Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast Maker Mix, with Bill Nye (Part 1) – StarTalk All-Stars About this episode Makers of the world, unite! Bill Nye and Chuck Nice roll up their sleeves to answer Cosmic Queries about the maker movement, including 3d printing of tools, food, human joints and organs; nanotechnology; ISRU and colonizing Mars; STEM vs. STEAM; and more.
NOTE: StarTalk All-Access subscribers can watch or listen to this entire episode commercial-free. Find out more at https://www.startalkradio.net/startalk-all-access/
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Chuck Nice? This is StarTalk.
0:08 Bill Nye? Welcome, welcome to StarTalk Radio. I'm your host, Bill Nye. This special segment of Cosmic Queries, Maker Edition, is brought to you by Google. Be sure to check out their website at MakingScienceWithGoogle.com. Now, I try to pull back, everybody, because I'm not alone here. No, no. I'm with world citizen Chuck. Nice, Chuck. How you doing?
0:32 Chuck Nice? Hey, Bill. How are you?
0:33 Bill Nye? I'm feeling great, because this is a special edition.
0:36 Chuck Nice? Yes, it is a special edition.
0:37 Bill Nye? This is the Maker Edition.
0:38 Chuck Nice? The Maker Edition.
0:39 Bill Nye? So, these are people that make things?
0:41 Chuck Nice? Yes. All of these people are progenitors of some sort, in one way or another.
0:48 Bill Nye? Progenitors?
0:48 Chuck Nice? Yes.
0:49 Bill Nye? Could be progenitrixes.
0:51 Chuck Nice? Ah, look at you.
0:53 Bill Nye? Progenitrices. So, with all this said, these are people that make stuff. That's what we do in engineering. We use science to build things and solve problems. What is our first query?
1:02 Chuck Nice? Well, let's get into our first query, and it's actually one of our Patreon patrons. This is from Terraco Pottery, a potter, living in St. Joseph, Minnesota. So, he indeed is a maker with a question about making.
1:18 Bill Nye? He makes pottery.
1:19 Chuck Nice? Makes pottery, yes.
1:20 Bill Nye? St. Joe.
1:22 Chuck Nice? In St. Joe, AMI. So, this is what he says.
1:25 Bill Nye? MN, MN.
1:25 Chuck Nice? MN, sorry. Sorry, you're right. Oh, God, what a faux pas. The people at the Mall of America are hating us right now.
1:31 Bill Nye? Yes.
1:31 Chuck Nice? Yes. Here's what he says. "What are your thoughts, Bill, on changing the STEM field to STEAM by adding ART into the acronym? Companies like Apple Computers and Tesla Motors advance STEM fields by creating artistically designed products that people resonate with worldwide. Do they provide evidence that ART might play an important role in getting more people excited about scientific progress?"
2:00 Bill Nye? And the short answer is yes.
2:02 Chuck Nice? Uh-huh.
2:03 Bill Nye? So, STEAM is fine. Science, Technology, Engineering, ART, and Math, that's fine. That's great.
2:09 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
2:09 Bill Nye? And by the way, when you make products, you want them to look cool. And I think this is why, just to name names, that's why Google is successful.
2:16 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
2:17 Bill Nye? You click on the Google main page, and there's not anything on it. It's just
2:20 Chuck Nice? Except Google.
2:21 Bill Nye? This beautiful minimalist thing. And that's why Apple products are so popular is they look good.
2:26 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
2:26 Bill Nye? So you certainly want products to look good. If I'm gonna buy pottery, be it in Minnesota or anywhere else.
2:32 Chuck Nice? Right.
2:33 Bill Nye? I want it to look nice.
2:34 Chuck Nice? Yes, I want my pottery, um, phone case for my iPhone.
2:40 Bill Nye? Oh, that would be, that'd be brittle. But who knows where that will lead? The guy with skills to make pottery may be able to make all sorts of things.
2:47 Chuck Nice? Yes.
2:48 Bill Nye? Because he's, he designs or makes shapes.
2:51 Chuck Nice? So now, uh, when you look at design as an element of engineering, uh, there's in art, they say form follows function.
3:00 Bill Nye? They say that in architecture too.
3:02 Chuck Nice? Yes. So now, does that work when you're engineering? Like, okay, you're building a.
3:06 Bill Nye? Look at an airplane. Aren't they good looking?
3:09 Chuck Nice? Yes, but they weren't always. When you look back at the old Sockwood Camels, the old biplanes, uh.
3:16 Bill Nye? They were kind of at that, in that era, they were the coolest thing going because they flew.
3:20 Chuck Nice? Right.
3:21 Bill Nye? So.
3:22 Chuck Nice? Yeah, exactly.
3:24 Bill Nye? It was pretty cool. Still is pretty cool. So, uh, form, that's one of the things, by the way, not changing the subject from pottery and steam.
3:31 Chuck Nice? Right.
3:32 Bill Nye? But that's one of the things that's really appealing for me about airplanes is everything on there has to do something. You, there's, it's very hard to add stuff to planes. It doesn't absolutely have to be there because they get too heavy.
3:42 Chuck Nice? Yes.
3:43 Bill Nye? So, um, my, uh, I'm a big fan of, uh, steam and writ large. I just don't want it to get to the point where all of school becomes an acronym. You know what I mean? But right now, we, I guess there's a conflict between funding science, technology, engineering and math and funding art. You have to fund both.
4:04 Chuck Nice? Right.
4:04 Bill Nye? So steam it is. Steam on if you will.
4:07 Chuck Nice? Not steampunk, but.
4:09 Bill Nye? Uh, steampunk never appealed to me.
4:10 Chuck Nice? Really?
4:11 Bill Nye? No.
4:11 Chuck Nice? Come on.
4:12 Bill Nye? The reason is it's not real.
4:14 Chuck Nice? Oh, well, yeah, I guess you're right. When you, when you look at it from the actual mechanical standpoint, like none of those inventions are.
4:22 Bill Nye? The helium balloons wouldn't really fly.
4:24 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
4:25 Bill Nye? The steam powered, uh, wheelchair wouldn't really run.
4:29 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
4:29 Bill Nye? It, it just, it's so that just always took me out of it a little bit.
4:33 Chuck Nice? Great conventions.
4:34 Bill Nye? Oh, yeah, yeah.
4:35 Chuck Nice? You know, when you see those people at the hotel and they've got their goggles on and their, their little caps and their trench coats and.
4:42 Bill Nye? Are you talking from personal experience here, Chuck?
4:45 Chuck Nice? I'm just saying.
4:45 Bill Nye? No, no, no, you're just saying, and it's not you.
4:48 Chuck Nice? I'm just saying.
4:48 Bill Nye? No, yes.
4:49 Chuck Nice? If you happen to be at the New York Hilton in October and you see a black guy wearing goggles at a steampunk convention, it might be Chuck Nice, maybe.
4:56 Bill Nye? That's all you're saying. That's all you're saying. Let's try another query. Good question, Steeman, Potter in Minnesota.
5:03 Chuck Nice? All right, let's move on to Matt Eli, who comes to us from Facebook and Bay City, Texas. And Matt Eli wants to know this. How are we going to print 3D stuff on Mars out of native material there? Or in the clouds of Venus? Or on the moon? Or in the asteroid belt? So is it necessary to to mine materials from that area or from that place to use as 3D print material?
5:39 Bill Nye? Uh, this is a great question, but we may be mixing. The modern verb everybody loves Chuck is conflating.
5:46 Chuck Nice? Ah, conflating.
5:47 Bill Nye? Or could be, not saying we are, conflating 3D printing in space with in situ resource utilization.
5:55 Chuck Nice? All right, now.
5:55 Bill Nye? ISRU.
5:56 Chuck Nice? Okay, now, now, see, now you got me right there.
5:58 Bill Nye? Well, so the idea is you could.
6:00 Chuck Nice? Say that again, because I can't even, I don't even know what you just said there.
6:02 Bill Nye? So everybody in the Mars community loves this acronym. Four, four, four-letter acronym. ISRU, in situ resource utilization.
6:12 Chuck Nice? In situ resource.
6:13 Bill Nye? In the situation. There you are on the surface of Mars.
6:17 Chuck Nice? Right.
6:17 Bill Nye? In the situation. Utilizing, which is another word we used to say, using the resources there. So that's a big plan.
6:25 Chuck Nice? I gotta grow some sprouts.
6:27 Bill Nye? Well, to scrape up, that's right. Uh, in the Martian, you can scrape the book or the movie, you scrape up some Martian soil and use chemistry to make rocket fuel out of it. Get the oxygen out of it. Maybe get the iron, recombine them and they burn and off you go. Uh, and on Mars, I think it'd be lower pitch. But anyway, um, it's a great idea, fine idea. Meanwhile. A recent study at NASA indicates that it's probably better to take material to make objects with a 3D printer, which seem to work well enough in zero gravity
7:03 Chuck Nice? Right.
7:04 Bill Nye? or microgravity. And so, instead of taking surgical scissors, a scalpel, what else do you take? Sponges?
7:11 Chuck Nice? Right.
7:12 Bill Nye? Sutures, suture needles. You make all that if you need it. You're ready to make it.
7:19 Chuck Nice? So now, at that point, kind of like a little more of a Star Trek like replicator type deal.
7:25 Bill Nye? But 3D printers are virtually replicators, man. It's amazing now, and this is now, it's, what year is this, 2016? We scan objects with hologram style lasers, create a three-dimensional image of it, then use that three-dimensional image to print it, is the verb, but or additively manufacture it. And so, this is an exciting time, but making rocket fuel out of the Martian surface, I'm not sure is quite the same thing as is intended by traditional spaceborne 3D printing. However, can't see why these two things wouldn't merge one day.
8:03 Chuck Nice? Right, so there's, there's not really a need to choose, it's not a selfish choice.
8:07 Bill Nye? It'll happen, it'll be organic, pun intended. It'll be, it'll come from the Martian surface, but you know, getting to the Martian surface is not trivial. Having a colony there is probably a real hassle. But I want to send people there to look for signs of life, and if those people need 3D printing additive manufacture technology to get it done economically, let's go!
8:31 Chuck Nice? So if you were to send, let's say, you know, sending people is a real pain in the butt.
8:35 Bill Nye? It's expensive and never been done.
8:38 Chuck Nice? And, and, and, you know, people are a pain in the butt. I mean, have you met people?
8:41 Bill Nye? Yes.
8:42 Chuck Nice? Have you met them?
8:43 Bill Nye? Some of my best friends.
8:46 Chuck Nice? But...
8:46 Bill Nye? Or dogs.
8:47 Chuck Nice? Is, is there still a need if you were to send autonomous machines that can work on their own? And then, would they still be able to utilize the...
9:00 Bill Nye? That's the whole idea. So the Mars 2020 rover, which does not have a name yet, we hope to do this experiment, try to scrape up Martian soil and make it into rocket fuel.
9:10 Chuck Nice? Wow.
9:10 Bill Nye? Be cool, yeah.
9:11 Chuck Nice? It would be very cool.
9:12 Bill Nye? So they can be done robotically, it is believed. And so, the chemistry and you do simulants... Uh, simulations with simulant soil, I mean to say, and we get that usually in Hawaii. That
9:24 Chuck Nice? Why is, why is there soil there simulant to?
9:27 Bill Nye? The iron bearing red volcanic sand is a lot, apparently, a lot like Mars. You can try this stuff and it seems to work, but to really pull it off and really plan to go to Mars and only get back if you can scrape up Martian soil and make it into rocket fuel. I mean, that's a whole nother.
9:43 Chuck Nice? Yeah, you might be planning a one-way trip.
9:44 Bill Nye? You, you might, yeah, it's
9:45 Chuck Nice? Inadvertently.
9:46 Bill Nye? Yes, and you don't want the inadvertent one-way trip. You don't want to, uh, die on impact and you don't want to be stranded. These are two really undesirable outcomes, uh, on Mars. So Chuck, we're on cosmic queries.
9:59 Chuck Nice? Yes, we are.
9:59 Bill Nye? We do our best to answer an inquiry.
10:02 Chuck Nice? Yes.
10:03 Bill Nye? From our beloved listeners.
10:04 Chuck Nice? People want to know about making things in space on other planets and
10:07 Bill Nye? That's what we do in engineering, Chuck.
10:09 Chuck Nice? Yes, it is.
10:10 Bill Nye? We use science to make things and solve problems. Take it.
10:13 Chuck Nice? All right.
10:13 Bill Nye? Query, number one.
10:15 Chuck Nice? Query, number one. Ooh. Michal Wegzren.
10:21 Bill Nye? Oh, yes.
10:22 Chuck Nice? Ah, Michal, I, I, I bet you I got that name right, Michal. Michal Wegzren, Wegzren. All right, that's as good as I can do. Uh, from Facebook. Says, Bill, nanotechnology versus 3D printing. When can we expect 3D printers to be able to print nano elements for future nanotech devices? That's a little meta.
10:47 Bill Nye? It is meta, but it's not that far.
10:49 Chuck Nice? Really?
10:50 Bill Nye? Yeah, many nano machines are made with the same technology as 3D printing, where you can move the probe tiny, tiny increments and tiny, tiny increments. And, um, shove molecules around or atoms around, I mean.
11:04 Chuck Nice? Wow.
11:04 Bill Nye? And so that's actually, uh, almost, spiritually, in the big picture.
11:10 Chuck Nice? Right.
11:11 Bill Nye? This tiny process does exist. When are you going to be able to do it and make airplanes out of it or aircraft carriers or something? That's the ways are.
11:18 Chuck Nice? So now, would there ever be this, you know, in every sci-fi movie, this is what you see, you know? The nanobots.
11:25 Bill Nye? Yes.
11:26 Chuck Nice? They all come together. And then they create something. So it's it's it's just this never ending process where the the there's the machine that creates the nanobots. Then the nanobots come together to create or build something.
11:39 Bill Nye? Well, they usually, I think they usually make a replica of Chuck Nice.
11:43 Chuck Nice? Yes.
11:43 Bill Nye? And I and the crew here cannot tell the difference between the real Chuck Nice and the nanobotical Chuck Nice and then.
11:51 Chuck Nice? One of us has a naval bill.
11:53 Bill Nye? And then things go badly. Things generally go badly. Cause the nanobot Chuck is motivated by something bad.
12:01 Chuck Nice? Yes, of course he is.
12:02 Bill Nye? But with that said, the idea of using uh 3D technology to move a probe or a an atom placer or machine. Tiny, tiny increments does exist. That's how uh in a sense, that's how we make some micro circuits.
12:19 Chuck Nice? Really?
12:19 Bill Nye? But this is the future where you'd have this machine working really fast on a much larger scale. So stay tuned. And maybe you'll be the mechanical engineer, the electrical engineer that, you know, gets on this and makes it all practical and inexpensive.
12:32 Chuck Nice? Nice. All right, fantastic. So it already exists. Look at that.
12:36 Bill Nye? In a sense.
12:37 Chuck Nice? How?
12:37 Bill Nye? In a sense.
12:38 Chuck Nice? In a sense, it's already there. Science future today.
12:42 Bill Nye? Today. That's why you listen to StarTalk.
12:44 Chuck Nice? That's exactly right.
12:45 Bill Nye? Maker Edition.
12:48 Chuck Nice? Brought to you by Google. Here we go. Uh Gabe Dominguez uh from Facebook. Wants to know this. Um. Instead of sending a rover to a planet. Could we send just a 3D printer? Plus assembly unit? To create multiple rovers? And are there any plans to do something like this? So instead of just one rover, you send kind of a whole manufacturing unit. Then you you got a bunch of rovers that now emanate from this one little manufacturing unit. And they can kind of comb the entire planet for you.
13:25 Bill Nye? So for those who just listening to the podcast, I'm sorry you can't see Chuck's uh arms, gesticulations, showing us how this robotic.
13:34 Chuck Nice? About.
13:34 Bill Nye? Robotic manufacturing on another world. So this gets back to that thing about using the material on, let's say, the Martian surface.
13:42 Chuck Nice? Right.
13:42 Bill Nye? Otherwise, you, I mean, everybody understand.
13:44 Chuck Nice? Wait, let me see if I remember. Wait. Oh, God. In situ.
13:50 Chuck Nice? Resource.
13:52 Chuck Nice? Damn it!
13:53 Bill Nye? No, no, it's not damn it. It's utilization.
13:56 Chuck Nice? Utilization. In situ, in-situation resource utilization.
14:01 Bill Nye? Yes, so the only way you would want to do this, everybody, is if you could manufacture this stuff out of the material that's already there. Here on Earth, we're really good at manufacture, or pretty good at manufacturing things. Sending all the raw materials to Mars would almost certainly not have an advantage. With that said, thinking out loud, as we hear on, as we are here on StarTalk, perhaps the problems associated with folding up the rovers so they fit in the rocket nose cone.
14:33 Chuck Nice? Uh huh.
14:33 Bill Nye? Maybe that is a hard problem, and maybe you'd want to send all the piece parts there in more compact fashion, and then have the manufacturing gizmo put the wheels on the car, kind of thing.
14:47 Chuck Nice? Right.
14:47 Bill Nye? I'm jamming here.
14:48 Chuck Nice? Right.
14:48 Bill Nye? I'm jamming.
14:49 Chuck Nice? Right, I like it.
14:49 Bill Nye? Because the rovers have to be origamatically folded up.
14:54 Chuck Nice? Origamatically?
14:55 Bill Nye? I think it might be origameically folded up.
14:58 Chuck Nice? Right.
14:58 Bill Nye? To get in there.
14:59 Chuck Nice? When they get there, they all look like little cranes.
15:02 Bill Nye? Yeah, yeah, that's right, they do, and then they unfold. No, there could be something to that, that's a cool question. But right now, what we want to, it's just all we can do to get government officials to get together to spend one and a half billion over 10 years, which is nothing. I mean, compared to other things we spent money on. And so, uh...
15:22 Chuck Nice? Now, if we were fighting a war on Mars.
15:24 Bill Nye? Oh, geez.
15:25 Chuck Nice? We would have at least 15 trillion to throw at that.
15:27 Bill Nye? Yeah, that's right, yes, about...
15:29 Chuck Nice? Like, what we need are some Martian terrorists.
15:31 Bill Nye? That's right.
15:32 Chuck Nice? That's what we really need.
15:33 Bill Nye? It's about a factor of 10, 10.2.
15:36 Chuck Nice? Exactly.
15:37 Bill Nye? You multiply the NASA budget by 10.2, you start to get to what the military spends.
15:45 Chuck Nice? Wow.
15:46 Bill Nye? Yeah.
15:46 Chuck Nice? That's a little sickening.
15:47 Bill Nye? Well, you know, we live on Earth, and so, I said NASA budget, I meant planetary science budget, yeah. There'll be emails, I've just ended my career. Yes, lead on, we have another query.
15:59 Chuck Nice? Yes, we do.
16:00 Bill Nye? About making things on the special edition of StarTalk with me, your host, Bill Nye, and citizen of the world, of the wide world, Chuck Nice. Chuck, take it.
16:09 Chuck Nice? Here we go. Uh, this is from Andy Bracken on Facebook, and Andy says this. "Greetings, Bill, from Columbus, Ohio." How difficult would it be to switch from one material to another, uh, AG going from PVC plastic to steel in the middle of a 3D printing process because those are the components needed to make the item?
16:32 Bill Nye? Well, it's being proposed, Andy. Instead of, you may not feed the plastic through the same head or dispenserizer machine as you do the steel, but you'd have multiple heads. This is all solvable.
16:47 Chuck Nice? Like a, like a soda gun at a bar?
16:49 Bill Nye? Yes, exactly. Not that you would know.
16:51 Chuck Nice? No, cuz you never see those places.
16:54 Bill Nye? No, you've never been to a bar, but, but you've read stories on the electric internet.
16:59 Chuck Nice? Yeah, it's a fabled tale.
17:00 Bill Nye? Yes, or maybe the occasional movie. So the, uh, that would be the idea. That's not that hard. In the same way, um, there are, uh, 3D printers that use different colored plastic.
17:13 Chuck Nice? Right.
17:14 Bill Nye? All at once. So you have different heads that feed the plastic.
17:16 Chuck Nice? So those heads would rotate or change?
17:18 Bill Nye? Yes, what I presume is not, not a robot maker guy person, but, uh, with an interest. It seems like a very reasonable thing to do, but there, let me emphasize, there has to be a good reason to do it. You know, these things operate at different temperatures.
17:33 Chuck Nice? Right.
17:34 Bill Nye? And so, uh, you, you may not, you don't want to melt the first thing with the second thing.
17:40 Chuck Nice? Second thing, right. So now how far are we in terms of our, um, I'll, I'll say molecular manipulation of plastic, uh, to get to the place where you can just make plastic that mimics different types of metals?
17:55 Bill Nye? That's our dream, man. That's what we do all day. You're, you're, I'm sure you're referring to polysulfone.
18:00 Chuck Nice? Yes, of course.
18:01 Bill Nye? Yes.
18:02 Chuck Nice? Well, I mean, what else would I have been referring to?
18:04 Bill Nye? No, some plastics are nearly as strong as steel nowadays.
18:07 Chuck Nice? Right.
18:08 Bill Nye? Especially the ones that you can get glass in, uh, glass fibers or, the other thing we all want to do is orient the fibers.
18:17 Chuck Nice? Right.
18:18 Bill Nye? Follow me?
18:19 Chuck Nice? Yeah, I got you what you're saying there.
18:20 Bill Nye? So, uh, you know, uh, plywood has grain that's oriented in 90 degree angles almost always for strength. And so. Ingots that come out of a steel mill or an aluminum mill have a strength that's different in this direction versus that direction.
18:37 Chuck Nice? Gotcha.
18:38 Bill Nye? As the way they're extruded or drawn out. And then the same is absolutely true of plastics. So you'd want to be able to exploit that.
18:44 Chuck Nice? That's so funny that you just said that. I used to, uh, work in a position where I had to do some stuff with fabrics and...
18:52 Bill Nye? That is the funniest thing I've ever heard.
18:54 Chuck Nice? (laughing)
18:56 Bill Nye? What sort of fab... Were you doing it on... Were you doing it on the Bible? On the bias? On the Bible? On the bias?
19:02 Chuck Nice? Cutting on the bias.
19:03 Bill Nye? You were cutting on the bias.
19:05 Chuck Nice? Look at you with your fashion, uh, uh, terminology. Knowing your fashion terminology.
19:09 Bill Nye? You were just in my mind's head. We were just at the soda gun at the bar.
19:14 Chuck Nice? And then all of a sudden we're transported.
19:16 Bill Nye? No, no. Well, you may have noticed that there's often fibers in those clear hoses.
19:20 Chuck Nice? Yes, there is.
19:21 Bill Nye? Those fibers are oriented to maximize the strength. And speaking of maximizing the strength, we're maximizing the fun here on StarTalk Radio. We'll be back right after this.
19:33 Bill Nye? Chuck, you know, this is a very exciting time here at StarTalk Radio because this is a maker edition.
19:38 Chuck Nice? Yes, it is.
19:38 Bill Nye? It's right brought to you by Google.
19:40 Chuck Nice? That's correct.
19:40 Bill Nye? Don't forget, making science with google.com.
19:43 Chuck Nice? That's where you go.
19:44 Bill Nye? You can get involved in the whole maker vibe.
19:47 Chuck Nice? (laughing)
19:49 Bill Nye? What's another... We got another query.
19:50 Chuck Nice? Yes, we do have another query. Let's, uh, let's read this one from Tom Ricks from Facebook. Tom Ricks? Tom Ricks from Facebook would like to know this. He says, "Bill Nye the Science Guy."
20:02 Bill Nye? Yes.
20:03 Chuck Nice? "How long do you think it will be before we can print a 3D agricultural crop in order to reduce CO2 emissions and water consumption? We have all the ingredients, right?" So he's talking about, forget going to space and printing something, can we print something here and now, namely, food?
20:25 Bill Nye? Yeah, I thought he wanted to print a crop.
20:27 Chuck Nice? He does. He wants to...
20:28 Bill Nye? That's pretty aggressive.
20:28 Chuck Nice? He wants to, uh, "our agricultural crops in order to reduce CO2 emissions and water consumption," which is, which is very important.
20:37 Bill Nye? So, Tom, I've, I think I follow you, but you're, you want, if I understand this, you want to eat a 3D printed plant?
20:45 Chuck Nice? Yes.
20:46 Bill Nye? So you, I mean, right at our current state of the art, you're going to be eating plastic. Okay.
20:51 Chuck Nice? Oh, that doesn't work.
20:52 Bill Nye? Why would you put the crop out in the sun if it's 3D printed and stuff like that? So, we may have, uh, once again, if I can use the verb, conflated a couple ideas. Very reasonable that you'll be able to 3D print beads that hold water in the soil.
21:10 Chuck Nice? Uh-huh.
21:11 Bill Nye? Right, so that there's less evaporation. That's very reasonable to me, or maybe even a, a mat for planting your crops akin to, uh, mulch? Plastic mulch, do you know what I mean? Are you hip to mulch?
21:23 Chuck Nice? Traps the moisture.
21:24 Bill Nye? Yeah, yeah, and keeps weeds from coming through.
21:27 Chuck Nice? The moisture doesn't evaporate back into the atmosphere.
21:29 Bill Nye? Right, but you don't want to have it too sealed up, then you get fungi of various brands.
21:35 Chuck Nice? Yes.
21:35 Bill Nye? So, I think I know what you're driving.
21:37 Chuck Nice? I'm talking about the inside of my sneakers.
21:39 Bill Nye? Oh, that's a lot of information, Chuck. So, we, I think I know what you're driving at. We would have custom-made mulch mats to plant our crops in, and they could be 3D printed, the mulch mats.
21:50 Chuck Nice? So, there is an application, uh, you know, his idea may have been slightly askew, but there is an application for 3D printing in agricultural.
21:57 Bill Nye? Oh, man, heavens, yes, just like, suppose you, one of the things you gotta learn, I think, as a farmer, is welding. This is to say, when stuff breaks, those people are continually repairing things.
22:10 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
22:10 Bill Nye? Discs and harrows and things.
22:12 Chuck Nice? You know what, now, see, what you just said there just, uh, struck in me a little chord because it seems like every movie or television show that you watch, where the people are out on a farm, and they're like, have all these acres around them. Anything that breaks, they immediately start to go in and fix it. The tractor breaks, they fix, you never see them call somebody.
22:35 Bill Nye? Tractor Co.
22:35 Chuck Nice? Yeah. They fix everything.
22:39 Bill Nye? Farm, farm guy skills, I guess, farm gal skills, and, uh, so it's very reasonable that you would have. 3D printers for farm equipment and and so what I'm imagining in the not too long future Chuck, not that it's all about Bill and his imagination, we're responding to, is it Tom's question?
22:54 Chuck Nice? This is, yes, Tom Ricks.
22:56 Bill Nye? Yes. Uh, that I'm imagining a time when something breaks into your house or your apartment and instead of ordering the spare part and having it shipped to you, you go down to the spiritual equivalent of FedEx Kinko's or Staples.
23:12 Chuck Nice? Right.
23:13 Bill Nye? And at that place, they make you a new part.
23:16 Chuck Nice? Just make-
23:17 Bill Nye? Their big 3D printer, which they have air cooled and is large and very accurate. You don't have to have one at home.
23:22 Chuck Nice? Right.
23:23 Bill Nye? And then in the same way, certain gearheads keep a collection of wrenches around.
23:28 Chuck Nice? Right.
23:29 Bill Nye? There'll be certain gearhead type people that have a 3D printer at home. I know guys with milling machines and lathes at home. So there'll be that sort of culture. I can understand it, but I wouldn't be surprised if there are big ones someday in the not too distant future for repairing farm equipment. Sure.
23:44 Chuck Nice? Okay.
23:45 Bill Nye? Bring it on.
23:46 Chuck Nice? But you don't want to eat what it's, what's printed.
23:48 Bill Nye? That's what threw me off a little. Probably not.
23:50 Chuck Nice? The, the application is mo- mostly for assisting in-
23:53 Bill Nye? But I can imagine 3D printing some candy, right?
23:58 Chuck Nice? Yes, because you can melt the sugar.
24:01 Bill Nye? Heck, and then why not-
24:02 Chuck Nice? The same way like glass and you print out some-
24:03 Bill Nye? Some 3D printed seaweed. I mean, I, it seems very re- sea plant, seems very reasonable, but uh, why you would do that rather than growing plants directly, okay, I have to think it through, but that's a cool question, Tom.
24:15 Chuck Nice? So Tom, cool question and the answer is candy. You'll be able to print candy. Mmm, candy.
24:24 Bill Nye? There's a 3D printer handy and it's gonna be dandy. Okay. Wide, citizen of the wide world Chuck, what's our next query?
24:32 Chuck Nice? Here we go. Uh, now, this might be another conflation, however, I know where he is coming from and this is uh, Jason Harvey, uh, coming to us from Twitter and Jason would like to know this. Can we 3D print an animal?
24:50 Chuck Nice? And then, and then it, then he goes a little crazy and then started up with an electric shock. It's alive. It's alive.
25:02 Bill Nye? The citizens, the towns, the villagers.
25:07 Chuck Nice? Why are they out there with pitchforks and?
25:10 Bill Nye? They just don't trust the doc. Oh. Doc Frankenstein. So everybody.
25:14 Chuck Nice? Wanted to pet the rabbit.
25:15 Bill Nye? It's very reasonable to me that, uh, people will be able to 3D print someday DNA. You'd make a synthetic organism.
25:23 Chuck Nice? Holy crap.
25:24 Bill Nye? Whether you'd build a whole woolly mammoth from scratch from a 3D printer, that might be harder.
25:28 Chuck Nice? But that's a little mind blowing what you're saying right there.
25:30 Bill Nye? I'm just saying it because people are talking about it.
25:33 Chuck Nice? So, and you don't mean like a model of the 3D?
25:36 Bill Nye? I'm making a virus from a molecular machine printer, gizmo.
25:40 Chuck Nice? Holy crap.
25:41 Bill Nye? And then making a, a single cell.
25:43 Chuck Nice? Right.
25:44 Bill Nye? And then fusing it and having it grow into a mammoth or a chuck.
25:50 Chuck Nice? Believe me, you went the mammoth before you went the chuck.
25:52 Bill Nye? No, no, I, I believe you.
25:55 Bill Nye? You didn't lose me. I don't think I'm alone. This is another one of these things where I would like to talk it over with Chuck's wife. I bring it up every show.
26:04 Chuck Nice? Oh, believe me, she is.
26:06 Bill Nye? She would prefer a mammoth.
26:07 Chuck Nice? She would prefer a mammoth over another chuck, that's for sure.
26:10 Bill Nye? Yeah.
26:11 Chuck Nice? And probably much easier to care for.
26:13 Bill Nye? Yes. Yes. Lower maintenance.
26:15 Chuck Nice? Lower maintenance.
26:16 Bill Nye? More logical.
26:17 Chuck Nice? And probably sheds less than I do.
26:20 Bill Nye? Uh, can't hear you. Lot of information. Uh, a little too much, Chuck. Okay.
26:26 Chuck Nice? All right, here we go.
26:28 Bill Nye? Cool question, Jason. All right, lead on.
26:30 Chuck Nice? Very cool question, and I have to tell you that I am just slightly disturbed by the 3D printing of DNA.
26:36 Bill Nye? It's very, it's not crazy. It's reasonable.
26:39 Chuck Nice? Has the ability to proliferate.
26:41 Bill Nye? Well, that's, look at us. We start from a single cell.
26:44 Chuck Nice? Yeah, you're right.
26:47 Bill Nye? And don't tell me you haven't held a single cell, an egg. A chicken egg is a single cell.
26:52 Chuck Nice? You know, I never thought of it that way, but you're right.
26:54 Bill Nye? It's a cool thing of, of which to think.
26:56 Chuck Nice? Yes. I don't think we're as delicious in our nascent stages.
26:59 Bill Nye? Can't hear you. Uh, all good. Can't hear you.
27:04 Bill Nye? Try another one, just a couple of minutes left in this segment.
27:07 Chuck Nice? Let's move on. Okay, here we go.
27:12 Chuck Nice? This is from Ian Landy from at Technolandy on Twitter. Any thoughts on if any age is too young to try Makerspaces and 3D printing? I had my kids do hour, an hour of code. I, I don't, I don't, I'm not sure.
27:31 Bill Nye? An hour of code, a code hour.
27:33 Chuck Nice? A code hour. Okay, I don't know what that is.
27:35 Bill Nye? That's fine. I don't see, if a kid is into it, I don't think you can have any trouble. Just how much plastic do you want to waste? Or how embarrassed are you willing to be when the kid makes this fabulous thing that you never thought of? So if your children, if your kids are able to run a 3D printer and write code for an hour, I mean, more power to them. Now, in general, I'm sure Ian's kids are exceptional.
28:00 Chuck Nice? Yes.
28:01 Bill Nye? Cause all of our StarTalk listeners are way above average.
28:05 Chuck Nice? They're pretty up there, yes. I have to say.
28:06 Bill Nye? Yes.
28:07 Chuck Nice? StarTalk, the average StarTalk listener is far above average when...
28:11 Bill Nye? How do you know that? I was trying to make a joke.
28:14 Chuck Nice? No, I'm serious.
28:15 Bill Nye? I was really going for it.
28:15 Chuck Nice? I'm serious.
28:16 Bill Nye? Get over yourselves, talkers.
28:18 Chuck Nice? I talk to them on Twitter all the time. A lot of them have like words like doctor before their name, stuff like that, you know?
28:24 Bill Nye? Alright, well, who knows what controversy I've gotten myself into with these offhand DNA musings.
28:31 Chuck Nice? All I can tell you is this, we live in a country where children are allowed to play with guns legally. So, like they're passing legislation to say that it's okay for children to shoot guns at ranges. So I don't see where 3D print, hey, better yet, why don't you get your kids to 3D print a working firearm?
28:48 Bill Nye? No, that's been done, Chuck. Oh yeah, yeah, that's been done. Oh yeah, that, that program exists online.
28:53 Chuck Nice? Oh, stop it.
28:54 Bill Nye? Yeah, you can download it.
28:55 Chuck Nice? Oh, come on.
28:56 Bill Nye? But you need a printer that works, you know, accurately enough.
28:58 Chuck Nice? Oh, you're killing me.
28:59 Bill Nye? Uh, I hope not. But yeah.
29:02 Chuck Nice? You're killing me with your 3D gun?
29:04 Bill Nye? Yeah, so the...
29:04 Chuck Nice? Are you for real? You can, there are no laws? Wait a minute, Bill, I'm really upset here. There are no laws to stop you from printing a firearm with a 3D printer?
29:13 Bill Nye? As far as I know, not, maybe they're proposed, but even if there were laws, Chuck, this is the electric internet. All the kids are using it. So it could be transmitted around. The thing is, you need the material and you still need bullets and all that stuff, so.
29:26 Chuck Nice? Oh my god.
29:27 Bill Nye? Deep breath.
29:27 Chuck Nice? Okay, so here is Derek Maddox.
29:31 Bill Nye? Derek.
29:32 Chuck Nice? And Derek comes to us from Twitter. Derek says this, "Do you think we'll ever be able to 3D print organs efficiently enough to end the need for donors?" Now, I have actually read, uh...
29:47 Bill Nye? You can read.
29:49 Chuck Nice? I, you know what, believe it or not, it's, it's, and really, okay, somebody read it to me.
29:53 Bill Nye? No, by the way, everybody, for you, if you're out there, Chuck is quite the science geek. He reads quite a bit of this stuff.
30:01 Chuck Nice? Yeah, let's, let's.
30:02 Bill Nye? But you're about to revel-ivate us, uh, give us a revelation of that.
30:06 Chuck Nice? No, I read this great article, I believe it was in Scientific American, and, and it was talking about the actual printing of organs.
30:13 Bill Nye? Yeah.
30:13 Chuck Nice? And, um, and the way they did it was somehow they infused the DNA from the person that they're, uh, going to implant the organ so that you don't have a rejection.
30:23 Bill Nye? That's right.
30:23 Chuck Nice? Like you would with an.
30:24 Bill Nye? Same DNA.
30:24 Chuck Nice? Is that, so, so.
30:25 Bill Nye? That's the plan. That's my understanding. That's the deal. And then you would grow them from the right number of, so, in the case, the classic is a liver, which apparently is, uh, if you're gonna do this, it's a good place to start.
30:38 Chuck Nice? Liver.
30:38 Bill Nye? Yeah.
30:39 Chuck Nice? Is, is that because the liver self-generates anyway?
30:41 Bill Nye? I guess, and also the way it is, um, the way its blood vessels run, the way, it's not enerved. It's like that. The way the, um, the blood vessels would somehow self-organize. I'm not an expert on this, and that's when we're gonna get all this mail because I spoke offhandedly. No, but I've heard that that's the one, a good place to start.
31:02 Chuck Nice? Is with the liver.
31:02 Bill Nye? Yeah.
31:03 Chuck Nice? So the answer, Derek, is yes, and yes, we will be, uh, 3D printing organs and one day efficiently enough where we won't need donors.
31:13 Bill Nye? Yeah, well, the big thing you won't need is, not only that, you won't need, uh, anti-rejection drugs, which you alluded to earlier, which would be huge, be huge.
31:20 Chuck Nice? So now, does that, wow.
31:22 Bill Nye? Does that mean we're living just at the wrong time?
31:24 Chuck Nice? That's what I was about to ask.
31:25 Bill Nye? You missed it by that much.
31:27 Chuck Nice? That I'm getting screwed by the fact that I'm here?
31:30 Bill Nye? But you got three kids.
31:31 Chuck Nice? Y- yeah.
31:32 Bill Nye? So your genes are going into the future.
31:34 Chuck Nice? My genes are going into the future. I'm not worried about my genes. I'm more worried about me.
31:37 Bill Nye? Well.
31:38 Chuck Nice? And, and speaking of liver, hey.
31:40 Bill Nye? You're just saying.
31:42 Chuck Nice? I'm just saying.
31:42 Bill Nye? You work a nightclub. You're just saying. Flows for free for you.
31:47 Chuck Nice? There you go, man.
31:49 Bill Nye? No, I've not, I don't want to change the subject too far, but I've known people that have got in trouble with alcohol because they were comics that got free drinks or, yeah.
31:57 Chuck Nice? Well, you know, you have to, you have to be cognizant. As a matter of fact, I have, I know we're off, a little off topic.
32:03 Bill Nye? Just a little.
32:04 Chuck Nice? Just a little off topic.
32:04 Bill Nye? Us?
32:05 Chuck Nice? You know, but, but I have to say that, uh, one of the things that I had to stop doing, because I work in a club most nights and I drink for free everywhere I go, was I had to make it a rule that when I'm working, I don't drink. Because otherwise, otherwise drinking became part of my job as opposed to the, uh, the social activity that it should be.
32:27 Bill Nye? Yes.
32:28 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
32:28 Bill Nye? Well, with all that said, let's get back to the special edition.
32:32 Chuck Nice? That we're all here for.
32:33 Bill Nye? The maker edition.
32:34 Chuck Nice? Brought to you by Google and, and.
32:36 Bill Nye? What's the website?
32:37 Chuck Nice? And make sure you check out making with google.com.
32:40 Bill Nye? So we're making.
32:41 Chuck Nice? Making.
32:41 Bill Nye? This is the maker edition.
32:42 Chuck Nice? That's what it is.
32:43 Bill Nye? Give me another query.
32:44 Chuck Nice? All right, here we go. A lot of people really are in love with this 3D printing stuff, man.
32:49 Bill Nye? And that's all it's been.
32:50 Chuck Nice? This is Jesse, uh, uh, from Twitter. Um, here's the deal. Hey, Bill, will doctors be able to 3D print medical tools? And specific parts like replacement joints for the body? And I, I guess she's thinking like in the time when we colonized someplace.
33:11 Bill Nye? I gotta say categorically, yes, absolutely yes. I saw a presentation by a NASA engineer about this. And she's got it down. This is what we do. We're gonna make your, your hemostats.
33:23 Chuck Nice? Right.
33:24 Bill Nye? Little clampy wamps for shutting off blood vessels while you're surgorizing.
33:29 Chuck Nice? Right.
33:29 Bill Nye? We're gonna make, uh, scissors, scalpels, all kinds of clamps and happiness.
33:34 Chuck Nice? You could make a scalpel, uh, out of plastic that.
33:38 Bill Nye? Oh, no, you'd make it out of metal, no, no.
33:40 Chuck Nice? So you, right, like we talked about at another time.
33:42 Bill Nye? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Or maybe just put a metal edge on it, or maybe make it out of some modern plastic that's good enough for a few slices.
33:50 Chuck Nice? Right.
33:50 Bill Nye? She's wore it out.
33:51 Chuck Nice? Right.
33:51 Bill Nye? Then you melt it down and make another one.
33:52 Chuck Nice? Another one. Jesse, great question, and the answer is categorically yes. Fantastic. Let us move on.
34:05 Chuck Nice? Pardon me, I'm gonna look for something a little different. Here we go.
34:09 Bill Nye? You're thumbing?
34:09 Chuck Nice? Here we are. Uh, this is Israel, uh, Geron.
34:14 Bill Nye? Israel Geron.
34:15 Chuck Nice? Is- Israel Geron, uh, from Twitter, uh, says, hello from Marana, Arizona. Never heard of it.
34:24 Bill Nye? Well, it's in, Arizona's in the US.
34:26 Chuck Nice? Oh, okay, good.
34:31 Bill Nye? All right.
34:31 Chuck Nice? As an educator, what are the benefits of having people flex their brains in creating something rather than purchasing something? So this one-
34:40 Bill Nye? No, there's no benefit at all.
34:41 Chuck Nice? No.
34:42 Bill Nye? I'm kidding, of course. It's rhetorical question city. No, the whole thing we want is hands-on interaction. Yes, make things. Become not just a scientist like what's his name? Neil Tyson.
34:56 Chuck Nice? That Tyson, the brass Tyson guy.
34:57 Bill Nye? Become an engineer, make stuff. Use science to solve problems and make things.
35:02 Chuck Nice? Got you. So, uh, there's your-
35:04 Bill Nye? Chuck, the guy, you got to, to, to this rhetorical question city there.
35:09 Chuck Nice? Well, you know, I, I, I think that is. You're, you're right. That is rhetorical.
35:13 Bill Nye? So I'm gonna follow- Let's follow it up.
35:15 Chuck Nice? I'm not, I'm gonna follow up with this, with, well, so, uh, same, same person says, so we've seen examples of 3D printing of mechanical parts. What are the prospects of 3D printing? Now, listen, chemical compounds. So-
35:32 Bill Nye? Well, this is very reasonable to me.
35:34 Chuck Nice? Really?
35:34 Bill Nye? Yeah, I mean, are you hip that when you buy polyethylene for commercial applications, you're gonna make a conveyor belt with pla- plastic rollers or something? Or a slide or?
35:45 Chuck Nice? No, I'm not-
35:46 Bill Nye? You can imagine.
35:47 Chuck Nice? I can imagine that, yeah.
35:48 Bill Nye? Anyway, you specify the plastic by its molecular weight.
35:52 Chuck Nice? Okay.
35:53 Bill Nye? There's this ultra-high molecular weight, very high molecular weight, and they they can infer how many carbon atoms are strung together in a chain of carbon atoms.
36:02 Chuck Nice? Okay.
36:02 Bill Nye? For example. So I can imagine a day where you're planting individual atoms onto molecules, and then if it were the kind of molecule you wanted, and you could get it to grow again like a crystal.
36:14 Chuck Nice? Right.
36:14 Bill Nye? You would have all of the molecules you would uh want to interact with. I mean, I can imagine this.
36:20 Chuck Nice? That's cool.
36:21 Bill Nye? Well, it's cool, but I mean, I haven't really done it, Chuck. I'm jamming here.
36:24 Chuck Nice? I mean, just the-
36:25 Bill Nye? Bill and I, the science fiction radio host.
36:27 Chuck Nice? But that is science fiction within the realm of reason.
36:31 Bill Nye? Very reasonable, very reasonable, yeah.
36:33 Chuck Nice? Okay, that's very cool. Look at that. That not two very good questions from Israel. I appreciate them. Let's move on. Uh.
36:44 Chuck Nice? Boy, you guys with these names, I tell you, these names. Sylvan Air. Sylvan Air wants to know this. Is there any food that a 3D printer would be able to make? I'm picturing the precursor to the Star Trek replicator. So now in Star Trek, they, you know, Captain Picard will go here. T, Earl Grey, hot.
37:10 Bill Nye? Yeah.
37:10 Chuck Nice? Boom.
37:11 Bill Nye? Yeah.
37:11 Chuck Nice? Would it just appear?
37:12 Bill Nye? Yes, uh, so I want to caution you, Chuck. That show is not real.
37:16 Chuck Nice? Now I don't know what to believe! Damn your bells!
37:22 Bill Nye? So, when you manufacture food, you know, there's a whole thing in the business. They talk about the taste, but they also talk about the mouth feel.
37:31 Chuck Nice? Yes.
37:32 Bill Nye? And I would not be surprised, and there's a product now called Soylent, which is based on soylent.
37:37 Chuck Nice? Did you say Soylent?
37:38 Bill Nye? Yeah, based on the-
37:39 Chuck Nice? Soylent?
37:39 Bill Nye? Yeah.
37:40 Chuck Nice? Okay.
37:40 Bill Nye? Isn't that the product?
37:41 Chuck Nice? I don't know!
37:42 Bill Nye? Yeah, it's the, it's the food of the future. It's a billboard, yeah. Yeah, well, so I could imagine people, well, you eat candy bars.
37:49 Chuck Nice? I do, every once in a while.
37:51 Bill Nye? Yeah, oh, you've seen them.
37:52 Chuck Nice? Three times a year, I'll eat a candy-
37:53 Bill Nye? Yes, uh, maybe you've had some- Uh, peanut brittle.
37:58 Chuck Nice? Yes, I have.
37:58 Bill Nye? Just the brittle part.
37:59 Chuck Nice? The brittle part.
38:00 Bill Nye? You've had caramel.
38:01 Chuck Nice? Yes, without a doubt.
38:02 Bill Nye? Okay, that's just, uh, can you imagine a machine that would make some fantastic, fantastically delicious thing?
38:09 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
38:09 Bill Nye? That would have a good mouth feel.
38:11 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
38:12 Bill Nye? And would not be natural, it wouldn't be recognizable from something in nature.
38:16 Chuck Nice? See, no, I cannot imagine that.
38:18 Bill Nye? Would be, you know, Chuck's Food Bar.
38:20 Chuck Nice? Yeah, I don't want-
38:21 Bill Nye? Chuck's Delicious Green Bar.
38:24 Chuck Nice? I don't want anyone eating Chuck's Food Bar.
38:27 Bill Nye? Well, what if it had a lovely woman's name? What if it was Malia's Delicious Food Bar?
38:33 Chuck Nice? All right, I'm interested.
38:34 Bill Nye? Yeah, yeah.
38:34 Chuck Nice? I'm, I gotta tell you the truth, I'm interested in it.
38:36 Bill Nye? Yeah.
38:37 Chuck Nice? I don't know what you just did there, Bill.
38:38 Bill Nye? It would be the shape, various shapes are possible.
38:40 Chuck Nice? Yes.
38:41 Bill Nye? Anyway, so this is quite possible, I can easily imagine printed food. You've been listening to Star Talk, I, I'm Bill Nye, your host, and I'm here with citizen of the world Chuck Nice, we'll be back right after this.
38:54 Bill Nye? Welcome, welcome, welcome to Star Talk Radio Cosmic Queries, this is a special edition Chuck.
39:00 Chuck Nice? Yes.
39:00 Bill Nye? This is the maker edition, it's brought to you by Google.
39:03 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
39:04 Bill Nye? And if you're listening, and I believe you are, uh, when you get where you have access to the internet, check out their website at makingsciencewithgoogle.com.
39:13 Chuck Nice? Nice, no other way to make science as far as I'm concerned.
39:16 Bill Nye? With Google?
39:17 Chuck Nice? That's the only way to do it.
39:18 Bill Nye? Okay, I'm sure you're right, uh, there are no competitors, it's all good. No, this is Star Talk, and we got queries from you, you have enquired, and by long tradition, our worldwide citizen Chuck Nice.
39:31 Chuck Nice? Yes.
39:31 Bill Nye? Will read your queries.
39:33 Chuck Nice? I-
39:34 Bill Nye? And he and I will comment insightfully.
39:36 Chuck Nice? Indeed, one of us will, that'll be you.
39:39 Bill Nye? All right, we'll try it.
39:40 Chuck Nice? The other one will just read them.
39:42 Bill Nye? That's you.
39:42 Chuck Nice? That's me, okay, here we go, um, this one coming to us from, um, Necro7 on Twitter.
39:49 Bill Nye? Necro, a little troubling.
39:51 Chuck Nice? Necro7.
39:52 Bill Nye? Little troubling.
39:52 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
39:53 Bill Nye? All right, and it's Necro, what does he or she have to say?
39:56 Chuck Nice? Says, "How would you compare the effects of accessible 3D printing today to the effects of the printing press in the early Renaissance?"
40:08 Bill Nye? Uh, I don't think it'll be quite as influential, the printing press was a big thing.
40:13 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
40:13 Bill Nye? However, 3D printing's absolutely the future, and I talk about this all the time, um- I'm imagining where we're making, you know, maybe I am wrong, as is so often the case. We use the term in mechanical engineering additive manufacture.
40:28 Chuck Nice? Additive manufacture.
40:29 Bill Nye? That's what 3D printing is.
40:30 Chuck Nice? That's 3D what?
40:31 Bill Nye? And but you know, when you think of, you know, this word machining.
40:33 Chuck Nice? Yes.
40:34 Bill Nye? Where you cut material, yeah, you make a screw, you cut the metal away.
40:38 Chuck Nice? Right.
40:38 Bill Nye? Or what have you. So this could revolutionize all that we know and love.
40:42 Chuck Nice? So you could possibly at one point envision a world where you just 3D print everything?
40:48 Bill Nye? Everything would be custom made. There wouldn't be anything adjustable. Everything would be made perfectly.
40:52 Chuck Nice? No, when I think about the economic repercussions of such a thing.
40:57 Bill Nye? Belts wouldn't even have more than one hole. The belt would be made and there'd be a single hole for your waist.
41:03 Chuck Nice? Well, that's it. You've sold me.
41:04 Bill Nye? No, but I mean, I can imagine it easily. Yeah. And so you go to the store and there's designers there. I'm thinking about fashion now, fashion. You go to the store and they custom make it for you and they almost sort of do that with Neal's suits.
41:19 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
41:20 Bill Nye? He gets them multi-measured at multi-measure.com and then they fit him better. And so I could easily imagine that the future, everything is customly 3D printed. Yes, you were saying you started to go
41:31 Chuck Nice? Well, no.
41:32 Bill Nye? Wide world on us worldwide.
41:33 Chuck Nice? I'm thinking like, what do you do with all the jobs of people who were making the screw?
41:42 Bill Nye? Everybody's got to make the printers.
41:44 Chuck Nice? So all those people are now just making printers?
41:46 Bill Nye? Well, or they're doing other wonderful, productive, artistic, wonderful, life-enhancing things. Thinking deep thoughts about how to make better printers, how to design new things. Everybody becomes a designer. Everybody's a designer. Everybody custom makes everything. Come on.
42:02 Chuck Nice? It's a scary world.
42:03 Bill Nye? Cheer it up, Chuck.
42:07 Chuck Nice? I'm going to say that, uh, yeah, because where I see this going is
42:11 Bill Nye? Let me just ask you about that sentence. I'm gonna say, uh, yeah.
42:15 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
42:16 Bill Nye? Can you expand on that just ever so?
42:18 Chuck Nice? Right here, just a little bit. 3D printers, making 3D printers, and now we're done. Now, nobody works anymore.
42:25 Bill Nye? Well, but who's shoveling the coal? That is to say, who's making the electricity? Somebody's gonna have to do something.
42:31 Chuck Nice? Somebody's gotta do something.
42:31 Bill Nye? Somewhere.
42:32 Chuck Nice? All right.
42:32 Bill Nye? Notice that People are as busy as ever. You know, you say, what did they do in the good old days? They churned milk, they grew crops, they tilled the soil, they got rid of the weeds, what have you. People has not led to a life of leisure.
42:47 Chuck Nice? Right.
42:48 Bill Nye? You wash the dishes automatically while you're doing a bunch of other stuff now.
42:51 Chuck Nice? Right. Okay.
42:53 Bill Nye? Humans are busy, busy humans.
42:56 Chuck Nice? Okay, alright, I'm gonna go with you.
42:58 Bill Nye? Like bees, only humans.
43:00 Chuck Nice? Alright, let's get to another question. This one from Twitter says, uh...
43:04 Bill Nye? Does it have a name, Twitter?
43:06 Chuck Nice? No, just Twitter. And...
43:08 Bill Nye? Twitter's on Twitter.
43:09 Chuck Nice? Twitter is on Twitter.
43:09 Bill Nye? Somebody secured that name early on, yes, so hello Twitter.
43:13 Chuck Nice? I would love to get that name, that'd be my Twitter handle.
43:16 Bill Nye? No, you wouldn't, it wouldn't say Chuck.
43:18 Chuck Nice? It would say @Twitter though, and everybody would know that that's me.
43:21 Bill Nye? You're the man.
43:22 Chuck Nice? Everybody would have @Twitter, everybody would have that.
43:25 Bill Nye? You'd figure you'd have a lot of followers, and that would lead to a pay raise.
43:29 Chuck Nice? Right. Because that's what you gotta do nowadays to get a pay raise.
43:32 Bill Nye? That's what I'm saying to you, so Twitter has a question.
43:34 Chuck Nice? Twitter wants to know this. How does 3D printed materials, carbon footprint, or other environmental strain metric compare to that of manufactured products? So, uh, is it on equal footing? Is it a less of a carbon footprint?
43:51 Bill Nye? Maybe less footprint. If you could efficiently ship the material to where you need it, and then manufacture in situ, then you wouldn't have all the bulky... Like, for example, I'm looking here in the studio at a stool, or a sofa.
44:04 Chuck Nice? Sofa.
44:05 Bill Nye? The packing for those things is large.
44:07 Chuck Nice? True.
44:08 Bill Nye? If they could be manufactured closer to where they're being used.
44:12 Chuck Nice? No need for it.
44:13 Bill Nye? You'd have probably more efficient shipping of the raw materials.
44:16 Chuck Nice? Right.
44:17 Bill Nye? You know what I mean, you wouldn't have that volume, just in these couple examples looking around the room here.
44:21 Chuck Nice? So now, do you think that, uh, it might lead to a more disposable world?
44:27 Bill Nye? Or a more recyclable world.
44:29 Chuck Nice? Ooh.
44:32 Bill Nye? The couch is made of magic plastic that you just melt down and make into a new stool, or ottoman, or settee, or headboard.
44:40 Chuck Nice? So the real...
44:41 Bill Nye? Or even dresser drawer.
44:46 Bill Nye? Just doing a furniture thing.
44:49 Bill Nye? So you were saying, or maybe a mattress.
44:52 Chuck Nice? So the idea is you would have to make materials that can be used again and again.
44:57 Bill Nye? Well, I mean, it's certainly reasonable. I mean, the 3D printed plastic that we're using now is melt downable.
45:02 Chuck Nice? Right.
45:03 Bill Nye? If I can coin that adjective.
45:06 Chuck Nice? I love when you get all sciency on me like that. It's
45:09 Bill Nye? It's just, it's nibonic.
45:12 Bill Nye? Melt downable.
45:13 Chuck Nice? Okay, let's move on.
45:17 Bill Nye? Moving on.
45:19 Chuck Nice? Kevin.
45:19 Bill Nye? Cosmic queries maker edition.
45:21 Chuck Nice? Kevin S. from Twitter.
45:22 Bill Nye? Kevin.
45:23 Chuck Nice? Kevin S. wants to know this. What's the strength of 3D printed metal parts cast, forged, or billet of the same material? So if you, if you got it strewn out of this little head.
45:37 Bill Nye? Oh, yeah, yeah.
45:38 Chuck Nice? Can it be as strong?
45:40 Bill Nye? I'm not an expert on that.
45:41 Chuck Nice? Die cast or something that's forged or?
45:43 Bill Nye? I'm not an expert on that, but I will say this. I saw a wrench made and it was a little oversized, I think for stiffness.
45:50 Chuck Nice? Okay.
45:51 Bill Nye? And sintered parts. These are parts made from powder that are, is fused together, melted essentially. Those aren't as strong, but they have other properties. In the, in the example of sintering, they hold oil for a bearing or whatever. That has an advantage.
46:05 Chuck Nice? Okay.
46:06 Bill Nye? So I could easily imagine a secondary operation where you roll or press or smash the 3D printed part or additively manufactured part to give it strength. I could easily imagine that. And I guess as a host of StarTalk Radio, I should know more about that and I will make a note to learn that.
46:29 Chuck Nice? All right. Well, there you have it.
46:31 Bill Nye? But as a mechanical engineer, I can imagine the secondary operation of smashing to work harden it, to give it strength.
46:37 Chuck Nice? Gotcha.
46:38 Bill Nye? You know how you can't straighten out a paperclip very easily?
46:40 Chuck Nice? Right.
46:41 Bill Nye? Because after you bend it.
46:43 Chuck Nice? Now you have to.
46:44 Bill Nye? It's called work hardening. You've done work on it and it, it gets stiff. It's the nature of the grains of metal.
46:50 Chuck Nice? Gotcha.
46:51 Bill Nye? So very reasonable that you'd have to re-smash, but that could be a lot cheaper than shipping a full-sized wrench to somebody.
46:59 Chuck Nice? All right.
47:00 Bill Nye? Trying to get that, trying to get that nut up under the sink, maybe you just make the perfect custom-made wrench just, just right there.
47:07 Chuck Nice? Just right for that.
47:07 Bill Nye? And then you'd melt it back down after you're done.
47:10 Chuck Nice? There you go.
47:11 Bill Nye? And have all those molecules floating around your house.
47:13 Chuck Nice? I like it. All right, this is Tim, uh, from Twitter.
47:17 Bill Nye? Tim from Twitter.
47:18 Chuck Nice? And he's, he's tweeting to us from at Evil Nut.
47:23 Bill Nye? Uh, can't hear you, can't read you. All right, at Evil Nut.
47:26 Chuck Nice? At Evil Nut wants to know this. Are they testing or printing in zero G? It seems like it would be impossible in zero G.
47:36 Bill Nye? They do it.
47:37 Chuck Nice? Cause it's metal.
47:37 Bill Nye? They did it on the space station.
47:39 Chuck Nice? Cause it's liquid, so.
47:40 Bill Nye? They did it on the space station. And the word liquid, you know, it's, it's a, uh, it's gooey. It's amorphous. It's literally both as the adjective and as the noun, plastic. You know, the earth's crust, I mean, uh, the earth mantle.
47:54 Chuck Nice? Right.
47:54 Bill Nye? Said to be plastic.
47:56 Chuck Nice? Really?
47:57 Bill Nye? Smush-a-roundable.
47:58 Chuck Nice? So, cause it's, it's.
47:59 Bill Nye? Cause it's hot, hot.
48:00 Chuck Nice? Very hot.
48:01 Bill Nye? So, uh, and yes, they have 3D printed in space. By paying attention to what they're doing, the thing squirts out and the plastic sticks to the plastic.
48:10 Chuck Nice? Okay.
48:11 Bill Nye? So you can shape parts in space even though with, even though you don't have gravity.
48:14 Chuck Nice? There you go.
48:15 Bill Nye? In fact, there's probably an argument from 3D Print Co. that says gravity is a real problem. You should do all your manufacturing in space.
48:21 Chuck Nice? Oh, really?
48:22 Bill Nye? Easily imagine somebody coming in here to say that and I, I would not be in a position to disagree, Chuck.
48:27 Chuck Nice? There you have it.
48:28 Bill Nye? The, I'd have to do the opposite of that, I'd have to agree.
48:30 Chuck Nice? So is, um, although Evil Nut, it's counterintuitive, actually zero G is great.
48:36 Bill Nye? Just imagine squirting toothpaste on to, like squirt toothpaste on the wall, now squirt another bead of toothpaste on the toothpaste, it would stick to it, right?
48:44 Chuck Nice? Right.
48:44 Bill Nye? Even though you're upside walled.
48:46 Chuck Nice? Upside down or no matter where you are.
48:47 Bill Nye? That's right, yeah. I mean, you can imagine that it's possible, yeah.
48:50 Chuck Nice? Squeeze it right out of the tube and right onto the toothpaste, uh, onto the toothbrush. Okay, uh, this is a great question, uh.
48:57 Bill Nye? How does it go?
48:58 Chuck Nice? Thomas, Thomas T J L K from Twitter wants to know this. Will people be able to 3D print medicine? So you're talking about manufacturing medicine?
49:09 Bill Nye? Sure.
49:11 Chuck Nice? Really?
49:11 Bill Nye? Imagine this, I mean, how hard can this be?
49:13 Chuck Nice? This is awesome.
49:14 Bill Nye? They tell you to take two aspirin.
49:16 Chuck Nice? Okay.
49:16 Bill Nye? They tell you to take one aspirin.
49:17 Chuck Nice? Right.
49:18 Bill Nye? You just custom print the size of the pill you want.
49:21 Chuck Nice? So you have now.
49:22 Bill Nye? It's your aspirin goo stuff.
49:24 Chuck Nice? So how do you dial up?
49:26 Bill Nye? The physician weighs you. Okay. And then prescribes the right-sized pill. Just for shooting from the hip, without even starting. Okay. Without even trying to make molecules from scratch. Alright, good. Not even doing that. Not even doing that. Just right from the get-go. And furthermore, at home, your bathroom scale is on the internet. It tells pill.com squirt machine how to squirt out the right-sized pill for how much you weigh, and then you're just perfectly healthy. Damn, that's awesome. And imagine it, I mean, it's one thing with aspirin, but imagine, you know, there's so many people with all these other exotic disorders, and they have to constantly manage their their dose, right?
50:08 Bill Nye? I can easily imagine a machine or a couple of machines that could do that.
50:14 Bill Nye? So no more, no more one-size-fits-all prescriptions? Yes, easily imagine. It's custom prescribed for you? Yes. Fantastic. From prescribeco.com, they're at your Rite Aid, your Duane Reade, your CVS. And this is where maybe you don't have the machine at home, but you have a bathroom scale at home. And it transmits your weight to your druggist, who then, when you show up with the prescription, the pills are just the right size. Wow. Whoa, how cool would that be? You've been listening to StarTalk Radio. I'm your host, Bill Nye, with my co-host, Chuck Nice. Keep looking up.
Previous The Lunar Legacy, with Buzz Aldrin Next Extended Classic – Cosmic Queries Holiday Edition Page updated October 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated