Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast Dark Universe Decoded with Katherine Freese About this episode What are the main candidates for dark matter? Neil deGrasse Tyson and comic co-host Chuck Nice sit down with theoretical physicist Katherine Freese to tackle fan questions about dark matter, dark energy, and the dark universe at large.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We are growing our stable of cosmologists.
0:02 Chuck Nice? Yes.
0:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Katie Freeze coming in.
0:04 Chuck Nice? That's right.
0:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? About dark matter, dark energy, big bang, rocking.
0:07 Chuck Nice? Yep, the only cosmologist who sounds like a Batman villain, Katie Freeze.
0:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Coming up on StarTalk.
0:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk, your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide.
0:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? StarTalk begins right now.
0:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is StarTalk. Neil deGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist. This is gonna be a Cosmic Queries edition on cosmology. There's no end of Cosmic Queries we can do on cosmology.
0:45 Chuck Nice? I suppose there is not.
0:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is Chuck Nice, right here.
0:48 Chuck Nice? That's right.
0:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Professional comedian, stand-up comedian.
0:50 Chuck Nice? There is an end to me.
0:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So cosmology.
0:55 Chuck Nice? Yes.
0:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So we're broadening our stable of cosmologists to whom we can reach out.
0:59 Chuck Nice? Yes.
1:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? For our queries.
1:01 Chuck Nice? Right.
1:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And today, we have a second timer.
1:04 Chuck Nice? That's right.
1:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The one and only Katie Freeze. Katie, welcome back.
1:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome back to StarTalk.
1:10 Speaker 02 Thank you, thank you.
1:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Last time you were here, I think we talked about the search for dark matter and. We did.
1:18 Speaker 02 We did.
1:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Cause that's cosmology writ large and we just, we poked your brain about all manner of things. And this is gonna be a Cosmic Queries where we have told our Patreon supporters that you're gonna be on. And they, they're fans of yours and they've written in, or they became fans of yours when they saw your expertise.
1:38 Chuck Nice? That's right.
1:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And they wrote in and the questions are here.
1:41 Speaker 02 Well, thanks a lot. I haven't seen these queries.
1:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, neither have I. He's the only one who's seen them.
1:46 Chuck Nice? Yes.
1:47 Speaker 02 Okay.
1:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So.
1:47 Chuck Nice? And I'm the only one who can't answer them.
1:54 Speaker 02 That may be true.
1:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That is kinda funny. The only people can't answer them haven't seen it. And the one who can't answer it has.
2:01 Chuck Nice? They have it.
2:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So... A couple of times, people have asked questions that no one has been able to answer. Like with the quark one going into a black hole.
2:11 Chuck Nice? Yeah, exactly. Quark into a black hole.
2:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That we still...
2:13 Chuck Nice? We still don't know the deal.
2:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We still don't know that one.
2:14 Chuck Nice? Everybody says that's...
2:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Maybe Katie knows. We can find out.
2:17 Chuck Nice? Well, we should find out, yeah.
2:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, let me get your bio here. Director of the Weinberg Institute for Theoretical Physics, UT Austin. That's Stevie Wonder, Steven Weinberg.
2:27 Speaker 02 Yeah.
2:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right?
2:28 Speaker 02 So Steve Weinberg, my hero, one of the founders of the standard model of particle physics.
2:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
2:34 Speaker 02 He was the greatest physicist of our time, in the opinion of many, including me. His office was three doors down from me. He recruited me to UT Austin. Maybe that's why I think he's the greatest physicist.
2:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That helps. Who gave you the good job, right?
2:50 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah.
2:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But he was only named...
2:51 Speaker 02 No, seriously.
2:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He was only named in his death, obviously.
2:53 Speaker 02 Yeah, he died about three years ago.
2:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, okay.
2:56 Speaker 02 And we started the institute in his honor.
2:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And now, he's more a hero for me than he is for you.
3:03 Speaker 02 Why is that?
3:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Cause he went to my high school.
3:05 Speaker 02 Oh.
3:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ba-bang!
3:07 Speaker 02 Oh, Bronx Science.
3:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The Bronx High School of Science.
3:09 Speaker 02 Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
3:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Both he and Shelley Glacho.
3:11 Speaker 02 Yeah.
3:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Went through, were in the same class. They were classmates and both shared the Nobel Prize.
3:16 Speaker 02 Okay, so the moral of the story is, when are you getting your Nobel Prize?
3:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I didn't mean to set it up that way. That was not... So what else do I have here? And you spent some time at Stockholm University? And that's ending, coming up very shortly?
3:29 Speaker 02 Ten years. They gave me a really... The Swedish government gave me a $15 million grant over 10 years to do cosmoparticle theory. And that was so much fun.
3:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wow.
3:40 Speaker 02 Oh, wow.
3:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Did you have students too and everything?
3:42 Speaker 02 Oh, I did.
3:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? With a budget to go back?
3:44 Speaker 02 I did, yeah. So I had students and I had postgraduate fellows and everybody running up and down the halls, having great ideas and having fun. It was awesome.
3:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wow.
3:55 Speaker 02 Yeah.
3:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay. Cause I think when we last interviewed you, you were like fully up and running with them. And what else? Oh, and I'd love this back now 10 years ago. The Cosmic Cocktail. Ooh. Can you get a better title than that? Shake it, not dirt. I don't think so. Three Parts Dark Matter.
4:16 Speaker 02 Yeah.
4:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's about right. That's pretty cool, man.
4:19 Speaker 02 You know, the amazing thing about that book is that I still give public lectures about it. And people are still buying lots of them. In fact, Amazon ran out again.
4:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Whoa.
4:28 Speaker 02 And that was a book I wrote 10 years ago, so.
4:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Good for you.
4:31 Speaker 02 I guess it was a good one.
4:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Whoa.
4:33 Speaker 02 And you wrote a blurb for it. You said, what did you say? I don't know, three parts dark matter, seven parts memoir or something like that?
4:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, because it was folded into your life.
4:42 Speaker 02 It was.
4:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, very important feature of that. Thanks for reminding me. It just made it a much more interesting account.
4:48 Speaker 02 Yeah.
4:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, right, cool. Here's another plug for it.
4:52 Speaker 02 Thank you.
4:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Amazon ran out again.
4:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, we're gonna chat for a bit before we go to Q and A.
4:59 Speaker 02 Okay.
4:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Catch us up on a couple of things. The James Webb, there's been a lot of talk about these early galaxies that it has discovered in a zone of the early universe where you're not supposed to.
5:10 Speaker 02 So wait, you're talking about the James Webb Space Telescope?
5:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, not the administrator of NASA during the 1960s.
5:15 Speaker 02 Yes.
5:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? After whom the telescope was named.
5:17 Speaker 02 Yes.
5:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You know, he was an accountant. James Webb? Yeah. I did. One of the rare non-scientists after whom a telescope is named. An accountant? I think that was his main training. That's pretty wild. I gotta say.
5:30 Speaker 02 I guess he was, what was he important for in NASA?
5:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He was head of NASA. Was the head of HR taken?
5:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? While we went to the moon, he was head of NASA.
5:39 Speaker 02 Ah.
5:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it was, it was, give a little back to that. Look at that. Fact, because you need, you need good administrators, not just good scientists to make stuff happen. Well. When you're in bureaucracy. You're a damn good administrator when they start naming stuff after you.
5:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, what's this we hear about paleo detectors? What is that? Is that a thing?
5:59 Speaker 02 Yeah.
5:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What is that?
6:00 Speaker 02 Well, the paleo part means that they've been around for a billion years. And so, let me back up. We're trying to figure out what dark matter is made of.
6:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
6:10 Speaker 02 And we think it's some kind of particle we haven't identified yet.
6:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
6:13 Speaker 02 And, most of the experiments now involve these giant, tons and tons of liquid xenon. And so, the idea is, okay, instead of having-
6:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's because xenon has some probability of interacting with a dark matter particle.
6:27 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah, dark matter particles flying around in the galaxy. And by the way, there would be billions going through your body every second. Yeah, yeah, but it's okay, only one a month hits you.
6:36 Chuck Nice? I thought I felt tired for a reason.
6:38 Speaker 02 And so-
6:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, wait. You know, there's a lot of elements on the periodic table. Why do you know that xenon might work when we otherwise know nothing about dark matter?
6:48 Speaker 02 The way these detectors work is the dark matter comes along, hits one of these xenon atoms, deflects off of it, and the xenon gets some energy deposited in it, and they're able to detect that. So, you have to have a detector design that works, and with xenon, we know how to do it.
7:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so it could be any particle that that would happen to, but xenon has some other convenient properties?
7:12 Speaker 02 So, the kind of interactions we're looking for is from the weak force, very, very weakly interacting particles.
7:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Hence the name.
7:20 Speaker 02 Hence the name, weakly interacting massive particles. And, there's, people need to build detectors that are, that they know, you need to know how to build the damn detector. I don't know how to answer this one, Neil.
7:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, so let's say differently. A neutrino detector, for example, that uses vats of liquid-
7:40 Speaker 02 Yeah.
7:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? ...uses like, some kind of chlorine molecule, but not xenon. So, where are these xenon detectors?
7:49 Speaker 02 They're deep underground.
7:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
7:51 Speaker 02 One of them is underneath the Apennine Mountains outside of Rome, okay?
7:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh, you know, the Apennine Mountains on the moon. Named after those.
7:59 Chuck Nice? I was gonna say that you've actually said that.
8:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, Italy came first.
8:04 Chuck Nice? The mountains here.
8:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The reason why I know them and the reason why they are important is the phase of the moon that's best for telescopic views is half moon.
8:14 Chuck Nice? Okay.
8:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because shadows are the longest and the Apennine Mountains crosses the half moon divider, the terminator, and so Apennines just pop on a first sighting of the moon.
8:25 Speaker 02 Oh, cool.
8:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So to me, the Apennine Mountains are on the moon, not in Italy.
8:29 Speaker 02 All right, all right. Well, if you could build something on the moon, that would be even better because the reason you have to go underground is to get away from cosmic rays.
8:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
8:37 Chuck Nice? Right.
8:37 Speaker 02 And there's a million cosmic rays for every one of these dark matter particles if you're on the surface of the earth, so we go deep underground because the cosmic rays don't make it down there.
8:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But the dark matter particle would.
8:48 Speaker 02 But the dark matter particles would.
8:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, based on what we think dark matter particles would be like.
8:54 Speaker 02 Well, because they're only weakly interacting.
8:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
8:57 Speaker 02 And normal, normal particles.
8:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Would interact electromagnetically.
9:01 Speaker 02 If you and I collide, we're not getting very far.
9:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, that's right.
9:04 Speaker 02 Because we have a lot.
9:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We don't pass through each other.
9:06 Speaker 02 We don't pass through each other.
9:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right.
9:08 Chuck Nice? I'll tell you something about xenon, makes a hell of a headlight.
9:16 Chuck Nice? Just wanted to contribute something, I don't know.
9:19 Speaker 02 I'll tell you, want to hear another something about xenon? There's another thing about xenon, it's become very expensive because the xenon experiments have bought the entire world supply.
9:29 Chuck Nice? Get out.
9:30 Speaker 02 No, I'm serious.
9:31 Chuck Nice? Wow.
9:32 Speaker 02 I'm serious.
9:33 Chuck Nice? Now you tell us.
9:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, you should have told us.
9:35 Chuck Nice? You should have told us before these experiments started.
9:37 Speaker 02 Which is why.
9:38 Chuck Nice? We could have got in on the cornering of the xenon market.
9:40 Speaker 02 Oh, my God, that's true.
9:41 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
9:43 Speaker 02 Which is why we want to propose an alternative. So instead of these, instead of giant detectors, we're gonna dig up little rocks from deep underground and they've been collecting dark matter tracks for a billion years, so we're replacing volume with time.
9:59 Chuck Nice? Wow.
9:59 Speaker 02 Isn't that cool? Hence paleo.
10:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh.
10:01 Chuck Nice? Okay, now that is, first of all, that's very smart, but yeah.
10:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, so how do you know which rock to get? Or any rock.
10:08 Speaker 02 Oh, well, we had to, we had to talk to a lot of geologists. And, you know, this was the first a paper with a few theorists, we're in 2018. And next thing you know.
10:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This was, so 2018, that was only a proposal?
10:20 Speaker 02 It was, yeah, we wrote a bunch of theory papers. Not every day does this stuff turn into reality. I've done it twice now, you know, the underground detectors. I wrote papers that got that going. And now with paleo detectors, that's actually becoming a major experimental effort. Isn't that cool?
10:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And it's a cool type name for a detector, too.
10:36 Speaker 02 Yeah.
10:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, so they tell you which rocks would best respond to this.
10:39 Speaker 02 Yes, and the answer is olivine.
10:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh! Olivine.
10:43 Speaker 02 Olivine.
10:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I know olivine.
10:44 Speaker 02 You do?
10:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
10:45 Speaker 02 Oh, okay.
10:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There's a class of meteorite called palisites. Where, oh my gosh. You, so where do you get a meteorite from? It's a smashed, whatever it used to be. Right. Right, okay, so if it's a protoplanet, and it partially, as the geologists would say, differentiated, because at some point in its formation, the heavy stuff would fall to the middle, the lighter stuff would float to the top. Right. Okay? If, however, it cools before it fully segregates, then the metallic innards can trap olivine crystals.
11:21 Speaker 02 Oh, wow.
11:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Within it, as they were slowly bubbling their way up to the top. Mm-hmm. And so, a slice of these meteorites, rear lit, if it's thin enough, the thickness of an olivine crystal, you see the metallic meteorite and these green crystals glowing through. And we have a sample of one in our hole of the universe.
11:39 Speaker 02 Oh, very cool!
11:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's called a palisite.
11:41 Speaker 02 Oh, I gotta see this.
11:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'll take you down, right after this. Very cool, very cool. So, so, in other words, it's rare because the boundary layer between the dense middle of a protoplanet and the lighter things that float up is very thin. Mm-hmm. And so, when you smash the whole thing, you have a lot of rocky stuff, less metallic stuff, and even less at the boundary layer.
12:05 Speaker 02 Ah.
12:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So.
12:06 Speaker 02 Well, can we borrow your olivine to look for dark matter tracks, please?
12:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I, I, you gotta know somebody.
12:12 Speaker 02 Okay.
12:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You gotta know somebody who works here.
12:16 Speaker 02 Thought I did.
12:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, no, we can totally, we can totally explore them. That could be the key. Sitting under our noses. It's been here for 25 years.
12:24 Speaker 02 Uh, well, then it's been collecting cosmic ray tracks.
12:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, yeah, no, it's, we didn't have it.
12:29 Speaker 02 Sad.
12:30 Chuck Nice? Yeah. Do you guys have any, like, deep under the earth here? Like, is there a?
12:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But it still has to get through the building.
12:36 Speaker 02 Yeah, we want to know about the sub-basements in this building.
12:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It still has to get through the building, though. The cosmic rays have to get through the building.
12:43 Speaker 02 Yeah, well.
12:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That'll block some of them, right?
12:45 Speaker 02 Nah.
12:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, so, congratulations on this.
12:50 Speaker 02 Thank you.
12:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is now a burgeoning, next, next step in this. So why a billion years and not 100 million or 50 million? Does it matter?
12:59 Speaker 02 Well, we have to go deep enough to get away from cosmic rays, and that's actually like 5 kilometers.
13:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, that's deep.
13:06 Speaker 02 It's deep. And then the other idea is if we get rocks from different ages, we are also can study neutrinos, because neutrinos will also leave tracks. The tracks will be different, okay, so you can tell the difference. But then you can figure out how many supernova went off in the galaxy, if you look in the past, a different amount of time. Isn't that cool?
13:27 Chuck Nice? Wow. And that is because the supernova, that's where the neutrinos come from.
13:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Copious.
13:32 Speaker 02 Oh, I forgot to say that. Yeah, neutrinos give off a lot of supernova. No.
13:38 Speaker 02 No, no, no, supernova give off a lot of neutrinos, and so you, which supernova, which are dying, exploding stars. And you can look for the neutrinos from the supernova.
13:47 Chuck Nice? Right. Cool, man.
13:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And neutrinos are, once again, your weekly interacting.
13:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, they are also weekly interacting particles, yeah.
13:54 Chuck Nice? Yeah, most unfortunate.
13:56 Speaker 02 Now, the other thing you can do with.
13:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Weekly interacting particles, yeah.
14:00 Speaker 02 Uh, well, we know who named them that.
14:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Who named them? I forgot.
14:04 Speaker 02 Uh, Mike Turner?
14:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is that right? Mike Turner.
14:07 Chuck Nice? That would have made sense if you said Ike Turner.
14:11 Speaker 02 Whoa. The word eponymous comes to mind.
14:28 Speaker 03 I'm Nicholas Costella and I'm a proud supporter of StarTalk on Patreon. This is StarTalk with Neil deGrasse Tyson.
14:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So I've got one more question before we go to Q and A. Some of the results of the James Webb Space Telescope and other sources suggest that we cannot reconcile the age we have derived for the universe by these different methods. One of them is from the CMB, Cosmic Microwave Background, others is from galaxies at other times. And it has been suggested that you can reconcile them if dark energy changes over time.
15:15 Speaker 02 The biggest evidence for dark energy changing over time comes from a different experiment, the DESI experiment.
15:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
15:24 Speaker 02 What they're looking at...
15:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Lucy and DESI? No.
15:28 Chuck Nice? Dark matter, you got some explaining to do!
15:31 Speaker 02 Oh, that's good, that's good.
15:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But DESI, so, other than Lucy and DESI, what does DESI stand for astrophysically?
15:38 Speaker 02 The Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument.
15:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, alright, that's clean and simple. And what does that tell us?
15:47 Speaker 02 What they're looking at is, based on some physics from the early universe, and there were waves which froze out at the same time the Cosmic Microwave Background was produced, that's 400,000 years after the Big Bang, which is like, I don't know, a thousandth of a percent of the age of the universe today. And what those waves did was leave an imprint that throughout the rest of time, galaxies form in these spheres left over from those waves. And so as time goes on, you look at how big are those spheres, and that tells you about the expansion of the universe.
16:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
16:24 Speaker 02 And what they're saying is...
16:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because the spheres would grow with the universe.
16:27 Speaker 02 Yeah.
16:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
16:27 Speaker 02 Yeah, and so by studying that, you can figure out what the expansion is doing, is it accelerating, what is it doing? And what they claim is that the dark energy, which everybody, the vanilla model, is that it doesn't change in time, but it definitely affects the overall expansion of the universe no matter what, it's causing the acceleration, so we think. And what they're claiming is that the acceleration is slowing down.
16:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh.
16:53 Speaker 02 So it's a decrease in the dark energy contribution to the universe. So now can I put it in a plug for my own work?
17:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Please.
17:02 Speaker 02 We look, so my collaborator Yunhong and I, so we looked at the same data and we looked at it differently with a simpler way of interpreting the data and we do not find that Evans to be very strong, actually. So I don't think it's happening. But big picture, there's a big debate. Is it real? Is the dark energy changing with time or not? Is it time varying or not? And different people have different opinions.
17:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If you found a simpler way to look at it.
17:26 Speaker 02 Yeah.
17:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Where the effect goes away.
17:28 Speaker 02 Yep.
17:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And we were betting on the likelihood of one truth or another, I'm betting with a simpler explanation.
17:35 Speaker 02 Thank you.
17:35 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
17:36 Speaker 02 Well, me too, obviously.
17:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That taps Occam's razor.
17:40 Speaker 02 Well, from the data, we're directly extracting the dark energy density, the amount of dark energy, instead of going through a...
17:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A secondary.
17:50 Speaker 02 A secondary thing which is called the dark energy equation of state. So we're doing it more directly, so that's why I like what we're doing better.
17:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you know about Occam's razor?
17:59 Chuck Nice? Uh, if, let me just think. Removing all other considerations, the simplest answer is the most likely.
18:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's a modern interpretation. What he actually said was...
18:09 Chuck Nice? Go ahead.
18:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Multiplicity ought not be posited without necessity.
18:14 Chuck Nice? Oh, wow!
18:15 Speaker 02 Wow!
18:15 Chuck Nice? Damn!
18:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Occam, named for William of Occam, he goes way back.
18:21 Chuck Nice? Okay.
18:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, like 700 years.
18:24 Chuck Nice? Wow.
18:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So he had some insights into nature that persist to this day. William of Occam.
18:30 Chuck Nice? Sure enough. He knows how to turn a phrase, that's for sure.
18:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So I'm betting on Katie on this one, definitely.
18:37 Chuck Nice? Very cool.
18:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, but let me exit this before we get to the questions with a related question.
18:43 Speaker 02 Okay.
18:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You said the vanilla version of dark energy is that it does not change over time.
18:47 Speaker 02 Yeah.
18:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's how it appears in Einstein's general relativity.
18:51 Speaker 02 Yeah.
18:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It is a constant.
18:53 Speaker 02 Yeah. A cosmological constant.
18:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right. If you want to start making that not constant, then it's no longer Einstein's general theory of relativity. It's some modification to it.
19:04 Speaker 02 No, it doesn't...
19:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How does he accommodate, how can his formulation of general relativity accommodate...
19:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A cosmological constant that's not constant.
19:17 Speaker 02 I just want to say about dark energy, it is a complete mystery to all of us. We have no idea what's going on, to be honest, okay? We could call it gobbledegook.
19:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I've already named it. Dark matter, dark energy, or Fred and Wilma.
19:30 Speaker 02 Okay.
19:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because it doesn't have any bias at all. They're just two words.
19:35 Speaker 02 Well, I don't know, because we know dark matter exists. I'm not so sure about dark energy. I want Wilma to exist, but anyway.
19:43 Speaker 02 But, so dark energy, there's two, there's two possibilities. One is, as you said, you have to modify Einstein's equations.
19:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And that feels wrong to me.
19:51 Speaker 02 Well, you know, I actually had an idea for how to do that in 2002, but let's not go there. I want to talk about the other way, which is, we stick with Einstein's equations.
20:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, in 2002, you had a way to modify Einstein's general theory of relativity?
20:04 Speaker 02 Well, more specifically, the evolution equation for the universe.
20:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
20:09 Speaker 02 The Friedman equation for the universe. What I, what I, we had been working in extra dimensions. If you have string theory.
20:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? As one would do.
20:18 Speaker 02 Yeah, as one would do, because.
20:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? As one does.
20:21 Speaker 02 Yeah, as one does. So in string theory, you have to have 10 spatial dimensions, instead of the XYZ.
20:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? T, yeah.
20:29 Speaker 02 The normal ones that we, that we usually work with. And if you do that, it's possible that, well, our universe is a three-dimensional surface in there. And there could be another one. And the stuff in between, which we call the bulk, is pulling on our surface and causing the equations to change.
20:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh. Interesting.
20:48 Speaker 02 So we posited.
20:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so, so the equations would be sound within the universe, left to its own devices, but influenced outside of it, you gotta get, you gotta give it some slack.
20:59 Speaker 02 Yeah, you do. You gotta add these other terms into the equations, which describe the evolution of our three-dimensional universe.
21:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? She just called our universe a slice.
21:08 Speaker 02 I did, yeah.
21:10 Chuck Nice? I believe that.
21:10 Speaker 02 It's kind of an interesting slice. I like it.
21:12 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
21:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's a dimensional slice.
21:15 Speaker 02 Yeah.
21:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's a dig if I ever heard one.
21:17 Chuck Nice? I don't know. Like during my ayahuasca trip, I met some beings that told me that there were dimensions alongside of our dimension, like more than we could ever know. Dimension, dimension, dimension, and that there were dimensions above and dimensions below. I don't want, anyway, I don't even know why I said this. Let's, but yeah.
21:38 Speaker 02 But you know what they're called in, in physics? They're called brains. B R A N E.
21:43 Chuck Nice? Okay.
21:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Which is short for membrane.
21:45 Chuck Nice? Membrane, yeah.
21:46 Speaker 02 It's short for membrane.
21:47 Chuck Nice? Yeah, just like, yeah.
21:47 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah.
21:49 Chuck Nice? Uh, like thin little dividers.
21:51 Speaker 02 So the question you're asking, do some other of these brains contain B R A I Ns?
21:56 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
21:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh.
21:58 Speaker 02 And we don't know.
21:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because we know ours does.
22:00 Chuck Nice? Right. I mean.
22:01 Speaker 02 I think so.
22:03 Chuck Nice? I was gonna say, if you wanna call it that. We use the term loosely in arguments.
22:10 Speaker 02 So on the, can I tell you what I called this theory?
22:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What?
22:14 Speaker 02 I called it Cardassian cosmology. And the reason is that Lisa Randall was going on about the warp factor, which I thought.
22:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's another physicist up at Harvard.
22:24 Speaker 02 Oh yeah, she's great. And so she was talking about the warp factor in her theory and I thought they came from Star Trek, but actually it's just a relativity term that I had heard called something else. And so I thought, well, I'm gonna go to Star Trek, so I went for the Cardassians. So I called it Cardassian expansion because everything would be made of ordinary matter, ordinary radiation, ordinary stuff. No weird dark energy, but the equations would be different. And so like the Cardassians, they are, they're weird looking, but they're made of the same. But they're, but they're two bipeds like we are and their goal is accelerated expansion of their evil empire.
23:00 Chuck Nice? Correct. That's right. They're quite draconian and their whole purpose is to take over everything. Yeah.
23:06 Speaker 02 Well, Cardassian.
23:07 Chuck Nice? Yeah, they're the Cardassians. Yeah.
23:11 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
23:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, all right, so you got questions?
23:12 Chuck Nice? We got, we got, let's get to it. Let's jump right in. These are directly for, uh...
23:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you haven't seen these questions?
23:18 Speaker 02 Uh, no, that's not fair.
23:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Why? What do you know?
23:21 Speaker 02 Well, I don't know.
23:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's the whole thing here.
23:22 Speaker 02 All right, all right.
23:23 Chuck Nice? Well, this first question is from Anthropoc cosmic Dylan, who basically says, hey, yeah. He says, "How do dark stars work? What would they be like to visit? And how do they impact extrasolar systems and potentially astrobiology?" So he's just, he wants you to just answer everything. Answer it all, Captain.
23:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Let me pre-pen that.
23:43 Chuck Nice? Go ahead.
23:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In, was it the 1800s or late 1700s? There was a calculation done by a physicist who said to himself, "The gravity on a star is whatever it is, but if the star shrinks, the surface gravity goes up. There'll be a point where the surface gravity prevents life from escaping, and the star will disappear from the universe."
24:05 Speaker 02 In other words, what we call now a black hole.
24:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Exactly. So it was like the first attempt at thinking about what we now would call a black hole. But so, that technically would be a dark star.
24:15 Chuck Nice? Like a dark star.
24:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I don't think that's what this question is about. I think they're asking, if matter can make planets, can dark matter make planets?
24:23 Speaker 02 No, I mean, I think he's asking about my work on dark stars.
24:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh!
24:27 Speaker 02 And dark stars are not made of dark matter. They're, the first stars that form, and they would be made of ordinary stuff. Ordinary hydrogen, ordinary helium, almost entirely. But they're powered by the, by the dark matter that's inside them. But doesn't, so it's ordinary matter powered by dark matter.
24:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is one of your early papers.
24:45 Speaker 02 It's, instead of by, there's no fusion. It's dark matter power.
24:49 Chuck Nice? Wow!
24:49 Speaker 02 Yeah.
24:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's some crazy innovative stuff.
24:52 Speaker 02 And these things, if, if they exist, these things, I'm so excited because we have candidates for them in the James Webb Space Telescope. I'm so excited. They would start out at about the same mass as the sun, but then they would grow, grow, grow, until they become a million times as massive as the sun and a billion times as bright.
25:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They grow because they're absorbing dark matter.
25:11 Speaker 02 No, because they're absorbing ordinary matter. Normal stars can't keep growing because their surfaces are hot. You know, they have fusion. Fusion's hot.
25:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right.
25:19 Speaker 02 And then so they blow stuff off. But dark stars are cool. Oh, in radius, they're 10 times the distance between the Earth and the Sun.
25:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So they're huge?
25:28 Speaker 02 They're huge and they're cool, which means they can keep accreting matter. Grow, grow, grow, and they get really, really big.
25:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So there's no pressure on the outer surface to prevent new matter from accreting to it?
25:37 Speaker 02 Yeah, exactly. Exactly right. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So they can get really big. And we have candidates in the James Webb Space Telescope for some of those really early objects that are super bright and they don't know how to explain them. Well, we'll take them.
25:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You'll take them?
25:49 Speaker 02 We'll take them.
25:49 Chuck Nice? Whoa.
25:51 Speaker 02 Yeah, I'm excited.
25:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? When you win your Nobel Prize, will you come back on the show?
25:56 Chuck Nice? Was that a kiss-off?
25:58 Speaker 02 No!
25:59 Chuck Nice? Oh, okay.
26:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Did you read the body language? That was a very, very...
26:03 Speaker 02 Oh, no, I'm sorry.
26:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, he's still learning social cues.
26:07 Speaker 02 Oh, I meant the opposite.
26:09 Chuck Nice? Oh, okay, cool, yeah. I'll tell you this much. Once you... He's right. That is Nobel stuff right there, man. That's fantastic.
26:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So the...
26:18 Speaker 02 You know, the thing about Astro... About my field is that you can have a great idea. And, you know, let me back up. Usually, when you have a great idea, you kill it in 10 minutes because it violates some observation. Occasionally, it not only survives those first 10 minutes, but then people start telling you, "Did you know you solved this problem? Did you know you solved that problem?" And that's what's going on here.
26:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, that's...
26:39 Speaker 02 We keep solving problems. So dark stars could explain a lot of things. They could explain, once they die, the supermassive black holes that you see in the early universe. They could explain the blue monsters, and they could explain the little red dots. And I figured you'd like those terms.
26:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wow.
26:54 Speaker 02 Yeah.
26:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? These are all... They're very bluntly descriptive of stuff we see in the early universe. Because there's nothing nearby that we have a counterpart to. There's a red dot. It's a red dot.
27:05 Chuck Nice? Okay, so we call it a red dot. Now, what about the blue monster? Where'd you get that reference?
27:10 Speaker 02 Blue monsters are really, really, really bright objects way early in the history of the universe.
27:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, it should be like the formation of galaxies. I mean, we know they're blue. They don't look blue. They look very infrared, because that blue has been red-shifted to the sweet spot of the James Webb Telescope. Yeah, yeah.
27:26 Chuck Nice? But, yeah, that's very cool. All right. Okay, well, hey, what a great question, anthropoc...
27:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So she said she's coming back after her Nobel Prize?
27:34 Chuck Nice? Absolutely. Now, here's the next question. Can I wear your Nobel Prize when you come back?
27:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So here's the best line related to that. It was from Hoop Dreams. Do you know the line?
27:44 Chuck Nice? I don't know. I don't know.
27:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You know this line? You know the movie?
27:46 Chuck Nice? I don't think I know Hoop Dreams.
27:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Hoop Dreams. Dude, it's a documentary.
27:51 Speaker 02 Oh, you don't know Hoop Dreams?
27:52 Chuck Nice? I do not know Hoop Dreams, but go ahead.
27:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, it's a documentary of following high school students, some who have ambitions to play in the NBA.
28:00 Speaker 02 Oh, okay.
28:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, and the social dynamic that surrounds it. It's a documentary. But here's the line. "When you're rich and famous, will you remember us?"
28:11 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
28:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? As one of them goes off. And he says, "If I'm not rich and famous, will you remember me?"
28:19 Speaker 02 Oh, that's good.
28:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's good.
28:22 Speaker 02 That's really good.
28:22 Chuck Nice? I'm gonna tell you the answer to both those questions is...
28:25 Speaker 02 Ouch!
28:25 Chuck Nice? No. The answer?
28:28 Speaker 02 Yeah.
28:29 Chuck Nice? No. And to both. Alright, let's move on.
28:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Let's hit take.
28:32 Chuck Nice? This is Nate. And Nate says, "Hello, Dr. Tyson, Dr. Freeze, and Lord Nice. Uh, this is Nate from southern Idaho. If dark energy has gravitational effects on everything just like regular matter does, why does it not coalesce and push away from itself? This seems counterintuitive considering the fundamental nature of gravity is to pull things together by bending spacetime. Does dark energy abide by its own rules? Where it can cause gravity, but it isn't affected by it? This would imply that it is not influenced by the curvature of spacetime in which it causes." Ooh. This guy did some thinking here. Freaking Nate, bro!
29:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Whoa!
29:14 Chuck Nice? Dude!
29:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Whoa. So let's start from scratch.
29:17 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
29:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We're calling it dark energy because it's a placeholder term. We don't know what the hell it is.
29:22 Speaker 02 Right.
29:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But if it's energy at all, then it has a mass equivalent and it should have gravity. So, does dark energy have gravity?
29:31 Speaker 02 The definition of matter is that it feels gravitational attraction.
29:35 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
29:35 Speaker 02 So that's true for ordinary matter. That would be you. And me, and you.
29:40 Chuck Nice? I was gonna say, thanks.
29:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He's not ordinary matter.
29:42 Speaker 02 He's not ordinary matter, and it would be dark matter, so all of that stuff clumps together. It's attracted together.
29:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And energy contains a matter equivalent.
29:51 Speaker 02 No, you know, for ordinary matter and energy, that is true, but for dark energy, it is completely different from matter. It is something that's causing a repulsive behavior. It's pushing things apart from one another.
30:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's why we should call it just Wilma, something that doesn't have the word "energy" in it.
30:06 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah, so it's confusing, because matter and energy in the ordinary world are related, but dark matter and dark energy are probably not.
30:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so the foundation of this question is not valid, because it's assuming that it's participating in the curvature of spacetime, and if it's helping to make it, why isn't it responding to it? Why is it spreading things out rather than pulling things in?
30:28 Speaker 02 Well, I mean, it does fit into Einstein's theory of general relativity. It's just that if you have this vacuum energy, it causes repulsion rather than attraction. It causes acceleration. So it's a completely different type of behavior.
30:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We calculated with that, and you're off by like...
30:47 Speaker 02 Oh, 10 to the 120?
30:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Power.
30:49 Speaker 02 Yeah, in the exponent, yeah, that's true. Well, I'm not saying we understand it. I'm not saying we can calculate it.
30:55 Chuck Nice? That's funny.
30:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Isn't that the biggest mismatch between a theory and a calculation ever?
31:00 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's really, it's just unbelievable. Vacuum energy, what does that mean? Well, what it means, by the way, there's vacuum energy in this room that you could measure. There are particle, and it doesn't mean there's nothing. It means particle-antiparticle pairs that pop into existence. They last infinitesimal amount of time, and then they disappear again. But that serves as an energy, and it has been measured. There's been two plates that are attracted.
31:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is not the Casimir effect.
31:27 Speaker 02 Yes, the Casimir effect.
31:28 Chuck Nice? It is!
31:28 Speaker 02 It's the Casimir effect, absolutely.
31:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is where two, in a vacuum, two parallel plates, you bring them very, very close together, and there's a point where there's...
31:37 Chuck Nice? They just attract, right?
31:38 Speaker 02 Yep, yep, yep. It's the same vacuum, the same, exactly the same thing.
31:43 Chuck Nice? That's pretty wild.
31:44 Speaker 02 But if you do the mathematical calculation, your answer is too big by 10 to the 120 in the exponent. So if you add up all the contributions from all those particles, it gets the wrong answer, and that's considered one of the biggest...
32:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's the very wrong answer.
32:02 Speaker 02 One of the deepest unsolved problems in all of physics.
32:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right.
32:05 Speaker 02 And it gets worse. People thought, well, it gets worse. People thought, yeah, look, somehow, somebody will figure out how to bring that number down to zero and we'll be, we'll be good. No. All of a sudden, it looks like there's a small amount left over. Well, it's, it's, it's not that small for, for our universe. But compared to 10 to the 120, there's dark energy, which means there is some vacuum left over that's driving acceleration. It's neither, the big answer nor is it zero. It's somewhere in between. What the heck?
32:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right.
32:36 Speaker 02 I feel like I'm talking too much.
32:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No!
32:38 Chuck Nice? We love it.
32:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's the whole point of why you're on here.
32:40 Chuck Nice? Exactly, yeah. Ooh, wow.
32:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If you're talking a lot, it means I have less to add.
32:46 Speaker 02 Oh.
32:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it is, your words and ideas and brilliance are gracing the stage.
32:51 Chuck Nice? You're a real expert.
32:56 Speaker 02 On some, on something.
33:18 Chuck Nice? All right, let's go to Sumit Sharma, who says, hello, Dr. Tyson, Dr. Freeze, Lord Nice. This is Sumit from Delhi. I am a new member here.
33:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Nice, okay.
33:27 Chuck Nice? Patreon member.
33:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome.
33:29 Chuck Nice? Well, go ahead, you do it.
33:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to the universe.
33:32 Chuck Nice? There you go. You got an official welcome there, Sumit.
33:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In my cosmos voice.
33:35 Chuck Nice? That's right. I want to know where does the scientific consensus stand on WIMP as an alternative hypothesis to dark matter today? I don't understand that. But anyway, I don't understand.
33:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? WIMP is the abbreviation.
33:47 Chuck Nice? I know, weakly interacting mass and particles.
33:50 Speaker 02 It's a candidate for the dark matter.
33:52 Chuck Nice? Oh, okay, but it can't be a substitute, but, but anyway.
33:55 Speaker 02 No, it is, it is a type of dark matter.
33:57 Chuck Nice? It's a type.
33:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's the answer.
33:58 Chuck Nice? That's what that's the answer.
33:59 Speaker 02 It's a type of dark matter, yeah.
34:00 Chuck Nice? Also, since dark matter is invisible and hard to detect directly, what indirectly, what indirect properties or effects of dark matter are scientists currently studying? And by what methods? I love that. Like, yeah, so what's the deal? It doesn't interact with anything. How are you guys measuring it? How are you figuring out anything about it?
34:17 Speaker 02 You know, the thing about dark matter is we've got about 20 different candidate particles that it could be.
34:23 Chuck Nice? Okay.
34:24 Speaker 02 Some of them are well motivated and some are, hmm, not as much. So my favorite three would be wimps, axions, and primordial black holes.
34:34 Chuck Nice? Okay.
34:35 Speaker 02 So wimps, the weakly interacting massive particles, they do have an interaction, which is the weak interaction, the weak force.
34:42 Chuck Nice? Okay.
34:43 Speaker 02 And axions, what they do is that they can actually, in the presence of a magnetic field, they turn into photons, into light. So they can switch axion photon, axion photon, and then you can detect that light. Now, primordial black holes, they would be black holes that formed very early in the history of the universe.
35:02 Chuck Nice? They don't evaporate right away?
35:03 Speaker 02 Some of them do, so they have to be bigger than, the smallest ones do. But there would be some left over, and they form wherever there's some region of the universe that has more, an excess of stuff in it, an over-density, that collapses into a black hole. And that, for example, could be at some phase transition in the early universe, this is like when water boils, it switches from liquid to gas, and that's where you get these fluctuations, and boom, you might make primordial black holes. And the reason people care nowadays is because gravitational wave detectors are seeing merging black holes, and some of those could be primordial black holes. So people got all excited about primordial black holes again.
35:48 Chuck Nice? Okay.
35:49 Speaker 02 As far as wimps go, there's, oh, you can either, to find them, you can make it, shake it, or break it.
35:55 Chuck Nice? Right on. Go ahead, do your thing. Shake what your mama gave you.
36:03 Speaker 02 Well, we're not doing the, let's talk about the make first.
36:05 Chuck Nice? Make it, shake it, or break it.
36:06 Speaker 02 Make it, shake it, or break it. So the make it is, in particle accelerators, such as the Large Hadon Collider at CERN, you shoot really rapidly moving protons into each other. Moving nearly at the speed of light and out come potentially dark matter particles like wimps and you look for them that way. No discovery yet, okay?
36:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it would have a signature that you couldn't otherwise identify and you would describe it to dark matter.
36:32 Speaker 02 Yeah.
36:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because you otherwise know what you're supposed to get out of it, right?
36:36 Speaker 02 Yeah, if it's ordinary stuff, then you know what to expect.
36:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right.
36:39 Speaker 02 But if you're making some kind of new particles, then they might escape from the detector without, and you'd see that as missing energy.
36:48 Chuck Nice? Okay.
36:49 Speaker 02 You'd add up all the energy of all the particles coming out and get there to be some missing energy.
36:53 Chuck Nice? Right, right on. Okay, there you go.
36:55 Speaker 02 And you want to hear about the shake it?
36:57 Chuck Nice? Yes.
36:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
36:58 Chuck Nice? And break, I mean, yeah.
37:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Now, we've got to make it. You can't, you can't leave without shaking it and breaking it.
37:04 Speaker 02 Okay, so the shake it is you've got your detector deep underground and a particle comes along, hits your detector, gives it a little bit of energy and you look for that energy deposit. So it's shaking that nucleus.
37:22 Chuck Nice? Like a little vibration.
37:24 Speaker 02 Exactly, in some cases. That's exactly what they're looking for in some cases.
37:29 Chuck Nice? Yeah, got you, got you.
37:30 Speaker 02 Or some, some light that comes off or whatever. So that's what they're doing.
37:33 Chuck Nice? Okay.
37:34 Speaker 02 And then the break it, that's called indirect detection and that's when, well, dark matter particles, these wimps, can be their own antimatter and that means when they hit each other, they annihilate and turn into something else. And what you got to do is measure that something else. So people are looking for neutrinos. You know where they look, where those detectors are? Underneath the ice at the South Pole.
37:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's Ice Cube.
37:57 Speaker 02 That's Ice Cube.
37:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ice Cube.
37:58 Speaker 02 Yep, two miles down.
37:59 Chuck Nice? Straight Outta Compton. I mean, Straight Outta South Pole.
38:02 Speaker 02 Oh, that's good, that's good, that's good, yeah.
38:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because Ice Cube wasn't in Straight Outta Compton.
38:08 Chuck Nice? Yes, he was.
38:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The actor, yeah.
38:10 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah, that's good.
38:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The rapper.
38:11 Speaker 02 We like that, yeah.
38:12 Chuck Nice? All right. Yeah, that was great. What a great question Sue made for your first time asking anything here on StarTalk.
38:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? From Old Delhi.
38:21 Chuck Nice? From Old Delhi. Make it, shake it, or break it. Just remember that. All right. All right, this is Chris Hampton. He says, uh, dear Lord nice or barren.
38:29 Speaker 02 Wait a minute, Christopher Hampton, that was a playwright. It's a playwright.
38:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Really?
38:34 Chuck Nice? Yes. I'm not familiar with him.
38:36 Speaker 02 Yes.
38:36 Chuck Nice? Oh, very cool.
38:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is it a living playwright?
38:38 Speaker 02 I think so.
38:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so it could be him.
38:40 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
38:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, treating nice.
38:42 Chuck Nice? There you go. He says, "Dear Lord Nice or Baron." No, actually, you dubbed Paul Mercurio Baron. So, it's just, which by the way, I found out they're kind of the same, the titles. Which, you know, we're gonna have to demote Paul.
38:58 Chuck Nice? I'm joking, I love him. "Could dark energy be caused by a constant inflow of spacetime itself, perhaps through black holes from a parent universe? In other words, we're bringing more in than there is flowing out, like a Brita flatiron system." Okay.
39:17 Speaker 02 Oh, wow.
39:18 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
39:19 Speaker 02 I'm not sure how to answer that one.
39:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Brita flatiron system?
39:21 Speaker 02 Yeah, what the heck is that?
39:22 Chuck Nice? I don't know what a Brita flatiron system is. I have a Brita at home, I put water in it. And, uh, yeah, it flows through and then I drink it. But, um...
39:30 Speaker 02 I mean, you know what Einstein had to do to get a static universe? He had to have material somehow bubbling into our universe and appearing out of nowhere on a regular basis. So that is not an insane idea, and people have thought about that.
39:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He knew, you know what Isaac Newton's solution to that was?
39:46 Chuck Nice? Go ahead.
39:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It was, if the universe were just finite, then all the galaxies would collapse to each other.
39:53 Chuck Nice? Okay.
39:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay? He didn't think of the universe as expanding.
39:56 Chuck Nice? Right.
39:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But, he said, "The only way out of this is if the universe is infinite."
40:00 Chuck Nice? Infinite, right.
40:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Then you can't favor one point or another.
40:04 Speaker 02 Oh, really? Newton said that?
40:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
40:05 Speaker 02 Wow.
40:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
40:06 Speaker 02 Smart guy. Damn!
40:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's why he's sitting right over there on my desk.
40:11 Chuck Nice? Did he know the universe... Oh, but that's because he didn't know the universe was expanding, right?
40:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, no, no.
40:15 Speaker 02 No, no, that was 1929 that they figured that out.
40:17 Chuck Nice? Ah, okay.
40:18 Speaker 02 Einstein did not like it.
40:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, the expanding universe was too weird for everybody.
40:22 Chuck Nice? For everybody, yeah. What did Einstein say, something about God or playing...
40:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He's always talking about God.
40:28 Speaker 02 That was quantum mechanics.
40:28 Chuck Nice? That was quantum God playing dice, like the expanding universe, yeah.
40:32 Speaker 02 He didn't like the quantum mechanics? He didn't like the expanding universe? Isn't that interesting?
40:36 Chuck Nice? That's wild.
40:37 Speaker 02 Which a lot of this is, these are fields of physics that he started.
40:41 Chuck Nice? That he created.
40:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Crumbs that fell off his plate.
40:44 Chuck Nice? From the stuff that he was just like...
40:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The Nobel Prize is given to crumbs that fell off his plate.
40:49 Chuck Nice? Well, I don't know what the hell this is, but whatever, let's move on, and that's him. Wow, that's amazing.
40:54 Speaker 02 I just...
40:54 Chuck Nice? That's, that's pretty wild. All right, but when he says "a constant inflow of spacetime itself..."
41:00 Speaker 02 No.
41:00 Chuck Nice? No.
41:01 Speaker 02 I don't, that doesn't make any sense to me, so I'm gonna just say no.
41:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so spacetime can't come from another brain?
41:07 Chuck Nice? Right.
41:08 Speaker 02 Spacetime would, to me, would include all of that stuff?
41:12 Chuck Nice? Got you.
41:13 Speaker 02 We're all living in, within spacetime.
41:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, okay.
41:16 Speaker 02 I'm a little uncomfortable with that notion.
41:19 Chuck Nice? Okay. Listen, I'll accept that because we are all living in spacetime. So, you know, that's pretty simple to accept. Greetings, STEM nerds.
41:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah!
41:29 Chuck Nice? Mike from Colorado. Yeah, there you go, buddy. Uh, Mike from Colorado here. Since the time of Edwin Hubble, we look at distant galaxies and calculate their speed based on the redshift we measure, which we attribute to the Doppler effect. However, we also know that photons lose energy when traveling out of the gravitational field, which also exhibits as a redshift. Given that dark matter accounts for some 80% of the gravitation in the universe, how do we know how much redshift is due to the Doppler effect? And how much is due to gravitation? Is it possible that the speeds we calculate for distant galaxies are just an upper bound on their actual speeds?
42:09 Speaker 02 Well, there are, on the average, galaxies are moving apart from one another. That's the Hubble expansion. That causes light between some distant past and us now to stretch, the wavelength of light stretches.
42:27 Chuck Nice? Right.
42:27 Speaker 02 However, there's no question when you go, for example, some of that light, if it goes through a galaxy on the way here, or goes through a cluster of galaxies, that also changes its wavelength. And, in fact, we use that to figure out where a cluster is, or what a cluster is doing. So, it's useful information. And we're very aware that you have both effects going on at the same time. So, if you're inside our galaxy, like in this room, we're not feeling the expansion. We're not feeling it.
42:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm feeling it.
42:57 Speaker 02 Yeah, you're feeling it?
43:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, this reminds me of what they used to call the tired light model.
43:05 Chuck Nice? Okay.
43:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The light's just too tired.
43:06 Chuck Nice? Right.
43:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Come through.
43:07 Chuck Nice? I've been through a lot, y'all.
43:11 Chuck Nice? I'm telling you, traveling, traveling between these galaxies, y'all don't know, this is oh lord, it's killing me, man, killing me.
43:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Tired light, because it would, you know.
43:22 Chuck Nice? I don't even have masks, I feel so damn heavy.
43:26 Chuck Nice? Oh, y'all don't know, y'all don't know.
43:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So.
43:30 Chuck Nice? Okay.
43:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So tired light would be reddened.
43:35 Chuck Nice? Right.
43:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, it would be reddened, however, there's also spectral features of elements within the spectrum. So you could take regular light and it would reden, but if it's the expanding universe,
43:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? and it's Doppler shifted, the lines would shift.
43:54 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah.
43:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They would shift and had nothing to do with red or anything, they would just shift.
44:00 Chuck Nice? Gotcha.
44:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And they shift.
44:01 Speaker 02 Yeah, they sure do.
44:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They sure do.
44:03 Chuck Nice? Gotcha.
44:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so, you can still have tired light, but you can't blame that redness on the expanding universe.
44:11 Chuck Nice? Very cool, that's a good answer.
44:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And if we animate StarTalk, you will be the voice of the photon.
44:20 Chuck Nice? I done had a hug, did I?
44:22 Speaker 02 Wait, now who's gonna be the wimp?
44:28 Speaker 02 Oh, and then of course, before that, there were the machos.
44:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The machos.
44:30 Chuck Nice? Oh, that's right.
44:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Massive, compact halo objects.
44:34 Chuck Nice? Right.
44:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So for a while, we had machos and wimps.
44:35 Chuck Nice? Macho and wimp.
44:36 Speaker 02 Yeah, we did.
44:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just so you know, men were naming things.
44:39 Chuck Nice? Yeah, right, yeah.
44:40 Speaker 02 And the experiments looking for machos, ogal.
44:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ogal, yeah.
44:45 Speaker 02 Eros, ogal, eros, and macho.
44:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
44:50 Chuck Nice? Okay.
44:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ogal, optical gravitational lens experiment.
44:55 Chuck Nice? Okay.
44:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And.
44:57 Speaker 02 Eros, E-R-O-S.
44:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What did that stand for?
44:59 Speaker 02 I don't know, the god, the god of love, like Cupid.
45:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
45:03 Chuck Nice? It's the only one I like.
45:06 Speaker 02 What's wrong with Venus?
45:07 Chuck Nice? Well, first you ogle, and that causes arrows.
45:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We got time for one last question, if you can answer it fast. Okay, go.
45:16 Speaker 02 Okay.
45:17 Chuck Nice? Okay, here we go. Uh, this is Brian Whelan.
45:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's a test of you.
45:19 Chuck Nice? Brian Whelan says, "Hello, Dr. Tyson, Freeze, and Lord Nice. Captain Ben from Sag Harbor here, reaching out thirty thousand, thirty-five thousand feet en route home." Oh, he's, he's, he's actually in the cockpit, sending us this, this message.
45:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, 'cause he's captain?
45:35 Chuck Nice? He's captain.
45:36 Speaker 02 Wow.
45:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, shouldn't you be flying the plane?
45:38 Chuck Nice? Well, no, at thirty-five thousand feet, the plane flies itself.
45:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, I guess so.
45:42 Chuck Nice? Uh, he goes...
45:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Still?
45:44 Chuck Nice? Yeah, still. Yeah, this doesn't inspire competence, okay? That's all we're saying.
45:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, okay.
45:50 Chuck Nice? I'd rather you be drinking. All right?
45:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Drinking, we're still paying attention.
45:56 Chuck Nice? Exactly. He says, "Listen, I've been wondering, does dark matter coalesce and condense similarly to regular matter? And if not, why not? It doesn't interact electromagnetically, but would gravity do something similar? Sending this message also on my birthday." Happy birthday, Captain Whelan."
46:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Captain Whelan.
46:13 Speaker 02 Yes.
46:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that has some overlap with the previous question, but let me tune that a little better. All right? If it interacts weakly, that's still an interaction.
46:23 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
46:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So why doesn't it just make weak planets, instead of regular planets?
46:28 Speaker 02 Well, I'm gonna answer, I'm gonna say something else first, which is that without dark matter, we wouldn't exist. It had to collapse and clump, and make protogalaxies, before ordinary matter could do it. And then ordinary matter falls into those things.
46:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're telling me that there are protogalactic dark matter galaxies out there?
46:46 Speaker 02 There were, in the early universe, and then ordinary matter fell in there. But is it possible there are some purely dark galaxies that don't have any stars in them? Yes, and people are looking for that, for sure. Isn't that cool?
47:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, wait. Okay, yes.
47:02 Speaker 02 Very cool.
47:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Very cool. So it wouldn't so much be dark, because that would imply it absorbed light. But they don't interact with light. They would just be invisible.
47:11 Speaker 02 Well, made of dark matter, right. So there's nothing to see.
47:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There's nothing to see.
47:15 Speaker 02 Well, except...
47:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, no. If it doesn't interact with light...
47:20 Speaker 02 Right.
47:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Then, then light just passes through, rendering them transparent.
47:24 Speaker 02 No, because of Einstein's lensing, gravitational lensing.
47:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, you see the lensing effects.
47:29 Speaker 02 You see distant galaxies, the light from behind the dark galaxies will get bent.
47:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so it gets bent.
47:35 Speaker 02 So you see that.
47:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But the galaxy itself, or the dark matter thing itself, would be invisible to you, right? You could just walk through it and you wouldn't even know.
47:45 Speaker 02 Yes.
47:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh.
47:47 Chuck Nice? That's cool.
47:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There's some serious science fiction material there.
47:50 Chuck Nice? There is.
47:51 Speaker 02 Yes.
47:52 Chuck Nice? Interesting. I love it.
47:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Chuck, have you met my dark matter friend?
47:57 Chuck Nice? Oh, well, he looks like a black rabbit.
47:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What's a black rabbit?
48:00 Speaker 02 Harvey the rabbit?
48:01 Chuck Nice? There you go. Harvey was a white rabbit. He's dark matter. He's a black rabbit.
48:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, sorry, okay.
48:06 Chuck Nice? I just went too far too fast. I went too far too fast. This is what happens.
48:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, Katie, thanks for joining us again.
48:12 Speaker 02 Thank you. That was fun. It was really fun.
48:14 Chuck Nice? Another great show.
48:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Now, if I remember correctly, you have kin in the city, so you...
48:18 Speaker 02 My boy, my son.
48:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Your son, so you get through town every now and then.
48:22 Speaker 02 I do, all the time.
48:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We will nab you 100% of the time.
48:25 Speaker 02 I have a rent-stabilized apartment. I just signed it to your lease, so I'll be here.
48:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Whoa.
48:31 Chuck Nice? All right.
48:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Whoa.
48:32 Speaker 02 Yeah.
48:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, we will, every time you come back here, you're coming right here, you're gonna sit right there.
48:37 Speaker 02 And actually, those queries were fun.
48:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? See, even though you hadn't heard or seen them before.
48:41 Speaker 02 That's right.
48:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, okay.
48:42 Speaker 02 They were good.
48:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, good.
48:43 Chuck Nice? Well, the audience knows you now, so believe me, they got a lot more questions for you.
48:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You got it.
48:47 Speaker 02 Sounds great. And you guys are so much fun.
48:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, well, thank you.
48:51 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
48:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, there, give me a fist bump on that. All right, all right. Yeah, we'll take it.
49:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This has been another StarTalk Cosmic Queries, a cosmology edition. I'm loving these. Nice. And how many cosmologists we got? We got Jana, we got Brian Green.
49:13 Speaker 02 Oh, Jana Levin, just so you know, was my first graduate student.
49:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Whoa!
49:18 Speaker 02 Yeah.
49:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Very cool. Whoa! Okay, we have the two Bryans. Yep. We have Brian Cox and Brian Green. That's... what more do you need? Yeah. We got... We got Chuck Lutu. Oh, Chuck Lutu, but he's not a deep cosmologist. He's an extragalactic guy. Extragalactic guy. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. All right. We got enough. Yes, enough, definitely. Anybody else out there, come on.
49:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, we gotta call it quits there. Chuck, always good to have you. Always a pleasure. Katie, you're gonna be a regular from now on.
49:45 Speaker 02 That sounds great.
49:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right.
49:46 Speaker 02 Love it.
49:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You got it. Neil deGrasse Tyson, you're a personal astrophysicist. As always, bidding you to keep looking up.
Previous True Crime & Forensic Pathology with Patricia Cornwell & Dr. Jonathan Hayes Next Our Burning Questions – Simulation Debate Page updated October 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated