Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast Low-Mass Mania with Emily Rice About this episode Could we find life around low-mass stars? Neil deGrasse Tyson and comedian Chuck Nice find out why life might be more likely around low-mass stars, what makes brown dwarfs, galactic archeology, and more with astronomer Emily Rice.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Coming up on StarTalk Cosmic Queries, my friend and colleague Emily Rice is going to tell us all about the latest in brown dwarfs and exoplanets. Oh, yeah. That all comes to you from right here in my office at the Hayden Planetarium of the American Museum of Natural History.
0:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk, your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is StarTalk Cosmic Queries Edition. Got Chuck Nice with me. Chuck, how you doing, man? Hey, what's happening, Neil? All right. You know, there's a part of the universe that is a little foreign to me because most of my research back when I was like active with it was galaxies, large-scale structure, Big Bang. And you come down, you get closer and closer and closer. There's a whole world there. Right. Literal and figurative world. Okay. People think about planets and stars being born around which you would find planets. Right. And we got one of the world's experts right here in the house. Oh. And here she goes.
1:10 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Emily Rice, Emily, friend and colleague. How you doing?
1:14 Speaker 01 I'm very excited to be here again.
1:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome back.
1:16 Speaker 01 Thank you, yeah.
1:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? To StarTalk. And just let the record show that whatever I'm wearing that's cosmic, and people say, oh, that's cool, that's cosmic. Right. I just want you to know that when I'm- Emily will come in with something cooler. When I'm with my people, it's just camouflage. Because everybody else has got something.
1:35 Speaker 01 Now it is, yeah.
1:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you were like leader of the pack there. Aren't you involved in some haberdashery or something? Yeah, haberdashery. What, clothing?
1:45 Speaker 01 A little bit of this, a little bit of that.
1:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Don't you have a jewelry line?
1:47 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Or do you still have a jewelry line?
1:49 Speaker 01 It's a super long story, but yeah, we, so, it started as a phenomenological, like, we noticed people. You know, you were one of the originals, but other people were doing it too.
1:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're an OG? Ooh, look at that.
2:00 Speaker 01 I think you might be one of the first, yeah.
2:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? To be loud in my attire.
2:04 Speaker 01 Yeah.
2:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, okay.
2:04 Speaker 01 But a bunch of people were doing it. And so we started a blog originally, Summer Ash and I. Summer was at, um- Columbia at the time and we were doing our outreach stuff and wearing our stuff like our galaxy leggings and our NASA swag and stuff like that. We were like, we should, this is so cool because some of the stuff we noticed was real, you know, real Hubble images and stuff like that. And so we started a blog that was, we meant to like share it with the public, like, oh, you bought this thing, what is it, where did it come from, you know, astronomically, how it was obtained and stuff like that. Add some science. Yeah, add the science to it. What I didn't expect is for the rest of the astronomers to be so into it that like, we presented it at a research conference, but there's always room at the research conferences for outreach and education and things like that.
2:47 Speaker 01 And the number one question we got at our poster at the research conference was, where do I buy this stuff? Mmm. Like from the other astronomers. The birth. Yeah. The genesis. Can make stuff with my science. And at the time, we were just finding things that were out there, you know, people's Etsy shops and small designers, like it was kind of everywhere. You were an aggregator at the time. Yeah, curator, you know.
3:05 Chuck Nice? Cosmological Joan Rivers. Oh, who are you wearing? What galaxy is that?
3:12 Speaker 01 Totally. But it's, and it's now become a shop. So, long story short, like we became an online shop, so we create our own stuff as well. And it's called? It's called Star Tori List. Star Tori List.
3:26 Chuck Nice? Instead of Star Tori.
3:27 Speaker 01 You see what she did there? Exactly, yeah. Okay, well, cool. So it's online, we can find it online. Yeah, Star Tori List. So, we, I really thought it would be a fad that would just kind of happen and, you know, fade away, like not be popular anymore, which, you know, is kind of fine. But it hasn't. It's continued to grow. We've added our own stuff, so I say that we're the dark energy of the, of the fashion universe.
3:49 Chuck Nice? Look at that.
3:50 Speaker 01 For astronomy. All right. Dark energy is a, is a power of expansion.
3:54 Chuck Nice? Exactly.
3:55 Speaker 01 It accelerates the expansion of the universe.
3:57 Chuck Nice? In other words, you're, you're unaware of why you are successful.
4:03 Speaker 01 Absolutely. Fully, it's not fully understood. It will be, we just need a little more.
4:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Maybe, we don't know, we don't know. So, your expertise is newborn stars, exoplanets, brown dwarfs.
4:16 Speaker 01 Yeah.
4:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And, I have an issue, first of all.
4:21 Chuck Nice? Uh oh.
4:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so when I think of a star, it's self luminous and it's
4:27 Speaker 01 Yes.
4:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's burning bright, even though burning to us is mean something different than to a chemist.
4:33 Chuck Nice? Fusing bright.
4:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, fusing bright, but that doesn't have the alliteration and it's not as cool.
4:38 Chuck Nice? Right.
4:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, stars will burn bright, even if they're burning dimly, they still sort of luminous in the infrared or somewhere, okay. At no time am I thinking, I'm looking at a brown object. So, why did these
4:52 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
4:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Why did these objects, which in the netherland between planets and stars?
4:58 Speaker 01 Yes.
4:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because I don't call planets brown, all right, because they're going to reflect light and they're going to have whatever colors they have. I don't call stars, where do you get the color brown from?
5:07 Speaker 01 The color brown apparently came from Jill Tarter, who you've had on your show before.
5:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, Jill's a friend of StarTalk.
5:14 Speaker 01 Yeah.
5:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Active with SETI, Jill Tarter.
5:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, I love, I watched her interview on StarTalk once and she told the story of her early career, it was actually in her PhD thesis where she did some research on these objects that were previously called black dwarfs. And so it started in the 60s.
5:32 Chuck Nice? Oh, so we had to take it away from the black.
5:36 Chuck Nice? Well, that makes perfect sense. Couldn't just let it be a black dwarf, nope. Mm mm, no, we can't have that. Sure, a hole can be black, no problem. Yes, exactly, you know?
5:47 Speaker 01 We have white holes too, apparently, that's my expertise.
5:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? On paper, but not in a real thing.
5:53 Chuck Nice? But anyway, sorry.
5:54 Speaker 01 So, the black dwarfs, yeah, they were black dwarfs originally because the idea was purely theoretical, was what happens when the stars don't have enough mass pushing down from the outside to get a high enough temperature at the inside to fuse hydrogen and helium as a steady source of power. And so they were called
6:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Which is what the sun does every day of its life.
6:12 Speaker 01 Yeah, so this is why the sun creates energy, it's a stable source of energy, of pressure pushing outwards against gravity. And the idea is that these things that, these things that started to form like stars but wouldn't have enough mass would kind of Still continue to exist, but what would they look like? What would their structure be? How would they radiate? Things like that. That was first kind of described by a theoretical physicist in the 1960s. S.S. Kumar was his name. And then Jill Tarter, I think it was in 1975, in her thesis, kind of proposed the term brown dwarfs. And that kind of stuck. So she originally studied these objects. It's still at that point theoretical.
6:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And of course, to Chuck's point, black holes were gaining very serious attention around that time.
6:56 Speaker 01 Yeah. And so I think that's what's like, like the way that we call stuff dark now.
7:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It was a cover story of the New York Times Magazine. Black holes, what new research? So, so it took the word. I think you're right.
7:07 Chuck Nice? Hmm.
7:08 Speaker 01 Yeah. But then they realized like, okay, they're not fully, you know, they're not fully unexplained. Like they are reasonably well explained by like kind of normal physics. And so they moved away from black and just called them brown. Jill Tarter on your show said, oh, you know, so I started out doing this and then I wanted to do research that mattered.
7:27 Chuck Nice? Wow.
7:28 Speaker 01 Talking about her shift into study, which I'm like, I can't argue with that too much, but it's
7:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But it is a little bit of a diss. It is a little bit of a diss.
7:36 Chuck Nice? A little, yeah.
7:37 Speaker 01 Um, but it's an amazing, so, so she coined the phrase in, in 1975. And they still weren't known to exist. Like they weren't actually discovered until the 1990s. Even then it kind of took a while.
7:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? For context here, right? And I hate thinking this way, but it just jumps into my head. You realize, you just described something that happened 50 years ago.
7:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, more than, we had a conference, actually, 50 years after to celebrate the original papers, 1963, 64, so that's already 10 years ago.
8:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Had it been 1975 and we had this conversation, you'd be talking about 1925 as 50 years earlier.
8:10 Chuck Nice? Wow.
8:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's what I'm saying. This, this, this.
8:12 Speaker 01 Oh, God.
8:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This, just to put that where.
8:16 Chuck Nice? Yes, and, and, and in the proper context.
8:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In the proper context.
8:19 Chuck Nice? You know, you guys old.
8:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That was not what I was trying to look. Would you? Who asked you to comment?
8:27 Speaker 01 It is amazing how far we've come and how quickly. Like, I do feel like the, you know, it's not typical. Like, this is the first time in our civilization, possibly, that these, like, cutting-edge research results are disseminated to the public so quickly. Yeah. Like, that's actually something that I love doing at Star Torielist. Like, there was the press release of the new polarized image of the black hole, the center of the Sagittar, the black hole at the center of the Milky Way galaxy. Right. And it came out, and I showed it to my students that day in class and described it to them. Mm-hmm.
9:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's amazing.
9:00 Speaker 01 Yeah, and, you know, I can put it on a T-shirt for you and sell it at Star Torielist.
9:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The three of us sound a little bit like we're on the porch. Right.
9:08 Chuck Nice? I remember when I can buy.
9:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And the young is today.
9:11 Chuck Nice? I remember we had to teletype each other and let them know about the discoveries that we made.
9:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Teletype? We had to send the teletype.
9:20 Chuck Nice? Dots and dashes is how we had to tell people about our great, significant discoveries.
9:27 Speaker 01 Who started it?
9:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Feel a little bit like that. So, before we go on to our Q and A here, let me give your full, dutiful introduction. You're a research associate here in our Department of Astrophysics of the American Museum of Natural History. And you even have a desk.
9:44 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
9:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So we get to count you as a resident research associate.
9:47 Speaker 01 Nice.
9:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, continued welcome.
9:48 Speaker 01 Taking up space up here.
9:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? To those ranks. You're also Associate Professor of Astrophysics at the Macaulay Honors College in CUNY, the City University of New York.
9:57 Speaker 01 Yeah.
9:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you're in the Faculty PhD Program at the CUNY Grad Center. So you're all in there.
10:03 Speaker 01 It's kind of all over the place, yeah.
10:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And we see some students of yours that come through here. It's very communal, so.
10:09 Speaker 01 I bring my classes here as much as I can.
10:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes! Didn't I talk to your class one time?
10:12 Speaker 01 Yes.
10:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
10:13 Speaker 01 Twice, twice, yeah.
10:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, thanks for bringing them by.
10:15 Speaker 01 Happening here, yeah.
10:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm delighted. Just call me. And you're a founding member of B D N Y C. And all those letters are like in subway. I was gonna say, and what line is that?
10:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, we are very proud. Oh, there's a whole story behind it.
10:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There's no Y. There's no Y.
10:32 Speaker 01 There was no Y. So we made up the, um, the Y is kind of, uh, we made it red and white in the, in the center. It's no, there's no Y train, but it's kind of the inverted, um, inversion of the WNYC logo a little bit. But we had a joke going for a little while because, so these brown dwarfs, they, you know, we have the stars that have the letters that go with them. And there's a whole story about that, right? O B A F G K M was, um, that was kind of set into order about a hundred years ago by the Harvard College computers or the Harvard Observatory, um, women who were working as computers there. Annie Jump Cannon took that letters and they were originally done by, uh, the strength of the hydrogen absorption line. But then they were realizing that actually it's a little bit different. It needs to be if we order by temperature, we change up the letters.
11:17 Speaker 01 And so that's why it's not alphabetical anymore. Um, but when we started to discover these new.
11:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Rather than re-letter them.
11:21 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. No, we kept them.
11:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They kept them. And just rearranged them. And confusing people for, for the century to fall.
11:29 Speaker 01 You call it confusion. I call it job security. Um, and there was a point, apparently there was a bunch of different systems that they were devised and a lot of controversy routed at the time. Um, but since the brown dwarfs were discovered, so the M dwarfs are the coolest and the faintest stars. But for the brown dwarfs, we had introduced new letters for the spectral type. And there are full papers going through the alphabet to say which letter should we use, basically. And so the next ones were L and T that were kind of proposed about the same time. Um, that is, uh, like forever messed up my understanding of the alphabet because it goes M L in stars. Um, but then the next one, we realized, okay, there might be things fainter than these T dwarfs, cooler than these fainter, cooler than the T dwarfs.
12:11 Speaker 01 They're going to have different spectral characteristics and things like that. We, um, they proposed that there would be Y dwarfs. And so this was even in my like scientific career in the last 20 years or so. Um, and so for a little while, we had a joke with the B D N Y C logo where there was no Y dwarfs yet discovered. And there was also no Y train that we would have to explain to people from outside of New York City. Then, then the Y dwarfs were actually discovered with the Wide Field Survey Infrared Explorer, this NASA mission in the infrared. Um, and so now we, the joke has been. Become far too long to be actually interested anymore. But we're very proud of our B D N Y C logo with the subway things on there. And I feel like we've sort of upped the game.
12:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's a local community of people of like interest, professional interest.
12:54 Speaker 01 Yeah, the three of us started out, myself, Kelly Cruz, who's faculty at Hunter College in CUNY, and Jackie Fahey, who's senior scientist and educator here at A M and H. Yeah. And it was, man, we, over 10 years ago now, something like 12, maybe 14 years ago, we founded B D N Y C. It was one of the first groups that was like led by a bunch of women. You know, like it was still rare back then for kind of the three of us to be working together, leading papers together. We were counting, how many papers could we find with only female authors? For example, we published one with just the three of us. We couldn't find another one that had any more.
13:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There were no sole, there were not sole authors.
13:32 Speaker 01 That were, that were more than three authors, but only women.
13:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It sounds like that back toll test on movies.
13:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, I was saying that, the B D N Y C test or something like that.
13:41 Chuck Nice? Sounds like black people in Utah.
13:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If you see three in one street, there's something.
13:47 Chuck Nice? You're no longer in Utah.
13:55 Speaker 01 It's getting better now, I feel like.
13:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You were teleported in that instant.
14:00 Speaker 01 Parallel dimension or something.
14:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, before, again, one last thing before we cross over. How does your interest in brown dwarfs take you to an interest in Exoplanet?
14:08 Speaker 01 Oh, they're very, very similar. So, the, the interesting thing is that the difference in between brown dwarfs and stars is actually relatively straightforward, relatively. It's the nuclear physics on the inside. Like, it's whether they have enough mass to create the high enough temperature at the core to fuse hydrogen in the helium. Like, that's a big difference, kind of evolutionarily.
14:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's a clean line, too.
14:30 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's a, it's a very, like, they either turn on or they don't.
14:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Or they didn't.
14:35 Speaker 01 Yeah.
14:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
14:37 Speaker 01 But for the lower mass things, it's not as clear. And originally, we had a, kind of, we wanted to have a similar definition. And so there was this, this lower mass demarcation that was 13 Jupiter masses. Instead of, between the stars and the brown dwarfs, it's about 75 Jupiter masses. And that was, again, derived in like the 1960s. For the 13 Jupiter masses, we wanted to make this nice clean break between the brown dwarfs and the planets, and so 13 Jupiter masses is the mass-
15:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just to be clear what you're doing, you've turned Jupiter into its own- Into its own measurement. Into its own measurement.
15:08 Speaker 01 Oh yeah, we always, oh yeah.
15:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I don't know-
15:10 Speaker 01 Oh, with the masses, yeah, yeah, yeah.
15:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I don't know how common an exercise that is in the rest of society, okay? So, but yeah-
15:16 Speaker 01 In New York City, I don't know, yeah, it's one block, but it's one avenue block versus one, you know, street block or something like that. It's whatever miles. But yeah, we do this in astronomy all the time. This is the great, like, astronomers, you know, we say astrophysicist if we want people to be impressed or something like that, we'll take anything and call it one, or like, set it relative to one another to make the math easier, like, we'll do anything to make the math easier.
15:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Earth's sun distance? Just one astronomical unit. Well, there you go, one. And how far away is it from the thing? Is 10 of us. Right. Or 5 of us, right.
15:45 Speaker 01 Yeah.
15:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right.
15:47 Speaker 01 Yeah. So the 13 Jupiter masses, above that, there would be some nuclear fusion going on. So more massive than that, you might fuse a little bit of hydrogen, a little bit of lithium, because that's easier to fuse. Deuterium, which is heavy hydrogen, is also easier to fuse, and so that, easier means it will fuse at lower temperatures. And so above 13 Jupiter masses, there might be a little bit of fusion going on. And then below 13 Jupiter masses, they figured out there's no fusion gonna happen ever. But the thing is that this, like, demarcation doesn't actually make a huge difference in the long term for these things. Like, not in terms of the structure, not in terms of the evolution.
16:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So how does it get you interested in exoplanets?
16:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, so, the, the, what ends up happening is that the brown dwarfs are actually really similar to the massive exoplanets. And some of these massive exoplanets are things that we found more easily than we found the Earth-like exoplanets.
16:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So the size of your party grew?
16:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah. 5, 10 times the mass of Jupiter, we found those exoplanets around other stars even more easily.
16:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you find yourself at the same conferences as these other-
16:50 Speaker 01 At fir-, yeah, we, we used to have, kind of, we called them cool stars conferences, and first the brown dwarf people went to the cool stars conferences, but then when the exoplanets got big enough, now there's a ton of different exoplanet conferences that the brown dwarf people go to. We kind of go to both, too.
17:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
17:05 Speaker 01 And we bring our karaoke along, but it's kind of like, yeah-
17:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And it's also where collaborations are born.
17:10 Speaker 01 Right, yeah, especially the-
17:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You can't undervalue-
17:13 Speaker 01 And then the planetary science people who have studied the planets and the solar system for so long are like, "What are you guys doing?" Because so much of it, you know, needs like Jupiter, we know in a lot more detail, but there's still a lot of open questions. Saturn, we know in a lot more detail, even Earth atmosphere stuff. Brown dwarf people can learn in order to study these things. Yeah.
17:43 Chuck Nice? Hi, I'm Ernie Carducci from Columbus, Ohio. I'm here with my son Ernie because we listen to StarTalk every night and support StarTalk on Patreon.
17:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is StarTalk with Neil deGrasse Tyson.
18:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Let's go jump right in.
18:04 Chuck Nice? Okay, we got questions.
18:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Let's do it.
18:06 Chuck Nice? And they are all from our Patreon people and they are all for you specifically. All right, so this is from Laura Fortier, says, greetings from Arizona. Hello, Doctors Rice and Tyson, Lord Nice. I have heard that brown dwarfs and hot Jupiters.
18:23 Speaker 01 Yeah.
18:24 Chuck Nice? Are similar. In what ways do they differ? And how are they made when they are clearly separated from a solar system? I heard somewhere that we don't really know how low density stars are even created. Have we learned more?
18:38 Speaker 01 Yeah.
18:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? People doing their homework before they come in on you.
18:40 Chuck Nice? Yeah, they really are.
18:41 Speaker 01 So the hot Jupiters are one of these things that like we found around other stars that we haven't found in our solar system. And they, the hot Jupiter is a nice one because it is what it sounds like. It's a Jupiter sized planet, Jupiter mass planet.
18:53 Chuck Nice? That all the other planets think are super sexy.
18:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Hot planets, right.
18:59 Chuck Nice? Oh, hot Jupiter in the house. Okay, go ahead.
19:02 Speaker 01 Close to its star so that it's irradiated by the star.
19:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it's not hot on its own.
19:08 Speaker 01 That's the thing is it's not hot on its own.
19:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, so that's a little circumstantial.
19:12 Speaker 01 Yeah, and so that's the interesting thing is that these hot Jupiters end up being similar to mass and maybe a similar temperature to a brown dwarf, but for a different reason.
19:23 Chuck Nice? For a different reason.
19:23 Speaker 01 Yeah.
19:24 Chuck Nice? Look at that.
19:25 Speaker 01 Whether the radiation is coming from the outside or the inside. And so there's similarities, but there's also differences. Yeah, so those are one kind of overlaps.
19:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thanks for clarifying that. And what's the other part of that question?
19:33 Chuck Nice? Um, she said, um. I heard somewhere, we don't really know how low-density stars are created.
19:40 Speaker 01 Yeah.
19:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, did they mean low-mass stars, what in low-density?
19:46 Speaker 01 Yeah, they can be kind of the same. The interesting thing is that because of the physics going on at the very, very cores, these things kind of plateau in size, and so they do get lower and lower density.
19:56 Chuck Nice? Okay.
19:56 Speaker 01 Because the mass decreases while the physical size stays the same. And so they do get lower and lower density, but we talk about them more in terms of their mass. Um, yeah, we don't fully know like how many of the low-mass ones are out there. That's just like counting them. We don't fully know that. We don't really know how they formed or how low the mass can go when it forms like a star does.
20:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But why did we invite you to this?
20:18 Speaker 01 Job security, yeah.
20:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, let's get to brass tacks. I have a gas cloud out there. There's so many beautiful images of gas clouds.
20:26 Speaker 01 Yeah.
20:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? From Hubble, from especially.
20:28 Speaker 01 D W S T, beautiful ones, yeah.
20:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, and we see stars being born. Why weren't those stars born a billion years ago? Why are they being born now? What happened in that gas cloud, ever at any time, to make a star?
20:42 Speaker 01 Oh, it depends on what the, yeah.
20:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And how does it know to make a high-mass star or a low-mass star?
20:45 Speaker 01 Yeah, that, I mean, the universe does, does that. Like, we don't necessarily, you know, we.
20:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Now, why'd she get away with that answer?
20:53 Chuck Nice? I was about to say, she actually gave you your answer, but much more succinctly. Which is the universe is under no obligation to make sense to you.
21:02 Speaker 01 That's true, yeah. We, that's kind of figuring out, seeing if there's a law. So, there does seem to be a law.
21:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We should allow that in the PhD defense, the thesis defense.
21:11 Chuck Nice? Right.
21:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, excuse me, why do you get this? The universe just does that.
21:16 Speaker 01 I feel like that is, like, as soon as you can say, like, confidently, "I have no idea," or "I don't know," or "I don't think we can know," like, that's when you're an actual scientist.
21:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, very good.
21:25 Speaker 01 Like, there's a lot of pressure to know the answer.
21:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Very important philosophical point.
21:29 Speaker 01 The confidence and the uncertainty, like, makes, makes a scientist.
21:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because everybody else is trying to give an answer.
21:34 Chuck Nice? I was gonna say, and that is the difference between, like, I hate to bring it up, but science and religion, and you said somebody BSing you.
21:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think so.
21:43 Chuck Nice? I said religion, but yeah.
21:44 Speaker 01 Oh, I didn't mean to complain those two, but.
21:47 Chuck Nice? But no, it's the truth. Like, you know, religion has an answer for everything.
21:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Basically, yeah.
21:51 Chuck Nice? They have an answer.
21:52 Speaker 01 Even when one answer contradicts the other answer.
21:54 Chuck Nice? It doesn't make a difference. I gave you an answer, you know, that's, yeah, that's very cool. Or, or I should say, maybe it's like my parents, which were, because I said so.
22:02 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly.
22:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's the ultimate answer.
22:03 Chuck Nice? That's the ultimate answer, because I said so. Uh, that's very cool. All right, well, this is great. That was great. That was really informative. Thank you very much, Laura.
22:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And say her last name one more time.
22:14 Chuck Nice? Fortier.
22:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Fortier.
22:15 Chuck Nice? Yes, which is not my forte, to pronounce Fortier. Okay, this is Jason, uh, Dorikson, and Jason says, what is the largest dwarf star ever discovered? Oh, look at that, he's, he's going for the jumbo shrimp angle.
22:34 Speaker 01 Yeah.
22:35 Chuck Nice? He's going for the jumbo shrimp angle. What is the largest dwarf star that we have actually seen?
22:41 Speaker 01 That's a good question. I don't think I can answer that very concretely, and the reason why is because there's more weirdness here that I haven't even really touched upon.
22:50 Chuck Nice? Ooh.
22:50 Speaker 01 Which is the fact that when the stars are formed, they then, they kind of form and they start to fuse their hydrogen and helium and they kind of, once they turn on, they stay that way for a while, they get stable.
23:01 Chuck Nice? Right.
23:01 Speaker 01 Right? And so they have the same temperature, the same luminosity, um, the same mass for a long time. That's the other thing is that the...
23:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Same as, except for the little bit they're losing when they convert into energy.
23:12 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah, but it's a tiny, even, even for the small stars, it's a tiny bit of mass.
23:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Tiny fraction of the total.
23:16 Speaker 01 Yeah, tiny fraction of mass. Um, even for the big stars, the mass doesn't change a huge amount with the nuclear fusion, but the, the big stars have shorter lifetimes and the small stars have longer lifetimes.
23:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah. So the low mass ones?
23:30 Speaker 01 The low mass ones, we think they can last, and I can't believe we can throw around this number, but for like a trillion years.
23:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah.
23:36 Chuck Nice? Well, you can throw it around because nobody understands what it is.
23:40 Speaker 01 Yeah, and probably nobody's gonna be around to prove me wrong.
23:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Way longer than the universe has been alive to this day.
23:45 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah.
23:46 Chuck Nice? Wow, right.
23:46 Speaker 01 Look at that. But the tricky thing is, so that star becomes stable and kind of doesn't stay, but the brown dwarfs were, will kind of gradually cool and fade over time.
23:55 Chuck Nice? Okay.
23:55 Speaker 01 Like, they have this kind of residual heat left over from forming.
23:59 Chuck Nice? Right.
24:00 Speaker 01 But then they're just kind of cool and fade. And so as astronomers look, just looking at them, we can't really tell whether we have a young...
24:09 Speaker 01 Low mass brown dwarf that's just formed, or an old high mass brown dwarf that's been cooling off for a while.
24:16 Chuck Nice? Because they, because they last for so long, you can't really tell. They look, they look the same.
24:22 Speaker 01 The regular, the stars last for a long, long time, but the brown dwarfs cool off.
24:26 Chuck Nice? Right.
24:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, and so we have this, we call it the age mass degeneracy. So we don't know if we have a young, low mass thing that's just hot because it's still young.
24:36 Chuck Nice? Right.
24:36 Speaker 01 Or an old, high mass thing that's hot because it's a little bit higher mass, but it's been around for a long time.
24:43 Chuck Nice? For a long time.
24:43 Speaker 01 Because they're cooling off with time.
24:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We have to get her to explain degeneracy.
24:46 Speaker 01 Degeneracy, yeah, it's like where you, degeneracy is you can't tell the difference.
24:50 Chuck Nice? That's a lecherous brown dwarf. I know, degeneracy. It has a gambling problem.
24:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The brown's worse of today.
24:56 Chuck Nice? Oh, God. It's just not what they used to be.
24:59 Speaker 01 I'm never gonna be able to explain my research again. It's so funny, we get so used to using these terms and don't think about the other.
25:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So degeneracy is a, it's a mathematical.
25:07 Speaker 01 A physical term for us.
25:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Physical mathematical, so, so, give it, give it a gamble here.
25:12 Speaker 01 There's a couple of different kinds even. So our degeneracy, the age mass degeneracy, is that you don't know one without constraining the other. So it's ambiguity is the colloquial, like that's the.
25:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, two things look alike, but they can be very different from each other, and are just happen to look alike in that moment.
25:28 Chuck Nice? Right.
25:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you can't distinguish one from the other without another, another dimension of data.
25:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, we have to be able to measure the mass somehow, or we have to be able to measure the age somehow.
25:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You need another data point to break the degeneracy.
25:39 Chuck Nice? Gotcha.
25:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And there's another degeneracy.
25:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, and then the other degeneracy is like the cores of the objects are partially degenerate, we say. And that's a, like a quantum mechanical thing, where the actual electrons in the atoms get so close together that they fill up the quantum states, and that provides pressure against the mass pushing down.
26:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Can't keep squeezing down.
26:01 Chuck Nice? Wow, look at that.
26:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's called degeneracy pressure.
26:03 Speaker 01 Yeah.
26:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So I'd forgotten we have degeneracy used in two completely different ways.
26:07 Speaker 01 Yeah, they are two different, I never thought about that before either.
26:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
26:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's such a weird, we speak our own language sometimes.
26:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
26:14 Speaker 01 Yeah. And so this high mass, so it's really hard to tell actually exactly how high mass something is. Like nominally, we have the 75 Jupiter mass cutoff.
26:22 Chuck Nice? Right.
26:23 Speaker 01 But we also don't know, you know, is it younger or is it old or something like that?
26:26 Chuck Nice? Which will factor into whether or not it is or it isn't, which factors into whether it's the largest brown dwarf we've ever seen.
26:34 Speaker 01 Yeah.
26:34 Chuck Nice? I got you.
26:35 Speaker 01 Yeah.
26:36 Chuck Nice? Wow, you put all the, damn, that's, that's rough.
26:38 Speaker 01 It's weird.
26:39 Chuck Nice? Science is hard. It's rough, man.
26:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Science is hard.
26:41 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
26:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If you'll just look through a telescope, here's the answer to that question.
26:45 Speaker 01 You find new problems as soon as you dig a little bit deeper.
26:49 Chuck Nice? So Jason, the answer to your question is, we don't know. We don't know, man. Sorry.
26:54 Speaker 01 How many is that? I think that's, I don't know for the first few questions so far.
26:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right.
27:00 Chuck Nice? Ah, that's pretty cool, though. I love it.
27:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But who's it that says, "The only thing I know is that I know nothing"? What's that quote?
27:06 Speaker 01 All I know is that I don't know nothing. That's Operation Ivy, but...
27:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I think before that, I'm thinking ancient Greece, Socrates.
27:14 Speaker 01 Socrates and Operation Ivy.
27:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it'd be Socrates, actually.
27:18 Speaker 01 Socrates Johnson.
27:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Socrates, it was, "If I know anything at all, it's that I know nothing." I'm paraphrasing.
27:26 Speaker 01 So, yeah.
27:27 Chuck Nice? All right, this is Knobble Gobble, and Knobble Gobble says, "Salutations, doctors and Lord. My name is Caleb Noah Getton." Mm-hmm, okay. Noah Getton. Noetken. There you go. "My name is Caleb Noetken." And, oh, thanks, Caleb. He says, "Good luck with that one."
27:50 Speaker 01 He even knows.
27:51 Chuck Nice? Son of a gun.
27:52 Speaker 01 He knows.
27:52 Chuck Nice? I can't believe you, man.
27:55 Chuck Nice? Then he says, "This is Caleb from Wichita, Kansas."
27:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? People are, people, I get no respect.
28:01 Speaker 01 So you're letting the cat mash on the keyboard that Chuck is gonna have fun with this one?
28:05 Chuck Nice? Yeah, tell me about it. He says, "Since brown dwarfs are sort of an intermediate object between a planet and a star, I was wondering if there was a common trend between mass composition and magnetic field strength."
28:19 Speaker 01 Oh, gosh, magnetic fields.
28:22 Chuck Nice? Look at that.
28:23 Speaker 01 This is one of those things where if you want to trip up an astronomer, you ask them about dust, or you ask them about magnetic fields.
28:29 Chuck Nice? Right.
28:29 Speaker 01 And it's nice because, it's nice because it applies really across any kind of research. We try to ignore it because those things complicate things hugely. So yeah, these things do have magnetic fields, but we actually don't know how the magnetic fields are generated on these stars. We think we know how magnetic fields are generated on the sun because there's this cool thing called the tachocline. And it's like, you know, these moving charges are going to generate the magnetic field. And we think that's where it comes from on the sun. And that tachocline is a border between a radiative zone and a convective zone. So there's energy transport is happening in different ways. But for brown dwarfs, what we think we understand of the structure, and this is all from modeling
29:12 Speaker 01 things and understanding how energy transport is supposed to happen, we think at some point they become fully convective. So this is kind of cool. It's like the convection is this big bulk motion of material that happens when you like boil water and stuff like that. So it's relatively familiar to us.
29:28 Chuck Nice? It's like an internal churning?
29:29 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's this churning. But instead of the churning only going down part of the way inside the stars, which it does for the higher mass stars, it goes all the way down.
29:37 Chuck Nice? So the two of those together, you have a radiative effect, which is the outward pushing of the star. And then you have the internal churning. And the two of them together, like the earth's core rolling around inside of us makes a magnetic field?
29:50 Speaker 01 Well, we don't know for the brown dwarf. That's the thing is that because...
29:53 Chuck Nice? I'm trying to figure it out.
29:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All I know is there are a bunch of seven I don't knows.
29:58 Speaker 01 So, and we also think the magnetic fields are going to be different across the different types of brown dwarfs.
30:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So why don't you call it a somethingy line and not a...
30:05 Speaker 01 A tachocline.
30:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And not just a dynamo? Or is a dynamo the broader term?
30:10 Speaker 01 Dynamo is the broader term that generates the magnetic fields. Yeah. Am I messing up my solar physics? Hopefully not. I could be. Somebody, you know, somebody can get their five cents back. Their five dollars back.
30:21 Chuck Nice? So what is the difference between that and a star? Because we know that's what had happened like in our own sun.
30:26 Speaker 01 Yeah, in our own sun, we've kind of got these bigger motions. In the brown dwarfs, we don't know fully where, there isn't this separation between the inner layers. And so we don't know where the magnetic field comes from. But there is a magnetic field. We see spots on the low mass stars and on the brown dwarfs. We see auroras on the brown dwarfs.
30:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Spots is good evidence of a magnetic field. On the sun, spots always come in pairs. And one is plus and one is minus.
30:50 Chuck Nice? Oh, I did not know that.
30:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, it's a cool fact.
30:52 Speaker 01 There's a bright spot that goes along with the dark spot. Yeah, I think the bright spot is harder to see usually.
30:57 Chuck Nice? Look at that. That is the first I've ever heard of that.
31:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
31:01 Speaker 01 And the solar winds that we're gonna see.
31:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Here's something else I heard, which is consistent with what you just said. Uh, back in my day, you would accuse someone of, if they're presenting their research, and they say, "The bigger is the effect of a magnetic field in what they describe, the less they know about the subject."
31:20 Speaker 01 Yeah.
31:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The less they can explain, they put in more magnetic field.
31:24 Chuck Nice? More magnetic field.
31:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Which is what accounts for everything that they don't otherwise know.
31:27 Speaker 01 It's, uh, it's, magnetic fields are challenging. They're very hard to understand.
31:31 Chuck Nice? Wow, that's really, well...
31:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Astrophysically, and in a lab, and we got it, but yeah, yeah.
31:36 Chuck Nice? If we're talking magnets, it's no big deal.
31:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Mm-hmm.
31:38 Chuck Nice? Yeah. Wow, well Caleb, that was a great question, man.
31:42 Speaker 01 Three I don't know, it's rough.
31:43 Chuck Nice? It doesn't make it, but here's what I'm...
31:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I was counting seven, but if it's only three, good, alright.
31:46 Chuck Nice? But this is what I'm loving about the "I don't knows." Every time we don't know something, I learn something.
31:51 Speaker 01 Yeah.
31:52 Chuck Nice? Like, something else comes out of it that I've never heard before.
31:55 Speaker 01 Yeah.
31:55 Chuck Nice? That's the third time that we've, didn't had an "I don't know," but every, every single time, there's something really cool
32:00 Speaker 01 Yeah.
32:00 Chuck Nice? that, that we find out in, in place of "I don't know."
32:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And by the way, it's also a measure that the field is very much embedded in its own frontier.
32:09 Chuck Nice? Right.
32:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? When you're on a frontier, every step you take is into the unknown.
32:12 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
32:26 Chuck Nice? Okay, this is Atticus Thompson. Atticus says, "Hello, Dr. Tyson, Dr. Rice."
32:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is this a, a letter from the Civil War?
32:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We need that voice.
32:36 Chuck Nice? "My dearest Dr. Tyson and Dr. Rice, today was an especially difficult day."
32:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Signed, Atticus.
32:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is anybody named Atticus today?
32:49 Chuck Nice? Nah.
32:49 Speaker 01 Yeah, they're all in Brooklyn.
32:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, is that right?
32:51 Speaker 01 Yeah, 100% they're all at the playgrounds in Brooklyn right now, I guarantee you.
32:55 Chuck Nice? And you are so right.
32:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wow.
32:56 Chuck Nice? But that's Atticus from Atticus Finch.
32:58 Speaker 01 Quite possible.
32:59 Chuck Nice? Yeah, I would, I would think. But anyway, um, he says, "My name is Atticus, and I am nine years old."
33:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, he's nine?
33:07 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
33:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
33:08 Chuck Nice? Uh, he says, "I live in Saudi-Daisy, Tennessee."
33:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright.
33:12 Chuck Nice? Uh, "I want to know if two brown dwarfs..." collided. Do they become a larger brown dwarf? Or would they just become a low mass star? Ooh.
33:25 Speaker 01 That is a very good question.
33:27 Chuck Nice? Nine years old? Okay, so Atticus, first of all, you ain't fooling nobody. I don't care if you're nine or not. I know your father helped you with this question.
33:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What are you talking about?
33:36 Chuck Nice? You're not fooling anybody, Atticus. I'm Atticus and I'm nine years old. I would like to know.
33:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait dude, when I was nine, I could have asked that.
33:45 Chuck Nice? You could have asked that question?
33:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, yeah.
33:46 Chuck Nice? Okay.
33:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, yeah.
33:47 Speaker 01 Yeah, I was gonna say you're gonna work for Atticus someday.
33:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? My interest in the universe was birthed when I turned nine years old.
33:52 Chuck Nice? Okay, alright. Well, Atticus, I take it back. No, I don't.
33:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, you wanna get at him? Ask him if he paid the five dollars.
34:02 Chuck Nice? Yeah, but if he's asking questions like that, he might have a job. I'm just saying.
34:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so what happens with when stars collide?
34:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's gonna depend on their mass.
34:13 Chuck Nice? Really?
34:13 Speaker 01 It's not outside the realm of possibility if you have, like, that's just a multiplication or an addition problem, really. If they, if the two brown dwarfs come together and have more than that 75 masses. In theory, yeah, it could ignite hydrogen fusion.
34:27 Chuck Nice? Right.
34:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, so the whole star will reorganize?
34:30 Chuck Nice? Right.
34:31 Speaker 01 Quite possible. It's something that we haven't, we don't like expect it to happen a lot. I don't think like...
34:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It wouldn't be an object with two separate cores, we don't think. Because gravity and friction would bring it together.
34:43 Speaker 01 As they get closer together, they would get like torn apart a little bit. And so it would probably, like, if they did coalesce.
34:49 Chuck Nice? And then coalesce again.
34:50 Speaker 01 Yeah. We know this happens for, like, the higher mass stars. Because we see that, you know, black hole mergers are what trigger the gravitational waves. We have, you know, stellar mergers, like, it creates more energy and so we have more evidence of it for the high mass stars. So we don't really think about it too much for the low mass stars. Because I think we don't have a lot of super close binaries, like, there's not gonna be a huge amount of energy loss, like, you're gonna need some kind of energy loss to get them to get closer and closer to one another.
35:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Somebody has to eat the energy of their orbit.
35:22 Speaker 01 Yeah, if they're gonna come together.
35:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's why we don't just... Collide into the sun.
35:27 Speaker 01 Yeah.
35:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right now.
35:27 Speaker 01 It's a very slow process for any kind of orbital change like that.
35:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, and, and.
35:31 Speaker 01 But if it did happen.
35:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And blue stragglers are, are similar.
35:34 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's all these weird stars.
35:36 Chuck Nice? Wait, what's a blue straggler?
35:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You know about the blue straggler?
35:38 Chuck Nice? No. Tell me, yeah, cause.
35:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, so you look at a cluster of stars.
35:42 Chuck Nice? Right.
35:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All born together, so they all should be evolving together as we understand stellar evolution. And there's some stars that are like hotter and bluer than, than anybody else is. And there's a big, in my day, it was a big mystery until someone said, maybe these are two stars that have merged.
35:59 Chuck Nice? Merged.
35:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And when you merge.
36:00 Speaker 01 So they've become hot again.
36:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You get to re-energize your core with fresh material.
36:05 Chuck Nice? Right.
36:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that you will have a, a prolonged life expectancy and you'll come out a little hotter than you're so otherwise supposed to be. They're the late bloomers of the stellar nursery. Well, they got a, they got an injection of new, of new. Had a growth spurt over the summer. Growth spurt. Look at me. Yeah, so they stand out from all the rest of the, the stars. Oh, wow. Blue stragglers, because everyone else has evolved.
36:25 Chuck Nice? Right.
36:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Together.
36:26 Chuck Nice? Yeah, cause they all were born together.
36:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They were born together and this one got an extra infusion.
36:30 Speaker 01 High mass ones especially are bluer to begin with and shouldn't live as long.
36:33 Chuck Nice? Right.
36:34 Speaker 01 Yeah.
36:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, and so these are, these are standouts. So, so I never thought about the brown dwarf. Do you can ignite a brown dwarf that otherwise would have had to live its life?
36:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, in theory, I think. In practice, I don't think we see it a lot. We do see, you know, it's hard to tell whether or not things are binaries. Yeah, maybe they, they just come into these stars.
36:52 Chuck Nice? Could be.
36:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Maybe they're just a star you're ignoring over in the side and it used to be two brown dwarfs.
36:58 Speaker 01 Yeah, would we see evidence of it?
36:59 Chuck Nice? It's hard to. Could very well be.
37:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Hidden in plain sight.
37:02 Speaker 01 Yeah.
37:02 Chuck Nice? Yeah, look at that. Hmm. Like a, like a. Like a YouTuber that actually crossed over to regular entertainment.
37:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What?
37:13 Chuck Nice? Okay, anyway, sorry.
37:14 Speaker 01 That's all the.
37:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So this is Atticus?
37:16 Chuck Nice? That was Atticus.
37:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Atticus, thank you, Atticus.
37:19 Speaker 01 That's a very good question, yeah.
37:20 Chuck Nice? That was a great question, Atticus.
37:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you know he's building something in his basement.
37:22 Chuck Nice? Something I don't want anything to know about, but I'm sure the US government does.
37:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The power grid dims every, every, every, once a week as he turns on his, his experiment.
37:33 Chuck Nice? All right. Okay, here we go. This is Jimmy Go Lightly. This is Holly's brother. Says, hi, this is James in Charlotte. How does the life-
37:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, for those who were not alive in 1964.
37:45 Chuck Nice? Oh, it's still on the, it's still on the movie channel.
37:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is it?
37:48 Chuck Nice? The Turner movie classics. It's a great movie.
37:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, so that was-
37:53 Chuck Nice? What's her face?
37:53 Speaker 01 Breakfast at Tiffany's.
37:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Breakfast at Tiffany's.
37:55 Chuck Nice? Audrey Hepburn.
37:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Audrey Hepburn. She was Holly Go Lightly.
37:57 Chuck Nice? Holly Go Lightly.
37:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Based on the novel by Truman Capote.
38:00 Speaker 01 Truman Capote, yeah.
38:02 Chuck Nice? Oh, ah.
38:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You, you didn't know that?
38:05 Chuck Nice? I did not know.
38:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're learning something every day here.
38:07 Chuck Nice? Let me tell you, that's why I come here.
38:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
38:09 Chuck Nice? Cause I'm stupid.
38:13 Chuck Nice? All right, this is, he says, hey, James in Charlotte here. How does the lifespan of a low mass star compare to the lifespan of other stars such as our sun?
38:21 Speaker 01 Yeah.
38:22 Chuck Nice? So.
38:22 Speaker 01 These, the brown dwarfs are gonna be around forever.
38:24 Chuck Nice? For a long, long time.
38:25 Speaker 01 That's what makes them super useful. Yeah, the sun is gonna stably fuse hydrogen for about 10 billion years. And we're about halfway through that. So if you want something to worry about, like the sun is about halfway through its lifetime. But the brown dwarfs, like we said, are gonna last basically forever. For like our practical definition of forever. Which we use it in kind of a neat way, which is, we call it galactic archaeology. Because some of the low mass stars that we can see now might have been around already since very early on. The high mass stars are gonna have come and gone. But the low mass stars are gonna be around. And one of the interesting things is that-
39:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, but you can make a low mass star today.
39:04 Speaker 01 Yes.
39:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And it's be a low mass star. But some of the pool of low mass stars could have been born first.
39:10 Chuck Nice? Right at the very beginning.
39:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, and they're still alive.
39:12 Speaker 01 You might ask, how can we tell the difference?
39:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How are you gonna know the difference? Or is it degenerate?
39:16 Speaker 01 Yeah. We can, this one, we can tell the difference. And the answer lies in those high mass stars. Because the high mass stars that have been fusing and then exploding have been creating heavier elements. And so the older a low mass star is, the longer ago it was formed, the fewer heavy elements it's gonna have. And so the more recently formed low mass stars are gonna have more of the heavy elements that were created in the subsequent generations of high mass stars, which is kinda cool if you think about it.
39:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? To get spectra and look at those elements.
39:49 Speaker 01 Yeah, so you get the spectra, you look at the elements, and we have a special name for the low, we call it low metallicity, because we call this composition, how many heavy elements are in it, we call that metallicity. The low metallicity stars are called sub dwarfs.
40:02 Chuck Nice? Oh.
40:03 Speaker 01 Because they're under the main sequence of stars on this HR diagram.
40:07 Chuck Nice? Okay.
40:08 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's a little bit weird, but, and they also tend to be blue in color.
40:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I did not know that, sub dwarfs.
40:12 Chuck Nice? That's super cool, man.
40:13 Speaker 01 They are fun to study.
40:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because they reveal themselves as their own population.
40:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, subsolar metallicity.
40:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Got it, got it, okay.
40:20 Chuck Nice? Wow, okay. All right, this is Matt Curtis, and Matt says, hello, doc, doc, lord, uh, Matt here, and Chuck is pronounced Matt.
40:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Stop it.
40:28 Chuck Nice? Well, these people, these people are brutal today, man. They are brutal.
40:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Chuck is pronouncing Matt.
40:40 Chuck Nice? Coming here from, he says, uh, coming from South Carolina here, uh, given that our space telescope's, uh, technology is improving, and we keep discovering more and more exoplanets, what will it take to directly capture an image of one of them? Deducing their existence, uh, through transit or gravity wobble is great, but what improvements would be required to show an image to the public directly?
41:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You wanna see like oceans and continents?
41:04 Speaker 01 Oh, he wants, so it depends.
41:05 Chuck Nice? He wants to travel, bro, sure.
41:07 Speaker 01 If you wanna, so I like to call, because we do have images of exoplanets.
41:10 Chuck Nice? Right.
41:11 Speaker 01 This is an amazing thing.
41:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Direct imaging.
41:13 Speaker 01 Direct images of exoplanets. It's hard.
41:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How many pixels?
41:16 Speaker 01 Uh, yeah, a handful. And how many planets? It's like also ten planets, maybe, or something like that. But one of them has stood the test of time, so this is also kinda back in my day of, um, exoplanets. Back in 2008, two directly imaged exoplanets were announced. Um, one was in, uh, around the star Fomalha, which famously had a disk, um, and was a little like... Bright thing in the disk.
41:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And that star is of southern hemisphere.
41:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's a pretty bright star, though. It's got a name, like a star with a, you know, relatively normal name is a star that you can see in the night sky. And then the other one was HR8799, which with a number like that, you can't see to the night sky. But it had three planets detected around it. And both of these, one was done with a Hubble Space Telescope, one was done with a ground-based telescope. But they're amazing discoveries, like, you know, it's, yeah, it's a handful of pixels and it's really fuzzy images. It's like, eh. But the Fowlhot one actually seems to have been a spurious discovery. Like, it's just a clump in the disk that kind of didn't move the way it was expected to move and has since gone away. The HR8799 system, they found another planet even closer in. So there's four planets in the system.
42:26 Speaker 01 And you can, over the time, put the images together and watch the planets orbit.
42:31 Chuck Nice? Oh, wow.
42:32 Speaker 01 It's beautiful. And so somebody, Jason Wang, I believe his name is, has made gifs that every once in a while go around social media of like a little animation of the images where we can watch planets orbit around a star other than the sun, which I think is just amazingly.
42:48 Chuck Nice? It's crazy. I love it.
42:49 Speaker 01 Yeah.
42:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But think about it.
42:50 Speaker 01 We haven't found that many more.
42:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A planet takes years to go around its host star.
42:53 Chuck Nice? Right.
42:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You need data over that entire time.
42:56 Speaker 01 Decades, yeah, basically.
42:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? To really get the good.
42:58 Speaker 01 Yeah, and these are, this is, the HR8799 system is like a souped-up solar system. It's a bigger star than the sun. The planets are bigger. They're like five to 10 times the mass of Jupiter. And they're all further out than our gas giant planets.
43:10 Chuck Nice? So it's bigger and brighter.
43:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, but similar to it.
43:12 Chuck Nice? That's cool, man.
43:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Time for like, one more question.
43:14 Chuck Nice? All right, okay, so since we're on exoplanets, let's, let's, let's do Paula Patsova, who says, hello, Dr. Rice, Dr. Tyson, Lord Nice. Paula here from Slovakia. What is the potential of habitability of orbiting planets around a brown dwarf or low-mass stars?
43:32 Speaker 01 Yeah.
43:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh, good one.
43:34 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
43:34 Speaker 01 Yeah, especially the low-mass star. Like, the brown dwarfs, maybe, but they're kind of the extension of the low-mass stars. But the, the low-mass stars, like, we, they might actually be better targets for finding Earth.
43:48 Speaker 01 I don't want to say Earth-like, but I'll say Earth-sized planets, at the very least. Because for these indirect methods that were mentioned earlier, the indirect methods, it's easier to see small planets relative to small stars. It's easier to see planets close in to the stars. And so both of those mean that if you look around a small star, it's easier to find Earth-sized planets, and kind of Earth-temperature planets.
44:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
44:13 Speaker 01 So they're, because those are going to be closer into the star because it's a cooler star. So it's like a smaller fire.
44:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If you're going to have an Earth-temperature, and it's way dimmer, or way less luminous than our sun, you've got to be way closer.
44:24 Speaker 01 You can be closer in.
44:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? To get that same temperature.
44:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, to get that same equilibrium temperature. But then it's easier to find that planet with these indirect methods that we use most of the time. And so now, the, those, these small stars have been like really intriguing targets for searching for exoplanets. And so the Trappist I system is a very famous system that was discovered a handful of years ago with seven Earth-sized planets in orbit around that star. And like, something like three or four of them are solidly... Yeah, this one, well, weirdly enough, the star was known before. Trappist is actually the acronym for...
45:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? An acronym?
45:01 Speaker 01 The survey.
45:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, okay, okay, the catalog.
45:03 Speaker 01 Transiting, blah, blah, blah, blah. But it's a Belgium, the group includes a Belgium observatory. And so it's, they, they, it's like, we call it a backronym sometimes, where they think of the clever term that they want, and then they make up the acronym to go with it.
45:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A backronym.
45:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, a backronym, yeah, that's a fun portmanteau. So the Trappist I system is super great because a solid three or four of those planets could be in the habitable zone.
45:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right.
45:26 Speaker 01 So the habitable zone is where it's the right temperature for liquid water.
45:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Goldilocks zone.
45:30 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, Goldilocks zone. But you still, it doesn't tell you anything about the atmosphere, which you would also need to have liquid water on the surface. And so there's still a lot of unknowns, a lot of what-ifs for those. But the low-mass stars are really exciting targets for Earth-sized exoplanets, at least.
45:47 Chuck Nice? Wow, cool, exciting.
45:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right.
45:50 Chuck Nice? Yeah, that's great.
45:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Emily, thank you. You don't come on here often enough. We've got to bring...
45:55 Speaker 01 I'm around.
45:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We'll just reach out.
45:57 Chuck Nice? I'm right upstairs.
45:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, upstairs.
45:59 Speaker 01 Yeah. Walking by.
46:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Call me.
46:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, thank you for bringing back your expertise on this, this, this, this zone of ignorance that existed for so long that finally people are jumping in.
46:15 Speaker 01 Yeah.
46:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Getting their, getting their hands dirty.
46:17 Speaker 01 We've always kind of wondered, right? But now we know for sure, which is amazing.
46:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Very cool.
46:21 Speaker 01 A lot of the things.
46:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, all right. Good stuff. All right, well, let me take us out with some reflections. Okay. On this moment. Hmm. In my field, astrophysics, many of us confront people who ask the very sensible question, why are we spending money on anything you're doing when we have all these problems here on Earth? And, okay, before we did all of this, did you not have those problems on Earth? I think you had them long before any of us spent a dime of tax money or any other money trying to understand the universe.
47:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What we do know is, what we discover expands our view, not only of the world, but of our place within it. And when I was growing up, there were planets and there were stars. And no one really thought much about, well, how do you get between one and the other in the universe? What does the universe say about that? And then we learned there's an entire field that we didn't even know would exist or could exist, and now does exist, that specializes in the transition between what you are as a planet and what you would become as a star. This is more about our world, our universe, our home.
47:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And it could be that this will help us discover life on a planet, around a star, sometime in our future. And so whether or not that specifically puts food on your table, I'll ask you a little differently. I'll say, how much is the universe worth to you? And that's cosmic perspective. Neil deGrasse Tyson here for StarTalk. Cosmic theories, as always, keep looking up.
Previous Stars Talk to Neil – Alien Love Next Cosmic Queries – Physics All Around Us Page updated September 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated