Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast Cosmic Queries – Proving Einstein Right About this episode Was Albert Einstein right? Neil deGrasse Tyson, comic co-host Chuck Nice, and theoretical physicist Jim Gates, PhD, investigate general relativity, special relativity, the process of proving equations right, and answer fan-submitted Cosmic Queries!
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk, your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is StarTalk. I'm your host Neil deGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist. And today's topic is proving Einstein right. Chuck, I needed you for this one because you're the man.
0:31 Chuck Nice? I don't know how you need me because I never knew Einstein was wrong. So I'm trying to figure out where's the controversy.
0:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Where is the controversy? Well, to talk about that controversy, I'm bringing a friend and longtime colleague Jim Gates. Jim, welcome to StarTalk.
0:51 Speaker 02 Well, Neil, it's good to be back at the presence of a star.
0:56 Chuck Nice? James, please, it's okay. Thank you. Thank you. I appreciate you.
1:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, we'll leave that one at that.
1:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Jim, you've been at this for a long time. Well, you've been an Einstein fan for sure, but a theoretical physicist and you're director for the Center for Theoretical Physics at Brown University, Providence, Rhode Island. And that's a title. How long have you been doing that?
1:22 Speaker 02 So when I was 66, Neil, I was recruited from the University of Maryland to Brown. I went around telling my friends, asking friends, why do you think you want an old car?
1:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, it's not the age, it's the mileage, okay?
1:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We know this.
1:38 Speaker 02 Well, one of my friends said, Jim, you're not an old car, you're an antique car.
1:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, there you go, a preservable antique.
1:46 Speaker 02 They hold their value.
1:49 Chuck Nice? I'm gonna go one better than your friend, James. You are vintage, my friend. You are vintage. Vintage gives you even more money than antique.
1:58 Speaker 02 Okay, well, I switched after 33 years at my previous university, came here and...
2:06 Chuck Nice? Where was the previous university?
2:08 Speaker 02 University of Maryland, College Park.
2:10 Chuck Nice? Wow. And are you still on speaking terms? Because I would be kind of angry after 33 years that you just up and leave me. Just leave our marriage after 33 years.
2:21 Speaker 02 Well, I don't know if marriage is the right analogy.
2:25 Speaker 02 But independent of debating that particular
2:30 Speaker 02 we did, we did part of the term.
2:32 Chuck Nice? Excellent.
2:33 Speaker 02 In fact, in fact, I'm an emeritus professor there. And as an emeritus professor, I have taught two consecutive years courses on public policy.
2:44 Chuck Nice? Nice.
2:45 Speaker 02 Evening courses. Yep. So I'm of good terms.
2:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So if I remember correctly, you were on Obama's Advisory Council for Science and Technology, right?
2:55 Speaker 02 That's exactly right, Neil. I served seven years on the President's Council of Advisors on Science and Technology. PCAS, the Acanet.
3:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? PCAS, that's right. That's right. So, but you were in the current administration, they didn't invite you to back in there, huh?
3:10 Speaker 02 I thought we were gonna try to keep.
3:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, I just want to.
3:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right.
3:16 Speaker 02 Up enough here.
3:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We'll leave it at that. So also.
3:19 Chuck Nice? That's all right. I was invited to be on this current administration's Advisory Council on writing jokes about technology.
3:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There you go. So if you're Director of the Center, that's not necessarily an academic title, that's a job title. So you're also Professor of Physics.
3:37 Speaker 02 Indeed. I'm an endowed professor here at Brown University. The endowment is before, I'm the so-called Ford Professor of Physics. I'm also an affiliate mathematics professor. And on top of that, I'm a faculty fellow at the Watson Institute for Public Affairs and International Affairs.
3:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wow. Excellent. Excellent. Okay.
3:57 Chuck Nice? Nice stuff.
3:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you're like, we should, we should bring you back for seven other excuses. Seven other reasons. Forget the theoretical physics. We got some policy we gotta figure out here. So what we're gonna do is, we're gonna structure this program. We're gonna spend the first segment just, you know, talking about why was Einstein proved right, or why did he need to be proved right? And then we'll go to Q and A. We go to go to our cosmic queries. And Chuck, you got cosmic queries for six, two and three?
4:25 Chuck Nice? I have the questions right here, and I have to say, these are some, man, people are excited that you're here, Professor. They are excited that you're here. We got, we got some great questions.
4:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There's no one that triggers more questions than Einstein and relativity. And we got the man for it.
4:40 Speaker 02 Well, I would say Einstein, relativity and Tyson.
4:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And what?
4:44 Speaker 02 And Tyson.
4:46 Chuck Nice? Okay, right on.
4:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, so Jim, you published a book in 2019 called Proving Einstein Right, and let me get the full title, The Daring Expeditions That Changed How We Look at the Universe.
5:00 Speaker 02 Sure.
5:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And do you have a co-author? Who was that?
5:03 Speaker 02 I do have a wonderful co-author. Her name is Cathy Pelletier. She lives in Alagash, Maine, which is just right across walking to Canada. And this book is not what people expected. Usually, you know, Neil, your first book, as I recall, was partly autobiographical, right?
5:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, that was one of my first, my fourth book, yeah.
5:26 Speaker 02 Okay, fourth. So what I wanted to do with this was to do something I had never seen done before with physicists. Usually, people talk about the wonder and the majesty of looking at nature, the struggle and what have you. But what I wanted to do, and I had wanted to do this for a decade, is to write a book about the interior lives of the people who do the science. And so this book is actually dedicated to eight astronomers and Albert Einstein. And we, yes, we tell the scientific story, but what we really want to do is get inside of their heads and tell the story of what they were feeling as they went through this almost decade-long struggle. So the book surprises me.
6:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so the book is published in 2019, and if I remember my history, that's basically the centennial of this big experiment that showed that Einstein was right.
6:14 Speaker 02 That's right.
6:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But let me back up a little bit. So most people, I mean physicists know Einstein for both, for many things, of course, but for special relativity and general relativity. I think often when people think of Einstein, they think of the effects of sort of ordinary relativity, like time dilation and this sort of thing. So that would all happen in 1905.
6:40 Speaker 02 That's correct.
6:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So why, if that's all happened, and it worked, and it was, you know, it was smoking effective at explaining our understanding of the universe, why didn't everybody say, "Yeah, Einstein is the man"? Why did it have to wait another 10 years for them to prove some other thing that he did?
6:57 Speaker 02 So let me talk about Einstein in 1905, and thank you for giving me this opening. As you know, Neil, in 2005, there was this so-called Einstein Year of Physics, and there were celebrations all over the world. I gave 37 talks on six continents on Einstein in that year.
7:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I thought there were only five continents.
7:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, I guess there were seven. I get my numbers confused.
7:18 Speaker 02 I, yeah, thank you.
7:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You left out Antarctica. Yeah, okay.
7:22 Speaker 02 That because that's the one I've never been to.
7:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But the Penguins will, will welcome you with open arms.
7:28 Chuck Nice? And happy feet, yes.
7:30 Speaker 02 But the, but the point was, yes, you're right, Neil. In 1905, he came up with some amazing things about space and time and how they bend and warp and what have you. But do you know that in 1907, he was still in the patent office? People think that as soon as he came up with his one world theories, the world beat a path to his door saying Hosea, Hosea, you know, whatever. But no, no, no, that's not what happened.
7:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's Hosanna. Wait, Hosea.
7:55 Chuck Nice? Yeah. Hosea is the prophet, but Hosanna, Hosanna is the praise, but we knew what you meant.
8:03 Speaker 02 Well, this is what happens when you go off script, guys. But anyhow.
8:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm sorry.
8:09 Speaker 02 No, no, but you're right. Uh, but, but the point was that he did this great, this work, but it took two years for physics community to recognize what he had done.
8:19 Speaker 02 While he was in that patent office, still trying to figure out how to get a job as a physics professor, he looked out the window one day and he saw some workmen on a roof. And he had this sort of story coming to him that if the guy, one of the guys fell, he wouldn't feel his weight. And so that started Einstein thinking about gravity.
8:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He's thinking of the death of someone working on a roof next door. I did not know this.
8:42 Speaker 02 Well, not the actual death, but the process that would lead to it.
8:46 Chuck Nice? Just, just his fall to imminent death.
8:49 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's right. That's just an imminent fall.
8:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay. I, I did know Einstein had this morbid side of him.
8:54 Speaker 02 Yes. And so.
8:55 Chuck Nice? However, I, let me just say, I totally get it because I think about the death of the guy that blows that leaf blower outside my bedroom window every Saturday morning. So.
9:04 Speaker 02 And so Einstein started thinking about gravity. And I, so this is like in. In fact, he calls this the happiest thought of his life.
9:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, so Jim, this is like Newton's apple moment.
9:17 Speaker 02 Yes.
9:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He sees the apple falling, and then he sees the moon, and then there's a, there's a, there's a eureka moment in there.
9:24 Speaker 02 And that's what happened with Einstein in 1907. So the thing is curious about Einstein is although people think about him as this mathematical genius, every time he did something, he actually had to learn more mathematics. So he didn't actually have the mathematics to realize what his intuition was. And he didn't get it right until 1915 or 16.
9:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You know, Jim, that happens to me all the time. I have thoughts, I have to invent new math to, you know, that's just a, that's just a thing.
9:53 Speaker 02 Well, you know, some of us actually do that, Neil. That's, that's another whole story, and I'll tell you about that one later.
10:03 Speaker 02 But anyhow, so he had this idea that took him almost a decade to get it down to the mathematics. And when he finished it, it was the theory of general relativity. It's the piece of thing that tells us that there was a big bang. It's the piece of mathematics that lets us know we live in a universe that is 13.8 billion years old. And so that came from that 1917 epiphany.
10:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wow. Wait, I mean, 1907?
10:31 Speaker 02 1907.
10:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right. Right, right, right.
10:33 Speaker 02 Now, now, remember, it's all math. It's all math. So if it's all math, how do you know he got it right?
10:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, just because the math works doesn't mean it has to correspond to any objective reality.
10:46 Speaker 02 Exactly. And so when he finally gets his discussion together, in fact, even before he gets the right answer, he starts talking about it. He starts giving talks about it. And so very early on, astronomers realized, well, he realizes first, that astronomers would be critical to try to prove that his math is actually, as you said, Neil, something that happens in the real world. And he begins it by talking to this German astronomer named Erwin Finde Foinde.
11:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I never heard of it again.
11:21 Speaker 02 No one's ever heard of it.
11:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If I'd ever met someone named Irving Fenley-Foyd.
11:28 Speaker 02 Yes.
11:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'd remember that, I'm pretty sure.
11:31 Speaker 02 Well, I have sent, for your program, I've sent some photographs of all the people that we're talking about. That's the first guy that Einstein starts talking to seriously as, you know, I have a way to prove my math. And he first starts saying, if you look at starlights, could you show that starlight bends when it passes near Jupiter? And the astronomer says, you know, nah, that doesn't quite work. Then he starts asking questions about, but suppose we were looking at the night sky in the morning, or early morning or late afternoon, could we see bending starlight around perhaps Venus or something? The guy says, you know, the astronomers go back, no, no, that won't work. And so finally, by this set of discussions with Freihlitz, he hits upon the idea that if you could watch starlight during an eclipse,
12:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right.
12:16 Speaker 02 that might be able to see the light being bent by the sun.
12:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because you can't otherwise see a star in broad daylight.
12:23 Speaker 02 Exactly. So, you know, it's very special circumstance. And so that's the race.
12:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so this bending of starlight would have been the first experimental verification of his general theory of relativity.
12:38 Speaker 02 Yes.
12:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And, okay, and so, so now, so what year did that happen? Was that?
12:43 Speaker 02 This is, this is, these conversations around 1912 or so that he starts telling other people about this idea.
12:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, and that's how you get the creativity of other people to help you figure out how to make it work.
12:54 Speaker 02 Bingo. And that's what our book is about. It's about the other people. It's not really about Einstein.
12:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so what's all this we hear about his wife possibly being a big engine to his creativity?
13:05 Speaker 02 A lot of people have, well, this is one book, Einstein's Wife, I think is the title. There are a lot of people who have posited that as, as having been important. But from my reading of the history, she was certainly his partner as he was working through in Bern as a poor patent examiner trying to do physics. She was certainly a partner that he-
13:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Bern, this city in Germany?
13:31 Speaker 02 The city in Switzerland.
13:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, Switzerland, excuse me, right, right.
13:35 Speaker 02 He was, so she certainly was his partner there. But in the actual settling of the special theory of relativity from, and I've read over a dozen books trying to get this straight in my own head, the preponderance of evidence is that he worked it out with the friend of his on a train, on a tram ride, thinking about the clock tower in the city of Bern. So, I mean, it's a fantastic story. So-
14:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What you're saying here, Jim, is had Einstein been a loner and not traveled anywhere, he wouldn't have come up with any of his ideas.
14:10 Speaker 02 That's actually-
14:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I mean, how much life exposure is the right amount to fully realize your creativity that can be expressed?
14:23 Speaker 02 I tell people all the time that being a scientist means that you swim in a sea of information, and that information comes from your colleagues. And so you cannot be, I mean, I know the archetype, stereotyped view is that as a scientist, you go off in the corner and you sort of think big thoughts. But that's not what actually happens. I've lived this life for almost, for over thirty years, and you are constantly in conversation with your colleagues. And you use them to hone and to refine your thoughts and distill your thoughts and curate your thoughts.
14:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Jim, the active word there is that you are swimming in these influences, not drowning in the influence. I was gonna say, yeah.
15:05 Speaker 02 Yeah. So that's where, that's why we're, with Kathy Pelletier, we wanted to talk about these people that basically were using what Einstein inspired them to do, but to swim towards this discovery of whether his math was an accurate description of nature.
15:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wow. Do you think Einstein had any doubts about whether it was all true?
15:31 Speaker 02 From my reading, no. He sort of says, you know, he sort of says things like, if the theory of general relativity had failed to receive experimental and observation support, that he would have felt sorry for the good Lord.
15:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because that was a really brilliant idea.
15:49 Chuck Nice? Right.
15:52 Chuck Nice? Which is, which is kind of say, a kind of way of saying like, I'm smarter than God, so.
15:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It definitely says that.
15:59 Speaker 02 No, it doesn't. It really doesn't.
16:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, Jim, Jim, you're lying. Jim.
16:02 Speaker 02 No, I'm not lying. If you read a lot about Einstein, you find out he's a very, very complicated character. And with, and Chuck, since you brought up the issue of God.
16:13 Chuck Nice? Okay.
16:14 Speaker 02 And you did bring it up.
16:15 Chuck Nice? I did, yeah. I mean, to me, when somebody says that statement, it kind of sounds like, you know, I'm smarter than God.
16:23 Speaker 02 No, no, but you see, Einstein's, although you can interpret that statement that way, that's not really what Einstein felt. Because in fact, he talks also about the illimitable spirit. That is a spirit without limits. So it's clear that if you can use a phrase like that, you're not putting yourself above such an entity.
16:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
16:45 Chuck Nice? All right, that's a very good point.
16:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He didn't use that phrase in that sentence, though, but okay.
16:50 Speaker 02 Not in that sentence.
16:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In that moment, he felt badass, is all I'm saying.
16:56 Chuck Nice? Yeah, yeah, yeah, it's not, yeah.
16:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because it is, you know, Jim, before we go into the second segment and solicit our, our cosmic queries, just give me a minute or two, I know it should be hours or two, but give me a minute or two on the idea that math is just something we invented as humans.
17:18 Speaker 02 Yeah.
17:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And it, and it works. What's up with that? There's no reason that it should work at all.
17:24 Speaker 02 You know, Neil, this is one of the most. This is the only piece of magic that I've ever experienced and seen in reality.
17:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'd love that. I'd love that. It's magic.
17:35 Speaker 02 It's a piece of magic, but it happens to be a part of our reality. I don't know of any other form of magic for which I can say this.
17:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And this is human-created magic. We create something and it magically describes reality. And enables you to predict and understand and extend.
17:55 Speaker 02 It acts like a third eye for those of us who are scientists. It lets us see things that are not seeable otherwise. I made a presentation at the New York Academy of Sciences about three years ago, two years ago. And it's precisely on this point of the magic ability of mathematics. It's an hour-long interview, so I'm not going to bore you with it, but I would...
18:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, is it on YouTube or something?
18:20 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's available on YouTube.
18:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, forgive me. I'll go find it. I'm gonna find it. Okay, the New York Academy of Sciences, a long-venerated institution.
18:29 Speaker 02 Absolutely. And I was there with Margaret Worktime. And we discussed this magical thing, this thing about mathematics. And at the end of the day, one of the things I said about it is that mathematics, as people like me use it, it's the only human language that we know accurately allows us to describe nature. However, any other conscious being that could produce mathematics will have access to this knowledge.
19:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So hence the idea that if we meet up with aliens, we might start with this symbolic representation of what is and is not.
19:08 Speaker 02 Sure.
19:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And math could be the only way we can prevent ourselves from getting our brains sucked out by the evil ways.
19:15 Speaker 02 Many of us think that that's right.
19:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So when we come back, more of this edition of StarTalk, where we're talking about proving Einstein right. And we're gonna go straight to our Cosmic Queries version of that, where we return.
19:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We're back, StarTalk, proving Einstein right.
19:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Chuck, thanks for being there.
19:57 Chuck Nice? Always a pleasure.
19:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And we got Sylvester Jim Gates, a longtime friend and colleague, who's an Einstein expert, a theoretical physics expert. He's all the kind of expert you need for this.
20:12 Chuck Nice? Absolutely.
20:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? For this incarnation of StarTalk. And we're going to devote this segment to cosmic queries. Jim, your presence on our show was announced to our fanbase, and they got completely excited by this prospect. And so, so I have 5%, no, I have 3% overlap with Jim's expertise in the subject. If I can find a 3% way to add, I will. But basically, this is all going to Jim. So Chuck.
20:41 Chuck Nice? Excellent.
20:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Do it.
20:43 Chuck Nice? Not that it needs to be said, but I have 0% overlap with Jim, which is why I'm reading the question. So here we go.
20:53 Chuck Nice? Let's start, you know what? Before we start, let me just quickly, can you, Professor, give us a quick breakdown between the special and the general? When it comes to relatively? I think that might be a nice framework for anybody who didn't ask a question to be a part.
21:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Good.
21:11 Speaker 02 Thank you, Chuck. So let me start with special because it's simpler. You know, if you were standing by a road, and there was a car that was speeding towards you with its horn blaring, what would you actually hear? It would go something like, "Ohhh."
21:28 Chuck Nice? Right.
21:29 Speaker 02 Right, because you hear that dip in the tone.
21:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It sounded like you were dying.
21:33 Chuck Nice? I was gonna say.
21:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You know, I could do better than that. Here you go, ready?
21:41 Speaker 02 Okay, so we'll go with-
21:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Let's work with that, nothing's dying.
21:43 Speaker 02 We'll work with the cat sound.
21:46 Chuck Nice? By the way, in his spare time, Neil does sound effects for Warner Brothers.
21:50 Speaker 02 I can see. And so, but, so the point is, that effect is because sound changes its frequency if you're, if it's moving towards you, that's when it's high pitched. Or, but if it's moving away from you, this pitch goes down.
22:06 Speaker 03 Meow.
22:08 Speaker 02 Exactly. So, so the, so the point is, so the point is, light actually does the same thing. When a light source is coming towards you, it appears to be bluer than it actually is. When it's moving away from you, it is appearing to be redder. And that is one of the primary effects of special relativity. It's about the relative motion of you and the source of the light. In my car analogy, it's this motion of the car either towards or with you. So that's what special relativity is all about is, if I'm moving and you're not, how do I perceive things? How do you perceive things? That's the simplest, that's my five minute class on special relativity.
22:49 Chuck Nice? Cool.
22:50 Speaker 02 We good?
22:51 Chuck Nice? And so, and then-
22:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Now, general, now, general relativity.
22:53 Chuck Nice? And you juxtapose that against the general and the distribution of mass and all that stuff.
22:58 Speaker 02 So the general theory of relativity is something very, very, very different. And what the general theory of relativity is about is, what is gravity? You see, in the special relativity, Einstein wasn't thinking about gravity. He was just thinking about how things would look if I'm moving. But in the general theory of relativity, theory of relativity, the question is, what actually is gravity? It's a very deep question that even Sir Isaac Newton didn't get the answer to. And the answer that Einstein teaches us through his mathematical wizardry is that gravity is the space which we move through and time which we experience durations in.
23:42 Speaker 02 Our combines this like thing he called spacetime and gravity is the bending of this thing. So that's my short course of general relativity.
23:50 Chuck Nice? Cool.
23:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, there you go.
23:52 Chuck Nice? All right. That was great. That was great. Okay, let's go to Izzy Rohr, who says.
23:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, is this Patreon? Do we do Patreon people first?
23:58 Chuck Nice? Yes, sir. Thank you. Um, yes, we always start with a Patreon question because Patreon people give us money. So, and, and for that we are grateful and we show our gratitude by giving you special preference.
24:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, so wait, wait.
24:14 Chuck Nice? Yeah, we're just like Congress. We're just like your congressman.
24:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But Chuck, this just in, apparently all your questions are Patreon questions. I have just learned.
24:22 Chuck Nice? Oh, excellent.
24:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This just in, this just in.
24:25 Chuck Nice? Every single one of them. So guess what? All of you.
24:27 Speaker 02 Let's go.
24:28 Chuck Nice? So thank you to all of you. Izzy Rohr, Neil, Chuck, Jim, this is your friend Violetta, the astrophysics-loving kid here in Birmingham, Alabama. My mom, oh, you know her? Okay, cool.
24:38 Speaker 02 We've been in contact.
24:39 Chuck Nice? Excellent. My mom and I have many discussions, have had many discussions about this. Scientists like to describe Einstein's general relativity as being incompatible with quantum mechanics. They say things like they mathematically don't work out, uh, or don't work together. So our question is, why the heck is that?
25:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Jim, yeah, what, what's up with that?
25:07 Speaker 02 Okay, so let, let me, give me a second here because I got to phrase this without the mathematics.
25:13 Speaker 02 So the idea.
25:14 Chuck Nice? That is so funny, by the way. Okay, let me just say, that may have been the most physics thing I've heard in a very long time. I've, I've got to figure out a way to say this without the mathematics.
25:29 Speaker 02 Well, you see, I don't know if you.
25:31 Chuck Nice? It's like, I'm sorry, me no speak English, me speak mathematics.
25:36 Speaker 02 Well, Chuck, you, Chuck, Chuck, you may not know this, but Neil can tell you this. Often at the end of my email messages, I ask forgiveness for spelling and punctuation errors because my first language is mathematics.
25:50 Chuck Nice? Ooh. Oh, snap.
25:53 Speaker 02 English is my second language. So, so I'm at a disability when people ask me to talk.
25:59 Chuck Nice? Listen, I've never heard a person admit a fault that makes you better than most people.
26:12 Speaker 02 I don't know about that, but it causes me difficulties Chuck on many, many occasions.
26:17 Chuck Nice? Okay.
26:18 Speaker 02 Okay, but to, okay, but to.
26:20 Chuck Nice? Back to quantum.
26:21 Speaker 02 Back to quantum. Okay, so what essentially happens is if you believe the universe is quantum mechanical, then it forces you to forget about things like electrons, because electrons we think about as little tiny balls. That's the classical picture that you're taught. And in fact, quantum mechanics says, no, that's not the way it works for electrons. You have to think of these things that are more like waves, except when they act like particles. So that's the first thing quantum. It gives you this really weird thing that you have to give up an idea, except sometimes, right?
26:55 Chuck Nice? Right.
26:56 Speaker 02 Okay, so now when you, so there's a piece of mathematics around this called Schrodinger's equation. So I gotta bring that in. And it tells you how to calculate.
27:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If you're gonna bring up Schrodinger, you can't leave out his cat. So just keep going.
27:06 Chuck Nice? Or that litter box which hasn't been changed in God knows how long.
27:11 Speaker 02 Schrodinger's litter box.
27:13 Chuck Nice? That's what I'm about. Schrodinger's litter box.
27:15 Speaker 02 We can also go back to Neil's, uh, Neil's rendition of a car horn as it approaches you.
27:25 Speaker 02 But anyhow, uh, so you have a piece of mathematics around giving up the idea of particles. And when you now give that piece of mathematics up and try to do gravity, you find out you just get into a total mess, that you cannot calculate answers anymore that take into account the quantum behavior. And that's the mess.
27:44 Chuck Nice? So that's the, that's the disconnect there, is that Schrodinger's equation, once you remove anything, does, none of the gravity stuff works.
27:54 Speaker 02 Because the way that Einstein and Newton and all those folks thought about gravity has the idea of particles embedded in it. That's the problem.
28:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, right. So, alright, so, uh, who's, at the end of the day, who's gotta give? Is it, is, is gravity gonna bend to quantum physics?
28:11 Chuck Nice? I see what you did there. I, I saw what you did there, Neil.
28:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? With the gravity bends, yeah.
28:15 Chuck Nice? Yes.
28:18 Speaker 02 Oh, you know, Neil, this is actually a very deep question.
28:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Or is there a third idea, bigger than both of those, that then encloses them under one umbrella?
28:28 Chuck Nice? Ooh.
28:29 Speaker 02 There are variants of all, of everything that you've just said. There, well, first of all, who's gonna bend? There are people who will tell you that gravity's gonna be one that loses this discussion.
28:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If I had to bet, I'd lean that way, too, yeah.
28:44 Speaker 02 Yeah, and there are a lot of people who believe that, that somehow gravity is going to have to give way in, uh, in some manner. There are other people who have this, uh, third idea approach, uh, that you were talking about, Neil. And one of those, uh, and sort of emblematic of that is a discussion that's underway about information and black holes. Uh, I know Neil is probably aware of this, but there's this whole discussion about whether information is conserved, like we say, energy is conserved, is information conserved? And if you have a universe with black holes, doesn't that mean that some of the energy disappear, I mean, some of the information disappears? And then you violate a cons- uh, conservation law? So there's a whole big discussion in theoretical physics that's been away, underway for over a decade about black holes and information compromise.
29:27 Chuck Nice? Alright, so when you talk about information, are, are you referring to, cause we just talked about this last week, give me one second, please? That when Neil was talking about virtual particles and the evaporation of a black hole, and if I'm not mistaken, then this particle actually materializes on the outside of the black hole, and then that is what escapes? And so then, if that were to happen, are you saying that that somehow messes up this whole idea of the comprom- conservation of information?
29:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Chuck, you were really paying attention in that episode.
29:59 Speaker 02 It does seem like it.
30:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Man, Chuck!
30:02 Chuck Nice? Neil, why you think I do this job, man? I'm getting a free education!
30:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Man, Chuck!
30:07 Chuck Nice? Yeah, okay, so that's what, okay, that's.
30:10 Speaker 02 No, but the point is that it's in a state of flux. We don't know what the final solution is gonna be. But many people like me, uh, actually think that string theory will have something to do with the resolution.
30:24 Chuck Nice? Okay.
30:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So the string people think this, yeah?
30:27 Speaker 02 Well, it's not just string people, I think. Uh, I, I don't consider myself a string person, for example. I am someone who's spent their life working on supersymmetry and strings happen to intersect that.
30:37 Chuck Nice? Okay, well, I consider myself a string cheese person, so.
30:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? String cheese, yes.
30:43 Chuck Nice? That's about as close as I'm getting to it. All right, cool.
30:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, go on, next one.
30:47 Chuck Nice? Here we go. This is Paul Vogel, who says, "Recently, between the detection of gravitational waves and a photo of an event horizon of a black hole, some significant predictions made by Einstein's general relativity have been verified. What's the next big prediction made by general relativity that scientists are testing?" Thank you.
31:11 Speaker 02 So that's a great question, and it's a great question, and the answer is the following. In 1905, one of, Einstein wrote four papers. Among those four papers is one that points out that energy has to be quantized. Now, we know that Einstein doesn't like quantum theory, but in fact, he's one of the fathers of quantum theory because of this 1905 paper on the photoelectric effect, that when you.
31:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just to be clear, he didn't like it because he didn't think the universe should be probabilistic, right?
31:46 Speaker 02 That's exactly right. He wanted determinism, as it's called, whereas as quantum mechanics says, no, you can't have determinism. You have to go with probabilities. So the answer to your question, Chuck, is now that we have seen waves of gravity, we want to see the quantization of the energy carried by those waves. Because when we do that, we will have the Star Trek graviton.
32:07 Chuck Nice? Yes.
32:08 Speaker 02 In our universe.
32:10 Chuck Nice? So the same way we know light has a particle, are you saying that gravity has particle? Or, wait a minute, it, it would, it would have to be that we find this gravity particle?
32:20 Speaker 02 That's correct. That's the next big prediction that. Want to find from the kind of experiments watching gravitoids. You want to be able to see the quantization of the energy that the gravity waves hold. That tells you that gravitons, just like you hear in Star Trek. You know, all this talk about graviton waves. At that point, it is no longer science fiction. It's a piece of science.
32:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, and Chuck, just to follow your line. So a photon is a particle of light, but you can also speak of light as waves.
32:50 Speaker 02 Right.
32:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, so that so that is a proper analogy. We've measured gravitational waves. Now we want to measure the gravitational particle.
32:58 Speaker 02 Oh, my God.
32:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You have a photon, then you have the graviton. So so so I don't know any experiments out there to measure a graviton. Is there something in the works?
33:06 Speaker 02 No, nothing to my knowledge, Neil. I don't know anyone who's this is going to have to be an exquisite experiment. And we're just at the stage of just being able to see the gravity waves. So, you know, is it 50 years, is it 100 years? I don't know. But as our technology improves, someone is eventually going to figure out how to do that detection. And then we can stop saying that Captain Kirk is the only only guy who gets to talk about gravitons.
33:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So if just a quick question. If we have gravitons, then gravity being the curvature of space and time has no meaning in the presence of a graviton.
33:45 Speaker 02 Ah, you're following along here. For a lot of people, the detection of a graviton will likely necessitate a real rethinking of what of what gravity is. I've already, I mean, some of us already are there. I don't actually think about gravity in terms of geometry. It's field theory. That's the tool for people like us.
34:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right. So what you're saying is Einstein's curved space happens to be a convenience in certain under certain situations that gets you the right answer.
34:15 Speaker 02 Yes.
34:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you're good with that, but it's not the total story.
34:18 Speaker 02 Nope.
34:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay. Wow. There you go. Okay. Yeah, that is. So just let let the record show Chuck that Jim Gates just said Einstein had his head up his ass.
34:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He just said that, just to make it clear.
34:35 Chuck Nice? That's funny. Okay. James is like, "I'm not saying that."
34:40 Speaker 02 I'm not saying that.
34:41 Chuck Nice? James is like, "I'm not saying that."
34:45 Chuck Nice? He was like, "Send your letters to Neil."
34:50 Chuck Nice? The professor's like, "Send your letters to Neil, because I did not say that." Okay.
34:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Actually, we gotta take a break, and when we come back, we'll go through our third and final segment of Cosmic Queries, Proving Einstein Right on StarTalk.
35:16 Chuck Nice? Hey, we'd like to give a Patreon shout out to the following Patreon patrons, Beverly Bellows and Christopher Mank. Guys, thank you so much. What would we do without you as we make our way across the cosmos and create this show for everyone to enjoy? And if you're listening would like your very own Patreon shout out, please go to patreon.com/startalkradio and support us.
35:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We're back, StarTalk, Proving Einstein Right. And Chuck is helping me, you know, in his, because he's, you're a big fan of Special and General Relativity, aren't you Chuck?
36:02 Chuck Nice? Oh, without a doubt. Are you kidding me? Come on, man.
36:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, of course.
36:08 Chuck Nice? I mean.
36:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But of course.
36:10 Chuck Nice? Some people like reality TV. I like rela-TV. Okay, that didn't work.
36:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, that just so did not work. But anyhow.
36:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But you're on social media. What's your best place people can find you on social media?
36:23 Chuck Nice? At Chuck Nice Comic. Thank you, sir. Appreciate that.
36:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Chuck Nice Comic. And you even have a, I stumbled on this, you never told me this, I stumbled on one of your, you have a TED Talk. On technology in the future.
36:33 Chuck Nice? I do, technology and the unintended consequences of human interactions.
36:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, or the absence of human interaction via technology. Yes, I stumbled on that. I'm angry with you for not telling me in advance about that. I have to find that on my own. We've got Jim Gates, an expert in theoretical physics. Jim, do you have a social media platform?
36:53 Speaker 02 I do. It's Dr. Jim Gates. You can see on, there's a Twitter version and a Facebook version.
36:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Doctor, it's just D R, I presume?
37:02 Speaker 02 Just D R.
37:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, all right. We'll find you there. And you've got this book, Proving Einstein Right.
37:07 Speaker 02 Yes.
37:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And co-authored with Kathy Pettier.
37:11 Speaker 02 Yes.
37:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah. So we're continuing our cosmic queries. And just before we begin, and Chuck, before you read one in. Jim, you've got a background there that looks, it looks kind of spacey, actually, but then not quite.
37:24 Speaker 02 Yes.
37:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Could you give us a minute on that?
37:26 Speaker 02 Sure. So I'm in the odd position, Neil, where it looks like both of my twin children are going to become physicists. So this is, you know, this is not something I set out to do, but.
37:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, right. Yeah. Keep telling yourself that, okay?
37:42 Speaker 02 So my daughter works on black holes. And so she's actually, actually started publishing. And I actually had a chance to watch her give a talk this week. So, you know, big props to my daughter. Her name is Delilah. But I also got to give big props to my son. The background that you're looking at, these green little splotches are artificial neurons that he's been growing in the laboratory because it looks like he's going to be a biophysicist.
38:06 Chuck Nice? Wow.
38:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, Chuck, he's, he's, he's creating the next generation superhero or superhero villain.
38:12 Chuck Nice? Without a doubt.
38:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Black holes and growing neurons?
38:16 Chuck Nice? So that, so that. The daughter will harness the power of the black hole and the son will imbue some, some being with that, with that power to rule the world.
38:28 Speaker 02 Have you ever heard of, have you ever worried about dark side?
38:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The dark side, there it is.
38:33 Chuck Nice? Right.
38:34 Speaker 02 Who knows?
38:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Jim is breeding the dark side. So this, so this, is it an actual photo? Or it looks like artwork?
38:40 Speaker 02 No, no, it looks like art. This is actual photo of some of the first successful cell lines that he's been growing that where you can see the evidence that they're developing a ganglia like real brain cells.
38:52 Chuck Nice? Sweet, man.
38:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
38:54 Chuck Nice? Wow, that's amazing.
38:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We'll watch that space.
38:56 Chuck Nice? That's so important. Okay, cool.
38:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, let's get to the next question. Chuck?
39:00 Chuck Nice? Yeah, big brain stuff going on in that family.
39:04 Chuck Nice? All right, here we go. Let's, um, let's go to, uh, let's go to Lisa Hansen. And she says, hello to you all from the Bay Area. String theories are so involved and fascinating. I love trying to wrap my brain around them. I'm wondering what, if any, other scientific disciplines are involved in the research for evidence and proof of these theories? What those clues might be?
39:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well. Yeah, clues in this real universe, Jim, and not some imagined one.
39:35 Chuck Nice? I know he was gonna say.
39:36 Speaker 02 It's very interesting that that question came up because just last summer, I did something for the first time in my life. Because I tell people, I exist at the boundary of mathematics and physics, so I'm a fallen mathematician in some sense. But last summer, I published a paper along with my colleague Stefan Alexander here at Brown University, Evan McDonough, who was one of our post-docs, and my post-doc, Konstantinos Koutourakis, as well as our graduate student, Leah Jinks. And in this paper, we set out a premise that strings might be able to write structures,
40:19 Speaker 02 create structures that could potentially be observed in the cosmic microwave background.
40:25 Speaker 02 We call these structures Susy Reels. They're like these funny patterns. I hope people are familiar with the CMB. It's this microwave radiation that you can detect by looking at the universe. And what we showed in our paper is if you take string, the ideas of string theory seriously, they have a way of writing a kind of signature in this structure. So what kind of science do you need? You need to be an astrophysicist, someone who could actually look in microwaves at how the universe gives us a perspective.
40:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Once again, it comes down to the astrophysicist.
40:59 Chuck Nice? There you go.
40:59 Speaker 02 Of course, absolutely. I start, look, Einstein.
41:03 Chuck Nice? But now, wait.
41:04 Speaker 02 Einstein needed astronomers.
41:05 Chuck Nice? Right.
41:06 Speaker 02 String theory may well need astrophysicists.
41:09 Chuck Nice? So that begs the question, in that collaboration, who was Batman and who was Robin?
41:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just a quick thing, if I remember, Stefan Alexander, isn't he, he's the jazz musician, isn't that correct?
41:27 Speaker 02 That's exactly right. Stefan is a professional level jazz musician, although he is a physicist on faculty here at Brown University.
41:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I should have said that differently. He's also a jazz musician. So he wrote that book, The Jazz of Physics, or The Physics of Jazz, or something?
41:41 Speaker 02 That's not The Jazz, so Physics is his work.
41:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, okay.
41:43 Chuck Nice? All right, cool, man. All right, great stuff. That's great stuff. Let's move on to Josh B., who says, who has more impressive mustache, Albert Einstein or Neil deGrasse Tyson?
41:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Do you know, I gotta say, anytime I'm on, I gotta show up in a movie or in a documentary, and they put you in hair and makeup, you know, and so they do the makeup, fine. And then they get to the hair, and they say, can we trim your eyebrows a little? And can we get some of the loose hairs out of your mustache? And I'm saying, wait, this is my Einstein look. You want to be all trimmed and manscaped?
42:17 Chuck Nice? You need a wiry, unkempt, just wild mustache.
42:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, so what's with that look, Jim, that Einstein sported?
42:25 Speaker 02 So, I'm not sure what the question is.
42:32 Chuck Nice? You know what? With that as the answer, we should just move on.
42:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We should just move on.
42:37 Chuck Nice? That was hilarious. Let's just go to Sam O'Neill.
42:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
42:41 Chuck Nice? Who says?
42:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, wait, just about eight years ago, I just want you to know I was nominated for the Mustache Hall of Fame.
42:47 Chuck Nice? Okay.
42:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just so you know. Okay. Just so you know.
42:49 Chuck Nice? Right on.
42:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
42:50 Speaker 02 Well, I'm going to return that I was once inducted into the Luxuriant Hair Association.
42:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Very nice. That's a thing?
42:58 Speaker 02 It was at the time.
42:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
43:01 Chuck Nice? Okay. Okay, here we go. This is from Sam O'Neill. He says, hey, Dr. Tyson, hey, Dr. Gates, what's up, Chuck? My question is, what do you theorize that the strings in superstring theory are made of? Love you guys. I would give you money, and I do. Samantha from Earth.
43:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? From Earth.
43:23 Chuck Nice? I love that.
43:24 Speaker 02 Well, my question is PayPal?
43:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, we don't. It's Patreon on this side of that.
43:32 Speaker 02 Oh, okay, okay. Well, someone's got to explain that to me, you know?
43:36 Chuck Nice? There you go.
43:37 Speaker 02 Well.
43:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's all you, Jim, so go for it.
43:39 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah. So the thing about string theory, which perhaps isn't completely understood, is that we don't think strings are made of anything. They are the fundamental thing if it's a correct picture of the universe.
43:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They are the thing everything else is made of.
43:54 Speaker 02 That's right.
43:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So therefore you can't say what it's made of, because it is the thing that everything's made of.
44:00 Speaker 02 That's all we know.
44:02 Chuck Nice? Wow, that.
44:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That feels like a cop-out.
44:04 Chuck Nice? I was about to say, that's a little circular.
44:07 Speaker 02 Yeah, but.
44:08 Chuck Nice? That's slightly circular.
44:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just a little.
44:11 Speaker 02 No, no, Chuck, you're right. But you see, one of the weird things about mathematics is that you have to take some things on faith. There's actually a mathematical theorem that says this. It's called one of Göth's theorems. So this is one of the really weird things about math that people do not appreciate.
44:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, no, Jim, be fair. It's not that you have to take it on faith, it's that you have to assert that it's true. If you assert that it's true, then everything else works. It's assertion. It's not, gee, I hope it's the... No, you just declare that it's true and then take everything from there. But you can't prove, you can't prove the thing that you assert that's true. That's not fair.
44:50 Speaker 02 And therefore, it's an element of faith, Neil.
44:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I don't, I don't, I use faith in a different...
44:54 Speaker 02 I know, I know you do. We have to have another discussion about it.
44:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A whole faith. We'll get you, I said, we'll get you back seven other ways on this.
45:01 Chuck Nice? Without a doubt.
45:02 Speaker 02 I'd love to talk to you about it.
45:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Forget Einstein. We got other, we got other business to resolve here.
45:06 Chuck Nice? If only George Michael were here to settle this debate. Okay. Sorry, pop culture reference project, shouldn't have brought it in. Here we go.
45:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? From 1987.
45:13 Chuck Nice? I know, I know.
45:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Damn, Chuck.
45:16 Chuck Nice? I can't help it.
45:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How old are you? Damn.
45:19 Speaker 02 He looks young, doesn't he, Neil?
45:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He does. He's, he's, he uses that oil of old age.
45:24 Chuck Nice? Yeah, oil of old age?
45:27 Speaker 02 That's exactly what he said.
45:29 Chuck Nice? Okay, I never heard that before. I like that.
45:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I heard that from an old friend of mine said that.
45:33 Chuck Nice? Oil of old age. I like it. All right, here we go. Uh, this is Woody. He says, after seeing Neil's enthusiastic response, what are Jim's thoughts on a cosmic gravitational background? And you just talked about the cosmic microwave background and string being able to be visible in that. What about a cosmic gravitational background? Do you have any thoughts?
45:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So this would be, this would be the paw print of the birth of the universe expressed in gravitational way.
46:01 Chuck Nice? Right, right.
46:01 Speaker 02 Would be, and I don't see, I've never actually heard a scientific discussion of this. But that idea, it really seems well grounded, that one could have met, no, that if one could, I mean, look, the cosmic microwave background is an electromagnetic background, is microwaves, right? Just like the microwaves you cook.
46:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's light, it's light.
46:23 Speaker 02 Right, it's a form of light.
46:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right.
46:25 Speaker 02 But, uh, but a gravitational background, a gravitational signature from the Big Bang? I don't see any reason why that's not possible. I've not heard of any scientific discussions of the concept, how.
46:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so part of why the, the cosmic microwave background is so useful to us. Not only that it exists, but we have a map, a very detailed map of its structure. And right now, when we're detecting gravitational waves, oh, something happened, we think over in that direction of the sky. You know, we don't, we have nowhere near the, the mapping precision to possibly do anything interesting yet. And I don't know when it would come.
46:59 Speaker 02 Oh, I would give us about 20 to 30 years because what, in order to do what you're saying, Neil, first of all, we have to get a sufficient number of gravity wave detectors. Right now, there are about four in the world that are one, there's one, for example, in Europe, there's one in Australia, and there are two in the US. So that's the minimum number you need to do the mapping. And they're not all sort of up fully functional. So we got some time.
47:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right. And then you need, then you want to get gravitational waves of different wavelengths. Right? And so that, so it's not just this one that came through. Get the whole spectrum, if I can borrow that word from light. And then you have this two dimensions of information.
47:41 Speaker 02 Exactly.
47:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? To interpret. So, yeah, so, yeah, so we're not there yet, but if we were there, it would tell us a whole lot about the very first moments of the.
47:49 Speaker 02 Exactly. And that's where science is pushing toward.
47:52 Chuck Nice? Cool. That is super, super cool. All right. Roman Precup or Precop says this, is it possible that some of the stars observed in the night sky are duplicated or multiply duplicated due to light bending and gravitational fields of a massive object like super, like some super black hole?
48:15 Speaker 02 I should let Neil.
48:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, I could, I could take that.
48:18 Speaker 02 Thank you. Go ahead, Neil.
48:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, I, I could take that one. So the answer is yes. Uh, next, next question.
48:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, so what happens is that the way this unfold, um, by the way, Einstein first predicted that you can make a ring. Einstein ring where the light would bend symmetrically in all directions around a single object and create a ring of light from that single object from behind. It turns out that's not realistic because that that requires exact lineup.
48:49 Chuck Nice? Right.
48:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that there's a perfect geometry of all sightlines that go around it. Most things don't line up exactly, but when we do find them sort of lineup, even if not exactly, you find distortions that resemble rings. They're arcs.
49:03 Chuck Nice? Right.
49:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They don't make a full ring, but they make arcs. Now, if you have one object behind, that object will make a minimum of three images. One that comes straight through, and then two that come around the side.
49:14 Chuck Nice? Mm hmm.
49:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And up from there, it can make three, five, or seven images. So yes.
49:20 Chuck Nice? Right.
49:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In fact, we did something cool. It's something cool. You ready? Ready? Okay. So we found, we found objects, quasars, whose light bent around gravity, uh, uh, uh, galaxy clusters that were sort of midway.
49:32 Chuck Nice? Right.
49:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right? From Einstein's gravity. And, but the path lengths were not the same.
49:39 Chuck Nice? Hmm.
49:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so this, this, the path on one side is a little longer than the path on the other. And you know how we know? Because quasars vary. They have explosions. The light varies. So we see it, and it varies up here, and then a scheduled time later, it varies over in exactly the same way. So you get to see the same event twice.
50:00 Chuck Nice? That's because of the change in intensity of light due to the explosion? Is that what's happening?
50:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, no, there are things, yeah, the quasars can eat things episodically.
50:07 Chuck Nice? Okay.
50:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A lot of weird things, episodic things that can happen in quasars. But the fact that you have two different path lengths is extraordinary testing of the shape of the curvature of space, and how much gravity is in the cluster, and how far away the, the quasar is. So it's, it's an amazing, it's an amazing thing.
50:24 Speaker 02 So it's funny, it's funny to me that you've come back to this because this is what my daughter works on. We talked about the cells behind me, but you, but when you have rings of matter around rotating black holes.
50:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Chuck, he's just giving equal time here.
50:36 Chuck Nice? I know.
50:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because he didn't want to pick his children.
50:38 Chuck Nice? He's a good dad.
50:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He's a good dad, good dad. Go on, good dad.
50:42 Speaker 02 You know, so, but when you have rings of matter that glow around spinning black holes, you can actually see the backside of the ring because the gravity bends the light from the little growing black. That's what my daughter works on.
50:53 Chuck Nice? Yeah, that's, that's very cool, man.
50:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Uh, one, one last quick one and we'll, uh, and we gotta call, we, we, we're over time.
51:00 Chuck Nice? We'll be done with it. Okay.
51:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, Chuck, go ahead.
51:02 Chuck Nice? Uh, this is from Glenn. He says, uh, Dr. Gates, do you think that white holes exist? Was Einstein observing gave, uh, what was Einstein observing that gave him the impression that they did? All right. Now I'm just going to answer this for you. No, there are no white holes. Einstein was racist like everybody else back at that time and just couldn't let it be just black.
51:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Started off Chuck.
51:29 Chuck Nice? Couldn't just let it be a black hole, could you? Okay. Yeah. So, no, of course.
51:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Chuck got it right off his chest.
51:35 Chuck Nice? You know what? I love, here's what I love about the professor. He's sitting there like, I have nothing to do with this. Whatever Chuck is saying right now, that's his crazy business.
51:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I only just met Chuck.
51:44 Chuck Nice? Exactly. He's like, I don't know this man. All right, go ahead. Sorry.
51:50 Speaker 02 Okay, so what's
51:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, make it quick, Jim.
51:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, so what's really quick, what's really interesting is that black holes aren't black. It turns out that because of Stephen Hawking, we know that they actually had this very slight radiation called Hawking radiation. So they're not exactly black. That went out a long time ago. So, you know, got to keep up with the news and physics.
52:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, but the white hole concept.
52:13 Speaker 02 The white hole concept, I, I
52:18 Speaker 02 People who, look, I don't know any solid scientific arguments about the existence of such things. I have not encountered.
52:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay. And plus, we don't see anything in the universe that would resemble what a white hole would be predicted to be, which would be the mathematical opposite of a black hole, right? So everything is spewing out, and that should look like something in the signature of light.
52:37 Speaker 02 Be something spectacular. We don't see it.
52:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah. But we really gotta cut it there. Jim, okay, we gotta get you back for nine other subjects.
52:44 Speaker 02 That's okay, Neil. I'm game.
52:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We got you on the Rolodex.
52:48 Speaker 02 I got game.
52:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right. And we'll get a picture from your other child's twin child behind you on the next program.
52:53 Speaker 02 Okay. Black holes, man. Black holes.
52:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Chuck, always good to have you. Always a pleasure. All right. This has been StarTalk. I'm Neil deGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist, as always. Keep looking up.
Previous Cosmic Crib, with Rainn Wilson Next Baseball Physics, with Bill Nye Page updated September 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated