Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast Science and Journalism, with Christiane Amanpour About this episode Neil deGrasse Tyson explores the intersectionality of science and journalism with CNN’s Christiane Amanpour, Eugene Mirman, reporter Azmat Khan, conflict journalism expert Judith Matloff, Bill Nye, Sarah Rose Siskind, Natalia Reagan, and Brian Sack.
Thanks to this week’s Patrons for supporting us:
Paul Sikes, Stephanie Judd, Michael McBride, François Fraser, Dan Yoder, John Ward
NOTE: StarTalk+ Patrons and All-Access subscribers can listen to this entire episode commercial-free.
Photo Credit: Brandon Royal
Transcript 8,134 words · 10 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? From the American Museum of Natural History in New York City, and beaming out across all of space and time, this is Star Trek: Where Science and Pop Culture Collide.
0:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to the Hall of the Universe. I'm your host, Neil deGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist, and tonight, we're featuring my interview with celebrated international news correspondent, Christiane Amanpour. So let's do this!
0:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, my co-host tonight, comedian Eugene Mirman. Eugene!
0:41 Eugene Mirman? Hello!
0:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You voiced the prank-loving, middle-child Gene on the animated series Bob's Burgers on Comedy Central. You've been doing that from the get-go?
0:50 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
0:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, thanks for coming back. Also joining us for this topic, we've got investigative journalist, Azmat Khan. Azmat, welcome!
1:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're a visiting professor on First Amendment issues at Columbia University. You're also a contributor to the New York Times Magazine and PBS Frontline. Christiane Amanpour, she's a chief international anchor for CNN, and she's host of "Amanpour and Company" on PBS. And she's covered news and conflict around the world for more than 30 years.
1:22 Eugene Mirman? That's a lot of conflict.
1:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, Christiane stopped by my office recently, and I asked her if learning math and science might have influenced her approach as a journalist. So let's check it out.
1:38 Speaker 02 I'm quite an ordered person. And I do think that if you understand maths and science, and you understand the order of that kind of scientific endeavor, it sort of helps. I think I need order to situate myself in the world of chaos that somehow I found myself in, whether it's in my own particular life of living through an Iranian revolution. I mean, that was my first major chaotic disruptive event. And whether it's... Being a war correspondent in the midst of all sorts of other people's chaos and violence and disorder and disruption, whether it's in today's political environment, which is chaotic and disruptive. I crave order and I think science, to an extent anyway, the way I interpret it,
2:23 Speaker 02 is quite orderly. There are formulas, there are procedures, there's evidence, there's fact. And again, for me, jumping all the way forward, the fact and the evidence and the science is especially important today when everything that we see and hear and touch and feel is in question. I mean, people want to question the color of the sky. So evidence has always been something incredibly important for me. But I hope that what I've also learned to do along the way is do that thing where you mix humanity with science. Because it's not just facts, it's also, I mean, it is, that's the, that's the, you know, the construct around what we're doing. But then you put people's humanity into it and you put people's emotions and you put,
3:06 Speaker 02 you know, the real stories of what individuals are going through in these stories that you're telling and these reports that you are, you know, being able to broadcast and communicate. And that's what makes the whole.
3:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, Asma, have you reported from conflict zones?
3:23 Speaker 03 Yes, from Afghanistan, Iraq and elsewhere.
3:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So how do you make order out of that kind of chaos? Or does order matter to you?
3:31 Speaker 03 It does. I think it's about getting local. So even before I hit the ground, I try to learn as much as I can about a place, its context, its history, the language if possible, and...
3:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I would think that's what any journalist should do, but I don't think they do. When you say you learn the language, meaning?
3:47 Speaker 03 I try my best to learn as much of it as possible. I mean, I studied abroad when I was young. I, when I moved to Pakistan, I, even though I grew up speaking Urdu, I hired a tutor to make sure that I was learning, you know, I knew how to say "oil rig" or whatever obscure bizarre thing I wasn't maybe used to saying or knowing or wouldn't understand otherwise.
4:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that would make others who you talk to more comfortable around you?
4:09 Speaker 03 It makes, it also is...
4:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're less far into them.
4:10 Speaker 03 You're more also aware of your surroundings. You're not necessarily always relying on a translator, which, which is okay. But you try to do as much as you can to get local. And in that, you start to see that order and you start to distill the facts and information you're learning in a way that can really resonate with the public.
4:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So do you agree that sort of science or its methods and tools, or at least the principles, can help bring order to that world?
4:36 Speaker 03 Absolutely. In fact, most investigative reporters rely on similar scientific methodologies, even if we maybe coat them in a narrative or a story or use something that might be a little bit more accessible to the public, but we're relying on similar methods of inquiry.
4:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Jean, you think science brings order?
4:54 Eugene Mirman? Well, it does to everything but your desk, Neil.
4:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, that is my desk, but I know where everything is in that desk. So just because it looks like it's disorder to you, it is order to me.
5:07 Eugene Mirman? I don't believe you.
5:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, so here's my question. Let's get back to the First Amendment. That has several things. The journalists can do their thing, free speech. So isn't saying the sky is not blue free speech? So why should any of us care?
5:24 Speaker 03 It's free speech. And of course, curiosity is one of the greatest traits, not just of journalists, but of people as a whole in any kind of democratic society. But that said, questioning when it's genuine, right? When it's an effort to learn the truth, whatever that truth might be, is very different from setting out on a journey in which you already know where you want to end, right? There's a difference between curiosity and being ideologically driven.
5:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? One is genuine curiosity to find an actual truth. Another one is disregard for what is true because you think you have the truth and whatever else is going out there doesn't matter. You will stitch together whatever thread so that it agrees with you.
6:07 Speaker 03 Right, when you have an end in mind and you're not really looking at the facts in front of you.
6:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Isn't that what most people in the world do?
6:14 Speaker 03 I think we're increasingly living in a world of confirmation bias, of echo chamber, in which we're following people we agree with, we're paying attention to news sources we agree with. It's an incredible danger.
6:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Christiane says that that good journalism is not just the facts, but brings humanity to the facts. So how would you do that as an investigative journalist?
6:37 Speaker 03 It's often narrative, right? So I'll have...
6:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Are you at risk of me thinking you are putting too much emotional layering onto it? And I'm gonna say, just give me the facts? What's the risk of that?
6:50 Speaker 03 Very few people want just the facts. I have to work very hard to fit those facts into a narrative that people will read. They'll wanna flip through, that they'll get to that section that might be, you know, the big, the data finding about schools in Afghanistan that the US funded, and whether and how many of them actually exist today, or whatever it might be. But you have to get them to get into character. They have to find people who come alive on that page or in that film.
7:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it's not just gathering the facts. You now have, because of the homework you do before you arrive on location, you have a context in which, you have a substrate in which you can embed the facts.
7:27 Speaker 03 You're always looking for drivers of that narrative that fit what the facts show you.
7:33 Eugene Mirman? Maybe more people would believe in climate change, that it was real and man-made if we gave them a list of people who are going to drown from it.
7:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, okay. Let's just make it more real.
7:43 Eugene Mirman? Just trying to connect.
7:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thanks for these helpful points here.
7:47 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, yeah. I think that's what we're missing.
7:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right. Well, I asked Christiane how she deals with finding facts in any situation. Let's check it out. You're confronted with people who are making news, important people, and some of them are just completely clueless.
8:08 Speaker 02 Well, I try not to be judgy because I don't believe that's what journalists should be. Journalists should be based in the fact-based world, the scientific world, so to speak, the evidence-based world. And I have, in fact, spent my career, not as a pundit, or as an opinion maker, or as an anchor, but as a correspondent in the field. So I had to come back with the minute details, observing them, remembering them, recording them, repeating them. And I just, that's what I like. That's natural to me. That's the only way to do it. Because if you just... Guess and pull sort of threads from the atmosphere. I mean, I know artists and others, you know, the creativity. That's not me.
8:52 Speaker 02 I'm really based in fact. And that, I think, is what has stood me in quite good stead as our environment becomes less and less respectful of the facts, as science becomes less and less respected and adhered to, as people, as I say, try to question the color of the sky amidst many, many other things. I mean, let's say the idea of climate change and all those things which we're living through right now. For me, it's very frustrating to see, because I've also, because of science, never drawn a factual, a false factual equivalence between things. So I've never been the kind who believes that there's ever been this, on the one hand, on the other hand, about science, because of course they're deniers, but they are a very small minority of the scientific community.
9:36 Speaker 02 And I've always been staggered by how that very small minority was able to have an oversized effect on public consciousness, on politics, on all that goes around climate change. And I was just listening just recently to this tragedy of how, you know, more than 50 years ago, we could have arrested climate change. We could have started and got a grip on it if the great NASA scientist, James Hansen, and the others who were working and warning at the time, had been believed. Instead of had a group of professional deniers decided to muddy the waters, and look where we are today.
10:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, Asma, we know from research and psychology that a person is more likely to be swayed or taken in by a story that resonates with their pre-existing bias. So you do something legit. Somebody else finds a thread that agrees with someone's bias, and rather than have the evidence matter. And so, what do you, how do you, how do we resolve this? Not only as a consumer of journalism, but journalists themselves. How do you address the fact that there are other journalists presenting disinformation and people as well? Journalists and people.
10:56 Eugene Mirman? Journalisty people?
10:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Journalists and journalist-y people.
11:00 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
11:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Trying to put disinformation about climate change as an example.
11:04 Speaker 03 Right. So in this case, I think that it often comes down to finding characters that they might, that might resonate with them. So depending on who the sort of, if you were to look at the demographics of deniers, and to understand maybe some of the communities they come from, right? And you're looking at a climate challenge, or looking at whether it's a weather phenomenon, or something else, and some kind of a problem, whether that's a flood, or something else, and really telling a story well about what happened to an individual person. And that, that is one way to do it. Another is to speak in their terms, right? Use language that doesn't necessarily completely veer them away from what you're doing, because it rings of, you know, what they associate with people who
11:49 Speaker 03 are climate pushers.
11:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So what you're, not to put words in your mouth, but are you suggesting that in the case of the disinformation people, you should study them the way you would study any other culture?
12:00 Speaker 03 I think you should.
12:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How to get in and to be able to communicate.
12:03 Speaker 03 Well, I think journalists in that case should actually be, should actually be doing, doing stories on climate deniers. They should actually try to investigate the lobby in place, understand how they put out that disinformation. And the PBS series Frontline did a great film called Climate of Denial that did just that, looking at these deniers. Now, the question is, how do you get people to pay attention to that? And that's really where narrative and good storytelling come into play.
12:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it's an antidote to bad journalism, basically?
12:33 Speaker 03 It's true.
12:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Eugene.
12:35 Eugene Mirman? Yeah?
12:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Have you seen bad journalism out there?
12:37 Eugene Mirman? I've, I've seen it, and I thought I'd actually create a test for our expert, and to watch this clip and see how many examples
12:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A test, okay, okay, sure.
12:44 Eugene Mirman? of bad journalism she can see in this clip.
12:47 Speaker 04 Breaking news, this just in. We are hearing reports that Russia is planning on launching a missile at the United States. We go to Brian Fingerbottom on the scene. Brian, how likely is Russia to follow through with these attacks?
13:00 Speaker 05 Well, I'm not going to speculate, Sarah, but it's 32.2% likely. Here's a graph showing a correlation in the decrease of Russian missile attacks and an increase in graphs on TV.
13:12 Speaker 04 And where are you getting these numbers from, Brian?
13:14 Speaker 05 We got most of our numbers from India sometime around the 5th century. But my anonymous source, Vlad Kasparov of the secret Russian Missile Attack Agency, tells me that this whole thing is just a big misunderstanding and that we should absolutely not worry about our seven most populated cities.
13:31 Speaker 04 I see. Do you have any other experts we could consult on this very urgent matter?
13:36 Speaker 05 I do. Let's go to Natalia Reagan. Natalia, you're a primatologist, so what can you tell us about ballistic missile launch trajectories? I study monkeys. Thank you, Natalia. Natalia clearly confirming that there will not be a missile launch. There is some activity going on here, but what it is, we won't be able to determine for some time. But no need for alarm, as any launched missile would burn up in the atmosphere because mercury is in retrograde.
14:05 Speaker 04 That is reassuring, Brian.
14:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, Asma, you are now tasked with listing what was wrong with the journalism in that report.
14:15 Speaker 03 I don't think we have enough time, but I'll do my best. Well, let's start with the very first thing she said. "We're hearing reports of..."
14:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
14:24 Speaker 03 "No source, no effort to try to verify that." She tosses it off to the reporter. The reporter, who in this case immediately says he doesn't want to speculate, proceeds to with a very specific statistic that he does not cite the source of, proceeds to show us graphs in which he confuses correlation and causation.
14:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Good.
14:46 Speaker 03 And then went on to consult an expert who said that they had no expertise in the subject. He then manipulated her words to fit his narrative, contradicted what was behind him. It could go on and on and on.
14:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay. So Krishan Amanpour, she's known for her journalistic integrity. And she also voiced the character of Enheduanna in a science series that I knew something about called Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey.
15:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah. So I asked her about her her interest in science and where that where she might trace those origins. Because it's, I would just like no one because I'm a science geek. And if there's a little bit of geek in somebody, I want to get to the bottom of it. I try to right here. Check it out.
15:36 Speaker 02 One of my earliest heroes, without me really understanding what a hero was at that time, was when I was woken up at the crack of dawn. I don't even really remember what time it was because I was in England and Neil Armstrong was on the moon. I can't remember what time, you know, GMT that was. But I do remember my mother and my grandfather waking me up and sitting me down beside the television, black and white, to watch that. And I remember, you know, even today, it kind of brings almost tears to my eyes to imagine that humankind was able to break those barriers and breach those frontiers. And, and somebody, a human being, was actually walking on the moon and planting a flag and, and that whole, you know, one small, you know, step, one giant leap. I've never forgotten it.
16:21 Speaker 02 I've never forgotten that moment, ever, ever, ever. And it is still, you know, it gives my imagination these flights of fancy. For a moment there, I thought I wanted to be the first woman to walk on the moon. But of course, that never happened because it just didn't, obviously. But I really did.
16:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, up, up next, we will discuss the risks of reporting from a war zone when StarTalk returns.
17:05 Speaker 06 Bringing space and science down to earth. You're listening to StarTalk.
17:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome back to Start Off from the American Museum of Natural History. We're featuring my interview with longtime war correspondent Christiane Amanpour. And I asked her about the dangers of reporting from the front lines. Check it out. Going in the middle of war zones, what is the... How much are you risking your life, your health, your well-being?
17:46 Speaker 02 Everything, everything. All of those things are at risk, but we do it knowingly. Most of us know what we're putting ourselves on the line for.
17:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I went to the News Museum in DC and there's a whole memorial to dead journalists.
17:57 Speaker 02 Well, yes, because there are a lot of us. And I tell you one thing.
18:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Journalists died in the line of duty.
18:02 Speaker 02 Indeed, and hearing the President of the United States call us fake news enables those malevolent actors out there who want to kill us and who want to shut down The Messenger to do precisely that. That's why I'm so upset about the President and his view on news and independent and free journalism. But going into the field is something that we understand comes with a very profound danger and more and more danger, more and more sophisticated danger, more and more sophisticated and brutal ways of doing away with us. As we've seen ISIS, you know, with the throat cutting and all the rest of it. No longer are we just caught in the crossfire. Now we are deliberately targeted. So that's very, very dangerous.
18:44 Speaker 02 And that's why we find it so important. And, you know, if you're not going out there to be serious, don't go out there because it could cost you your life. And so that's why I'm so, so serious and attached to the mandate, which is to seek the truth and to seek the facts. Because we put our lives at risk and on the line in order to go there, which is why I then hate being called the enemy of the people because we are actually serving the people, those people who cannot get up for whatever reason of their own free will and accord to go to wherever, the war zones. We're their eyes and ears. We are their eyes and ears. And we perform that vital function, I think. But I do also think that one of the flip sides
19:28 Speaker 02 to all this violence and conflict and war is that I have seen shine through, and this is what keeps me going, the indomitable nature of the human spirit, the incredibly inspirational reality of people even at war.
19:42 Speaker 02 Who can manage somehow, maybe their family members, maybe their friends or whatever, somehow manage to understand the story of the other, to still want to build the bridges, to not want to live in endless conflict, and who even throughout the worst, worst moments of their wars are dreaming and thinking about the possibility of how to one day again live together. I find that war forces you, if you have half a brain and half a heart, to really focus on the story of the other. And that's what we don't get enough of in today's politics. You must be willing to hear and absorb the story of the other. You must have some kind of sympathy and empathy. Otherwise, if it's all about you, it's a zero-sum game.
20:27 Speaker 02 I win, you lose. That's not a negotiation. That's not a recipe for peace. It's a recipe for continued conflict.
20:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, okay. Joining us now to discuss reporting from war zones is conflict journalism expert Judith Matloff. Judith, welcome to StarTalk. You're a professor at Columbia School, Graduate School of Journalism, and you develop safety training for journalists around the world. And you have a recent book about conflict called No Friends But the Mountains, and it's subtitled Dispatches From the World's Violent Highlands. So you train journalistic safety. That's just... So how has the landscape shifted from covering the war in Vietnam, which we all saw, well, I'm old enough to remember seeing it on TV,
21:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? to journalists in Syria today? And are those risks the same? Are they different?
21:32 Speaker 07 Well, I think there is some very big differences. I mean, the big risk is always you might be killed or you might be arrested or you might be tortured or you might be maimed or you might be blown up in a landmine. Those are still there. Those are the constants. One major thing which is very different is the rise of freelancers. Because as major news organizations have either collapsed or they've contracted their foreign reporting bureaus, more freelancers have filled the vacuum. And it's very, very dangerous for them because they don't have the institutional backing.
22:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just so I hear, so a freelancer is not someone who's a rogue journalistic element. They're someone who sells you their stories. Because they went someplace that your bureau didn't send anybody.
22:16 Speaker 07 Right, and oftentimes, they do it on spec, which means that they're pushing the boundaries of safety. They will go into a very dangerous situation and a news organization will say, "Come back and show me what you have." So they will take incredible risks to get that story.
22:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Uncompensated risks at the time they take the risk.
22:33 Speaker 07 Exactly, exactly.
22:35 Eugene Mirman? That's a terrible business model.
22:38 Eugene Mirman? But I understand why it exists.
22:40 Speaker 07 Yeah, so that's one major difference. Another major one is the rise of digital and mobile communications. Because this too puts us in much more dangerous situations because it increases the surveillance of ourselves, even of our movements. People can find out where we are at a given time.
22:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Rogue elements.
22:59 Speaker 07 Rogue elements, or governments. For instance, the Russian government or the Chinese government. They know where you are oftentimes and where you're operating.
23:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But someone has to view you as some kind of an enemy rather than as someone who could tell their story.
23:14 Speaker 07 Right, like our president.
23:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, okay.
23:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so Ahmad, you reported recently on the war against ISIS in Iraq, both in Iraq and in Syria. So what precisely were you investigating?
23:30 Speaker 03 I was looking at civilians who were dying in US-led coalition airstrikes. And so, over the last two, almost three years now, I've been visiting the sites of airstrikes in Iraq. And for a particular New York Times Magazine investigation, I went to the sites of 103 airstrikes in three areas formerly held by ISIS, just to understand who was dying in them. And what I found was that... Civilians were dying at a rate, at least in these areas, which is likely an undercount of civilian death, at a rate that's 31 times higher than what the US military claims when it puts out its statistics about its airstrikes being the most precise in the history of aerial warfare.
24:14 Eugene Mirman? Did you say they're 31 times wrong?
24:17 Speaker 03 31 times higher than what the US government claims, and it's likely an undercount for many reasons.
24:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? At any time, did you fear for your life? Or is this post-attacks? And so you're there rummaging in the rubble with others?
24:30 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, I often am afraid while I'm doing my reporting. And I actually think that being fearful is what can help keep me safe, to always feel that way at different moments makes me more observant.
24:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Biologically natural to not want to die, yeah.
24:45 Speaker 03 Yes, no, it's a strong feeling that grips me. But, you know, I can think of moments where I did fear. There was an area that was recently retaken from ISIS. It was the last ISIS stronghold in Iraq. It's called Hawija. And I had been obsessed with Hawija for years. Plot, wanted to get there, it wasn't safe to go. It still wasn't, I wasn't sure how safe it would be. I made these plans and I was terrified. This was a place that had been, played such a historic role in the rise of ISIS. And honestly, it was the easiest trip I'd taken in all of my reporting in Iraq. It wound up, I just flew through checkpoint. I have no idea why, but I think the more fearful I am, oftentimes, the more precautions and preparation I do.
25:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Jude, what can journalists do to handle these kinds of situations?
25:35 Speaker 07 Well, first of all, you can avoid them.
25:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, sure, number one, stay home, yeah.
25:39 Speaker 07 But that's not our job.
25:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Stay home, yeah.
25:42 Speaker 07 You do your preparation beforehand, you do your research. So you do what we call a risk assessment. You speak to as many people as you can who've been there or who are looking at the situation. And you identify what the biggest dangers are. And then you work backwards from the worst-case scenario and try to mitigate that risk. Well, let's say your biggest risk is, as what happened to me in Dagestan, in a Muslim Republic of Russia. The biggest risk at that point was being arrested by the government. So I had to think about how I was going to avoid that. And that's where the surveillance comes in.
26:19 Eugene Mirman? How do you avoid being arrested?
26:20 Speaker 07 Well, I was arrested, so I didn't.
26:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That would fail.
26:24 Speaker 07 Yeah, that was a risk analysis that kind of didn't go the right way. The other big risk.
26:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So your risk assessment was accurate? Yes.
26:31 Speaker 07 The risk assessment was accurate, the steps I took didn't necessarily mitigate it, but I did my research. Then another big risk was at that time, the extremists were blowing up establishments that sold alcohol. So you look at the risks and you try to work backwards. Another thing you do is you try to figure out what your escape routes are gonna be. You try not to go into one place where there's only like one way to get out.
26:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just the backdoor plan.
26:58 Speaker 07 The backdoor plan, yeah, Plan B. Always want a Plan B.
27:01 Eugene Mirman? So that and stay at places with speakeasies.
27:05 Eugene Mirman? Got it?
27:05 Speaker 07 Right, yeah. Not too many in Dagestan, but note to south.
27:09 Eugene Mirman? That you know of?
27:10 Speaker 07 That I know of, that's true.
27:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So right now, it's time for Cosmic Queries, yes?
27:15 Eugene Mirman? Yes.
27:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We got questions about the science of reporting from the frontlines. So I've got the two of you here to help us answer these questions, because I'll be helpless in this part.
27:27 Eugene Mirman? Okay.
27:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Hit it.
27:29 Eugene Mirman? JJZ112 asks, "What precautions do you take for cellphone use?" Do you take any?
27:37 Speaker 07 I don't want to give too much information, because I don't want my secrets to be given up here, but you would encrypt your communications.
27:45 Eugene Mirman? Do you want to give us more details? Just kidding.
27:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So get a burner phone or something?
27:50 Speaker 07 You would get a burner phone that you would throw away, or you would limit your cell communications.
27:55 Eugene Mirman? You're also really set up to sell drugs.
27:59 Eugene Mirman? J. Clark from Virginia asks, "How much protection does a bulletproof vest and helmet actually give you?" And I-
28:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I've always wondered about that.
28:09 Eugene Mirman? Well, I can show you.
28:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, you got a helmet?
28:10 Eugene Mirman? I brought it with me.
28:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh.
28:12 Eugene Mirman? From my yoga instructing in the war zone.
28:16 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, so I'm assuming people shoot from the top. And no one ever tries to go for the face, so that's nice of people.
28:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, so Judith, come on, your face is exposed. So what is this, this is heavy.
28:31 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, but once they see that it says press on you, wow, this is really heavy.
28:34 Speaker 07 That's very heavy.
28:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so I never understood, okay, so this protects your vital
28:41 Speaker 07 It protects.
28:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Chest organs, but not your face, which I count as a vital organ. So is this really just to protect against debris rather than a bullet?
28:50 Speaker 07 And bullets as well. And the flak jackets have different degrees of strength. So some of them will protect against certain weaponry and others not. You know, it's heavy, you have to actually train to walk and run in those. But I have had friends that have died with a helmet because a bullet. It was slightly freaky, but a bullet went up there. And I have had friends who've died because the bullets went in the side. They're not, they won't protect every part of your body, but they'll obviously protect you from a lot.
29:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So your alternative is just not go at all, as you said earlier, just stay home. And then no one learns about anything.
29:24 Speaker 07 Or you go, you know, you can also do long distance reporting. For instance, there were quite a lot of revelations about Russian troops being in Ukraine that were, well, it's done purely off of social media.
29:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I know what you mean.
29:38 Speaker 07 I mean, you can actually do quite a lot of investigative work at a distance.
29:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I got this. The journalist drones.
29:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And this command central, and you put drones anywhere in the world. And you put them in and they become your eyes and ears as journalists.
29:52 Eugene Mirman? We'll call them satellites and we'll put them in space.
30:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Judith, thank you for joining us tonight on StarTalk.
30:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Up next, Christiane Amanpour shares how she convinced a member of the Taliban to sit down for an interview when StarTalk returns.
30:18 Speaker 06 This is StarTalk.
30:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome back. StarTalk. American Museum of Natural History, right here in New York City. We're featuring my interview with international news correspondent Christiane Amanpour. And I asked about some of the cultural challenges that she faced around the world. Let's check it out.
30:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We know there are men out there, especially men in power, who run stuff. In other cultures, occasionally in our culture, but especially in other cultures, where why is a woman interviewing me? I need a man who... I don't care what her credentials are, she's a woman. You know there are cultures where this is the attitude.
31:06 Speaker 02 I've been there.
31:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, how do you get through that?
31:09 Speaker 02 By not taking that nonsense and not dealing with it, you know? I'm just like, "Excuse me, what? No, I'm the interviewer, we're gonna do it." I'll give you a perfect example. Afghanistan, at the beginning of the Taliban. So, there is nothing more patriarchal and religious and a little whacked out than the Taliban when it comes to women.
31:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Uh huh.
31:30 Speaker 02 But because of their interpretation of religion, they decided that A, they didn't want to be interviewed because they don't believe in television. Remember, they don't believe in television. And certainly, they didn't believe in a woman engaging with them. But I convinced them. I convinced this leader in this particular town where they had just stormed up from Pakistan and were beginning to take over Afghanistan. This is 1996. And so, how we negotiated this interview was that, you know, here I was, but the camera was... They insisted that the camera be focused not on the gentleman's face, but on... The vase of plastic flowers on the glass table that was, you know, at his knees.
32:15 Speaker 02 So we did that, and then we broadened it a little bit, the shot, to see his hands and things like that. But it became a very memorable interview, very memorable because of the complete weirdness of the unscientific evolution of this person's brain, and who did not want to have anything to do with my gender or the technology that is television. That too was verboten for the Taliban.
32:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's surreal.
32:39 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah, and I had two whammies against me, right? I was a woman and I was a television journalist, but we got it.
32:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, Asma, have you experienced things like what she described with the Taliban? I mean, with anybody?
32:56 Speaker 03 Absolutely. I mean, I've interviewed warlords, clerics, mullahs, people who were ISIS, but I didn't realize it at the time until I did a little bit more digging.
33:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is the goal to get the interview no matter what it takes?
33:08 Speaker 03 No, I mean, your safety comes first. I do believe that, you know, not taking no for an answer has been critical to a lot of my work. But of course, I mean, if your safety is at risk, that's when, you know, you may have to let go.
33:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, Christiane, she's famous for scoring interviews that nobody else can get. I have to ask her what her secret is. Check it out.
33:33 Speaker 02 I think the secret is authenticity and that they know me. I've been doing this in their backyard.
33:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You got a rep?
33:39 Speaker 02 Yeah, basically, and I like it. I like the rep. That I've been doing this since the first Gulf War. My career essentially, you know, became public.
33:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? First Gulf War in 1991.
33:50 Speaker 02 Yeah, 90 to 91. Saddam Hussein invaded Kuwait in 1990, and in 91, the war against him started.
33:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's where CNN really...
33:59 Speaker 02 That's right.
34:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Really...
34:00 Speaker 02 That's right.
34:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Made a presence.
34:01 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah, yeah, sort of exploded into the American, you know, living room, but also around the world. It's where CNN truly went global.
34:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Did the president at the time say, ask, "Well, how did you learn this?" "Well, I saw it on CNN."
34:12 Speaker 02 Yes, we had plenty of ads that quoted all these leaders. And again, it was the first.
34:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
34:18 Speaker 02 There was no Al Jazeera, there was no BBC World Television, there was no Fox News, there was no MSNBC, there was CNN, period, end of story.
34:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Asma, can you reflect on the importance of CNN's presence in that first Gulf War as a moment on the journalism timeline?
34:41 Speaker 03 It was a game changer for people to be able to watch war unfold in real time and to come from an authority that was first at the scene, before your government, before others, before intelligence agencies.
34:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because in the Vietnam coverage, it wasn't in real time. We saw the footage, but it was delayed. And so that's an important difference that you're saying.
35:01 Speaker 03 Absolutely. There was an urgency to it. And I would almost liken it to the way in which, in terms of being a game changer, to the sort of contemporary instance in which people are sharing via smartphones, you know, as bombs are dropping in Syria in real time. We actually have more access to what's happening on the ground than we ever have in the past.
35:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, up next, we discuss how technology shapes the landscape of news when StarTalk returns.
35:39 Speaker 08 Hey, we'd like to give a Patreon shout out to the following Patreon patrons: Francois Fraser, Dan Yoder, and John Ward. Thanks, guys, for helping us make our trek through the cosmos. And if you would like to get a Patreon shout out, go to patreon.com and support us.
35:58 Speaker 06 Bringing space and science down to Earth. You're listening to StarTalk.
36:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome back to StarTalk. We're featuring my interview with international news icon Christiane Amanpour. And Christiane has covered events around the world since the 1980s. And I asked how important technology has been across all that time. Let's check it out.
36:31 Speaker 02 Technology is fundamental. From the very beginning, where we used to go out with these massive cases, you know, 20, 30 cases, full of huge satellite equipment. Of course, it all collapsed down and got smaller and smaller, and more and more mobile and manageable. So it is what has allowed us to keep broadcasting in, you know, ever further distances, where you can tell stories now from places that you could never get to before.
36:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But that worried me, that maybe parts of the world, things were happening, either good or bad, and no one knew about it.
37:03 Speaker 02 Yes.
37:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You couldn't get a journalist in there to report.
37:04 Speaker 02 I mean, that's true. So I think, in one way, we have managed to have an impact on the world, because, as we say in this sort of cliché, we've shone the light into the dark corners. Oxygen is the antiseptic, right, of all the evils and horrible things that go on in the world. But on the other side, I think also, technology has had a limiting impact in that it's made things come at you so fast, and at such warp speed, and so quickly. And the cycle moves on and moves on.
37:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Warp speed, I caught that, that's good.
37:34 Speaker 02 Yeah, there you go, warp speed.
37:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We're good.
37:35 Speaker 02 Yeah. Got it.
37:39 Speaker 02 Light years.
37:43 Speaker 02 That you don't have time
37:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Overload.
37:46 Speaker 02 to digest and to stay with something that we need to do. We can't solve all these dreadful issues, or really understand what's going on, whether it's politics, or whether it's grave violations of, you know, international law and order. You can't do it unless you're ready to think in complex ways, to think that you can spend time trying to work it out.
38:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Eugene, you think smartphones are feeding us too much news?
38:16 Eugene Mirman? Mostly social media, because it's all just upsetting loops. Regular news is fine, it's a little upsetting.
38:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But I think the next generation, they've only ever known smartphones, so they don't think it's going too fast.
38:26 Eugene Mirman? They don't know that they're... Yeah, but they're all upset. There was just a thing today that all people under some age are all upset.
38:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, and anxious.
38:33 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, and anxious. Like 90% of millennials are anxious. So maybe they kind of know that it's a problem.
38:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Osmat, what's your take on news being shaped by technology?
38:44 Speaker 03 So, I mean, it has its strengths and it has its weaknesses in so many ways. Like the smartphone technology I mentioned earlier. We're getting pictures and portraits from the ground. I don't think we would have the lens on police violence or allegations of police abuse that we have today if it were not for ordinary citizens, you know, using their phones to share that information quickly. At the same time, we are now living in a world in which there are echo chambers, in which you're bombarded with pieces of information every minute, every second. And it's very easy to lose the big picture, to understand these systems and these long-term structures that underlie fundamental problems of our society.
39:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, I asked Christian about the rise of social media as a force on journalism. Let's check it out.
39:33 Speaker 02 Suddenly, the dialogue has been taken over by this thing called social media. We don't even know really who these people are, but there's corners of outrage. There's professional destroyers on social media. There are people who, you know, shut down a debate or exacerbate a debate. So, you know, for every good aspect of social media, there are probably about, maybe 10 negative aspects?
39:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? 10 to 1. That's bad. So...
40:01 Speaker 02 What do you think?
40:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, but does that mean everyone with social media and everyone has a video camera, does that dilute the potency of a professional journalist?
40:12 Speaker 02 In a way, yes, but in a way, no. In a way, yes, because of the obvious nature of everyone. Having something, it makes it, you know, less special and less unique. But on the other hand, on the other hand, people, I think, I observe right now in this era that we live in of maximum political dysfunction, of populism, of partisanship, of poisonous...
40:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Tribalism.
40:36 Speaker 02 Tribalism and the inability to have dialogue and the inability to get out of your own echo chamber. So, in a way, right now, people are looking to the established...
40:48 Speaker 02 You know, established media, whether it's the New York Times, whether it's CNN, whether it's all the others that are doing incredibly well right now, rising to the occasion, understanding that we stand between, you know, them and the deluge, essentially.
41:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
41:02 Speaker 02 We are a vital pillar of civil society, and I'm not being arrogant about it. That is what makes a democracy. The difference between a democracy and dictatorship is the difference between truth and lies, the difference between a free and independent press and a propaganda machine.
41:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We'll just end the show right there. I don't know what we can add to that. Well, up next, I asked journalist Christiane Amanpour how she would have handled an interview with Adolf Hitler when StarTalk returns.
41:40 Speaker 06 This is StarTalk.
41:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome back to StarTalk from the American Museum of Natural History, right here in New York City. We're featuring my interview with international news correspondent, Christiane Amanpour. And I asked how the press should present the atrocities of war. For example, how would she have handled an interview with Adolf Hitler? Check it out.
42:08 Speaker 02 First and foremost, we are not megaphones, and we are not platforms, and we don't give free advertising to anybody. We're not anybody's paid political consultants. We're not their campaign managers. We're not their advertising agency. We are people who have learnt a lot, studied a lot, been around a lot, hopefully, who understand the complexity, who don't reduce everything to simple lowest common denominator. And it is absolutely up to us to understand what we are engaged in. If something of that horror and of that evil is sitting in front of any one of us, we have to know what we're dealing with. It's not just another point of view. In fact, I was criticised very heavily by many of my own colleagues
42:53 Speaker 02 during the Bosnia war. That was my... Signal career making coverage, covering the Bosnia war. Bosnia. Remind me, within the nineties? Bosnia was, was what, racked Europe apart during the nineteen nineties? Nineties, right. Where the former Yugoslavia split up and the strongest group wanted to survive alone and strongest. That was the, the Serbs in general. When it came to Bosnia, they waged a campaign of ethnic cleansing and genocide against the other ethnic groups, most of whom were Muslim. So you had these white Christians ethnically cleansing and committing human rights abuses,
43:32 Speaker 02 violating international humanitarian law, genocide against Muslims in order to pursue their political agenda and their territorial cleansing. They wanted to get the territory and they. And purify the territory. Correct. I told the truth in this war, which was that. I never said that, that each had, you know, an equal but opposite point of view. I never, ever drew a false moral equivalence. But it was only when I was criticized for taking sides that I understood what I was doing and what I was there to do. And that was to report the truth. And the truth is, is, is right in front of you.
44:15 Speaker 02 And reporting the truth does not mean creating neutrality, a false neutrality. It's not either or. It's not. We have to be cognizant and aware of what it is that we're confronted with. So to your question about Hitler, I asked my critics, I said, so if I was reporting during World War Two and I had gone to a concentration camp or I had sat in front of Hitler and heard what you just said, would I have said, oh yeah, I must give this Adolf guy his say, you know, he's got a point? Well, now we hear the other side's point. No, that's, that's danger. That's real danger.
44:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, Asma, what do you teach your students about truth and neutrality in journalism?
45:04 Speaker 03 You know, you're not here to make false equivalence. You're not here to give two opposing views equal weight. It's your job as a journalist to take every piece of information that you can and try to understand what is truth and what is not, and to convey that accordingly.
45:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, my buddy, Bill Nye the Science Guy, sent in his own dispatch on the power of journalism in a world at war. Let's check it out.
45:31 Bill Nye? Since humans first walked the earth, there has been conflict. Neighbor against neighbor, tribe against tribe, country against country.
45:42 Bill Nye? We've applied enormous intellect and treasure to build deadly machines of war. But I claim that even the most powerful mechanized cavalry will be ultimately brought down by good journalism. The pen is mightier than the sword. Good journalists and their crews go into war zones as warplanes streak overhead and the rattle of gunfire can be heard in the distance so that you can learn what they've learned about the struggles of our time. So to the journalists and their crews, I say, "Thank you, and be safe out there."
46:18 Bill Nye? Back to you, Neil.
46:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I think at the heart of this is, what do we do about truth? Who establishes it? Who reports it? Who consumes it? And I've thought a lot about this concept of truth.
46:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And what I've done is I've divided sort of the world of truth into three regimes. One of them is a personal truth. This is something that you feel is true, and you don't care what anybody else says about it. So what kinds of truths are those? These would include religious truths. So if Jesus is your savior in this country, no one will take that away from you. That's a personal truth. If Muhammad is your last prophet on earth, that is your personal truth. Okay, we have laws that protect that.
47:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What other kind of truths might there be? Oh, there's, let me call it a political truth. This is a truth that becomes true in your head because of how many times it has been repeated. This is particularly potent in politics. That's how people get you to vote for them. They repeat something endlessly.
47:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There's another kind of truth, however,
47:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? an objective truth. The entire enterprise of science is conceived and designed to establish objective truths. These are things that are true whether or not you believe in them.
48:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They are true no matter the state of your sensory system. They're true no matter how you feel about it.
48:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So journalism, if it's reporting on people and places and things, yes, it should know about people's personal truths. Yes, yes. But if your personal truth now infringes on someone else's personal truth and there's conflict there, somebody should call that out. You're taking your personal truth and imparting it on someone else's personal truth.
48:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's a different kind of report from saying this person is right and that person is wrong.
48:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because really, at the end of the day,
48:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? the methods and tools of science are uniquely conceived to know what is right and what is wrong.
48:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Everything else becomes opinion.
49:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And diversity of opinion is diversity of culture. We want that. We need that.
49:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But if you hate someone because their opinion differs from yours, that's a problem. And what we heard tonight, I greatly value. I cherish the idea that you're after truth. You're not after balance. Two things aren't balanced if one of them is objectively false.
49:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Someone says Earth is flat. You don't say, "Well, I gotta give them half the column inches" in the article because they have a different view. We live in a time when people don't understand the differences among these truths.
49:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And scientists, we do our little part. But at the end of the day, it's on the backs of the journalists to fix their house.
49:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And understand what it is to report, and what is and is not true in this world. That is a cosmic perspective.
49:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You've been watching StarTalk.
50:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I've been your host, Neil deGrasse Tyson. And as always, I bid you to keep looking up.
Previous StarTalk Live at NYCC 2019 with Neil deGrasse Tyson Next Cosmic Queries – The 30-Second Universe Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated