Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast Cosmic Queries: GMOs with Bill Nye (Part 2) About this episode Just in case Part 1 wasn’t controversial enough, Bill Nye and Chuck Nice are back to answer new fan questions about Genetically Modified Organisms, unintended consequences, pollinator problems and more.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk. Your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:22 Bill Nye? Greetings, greetings, ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, kids of all ages. Welcome to StarTalk Radio. I am your guest host, Bill Nye, and with me is my beloved colleague and insightful science commentator, Chuck Nice.
0:37 Chuck Nice? Hey, Bill.
0:38 Bill Nye? And today is some more Cosmic Queries.
0:40 Chuck Nice? Yes.
0:41 Bill Nye? Where we attempt to comment and answer your queries from the cosmos. I was going for some alliteration there.
0:49 Chuck Nice? I think you got it.
0:50 Bill Nye? Hey, sounds.
0:51 Chuck Nice? I think you nailed it.
0:52 Bill Nye? Well, let's, uh, let's take our first query.
0:55 Chuck Nice? All right, so, uh, let's just jump right into this. This is, you know what, before we, before we go any further, since we're right.
1:01 Bill Nye? We hardly started, Chuck.
1:02 Chuck Nice? Yeah, exactly. Since we're right at the top of the show, why don't we take a question from our Patreon patron?
1:08 Bill Nye? Oh, a Patreon patron. So if you're a patron of StarTalk.
1:12 Chuck Nice? Right. Through Patreon.
1:14 Bill Nye? Through Patreon, you have a question. Wait, that's not working. A question, a query.
1:20 Chuck Nice? Uh huh. And we're definitely gonna read it because you have proven yourself and your loyalty by giving of your substance to this show.
1:28 Bill Nye? Yes, so if you support the show, we'll get your question on.
1:31 Chuck Nice? Hey, man. Kinda sounds a little quid pro quo to me, but who am I, right? Who am I? I don't judge, you know?
1:38 Bill Nye? Quid pro quo is an excellent way to tie in with Cosmic Query Questions.
1:43 Chuck Nice? Nicely done, Bill Nye!
1:45 Bill Nye? Hit me the ball, Chuck. We gotta keep moving here.
1:48 Chuck Nice? Oh, man! I was impressed with that, I gotta say. This is from Yawa, and she says, "A Queens, New York native, asking, isn't there a fundamental difference between genetically modified foods and the cultivation of foods?"
2:04 Bill Nye? Uh. Is there a fundamental difference? So I think by cultivation, she, I think she means traditional hybridizing. Mm-hmm. Where you would take the pollen from one plant, shake it onto the eggs, the ova of another plant. And see what happens. And you get a hybrid. Yeah. So George Washington is said to have done this. Sounds sexy. It is, literally. That sounds sexy, baby. No, no. This is what happened in nature. We have two sexes. Yeah. Males and females. Okay. But, uh, but in fungi, it is believed certain species have hundreds of sex types. Aha. And that's a whole nother deal out there in the land of fungus. So what happens is... Clearly in the land of fungus.
2:47 Bill Nye? So humans have been hybridizing within species, shaking pollen from one plant onto the eggs of another. Okay. For centuries. Shake it, baby. But we found out that not only in nature, not only do humans now, biotechnologists, have the ability to take genes from one species and insert them into another. For example, the Bacillus thuringiensis bacterium gene into the corn. Okay. Or the soybean, making BT soybeans, BT corn. Right. Which the corn boar eats, the protein from the Baron, uh, Bacillus thuringiensis, uh, crystallizes in the corn boar's gut and the corn boar dies. What? So that's where, that's the deal. So that's why the corn boar is not a problem anymore.
3:32 Bill Nye? Instead of fighting these, or these pests. So you let the plant do the fighting for you? Instead of fighting the pests with chemicals of death. We're empowering the plant to do it on its own. That's right. And so you do it as carefully as you can to be sure. But the other thing that was discovered recently, as I mentioned in our recent show, is that, uh, sweet potatoes, in this way of example. Yeah. This happened naturally. A virus got its genes in sweet potatoes, the ones that we know and love. Mm-hmm. And we supported that as cultivators of sweet potatoes and encouraged that in nature. So it happens in nature and now we're doing it. Uh scientifically or biotechnologically and the difference really becomes blurry.
4:16 Bill Nye? Uh whether it's natural or humans are doing it.
4:19 Chuck Nice? Right, because all we're kinda doing is mimicking what nature has already done.
4:24 Bill Nye? Yeah, so the whole thing though, your concern is if you're doing it so fast that you're gonna do something in the ecosystem that nobody anticipated.
4:32 Chuck Nice? Uh huh.
4:33 Bill Nye? And you don't want this so-called knock-on or unintended consequences.
4:37 Chuck Nice? Right.
4:37 Bill Nye? And the classic is.
4:38 Chuck Nice? Like lizard babies or something like, you know.
4:40 Bill Nye? Uh, yes.
4:42 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
4:42 Bill Nye? Like the Jurassic Park.
4:44 Chuck Nice? That's what I'm saying. Lizard babies or, uh, you know, uh, or an intelligent dinosaur.
4:50 Bill Nye? Yes, named Charlie, who leads us all sorts of trouble with that.
4:54 Chuck Nice? Right.
4:54 Bill Nye? Uh, that and the unintended consequence that really did happen in nature through humans. We developed this, we, people developed this herbicide called glyphosate. Kills all the weeds, kills all of everything.
5:08 Chuck Nice? Everything.
5:09 Bill Nye? Except the plants that have this cool gene in them that allows them to grow right through it. Uh, we also killed the milkweed and the milkweed, which I now prefer to call milk flower.
5:20 Chuck Nice? Oh.
5:21 Bill Nye? Is what, yes, is what the monarch butterflies rely on.
5:24 Chuck Nice? Oh, really?
5:24 Bill Nye? Yeah, so we accidentally have decimated, uh, the monarch butterfly population, reduced it over the last two decades by ninety percent.
5:33 Chuck Nice? Which is probably a good thing, cause when they flap their wings over here, it causes a pretty bad storm in Japan.
5:39 Bill Nye? Oh, this is the butterfly effect. But seriously.
5:43 Chuck Nice? Go ahead.
5:43 Bill Nye? Brilliant, Chuck, really, really good, really brilliant. Uh, so the thing is, you don't want that where you're accidentally wiping out a pollinator, potential pollinator species.
5:54 Chuck Nice? Right.
5:55 Bill Nye? So I went to the meeting in Minneapolis, the Monarch Venture, where they got the crazy bleeding heart liberal hippies.
6:03 Chuck Nice? Okay.
6:04 Bill Nye? Like me. Uh, and the corporate pigs like Conagra Monsanto Dowt Pioneer.
6:12 Chuck Nice? Boo.
6:13 Bill Nye? Well, anyway, they all got together. They all want to bring monarchs back and they believe that they can by creating this so-called hopscotch highway of milk flowers.
6:23 Chuck Nice? Gotcha.
6:24 Bill Nye? Growing these milkweeds on purpose.
6:26 Chuck Nice? Right.
6:27 Bill Nye? In certain tracts of land on the flyways that the monarchs exploit getting north and south.
6:32 Chuck Nice? So, and along their migration pla- path, you purposely put this milkflower. They have a monarch filling station from north to south.
6:43 Bill Nye? That's it.
6:43 Chuck Nice? And along the way, they're doing the little butterfly horizontal mambo and we get more and more monarchs.
6:51 Bill Nye? That's right. So they're, the, the prediction of the venture, this group that met in Minneapolis, diverse group, people that you would not think getting along are all in this to, I gotta say, as an observer, they're all in this getting along. They believe that this year, the monarch population will go back up.
7:06 Chuck Nice? Wow.
7:07 Bill Nye? One test is worth a thousand expert opinions. So stay tuned and let's see if the monarchs come back. Let's take a look.
7:13 Chuck Nice? All right, people. There you have it. That was a great question. Let's move on to Dave Ross from Facebook who says, dearest Mr. Nye. My God, it sounds like the beginning of a civil war letter. Dearest Mr. Nye, the days here have been brutal.
7:27 Bill Nye? Wow, Chuck. Chuck, Chuck, Chuck, come back.
7:32 Chuck Nice? Here we go. Sorry. All right. Okay. Here we go. Okay. Dearest Mr. Nye, uh, what do you find to be the best way to explain to people that GMOs are harmless and can actually be beneficial to humanity? This is a guy who's already on your side here, Bill. Are there any dangers to local ecosystems if GMOs manage to find their way, ooh, outside of farmers' fields? This is a great question because...
7:56 Bill Nye? No, they do. I mean, they do find their way outside of farmers' fields.
7:59 Chuck Nice? You get a little windblown?
8:00 Bill Nye? They get windblown, yeah.
8:01 Chuck Nice? Yeah. So it's, it's, so, so it... Can that happen? Can we actually decimate unintentionally neighboring crops? Because you're using GMOs, they get caught up in the wind and now somebody's growing them even though they don't want to.
8:18 Bill Nye? Oh, this is a concern of certain organic farmers that they're, these seeds end up in their soil. They get contaminated and they work very hard to sort them out. With that said, I would ask you, how often do soybeans grow in your yard? You know, not that much, but in the, in-
8:36 Chuck Nice? Nothing grows in my yard, Bill.
8:38 Bill Nye? But in agricultural areas- In agricultural areas, if you, people have to be very diligent, but most, most plants that grow as crops-
8:48 Chuck Nice? Okay.
8:48 Bill Nye? Are planted on purpose. That's, I guess that's where the word plant is tied in. So if you're not planting them on purpose, there's just not that much contamination. And the infamous cases where when people claim they got canola growing, they grew into their, that flew into their fields accidentally and started growing. But there is substantial evidence that those cultivars were carefully cultivated. This is to say, one guy claimed that these seeds blew into his field, but they really didn't. He really planted them.
9:20 Chuck Nice? Oh.
9:21 Bill Nye? And so this is where these notorious-
9:23 Chuck Nice? So basically, he's trying to skirt paying for seeds.
9:25 Bill Nye? Well, that's, so by the way, if you watch that movie Food Incorporated and this, you know, guy's in tears about the seeds. It turns out he was reported by his neighbors.
9:34 Chuck Nice? Uh huh.
9:35 Bill Nye? Who were resentful of him not paying the licensing fee for these extraordinary or these improved, claimed to be improved seeds. So I get it.
9:45 Chuck Nice? He's a seed hacker.
9:47 Bill Nye? He was a seed hacker, which is understandable, but the neighbor, his neighbors were angry about it.
9:53 Chuck Nice? Snitches. Okay, cool. By the way, Dave brought, that was a great, great answer, Bill.
9:58 Bill Nye? You don't have to sound so surprised, Chuck.
10:02 Chuck Nice? So Dave, actually, I want to read this because he says, "As an aside, I'm proud to say, I'm a relatively new member of the Planetary Society's Discovery Team."
10:13 Bill Nye? I love you, Dave. The Discovery Team's a level of participation we encourage you all to consider. So we just had a big success, you know, we launched our light sail spacecraft.
10:23 Chuck Nice? Yes, you did.
10:23 Bill Nye? First, we qualified the thing, which is takes some vibration and thermal vacuum testing and all this stuff. And then we got it on a rocket, then we got it into space, we deployed the sails, we took a picture. Mission success.
10:34 Chuck Nice? Nice, congratulations.
10:36 Bill Nye? And next year will be bigger and cooler. I mean, the orbit will be bigger and much more, to me, much more exciting.
10:43 Chuck Nice? Alright.
10:44 Bill Nye? Except, we pulled it off, which was pretty exciting.
10:46 Chuck Nice? That is exciting, and you should be proud.
10:48 Bill Nye? I am.
10:49 Chuck Nice? Excellent. Let's move on to Juan Diego Lopez.
10:53 Bill Nye? Juan Lopez.
10:53 Chuck Nice? I have to say it like that. Juan Diego Lopez.
10:56 Bill Nye? You could say it with a Hispanic, "Juan Lopez."
10:59 Chuck Nice? No, Juan Diego Lopez.
11:01 Bill Nye? Okay.
11:02 Chuck Nice? "You killed my father." Never mind.
11:04 Bill Nye? Are you confusing that trauma with a Kung-Fu movie? Because they have a lot of the same issues, you know, they got...
11:13 Chuck Nice? They do. But that would be "You killed my master."
11:15 Bill Nye? Those are evolutionary ties there, where if your family, and you mess with somebody, a family member, it's like the mafia, you know, there's trouble.
11:25 Chuck Nice? That's always, always. That's right. "You have the right to avenge my death."
11:29 Bill Nye? That's right, yeah.
11:30 Chuck Nice? Okay. This is, hey, Juan says, "Hi from Bogota, Colombia." Phew, okay, let me see if I can get this right now. "Why is that, why is it that the protection of genetic patrimony, literal translation from the Spanish term, I don't know if it's right, is way more strict for GMOs than for actual endemic plants and animals? Both are profitable, but endemic plants often have new chemicals that we can use for medicine. For example, you could take samples of endemic life in Colombia to the US relatively easy. But if you dare to try to bring seeds of alfalfa from the US, it's impossible or even illegal."
12:15 Chuck Nice? So I think what Juan is really wanting to know is, why do we stop? People from bringing flora and fauna from different countries to other countries.
12:27 Bill Nye? Well, shooting from the hip, you don't want to contaminate ecosystems.
12:31 Chuck Nice? Okay.
12:32 Bill Nye? But he's asking, it sounds like an agricultural policy question.
12:34 Chuck Nice? Hey, I think he is because he's talking about endemic plants.
12:37 Bill Nye? So I don't, I don't work for Pioneer Seeds or Monsanto Seeds. But I imagine that there's something in Colombia where they don't want these, the man to bring these farm products to their farms so that they can have their own farms. It's like a tariff. It's what it sounds like.
12:54 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
12:54 Bill Nye? Uh, so I'm not an expert on the farm policy in Colombia.
12:58 Chuck Nice? That's it.
12:59 Bill Nye? But, uh, I'll tell you this, in India, where there's a lot of subsistence or near subsistence farming. In Africa, where there's a lot of close to the bone farming.
13:09 Chuck Nice? Right.
13:10 Bill Nye? Everybody embraces genetically modified seeds because they get much higher yield and they do not, are not subject to these pests and these plant diseases that are troublesome for farmers. So that's gotta be part of the thinking, uh, for those of you who are voting and taxpaying with respect to the, uh, commerce associated with agricultural products. Take it Chuck.
13:35 Chuck Nice? All right, um, with that being said, here, let me ask you a question from Chuck Nice. Uh, Chuck Nice comes to us from the Argo Studios, uh, StarTalk Radio.
13:44 Bill Nye? From right across this table.
13:45 Chuck Nice? Chuck Nice comes to us from right across the table.
13:49 Bill Nye? What's the capital of right across the table?
13:51 Chuck Nice? Uh, that would be, um...
13:53 Bill Nye? Right Across the Table City.
13:54 Chuck Nice? Yes.
13:55 Bill Nye? Right Across the Table Annapolis.
13:56 Chuck Nice? And, uh, Cupville, which is, uh, located right here.
13:59 Bill Nye? It's right, the Cupville is right across the table.
14:01 Chuck Nice? Right where that cut is, Cup is. So here's the thing. Um, as we talk about this, I believe that a lot of this is due to the fact that, uh, there seems to be a great deal of secrecy around GMOs when it comes to these large companies, uh, these multinational, uh, agricultural, agricultural companies. Why is it that they seem to be so proprietary, somewhat secretive? And also, they go out of their way to stop labeling from happening, which elicits suspicion from the general public?
14:33 Bill Nye? Uh, you got me on the labeling thing.
14:35 Chuck Nice? Okay.
14:35 Bill Nye? I, I told those, those people at Monsanto and when I was at the Monarch Butterfly Meeting at, I guess it was Pioneer Dow, Dow Pioneer Seeds, I told them, why don't you just put on there proudly GMO? Go for it.
14:48 Chuck Nice? That would help.
14:49 Bill Nye? Well, would it? Or would it have this huge backlash against the people who, uh, protest these things and they, the guy was singing a song about Monsanto must burn and, uh, I don't know, would, or would it have a backlash?
15:03 Chuck Nice? Well, no, it'd have a backlash initially.
15:06 Bill Nye? In the short term?
15:06 Chuck Nice? In the short term, and then people will actually start looking at it.
15:09 Bill Nye? So Chuck Nice is preaching it, everybody. Bring it on.
15:12 Chuck Nice? Well, no, I'm just saying the natural progression would be you deal with the backlash, which causes people to take note, which causes them to do some research, and then they find out the truth, and if the truth is innocuous, then it's not a big deal anymore.
15:25 Bill Nye? Exactly. So I say let the market sort it out. I say this all the time. If, if they think, if people think they can grow organic food, that's more appealing and cheaper and better and so on, then people will buy that stuff instead of the traditional farm foods. So we'll see. I mean, I say, you got me. Why don't they try it?
15:44 Chuck Nice? Why don't they try it? Alright, here we go. This is Joshua White from Facebook. He wants to know, "Hey Bill, when do you think GMOs will be used to bioremediate contaminated areas? Like plants that are specifically designed to draw up heavy metals out of soil, or bacteria that can clean up underground aquifers contaminated with solvents?"
16:02 Bill Nye? Uh, that's a great idea. And so, the, the place to start with that, making, let's say in this case, bacteria that could metabolize oil in an oil spill.
16:14 Chuck Nice? Okay, now we're talking some serious money here. I love the way you're thinking.
16:18 Bill Nye? So that would be a really cool application. However...
16:22 Chuck Nice? Can we do that? Cause I'd need some money, cause that would be great.
16:25 Bill Nye? So are you in the oil spill cleanup business?
16:27 Chuck Nice? No, but I will be.
16:28 Bill Nye? Not yet. So this is a good example of a place where maybe you could take the organic chemicals and organ, organic chemicals are chemicals that come from organisms which nominally have carbon. That's what organic chemistry is. And you could have some bacteria that could metabolize that, and then leave behind all the other stuff that comes out of oil wells, sulfur and so on, and let it sink to the bottom of the ocean. Or metabolize that too, and make it into some amazing... Plastic or have it all stick together in a big, in a big oil tar sheet that is much easier to lap up with your oil tar sheets lapping up ship.
17:07 Chuck Nice? Yeah, your oil tar bounty.
17:08 Bill Nye? Yeah, uh, so this would be an example of something that, uh, I mean, a place to start. As far as taking heavy metals out of the soil, that's okay. Then you gotta put, process those plants. That might be a fine thing.
17:21 Chuck Nice? So now.
17:22 Bill Nye? Like at a landfill.
17:23 Chuck Nice? So when you say.
17:24 Bill Nye? Someplace where you want to build a condominium or whatever.
17:26 Chuck Nice? Wouldn't you just, uh, pull the stuff out of the soil and then uproot the trees and then use them for something else?
17:32 Bill Nye? That's what I'm saying.
17:33 Chuck Nice? Oh, okay.
17:34 Bill Nye? And then build your condos right there without having the children at risk of, uh, being around all these heavy metals.
17:38 Chuck Nice? Gotcha.
17:39 Bill Nye? That's a great, I mean, it's a fine idea. I'm not in that business and I got a feeling though, there's somebody who is. Man, those guys at Monsanto, they, I'm not saying it's all about Monsanto, okay, everybody.
17:52 Chuck Nice? Please.
17:53 Bill Nye? But they spend $2 million a day.
17:55 Chuck Nice? On R and D?
17:56 Bill Nye? On research. A day.
17:58 Chuck Nice? See.
17:59 Bill Nye? They spend almost a hundred million dollars a year on research, not on, not on shipping their products, just on research.
18:06 Chuck Nice? Okay.
18:07 Bill Nye? And that's, I think they're a victim of their own success. And I know the feeling, look at you and me Chuck.
18:11 Chuck Nice? Right.
18:12 Bill Nye? We're victims of our own success because we've been so fascinating in this first segment of Star Talk Radio.
18:18 Chuck Nice? That it's over?
18:19 Bill Nye? That we're out of time. So stay tuned. We'll be right back. It's Chuck Nice and Bill Nye. You're listening to Star Talk. Welcome back, ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, kids of all ages. Bill Nye here, your host, your guest host of Star Talk Radio. I'm here with my beloved fellow science commentator, Chuck Nice.
18:43 Chuck Nice? Hey.
18:44 Bill Nye? And today is the next segment of your Cosmic Queries where we, uh, work hard to answer your questions that have come into us from the electric internet out there in the cyber ether space that all the, all the kids are using.
18:59 Chuck Nice? All the kids are doing it and we're gonna do it too.
19:01 Bill Nye? So hit me the first question there.
19:03 Chuck Nice? Okay.
19:04 Bill Nye? Doctor Nice.
19:05 Chuck Nice? All right, here we go. Coming from, uh, Facebook, this is Sylvain, uh, Boutigny.
19:12 Bill Nye? Oh, yes.
19:13 Chuck Nice? Okay. Facebook wants to know, I would be interested.
19:19 Chuck Nice? Uh, in having your insights about genetically modified animals. And how important they may be for basic research as well as the pharmaceutical industry. Now you are opening up a whole nother can of worms here, buddy. Cause we're talking about animals, plants are insentient, animals have feelings. So where do you stand, Bill?
19:40 Bill Nye? Plants are insentient. Bring it on Chuck. They don't think.
19:45 Chuck Nice? They don't think.
19:46 Bill Nye? As far as we know.
19:46 Chuck Nice? That's right. Well, as far as we know.
19:48 Bill Nye? That's right. Did you ever see the original movie, The Thing? Oh, it's good.
19:54 Chuck Nice? I don't think I did.
19:55 Bill Nye? Imagine no heart, no feelings, the perfect creature. And it's because The Thing is like this vegetable deal. Alright, so. Uh, we do genetically modify animals and this we're talking about lab rats that glow in the dark, the little mice.
20:08 Chuck Nice? Or the mouse with the ear on its forehead, the human ear.
20:11 Bill Nye? Yeah, so these are very important to our research. These are very important to the way humans know, uh, our genes. And on balance, I'm in favor of it and, and I'm not a vegetarian. Maybe one day soon I will become one.
20:27 Chuck Nice? No, no, you won't.
20:28 Bill Nye? Uh, well, maybe, I mean, but.
20:30 Chuck Nice? You love bacon too much.
20:31 Bill Nye? Oh, I mean, maybe, but I understand, you know, we raise animals to kill them and eat them routinely. So we, by analogies, analogy, we raise especially mice for laboratory studies that, uh, that enable wonderful things. With that said, I'm very sympathetic to the idea that there's a, there's a line that you draw.
20:53 Chuck Nice? Right.
20:54 Bill Nye? And a rhesus monkey is like very similar in, in, to me, in many ways, superior to my old boss. So I can understand where you don't want to do experiments on, on that guy. Or gal.
21:09 Chuck Nice? That.
21:11 Bill Nye? Well, you met him. So you know who I'm talking about. So I kid because I love.
21:17 Chuck Nice? Oh, that's hilarious.
21:19 Bill Nye? If you're one of my old bosses out there, just notice that consider yourself an amalgam. You are the old, for Bill and I, the old boss is a, is a mixture of many characteristics of people for whom I worked. And I remind you all.
21:32 Chuck Nice? Composite man.
21:33 Bill Nye? Yes, as a manager myself nowadays, people don't quit jobs. They quit bosses. So with that said, I think it's still very important for humankind to have access to these so-called laboratory models. That's the noun they use to describe these rats and mice.
21:52 Chuck Nice? Okay.
21:52 Bill Nye? That we have, whose genes we have modified to understand our own genes.
21:57 Chuck Nice? So now, uh, with that being said, okay, so you do, you're, you're, you're saying that it is important. Um, should there be a push?
22:10 Chuck Nice? That sounded like a very specific kind of push for a second there. Uh, should there be a push to find a different way? Or now here's my, here's my follow-up. To genetically modify these animals so that as you work on them, they feel no pain or like, do you understand me?
22:29 Bill Nye? I do, absolutely.
22:30 Chuck Nice? Suppose you could genetically modify a mouse so that the pain receptors, a mouse is born with no pain receptors. Therefore it never knows any type of physical suffering because it can never feel that. Should that be the way that we're, we handle it?
22:43 Bill Nye? That's a hard question Chuck, because I don't know that you can prove that a mouse would never do that. Plus, would it really be a mouse and would it be a good model for a human? After you changed it? And so the example I give you.
22:54 Chuck Nice? See, see.
22:55 Bill Nye? Is I know a guy not too well, but I know a guy who's in his 30s who wants to have his head frozen. So that in centuries hence, they can unfreeze his head and connect it to some future unfrozen head machine. And he will then be able to conduct his life and experience life three centuries from now. With that said, after you do that, can you really replicate the brain combined with the central nervous system? Now, we're talking about mice in a laboratory.
23:27 Chuck Nice? Right.
23:28 Bill Nye? And so I, I believe that like, try to talk without moving your hands, even when we're on the radio. There's something going on between, there's feedback between your distant nerve endings and your brain. And so I think if you were to modify a mouse so that it felt no pain, I'm not sure he would still be a good model for a person. There's people I'm sure who think deep thoughts about this.
23:50 Chuck Nice? Right.
23:51 Bill Nye? Uh, but I don't know the answer.
23:52 Chuck Nice? Yes, and, uh, those people are heads in a jar. That's what we're looking at. All right, well, listen, that was a really, uh, thought provoking question, Sylvan, uh, or Sylvane, and we appreciate you for that. Let's move on to Brandon.
24:09 Bill Nye? Wow, God. You guys, you can't see Chuck's face, but he's a back he has taken, a back he has been taken.
24:17 Chuck Nice? Brandon.
24:18 Bill Nye? Brandon, this better be good. I got a feeling it is.
24:21 Chuck Nice? Ag Cameran. Brandon Ag Cameran.
24:26 Bill Nye? Ag Cameran.
24:27 Chuck Nice? Ag Cameran. Okay.
24:29 Bill Nye? The Branster.
24:30 Chuck Nice? I think I got it. Brandon says, hey, Bill, considering you've been on both sides of the argument on GMOs, can you, in your opinion, I don't know whose else opinion you would do it in.
24:41 Bill Nye? I'm very good at mine.
24:42 Chuck Nice? Yeah. Uh, list the most beneficial and non beneficial reasons for GMOs. Ooh, nice one, uh, Mr., uh, oh, he spelled it out phonetically here, Ag Cameran, Ag Cameran. So, uh, Mr. Ag Cameran, here's the deal, he wants you. To play your own devil's advocate.
25:02 Bill Nye? Yeah, good and bad.
25:03 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
25:03 Bill Nye? So as I say, the good thing is-
25:04 Chuck Nice? Ladies and gentlemen, Bill Nye, pro and con.
25:08 Bill Nye? Uh, the good side is we get more yield for per hectare or acre.
25:13 Chuck Nice? Okay, one.
25:13 Bill Nye? So in other words, we have less impactful farming. In other words, we affect the ecosystem less because we'll produce more food on less land. That's the upside of genetically modified-
25:23 Chuck Nice? That's one, four.
25:24 Bill Nye? We're using biology to fight pests and diseases rather than chemistry.
25:28 Chuck Nice? That's two, four.
25:29 Bill Nye? So that's good. The unintended consequence, the classic one, is either the things you don't know. To be, not to go all misguided military principle, uh, policy on you, but the unknowns, the known unknowns.
25:44 Chuck Nice? The known unknowns.
25:45 Bill Nye? Like, well, you don't know what you're gonna do. But the, the one that everybody has observed is the monarch butterflies, where we have reduced their population 90%. Not as a consequence exactly of raising genetically modified food, but by using this extraordinarily effective herbicide that has killed the milk flowers, or milkweeds, which nourish the monarchs.
26:07 Chuck Nice? So an unintended consequence there.
26:10 Bill Nye? And so are there ones that you don't know? Are there other insects and pollinators that you affected accidentally by messing up their food source? And the other unintended consequence, uh, and not a necessary one, is by monoculture farming. Enormous tracts of a single type of plant make it very hard for bee, bees as pollinators to get the job done. They gotta go out there, do that one crop, then there's nothing to do, and somebody puts them back in a box and puts them on a truck and takes them to a different crop, and they just get beaten up. They can't handle it. But this is not necessarily-
26:43 Chuck Nice? Then you get bees coming home stressed out.
26:45 Bill Nye? They do, they are.
26:46 Chuck Nice? Babe, God, what a day, I gotta tell you. You should've seen it. It's stressed on and on forever.
26:52 Bill Nye? It's a girl voice.
26:53 Chuck Nice? Oh, that's correct, cause all the bees are female.
26:55 Bill Nye? All the ones that are pollinators, yeah. So go, go ahead, do it again.
26:58 Chuck Nice? Honey, I just can't believe the day I had. I'm telling you, this is just awful. Those fields just seem to stretch forever.
27:07 Bill Nye? Yes, alright. Chuck Nice is a four-winged fly. Alright, so, uh-
27:13 Chuck Nice? Alright.
27:13 Bill Nye? Uh, the unintended consequences are-
27:17 Bill Nye? Things like the monarch butterflies and this monocultural farming, which affects the pollinators and our whole agriculture system. So, these are things that are avoidable.
27:25 Chuck Nice? Gotcha.
27:26 Bill Nye? So, it's good and bad, but it's manageable. And I think it's just a necessary consequence. When you're gonna have 7.2 billion people become 9.2 billion people, you're gonna have to do something to feed them.
27:37 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
27:37 Bill Nye? And indeed, we all prefer the texture, taste, and nutrients from nominally, uh, hybridized crops over the last 10,000 years.
27:46 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
27:47 Bill Nye? And this modern biotechnological way of modifying is just the next thing humans are doing.
27:52 Chuck Nice? Gotcha. So, alright, that was great to see you, uh, argue both sides there. And basically, the, the, the biggest problem is the unknowns.
28:01 Bill Nye? Well, that's it. That's what you wanna avoid.
28:03 Chuck Nice? But you can't do it until you do it. You can't know until you do it.
28:06 Bill Nye? But, well, humans have been doing this for centuries. You know, we try this plant, it doesn't work, so we try that plant. And so, the claim is...
28:13 Chuck Nice? Believe me, I've been there.
28:14 Bill Nye? Yeah, so, the claim is that you do it very carefully.
28:19 Chuck Nice? Right.
28:19 Bill Nye? And so, for those of you tuned into our previous episode, I talked about, these guys are able to ass, these people are able to assay or sequence genes literally 10 million times faster.
28:31 Chuck Nice? I know.
28:32 Bill Nye? Than they could even a decade ago.
28:34 Chuck Nice? Fantastic.
28:34 Bill Nye? It's amazing. 10 million times. And the reason is, people have invested in the technol, people, engineers who've developed the technology worked really hard on it because there's so much, uh, to be, so much gain to be had.
28:47 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
28:47 Bill Nye? And everybody prefers delicious corn to not delicious corn. Everybody prefers delicious apples or good tasting apples, not to single out a particular flavor. I do like the red delicious.
28:59 Chuck Nice? I'm a Honeycrisp man myself.
29:01 Bill Nye? I'm down with Honeycrisp.
29:02 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
29:03 Bill Nye? But I, I will remind everybody, there's two things about red delicious that I really like.
29:07 Chuck Nice? Uh, which are?
29:08 Bill Nye? They're red.
29:08 Chuck Nice? Okay.
29:09 Bill Nye? And they're...
29:10 Chuck Nice? Delicious?
29:10 Bill Nye? Yes. I like my Galas.
29:13 Chuck Nice? Uh, Galas are okay.
29:15 Bill Nye? Yeah, I like the Braeburn.
29:15 Chuck Nice? Yeah, the Braeburns are right, too.
29:17 Bill Nye? I'm, uh, I'm not a big Granny Smith guy, but I'll choke it down. So, anyways, with that said, uh, when it comes to genetically modified food or crops, we just have to be diligent.
29:27 Chuck Nice? Okay. So, here's the deal.
29:29 Bill Nye? And that requires regulation. Wah!
29:31 Chuck Nice? Now, uh, see, now you lost me, man. I'm a Republican. I'm, I'm all against the regulation of any kind. Sorry. Okay.
29:38 Bill Nye? Okay. So, I'll watch for you when the light's red.
29:40 Chuck Nice? Exactly. Uh, here we go.
29:46 Chuck Nice? Dietrich, Diet- Dietrich, oh Jesus.
29:48 Bill Nye? Dietrich?
29:49 Chuck Nice? Dietrich, thank you. Dietrich Inswig wants to know this. Oh, Kaya. Dietrich Inswig Kaya. That's the name, right? Okay.
29:59 Bill Nye? D I Kaya.
30:00 Chuck Nice? D I Kaya. Says-
30:02 Bill Nye? Do it yourself, Kaya.
30:03 Chuck Nice? There you go.
30:04 Bill Nye? No, that's D Y. I'm sorry, carry on.
30:06 Chuck Nice? There we go. Hello, Mr. Nye. Do you foresee the GMOs will be the sole food source at the grocery stores anytime soon? Meaning, will food be so difficult to come by as the population grows exponentially? That all food will have to be modified in some way so that it can be grown and harvested in widespread locations? In other words, are we headed towards soylent green, but it's not people?
30:31 Bill Nye? Uh, the answer is we're already there.
30:33 Chuck Nice? Ooh.
30:33 Bill Nye? Not to get too weird on you, but everything that you eat, with very few exceptions. I mean, you might wander through the occasional forest and eat a nut. Or I remember there were some wild blackberries that I encountered often as a kid. You'll eat those, but generally, everything you eat is from a farm where people over the last 10,000 years have hybridized, modified, selected artificially, or induced choosing of, uh, the offspring, so that we got these, the foods that we all enjoy today. So the answer is, we're already there. Not to be dismissive, just that taking genes from one organism and putting them in another for farming
31:18 Bill Nye? is what we're doing now, which happens in nature from time to time. These viruses work their way into the genes of the classic, is the sweet potatoes. Uh, this is happening naturally, so we're just doing it carefully and diligently and fast, and that's how we're able to feed so many people.
31:35 Chuck Nice? All right, now here's an addendum to that question.
31:37 Bill Nye? Please.
31:38 Chuck Nice? I'm gonna speak on behalf of-
31:41 Bill Nye? Chuck Niceco.
31:42 Chuck Nice? Yes, so is is there a possibility or a danger of centralizing our food source in such a concentrated fashion where we harm ourselves by giving too much power to the people that feed the world? I I think psychologically, there's a real fear amongst people of that being the case.
32:03 Bill Nye? So is it, I think I know what you mean, is it a corporation that you're afraid of?
32:07 Chuck Nice? Yes, that's my point, man.
32:08 Bill Nye? Okay, but you're not exactly afraid of a farmer?
32:11 Chuck Nice? No, I'm not afraid of a farmer because if I don't like my little upstate farmer guy, I'm like, alright, well, screw you, upstate farmer guy, I'm gonna go to downstate farmer guy. But if the upstate farmer guy and the downstate farmer guy are all one guy, well, maybe I'm in a little bit of trouble now.
32:26 Bill Nye? Alright, I get you. So bear in mind, farmers make choices. Now, look, I sound like, farmers make choices, they can buy seeds from this guy or that guy.
32:36 Chuck Nice? Alright.
32:37 Bill Nye? And like everything else, do you remember Gateway Computers?
32:41 Chuck Nice? Yes.
32:42 Bill Nye? Like everything else, things have gotten consolidated because of international commerce has made it more efficient. And I understand our fear of corporations, but nevertheless, that is manageable through, dare I say it, regulation. Yeah, where you would make it so that the marketplace is generally fair. So, uh, this is, seems like a very solvable problem, but I I am not worried about the man, uh, taking over the world because farmers make choices and producing seeds with certain characteristics, uh, is very competitive business. And so it'll, and the seed being one example, this will remain, this will be the way it is. You know, Roundup is a famous brand.
33:23 Chuck Nice? Yes, it is. I have some in my basement, I hate to say it, but that too.
33:27 Bill Nye? But there are dozens of country, companies, several of them are in Asia, that manufacture a very similar glyphosate salt that is well suited as an herbicide.
33:39 Chuck Nice? Gotcha.
33:40 Bill Nye? So it's a competitive business.
33:41 Chuck Nice? Alright.
33:42 Bill Nye? Just that the glyphosate thing was so successful. That everybody embraced it. Home gardener and farm, industrial farmer alike.
33:50 Chuck Nice? Gotcha. All right. Good stuff, man. Good question. All right. Biff Handy from Biff Handy.
33:58 Bill Nye? Now, Biff Handy's only got 30 seconds. You want to make this a cliffhanger?
34:01 Chuck Nice? Let's make it a cliffhanger.
34:02 Bill Nye? Oh, man.
34:02 Chuck Nice? Here we go. I'm gonna read it like this. Hey, Bill, because I'm Biff. Uh, why is it that we only?
34:07 Bill Nye? From Back to the Future, is that who you were there?
34:09 Chuck Nice? So, why is it that we only hear about Monsanto when it comes to GMOs? Are there other companies anywhere else competing with them? Uh, that do anything differently that might make it better?
34:21 Bill Nye? Well, they're always trying to do it better. And the big one that Monsanto competes with is Dow. And the seed sign you'll see along the road is Pioneer. They compete with Monsanto head to head.
34:32 Chuck Nice? So that's the Holy Trinity?
34:33 Bill Nye? Are they better? We'll be back after this on StarTalk Radio with Chuck Nice and Bill Nye.
34:46 Bill Nye? Welcome back to StarTalk Radio. I'm your guest host, Bill Nye, sitting in for my beloved colleague, Neil deGrasse Tyson, and I'm here with another beloved colleague. Of course, I mean Chuck Nice.
34:57 Chuck Nice? Hey.
34:58 Bill Nye? Hilarious science commentator. When we left the last segment.
35:02 Chuck Nice? Yes.
35:03 Bill Nye? There was questions as to whether a company like Monsanto has a competitor. Yeah, yes. The big one is Dow and their seed company is Pioneer, but there's several others, Conagra and so on. And there's Syngenta, which Monsanto's trying to acquire. And these are seed companies that compete very hard to make better plants, better crops.
35:25 Chuck Nice? Not one of those names made me feel better about GMOs.
35:28 Bill Nye? Well, uh.
35:29 Chuck Nice? I mean, not one of them. You, you went from Monsanto to Dow. Ooh, oh, that got better.
35:35 Bill Nye? In the business.
35:35 Chuck Nice? And then Conagra.
35:36 Bill Nye? What do you want it to be called? Uh, Farmhouse Seed?
35:40 Chuck Nice? Yeah, see, now that's a company I can get behind.
35:42 Bill Nye? So Farmhouse Seed are really nice.
35:45 Chuck Nice? Uh, yeah, throw.
35:46 Bill Nye? They're friendly.
35:47 Chuck Nice? Yeah, you know, and throw a name in there like Wilford, like Wilford's Farmhouse Seed.
35:51 Bill Nye? Okay, well, that's what they market all that stuff. But I remind you, these farmers, look, I'm not in the farming business myself, except I have a nice garden. Uh, farmers choose what seeds to plant based on the ones that perform the best, not based on gunpoint from a corporation.
36:09 Chuck Nice? Kind of makes sense.
36:10 Bill Nye? So.
36:11 Chuck Nice? What you're saying, there is a market, it is in competition.
36:14 Bill Nye? And it's huge.
36:15 Chuck Nice? It may not be perfect competition, but it's in competition.
36:17 Bill Nye? So, think how many car companies there are.
36:20 Chuck Nice? I'm thinking.
36:20 Bill Nye? Are there thousands?
36:21 Chuck Nice? No.
36:22 Bill Nye? Yeah, there's a handful.
36:23 Chuck Nice? There's a handful.
36:24 Bill Nye? And even, they talk about, uh...
36:26 Chuck Nice? And even those handful are owned by just a few.
36:29 Bill Nye? Because it's a hard thing to make a complicated thing like a car.
36:32 Chuck Nice? Okay.
36:32 Bill Nye? And it's a hard thing to make a complicated thing like a seed that's resistant to a specific insect. It's a complicated business.
36:41 Chuck Nice? That's it.
36:41 Bill Nye? People invest a lot of money, so...
36:42 Chuck Nice? So, you're not gonna have a bunch of people in this business. It's basically, just the nature of the business itself.
36:46 Bill Nye? When you say a bunch, there's a handful. And it's very competitive among the handfuls.
36:50 Chuck Nice? Okay.
36:51 Bill Nye? The thing where, the idea that there's a, um, a conspiracy to take over the world, I'm very skeptical of because they really are out to get each other.
37:01 Chuck Nice? All right. Okay. Listen, that was actually a very thoughtful answer to...
37:06 Bill Nye? You don't have to sound so surprised, Mr. Nice.
37:08 Chuck Nice? I, I, I, you're right, I shouldn't. You know, that was a thoughtful answer, and I'm not surprised at all, Bill.
37:13 Bill Nye? Thank you, Chuck.
37:13 Chuck Nice? Okay, here we go. So, let's move on to Joe Gaswa, uh, or Gassior. So, he's coming from Facebook, and he says...
37:23 Chuck Nice? He goes, "Hey, Bill, don't forget the dioxins better address this one, Bill."
37:30 Bill Nye? Uh, yeah, so dioxin was, uh...
37:33 Chuck Nice? I put that tone in there myself, by the way.
37:34 Bill Nye? Thank you, yeah. Uh, but I, I think you're in the spirit of his, uh, in- inquiry, his query. Uh, the, uh, dioxins were another chemical used, I guess, as a pesticide that turned out to have really troubling consequences.
37:47 Chuck Nice? Okay.
37:48 Bill Nye? And so, they've been curtailed, stopped. But I've met people in the biotech industry, in the seed business, who think DDT is a, was a great thing, cuz it...
37:58 Chuck Nice? Cuz it's hit the job.
37:59 Bill Nye? Well, suppressed mosquitoes, and that suppressed malaria, but I'm not sure DDT is what we all wanna be drinking. And so, dioxin was even more, uh, aggressive as a medical problem, and so, it's been curtailed, just that these companies used to make... Uh deadly herbicides used in warfare, Agent Orange.
38:20 Chuck Nice? Mm hmm.
38:21 Bill Nye? Well, they're, they were hired to do that and they're not doing it anymore. I don't know how responsible we should hold them. However, we should learn from the past. Like, don't, don't just make stuff that's amazingly deadly and spread it all over the place on another country and take no responsibility for it.
38:38 Chuck Nice? You know, that sounds like a good policy.
38:40 Bill Nye? But this, once again, Chuck, demands that, that evil word that is troubling to so many people nowadays.
38:48 Chuck Nice? Regulation.
38:50 Bill Nye? Where we'd all get together and decide what's fair and make people stick to it.
38:54 Chuck Nice? Regulators, mount up.
38:56 Bill Nye? Okay. Well, in moderation. So, uh, in general, this is a solvable problem. Far, the seed companies are in business to sell seeds to farmers and farmers want to buy seeds that they want to buy. And so the market takes care of it. However, having companies make pesticides or herbicides, which have bad consequences, you can regulate that.
39:19 Chuck Nice? I think what happens is, in the mind of the consumer, is you have a company like Monsanto, who makes the seeds. They genetically modify the seeds.
39:32 Bill Nye? They modify the plants that create the seeds.
39:34 Chuck Nice? They modify the plants to create the seeds. And then, they plant those seeds, then they make the food, and they also put the food on the shelf. And I think this is where a great deal of suspicion stems from.
39:47 Bill Nye? Vertically integrated.
39:48 Chuck Nice? It's vertically integrated and that makes you, that makes you scary. You know, that, that, that's, that's.
39:53 Bill Nye? Scared.
39:54 Chuck Nice? Yeah, it's scared.
39:55 Bill Nye? Well, yes, thank you.
39:55 Chuck Nice? I'm frightened.
39:56 Bill Nye? Sitting here is very troubling. Uh, I know what you meant, though.
40:01 Chuck Nice? Okay.
40:01 Bill Nye? It's another adjective related, the same root. I got you. But root, pun intended, when it comes to agriculture. So, the, the deal is, farmers make choices. They can do business with Pioneer or Monsanto or whatever and.
40:16 Bill Nye? Uh, you can buy food from this guy or that guy, but I know what you mean. It's troubling when you feel like you're out of control.
40:21 Chuck Nice? Right, because the whole process from stem to stern seems to be that.
40:25 Bill Nye? This is why, uh, the non-GMO movement has a place.
40:29 Chuck Nice? Okay.
40:30 Bill Nye? We'll see if that's economically competitive, like, and you can say corporations are squashing them. I don't think so. I think you'll find that organic farming takes more input than, uh, than, uh, farming with genetically modified crops. And so we'll let the marketplace sort that out. I mean, people make jokes about a certain business. And they call it whole paycheck.
40:54 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm, right.
40:55 Bill Nye? Because the food is so expensive.
40:57 Chuck Nice? That's right.
40:58 Bill Nye? Because it's grown in such small quantities with high input. So we'll see what happens in the marketplace.
41:04 Chuck Nice? All right. Okay, so let's move on to Tristan Cooper. Tristan Cooper wants to know, is it possible to genetically modify an animal to receive part of its daily energy requirement from photosynthesis? Now, this guy has gone sci-fi, baby.
41:23 Bill Nye? Well, there is an animal that makes a living that way. Zoazanthelie, the coral.
41:29 Chuck Nice? You are absolute... Oh my God, I never thought of it, because coral is a living animal.
41:34 Bill Nye? Yeah.
41:35 Chuck Nice? And it also gets its food from the sun.
41:38 Bill Nye? So it has a deal with some photosynthesizing, uh, organisms inside it. And a deal is a symbiotic relationship. So whether we're gonna have green cows, I'm open-minded, but I'm not sure. Because you think how much land, how much grass a cow has to consume to make its living.
41:58 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
41:59 Bill Nye? In other words, in order to get that much energy, the cow would have to be as big as a field. And so I get it, there could be a compromise of a giant solar panel cow that gets some of its energy from the sun and some of it from the grass. But what has happened through evolution is... We have cows eating grass.
42:17 Chuck Nice? Gotcha. Right.
42:18 Bill Nye? That's an example.
42:20 Chuck Nice? So it could happen. It's just not going to.
42:24 Bill Nye? However, on a much smaller scale at sea, it does happen with the Zoazanteli.
42:28 Chuck Nice? Which is the Carl. Fantastic. Man, that was, that was actually, I, I thought it was gonna be a silly question, but it's actually a very good question.
42:36 Bill Nye? Well, of course, our cosmic queerers, queryists, inquirers, our cosmic inquirers. There we go. Our cosmic inquirers. Are thoughtfully thoughtful. And of course, they're wonderful questions, Chuck. Let's take another.
42:49 Chuck Nice? All right. Okay. Hey, Bill, are there any true non-GMO foods? In other words, vegetables that just grow wild somewhere. No input from us whatsoever. And they have existed for years and years that way. And, and we just pluck them up from the side of the road and eat them or whatever.
43:13 Bill Nye? So, yeah. I, as a Boy Scout, spent some time eating wild carrots.
43:18 Chuck Nice? Wild carrots?
43:19 Bill Nye? Which are also called, they go by the name Queen Anne's Lace because the flower is quite lovely.
43:24 Chuck Nice? Oh, okay.
43:25 Bill Nye? And you pull them up and they're tiny. They're, yes, they're the cutest little Tonka Truck styled carrots. And they're barely a centimeter and a half. They're barely an inch long. And you pick them up and they really smell like carrots and you boil, you cut them, trim them. They're a root vegetable. And you boil them and you have Queen Anne's Lace soup. It's a thing to do.
43:47 Chuck Nice? Right.
43:47 Bill Nye? And as far as I know, there's no genetic modification of those organisms.
43:51 Chuck Nice? There you go.
43:52 Bill Nye? That's by way of one example. And people wander through the woods, they eat the nuts. There are some subsistence tribes. That harvest certain places in the woods. Truffles. But even truffles, my understanding, are cultivated. They're, you like, you leave this area alone, let the truffles happen. Well, I mean, I'm asking. And so then there's, even if you're a subsistence tribe in a rainforest, you move from area to area and let those areas replenish. So it is not a, not a huge step from that style of life, from, from sanctuary to sanctuary, getting the food that comes ripe at the right time.
44:34 Chuck Nice? Gotcha.
44:34 Bill Nye? To. Planning the stuff on purpose and managing it.
44:37 Chuck Nice? Okay, and P S, uh, um, Michael actually says, I'm writing you in for president.
44:44 Bill Nye? Oh, that's good. Uh, good to know.
44:46 Chuck Nice? So now it is time.
44:47 Bill Nye? That job. Man, oh, man. Is it time for the lightning round?
44:52 Chuck Nice? It's time.
44:55 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
44:55 Bill Nye? We love the lightning round. Hit me the ball.
44:57 Chuck Nice? All right, so our lightning round, we're gonna do as a potpourri. Okay, just miscellaneous questions from everywhere. All right. Here we go. This is Joss Squatch Stringer. Serious, that's the name, Joss Squatch Stringer. When can we get a new Bill Nye, the Science Guy show, even a web show, anything, Bill, please?
45:17 Bill Nye? I'm working on it. I'm starting with StarTalk Radio.
45:21 Chuck Nice? Bang. Let's talk about the space station. This comes from Brian. Let's talk about the space station. Do they get blinded by the sun every few minutes if continuously stargazing?
45:32 Bill Nye? I think the windows are tinted.
45:37 Chuck Nice? Okay.
45:40 Bill Nye? Chuck, it wasn't that funny. You have the option as an astronaut of not staring at the sun. And the thing is not aimed right at the sun. In fact, a couple of, where everybody hangs out there as an astronaut, looks at the earth because it's so beautiful and fascinating.
45:57 Chuck Nice? Jennifer Holford from Facebook wants to know, when are you two going to discuss nuclear energy? I can suggest several dozen experts who would love to help you out. Why don't we talk more about nuclear energy, Bill?
46:08 Bill Nye? Nuclear energy has great promise, but the nuclear industry in the U.S. has kind of been, how to say, not the most reliable. I used to live in Washington State. Every week, there was a problem at Hanford, some leak, some solvent, some something. And but look at the country of France.
46:23 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
46:24 Bill Nye? Forty years, they've been running eighty percent of their electricity with nuclear power plants. If we could get them... Figured out, maybe it's an alternative. However, I as a taxpayer and voter would like a little, a little better track record from the nuclear industry. You blow, you have 430 nuclear power, commercial nuclear power plants and three of them have catastrophic failures? Oh, that's not good.
46:48 Chuck Nice? Okay. All right. This is, uh, Jolene Williamson from Facebook. Who wants to know? Uh, Bill, are GMOs affecting the honeybees?
47:00 Bill Nye? Indirectly, yes. Uh, because monocultures, that is to say, our ability to grow enormous tracts of land into one style of plant has made the pollination of those plants troublesome for bees. They gotta show up. They gotta work this enormous field or sets of fields and then they gotta go back to their hive and get on a truck and go somewhere else. It wears them out, but it's an unintended consequence and something we could definitely address with careful farming practice.
47:31 Chuck Nice? All right. Jeff Norbury wants to know, a little time travel here. What do you think the most profound scientific discovery of the 21st century will be? We're in the 21st century right now. What do you think of, where, where are we headed? Where are we headed?
47:45 Bill Nye? Got no idea. However, I predicted in a hundred years, people will know whether or not there was life on Mars, whether or not there was life on the moon of Jupiter, Europa. Let's get it done right now.
47:57 Chuck Nice? Nice. Okay. This is Dave Harrison wants to say, he says, in your opinion, sir, is the difference between a bad GMO and perhaps a good GMO, is there such a difference? Is there good and bad GMOs?
48:10 Bill Nye? Well, sure. It's, uh, some of those tomatoes that were produced were not very, uh, enjoyable to consumers and they don't make much of them anymore.
48:20 Chuck Nice? Wow. There you go. So when they taste like crap, then, uh, that's a bad GMO.
48:26 Bill Nye? Or they're bland, or they're bland.
48:28 Chuck Nice? Gotcha. Would every strain of G, uh, wouldn't every strain of GMO need to be medically tested to be sure it's safe for human constru- consumption and do we do that?
48:38 Bill Nye? Yeah, we do. The Department of Agriculture does that. That's, that's their gig.
48:43 Chuck Nice? All right.
48:44 Bill Nye? They are a government agency that works for the good of all. For you anti-regulation people out there, you gotta have some regulation. The, the Department of Agriculture is a classic.
48:58 Bill Nye? Now Chuck, this has been perhaps the most enjoyable Cosma Query of my life. And I'm very happy that you are here. Thank you all for listening to StarTalk Radio. I've been your host, Bill Nye, and I'm here with my guest, science commentator Chuck Nice. Tune into StarTalk and turn it up loud.
Previous Cosmic Queries: GMOs with Bill Nye (Part 1) Next Exploring Science and Religion with Richard Dawkins Page updated September 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated