Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast Cosmic Queries – Humans and Robots About this episode What separates humans from robots? Will humans eventually be fully dependent on automation? Neil deGrasse Tyson, comic co-host Chuck Nice, and robot ethicist Kate Darling, PhD, answer your Cosmic Queries on humans, robots, and everything in-between.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk. Your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now. StarTalk, Cosmic Queries Edition. I'm your host, Neil deGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist, bringing you this episode from my office at the Hayden Planetarium of the American Museum of Natural History, right here in New York City. And of course, I have with me Chuck Nice.
0:32 Chuck Nice? Hey Neil. What's up, buddy?
0:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How you feeling?
0:35 Chuck Nice? I'm doing well.
0:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right. Good. You ready for some cosmic queries?
0:39 Chuck Nice? Always ready for the cosmic query.
0:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This one in particular, because it's on the relationship between humans and robots.
0:43 Chuck Nice? Ah.
0:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's weird.
0:45 Chuck Nice? Yes.
0:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There's a lot of dark places that can go.
0:48 Chuck Nice? Does not compute. Of course. That's the big, you know.
0:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And of course, you tweet at ChuckNiceComic.
0:53 Chuck Nice? Thank you, sir. Yes, I do.
0:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you'd have, want me to take out the person who's got Chuck Nice as the handle?
0:58 Chuck Nice? Please do. I don't know, and you know what? He's got like 12 followers.
1:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you want your 20 followers to...
1:06 Chuck Nice? And I want my 22 followers to be able to just cut, no, I kind of like the Chuck Nice Comic now.
1:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, it grows on you, right?
1:14 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
1:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It becomes your thing, right? So, on that subject, we have expertise.
1:19 Chuck Nice? Yes, we do.
1:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We reached out 200 miles away.
1:24 Chuck Nice? Right.
1:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Up in Cambridge.
1:26 Chuck Nice? Yes.
1:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And we found a Canterburyian. Kate Darling, Kate.
1:29 Speaker 02 Hi.
1:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Hi. Welcome to StarTalk. And you are an expert on issues related to humans and computers.
1:37 Speaker 02 Yes. Specifically, robots, yes.
1:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, sorry. Yes, robots.
1:43 Speaker 02 I like computers, too.
1:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right. Yeah, yeah.
1:46 Chuck Nice? There are no robots, though, you know. Computers, they don't really, I mean, robots are cool. Computers are just computers.
1:51 Speaker 02 Exactly.
1:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Good point. Right, yeah. I get that.
1:55 Speaker 02 It is known, yes.
1:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, the MIT Media Lab. And you've been there how long?
2:00 Speaker 02 Nine and a half years.
2:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you, did you come there, and you came there from how?
2:05 Speaker 02 I was a doctoral student at the ETH in Zurich, which is a tech university. It's kind of like the Europe MIT, but no one knows that.
2:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? ETH, is that a word, or is that an abbreviation?
2:17 Speaker 02 It's an abbreviation.
2:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? For?
2:19 Speaker 02 Allgemeine Technische Hochschule.
2:21 Chuck Nice? Allgemeine Technische Hochschule.
2:24 Chuck Nice? She was showing off there. Yes, exactly.
2:28 Speaker 02 I think you said it better than I did.
2:30 Chuck Nice? What is Hossula?
2:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, so that translates to what?
2:34 Speaker 02 Uh, federal technical institute, no, federal, yeah, federal technical institute.
2:42 Chuck Nice? Are you sure you speak German?
2:44 Speaker 02 Not anymore.
2:47 Speaker 02 You're not sure anymore.
2:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So what was, what were your research topics there?
2:53 Speaker 02 Okay, so there I was doing law and economics and intellectual property.
2:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh.
2:58 Speaker 02 But.
2:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What kind of economics?
2:59 Speaker 02 Law and economics.
3:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Law and economics and intellectual property.
3:01 Speaker 02 Yeah, but the ETH has a great robotics program, a lot of roboticists there, and I've always loved robots. And so when I got the opportunity to come to the Media Lab, I made friends with all the roboticists and switched fields.
3:14 Chuck Nice? Nice.
3:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's good.
3:15 Speaker 02 Yeah.
3:15 Chuck Nice? Very cool.
3:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? To be, to be, not only to know you, you needed to be that nimble that the system can accommodate it. That's not always the case.
3:24 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah.
3:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, very good. All right, Chuck, so we got these questions that came in.
3:29 Chuck Nice? Yes, we do.
3:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Solicited on.
3:30 Chuck Nice? Lots of them.
3:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Humans and robots.
3:32 Chuck Nice? That's right, and everybody wants to know.
3:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Everybody, this is not a, this is a, this is not a small topic.
3:38 Chuck Nice? Yeah, this is something that everybody gets into, you know?
3:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, all right, let's do it.
3:41 Chuck Nice? And so we always start with a Patreon patron.
3:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
3:44 Chuck Nice? Because they, uh, they offer us support in the form of, uh, financial contributions.
3:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Money.
3:51 Chuck Nice? Money. That's right.
3:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So many euphemisms for money. It's amazing.
3:55 Chuck Nice? Isn't it really? Yes. Uh, yes, exactly.
3:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We used to have a fundraising department, now there's development department.
4:02 Chuck Nice? Oh, development. We're going to develop some funds. We, I believe they call that counterfeiting.
4:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Developing funds in the back office.
4:09 Chuck Nice? Yeah, we're developing some funds.
4:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The machine is running right now.
4:13 Chuck Nice? Exactly. But anyway, uh, let's go with Jared Goodwin, who says, uh, "If a robot can pass the Turing test, should it be endowed with inalienable rights? Could it be a marriage partner? If it's the cause of a human death, should it stand trial?"
4:33 Chuck Nice? Also, uh, isn't the human fear of AI just a fear of any species should have of evolution? And I mean, that begs another question, is AI the next incarnation of human evolution?
4:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, that's a lot there.
4:48 Speaker 02 That was five questions.
4:49 Chuck Nice? Five questions. So I'm gonna tell you what, uh, let's go with just the first one, which is, let's say it passed the Turing test, which, I mean, everything does now.
4:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Should it have inalienable rights?
5:00 Chuck Nice? Right, should it have inalienable rights?
5:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Or we can broaden it and say, is there a threshold, even if not the Turing test?
5:05 Chuck Nice? Oh, yeah, it's a good question. That's a better question.
5:08 Speaker 02 That's a better question, because arguably, robots have already passed the Turing test.
5:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I would think so too.
5:12 Speaker 02 Yeah.
5:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Uh huh. But tell us what the Turing test is.
5:15 Chuck Nice? That's a good question.
5:16 Speaker 02 So, yeah, the Turing test, so Alan Turing, way back in the day, one of you probably knows the exact year, he came up with this concept of the Turing test, where he was like, it doesn't actually matter if a machine is intelligent, as long as it can pass as intelligent. So if it can fool people into thinking it's intelligent, that's basically just as good. Um, and...
5:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I know some people.
5:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Who just barely passed the Turing test.
5:45 Speaker 02 Yeah. Yeah, and, and well, so some people have turned this into contests around the world, where the, it's popular for chatbots, you know, can a chatbot fool judges into thinking that it's a human, that they're talking to a human for a specific amount of time, and, you know, multiple chatbots have passed that test.
6:05 Chuck Nice? But they never helped me. I never received help from a chatbot.
6:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So these are, these are, just so I understand it, a chatbot is, would be software that can interpret your question well enough and give an answer good enough.
6:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that you're listening and you say I'm talking to a human?
6:26 Speaker 02 Yes.
6:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
6:28 Speaker 02 And there's some tricks that they use to get them to pass it, like, for example, one year this chatbot won one of the competitions by pretending to be a 13-year-old from the Ukraine, from Ukraine, and like, the expectations for how it would chat with you are maybe a little bit different than if it was pretending to be you, for example, so I, I think that, you know, there are a lot of little design tricks where we can get people to think that robots are intelligent. Um, we're already there.
6:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But so is that even fair, because now you're, you're using tactics to trick a human rather than have it be an authentic profile or properties? That's a good point.
7:05 Speaker 02 I mean, all of our communication is tactics, though, isn't it?
7:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'll give you an example. So, I go way back, just, I'm an old man. Okay, alright. However old you don't think I am, it's makeup. So, so, I remember the early days of playing chess against a computer. And I did this and it beat my ass every time. And then I realized, I can trick it. So here's what I did. I would, about to be, about to make a good move, where I'd, and I wouldn't take it.
7:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'd make a different move. And it doesn't understand that, because it's a very obvious move I should be making, and I'm not. And it disrupted its logical sequencing, and it doesn't know how to defend against something that I'm not attacking. Right. And so it started moving in random places, and then when I got it distracted, then I went in for that move, when it was no longer expecting it. Because it gave up on me having to do, and so, I tactically beat the computer. But I didn't feel good about that, because I, it wasn't just a brute force, head-to-head. So, uh, uh, should we allow someone to purposely tactically fool a human into thinking it's human?
8:16 Speaker 02 Well, I mean, that's Turing's whole thing, right? If you can fool them, it doesn't have to actually be intelligent.
8:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, but if you fool it with, with targeted algorithms, that feels unfair.
8:28 Speaker 02 Yeah, I guess so. Yeah, I mean, I, I'm curious, I mean, Turing unfortunately is dead, so we can't ask him.
8:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Where the he be okay, where the he be, yo, you cool with that?
8:38 Speaker 02 Yeah.
8:39 Chuck Nice? Fool me once, shame on me.
8:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm just saying, I don't feel like I actually defeated the computer.
8:45 Speaker 02 Yeah.
8:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I beat it. I, I beat it, cause I beat it.
8:48 Speaker 02 Cause you kinda cheated.
8:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I cheated a little.
8:50 Speaker 02 You didn't actually beat it because you were skilled at chess.
8:53 Chuck Nice? Right.
8:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thank you, that's how, how I should have said it.
8:55 Chuck Nice? Right, exactly.
8:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, I beat it because I, I figured out how it worked. And then outwitted it. Yeah, I'm, I'm, and I'm not proud of this, I live with this.
9:08 Chuck Nice? I've lost lots of sleep over this.
9:11 Speaker 02 Weighs on you every day still.
9:13 Chuck Nice? Well, the chatbots work, I mean, you know, the, the, most companies now use them for, uh, customer service when you are on the website. And they say, can the thing, it, it pops up, can I help you with something? And it knows, there's only so many reasons you can come to this website. So whenever that happens, whenever it pops up and says, can I help you? Just actually say something that is, has nothing to do with the website. And you, and, and it's just like, yes, like, I'm losing my home right now. Can you help me? Or can you loan me thirty dollars?
9:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The fact that you know that this is something to do tells me you need a life.
9:53 Speaker 02 Yeah, why are you sitting at home trying to trick the chatbots?
9:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Chuck, this is sad.
9:59 Chuck Nice? That, I was gonna say, maybe we shouldn't be talking about this right now. Because, why am I doing that? It's a good question. I don't know, it's, it's, it's, it's great to see, because you just, I just wanna see what it says, you know what I mean?
10:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so let's look at, let's look at the limit. So you, you have a chatbot that fools in these contests.
10:17 Speaker 02 Yes.
10:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is that a threshold where you start giving it rights?
10:21 Speaker 02 No, definitely not. And, and, and I'm not sure what this question asker means by the Turing test. Like, maybe he means... If it could fool you no matter what, like not just in this contest and not by cheating, if it could fool you into thinking it's intelligent.
10:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Imagine a flexible Turing test appropriate for whatever is the thresholds of the day. So if Turing were around today, whatever his Turing test would be, should that be sufficient?
10:48 Chuck Nice? Suppose it says, "I don't want to die," okay?
10:52 Speaker 02 Uh huh.
10:53 Chuck Nice? And no one ever programmed it to say this.
10:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh.
10:56 Chuck Nice? And it says, because it's machine learning and through many interactions it has determined, "I'm alive and I don't want to die."
11:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Chuck, you're freaking me out, Chuck.
11:06 Chuck Nice? Does it deserve rights?
11:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
11:08 Speaker 02 I mean, it depends on your theory of rights. Because animals arguably say in their animal language, "I don't want to die," and we kill them anyway.
11:20 Chuck Nice? Well, because machines aren't delicious. I mean, let's just be honest. I'll tell you right now, if my Apple computer actually tasted like an apple, it wouldn't stand a chance.
11:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Kate, you make a very important perceptive point. That even though an animal, another animal cannot tell you, "I don't want to die," it's behaving like you don't want to get hurt.
11:44 Speaker 02 And we actually know that they feel pain.
11:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We know it, all, all, top to bottom, right. Yet we killed them anyway.
11:51 Chuck Nice? Oh my god, you guys are gonna make me vegan right now. This is terrible. This is awful. I never thought of it like that.
11:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, Kate, you're messing with us. So, yeah, what you said is unarguably correct.
12:03 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
12:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that alone would be insufficient to give it rights.
12:08 Speaker 02 I mean, if we're gonna behave like we have for the past millennia, but we could also say, "Hey, we want to be better," and we could give animals rights and give the robots rights.
12:18 Chuck Nice? That's just too much, I'm sorry.
12:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? My God, Chuck, it doesn't say, "I don't want to die," it says, "And this too shall pass."
12:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Looks like...
12:28 Chuck Nice? Whoa, wow. Wow.
12:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Or if it says, "Tell me about your mother." There might be some that, no, but I, I agree. I, I can't, it's, what you said is, we, we kill stuff. We kill stuff that we know.
12:42 Speaker 02 And you know what the sad thing is? We'll probably give some robots rights before we give the animals rights because the robot can manipulate us and can be designed in a way that particularly appeals to us. The way that we protect certain animals over others.
12:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Which I think is, is, is, is not entirely fair. We like fuzzy furry animals better than animals that don't have our fur. That's true.
13:05 Chuck Nice? That's true. Shrimp never stand a chance.
13:09 Chuck Nice? Shrimp, shrimp don't stand a chance.
13:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Shrimp don't have fur.
13:11 Chuck Nice? That's right. Ugly spiders, sea creatures. You know, and you delicious, oh, and you delicious. You ugly and delicious, you don't stand a chance. That's why lobsters.
13:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you can see in some dipping sauce.
13:27 Chuck Nice? Yes, exactly. You know, it's like, that's how lobsters, like, somebody made drawn butter and they were like, let's just start dipping stuff in it. And they got the lobster and they were like, this is it.
13:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, because the first person to eat a lobster, that's a brave person.
13:39 Chuck Nice? That's a brave person.
13:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's some ugly animal right there.
13:42 Chuck Nice? Really? Are you gonna eat that ocean roach? Like, are you real? Yeah, and it's like, yeah, no, don't try it with a drawn butter. Oh my God, what a delicacy. But yeah, okay, well, great answer. It doesn't.
13:55 Speaker 02 Not for the animals.
13:56 Chuck Nice? Not for the animals and not for the, not for the machines either. You know, it seems as though it's like, you know, I, I really, what it has, what, what you just described is, uh, human, our need to be superior. It's basically our need to play God over these other, you know.
14:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? To be able to decide if they live or die.
14:15 Chuck Nice? Decide their fates.
14:16 Speaker 02 And we do that even to other people, right? This seems to be.
14:18 Chuck Nice? Yeah, it's.
14:19 Speaker 02 Kind of our dark side.
14:20 Chuck Nice? It's our dark side. Wow, okay.
14:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're turning me out here.
14:24 Chuck Nice? Damn.
14:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, go.
14:25 Speaker 02 Well, we could just stop doing that. We, couldn't we just stop doing that? Like.
14:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Apparently it's been very hard over the millennia.
14:33 Chuck Nice? I was gonna say, if you look at our history, no we can't.
14:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Apparently, it's really, really hard.
14:38 Chuck Nice? Clearly, we can't do that, you know?
14:40 Speaker 02 I do think we should try.
14:42 Chuck Nice? Okay, the trying is a good thing. All right, here we go. This is David Blum from Instagram. He says, hey there.
14:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Do we finish with the Patreons?
14:49 Speaker 02 With the five questions?
14:50 Chuck Nice? Well, he had five questions, but that was the big one.
14:52 Speaker 02 That was.
14:53 Chuck Nice? The rest of them were just lesser.
14:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Versions.
14:56 Chuck Nice? Lesser versions of, do they have those rights, like the right, you know? Cause like, I mean, if you don't have the right to be alive.
15:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Nothing else matters.
15:04 Chuck Nice? Nothing else matters.
15:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, it ain't about whether you can.
15:06 Chuck Nice? I don't care if you get married or not, you know what I mean? If machines marry, we're gonna kill you anyway. I don't give a damn if my sheep is married when I eat it. Okay, well, I don't eat mutton, but my lamb.
15:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Nobody's eating mutton today.
15:18 Chuck Nice? Yeah, exactly, you know, so, there you go. Marry all the chickens you want. I am still eating that chicken sandwich. That's what I'm saying. That was my husband, all right.
15:33 Chuck Nice? Okay, here we go.
15:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, give me another one.
15:39 Chuck Nice? Here we go. David Blum from Instagram says this, hey, David Blum here, and Chuck, it's pronounced bloom. You know?
15:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They know you have issues.
15:47 Chuck Nice? There you go. Big fan, great show. Here's the question. We tend to imagine robots like humanoids, two arms and two legs. But things have already, uh, things already have, uh, like automated vending machines and self-driving cars and responding cars. These should be considered robots. What defines a robot? And does AI have to be involved?
16:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Great question, and we don't have time to answer that.
16:12 Chuck Nice? Oh, okay.
16:13 Speaker 02 What?
16:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, no, just for this segment, just for this segment.
16:17 Chuck Nice? Hey, he's excited for this one.
16:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Man, I was like, okay. When we come back, we will find out what in modern day defines a robot. I'll start.
16:41 Speaker 03 I am Michelle Danek and I support StarTalk on Patreon. This is StarTalk with Neil deGrasse Tyson.
16:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? StarTalk, we're back. Robots, humans.
17:00 Chuck Nice? What's the deal? What's the deal with robots? Robots and humans.
17:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We've got Kate from Cambridge helping us out here.
17:13 Chuck Nice? Right on.
17:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, so we last left off.
17:19 Chuck Nice? With David Bloom.
17:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? David Bloom.
17:21 Chuck Nice? Who wanted to know-
17:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And he taught you how to pronounce his name.
17:23 Chuck Nice? Yes, he did. And basically, a quick recap. We think of robots as humanoid, two arms, two legs, but we know that we have things like vending machines, self-driving cars, responding cars. Are these considered robots? What defines a robot? And does AI have to be involved?
17:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There you go.
17:41 Speaker 02 Oh, thank you, David. So, one of my pet peeves is if you do a Google image search for "robot", you get almost only humanoid robots, right? Like he describes them. A head, a torso, two arms, two legs. Are you doing it right now?
17:54 Chuck Nice? I'm doing it right now as you speak.
17:55 Speaker 02 He's Googling.
17:56 Chuck Nice? I'm doing it. I'm just gonna put in "robots", R-O-B-O-T-S.
17:59 Speaker 02 Because a lot of people immediately think of the humanoid robot, but he's absolutely right. There are many, many, many different forms of robots out there, and I do think that the definition of "robot" already does include those.
18:12 Chuck Nice? You are absolutely right. There's not one image here of just a machine.
18:15 Speaker 02 It all, they have eyes, even faces.
18:18 Chuck Nice? It's all, they all have, they're all humanoids. And, okay, so all the way down at the bottom of the page, here's your first one without a face.
18:26 Speaker 02 But that even has like, it's standing on two legs.
18:29 Chuck Nice? It's standing on two legs, but I'm just saying, it's, you gotta go all the way down and then all you get is like, one without a face.
18:34 Speaker 02 Yeah.
18:34 Chuck Nice? But it's still a humanoid, so-
18:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So then, clearly you're losing this battle.
18:40 Speaker 02 I mean, I only just got started.
18:44 Chuck Nice? Right on.
18:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Kate throwing it down.
18:46 Chuck Nice? Throwing down the gauntlet.
18:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Kate Garland is on the case.
18:49 Chuck Nice? All right, how do you think about that one? There's one, there you go, Kate. That's a robot dog.
18:52 Speaker 02 Ooh, that cheetah.
18:53 Chuck Nice? That's a cheetah, that's, I'm sorry.
18:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Why are you sharing robots and the people on the thing, oh, I'm sorry. This is your own private show here?
18:59 Chuck Nice? I gotta tell you, I forgot we were doing this show.
19:02 Chuck Nice? Damn, Jack. Damn. I'm sorry. Go ahead.
19:09 Speaker 02 Wait, what was there?
19:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, the point is, anyone's first idea of a robot is humanoid.
19:15 Speaker 02 Yeah.
19:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And, and you have issues with this.
19:17 Speaker 02 Yes.
19:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How are you gonna change it?
19:18 Speaker 02 Um, by telling people that this comparison between robots and humans is something that we like to do, but it limits us. It limits us. Really, the potential of this technology is that we can create anything we want. We don't have to make it a human shape. People always say, "Oh, we need humanoid robots because we have a world that's built for humans, and we have doorknobs and stairs," but I'm also kinda like, "Yeah, maybe that's true in some cases, but robots could climb the walls, or we could make things wheelchair accessible and be able to have cheaper robots and have a better world for humans. Why do we need humanoids?"
19:53 Chuck Nice? That's true.
19:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
19:54 Chuck Nice? Right on. Even, you're right, even a manufacturer, and we call them robot arms, but no arm moves like those things. You know, no arm spins and twists and, you know, is, is, is opposable in every single direction, 360 degrees, but yet we still call it an arm, you know?
20:10 Speaker 02 Why are we limiting our imagination?
20:13 Chuck Nice? Right, okay. So what do you make something a robot? Is there a definition, a threshold?
20:21 Speaker 02 There's not a good definition.
20:23 Chuck Nice? Okay.
20:24 Speaker 02 But what a lot of roboticists use is the think, sense, act paradigm. So something that's a physical machine that can sense its environment, you know, somehow think about or make a decision about what it, what it sensed, and then act on its environment.
20:38 Chuck Nice? Okay.
20:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right.
20:40 Chuck Nice? Not bad.
20:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so a simple, one-task thing, you wouldn't call a robot? So, so, so for example, the coffee machine in the morning, you wouldn't call it a robot?
20:49 Speaker 02 Not necessarily, not unless it's making some sort of decision on its own.
20:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, no, it's not. You're pushing a button and following, or you programmed it to make you coffee in the morning.
20:57 Chuck Nice? But if it were able to make you to sense that you're in the room, right? And then determine whether or not it's Wednesday and you like cappuccino on Wednesday. It's Thursday, you like black coffee on Thursday, and then Friday, you like a cafe mocha, and it does that, now is that a robot?
21:17 Speaker 02 I would say probably yes.
21:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, not based on your definition, I don't agree. Because you just programmed it to do that. It'd be different, it'd be different if it read your mood in the morning. Oh, she needs a double dose.
21:29 Chuck Nice? Oh, that's funny, yeah.
21:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Then that's it, that is sensing an environment. What Chuck said is not sensing anything.
21:36 Speaker 02 But like, I think because of the facial recognition aspect of it, you could say arguably that's powered by AI. And that gets back to the question, which is, is AI involved in this? Yeah.
21:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But I'm saying if it knew how much caffeine you needed in the morning, how, it talked to the alarm clock and said you hit snooze four times.
21:56 Chuck Nice? Right.
21:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You know.
21:57 Chuck Nice? Right. And it talks to the medicine cabinet and said, he got home at two and then took some aspirin, he's clearly been drinking.
22:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If it figured all that out.
22:05 Chuck Nice? Figured all that out, that's right.
22:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is serious AI in your, in your situation.
22:10 Speaker 02 Yeah, can I get that now? I would like that robot, please.
22:14 Chuck Nice? Alright, cool. No, that's good stuff. Alright, here we go. Um, let's go to, oh my god, what a name is this? Uh, Pharaoh Mamuri, Mamuri. Okay, so, uh, it says, why do we project human emotions in machines and robots? So I think that's, that's, that's a great question, but that, does that really happen in real life?
22:40 Speaker 02 Oh, yeah.
22:40 Chuck Nice? Or, are we doing that now?
22:42 Speaker 02 Oh, yeah, over eighty percent of people name their Roombas.
22:45 Chuck Nice? Ech. That's disturbing.
22:48 Speaker 02 Really?
22:49 Chuck Nice? Yes.
22:49 Speaker 02 Why?
22:50 Chuck Nice? Because it's a thing.
22:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, it's disturbing to you.
22:53 Chuck Nice? Yeah, correct, I'm gonna.
22:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You don't make it absolute, that is disturbing.
22:55 Speaker 02 It's clearly not disturbing to most people, because they do it.
22:59 Chuck Nice? Okay, I guess there's something wrong with me.
23:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Let's just.
23:04 Chuck Nice? Let's, let's reassess Chuck now.
23:08 Chuck Nice? Okay, but I mean, the thing of this is.
23:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But just for all was worth, uh, I have a Roomba gifted this past Christmas, and we haven't named it.
23:15 Speaker 02 Really?
23:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Nor is there any chance of that.
23:18 Speaker 02 Really? That's so interesting.
23:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because it, plus it's too noisy, it goes around, make it, and it's like, would you hurry up, please? I mean, I.
23:25 Speaker 02 Are you supposed to run it when you're out of the home?
23:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, I know, but still, I don't know, I don't trust it.
23:30 Speaker 02 You don't trust the machine.
23:33 Chuck Nice? Honey, have you seen my earrings?
23:35 Speaker 02 Oh, God.
23:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It opens up a gate, it's got all your valuables. All silverware.
23:43 Chuck Nice? It's hilarious.
23:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Roombas at a pawn shop the next day. Talking other roombas, what's your take for the night?
23:51 Chuck Nice? That's hilarious.
23:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so, yeah, so I'm not among those who name my Roomba. But if 80% do, that's telling you something, right?
23:58 Speaker 02 Yeah, and, and they even, so I was just visiting the company that makes them, and people will even send their Roomba in for repair, and they'll turn down the offer of a brand new replacement. They'll be like, "We want you to send Merrill Sweep back."
24:11 Chuck Nice? Merrill Sweep, oh my goodness. Wow.
24:15 Speaker 02 That's a real, actual Roomba name, yeah.
24:17 Chuck Nice? Is Curtis Blow amongst those as well?
24:21 Speaker 02 That should be, you should name your Roomba Curtis Blow.
24:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, I don't know, I don't know. So, wait, so I misunderstood the question. It's not, our robots programmed to have human traits?
24:31 Chuck Nice? No, yeah.
24:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is that we imbue them with human traits?
24:34 Chuck Nice? Yeah, he's saying, "Project, project."
24:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Project human traits.
24:37 Speaker 02 We absolutely do.
24:38 Chuck Nice? Why do we project?
24:39 Speaker 02 And why, so the why is interesting. So, there's a couple of different reasons I think we do this. First is, science fiction and pop culture really primes us to want to personify robots.
24:48 Chuck Nice? Okay.
24:49 Speaker 02 Second is...
24:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And NASA does that too with our rovers.
24:51 Speaker 02 Oh, yeah.
24:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? First, they're named, and then they, they each have like a Twitter handle.
24:55 Chuck Nice? Right.
24:56 Speaker 02 Oh, yeah, and they like...
24:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, I got stuck on my thing, they're using first-person narrative.
24:59 Speaker 02 They play themselves a birthday song on their birthday, yeah, all kinds of stuff like that. We, everyone does it, like, we love doing this with robots. But then there's something deeper biological about it too, because robots are these physical, moving things that kind of tap into this instinct we have to separate things into objects and agents. And so if something's moving around autonomously, we will automatically project intent onto it. And so a lot of people treat robots subconsciously like living things, even something as simple as the Roomba. And then, if you design them with like the faces and the arms and the legs, as we were talking about, then even more so.
25:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is this any different from... imbuing stuffed animals with, I mean, we, we, don't we do that with almost everything?
25:44 Speaker 02 So it's, yeah, so we do.
25:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We name our cars.
25:47 Chuck Nice? People do name cars.
25:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Even before cars had any kind of technology in them at all.
25:51 Chuck Nice? Absolutely.
25:52 Speaker 02 We anthropomorphize everything, and this is just that on steroids, because you add to that the movement, you add to that the fact that we can program robots to mimic social cues, whereas stuffed animals are only our imagination, right?
26:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, unless it's Ted.
26:06 Chuck Nice? All right, well, just stay right there in that exact space, because the geekiest one from Instagram, uh, says, uh, um, Kate, in your paper, Who's Johnny?, you mentioned the effects of anthropomorphism of robots.
26:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There's a paper we all should have read.
26:23 Chuck Nice? There, well, apparently Kate wrote a paper, and the geekiest one actually read it.
26:28 Speaker 02 I didn't know anyone was gonna read that.
26:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We got people, you don't know who our people, we got people, okay?
26:33 Chuck Nice? So, yeah, they went out and did some homework real quick.
26:35 Speaker 02 I hope, I hope there are no typos.
26:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Fill us in on that when, after this question gets asked.
26:39 Chuck Nice? And then this is what the geekiest one, the geekiest one says, um, hey, in your paper, Who's Johnny?, you mentioned the effects of anthropomorphism of robots within the social world. Uh, will we see robots being capable of offering support benefits in the form of emotional support animals? Very cool question.
27:01 Speaker 02 Very cool, because he read my work, yeah. That's the coolest part, or she, like, was it, do we, we don't have a name?
27:07 Chuck Nice? The geekiest one.
27:08 Speaker 02 The geekiest one could be he or she.
27:09 Chuck Nice? It could be anybody.
27:10 Speaker 02 Um, yes, so.
27:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And maybe it's not even binary.
27:14 Speaker 02 Yeah, we don't know.
27:15 Chuck Nice? That's right, exactly.
27:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so tell us about that paper.
27:19 Speaker 02 Okay, so the paper, uh, oh, it got published years ago, this is, um.
27:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is there a journal for this?
27:25 Speaker 02 Uh, it's, it's online on SSRN, which is kind of a pre-publication site, so anyone can download it, but it's also a book chapter in Robot Ethics 2.0, which is a collection of. Of work.
27:38 Chuck Nice? Mm hmm.
27:39 Speaker 02 Uh, so the paper looks at this tendency we have to treat robots like they're alive, even though we know that they're just machines. And looks at, you know, which cases might that be something that is good? And which cases might that be something that's bad? And is there anything we can do about it? Um, and I can't remember if I talk about, uh, therapy animals in that paper, but we're already seeing robots being used as a replacement for therapy animals. For example, like the Paro baby seal robot. It's used with dementia patients. It's really cute and furry and like, um, so I, I think that it's, it's already an application. That was the question, right?
28:18 Chuck Nice? Yes.
28:18 Speaker 02 Whether that's a possibility.
28:19 Chuck Nice? Will it happen?
28:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so.
28:21 Chuck Nice? And you're saying it is happening?
28:22 Speaker 02 It is happening.
28:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, so there's, there might be a difference between a robot that can do this emotionally and a robot that looks like you want to cuddle with it. Right?
28:31 Speaker 02 What do you mean?
28:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Are you gonna make a cube that has emotions? No.
28:36 Speaker 02 I mean, I bet Pixar could.
28:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Huh, huh. It would need eyebrows and teeth or something.
28:42 Speaker 02 We'd need something.
28:42 Chuck Nice? They make a lamp cute.
28:44 Speaker 02 Yeah.
28:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, the hopping lamp.
28:46 Chuck Nice? The hopping lamp, I mean, yeah.
28:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The squeaky hopping lamp. So, so I guess what I'm asking is, what is the variable here? Is it that they can imbue it with emotions? Program it with emotions or that it is something that looks like you want to spend, you want to get close to?
29:03 Speaker 02 It's, it's both. Like the seal doesn't do much. The seal makes these little sounds and movements and responds to your touch. That's all it does. But just those little cues are enough to make people project onto it.
29:14 Chuck Nice? Right. And so you're giving it love.
29:16 Speaker 02 Yes.
29:17 Chuck Nice? Basically.
29:17 Speaker 02 Kind of like a cat. It doesn't love you back.
29:19 Chuck Nice? Right. Okay. So now, now.
29:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Cat's a good, cat's a good room.
29:24 Chuck Nice? Kind of like a cat just doesn't love you back. That's funny. My cat loved me, Kate. Thank you very much.
29:30 Speaker 02 Everyone thinks that.
29:31 Chuck Nice? Oh, my God. Now I'm even worse.
29:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, just let that one go.
29:37 Chuck Nice? Yeah, just let it go. I'm fighting a losing battle here.
29:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, you know she's right. In your heart, you know Kate is right. Let that one go.
29:45 Chuck Nice? All right, so, um, well, with respect to the cube then.
29:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Cube versus some animal.
29:51 Chuck Nice? Cube versus some animal, what Neil, in Neil's, um, um, uh, example. If the cube were to establish, let's say, a relationship with you early where it's giving you love, would that then create an emotional support dependency?
30:05 Speaker 02 It could. I mean, it's hard to make a cube kind of mimic the emotional cues that we recognize, but again, animators can do it, so we should be able to do it with cubes or robots.
30:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And, and we, and what's the movie, Her?
30:21 Chuck Nice? Her, right.
30:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That was not an animal.
30:22 Chuck Nice? That's not an animal.
30:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
30:23 Chuck Nice? Right.
30:24 Speaker 02 It was Scarlett Johansson, basically.
30:28 Chuck Nice? You know what? You're winning every argument.
30:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I know, yeah. Damn, Chuck, we just.
30:33 Chuck Nice? We're getting housed.
30:38 Chuck Nice? All right.
30:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, yeah, and Scarlett, but the, the object was not the thing. It was the voice and the personality.
30:45 Chuck Nice? Exactly.
30:45 Speaker 02 Yeah.
30:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Of the Siri character.
30:47 Chuck Nice? Right.
30:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right.
30:48 Chuck Nice? Okay.
30:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it could, that means it could be a cube.
30:49 Chuck Nice? It could be a cube.
30:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's like you said, especially in the hands of Pixar animators, yeah.
30:53 Chuck Nice? All right, here we go. This is, uh, let's go back to Patreon. This is Sheri Lynn, S K. She says, hi, Dr. Tyson and Dr. Darling. Empirical studies show long-term friends slash partners mimic each other's body language, emotions, speech, and other behavioral characteristics. If a robot is protected under intellectual property law and I hang out with it long enough to unconsciously mimic or imitate the robot's speech patterns or attitude, would I be violating IP law because I am copying parts of the robot? Sheri.
31:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Whoa.
31:22 Chuck Nice? Get a life! Sheri, who the hell cares?
31:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You know that was a good question, Chuck.
31:28 Chuck Nice? That's a damn good question.
31:29 Speaker 02 That took a turn. I was not expecting.
31:31 Chuck Nice? No, no, she, no, no. Sheri, that was amazing. Anyway.
31:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
31:36 Chuck Nice? So let's.
31:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Intellectual property.
31:37 Chuck Nice? Forget that. Let's go a little bit further. Let's say I have a personality disorder that causes me to adopt, like, that, it's not a good thing. I adopt your personality. I hang around you and then I become that robot. Would, would I then be in violation?
31:55 Speaker 02 No, no.
31:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is it in order for property theft?
31:59 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
31:59 Speaker 02 No, it's not. But if you had a robot that then hung out with other robots and started copying what they were doing because it's programmed to copy the behavior of those around them to emotionally connect with them, then then maybe you'll come closer.
32:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because it's a commercial product?
32:17 Speaker 02 But probably not, yeah.
32:20 Chuck Nice? That's very interesting, though, because you're saying like, let's say I designed a robot to take on the characteristics of other robots, like that X-Men character Rogue, right? And like, and then, but that makes me a better robot. But the only way I become that better robot is by stealing from these other robots. What then?
32:39 Speaker 02 Yeah, what then? And then if you're like stealing code, then you might also be violating copyright. Yeah, yeah, that's, I mean, there, there are fortunately people working on this, not me, who look at IP issues with AI and, you know, what happens if an AI generates artwork that's based on other artwork? You know, who owns the, who owns that? Um, so it, there are some really interesting questions that are popping up.
33:04 Chuck Nice? Okay, cool. All right, uh, how about Daniel Ferrante? And Daniel Ferrante from Facebook says, "I've seen videos of people kicking delivery robot vehicles. What does this communicate about people? Is it bad to punch a machine?" Not if it took your money.
33:23 Chuck Nice? I'm just, I'm just saying before we, but, or is this a sign?
33:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Chuck's rules.
33:28 Chuck Nice? I know. As I read the rest of his question, I'm like, let me slip this in here real quick. He says, "Is it a sign of sociopathy? Or is it a sort of resistance against, uh, automating jobs and all of the other things that these machines represent?"
33:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Fight back.
33:44 Chuck Nice? Yeah, yeah.
33:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We'll get to that question after the break when we return on StarTalk.
34:05 Chuck Nice? Time to give a Patreon shout out to the following Patreon patrons, Rusty Faircloth and Jaclyn Mashak. Thank you so much for being the gravity assist that helps us make our way across the cosmos. And if you would like your very own Patreon shout out, go to patreon.com/startalkradio and support us.
34:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We're back. Startalk. Robots and humans. I've got Kate Garland. Kate, welcome. Welcome to the universe.
34:44 Speaker 02 Oh, thank you. I didn't realize you were welcoming people to the universe.
34:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, to this part of the universe.
34:50 Speaker 02 Okay.
34:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is where we... And Chuck, you've been reading questions?
34:53 Chuck Nice? Yes, we have.
34:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And we left off.
34:55 Chuck Nice? Yes, we did.
34:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We last left off. And...
34:58 Chuck Nice? I love when you say that. "We last left off." "Our hero was dangling above a ravine."
35:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Chuck was trying to pronounce a name.
35:08 Chuck Nice? Ah, that's hilarious.
35:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Let's check back in with him to see if he's gotten there yet.
35:12 Chuck Nice? There we go. So Daniel Ferrante from Facebook said, "I've seen these videos where people are kicking delivery robots. What does this communicate about people? Is it bad to punch a machine? Or is this a sign of sociopathy? Or is it a sort of resistance against the automation of society?"
35:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Resistance to the rise of machines.
35:28 Chuck Nice? There you go.
35:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And what is sociopathy? What is that?
35:31 Speaker 02 Why are you asking me and not him?
35:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because they rolled off the question like it was a soci...
35:39 Speaker 02 I mean, I think, I mean, he means, are you a sociopath if you take a robot?
35:43 Chuck Nice? Isn't it a form of being a sociopath?
35:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I got it. I got it. Sorry. Okay.
35:46 Speaker 02 I assume that's what it is.
35:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah. That makes sense.
35:49 Chuck Nice? And like I said, unless the machine took your money. I mean, you know, then...
35:52 Speaker 02 Well, yeah, but I think you make a really good point. Like, if a person takes your money, you can, it's probably justified to punch them and you're not a sociopath for doing that.
36:01 Chuck Nice? Right.
36:01 Speaker 02 And so there are a lot of people who are, like, justifiably angry or, like, reasonably angry about the robotics that's being deployed in Silicon Valley right now and in the Bay Area. There's a lot of, like... These delivery robots, there's also the scooters that are just everywhere on the sidewalk. There's security robots in parking lots. People don't like the fact that they're being watched and that they have no control over how this technology gets deployed. And, you know, it's a little bit interesting to see people's ire get directed at the robots, which I think might also be a form of anthropomorphism, of us treating the robots like a thing with agency.
36:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In fact, we're the ones who invented the robots.
36:45 Speaker 02 Yeah, and the people deploying them aren't the robots themselves, right? So instead of, you know, destroying the robot, you should probably go after the company that deployed it, but...
36:56 Chuck Nice? Yeah, and those were the opinions of Kate Darling.
37:00 Speaker 02 Smash capitalism.
37:02 Chuck Nice? All right, well, that makes sense in many ways. Here we go, this is Eli, or Ellie. No, it's Eli. Okay, there we go.
37:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? One L or two Ls?
37:16 Chuck Nice? It's just one L.
37:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Let's call it Eli, yeah.
37:18 Chuck Nice? Neil, you often talk about a day when AI will realize that they don't need humans, and in fact, humans are detrimental to their survival. We are destroying the planet, as an example. So, do they do away with us? Some people like to suggest that free-feeding your dog... Wait, wait, where's he going with this? I'm sorry. Some people suggest not free-feeding your dog so it knows or depends on you is how to keep AI dependent on humans, so robots don't kill us.
37:54 Speaker 02 I'm really glad that that is directed at you.
37:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it means don't make robots self-sufficient?
38:00 Chuck Nice? Right.
38:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
38:02 Chuck Nice? So you're building in a dependency.
38:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So they need us. Oh, and that way, they can't kill us off. Because they need us to survive.
38:08 Chuck Nice? Exactly.
38:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that's an insurance policy.
38:10 Chuck Nice? An insurance policy. Do you agree with that? Do you think that we should do that?
38:13 Speaker 02 Why do we assume that if the robots take over, that they'll get rid of us?
38:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because they might have, they might evolve a higher moral code than we can ever even imagine.
38:22 Speaker 02 But if it's a higher moral code, like, do you really think that's gonna involve just getting rid of us?
38:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Kinda.
38:28 Speaker 02 I mean... I don't know, that seems like a very like human dominance way to think about it.
38:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, so Chuck, could you repeat that question and do it in like a third of the time?
38:36 Chuck Nice? A third of a time, I know, it took me a long time to get there. Alright, so look at it this way.
38:42 Chuck Nice? All life on the planet is equal, alright? Human beings are not special because all life is equal. The robots-
38:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're creating a scenario.
38:49 Chuck Nice? I'm creating, creating a scenario. The robots or AI actually determine this, but then determine that we are killing the planet. In order to save the planet and all other life, they've gotta get rid of us.
39:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's in the greater interest-
39:02 Chuck Nice? It's in the greater interest-
39:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The interest of the many.
39:04 Speaker 02 Why would they have to get rid of us instead of diverting us to something like that we like to do instead of destroying the planet?
39:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Give us a distraction.
39:12 Speaker 02 Yeah.
39:13 Chuck Nice? Oh, I see what you're saying.
39:14 Speaker 02 I mean, there's just so many other ways. They wouldn't have to just kill us all, right?
39:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, they don't have to, so here's what you're saying, instead of kill us, just give us something else to do.
39:22 Chuck Nice? Like casinos.
39:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, casinos.
39:27 Speaker 02 Maybe it's already happening.
39:32 Chuck Nice? Alright.
39:33 Speaker 02 Facebook.
39:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The rise of casinos and Facebook is the machine.
39:38 Chuck Nice? That's the machines doing their thing.
39:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Man.
39:40 Chuck Nice? Alright, alright, cool, cool, cool, cool, alright.
39:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Freaking us out, Kate.
39:45 Chuck Nice? This is Leopia, uh, from Facebook. What kinds of, I'm sorry, I just love Leopia. Uh, what kinds of jobs slash tasks, if any, do you think would ever be able to be automated?
40:01 Chuck Nice? That have, that have not as of yet?
40:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, good one.
40:05 Speaker 02 Well, robots are really good at doing specific things, so single tasks. That's why we have a robot vacuum cleaner, it can vacuum, right? But things that are more complicated, that require context and concepts are a little harder for a machine. So I think anything that is really easy, simple and well-defined should be able to be automated.
40:27 Chuck Nice? So now, do you also see kind of like an automated interface? So for instance, um, there's no human being that could be as steady with a scalpel or a laser-
40:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? As a machine.
40:39 Chuck Nice? Than a machine. So a pre-programmed surgery, so I am the surgeon, I program the surgery, and then the robot actually does the surgery.
40:48 Speaker 02 Don't we already have that?
40:48 Chuck Nice? Do we? I don't know.
40:50 Speaker 02 I'm pretty sure, I'm pretty sure we do.
40:51 Chuck Nice? I'm not sure if we do, I don't know.
40:53 Speaker 02 I just assumed-
40:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, but they had it in the movie Prometheus.
40:56 Chuck Nice? Oh, you're right. Maybe that's, maybe that's what I'm seeing in my head. Maybe that's what I'm seeing in my head.
41:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So there are these pods, and, and you can dial up what opera, what surgery you want.
41:07 Chuck Nice? That's right.
41:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And then you go in, and then it disinfects it, it opens it up.
41:11 Chuck Nice? Right.
41:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Pad it down.
41:12 Chuck Nice? Right.
41:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A laser cuts, it opens it up, does a thing, it stitches you back, and then you're...
41:17 Chuck Nice? Right, but it's all done by a robot.
41:19 Speaker 02 I mean, some of this is already happening.
41:21 Chuck Nice? Some of this is happening.
41:21 Speaker 02 Yeah.
41:22 Chuck Nice? Okay.
41:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, so did you, did you see Prometheus?
41:25 Speaker 02 Yeah, a long time ago.
41:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
41:27 Speaker 02 I mean, I guess it didn't come out that long. It feels like it was a long time ago.
41:30 Chuck Nice? It does feel like a long time ago.
41:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, so, is, I think it's my single favorite scene in all of movies.
41:36 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
41:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Where she goes up to it, she's gotta get the alien out of her womb.
41:39 Chuck Nice? Yes.
41:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And the female pod is damaged.
41:44 Chuck Nice? Yes.
41:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because the female part has, has an abortion setting. So that, okay, so she has to go into the male pod, and she takes it off of automation mode.
41:57 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
41:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because there's the normal surgery that would happen if you're male, so she has to program it in from scratch. Surgery, what region? Lower abdomen. Bad, bad, this, so it's, it's, what kind of surgery? Cesarean. Where, where, into the, so she, it was a brilliant scene.
42:13 Chuck Nice? It's a very well done scene.
42:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And the alien is getting more alive in her, so anyhow, so that would, why'd I even go there?
42:20 Chuck Nice? Well, that's, that's what, basically, this person, you know, we were talking about whether or not, you know, a programmable interface between robots and human beings, so we, we put in the task, they carry out the task, but those tasks would change.
42:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, so, so...
42:32 Chuck Nice? So it's not a single task, the tasks would change.
42:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Gotcha, so let me turn that into a question. So, uh, your appendix removed, do we really need doctors for that? As routine as that surgery is.
42:42 Chuck Nice? Right, or tonsils.
42:44 Speaker 02 They don't even remove tonsils anymore, do they? And even the appendix, my husband had appendicitis, and they're like, "We're not taking it out, we're just giving you antibiotics."
42:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And he's now dead.
42:52 Speaker 02 That would be a mistake.
42:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You slipped him a 20.
43:02 Chuck Nice? Sorry, we're gonna leave your birth dependents in.
43:05 Chuck Nice? Ah, don't worry, you'll be fine. You'll be just fine. Your wife told us that.
43:11 Speaker 02 Dang, we're gonna have to cut all this out.
43:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But so, so...
43:14 Speaker 02 Okay, I didn't answer the question.
43:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, what? I just wanna know about your husband. What? Why didn't they take it out?
43:20 Speaker 02 Because nowadays, they're like, "Well..." Some, in some cases, we know that antibiotics can like, clean that up and we won't actually take it out 'cause taking it out turns out to be riskier than leaving it in.
43:33 Chuck Nice? Gotcha, okay.
43:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Under antibiotics.
43:35 Speaker 02 But that said, like, yes, robots can help take things out, like, that, that seems like a really great use and, and I know it's being worked on.
43:43 Chuck Nice? Okay.
43:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right.
43:45 Chuck Nice? All right, how about Brandon Vialli says this from Facebook. "Have Isaac Asimov's three laws of robotics aged well?"
43:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Nice, good question.
43:55 Chuck Nice? "Do they still have an influence on how robots are programmed today?" What a great question.
44:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
44:01 Speaker 02 That is a good question. So, I think the thing that a lot of people forget is that most of Asimov's stories were about how the laws don't work and, in that sense, they've aged really well. Because I don't think we've solved machine ethics.
44:18 Chuck Nice? So encouraging. Wow. Damn, that's scary. Okay, okay.
44:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So just remind me, a couple of more important of those laws. Was there only three? I thought there might have been five.
44:29 Speaker 02 There was a fourth that got introduced later.
44:32 Chuck Nice? The most important, of course, is never do harm to a human.
44:35 Speaker 02 Is that the most important?
44:36 Chuck Nice? That is. You know why?
44:38 Speaker 02 Why?
44:38 Chuck Nice? I am human.
44:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But she asked you very honestly, quizzically, "Really? Why, why would you think that?"
44:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And, and one of them is, "Don't do anything that disobeys the other law," or something?
44:56 Speaker 02 Yeah, there's a hierarchy of the laws.
44:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Nested, they're nested.
44:59 Speaker 02 But then, when you get into the details of like, what can happen in practice, it turns out to be a little more messy than just...
45:06 Speaker 02 Program three laws.
45:07 Chuck Nice? That was kinda like the Will Smith movie about the iRobot, thank you.
45:10 Speaker 02 Yeah.
45:10 Chuck Nice? That was the name of that.
45:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Which is an Azagazimov story.
45:12 Chuck Nice? That's correct, right. And so like that's, that was the whole idea was basically this one robot that violated all the rules.
45:22 Chuck Nice? Alright, cool. So your answer, sir, is we're all gonna die.
45:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Do we have time for one more?
45:29 Chuck Nice? Okay, one more. Okay, here we go. Alright. Eddie Organista says this. Would the advent of robotic servitude or companionship in our daily lives cause us to evolve in an unexpected way? Ooh, this guy's getting deep. I love it. For instance, would our bodies evolve to be less, you know, robust?
45:55 Chuck Nice? With more energy for our brains, thus bigger brains? Or would our brains basically rot instead? I love it.
46:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So I gotta, I gotta jump in there because there's, that is not an accurate understanding of how biology works.
46:10 Chuck Nice? Ooh.
46:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Or evolution. So just because you don't use something doesn't mean it's just gonna go away. It's the, it's, you have to, there has to be something about you that prevents you from breeding.
46:22 Chuck Nice? Okay.
46:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay? So if you have a computer and you're not developing your own mind, if that makes you less of an attractive breeding partner? Yeah, your kind will disappear. Okay? So it has to have an effect on how you breed.
46:38 Chuck Nice? It's all about furthering.
46:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's not just, oh, one day we'll have big heads.
46:42 Chuck Nice? Right.
46:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? First you have to birth the head.
46:44 Chuck Nice? Right.
46:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, that's hard.
46:46 Speaker 02 Yes, it's very hard.
46:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Firsthand knowledge here about birthing the head of a baby. Okay.
46:53 Chuck Nice? The other two in the room will remain silent.
46:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, just as an example, um, there is, there's a discussion that the human head wanted to evolve to be even bigger. Because we were taking such advantage of our intellect. But it was killing the mothers.
47:09 Chuck Nice? Is that so?
47:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
47:10 Speaker 02 Yeah, and in fact, the first three months of the baby is outside of the womb.
47:14 Chuck Nice? That's the...
47:15 Speaker 02 Basically should still be in the womb, but if we kept it in any longer...
47:18 Chuck Nice? It would never... We could never come out.
47:20 Speaker 02 Yeah.
47:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It would never come out, right. So, so this was the backhand way to make that happen. So now the baby's on life support. You ever, you ever see other animals give birth?
47:28 Chuck Nice? Right.
47:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You know?
47:29 Speaker 02 Yeah, they walk around.
47:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They walk around, they pop out.
47:32 Chuck Nice? Yeah, they're just like, "All right, all right, just check it out." "I'm hungry."
47:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so I don't, so I don't think that's gonna work the way he's imagining.
47:42 Chuck Nice? Right.
47:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But, your favorite robot, we learned,
47:46 Speaker 02 Wally.
47:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Was Wally.
47:47 Chuck Nice? Mommy.
47:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And in Wally, they have these characters who are big and, and...
47:52 Speaker 02 That's exactly what I thought of.
47:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Slovenly.
47:55 Chuck Nice? Right.
47:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Then they're floating around, if I remember the movie.
47:58 Chuck Nice? On floating chairs.
47:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right.
47:59 Chuck Nice? Right.
48:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that they, I don't want to call it evolved to that, but they became completely useless bodies.
48:07 Chuck Nice? Right.
48:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Relying on the, on the, on the robots.
48:10 Chuck Nice? Right.
48:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, why are you, you're...
48:14 Speaker 02 I'm just so excited because you started talking about Wally and I love that movie.
48:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh.
48:19 Chuck Nice? And why is Wally your favorite robot?
48:23 Speaker 02 I think the design of the robots in that movie is really brilliant. Like, they are so... You just empathize with them so much without them needing to look humanoid.
48:33 Chuck Nice? They're not human, but yet they still elicit empathy.
48:36 Speaker 02 Yeah.
48:37 Chuck Nice? Gotcha.
48:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So these are clever illustrators and writers?
48:40 Speaker 02 Yes.
48:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's very good, very good.
48:42 Chuck Nice? Cool, cool.
48:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, so, so, so that question, I think it's not how that's gonna go.
48:47 Chuck Nice? Right.
48:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right.
48:48 Chuck Nice? So you're saying just because we atrophy, doesn't mean that we'll continue to, that we'll birth atrophy people?
48:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I remember, I'm old enough to remember, when everything was controlled by buttons, people said, "Oh, the hu, the future of humans will have a big index finger."
49:01 Chuck Nice? Big time.
49:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's like, what?
49:04 Chuck Nice? Everybody's walking around with a weird number one on their hand.
49:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There's no evolutionary pressure to have a bigger finger to push a button. It's just not.
49:12 Chuck Nice? That's an excellent.
49:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just think this through.
49:15 Chuck Nice? There you go. You can't get a better example than that. That makes perfect sense.
49:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Kate, we gotta end it here. Oh my gosh.
49:21 Speaker 02 This is so much fun.
49:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It was great having you. Oh my gosh. Well, thanks for coming down from Cantabrigia.
49:30 Speaker 02 That's what I'm calling it from now on.
49:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I think one who is from Cambridge is a Cantabrigian. I did not. I have no idea.
49:37 Speaker 02 I mean, me neither, and I am one, so.
49:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm pretty sure. Chuck, always good to have you. Always good to be here. And Kate, good luck. And it doesn't take luck, it takes hard work, but all that you do, we will need you more and more. Society will need you more and more as we go forward. So keep it going.
49:52 Speaker 02 We're all doomed.
49:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? On that happy note, we're all gonna die. This has been StarTalk, and I've been your host, Neil deGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist, and as always, big news. Looking up.
Previous Science Fiction and Star Trek, with Zachary Quinto Next Wrestling the Pandemic, with WWE’s Xavier Woods Page updated September 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated