Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast Quantum Quandary: StarTalk Live! With Brian Greene & Janna Levin About this episode Why three dimensions? Neil deGrasse Tyson and comedians Chuck Nice and Hasan Minhaj celebrate 100 years of quantum physics and everywhere it’s taken us, joined by theoretical astrophysicists Brian Greene and Janna Levin.
Transcript 12,513 words · 6 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Coming up on StarTalk, we have StarTalk Live at the Beacon Theater in New York City. We're celebrating the 100th anniversary, decade, of the discovery of quantum physics. Not only that, the 1920s was when we discovered that the Milky Way galaxy was not alone in the universe, and that the universe itself was expanding. So, we brought out the big guns for that one. We've got Jan Levin and Brian Greene, two cosmologists with whom you are most familiar, and a very special comedic guest, Hasan Minhaj. So join me and Chuck Nice as we host that evening, coming up.
0:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk, your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
1:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So before we begin, I just want to, I didn't know this until today, that the two of you are actually current collaborators on some research. Could you just highlight what that is? What are you doing?
1:11 Janna Levin? I mean, Brian and I have been working together for years. Mostly, we've been thinking about extra spatial dimensions, and different cosmological implications, implications for theoretical physics, you know, hiding some dark energy in some extra dimensions.
1:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? As one does.
1:27 Janna Levin? As one does, yes.
1:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're thinking about higher dimensions?
1:31 Janna Levin? Yes.
1:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because the three plus time dimensions are not enough for you?
1:35 Janna Levin? Well, you know, even Einstein, when he started working, wondered why three? I mean, it's a curious question, once you start...
1:43 Chuck Nice? Well, it's a magic number.
1:44 Janna Levin? Yeah? Is it your favorite number?
1:48 Chuck Nice? Wait, those are Schoolhouse Rock people right there.
1:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They count to three.
1:53 Chuck Nice? They got it right away.
1:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, but how many dimensions are there, really?
2:01 Brian Greene? We don't know, but certain theories tell us that it could be much more than the ones that meet the eye, so it could be as many as 10 or 11.
2:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, like gender!
2:16 Brian Greene? I said it, and now I'm getting arrested.
2:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, but did you just make up other dimensions? I mean, it sounds like you're pulling it out of your ass.
2:29 Brian Greene? Yeah, it's all...
2:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You didn't deny that immediately.
2:34 Brian Greene? Well, partly it is, but it was also deep mathematical reasons that lead us to these ideas.
2:40 Janna Levin? Yeah, and you know, we figure if nature can try some experiments, she will. So, every possibility might actually happen.
2:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
2:49 Janna Levin? So, we're just exploring.
2:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright.
2:52 Chuck Nice? How much weed do you guys smoke?
2:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, so...
2:58 Janna Levin? Complete silence.
3:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The microscope and telescope were invented 400 years ago. And, like I said, they take us to the grandest visions of our understanding of our place in the universe. And the tiniest visions that also give us an understanding of our place in the universe. And so, this, those first steps were magnified at the dawn of the 20th century, especially through the 1920s. And so, let's start out with the large, and we'll end with the small, okay? So, let's go back to the roaring 20s. Let's just do that.
3:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And here's something that it's hard to even believe, that just 105 years ago, we didn't know if there were other galaxies. We just thought all the stars in the night sky,
3:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? the Milky Way was the entire universe. There was no, we weren't given reason to think anything else. There were these fuzzy things in the sky, okay, they're just fuzz. We call them nebulae, which is Latin for fuzz.
4:10 Brian Greene? For fuzz.
4:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, thank you. So...
4:12 Brian Greene? So, you just thought it was just space lint?
4:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
4:16 Janna Levin? Sure.
4:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And, but some fuzz lint, space, now you're messing with me. Nebulae, some nebulae were spiral shaped, and others were irregular. And the irregular ones were found in the plane of the galaxy.
4:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Whereas the spiral ones were in every direction you looked. Interesting. So, that was odd. It was a first thing. Well, maybe we can unpack this. And figure out what's going on. So, there was a famous debate. Took place in nineteen twenty. At the National, hosted by the National Academy of Sciences. Between. Heber D. Curtis. Unfortunate name. Yeah, that name. And Harold Shapley. Soon to become the director of the Harvard College Observatory. And Heber Curtis was director of the Allegheny Observatory. Two very different. Yeah, I'm gonna say, one of those sounds more expensive.
5:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, so, they debated whether these spiral things were other galaxies. With a term coined by. Immanuel Kant in the seventeen hundreds. Who thought about this? Philosopher. Yes, Chuck?
5:36 Chuck Nice? No, Brian, Brian did it to me, man. I'm sorry.
5:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What did Brian do to you?
5:41 Chuck Nice? Because he knows I can't hear the name Immanuel Kant without. Being twelve years old. I'm so sorry.
5:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so he, he's a philosopher, deep-thinking philosopher. He looked up and he saw these spiral objects. And he, he thought of them as possible island universes. Oh, that's, that's pretty cool. An island universe. That's beautiful. That is. But we didn't have evidence to say that, to, to support it, but it was a deep idea at the time. So, there they are. They debated this. And. But based on what evidence? Just hot taken? They're scientists. Okay, alright. Which means. Sometimes we have rose-colored glasses towards the past. Yes, I get it, I get it. So, here's how it works. Two scientists argue. There's a pact implicitly signed before they even begin. Which is, either.
6:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're right and she's wrong. You're right and he's wrong. Or you're both wrong. They know this going into the conversation.
6:47 Chuck Nice? It's nerd thunder dog. So. Two scientists enter. Two scientists leave, but one's a little embarrassed.
7:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Pay-per-view, Saturday night. So, so, so here's what.
7:07 Speaker 04 This is their Tyson, Jake Paul, real kinda throwdown.
7:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So let's go to the Harvard fellow.
7:12 Speaker 04 Yeah.
7:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Cause you can always tell a Harvard man, but you can't tell him much.
7:17 Speaker 04 Oh, got it, got it. Also, they were insufferable back then as well. Were they also like, "I went to school in Boston." Fuck you. Just say it, just say it. Say it, you know? I don't know.
7:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, so here's what happened. Shapley was heavily invested in the entire night sky being part of the, being the whole universe and the Milky Way. And he had evidence at the time from a fellow astronomer who had looked at the spiral nebulae and claimed that he found them having moved on the sky. Now, if you're really, really far away, that's essentially impossible to measure. But if you're close up and you're moving, you can see that movement. Okay? Things that are close to you.
8:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The example here is, if I see a plane moving across the sky and then I see a bird moving at the same angle, I don't conclude that the bird is going 600 miles an hour. The bird is much closer. So at much lower speeds, I can see it cross my field of view. So, because it's closer.
8:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That evidence suggested that the spiral nebulae were nearby and he he bet on that horse, but it was the wrong horse.
8:45 Chuck Nice? Mm.
8:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He was, he was doing what a good scientist will do. He took the data, put his confidence in the data. It was later shown that the data he was basing his argument on was false. It could not be verified by the work of other scientists. In fact, no, the spiral nebulae had no motion across the sky. And so Shapley was just wrong.
9:08 Chuck Nice? Mm.
9:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Later, we would later show that he's wrong. And what puts the nail in the coffin? 1923. Edwin Hubble.
9:21 Chuck Nice? Oh, the man.
9:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Hubble was a person before he was a telescope. Yeah.
9:27 Speaker 04 I thought he, he was born a telescope.
9:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Born a telescope.
9:31 Speaker 04 Yeah, just like when you're a kid, you're like, of course, you, there was Ninja Turtles and they were birthed.
9:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, there it is, there it is. So he had an idea based on evidence and it turned out to be wrong because the evidence was flawed. So this is some lessons there, alright? And if one scientist has one bit of evidence, you don't alert the authorities yet until there's confirming of their experiments to do so.
9:58 Chuck Nice? That is, uh, what the peer review is all about, right?
10:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's peer review is all about.
10:02 Chuck Nice? And by the way, for anybody who wants to know, uh, scientists are haters. Okay, that is what they do. You come up with something and somebody goes, I call bullshit and then it's on. Then it's just on.
10:16 Speaker 04 Wait, so Neil, so Neil, a peer review to, to us non-scientists is basically, it's scientific group chat where you present your take or information.
10:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, yeah.
10:28 Speaker 04 The seventeen other friends that are in the group chat get to be like, well, shit.
10:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And Shapley had a, had a green bubble in, in the chat.
10:36 Speaker 04 Oh, goddamn. Goddamn, what a horrible, what a horrible life to live. He was the one green.
10:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He was the one green.
10:44 Speaker 04 Surrounded by blues.
10:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, if you have an idea and it's shown to be wrong, then it's just wrong. In fact Einstein, after his relativity, which we'll get into in a couple of minutes,
10:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? that was hard to accept by people, right? It was, you know, it was hard. It was very counterintuitive. Someone came up with a work saying a hundred against Einstein. A hundred against Einstein. And then he's rumored to say what after that?
11:13 Janna Levin? Let's see, I just learned this anecdote, but he's rumored to have said, "Why a hundred? If I'm wrong, one would have been enough."
11:22 Chuck Nice? Wow.
11:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
11:23 Janna Levin? It's pretty great.
11:24 Chuck Nice? Yeah. And believe me, I've been married for 27 years, that is right.
11:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so here's what happened. So Edwin Hubble is curious about the spiral nebulae, and he finds a star in them that matches a kind of star that's not in a nebulae, that's just sort of nearer by than that star. It's a very specific kind of variable star, named after the very first of its kind, Cepheid variable. The first of its kind was found in the constellation Cepius. And so that's how we categorize types of variable stars. The first one in a constellation, all the others, no matter where you find them, are that variety. Found a Cepheid variable there, and what was spe... Tell us what's special about the Cepheid variables.
12:15 Janna Levin? Well, they have a very predictable property where their luminosity, how bright they shine, is related to a sort of oscillation. And so you can tell that you're looking at precisely one of those. It's very easily identifiable.
12:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If you get the luminosity out of it,
12:31 Janna Levin? Yeah.
12:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? then you can say, "I can see the period vary."
12:34 Janna Levin? Right.
12:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Based on that period, I know how bright it should be.
12:37 Janna Levin? How bright it should be. So it's as though you knew your light bulb, right?
12:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
12:41 Janna Levin? You can tell if you have a very bright light bulb far away, or a very dim light bulb up close.
12:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right. How can you distinguish the two?
12:48 Janna Levin? And how do you distinguish the two if you know nothing about the light bulb? But if you know everything about your light bulb,
12:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
12:53 Janna Levin? you know exactly what it is, then you can say, "Oh, I know this light bulb, and so I know exactly how far away it is."
12:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So he says, "This star is of this particular luminosity, and the only way it can be that dim?" Is if it is far outside our galaxy.
13:06 Janna Levin? I just recently saw the actual plate and it's really stunning. He crosses out.
13:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The photographic plate.
13:12 Janna Levin? Yes, the photographic plate where he makes this detection. He wrote NOV, I think for Nova originally. He thought it was a different kind of object. And then he crosses it out and writes VAR exclamation point for a variable star. So it's a real epiphany that he realizes. He knows what he's seen and right at that moment, he understands it's far away.
13:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Emmanuel Kahn. Turned out to be right. These were in fact island universes. And Hubble wrote to Shapley on this. And I had to look this one up. Shapley, what's the quote here? He said, here's the letter that destroyed my universe.
14:09 Speaker 05 I'm Kais from Bangladesh and I support StarTalk on Patreon. This is StarTalk with Neil deGrasse Tyson.
14:27 Brian Greene? It's important to know what he actually meant by that because Hubble himself never was convinced that these were actually other galaxies. He proved that there was something beyond the outskirts of our galaxy. We knew our galaxy about 100,000 light years across. His analysis showed this to be 900,000 light years. We now update it to 2 million light years. But Hubble was so conservative that he was unwilling to then say this is an island universe. This is a galaxy in its own right.
15:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What an idiot.
15:03 Speaker 04 Wait, what's the difference, just from a space real estate standpoint? What's the difference between an island universe and a galaxy? What are we talking?
15:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They're poetically identical.
15:11 Speaker 04 They're the same. They're the same.
15:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Poetically identical.
15:14 Speaker 04 Got it.
15:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
15:16 Speaker 04 Okay.
15:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, because if our galaxy is our universe and is another galaxy, then you get to call that a universe. Except, once we see the full breadth of it all, we gotta reallocate how we use the word "universe." Because it's uni-verse. One in...
15:35 Speaker 04 One verse. Right. But we're in the, we're in the multiverse. Spider-Man. We're in the...
15:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We'll get to that.
15:45 Speaker 04 Okay.
15:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, yeah, we'll get to that.
15:47 Speaker 04 All right.
15:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Minus the Spider-Man, but we'll...
15:51 Speaker 04 You didn't like the second one?
15:54 Speaker 04 I thought it was great.
15:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so, Jana, how did... We're reeling from the fact that we are not the universe, we're just a part of a universe. And then a few years later, Hubble discovers that the spiral nebulae are in motion, body and soul. So what's going on there?
16:16 Janna Levin? Yeah, so, once he's starting to be able to use these Cepheid variables and these standard candles to get a strong sense of how far away things are, he can start to do that, he can start to do that kind of mapping out the local environment, what we have right nearby, and then also galaxies further away, these little smudges on the sky. And he begins to catalog not only that there are other galaxies around us at great distances, but there also seem to be receding away from us, largely, predominantly.
16:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, and so he makes a plot of this.
16:48 Janna Levin? Makes a plot. So this is very strange. I mean, you're looking at all of these enormous galaxies. So a galaxy is a collection of hundreds of billions of stars, and they're pretty localized, and maybe they're spirals and blobs, and they're very far away. And they're also moving away from us in every direction. Which is very peculiar. So he makes this plot. It's completely freaky, but it gets freakier because the further away they are, the faster they're expanding away from us.
17:13 Speaker 04 And they're calculating this all without computers?
17:16 Janna Levin? Well...
17:16 Speaker 04 Hundreds of billions of stars.
17:17 Janna Levin? People were called computers back then.
17:21 Brian Greene? Sure.
17:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, if you look at old dictionaries, look up the word "computer," a person who makes computer.
17:26 Janna Levin? The person who computes, yeah, so.
17:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But wait, and there's a room full of-
17:31 Janna Levin? And yes, but they're doing it without the machines.
17:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There's a room full of computers at Harvard at the time.
17:35 Janna Levin? Yes, so he actually uses the work of one of the Harvard computers, which was a woman named Henrietta Levin, and she was part of a group of women who worked at the Harvard Observatory that were called-
17:45 Brian Greene? And she talked like this.
17:49 Janna Levin? Well, they were called Pickering's harem because Charles Pickering, at one point, was so frustrated with his male computers that he fired them all, and he said, "My maid could do a better job," and he hired his maid, who was Wilhelmina Fleming, and she did a great job.
18:04 Janna Levin? And she hired all these other women, and one of whom was Henrietta Levin, and she made thirty cents an hour.
18:12 Janna Levin? Go ahead, Henrietta.
18:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Are we applauding her or her pay? That was weird.
18:19 Brian Greene? Thirty cents an hour, that's it.
18:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? She should be making iPhones. Okay, so-
18:27 Brian Greene? I said it. I said it.
18:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, so, but mixed in here, we've got simultaneous things going on. Einstein's general theory of relativity is already at the races, okay? So that came in in nineteen fifteen.
18:44 Brian Greene? Fifteen.
18:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay? That gave us a mechanism to understand what the whole universe could be doing, to just catch us up on that.
18:53 Brian Greene? Well, Einstein writes down his equations in nineteen fifteen, and initially he applies them to things like the motion of the Earth around the Sun, and terrestrial and nearby motion, local things. But then, some other very creative thinkers, one in particular was a Belgian priest named Georges Le Mettre, he-
19:18 Brian Greene? Decide to apply the mathematics not to something in the universe, but to the entirety of the universe, and find from the equations that the universe should be expanding over time. It should be slowing.
19:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Robert, just to be clear, he was able to do that not based on his training as a priest. He was a priest physicist.
19:39 Brian Greene? He was a priest physicist, but no doubt his interest in applying these ideas to the entirety of the universe was not distinct from his focus on the big questions of existence. So they weren't that separate, although he, in his own mind, was very clear. He said, "There are two ways to have deep insight about the world. There's mathematics and there's salvation." And he said, "Let me follow both." And that's what he did.
20:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But not intermingled?
20:08 Brian Greene? He was very clear not to...
20:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There was a line in the sand between the two. Wait, so what, so, so... Le... le mat...
20:17 Brian Greene? I'll let you guys figure out the pronunciation.
20:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, he takes the equations. We have an expanding universe. But he, so, Le Matzer...
20:26 Brian Greene? Before, before Hubble.
20:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Le Matzer predicts an expanding universe. Using Einstein's equations. So Einstein could have made the prediction, and he didn't.
20:34 Brian Greene? Yeah, in fact, in 1917, Einstein actually got there first. And when he applied the equations to the entirety of space, was very disturbed that he couldn't get a universe that met his own philosophical prejudice.
20:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Which was?
20:48 Brian Greene? That the universe is fixed, eternal, static, and unchanging.
20:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Why would anybody think the universe could be anything other than that?
20:55 Brian Greene? Well, I mean, there is this book called Genesis, which seems to suggest a beginning. So there are some people who think perhaps that that vision is not correct. But Einstein, and many others at the time, very firmly believed that the universe could not change on the largest of scales.
21:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And that's just a philosophical bias.
21:13 Brian Greene? Totally. And in fact, he changes...
21:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, wait, how could he get away with that if all the galaxies have gravity? And if they all feel each other's gravity, they would all collapse down into one point?
21:24 Brian Greene? Yeah, so this was an argument that Isaac Newton actually gave hundreds of years ago. Earlier, but if the universe is infinitely big, and if the galaxies are spread across an infinity of space, then there is no center for them to collapse toward.
21:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Got it.
21:39 Brian Greene? So you can envision a static universe now.
21:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If it's infinite.
21:43 Brian Greene? If it's infinite.
21:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If and only if.
21:44 Brian Greene? But even more than that, Einstein then, in his own general relativity, recognized basically the issue that you're raising in a finite universe. And he said, "Let me introduce a repulsive push to counter the attractive pull of gravity."
22:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? An anti-gravity.
22:02 Brian Greene? An anti-gravity force field called the cosmological constant. So he introduces this into the math in 1917. It was not in the 1915 equations. He introduces it just to have a static universe that will allow him to breathe easy.
22:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And to fulfill his philosophical bias. Then the mantra says, "We can have an expanding universe." And so how did Einstein react to that?
22:25 Brian Greene? Einstein learns of this from Le Maitre in 1927. And he says to Le Maitre, "Your calculations are correct, but your physics is abominable."
22:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, them's fighting words.
22:38 Brian Greene? They were fighting words. By which he was saying, "You can't trust that every mathematical calculation tells you something real about reality. Some math should be in math textbooks, and it's interesting, but it's nothing more than a mathematical curiosity." And he says, "Le Maitre, your idea of an expanding universe, that's a mathematical curiosity. It's not real."
22:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so then, 1929, Hubble discovers an expanding universe. Now what? What happens next?
23:04 Janna Levin? Well, so it's interesting, because the way I originally described it is kind of confusing. You might think it makes it seem like we're at the center of this expansion, and everything's receding away from us. But the way the Hubble Law is specifically, it's much more like the space between every galaxy is actually stretching. So from their point of view, if you were on one of those other galaxies, it would also look like everything's receding away from.
23:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're moving away from them.
23:25 Janna Levin? Right, everything's receding away from. And if you imagine that it's not the galaxies literally moving on spacetime, but actually the distance between the galaxies that's stretching, then something further away is actually moving away from you faster. There's more space stretching. And this was really closer to Le Maitre's. Description, not even closer, it simply wasn't static.
23:47 Speaker 04 So just so I'm clear, at that time, they believed there's only one galaxy in approximately nineteen twenty-five. Just so I'm following.
23:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Uh, it-
23:54 Speaker 04 I feel like I'm in a Chris Nolan right now.
23:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, no, no.
23:56 Speaker 04 Watching Tenet, let me just, let's pause real quick.
23:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, up until nineteen twenty-three, twenty-four.
24:00 Speaker 04 One galaxy.
24:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? One galaxy, it wasn't one galaxy.
24:03 Speaker 04 We are the main character.
24:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It was one universe.
24:04 Speaker 04 One universe, copy.
24:05 Janna Levin? Yes.
24:06 Speaker 04 Here we are, twenty twenty-five, from what I understand.
24:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
24:08 Janna Levin? Now there's other-
24:09 Speaker 04 How many, how many universes are we in now?
24:11 Brian Greene? But are you talking island universes, or are you talking universe universes?
24:14 Speaker 04 I'm talking about the whole-
24:15 Brian Greene? Oh, good God, there's one universe that we know about. Filled with a hundred billion galaxies, each of which has on the order of a hundred billion stars. There are theoretical ideas that Neil suggests we might get to tomorrow. That, that speak to the possibility that there might be other universes. So the answer is, we don't know for sure.
24:35 Speaker 04 Okay.
24:35 Brian Greene? But the data seems to suggest that there's one universe.
24:38 Speaker 04 Well, we, we were talking about this backstage. If the, the delta is that big between those two numbers, which is one and, which you just basically said a gajillion. How do we, how do we know that, that what we're living in right now, the data that we know right now, isn't gonna be wildly off? And fifty years from now, or a hundred years from now, they'll be like, look at those dum-dums in twenty twenty-five.
24:59 Brian Greene? We hope, we hope that that's what will happen.
25:02 Janna Levin? Yeah.
25:02 Brian Greene? That's what we live for. We live to be- Wrong! Stupid. We live to be wrong, we're scientists!
25:09 Speaker 04 Oh, got it.
25:14 Speaker 04 We live to be wrong, we're scientists. Got it, okay.
25:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, so let's, let's follow through this reasoning. We discovered expanding universe, if we're expanding, that means we're bigger today than we were yesterday. And bigger yesterday than we were the day before. So, logically, where does that take us?
25:35 Janna Levin? Bigger?
25:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, going back in time.
25:37 Janna Levin? Oh, I'm sorry, so yes, so if you're already disturbed about the lack of permanence to the universe, then this very quickly leads you to have even greater existential dread, because if you run the movie backwards, then everything was once closer together, and if you keep running the movie backwards, it gets to a point which seems quite catastrophic, where these galaxies are literally on top of each other. And eventually, you're kind of imagining something that's so dense that you have to start thinking of it as hot and, soupy and, and, and chaotic and-
26:10 Janna Levin? Then what?
26:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What did Le Maitre call this?
26:14 Brian Greene? Yeah, so Le Maitre basically said, "Look, if the math is saying that the universe is expanding today, and if then Hubble's data shows that the universe is expanding today, just wind the cosmic film in reverse." You run the film backwards and things get closer and closer together, and there suggests that there's a point in the distant past when everything was on top of everything else, and he calls this the primeval atom. This is the beginning, according to his description.
26:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, I happen to know there was an astronomer active at the time, very brilliant guy, named Fred Hoyle, who was not into a universe that would be changing.
26:52 Brian Greene? Yeah.
26:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He knew the universe was expanding, he couldn't reason that away.
26:55 Janna Levin? He accepted that.
26:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, he accepted that, but if you're expanding but you're always the same, that must mean matter is being spontaneously created in the void to create new galaxies, so that statistically, the universe always looks the same.
27:11 Brian Greene? Yeah.
27:12 Chuck Nice? You know, but here's the thing, if the universe is expanding, that in itself is a change, so why would you not accept a changing universe?
27:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because he wanted to always look the same for all of time, for all eternity, in the past and in the future. Again, it's a philosophical bias.
27:27 Janna Levin? But I think the idea of the beginning was particularly disturbing. The idea, so this primeval atom that Le Maitre was talking about...
27:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is it disturbing to scientists but not for religious people, where God made the universe? They're perfectly happy with the beginning.
27:39 Brian Greene? Look, Pope Pius XII, perhaps the nerdiest pope in history, who loves science...
27:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, why do you know this?
27:46 Brian Greene? He, I don't know, he took Le Maitre's work, and he said, "There is the scientific evidence for Genesis." That's what he said. And when Le Maitre heard this, he threw a fit.
27:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Belgian priest, Le Maitre.
28:01 Brian Greene? That's right.
28:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The pope is talking to him.
28:03 Brian Greene? Not directly, but yes, when he catches wind that this is what the pope is saying, and one of his students, who was in the class that Le Maitre had to teach that afternoon after learning, says that Le Maitre, who normally is very quiet and mild-mannered, he came in and ranted for 45 minutes, because his whole point was, "I am not blending my religious life and my scientific life, and here the pope is taking my scientific work and he's turning it into religion."
28:29 Chuck Nice? But notice, he said all that to a student and not the pope.
28:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You don't want to know the Galileo situation. Exactly. Yeah, so I have a tamer version of that quote. It's, "As far as I see, such a theory of the primeval atom remains entirely outside any metaphysical or religious question."
28:52 Brian Greene? Yeah, that's after I had a couple of drinks and chilled.
28:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so, so then it got called the Big Bang by...
28:59 Brian Greene? By Fred Hoyle.
29:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? By Fred Hoyle.
29:01 Brian Greene? Yeah, so Fred Hoyle was in a 1948 BBC Radio interview.
29:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Why do you know this level of detail about this?
29:07 Brian Greene? I don't know. And so, he is describing his own approach, which as you mentioned, is this steady-state approach where matter is created spontaneously and fills in the gaps in space. And so, they ask him about this other approach, not his. And he says, "Oh, that theory in which all matter must be created in one Big Bang", and that's where the idea of Big Bang theory comes from. Now, people have interpreted that as a derogatory description. His own way of recounting the story is, he was simply trying to draw a distinction between a theory in which, in his steady-state, only a little bit of matter is created here and there across space versus this other theory...
29:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Like one hydrogen atom per century, per cubic light year. I mean, there's some small rate...
29:58 Brian Greene? Not quite that small. So, it is one atom per century, per Olympic-sized swimming pool.
30:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, okay, I thought it was bigger than that.
30:04 Brian Greene? And that's all that you need. And so, it's kind of an amazing thing.
30:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In the whole universe, yeah, yeah.
30:08 Brian Greene? Yeah, because what's more believable? That one little atom forms in a cubic, you know, in a swimming pool-sized arena of space per century? Or that there's this moment where everything is created all at once? Framing it that way, his theory sounds perhaps a little bit more believable.
30:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Less crazy.
30:25 Brian Greene? Yeah.
30:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah. So, what do we have to assume if there is a Big Bang? So, we've got to assume that the expansion has been uniform the whole time.
30:35 Brian Greene? No, it doesn't have to be uniform.
30:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No?
30:37 Brian Greene? Yeah, it can change over time.
30:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, that's been always expanding.
30:39 Brian Greene? It's always expanding.
30:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
30:40 Brian Greene? Yeah.
30:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And...
30:42 Janna Levin? Unless there's extra dimensions, those might...
30:44 Brian Greene? All right.
30:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They could expand differently in a higher dimension.
30:47 Janna Levin? Brian and I will talk about it later. Well, yeah, you can squeeze the other dimensions. There could have been chaotic mixing of the expansion and contraction, but overall, the overall volume of the universe was expanding.
30:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But the way you get this is looking at the rate at which the universe is expanding.
31:02 Brian Greene? Yes.
31:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And that is a slope on a graph. And Hubble first derived that. And it's, there's a slope. It's just, he called it a letter C, which is for constant. But since then, we swapped that out with a capital H for Hubble.
31:19 Brian Greene? Yep.
31:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And we call it the Hubble constant. Very famous Hubble constant.
31:22 Janna Levin? So it's constant over space. I mean, it's not necessarily over time.
31:25 Brian Greene? Yeah, it's important to realize, it's really the Hubble parameter, we should call it, because it does change in time.
31:29 Janna Levin? It was, it could have been faster in the early universe, faster in the future.
31:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, so Hubble, he had the wrong, turned out, the Cepheid variable he used, he didn't know at the time, there were two varieties of Cepheid variables. The one that's near us and the one that you can see from far, far away. And he presumed they were the same, no reason to think otherwise.
31:52 Brian Greene? Right.
31:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So he got the wrong distance, the wrong expansion rate of the universe.
31:57 Chuck Nice? So Cepheid is like diabetes, is type 1 and type?
32:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, there's a type 1 and type 2, exactly, I think.
32:07 Janna Levin? Maybe not exactly.
32:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, there's literally type 1 Cepheid and type 2 Cepheid. And you gotta use apples and apples when you're doing this exercise. So, so he got an age of the universe of 2 billion years. We would later refine these numbers. When I was in graduate school, many moons ago, the uncertainty in the Hubble constant was a factor of 2. There was a 10, so with, with the Hubble constant, you run the film backwards, ask how much time, at this expansion rate, looking backwards, when do we get to time zero?
32:43 Chuck Nice? That makes sense.
32:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, yeah, just, just when is everybody in the same place at the same time? That's a perfectly sensible question.
32:49 Brian Greene? Yeah.
32:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And we got two numbers, there are two camps.
32:51 Brian Greene? Okay.
32:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A 10 billion year camp.
32:53 Brian Greene? Okay.
32:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And a 20 billion year camp. A fact, a whole factor of 2. And everyone is, you know, fighting for their, and we know they both can't be right. And so, we need better data. One of the goals of the-
33:09 Brian Greene? Wait, isn't, isn't being off by 10 billion quite a bit?
33:13 Speaker 04 That's a lot. Again, cop a median and I only took physics one in undergrad. I did not advance, not, I don't want the smoke, but I am saying being off by 10 billion is a lot.
33:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Here's the thing.
33:25 Speaker 04 Like if you go out to dinner and we split it and I'm off.
33:30 Speaker 04 By that, like that big of a delta, if I'm fif, if I'm, yeah, if I'm 100% off.
33:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, yes.
33:37 Speaker 04 Aren't you like, you lose your science little thing?
33:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no.
33:42 Speaker 04 You know what I mean? Like, you've been disbarred?
33:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, right. Here's the thing.
33:46 Speaker 04 But you know, you just get to talk your shit?
33:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Here's the thing.
33:49 Speaker 04 You're off by 10 billion, you get to talk your shit still.
33:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Here, here's the thing.
33:53 Speaker 04 Like my dad in the fucking living room when he's giving his opinions about politics. He just gets to run his mouth continuously?
34:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I got this.
34:01 Speaker 04 Go ahead. This is me and my, this is a me and my dad thing, but I'm just a little mad that, that, that a capital S scientist was this off.
34:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
34:09 Speaker 04 Go ahead. And I have a second question, but go ahead.
34:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The universe is vast.
34:14 Speaker 04 Yes.
34:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In time.
34:15 Speaker 04 Yeah.
34:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And in space.
34:17 Speaker 04 Sure.
34:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It is vast in every metric we've ever established for it. There are things that are vast in size, in temperature, in speed, in gravity. And so if I'm off by a factor of two between 10 billion and 20 billion.
34:44 Speaker 04 Yeah.
34:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I could have been off by a factor of 10, by a factor of a thousand, by a factor of a million. We were quite happy we were in the same sandbox having that conversation.
34:56 Chuck Nice? So it's kind of, it's kind of like being Jeff Bezos, you know? If I'm off by 10 billion, eh, not so bad.
35:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so.
35:07 Speaker 04 Could I also ask you the second philosophical question, which is?
35:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Sure.
35:10 Speaker 04 Which is, no, no, no, this is, this is for real. When you, when you were like, it's either 10 billion or 20 billion. And I was asking you this backstage, which was if, when the number is that big, is it almost like the United States' debt? Where they're like, the, the deficit is at 28 trillion. And you're like, what does it even matter now?
35:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
35:26 Speaker 04 It's at a gajillion manillion. Like, what does it matter?
35:29 Chuck Nice? Well, when I'm done.
35:30 Speaker 04 Why does the number, because I feel like a freshman in college.
35:32 Chuck Nice? When I'm done, it's gonna matter an awful lot.
35:40 Janna Levin? I would say that actually 10 billion is actually quite good. 10 to 20 is very much in the ballpark.
35:46 Speaker 04 You should run the Federal Reserve.
35:49 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah.
35:50 Janna Levin? This stage, you know.
35:51 Speaker 04 Pretty funny. This is a good way to think about it.
35:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You could have been off by a trillion.
35:54 Janna Levin? Well, but the future is going to be much, much longer than the past. So it's not as though the universe kind of will expire within another 10 billion years like we're confined to this number. The future could be just a huge number. We could be living in a time where it's not 10 billion.
36:07 Brian Greene? But can I just give you perhaps one, these are all very, very good answers. But perhaps one other way of looking at it.
36:12 Speaker 04 You're saying it was a bad question? Bad question? Your great answer is bad question?
36:16 Brian Greene? We don't care whether it's 10 billion or 20 billion. The number doesn't matter. What does matter is.
36:22 Speaker 04 That's the most American answer, by the way. That's the most American answer.
36:26 Brian Greene? Here. The truth is, we don't care, but we want our theories to work. We want our theories to make predictions that match with observations. That's the only thing that matters to us. The actual answer that comes out, whether it's 10 billion or 50 billion.
36:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Or 42.
36:42 Brian Greene? Like you're saying, it just doesn't matter. But we need to have a consistent description so that we have evidence that we know what we're doing, because evidence matters.
36:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And both sides could not be right.
36:52 Brian Greene? Right.
36:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so when the Hubble telescope was launched, okay? I'm just getting out of graduate school. It is launched. The number one goal set for that telescope was to resolve that discrepancy. The telescope's named after the guy who gave us the Hubble constant in the first place. Within two or three years, we nailed it. And the Hubble constant, its value would give us an age of the universe at about 14 billion years, which is comfortably between those two extremes. And that's science working at its best. It was, there's a limit to how much we can keep beating each other over the head. Let.
37:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Let's get more data. Let's build a telescope that'll solve this.
37:34 Brian Greene? And in fact, today, there is a similar argument happening. It's not between 20 billion and 10 billion, which, as you say, is a factor of 2 or 100% difference. Now, we're down to the 5% difference. We understand things that well, that we have 2 groups that are 5% apart, describing a number of years, billions of years into the past, and that's the precision with which we can do it, within 5%.
38:01 Chuck Nice? And they will kill each other.
38:04 Brian Greene? So again, we don't care the exact number. We care that we can describe it with that level of precision when we're talking about events that happened billions of years ago. That's the mind-bending.
38:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And here's the issue. When it was 10 and 20 billion, you always have to report your uncertainties for a number in science. And those uncertainties had a little bit of overlap in the middle. And it landed where you expected it to land. Now that we have 2 other warring factions on the value of the Hubble constant, those 2 numbers are within 5% of each other, but the uncertainties are tight. So the uncertainties don't overlap. And if you look at, go Google search on Hubble tension, and that's what will come up.
38:47 Janna Levin? Adam Rees is coming to Pioneer Works in October. I just planted an ad.
38:53 Janna Levin? Adam Rees, who's a Nobel Prize, one of the Nobel Prize winners, who discovered that the universe is not just expanding, the expansion's getting ever faster, it's accelerating, who is part of this Hubble tension debate, will be speaking at Pioneer Works on the Hubble tension.
39:08 Chuck Nice? Without waxing philosophical, I just don't want to miss this point that we're not actually saying, which is what makes science so incredibly great is exactly what you all just demonstrated. It is this pursuit of the truth based upon the best available information at the time. So it's okay if it's wrong. Because when it's right, we're gonna get there.
39:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
39:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You got it.
39:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, so, we're turning the clock back. And, we get to the Big Bang. And, but, now the universe, large-scale universe described by general relativity, is now small. It is so small, you extend, the equations go back, the universe is the size of an atom. Does quantum physics apply to the entire universe? Or only to atoms? Where does that, where are you on that, both of you?
40:19 Janna Levin? Well, at this point, we feel we have to invoke quantum mechanics to understand what was happening in the Big Bang. The energy scales are so dramatic, and that we're really probing quantum physics. High energies, you're really looking, somewhat surprisingly, at small scales. So, we are still trying to grapple with what the Big Bang is telling us about the potential to understand not just general relativity, but a kind of quantum variant of that, if there is such a thing.
40:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, so I got general relativity, I got quantum physics. Do they make nice in the sandbox?
40:56 Brian Greene? It's a deep and difficult question, and one that I and many others have spent their lives trying to answer, and we do not fully have the answer yet.
41:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Let me restate that.
41:05 Brian Greene? Yeah.
41:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That you and others have spent your lives failing to answer.
41:09 Brian Greene? Yes, I agree.
41:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But I think we established that's okay.
41:14 Brian Greene? You hear that? Ah, take that.
41:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, you got a fan over here, alright, go.
41:18 Brian Greene? No, it's exactly the case. So, when you take Einstein's equations of the general theory of relativity, and you try to invoke quantum mechanics within the same calculations, which as you eloquently noted, you'd have to do. If you're talking about the whole universe, when it's incredibly small, you need Einstein's general theory of relativity. It's the whole universe, after all. But you also need quantum physics, because it is so small, and that's the theory that describes the small things. And when you try to simply put the equations together, you get one answer out from almost any calculation, which is infinity.
41:56 Brian Greene? And that might sound, "Oh, that's interesting, a big, deep, mystical number." No, it's nonsense. Infinity is nature's way of grabbing us by the lapel and slapping us around and saying, "You're doing something wrong. You've got to figure this out."
42:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So I've heard another one, that's where... Infinity is where God divides by zero.
42:12 Brian Greene? Yes.
42:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
42:13 Brian Greene? Stephen Hawking, yes.
42:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah. Oh, Stephen Hawking said that.
42:16 Brian Greene? Well, at least that's what he's attributed to.
42:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, okay. So, but, you're saying they don't make nice in the sandbox?
42:22 Brian Greene? Yeah.
42:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, there's a limit. What's this Planck length? What's going on there?
42:28 Janna Levin? Well, the Planck length is the scale at which...
42:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Named after who?
42:33 Janna Levin? After Max Planck, the...
42:37 Brian Greene? I love how you say "Max."
42:38 Janna Levin? I don't know, is it... What do you think?
42:40 Brian Greene? I say Max Planck.
42:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Max, okay.
42:43 Janna Levin? Well, 100 years ago, in the early discoveries of quantum mechanics, was thinking about whether the universe was discrete or if it really was a continuum. And if I looked, for instance, at the air in this room, if I look closer and closer, do I find out it's actually made of individual molecules moving around and is not actually a continuum? And same with water. Was thinking about these things.
43:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In other words, water is not infinitely divisible. You get to a molecule at some point.
43:14 Janna Levin? Eventually, you get to an individual quanta, a little particulate, a discrete bundle. And in thinking about this, there was sort of a fundamental scale that we would say is when we can definitely no longer think in a way where we're ignoring this quantum scale, where we're forced, as Brian's describing. Beyond that, we're definitely going to strike an infinity. But by the Planck length, we're in trouble. We really should be trying to understand the theory of gravity at a quantum level. Maybe that means that spacetime is coming in little individual bundles. I don't even know how to think about that. I'm just thinking about correlations between little tiny...
43:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're saying spacetime is coming?
43:56 Brian Greene? Yeah. That was a wild...
43:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Say that?
43:58 Brian Greene? That was a wild sentence.
44:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, that was very Game of Thrones.
44:02 Brian Greene? Spacetime is coming.
44:06 Janna Levin? Well, I mean, if it came from the Big Bang, I mean, was it the moment that space and time was in fact created? And are we thinking about things of a continuum of spacetime itself?
44:16 Brian Greene? Brian, how big is that smallest unit? The Planck length is 10 to the minus 33 centimeters. And again, I know the question will be, well, you know, how do you think about something that's so small? What does it matter if it's 10 to the minus 33 or 10 to the minus 31? And again, we don't care about the exact value, but that's where the mathematics takes us. And just to get a feel for that, if you were to take an atom and, well, take a tree. Take a tree and expand it to be the size of the observable universe? A tree? Yes. Then the Planck scale, that tends to minus 33 centimeters, would expand roughly to the size of an atom. So the Planck scale is to an atom as a tree is to the universe.
45:00 Brian Greene? That's how tiny the distance we're talking about here. And why, I'm gonna channel Hason now.
45:06 Chuck Nice? And so you measure this with a ruler?
45:08 Brian Greene? Yeah, I know, I'm gonna channel Hason. Can I channel you right now?
45:11 Speaker 04 You can channel me. I'm not gonna even pretend like I understand what's happening right now. I'm gonna be 100% honest. There's like 3,500 people here and I'm like, don't act like you know.
45:22 Brian Greene? I'm gonna channel you.
45:23 Speaker 04 You lost me at spacetime is coming. And by the way, you came in quite hot, Brian, and you're like, I know what you're thinking. And that's not what I was thinking. I was thinking, I think it's really incredible, let's just have a quick little tangent here. I think it's really incredible. It is almost 9:00 PM and this many people went on Ticketmaster.com. Paid fees, you way back there, up there, yes. Way up there, yeah. You guys paid tickets to learn about space nebulae. It really, it was very heartening. So that's what I was thinking about, Brian. It's actually like, you know, when people say this country's going to shit and math and science is at an all-time low? I'm like, you know what? It's, it's the math and science lovers. I feel like we could theater on a...
46:10 Speaker 04 Yeah, of all things you could be doing at 9pm, just...
46:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, I'm channeling Hassan here.
46:18 Speaker 04 Sure.
46:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What, why do you have any confidence at all that you know what's happening on a scale that's small?
46:26 Speaker 04 We don't.
46:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, okay, that's it, that's it. Thank you. Oh, Chuck, come back.
46:32 Speaker 04 Thank you, you guys. We don't know anything and we could be off by a whole lot. Good night, take care. Thank you, Beacon.
46:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, so, so, let me see if I can unpack this.
46:44 Speaker 04 Yeah.
46:46 Speaker 04 Oh, we're gonna figure it out right now?
46:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
46:48 Speaker 04 Okay, sure.
46:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is it true that every prediction we've ever made with quantum physics, when we've been able to test it, has come true?
46:56 Speaker 04 Absolutely.
46:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, is it true that in general relativity, we already know what its boundaries are? Because there are calculations you cannot make because of this infinity problem?
47:08 Speaker 04 Absolutely.
47:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Therefore, if one of those is going to succumb to the other, it sounds like Einstein has to...
47:16 Speaker 04 He's gonna have to bow down to the quantum.
47:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He's gonna have to...
47:19 Speaker 04 That's what's happening.
47:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Bend the knee to the quantum.
47:21 Speaker 04 He's gonna bend the knee to the quantum.
47:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, either quantum will absorb Einstein, or there's a higher level understanding that'll absorb them both.
47:29 Janna Levin? I would say it's, it's, that's true, but also, quantum isn't in competition. We have theories of matter, for instance, nuclear forces that we understand, they can be quantized, right? Theory of electromagnetism can be quantized. So, there are laws of physics, and quantum mechanics is a regime in which we're understanding the highest energy attributes of those laws of physics. Now, gravity, Einstein's general relativity has replaced the theory of gravity with this theory of spacetime, this theory of geometry.
48:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Replace Newton's theory of gravity.
48:03 Janna Levin? Replaces Newton's theory of gravity, but it is one of those forces. It should sit with the matter forces and have a classical regime, meaning a regime in which we don't have to worry about quantum mechanics, things look smooth, we understand general relativity works beautifully.
48:17 Speaker 04 Regime sounds very political.
48:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It does, it does.
48:19 Speaker 04 Dictator.
48:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Totally does. Dictated by.
48:23 Speaker 04 It sounds very, very USSR. It sounds very Kim Jong-un like.
48:28 Janna Levin? Unfortunately, it's true everywhere.
48:28 Speaker 04 Okay, got it, okay.
48:29 Janna Levin? But then, when we go to the early universe, like the Big Bang or in the cores of black holes, where, where things start to get very extreme, we want to be able to quantize. That law of...
48:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? As we have quantized other things successfully...
48:43 Janna Levin? It's not gonna replace gra... Exactly, it's not gonna replace gravity. We wanna quantize gravity, and that seemed like a perfectly reasonable request.
48:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so Einstein's equations are not quantized.
48:53 Brian Greene? Yeah.
48:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They require continuum.
48:55 Brian Greene? Yeah.
48:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So how do you quantize gravity?
48:56 Brian Greene? Good, so Jan is describing the history as very insightful and useful. So, we had an equation for electricity and magnetism that came from Maxwell. We were able to blend that with quantum mechanics, giving us quantum electrodynamics. It works. We had equations describing the strong and weak nuclear forces. We were able to embed quantum mechanics into those theories. Works wonderfully well. When we try to play exactly the same game with Einstein's theory of gravity, general relativity, and try to put quantum mechanics in there to quantize it, it just doesn't work. So what does that mean?
49:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It means you're not smart enough to...
49:35 Brian Greene? Well, it's interesting. It could be that we're not smart enough, and I'm full well willing to take that as the ultimate answer, but there's a lot of evidence, if you allow me to come right up till today for just a moment, I know you want to go temporarily...
49:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is the centennial, but go on.
49:49 Brian Greene? Yeah, so there's evidence today that Einstein's general relativity, the reason why you can't quantize it, the reason why you can't put quantum mechanics into it, it already seems to have quantum mechanics embedded in a deep and subtle way that Einstein himself didn't recognize.
50:05 Chuck Nice? Oh, please do tell me, because my edible just kicked in, and this is fascinating. I mean, what you're saying right now is revolutionary, because what you're saying is you can't put something into something where the thing is there.
50:21 Brian Greene? If it's already there.
50:22 Chuck Nice? We just don't know where it is inside of that thing, but once we find it in there, we're gonna be like, "Yo, that's where it is!" And be like, "I told you not to put it in there, it was already in there!"
50:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
50:34 Chuck Nice? Amazing!
50:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Chuck just blew a gasket. We gotta...
50:38 Chuck Nice? No, that is like, that's like, that's simple, it's elegant, it's profound, it's amazing!
50:44 Brian Greene? I agree.
51:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, so, let me, let's back up, back to the roaring twenties. And I just want to go down the list of completely freaky things that quantum physics prescribed that defied anybody's common sense. And, which is why it's still freaky. In fact, what's that quote from, was it Feynman about quantum physics? What did he say?
51:34 Brian Greene? Yeah, there are a few, but if you think about quantum mechanics without getting dizzy, you haven't understood a single, single thing about it.
51:41 Chuck Nice? Oh, then I understand it very well.
51:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so, 1923. The wave-particle duality is proposed.
51:54 Brian Greene? Yeah.
51:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, that's kinda freaky. That particles are also waves.
51:59 Brian Greene? Yeah, it was Prince Louis de Broglie, who basically-
52:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He was a prince?
52:02 Brian Greene? He was a prince, yeah. And so, he said, "Look, in 1905 Einstein showed us that light, which we had thought of as a wave, actually needs to be described as a particle. So-called photoelectric effect, that's how he went to-
52:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, 05, 1905.
52:15 Brian Greene? 1905. And then in 1923, in his PhD thesis, Louis de Broglie says, "Let me do the reverse. Electrons, we always think about them as particles, maybe they need to be thought of as waves." And that is a key moment in-
52:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And wasn't his PhD thesis like-
52:31 Speaker 04 That was a prince who did that?
52:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A prince.
52:33 Speaker 04 A prince? I don't believe it.
52:37 Speaker 04 I, I, I know current monarchy, not that intelligent. Let's be honest, Harry or William, you're not cooking, you're not cooking this up. There's, there's too much incest. I mean, you know this, you understand science. For you to be operating at that level, so, not buying it. You cheated off someone's paper, not buying it.
52:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, his PhD thesis, if I remember correctly, was like 12 pages long or something?
53:03 Brian Greene? Very short.
53:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Very short?
53:04 Brian Greene? Yeah.
53:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And he got a Nobel Prize for it?
53:06 Speaker 04 It was a 12-page PDF. And he got a Nobel Prize for a 12-page-
53:10 Janna Levin? PhD.
53:11 Speaker 04 A PhD paper.
53:13 Chuck Nice? Okay, let me just say, that's the smartest dude ever.
53:18 Brian Greene? Well, that's how, that's how you know he was royalty. He turned in a 12-page PhD paper. They're like, "Doctor Prince." And he's like, "Thank you." Double-spaced, 12-page PhD paper.
53:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Tighter margin.
53:33 Brian Greene? You entitled piece of shit.
53:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Couple of years later.
53:38 Brian Greene? Sorry, sorry. Neil, you just, I'm sorry, Neil. I shouldn't have, shouldn't have spoken ill of the monarchs there.
53:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, I got nothing. This is America. We fought a war to get away from monarchs.
53:50 Chuck Nice? Not for long.
54:00 Chuck Nice? Just give it time.
54:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay. So, so then Schrödinger came around.
54:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, we have a Schrödinger fan up there.
54:12 Chuck Nice? That was the cat.
54:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
54:14 Chuck Nice? That was the cat.
54:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Cat. So, what does Schrödinger do for us?
54:21 Janna Levin? Well, Schrödinger begins to think more abstractly about what's real and what's not real. So, we're used to thinking of particles. You've already described de Broglie and the electron. We think of these little fundamental particles, almost like billiard balls, acting out their lives. And they have some concrete existence. Schrödinger starts to say, "Well, there's wave-particle duality. That's pretty profound. But maybe the only thing that's real is this thing called the wave function, which is the probability for the particle to be in a certain state, to be in a certain location, to be moving with a certain speed. But the particle itself, in some sense, isn't real anymore. If you look for it, sometimes you'll find it in a concrete location.
55:05 Janna Levin? But what is really determined by equations, by the laws of physics, is the wave function, which is this probabilistic description."
55:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And the wave function occupies physical space, doesn't it?
55:16 Janna Levin? Yeah, the wave function occupies physical space.
55:18 Brian Greene? Only for, only for a single particle. So, it's a kind of important subtlety.
55:23 Janna Levin? Yeah.
55:23 Brian Greene? For one particle, you can think about this wave function as filling space. If there are two particles, it lives in six-dimensional space. If there are three particles, it's in nine-dimensional space. So, you really can't think of it in these ordinary terms.
55:37 Chuck Nice? Ooh, I am high.
55:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, okay. So. So, if the particle can be anywhere here, and I have some barrier here, it could show up on the other side of the barrier.
55:51 Janna Levin? Right, but it doesn't actually travel through. So let's say your barrier is a concrete wall. There's some small probability that you would find the particle. The wave function would describe the probability of finding the particle in this region of space, but it doesn't actually, like a billiard ball, travel through the cement wall.
56:07 Chuck Nice? Okay, now, this might be the THC talking, but the way you guys are talking, there just might just be one particle. Like, there aren't a bunch of particles. It's just one particle.
56:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I told you he blew a gasket.
56:23 Brian Greene? Well, but, but, but Richard Feynman had the idea that maybe there was one particle that circled around through time and cycled back over and over again, giving what appeared to be many particles now, but there's only a single particle through this temporal cycle.
56:39 Chuck Nice? I just said it.
56:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Moving forward and backwards through time.
56:44 Brian Greene? Yep. Oh my god.
56:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, okay. Alright, so, but what I'm saying is if a particle can show up on the other side of the barrier, then that's, you guys came up with a word for that, and it's tunneling.
56:55 Brian Greene? Quantum tunneling.
56:56 Janna Levin? It can quantum tunnel through the barrier, but that, but that's the, the point of Schrodinger saying, what's real is just this probabilistic likelihood of finding the particle. The particle itself, in some sense, does not have concrete existence anymore.
57:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so you know what?
57:11 Janna Levin? It challenges the whole nature of reality.
57:12 Brian Greene? No, but, but concretely, there is a probability that we could calculate
57:16 Janna Levin? Yes.
57:16 Brian Greene? for the likelihood of you tunneling through the stage and being underneath the floor. And it's a non-zero probability. It's kinda small, so it's unlikely to happen, but that's what quantum mechanics tells us.
57:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But the smaller I get, the more likely it will happen.
57:31 Brian Greene? Exactly.
57:32 Janna Levin? It can happen in the laboratory.
57:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, okay. So, just for context here.
57:36 Brian Greene? Wow.
57:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We were trying to understand how the sun made energy. And we did the calculation. Once we determined the sun is mostly hydrogen and it's hottest in the center, we said, "It must be undergoing fusion." And so what you run the math, to undergo fusion, a proton,
57:53 Brian Greene? Yep.
57:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? the nucleus of a hydrogen atom, has to merge with another proton, the nucleus of another hydrogen atom. Protons have the same charge. Electrostatically, like charges repel. So, they have to be moving fast enough. So that before they have a chance to repel, they stick together and form a new nucleus. Okay. We calculated what temperature that was necessary because high temperatures give you higher speeds. We calculated that temperature and it was 100 million degrees and there was no way the center of the sun was going to give us 100 million degrees. Because you can calculate through sensible laws of thermodynamics what that should be and we were scratching our heads. And then quantum physics comes around
58:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? and then you invent this spooky magical thing called tunneling. And we discover in our calculations that at a mere 10 million degrees, see, this matters, 10 million, 100 million. At a mere 10 million degrees, they would otherwise not hit, but some of them tunnel through and connect. Tunneling makes the sun's energy production even possible. And I was like,
59:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? because it's not just some, something that particle physicists worry about in their laboratory. I had to worry about it as an astrophysicist.
59:20 Speaker 04 Why are you worried about this? It's okay.
59:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay. Thank you, thank you.
59:24 Speaker 04 The sun's gonna sun, you know? Hell, Robbins, let them, let the sun, let the sun do that.
59:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thank you.
59:31 Speaker 04 It's okay.
59:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
59:33 Speaker 04 We need you, Neil, don't, don't blow it.
59:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thank you, that's very, very.
59:37 Speaker 04 Okay, so tunneling, tell us more, there's a lot tunneling and.
59:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So now what about the Heisenberg uncertainty principle? That's, that seems like the biggest thing of them all. Talk me through that real fast.
59:46 Brian Greene? Yeah, I would say so, that's the real moment when the old ways of looking at the world are shown, they have to be jettisoned. Because the old way of looking at the world, what is reality? Reality is stuff that's at a location moving with a certain speed. That's the way we describe the world. And Heisenberg, with the armature of quantum mechanics, says you can't actually do that. You can't specify the location and the speed simultaneously of any object. You can't do it according to the quantum equation. So the very language of reality that we used to use
1:00:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No longer applies. Why can't you measure both at the same time?
1:00:26 Brian Greene? Well, if you have a particle described as a wave, right? And you want that particle to have a definite location, that wave has to be highly spiked, so that you can say, ah, almost 100% likelihood it's at this location. But when you see how the notion of velocity comes into quantum mechanics, it has to do with the wavelength of the wave. And so if you want something to have a definite speed, it has to have a definite wavelength. That's not spiky. So to have definite location, you need spike. To have definite speed, you need wave. Those are different shapes.
1:01:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you can't have them at the same time?
1:01:03 Brian Greene? You can't have them at the same time.
1:01:04 Janna Levin? Can I try analogy nowhere near as precise as what Brian just said? But sometimes I like this musical analogy. If you play a chord, which is a whole bunch of notes together, you can play chords, but you can't simultaneously be playing a single note. So the chord is like a superposition of the notes. And how this relates is that when you're in a precise location, what Brian's describing as a sharp spike, you're sort of in a superposition of velocities or momenta. So it's like, it's like the, the location is the note, the, the velocities are the chords, or vice versa. If I know the velocity exactly and I'm playing chords, I'm no longer playing individual, I'm, I'm playing, I can't isolate a single individual note in a superposition of notes.
1:01:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So what is, so how does all this connect to the, what they call the observer effect? Where you, I, I want to measure the particle right there. I, I got to look at it, so I shine light on it, and the light sends it somewhere else.
1:02:00 Brian Greene? Yeah.
1:02:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So I can't actually ever know what the particle's doing.
1:02:03 Brian Greene? Right. And, and so there's two things in there. One is, as you're saying, to look is to interact. And when you interact, say by bouncing a photon off a particle, you affect the particle.
1:02:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because I need the photon to take the picture.
1:02:16 Brian Greene? That's right. So that's one key point that emerges from these ideas. But the other point-
1:02:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So we can never know anything?
1:02:24 Brian Greene? No, no. No, no, this is-
1:02:26 Speaker 04 I've started here. That's the crazy thing. Y'all went on this crazy-
1:02:30 Brian Greene? Hello? I'm sorry, I'm sorry. I got it. That is just not right, okay? Quantum mechanics tells us that the things that you thought you could know are not the things that you can know. But with quantum mechanics, we made predictions of the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron to 14 decimal places, using a theoretical calculation. And we've measured it in degrees, decimal by decimal by decimal, on all of those numbers. And that's why we love these numbers. They show us that we understand what we're doing.
1:03:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, Brian just blew a gasket.
1:03:09 Chuck Nice? So you can know without knowing, is what you're saying? We can know some things.
1:03:14 Speaker 04 Let me say this, Brian. The type of energy you're bringing-
1:03:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, wait, wait.
1:03:19 Speaker 04 Oh man, you are built for CNN. This type of panel smoke? Oh, fantastic.
1:03:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah. Alright, so this-
1:03:28 Speaker 04 You should so be in one of those Street Fighter squares. The decimal to the decimal to the- Yeah, oh, it's great. This is great. This is good stuff. This is good television.
1:03:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so-
1:03:39 Speaker 04 Go ahead, Neil.
1:03:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, this, this observer effect-
1:03:42 Speaker 04 Bring us home with certain-
1:03:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Has been widely misapplied by people thinking my consciousness is affecting the measurement.
1:03:51 Brian Greene? Look, there is a big mystery at the heart of quantum mechanics. Even with our capacity to make calculations that agree with observations to the level of precision that I just emphasized, perhaps with unnecessary theatricality, there is, there is a question that we don't know how to answer, which is what you're asking. When you observe, you seem to be able to coax one result, one answer, even though the quantum description embodies many possibilities. We don't understand how that happens.
1:04:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is this the many worlds hypothesis?
1:04:20 Brian Greene? It's, it's one answer.
1:04:21 Janna Levin? But the Schrödinger equation is so beautiful, and it does not actually include in it a way to understand how measurements are made.
1:04:29 Brian Greene? Yes, that's the key point.
1:04:30 Janna Levin? And, and so if you really take the Schrödinger equation very seriously, it simply says there are all of these possibilities, and they're all half-
1:04:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So we don't have a theory of measurement? To get us through where we are in the physics.
1:04:44 Brian Greene? Just you know, there are proposals. People have put down mathematical equations that do answer this question.
1:04:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What is the many worlds hypothesis?
1:04:51 Brian Greene? The many worlds hypothesis is if you have a description of a quantum system like a particle, and the quantum wave says 30% chance here, 20% chance here, 50% chance over here. When you measure it, you don't get only one result. There's one of you that finds it over here. There's another one of you that finds it over here. And there's a third one of you that finds it over here, but these are all in different universes. Oh, it's Rick and Morty.
1:05:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you just invented multiple universes to explain something you can't otherwise explain?
1:05:24 Brian Greene? The math invented it.
1:05:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thank you, Chuck.
1:05:27 Brian Greene? Wait, wait, wait. That's really important. So this guy named Hugh Everett, in 1957 in Princeton, he studies the math, the very equation that Janna made reference to, the Schrödinger equation. He says to himself, "Let me take the math completely seriously and see where it takes me." And the math takes you, when you look at the paper, it's direct to this possibility of there being multiple universes. It's not made up. It really emerges directly from an analysis of the equations, and the equations make predictions that are confirmed. So you say, "Maybe I should take this math fully seriously," and that's where it takes you.
1:06:01 Chuck Nice? The passion with which Brian is describing this is like me explaining why I have glitter on my face when I come home because I was at an arts and craft fair.
1:06:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, we're gonna have to land this plane soon. Just briefly, I know you spent your career doing this, but just in 30 seconds, explain string theory.
1:06:35 Speaker 04 Twenty seconds, does life have meaning? Go!
1:06:38 Brian Greene? I only need ten. No, look, the old picture was that the fundamental constituents of matter were little dot-like particles. The string idea is that maybe they're little extended filaments. And why do we introduce this idea? When you introduce this idea, quantum mechanics and general relativity do play well in the sandbox.
1:06:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wow. Okay. And that was less than thirty seconds. Whoa, all right, okay. So what's in the future? So I know astrophysically, we don't know anything about dark matter, we don't know anything about dark energy, we shouldn't have even named them, because we don't know enough about them to even name them.
1:07:15 Janna Levin? And they should be called invisible.
1:07:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I should, they should be called Fred and Wilma. With no bias. So, or faster than the light, time travel, time travel, faster than the light travel, before the big bang. Is what you're working on, or your peeps, does it address any of this? Will quantum mechanics take us to all the places we need?
1:07:36 Brian Greene? Yeah, I mean, there's zero evidence that quantum mechanics has any cracks whatsoever. It's the only theory that we've written down in the history of science.
1:07:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's the most successful theory.
1:07:45 Brian Greene? Most successful theory.
1:07:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ever.
1:07:46 Brian Greene? And so we introduce this.
1:07:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Which gives you confidence to believe crazy stuff that it predicts.
1:07:50 Brian Greene? Exactly. And so we're pressing on, and ultimately, we think putting general relativity and quantum mechanics, either because they're already born together, or because they're blended together, will be the key to answering these questions. We're not there yet, but that's exactly where we're headed.
1:08:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And why do you need these extra dimensions?
1:08:07 Janna Levin? Well, Brian was describing string theory, which may or may not be true, but string theory actually requires extra dimensions for it to make sense, for the mathematics to allow gravity and matter and quantum mechanics to play nice together. But even without string theory, the idea that there are extra spatial dimensions is just kind of a natural extension when you start to think about space and time, and you start to take seriously Einstein's ideas. So now we're in the predicament where maybe those extra dimensions are harboring the dark energy. Maybe there's some explanation for the dark matter having to do with the extra dimensions. So now, we can start to think of the extra dimensions as a dark sector that are harboring, really, the resolutions.
1:08:49 Janna Levin? Like, we're observing them already, we just don't have the direct connection, to be certain.
1:08:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So they're invisible in plain sight? Is that what you're saying?
1:08:59 Janna Levin? Yeah, I mean, they're literally visible, but maybe dark energy is a consequence of quantum energies, which is a paper Brian and I wrote many years ago. Dark energy. Dark energy, which is driving the universe to expand ever faster, which is something we observe.
1:09:14 Chuck Nice? It is also driving my administration.
1:09:19 Janna Levin? I've got to land this plane.
1:09:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Uh, go on, go on.
1:09:24 Janna Levin? Oh, well, just that we might be observing through something like dark energy, indirect evidence of extra dimensions. We can't literally see into them, we can't point to them, we can't move around in them yet, but we are living with the consequence.
1:09:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So these could be manifestations
1:09:39 Janna Levin? Yes.
1:09:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? of these higher order phenomenon in the universe.
1:09:42 Janna Levin? Which is part of the motivation for thinking about them. Perfect sense.
1:09:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thank you, Chuck.
1:09:48 Chuck Nice? All right, just wanted to put a button on that.
1:09:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Quote from Einstein in his denial of quantum physics, in spite of him contributing so mightily to the field. He, you described the probabilistic nature, especially from Schrödinger's equation, and Einstein said, "God does not play dice with the universe."
1:10:06 Speaker 04 And Niels Bohr retorted, "Einstein, stop telling God what to do."
1:10:12 Chuck Nice? You know, you don't know if God needs to make some money real quick, you don't know that.
1:10:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? With the dice?
1:10:16 Chuck Nice? Yeah, you know, I can see him down.
1:10:21 Chuck Nice? Papa needs a new universe.
1:10:27 Speaker 04 I like how back in the day scientists threw shade at each other very poetically. The way they, you know, kind of shit-posted was very, the use of...
1:10:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, we have good vocabulary to work with.
1:10:38 Speaker 04 Yeah, great vivid language.
1:10:39 Chuck Nice? They still do it the same today.
1:10:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The way I'm going to land this plane is offer you a cosmic perspective, something that I'm prone to do when we're exposed to this much information. When I think of the 1920s,
1:10:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? as a scientist, it may be the most consequential decade ever in the history of science, based on how it influenced our thought, our, the trajectory of our research that would follow, and, but I want to make a slightly different point.
1:11:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Before the 1920s,
1:11:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What are scientists doing? Well, they're doing sciency things, right? In a lab, there's a chemical, or there's a particle, there's a material.
1:11:35 Speaker 04 Merlin Meyer flask.
1:11:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, flask, thank you, Jess. You flesh out the picture of your lab, okay. Suppose it was the 1920s, and you had a friend, relative, or you were a politician, and you heard that someone is working on the structure of atoms and molecules. You'll say, "Why does that matter to anyone? I'm a carpenter, I just care that my wood atoms cut, or that they can be shined, or polished, or painted. Why does that matter to me? I'm making cars in an assembly line. Why does it matter to anybody?" You're taking your brilliant intellect,
1:12:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? and applying it to something that nobody cares about except your cadre of people. But they will tell you, "Well, it's the foundations of matter." And they'll tell you, "I don't care you're using up national resources to do this." Well, what has happened every time we researched the frontier of science, in basically every frontier of science? Whatever it looks like when you're doing it, it's easy to say, "That'll never apply to anything." Why are you doing that?
1:13:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You wait a little while, they're clever engineers, clever other scientists. They see problems in the world, and they see a possible solution? Do you realize today there is no creation, storage, and retrieval of digital information without an exploitation of the quantum? The IT revolution, that is responsible for nearly half the GDP of the world, at some level, was birthed in that decade, at a time when people are just exploring the edge of our understanding of the world.
1:13:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, it would take 50 years, longer than what is typical for an R&D project to show up as a household product.
1:13:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But all I can tell you is if you know anyone who says we're doing too much science, or this science is not relevant to me, or I don't know why you're doing this, that doesn't sound like it makes sense.
1:14:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What you're doing is you're cutting out at the kneecaps, the legs of a future waves of discovery that could transform civilization. Not only take us to where we might want to go, but possibly solve problems that we might have created for ourselves.
1:14:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So,
1:14:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? there is nothing more shortsighted in this world than anybody running up and saying we should do less science. Because every one of us in this room has been touched by it.
1:14:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And there's no greater demonstration of that than the science that unfolded in that decade, the 1920s. That's the quantum side of it. In the astrophysics side, that birthed our understanding of the beginning of the universe and how the sun makes its energy. We would then learn how the stars manufacture elements in their core. We would learn, take a few more decades, exploiting the quantum, applying to other realms of science.
1:15:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We would learn that the very ingredients of our bodies, the carbon, the oxygen, the nitrogen, the iron are traceable to stars that underwent thermonuclear fusion following all the rules of quantum physics. And those stars exploded, scattered that enrichment across the galaxy, creating the environment, the chemical ingredients, to make star systems with planets, and on some of those planets, life.
1:15:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that that era not only gave us our IT revolution, it gave us an awareness of ourselves that borders on the spiritual. And it's the fact that not only are we alive in this universe, because of our ingredients are traceable to stars, the universe is alive within us.
1:16:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And that is a cosmic perspective. This, this has been StarTalk, live from the Beacon Theater. This is like a fifth time at the Beacon Theater, fifth or sixth time, and you guys have been a marvelous audience for us. We love you all. And... Oh, no, thank you. And, but more than loving you all, we love the support you give for science, because there is no future of civilization without it. We might as well just move back to the
1:17:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? cave. So, as always, Neil deGrasse Tyson here, thanking our panel. We've got Chuck Nice, Brian Greene, Ken Levin, Hasan Minhaj. Neil deGrasse Tyson, you're a personal astrophysicist, as always bidding you to... Keep looking... Eight of you knew this, okay?
1:17:38 Speaker 04 We're gonna do it one more time, come on. All right, here we go. What's the tagline?
1:17:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay. Neil deGrasse Tyson, you're a personal astrophysicist.
1:17:49 Speaker 04 Astrophysicist?
1:17:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Bidding you to...
1:17:51 Speaker 04 Bidding you to?
1:17:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Keep looking up.
1:17:53 Speaker 04 Keep looking up, here we go. Remember, it's, he's gonna go, Neil deGrasse has a da-da-da-da-da. And remember, those eight people, they cared. You guys all paid money, rusty currency, a real number that we know, Brian. We know exactly how much you paid to those sharks at Ticketmaster. Them. Now, he's gonna go, Neil deGrasse has a da-da-da-da-da, to keep, and you go, looking up. Here we go.
1:18:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Neil deGrasse Tyson, you're a personal astrophysicist, bidding you all to...
1:18:20 Speaker 04 Keep!
1:18:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Keep looking up.
1:18:22 Speaker 04 Looking up.
1:18:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right.
1:18:24 Speaker 04 Yes.
Previous Curing All Disease with AI with Max Jaderberg Next Cosmic Queries – Alien Worlds and Extremophiles with Kennda Lynch Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated