Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast Season 5 Time Capsule (Part 1) About this episode As Season 5 draws to a close, join astrophysicist Neil deGrasse Tyson in looking back at the brightest moments of a year brimming with science, comedy, urban legends, the COSMOS and even God.
Transcript 8,985 words · 16 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk, your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk Radio. I'm Neil deGrasse Tyson, your host. I'm an astrophysicist and director of New York City's Hayden Planetarium. The following show is our annual time capsule, a collection from our fifth season, selected by you, our audience, as your favorite shows of the year. First up, a conversation with the one and only Seth MacFarlane. In addition to being the writer and director of the hit TV series Family Guy and of the movie Ted, he was an executive producer for Cosmos, a space-time odyssey, the continuation of the original journey begun by Carl Sagan back in 1980, and which I had the privilege of hosting this time around. Do you remember when we met?
0:58 Speaker 01 It was at that seafood... Well, we met at the Science... That's where we discussed Cosmos.
1:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But we met...
1:04 Speaker 01 At the Science and Entertainment Exchange.
1:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Now, evidence that there's a science thread running through Family Guy is that you're like a founding advisor to the Science and Entertainment Exchange. This is crazy. It's crazy good.
1:17 Speaker 01 It's an honorary title of sorts, but...
1:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But you have to have some energy to try to join the two.
1:23 Speaker 01 Yeah, I love the idea because, you know, well, first of all, everyone in Hollywood is also very interested in science. These are people who are...
1:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And they're educated and...
1:31 Speaker 01 Yeah, they're creative by nature, curious by nature, and they want to know. They don't want to settle for what the most comfortable illusion is. They want to know what science can tell them.
1:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you and some of your pals, who else is in this...
1:42 Speaker 01 Well, Jerry and Janet Zucker founded it.
1:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, Jerry Zucker of Airplane...
1:46 Speaker 01 Airplane, Naked Gun.
1:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Naked Gun, that whole series.
1:48 Speaker 01 Top secret.
1:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it's a way for writers, producers, creative Hollywood types...
1:52 Speaker 01 To connect with scientists.
1:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? To connect with scientists. And it's a branch of the National Academy of Sciences.
1:56 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I think the thinking was that, well, look, Hollywood wants to get its science right because it just makes us look like we've done our homework. And it's in the interest of the scientific community because the entertainment industry is so widespread. And when they see a... Forensic show, or a space show, or a medical show, or a show that deals with any branch of science, audiences assume that we've all done our homework, and we almost never have. Unless you have a science consultant on staff. We've almost never done our homework.
2:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Look at the success of the sitcom The Big Bang Theory. They have a physicist on staff. Who changes the whiteboards every day with a new equation, relevant to what's going on in that show. And then it gets talked about in the blogosphere. So it's a very rich thing. To my surprise, after we had lunch one day, all you did was ask me questions about the Big Bang and the early universe. So I say, yeah, this guy's like, he's all there. Yeah, yeah. And then nothing else was spoken, and you walked away into the mist. And eight months later, six months later, Stewie visits the Big Bang in his time machine. Now, I didn't see that episode when it aired, but my cellphone started lighting up. There it was, a full-screen
3:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? credit, Neil deGrasse Tyson, "Science Consultants."
3:10 Speaker 01 I'm trying to remember, did we ask you if we could do that?
3:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, not at all.
3:14 Speaker 01 I was just, I was being extraordinarily presumptuous, trying to legitimize ourselves. This'll get the critics on our side, damn it all.
3:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But how many cartoons get to cite "science consultant"?
3:25 Speaker 01 Exactly.
3:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, it was good. I recommend anybody, you can probably get it on Netflix or wherever. It's the episode called "The Big Bang Theory." Stewie uses his time machine to go back to the Big Bang, and he's outside of the space-time continuum.
3:38 Speaker 01 Yeah.
3:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? With Brian. That was brilliant. It was brilliant. Not just because I inadvertently advised on it, but I think it was very well done. In my world, everybody's favorite scene in Family Guy is when Peter wants to become a redneck.
3:49 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
3:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And take on the culture.
3:51 Speaker 01 Yeah.
3:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Guess the hat, guess the boots, they move south, and he turns on the TV.
3:55 Speaker 01 Cosmos.
3:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Tell me what went through your head there. What is that?
3:57 Speaker 01 It's an illustration of the modern-day clash between science and religion. And I don't remember who wrote that gag, but it was in one of our cutaway rooms. We have these satellite rooms that go off the main room, and they come back with a series of gags, and we'll pick the best one. So, you know, I'm not the only Cosmos fan on that staff. I did do the voice of Carl Sagan, though.
4:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Let me hear, let me hear something, Carl.
4:18 Speaker 01 It's just a slightly, slightly altered Kermit the Frog.
4:24 Speaker 01 I feel terrible. He's one of my heroes. But it was, he had a very distinctive voice.
4:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, yeah. And so in that scene, in case you hadn't seen it, there's Carl Sagan delivering some lines from the original Cosmos, and it's edited. And Peter says, "Honey, look, it's Cosmos edited for rednecks." And he says, "In the beginning, there was the Big Bang." God.
4:45 Speaker 01 Yeah, they gotta stretch it all out, because that's...
4:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And the universe is 13 billion, 6,000...
4:54 Speaker 01 You know, it's interesting, and I do try, and I know you do as well, to try to talk about that without succumbing to the temptation to say, "Come on, there's just no evidence." I mean, the Earth cannot be 6,000 years old. It just can't. I mean, it's not a matter of your beliefs versus my beliefs. It just can't.
5:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But there aren't many cartoons that address this. That's my point. So I tip my hat to you. Our live shows are always extremely popular, and this year proved no exception. You selected Big Brains at BAM as one of the top picks of the season. Recorded live at the Brooklyn Academy of Music, my co-host Eugene Mirman and I were joined onstage that night by, get this list, Bill Nye the Science Guy, neuroscientist Dr. Heather Berlin, the actor Paul Rudd, comedian Michael Ian Black, and the star of the TV hit series Big Bang Theory, Mayim Bialik.
5:48 Speaker 02 BF Skinner's idea was that we're born sort of tabula rasa, blanksly, and you can make anybody into anything just by training, by giving them rewards and punishments and modifying their behavior accordingly. What we know now is that we're born with certain genetic predispositions to behave in certain ways, and then you can modify behavior within a range that you're given biologically. So for even something like intelligence, for example, you can be born with a genetic predisposition to be within a certain, let's say, IQ range. Then your environment can push you sort of towards the top end of that range or maybe, you know, towards the low end of that range. Then we're knowing now from mapping out the brain and looking at the genome that what seems to be most affected by the environment is the way the brain is wired. So you're born with certain genetic predisposition in terms of the structures of the...
6:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But let me just ask you. Can you teach someone math faster by giving them candy than just by teaching them? I mean, I'm just wondering...
6:35 Speaker 03 Yeah, well, actually, yeah. ...for holding them underwater and being like, "Learn it! Learn it!" And then raise... Waterboarding, I guess I'm describing waterboarding. A towel on the face, a little bottle of water, and some math.
6:50 Speaker 02 Well, we know that people discount delays with rewards. So if you give someone like a reward right away, they'll put more emphasis, they'll want that rather than waiting for a reward later.
6:58 Speaker 04 Well, I think the issue there is motivation, and not necessarily a skill set and a cognitive ability, or a technical ability. So the fact is, yes, candy makes everything better, no matter what you're trying to learn, because it's a very strong motivator, and it's a potent motivator.
7:10 Speaker 02 It might not make you better at math, but it might make you study for longer, for example.
7:14 Speaker 05 What will cocaine do for my math skills?
7:21 Speaker 03 A kid could learn French in a week on heroin.
7:27 Speaker 03 Now, that's a reward.
7:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? OK, so a little of both might help, I guess. I mean, this is the gold star that children get in elementary school, right? That's the...
7:36 Speaker 02 I mean, it does work to a certain extent. As I said, it'll help motivate behavior, but it won't give you a skill set that you don't have.
7:42 Speaker 04 Well, and I think also, as parents, it's one of the early things we learn when we're talking about how we discipline children. And waterboarding, joking aside, threats and fear and punishment and pain are very, very strong motivators to change behavior. The "do you want to condition a child with fear?" is a much larger question, which is probably not funny at all, and I won't go into it.
8:01 Speaker 02 There's positive reinforcement and negative reinforcement. There's also taking away of a positive, which can be another way to help somebody learn. So there's a whole variety of ways you can model behavior.
8:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I thought about taking away... So if someone lives with a positive, you threaten to take that away.
8:14 Speaker 03 Like a finger.
8:19 Speaker 03 Don't tell me it's not a positive.
8:24 Speaker 03 I don't have a child, so it's fine that I'm saying all this.
8:27 Speaker 05 I have two children, and it's fine that you're saying this.
8:32 Speaker 05 You see certain populations, like people from the Dominican Republic, which is such a small country, but have a large portion of people entering the major leagues of baseball. Is it because they have peer...
8:42 Speaker 04 This is such a dangerous question we know you're about to ask. It's so dangerous.
8:47 Speaker 05 I was not going into racism, although I will if you want me to.
8:51 Speaker 05 No, it was about something somebody else asked, about observing other people in peer groups ascending to higher levels, and therefore seeing firsthand what's possible. Does that make you more susceptible to those possibilities?
9:02 Speaker 04 I think that's a huge sociological, environmental, behavioral influence, but I don't know...
9:08 Speaker 05 I know, I'm writing my dissertation on it.
9:10 Speaker 04 Sorry.
9:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Have they found a gene for baseball? That's really what they're asking, right?
9:15 Speaker 02 You're born with certain genetic predispositions towards, you know, maybe better athletic prowess, but it gets dangerous.
9:21 Speaker 04 Different distribution of muscle fibers, for example, in runners.
9:24 Speaker 02 The thing we're dancing around is it can be very controversial. There was a book written called "The Bell Curve" about intelligence, and it said, "We did this whole study and looked at populations, and X number of people from a certain type of background have the highest IQ and others don't." And it really can lead to...
9:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ashkenazi Jews.
9:37 Speaker 02 It was, happened to be Ashkenazi Jews, but it was... Who have the highest IQ? Yeah.
9:45 Speaker 06 Wait, wait, me too, me too. That's right.
9:49 Speaker 07 Another factor, as a baseball fan, another very strong motivator in those countries is you can play baseball all year. I was just in Minneapolis this morning. Very challenging, and that's because the snow is white, the ball's white.
10:06 Speaker 07 And then you also have this...
10:07 Speaker 05 Now who's being racist?
10:11 Speaker 07 You also have this extraordinary motivation of money. You can make it in the big leagues. And have you ever seen the World Baseball Classic?
10:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah. Yeah, mostly Latin American.
10:20 Speaker 07 Extraordinary players.
10:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
10:22 Speaker 07 But it's one more click to hit it.
10:24 Speaker 04 I'd like to change the topic.
10:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, well, go on.
10:26 Speaker 04 To anything.
10:27 Speaker 02 To ice hockey?
10:28 Speaker 05 Let's talk about eugenics for a moment.
10:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Science that first makes you laugh and then makes you think. That's the Ig Nobel Prize in a nutshell. Comedian co-host Leigh Anne Lord and I spoke with the founder of the prize, Mark Abrams, and we learned about some unusual but highly amusing research that scientists have pursued over the years.
10:55 Speaker 08 This report is the first scientifically documented case of homosexual necrophilia in the mallard duck. Okay.
11:08 Speaker 09 My blood just ran cold. Did anybody else? Because somebody's watching this.
11:13 Speaker 08 I would be happy to give you more detail if you would...
11:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Now, how much more detail does one need than homosexual necrophilia in the mallard duck? That title has all the detail you need.
11:24 Speaker 08 Neil, it's seldom a question of need.
11:28 Speaker 08 It's a matter of desire.
11:30 Speaker 09 Yes, yes, now it's a car accident, now I gotta stop and watch.
11:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, very interesting analogy.
11:36 Speaker 08 Yeah.
11:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's rubbernecking on what's going on on the side of the road.
11:40 Speaker 09 I am indulging in my natural human instincts, I am not rising above them at this moment. I need to know about the duck.
11:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so what motivated this research?
11:50 Speaker 08 Well, first of all.
11:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Did you get to know that even?
11:52 Speaker 08 First of all, I should not exactly correct, but channel what Leanne just said. You need to know about the duck, you said. There were two ducks involved in this.
12:04 Speaker 09 Uh, yes.
12:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, the dead one and the live one, I would presume.
12:07 Speaker 08 Yes, would you like to hear the story?
12:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
12:09 Speaker 09 I have to, I'm sorry Neil, I have to.
12:11 Speaker 08 The paper was written by a man named Kees Mulikker, he's Dutch. He is the curator of a museum in the city of Rotterdam, it's the Natural History Museum in Rotterdam, a very nice museum. A few years ago, they put up a new wing with all glass walls and from the very beginning, birds every day slam into that thing, they don't see it certain times of day, depending on the light. And the people who work there got used to the, they pay very little attention, but one day Kees Mulikker was sitting there.
12:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait. So the sound of birds snapping their neck, flying into a window they don't see.
12:53 Speaker 08 They don't all snap their neck.
12:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Became the natural din of sounds in their day.
12:57 Speaker 08 If this happened several hundred times a day where you work, you would get used to it very quickly.
13:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, I would stop it from happening, I'm sorry.
13:04 Speaker 09 No, no, you would adjust, human beings adjust to all sorts of things.
13:08 Speaker 08 You would see if you could find a way to stop it, but back to the case of the, one day he was sitting there, Kees Mulikker was, and he heard an especially loud. And he was curious, so he went and he looked out the window and he saw that there was a mallard duck on the ground that pretty clearly had just slammed into the building at very high speed, broken its neck and was dead. While he was watching, a second mallard duck flew in, landed next to the dead one, and began engaging in activity with the dead one. Now, Case-
13:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Freshly dead.
13:46 Speaker 08 Yes, freshly dead if you want to think of it that way.
13:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
13:49 Speaker 08 You know, Case studies birds and he realized quite quickly, he had never heard of anything quite like this happening, so he decided to, and he did, get his notebook and his camera and he moved a little closer to that spot. He sat there taking notes while this was happening.
14:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? As any good scientist would do.
14:08 Speaker 08 Yes, or at least many. And he continued taking notes as this unfolded over the next 75 minutes.
14:16 Speaker 09 So clearly, these weren't resuscitation efforts.
14:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Apparently not.
14:22 Speaker 09 Mallard duck, mouth to mouth.
14:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Scientists from the Czech Republic, Japan, India, and the United States investigated whether it is mentally hazardous for a human being to own a cat. That got an Ig Nobel Award.
14:39 Speaker 08 Oh, yes, that was this year, 2014.
14:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? 2014.
14:42 Speaker 08 And the prize was split between two different teams, one of them based in Europe, one of them based here and in India. The Europe team is really headed by a colorful guy, you should look this guy up on the internet, he's the most interesting-looking person you have ever seen. His name is Jaroslav Flegar, F-L-E-G-R, he's from Czechoslovakia.
15:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A name like that, you gotta be interesting-looking, right?
15:07 Speaker 08 And he, for 20 or 30 years, has been looking at a particular parasite called toxoplasma that pretty commonly lives in cats.
15:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it's a natural parasite to a cat.
15:19 Speaker 08 Yeah, yep. And it's easily transmitted from cats to people who hang around the cats. And what-
15:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just to be clear, if a cat has this parasite, the cat is not sick.
15:32 Speaker 08 Right.
15:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's just normal for a healthy cat.
15:34 Speaker 08 Right.
15:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
15:34 Speaker 08 Right.
15:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Gotcha.
15:35 Speaker 08 Well, in some cases, and nobody understands why sometimes it goes one way, sometimes the other, that sometimes the cat seems to behave just like a normal cat, but sometimes because it has this parasite, the cat will start behaving in ways that are very destructive to itself.
15:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That are toxoplasmic to itself.
15:54 Speaker 08 Yes, toxoplasmosis is the disease. And sometimes, apparently, that happens to humans. And these people are now wondering, well, have been for a while, and other people, that you've heard the phrase "cat lady",
16:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
16:08 Speaker 08 of somebody who owns hundreds of cats and behaves in a very, very eccentric way, that maybe a lot of those people are infected with this parasite.
16:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Does part of the manifestation of that infection make you want to acquire more cats? Because the old cat lady never has just one cat.
16:26 Speaker 08 Well, no. Well, that's the thinking that this probably happens.
16:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So this is a way for the parasite to reproduce itself?
16:32 Speaker 08 Yep.
16:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? By getting you to want more cats that contain the parasite?
16:36 Speaker 09 I'll go with it.
16:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's a brilliant parasite.
16:38 Speaker 08 Yeah.
16:38 Speaker 09 All this time, I thought it was the cats that were in charge.
16:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's all about the parasite.
16:42 Speaker 08 And there are other parasites that behave in similar ways in other animals.
16:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so what are some of the disorders? I mean, when I think of a cat lady, they're a little odd, but a lot of odd, older people. So I never uniquely implicated the fact that it's a cat lady.
16:56 Speaker 08 It's not always a cat lady, and it's not always a lady.
16:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right.
16:59 Speaker 09 Yeah, they're crazy cat dudes.
17:01 Speaker 08 There are a whole range.
17:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Really? Wait, wait, wait. Pause. How many crazy cat dudes do you know?
17:05 Speaker 09 I'm dating. There are lots of crazy cat dudes out there.
17:09 Speaker 08 Okay, fine. And you find yourself especially attracted to?
17:15 Speaker 09 No, not at all.
17:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thank you.
17:16 Speaker 09 No.
17:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I was gonna ask that.
17:18 Speaker 09 What happens is, they hide the cat, and then I find out there's a cat.
17:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh.
17:21 Speaker 09 You know, because you don't necessarily, the first date isn't necessarily at their apartment.
17:24 Speaker 08 How does one hide a cat?
17:25 Speaker 09 Well, it doesn't, it's not, you don't lead with the cat.
17:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? She doesn't go home with the first date.
17:30 Speaker 09 Right.
17:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Every night.
17:30 Speaker 09 And it may not, it's not something they might not lead with, like, "Hi, my name is so-and-so, I have a cat." You know, that would be a little off-putting.
17:37 Speaker 08 If you've had so many bad experiences, I would expect that by now, you lead with the question, "Hi."
17:41 Speaker 09 Like, "Terry, do you have a cat?"
17:42 Speaker 08 "Hi, I find you very attractive, do you have a cat?"
17:44 Speaker 09 Not even, "Do you have a job? Is your mom crazy? Do you have a cat?"
17:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But I'm looking at these symptoms. You've got obsessive-compulsive disorders, schizophrenia, and that leads me to wonder whether these legends of cat people...
17:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? These are people with multiple personality disorders. Catwoman. You, uh, what's, uh, and the Natasha Kinsky film Cat People. Well, I, I think there are more than one version of that film. Her, the one she's in is the one I remember. These are people.
18:11 Speaker 08 I wonder why.
18:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? These are people who, who the cat manifestation interferes with their psychological state.
18:19 Speaker 08 I heard you.
18:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you think this might go way back?
18:20 Speaker 08 I heard you laugh when you first brought up this topic and now I hear you asking very good questions thinking about it.
18:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But I'm not crying yet.
18:27 Speaker 08 That's why we gave a class.
18:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'll be crying soon when it's, when we're done.
18:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome back to StarTalk Radio. I'm Neil deGrasse Tyson. In this time capsule show, we're featuring fan favorites from season five. Next up, a conversation with Anne Druyan, the co-creator, writer, director, and producer of Cosmos, a space-time odyssey. She also was one of the original writers of the original Cosmos with Carl Sagan. Hyper literate people often, to my disappointment, say, well, I was never good at science. I was never good at math.
19:20 Speaker 10 Right, right.
19:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And use that as a reason to not learn more.
19:22 Speaker 10 Right.
19:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And clearly that wasn't the case with you. So what happened there?
19:26 Speaker 10 Okay, so as a child of the sixties, I was hungry for a way to understand the world that could cut through deceit and lies. And, you know, if you think of the sixties as a moment when the great middle, including me, of the American people began to realize that they couldn't trust the government after a years of, you know, during the Second World War, whose total faith and credit, the government was beyond reproach. And in the sixties, this edifice starts to crumble. And so.
19:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? For the first time, right? In America.
19:59 Speaker 10 See, I don't know what was happening a hundred years before, but certainly in modern history. And so I was hungry for a way to know what's real.
20:10 Speaker 10 And I looked everywhere and I found it in the pre-Socratic philosophers, the ancient Greeks who invented science. And I suddenly realized, oh, Jesus, I was such an idiot. I didn't really pay attention in science when it has this error correcting mechanism that nothing else has. And so that's what attracted me to science.
20:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The urge to know the truth in anything.
20:33 Speaker 10 Nothing absolute, but just give me some truth, is John Lennon famously saying.
20:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We spend 13 episodes teaching you about the universe and why it matters and what it feels like and what it means. And then you give us a little space at the end to emote.
20:48 Speaker 10 Yeah, exactly.
20:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? By the way, there's some passages I couldn't keep a dry eye while I was reading them.
20:53 Speaker 10 I know, I was choking up. Every time I would be sitting in the editing room and the editors too, and the assistant editors.
21:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And this is a place where you hear the same damn passage 100 times in a row.
21:02 Speaker 10 100 times. People start welling up. Someone asks someone a question, there's no answer. Well, the guy sitting in there in the dark with you, what's up? And didn't you hear me? And it's like, I can't talk, I'm just gonna cry. So I feel like the case for science, which was at the nucleus of the dream of cosmos, is being made. And finally, we get to tie it all together with your amazing performance and astonishing visual effects and the script. You know, what really gets me and why we all cried, like 30 of us in this screening room who had worked on it for years, was when you let that ship go and the chair is
21:47 Speaker 10 empty. People in 180 countries around the world have seen this case for science, have seen what we have to show about the universe. The dream that all of us could be changed sufficiently so that we could awaken from our stupor and act in defense of the planet and science and demand our governments to be more scientifically aware of the needs and challenges of our planet, but also of the promise of the cosmos.
22:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Show me your file cabinet in your home. Just stories in progress that are not yet realized.
22:33 Speaker 10 Yes, I'm so thrilled. I mean, if you see Jan Ort and Edmund Halley trending in the top three subjects on Twitter, you know that you have struck a chord. And there are so many other stories. I mean, why not make heroes of the people who've brought us knowledge instead of heroes of the people who have the best stylists? Or the people who spend the most money? Or the people who have a mask?
23:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Who drive the fanciest car.
23:07 Speaker 10 Yeah, why? I mean, do we want our kids to be scientists? Or we want them to be clothes hangers? That's the question.
23:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We've had a lot of amazing guests on StarTalk over the years. But this season, we got the ultimate interview with God. Yeah, you heard me. God. I first ran across God through his "The Tweet of God" postings on Twitter. And although he's a very busy entity, he spared an hour of his time to answer some of my burning questions about life and everything else under the sun and in the universe. When were you born? And where were you born?
23:47 Speaker 11 I was born an infinite number of years ago. It was October 8th. Negative infinity.
23:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Born to whom?
23:58 Speaker 11 I was my own father. And then I never knew my mom. She left me when I was about eighty-seven trillion, so I was still very young. And has that scarred me? Some have argued it has, and perhaps it has. I don't really know. But I learned very early on that anything I was going to have in this existence, I would have to create for myself. And so that's what gave me the idea to create the universe. Because I thought if I create the universe, I'll have something that I can call my own. And I think that was important to me. That was a turning point in terms of my own self-esteem.
24:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Our best thinking today about the universe tells us that maybe this is not the only universe, that there could be a multiverse, an infinitude of other universes out there. Yet I've got you sitting next to me in a StarTalk interview in this universe. Do the other universes have their own gods?
24:53 Speaker 11 No, I am the god of all the other universes.
24:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Now, how do you even know that? Oh, I'm sorry, you're god, sorry.
24:59 Speaker 11 There are six different other universes, six universes total.
25:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But it's not infinite?
25:03 Speaker 11 No, just six. The only difference is which of the characters from Friends goes on to be the biggest star after the show. Everything else is exactly the same, but in one universe, Lisa Kudrow is the big star, in one, David Schwimmer is the biggest star, in another one, Jennifer Aniston's the biggest. So those are the only six universes that there are.
25:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How about the laws of physics within those universes?
25:25 Speaker 11 Oh, same, same.
25:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Same? Yeah. That's no fun.
25:28 Speaker 11 I settled on these constants for a good reason. Every mathematical constant in the universe is there for a good reason.
25:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because we've got the speed of light, that's a good one. That one is same everywhere. We've got Planck's constant, the gravitational constant.
25:40 Speaker 11 Yes.
25:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Why not experiment with some more?
25:43 Speaker 11 I'm very happy with those. By the way, it's not just mathematical constants, there's also other, well, Murphy's Law. That's a constant. That's a constant as much as any of the ones you mentioned. Anything that can go wrong will, that is a universal law.
25:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What's with the commandments? Why are there only 10? I keep thinking we need more instructions than that.
26:05 Speaker 11 There should only be one commandment, really. And the only commandment that was necessary, and I realize this too late, is just quit being a dick. That's the one commandment, that's really the only essential one for life. Just quit being a dick. And looking back, that's the one I would have.
26:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And that covers all of them.
26:25 Speaker 11 That covers all of them in its way. I believe, when loosely interpreted, the quit being a dick rule will cover any moral situation.
26:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In this live show, recorded at Sketch Fest in San Francisco, Bill Nye the Science Guy sits in for me, along with co-host Eugene Mirman and comedian Dave Foley, where they talk about the possibilities of alien life, with SETI astronomer Seth Shostak.
26:54 Speaker 07 Astronomers have been looking at the heavens for a long time. You guys have been looking at the heavens for 60 years. Is that accurate? 50-something years? Mm-hmm. And you haven't heard a thing? And this gets back to Fermi's paradox. If they're out there, why haven't you heard from them?
27:11 Speaker 12 Well, I don't know if everybody in the audience knows Fermi's paradox, unless they're related to the guy. But Fermi was having lunch with a couple of physicists, and at some point, between two bites of a tuna fish sandwich, he says, "So where is everybody?" And he wasn't referring to the lack of company at the lunch. What he was referring to was the fact that the time that it would take to colonize the galaxy, if that's on your agenda. If you're the Klingons and you decide you want to colonize the galaxy, and even if your rockets aren't all that fast, but if you stay at it, you can do it in, you know, a few tens of millions of years, maybe 30, 40, 50 million years.
27:43 Speaker 07 It's like that.
27:44 Speaker 12 That's a long time. Yeah, that's a long time for you waiting for a bus from San Francisco. But that's not very long compared to the age of the galaxy. So what he was saying is, if there really are advanced societies out there, some of them, one of them, would have colonized the entire galaxy by now. We see no evidence of that, and that's why I said, "So where is everybody?", at which point he let the subject drop. And ruined lunch.
28:08 Speaker 07 You guys, it's extraordinary, but it's not crazy to suggest that life started on Mars when Mars was very wet. And then they got hit with an impactor. I mean, I'm sure it was excited also.
28:26 Speaker 03 You are all a bag of perverts!
28:32 Speaker 07 I didn't know science was so dirty.
28:35 Speaker 03 Any chance, any, tiny!
28:40 Speaker 07 That's your problem.
28:42 Speaker 03 Yes, I know!
28:43 Speaker 07 Okay, so, this thing is, uh, it gets hit with an impactor, three billion years ago. Stuff's thrown into space, it gets in, a few bits of it get in this extraordinary mathematical thing called a home in orbit, yeah? And, except it's in outer space, so it goes, and lands on the Earth. And you and I are somehow descendant from a Martian microbe. And let me just say, it would be an extraordinary discovery about the course of events. It would really be something. And so, along this line, if we are all descended from a common ancestor, which seems a reasonable conclusion when you look at your DNA and all those, uh, the primitive life forms, like, anyone?
29:28 Speaker 07 My old boss?
29:31 Speaker 03 Ted Cruz!
29:34 Speaker 07 And so, so, it is another question, though, could have life started a second time, or the time before us, here on Earth? And it's, if we just had the right place to look, we would find the so-called second genesis. We are the aliens we're looking for.
29:53 Speaker 03 Boom!
29:57 Speaker 07 And that theory has, is called, what is it called? Second genesis? No, this theory that, that life came here from, uh, from space. Pan-fermia. Trans-fermia. I know!
30:15 Speaker 07 We have, we have modern telescopes. And people look out there and they, they observe planets. And they can infer from here that these places are probably inhabitable. But what does it take to be habitable?
30:29 Speaker 12 Well, that's actually a good question because all we know is what it takes for life like our own to be habitable. So you have to start there because you don't have any other data points. But that means, yeah, maybe something to breathe, but not necessarily. I mean, if you dug a hole one mile deep here, it'd take you all night. But if you did that and you pulled up the muck at the bottom and put it under a microscope, you'd see, you know, microbes.
30:50 Speaker 07 That don't need air to breathe.
30:52 Speaker 12 They don't need air. They don't need, they don't need sunlight, no photosynthesis. I mean, they're alive, but they're down there. So, there's no good definition of life, right? You might think of Justice Potter talking about pornography. "I'll know it when I see it." Life is kind of the same way, right?
31:05 Speaker 03 It can definitely high-five. I think we can all kind of agree that it's not life if it can't go "Yeah!" But what else? And you know what? And if, and if it leaves you hanging, it is dead to me.
31:24 Speaker 03 Other than, of course, high-fives, what are some of the, what are some of ways that you could categorize something being alive?
31:30 Speaker 12 It's, it's actually quite hard to do. I mean, you can see, if you pick up your 10th grade biology book, if you still have that, and you open it up, it starts out with a definition of, "Well, life has metabolism and life reproduces."
31:41 Speaker 07 Homeostasis.
31:42 Speaker 12 There's all this stuff. Yeah, whatever.
31:44 Speaker 07 Keeps itself.
31:45 Speaker 12 But it, you know, you can, you can think of examples of things that fit the definition but aren't alive, right? Things like mules, they don't reproduce, it turns out. But they're, you wouldn't, you know, contest the fact that they're alive, right? Fire reproduces, but it's not alive. So there's no good definition for life. The current working definition? If it evolves in a Darwinian fashion. What?
32:06 Speaker 03 That isn't even true.
32:09 Speaker 12 Probably not.
32:10 Speaker 07 What if it's in a Freudian fashion or?
32:12 Speaker 12 Yeah. So that makes it hard to build an experiment to look for life.
32:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome back to StarTalk Radio. I'm Neil deGrasse Tyson. This time capsule show is a collection of fan favorites from season five and one of your favorite interviews with Cassini imaging scientist Carolyn Porco. She's not only responsible for that mission's stunning images of my favorite planet Saturn and its many moons, but she has a compelling life story that resonated with many of you. So how early did you know you wanted to do this?
33:07 Speaker 13 So I got into astronomy the backdoor. I was attracted more from my spiritual questioning when I was just a young teenager. I was like 13 going on 80. And I was thinking things like, what am I doing here? What is the meaning of life? You know, I was probably very depressed. That's probably why I was thinking these things.
33:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you had existential angst at age 13?
33:30 Speaker 13 I had enormous existential angst.
33:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That is the beginning of a troubled teenage.
33:33 Speaker 13 I know. And I read about Hinduism. I read about Buddhism. I read about...
33:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you were totally messed up?
33:40 Speaker 13 I was totally messed up. I even for a while got very, very serious about my religion, Catholicism. And for a period of about four months, I went to church like four times a week and I did all the indulgences.
33:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you're still around 13?
33:53 Speaker 13 Yeah. And I thought that just didn't cut it for me. I even did read about existentialism and that was really depressing. But, you know, thinking about what is the meaning of life? And, you know, who am I? Where am I? Got me thinking, all right, where am I? Well, you know, where is where?
34:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Beyond just being in the Bronx.
34:11 Speaker 13 Yeah, really.
34:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If you ask anyone, you're in the Bronx right now, man.
34:15 Speaker 13 The ultimate existential question, is there anything outside the Bronx? So I started reading about the universe and about galaxies and stars and so on. And that's how I became interested in astronomy.
34:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's the first that I've ever heard.
34:29 Speaker 13 Well, you know, most males, I don't know if this worked for you, most males seem to get interested in astronomy by doing things like grinding lenses and building telescopes. I was never a tinkerer. I was a seeker. That's how I described myself. I was a seeker. And I thought the answers to the question of the meaning of life, you know, lay in the universe.
34:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So if this were a few thousand years ago, you could have been a prophet.
34:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Think about it, because if you're young and you're having these kinds of questions, most adults don't even think that way. So you would have been labeled as someone with a search for wisdom, and then you'd acquire it and share it with others.
35:03 Speaker 13 And they probably would have like hung me for it.
35:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, burned you. You're a girl. They burn girls and they hang boys.
35:08 Speaker 13 They hang boys, they burn girls. This woman, her name was Carolyn Neathammer, wrote, "I thought a very good article about me." It was the Scientist at Work series in the New York Times.
35:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And what year is this now?
35:21 Speaker 13 1999.
35:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, that's not that long ago. It's not like in the 80s or the 70s.
35:26 Speaker 13 No. It was done to be coincidental with Cassini's flyby of Earth, which happened in 1999. And then, you know, there was a lot of hoopla about whether or not the radioactive material on Cassini was going to destroy the Earth.
35:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it flew by Earth to gain some extra orbital energy to get out to Saturn?
35:41 Speaker 13 Yes. That's exactly right. That's exactly right.
35:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because you didn't have enough fuel to get it there on its own?
35:45 Speaker 13 No.
35:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You had to like borrow orbital energy?
35:47 Speaker 13 Oh, we borrowed a lot. We're in debt after all these years.
35:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah. So what planets did you take orbital energy from?
35:53 Speaker 13 We took it from Venus twice, would you believe?
35:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Twice? Oh, poor Venus.
35:56 Speaker 13 Poor Venus. It's still there, though.
35:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's still there, alright.
35:59 Speaker 13 And one from Earth. And then we slipped closely by Jupiter. That really helped a lot.
36:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, of course. Yeah, alright. And that got you to Saturn. Alright, sorry. But we digress.
36:08 Speaker 13 So August 1999, this article is being written, and the woman says truthful things, good things and bad things or whatever, and she submits it to her editors, and they come back and say, "Find out why Porco's not married." And I said to her, "You see? I told you so. I knew this kind of thing was going to happen because I knew they would be very sexist."
36:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, it's not only not married, but never married.
36:31 Speaker 13 Never married.
36:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's the real issue. There are plenty of not-married people who have been.
36:34 Speaker 13 Yeah. How old was I then? I was 40-something.
36:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In your 40s, okay.
36:38 Speaker 13 Yeah. So I gave her two responses to use because I was kind of pissed. The first answer was something like, "Well, just tell them I have a different man every night and I like it that way."
36:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
36:48 Speaker 13 You know? And then the other answer was, "There are no high-maintenance items in my house of any kind, pets, plants, or husbands." And Carolyn Neathammer, in her discretion, used that one.
37:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? She used the second one rather than the first one.
37:01 Speaker 13 Yeah. And actually, I got a lot of fan mail from that. People write to me, "Oh, my 17-year-old daughter thought that was the greatest thing she ever heard. My advanced age, there are still no high-maintenance items in my house of any kind, pets, plants, or husbands."
37:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What's this about you trying to get everybody to smile?
37:18 Speaker 13 Ah, that was probably the greatest thing I've ever done. I think...
37:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We'll be the judge of that, okay?
37:26 Speaker 13 Well, let me back up. There have been other pale blue dot pictures taken by other missions, right? Mars missions probably took many pictures of the Earth from Mars orbit.
37:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, because Earth shows up in the Martian sky.
37:37 Speaker 13 Yeah, and people, of course, they got moved by the first pale blue dot. They wanted to do it over again, too. So I'm thinking, not only would ours be even more gorgeous, because we're going to see Saturn in the field with Earth...
37:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Saturn is unimpeachably beautiful in any shot.
37:51 Speaker 13 Right. But I thought, wouldn't it be fabulous if in...well, let me back up. In all those previous...
37:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is the second time you've backed us up. I don't know where I am now.
38:02 Speaker 13 In all those previous pale blue dot images, the picture was taken, and then afterwards, people were told, "Look, here was the Earth taken three weeks ago." And I'm thinking, well, why don't we tell people in advance, "Your picture is going to be taken from the outer solar system from a billion miles away." And I wanted to use this as an opportunity for people having a communal feeling with the universe.
38:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is the spiritual side of you showing up?
38:28 Speaker 13 It is, I'm sorry.
38:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're going up.
38:30 Speaker 13 And I thought it would be just fantastic. People could feel a sense of unity with the cosmos. They could feel a sense of unity with their fellow human. And they could also appreciate, at that moment, their pictures being taken from a billion miles away. How better to let them know how far humans have come in the exploration of the solar system. It becomes something personal to them.
38:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you're telling me you actually got people to go outside and look up at Saturn in the sky and smile at it?
38:58 Speaker 13 Well, I...no, no, here, even the people on the other side of the planet smiled, because the idea was to smile in celebration, to get this communal feeling out of people, this kind of cosmic love. I was after cosmic love.
39:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Where were you in the 60s? We needed you there.
39:14 Speaker 13 What do you mean? I was about 16 years old, smoking dope. What were you doing?
39:19 Speaker 13 I can say that now, because it's legal in my state.
39:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Colorado, yeah, you're from Colorado.
39:24 Speaker 13 So anyway, I was after cosmic love and it worked and I was so proud.
39:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There was quite the social media attention given to it in blogs and in the Twitter streams.
39:33 Speaker 13 It ended up not being announced as early as I would have liked. We should have done it a year ahead for various reasons I won't go into. It didn't get announced until a month ahead, so there wasn't really as big a campaign and as big an announcement as I would have liked. But nonetheless, we got comments from people that were just beautiful. People saying, "My God, I've never felt a feeling like this." You know, for once, I felt so united with everybody around the globe. And one person wrote, "You know, darn it, we may be floating around on a dustmote. We may be transient, but for 15 minutes, we were there, we were aware, and we smiled." And that's exactly the kind of feeling I wanted people to have.
40:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's beautiful.
40:13 Speaker 13 Oh, thank you, Neil. And I have to say this. For me, it was the same thing. I mean, I'm the one who started this whole thing, but the 15 minutes that it was happening, and I'm looking where Saturn is, and I'm thinking, "Wow, there's a camera there taking our picture." And knowing that people all over the world were doing the same thing, it was fabulous. It was so fabulous. So I'm pretty pleased with the way it turned out. By the way, I called the whole event "The Day the Earth Smiled" because that's what it was.
40:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And that photo made page one of the New York Times.
40:45 Speaker 13 Oh, man, was that cool.
40:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Back on November 13th, 2013.
40:49 Speaker 13 November 13th?
40:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? 13/11/13.
40:51 Speaker 13 That was the very day that I got the phone call from NASA headquarters that I was made the imaging team leader. Is that cosmic or what?
40:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The day of the year, not, I mean, in what year?
40:59 Speaker 13 1990.
41:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? 1990, okay. So there is cosmic alignment.
41:02 Speaker 13 Cosmic love and alignment, Neil. Right here on your show.
41:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We're wrapping up our season five Time Capsule Show with Adam Savage and Jamie Heineman, stars of the hit TV show Mythbusters.
41:18 Speaker 14 Actually, we were hired talent at the beginning. We had nothing to do with the pitch for Mythbusters. I won't say that we had nothing to do with the creation.
41:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you were pretty faces, is what you're saying?
41:28 Speaker 15 Well, it was just a job, you know, we gotta pay the rent.
41:31 Speaker 14 Somebody contacted Jamie, said, "Do you wanna do this show called Mythbusters?"
41:35 Speaker 15 And I'm like, "Like, that's ever gonna happen." But just as a matter of principle, I went ahead and tried it, because you gotta try things, or you're never gonna... Tried, you mean, screen test, or you tried it?
41:43 Speaker 14 Well, actually, yeah, so he called me up and said, "Listen, I got this call from Discovery about this thing. I don't think I could do it on my own, but you're a ham, so you wanna shoot a demo reel together?"
41:52 Speaker 15 I had to think of who's a ham that I know, but also somebody that's good at doing what we do, because it wasn't just about talking, it was about replicating urban legends, and the fact that we were guys that build things was part of this premise, that we would actually replicate these things. So you become a participant in the test, not just an observer of something, some other effort?
42:12 Speaker 14 Exactly, and in terms of, you know, being freelancers, where we're always trying to look at what the next avenue is, I had actually just bought a laptop, the first power book that you could edit digital video on, and I was teaching myself...
42:23 Speaker 15 Way back in the day.
42:24 Speaker 14 Way back, the Pismo, and I was teaching myself digital video editing. And so when Jamie called, I had all the equipment necessary, and we shot what ended up being a 14-minute demo reel, and they ended up kind of building the backbone of the show off of that demo reel.
42:36 Speaker 15 So you got to shape the profile of the show based on how you expressed your talents?
42:40 Speaker 14 No one told us that we had done that for several years.
42:43 Speaker 15 Yeah, well, and you also have to understand a little bit of the background. Adam and I, we're not exactly friends, but in fact, we don't get along very well at all.
42:52 Speaker 14 In 21 years, we've never had dinner alone together.
42:54 Speaker 15 Yeah, but we have common interests, and I would call Adam up and, "Come down and check this out." I'm tinkering in the shop on the weekend.
43:01 Speaker 14 We were professionally interested in what each other was doing.
43:04 Speaker 15 Yeah.
43:06 Speaker 14 The third time, we revisited the rocket car. It's an original Darwin Award myth, where a guy strapped a military Genesee to take off rocket to his Impala, and supposedly flew a mile through the air, embedded into a mountain, and they pulled his teeth out of the wreckage to identify him. That was actually our very first episode of Mythbusters.
43:22 Speaker 15 So you wanted to redo that?
43:23 Speaker 14 Well, we did it first, like, 10 years ago.
43:25 Speaker 15 Yeah, that's something I wanna do.
43:27 Speaker 14 Then we did it a second time, where we got these really powerful rockets that blew up on the stand. So we spent 20 grand on these rockets. Everything we did worked perfectly, the rockets blew up. Took us another five years to give us discovery, to fork over enough dough to do it for real. And this time, we did two launches last summer in the Mojave Desert. One with a car hitting a bump in the road and the other with a real straight-up ramp. But why is that interesting? Sure, I put rockets on my car, I fly. Well, there's two things to this. The first- It's the car's version of a jetpack. Essentially, except that rockets aren't shaped like cars for a very good reason. And so, the first time we did it, we put the normal J dough amount of power on the car, and it only accelerated the car to 150 miles an hour. And traditionally, on Mythbusters, when we get to a place like that, we want to find out what would it take to replicate
44:11 Speaker 14 the behavior that is stated in the myth? To get the car to accelerate to 350 miles an hour and fly perhaps roughly a mile through the air. 350 miles an hour, you go backwards in time. With the red shifting. Marty! So then we- It's the flux capacitor. The math said to get the car up to that speed, and we attempted to balance correctly using, you know, model rocketry formulas to get the rockets in the right place. The question is, is if you have the car balanced, and the rockets in the right place, and they have enough power, will they actually make the car fly straight and true? And that was the answer we hadn't fully come to as the second part of the story. That was half of the design concern in the Apollo era. Have you have a straight rocket, how do you point it? How do you aim it?
44:54 Speaker 15 Yeah, well, we, of course, could have gone to a place where we start to add fins and do other things to this car.
45:01 Speaker 14 We get people that say, "Why don't you just put fins on the thing or wings?" And we say, "That's a car-shaped rocket. We want a rocket car." Gotcha. For us, there's an ethical difference. Your formula said that you'd be able to fly at 350 miles an hour? Yes, according to the amount of rocket power. So, did it? It never really got to chance to.
45:20 Speaker 15 They were so unstable that they-
45:22 Speaker 14 So, the answer is no? The answer is no. Say no. Let me hear you say it. Did it work? The scientist even wants to say, "I guess on an infinitely straight track, maybe, but with us, going off a bump in the road, it's too unstable, and they bounced after about 300 feet."
45:35 Speaker 15 They did what I was talking about, which is they interact with the ground rather quickly.
45:39 Speaker 14 You guys have a whole euphemistic vocabulary.
45:43 Speaker 15 The other favorite term is catastrophic failure.
45:46 Speaker 14 That is my favorite engineering term.
45:48 Speaker 15 Yeah, we use that all the time on the show.
45:50 Speaker 14 Or, in rocket propulsion lore, there are rocket launches that succeed, and others that are rich in learning opportunities.
45:59 Speaker 14 What is the weirdest urban legend that turned out to be true? Elephants are afraid of mice. No, don't say that. We were in South Africa filming with sharks and bad weather kept us off. Wait, because everyone for Discovery Channel has to do sharks at some point. Yeah, we've done Shark Week twice. Three times. This is rice of passage. Oh, yeah, but bad weather kept us off the water, which was a disaster from a production standpoint. So we went in inland and thought, well, let's just produce five minutes of filler. Let's do elephants are afraid of mice. So we found someone with some mice. We found a nature preserve with some sad elephants and we set up a procedure.
46:33 Speaker 15 We got a big ball of dung. Elephant turds are like basketballs and we hollowed out a space in the bottom of the turd.
46:39 Speaker 14 Big enough for a very unhappy mouse.
46:41 Speaker 15 Yeah, one very unhappy mouse in there, tied monofilament onto it and went hid behind a bush. And the people at the game reserve opened the fence. They knew.
46:49 Speaker 14 Elephants walk on paths that are predictable.
46:51 Speaker 15 Yeah. And we thought this was a fluff piece. The elephant's not going to be able to see what the little mouse or.
46:56 Speaker 14 We thought our biggest problem was going to be what do we do when the elephant steps on the mouse? Do we film it? Show it? It's Bambi meets Godzilla.
47:03 Speaker 15 Yeah. So the elephant comes out on cue and darned if it didn't come screeching to a stop once the mouse came out.
47:11 Speaker 14 A cartoon.
47:11 Speaker 15 Yeah. And it very carefully, almost tiptoed.
47:14 Speaker 14 No. Totally, totally, totally. No.
47:17 Speaker 15 And.
47:17 Speaker 14 Like Disney style tiptoeing around a mouse. So then we're thinking, well, maybe the elephant's never seen its own dung roll by its own accord. Maybe it's afraid of its dung. So we removed the mouse. We had another elephant come through. We moved the dung. Elephant didn't do a darn thing.
47:31 Speaker 15 Yeah. And then we repeated.
47:32 Speaker 14 This is the control that you're trying to put into the thing. We posited that that must be a control. Then we added another mouse and did it with a different elephant.
47:39 Speaker 15 And the same thing happened.
47:40 Speaker 14 Got the same. So it wasn't just a neurotic? Not a neurotic elephant. We did have, and this is another thing that I love. We were doing an appearance at a college a few years ago and this eight-year-old girl raised her hand. She was like, I wanted to know why you used a white mouse in the experiment. Elephants are afraid of mice because they're not very natural. And why didn't you use a more natural colored mouse? And I said, you're absolutely right. It's because we weren't thinking far enough ahead. We thought we were doing a fluff piece and we were just wanted something that was bright on camera. She was all over that story. She was totally all over it. More power to her. A future scientist. We failed.
48:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You've been listening to StarTalk Radio. I'm Neil deGrasse Tyson, and as always, I bid you to keep looking up.
Previous Extended Classic: Cosmic Queries: Pseudoscience, now with Elise Andrew of IFLS and Bill Nye Next Season 5 Time Capsule (Part 2) Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated