Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast Live at Awesome Con – To Mars and Beyond About this episode We explore the mission to Mars and beyond with Bill Nye the Science Guy, co-host Eugene Mirman, astrobiologist David Grinspoon, former NASA Deputy Administrator Dava Newman, and comedians Jo Firestone and Hari Kondabolu, recorded live at Awesome Con 2017.
NOTE: StarTalk+ Patrons and All-Access subscribers can listen to this entire episode commercial-free here: https://www.startalkradio.net/show/live-at-awesome-con-to-mars-and-beyond/
Thanks to our Patrons Justin Adamson, Forrest Shepard, Andrew Wood, William Price, and Kynan Woodford for supporting us this week.
Photo Credit: Elliot Severn.
Transcript 10,584 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk. Your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:16 Eugene Mirman? Hello, everybody. It is my great pleasure to welcome StarTalk Live to the show, to AwesomeCon. Ladies and gentlemen, let me bring on your host, one of America's great science educators and communicators, Bill Nye the Science Guy.
0:35 Bill Nye? Eugene, Eugene, guy hug.
0:37 Eugene Mirman? Hello.
0:38 Bill Nye? Yes, good to see you.
0:39 Eugene Mirman? Welcome.
0:39 Bill Nye? Greetings.
0:43 Bill Nye? Wow, look at you guys. Greetings, greetings.
0:49 Bill Nye? I imagine this is not the first time you've heard this this weekend. This is awesome!
0:55 Bill Nye? So, speaking of awesome, should we introduce our guest?
0:59 Eugene Mirman? Let's do it.
1:00 Bill Nye? Well, start out, where should we start? We'll start over here. The most hilarious woman ever. And you know her by her Twitter handle, @KingFireStorm. Ladies and gentlemen, Joe Firestone.
1:22 Speaker 03 Hello, hello.
1:25 Eugene Mirman? Hello.
1:26 Speaker 03 Hello.
1:29 Bill Nye? Next, in this corner, or this chair, from the Astrobiology Institute, you know him by his Twitter handle, Dr. Funky Spoon. David Grinspoon, David, David, David.
1:52 Bill Nye? Good to see you, sir, yes. Good to see you too. Then, in this corner, which is a chair. And I'd give you his Twitter handle, but he said, "No, just Google him." Hari Kondabolu.
2:07 Eugene Mirman? Welcome.
2:08 Bill Nye? Hari Kondabolu. And then lastly, everybody. Somebody who's, who really works in the business full-time. Uh, the second-in-command at NASA. Uh, the deputy administrator. Dr. Dava Newman. Give it up. Here she is.
2:27 Speaker 04 Hi, guys. Thank you, sir.
2:30 Bill Nye? Oh, we'll do this, and then this, and then this. Oh, we messed up our microphones. Look at that. There it is. Now, please, everybody, please sit down. Are there any questions on what we've covered so far? No, we're at Awesome Khan. This is superhero time. And onstage here with me, I claim, are the superheroes of space exploration.
2:54 Bill Nye? So... So for me, what I'm hoping for is to have superpowers. Right? Now, what do you guys want in superpowers? Main thing for me, I want to be able to fly. And then the next thing down that list for me is to be able to have extraordinary vision.
3:12 Eugene Mirman? What's extraordinary vision? Like, how far?
3:16 Bill Nye? Well, I'd like to see other planets.
3:18 Eugene Mirman? Oh, okay.
3:19 Bill Nye? Yeah. And then, I'd like to have vision that would find life, and stuff like that. So, to get this started, Dr. Newman, you are an expert in aerospace and biomedical engineering. Yes? Your research studies include advanced spacesuit design and dynamics and control of astronaut motion, which is not trivial when you're in zero G.
3:41 Speaker 04 Right, or Mars.
3:42 Bill Nye? Or Mars. And, uh, you're the director of MIT's Technology and Policy Program.
3:48 Speaker 04 On leave to serve NASA?
3:50 Bill Nye? And as well as your deputy director at NASA. Now, Dr. Greenspan. Sir. You're, of course, you're a regular here on StarTalk. That's why you're beloved.
4:02 Eugene Mirman? Oh my.
4:03 Bill Nye? And you are, I presume you are funky and you're good with a spoon. And that's why you're Dr.
4:08 Eugene Mirman? I do my best.
4:08 Bill Nye? Yeah, you're Dr. Funky Spoon. But right now, you're the senior scientist at the Planetary Science Institute, right? Which is like, an amorphous thing.
4:17 Eugene Mirman? It's distributed.
4:18 Bill Nye? Distributed, because it's the modern world in which we now live. And you're a co-investigator on Mars Curiosity Rover, right? And stuff like that.
4:25 Eugene Mirman? This is right.
4:26 Bill Nye? So, uh, here's the thing, you guys. I want to just ask you to start with, because we're at Awesome Con. What would be your favorite, let's see, we'll start with David. What would be your favorite superhero?
4:36 Speaker 04 So I'm gonna combine a few. So it's Elasti-
4:39 Bill Nye? Will you, what, you can do that?
4:41 Speaker 04 Yeah, I'm gonna do it. It's Elastigirl with Spider-Man, because the suit is cool. We came up with it first, you know, for a suit for Mars. And I like to fly too. So Batman, so Elastispiderbatgirl. That's what I'm going with.
4:53 Bill Nye? Yeah.
4:54 Speaker 04 That's what I'm going with.
4:54 Bill Nye? Cool. And, uh-
4:57 Eugene Mirman? Batman just doesn't really fly as much as he falls incredibly well.
5:00 Bill Nye? Yeah, yeah. And he doesn't ever, seldom gets hurt.
5:05 Speaker 05 What was Elastigirl's, I'm not familiar, Elastigirl was just kinda bendy? Or what was her thing?
5:10 Speaker 04 Super bendy, cool, yeah.
5:11 Speaker 05 Super bendy?
5:12 Speaker 04 Around, yeah, nothing got in her way. And fast.
5:15 Speaker 05 What was the difference between her and say Gumby?
5:19 Eugene Mirman? Gumby, I think, is more Christian.
5:21 Speaker 05 Oh.
5:24 Speaker 04 And green, right. She's, she's red, she's kinda more reddish.
5:27 Bill Nye? Oh, so Gumby's green and she's red.
5:30 Speaker 05 Right.
5:30 Bill Nye? There.
5:30 Speaker 05 Okay.
5:31 Bill Nye? Just start with that.
5:32 Speaker 05 Just start with that.
5:33 Bill Nye? But seriously, you made, you made an allusion to spacesuits? That are, resemble superhero costumes?
5:41 Speaker 04 There you go, but the, the technology came first, I think, yeah.
5:45 Bill Nye? The technology came first?
5:47 Speaker 04 I think so, we've been working on the technology for a long time.
5:50 Bill Nye? What technology are you talking about?
5:53 Speaker 04 Advanced spacesuit design, it has to be, you know, lightweight, mobile, flexible. We're going to Mars, did you hear? We're gonna become interplanetary, so-
6:00 Bill Nye? We're going to Mars, not, you guys, we're not going to Mars during, uh, this-
6:06 Eugene Mirman? Surprise, we're going to Mars, pick a partner. I hope you're with someone you love.
6:13 Eugene Mirman? Strap in.
6:14 Speaker 05 Well, what are we doing in Mars? What are we doing? We're setting up shop, or what's happening there?
6:19 Speaker 04 Well, we're already there, we've been there for the last 50 years.
6:22 Speaker 05 Right.
6:22 Speaker 04 With orbiters, landers, and the next 50 years are even cooler. We're going with people. So, first we're going out. Space station that's in low earth orbit, phase one. We've been doing this for 16 years together with the world. Then we move out to Earth, Moon, in all the 2020s. And our rovers are still hanging out, doing Mars. We have these great experiments. We keep popping off the robotic missions to Mars. And then boom, boots on Mars with people in the 2030s. It's like stuff, stuff will be there.
6:48 Eugene Mirman? What's the year that you think that there'll be boots with people inside the boots?
6:52 Speaker 04 People inside the boots? In the 2030s. In the 2030s. It's the 2030s and it's probably not all of us, but it's my Mars, the Mars generation.
6:58 Eugene Mirman? Nice.
6:59 Speaker 04 Teenagers, teenagers today.
7:01 Speaker 06 Is there gonna be commercial, like, flights to Mars? Is that the plan? When does that start?
7:05 Speaker 04 Well, government and commercials. So it's public-private partnership. And it's the world, too. I heard Southwest is doing specials.
7:14 Eugene Mirman? I can't wait till there's some weird line where you have to get into to get a Mars. Special TSA. Great Southwest joke, terrible airline.
7:22 David Grinspoon? Watch out for the baggage charges.
7:24 Bill Nye? Before we go too far along, David, you have a favorite superhero?
7:28 David Grinspoon? Yeah, I guess my favorite superhero is Planet Girl slash Planet Boy. Because...
7:35 Bill Nye? Planet Girl?
7:37 David Grinspoon? Slash Planet Boy because she's transgender and interplanetary. And she's got spectrometer eyes, multi-wavelength imaging spectrometer eyes. And she's got ion drives on her toes. So she can go in orbit around any planet and image just about anything you would want to.
7:57 Bill Nye? Dr. Newman, you are the second in command at NASA. That's like a superpower.
8:02 Speaker 04 It is super cool. I have the best job in the world. Maybe the second best. I think it's the best job in the world.
8:08 Eugene Mirman? Can you ever go like, "Get out of here, go to outer space"?
8:12 Speaker 04 Not out loud.
8:15 Bill Nye? Because if you did, it would cost a lot of money.
8:17 Speaker 04 Yeah.
8:19 Bill Nye? So, so when you say journey to Mars, we spell that J two M?
8:24 Speaker 04 I like that, that's a good acronym.
8:25 Bill Nye? Is that right?
8:26 Speaker 04 That's my shorthand for it.
8:27 Bill Nye? And so, uh, uh, in order to make the journey to Mars, let me ask you a couple of things. What do we need to do?
8:34 Speaker 04 We need a big rocket, so we're designing and developing, and this is real, our space launch system is well under development.
8:42 Eugene Mirman? How long will it take to travel from Earth to Mars?
8:44 Speaker 04 So, you know, round trips, about eight months to get there, but just think of it as about a two-year round trip in transit. But hopefully we stay 600 days on the surface of Mars, exploring.
8:54 Bill Nye? And when you say 600 days, 600 Earth days, 600 Sol's?
8:58 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's a, that's debatable. Let's say it's 600 Earth days, since I'm kinda counting in Earth days right now.
9:03 Eugene Mirman? And 600 days is also just 600 days?
9:06 Bill Nye? I think anybody who's ever seen the movie 2001 Space Odyssey would say, "That is awesome." And the reason, part of the reason it was awesome, it was spinning. Right? The space station is spinning, creating some artificial gravity. But, uh, right now, the proposal is to punch it and go to Mars fast enough, exercise enough on the way, and take the right medications to preserve bones.
9:31 Speaker 04 Keeping, preserve muscles and bones. Musculoskeletal, the bone, uh, we lose, uh, typically you lose 1 to 2% bone mineral density per month. Here on Earth, that's per decade. But maybe we have some small, you can do small, short arm centrifugation that fits in the craft. That's a really interesting concept, you know, like a spin in the gym. You know, imagine instead of the elliptical, it's a, could be a spinning thing. So we're still, you know, playing around with the concept.
9:53 Eugene Mirman? You would be in a spinning thing and it would?
9:55 Speaker 04 Well, say the spacecraft, you know, you know what? You know, 2001, that was fantastic. Engineers love it, but that's expensive when you have a two-kilometer radius, right?
10:04 Bill Nye? Tell me about it.
10:05 Speaker 04 So, let's do a smaller one, cause you know, we have great budgets. But we could spin inside.
10:10 Bill Nye? Just a second, David. Just a normal blank? What, a normal what?
10:15 Speaker 04 A normal spacecraft, normal Mars spacecraft.
10:18 Bill Nye? A normal Mars spacecraft?
10:20 Speaker 04 That's what I think about every day. And we could have little, think of like little spinning beds inside, see? That's cool, that's still artificial gravity, but within the constraints of a normal Mars spacecraft.
10:30 Bill Nye? So, let's say that problem is solved. What is the biggest challenge?
10:33 Speaker 04 The biggest challenge for getting people to, uh, become interplanetary, cause we will become interplanetary, I hope sooner than later, that's what I'm working on. Biggest challenge is... The will.
10:45 Bill Nye? The will, deciding to do it.
10:47 Speaker 04 We have to focus just deciding yes. The biggest challenge is just saying yes and getting, all of you, getting all the people behind it say that, first answer why, why are we going? They're the enduring questions. Are we alone in the universe? Is there life? Has there been past life? That's the why. Biggest challenge is just say, let's just say yes.
11:05 Bill Nye? So...
11:05 Speaker 04 And stay the course and don't get, you know, derailed and just focus, focus, focus, and then we get there.
11:11 Bill Nye? So that's the biggest challenge, yes.
11:13 Speaker 05 Who's saying no? Who's saying no to this? Like, people that are afraid of aliens?
11:19 Speaker 04 It's not no, it's just, you know, apathy.
11:21 Speaker 06 Who gets to, who gets to own Mars?
11:23 Speaker 04 Oh, it has to be global. I mean, NASA, we're saying, here's our plan, here's what we want to lead, we have all of our elements, you know, heavy lift launch, Ryan capsule on top, we get out, and then we're saying, world, come with us.
11:35 Eugene Mirman? Even Estonia?
11:37 Speaker 04 Estonia, yes.
11:39 Eugene Mirman? Sure, sure.
11:40 Speaker 04 Who wants to join? It's global, it's global exploration.
11:43 Speaker 06 Isn't that a risk? Because that's the way colonialism worked before, like, all these different countries were going to a land and claiming it, so won't that just happen again with, like, different companies and different, like...
11:53 Speaker 04 You know, you think, maybe we can get it right this time.
11:55 Speaker 06 Ultimately, the Martians will probably own Mars. Yeah, but we're gonna kill them off, I discussed this earlier.
12:02 Speaker 04 It could be, uh...
12:03 Eugene Mirman? We're gonna become the Martians we're colonizing.
12:06 Speaker 04 It could be really fossilized now.
12:06 Speaker 06 When we go there, we'll be the Martians.
12:08 Speaker 05 Sorry, really quickly, we're talking about Martians in this scientific form. They're real, what's happening?
12:14 Speaker 04 Well, okay, Earth and Mars, 4.5 billion years, sister planets, beautiful, wonderful, and we think, because we have a lot of scientific data, Mars, 3.5 billion years ago, is probably wet, wonderful, maybe a little wild.
12:26 Bill Nye? Back in the day.
12:27 Speaker 04 Back in the day, 3.5 billion...
12:28 Eugene Mirman? Like Costa Rica? Like a little like Costa Rica?
12:32 Speaker 04 Maybe, could, yeah, Costa Rica, and then something, something might have gone terribly wrong. Well, what went terribly wrong?
12:38 Eugene Mirman? Too many parties.
12:39 Speaker 04 Too many parties. We'd like to figure that out, because that tells us a lot, again, about Earth, about spaceship Earth. And so if there's past life, it's probably kind of fossilized and, you know, that's what we're looking for, past life, probably.
12:51 Bill Nye? So a couple things, though, literally, there is a space treaty from 1967.
12:58 Eugene Mirman? Signed by John Lennon.
13:03 Bill Nye? The wording of it is a little bit vague of the space treaty, kind of deliberately, because it talks about going to the moon and other celestial bodies, like people, the Mars was a long way away. Nevertheless, Mars is getting to be within reach, it's getting to be a reasonable thing that people might do. And if we can really do this, I just, my opinion, which as you know is correct, is that it's just not so easy to get to Mars. It's just not, it's not like these guys came.
13:32 Speaker 04 It's hard.
13:33 Bill Nye? They came from Europe, and they went across North America, they came from Europe, they went to South Africa, and they did, they started eating things, and setting up tents and stuff, but on Mars, it's a much more difficult deal.
13:45 David Grinspoon? Well, there's also a big difference, which is that there were people here, uh, when Europeans got here, and they weren't always recognized as people, and that caused a lot of problems. It seems as though there are no people on Mars, so the setup is inherently different.
14:00 Bill Nye? But what about, what about the, uh, protecting, the role, let's say, the objective to protect Martian life if it's found?
14:10 David Grinspoon? Yeah, well, that's one of our big scientific objectives now, of course, is to find out if there is Martian life, so that we don't inadvertently do something really stupid to it.
14:20 Bill Nye? So that, along that line, we're sending robots, right? By robots, we mean spacecraft that land, drive around, cool tires, and, uh, to look for things, but what, how do we know that those things are sterile, those robots have been made clean enough to land there without contaminating the Martian life when we see it?
14:41 Speaker 04 Well, we're work on it, we take it serious, that's, you know, planetary protection. And we think about forward protection, we bring life, we're looking for life on Mars, well, we sure won't, don't want it to be our life, so we do that, and back contamination, so forward contamination, so it has to be, you know, it's a whole area.
14:55 David Grinspoon? There's no, there's no way to know for sure, um, but, but it is taken seriously, we do our best, uh, there are planetary protection protocols, we try to clean our spacecraft, we don't sterilize them 100%, but we, so we know we've brought some microbes to Mars.
15:10 Bill Nye? Well, when you say we don't sterilize them 100%, I will ask the obvious, why not?
15:16 David Grinspoon? Because it's very hard to, in order to sterilize a spacecraft, you would have to cook the whole thing to a point where you would destroy a lot of the scientific instruments.
15:26 Bill Nye? You'd melt the electronics.
15:28 David Grinspoon? So we kind of play this game where we get them clean enough so that we know how many microbes are on there and we land them in places where we don't think those microbes would survive. It's a little bit of a game you have to play. And we don't, so we know there are some microbes on Mars that we've brought there, but we don't believe we've started colonies of Earth organisms on Mars.
15:49 Eugene Mirman? Because I would love to beat everybody there and put a bunch of rabbits on Mars. And then you go like, "Oh my god, there's so many rabbits."
15:58 Speaker 05 What are we looking for as far as Martians? Are we looking for like plants or worms or?
16:04 Speaker 04 Fossilized, it's kind of like thinking about going to the beach and looking at those cool, you know, fossilized shells, kind of like that.
16:09 Speaker 05 Like something like, like a mussel, like a mussel, like a seafood.
16:14 Speaker 04 Harder and flatter and 3.5 billion years old.
16:16 Eugene Mirman? So you're looking for what was there, not what is there?
16:19 Speaker 04 Past life.
16:20 Speaker 05 There's nothing there.
16:21 Speaker 04 What is there, well, what is there, we're finding out every day. We know how Mars lost its atmosphere. Our maven observer just helped us figure that out. And we know there's methane. Mars is breathing, kind of saying hi to us with methane coming out. Think it might be active methane.
16:36 Bill Nye? So when you find-
16:37 Eugene Mirman? Active methane from what?
16:40 Bill Nye? Do, do, do, do, do, do, do, do.
16:42 Speaker 05 Oh my god.
16:43 Eugene Mirman? People lighting matches?
16:45 David Grinspoon? Yeah, we don't know. In fact, in fact, the existence of the methane itself is somewhat controversial, although it's looking better and better. There probably is methane. And of course, a long time ago, before we found the methane, that was one of the things that scientists said would be a biosignature on Mars. If you find methane, then there's gases that are weird gases that shouldn't be in the atmosphere. Just like on Earth, there's oxygen in the atmosphere that comes from life. If you find methane on Mars, we used to say, then that'll be a sign of life. So now we found methane on Mars, but we're not sure it's a sign of life because there's not much of it and it behaves in weird ways. And there are some just chemical geological reactions that can make methane inside the Earth.
17:29 David Grinspoon? Inside a planet. But most of the methane- On Earth's atmosphere does come from bugs, from life.
17:36 Speaker 06 Just to clarify, we're talking about space farts, right?
17:38 Bill Nye? Yes, that's right.
17:40 David Grinspoon? And burps.
17:41 Speaker 04 It could be propulsion, you know, see methane would be great propulsion force, that's why it's a...
17:45 Eugene Mirman? You think if we could use the methane to get back to Earth?
17:48 Speaker 04 There you go, gas station, you know, we gotta have that first gas station on Mars.
17:51 Speaker 05 The first gas station, how cute.
17:54 Bill Nye? Is it gonna have like a mini Mars and stuff? I guess we'd have to set that up, but imagine this, everybody, you land...
18:01 Speaker 04 Run by rabbits.
18:02 Bill Nye? You land the right spacecraft on Mars and you use the chemistry of the rocks and the atmosphere to make rocket fuel...
18:10 Speaker 04 There you go.
18:11 Bill Nye? To fly back. I mean, that is an extraordinary idea and very cool. And we will talk about that coming up in the next segment. You've been watching, you've been listening to StarTalk Radio. We'll be back right after this.
18:46 Bill Nye? Welcome back to StarTalk Live. We're at the Convention Center in Washington DC. And I am joined by this fabulous panel, which includes our beloved Eugene Mirman,
19:01 Bill Nye? Hari Kondabolu, Joe Firestone, David Grinspoon, and Second-in-Command at NASA, David Newman. So...
19:14 Bill Nye? When we left, we were talking about life on Mars, we were talking about what we'd be looking for on Mars. How would we know whether or not we found something alive on Mars? What exactly are we exactly looking for?
19:26 David Grinspoon? Well, it's a puzzle, right? Because we don't know if there's any life beyond Earth.
19:32 Bill Nye? By the way, what is life?
19:34 David Grinspoon? Yeah.
19:35 Bill Nye? Like, wow.
19:36 David Grinspoon? That's the puzzle. How do we define it when we only have one example? You think there's all this biodiversity on Earth, but we know, one thing we've learned for sure, is that it's all related. So there's one example of life on Earth.
19:47 Bill Nye? How do we know it's all related?
19:49 David Grinspoon? Well, chemically, of course, it all uses DNA and proteins. And even better than that, by looking at the sequences of DNA and proteins, you can tell what's related to what. And you can make this tree of life. And we go all the way back, and we do not find any organisms that we're not obviously related to on a biochemical level.
20:10 Bill Nye? Even my old boss?
20:12 David Grinspoon? Yeah. Even snails are your distant cousins. Yeah. You and an escargot are just, you know, a few generations removed. A little garlic away from being the same. Yeah. So we can't really define something that we only have one example of. It's not very scientific. You want a bunch of examples of something to say what it all has in common. And yet, we want to search for life elsewhere, so we have these sort of provisional definitions. We think we know what its signs will be. We think we know what it is. But in order to really know what it is, we have to find it and then be able to compare it.
20:46 Bill Nye? What would you speculate it would be? What would it take?
20:51 Speaker 04 Present life and past life. Right now, on Mars, we really think that it's past life. But we say, when you look for life, the search for life, follow the water. You know, that's kind of rule number one. Follow the water.
21:00 Bill Nye? Why do you say follow the water?
21:02 Speaker 04 Well, because David was saying, you know, we're kind of looking for carbon-based life. That's what we know. Kind of carbon-based life forms, that's how life is on Earth now. There could be something we haven't thought of, but right now, we're saying, go for the water. We have water on Mars. Mars has a carbon dioxide atmosphere. Pretty cool.
21:18 David Grinspoon? Yeah, I mean, when we're talking about Mars, we're following the water.
21:20 Speaker 04 We're gonna make oxygen there.
21:21 David Grinspoon? If we're talking about just life in the universe, looking at exoplanets and such as well... We tend to take a more general view of thinking, well, life, at least we know, is something that perturbs its environment chemically.
21:33 Speaker 04 Sorry, what are, you said exoplanets?
21:35 David Grinspoon? Planets around other stars.
21:37 Speaker 04 You know how many we have?
21:39 David Grinspoon? Which now we know.
21:40 Speaker 04 They're super cool.
21:41 David Grinspoon? Now we know. We didn't know this 20 years ago. This is one of the revolutions of our time, is we, now that we know that all the stars in the sky, almost all of them have planets, multiple planets.
21:50 Bill Nye? So when I was in school, Joe, people speculated that there might be a planet around one in every hundred stars. Now it's generally agreed in sort of orders of magnitude, factors of 10, that every star has at least 10 planets, about 10 planets. And then if you want to get in the argument about Pluto, Sedna, Eris, and these other fairly distant icy worlds, then you're talking about hundreds of planets.
22:16 Speaker 04 Thousands. We just let out, we just categorize and let out 1,200 new exoplanets.
22:22 Bill Nye? But let me just say, just a doggone minute.
22:25 David Grinspoon? So if we're looking for life on those, it would be great if we could detect water, but even if we just see weird chemistry in the atmosphere.
22:31 Eugene Mirman? So Mars has carbon dioxide atmosphere?
22:34 David Grinspoon? Yeah.
22:35 Eugene Mirman? And then we can turn that into oxygen?
22:36 Speaker 04 We're gonna do that on our Mars 2020 rover.
22:39 Eugene Mirman? Nice. Can I have some of that oxygen?
22:42 Bill Nye? You have to go there.
22:43 Speaker 04 Won't be enough for a person, but we're gonna make oxygen on a planet for the first time ever.
22:47 Bill Nye? But hang on, people, hang on, just a minute. Davi, you said, "Well, you know, we're gonna look for life that was once there on Mars. We were back there, you know, back in the old..." Look, we, there's methane on Mars, people.
22:57 Speaker 04 Methane, I know.
22:58 Bill Nye? We have the Mavon, what's that, Mars Atmospheric Volatile Emissions, what's the N? N D.
23:07 Speaker 04 It's Volatile's Environmental.
23:08 Speaker 05 Yeah, I think it's Nancy.
23:09 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, we think it's Nancy.
23:11 Bill Nye? Nancy, and she's fabulous.
23:12 Speaker 05 She's fabulous.
23:14 Bill Nye? But anyway, if they're finding methane, there's gotta be a source of it. I'll give all of you chemists, and I love you all out there, if there's some inorganic chemical process that produces methane, right? But everywhere on Earth we find water, we find living things. Even the tiniest dampness of nothing damp. In Death Valley, there're cyanobacteria that live, right, the green, blue-green things that live under the rocks. Rains once every couple of years, and something's alive there, right?
23:46 Speaker 04 Right.
23:47 Bill Nye? All right, so if we're finding methane on Mars with, what is it, the Trace Grass Orbiter, it's out there, and Mavon...
23:57 Bill Nye? And we're finding liquid water in these recurring slope linie, right? And geologists love, they love the Latin.
24:04 Speaker 04 Seasonal, yeah, exactly, seasonal.
24:04 Bill Nye? So it's a little rivulet, a little rill, a little drip of water every year.
24:09 Speaker 04 And lots of ice on the poles.
24:09 Bill Nye? Hari, I like it. You can't see it on the podcast, people, but he is inquisitive man.
24:14 Speaker 06 Oh, I'm just kind of...
24:14 Bill Nye? He's hanging on this.
24:15 Speaker 06 Like, how much water are we talking about right now?
24:18 Speaker 04 Right now, just a small amount, briny, salty water. You don't want to drink it yet. But the great thing is, we knew there's ice.
24:24 David Grinspoon? Enough to step in?
24:26 Speaker 04 But now this is...
24:26 David Grinspoon? Almost none on the surface.
24:28 Speaker 04 Yeah, and this is seasonal. So, you know, it's seasonal, but, you know, it's seasonal.
24:32 Bill Nye? Every Martian summer, there's a little waterfall.
24:35 Speaker 04 It's cool, it's fantastic. I'm with you, Bill. I am with you.
24:38 Speaker 05 Wait, are you making... Are you making... That's true. You didn't... That's not a thing you just lied about?
24:43 Bill Nye? No, no, not about that, no.
24:46 Speaker 05 It's true. It's a Martian waterfall.
24:49 Bill Nye? Well, or rivulet.
24:51 Speaker 04 Rivulet, I like rivulet, it's better.
24:52 David Grinspoon? But there's a lot of water underground.
24:54 Speaker 04 Yeah.
24:54 David Grinspoon? We believe, we know, actually.
24:56 Bill Nye? So, you guys, I am open-minded, of course. But you're telling me that we've got liquid water on Mars? And we have methane that we detect, albeit in strange ways, from billions of kilometers away with these extraordinary spacecraft, all right? And you are not optimistically optimistic about finding something still alive?
25:17 Speaker 04 I am completely optimistic, and I think it's going to be sooner than later.
25:19 David Grinspoon? I'm not. I don't think there's life on Mars today.
25:22 Speaker 06 By life, do we mean something...
25:23 David Grinspoon? And I think, actually, that's a good thing. I'm optimistic that there's no life on Mars today. Because that makes it much less complicated for us to do the things we were talking about earlier and not be wiping out biosphere.
25:33 Bill Nye? Okay, just a minute, European immigrant man.
25:36 David Grinspoon? Yes.
25:39 Bill Nye? It sounds like you might be saying, "Well, I'm pretty sure there's nothing alive there. We're not going to contaminate it. Let's just show up."
25:45 David Grinspoon? No, because I very much support our carefully investigating this question. I think that right now, our ignorance vastly outweighs our knowledge. But I am a skeptic as far as the methane we've seen and the water we've seen indicating a biosphere.
26:00 Bill Nye? Why are you skeptical of that?
26:02 David Grinspoon? Because I think that on a planet like Earth... You look at, if you were a-
26:07 Bill Nye? Showed here.
26:09 David Grinspoon? For instance, this room. If you were an alien looking at our solar system from afar, there'd be this planet Earth that has flagrant biosignatures. This oxygen is off the charts.
26:20 Bill Nye? Flagrant! You people are flagrantly signing your biomiss.
26:24 David Grinspoon? I don't think a planet like Mars that has very subtle potential biosignatures will ever be alive. Because on a planet like Earth, the biosphere is coupled to the active biogeochemical cycles.
26:36 Bill Nye? Those of you watching the podcast, his arms are just like waves.
26:39 David Grinspoon? I'm waving my arms.
26:40 Bill Nye? There's making-
26:41 David Grinspoon? Because Earth has-
26:41 Bill Nye? Snow angels in the sky.
26:42 David Grinspoon? Earth has this active hydrological cycle with rainfall and evaporation. It has plate tectonics, the geology is alive, the chemistry of the interior is in communication with the atmosphere.
26:55 Speaker 04 He's still waving his arms.
26:56 David Grinspoon? I'm waving my arms.
26:57 Eugene Mirman? We can always now become modern dance.
27:01 David Grinspoon? On Earth, life-
27:04 Bill Nye? He's out of his chair to get to arms.
27:06 Eugene Mirman? Do you think there's like microbes in the water and like-
27:10 Bill Nye? That's what I think.
27:11 Eugene Mirman? I guess that there aren't like squalls.
27:12 David Grinspoon? What I'm saying is that on Earth, life rides the cycles of an active geological planet. Mars, in that sense, is a pretty dead planet. I think, as David was saying, we will probably find signs of life in the past when Mars was a less dead planet. But if I had to bet, I would bet that Mars does not have life today.
27:31 Bill Nye? So, speaking of betting, they won't take the bet now.
27:37 Eugene Mirman? I'll bet a dollar and we'll figure it out in what, 2032?
27:40 Bill Nye? I say I would go with 2033.
27:42 Eugene Mirman? Okay, 2033 it is.
27:43 Speaker 04 And we'll be there, we'll be there.
27:44 Eugene Mirman? When do you think we'll be on Mars? You're the most qualified.
27:47 Speaker 04 Well, we are on Mars today with five vehicles in orbit and surface.
27:49 Eugene Mirman? Sorry, it was like a group of kids playing soccer.
27:52 Speaker 04 Group of kids, kids playing Mars generation, the 2030s.
27:55 Bill Nye? So let's back up to the disco era.
27:59 Speaker 05 My favorite time!
28:01 Bill Nye? Yeah, good. You're in the right place. So the Viking landers had these scoops. This was in 1976, July 4th, coincidence, 200th anniversary of the United States. Viking one lands there, has a scoop akin to an ice cream shovel, and scrapes into the soil and stuff. Then it drops some of that soil into some chemistry experiments that were spacecraft style. You can't see them from here, but the scoops dropped the dust in there and something happened, right? And people, for a couple of days, for those of you who were not around in the disco era, there were a few days or even weeks when people around the world like totally freaked
28:45 Bill Nye? because it seemed like something was bubbling on Mars that might be alive, right? Now, can you comment on that thing?
28:50 David Grinspoon? Yeah, well, so this gets back to this vexing question of how do we look for life when we really don't know anything about life elsewhere? And the Viking biological experiments were a wonderful set of investigations, but in hindsight, they were maybe a little bit naive in that what we were really...
29:07 Bill Nye? What did they really do, really?
29:08 David Grinspoon? They were looking for life on Mars that was very much like life on Earth. Essentially, they scooped up stuff, like you said, and they sprinkled it with what they called chicken soup, which was water and nutrients.
29:19 Bill Nye? So right now, it's like rocks, scissors, papers, his fist has gone into his hand.
29:22 David Grinspoon? Yes. They sprinkled up stuff, they put it in this experimental apparatus, and basically they sprinkled it with water and what the scientists nicknamed chicken soup, which was a set of nutrients which Earth organisms would have loved, simple organic compounds, and they looked to see if anything happened. And did it give off gases where the carbon...
29:44 Bill Nye? Which it would if you put a scoop of Earth soil.
29:47 David Grinspoon? Yeah, and they even labeled the carbon with radioactive carbon, heavy isotopic, isotopically heavy carbon, so you can see if the carbon in the chicken soup...
29:56 Bill Nye? You can see if you have the right instrument.
29:58 David Grinspoon? Yeah. With that instrument, you could tell that the carbon in the chicken soup was the same carbon that came out. It was as if this stuff was breathing out carbon dioxide. So they said, "Aha, there's something in there that's eating chicken soup and breathing out carbon dioxide. It's alive!" But then, it didn't really behave like living organisms. There was a big fizz of this carbon dioxide, and then it went... It tailed off as if it was more of a chemical reaction.
30:24 Bill Nye? For those of you listening, his hand went way up like he was gonna do a hook shot. And then it came down like he was gonna, like he was gonna...
30:35 David Grinspoon? An exponential decline.
30:37 Bill Nye? The exponential decline.
30:38 Speaker 05 I feel like it would help the listeners if you just picture one of those things outside car washes.
30:42 David Grinspoon? Yeah.
30:42 Speaker 05 You know, like every time, I feel like that's a great visual.
30:45 Bill Nye? Oh, the inflatable guy that walks around.
30:48 Speaker 05 Yeah.
30:49 Bill Nye? There you go.
30:51 David Grinspoon? It first looked like it was behaving like life. It breathed all this stuff out. And then it looked more like, like Pop Rocks or something where something fizzes, or Mentos and Pepsi, where something fizzes all of a sudden and then just dies off. If it was organisms, it would sort of perpetuate longer. So it ultimately had a shape over time where it acted like some chemical in there was really excited to react with the stuff we gave it.
31:17 Eugene Mirman? We brought Pop Rocks to Mars and Pop Rocks were like, "We're Pop Rocks."
31:20 David Grinspoon? Exactly.
31:21 Eugene Mirman? But they didn't find life.
31:22 David Grinspoon? So it fizzed, but it didn't really metabolize, unfortunately.
31:26 Bill Nye? That's the way we would understand it.
31:28 David Grinspoon? Now, one should say there are still some holdouts. There's this guy named Gil Levin who was one of the original investigators on this. He's still alive and he's a smart guy. And he thinks that they found life on Mars with this experiment. And he refuses to be convinced otherwise. And he's a smart guy and there's still a little controversy about this is an indication of the fact that we don't completely know what we're doing when we're looking for life, which is kind of what's exciting about this. We're on the edge of our knowledge and we're trying to investigate something that we can't completely grasp.
31:59 Bill Nye? So Mars is crazy cold.
32:01 Speaker 05 Yeah.
32:02 Bill Nye? Venus is crazy hot.
32:04 Speaker 05 We're the classic Goldilocks.
32:06 Bill Nye? Exactly, that's the word we use. We are the Goldilocks planet. You've convergence of a great scientific mind, right here, way to go.
32:14 Speaker 05 We got the porridge that's the right temperature to eat.
32:17 Bill Nye? That's what we've got.
32:18 Eugene Mirman? Earth is the right temperature to eat, gobble, gobble.
32:20 Bill Nye? It is, no, it really is.
32:22 Speaker 05 Beautiful planet.
32:23 Eugene Mirman? Don't tell Galactus.
32:26 Speaker 05 But isn't there, okay, listen, I'm just, my mind is sort of
32:30 Bill Nye? This is good, this is good.
32:31 Speaker 05 Exo, exo, exo
32:33 Bill Nye? Planet?
32:33 Speaker 04 Exoplanets, yeah.
32:34 Speaker 05 It does seem like exo gossip girl. Okay, but listen, so exoplanets, there must be around those stars, a planet that's equidistant from
32:45 Bill Nye? Do, do, do, do, do, do, do, do, do.
32:47 Speaker 05 To Earth, what's happening?
32:48 Bill Nye? I know, so that's it, so we have an instrument, and the James Webb Space Telescope's coming up, Kepler's out there now, but this telescope is gonna look with such sensitivity, how sensitive will it be, that people believe they'll be able to look through the atmosphere of a planet backlit by its star. Are you digging me? Sunlight from a star is gonna go through this planet's atmosphere, and this telescope out in space will be able to detect what gases are in that atmosphere, and what everybody's all hot for is water vapor and methane, the natural gas, the stuff in the blue flame of your stove.
33:29 David Grinspoon? And oxygen.
33:30 Bill Nye? And oxygen, this would be like so cool. And so, this, my claim, everybody, is these discoveries, if we were able to discover life on Mars, on Europa, the moon of Jupiter, with twice as much seawater as the Earth, at least.
33:45 Eugene Mirman? Twice as much seawater as what?
33:46 Bill Nye? As the Earth.
33:47 Speaker 04 All of Earth.
33:48 Eugene Mirman? Oh, really?
33:49 Bill Nye? And maybe even a little more than twice as much.
33:50 Speaker 04 Europa has filled the ocean world, great place to go look for
33:51 Eugene Mirman? Oh wow, does Kevin Costner know? He'd love it!
33:56 David Grinspoon? Don't tell him.
33:58 Bill Nye? So, so anyway, what we wanna do, my claim is if we were to find life, if we were to find life on one of these places, it would change this world. So, let's say we were gonna go do this. David, at DrFunkySpoon, man.
34:17 Eugene Mirman? Sir.
34:18 Bill Nye? What is your dream scenario, finding life on Mars? How would you go about doing it?
34:23 Eugene Mirman? Well, I think that
34:26 David Grinspoon? We're going about it the right way. I would love to accelerate. If my dream scenario would be, you know, we double or triple the NASA budget for exploration and could do more. I think we know what to do. Um, thank you.
34:38 Bill Nye? By the way, let me just say-
34:40 Speaker 05 More sandwiches. Who wants more sandwiches?
34:42 Bill Nye? Yes. But let me, let me just say, as CEO of the Planetary Society, I spend a lot of time on this stuff, and we've gotten the planetary science budget now up to about 1.7 billion, which I know doesn't sound like much.
34:59 Bill Nye? But everybody, the NASA budget is about 0.4% of the federal budget.
35:05 Eugene Mirman? 0.4, right. How do we get it to say 2%?
35:09 Bill Nye? Well, so, in the Apollo days, it was 10 times that. It was 4% of the federal budget. And so, the planetary science line item within the NASA budget is less than 10% of the NASA budget. 9 and plus percent.
35:25 Eugene Mirman? We do a lot.
35:25 Bill Nye? And so, these were the extraordinary discoveries are made. So, your dream scenario starts with getting more money.
35:33 David Grinspoon? Yeah.
35:34 Bill Nye? And then where do we go from there?
35:35 David Grinspoon? My dream scenario for Mars, specifically, is, as I said, I think we're going to confirm that there's no life on Mars today. Um, but I want to be really sure before we go into other things there. So, we gotta check out this methane, figure out where it's coming from. If it's not life, it's telling us something really interesting about the geochemistry of Mars that we need to know. But my dream scenario for Mars, as, as David mentioned, the possibility of finding fossils. There should have been life on early Mars, given what we know. We'll either find fossil signs of life on Mars, or if we study Mars really carefully and understand those early environments, and find that there was no life ever on Mars, that is also a really exciting thing to find. It tells us something about Earth, that there's something special we don't understand.
36:20 Bill Nye? Everything we learn about stuff in outer space informs, uh, what we know about the Earth. And I claim that the more we know about our solar system and other solar systems with other stars and exoplanets, Joe-
36:33 Speaker 05 Exoplanets.
36:35 Bill Nye? The more it informs, uh, ourselves and, uh, and where we all came from. This is the two deep questions. Are we alone in the universe? Just here's a big question, though. What would we do with life if we found it? And we're gonna talk about that when Star Talk Live comes back, right after this.
37:07 Bill Nye? We'd like to give a Patreon shout out to the following Patreon patrons, Justin Adamson and Forrest Shepard. Thank you guys for your support because without you it'd be very difficult to do what we do. And if anyone else would like their very own Patreon shout out, make sure that you go to patreon.com/stargtloradio and support us.
37:39 Bill Nye? Welcome back to StarTalk Live here in Washington DC. I'm here on the fabulous panel with Joe Firestone, Dr. David Newman, Hari Kumbaloo, and our beloved Eugene Merman. So, we're having nothing but fun here on StarTalk this week. We're talking about life on other worlds. We're talking about space science superheroes. And this segued into this search for life. And now we're talking about how we exactly would actually exactly go looking for life. We have some assets there on Mars right now, right? We have the Curiosity Rover.
38:23 Bill Nye? We have some, a lot of assets in orbit around Mars. And the idea, let me just, let me just start by going back to begin, to start with. Why are we all so hot to look for life on Mars? Why not life on Mercury? Or Venus?
38:42 Speaker 04 Close by Mars is the best place to look for life. And then we get further out into the solar system and then we go to these ocean worlds, which even look, you know, better. But again, Earth and Mars really are sister planets.
38:54 Bill Nye? And it looks like Mars was wet.
38:57 David Grinspoon? It's the most Earth-like environment on the surface of another planet that we know of. And we have a lot of evidence that in the past it was much more Earth-like. Do we have a sense of why it's so sad there now?
39:11 Bill Nye? Yes. It doesn't, it's not big, as big as the Earth. So it cooled off faster. So it's, uh, does not have the churning iron in the middle that we have on Earth, creating a magnetic field, which makes the solar wind particles, uh, go downhill when they get to the north and south pole. But on Mars, apparently, uh, these same particles scrape the atmosphere off, scraped it into space.
39:39 Speaker 04 So it lost its atmosphere, it ablated. We can see it, it's still going on today. Our Maven spacecraft is in orbit. Check out, you know, the, we can see the ions ablating. It's only 1% atmosphere. Mars has a 1% compared to Earth, 100% here, has 1% in its carbon dioxide. So we see it's not protected by that magnetic shield.
40:00 Eugene Mirman? Is there any way to put an atmosphere back on?
40:02 Bill Nye? So hang on, so hang on, how are we gonna get there, you guys? We just had a humans orbiting Mars workshop. Uh, the Planetary Society pitched a humans orbiting Mars, uh, architecture as it's called. And along with all the many things NASA was gonna do was develop these solar electric propulsion spacecraft. And how does that work? And the solar electric was gonna go out to an asteroid, asteroid redirect retrieval mission, right? How does solar electric propulsion work and how is it part of going to Mars?
40:37 Speaker 04 Right, so, uh, when we go to deep space, back Earth, Moon, cis lunar, right? That's the next step, that's phase two. First on space station, low Earth orbit. 2020's will be on our space launch system, that's our heavy lift launch.
40:50 Bill Nye? Space launch system is a massive word for big rocket.
40:53 Speaker 04 Big rocket, big rocket. We haven't had one like this for 40 years. Moveover Saturn V, it's more powerful.
40:59 Bill Nye? More powerful than a Saturn V.
41:02 Speaker 05 And these rockets, these are made of your standard metals, your tins, your, your...
41:07 Speaker 03 That's a great question, Joe.
41:08 Speaker 04 Yeah, using, using aluminums, using additive manufacturing though, to make it, it's much more efficient, so we're using, you know, high-tech, but big rockets.
41:16 Speaker 05 But we're basically using Home Depot stuff, you know, we're using the screws and the...
41:20 Bill Nye? Yes, yeah, nice stuff.
41:22 Speaker 04 Yeah, nice, nice, high-end, high-end.
41:24 Bill Nye? Yeah, yeah, you gotta go to the aisle way at the end.
41:26 Eugene Mirman? Imagine the fanciest Home Depot you can and double it.
41:29 Speaker 04 And then we get out to Cisneros, so now we're in deep space, okay? We're in deep space, not quite yet to Mars, yeah, that's phase three. But in phase two, we're into deep space and we have to demonstrate some technologies. Because you don't just get to Mars in one leap.
41:41 Bill Nye? No, but here, let me just tie this in.
41:43 Speaker 04 Space electric propulsion, you want to know, in-space propulsion.
41:45 Bill Nye? But here's the thing, as Joe just said, Home Depot-style rockets, chemical rockets. It's what yours, you know what I mean, Joe? You got a liquid oxygen, you got some other fuel, you mix them with a fuse, and they burn like crazy, and they make that cool noise, and then they go into space.
42:01 Speaker 04 The shhh.
42:02 Bill Nye? Shhh, but it's usually woo.
42:04 Speaker 04 Oh, right.
42:04 Bill Nye? Yeah, yeah.
42:05 Eugene Mirman? And then, and then what happens after that?
42:07 Bill Nye? Then you're in space and there's some reason you don't want to use chemical rockets anymore, and that is?
42:14 Speaker 04 Well, we need, we need breakthrough technologies, we need new technologies. So what we're investing in now, now we're getting to the moon, right? So you're deep space. Our top technologies we're investing in today is in-space propulsion.
42:27 Bill Nye? It's hard to carry all that much fuel, right?
42:29 Speaker 04 It's hard to carry cargo and fuel.
42:31 Eugene Mirman? So what is in-space propulsion?
42:32 Speaker 04 In-space propulsion, so there's different ones, but so we're talking about solar electric propulsion. That can move, move big cargo, lots of mass, heavy mass, goes slowly, but that's all right. We'll get there, so it moves a lot of cargo, you know? You're going on a camping trip.
42:48 Bill Nye? We're rockets in space.
42:50 Speaker 04 Yeah, we're 17,000, yeah, we're more than 17,500, you know, miles per hour, but still slow for space, you know, so for, so for space.
42:56 Eugene Mirman? Oh, wait, so how fast is faster space for us?
42:58 Speaker 04 Well, you know, light, light speed is fast, right?
43:00 Eugene Mirman? Yes, sorry, but meaning...
43:02 Bill Nye? Joe, Joe.
43:03 Eugene Mirman? When you say slow, you mean as fast as we can bake, not like we're...
43:07 Speaker 04 Slower, let's say, you know, a little bit, you know, a little slower, because you want to get your people there as quickly as possible. So big rocket, let's go fast, about eight months, you know? That's, that's, that's fast for us.
43:17 Bill Nye? Punch it, punch it.
43:18 Speaker 04 Punch it, eight-month trip, because we got to get boots on Mars. We'll get in orbit, but this in-space propulsion, solar electric, that's a nice candidate. Constant acceleration, so ch-ch-ch-ch, just keep going all the way.
43:29 Eugene Mirman? You get faster and faster as it goes.
43:30 Speaker 04 You know, you know, carry this stuff you need with us. We're, we always bring a lot of stuff.
43:35 Eugene Mirman? Does it arrive later, after the people, or before?
43:38 Speaker 04 Well, we'd be popping them off, right?
43:40 Bill Nye? So what we want to do... All we want to do is have stuff in place before a human show up. You want to land some tents.
43:47 Speaker 04 And fuel, fuel depots, we said, habitats, so that's what we're investing in.
43:51 Bill Nye? I just want to talk for a second about the rocket equation, who doesn't?
43:54 Speaker 04 Oh, I love the rocket.
43:55 Bill Nye? Yeah, so the, the big thing that makes a rocket go, and you've seen this, Joe, is the stuff coming out the back is going really fast.
44:02 Speaker 05 The classic, the classic orange in the child's drawing.
44:06 Bill Nye? Yes.
44:06 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, afterburners, yeah, that's it.
44:08 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah.
44:09 Speaker 04 The orange.
44:10 Bill Nye? So it's going really fast out the back. But, uh, it takes, you need a lot of fuel and you reach a point where you can't get the rocket going too much faster because you can't get the exhaust going that much faster.
44:23 Speaker 04 That's called specific impulse, so that's what we call it in the rocket equation.
44:27 Bill Nye? So in solar electric propulsion, we're going to take a big tank of xenon, is that right?
44:32 Speaker 04 Xenon is good.
44:33 Bill Nye? Yeah, so anyway, you get a, a tank of this stuff liquefied and you, you get it by getting the atmosphere, getting a big tank of air on Earth cold and the xenon separates out in a layer like a parfait and then they extract it, put it in a tank and then they put it on this rocket.
44:52 Speaker 05 Sounds delicious.
44:53 Bill Nye? So, yeah, it's good, it's nothing better. Well, you breathe it all the time in tiny amounts and look, I've been doing it my whole life and I'm fine. No, so then you have solar panels, is this right, David?
45:03 Speaker 04 So far, so good. They need electricity, power.
45:05 Bill Nye? Then we have a window screen looking thing and it electrically attracts the xenon from its little tank and shoots it out the back at super fast speeds, right? And that's really an ion drive, like in science fiction. But anyway, the solar electric propulsion idea is going to be used to go to Mars, right? Now, what are we going to do with that?
45:27 Speaker 04 Absolutely, we're counting on it. Solar electric propulsion, we're counting on that. Let me tell you a few other ones we're investing in right now. Deep space habitats, incredible, you know, public, private, again, industries working with us, deep space habs.
45:38 Bill Nye? So what goes on in the deep space habs?
45:41 Speaker 04 We're sending people, we got to figure out. Life support systems, you got to figure out to get, you know, we're going way beyond low Earth orbit, so we need deep space habs. Beam, Bigelow's beam, just, it just inflated, expanded this week on Space Station.
45:52 Bill Nye? Beam is an acronym.
45:53 Speaker 04 Yeah, for the Bigelow Expandable Module on Space Station.
45:58 Speaker 04 Expandable habitat.
46:00 Bill Nye? It's a big inflatable thing, attached to international space. You got me doing it with the hands.
46:04 Speaker 04 But not too big. I mean, space station is big, a football field size, right? These are smaller halves. We need to test them out. Now, number one, radiation. What about radiation protection?
46:13 Bill Nye? What about radiation? Years ago, people said if you tried to go from the Earth to Mars, the radiation would kill you. But now people have rethought that.
46:22 David Grinspoon? It is a problem. The radiation is one of the serious physical problems with sending people to Mars. And we know a lot more about this now because of the Mars Science Laboratory, which is our Curiosity rover, which is on Mars now doing wonderful things. But on the trip to Mars, this instrument called RAD, the Radiation Assessment Detector.
46:44 Bill Nye? Radiation Assessment Detector.
46:45 David Grinspoon? Yeah, and I'm actually a co-investigator on that instrument, so it's near and dear to my heart. I'm a co-I on the RAD team. And one of the things that was cool we were able to do with RAD, it was designed to measure the level of high-energy radiation on the surface of Mars on the rover, which it's doing in a wonderful way. But we realized that we could also turn it on before we got to Mars. It's the one instrument on the rover that we turned on while it was still in the spacecraft on the trip to Mars, because it allowed us to measure the amount of radiation in interplanetary space and basically simulate what a human would experience in terms of radiation on the way to Mars. And so it's the first time we ever did that, and now we really know much more than we did before this mission.
47:30 Bill Nye? Will it kill you or not?
47:31 David Grinspoon? It will not kill you, but it will put you at greater risk of getting cancer, which could ultimately kill you. But it's not like just going to Mars is gonna fry you and you'll be dead when you get there. But it is, it will by a few percentage points. You'll die when you get back to Earth. Well, it's equivalent to, you know, you go to the doctor and you get like a CAT scan. Yeah. So, and that, you know, if you do that... It feels like getting an eight-month CAT scan. If you do that a lot, you're slightly increasing your chances, so you don't want to do that all the time.
48:04 Bill Nye? Chances of getting cancer.
48:05 Speaker 04 So your life, yeah, for radiation.
48:06 David Grinspoon? It's as if you did that once a week.
48:08 Speaker 04 And we look at total life dose, total life radiation dose, and we're gonna protect the astronauts. That's what we're mapping. We're taking this data, now we're looking at the Mars radiation environment, and then it's our job, how can we protect the people? How can we protect the spacecraft? Don't wanna fry your instruments either. So, we protect the people, and we have some interesting ways to do that.
48:28 Bill Nye? The kind of people that wanna be astronauts, if you say, "Well, you got an extra 1% chance of getting ca-" I'm in, I'm going, man.
48:35 Eugene Mirman? But you still wanna protect them. So, what are some of the ways that we...
48:39 Speaker 05 Like, is it similar to like, when you go to the dentist and they take pictures of your mouth, they put the thing over your...
48:44 Speaker 04 There you go. That's shielding. So, high density is very good for shielding, especially for, you know, galactic cosmic radiation that we're gonna see on Mars.
48:54 Eugene Mirman? Created the Fantastic Four, for instance.
48:56 Speaker 04 But we're in this, there you go, superheroes. So, but in the craft, water, because we like water to drink, it's pretty high density.
49:05 Bill Nye? Yes, I'm a big fan.
49:06 Speaker 04 Yeah, it's a pretty good radiation shield. So, there's interesting concepts in the vehicle, high-density materials. We're gonna take water anyhow. It'd be nice to kinda live in the water walls. That'll really help the astronauts.
49:16 Eugene Mirman? And does it harm the water for it to be radiated for you to drink it?
49:18 Speaker 04 No, the water doesn't care at all.
49:20 Speaker 05 Water doesn't care?
49:21 Eugene Mirman? Meaning, the water doesn't care, but when you drink it, it doesn't matter to you?
49:24 David Grinspoon? No, no, no.
49:24 Speaker 04 You're okay. Most of it passes right through.
49:26 David Grinspoon? If anything, if there were any little bugs in the water that you didn't want there to be, it would, you know, make it nice and clean.
49:32 Bill Nye? So, you have a jacket, you'd have a ball, a sphere, a shell of water around your spacecraft.
49:38 Eugene Mirman? Like a water bed.
49:39 Speaker 04 A water bed.
49:40 Eugene Mirman? Like a water bed to space.
49:41 Speaker 05 It's a good concept. Great MTV Cribs.
49:43 Speaker 04 When we get to Mars, you know, don't wanna put it in the suit, because you wanna be mobile, lightweight, but, you know, lava tubes, and there's lava, you know, volcanoes, so where are we gonna hide, where are we gonna live? Yeah, underground caves, things like that. These are all actually amazing shields.
49:57 Bill Nye? So, hang on.
49:58 Speaker 06 Is there space underwear? Has that been discussed? Like, what are the sexual side effects of radiation and the... I'm just getting to the question, I'm sure you were all considering from the get-go. Like, what happens, you know, like, is there extra protection in those areas?
50:15 Speaker 05 How is that Kelly's long-term, long-distance relationship?
50:18 Speaker 06 I'm sure he asked that question. There's no way he wasn't asking that question.
50:21 David Grinspoon? I think, I think if you're going to have children...
50:25 Eugene Mirman? Do it before you go to Mars?
50:27 David Grinspoon? Or at least put some in the freezer. You know what I'm saying?
50:32 Bill Nye? No, that's a good idea.
50:33 Speaker 06 Have one before and then have one after and see if the second one's a mutant.
50:37 Bill Nye? Oh.
50:39 Speaker 06 That's the scientific approach.
50:41 Bill Nye? I think here at Awesome Con, let me rephrase that, a friendly amendment. If the second one has superpowers. Because that's what you get. You know, if you're a superhero, a lot of times you were irradiated. Maybe you were bitten by a radioactive spider.
50:56 Eugene Mirman? So maybe what's been irradiated is just your father's ding dong.
51:01 Speaker 06 I like how you used the scientific term for penis.
51:04 Eugene Mirman? I'm a gentleman.
51:06 Bill Nye? So, just as far as I know, ding dong is not an acronym. It's a...
51:11 Eugene Mirman? No, it's just the thing it is.
51:15 David Grinspoon? You know, when you say ding dong, I'm looking over at the interpreter here and just wondering what... But anyways.
51:22 Eugene Mirman? Yeah. Or if you're a lady, you're doodle.
51:27 Bill Nye? Let her...
51:27 Eugene Mirman? That was so worth it.
51:29 Bill Nye? That was good. That was good. She explained.
51:34 Bill Nye? Where were we? Where were we? I think we were going to Mars. We're on our way to Mars. We're on our way to Mars. Now, you mentioned the radiation detection instrument. What other instruments would you take? Why would you take them? And then fundamentally, everybody, everybody. Would you go to Mars if you had a chance to go to Mars? What instruments would you take?
51:54 David Grinspoon? If I was going to Mars?
51:55 Bill Nye? Yeah. Or what are you gonna send? What are you gonna do?
51:57 David Grinspoon? I want to... The thing that I most want to do if I were gonna go to Mars is look for fossils.
52:03 Bill Nye? Fossil life. These would be bacteria in a mat.
52:06 David Grinspoon? I would take rock hammers and drills and a microscope. A scanning electronic microscope if I can get away with making one small enough and...
52:15 Bill Nye? To carry there. Because right now, scanning electron microscopes are big, uh...
52:19 David Grinspoon? Yeah, but they're... But one thing that NASA's really good at is making things small when we need to and put a little technology development into it. I would want, on my Mars laboratory with my astronauts there, I would want to be able to go out and drill and find samples in the most promising sites. And I want to look for the isotopes. So I'd want a really good mass spectrometer to look for isotopic signs of life, for signs that life had altered the chemicals in the past. And I would really want to look actually for physical fossils and the right kinds of deposits.
52:54 Bill Nye? So, let me say, I, uh... My father was a rockhound, liked the rocks. Every rock tells a story. My uncle was a geologist. And the way you're describing this to me, Dave, David, is, um, geology tools.
53:09 David Grinspoon? Yes.
53:10 Bill Nye? But what non-geologic instruments would you take?
53:15 Speaker 04 Oh, I thought so. Well, first, we're taking the people. That's what I'm about. We're taking the people and our rovers and machines, because that's how we work better. We will explore tens, a hundred times more of Mars if we get there and we're mobile and we're working in teams, people.
53:29 Bill Nye? I've heard this said that, uh, what our best rovers do in a week, a human would do in less than five minutes, maybe even less than a minute.
53:36 Speaker 04 So it's order of magnitude. We're much more, you know, mobile and quicker, so we're all in this together. And, uh, what are their instruments?
53:43 Bill Nye? Our robots and our people.
53:44 Speaker 04 Our robots and people. We're, yeah.
53:46 Bill Nye? Well, what instruments would you take?
53:47 Speaker 04 What are their instruments? Well, actually, back to life support systems and bioregenitives. I actually would, uh, make sure I could, uh, make oxygen, bring it, you know, make oxygen.
53:57 Bill Nye? Yeah, you want to start on that.
53:58 Speaker 04 And water, you know, things like that. There's not enough there for us yet, so I'm kind of worried about staying alive. So I'd like some water, like some oxygen to breathe.
54:05 Bill Nye? Well, let's say you got that problem solved.
54:07 Speaker 04 Grow some plants.
54:07 David Grinspoon? Bill, you know, it's funny the way you phrase the question, non-geological instruments, because the word geological has geo, which means Earth. So any of these instruments on Mars are areological, right? They're, uh, which Ares is Mars and anyways.
54:23 Speaker 04 I was gonna say that as well.
54:24 David Grinspoon? Okay. So if we wanna, if we wanna understand the ancient story of Mars, then we're gonna apply a lot of the same tools we used to understand the ancient rocks and the ancient story of Earth. So, so we look at ancient sediments, because they're what capture the atmosphere too, the bubbles, the bubbles of air.
54:42 Bill Nye? Okay, okay. But hang on a second. The Viking missions had some chemistry thing that everybody got excited about, right? That was wrong, though, right? Well, one guy says, maybe not so wrong. Okay. So, but that was a biology experiment. That was, uh, the spiritual equivalent of a, of a Petri dish.
55:01 David Grinspoon? Sure.
55:01 Bill Nye? Right? So what is the spiritual equivalent of a, let's say, uh, Mark Watney has it all figured out. He can breathe and, uh, grow potatoes and whatever he's gonna do to take care of himself. How is he gonna find, or she gonna find, evidence of life on Mars? What instruments do we need?
55:19 Speaker 04 Okay, do the instruments, but let me tell you, I wanted to say, you know, who are the people? Because you asked about, is it the astrobiologists? I hope not, I hope it's not a single discipline of anyone. Because we need, you know, a whole new education. So, this is, you know, the point you need, know a little astrobiology, right? You want to know your geology? Hmm, you know, I'm thinking an M.D. might be, you know? A little medical knowledge. So, we really need cross-disciplinary trained folks. So, I hope it's not just an astrobiologist.
55:44 David Grinspoon? But what you just described is astrobiology. Because astrobiology is a sort of poly-discipline. If you go to an astrobiology meeting, there's people talking about geology, people talking about astronomy, chemistry, glaciology, philosophy.
55:57 Eugene Mirman? But not botany, so you do need a few different people.
56:00 David Grinspoon? Well, that too.
56:02 Speaker 04 A few different people, but I'm all about steamed. I'm all about steamed.
56:04 David Grinspoon? I mean, I agree with what you're saying, obviously.
56:06 Speaker 04 We need the STEM fields, but the artists have to be there, the designers, we're all in, we need everyone. Also psychics. Psychics. Comedians, you're gonna need some laughs. We are gonna, this is a psycho, you know, psychosocial, this is a tough trip.
56:19 David Grinspoon? But if we really think we're looking for extant life, then we want to bring, you know, Petri dishes, and we want to try to culture stuff.
56:26 Bill Nye? That's what I'm saying.
56:27 David Grinspoon? Now, what are you gonna use for your agar in your Petri dish? You don't know what Martian bugs like, so you gotta get very clever there. And that's why I'm drawn more towards microscopes and things where you don't necessarily assume too much about what that stuff is doing chemically. You just want to see, if, you figure if there's a bug, you're gonna recognize it.
56:44 Bill Nye? The geologists all want to bring back samples. They're crazy for it. And if you take a geology course, you got a rock hammer, you go to the rocks and you knock them open, and you bring them back to your dorm room, and your friends think you're having issues. And, uh, they want to bring back a sample, it'll be three steps, 2020 rover drills in the soil, picks them up, 2022, flies them up into Martian orbit, then 2024 or 2025, brings them back to the International Space Station, and we open them up and take a meeting, right?
57:16 Speaker 04 Take a meeting.
57:17 Bill Nye? But is there any concern that we're gonna bring back the Martian microbes of death?
57:23 Bill Nye? What are you gonna do about that?
57:24 David Grinspoon? There's a slight concern. But I would say very, very slight.
57:28 Bill Nye? Very slight. Is it worth the risk, Mr. Bond?
57:33 David Grinspoon? Yes, because, here's the thing. You can't explore with zero risk. If we wanted to be perfectly safe, we would not, never bring back a rock from Mars. If you wanted to be perfectly safe, you would never leave the house in the morning, right? So, anything interesting involves a certain amount of risk. But, we're not gonna-
57:51 Speaker 05 Like befriending scorpions.
57:53 David Grinspoon? Yeah, exactly. There could be nasty things, but, but, this is why we're doing the precursor missions, and, this is also why we have protocols. If we do bring back a sample of Mars, there are requirements to keep it very carefully isolated, and-
58:09 Bill Nye? In like, Area 51?
58:11 David Grinspoon? Even, this is like, Area 52, man, you haven't even heard of it. It's really secure.
58:17 Bill Nye? So, you guys, I just wanna thank you all. This has really been a cool discussion. Everybody had these terrific insights, asking these fundamental questions about the nature of life on another world. How would we find it? What would it be like? How would it affect us? How are we gonna get there? Even, how are we gonna pay for it? We talked about all of this. This has been like, the greatest StarTalk Live ever! Give everybody a hand, this has been a great panel. Joe, David, Deva, Hari, and Eugene, Ivan, Bill Nye, your hosts. This has been StarTalk Live. Thank you all so much.
58:57 Bill Nye? Thank you.
Previous Cosmic Queries: Space Probes with Dr. Amy Mainzer Next Cosmic Queries – The Joy of Tech Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated