activities to place your mind to receive creativity.
40:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, Chuck, I want Heather to inject a joke into my head. Okay, that's what I want Heather. Heather, you know she's working on that.
40:59 Chuck Nice? Wait a minute, let me just say this, Neil. I want Heather to inject a joke into my head.
41:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You see behind that screen, behind her there, see that's behind that screen?
41:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Heather, a very, very serious question. Let's look at, you know, Van Gogh, of course, was an impressionist artist, but let's, let's back up a little and let's go to Leonardo. So Leonardo is illustrating perfectly human physiology in his artwork. Where is the creativity in that if he is only drawing what he sees?
41:35 Chuck Nice? Hmm.
41:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh, that was a good one, wasn't it?
41:37 Chuck Nice? Wow.
41:38 Heather Berlin? Yeah. So in a way, I wouldn't call that part of his, uh, uh, output the most creative part. The creativity was in his drawings of like flying machines and, you know.
41:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He's, he's thinking way, the way no one has thought before.
41:56 Heather Berlin? Right. Doing detailed anatomy is, is talent for sure, but I wouldn't say that is the most creative aspect of, um, Leonardo. And, and, you know, what we see is that when people are in these really highly creative states, we're seeing these differences in network activation, but then we can also pinpoint certain just like nodes within that network that if we kind of focus in on those, that maybe we could stimulate creativity or, or decrease creativity. But one of them is the dorsal lateral prefrontal cortex, which we find when it's turned down, people tend to be more creative and in these flow states. And when it's turned up, they tend to be more self-aware, self-conscious and less, um, creative. But-
42:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So by creativity, you mean a new idea?
42:40 Heather Berlin? A new idea, a new novel. So we all have access to the same information. Um, I like to use Darwin as an example. Like we all, all the scientists at the time had access to that basic data, but he kind of put that data together in a novel way, which when, when they come up with it, it seems of course obvious. It's just that nobody else had thought of that before. And so it's novel thinking, it's divergent thinking, new associations between ideas when everybody had access to the same information.
43:06 Chuck Nice? So it's so funny you say that, uh, when comedians watch each other work, the thing that they'll do is they'll sit there and they'll go, oh, that was funny. Oh, that's funny. They never laugh. And the reason is because they're watching that person make associations that they themselves did not make. And so they're thinking like, oh, wow, I didn't even look at it that way. So if, if that's the case, if his creativity is a great, has a great deal to do with associations like Darwin, same information, making new associations.
43:41 Chuck Nice? Will AI be able to be more creative than human beings? Because AI is able to make millions of associations at once.
43:52 Heather Berlin? So there, well, first of all, there's been some studies with comedians which look at amateur versus professional. Um, when they have to look at a cartoon and then the task was just come up with a novel, like, uh, you know, creative punchline to this cartoon, like a New Yorker cartoon. And, um, it takes less work for the professional comedians to activate, to come up with something. And we find that the association areas, um, are more quickly activated. So you're, you're quicker to make these associations. Now with AI, um, it's, I just recently came across this video. It was the first comedy set that was created by AI. I, I urge you to watch it. It is simultaneously awkward, yet strangely funny in a weird awkward way.
44:37 Chuck Nice? Are you sure somebody didn't just tape my set?
44:42 Chuck Nice? That sounds a lot like weirdly awkwardly funny. Yes, weirdly awkwardly funny.
44:49 Heather Berlin? In an uncomfortable, uneasy way. You know that they say that uncanny valley, right? When you are trying to create the AI thinks there's just something slightly off. That's what it's like with the comedy. But I, however, I do, I do think that after they perfected and after they, you know, keep feeding in this algorithm over and over again with self-learning processes, that they will be able to come up with these novel jokes and to rival, you know, the, the greatest comedians, so.
45:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Heather, let me ask, uh, there's been rumors that Van Gogh may have had a, uh, I don't want to say suffered from, because that places value judgment on it, but had a condition of synesthesia or chromesthesia? Uh, there's been rumors about that. I guess where you hear color. Or you smell color, where there's a cross wiring of your senses. Right, right, right.
45:39 Heather Berlin? Right.
45:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, any, um, what can you tell us about those two conditions within the human mind?
45:46 Heather Berlin? Well, chromesthesia is like a subset of synesthesia, which is sort of crossing over the senses. So sometimes people will see, um, letters as different colors or numbers as different colors. Um, and they will cross over, chromesthesia specifically, sound relating to colors. So colors will sound like something. Um, so if you imagine Van, the Dutch would say Van Hooch, but Van Gogh, uh, for the English speaking people, which I am one. Um, they imagine his painting would sound musical to him. It would be like a symphony made up of colors. Um, there's some, there's some speculation that he had this because of the letters he had written to his brother Theo.
46:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, in fact, I have a note here, it says, quoting Van Gogh, in a letter to his brother Theo. So it says here, some artists have a nervous hand at drawing, which gives their technique something of the sound peculiar to a violin.
46:41 Heather Berlin? Hmm.
46:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How could you even write that unless there was some cross wiring in your brain?
46:47 Heather Berlin? Exactly.
46:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's what I'm thinking, that's, that's what I'm thinking.
46:49 Heather Berlin? And it's not just in terms of what's happening in the brain, it's not, there's one idea that it's a sort of cross wiring. Um, another is that there is this disinhibition of feedback, so a reduction. Normally we're having lots of information coming out of the brain and parts of it have to inhibit information from crossing over. But when you lift that, um, inhibition, you can get these, you know, um, melding of senses. And you can actually induce synesthesia in people. People who have, um, certain types of strokes or temporal lobe epilepsy, or then with drugs like psychedelics. When you lift the constraints of the brain, which we normally need the constraints to be able to function.
47:31 Heather Berlin? But when you lift the constraints, that's when you can get these hallucinations and these blending of the senses. And there's a paper I read years ago, it was in the American Journal of Psychol- Psychiatry in two thousand and two. That, um, has a theory that Van Gogh actually had temporal lobe epilepsy. He was having epileptic seizures they think were induced by absinthe. Um, and those seizures might have actually been related to the um, chromosgesia. But other people are born with it too. So it could be, it's a genetic, there's a genetic, um, there's some inheritance with this as well.
48:02 Chuck Nice? So what you are really trying to tell us is that Van Gogh was high and tripping.
48:12 Heather Berlin? You might say, or others might say he just had a secret window into the reality that we all are, you know, being constrained.
48:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wow, good reply there. He, he has access to doorways that the rest of us don't. So, so is, is the transition from representational art to impressionist art, is that a creative leap? Or is it, or was, is the first artist to do that just lazy?
48:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm just wondering, I mean, I don't mean, you know, you know, I don't mean disrespect. Yeah, I don't mean any disrespect. But did they just say, I'm just gonna, you know, I'm not gonna paint every leaf on this tree.
48:54 Chuck Nice? Throw some blobs up here.
48:58 Chuck Nice? Yeah, my, my theory is that they were all nearsighted, so.
49:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, so everything was blurry.
49:04 Chuck Nice? Yeah, everything was all blurred, right.
49:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The, the nearsighted painters, painters movement, right.
49:09 Heather Berlin? You know, I dare say, and as someone who does paints and how was trained um, in, in paint, I was a fine arts minor and I painted. I do know that we have to get trained in all of the skill sets first. You have to be, you know, perfect, the actual representational before you can go into the abstract. I do think it was a creative leap because, you know, it was something new. It was something different. It was a new way to perceive the world. And now we're getting into the realm in, you know, current um, art theory where it becomes so abstract that like, you know, there was recently a sculpture that was put out there, an invisible sculpture. It's just a pedestal.
49:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I read about that. We're talking on it.
49:48 Heather Berlin? With nothing on it. And it's an invisible sculpture. And then it was crazy as another guy said, oh, you stole my idea. That was my,
49:55 Chuck Nice? My invisible.
49:56 Heather Berlin? My invisible sculpture came first.
50:00 Heather Berlin? Um, but, but it's become an attraction now where it's not even about the art. And there's still, of course, you know, realist painters out there.
50:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, wait. Did they steal that from John Cage? Who has, he has a piano sonata. Was it, it's just called four eleven or something, which is like the minutes and seconds. I forgot. There's some duration and the pianist just sits there and, and just, and yes, their hands hover over the keys and they don't do anything. And the claim is, if you do this in a theater, then the concert is basically the sound of the audience.
50:32 Chuck Nice? And the sound, right, the, the.
50:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The sound of silence is the sound of the audience rustling and, you know, clearing their throat. And so that's the acoustic version of the invisible sculpture.
50:42 Chuck Nice? And let me just say this.
50:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And Heather, what the hell part of the brain comes up with that?
50:45 Chuck Nice? Right. Well, that's some creativity and that is also, that's the, that's the greedy part. Cause you charging money, you stealing money is what you're doing.
50:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay. So Chuck, the day you can pull off a comedy act, you just stand there and with your mouth open and nothing coming out at the microphone?
51:02 Chuck Nice? Well, the people, that would make people happy, Neil.
51:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, we gotta call Heather quick on that.
51:08 Chuck Nice? Right.
51:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You gotta Heather intervention to figure out how, how that one worked. Guys are running out of time, but this has been great. Heather, thanks for bringing some neuroscientific insights to add to our artistic, our artistic and scientific insights into the mind of Vincent Van Gogh. Van Gogh, this is Merka, Jack. No, no, Van Gogh. And I'm not, I'm not hawking a Louis here.
51:32 Chuck Nice? And that's why we don't say it like that. It was just like, huh, oh, I'm so sorry. I didn't mean to spit on you. I'm so.
51:40 Heather Berlin? In the time of COVID, you no longer.
51:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In the time of COVID, right. You got it. Well, Heather, it's a delight always to have you on the show. Thanks for being such a good sport every time we call you. For our emergency neuroscientific inquiries.
51:53 Heather Berlin? I'm on call.
51:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? On call, you're, that's right. And Chuck, always good to have you. So, uh, this has been the, we now just concluded our three-part investigation into impressionist art focusing on Van Gogh. And of course, my favorite of his is The Starry Night, of course. I'm Neil deGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist. As always, I do you. Keep looking out.
52:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You.
Previous Cosmic Queries: Jiggle Wiggle Waggle Walk with Charles Liu Next Cosmic Queries– Exoplanetary Exploration with Dr. Aomawa Shields Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated