Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast Cosmic Queries: Comets and Asteroids with Dr. Amy Mainzer About this episode Curious about comets? Anxious about near-Earth asteroids? Join us as guest host Dr. Amy Mainzer from NASA/JPL answers your Cosmic Queries with a little help from comic co-host Chuck Nice.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk, your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:21 Speaker 01 Welcome to StarTalk Radio. I'm your guest host today. My name's Amy Mainzer and I'm an astronomer from the Jet Propulsion Laboratory. And I'm here today with my co-host Chuck Nice.
0:32 Chuck Nice? Hey Amy, how are you?
0:34 Speaker 01 I'm doing great. How are you?
0:35 Chuck Nice? I am great. I am, I gotta tell you, I am better because you are here and you are so much better looking than Neil.
0:43 Speaker 01 Oh, thank you.
0:45 Chuck Nice? Even though I miss Neil, I love him to death. Of course, he's off, uh...
0:49 Speaker 01 He's a busy guy right now.
0:50 Chuck Nice? Yes, he is. Doing the cosmos. That's what he's doing right now.
0:53 Speaker 01 Yeah, he's gonna become Mr. Universe pretty soon.
0:55 Chuck Nice? You know, and I'm sure that has been a dream of his for so long, to carry the title Mr. Universe. He actually can do that now.
1:02 Speaker 01 He actually can now.
1:03 Chuck Nice? So let me ask you something. Before we, before we jump into the show, of course, we're doing cosmic queries where we have a bunch of questions that are taken from Facebook, the internet, Twitter, StarTalk.net, and any number of outlets where you might find the StarTalk brand. But before we get into that, tell me about Jet Propulsion Labs. And I know that's part of NASA, or is it part of NASA?
1:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, this is part of NASA. And the funny thing about the name is, there really is no jet propulsion that goes on there whatsoever.
1:34 Chuck Nice? No jet propulsion at Jet Propulsion Labs?
1:36 Speaker 01 There is no jet propulsion at the Jet Propulsion Labs. It's a historical name.
1:39 Chuck Nice? Right.
1:40 Speaker 01 And it's back from the early days of rocketry. And I guess they thought calling it the Rocket Spaceship Lab was a little too weird in science fiction at the time. So they called it Jet Propulsion.
1:49 Chuck Nice? Jet Propulsion Labs.
1:50 Speaker 01 Yeah, sounded a little better.
1:51 Chuck Nice? And now what do you guys do there for NASA?
1:53 Speaker 01 Well, mostly we do robotic space missions. So we explore the solar system and the rest of the cosmos with our robots, which are basically our eyes and our ears.
2:02 Chuck Nice? Oh.
2:03 Speaker 01 Yeah, so it's great. I get to go explore the cosmos from the comfort of my couch, which I love.
2:10 Chuck Nice? Your own little robot up there doing the work.
2:11 Speaker 01 Absolutely. Yeah. So I don't have to, you know, I can still eat donuts. I mean,
2:17 Speaker 01 it's a much better life.
2:19 Chuck Nice? So you guys are, you're listening and watching the universe for us. You're like the NSA of the cosmos.
2:25 Speaker 01 Yes, except that we are not really interested in, you know, any sort of bad behavior, although we do like to look for things like potentially bad behaving asteroids. We do keep an eye on those with our robots.
2:36 Chuck Nice? Very cool. Very cool. And you look familiar to me in a way. I, I feel like I may have seen you on the History Channel. I hope I'm not embarrassing you, but I got, is that true?
2:46 Speaker 01 Yeah, I did. It used to be on that. Yeah.
2:48 Chuck Nice? Sweet.
2:49 Speaker 01 It was fun. It was really nice.
2:50 Chuck Nice? Very nice.
2:51 Speaker 01 One thing about scientists, we love to talk about science. In fact, try to get us to stop talking about science.
2:56 Chuck Nice? Well, that's good to know because that's exactly why we're here. And that's exactly what I got for you right now, which is a bunch of questions. And it is perfect for you because it's comets and asteroids.
3:06 Speaker 01 Oh, some of my favorite topics.
3:07 Chuck Nice? So here, here, so let's jump right into this and um, let's start off with uh, Steve Bristo. How did the asteroid belt in our solar system come to be in orbit?
3:23 Chuck Nice? And how did they come to be? Period. Where did they originate?
3:28 Speaker 01 Oh, the asteroids. They asteroids and comets are kind of like the leftover bits of junk. They were the remnants of what happened when our solar system first formed about four and a half billion years ago. Now I'm going to channel Carl Sagan here. Four and a half billion years ago.
3:44 Chuck Nice? Wow. Okay.
3:45 Speaker 01 How's that?
3:46 Chuck Nice? You sound a little Dr. Evil when you do it. Four and a half.
3:49 Speaker 01 Billion.
3:52 Speaker 01 Well, the thing about that is, is that all those years ago, there was a giant cloud of gas and dust. In the beginning, there was a whole lot of junk, a lot of gas and dust, and it collapsed under the influence of gravity. Eventually it formed a sun in the center. The stuff got hot enough and dense enough to ignite fusion. And the rest of it clumped into planets. Jupiter swept up most of the stuff because Jupiter is the biggest planet.
4:16 Chuck Nice? So huge.
4:16 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's this whopping massive planet in our solar system. And then it forms. Saturn and all the other smaller planets. Well, the thing is, is they didn't quite clean up the mess they left behind.
4:26 Chuck Nice? Gotcha.
4:26 Speaker 01 There's always a little bit of bits and pieces there left. And those little bits of kind of space debris, if you will. Those are what became the asteroids and the comets today. Things that formed a little further away from the sun where it was cold, really dark. Those are what formed the comets, the icy stuff.
4:43 Chuck Nice? Right.
4:44 Speaker 01 And the stuff that formed closer to the middle, well, that's the rockier stuff. It was too hot for ice to form there. So that's how you get asteroids. Yeah.
4:51 Chuck Nice? So right there is the difference between comets and asteroids.
4:54 Speaker 01 Yes.
4:55 Chuck Nice? So one, big giant ice balls.
4:57 Speaker 01 Yep.
4:58 Chuck Nice? And the other, big giant rock balls.
5:01 Speaker 01 Exactly. Space rocks versus space sort of icy rocky things.
5:05 Chuck Nice? Okay.
5:06 Speaker 01 And now it's kind of a continuum. We find asteroids that sometimes masquerade as comets. And then we have comets that sometimes turn into asteroids. So there's kind of a weird, we used to think they were two totally different kinds of things. And now we know that there's kind of a gray area in between. Yeah.
5:22 Chuck Nice? Kind of like actors who want to be music stars.
5:25 Speaker 01 Okay, so yeah, they're slashies, right?
5:27 Chuck Nice? Right, there's actor slash dancer.
5:29 Speaker 01 Yes.
5:29 Chuck Nice? Actor slash, you know, musician. I'm Kevin Bacon. I'm a big actor, but I'm also in a band with my brother. Like that type of dude.
5:38 Speaker 01 Exactly. Sometimes we have asteroids who are, well, sometimes we emit lots of gas and have, you know, comas that come off of us.
5:44 Chuck Nice? Okay, thank God you were talking about the asteroids.
5:50 Chuck Nice? You caught me, bud. You caught me off guard there, baby.
5:55 Chuck Nice? Go ahead, though.
5:56 Speaker 01 So yeah, so sometimes these are, these are the slashies of the, of the, of the solar system. They're basically things that sometimes can cross the boundary between asteroids and comets.
6:05 Chuck Nice? And comets.
6:05 Speaker 01 So that's right.
6:06 Chuck Nice? So basically, these things have been here from the beginning of our solar system.
6:09 Speaker 01 Yes, that's right.
6:10 Chuck Nice? And they're just basically remnants that are still kind of hanging around.
6:13 Speaker 01 Exactly.
6:14 Chuck Nice? Like teenagers that will not move out of their parents' house.
6:17 Speaker 01 In, in fact, and they make a giant mess occasionally.
6:20 Chuck Nice? Right.
6:20 Speaker 01 Sometimes they even crash into things.
6:23 Chuck Nice? They really are teenagers.
6:24 Speaker 01 They are very badly behaved sometimes.
6:26 Chuck Nice? Asteroids, the teenagers of the cosmos. All right, cool. Well, there you go, Mr. Bristow. There's your answer. So let's move on. That's a, that's a very good answer. I'm glad you said that. Here's another one from Twitter. Uh, EM at. Infinity X-91.
6:42 Speaker 01 Hmm.
6:42 Chuck Nice? Okay, there's a handle for you.
6:44 Speaker 01 Hmm.
6:44 Chuck Nice? How does a rock become a comet? So you told us about this gray area, so you know, this is a great follow-up question. How does a rock become the actual comet?
6:55 Speaker 01 Well, every now and again, we see some strange behavior in the asteroid belt between Mars and Jupiter.
7:00 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
7:00 Speaker 01 In fact, in recent years, we've seen asteroids that suddenly kind of explode or have like a big poof of dust come off of them.
7:06 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
7:07 Speaker 01 We think what happens is that sometimes they get hit by other asteroids.
7:10 Chuck Nice? Okay.
7:11 Speaker 01 And it makes a mess and it looks like a comet.
7:13 Chuck Nice? Ah.
7:14 Speaker 01 They're tricky. They masquerade sometimes.
7:16 Chuck Nice? So they're masquerading as a comet?
7:18 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:18 Chuck Nice? They're not necessarily, so they don't really have the ice on them.
7:22 Speaker 01 Exactly.
7:22 Chuck Nice? They just have the dust that's coming off of them like ice melting away.
7:27 Speaker 01 You got it.
7:27 Chuck Nice? So it creates the appearance of a tail, but it's not really like a comet.
7:31 Speaker 01 And they are a big mystery. So that's one of the great mysteries of our solar system. There's always something new to learn, you know?
7:36 Chuck Nice? Right.
7:37 Speaker 01 Sometimes asteroids act like comets.
7:39 Chuck Nice? There you go.
7:40 Speaker 01 So...
7:41 Chuck Nice? Oh, so I get it. Asteroids are the drag queens of the universe.
7:46 Speaker 01 Call RuPaul, yes.
7:47 Chuck Nice? (laughing).
7:48 Speaker 01 And with that, it's time to take a short break. We will be right back.
8:10 Speaker 01 Welcome back. Here we are again on StarTalkRadio.net and I'm here with my co-host Chuck Nice. You can catch him on Twitter.
8:16 Chuck Nice? That's right.
8:17 Speaker 01 At ChuckNiceComic.
8:18 Chuck Nice? At ChuckNiceComic and I might as well return the favor because you are at Amy Mainzer and that's M-A-I-N-Z-E-R, Amy Mainzer, right?
8:28 Speaker 01 Yeah.
8:28 Chuck Nice? On Twitter.com.
8:29 Speaker 01 It's a very good German name, yes.
8:30 Chuck Nice? Yeah. And I understand you roller skate. That's something that we were talking about in the break.
8:33 Speaker 01 I do, I roller skate.
8:34 Chuck Nice? And what is the purpose of that?
8:35 Speaker 01 Oh, it's because it's as unlike work as you can get, but it is also, it is very good exercise. That's what I tell myself.
8:42 Chuck Nice? So not inline skating, actual roller skating?
8:44 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah. Old school quad skates, yeah.
8:46 Chuck Nice? And do you, do you roll and bounce?
8:48 Speaker 01 I do, in fact, roll and bounce and...
8:50 Chuck Nice? And do you have a giant like, uh, radio that you carry on your shoulder while you're doing it?
8:54 Speaker 01 Well, I'm actually very proud of this. Uh, my skate partner and I, we, uh, won the JPL Talent Show, the first annual JPL Talent Show. So I'm very proud of that.
9:02 Chuck Nice? Sweet.
9:02 Speaker 01 It was, you know, it was the JPL Talent Show, so it's not exactly American Idol, you know?
9:07 Chuck Nice? Right, I understand. Yeah, you gotta consider the competition, right?
9:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, but we roller skated for that, so.
9:11 Chuck Nice? Sweet.
9:12 Speaker 01 That was good.
9:13 Chuck Nice? Hey, well, let's jump back into our cosmic queries and, uh, we're talking about comets and asteroids, and we have, uh, called questions from all over the internet. And this one comes from Facebook, Jeff Turner, and he says, "Any concrete plans for launching exploratory missions to the Kuiper Belt?"
9:29 Speaker 01 Ah, okay, so the Kuiper Belt for folks is a region of, of icy bodies that are comet-like, and probably some of the, the origins of the comets are out there. And it's out really pretty far away in the solar system. So this is this leftover bits of stuff from the formation of the solar system. It's very cold, very far away.
9:47 Chuck Nice? Right.
9:47 Speaker 01 Getting there is tough. Now, the thing is, we have a mission that NASA has launched a long time ago. I think it might even be nine years ago now. It's not going all the way out there, but it is going to Pluto, our favorite non-planet.
10:02 Chuck Nice? Our favorite ice ball in the sky.
10:04 Speaker 01 Yes, and there are some plans, once this mission, which is called New Horizons, once it goes flying past Pluto, there may be a plan to see if there's a place it could go to visit in the Kuiper Belt. So we're just gonna have to see what comes up.
10:16 Chuck Nice? Okay.
10:17 Speaker 01 But it is on its way, and it has got a long way to go.
10:20 Chuck Nice? So, um, there's your answer, Jeff. Um, there are concrete plans, um, they're just somewhat tentative.
10:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, they gotta find the object first, that's the problem.
10:31 Chuck Nice? Right.
10:31 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's actually tough. These things are so far away and they're super faint.
10:35 Chuck Nice? Right.
10:35 Speaker 01 It's really hard to see them, so they're trying to find a place for, for New Horizons to go after the Pluto encounter.
10:40 Chuck Nice? Right.
10:41 Speaker 01 So wish us luck.
10:42 Chuck Nice? Again, and in the meantime, you got Pluto to hold you over.
10:44 Speaker 01 Exactly.
10:45 Chuck Nice? Okay, and that's not so bad.
10:46 Speaker 01 It's gonna be a nice show for Pluto, pretty soon.
10:48 Chuck Nice? All right, so, uh, let's go to our next question, also from Facebook, and this is, uh, Tony Anunziata, okay? "When was the first comet discovered?" And what was it called?
11:00 Speaker 01 Oh.
11:00 Chuck Nice? Ah, that's a good one.
11:02 Speaker 01 Okay, that is a good one.
11:03 Chuck Nice? Little comet history for you there, Amy.
11:04 Speaker 01 Cometary history, yes. So actually, I think the first comet was probably observed by ancient humans long before recorded history. And if you look back, you can see drawings of where obviously comets in some very, very ancient texts, you know, from the Chinese, from all over the world, people saw these these strange wandering stars in the sky.
11:25 Chuck Nice? Right.
11:26 Speaker 01 And of course, if you were a court astronomer and you did not correctly predict one of these objects' arrivals, you could get in some very big trouble.
11:33 Chuck Nice? Really?
11:34 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah. Because comets in a lot of times in the past were considered bad omens.
11:40 Chuck Nice? Okay.
11:40 Speaker 01 And frightening. People were scared of them because they didn't know what they were. I mean, they're just these bright things that appear in the sky randomly.
11:45 Chuck Nice? Right. And the gods were angry.
11:47 Speaker 01 Yeah.
11:48 Chuck Nice? And of course, we got some really good information from the dinosaurs about, you know.
11:52 Speaker 01 Yes, we know today.
11:53 Chuck Nice? What could possibly happen?
11:54 Speaker 01 What could possibly go wrong, right?
11:56 Chuck Nice? Right, yeah.
11:56 Speaker 01 So nowadays, you know, we have a little better chance at predicting the arrival of comets. And fortunately speaking, as a professional astronomer, I know that it's not off with my head if I don't correctly predict one's arrival.
12:07 Chuck Nice? Right.
12:07 Speaker 01 But we still try to do our best.
12:08 Chuck Nice? Yeah. You know, one of my favorite, this is an aside, but now that you said this, one of my favorite animated series of all time is a series called The Avatar. And it's all about, the very beginning of the series is all about the arrival of a comet.
12:23 Speaker 01 Oh.
12:24 Chuck Nice? That will give these people superpowers.
12:28 Speaker 01 Very cool.
12:29 Chuck Nice? It is cool.
12:30 Speaker 01 Well, you know, the kind of funny thing about comets is we think that they may have even brought some of the chemicals we need for life. That's kind of a superpower.
12:37 Chuck Nice? That is a superpower.
12:39 Speaker 01 After a way.
12:39 Chuck Nice? So now, let me ask you this. When you, because this is one of the theories that I've heard, is that the Earth, not only is it in a perfect position to support life, but the life itself was seeded on the planet by, in fact, a comet itself.
13:00 Chuck Nice? Is that the case?
13:01 Speaker 01 Well, we know for sure that comets have a lot of water and they got a lot of other chemicals in them. They even have, in some cases, I think they know of some really complicated things, which are the precursors of our DNA, basically. So it could be possible, and there are theories out there that say that these comets came in and basically pouted the Earth when it was first formed.
13:20 Chuck Nice? Right.
13:21 Speaker 01 And that may have been enough to get the process started.
13:24 Chuck Nice? Nice!
13:25 Speaker 01 Pretty cool.
13:26 Chuck Nice? There you go, people. You have your whole life, it's owed to a comet. There you go.
13:31 Speaker 01 That's a pretty good omen, right there.
13:33 Chuck Nice? That's not a bad omen. Alright, let's go on with Robert Rushing. And Robert says this, "Greetings from the UK," or should I say, "Greetings from the UK."
13:44 Chuck Nice? "I have heard some theorize that the water on Earth could have been deposited here by comets, which is what you just said. These comets have to come from somewhere. So do you think they orig- so where do you think they originated from? And what is the source of their water?" And that's a really involved question there, and that's a tough one for you to test.
14:05 Speaker 01 Well, it's certainly not the tap, clearly.
14:09 Speaker 01 They definitely have to come from somewhere far away.
14:11 Chuck Nice? It ain't Avion.
14:12 Speaker 01 No, it is not Avion, definitely not. So we know that the comets come from a couple different sources in our solar system. They are, some of them are way out there, and we think they might even be halfway to the nearest star.
14:23 Chuck Nice? Wow.
14:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, really far, really cold, super cold, deep freeze. And that stuff that's been out there is very, very old. It is ancient.
14:31 Chuck Nice? Right.
14:32 Speaker 01 And it is, again, billions.
14:33 Chuck Nice? Billions.
14:34 Speaker 01 Billions.
14:34 Chuck Nice? Billions of years old.
14:37 Speaker 01 It's extremely old. So when it gets here, every now and again, we don't even know exactly how, but sometimes these objects get kind of shuffled loose from that cloud that surrounds our solar system. We call it the Oort Cloud. And occasionally, one will get flung inward and bring all of that ice and volatile material inwards. And when it gets to the sun, what happens?
14:56 Chuck Nice? It starts to melt, because our sun's, from what I hear, kind of hot.
14:59 Speaker 01 Uh, yes.
14:59 Chuck Nice? Yes.
15:00 Speaker 01 Exactly. So the sun basically does a number on the comet, starts to vaporize it, and it can form a big, long tail. And eventually, some of them actually make their way to Earth. We think that that may have been how a lot of the Earth's oceans actually formed.
15:14 Chuck Nice? Wow, are you serious? Like, it was that much ice?
15:18 Speaker 01 Could have been, yeah.
15:19 Chuck Nice? So, wow. So, the tail of the comet is actually expelling that much ice that if it were to get caught in the Earth's gravitational pull, pulled down, it creates oceans?
15:30 Speaker 01 Imagine lots of comets.
15:32 Chuck Nice? Lots of them.
15:33 Speaker 01 Lots of comets. I mean, right now, this is kind of a quiet time in our solar system's history.
15:37 Chuck Nice? Oh, God, you're scaring me.
15:38 Speaker 01 And now, we're kind of glad, we're glad for that, right?
15:40 Chuck Nice? Yes, we are.
15:41 Speaker 01 Because life here on Earth does not really like it when things get too interesting.
15:43 Chuck Nice? No, exactly.
15:44 Speaker 01 So, but early on, when the solar system was first forming, we do think there was a period when the Earth pretty much just got pelted by asteroids and comets. And that could have been when the water got here.
15:54 Chuck Nice? Wow. That is fascinating. Very cool. All right, well, there you go, Robert. That's, uh, there's your answer. That's where this stuff comes from. And, uh, let's hope it never happens again.
16:04 Speaker 01 Yes.
16:05 Chuck Nice? Exactly. All right, let's move on to, uh, Dimitri. And, uh, Dimitri wants to know this, writing us from Facebook. What is the biggest asteroid we've ever observed?
16:15 Speaker 01 Oh.
16:16 Chuck Nice? If it gets to a certain size and it isn't orbiting anything, is it just considered a rogue planet?
16:25 Speaker 01 Oh, ho.
16:25 Chuck Nice? So, compound question. First of all, what's the biggest one we've ever seen and we've recorded? And secondly, what is the size where it's no longer an asteroid that it's just rogue planet? And do we know those answers?
16:37 Speaker 01 Right, we do know those answers, although the second answer is kind of a religious warfare question.
16:41 Chuck Nice? Really? Ooh.
16:43 Speaker 01 Always the fun stuff.
16:44 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
16:45 Speaker 01 But, uh, yeah, the first, the biggest planet, or the biggest asteroid that we know about in our solar system is called Ceres.
16:50 Chuck Nice? Ceres.
16:51 Speaker 01 Yes. And it's, I think it's about the size of Texas. It's a big asteroid.
16:54 Chuck Nice? Holy moly.
16:55 Speaker 01 But, lucky for us, it is safely away in the main asteroid belt between Mars and Jupiter, so it's not going anywhere.
17:02 Chuck Nice? So, it's not going anywhere?
17:03 Speaker 01 No, you don't have to worry about Ceres.
17:04 Chuck Nice? So, Ceres is not trying to make a house call?
17:06 Speaker 01 Uh, oh, no. We actually like it right where it is.
17:09 Chuck Nice? Okay.
17:09 Speaker 01 We do not want it to come visit us.
17:11 Chuck Nice? Unlike Apophis.
17:12 Speaker 01 Which is gonna get really close.
17:14 Chuck Nice? Who's, who's kind of just like peeking in the window.
17:16 Speaker 01 Yeah.
17:17 Chuck Nice? Little pervert that it is.
17:18 Speaker 01 That is gonna get a little too close for comfort. It won't hit. We are very sure of that.
17:22 Chuck Nice? We're sure of that.
17:23 Speaker 01 But we're gonna keep track of that one.
17:24 Chuck Nice? Okay.
17:25 Speaker 01 We're gonna keep watching that one.
17:26 Chuck Nice? All right, and so now, uh, the second part of this compound question was, what size, if there is, because I don't know, where it's no longer an asteroid, it's a rogue planet?
17:38 Speaker 01 Well, the funny thing about Ceres is it has a joint name. It is also called a dwarf planet. And that's the religious warfare part, right? Because look what happened to poor Pluto. Is it a planet, or is it now what's called a dwarf planet?
17:51 Chuck Nice? Okay, now, before you go any further, is it true that the reason why Pluto isn't really a planet is because it's mostly ice? Is that what it be?
17:58 Speaker 01 Oh, boy.
17:59 Chuck Nice? So now, if Ceres were mostly rock, is it really a dwarf planet?
18:02 Speaker 01 These are all really tricky questions, and I predict that astronomers are going to be fighting over this for many decades to come.
18:08 Chuck Nice? Oh, so really, this is, this is basically the contention at the Thanksgiving table where it's just full of...
18:13 Speaker 01 Yeah, it gets pretty unpleasant at some of these meetings, I gotta say. Astronomers are normally pretty quiet people, but not when it comes to this stuff.
18:19 Chuck Nice? Not when it comes to dwarf planets.
18:20 Speaker 01 No. Well, that brings us to the end of this segment, and we'll be right back on StarTalk Radio.
18:43 Speaker 01 And we're back on StarTalk Radio. So you ready to go, Chuck?
18:47 Chuck Nice? Yes, I am, Amy, and, uh, we're doing cosmic queries. We've got questions from all over the internet, no matter where they come from, uh, whether it's Facebook, Twitter, or what have you. And this next one is from Marco Horvath. Marco says this, "Everyone knows about Halley's Comet. How often does a comet that is visible to the naked eye appear, and when is the next one?"
19:09 Speaker 01 Oh, when is the next super comet?
19:12 Chuck Nice? Yes.
19:12 Speaker 01 Oh, boy. Okay, well, there's always a comet of the century that people get really excited about, but they don't happen that often, actually. So, we see naked eye comets, oh, maybe once every few decades or so, something like that. If you're really lucky, one will get really, really active. The thing about comets, though, is they are so hard to predict. They just do whatever they feel like.
19:32 Chuck Nice? Oh, I like that about.
19:33 Speaker 01 I know. Sometimes, well, it's annoying if you're an astronomer because you want to know what are you doing, stupid comet, right?
19:38 Chuck Nice? Right.
19:39 Speaker 01 So part of the time, we can tell that they're going to get really bright and really active when they get close to the sun, but sometimes they just don't feel like it. And they don't.
19:48 Chuck Nice? They really are like teenagers.
19:49 Speaker 01 They are exactly like teenagers, or cats.
19:51 Chuck Nice? Or cats. I like that. Comets, the cats of the universe.
19:54 Speaker 01 Exactly.
19:55 Chuck Nice? Come here, come here.
19:56 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's like, I don't feel like it.
19:57 Chuck Nice? Oh.
19:58 Speaker 01 So we just recently had a so-called comet of the century called Comet Ison.
20:03 Chuck Nice? Comet Ison.
20:04 Speaker 01 And it was supposed to make a very close pass by the sun and people thought it might become a spectacular naked eye comet that everybody could see.
20:12 Chuck Nice? Right.
20:13 Speaker 01 Thing is, it got a little too close to the sun.
20:16 Chuck Nice? Oh, so now does that negate all of the fireworks because things just burn off so quickly?
20:23 Speaker 01 Yeah.
20:24 Chuck Nice? Is that what happens?
20:25 Speaker 01 It pretty much was a, it was a bust.
20:26 Chuck Nice? So it's a dud.
20:27 Speaker 01 It, it wasn't just even a dud, it was a nothing. I mean, the comet literally fell apart.
20:33 Chuck Nice? Oh, really?
20:34 Speaker 01 It got super close to the sun and it got so close that it basically, everybody was watching and waiting to see what would happen and the sun pretty much just.
20:41 Chuck Nice? Just destabilized it completely.
20:43 Speaker 01 Yeah, poof, gone.
20:44 Chuck Nice? So now it's just, oh, man, what a shame.
20:45 Speaker 01 It was such a disappointment because we were really hoping it would come back and make this great light work, you know, great fireworks show and yeah.
20:51 Chuck Nice? And nothing.
20:51 Speaker 01 Nothing, just like.
20:53 Chuck Nice? A big nothing.
20:54 Speaker 01 Just like cats.
20:54 Chuck Nice? Uh, kind of like Geraldo Rivera and the vault.
20:58 Speaker 01 Yeah, I, oh, I remember that.
21:00 Chuck Nice? Remember that?
21:01 Speaker 01 That was really disappointing.
21:02 Chuck Nice? That was very disappointing, right?
21:04 Speaker 01 Well, this was the vault of the comet world, Comet Ison.
21:07 Chuck Nice? There we go.
21:07 Speaker 01 It was a bust.
21:08 Chuck Nice? All right, Marco, there you have it. That is, uh, that's what's happening. Um, let's move on to Scott McGregor. And here's what Scott wants to know. Do you, Amy, have a favorite asteroid or comet? If so, why? Which one do you think is the most interesting?
21:24 Speaker 01 Oh, this is just, this is, no, I can't answer this question. This is like Sophie's Choice.
21:29 Chuck Nice? Is that like asking you to pick a kid?
21:30 Speaker 01 I love them all. They're all my favorites. I love them all.
21:34 Chuck Nice? Come on now.
21:35 Speaker 01 Okay, well, all right. I like the ones that I discovered.
21:41 Chuck Nice? You really do like your own children.
21:43 Speaker 01 I do like my own children. It's kind of bad. Actually, there is one particular weirdo thing that we found with our survey when we were out looking for asteroids. And it's called the first known Earth Trojan. And this is an asteroid that actually is stuck to the Earth in a peculiar way.
21:59 Chuck Nice? Okay, really?
22:01 Speaker 01 Yeah.
22:02 Chuck Nice? Now, it's stuck to the Earth?
22:05 Speaker 01 It is actually trapped in a gravitational resonance with the Earth, which sounds really cool. And this actually is a really cool asteroid. It's basically, Earth is following it around in its orbit around the Sun.
22:18 Chuck Nice? Sweet.
22:19 Speaker 01 And it's kind of trapped there. And what's going to happen is, after a while, eventually it's going to pop its way out.
22:25 Chuck Nice? Right, but right now it's like a little mama's boy.
22:27 Speaker 01 Oh, yes.
22:28 Chuck Nice? Just trapped, can't get out.
22:29 Speaker 01 Can't get out, won't leave.
22:30 Chuck Nice? Won't leave. And Earth is like, no, you come with me! No, I can't see my baby go.
22:37 Speaker 01 She's like, no, no, don't leave me.
22:39 Chuck Nice? So, so that's, that's, okay.
22:41 Speaker 01 That's one of my favorites.
22:42 Chuck Nice? That's one of your favorites.
22:42 Speaker 01 If I had to pick.
22:43 Chuck Nice? Very cool. All right, let's move on. Nathan Holmes wants to know this, writing in from Facebook. I just read about the Rosetta satellite that would be launching a probe into a comet. Would it be possible to land equipment on the surface? That would, in essence, turn the comet, check this out, into a deep space satellite?
23:08 Speaker 01 Ooh.
23:08 Chuck Nice? Yo, that's a brilliant idea.
23:10 Speaker 01 That is some cool science fiction right there.
23:12 Chuck Nice? That's some cool sci-fi right there.
23:14 Speaker 01 Yeah.
23:14 Chuck Nice? So what is the probability and could it happen?
23:16 Speaker 01 Okay, well, so the Rosetta mission is actually going to send a lander to this comet. Now, don't ask me to pronounce the name, I always get it wrong. We call it Cherry Gary for short.
23:25 Chuck Nice? Cherry Gary comet?
23:26 Speaker 01 Yeah.
23:27 Chuck Nice? Sounds like a flavor of a soda.
23:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly.
23:29 Chuck Nice? I was drinking some Cherry Gary, man, it's delicious.
23:31 Speaker 01 It's like Cherryumoff Grasimenco. Yeah, Cherry Gary.
23:36 Chuck Nice? Cherry Gary.
23:37 Speaker 01 So this thing is going to land on Cherry Gary, coming up pretty soon. And it's going to basically take a whole bunch of measurements of this comet. It's going to tell us a lot about what it's made out of.
23:48 Chuck Nice? Okay.
23:48 Speaker 01 Now, turning an asteroid or a comet into a spaceship, well, that's a tougher thing to do.
23:54 Chuck Nice? Okay.
23:54 Speaker 01 That's a lot harder because these things are huge compared to our spacecraft, a lot of them. And this comet is a pretty big one. This is, you know, a kilometer or more across. So it's pretty large and the little lander is really not that much bigger than a suitcase.
24:07 Chuck Nice? Okay.
24:08 Speaker 01 It's not a very large lander.
24:10 Chuck Nice? Right.
24:10 Speaker 01 So you're really talking about a flea trying to push an elephant.
24:13 Chuck Nice? Okay, I got you. So now, is it possible to hitch a ride on a comet and use it as a deep space probe? Or would that even be necessary?
24:26 Speaker 01 Sure. Well, who wouldn't like a ride along with a comet?
24:28 Chuck Nice? Right.
24:29 Speaker 01 It could be really fun. So that's kind of what Rosetta is going to do. It's actually going to ride with this comet as it goes around the sun for a while.
24:37 Chuck Nice? Got you.
24:37 Speaker 01 And it's going to monitor the comet to see how it changes when it gets too close to the sun, when it, as it heats up, as it cools down. So it is going to teach us a lot about how comets behave.
24:46 Chuck Nice? Sweet.
24:48 Speaker 01 Yeah, Rosetta's a pretty cool mission. Really looking forward to it.
24:50 Chuck Nice? Awesome, awesome. Well, there you go, Nathan. There's your answer.
24:53 Speaker 01 So we're going to take another short little break here and we will be right back with StarTalk Radio.
25:16 Speaker 01 And we're back. We're here on StarTalk Radio Cosmic Queries Edition. And check us out on social media. We are all over the internet. We're at StarTalkRadio.net and you can catch us on Facebook and Twitter at StarTalk Radio.
25:28 Chuck Nice? Absolutely. Well, let's jump right back into this, Amy. We have from Yelena Noskina, who actually has kind of a follow-up question. Some comets are said to be traveling for thousands of years and yet we see Ison get burned up by the sun. How is it that we have comets at all?
25:52 Speaker 01 So Ison was a spectacular science event of the year. This is a comet that came in from the Oort Cloud. It came in from far away and it has been out there for billions of years.
26:03 Chuck Nice? Right, right.
26:04 Speaker 01 Wait, you have to say it.
26:05 Chuck Nice? Billions of years.
26:07 Speaker 01 Yeah, that.
26:08 Chuck Nice? Right.
26:09 Speaker 01 So it came in and it made its way into the inner solar system. But not only did it get in, but it made a very close brush with the sun. Just a few times the radius of the sun itself. And that is so hot. The thing is, is people had no idea what was going to happen. Now, we see sun, what we call sun grazer comets. And these are little tiny comets by and large that just get pulled into the sun. We see them with our satellites that are actually watching the sun. And the sun just eats them up, just like breakfast cereal.
26:37 Chuck Nice? There you go. It's a Scooby snack for the sun.
26:40 Speaker 01 Exactly.
26:40 Chuck Nice? Comets.
26:41 Speaker 01 Exactly. Well, this one was a much bigger comet.
26:45 Chuck Nice? Okay.
26:46 Speaker 01 This was about more than a kilometer across. It's mostly very primitive ice that sat there from the beginning of time.
26:53 Chuck Nice? Wow.
26:53 Speaker 01 Okay, the beginning of our solar system, anyway.
26:55 Chuck Nice? Right.
26:55 Speaker 01 And when it got close to the sun, nobody knew. Was it gonna flare up and put on this spectacular light show in our night sky? Or was the sun just gonna tear it apart? And we were watching this thing on our satellites in real time. It was really spectacular. I mean, these satellites allow us to have this great view of the thing.
27:13 Chuck Nice? Right.
27:13 Speaker 01 Well, turns out the sun tore it apart.
27:16 Chuck Nice? Tore it apart.
27:17 Speaker 01 Yeah.
27:17 Chuck Nice? Dag. So it just, basically, the sun is Thunderdome for comets.
27:23 Speaker 01 Poor old comet Ison did not leave the Thunderdome.
27:26 Chuck Nice? Did not leave the...
27:28 Chuck Nice? One comet checks in, no comet checks out.
27:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, it was pretty disappointing for comet watchers.
27:35 Chuck Nice? So, uh, basically, it's kind of like, um, you know, it's very fortuitous to be able to see a comet, you know, get into our solar system, get by the sun, and then continue on so that we can see this spectacular display in the sky.
27:53 Speaker 01 Absolutely, yeah.
27:54 Chuck Nice? Because what you're saying is these sun grazer comets, as you called them,
27:57 Speaker 01 Yep.
27:57 Chuck Nice? happen all the time.
27:58 Speaker 01 Yeah, they happen all the time. And that was a huge surprise until we really started monitoring the sun consistently.
28:03 Chuck Nice? Right.
28:03 Speaker 01 We didn't know about these things. I mean, we saw comets that, you know, kind of went around the sun and didn't get too close and they went on their merry way. But these sun grazers, they just get swallowed up whole.
28:14 Chuck Nice? Well, there you go, Yelena. There's your answer. The sun, the roach motel for comets.
28:20 Chuck Nice? All right, let's move on. We have Anton Prius. And Anton says, could we ever send some sort of organism to test if they could survive on an asteroid or a comet? So now, we're always interested in pulling stuff off of these things.
28:39 Speaker 01 Sure.
28:39 Chuck Nice? Could we put something on it?
28:41 Speaker 01 Ooh, well, this is a toughie. Okay, so in a sense, we kind of already have. When we send spacecraft to asteroids, there was a spacecraft called NEAR, the Near Earth Asteroid Rendezvous Mission, and it went, and it actually touched down on an asteroid. In a curious sense, we do our very best to clean these spacecraft and get them super duper clean. But you know, there's always little bits of germs and bacteria that are left. We try really hard to get them super clean. So I'm sure there's a little bit of some space DNA now out there on that asteroid. Whether it survived, of course, probably not. Asteroids are pretty hostile. There's no air.
29:16 Chuck Nice? Right.
29:16 Speaker 01 For most of these things.
29:17 Chuck Nice? Right.
29:18 Speaker 01 And they can get either burningly hot or terribly, terribly cold.
29:22 Chuck Nice? So it's very unlikely that life would be able to survive on an asteroid.
29:28 Speaker 01 That would be my guess. You know, it's a, it's a nice place here on Earth, and it's probably not such a nice place to take a vacation.
29:35 Chuck Nice? There you go. So, but we can always hope.
29:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, there is always hope.
29:40 Chuck Nice? Unfortunately, whatever did survive there would probably come back and kill us all. Like Wrath of Khan.
29:46 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's it. Andromeda strain style, that's it.
29:49 Chuck Nice? Exactly, Andromeda strain, exactly. All right, let's move on. We got Jake Betcher, at Jake Betcher. He says, if an asteroid were on a collision course for Earth, what method would be used to deflect it, and how long would it take to prepare this?
30:03 Speaker 01 You got it. Okay, so we actually think about this a lot. And what we try to do is find the asteroids well in advance of any potential close encounters, because that gives us the most flexibility to design a mitigation system. There are options to deflect it by just, you know, simply whacking into it.
30:19 Chuck Nice? Just hit it.
30:19 Speaker 01 Just hit it. The Deep Impact Mission actually did that with a comet in 2005. It just ran into the comet.
30:24 Chuck Nice? Right.
30:25 Speaker 01 And that actually can push something. If you have enough time. You might be able to do something that's just a simple kinetic impactor.
30:31 Chuck Nice? So there you go, Jake. Your answer is just like your health, early detection is the key.
30:36 Speaker 01 Exactly. So we're going to have more here when we come back to StarTalk Radio.
30:59 Speaker 01 And we're back on StarTalk Radio. I'm Amy Mainzer, your friendly neighborhood astrophysicist from the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, and I'm here with Chuck Nice. And now it's time for the lightning round.
31:09 Chuck Nice? Yes.
31:10 Speaker 01 Okay.
31:11 Chuck Nice? And that's the sound you will hear when you finish answering the question, or when Amy finishes answering the question. And let's jump right into this.
31:19 Speaker 01 Here we go.
31:20 Chuck Nice? Steve B. from Twitter wants to know, who tweets at @BeerCannon, "Is there a maximum speed for asteroids/Comets and could something approach so quickly that we'd never see it coming?"
31:30 Speaker 01 Oh, the average speed of most asteroids and comets is about 20 or 30 kilometers per second. That's really fast.
31:36 Chuck Nice? That's very fast.
31:37 Speaker 01 Forty thousand miles an hour. And it is possible that they sometimes come in faster depending on their orbits. Things can come in from directions that we cannot see.
31:47 Chuck Nice? Oh, that is not the answer I wanted to hear.
31:49 Speaker 01 Oh.
31:50 Chuck Nice? Okay. Shahan Tasneem wants to know this. "How plausible is the theory that our moon was the result of an asteroid strike on Earth? If true, are there any other planets that have moons resulting from the same event?"
32:03 Speaker 01 Aha. Okay, well, we think one theory is that a Mars-sized protoplanet hit the Earth when the Earth was forming. It actually scraped off the crust of the protoearth and formed our moon. It is potentially possible that this could have happened on other worlds.
32:17 Chuck Nice? Okay, good to know. Anna Williamson wants to know this. "How big of an asteroid would it take for a strike to break the Earth?" Would it have to be a moon-sized asteroid?
32:33 Speaker 01 She wants to know, like Alderaan-style destruction?
32:36 Chuck Nice? That's it, just obliterate.
32:39 Speaker 01 All right, well, we think that a Mars-sized protoplanet was enough to knock off the moon, but not destroy the Earth. So for something like that to happen, it would have to be a pretty big object, almost the size of the Earth.
32:50 Chuck Nice? Ah, one-to-one ratio.
32:51 Speaker 01 Yeah.
32:52 Chuck Nice? Okay, so Phil Green would like to know this. In the movie Armageddon, they were describing how a rogue comet went through the asteroid field and all that rock turned Earth into a shooting gallery. Is that scenario realistically possible?
33:08 Speaker 01 Well, the Armageddon movie had a few flaws, surprise, surprise.
33:12 Chuck Nice? Shock, shock, shock.
33:14 Speaker 01 Shocking, but the thing they got mostly right is that if a very large comet were to come in, it would certainly cause a lot of destruction. We do think that the asteroid belt was reshuffled early on in the formation of our solar system in an event called the late heavy bombardment.
33:29 Chuck Nice? Uh-huh. Boom, there's your answer. Late heavy bombardment, deal with that, Phil. All right, here's one from Rich Coto. Can an asteroid consisting of gold or silver be out there? And if it hit the Earth, who would own it?
33:46 Speaker 01 Well, I say I would love to find a gold or silver asteroid if I could, but the ones we find that are metallic tend to be nickel-iron.
33:54 Chuck Nice? Nickel-iron, not nearly worth as much.
33:57 Speaker 01 No, not nearly as much fun.
33:58 Chuck Nice? And the answer to the second part of the question is, if it does exist, I own it, okay Richie? Okay, so just back up off my asteroid. Get off my ass, Troy. Okay. This is from Twitter, I H Y H, okay? Is there a possibility of discovering new elements that are not on our periodic chart? Can we find that in asteroids?
34:23 Speaker 01 Oh, well, we certainly find a lot of very exotic materials that are not common here on Earth because they have sunk to the center of our planet long ago. Maybe it's remotely possible that someday somebody will find one that is way out there on the periodic table. Hasn't happened yet, mostly these very exotic weirdo elements are created in laboratories.
34:42 Chuck Nice? Ah, so we don't even need asteroids for that. There's your answer. So Melanie Bowman wants to know this. Would it be possible to redirect a comet to hit Mars for terraforming purposes? After impact, would terraforming work? Or would it just make a Martian mess?
35:01 Speaker 01 Oh, well, we do actually have a comet that is getting very close to Mars. It will not impact, so we don't get to do the experiment. Now, comets are pretty big, really big. A lot of them are more than a kilometer across, and that is very hard for us to move. Unfortunately, it's not easy for us to do that experiment, so we don't know.
35:21 Chuck Nice? Oh, my goodness. We got a we don't know. Look at that, Melanie. Okay, um, this one comes from Google Plus, and Elad Avran wants to know this. Can comets travel between star system? Or are they always bound to one star?
35:39 Speaker 01 Oh, this is a toughie. Okay, so we think that the comets in our Oort Cloud, which is a shell that kind of surrounds our solar system, and we are a tiny, tiny thing in the middle. Well, we think that sometimes it's possible for a nearby passing star over the course of many
35:54 Chuck Nice? billions of years
35:56 Speaker 01 could potentially grab some of our Oort Cloud comets and pull them off. It could happen.
36:01 Chuck Nice? So the answer is yes.
36:03 Speaker 01 Yes.
36:05 Chuck Nice? Cool. Okay, Alex Fawcett wants to know this. How scientifically accurate is the 1979 Atari game Asteroids?
36:14 Speaker 01 Okay, I spent way too much of my childhood playing that game.
36:17 Chuck Nice? Me and you both.
36:18 Speaker 01 Yes, and so when I became an asteroid scientist, it turns out the game is actually not that bad. If you hit an asteroid that is big in the game, it breaks into a lot of little pieces. And sure enough, that is exactly what happens to the asteroids.
36:31 Chuck Nice? Wow. That is awesome. All right, here's a very quick one. What role do you think plasma physics plays in the landscape of comets?
36:40 Speaker 01 Oh, my goodness, a confusing one.
36:44 Speaker 01 Okay. And that's all the time we've got for this lightning round on StarTalk Radio. Thank you so much Chuck Nice for being a great co-host.
36:51 Chuck Nice? Thank you. It was seriously a pleasure.
36:53 Speaker 01 It's been a blast. And I'm Amy Mainzer. I'm an astrophysicist at NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory. I'm co-hosting the show for our own Neil deGrasse Tyson, who is off around the cosmos right now. So, check us out on StarTalkRadio.net and we're on StarTalk Radio on Twitter and on Facebook. Thanks so much and clear skies, everyone.
Previous Cosmic Queries: New Discoveries Next Reporting on Science (Part 1) Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated